Professional Documents
Culture Documents
guardian.co.uk Mecca for architecture? A 9bn clocktower is just the start Badgers get a reprieve Government remains committed to cull Champions League comeback Manchester United overturn 2-0 decit
6-7
Continued on page 2
Naomie Harris and Daniel Craig at last nights premiere of the James Bond lm Skyfall at Royal Albert Hall in London Photograph: David Fisher/ Rex Features
Continued on page 2
Obama wins last debate but Romney may still emerge victor
f Mitt Romney is elected president of the United States on 6 November an outcome which is no longer the statistical implausibility it once was then historians will say it was the October debate season, which ended in the early hours of yesterday morning, that turned it around. Before he came face to face with Barack Obama in Denver three weeks ago, Romney existed in much of the American public mind as a cartoonish gure, a comic-book plutocrat so rich his wife had two Cadillacs and his cars had an elevator of their own. Extravagantly out of touch, he was Mittens, the pampered son of privilege who refused
12A
The Republican challenger achieved his aim in TV duels to transform himself into a plausible president, says Jonathan Freedland
to come clean about his taxes and whose personal rate turned out to be a measly 14%. Ideologically, he was either unpalatably extreme a severe conservative by his own description, whose message to Americas undocumented immigrants was that they should self-deport or an insincere ip-opper who had reversed countless previous positions rst supporting, then opposing, abortion rights, for instance to curry favour with the hardcore faithful who pick Republican presidential candidates. And he was useless to boot: clumsily embarking on a summer overseas tour that alienated a string of allies, including Britain, whose imminent Olympics he hinted would be a op. As late as
September his candidacy seemed doomed to failure. He had condemned himself out of his own mouth, thanks to a covert video of a fundraising speech in which he wrote o 47% of the American electorate as feckless parasites who would never vote for him anyway. The conventional wisdom deemed Romney perhaps the most inept nominee of a major party ever to seek the presidency. Obama was on course for a blowout, tipped to retake states that, when he won them in 2008, had seemed like an unrepeatable uke. But that was before the debate Continued on page 2
The Guardian Kings Place, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU. Telephone: 020 3353 2000 Fax: 020 7837 2114
the investigation had turned out to be as inaccurate as it was. On Monday Rippon agreed to step aside on full pay after his account of the Newsnight aair had to be corrected three times. Rippons lawyers, Davis Price, said they had no comment on Entwistles evidence yesterday. Entwistle also said that he was not involved in the BBC discussions about the Savile lm, but said he was warned at a busy lunch by Helen Boaden on 2 December that Newsnight was investigating Savile and possible implications for the schedules because Christmas tributes to the late presenter were planned. Entwistle, then the director of vision, responsible for the BBCs television channels, said he inquired no further, reecting a determination not to show an undue interest in the matter because Newsnight was not part of his division of the organisation. This phase of his evidence prompted several critical remarks from the MPs present. A committee member, the Conservative Damian Collins, said: You sound a bit like James Murdoch. Simon Jenkins, page 31 Leader comment, page 32
Michael Gove said that forces inside Whitehall were blocking progress
The Conservatives are trying to expose divisions in Labour over its approach to academies and free schools, and to pin responsibility on mainly Labour-run areas for inadequate school standards. In a speech to the rightwing thinktank Politeia, Gove said: There are hundreds more underperforming primary schools, many concentrated in other disadvantaged communities, where we need to act. He was writing to MPs in areas of educational underperformance outlining why we need to act and drawing attention to the failure, so far, of those in positions of power in local councils to move fast enough in improving our schools. In a number of communities the local forces of conservatism have worked against reform and have thrown every possible obstacle in the path of potential academy sponsors and free school founders trying to make a dierence. He says the MPs have a simple choice: stand with those in the academies and free schools movement who want to put chil-
2011 stating that it supports the current situation in which no sentenced prisoner is able to vote except those imprisoned for contempt default or reprimand. The motion was passed by 234 to 22. The debate was led by the prominent Tory backbencher David Davis and by the former Labour justice secretary Jack Straw. Davis argued: If you break the law, you cannot make the law. Straw asserted: The issue of prisoners voting rights was by no stretch of the imagination a breach of fundamental human rights but was a matter of penal policy which the minority of judges at Strasbourg said should be left to the UK parliament. He accused the Strasbourg court of trying to set itself up as the supreme court of Europe. Grieve, due to appear at the justice select committee today, has argued that prisoners might be entitled to compensation of between 1,000 and 1,500 if the UK continues in deance.
Contact
If you would like to contact us, the relevant details are below. For missing sections please ring 0800 839 100 For individual departments please ring the Guardian switchboard 020 3353 2000 For the Readers editor, Corrections & Clarications on specic editorial content, please ring 020 3353 4736 10am to 1pm UK time Monday to Friday excluding public holidays or email reader@guardian. co.uk Letters for publication should be sent to letters@ guardian.co.uk or the address on the letters page
Guardian News & Media, Kings Place, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU. 020 3353 2000. Fax 020 7837 2114. In Manchester: Centurion House, 129 Deansgate, Manchester M3 3WR. Telephone Sales: London 020 3353 3400; Manchester 0161 908 3800. guardian.co.uk. The Guardian lists links to thirdparty websites, but does not endorse them or guarantee their authenticity or accuracy. Missing sections: 0800 839 100.Back issues from Historic Newspapers: 0870 165 1470. guardian.backissuenewspapers.co.uk. The Guardian is published by Guardian News & Media, Kings Place, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU, and at Centurion House, 129 Deansgate, Manchester M3 3WR. Printed at Guardian Print Centre, Rick Roberts Way, Stratford, London E15 2GN; Guardian Print Centre North, Longbridge Road, Manchester M17 1SN; and at Carn Web, 2 Esky Drive, Carn, Portadown, Craigavon, County Armagh BT63 5YY. No. 51,675, Wednesday 24 October 2012. Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office ISSN 02613077
lashed himself to his opponent, oering a me-too echo of Obamas foreign policy. He too would withdraw troops from Afghanistan by 2014. He too had no plans to intervene militarily in Syria. He too regarded war to halt a nuclear Iran as a last resort. Why, the only differences were ones of style: he would show Vladimir Putin backbone, rather than the exibility Obama had promised. And he would never apologise for America. Instead he declared: Mr President, America has not dictated to other nations. We have freed other nations from dictators. Most neutrals gave the debate to Obama, who regularly exposed inconsistency on Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran youve been all over the map and used humour when he rebutted the Republicans lament that the US Navy had fewer ships now than at any time since 1917. Obamas reply: Governor, we also have fewer horses and bayonets, because the nature of our militarys changed. But for Romney, none of that much mattered. As David Frum, former speechwriter to Bush, tweeted: Romney reassured voters who fear he might be too hawkish; otherwise gave nobody reason to vote against him. Mission accomplished. That goes for the whole debate season. Romney needed to use October to transform himself from a near jokegure into a plausible president and he did. Thats why Republicans like to recall Ronald Reagan in 1980. Early that autumn, too many voters regarded Reagan as unt to be president. But during the TV debates, Reagan laid their fears to rest. This autumn also began with the US electorate disappointed in the occupant of the Oval Oce. But it rst needed to be reassured that it was safe to vote for the alternative. Romney may have lost two out of the three debates but it doesnt matter he did what he needed to do. Now a campaign that began nearly two years ago enters its nal stretch. There will be no more grand set pieces, just the hard graft of on-the-ground organisation, as both parties sweat to get out their vote. It will all come down to Ohio, says one former Democratic strategist. And it will be a district by district street ght. While Romney looks to energise miners in the south of the state, Obamas hopes will rest on bailed-out car workers in the north. Americas future rests in the narrow space that pollsters call the margin of error. Seumas Milne, page 30 Leader comment, page 32
News
The verdict may have been understandable in the Dark Ages but today its embarrassing
ing the Earth revolved around the sun. It is an analogy that has echoed around the world since the ruling. Professor Lord May of Oxford, former chief scientific adviser to the British government and president of the Royal Society, said: The sentence handed down to six Italian scientists is truly shocking, revealing appalling ignorance of the basic nature of scientic inquiry within the Italian legal system. The verdict might have been understandable in the Dark Ages, standing alongside the persecution of Galileo, but in todays world it simply is an embarrassment to the Italian government and anyone associated with it. Many scientists warned that the ruling, if upheld, sets a dangerous precedent for others working in hazard prediction. Luciano Maiani, head of the Italian commission that monitors seismic risk, resigned yesterday, saying: I dont see the conditions are there for working serenely. His deputy also quit. Stefano Gresta, current head of the geology and volcanology institute, said: From now on, it will be very dicult to appear in public to speak about seismic activity in Italy. Eva said: From what I hear no one wants to join commissions. Italys environment minister, Corrado Clini, said: The risk is of conrming the principle that no doubt is permitted in any scientic evaluation. Roger Musson, from the British Geological Survey, and David Rothery, a senior lecturer in Earth Sciences at the Open University, both warned that the judgment might have an unwelcome impact on the work of volcanologists monitoring the behaviour of Vesuvius, near Naples. Musson said: The question being asked by people is: what is this going to do for future relations between the scientic community and the public and state? One can imagine that next time there are rumblings heard from Vesuvius, Italian volcanologists are going to be reluctant to make any statement, because they have no guarantee that they wont nd themselves arrested if they say one thing and it turns out to be another. The convicted scientists Italys top earthquake experts were members of a committee known as the Major Risks Commission in 2009. They were summoned by Italys civil protection agency six days before the earthquake on 6 April to consider a series of tremors in the LAquila area. Prosecutors alleged they gave incomplete, imprecise and contradictory information on the risk to locals. One of those convicted, the former deputy civil protection chief Bernardo De Bernardinis, who organised the meeting, said scientists told him the situation was favourable. He was also quoted as advising locals, before the meeting, to relax with a glass of wine. Thats just not true, he said yesterday. A journalist asked me if he should have a glass of wine while awaiting the end of the meeting and I agreed. Lawyers now await the judges explanation of the sentencing expected in 90 days to nd out if the group was conItalian emergency services rescue a survivor from a collapsed building after the magnitude-5.8 earthquake struck LAquila in Abruzzo in April 2009. More than 300 people were killed and much of the historic centre of the city still lies in ruins Photograph: Peri-Percossi/EPA/Ansa victed not just for failing to warn locals, but for actively downplaying the risk that a quake was on the way. A local official, Stefania Pezzopane, who backed the verdict, claimed that the experts had been called in by the civil protection agency specically to reassure people. Scientists, she said, should be scientists and not buoons. They reassured us and then we died in our homes, said a local resident, Domenico Di Giamberardino. But Eva insisted neither he nor his colleagues had given any reassurances in their 40-minute meeting. We always maintained it was not possible to predict or exclude an earthquake, he said. With two appeals permitted under Italian law, the scientists will not be jailed immediately, but Eva said his morale was devastated by the verdict. I do not feel guilty from a scientic point of view, he said. In court, the prosecutor referred to the failure in predicting Hurricane Katrina, but it is a lot easier to predict a hurricane than an earthquake, he said. LAquila, which still lies in ruins, was also damaged by earthquakes in 1349, 1461 and 1703. An earthquake is like an assassin that returns to the scene of a crime, said Eva, but you can never tell when. Leader comment, page 32
It was a very Italian and medieval decision the judge, prosecutor and public were local
Physicist Claudio Eva, above, with Bernardo De Bernardinis, right
The Guardian | Wednesday 24 October 2012 National editor: Dan Roberts Telephone: 020 3353 4090 Fax: 020 3353 3190 Email: national@guardian.co.uk
National
On the site
Nick Hopkins on the new RAF drones that are beginning operations over Afghanistan guardian.co.uk/defence
The bigger picture Wide wild western prints at the Royal Academy
The Big Country a narrative screenprint by the artist Stephen Chambers stretches around the walls of the Royal Academy in London. More than 75 prints feature in the exploration of atmosphere and landscape inspired by the 1958 western of the same name. Until 2 December Photograph: Graeme Robertson for the Guardian
National
The Duchess of Cambridge chatting to Carl Hester, Charlotte Dujardin, and Scott Brash (left to right) at Buckingham Palace yesterday Photograph: John Stillwell/PA Wire
Olympic savings
Projected savings from the costs of the Olympic and Paralympic games Funding package
9.298bn
Projected saving Anticipated nal cost
8.921bn
377m
SOURCE: DCMS
ernment announced that the bid budget of 2.4bn had more than tripled to 9.3bn, that the project could be delivered on budget. He praised the delivery of the Games within the agreed budget, which included more than 2bn of contingency funds, as a tremendous success against the backdrop of a global recession. The work of the construction and delivery teams, from the ODA [Olympic Delivery Authority] and Locog, has set a very high standard and I have no doubt that London 2012 has set a new benchmark for the management of Olympic and Paralympic Games in future, he said. Talks are also still ongoing between London 2012 organisers and G4S to get it
to pay for the army sta brought in at the last minute. Robertson said the future of the 429m Olympic Stadium should be concluded in the next couple of weeks. Talks are ongoing between the London Legacy Development Corporation (LLDC) and potential tenants, including West Ham. Negotiations with the club are at an impasse over who will pay for conversion costs of up to 160m to make the stadium suitable for football as well as athletics. The London mayor, Boris Johnson, is keen to explore the possibility of using some of the unspent contingency, which will ow back to the Treasury, towards the conversion costs.
Last night Great Britains Olympic and Paralympic heroes were celebrated at a Buckingham Palace reception hosted by the Queen. The athletes arrived in their official Team GB formal wear of suits, which included a special inside pocket for their medals. The Queen, joined by the Duke of Edinburgh and the Duchess of Cambridge, had watched the Olympic opening ceremony and the Queen took part. Team GB began the summers medal rush by winning 65 in total, including 29 golds, an achievement that was hailed as the athletes greatest ever performance by Andy Hunt, their chef de mission for London 2012.
National
On the site Breaking news and analysis throughout the day guardian.co.uk
George Entwistle leaves Portcullis House after giving evidence to the culture, media and sport select committee Photograph: Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images
Whos who
Mark Thompson
Director general until September 2012 Thompson started his job as chief executive of the New York Times Company on Monday. He said he had never heard allegations or complaints about Savile while he was as DG, was never formally notied about Newsnights Savile investigation, and was only alerted to it when a journalist asked him about it at a drinks reception. He has oered to appear before the culture select committee. Thompson said he had not yet been contacted by the corporations review into the aair. Thompson said the BBCs editorial policy department had a list of potentially sensitive programmes but it did not often include segments of strands such as Newsnight or Radio 4s Today programme. He said. I do not believe the Savile investigation was included on it. Certainly I do not recall seeing it there.
Stephen Mitchell
BBC News deputy director Newsnight editor Peter Rippon consulted Mitchell and Boaden as the programmes Savile investigation developed during November 2011.
Helen Boaden
BBC news director As news director, she had responsibility for Newsnight. Entwistle said the message he took from the 2 December conversation was it wasnt clear to Helen whether or not [the Savile story] was going to stand up. They never spoke about the investigation again, he added: I inferred the decision had been taken not to go ahead.
Peter Rippon
Newsnight editor Stepped aside on Monday, while an internal review of the handling of Newsnights Savile investigation is completed, after the journalists behind the story, Meirion Jones and Liz MacKean, challenged his reason for why it was dropped. Rippon had a change of heart about the Savile investigation on 30 November 2011, less than a week after expressing his enthusiasm in an email, MacKean said.
National
Journalisms future lies online at least according to Supermans alter ego Clark Kent, who is about to quit his job at the Daily Planet and found a version of the Drudge Report. In the new issue of DC Comics Superman series, out tomorrow, Clark will stand up in front of sta in a Jerry Maguire-type moment and resign, bemoaning how journalism has given way to entertainment, writer Scott Lobdell told USA Today. Clark, played by Brandon Routh, left, in Superman Returns, will call on his fellow reporters to stand up for truth, justice, and yeah Im not ashamed to say it the American way, said Lobdell. Rather than Clark be this clownish suit that Superman puts on, were going to really see Clark come into his own in the next few years as a guy who takes to the internet and to the airwaves and starts speaking an unvarnished truth. I dont think hes going to be lling out an application anywhere. He is more likely to start the next Hungton Post or the next Drudge Report than he is to go nd someone else to get assignments or draw a paycheck from. Clark Kent has worked at Metropolis paper the Daily Planet since the 1940s, though Comic Book Resources notes he has left the company in the past. Lobdell said his departure this time is what happens when a 27-year-old guy is behind a desk and he has to take instruction from a larger conglomerate with concerns that arent his own Superman is arguably the most powerful person on the planet, but how long can he sit at his desk with someone treating him like the least important person in the world? asked the writer.
o MYTH N 1
THATS RUBBISH.
Marketing works, and we can prove it. With Adobe Marketing Cloud, you get a complete set of integrated solutions: analytics, social, advertising, targeting and content management. Go from data to insights faster than ever. Metrics, not myths.
ADOBE
MARKETING
Follow us @AdobeMktgCloud
2012 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved. Adobe and the Adobe logo are registered trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated in the United States and/or other countries.
11
National
Badger cull
Commentary
The musician Brian May, whose successful e-petition won the rst Commons debate on the proposed badger cull, scheduled for this Thursday, said: This is by no means the end of the line. What we need is a complete abandonment. He pledged to work with farmers on a pilot vaccination scheme that could come in months, not years. Gavin Grant, the RSPCAs chief executive, said: Hopefully this marks the beginning of the end for these unscientic, foolish and cruel plans to cull badgers. This must not be a temporary reprieve, but must mark an end to all cull plans. The cull delay follows an embarrassing U-turn in 2011 by the environment department on the sale of public forests and comes after a dicult week for the government in which Cameron was criticised over an apparently bungled announcement on energy bills, and the chief whip, Andrew Mitchell, resigned. Ministers and farmers have argued that a badger cull is essential to help stop the spread of TB, while opponents maintain that the main problem is disease transmission between cattle and warn that a cull could prompt badgers to disperse and so spread the disease more widely. Last year 26,000 cattle were slaughtered and the disease cost taxpayers 90m, which included compensation to farmers.
Reaction
Steven Morris
Its a mess, a bloody mess, said Carol Wainwright, who farms in the planned cull area in Gloucestershire. The governments messed the whole thing up. Its disgusting. Theyve put us through all this, promised theyre going to sort out the problem and then at the last minute they give up. Steve Jones, a farm manager in the Forest of Dean and a critic of culling, said: I thought it would be derailed. But I thought the train would at least get out of the station. This just goes to show how awed the cull was. Public opinion is against it, science is against it, commonsense is against it. Jones feels sorry for farmers who are having to cope with bovine TB but
believes they need to do more and be helped to do more to improve animal husbandry and biosecurity. Dairy farmers have a really big problem. The price of milk is so low that these farms are becoming more and more impoverished. They cant aord to look after the animals, he said. Roger Yeates, a Forest of Dean farmer and Conservative councillor, said the planned cull had been badly handled. I didnt think shooting badgers was the way to go that would mean killing the healthy ones that were running about; the infected ones tend to stay underground. Im pleased its o. The Forest of Dean district council had voted to ban badger culling on its land and was calling on all landowners within its boundary to do the same. Jackie Fraser, the Labour councillor
who proposed the ban on culling, said: Im pleased but cautious. I hope the government is going to look seriously at other ways of tackling bovine TB. Campaigners (right), including Gloucestershire Against Badger Shooting, expressed delight. Liz Gaer, a GABS spokeswoman, admitted she had tears in her eyes when she heard. We are so, so pleased we hope the government will not just delay but will decide not to pursue a cull as the evidence is clear that culling badgers is not the most eective, ecient or humane way of reducing bovine TB. People in Gloucestershire e have voiced their concern
over the rationale behind it and the safety issues involved. We believe the government may have taken this on board and we will continue a to campa campaign for a vaccination programme of cattle and badgers. program For now the saboteurs, who had n been ready to get out into the cull r zones in high-visibility jackets and carrying horns and rape alarms, carryi can stand down. Over the last few st months experienced saboteurs have been joined by many newcomers to joi the animal rights scene, keen to map anim setts and disrupt the cull. an Kayleigh, an activist, said: Its Kayl fantastic news; it takes the pressure fantast o us a bit but well continue to survey setts and continue to prepare. Well a also be making sure farmers dont start b taking the law into their own hands. takin
12
National
Household income
Real household income per head is struggling to recover from this recession
110
1990 recession
105
2008 recession
Household savings
Increases in household savings are associated with worries about the future economic climate
8 6 4 2 0
1990
1995
2000
2005
2010
SOURCE: ONS
13
Laurie Sansoms production of The Holy Rosenbergs at the National Theatre in London last year Photograph: Tristram Kenton
Audio Hear the latest podcasts and subscribe for free guardian. co.uk/ podcasts
15
National
Food
adverts featuring Rachel Weisz, Christy Turlington, Julia Roberts and Penlope Cruz banned. Christian Dior said consumers expected images used in adverts for beauty products to have used professional styling and photography. It admitted Portman had not worn false eyelashes in the photoshoot, but it had added the appearance through digital enhancement using Photoshop. Christian Dior said a minimal amount of retouching took place in relation to increasing the thickness and volume of a number of her natural lashes. The main point of the airbrushing was to stylistically lengthen and curve her lashes and the look achieved did not go beyond what consumers could do with the products themselves. The ASA said: Because we considered that we had not seen sucient evidence to show that the post-production retouching on Natalie Portmans lashes in the ad did not exaggerate the likely eects of the product, we concluded the ad was likely to mislead. Mark Sweney
Disability
Health
Transport
Consumer
16
The Tory who found a new way to get under his partys skin
Andy Beckett
ameron has been one of the most disappointing Conservative leaders. During his tenure, error has been piled upon error. His party is still seen as a party of the rich. His big society has been a complete failure as a message. In oce, as well as lacking a plan, his party has lost a sense of social justice Conservative rhetoric often borders on social Darwinism. Instead of a rightwing party with a heart, Cameron has created a centrist party with cuts. Even after months of Tory troubles, it is still a shock to hear these things from a lifelong Conservative. And not from some disgruntled activist or marginalised, anonymous cabinet dissident, but from one of the partys dominant gures, on the record, in the New Statesman, this newspaper and the Spectator over the past 12 months. Yet Tim Montgomerie is not like previous important Tories. Instead of a parliamentary constituency or ministry, or a personal fortune used for strategic donations, he has an unocial party website, ConservativeHome, and an increasing ubiquity in the rest of the political media. At 42, he is a uent, seemingly inexhaustible writer, broadcaster, thinker, alliance-builder and campaigner. Over the past dozen years, he has played multiple, apparently contradictory Tory roles: internal critic and cheerleader; intimate of the party elite; self-appointed voice of the grassroots; polemicist for a more populist Conservatism sometimes more, sometimes less right wing and dispassionate analyst of the partys ups and downs. Its a new role in British politics, said Max Wind-Cowie of the Progressive Conservatism Project at the thinktank Demos. Without being elected, originally without the endorsement of a national paper, standing outside the ocial structure of one of the main parties, he has established himself as one of the foremost voices about what that party should do. Robert Halfon, Tory MP for Harlow, who has known Montgomerie since university, said: Ive never met anyone like him. Hes got so much energy in his head. He is a political entrepreneur. Montgomerie founded ConservativeHome in 2005. Since 2009, it has been funded by the wealthy, perpetually manoeuvring Tory peer Lord Ashcroft. Edited by Montgomerie and four other sta, written by them and scores of contributors, it serves as a unique one stop shop for hundreds of thousands of rightwing Britons. ConHome, as it is known in Tory circles, oers punditry, gossip, political philosophy, policy wonkery, a comprehensive roundup of Westminster news, appeals for help with Conservative causes, sales pitches from ambitious MPs, and sometimes raw contributions from party members and supporters. I and almost everyone else I know in the party read it at least once a day, said Wind-Cowie. Jesse Norman, Conservative MP for Hereford and South Herefordshire, said: Very few younger MPs dont check it. Halfon added: There are a lot of people in the Commons who say we dont look at it when they look at it 50 times a day. Wind-Cowie, Norman and Halfon are all contributors few prominent youngish Tories are not but the site is also respected by bloggers on the left. Sunny Hundal, editor of Liberal Conspiracy, said: As a political operation I think ConHome sets the benchmark for everyone else. One well-connected Tory-watcher calls the site a party within a party. A Tory MP said: Being a ConHome reader has almost replaced the party membership. I dont think Ive looked at the ocial Conservative party website for about six months. Strikingly, senior Tories criticised on ConservativeHome, such as the former health secretary Andrew Lansley, the former Tory chair Lady Warsi, and the former justice secretary Ken Clarke, often lose their jobs. On BBC Question
Potted prole
Born 24 July 1970 Career Son of a soldier who discovered Thatcherism and Christianity in his teens, rose and then fell as an inuential behind-the-scenes Tory, then reinvented himself as a new kind of political player through his website ConservativeHome. High point Predicting before the 2010 general election that the rst-ever televised party leaders debates would be a big boost for Nick Clegg, and that the Conservatives might live to regret agreeing to participate. Low point Failure, as Iain Duncan Smiths chief of sta, to help protect the Tory leader in 2003 from a party coup. What he says Im not worried about ConservativeHome being too powerful. Im worried that Ill wake up tomorrow morning and nd a group of Conservatives with a lot of money behind them have launched a rival. What they say Hes a natural politician, says one Tory journalist. Hell make an alliance with anyone on a single issue. What if he had become an MP in 2001 like Cameron and Osborne? It was an incredibly weak intake; had Montgomerie been there, Cameron and Osborne would have had more competition since. for a polemicist, he retains an unusual zest for gures Montgomerie moved into full-time politics at Conservative central oce, rst under the leadership of William Hague, then under Iain Duncan Smith. Montgomerie saw his mission as strengthening the Tories social conscience while keeping them as a strongly rightwing party. Duncan Smith increasingly relied on him, rst as a speechwriter, then chief of sta. The fact that Duncan Smiths leadership went so badly has provided ammunition for Montgomeries enemies. As one MP put it: Tim is part of the problem, not part of the solution, some would say. The last time he had inuence, the party was not in a beautiful place. To some of his critics, Montgomerie combines a restless search for ideological purity with electoral naivety: The Conservative version of Michael Foots Labour party, wrote Matthew Parris in the Spectator last year. Others nd Montgomeries ever-quotable outspokenness sly or baing or self-indulgent, given the already-bueted government. He does cause a lot of angst, particularly in No 10, said the Tory blogger Iain Dale. But they still deal with him. Montgomerie is still invited to Downing Street drinks parties, and Cameron still talks to him at them. Few doubt that Montgomerie would prefer a dierent leader. He was one of the earliest Tory pessimists about the partys chances at the next general election, and ConservativeHome, some Tories speculate, will play a pivotal kingmaking role if Cameron fails to win. Montgomerie said carefully: One day, we could bring two huge assets together, Boris, as a presidential PM, and the [very rightwing] class of 2010. Yet Montgomerie is more complex than sometimes imagined. Disarmingly mild-mannered, he never forgets if he feels youve let him down, said Halfon. He lives in Salisbury, not London, most of the week. He is single, and able to work six days a week, he says, following biblical principle: on the seventh, he gets the train with his sister to watch Manchester United. Like many obsessive activists Montgomerie insists he never wants to be an MP he oscillates between optimism and pessimism, dissidence and loyalty. He recently launched another website, strongandcompassionate.com, dedicated, it appears, to campaigning for a Tory majority in 2015. He has described his political trajectory as a journey. He said: Perhaps Ive moved leftwards on the NHS and rightwards on crime. His ambition, he said, is for ConservativeHome to be handed over to someone else to run. Then what? There is an uncharacteristic pause. Maybe something in the [international] development world. Whoever is Tory leader then may breathe a sigh of relief.
Time in February, Clarke railed against Tim Montgomerie, who sets himself up as representing every active Tory in the country on his blasted website. Sometimes mockingly, sometimes fearfully, many Tories now refer to Montgomerie as the high priest of Conservatism. In truth, ConservativeHome is a little too broad in tone and content to be a personal mouthpiece. It publishes hostile reader responses to Montgomeries more controversial stances, such as support for a wealth tax (This is madness) and gay marriage (Youve sold your soul). Yet an argument for a particular sort of Conservatism pervades the site. Montgomerie and his online allies are sceptical about the EU, and about Cameron and his Tory modernisation, which they consider too metropolitan
One day we could bring together two huge assets, Boris as a presidential PM and the class of 2010
and gay marriage aside too socially liberal. Most Britons, they argue, want the party to be tough on crime, welfare and immigration; but also more socially concerned and less elitist rightwing with a heart, in Montgomeries phrase. Hes got a robust, highly intelligent, well-organised critique of Conservatism from within the right, said Norman. The hybrid that Tim is pulling together is rediscovering arguments from the 80s and 90s, but explicitly actuated by concern for the less well-o. The political eect of that is to reach out across political, class and emotional lines. Recently, there have been signs that the government is paying these ideas close attention. Conservative methods are not just good for the strong and the successful but the best way to help the poor, Cameron told his party conference this month. Montgomerie and ConservativeHome were even more prominent at the event than usual, their large, showily positioned marquee hosting events featuring Tory stars such as Michael Gove, Iain Duncan Smith and, most noisily, Boris Johnson whose party leadership credentials Montgomerie has been pointedly talking up. At Tory gatherings, Montgomerie is easy to spot: tall, more casually dressed than many, speaking in a seductively calm voice that combines politeness and jolts of candour. At conference this month, he was just king of the whole place, said one attendee.
Montgomerie said: I do not want ConservativeHome to be a party within a party. I want it to be the conference fringe that never stops. Have he and the website prompted the Tories populist turn? It is possible that I was a little bit ahead of time on the need for the party to support Britains strivers. But the focus groups and opinion polls have been telling them similar things. Conservative unpopularity, and trying to nd ways to end it, have been the near-constants of his political life. Born into an army family in Hampshire in 1970, his politics were Tory from the start. But his teenage Thatcherism was tempered, he says, by discovering evangelical Christianity at 16. At Exeter University, he helped run the Conservative Association with Halfon and two other current Tory MPs, Sajid Javid and David Burrowes. It was the end of the 80s and support for the Tories was ebbing. Tim had a BBC computer with an oldfashioned printer, said Halfon. Hed produce leaets, newsletters, posters. A complete workaholic. ConHome is just an outgrowth of that. At Exeter, Montgomerie and Burrowes also started the Conservative Christian Fellowship. Inuenced by the US religious right, Montgomerie ercely promoted what he now calls traditional views on homosexuality. That was my upbringing. I dont hold those views any more. After working briey in the 1990s as a Bank of England statistician
17
National
24 hours in pictures The most arresting news photography from the last 24 hours guardian. co.uk/ inpictures
18
US election
23
18
19 17 12 4
Lat
China Iran
14 15
Gr
ee
d
Pola n
ce
ria Sy Iraq
1 Gr
Iran
Isr ael
ee
d
Isr ael
18
China
1 UK 1
ce Fran
lia
lia
frica
So
So
South A
South A
frica
ma
ma
Lat
s Ru
in A
in A me
sia
me ric
ric a
1 Polan 12 1
ce
r Sy
ia
Obama
Lib
Mali
Afghanistan
Turk ey Eg yp t
UK
ce Fran
Romney
sia Eg y
a
Mali
Iraq
4 8
Afghanistan
Turk e y
s Ru
pt
Lib ya
ya
On the ground
Race for the White House News, analysis and the latest polling guardian.co.uk/world/usa
19
Debate over Clockwise from left: Mitt Romney and his wife Ann greet members of the public; Bob Schieer, moderator of the third debate, watches the candidates; Michelle Obama joins her husband; Richard and Carol Smith watch the debate in Boca Raton, Florida Main photograph: Saul Loeb/ AFP/Getty Images
unshakable commitment to cautious, reasonable, and peace-loving leadership. Many others agreed. Put simply, writes Kevin Drum of Mother Jones magazine, diagnosing gnosing a longstanding phenomenon in n US politics, we liberals dont t have enough bloggers/ pundits/columnists/talking heads who are willing to cheerfully say whatever it takes to advance the party line, no matter how ridiculous it is. One side-eect of this syndrome is especially troubling: it provokes feelings of warmth for conservative rebrand Glenn Beck (below), whos incapable of self-censorship. I am glad to know that Mitt agrees with Obama so much, Beck tweeted late on Monday. No, really. Why vote? Anyway, much more importantly, the ag pin Obama wore during the debate was smaller than Romneys, and that means he must be less patriotic, according to a detailed analysis by the National Reviews Charles Kesler, which he appears to have produced without the aid of psilocybin mushrooms.
Though hes tried to put Sixtiesstyle anti-Americanism behind him he hasnt quite succeeded, Kesler writes. Never let it be said that political discourse discour avoids the substantive issues. issu u Although, for their part, left-wing critics p werent really justied in w complaining about the absence of drones from Monday nights debate. M Wolf W Blitzer was there, hosting CNNs coverage, as h ho always! alw w Meanwhile, on the matter of horses and bayonets: not everyone responded positively to Obamas eorts to provide a stimulus for the internetmeme industry on Monday night. An entire psuedo-controversy has arisen, based on the presidents claim that bayonets were no longer used at all. Actually, NBC Newss Chuck Todd informed his audience, bayonets are still actively used by the military, while Dan Riker, of the military surplus company Bayonet Inc a man who may conceivably have grounds for being biased was incensed. The comment was ignorant because our soldiers still use bayonets, the website TMZ quoted him as saying. He should get educated on it. Right. Yes. Never mind that what the president actually said in what was, in any case, a throwaway line was that fewer bayonets were in use. In a campaign where most voters have made up their minds, facts dont get in the way of a promising microscandal. Its enough to make you want to stab yourself in the face with a sharp object of some kind.
I didnt like Obamas horses and bayonets remark. I think it sounds unpresidential
applause followed the Republican candidates invocation of Obamas comment to the Russian president, Dmitry Medvedev, that he would have more exibility on contentious issues after the US presidential election. Obamas boast that America was stronger now than when I came into oce received a collective outburst of laughter. When the president made his most scathing comment of the night, ridiculing Romney for saying there were fewer ships in the US Navy today than in 1917 by pointing out that we also have fewer horses and bayonets, there were
days to go
18
21
International
Existing examples
France, Spain, Belgium, Denmark and Italy have introduced quota laws, as have non-EU nations Iceland and Norway, which has had a quota system since 2006 that requires at least 40% of either sex on all listed company boards. Firms were given only two years to comply. The Spanish law, passed in 2007, obliges quoted rms with more than 250 employees to aim for a 40%-female minimum on their boards by 2015. France passed its law in 2011, forcing large companies to reserve at least 40 % of boardroom positions for women by 2017. It applies to 2,000 companies in France that are either listed, have more than 500 employees or revenues over 50m.
tomorrow on Menschs appointment to the ECB, after the chambers economic and monetary aairs committee rejected the German-style ination hawk on Monday on gender grounds. Va n Ro m p u y t o l d t h e p a r l i a ment yesterday that female underrepresentation in top posts was blatant, and that he was working to remedy it, but still believed Mersch should get the job. Merschs appointment would delay any real chance of redressing the total imbalance in the ECB executive until 2018. Sharon Bowles, the Lib Dem MEP and economic committee chair who is running for governor of the Bank of England, said: What we heard today is no dierent to all the promises on equality that have universally failed: we need more than just talk and promises. We are objecting to the EUs most powerful institution being run by only men for the next six years.
Qatari emirs ying visit to Gaza brings Hamas in from the cold
Ian Black and Harriet Sherwood
Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani is used to basking in the limelight. But when the emir of Qatar arrived in Gaza yesterday the rst Arab leader in years to visit the impoverished coastal strip he was hailed for breaking its siege, demonstrating his countrys huge and growing inuence in the Middle East. Palestinians rolled out the red carpet for the emir as his black Mercedes bumped along a rutted main road that he has promised to rebuild, past white and maroon Qatari ags, the song Thank You, Qatar playing endlessly on local radio and TV. Sheikh Hamad ew to Egypt and crossed the border into Gaza, a move billed as breaking the blockade in force since the Islamists of Hamas took power in 2007. It also underlined the ability of the tiny, fabulously rich Gulf state to punch above its weight internationally. He arrived with 90 tonnes of aid and pledged $400m (250m) to invest in housing and infrastructure to replace property damaged in the 2008-09 war with Israel. Flanked by his wife, the elegant and high-prole Sheikha Mozah, he spoke to a large crowd at Gazas Islamic University, the biggest event of a six-hour stay. The last head of state to visit the strip was King Abdullah of Jordan, who went there in 1999 for talks with then Palestinian president, Yasser Arafat. Predictably, the royal visit was the top news item on al-Jazeera, the satellite TV channel owned by the emirs family and which has been an unabashed and inuential cheerleader for the uprisings of the Arab spring from Tunisia to Syria. Qatars ambitious move was a stunning boost for Hamas, shunned by Israel, the US and western countries as a terrorist organisation. Ismail Haniyeh, its deposed prime minister, called it a historic event that had broken the unjust blockade. The visit gives Hamas legitimacy in the Arab world and internationally, said Mkhaimar Abusada, an independent analyst at Gazas al-Azhar university. It was further striking evidence that Qatar, whose per-capita income is now the highest in the world, is in eect using its enormous oil and gas riches and close ties to Islamist organisations to expand its regional inuence in the wake of its involvement in the uprisings against Libyas Muammar Gadda and Bashar al-Assad in Syria. The emir is conrming that Qatar is the principal supporter of the Muslim Brotherhood takeover in Egypt and everywhere else, said Ahmed Asfahani, the respected al-Hayat columnist. Qatar is using the Brotherhood to promote its own interests. It also shows that Qatar is trying to replace Iran as a major player on the Palestinian issue. Observers in the region also see the visit in part as a reward to Hamas for ending its support for Assad. Until a few months ago, the movements exiled
leadership was based in Damascus, helping bolster Syrias credentials as a key member of the axis of resistance confronting Israel, along with Iran and Hezbollah in Lebanon. But its veteran leader, Khalid Mishal, decamped to Doha. And Haniyeh came out in open support of the right of the Syrian people to oppose Assad. Mahmoud Abbas, the western-backed Palestinian president and leader of Fatah, had let it be known that he was furious about the visit. Nobodys happy about it, said one Palestinian source. It denitely makes a statement. And there is a track record of Arab regimes playing into intra-Palestinian politics. The PLO welcomed any help with reconstruction in Gaza, but called on all Arab brethren to use their leverage to ensure an end to the division and the policy of creating a separatist entity in the Gaza Strip, as [this] principally serves the Israeli agenda. There is also an unspoken fear of eroding the claim of Abbass Palestinian Authority to be the sole representative of the Palestinians. Israel angrily condemned the Qatari visit as well. We nd it weird that the emir doesnt support all of the Palestinians but sides with Hamas over the Palestinian Authority [in the West Bank] which he has never visited, said its for-
eign ministry spokesman, Yigal Palmor. The emir has chosen his camp and it is not good. In the background, it is possible to discern a new pattern of relations emerging in a political landscape transformed by the Arab spring in which a key player is the Egyptian president, Mohamed Morsi. In the era of Hosni Mubarak, Qatar was often at loggerheads with Egypt, which, like many other Arab governments, hated al-Jazeera and saw it as a disruptive instrument of Qatari policy. Even now, Doha is being more radical than Cairo. Formally, Egypt considers Abbas as the representative of Palestinians and Gaza as under PA authority. The emir called publicly for eorts to promote reconciliation between the Palestinian rivals to confront Israel. It will be interesting to see if Qatar is now going to play a more active role in mediating between Hamas and Fatah, or even Hamas and Israel, said Abusada. Doha has won admiration and irritation in equal measure in the Middle East and beyond. Uniquely, it maintains cordial, if low-key, relations with Israel as well as Iran, hated by other Gulf Arabs. It is also home to a large US air base. Its wealth speaks eloquently. In September, it announced plans to invest $18bn over ve years in Egypt. Its aid also helped reconstruction in south Lebanon after the 2006 war between Hezbollah and Israel. At that time, the emir worked closely with Assad, only to turn against him when the Syrian uprising began 19 months ago. In Libya last year, Qatar bankrolled the anti-Gadda rebels but channelled resources through Islamist brigades only to face criticism that it was behaving in a manipulative manner. Now Qatar has become a key supporter of the armed Syrian opposition, amid concern in the west that the weapons it pays for are reaching jihadi-type groups. Rachel Shabi, page 32
Sheikh Hamad and Sheikha Mozah are received in Khan Younis in the Gaza Strip. Below left, Palestinians wave the Qatari ag Main photograph: APA Images/Rex Features
We nd it weird that the emir sides with Hamas. He has chosen his camp and its not good
22
International
Guan Yifan, the 90-year-old father of , the author Mo Yan (below), sits outside ( the abandoned family home in Pingan, fam Shandong province, China province Photograph: Jason Lee/Reuters
Every Everybody want wants to know what Mo Yans life used to b be like
ment is reportedly planning to pay local farmers to plant 1,600 acres (650 hectares) of the unprotable crop. The Gaomi press centre director, Wang Youzhi, told the ocial Xinhua news agency that the theme park was more a vision than a concrete plan. Although the idea sounds promising, we have yet to take the whole situation into consideration, he said. This might be the regulatory commissions long-term plan over ve or 10 years. But a large-scale tourism project in Gaomi remains unsurprising, analysts claim. According to Tao Ran, an economics professor at Renmin University in Beijing, local governments often borrow massive sums of money from state-owned banks to nance expensive development projects, hoping that they will drive up the value of local property.
If you go to almost any Chinese county or city, youll see that theyre building new cities, new industrial parks, and new theme parks every day. In July authorities announced a 810-hectare, 2.9bn Tibetan Culture theme park, currently being developed on the outskirts of Lhasa. Last week ocials in the Xinjiang Uyghur autonomous region unveiled plans to build a 600,000 Malan Military Expo Park at Chinas rst atomic bomb test site. Mos brother, neighbours and 90-year-old father say they have not heard of plans for a theme park. Its impossible that the government here would spend so much money on such a surface thing, Guan said. Mo Yan, who was born Guan Moye his pen name means dont speak could not be reached for comment.
guardian.co.uk/africanetwork
Running with white people Fun run through suburbs and townships of Johannesburg exposes bitter racial divisions, says Lindokuhle Nkosi Military regime posing as democracy Boubacar NDiaye analyses the situation in Mauritania, where soldiers accidently shot the president German amnesia Herero deserve reparation, says Dan Moshenberg
39.00
The Concept 2 isnt just a great way to lose weight, though. Its also designed to help you get t, stay t, keep in shape, maintain your weightwhatever your goals and targets, the Concept2 will help you achieve them. All in the comfort of your own home. And all for as little as 39 a month. Find out more about the low-cost rental and purchase nance options. What have you got to lose? Apart from some unwanted calories.
To nd out more about the rental scheme please call 0844 826 0981 @concept2uk Facebook.com/concept2
23
International
Kuwait
Fighting spirit
Japan
Martial arts students perform kung fu at the Shaolin temple, Dengfeng, for the ninth Shaolin Wushu festival held each year in China Photograph: ChinaFotoPress/Getty
between 2006 and 2009. Japan forbids politicians from knowingly accepting funds from foreign sources. His oce said it had returned the money. Tanaka claimed he had been unaware of the yakuza connections. His resignation which the government ascribed to poor health after he was admitted to hospital last Friday with chest pains has attracted fresh criticism of Nodas judgment. In September 2011 his trade and industry minister, Yoshio Hachiro, resigned after describing an area in Fukushima, scene of last years nuclear disaster, as a ghost town and joking about radioactive contamination. Noda has resisted calls for an early general election, with polls suggesting his party would lose, three years after it swept to power in a landslide. He also faces criticism over his handling of the economy. Justin McCurry Tokyo
Gulf of Aden
Venezuela
Venezuelans are celebrating their homegrown baseball heroes as a record contingent heads into the World Series with the Detroit Tigers and San Francisco Giants. Nine Venezuelans, including ve with the Giants, will feature in the series, the most ever. Its the rst time, but it had to happen one day. All the time there are more and better Venezuelan players in the major leagues, said Alberto Mendoza, who was among dozens of fans in Caracas celebrating the Giants win over the St Louis Cardinals in the National League Championship Series. Venezuela is a power in baseball. The games star was one of their own, Marco Scutaro (above), who was named the most valuable player of the series. Baseball is the most popular sport in Venezuela, sharing the passion with Caribbean neighbours the Dominican Republic and Cuba. AP Caracas
24
The Guardian | Wednesday 24 October 2012 Business editor: Julia Finch Tel: 020 3353 3795 Fax: 020 3353 3196 Email: nancial@guardian.co.uk Follow us at twitter.com/BusinessDesk
Financial
FTSE 100 -85.00 5797.91 FTSE All Share -42.96 3029.81 Early Dow Indl -223.47 13122.42 Early S&P 500 -19.03 1414.79 Nikkei 225 +3.54 9014.25 UK 10 year gilt -1.4790 120.2200 Oil ($ per barrel) -1.78 107.66 Gold ($ Troy oz) -15.75 1711.00
Rate Change
1.2295 +0.0028
Rate Change
1.5940 -0.0094
$
SOURCE: INTERACTIVE DATA
Mulberrys spring/summer 2013 collection was on display at London Fashion Week in September Photograph: Suzanne Plunkett/Reuters
25
Financial
Business analysis
BAE
Pressure is building for change at the top, says Nils Pratley
The curse of the award strikes again. Guess who picked up top prize in the annual Non-Executive Director Awards (yes, they really exist) in March? It was Dick Olver, chairman of BAE, whose advice to the assembled worthies was to lead extraordinary change. Change is what BAE needs, extraordinarily quickly, thinks the companys largest shareholder. Neil Woodford at Invesco Perpetual wants Olver out, plus the companys senior independent director, Sir Peter Mason. Woodford usually gets his way (just ask David Brennan, departed chief executive of AstraZeneca) and his funds 13.3% shareholding represents a big obstacle to Olvers ambition of leaving in May 2014 after a decade at the helm. Olver clearly wants to try. BAEs position is that the majority of the companys principal shareholders are supportive. Well see if that statement looks robust in, say, a fortnights time. If it does, Olver may be able to dig in. If not, its surely game over. Woodfords only wingmen at the moment are Artemis and Henderson. One purpose of their joint letter to the board, it would seem, was to encourage undecided shareholders to make up their minds. Three or four big-name recruits to the cause would probably be enough. Few chairmen can survive if opposition to their presence passes 20%. Olvers main problem is that he cant point to many recent successes. Hes been at the helm for eight years but the share price currently stands at 2005 levels, depressed in part by the perception that BAE overpaid when buying United Defense Industries and Armor Holdings in the US. Those deals, and the sale in 2006 of the 20% stake in Airbus, set the companys course towards the US defence industry. But last months proposal to merge with EADS was a belated embrace of the civilian market and Europe. Strategic confusion or free-thinking opportunism? Thats one debate. Another is whether the opportunity ever really existed. The deal collapsed because of politics in Berlin but could have been felled by any number of other hurdles not least the opposition of Woodford himself. Add it all up, and Olvers chances of staying until 2014 look about 50-50. Heres a view from an undeclared shareholder: The company is at a crossroads. In those circumstances, it is often helpful to have a change at the top. Olver has his work cut out.
Costa Coee
Nothing frothy or ashy just solid business sense, says Simon Bowers
It is wise of Costa Coee bosses not to hold their breath for hordes of tax campaigners, intellectuals and poets rushing to patronise its 1,479 cafes in protest at the tax aairs of Starbucks. Reminiscent of Pariss Left Bank establishments they are not. Nevertheless, YouGovs latest brand preference survey suggests Costa is continuing to show a clean pair of heels to Starbucks in UK aections. Costas parent group Whitbread has avoided the kind of tax acrobatics that last week provoked outrage against Starbucks. It has long resisted the siren calls of nancial engineers promising an easy boost to the bottom line and to boardroom bonuses. There is nothing clever or ashy about Whitbread. And this explains a lot about how the group has found itself a standout success story in Britains embattled leisure industry. Yesterday it delivered yet another strong set of results, with half-year revenue bursting through 1bn for the rst time Growth has been generated by new Costas and Premier Inns across Britain, and many more overseas. There are 10,000 more British jobs promised over the next three years. If Whitbread has outperformed its UK-listed peers, the contrast with other competitors is even more stark. Starbucks is mired in controversy about whether it has been meaningfully profitable in Britain for the last 14 years. Travelodge, private equity-backed, has presided over a calamitous destruction of value and was forced into a rescue deal with landlords last month. Those at the top of Whitbread have never enjoyed anything close to the pay windfalls seen at competitors which then went on to fare so poorly. But better builders of long-term shareholder value, in the leisure sector at least, you will struggle to nd.
The A350 on the nal assembly line in Toulouse, France. An Airbus CEO said a last opportunity had been missed Photograph: Jean-Philippe Arle/Reuters
long-distance A350 plane, Butschek said Airbus doesnt have any need to change our industrial footprint, referring to the companys pan-European manufacturing strategy. Because Airbus has no advanced plans for an entirely new plane, Butschek said, there was no need for a decision on the location of future Airbus work. As long as the decisions are not made [about next generation programmes] there is no need to decide on the allocation of the work package, said Butschek. However, the A350 carries an additional boost to UK manufacturing: it uses Trent XWB engines made by Derby-based Rolls-Royce. The UK accounts for around 15% of all Airbus manufacturing and the com-
pany has a workforce of 10,000 in Britain, largely at its wing manufacturing plant in Broughton, north Wales, and at its design and testing facility in Filton near Bristol. The rms production footprint is a legacy of its complex origins as a combination of aerospace manufacturers. EADS, the Airbus parent, is controlled by the French and German governments, who hold 22.35% each of the business. Concerns over their inuence in a combined BAE/ EADS helped scupper the deal, with the German chancellor, Angela Merkel, considered the most implacable obstacle. The Airbus chief executive, Fabrice Brgier, indicated the company will focus on markets such as China and the US.
26
27
Global gathering Pilgrims wait for the start of prayers at the Grand Mosque in Mecca. Muslims from all over the world have been arriving in the city for the hajj, which starts today Photograph: Fayez Nureldine/AFP/Getty Images
28
Financial
A student plays the trumpet during an anti-austerity protest yesterday in front of the Greek parliament in Athens, where political leaders failed to agree a 13.5bn package of spending cuts and tax increases Photograph: Yorgos Karahalis/Reuters
43
The share of the total market of cross-Channel tunnel and ferry services that the Eurotunnel group now handles
trac records. Our exibility enabled us to provide an excellent quality of service and to attract new customers away from the airlines. He admitted: Eurostar was slightly disappointing, but we had signicant levels of trac in the Olympics period and the Paralympics too. He estimated the additional level of trac due to the Games to be a boost of 3%. The group now accounts for 43% of the total cross-Channel market of tunnel and ferry services. Gounon said: The strong gures arent just the direct deliveries and visitors but the indirect effect the Olympics had in generating interest in London. We believe that there is a kind of post-Olympics eect that continues to generate business and supports the market. He added: We believe that the truck market will continue to grow at 3% a year in 2013 although still below 2007 levels.
Reviews Reviews
Autumn leaves From Twombly to Titian, the artists take on the turning season guardian.co.uk/art
Glitter, gold and utter self-belief but shes still Jenny from the block
Pop
Jennifer Lopez 02, London
Its surprising to learn that Jennifer Lopez had never headlined her own tour before her current jaunt. Most divas in her glittery league consider an occasional sweep of global arenas essential for keeping fans on side, but then again, J-Lo has always given the impression that her pop career is fairly low on her list of priorities. Shes better known as an actor, entrepreneur and emblem of Hispanic America than she is for any of her albums. Banks of empty seats at this show suggest she may have left it too long. Now that shes nally got around to it, though, shes giving it the 1,000% customarily demanded by talent show judges. The theme of the set is New York, alluded to by a backdrop showing the Statue of Libertys crown studded with diamonds, and Lopezs every atom is permeated with the citys go-getting condence. Shes not the strongest vocalist in the world, and too many of tonights 18 or so pop-R&B tracks leave no aftertaste, but Lopez could teach Madonna a thing or two about selfbelief. Thundering around the stage, shaking hands with overwhelmed fans (Dont cry! she sternly instructs), shes warm, funny and, despite the gloss, very real. Im just a simple girl from the Bronx, she informs us with a gurative wink and nudge. The show takes the girl-from-the-hood idea and runs with it. Ushered on by a troupe of dancers dressed in Broadway-inspired top hats and tails, she immediately rips o her oor-length skirt, revealing a sequined leotard. Thus dressed for battle, she steams in and roars through Get Right, Love Dont Cost a Thing and Im Into You. These three summarise her musical breadth as well as anything skittering hip-pop, bouncy bubblegum and handsin-the-air club fare but they would be so much generic dance-pap if Lopez werent there, giving them life through sheer alpha-female force. A costume change later, shes in a boxing ring, singing Goin In; then she clambers into a gold tracksuit to go back to the Bronx, where she leads the dancers through a quickstep Jenny from the Block. Were transported to an oldschool uptown theatre for Hold It Dont Drop It, and to the ctitious Club Babalu during Papi. All these vignettes are executed with such moxie that she can be forgiven a ve-minute video montage of her with her four-year-old twins. At the end, it isnt J-Lo the mother or even J-Lo the diva who sticks in the mind, but Jenny from the block, who still knows where she came from. Caroline Sullivan presented in Exaudis 10th-birthday concert. Typically, the programme juxtaposed old and new, with madrigals taken from the third and fourth books by Monteverdi, and the fth and sixth by Gesualdo, performed with the same fastidious attention to detail, one singer to a part, that the group brought to each contemporary work. There was a benchmark for the new pieces, too, in three of Salvatore Sciarrinos 12 Madrigals from 2008 brief, exquisite Italian settings of Japanese haiku that instantly conjure Sciarrinos unique soundworld of sighs and whispers. None of the new pieces equalled Sciarrinos for vividness, nor matched the brilliant mix of narration and evocation of the other miniature in the programme, Morgan Hayess 2010 E Vesuvio Monte. Larry Govess Sherpa Tensing Stands Up from the Piano set a repetitive text by Matthew Welton in a vaguely Italianate way, though the joke wore thin rather quickly, while Christian Wol had used brief, deliberately everyday texts by John Ashbery for three austerely homophonic pieces. Evan Johnsons Three in, ad Abundantiam, took scraps of a Petrarch sonnet and atomised them further into isolated sounds and syllables, while in Sesto Libro di Carlo Gesualdo, Michael Finnissy added further decorative layers to the already rich mix of Se la Mia Morte Brami from Gesualdos nal collection, neatly bringing Exaudis celebration full circle. Andrew Clements
Lazarus sounded far more powerful with Klezmatics support than on her album, and the collaboration continued with a stirring and jazzy klezmer-swing workout, and the celebratory nale of an old socialist Yiddish anthem. They should do this again. Robin Denselow
29
Comedy
Joan Rivers Royal Albert Hall, London
The Albert Hall doesnt look as stately as it did but its still incongruous to see Joan Rivers in this grand old rotunda, making the air curl with malice, mischief and the monstering of pieties. She prowls the stage, with the bristling energy of someone half her age (actually, scratch that: Im half her age and was out of breath just watching). And tonight, her rants against the Kardashians, the Germans, thin people, and, crucially, herself brook no opposition. Its a far cry from Rivers recent outing in a small-scale play on the Edinburgh fringe about her life. That was introspective, whereas tonight Rivers is a sequin-studded up-yours to reection of any kind. Her act is what happens when speech precedes thought, a devil-onthe-shoulders stream of consciousness venting every prejudice and neurosis, and to hell with how we usually dress up those impulses for public consumption. Its not always witty. Wit isnt the point; audacity is. She shouldnt be able to get away with saying: Mexicans are so ugly, they make Haitians look attractive. But she does because the joke is clearly on Joan, a persona that brings to a head the me, me, me vacuity of consumercelebrity culture. Its also because of the emphatic absurdity of it all, as when she depicts the chain-smoking Japanese midget who plays Tom Cruises infant daughter for a living. Occasionally, the shallowness grates, as with her Union ag-bedecked encore, when she hymns the adorableness of Kate Middleton. I found this more oensive than her Chinese-bashing shtick, which is somehow beautiful in its brutality (We dont eat dog! We dont eat dog! And theres a fucking leash hanging out of their mouth. They fucking eat dog!) At 79, Rivers is ageing heroically, getting nastier and livelier where others are stoical. This isnt raging against the dying of the light its throwing yourself headlong into the darkness and coming back with a supernova. Brian Logan
Theatre
A Midsummer Nights Dream Royal Lyceum, Edinburgh
Towards the start of Shakespeares comedy, the fairy queen Titania tells her lover Oberon how their quarrel has turned nature upside down. The seasons alter, she says, and the mazed world knows not which is which. Much later, as the play nears its conclusion, would-be husband Demetrius confesses that his love for Hermia is now melted as the snow. Neither line usually catches the attention, but here in Matthew Lentons production, both leap out. This particular Midsummer Nights Dream is set in the depths of winter: fairies in white toss snowakes into the air, the rude mechanicals huddle in their overcoats and, at moments of greatest tension, blizzards blow up. To prove their mettle in front of Helena, rivals Demetrius and Lysander strip down to their bare chests in a feat of icy endurance. Its an idea that minimises the plays sense of feverish midsummer madness, but replaces it with a vision of rebirth and renewal. With the return of sanity come spring owers pushing through the frozen stage and the promise of a fertile future. The image is reinforced in a framing device, in which Jordan Youngs excellent Bottom sits at his wifes hospital bedside, waiting for signs of recovery. The whole play is his dream complete with the funny and surreal image of his fellow mechanicals doubling as fairies during his transformation into a donkey and its resolution oers him personal hope. Despite these arresting ideas often realised with striking beauty th on Kai Fischers set the hers production scores less well in n making you care about the u lovers. Dressed in primary ssed colours, like extras from a 1970s ke sci- series, they do better at s, comedy than romance. an Because we dont fall e in love with them h ourselves, their eventual union carries no special frisson. son. Mark Fisher er Until 17 November. Box vember. oce: 0131-248 4848. -248 248 Excellent Jordan Young in A Midsummer Nights Dream eam
World music
The Klezmatics with Sophie Solomon Union Chapel, London
The Klezmatics have been one of the most adventurous roots bands in New York for more than quarter of a century. Their starting point is klezmer, the music that was traditionally performed at Jewish weddings and celebrations across eastern Europe, which has enjoyed a revival in the west, thanks in no small part to this band. Its not just a dance style, as they showed with their rst song, a thoughtful lament in Yiddish sung by the black-hatted Lorin Sklamberg, a multi-instrumentalist with a haunting, soulful voice, backed by cimbalom, ute, violin and trumpet. Then they were o, starting with a brassy reminder of how klezmer fused with jazz in America, followed by dance songs driven by Sklambergs accordion and violin solos from Lisa Gutkin. Then they switched styles again for a set of songs in which they matched their own music to lyrics written but never m performed by Woody Guthrie. p Now they sounded like a classy N American folk band, stomping A sedately through Mermaid Avenue sed and showing o exquisite, six-part s harmonies on Holy Ground, which harm sounded more like a spiritual than sound klezmer. They are impressive kl musicians, all they lacked was the m little extra verve and attack that l those songs required. t They were joined for part of their set by special guest Sophie Solomon, a classically trained violinist who has clas had an uneven career. She started out with the adventurous London klezmer-fusion band Oi Va Voi, but then klezm aimed for the mass market with Poison aime Sweet Madeira, a less successful solo Swee album. Now shes artistic director of album the Jewish Music Institute, and still an J engagingly amboyant player. Her song enga
Classical
Exaudi Wigmore Hall, London
Its a decade now since the conductor and composer James Weeks and soprano Juliet Fraser brought together a group of young singers, a consort rather than a choir, to perform contemporary music. Exaudi have gone on to build an international reputation, with a steadily increasing list of important premieres to their credit, and have marked their anniversary by guaranteeing themselves a lot more, inviting composers to contribute short settings to a 21stcentury book of madrigals. The rst results of that initiative were
30
Comment
Debate
Seumas Milne The presidential foreign policy debate showed how close the candidates were and how far from their own public opinion
Aung Americans would also gain EuropesKyi San Suu from scaling back the empire
Georey Robertson
The US empire is in decline, hastened by overreach in the war on terror and paid for in blood and treasure
hoever runs Washington heads a global empire. American politics aects peoples lives in every part of the world, often as a matter of life or death. So its scarcely surprising that more than 40% of those polled around the world say they want the right to vote in US presidential elections. After all, the American revolution was fought on the slogan of no taxation without representation. So long as the US government arrogates to itself the right to impose its leadership by force across the world, a contemporary version of the colonists demand might be: no global power without accountability. And with George Bushs blooddrenched presidency still fresh in the memory, its only to be expected that 81% want to see the less belligerent Barack Obama re-elected. Only in Pakistan, target of relentless civilianslaughtering US drone attacks, do a larger number prefer his Republican opponent, Mitt Romney. Of course, enfranchising foreigners is fantasy. Only US citizens will have a say in these elections, and barely half of them are likely to bother to vote. Their choice will be made overwhelmingly on domestic issues, not how the administration should deploy its fearsome arsenal on the other side of the world. The race is tight mainly because the economy is still hobbled and poverty has risen 19% since 2000. But for all Obamas disappointments and an electoral system in the grip of the wealthy, the domestic choice is real enough: from spending and taxes to healthcare and abortion facing a challenger who thinks 47% of Americans are scroungers. But for most of Monday nights candidates TV debate on foreign policy, it was hard to put a credit card between them. They competed to demonstrate unconditional commitment to Israel, determination to prevent Iran developing nuclear weapons at all costs and their rm intention to compel China to play by the rules. Romney had sharply toned down his more menacing rhetoric. Apart from grumbling about Obamas lack of strong leadership, his inner hawk only really broke cover to insist on direct arming of the Syrian rebels and the necessity of yet further decit-defying increases in the already gargantuan US military budget. At one point the Republican rightwinger even criticised Obama for behaving as if the US could kill our way out
of this mess in the Muslim world. That shouldnt be taken too literally. If nothing else, the experience of Bush who presented himself as a compassionate conservative with a humble foreign policy in 2000 and went on to launch the most devastating war of aggression in modern American history is an object lesson. But Romneys determination to shake o his image as a warmonger reects the need at least to nod to US public opinion. Unlike the Washington establishment, large majorities of Americans believe neither the Iraq nor Afghanistan wars were worth ghting, polling shows; more than three-quarters think the US plays world policeman more than it should; and most want military spending cut, reject a US strike on Iran, and oppose arming Syrias opposition. But that also underlines how little inuence most people in the US (as in Britain) have on their governments foreign policy and military adventures. For all Obamas tone of reason and his stand against the Iraq war, his record is anything but pacic. He accelerated withdrawal from Iraq, but escalated the war in Afghanistan and failed to subdue armed resistance, at a cost of thousands of extra deaths. He sharply intensied the drone war in Pakistan, spreading it to Somalia and Yemen, personally vetting the kill lists while expanding legitimate targets to include all military-age males. He backed Natos war in Libya, ratcheting up the death toll at least tenfold
and unleashing mass ethnic cleansing; supported the suppression of Gulf protest; and managed a violent coup in Honduras to a successful conclusion. With a little help from Congress, he reneged on his pledge to close the Guantnamo internment camp, acquiesced in Israels refusal to end illegal colonisation of Palestinian territory, and has now dispatched US troops to sub-Saharan Africa and Jordan. Whatever the personal views of the politician at the top, the US empire is a system, not a policy, underpinned by corporate and military interests. Romney would very likely be a more dangerous leader, but almost every US president has sanctioned military action, and the risk of war with Iran or growing intervention in Syria would remain under a second Obama term. But its also a system in evident decline, hastened by overreach in the war on terror and paid for in blood and treasure both by Americans and across the world. US military spending is larger than the combined spending of the next 20 powers combined, its troops stationed in a majority of countries. Of course the rest of the world doesnt really want a vote in American elections but the US o its back. Far better for most Americans, too, if that bloated military budget were to be slashed, troops withdrawn and bases closed and the money spent instead on jobs, schools and health in the US itself. Twitter: @SeumasMilne
BELLE MELLOR
Stalinist justice was used to crush Ukraines former prime minister. Today the UN will hear of her plight
ulia Tymoshenko, heroine of the orange revolution and the only woman ever to achieve prime ministerial oce in the former Soviet republics, is not allowed to stand in Ukraines current national election. For the last 15 months she has been in prison, convicted for actions that would not amount to a crime in any other democracy. She is subjected to the grossest invasion of her privacy (almost every movement she makes is videoed) and constantly defamed by the president and his tame prosecutors. Europe seems to have abandoned her; but today, at the UNs human rights committee, the UK can bring her situation to the worlds attention. Her innocence of any real crime is clear from the judgments at her trial and nal appeal. She was convicted of the vague charge of abuse of oce by reaching a deal with Putin which resolved a gas crisis in January 2009 that risked causing deaths in central Europe. Russia had cut o gas to Ukraine and through it, to a number of countries and was going to continue doing so unless transportation charges were increased. With the encouragement of the EU and Angela Merkel, Tymoshenko ew to Moscow and reached a compromise. Her opponents thought she should have held out for better terms. The issue was fully canvassed over the next few months in the presidential election, in which she was narrowly beaten by Viktor Yanukovych (winner of the rigged 2004 election that the orange revolution overturned). An example of functioning democracy, you might think. But not in Ukraine, where Tymoshenko was then prosecuted. It was not suggested she had made a penny out of the gas deal, or had been dishonest or criminal in any accepted sense of that word. Her crime, according to her judge, was that she had acted in her personal interests, desiring to create for herself the image of an ecient leader of its state who could deal with the gas crisis shortly before the presidential elections. In other words, she had acted as any other populist leader in a democracy she had resolved a crisis, then submitted herself and her conduct to the electorate. The charge had been used by the regime to silence a political opponent. Ukraine maintains the Stalinist system whereby the prosecution service (its top ocials appointed by the president) controls the courts. Its judges have no independence. This can be proven by a single statistic: the conviction rate in criminal cases is an incredible 99.8%. On his appointment, Tymoshenkos prosecutor, Viktor Pshonka, declared himself on the presidents team and his deputy appears regularly on TV to defame her. If judges rule against the prosecution in a political trial, it then prosecutes them for the oence of being untrue to their oath. They do not have tenure until they serve loyally for ve years. Tymonshenkos judge was plucked from a small town court and given the most important trial in Ukraines history. He showed his colours by a brutal early decision to put Tymoshenko in prison. Her sentence seven years and an order to pay $186m was calculated to destroy her. And all for acting as a prime minister should, to avert a humanitarian crisis in central Europe. Once, Stalinist systems delivered telephone justice a call to the judge from the party boss. In Ukraine it is megaphone justice: the president and his prosecutors publicly declared Tymoshenko guilty before her trial, and a lickspittle judge then did their bidding. The Council of Europe has passed motions condemning her treatment but has done nothing to sanction her persecutors or to suspend Ukraines membership. When Britain speaks at the UN, it must make clear that Yulia Tymoshenko has become Europes Aung San Suu Kyi. Georey Robertson is the author of Crimes Against Humanity
he report published yesterday by HM Inspectorate of Prisons into the governments rst family friendly detention facility for parents and children awaiting forced removal from the UK is a mixed bag. The chief inspector of prisons, Nick Hardwick, describes the unit Cedars, near Gatwick as an exceptional facility. But there is also plenty of criticism in his report. Hardwick highlights the unacceptable force used against a pregnant woman in a wheelchair and ags up force used on six of 39 families placed in the facility. He adds that children became very distressed during removals, and says it was not possible to measure the psychological impact of that process on them. Incidents of self-harm along with shortcomings in healthcare and training were also pointed out. What this report does not do is address two of the continuing controversies surrounding the detention of children for immigration purposes. But its publication is a timely reminder that they are a long way from resolution. The rst concerns the fact that the coalition government in general, and deputy prime minister Nick Clegg in particular, have maintained a consistent narrative that child detention has ended. The governments own data relating to numbers of children detained proves this is not true. The second is the continued and controversial involvement of the childrens charity Barnardos, which has a contract with government to sta the
centre alongside G4S, the rm behind the Olympics security asco. G4S has been the subject of many allegations of assault by immigration detainees including Jimmy Mubenga, who died during an attempt to remove him. The Lib Dems promised to end child detention in their 2010 manifesto, and they insist they have delivered on this objective. Clegg received much adulation from the organisation Citizens UK at his partys conference last month for ending child detention. Basking in their gratitude, Clegg said: Were not accustomed to being thanked for pledges weve kept. Yet the governments own gures show that the number of children they are detaining is on the rise. A total of 91 children were detained last year. In the rst six months of this year 107 children were detained, 35 of them not in the family friendly Cedars but in ordinary immigration removal centres such as Tinsley House, near Gatwick. Clegg is engaging in a form of doublespeak. In the face of the statistical evidence from his own government, he continues to insist that child detention has ended. And what of Barnardos, which attracted a urry of controversy when it was announced that it would be working with UK Border Agency to help sta Cedars? The childrens charity insisted that if certain red lines were crossed, it would walk away from the contract. The red lines include disproportionate use of force, use of Tinsley House as an overow facility, and the detention of families more than twice. Hardwick stated that one family was detained three times, and several were detained
twice, as well as describing the use of force on the pregnant woman as unacceptable. Alison Worsley, Barnardos deputy director of strategy, insists: We have always been clear that our involvement at Cedars does not stop us speaking out on behalf of asylum-seeking families. We raise any concerns with UKBA at the time that they arise at the appropriate level, from operations up to ministers, and have already spoken out twice publicly. The government insists that only families who have exhausted their appeal rights will end up in Cedars. Yet nine of the 39 families who have been detained there were released, suggesting that their appeals were not exhausted, and so they should not have been there in the rst place. The government has tried extremely hard to convince us that child detention has ended, but this years gures continue to creep upwards. Those who are campaigning to end the detention of children say their work is not yet done. In the meantime Clegg and the organisations who champion him for ending child detention need to stick to the facts. The xtures and ttings at Cedars are prettier than in the rest of the governments immigration removal estate, but Hardwicks report has highlighted some of the same concerns that existed about child detention in its previous incarnation in various immigration removal centres. If the government really wants to end child detention, it should stop detaining children. Diane Taylor is a freelance human rights journalist and author
The Guardian | Wednesday 24 October 2012 Follow us on Twitter @commentisfree Join us on Facebook facebook.com/guardiancomment
*
Comment editor: Becky Gardiner Telephone: 020 3353 4995 Fax: 020 3353 3193 Email: cif.editors@guardian.co.uk
31
Simon Jenkins In our rush to apportion blame for the actions of an individual, we risk becoming blind to the real issues of the day
The problem with the BBCs metropolitan programmers was that they could not tell a Savile from a Cilla Black
Murdoch in the same seat last spring, giving much the same answers, if less elegantly. The BBC is an archetypal case of corporate elephantiasis, an organisation too big to take clear and swift decisions. Its senior managers are lost in a corporate maze of directorates, divisions, Chinese walls and spectrums of delegation. He could not begin to explain how an editor-in-chief was not a chief editor, or how the head of television was not, in fact, the head of television. The BBC makes the Vatican seem like a corner shop. The corporation may be commended for the vigour with which its disparate empire, from news to Panorama, reported on the miseries of its elders. But if there is one group that BBC journalists hate even more than the Murdoch family, it is their own bosses. For two days, the Today radio programme revelled in their distress. Its presenters could not stop talking about it, hauling in fellow employees to declare the crisis the worst in 50 years, and their superiors to be close to toast. The reality is that the BBCs survival depends on its self-abasement. Given its unique status as a statutory body and its near monopoly of broadcast news, anything less than total disclosure would be inexcusable. Jimmy Savile mesmerised the BBC in life, as now he does in death. Its metropolitan programmers indulged him outrageously, assuming him to be the authentic voice of working-class eccentricity. Their problem was that they could not tell a Savile from a Cilla Black. It is hard to see what real benet will come from any of this. The case is awash in malice, vilication, exaggeration and litigation. After yesterdays grilling, the BBC might well decide never again to let a child near a male studio presenter. Hospitals will be advised to recruit chaperones for males in childrens wards. MPs would apparently deplore anyone permitting children near adult strangers. Nor are children the only consideration. The Commons yesterday elided paedophilia with sexual harassment. Again the consequence must surely be for the BBC, and any entertainment organisation, to deny lone females entry to mens dressing rooms unaccompanied, for fear of having permitted
sexual harassment. This already applies to school and university tutorials, irrespective of the age of those involved. Soon doctors, lawyers and priests will have to practise, like the police, in pairs. Responsibility for our behaviour apparently no longer rests on us as individuals but on anyone whom a lawyer can claim was responsible for our contact with others. We are no longer our own masters. This is the royal road to Orwellian hell. The recent disproportionate treatment of phone hacking is threatening the media, not with the already existing criminal law, but with statutory restrictions on its work in respect of personal (and perhaps corporate) privacy. These restrictions seem likely to be out of all proportion to the harm they seek to avert. The same may now apply after Savile.
hose running big organisations, in the public and private sectors, face a lethal pincer movement. On the one side is a rising tide of risk aversion, seeping into every factory, oce and profession, stiing enterprise, reassessing risk, clogging decision. On the other is a fear of what happens should this process fail. Just as the concept of an accident has slid from legal status, so has the honest mistake. When Entwistle yesterday admitted and regretted his mistake in not asking in more detail about the Savile programme, his tormenters hardly noticed. Honest mistakes do not exist, being replaced by only the most serious and probably criminal negligence, t only for the pillory, the stocks or the gallows. We now have a new form of accountability, to an inquiriat, a cackle of inquisitors and lawyers jumping to the bidding of public opinion, apping round every executives head and piling accusation on every error. This can only lead to ever more defensive behaviour in every sphere of public life. It is the paranoia of the modern state. Every document is open, every conversation on the record and your friend today is tomorrow the witness against you. simon.jenkins@guardian.co.uk
32
Chain of command
Hands clean or hands-o ? That is the immediate judgment to reach on George Entwistle over the Jimmy Savile aair. The director general went to parliament yesterday to prove that he had kept a virtuous distance from decisions about what the BBC would broadcast about its late, disgraced star. But the prevailing impression was of an editor-in-chief who kept himself rather too far from the fray. After three fumbling weeks, it was a mediocre performance. Perhaps it was unrealistic to have hoped that he could answer the hankering for somebody to grip this whole horrid business. We are, after all, talking about four decades of abuse, both within and beyond a corporation of 8,000 journalists. The principal culprit was protected by countless blind eyes, and by an on-screen culture which tittered indulgently at lechery, as if it were only natural for red-blooded males. Given the allegations about what he was up to backstage, it is chilling to watch old Top of the Pops clips in which Savile hugs young girls too close. Even at the time, there would have been outrage if the full facts had come to light. A mix of indierence and incuriosity ensured they never did. The Tory MP Philip Davies sought to pin all this on a DG who has been in post for ve weeks, grilling him about which managers held keys to the Savile dressing room in days so distant that Mr Entwistle himself was a child. The rest of the culture committee concentrated on the ditched Newsnight expos of Savile. The row has become an outlet for wider revulsion, whose real target lies in the ground. The BBCs own Panorama had done valuable spadework for the committee the night before, an impressively open contrast with other media organisations; recall that not long ago one apologised for having employed an investigator to keep MPs under surveillance. Nonetheless, this proxy row matters in its own right. The public service ideal relies on BBC journalists being free to follow their noses without fear or favour. Newsnight editor Peter Rippon pulled the report on Savile for reasons that remain unclear. Mr Entwistles initial lack of interest invites scrutiny, as does the his senior colleague Helen Boadens warning to Mr Rippon about maintaining editorial standards on this story. The committee ought to want to hear from both Ms Boaden and Mr Rippon, but has declined to call the latter. Then it needs to hear from Mark Thompson, for it was he and not Mr Entwistle who was DG at this time. There may be institutional as well as personal failures a healthy reluctance to manage editorial decisions downward may have grown warped into a failure to refer conict up. All of this needs clearing up, but these mistakes should not be confused with the alleged crimes themselves, or the culture that allowed them to happen.
Rachel Shabi With many Palestinians and Israelis coming round to the idea of a binational state, a peaceful future can be glimpsed
e could argue over who killed it, but whats the point? Its increasingly obvious that a continued insistence on zombie peace talks between Israelis and Palestinians is deluded, because the two-state principle framing them is dead. To prcis: its now impossible to remove half a million Jewish settlers and infrastructure from the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem; the international community is opposed to settlements on paper but does nothing in practice, and after 19 years of failed two-state talks, the fault plainly lies in the plan, not the leadership. This view has been expressed more vocally of late on both sides, from unlikely quarters and for dierent reasons. Prominent Israeli commentators have declared the end of the two-state period. The latest to do so was the veteran journalist Nahum Barnea, who in August wrote in the mass-circulation Yediot Aharonot that the Oslo two-state peace process is dead. His view Everybody knows how this will end. There will be a bi-national [state], he claried on Israeli TV is shared by others once supportive of the Oslo framework but now calling time on it. I do not give up on the two-state solution on ideological grounds, wrote Haaretz columnist Carlo Strenger last month. I give up on it because it will not happen. Were also starting to see the practical consequences of those Jewish settlers who, surprisingly, started talking about one-state approaches two years ago. Last week a Palestinian village in an Israel-controlled area of the West Bank
was given building permits the rst time thats happened during a 45-year Israeli occupation thanks to petitions from their Jewish settler neighbours. Meanwhile, rightwing Israeli politicians such as Knesset speaker Reuven Rivlin and ex-defence minister Moshe Arens have been arguing for one state and while their vision isnt premised on immediate equal citizenship, they have taken the sting out of the subject. Among Palestinians, support for a one-state approach is also growing. A poll last month showed that support for a one-state formulation premised on equal rights has inched up among both Palestinians and Israelis. In the West Bank, there are fresh peaks of disillusion with the Palestinian Authority whose tenure was always supposed to be temporary, pending statehood, as set out in the Oslo Accords. Unelected, tainted by corruption, aid-dependent and viewed as enforcers of the Israeli occupation, the PAs last stab at credibility was probably its statehood bid at the UN last year. But you could practically hear the hope hissing out of that media-inated bid when, pressured by the US, Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas switched to a hollowed-out version that was meaningless and destined to fail. Now a new generation of Palestinian activists are bypassing territorial demands to focus on civil rights and freedoms. In Israel, there are green shoots of debate around practical questions of how to share the space between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River. Weeks ago, Israeli analyst and blogger Dahlia Scheindlin previously a twostate advocate set out a list of key questions and suggestions, concerning issues such as voting systems, refugees and land rights. Already, Israeli intel-
lectuals are working out the idea that Jewish claims to the region currently enforced with guns and walls would need instead to be enshrined by law, alongside equally guaranteed Palestinian protections. In his new book, Beyond the Two State Solution, Israeli sociologist Yehouda Shenhav draws on a pre-Israeli, bi-national strain of Zionism that was historically drowned out but should now, he argues, be reclaimed. Countering a common criticism of one-state proposals, these emerging formulations dont insist that Palestinians and Israelis give up outdated attachments to nationalism which is helpful, because it seems that neither side wants to, yet. A small group of Palestinians, Israelis and Jewish settlers, Eretz Yoshveyha land of its inhabitants set out principles for a single spatial polity last year, among them safeguarding the collective rights of the two nations. One settler tells me of a consensus emerging within nascent, one-state settler groups that, while national identity may be important, exclusive Jewish sovereignty is not. Its all germinal and there are problems, of course. Most Palestinians
Now a new generation of Palestinian activists are bypassing territorial demands to focus on civil rights and freedoms
and Israelis still support a two-state framework, even while believing it doomed. Shared-space alternatives have grassroots momentum, but no leadership support. The left needs to ensure Gaza remains part of the picture. And doubtless some West Bank settlers support one-stateism as a way of avoiding potential eviction, with scant regard for Palestinian rights. A recent poll suggests Israelis agree, with a majority supporting discriminatory policies if the West Bank were annexed. Tentative meetings between settlers and Palestinians could crash once they progress beyond relatively safe community issues a belief in the power of people sitting together over cups of tea was a theme of the peace process years, and look how that turned out. But one idea is crystallising: that clinging to a two-state approach is, by default, a victory for the far-right claims of one state called Greater Israel, with a Jewish minority and two ethnically coded tiers of rights and freedoms. Thats the reality on the ground, cemented by Israel while paying lipservice to the idea of Palestinian statehood. Now the Israeli government wants to consolidate this even further, through approval of a report that declares all settlements legal under international law enshrining the idea that the West Bank isnt occupied. In this context its heartening that peace camps on both sides are starting to break a period of paralysis, discarding the spent husks of the Oslo phase to claw back fresh thinking space. Its only when freed from the dead weight of a two-state paradigm that a just, dignied and peaceful solution has the chance to ourish. Rachel Shabi is the author of Not the Enemy: Israels Jews from Arab Lands
*
Kings Place, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU Telephone: 020 3353 2000 Fax: 020 3353 3193 Email: letters@guardian.co.uk We do not publish letters where only an email address is supplied; please include a full postal address, a reference to the article and a daytime
33
Reply
Letters and emails Skilled probation ocers cut crime
The prime ministers armation of rehabilitation as a guiding principle of penal policy is welcome (Editorial, 23 October), his vision of how it is to be achieved less so. In some respects he appears to be repeating the same ideas that have contributed to the relentless rise in the prison population with limited reduction in reconviction rates. A research study we have undertaken in co-operation with the Jersey probation service has found a strong link between probation ocer skills and the reconviction of those people they supervise in the community: put simply, the higher the level of skill, the lower the level of reconviction. One of the lessons is that successful rehabilitation is dependent on, among other things, sucient investment in the training and education of the professionals involved. Without an investment in the required resources, the prime ministers rhetoric will remain just that. Its now time to move towards a more serious commitment to developing evidence-based policies. Professor Maurice Vanstone, Professor Peter Raynor, Dr Pamela Ugwudike Swansea University Unmeasurable performance targets with the potential for perverse results do not seem to deter governments from introducing them. Payment by results based on reconviction rates provides a disincentive to organisations supervising oenders from reporting breaches of orders or further oending; not being reconvicted is not synonymous with not reoending. It makes me wonder whether there is a potentially lucrative market for me providing courses in alibi construction and evading detection. Roy Grimwood Market Drayton, Shropshire
telephone number. We may edit letters. Submission and publication of all letters is subject to our terms and conditions: see http://gu.com/letters-terms
The right are using this to attack the BBC when Savile may have got away with it by being one of us
Nick Toms
Bog-standard cubism Back to a world of bed and breakfasts and food banks
It is Picasso who will transform the images of the 21st century, not Duchamp (Report, 16 October). Duchamps cubism was naive: his nude descending a staircase is about the nude moving. Picassos was far more subtle, it being about us (the spectator) moving, ie living. The transformation of images is far more important than the transformation of Art. David Hockney Bridlington, East Yorkshire George McGovern dedicated his life to public service (including underreported but heroic military service), representing the most disadvantaged citizens, and feeding the poor. But in his obituary (22 October) he is remembered mainly for an election campaign in which he was subjected to practices that were vicious and illegal even by US standards. He was a good and decent man in a time that was neither, and it is a pity to see in his obituary another case of blaming the victim. John C Hirsh Washington DC Amid all the Audis, US holidays and houses with hot tubs (Report, 22 October), did not even a few of the 3,000 lottery millionaires consider sharing a little of their good fortune with, say, Amnesty International, the World Hunger Fund, Children In Need or Cancer Research? David Carl Guildford, Surrey How come a man who disrupts a sporting event by swimming in front of Oxford and Cambridge rowers but harms no one gets six months in jail, but one (with a record of hooliganism) who runs on to a football pitch and assaults the goalkeeper gets four months (Report, 23 October)? Anything to do with class and snobbery? Richard Bates Penzance, Cornwall The crisis in the eurozone demonstrates that there can be no monetary union without political integration. If Scotland gains independence while retaining sterling, it may prove convenient that Edinburgh is already the Athens of the North (Letters, 23 October). Dr Mark Ellis Hudderseld, West Yorkshire The cremation of one of my in-laws was accompanied by Bon Jovis Blaze of Glory (Letters, 23 October). David England Liverpool Amelia Gentlemans distressing article on the return of the bed and breakfast regime for homeless families (No place like home, G2, 16 October) takes those of us old enough to remember back to the bad old days we thought had gone for ever. The current ruthless rationing of the benet system will destroy all that was best about the postwar eorts of Beveridge, the architect of the welfare state, and of successive governments, determined to eliminate the destitution of prewar years. Benet cheating can be prevented by ecient administration and cannot justify hounding the vast majority of those in need of help, most of whom have paid their national insurance contributions while in work. Excessively high rents used to be controlled; why not now? How many new houses have been sold for private rental rather than for owner occupation? Dr Patricia Dale London The scourge of families living in squalid and unsuitable temporary accommodation aects people from all backgrounds, in all towns and cities. In my home town, middle-class Harrogate, there are dozens of working families living in council-run hostels. At the time of the last election, I spent some time with these families and was appalled at the conditions and the length of time they were expected to stay in temporary accommodation. These families, who have lived and worked in Harrogate all their lives, were expected to eke out an existence in conditions the Victorians would have been ashamed of. What kind of society are we when young children are being brought up for months in a hostel where they share a bedsit with their parents and siblings? I was no great defender of the Labour government. But anyone who argues that it makes no dierence who is in government should read this article and study the facts on homelessness. Daniel Maguire Newcastle upon Tyne The reports on hunger in schools (Report, 16 October) and on the rise in the number of people receiving food aid from food banks provide quantied examples of what anecdotally has been a growing issue for some time. Recent reports in London have included accounts from the police of children stealing bread for their families, and people going without food for a day at the end of the week when their money runs out to make sure their children eat. Most shocking, perhaps, is the speed at which the numbers of people accessing food banks is rising. In London, the Trussell Trust provided food for around 15,000 between April and September, 6,388 of whom were children. This is virtually the same as the number for the entire previous year. While part of the rise must be due to the rise in the number of food banks, the overall picture remains bleak. Government needs to do more than welcome the existence of food banks as a sign of a big society. They are a sign of a system that is failing large numbers of people, many of them working. I am leading an investigation on behalf of the London assemblys health and environment committee into the issue of food poverty and would welcome contributions to the consultation at www.london.gov.uk Fiona Twycross Labour, London assembly
Country diary
Freedom ghter
I trust that the Kalakuta Commune will acknowledge that Fela Kuti inherited some of his politics from his mother, Funmilayo Ransome-Kuti (Fela Kutis persecutors now dancing to the new tune, 20 October). Having set up a womens group to campaign against a variety of injustices to women and Nigerians in general, she founded the Federation of Nigerian Womens Societies in 1953 and became a very active member of the National Council of Nigeria and the Cameroons, struggling for independence. In the same year she was one of the speakers at the conference called by Kwame Nkrumah in the Gold Coast to foster African unity. She travelled so widely to foster African independence that the colonial government withdrew her passport in 1956. Her activism at home continued and she became one of the Nigerian representatives at the discussions in London for Nigerias independence in 1960. Marika Sherwood Senior research fellow, Institute of Commonwealth Studies
34
Secret lming by an undercover Panorama reporter showed serious abuse of vulnerable patients at Winterbourne View, a Castlebeck hospital Photograph: PA
says, referring to managers who werent seeing what was wrong. In March, having drawn up a detailed action plan, he was made executive chairman and told to go ahead and implement the 51-point plan. Since then, he has swept through the organisation, spending 8m, instituting new practices and clearing out most of the management. Since March we have had a full-on, A-to-Z turnaround of all and everything that Castlebeck involves to get it into some sort of shape that is attractive for [care] commissioners, right for patients and has some commercial reality to it, he says. Its not 100% yet you cant change every unit immediately but we have turned around now in over 80%, perhaps 90%, of the units. I think we reached that point about three or four weeks ago. It is a repaired business. Many will be sceptical of his claims. It is an open secret that Lydian and/or the banks are seeking a buyer for the company and there will be suspicions that the makeover is only skin-deep. But the company is being unusually transparent about the transformation it says it is undertaking, and some inuential voices in the care sector are impressed.
70
3m
The number of pounds spent on refurbishing and re-equipping Castlebecks 20 remaining units
that has been revamped radically: Sullivan says that half its members now have a medical or nursing background. These include Debra Moore, brought in as director of nursing and patient safety, who was a learning disability nurse adviser to the Department of Health and joint lead of Valuing People, a programme for learning disability. Lee Reed, who had recently been appointed as the companys chief executive at the time of the Winterbourne View scandal, and who declared himself personally ashamed, remains on the board as group director responsible for the separate mental health business. Moore has taken the main responsibility for quality, audit, clinical risk and compliance across the organisation. But Sullivan sees the unit managers as the key to the success of his action plan built on the ndings of consultants PwC and he has felt it necessary to take drastic measures. Probably 70% [of managers] have exited the business, he says euphemistically. You have got to have people who used to be a commissioner, or a senior nurse, and who are able to engage with commissioners in that same eld. Suddenly they click and they get it. He found some familiar faces among the s managers he inherited. There ed. were individuals that I had hat let go at other organisaganisations I turned around, he nd, says. They have moved on again. Sullivan is sure poor e management was at the root of Castlebecks mals aise. Winterbourne View ne was a photograph in time, he says. He describes the bes abuse as appalling ng b u t s ay s t h at
culture had been allowed to build up over a long period. He says he has found some stars among the 1,100 sta, who have been rewarded with promotion, but he has relied heavily on bringing in experienced interim managers (I have a little black book), about half of whom he expects to stay on permanently. All 20 remaining units in England and Scotland operating under the Castlebeck brand, and with a total capacity of about 350 people, have been refurbished and reequipped from top to bottom at a cost of 3m. More importantly, though, all users of services are now reassessed regularly, with the involvement of their families and care commissioners, to try to make sure they do not languish in the system. Some, Sullivan admits, ought to be receiving dierent care elsewhere. Various outside organisations, including Bild, have been contracted to oer support. Occupancy of the units, which dropped sharply after the revelations, has been rising again and, Sullivan says, is exceeding his target of 80% at 12 of the sites. For the rst time in 16 months, care professionals are said to be calling unprompted to inquire about job openings, while internal satisfaction ratings by commissioners and families, shared with Society Guardian, show a positive score though complaints about standards persist. The unanswered question is whether Castlebeck will wholly abandon the assessment-and-treatment model, as critics demand. Sullivan, who expects to remain at the company for only a few more months, says part of the turnaround involves placing the units on care pathways so that they play a clear, timelimited role in an individuals progress. He cites Thornfield Grange, formerly what he calls a generic learning disability facility in Bishop Auckland, County Durham, which has been converted into a rehabilitation unit for people with autism moving on from the companys service g near Darlington. Darlingt However, he believes there is a However continuing need for long-stay units for some p people who have been in hospital-type settings for most of hospital-t their lives. Its a very dicult area, lives but we do have people in the UK, perhaps aged 60, who have a 40a year background in these services backg and may have been heavily medih cated for m much of that time, Sullivan says. What is the future for say them if we do not provide a safe and support ive home for life?
35
Society daily Sign up for our weekday newsletter for the latest on public and voluntary sector news, comment and best of the blogs
Opinion
Mary OHara Drugs and alcohol spending must not lose out, says Gerry Stimson
The biggest-ever overhaul of the public health system in England becomes a reality in six months. Local authorities, most without any history of public health management, will take over responsibility for improving the health of local populations. Money currently spent on the delivery of drug, alcohol and sexual health services will contribute about 60% of the funding. But, as of April 2013, money previously ringfenced for those services will be lumped together with money for other public health services. No one really knows how clinical commissioning groups, responsible for commissioning local services, and local health and wellbeing boards will work together. There are fears that, with an emphasis on localism, access to drug and alcohol services could suer. Will councillors turn their backs on electorally unpopular services? Or will it lead to joined-up locally led responses that address issues across sectors and tackle the determinants of health and wellbeing? When galvanised by political will, cities act quicker and more comprehensively than governments. With the identication of Aids in the mid-1980s, several
GARY ROEBUCK/ALAMY
Second thoughts
In Stockholm, community involvement, bar sta training and stricter enforcement of existing alcohol laws has led to a 29% decrease in violent crimes. But cities can also get it wrong. In Vancouvers Downtown Eastside, large numbers of drug users with serious physical, mental and social problems were concentrated into an area the size of six blocks, with little or no services. In the UK, the regeneration of inner cities has concentrated bars and clubs into small areas, with competition for customers leading to unhealthy drinking incentives, overcrowding, lack of public toilets, and large numbers of people leaving at the same time and vying for scarce transport. Cities need to bring together expertise and powers across local planning, policing, licensing, urban design and transport, and environmental and public health in order to reduce alcohol-related issues. The changes being ushered in for public health provide huge potential to both maintain and improve alcohol, drug and sexual health services, and also to develop truly integrated responses. The evidence is in we would be foolish to ignore it as English public health takes its rst steps towards a new brave world.
Gerry Stimson is former executive director of the International Harm Reduction Association and director of KnowledgeAction-Change, co-organiser of the City Health 2012 conference (cityhealth.org.uk)
he language deployed to justify the governments cuts is so steeped in scaremongering and hyperbole it is a wonder anyone listens any more. The word austerity has become so loaded with political moralising its meaning has been distorted beyond recognition. But one phrase guaranteed to upset and anger people is the patent untruth Were all in this together. Today, as activists from the north-east of England arrive in parliament to present MPs with a report documenting the devastation inicted by government cuts on the women of their region, they will be the latest to expose the hollowness of such pronouncements of shared pain. The report, put together by a coalition of womens advocates and academics spearheaded by the North East Womens Network and the Womens Resource Centre, points to the fact that women in general have been grossly and adversely aected by the austerity programme. From the loss of hundreds of thousands of public-sector jobs to drastic revisions of benets and the closing of vital services used mainly by women, such as childrens centres, the wider gender dynamic is clear. However, the report seeks to highlight the disproportionate impact of government policies on the women of one of the UKs poorest areas. The organisation has pulled together evidence of just how deleterious the situation has become. In a region all too familiar with long-term unemployment and deprivation (a TUC report in September conrmed that the regions job market was the worst in England), the report documents the increasingly perilous position of women and predicts much worse to come when further welfare reforms hit. The report points specically to a number of key areas. Among these is the reliance of women in the region on employment in the public sector: 46% of all women working in the north-east higher than the national average of 40% have jobs in the public sector. This compares with 18% of working men in the region and, according to the reports authors, means the haemorrhaging of public-sector jobs has been particularly dramatic for female workers and their families, many of whom rely on womens wages to get by. With a pay gap between men and women that was already considerably higher than the national average (35% versus 21%), women have been at a serious disadvantage for some time, it concludes. A primary concern is that the stubborn gender inequality in the region is being entrenched by cuts to the services women need most, such as domestic violence and legal aid assistance. Womens groups across the region, and national bodies such as UK Feminista, which is organising a feminist lobby of parliament today, have told researchers that swingeing funding cuts and the closure of many services that work with vulnerable women and children will lead to an escalation in social problems ranging from family breakdown to domestic violence. On a whole raft of measures including educational attainment and health outcomes, women in many parts of the north-east fare badly compared with other parts of England, and the report underlines the fact that this stands to worsen if sucient resources are not available to women. Sue Robson, one of the reports authors, says this is not special pleading and she is right. Regional variations in deprivation and womens outcomes are nothing new. However, the painting over of these dierences with the vapid mantra Were all in this together ies in the face of the evidence and stores up problems for women in need and for the people who depend on them. Mary OHara is a social aairs writer and Fulbright scholar
A copy of the report, The impact of austerity measures upon women in the north-east of England, is available at newwomens.net
Swingeing cuts will lead to an escalation in social problems from family breakdown to domestic violence
cities in the UK and overseas, including Liverpool, San Francisco and Amsterdam, swiftly provided condoms and syringes to high-risk populations. In Liverpool, the Mersey harm reduction model involved the NHS, communities, primary care, police, church leaders, drug users and sex workers. It led to one of the rst needle exchanges in the UK, extensive outreach and an expansion of drug treatment. Cities can also deliver public health prevention. Community-based alcohol projects of the kind implemented in Glasgow, Birmingham and Cardi can reduce alcohol-related problems. The projects work best when there is a range of local actions that change the drinking environment, such as promoting responsible serving of alcohol in bars and shops, training bar sta, enforcing licensing laws, and working with transport and fast-food outlets (often a source of friction late at night).
hen the Australian prime minister, Julia Gillard, this month openly criticised misogyny (leading to a change in the the dictionary denition of the term), her comments went viral and were praised by my male and female Facebook friends alike. This was because her statement was rooted in experiences, rather than rhetoric, and struck a chord with many people, regardless of whether they identied themselves as feminist. In contrast, a Netmums survey this month showed feminism irrelevant to the vast majority of women and girls in the UK. The survey drew out a disconnect between how women and girls perceive feminism, and their experiences of inequality and discrimination. It reminded
36
Expert insight
What dierence will greater government transparency through open data make to citizens?
Sophia Oliver, director, Open Government Partnership, and transparency, Cabinet Oce Share and adapt We have a responsibility to put the data out so that others can use it, adapt it, combine it with other information and share it and, hopefully, provide feedback on it. Part of the transparency agenda has to be about asking: are we holding the right data? Are we publishing the right data? If we dont hold it, should we collect it and publish it? Marija Novkovic, project manager, United Nations Development Programme, Montenegro Relevant data Citizens are now being given access to raw data sets on many facets of public sector performance. But do citizens care about [spread]sheets? Probably not. Do they wish to know which hospital has the biggest survival rate in complex surgical procedures, [or] which bus routes are more reliable than others? Probably yes. Data should be used to tell stories; ideally it would be interpreted by infomediaries so that the citizens can relate to it. [But] does open data empower the already empowered? Do marginalised, vulnerable groups have access to the internet? Are they aware of open data portals? Will they help them access healthcare, join the labour market, access social welfare? Heather Savory, chair, Open Data User Group (ODUG) Community engagement The ODUG has been set up to represent the views of the open data community to government. The way ODUG is engaging is to open the door wide for members of the community to come forward with their thoughts on how we can best serve their data needs. [It] already has about 50 new requests. These are open for anyone to view and comment on at data. gov.uk. We have so far identied eight key themes for datasets land and property, environment, social organisations and companies, education, transport health and nancial. The Guardians professional networks bring together advice, insight and best practice from professionals. Read the full Q&A at http://bit.ly/QKpfk6
Jan Morgan with her daughter, who has been a primary carer for her since she was 12 Photograph: Andrew Fox
supposed to sit on this to have a shower, but couldnt get on or o without help. Some of the carers left me feeling I was about to fall o. Once I did slip o, and it was a struggle to get me back on. It didnt ll me with condence. A few carers had poor English, and none of them were able to put on my shoulder support correctly, which I wore for my partially dislocated shoulder. Putting it on was ddly and required practice. As there was no consistency of care, none of the carers had any opportunity to improve. The result was that for the rst month out of hospital I may as well have not worn the shoulder cu as it wasnt supporting my shoulder, which continued to be excruciatingly painful. The carers trudged mud, slush and dirt on the carpet up the stairs and across my bedroom. My bedroom carpet became filthy with footprints. We had no help for things like vacuuming, so again my daughter had to do everything. I often felt physically sick each morning as I woke to the dirt on my bedroom carpet and the arrival of yet another dierent carer, who was supposed to wash my intimate areas. I felt miserable, and began to hate going to
bed because I didnt want to face another morning start. Adult social care did investigate my complaint and found in my favour on eight separate instances, including the need to ensure that rotas should be scheduled to ensure continuity of care by having a smaller number of carers allocated to each person. A great deal is written about the importance of dignity, but it takes someone to complain before any action is taken or changes are made. A dierent care agency was appointed to provide my home care. The supervisor promised that morning care would arrive consistently and in good time for me to be up before my daughter left for school. She also said they would provide a cleaner for two hours a week. Things didnt begin well, as they were late on the rst day. The light cleaning didnt begin until six weeks after I left hospital. It included changing the bedding and doing some laundry. I dont know how I was supposed to manage before this, or indeed how I was supposed to manage with just two hours of help a week. In March last year, I received a letter informing me that after my nancial assess-
ment I needed to contribute to my daily care 5.07 a week more than I receive in benets. I had to make another complaint. By June 2011, I was moved on to direct payments. I was assessed as needing 14 hours of care a week, for which social services made a four-weekly payment. The onus was on me to nd, recruit and employ a personal assistant. I had to open a separate bank account, set up a payroll system and become an employer with all the legal responsibilities and obligations. If the PA didnt work out, I would be left in the vulnerable position of having to deal with diculties in my own home. At the time of writing, it has been more than a year since Ive had contact with a social worker. I could be struggling or worse. Fortunately I am ne and after two disasters we now have a wonderful PA, though the bulk of my care is still provided by my daughter who is now 14 years old. But what of elderly or more vulnerable people who are on their own? This is an extract from Stroke to Gold, Jan Morgans as yet unpublished book on her recovery
The car is a valuable place for open disclosure because it is truly private
37
Gallic tips What the UK can learn from Frances public reform programme guardian.co.uk/publicleaders-network.co.uk
Expert coverage Read about the National Children and Adult Services conference guardian.co.uk/socialcare-network
Curriculum vitae
Age 66. Lives Oakland, California. Family Divorced with two children. Education CK McClatchy high school, California; University of California, Berkeley, engineering BSc and design MA Career 2001-present: founder/ CEO, Family Independence Initiative; 1981-2000: executive director, Asian Neighbourhood Design; 1978-81: programme director of Asian Neighbourhood Design; 1972-78: student at UC Berkeley; 1968-72: Union Carbide, plant engineer; 1969-71 drafted, US Army Signal Corps (sent to Vietnam). Awards 1997 Eureka fellow; 2010 Whitehouse Council for Community Solutions; 2011 Ashoka fellow; 2012 MacArthur fellow. Interests Learning salsa and playing the guitar.
Dependency
The idea, Lim Miller stresses, is that low-income households are steered away from dependency on welfare programmes, which, he says, no matter how well meaning are disempowering. It is taken for granted that the families will spend the money much more eciently, he adds, if it is simply handed over and left up to them. He says the guiding principle is that people from poor backgrounds are neither the victims they are often portrayed as by people on the left, or lazy and undeserving as they are frequently labelled by the right. Just like anyone else, these families want some control and choice in their lives. The project, which Lim Miller acknowledges was a bold experiment when it launched with a small cohort of families in Oakland almost a decade ago, has grown steadily. There are now more than 350 families participating in Boston, San Francisco and Oakland with further expansion planned, including an online social networking hub. In the rst two years [of the project] in Oakland, incomes jumped among the group by 27%. Savings were up by 300%. Nine out of the 23 families had bought homes, he says. The latest data from the initiative shows considerable progress in San Francisco and Boston with average incomes up. Lim Miller talks too of a ripple eect within communities. People can see that somebody achieved something Expectations change. The perception people have of their life chances is critical, he argues. If you are in a community where no one is getting ahead, what does that do [to you]? The participants are not families in crisis but those trying to get a foot on the social mobility ladder. Ive been working with low-income families for over 20 years. These are families
who are trying, who want to get out [of poverty] but are stuck, he explains. Lim Miller speaks eloquently about how his background as the son of an impoverished immigrant Mexican mother propelled him to nd new ways to tackle the cycle of extreme poverty. This approach is very personal. My mom was a single mom who was determined for me to get out of poverty for good. Pride was important to her, he says. However, FII was also born of professional frustration. I came into [FII] from doing non-prot work. When I saw the kids of the people I worked with, when I started out, coming [to services for help], I thought: Whatever we are doing, it isnt working. I began to question why. Just as Lim Miller was beginning to probe into why anti-poverty strategies had failed for so long, he was asked in 1999 by the then mayor of Oakland and current governor of California, Jerry Brown, to come up with alternative ways to channel money already set aside to tackle poverty. Brown asked Lim Miller why, when so many social workers and professionals were being employed to run schemes to help poor people, the problem remained so intractable. Jerry said to me: Doesnt this seem like poverty pimping to you? When he went back to Brown with the idea to give money directly to poor families to see what they did with it, the mayor took an unexpected leap of faith and FII was born. Lim Millers work has been recognised at the highest levels and his input is being sought by thinktanks including the rightwing Heritage Foundation. In 2010, he was appointed to President Obamas White House Council for Community Solutions, an advisory board exploring fresh approaches to mobilising people to work together on addressing community problems. In 1999, even before FII was up and running, Miller was honoured by the then president Bill Clinton at the state of the union address for his youth, race relations and poverty work. A string of other awards has also been lavished on him. Yet, for all the accolades, Lim Miller is clearly a pragmatist. The recognition means nothing more than an
opportunity to bolster FIIs work. Cuts to social services have ensured that spare cash is in short supply although it is doubtful state money would be forthcoming even without cuts. In his experience, ocials are not amenable to an unorthodox project that deliberately does not prescribe its outcomes. Some funding has been secured from private foundations, but many remain reticent for similar reasons to government. Lim Miller suggests that, despite such obstacles, a combination of factors has coalesced to mean attitudes to tackling poverty might be shifting. Among these is the evidence of FIIs success and that the most severe recession since the 1930s has hurled a multitude of families into poverty. Important also, he says,
has been the growing awareness of the widening wealth gap between rich and poor and the decline of social mobility. So, does he think his approach might translate to Britain or to other countries? He says one of the most important lessons he learned when the project moved beyond Oakland was that cultural, ethnic and local dierences may exist, but the very fact that families set their own goals makes the programme uniquely adaptable. People in Britain concerned about poverty in the future need to look at the social context, he says. Lifting people above a poverty line is not enough. People must have a stake. There has to be something tangible in the long term. Thats what gives people hope.
To apply, go to www.networkhg.org.uk Closing date: 14th November 2012. Interviews: Week commencing 27th November 2012
courageous
exible
positive thoughtful
loyal practical
communicative
open-minded
alert focused
reliable
humble dutiful
diligent
patient
bright
honest
39
Arts and Humanities Research Council (AHRC) Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) Science and Technology Facilities Council (STFC)
THE CLOSING DATE FOR THE RECEIPT OF APPLICATIONS IS 19 November 2012 The Secretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills will appoint members to the Councils on merit after considering advice from the Appointments Panel. The Secretary of State is committed to the principle of public appointment with independent assessments, openness and transparency of process and to providing equal opportunities for all. We are keen to obtain more diversity in public appointments which enable us to reflect all the communities we serve. We would therefore welcome a diverse range of candidates. An honorarium of 6,850 is paid annually. In addition consideration will be given to reasonable expenses incurred. Further information about the vacancies, application forms and interview dates are available to download via our web site at: http://publicappointments.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/ and Research Councils websites: www.ahrc.ac.uk/Pages/Home.aspx www.bbsrc.ac.uk/vacancies www.esrc.ac.uk/vacancies.aspx www.epsrc.ac.uk/Pages/default.aspx http://www.nerc.ac.uk/about/work/boards/council/vacancies www.stfc.ac.uk/About+STFC/20067.aspx Alternative formats are available, if you do not have internet access for the vacancies, please contact the relevant person: AHRC: Cecilia Sparke, telephone: 01793 416013 BBSRC: Jane Rutherford, telephone: 01793 413259 ESRC: Marie Root, telephone: 01793 413132 EPSRC: Michaela Simpson, telephone: 01793 444028 NERC: Zena Davis, telephone: 01793 442614 STFC: Sharon Bonfield, telephone: 01235 567242
Managers and Deputy Managers, Specialist Support Ofcers and Support Ofcers
Opportunities throughout London and the South East
A total commitment to innovation, quality and making a lasting difference has made One Support a growing force in providing supported housing services to vulnerable adults and young people. With this expansion comes opportunity and plenty of it. Because weve created a number of exciting openings for dedicated managers and support staff who can help people live safely, happily and independently in their local communities. We want to meet inspiring leaders and accomplished communicators who are brimming with fresh ideas. People who thrive on autonomy, make informed decisions without being judgemental and raise the aspirations of others as well as their own. Recognise yourself? Then theres one remarkable future ahead with one unique organisation. To apply for these positions please visit onehousinggroup.co.uk/careers Closing date: 7 November 2012.
onehousinggroup.co.uk/careers
Chief Executive
The Council for Awards in Care, Health and Education (CACHE), regulated by Ofqual, is a growing, specialist awarding organisation for qualifications in the care sector with a strong track-record for excellent service. It is an established charity whose beneficiaries are children and adults in receipt of care. Our mission is to nurture the achievement of those who care for children and adults through provision of outstanding qualifications, support services and positive partnership working. A new Chief Executive is now sought to succeed Richard Dorrance, who will retire in 2013 after many years of distinguished service. The appointee will provide strong leadership, working closely with the Board, to fulfil CACHEs aspirations to be the awarding organisation of choice for care, health and education qualifications. The awarding sector is undergoing significant change, and the new Chief Executive will be tasked with steering a values-driven organisation to continued success in a highly competitive commercial market. The appointee will represent the organisation to a range of external stakeholders, including government and regulators, as well as clients and partners. The postholder will lead a high-performing and ambitious senior team. Strong candidates will be proven strategic leaders who will have gained senior management experience, probably but not necessarily in a relevant sector. Evidence of successfully leading and delivering change within a dynamic and challenging external environment will be key, as will the ability to communicate persuasively to a wide range of audiences. The successful candidate will demonstrate genuine empathy with the charitys mission and values combined with commercial flair. S/he will bring energy and commitment with superb motivational and ambassadorial skills. This is an opportunity to lead an organisation with a great history and equally great ambition for its future. To download the Further Particulars for this appointment, please go to www.heidrick.com/CACHE To apply for this position or for a conversation about the role, please contact Heidrick and Struggles via cache@heidrick.com Closing date for receipt of applications: 19 November 2012.
To nd out more about the role and to apply please visit www.rcpch.ac.uk/vacancies-rcpch
guardianjobs.co.uk
Twin is the unsung hero of the fair trade movement.
MANAGING DIRECTOR
London circa 55k
To advertise contact
TWIN and TWIN Trading are pioneers and leaders in the Fair Trade movement, working to build better lives for the poorest and most marginalised women and men in the trading chain. TWIN works with more than 50 farmer organizations in 18 countries, representing some 400,000 smallholder farmers of coffee, cocoa, sugar and nuts. TWIN was instrumental in launching Cafdirect, Divine Chocolate Co and Liberation Nuts. We are now looking for an exceptional individual to lead the next phase of the organisations development as Managing Director. You will work with the Trustee Boards to develop the vision and business plan and lead the organisation to deliver its strategic objectives, ensuring its operational sustainability. You will also lead the ongoing development of relationships with a diverse group of stakeholders and develop TWIN and TWIN TRADINGs relationship with the Fair Trade movement. You will be an experienced leader and inuencer, able to inspire a staff team, inuence policy debates, and manage programmes. To be successful you will be committed to the values of Fair Trade, have signicant commercial experience, international development experience and experience of the not-for-prot sector as well as an understanding of the potential of smallholder farmers and of cooperatives in development. If you can demonstrate the experience, passion and leadership skills to inspire and develop TWIN as our new Managing Director we want to hear from you. For an informal discussion please contact Kathryn Flanagan on 0207 489 2053 or send your CV with covering letter including salary details, outlining how your skills and experience meet the requirements of the role description to contact@gtfgroup.com by 9th November 2012. Please visit our website for a more detailed description of the role and our organisation: http://www.twin.org.uk/about/recruitment
An advice, advocacy and resource centre for black and minority women Currently have a vacancy for:
Guardian Jobs
London: 020 3353 3400 Edinburgh: 0131 272 2751
Director of Development
40,000 per annum inclusive of Essential Car Users Allowance Package includes pension and contributory lease car schemes Based: Sutton Coldeld
We wish to recruit a dynamic Director of Development due to the current post holder relocating, after many years service. The roles primary purpose will be to continue the development of new and existing services, ensuring there is adequate funding, primarily through successful tender submissions. The post holder will be very experienced in this regard. The development of commercial activities is a major requirement as is the production of Business Plans for all services. The successful candidate will demonstrate signicant success in securing funds for the development of key services and the ability to commission same. A sound understanding of statutory sector purchasing and commissioning across Birmingham is imperative, as is the ability to gain knowledge in other areas. Senior managers are expected to work exibly according to the organisations need and this may include evening and weekend working. Closing for applications: 5pm, Wednesday 14th November 2012 Visit www.ageconcernbirmingham.org.uk for more information including full JD and Person Specication. If you fully meet the role requirements please also download an application pack from our website or call 0121 362 3650. Age Concern Birmingham is an equal opportunities employer Registered Charity 518610
Independent Chairs
500 per day (inclusive) Approximately 30 days per year One year rolling contract
Are you ready for the challenge of leading a Local Safeguarding Children Board? Following the retirement of their independent chair, Merton and Sutton LSCBs are jointly recruiting for new independent chairs for each Board. Applicants can apply for either or both positions. Each LSCB is at a different stage of development, and will present different challenges for a knowledgeable and effective independent chair. You will need: r PTIBSFPVSBNCJUJPOTGPSFYDFMMFODFJOTBGFHVBSEJOHBOE 5 protecting children and young people r YQFSJFODF
LOPXMFEHFBOEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGMPDBMBOEOBUJPOBM & safeguarding agendas and ability to lead improvements across the SCB partnership network r YQFSJFODFBOEBCJMJUZPGDIBJSJOHDPNQMFYNVMUJBHFODZ & professional and strategic meetings at a senior level in an efficient manner r TUSPOHUSBDLSFDPSEJOMFBEJOHDPOUJOVPVTJNQSPWFNFOU " through partnership working r PVOELOPXMFEHFPGSFDFOUBOEQSPQPTFEEFWFMPQNFOUT 4 in childrens services, health and social care, as well as key legislation and research underpinning this work to lead with credibility across the LSCB partnership *UJTBOUJDJQBUFEUIBUZPVXJMMCFSFRVJSFEUPXPSLBQQSPYJNBUFMZ 30 days per year and the contract is for one year initially with the option to renew. For further discussion contact: .FSUPO:WFUUF4UBOMFZ
5FM 4VUUPO5PMJT7PVZJPVLBT
5FM For an application form and further details please visit: www.merton.gov.uk/lscb For more information on Sutton Safeguarding Children Board visit: www.suttonlscb.org.uk Closing date: 16 November 2012. Interview dates: 10 or 11 December 2012.
www.globalwitness.org/about-us/jobs
To apply for this position, please send a CV and covering letter, neither of which should exceed two-pages, to recruitmentcampaigns@globalwitness.org. For this vacancy only shortlisted candidates will be contacted. Email: recruitmentcampaigns@globalwitness.org Deadline: Monday 19th November, 12.00 noon (UK time) Salary Range: 50 - 60,000 per annum dependent on experience
www.merton.gov.uk/lscb
Further information about these jobs can be found on our website at www.merton.gov.uk/lscb where you can apply online. Recruitment packs are also available in large print or braille. Creating Equal Opportunities for all
Coeliac UK is a successful charity representing people with coeliac disease. We work for over 60,000 Members actively campaigning on their behalf to improve healthcare and access to gluten-free food in shops and when eating out.
Guardian Jobs
London: 020 3353 3400 Edinburgh: 0131 272 2751
41
Director of Care
Independent Care Village, is seeking an experienced, dynamic, Director of Care, to lead policy & service development, provide leadership to General Managers & Care Matron. Will consider applicants seeking part-time / exible working hours. Negotiable package For further information please contact:Clive Ansell-Jones Operations Director The Old Deanery Care Village Deanery Hill Bocking, Braintree. Tel: 01376-328600 Email: clive@olddeanery.com www.olddeanery.com
The next Open Evenings will be at 7pm, Friday 14th September and 26th October 2012
The Guardian carries more public sector recruitment advertising than Community Care or any other publication
VOLUNTEERS
Notice to Advertisers
It is a condition of acceptance of advertisement orders that the proprietors of The Guardian do not guarantee the insertion of a particular advertisement on a specified date, or at all although every effort will be made to meet the wishes of advertisers. We reserve the right to edit or delete any objectionable wording or reject any advertisement. Although every advertisement is carefully checked, occasionally mistakes do occur. We therefore ask advertisers to assist us by checking their advertisements carefully and advise us immediately should an error occur. We regret that we cannot accept responsibility for more than ONE INCORRECT insertion and that no republication will be granted in the case of typographical or minor changes which do not affect the value of the advertisement. All calls, both incoming and outgoing, will be recorded automatically; however, we only intend to listen to these calls for training and monitoring purposes, for the resolution of invoice disputes, and/or for any other business purpose which is permitted by applicable legislation.
Evaluation Ofcer
NSPCC 32,800 - 36,300 p.a.
London EC2A
Ref: 4530092 Job Type: 2 FTE
If you have a background in social sciences and some experience of undertaking original social research or service evaluations, apply now!
For more information please visit www.guardianjobs.co.uk
Chief Executive
KCA UK services in the community Competitive salary
Kent
Ref: 4528904 Job Type: Full Time
We are looking for an inspirational leader with a track record of motivating and empowering people across a wide geographical area.
For more information please visit www.guardianjobs.co.uk
Chief Executive
The Vegetarian Society 48,000 - 55,000
Altrincham, Greater Manchester
Ref:4528454 Job Type: Full Time
We need a strategic and operational leader with senior management experience, a commercial edge and a vision for a sustainable future
For more information please visit www.guardianjobs.co.uk
SUSTAINABILITY MANAGER
Greenoak Housing Association Up to 35k
Woking, Surrey
Ref:4529046 Job Type: full or P/T
Talented person to develop/ deliver our green objectives, building on our track record in sustainability and of providing eco-friendly homes
For more information please visit www.guardianjobs.co.uk
42
The Guardian | Wednesday 24 October 2012 Obituaries desk Email: obituaries@guardian.co.uk other.lives@guardian.co.uk Twitter: @guardianobits
Obituaries
Walter Harrison
Wakeeld MP and tough Labour deputy chief whip who kept Callaghan in power
he long-serving Wakeeld MP Walter Harrison, who has died aged 91, established an unequalled record in his 13 years as Labours deputy chief whip, from 1970 until 1983. In particular, he kept in power the minority 1976 Callaghan government for two and a half years rather than the few months it might have expected. James Callaghan conrmed the debt he owed Harrison by inscribing a copy of his memoirs to Walter, who made it all possible and in 1977 elevating him to the privy council. Harrisons achievement was to mount a erce campaign to keep Labour in power and Margaret Thatcher out, establishing a one-man intelligence system and exploiting with minimum scruple every weakness of his opponents. There had been no advance indication when Harrison reached Westminster as Labours new MP for Wakeeld in 1964 that he was other than a run-of-themill loyalist sponsored by the electricians union. He was distinctive only for his rolling gait, friendly grin and his frisky attitude in Annies Bar, where he declared that he would never mix London tap water with his spirits. He was born in Dewsbury, West Yorkshire, the 10th child of Henry Harrison,
an electrician with the Yorkshire Electric Power Company and a Labour councillor, and his wife, Ada. After Dewsbury and Castleford technical colleges, and an apprenticeship in the company where his father worked, he did his fouryear wartime stint as an RAF electrician, serving in 20 countries. Released early because of his civilian skills, he went back to Yorkshire Electric, before switching to Richard Costains as a site electrician and then as a welfare and personnel ocer. This involved a wandering life to which his new wife, Enid, whom he married in 1948, objected. He returned to the Yorkshire Electricity Board, becoming active in the Electrical Trades Union (ETU). The backing of a union was crucial for his political ambitions. He started in 1952 as a councillor in Castleford, becoming a West Riding county councillor in 1958. He went on to the Yorkshire regional executive of the Labour party. A parliamentary seat seemed to elude him, though, as he missed out on Kingston upon Hull West, Newark, Ilkeston and Rotherham. He was nally adopted for Wakeeld and elected in 1964. He made a cautious start in the Commons, but after the 1966 election was named an assistant whip in charge of pairing. He became a full whip in 1968. Some thought Harrisons career might be cut short when Harold Wilson dropped his soft-left chief whip, John Silkin, for a rightwinger, Bob Mellish. But both Mellish and Harrison were trade union loyalists, united in their opposition to Barbara Castles In Place of Strife legislation. When Edward Heath won the 1970 election, Mellish made Harrison deputy chief whip. Harrison showed his tough-
He once threatened a police sergeant that he would be directing trac on the North Circular unless he released Ian Mikardo, needed for a close vote. But despite his eorts, the Callaghan government collapsed after a vote of condence was lost 311 to 310 in March 1979. By the 1983 election, Harrisons majority in Wakeeld was reduced to 360. He declined to stand again as deputy chief whip. But although he no longer had the job, it was dicult for him to shake his long-xed habits; he still padded around the Commons corridors as if hunting for errant Labour MPs. He stood down in 1987, after 23 years, partly due to the poor health of his wife. After Enids death in 1990, he married Jane Richards, long the popular secretary of the Labour whips oce. She died in 2000. Harrison is survived by his son and daughter. Andrew Roth Julia Langdon writes: It was a source of some surprise at Westminster that after his retirement as an MP, Walter Harrison was never oered a seat in the House of Lords. It was a position he had unquestionably earned, having made such a huge contribution to the survival of the Callaghan government and having clearly deserved such elevation rather more than many others among his less distinguished colleagues who were so preferred. It was a personal slight attributed to a longstanding disagreement with Neil Kinnock, who was Labour party leader at the time, and one which was bitterly resented on Harrisons behalf by his many friends. Despite the tough dealings in which he engaged as the deputy chief whip during those immensely dicult years
ness in 1971 when he could be seen nger-jabbing the Tory chief whip, gentlemanly Francis Pym, for ve minutes for guillotining the Tories industrial relations bill without having discussed this through the usual channels. Harrisons Machiavellian side was restricted to Westminster and unknown in his constituency. There he was a genial Yorkshireman with a genius for organising publicity for himself and the party and attracting political bigwigs. When Wilson unexpectedly resigned in 1976, Harrison backed his fellow Yorkshireman Denis Healey for the succession. But when Callaghan won, Harrison devoted himself to his survival. His obsession with keeping Thatcher out of power was such that he frequently sailed close to the wind.
in which he helped keep Labour in oce, there was a considerable nobility to Harrisons personal role. It has only recently been revealed that in order to try to spare the dying Labour MP Sir Alfred Broughton from being brought into the Commons for the vote of condence which precipitated the 1979 general election, Harrison approached his opposite number in the Conservative whips oce, Bernard Jack Weatherill. He asked the Tory deputy chief whip to observe the convention under which a member of the other party would abstain to match the absence of a sick MP. According to a new play, This House by James Graham, currently being staged at the National Theatre, Weatherill asserted that the convention was not applicable in such a critical vote and no Tory MP could possibly agree to abstain; he then oered to do so himself out of his own sense of honour. Harrison, motivated by a similar decency, recognised that such a gesture would certainly aect Weatherills future career and refused to accept the oer. Broughton was not obliged to attend the vote and the government lost by one vote. Broughton died ve days later and Weatherill was subsequently elected Speaker of the Commons, despite the opposition of the new prime minister, Margaret Thatcher, to his candidacy. Harrison always treasured a letter from a defeated but unresentful Callaghan assuring him that he had done the right thing in deciding not to bring Broughton to Westminster for the vote. Walter Harrison, politician, born 2 January 1921; died 19 October 2012 Andrew Roth died in 2010
William Walker
Birthdays
F Murray Abraham, actor, 73; Roman Abramovich, businessman and owner, Chelsea FC, 46; Sir John Adye, former director, GCHQ, 73; Ian Baker-Finch, golfer, 52; Ian Bishop, cricketer, 45; VV Brown, singer and songwriter, 29; Judith Chernaik, founder of Poems on the Underground, 78; Anthony Christian, painter, 67; Prof George Crumb, composer, 83; Simon Danczuk, Labour MP, 46; Barry Davies, sports commentator, 72; Frank Delaney, writer and broadcaster, 70; Elaine Feinstein, writer, 82; Air Chief Marshal Sir Michael Graydon, former chief of the Air Sta, 74; David Hamilton, Labour MP, 62; Dervla Kirwan, actor, 41; Kevin Kline, actor, 65; Esther McVey, Conservative MP, 45; Prof Carrie Paechter, professor of education, Goldsmiths, University of London, 54; Piers Rodgers, former secretary, Royal Academy of Arts, 68; Wayne Rooney, footballer, 27; Lord (David) Sainsbury of Turville, former Labour minister, 72; Jane Stern, writer, 66; Sir Mark Tully, broadcaster, 77; Andrew Turner, Conservative MP, 59; Paul Vaughan, radio journalist, 87; Mark Williams, comic, 53; Jeremy Wright, Conservative MP, 40.
Announcements
Battle of Britain pilot shot down over the Channel in August 1940
hot down by a Luftwae Messerschmitt Bf 109 ghter in August 1940, the Spitre pilot William Walker, who has died aged 99, took refuge on a sandbank in the Channel, with a bullet in his leg and was rescued by a passing shing boat just before he succumbed to hypothermia. He was ying again within six months and, at the time of his death, was the oldest surviving Battle of Britain pilot. Walker was the son of a brewer, born in Hampstead, north London, a year before the rst world war began, and educated at Brighton college. At 18, he learned his fathers trade, joining the Ind Coope brewery company two years later. He eventually rose to become
chairman, as his father had been. Walker volunteered for the armed forces at the time of the Munich crisis in September 1938, joining the RAF Volunteer Reserve at Kidlington, Oxford. When war broke out a year later he was called up for full-time service. After completing his training, he was posted to 616 Squadron, Fighter Command, as a pilot and was commissioned in June 1940. Within weeks, the Battle of Britain began. RAF ghters took on swarms of Luftwae bombers and their ghter escorts in a life-or-death struggle for air supremacy over south-east England, prerequisite for a German invasion. Their initial strategy was to knock out the RAF, its airelds and radar chain. On 26 August, at the peak of this phase of the struggle, Walker and his fellow pilots of 616 Squadron were scrambled as 40 German bombers approached Dover with heavy ghter cover. Unable to gain enough height to exploit the Spitres main advantage over the Messerschmitts, Walker was hit from behind even as he was attacking an enemy ghter.
Walker inspects a Spitre in Trafalgar Square, central London, in 2008 Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PA
Wounded in the lower leg and with his controls shot away, Walker was forced to bale out over the Channel at 20,000ft. He managed to swim to the sandbank in the Goodwin Sands, from where he was rescued by the shing boat. He was transferred to a RAF rescue launch for transport to Ramsgate. He was taken to hospital, where the bullet was removed. Hermann Goering, the Luftwae supremo, made his most fateful blunder in the rst week of September 1940. Having declared 13 August Eagle Day, he had stepped up his campaign. But, angered by a token RAF bomber raid on Berlin two weeks later, he switched his focus from a sorely stretched RAF Fighter Command to civilian targets in London. The dogghts continued until the end of October, as Hurricanes went for the bombers while the faster Spitres chased the ghters, by then operating at the
limit of their range. After his recovery early in 1941, Walker had several postings ferrying new aircraft to squadrons, working with anti-aircraft units and on patrols to protect airelds. He left the RAF in September 1945 as a ight lieutenant, with the Air Eciency Award. He resumed his career with the brewery and devoted much time to working for the Battle of Britain Memorial Trust. In later years, he attended the annual remembrance ceremony at the Capelle-Ferne memorial in Kent, where he recited poems he wrote about the battle. One poem was carved in stone in 2010 and erected alongside the memorial bearing 2,937 names of the Few. Proceeds from a book of his verse published in 2011 are destined for the trust. Walker is survived by ve of the seven children of his marriage to Claudine Mawby, who predeceased him. Dan van der Vat William Louis Buchanan Walker, wartime pilot, born 24 August 1913; died 21 October 2012
guardian.co.uk
Read our obituary of Mike Morris, the TV-am and Yorkshire TV presenter
guardian.co.uk/obituaries
43
guardian.co.uk/sport
Betting 2-1 So Beloved, 5-2 Hoarding, 3-1 Rhamnus, 7-1 Ocean Applause, 15-2 Master Ming.
Form guide Rhamnus disappointed in the Rose Bowl Stakes but he has been given time to strengthen up and his emphatic Sandown success came on soft ground. Like the selection, So Beloved possesses speed in his pedigree but saw out this trip at Salisbury, accounting for a subsequent winner by four lengths.
The Aidan OBrien-trained Kingsbarns has been supported into clear favouritism for Saturdays Racing Post Trophy at Doncaster Pat Healy/racingfotos.com
Todays tips
Newmarket
2.00 2.30 3.05 3.40 4.10 4.45 5.20 Will Hayler Aloha Yarroom So Beloved (nap) No Truth Dance King Subtle Knife (nb) Shamaheart Top Form Desert Image Yarroom (nap) Rhamnus Mujazif (nb) Duke Of Perth Hippy Hpy Shake Quintilian
Kempton
5.50 6.20 6.50 7.20 7.50 8.20 8.50 9.20 Will Hayler Neige dAntan Out Do Celebrated Talent Greatwood Muharrib Pastures New Kakatosi Lowther Top Form Neige DAntan Out Do Secret Number Greatwood Sesentum True Prince Take Cover Roxelana
Betting 11-2 Hippy Hippy Shake, 6-1 Shenas Dream, 7-1 No Poppy, 8-1 Raheeba, 10-1 Sputnik Sweetheart, 12-1 Hurricane Lady.
Worcester
1.40 2.10 2.40 3.15 3.50 4.20 4.55 5.30 Volador Golden Chieftain Woodpole Academy Rocky Ryan Toot Suite Cayman Islands Fox Run Mabel Tasman Volador Current Event Noble Friend Heezagrey Young Victoria Wilton Milan Fox Run Wild Rhubarb
Fontwell
2.20 2.50 3.25 4.00 4.30 5.05 5.40 Tigre dAron Award Winner Mission Complete Easter Day No No Bingo Farbreaga Kallina Tigre DAron Award Winner Red Mile Easter Day Gee Dee Nen Himayna Royal Present
Whos running today? Racecards, news and live results online at guardian.co.uk/ horseracing
Results
Football
UEFA CHAMPIONS LEAGUE Group E P W Shakhtar Donetsk 3 2 Chelsea 3 1 Juventus 3 0 Nordsjaelland 3 0 Nordsjaelland Beckmann 50 10,100 (0) 1 D 1 1 3 1 L 0 1 0 2 F 5 7 4 1 A Pts 2 7 4 4 4 3 7 1 (0) 1 Bolton Barnsley Charlton Millwall Birmingham Bristol City Sheeld Wed Peterborough Ipswich 12 12 12 12 12 12 11 12 12 4 4 3 3 3 3 2 3 1 3 3 4 4 4 2 3 0 4 5 5 5 5 5 7 6 9 7 18 14 13 19 14 23 15 13 10 20 16 14 24 21 29 22 20 23 15 15 13 13 13 11 9 9 7 Brentford (1) 2 Forrester 41 90pen 5,415 Bury Hopper 37 Worrall 55 Carlisle Garner 57 74 Robson 82 Crawley Town Clarke 21 90 Crewe Moore 29 41 4,010 Leyton Orient 3,378 Notts County (2) 3 J Hughes 21 Arquin 32 Campbell-Ryce 84pen Scunthorpe Clarke 42 Hawley 72 Sheeld Utd Blackman 14pen Shrewsbury Richards 81pen 4,711 Stevenage Morais 14 61 4,012 Tranmere Cassidy 87 7,386 LEAGUE TWO P W Gillingham 14 10 Port Vale 14 9 Fleetwood Town 14 7 Cheltenham 14 7 Bradford 14 7 Rochdale 14 6 Rotherham 13 6 Torquay 14 5 York 14 5 Burton Albion 14 5 Exeter 14 6 Southend 14 5 14 4 Chestereld 14 5 Morecambe Plymouth 14 4 Accrington Stanley 13 5 Northampton 14 4 Oxford Utd 14 5 Dag & Red 14 3 Bristol Rovers 13 3 AFC Wimbledon 14 4 Wycombe 13 3 Aldershot 14 3 Barnet 14 1 Accrington 1,506 AFC Wimbledon Kenneth 20og Yussu 29 Antwi 33 (0) 0 (3) 3 D 2 3 4 4 3 4 3 6 6 5 2 3 6 3 5 2 4 1 6 5 2 3 2 4 L 2 2 3 3 4 4 4 3 3 4 6 6 4 6 5 6 6 8 5 5 8 7 9 9 F 29 33 21 19 24 21 22 22 20 22 21 19 17 18 20 17 18 19 20 14 18 12 12 12 A 10 14 13 17 17 19 17 18 18 20 21 17 17 20 20 22 21 26 22 22 28 20 25 26 Pts 32 30 25 25 24 22 21 21 21 20 20 18 18 18 17 17 16 16 15 14 14 12 11 7 (1) 2 (1) 2 Coventry McGoldrick 7 Hartlepool Noble 56 1,877 Oldham Baxter 85pen 3,310 MK Dons 2,853 Swindon De Vita 25 Colchester Wordsworth 33 Henderson 51 (1) 1 Burton Albion Chapell 73 3,975 Cheltenham Elliott 37 Mohamed 78 Chestereld Darikwa 44 4,372 Dag & Red Elito 37 1,487 Northampton 3,541 (1) 2 Rochdale Donnelly 78 Grant 87 Rotherham Nardiello 64 66 5,632 Southend Phillips 68 4,600 Torquay Craig 56 Nicholson 84 Wycombe 3,244 (0) 1 Port Vale Williamson 75 Plymouth Hourihane 30 3,058 Fleetwood Town Gillespie 6 Atkinson 90og Exeter Cureton 51 Bradford Wells 53 Oxford Utd 1,619 (0) 2 Morecambe Ellison 30 Aldershot Hylton 1 Bradley 87 Gillingham Burton 53 2,251 Barnet (1) 1 (0) 1
Tennis
ATP SWISS INDOORS (Basel) First round: R Gasquet (Fr) bt R Haase (Neth) 4-6 6-3 6-2; M Ebden (Aus) bt V Hanescu (Rom) 6-3 7-6 (7-3); M Youzhny (Rus) bt B Tomic (Aus) 6-0 6-2; B Baker (US) bt R Stepanek (Cz) 2-6 7-6 (7-5) 6-3; M Chiudinelli (Swi) bt G Garca Lpez (Sp) 5-7 6-3 6-4; N Davydenko (Rus) bt S Wawrinka (Swi) 7-6 (9-7) 7-6 (7-3); K Anderson (SA) bt J Nieminen (Fin) 7-6 (7-4) 6-3. ATP VALENCIA OPEN (Spain) First round: A Dolgopolov (Ukr) bt F Volandri (It) 6-3 7-6 (7-5); D Ferrer (Sp) bt O Rochus (Bel) 7-5 7-5; J Melzer (Aut) bt C Berlocq (Arg) 6-3 6-3; A Ramos (Sp) bt R Ram (US) 6-3 6-3; S Querrey (US) bt F Lpez (Sp) 6-3 7-6 (7-4); N Almagro (Sp) bt JC Ferrero (Sp) 7-5 6-3; X Malisse (Bel) bt J-W Tsonga (Fr) 3-1 ret; G Simon (Fr) bt J Tipsarevic (Ser) 5-4 ret. WTA CHAMPIONSHIPS (Istanbul, Turkey) Red Group: S Williams (US) bt A Kerber (Ger) 6-4 6-1. White Group: A Radwanska (Pol) bt P Kvitova (Cz) 6-3 6-2; M Sharapova (Rus) bt S Errani (It) 6-3 6-2.
Fixtures
Football
(0) 1
(1) 2
(1) 1
(0) 3
(0) 1
(1) 1
(1) 2
Shakhtar Donetsk (1) 2 Teixeira 3 Fernandinho 52 Group F Bate Bayern Munich Valencia Lille Bate Lille Group G Barcelona Celtic Spartak Moscow Benca Barcelona Iniesta 45 Alba 90 P 3 3 3 3 (1) 1 P 3 3 3 3 (0) 0 (0) 0
(0) 1
A Pts 5 6 4 6 2 6 6 0
A Pts 3 9 4 4 7 3 4 1 (1) 1
Barnsley (0) 1 Perkins 86 8,195 Blackpool (0) 2 Grandin 70 Taylor-Fletcher 75 13,228 Bristol City (1) 3 Davies 17 Baldock 77pen Anderson 90 Cardi (0) 2 Whittingham 71pen Gunnarsson 90 Ipswich (1) 1 Campbell 24 15,417 Leeds (1) 1 Norris 37 17,484 Leicester (1) 1 King 10 Middlesbrough (0) 2 Haroun 59, Miller 66 Millwall Wood 11 18 Taylor 13 Peterborough Boyd 16 24 Ntlhe 48 Wolves Doyle 27 30 20,915 LEAGUE ONE Tranmere Stevenage Sheeld Utd Crawley Town Notts County Doncaster Swindon Preston Brentford MK Dons Yeovil Colchester Carlisle Portsmouth Walsall Crewe Oldham Leyton Orient Bournemouth Shrewsbury Coventry Scunthorpe Bury Hartlepool P 14 14 14 14 14 13 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 13 14 14 14 14 14 14 14 (3) 3
(1) 1
(1) 2 (2) 2
(0) 0 (1) 1
(1) 1
(0) 1
Nottingham Forest (1) 2 Sharp 25 Blackstock 90 Burnley (1) 4 Austin 9 59pen Paterson 60, McCann 90 11,836 Watford (1) 1 Hoban 28 20,077 Derby (1) 2 Robinson 40 Tyson 90 Charlton (0) 1 Dervite 50 Brighton 25,726 Hull 14,129 Birmingham King 45 49 63 9,258 Hudderseld Hammill 51 6,348 Bolton Afobe 21 M Davies 90 W 9 8 7 9 7 7 6 6 5 5 6 5 5 5 5 4 4 5 3 3 2 2 1 1 D 3 5 7 1 4 3 4 3 6 5 1 4 4 3 3 5 4 1 6 4 5 4 5 4 L 2 1 0 4 3 3 4 5 3 4 7 5 5 6 6 5 5 8 5 7 7 8 8 9 F 31 20 18 22 26 18 19 24 19 15 24 15 17 22 17 14 14 11 20 14 14 11 14 11 (0) 0 (0) 0 (1) 3
(0) 0 (0) 2
(0) 1 (0) 0
(0) 0
Bournemouth (0) 3 McQuoid 51 Arter 60pen, Tubbs 85 4,584 Preston Wroe 1 28 36 2,671 Walsall 15,744 (3) 3
UEFA CHAMPIONS LEAGUE Group A Dinamo Zagreb v Paris St-Germain; Porto v Dynamo Kiev Group B Arsenal v Schalke; Montpellier v Olympiakos Group C Mlaga v Milan; Zenit St Petersburg v Anderlecht (5pm) Group D Ajax v Manchester City; Borussia Dortmund v Real Madrid NPOWER CHAMPIONSHIP Blackburn v Sheeld Wed EVO-STIK NORTHERN PREMIER LEAGUE Buxton v Worksop; Whitby v Stocksbridge PS
(0) 1
(1) 2
(1) 1 (0) 1
(0) 0
(0) 2
(0) 1
Yeovil (1) 3 Madden 9, Hayter 60 Madden 70 Portsmouth Harley 51 Doncaster Paynter 48 Hume 90 (0) 1
(0) 0
(0) 0
(1) 2
(0) 1
(0) 2
BUDWEISER FA CUP Fourth qualifying round replays Dartford 1 Forest Green 4; East Thurrock L Chelmsford L; Gosport Borough L Slough L; Halifax 0 Lincoln City 2; Harrogate Town L Hyde L; Newport County L Yate L; Nuneaton L Telford L BLUE SQUARE BET NORTH Altrincham 1 Workington 2 BLUE SQUARE BET SOUTH Staines Town 1 Truro City 0 EVO-STIK NORTHERN PREMIER LEAGUE Frickley 1 Eastwood Town 0; Hednesford L Witton Albion L; Kendal Town L Ashton Utd L; Marine L Staord Rangers L; Matlock Town 1 Chorley 0; North Ferriby Utd 1 FC United 1 EVO-STIK SOUTHERN PREMIER LEAGUE Hemel Hempstead 1 Cambridge City 0 RYMAN PREMIER LEAGUE Bognor Regis Town 0 Harrow Borough 3; Canvey Island 3 Margate 1; Carshalton Athletic 0 Whitehawk 1; Cray Wanderers L Bury Town L; Hendon L Met Police L; Lowestoft Town 3 Wingate & Finchley 0
Spartak Moscow (2) 2 Carioca 3 Jardel 43og Group H Manchester Utd CFR Cluj Braga Galatasaray Galatasaray Yilmaz 77 46,000 Manchester Utd Hernndez 25 75 Evans 62 P 3 3 3 3 (0) 1
(1) 1
(2) 3
(0) 1
(2) 2
(1) 2
A Pts 3 9 3 4 5 3 4 1 (1) 1
(1) 3
(2) 2
NPOWER CHAMPIONSHIP P W Leicester 12 8 12 8 Cardi Middlesbrough 12 7 Crystal Palace 12 6 Wolves 12 6 Hudderseld 12 6 Leeds 12 5 Hull 12 6 Brighton 12 5 Nottingham Forest 12 4 Blackpool 12 5 Derby 12 4 Blackburn 11 4 Burnley 12 5 Watford 12 5
D 1 1 1 3 2 2 4 1 3 6 2 5 5 2 1
L 3 3 4 3 4 4 3 5 4 2 5 3 2 5 6
F 19 22 19 21 17 18 20 18 15 16 21 18 17 26 17
A 10 15 17 20 13 15 18 17 8 13 17 15 14 25 20
Pts 25 25 22 21 20 20 19 19 18 18 17 17 17 17 16
A 13 12 10 18 15 12 14 18 15 11 21 16 23 22 20 20 14 17 25 18 22 24 26 24
Pts 30 29 28 28 25 24 22 21 21 20 19 19 19 18 18 17 16 16 15 13 11 10 8 7
Cricket
CHAMPIONS LEAGUE TWENTY20 Group A P W L T NR RR Pts Delhi (Q) 4 2 0 0 2 +1.44 12 Titans (Q) 4 2 1 0 1 -0.02 10 Kolkata 4 1 2 0 1 +0.49 6 Perth 4 1 2 0 1 -0.47 6 Auckland 4 1 2 0 1 -0.96 6 Centurion Perth 140-7 (PD Collingwood 38, MJ North 37; MD Bates 4-34). Auckland 124-8 (MJ Guptill 36; MA Beer 3-13). Perth won by 16 runs. Centurion Delhi v Titans. Match abandoned, rain.
(0) 1 (0) 1
Golf
PGA GRAND SLAM (Southampton, Bermuda) First-round scores: 66 P Harrington (Ire). 68 B Watson (US). 69 W Simpson (US). 72 K Bradley (US).
44
Cycling
Pat McQuaid doubts that a truth and reconciliation process in cycling would help eradicate doping in the future Salvatore Di Nol/AP
Richard Williams
On Friday the men who run cycling will sit down in their headquarters outside Geneva to talk about the past and the future, and whether the two can be reconciled by the use of a truth and reconciliation process modelled on the one that brought a measure of peace and sanity to post-apartheid South Africa. Their president, Pat McQuaid, is sceptical. In his view, solving South Africas problems was a doddle compared to the mess in which professional cycling nds itself. Where youve got a white population and a black population whore killing each other over a number of years, thats one thing, he said on Monday afternoon. Whether it works in antidoping or sport is another question. You have to ask yourself, if you can set it up, whos going to give information? Are riders and managers going to come forward? I dont know. Will it stop people wanting to cheat? If they come forward and thats a big if will it help much in the future? My personal objective is to work on today and tomorrow, the here and now, rather than the past. We do face the past. Ive faced the past on several occasions since I was elected. But I prefer to work on developing a landscape for the future so that this wont happen again. The United States Anti-Doping Agency (Usada) report, however, is not the end of cyclings exposure to scandal. Some time in the next couple of months Benedetto Roberti, a prosecutor in the Italian city of Padua, will release the results of a two-year investigation into the wider activities of Dr Michele Ferrari, who according to Usada was at the centre of Armstrongs doping web. When the Gazzetta dello Sport previewed some of its ndings the
of a Festina team van containing copious amounts of doping equipment cast a shadow over Dublins Grand Depart. That same year, however, he was elected to the UCI, and promptly appointed to the presidency of the road racing commission by Verbruggen, who had entered cycling in 1970 when, as a sales manager for Mars, he persuaded the company to sponsor a team. The two have been in harness ever since, when Verbruggen was coming to the
Who is going to give information? Are riders and managers going to come forward? I dont know
end of a 21-year spell in charge of the governing body in 2005, he shoehorned his protege into the overall presidency, having warned the voting members of the unsuitablity of the two other candidates for the post. Now 71, the Dutchman, remains as the UCIs honorary president, as well as an honorary member of the International Olympic Committee although David Millar called for his resignation this week on the grounds that the Armstrong victories happened on his watch. Theres nothing in the Usada report which implicates Mr Verbruggen in any wrongdoings, McQuaid replied on Monday, coming to the aid of his patron. The decision of McQuaid and Verbruggen to pursue a libel action against Kimmage, a rider turned journalist and a prominent critic of Armstrong who questioned the propriety of their acceptance of the Texans donations, certainly makes it look as though they are continuing to concentrate on the wrong targets. I would agree that Paul has been a consistent anti-doping advocate, McQuaid said when it was put to him that dropping the action against the author of Rough Ride, which blew the whistle on doping in the 1980s peloton, might been seen as a useful act of reconciliation. I know him very well. Ive known him since he was in his pram. I managed his amateur career. I was a good amateur myself in my day and I took a decision not to go professional. I went to college instead. All Ive done, all my life, is work for the benet of this sport. I will not accept to be called corrupt. To many cycling fans, however, the organisation is failing in its duty. During Mondays press conference McQuaid was asked if his organisation had also started to investigate the mention in the Usada report of payments allegedly made to Dr Ferrari by two Kazakh riders, Andrey Kashechkin and the current Olympic champion Alexander Vinokourov. The president of the UCI leaned across to one of his aides. Have we? he whispered. Not yet, came the muttered reply. Once again, cyclings governing body had missed the break.
Coppell favourite for Palace after Freedman quits for Bolton job Page 46
In the UCI Decision, McQuaid claimed that if his body had had prior sight of Usadas evidence, it would have concluded that Armstrong had a case to answer and would have advised Armstrongs national governing body, USA Cycling, to institute proceedings. Tygart has little condence that an investigation led by the UCI would have produced the same result. All in all, given what was at stake for the sport, said Tygart, I was very doubtful this day would ever come. Perhaps the most serious of McQuaids claims is that Usada deprived Armstrong of the benet of an eight-year statute of limitations under Wadas Code. Theoretically, this would rule out of court all Usadas evidence of doping violations prior to 2004, the year of Armstrongs penultimate Tour de France victory. McQuaid goes on to note that this statute of limitations could have formed the basis for a partial defence if Armstrong had accepted a Cas hearing on his case. The UCI president adds that while the UCI itself would not appeal to Cas on the basis of this claimed infringement of the statute, Wada should, or could, in his view, make such an appeal for the sake of enforcing compliance. In short, the UCI advises Wada that it has a responsibility to appeal against Usadas ruling against Armstrongs doping operation. Armstrong denied himself the benet of any statute because he lied under oath and many other forums, swearing that he did not dope, in addition to bullying witnesses into silence, Tygart responded. If he had not done this, he might have beneted from the statute of limitation. Doubts over the report that led to Lance Armstrong losing his seven Tour de France titles have been raised by the UCI
To raise this now, only further shows their reluctance to do the right thing for the sport going forward. Tygart added that he would have been happy to have seen the case go to Cas. We welcomed a Cas proceeding for all the evidence to be presented under oath and in public for the world to see, and we were condent the world would know the truth, as it does today. In a section in the Decision commenting on Usadas evidence, McQuaid casts several aspersions. Implying duress, he notes that witness statements have been under penalty of perjury and have not been submitted to cross-examination. Even if, purely as an assumption, noted McQuaid, some statements made against Mr Armstrong would be incorrect, vague or confusing, the UCI does not have the elements to show that this would be the case. [This is] another example of the UCI attempting to escape responsibility for their failures and it is quite sad they would continue to resort to such underhanded tactics at this time, said Tygart. This is absolutely ction, made up by them to justify their ineptness at failing to prevent this great heist in their sport. McQuaid closed the UCI document with the proviso that the UCIs recognition of the Usada ruling is conditional on whether Mr Armstrong or Wada will appeal Usadas decision to Cas. Given the history of tension between the UCI and Wada McQuaid and his predecessor Hein Verbruggen even sued Wadas former head, Dick Pound, over his criticism of their antidoping eorts an appeal by Wada seems very unlikely. Despite what might be seen as the encouragement oered by McQuaid to Armstrong in the UCI document, Tygart is not losing any sleep over any move by Armstrong himself. Armstrong has waived his right to any appeal, he said. He does not have any right to appeal at this time.
45
Football
Football
In brief
Governing bodies united in desire to cool talk of breakaway union for black players
Anger over Terry sentence threatens to boil over Minister urges football not to fracture over racism
Owen Gibson
The government and the Football Association have moved to try to quell talk of a potential breakaway union for black players, as barely concealed frustration over the punishment meted out to the Chelsea captain, John Terry, for racially abusing Anton Ferdinand threatens to boil over. Rio Ferdinand, said to be one of the prime movers behind a new Black Players Association, distanced himself from the speculation via Twitter yesterday, as did Jason Roberts. But the Society of Black Lawyers chair, Peter Herbert, conrmed that talks about a new organisation were at an early stage. It is understood that the idea, in various iterations, has been discussed among some players for at least a year but there had been little sign of getting it off the ground until the outpouring of frustration at the sentence handed to Terry. Both Ferdinand brothers and the Reading striker Roberts were among players to boycott Kick It Outs campaign at the weekend by refusing to wear its T-shirts. The sports minister, Hugh Robertson, the FA chairman, David Bernstein, and the Professional Footballers Association chief executive, Gordon Taylor, were among those to praise Kick It Out yesterday and argue that any breakaway move would be counterproductive. I can understand why feelings are running high but I dont think this is the moment for football to fracture. Kick It Out and other anti-racism bodies have moved things forward enormously and I think this is a moment to unite behind them and try and make sure that progress continues, said Robertson. He said Ferdinand and others who have mooted the idea of a breakaway body should rally behind Kick It Out, which some feel has been caught in the crossfire amid intense frustration at what is perceived as a lenient sentence for Terry from the FAs independent regulatory commission. I absolutely understand why the temperature is raised on this but its important to back Kick It Out and build on the progress theyve made over the last 20 years, said Robertson. Bernstein concurred. I dont think fragmentation is in anybodys interest. Kick It Out have a fantastic record, they are led by someone who has done a tremendous amount for equality and diversity in this country. I have a lot of admiration for Lord Ouseley, said the FA chairman. But this week Ouseley, the Kick It Out chairman, also c alled on the Premier League and the FA to do more to help its cause. The organisation is jointly funded by the FA, the Premier League and the PFA to the tune of 345,000 a year. But Bernstein insisted it supported Kick It Out morally and nancially. The PFA chairman, Clarke Carlisle, said he planned to seek a meeting with Roberts and possibly Rio Ferdinand to divine their intentions. The threat is very real because the proposal is there and the discussions have been had, so its obviously something that has been mooted within the industry, he said. We need to know exactly what it is they are wanting, whether this is a movement that is in full ow and whether they think it is going to happen irrespectively or whether it is something where they are trying to instigate change within the organisations that are currently in place. Herbert told the BBC that the new organisation would be more radical than Kick It Out and would be able to take a more proactive approach. I think there comes a point in any communitys life or experience where enough is enough, he said. People appear to have decided they have to do something more vigorously. Rio Ferdinand has attempted to distance himself from speculation over a possible association for black players Twelve months to the day since the Terry-Ferdinand incident at Loftus Road, Robertson said he could absolutely understand why the issue remained such a toxic one. We were all 20-odd once and I can absolutely understand why people feel strongly about this. But this is a moment for cool heads, not hot ones. There is a degree of frustration at the fact that Rio Ferdinand and others have yet to outline the exact nature of their grievances publicly. But Bernstein said it was clear to him that the players who rebelled against Kick It Out were angry with the FA over both the sanction given to Terry and the length of time the case dragged on for. Carlisle said it was incumbent on the FA, which has said it will put the issue before the independent Football Regulatory Authority, to ensure that stronger penalties were laid down for future oenders. I feel the FA need to respond by addressing all of the issues that have caused all of the discontent over the last 12 to 18 months and thats the reporting mechanisms, the investigation process and the sanctions levied for racial abuse oences. A four-game ban is just not strong enough, especially not when the rst incident, the precedent set, was eight games [for Liverpool striker Luis Surez]. The message that was sent out was that racial abuse can be mitigated against and that message is diluted in the next case.
Anthony Knockaert of Leicester City, left, holds o Brightons Spanish defender Bruno Saltor during last nights Championship game Alex Morton/Action Images
Brighton & H A 0
Seven matches ago, when Leicesters defeat at Wolves meant they had lost their rst three away games of the season, the manager Nigel Pearson was widely believed to be on the brink of being sacked. Andy Kings early goal in a match far more one-sided than the scoreline suggests means their record since that loss at Molineux reads six wins, one draw, and leaves the Foxes on top of the table. Brighton, in contrast, have faltered after beginning the season strongly, and a return of just one point from their last three home games has seen Gus Poyets team slip out of the play-o places. The Uruguyan has insisted that his team is not doing much wrong other than not getting the rub of the green, but they were comfortably second-best last night. Away from home the Seagulls form has
remained relatively solid, but they looked anything but secure when Leicester put them under early pressure. Four successive corners were beaten away, but a sense of panic was already present, and the Foxes duly went ahead when David Nugent cut in off the left wing and found the visitors defence in full retreat. An unselsh pass gave King even more space inside the Brighton penalty area, and though his rst shot was blocked, the rebound fell kindly for the midelder to side-foot past an exposed Tomasz Kuszczak. Martyn Waghorn should have gone a long way towards making the points safe soon afterwards. The full-back Ritchie De Laet followed his overlapping run down the right with a cross into the six-yard box that Waghorn, having escaped his marker and with only Kuszczak to beat, wastefully turned over the bar. Anthony Knockaert, a bright, busy young midelder bought from French side Guingamp during the summer, has been one of the most important inuences in Citys improved form in recent weeks and
after nearly creating a chance for Lloyd Dyer with a cross that Kuszczak just managed to touch clear, drew a good save from the goalkeeper with a powerful drive from outside the penalty area. The longer the half progressed without City adding to their lead, the more Brightons condence grew. Will Buckley on the right wing and Ashley Barnes on the left began to see something of the ball, but Craig Mackail-Smiths shot from 25 yards, comfortably saved by Citys goalkeeper Kasper Schmeichel, was their only eort on goal in the opening period. Kuszczak had to save again shortly after the re-start, a strong Nugent header extending the goalkeeper to his right, but Brighton should have levelled when
Leicester 4-4-2 Schmeichel; De Laet (Moore, 54), Morgan, Whitbread, Konchesky; Knockaert, Drinkwater, King, Dyer; Waghorn (Marshall, 69), Nugent (Vardy, 67). Subs not used Logan, James, Schlupp, Futacs. Brighton 4-1-4-1 Kuszczak; Bruno, Greer, ElAbd, Bridge; Bridcutt; Buckley, Dicker (Dobbie, 58), Crofts (Hammond, 77), Barnes; Mackail-Smith. Subs not used Dunk, Calderon, Ankergren, Lopez, Lualuat. Referee N Swarbrick
Zak Whitbread bundled Buckley over as he pushed the ball past the American in the City penalty area. The assistant rather than the referee called the foul, but Schmeichel assuaged Citys sense of injustice by diving to his left to block Barnes rather weak spot-kick, and the Brighton player volleyed the bouncing rebound over the bar. The pattern of the game resumed, Leicester well on top and creating chances that they failed to take. Dyer was the next to miss, heading a Waghorn cross wide before King pulled another shot just the wrong side of the beaten Kuszczaks righthand post. The crowd, boosted by a reduction in ticket prices for half-term, almost had its collective nerve soothed when Ben Marshall, found in space by a classy Knockaert pass, cut in from the right and drew another good save from the busy Kuszczak. Still the second would not come, though, and Mackail-Smith, his prodigious work-rate a testament to his tness, nearly pinched a point with an attempted lob which Schmeichel held with some relief.
46
We have to win then we talk says Mancini as City face high noon
Champions League Daniel Taylor Amsterdam
Frustrating, was the word Roberto Mancini used from his seat in the bowels of the Amsterdam Arena. The Manchester City manager had just been asked about his teams diculties in the Champions League and how, only two games in, they were suddenly confronted with a match they simply dare not lose. Would another bad result be the end for another year? We cannot think this way, Mancini replied. We have to win and then talk. This is the reality, however, of Citys visit to the Netherlands and where they stand in Group D, third from bottom with only a solitary point from two xtures and more shots conceded, 57 in two games, than anyone else in this seasons competition. OK, when the opposition are Real Madrid and Borussia Dortmund there are mitigating circumstances, but that does not alter the fact it has left them vulnerable again. Worrying was another word Mancini could have used. At the very least City will need four points from back-to-back games against Ajax, but it may even be that only two wins will do given that the following assignment is against Real Madrid before the group concludes against the Dortmund side that played with so much air and penetration at the Etihad this month. Too negative? Vincent Kompany certainly thought so. We can lose our chance, Mancini admitted, but Citys captain was not willing to entertain the idea, nor turn it into a discussion about Citys struggles adapting to the competition they crave the most in Abu Dhabi. The past is irrelevant. We cant bring up things that have gone wrong in the past. What we have to take with us is the things that have gone well. We still think we have a big chance and that we are capable of winning every game.
Group D
7.45pm SS2
Venue Amsterdam Arena Referee S Oddvar Moen (Nor) Radio BBC 5 Live
Vermeer Alderweireld
24 3 1
13
Moisander
4 17
Van Rhijn
10
Poulsen
5 8
Blind Eriksen
De Jong
19
Babel
49
21
Sana
Boerrigter Milner
7
Manchester City
Subs from Nasri Johansen, Pantilimon, 8 Lescott, Clichy, Evans, Dzeko, Sinclair, Barry Balotelli, Nimely 18 Injured Garca, Maicon, Kolarov Rodwell, Silva 13 33 Inelegible Nastasic K Tour
Agero
16 32
Tevez
Y Tour
42 4
Zabaleta
5
Kompany
Hart
Probable teams
Group D
P W D L F A GD Pts
2 2 2 2
2 1 0 0
0 1 1 0
0 0 1 2
7 2 3 1
3 1 4 5
4 6 1 4 -1 1 -4 0
Sergio Agero focuses on the ball as Manchester City prepare for their Champions League match against Ajax in Amsterdam tonight Olaf Kraak/AFP/Getty Images
Results Dortmund 1 Ajax 0, Real Madrid 3 Man City 2 Ajax 1 Real Madrid 4, Man City 1 Dortmund 1 Remaining xtures Today Ajax v Man City, Dortmund v Real Madrid 6 Nov Man City v Ajax, Real Madrid v Dortmund 21 Nov Ajax v Dortmund, Man City v Real Madrid 4 Dec Dortmund v Man City, Real Madrid v Ajax
The alternative, after all, is barely worth thinking about. Mancinis team never recovered after taking one point from two games last season. To miss out again would represent one of the bigger disappointments of the Abu Dhabi United Group era. Rightly or wrongly, it would also mean their manager being subjected to the kind of scrutiny that has rarely come his way since arriving in Manchester. Mancinis record in this competition never getting any further than the quarter-nals with Internazionale is already fairly undistinguished for a man of his ambitions, not to mention those of his employers. If there is reason for encouragement, it is that Ajax have had a slow start to the season themselves, unbeaten in the Eredivisie but losing a 3-1 lead against Heracles Almelo at the weekend to make it ve draws among their rst nine games. Frank de Boers team are currently bottom of Group D, having lost against Dortmund and Madrid. If we want to stay in Europe after the winter break, whether in the Champions League or Europa League, we need a result, De Boer said. We believe in it. The Real match was a poor match for us, but in the Dortmund game we were unlucky. This game is dierent. They are a good team but we have a good team as well. Ajax will certainly be encouraged by the fact City have lost three of their last four away games in Europe. For their latest expedition Mancini has changed the usual preparations ying early and training at the stadium rather than a practice session in Manchester and then arriving in the evening. A small tweak, perhaps, but one that recognises the need for change.
Arsenal v Schalke
Venue Emirates Stadium Referee J Eriksson (Swe) Radio BBC 5 Live Arsenal
Group B
7.45pm SS4
Mannone
15
Subs from Shea, 24 Koscielny Vermaelen Mertesacker, Djourou, 25 6 5 11 Squillaci, Miquel, Jenkinson Andr Santos Coquelin, Arshavin, Chamakh, Gnabry 16 8 Injured Chamberlain, Ramsey Cazorla Arteta Diaby, Fabianksi, 19 Frimpong, Szczesny, 27 9 Walcott, Wilshere, Gervinho Podolski 12 Rosicky, Gibbs, Sagna Giroud Huntelaar Schalke Subs from Afellay Farfn 25 Hildebrand, Matip, 11 17 Papadopoulos, Jones, 10 Metzelder, Barnetta, Hger Neustdter Holtby Moritz, Draxler, 12 33 Marica, Obasi, Pukki Doubtful Draxler, Uchida Fuchs Popodopoulos 23 32 4 22 Injured Matip Hwedes 36 Escudero, Pliatsikas Unnerstall
Probable teams
Group B
P W D L F A GD Pts
2 2 2 2
2 1 0 0
0 1 1 0
0 0 1 2
5 4 3 2
2 3 4 5
3 6 1 4 -1 1 -3 0
Results Montpellier 1 Arsenal 2, Olympiakos 1 Schalke 2 Arsenal 3 Olympiakos 1, Schalke 2 Montpellier 2 Remaining xtures Today Arsenal v Schalke, Montpellier v Olympiakos 6 Nov Olympiakos v Montpellier, Schalke v Arsenal 21 Nov Arsenal v Montpellier, Schalke v Olympiakos 4 Dec Olympiakos v Arsenal, Montpellier v Schalke
foreign players on the English scene is so great but it often feels as if they adapt to the character of the Premier League instead of altering it conclusively. Arsenal had almost made it a matter of principle that they should be rened. Wenger, however, has still been attempting to make adjustments. There is an air of heightened experience now that players such as Santi Cazorla and Lukas Podolski have been bought. Jack Wilshere missed the whole of last season with an ankle problem and, having featured for the whole 90 minutes in an under-21 match with Everton on Tuesday, he will not be asked to take any part. Wenger, in general, is less inclined to put the emphasis on precocity any more, even if he will be relieved when Wilshere makes his expected return soon. While the average age of the side is still relatively low, Cazorla and Podolski are both 27. In essence Wenger has opted to turn to men who have already matured and established a style of play. Cazorla, bought from Mlaga, is meant to bring knowhow to bear in matches. He can open defences with the quality of his passing, said Wenger. And he gives us a technical security that allows us sometimes when we are under pressure to get out of it. Overall I believe that he typies the game we want to play. He ought to be a reassuring presence in a match that players such as Alex OxladeChamberlain and Theo Walcott will miss through injury. Nonetheless Schalke present real menace, especially in the shape of the much-travelled Klaas-Jan
Lukas Podolski, left, and Santi Cazorla in training before the visit of Schalke
Huntelaar. He was the Bundesligas top scorer last season with 29 goals. These could turn into even more troubling times for Wenger. The [international] break didnt help, he said, but everybody has to cope with that. Wenger now looks for as much continuity as is feasible. He will not drop Vito Mannone despite the fact that he was at fault for Norwichs goal on Saturday. With Wojciech Szczesny and Lukasz Fabianski injured, he is the third-choice goalkeeper but the manager will not be replacing him with the 20-year-old Damin Martinez. There has been enough disruption already and the task now is to make sure that mayhem descends on Schalke. Arsenal, however, will rst have to recover poise and durability.
47
Celtic 1
Samaras 18
Celtics Scott Brown sticks rigidly to Lionel Messi as his side almost held out for a famous draw at Camp Nou Albert Olive/EPA
Barcelona claimed their 100th Champions League win courtesy of a stoppage-time winner against a Celtic team who emerged with tremendous credit, if no tangible reward. The Scottish side had stunned the Camp Nou by taking the lead, the seventh time already this season that Barcelona have lost the rst goal in a match. The reigning La Liga champions recovered from that setback, Jordi Alba stealing in at the back post to secure a home win. Celtic still have genuine aspirations of a place in the knock-out stage, but this will still prove a wounding loss. Barcelona were victorious, and will claim deservedly so on the balance of play, but should also have oered quiet respect Celtic are hardly alone in arriving at Camp Nou as massive underdogs but for the Scottish champions, that must have been a strange feeling. On the domestic scene this season, Celtic will be regarded as the strong favourites for virtually every match they play; the absence of routine Old Firm fixtures for the time being has been offset by Champions League involvement. Entering this match, Barcelona had won 14 and lost none of their previous 17 home games in this competition. Spartaks win over Benca in Moscow in Group Gs early kick-o ensured Celtic would nish the evening at least in second place, regardless of events here. An impressive Celtic win in Russia earlier this month triggered the legitimate sense that Neil Lennons team would essentially be aorded two free hits at Barcelona. Lennons counterpart at Bara, Tito Vilanova, was subjected to some pretty fierce interrogation by the local media on Monday evening. The motivation for
Group G
P W D L F A GD Pts
3 3 3 3
3 1 1 0
0 1 0 1
0 1 2 2
7 4 6 1
3 4 7 4
6 0 -1 -3
9 4 3 1
Results Barcelona 3 Spartak Moscow 2, Celtic 0 Benca 0 Benca 0 Barcelona 2, Spartak Moscow 2 Celtic 3 Barcelona 2 Celtic 1, Spartak Moscow 2 Benca 1 Remaining xtures 7 Nov Benca v Sp Moscow, Celtic v Barcelona 20 Nov Benca v Celtic, Sp Moscow v Barcelona 5 Dec Barcelona v Benca, Celtic v Sp Moscow
that was the loss of four goals during Saturdays match at Deportivo La Corua; Vilanova could and did reasonably point to the fact his own team scored ve. The 21-year-old centre-back Marc Bartra was handed a rare Barcelona start for Celtics visit. Cesc Fbregas, who excelled in La Corua, dropped to among the substitutes. Lennon was delighted to be able to call upon his captain, Scott Brown, who is plagued by a hip problem. Barcelona remain unbeaten in La Liga this season but the concession of 10 goals in their last six outings apparently constitutes cause for concern. If nothing else, that supplies just one minor indication of the Catalan teams standards.
There should have been little surprise attached to the fact Celtic spent the opening exchanges toiling to get out of their own half. Alexis Snchez, preferred in the home attack to David Villa, should have opened the scoring within two minutes but screwed wide from a Lionel Messi pass. Bartra was the next to threaten, with a header which Fraser Forster batted away. From the subsequent break, however, Celtic created ripples across the European football scene by opening the scoring. A foul on Brown during the visitors counter-attack allowed Charlie Mulgrew to curl a menacing free-kick into the Barcelona penalty area. Georgios Samaras
was afforded sufficient space to angle a header goalwards; the ball also took a crucial deflection off the shoulder of Javier Mascherano. Vctor Valds therefore found his rst touch of the ball was removing it from his goal net. Celtic suered a double blow in the rst halfs dying throngs. Samaras limped from the eld, moments before Andrs Iniesta played a wonderful one-two with Xavi and supplied a low nish. Suddenly, the tenacity shown by Celtic when not in possession had been clinically undone. Barcelonas vulnerability at crosses was highlighted again, eight minutes after the restart. From a Mulgrew corner, Efe Ambrose headed wide. Messi was denied by a ne Forster save Pedro the supplier as Celtic endured a subsequent spell on the ropes. Brown had been the rst to succumb to fatigue, the midelder being replaced by Commons shortly after the hour mark. Forster, who was part of the England party for recent matches against San Marino and Poland, endorsed that status with a one-handed stop from a Messi header. With a quarter of an hour to play, Celtic were battling to stem a pressure ow. Just when Lennons men looked like holding rm, Alba popped up. Adrianos cross eluded the entire Celtic defence, with his fellow full-back scoring from all of two yards range.
Barcelona 4-3-3 Valds; Adriano , Bartra, Mascherano , Alba; Xavi, Song, Iniesta; Pedro (Tello, 76), Messi, Alexis (Villa, 80). Subs not used Pinto, Fbregas, Dos Santos, Montoya, Roberto. Referee G Rocchi (It) Celtic 4-4-1-1 Forster; Lustig, Wilson, Ambrose, Izaguirre; Brown (Commons, 63), Ledley, Wanyama, Mulgrew (Kayal, 76); Hooper; Samaras (Forrest, 43 ). Subs not used Zaluska, Matthews, Rogne, Miku.
There is frustration at the fact that Rio Ferdinand and others have yet to outline the exact nature of their grievances publicly Page 45
48
Braga 2
Alan 2 20
Only once before had Manchester United won when two goals behind in the Champions League: the famous night in Turin when Roy Keane dragged them to a 3-2 victory over Juventus that led the way to the 1999 nal. On 75 minutes of an evening that again did nothing to ease the heart rates of the home support Javier Hernndez was the man who changed this statistic, the Mexicans head connecting with a sweeping Tom Cleverley cross from the right to give United the lead. There were further scares for them. An 80th-minute corner from Alan, who scored both Bragas goals, skimmed over the area before the ball found a route safely into the hands of David de Gea, as United ended proceedings as they began: living dangerously. The rst half continued the thrills and spills in attack and the defensive mishaps that have been the Manchester United movie this season. Even by their sluggish standards the start was dire. The clock showed 80 seconds as they fell behind to an Alan header after Michael Carrick who would later be hoodwinked for the visiting captains second conceded a corner in the second minute. This was defended well but, when play continued and the ball broke to Hugo Viana, a swinging delivery from the left found the head of Alan, who got ahead of Alexander Bttner to give his side the lead. This was the eighth time in 12 outings Sir Alex Fergusons men have trailed during this campaign. Worse was to follow as a stunned United saw their decit doubled. This time Carrick, playing as an auxiliary central defender, was the patsy in a Cruy turn smoothly executed by Eder down the left. The striker cruised towards De Geas goal, then rolled the ball into Alan whose nish was expert. For each of these goals the space United allowed when turned was the issue, a problem that continued until half-time. For the home congregation normal service was partially resumed after 25 minutes. Robin van Persies tricky footwork moved him inside from the left. He Michael Carrick congratulates Jonny Evans after he scored Uniteds equaliser at Old Traord last night
was chopped down by Leandro Salino, the visiting right-back but the referee, Milorad Mazic, played advantage as the ball found Shinji Kagawa. After a look up he oated a cross on to Hernndezs head and, though Beto parried the ball, it followed him over the line. Van Persie followed this with a neat chest-down and swivel-then-shot, though it went wide. There were other moments when United might have drawn level: Wayne Rooneys probing down the right with Rafael da Silva went unrewarded and Bttners mazy run into the Braga area might have won a penalty as he fell. Hernndez might have had a second when Van Persie again hurt the visitors down their right this time his tipped attempt was saved by Beto. But a jittery rearguard that has plagued the Reds this season was again evident when a regulation clearing header from Da Silva was instead spooned behind to give Braga a corner. With all six of the available points so far gathered Sir Alex Ferguson had been content before the visit of the Portuguese. Given our defensive injuries we are in a stronger position in Europe than I might have expected, he told United Review. The main aim tonight is to make sure we dont waste our advantage and get the points which almost see us through.
Group H
P W D L F A GD Pts
3 3 0 0 6 3 3 9 3 1 1 1 4 3 1 4 3 1 0 2 4 5 -1 3 3 0 1 2 1 4 -3 1
Javier Hernndez heads home a cross from Shinji Kagawa for Manchester Uniteds rst goal against Braga Phil Noble/Reuters
Results Cluj 0 Man Utd 4, Galatasaray 0 Braga 2 Braga 0 Cluj 2, Man Utd 1 Galatasaray 0 Galatasaray 1 Cluj 1, Man Utd 3 Braga 2 Remaining xtures 7 Nov Braga v Man Utd, Cluj v Galatasaray 20 Nov Cluj v Braga, Galatasaray v Man Utd 5 Dec Braga v Galatasaray, Man Utd v Cluj
A win would take us to nine points, just one point from my target of 10 with three games left. While the holy grail of 10 points does not always guarantee passage as Manchester City learned last season, Rio Ferdinand, whose role in the proposed breakaway black players union is yet to be claried, was on the bench, with no place at all for Scott Wootton, who might have been give a full Champions League debut alongside Jonny Evans but was not included in the 18-man squad. Ferguson had lined his side up in a diamond shape for the second time running in this group stage, with Rooney at the tip behind Van Persie and Hernndez. This dynamic changed when Nani replaced Kagawa for the start of the second half, possibly due to the knock he had taken possib during the opening period, and Rooney moved to the left. With Nani on the right, Fergusons men Wit were n now operating in a more orthodox 4-4-1-1, at across mideld. After Da 4-4 Silva won a free-kick down the right Si for which Elderson was booked, Van fo Persie stung Betos fingers with a P curving attempt from the angle. c Rooney was next up, rst pinging in an attempted through-ball into Van Persies run that was blocked, V then offering the collectors item t of a cross with his left foot that did nd the Dutchman, though again danger was cleared. But Braga failed to do so for Evanss equaliser. A Van Persie corner was flicked off Carricks back and, when the Irishmans airshot missed the ball, it rebounded o Alan and this time Evans scrambled it home. bl
Manchest Manchester Utd 4-4-1-1 D De Gea; Da Silva, Evans, Carrick, B Bttner; Fletcher, (Nani, h-t), Cleverley, Kagawa (N Rooney; V Persie; Hernndez Van (Giggs, 79 79). Subs not used Johnstone Johnstone, Ferdinand, Anderson, Young, Welbeck. Braga 4-2-3-1 Beto; Salino, Coelho, Vinicius, Elderson ; Viana, Custdio ; Alan (Mossor, 86), Micael (Z Lus, 88), Amorim (Barbosa, 80); Eder. Subs not used Quim, Michel, Baiano, Capela. Referee M Mazic (Ser)
the only player in a position to challenge Alan, and he allowed his opponent to get in front of him with predictable results. Say what you like about Ferdinand and his Kick It Out stance, he can usually be relied upon to head it out when confronted with a routine cross. The fact that Michael Carrick was beaten all ends up by the delightful piece of skill from Eder that led to Bragas second goal does not mean he was a poor choice as emergency centre half. But you did have to wonder rstly what he was doing so far out on the right, leaving just Jonny Evans in the middle to attempt to deal with the eventual cross, and secondly what was the emergency?
Ferguson still has plenty to mull over despite his teams show of ghting spirit, writes Paul Wilson at Old Traord
49
Weather&Crossword
Weather forecast
UK and Ireland Noon
Shetland Islands
10
Temperature () X Wind (mph) X Sunny Sunny intervals Mostly cloudy
Summary
SE England After a fairly cloudy start, it will become brighter with some long sunny spells during the afternoon. Mild. Gentle easterly winds. Max temp 15-18C (59-64F). Tonight, clear spells. Min temp 9-12C (48-54F). London, E Anglia, Cent S England It will be a mostly cloudy start to the day with patchy light rain. Becoming brighter later with some sunny spells. Light easterly winds. Max temp 14-17C (57-63F). Tonight, cloud increasing. Min temp 9-12C (48-54F). SW England, Wales, Channel Is, W Midlands, E Midlands, Lincolnshire, Yorkshire, NE England It is going to be a generally cloudy day with light rain or drizzle in places. It will become drier later. Light easterly winds. Max temp 13-16C (55-61F). Tonight, patchy light rain. Min temp 6-9C (4348F). NW England, SW Scotland, W Isles After a cloudy and locally misty start, it will become brighter with some sunny spells during the afternoon. Light north-easterly winds. Max temp 11-14C (52-57F). Tonight, clear spells. Min temp 4-7C (39-45F).
35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 -5 Slight
12 1028 10
7
Slight
12 1024
14
Slight
14
14
N Isles, NE Scotland, NW Scotland, SE Scotland, Northern Ireland Early mist clearing to leave a lot of cloud but also a few brighter periods in places. Drizzle in the far north. Light northerly winds. Max temp 9-12C (48-54F). Tonight, cloud building. Min temp 3-6C (37-43F). Ireland Generally cloudy with patchy drizzle in the south and east. Some sunshine towards the west coast though. Moderate easterly winds. Max temp 11-14C (52-57F). Tonight, mostly cloudy. Min temp 6-10C (43-50F).
Channel Islands
15
17
1020
12
-10 -15
1008 1016
H
1016
1016
High 14 Low -2
High 10 Low -2
High 9
Low 1
High 10 Low 3
High 11 Low 2
Across
1 Plan ups extra revenue (8) 5 Work the Queen leaves for one providing horse, say (6) 9 They may be sarcastic, when press is across the street (8) 10 Junkie kept quiet for old archbishop (6) 12 Try on Google, say, for study of the elderly (11) 15 Course for Angus, say? (5) 17 Sport has sign defect, but it keeps order (4,2,3) 18 How I told pope I was leaving? (6-3) 19 The thanks given in a letter from Athens (5) 20 Roger is paid for training North American marmots (7,4) 24 Tea set broken without blemish (6) 25 Dance with lover, a sergeant? (8) 26 The outcome of intimacy may be more by accident (6) 27 City sits uneasily with trouble in waterworks (8)
9 11 12
10
13 15 16 17
14
18
19
20 22 24 23 25
21
26
27
3 Rule where to abdicate is pointless (5) 4 Court case over drama, following dispute with referee (6,6) 6 Face of toy designed to be indecisive (9) 7 Teachers heart complaint? (4) 8 Deserve a pot, as they say (4) 11 Loss of player perhaps from something that disagreed with him? (5,7) 13 Scots peasant goes on ahead, if spaced (4-6) 14 Days in which we have dances where people are exploited (10) 16 Plate they designed for wireless communication (9) 21 Worker visiting Cornwall? (5) 22 Skin trouble said to be found in London (4) 23 Dress to boast about (4)
Down
Stuck? For help call 0906 751 0038 or text GUARDIANC followed by a space, the day and date the crossword appeared another space and the CLUE reference to 85010 (e.g GUARDIANC Monday12 Across1). Calls cost 77p per minute from a BT Landline. Calls from other networks may vary and mobiles will be considerably higher. Texts cost 50p per clue plus standard network charges. Service supplied by ATS. Call 0844 836 9769 for customer service (charged at local rate, 2p per min from a BT landline). Want more? Access over 4,000 archive puzzles at guardian.co.uk/crossword. Buy the Guardian Cryptic Setters series (4 books) for only 20 inc UK p&p (save 7.96). Visit guardianbooks.co.uk or call 0330 333 6846.
1 Supercial treatments for ruler with large amount on board (4,6) 2 Does one measure degrees of support for mechanised farming? (10)
P R O L A P S E
L U N I L A N C I ON G
F T AME E N C ON E E S T R
C K Y O U E D B A O L E S T O R O G A N D D N P F E A R L C E N D S H O S S T R U C E R E S S E D
B A N K S T A T E M E N T
E D R DO P K I N C K S S
I E M N E T N I C E S N E D L L F I E M TWE G N P O R T
N T I ON D F E R A S S P S H O E D E A L
Wednesday 24.10.12
guardian.co.uk/sport
John Terrys return to the Chelsea team and captaincy had been steeped in contention, coming as it did while he serves a four-match domestic suspension for racial abuse of Anton Ferdinand. As this vital tie got away from him and the defending European champions, it seemed appropriate that a Shakhtar Donetsk player called Fernandinho should not only star but conjure up the decisive blow. There had been bitter irony at the outset when Terry, pictured below right, had seen the ball rear up against his armband, which was embroidered with an antiracism slogan, to drop for Alex Teixeira to score the opening goal. The captain played well but his team were second best and once Fernandinho had punished Eden Hazard to score the second, it seemed to be a question only of the victory margin. They failed to take any of their subsequent chances and there was brief alarm when Oscar scored from close-range with two minutes to go. There was only one team, though, who merited victory and in truth the nal score attered Chelsea. Shakhtars performance represented an exhilarating statement. There was, though, the significant consolation for Chelsea of Juventus only managing a draw in Denmark against Nordsjaelland. It felt as though all eyes were on Terry, though. There were less than three min-
utes gone when the Chelsea captain tasted misfortune when his block tackle on Luiz Adriano saw the ball fall kindly for Teixeira, who kept his cool to place a low nish into the far corner. The mood ignited. There was a swagger about some of the home teams football, with their technique, comfort on the ball and threat most pronounced in the threeman line behind Adriano, where two more Brazilians, Teixeira and Willian, anked the Armenian Henrik Mkhitaryan. Willian checked on to his right foot and shot on more than one occasion as Shakhtar controlled the rst-half. They caught the eye with their slick interchanges and swift counters in what was an entertaining tie. Roberto Di Matteo knew that his teams focus had to be spot-on and he took no chances with his selection against opponents who have reduced the notion of competitiveness in their league to rubble. He was forced into an 18th minute change when Frank Lampard felt a muscle pull, however; the midfielder will not look back fondly upon a record 100th European appearance for the club. Di Matteo, who saw Ashley Cole pick up a silly booking for a foul on the goalkeeper Andriy Pyatov, sent on Eden Hazard in an attacking change but Chelsea merely flickered in the first-half. They worked Fernando Torres into some good
Group E
P W D L F A GD Pts
3 3 3 3
2 1 0 0
1 1 3 1
0 1 0 2
5 7 4 1
2 4 4 7
3 7 3 4 0 3 -6 1
Shakhtars Alex Teixeira is mobbed by his team-mates after scoring the early opener in last nights Group E win against Chelsea Gleb Garanich/Reuters
Results Chelsea 2 Juventus 2, Donetsk 2 Nordsjaelland 0 Juventus 1 Donetsk 1, Nordsjaelland 0 Chelsea 4 Donetsk 2 Chelsea 1, Nordsjaelland 1 Juventus 1 Remaining xtures 7 Nov Chelsea v Donetsk, Juventus v Nordsjaelland 20 Nov Juventus v Chelsea, Nordsjaelland v Donetsk 5 Dec Chelsea v Nordsjaelland, Donetsk v Juventus
areas but the striker, frustratingly, could not fashion shooting opportunities. It was Shakhtar who entered the interval with regrets, although none were related to the incision of their football. But for Petr Cechs eorts, the tie might have been over. He tipped over from Mkhitaryans drive following Willians lovely ick and after a Dario Srna corner had led to chaos, the goalkeeper thwarted Tomas Hubschman, brilliantly, at point-blank range. Chelsea could also be grateful to Terry for a couple of vital interventions. Torress woes were epitomised early in the second-half, when his touch and decision-making completely broke down. Chelsea fans squirmed and after Juan Mata shot wide from Hazards cross, there was worse to come. Fernandinho was an
all-action presence, snapping at Chelsea heels and helping to set Shakhtars tempo with his intelligent distribution. He started and nished the move for the second goal, crashing into Hazard to win the ball on halfway and driving forward on the break. The Belgian was crestfallen; Chelsea horribly exposed. Fernandinho swapped passes with Adriano, taking the return smoothly and hitting a low shot past Cech inside the far post. Chelsea had their moments in the second-half. Ramires hit a shot from distance; Hazard nearly exposed Olexandr Kucher; Mikel John Obi pivoted and lifted over and Hazard, having wriggled through for Chelseas best chance, was denied by Pyatov. But it was Shakhtar, inspired by Willian, who played the better football and created the clearer opportunities. Fernandinho and Mkhitaryan spurned chances or were denied by Cech. Oscars goal could not reverse the tide for Chelsea.
Shakhtar Donetsk 4-2-3-1 Pyatov; Srna, Kucher, Rakitskiy, Rat; Fernandinho, Hubschman; A Teixeira (Ilsinho, 77), Mkhitaryan, Willian (Costa, 88); Luiz Adriano. Subs not used Kanibolotskiy, Stepanenko, Eduardo, Gai, Kryvtsov. Chelsea 4-2-3-1 Cech; Ivanovic, David Luiz, Terry, Cole; Mikel, Lampard (Hazard, 18); Ramires, Oscar, Mata; Torres (Sturridge, 70). Subs not used Turnbull, Romeu, Cahill, Azpilicueta, Bertrand. Referee D Skomina (Svn)
The FA chairman David Bernstein, has sympathy for Anton Ferdinand over the time the racist-abuse case took to complete clusion, was the fact that a key interview with Ashley Cole was not recorded. Bernstein said he had every sympathy for Ferdinand, who has been embroiled in the aair for a year since Terry insulted him during a Premier League match. I have great respect for all the parties. They have had a pretty rough time. Anton has had a very dicult time as has his family, said Bernstein. The fact this thing has taken so long even though I would justify the process certainly hasnt helped. I have every sympathy for Anton. He conrmed that Ferdinand and his brother Rio had issues regarding Terrys ban, which led to their protests when they refused to wear Kick It Out T-shirts in the warm-ups before their games. I am fairly clear of the issues regarding the FA, which revolve around the time its taken and the length of the penalty. As between themselves and Kick It Out, thats for them to resolve. The issues around the FA are clear, he said. Bernstein also repeated the FAs apology for its part in the events leading to the Hillsborough disaster. It was long overdue, he said. FA against union breakaway, page 45
The chief executive of the US AntiDoping Agency, Travis Tygart, has responded angrily to claims made in a document released by the UCI, saying that cyclings governing body are simply diverting attention away from their own failures. On Monday, the UCI president, Pat McQuaid, convened a press conference to deliver the UCIs verdict on the Usada report which had revealed the extent of the doping scheme that enabled Lance Armstrong to win seven consecutive Tours de France. The reports publication followed Armstrongs decision not to contest Usadas case against him in an arbitration hearing
even though that decision meant he would be stripped of all his titles. In Geneva, McQuaid said the UCI recognised the Usada ruling and that Lance Armstrong now had no place in cycling. But in a document published later the same day on the UCIs website, and personally signed by McQuaid, he Travis Tygart, the head of Usada, says the UCI is using criticism his agency to divert attention from its own failings
delivered a dierent message. The UCIs Decision document accepts Usadas sanction against Armstrong, but calls its evidence and methods into question, and raises grounds for a possible appeal either by Armstrong himself, or by the World Anti-Doping Agency against the reports conclusions. After rst welcoming the UCIs announcement on Monday, Usadas Tygart reacted indignantly once he had reviewed McQuaids critique. The truth is Lance Armstrong, on their watch, pulled o the greatest heist sport has ever seen, said Tygart. Instead of attempting to explain or justify their inadequacies,
the UCI should acknowledge their responsibility and failures and nd ways to make it right. During the press conference McQuaid had to eld uncomfortable questions over the UCIs acceptance of $125,000 in donations from Armstrong. In the four-page Decision document, however, McQuaid refers to the Usada reports overstated language, incorrect and incomplete statements, and questions whether Usada had a sucient degree of detachment to make a disciplinary judgment. Continued on page 44