Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
Secret
The Trading Pro’s
by Jim Wyckoff
Foreword by Darrell Jobman
One of the best ways to learn about the markets and trading is to
have a mentor, an experienced person who knows the ropes
thoroughly and is willing to pass along his or her knowledge to you
personally. As a reporter for a wire service on every major
exchange floor at one time or another, Jim Wyckoff had access to
some of the best and brightest people in the business – not just one
mentor but many mentors.
Over the years, Jim became an expert analyst in his own right,
sifting through all the ideas to which he had been exposed,
selecting those that made the most sense and developing his own
way of analyzing markets. He has been passing along that
perspective to subscribers of his own information service and as a
senior market analyst for www.TraderEducation.com for several
years now.
One of the most valuable lessons Jim learned from his years of
involvement in the markets is the importance of intermarket
analysis and how highly professional traders regarded this type of
analysis. He had observed many successful traders using
intermarket analysis to trade spreads and other positions, both on a
long-term position basis and in short-term intraday trading, and he
adopted intermarket analysis as one of the “tools in his toolbox,” as
he likes to call those things that help him analyze markets daily.
In this e-book, Jim shares some of the tips and ideas he has learned
from the professionals as well as his own conclusions about how to
be a successful trader. He explains the significance of intermarket
analysis and shows how VantagePoint Intermarket Analysis
Software can be one of those “tools” that can help you analyze
markets and make sound trading decisions to improve your trading
results.
Darrell Jobman
Editor-in-Chief
www.TraderEducation.com
Introduction
Thank you for making the effort to obtain and read my new e-book
on intermarket analysis. I know you will learn and benefit from
this e-book because I try to do all of my writing in "plain English"
so it is easy to understand, no matter what your trading experience
level.
More recently, what I call the "axis" markets – crude oil, gold and
the value of the U.S. dollar versus other major currencies – have
been a defining example of the reality of intermarket behavior.
These three market areas combine to produce a powerful influence
on daily price activity in many other commodity markets. In fact,
for a while the axis markets were the main factor driving prices.
I think you will enjoy the format of this book: short chapters that
are easy to comprehend. Too many times in this industry, books on
trading have been so technical and complicated that traders find
themselves swimming in a sea of market statistics, computer code
or mathematical formulas. You will find none of that in this book.
What you will find are important lessons and anecdotes that will
move you up the ladder of trading success.
2
Examine Fundamentals
Even As a Technical Trader
Those who have read my features know I base the majority of my
trading decisions on technical indicators and chart analysis – and
also on market psychology. However, I do not ignore certain
fundamentals that could impact the markets I'm trading. Neither
should you.
When I was a reporter and editor for a wire service, I was forced to
learn about the fundamentals impacting all the markets I covered.
(At one time or another, I covered every U.S. futures market and
also many overseas futures markets.) I had to talk to traders and
analysts every day, and often the comments related to the
fundamentals that impacted the particular market on which I was
reporting.
3
• Know how professional traders think. Professional
traders anticipate market fundamentals and often factor the
fundamentals into prices even before the fundamentals
occur. In fact, this happens quite often in futures markets.
For example, it stands to reason that heating oil demand
will increase in late fall and winter and that heating oil
futures prices should rise in that time frame compared to
summertime prices. A novice trader may think it's a no-
brainer to go long the December heating oil contract in
September. However, keep in mind that all the professional
and commercial traders know this, and they have likely
already factored this seasonal fundamental into the price of
the December contract.
4
• Realize that markets are interrelated and influence each
other. That’s especially true for major markets such as
crude oil, gold and the U.S. dollar, which have an effect on
many other markets. This "intermarket analysis" should
never be ignored. "Intermarket analysis empowers traders
to make more effective trading decisions based upon the
linkages between related financial markets,” says Louis
Mendelsohn, developer of VantagePoint Intermarket
Analysis Trading Software™. “By incorporating
intermarket analysis into your trading strategies, rather than
limiting your scope to each individual market, these
relationships and interconnections between markets will
work for you rather than against you."
5
Make a 'Checklist'
To Help You Execute Trades
One of the questions my readers frequently ask me is how to
improve "pulling the trigger" to enter a trade. How many traders
have ever pondered a potential trade for so long that, once they
actually got ready to execute it, they then got cold feet and missed
the move?
Put your most important trading tools on the checklist in the order
of their importance to you.
7
Source: VantagePoint Intermarket Analysis Software (www.TraderTech.com)
8
Source: VantagePoint Intermarket Analysis Software (www.TraderTech.com)
The five-year chart shows that while the steep trendline of the last
year has been breached, soybean prices are still well above the
longer-term trendline to the upside. The chart also shows the
previous high around $10.50 (red dashed line) from several years
earlier that was surpassed on the runup to new highs. Once prices
moved above that point, traders looked to the all-time high in
soybean futures of $12.90 established way back in the 1973 as a
price target.
It’s like looking at a roadmap to see where you are now and where
you might be going in relation to where you have come from in the
past. If you don’t look at the bigger picture, you could be lost in
the wilderness of prices without a good idea of where the value of
the current market really is.
With both the major trendline and a previous high that now serves
as potential support crossing in the $10-$10.50 area on this chart,
that area now becomes a focal point for soybean price action and
could become a key battleground if soybean prices sink to that
level. At this point on the right edge of the chart, the longer-term
trend is still up until proven differently.
9
If the trends for different time periods do not agree and the very
first (and most important) objective on my trading checklist is not
met, then I really don't need to go any farther down the list. I'll
look for another trading opportunity.
Also keep in mind that the times you are looking at may not be
days, weeks and months but could be minutes, hours and days if
you are a more active trader and can watch the market more
closely. It all depends on your trading plan, which we’ll discuss in
the next chapter.
You may have a favorite technical indicator or some other tool you
would put on your own checklist. Every trader should have at least
a few trading tools to help them determine a trading opportunity
and how to capitalize on it. Listing those tools on paper, in order of
importance, and then examining that list when deciding each trade
should make the sometimes difficult task of pulling the trigger a
little easier.
10
Refining Your Own Specific
Trading Plan of Action
The old expressions, "There's more than one way to skin a rabbit"
or “If it isn’t broken, don’t try to fix it” come to mind and certainly
ring true in successful futures or stock trading methods. Just
because one trading method or plan works well for a particular
trader does not mean the same plan will work well for another
trader. Trading plans should be customized to fit each person.
Below are a few general questions that may help you define or
refine your own trading plan or that may help you reaffirm that
your trading plan is right on the mark for you:
11
but the point here is that some different trading tools should be
employed for each type of trader.
12
Establishing Your Own
Favorite Trading 'Setup'
My readers are always asking me about trading secrets to get into
and out of positions. Well, here is my secret: I don't have any
trading "secrets."
The first step to get better entry and exit points for your trades is a
trading plan – before you enter the trade. Then you need to stick to
it. Your trading plan can have different scenarios and options once
you're into the trade, but the key here is don't "fly by the seat of
your pants" when you're in a trade. You don't want to let emotions
dictate your strategies while you're actively trading a market.
As you are developing your trading plan, realize that the amount of
money you have to trade can dictate the markets you can trade and
how you can trade them. Know how much money you can stand to
lose and then place protective buy or sell stops accordingly. You
can tighten your stops, depending on how price action unfolds, but
don't change your mind and pull your stops when you're in the
middle of the trade.
If you've got a winner going, you should also have a plan in place
about when and where to take your profits. Again, your trading
plan can allow for some flexibility once you are in the trade.
If you are long the market, set your sell stop just below a technical
support level that's within your tolerance for a drawdown. If you're
short, set your buy stop just above a technical resistance level that's
within your tolerance for a drawdown. Don't set your stops right at
support or resistance levels, because there's a decent chance that
those levels will check and possibly reverse the price move. That
14
may prevent you from getting stopped out and then watching as the
market resumes its directional march.
If you've got a winner and decide to let your profits run (per your
initial trading plan), use trailing stops that utilize technical support
and resistance levels, moving your stops as the market moves in
your direction.
When the direction of prices is not so clear and you are in the
middle of a trade, it’s also important to employ intermarket
analysis techniques so you know how your particular market is
reacting with other key markets. Some markets can and do lead
other markets on trending price moves. Although it hardly qualifies
as a “secret” to many traders, intermarket analysis is a key in
trading a number of markets.
15
Understanding Historical
Market Correlations
In nearly a quarter century of active involvement with trading and
the markets, rarely, if ever, have I seen the type of market activity
like the events that have unfolded in recent years. A powerful axis
of three markets – the U.S. dollar, crude oil and gold – has
combined to impact most other markets significantly.
What has been different and unique recently is the degree to which
the axis influences most other markets. Arguably, the axis of the
dollar, crude oil and gold – sometimes referred to as the “outside
markets” that influence other markets – often seem to be exerting
more influence over near-term price direction in many markets
than those markets' own fundamentals. This is an important factor
for traders to keep in mind.
16
been trader favorites over the years and that today’s traders might
want to watch, keeping in mind that these basic correlations among
futures markets may have weakened or strengthened over time:
U.S. dollar-gold: The gold market and the dollar usually trade in
an inverse relationship – when the value of one goes down, the
value of the other goes up. This has been the case for many years.
During times of U.S. economic prosperity and lower inflation, the
dollar will usually benefit as money flows into U.S. paper assets
(stocks and bonds), while physical assets (gold) are usually less
attractive. Conversely, during times of weaker U.S. economic
growth, higher inflation or heightened world economic or political
uncertainty, traders and investors tend to flock out of “paper”
assets and into “hard” assets such as gold. Inflation is a bullish
phenomenon for gold.
18
Grains-U.S. Dollar Index: A weaker U.S. dollar will be an
underlying positive for the U.S. grain futures markets because it
makes U.S. grain exports more competitive (cheaper prices) on the
world market. Larger-degree trends in the U.S. dollar will have a
larger-degree impact on the grains.
19
Laying the Base
For Intermarket Analysis
Intuitively, traders have no problem seeing the correlations
mentioned in the previous chapter and understanding how
developments in other markets can have an impact on the market
they are trading. They realize markets do not function in a vacuum,
and it seems quite logical to assume that single-market analysis
will not be sufficient in today’s global marketplace where trades
are taking place 24 hours a day.
The most helpful tool I have found that accomplishes this task is
VantagePoint Intermarket Analysis Software, developed by
respected trader/analyst Louis Mendelsohn, whom I have
mentioned several times already in this e-book.
What VantagePoint does first is identify the markets that have the
most influence on a target market. Instead of correlations involving
several markets, as described in the previous chapter, the software
takes price, volume, open interest and other data through a neural
network process to find as many as 25 markets that have the most
influence on a target market. Then VantagePoint evaluates the
degree of influence that each market has on a target market. The
result is a set of intermarket data that can be used as the price input
for technical indicators such as moving averages, stochastics and
Relative Strength Index.
21
Applying Intermarket
Analysis to Trading
Rather than studying all the nuances of how the neural networks
are structured and how they evaluate the data input, I am more
interested in examining how VantagePoint’s predictive capabilities
can help me develop trading strategies that can give me an edge as
I compete with the market crowd for the best trading positions.
There are many possible tactics that can be developed with
VantagePoint’s predictive indicators, but I will illustrate only a few
of the basic techniques that traders use to take advantage of
VantagePoint’s forecasting capabilities.
22
Using the predicted and actual medium-term moving averages in
VantagePoint, the soy oil chart above illustrates three potential
crossover locations that could have been used to enter positions to
ride the long uptrend in late 2007 and early 2008. Depending on
your risk tolerance, patience and discipline, you could have gotten
long when the crossover itself occurred or you might have used
traditional chart analysis techniques and waited until the market
broke above the previous high before establishing a position,
keeping a trailing stop below the actual moving average.
I’ll work through the numbers on the soy oil chart above to
illustrate how a moving average crossover and the predicted
Neural Index and predicted difference indicators might be used
together in a typical trading strategy:
24
5 – With the predicted Neural Index at 1.00, the predicted medium-
term moving average crossing above the actual medium-term
moving average, the predicted short-term difference above zero
and prices moving above the previous high, VantagePoint indicates
another long position. With the predicted long-term difference
moving above the predicted short-term moving average and above
the zero line, the crossover could be interpreted as an acceleration
as the long-term trend gains strength and provides an add-on
opportunity.
25
Source: VantagePoint Intermarket Analysis Software (www.TraderTech.com)
26
Getting into
Intraday Trading
The basic strategy involves placing four orders early in the regular
trading session when the open is within the predicted daily range –
that is, between the predicted high and predicted low. If the open is
beyond the daily range (or if overnight price activity has been
27
outside the range and very volatile), take a pass on this strategy
and come back another day.
1. Limit order to buy at the next day’s predicted low plus a set
amount (X points, X percent of the recent daily range or some
other criteria).
2. Limit order to sell at the next day’s predicted high minus a set
amount (X points, X percent of the recent daily range or some
other criteria).
3. Protective sell stop at the next day’s predicted low minus a set
amount (X points, X percent of the recent daily range or some
other criteria).
4. Protective buy stop at the next day’s predicted high plus a set
amount (X points, X percent of the recent daily range or some
other criteria).
Set a time limit for these orders (two hours?). If your entry order is
not activated within that time limit, pull the orders. Do not try to
use this strategy late in the day. If the market moves up and
reaches your limit sell order with five minutes left in the regular
trading session, it could leave you with an unwanted short position
overnight. (On the other hand, of course, if you are a longer-term
trader, this could be an entry tactic, depending on the flow of the
market).
28
Source: VantagePoint Intermarket Analysis Software (www.TraderTech.com)
The E-mini chart above shows four days when this strategy would
have worked well during the time period shown. On other days, the
market generally (1) never reached your entry order points, (2)
opened outside the predicted daily range, (3) reached your entry
point too late in the day (opened in the middle of the predicted
daily range but closed near the predicted high and your limit sell
order, for example), or (4) stopped you out with a loss.
In effect, you are fading the day’s predicted high and low and
attempting to take a piece out of the middle of the predicted daily
range with this strategy, not a long-term position. We’ll use 2
points as our “fade” criteria – that is, 2 points below the predicted
high and 2 points above the predicted low, rounded to the nearest
quarter point, as the place to set our limit orders. Stops will be
placed 2 points above the predicted high and 2 points below the
predicted low so that, assuming you are filled at the prices
indicated, you have a risk of 4 points or $200 on each trade.
29
1. The predicted high was 1527.83, the actual high was 1527.00
The predicted low was 1507.83, the actual low was 1475.50.
You would have been short on a limit sell order at 1525.75; the
stop order at 1529.75 was not reached. You would have ridden
the market down to your limit buy order at 1509.75 to exit the
short trade. Result: 16 points or $800 profit for the day.
2. The predicted high was 1462.18, the actual high was 1461.75.
The predicted low was 1435.88, the actual low was 1485.00.
The chart and table below provide a more detailed explanation
of the results from this example.
3. The predicted high was 1511.73, the actual high was 1527.00.
The predicted low was 1507.83, the actual low was 1475.50.
This bar is similar to Example 1 but not as extreme. The main
question might be whether you entered a short trade at all
because the open was at 1509.75 and the predicted high for the
day was 1511.75, right on the 2-point criteria for the strategy.
Assuming you did have a limit sell order in place and got into a
short position at 1509.75, you would have exited at the limit
buy stop at 1501.25. Result: 8.5 points or $425 profit.
4. The predicted high was 1438.89, the actual high was 1437.75.
The predicted low was 1402.89, the actual low was 1393.00.
The market again opened in the middle of the predicted price
range and, as before, we don’t know whether the high or low of
the day came first. By looking at the long black bearish candle,
we’ll assume the market moved to its high first and then sank
to its low for the day. With a limit sell order at 1437.00, you
sold near the high of the day, pulled the sell stop order and
closed out the short trade at the limit buy order placed at
1405.00. Result: 32 points or $1,600 profit for the day. Again,
you could have made more money on this day, but that’s not
part of the trading plan.
30
different types of days – one a small loss, the second a nice profit
and the third a no-trade day.
Limit
Predicted Actual Limit sell Predicted Actual Sell
Buy stop buy
high high order low low stop
order
31
the predicted range, the market kept sliding, hitting the sell stop
order at 1458.25. Result: Loss of 4 points or $200.
Bar 3 – The market opens within the predicted price range but falls
short of reaching the limit sell order by a point and the actual low
stays about 8 points above the limit buy order in a narrower range
day. Result: No trade.
Although VantagePoint’s predicted highs and lows for the next day
might seem to be most useful for an intraday trading strategy, they
can also be used by a position trader in several different ways. For
example, assume VantagePoint’s predictive indicators have
forecast an uptrend. You could place a buy stop a few points above
the predicted high as a good spot to jump on board the pending
move.
32
Sharpening Your Trading Skills
During Market 'Noise'
33
Tuesday the futures market dropped a bit because of ideas the cash
cattle trade later in the week might not be at firmer money but
steady at best. Nobody was trying to manipulate live cattle futures
prices that week. It was just a case of differing opinions getting
center stage when the market closed on different sides of
unchanged.
The lesson here is that prudent traders should not become overly
sensitive or reactive to most of the day-to-day fundamental news
events that are reported to be moving the market on any given day.
What is important for traders is that they recognize and understand
the overall trend of the market. Daily market "noise" is usually an
insignificant part of the overall process of trading and of market
behavior itself.
34
Trading ‘Nuggets’
That May Be Helpful
The one truth about futures trading that “psyches out” many traders
is that losing is part of the overall process of trading. If a trader
cannot accept the fact that during most years he or she will likely
have a higher percentage of losing trades than winning trades, then
odds for his or her ultimate trading success are very low. Most
professional traders will “cut their losses short” on the more
numerous losing trades and “let their profits ride” on the fewer
winning trades – that’s why they are profitable traders.
It is much more difficult to try and figure out where you are going
to exit a trade when you are in the heat of battle in the middle of a
trade. Most veteran trading professionals agree that “any fool” can
35
enter a trading position, but it’s the astute and successful traders
who know when to exit a trade. Having an exit strategy, via
protective buy or sell stops, in your initial trading plan will take
you a long way toward the goal of trading success.
36
even bat .400. In fact, the best baseball sluggers may be successful
only about 3 out of every 10 times they step up to the plate.
The same is true with futures trading. The very best traders in the
world may lose on well over half of all the trades they make. The
key is limiting losses on the more numerous losing trades and
maximizing profits on the fewer winning traders. Some egos
cannot accept the fact that they may have more losing trades than
winning trades, but that’s part of the futures trading game.
38
A Never-Ending Quest
For Trading Knowledge
Not too long after that bold statement, I began to realize that
trading and analyzing markets is a lot like playing the game of
golf. The beginners don't have any idea how bad they really are!
Then, once a few basic skills are understood and mastered, the
beginners suddenly realize how difficult the task is and how much
work lies ahead on the road to success.
DO: Read books on trading and markets. Books are a great (and
inexpensive) way to continue to learn about this challenging field.
Many good futures trading books are readily available – many
more than when I first got into the trading world. Check out the
bookstore at www.TraderEducation.com and you will find many
good books and other trading resources available.
DO: Search the Internet for websites that offer free research and
educational material on trading and markets. Start with
www.TraderEducation.com where you can find my daily and
weekly commentary as well as other experts comments, trading
tutorials, etc. – all free! It's surprising and refreshing to see how
much free educational material on markets and trading is available
39
on the Internet. Exchanges also have major sections of their
websites devoted to educational material that is of high quality.
DO: Keep in mind that all markets are related and react to each
other. Don't think that you can just follow one market closely and
forget about what other markets are doing. The intermarket
analysis approach is a valuable concept that no trader can ignore.
DO: Invest in the best software and other resources that can help
you learn trading skills or give you an edge in today’s volatile
trading environment. One such tool is VantagePoint Intermarket
Analysis Software, a product of years of computer research that
provides forecasts of short-term market trends that you would not
be likely to spot with traditional chart analysis.
40