You are on page 1of 235

:

<e< < qji< ]< ,]< ]< ]< ]< _f]< c


<]< < ,l^v]< < < ji< ru< < ^f
< <=i<_<<^]<j<^]<]
 


  

t ue4 , ,7$* ?8 g 


8  T-4s A
 6 A ,7$
j4 , (  B6I v
,4  wEF 81  D ,L!
1y j4 , ,,  z-m T8_% Y. BB.
 7 
=p,D [1 d61% T]D v P( 81
C8: T6 i* u,4  4 jg; {s  reg; ,p,D [1
81 d[ D}
, [1 'D =| ,:  6B
7 ,: ,M4
='M
6B> 3 , 7,(-   ' ~  I_e  8I
L,  ,r$*
  67*  p,D /_% )1% ' ~ w
uy 6_ u:4
6
F A /_F {$> /- Z j% 6B q; 'D ,;% Y_6> i* N8I.
1 DE% hIe W$ Be% j% i* ~ _ u:4
8 =(- b[1 '
B: ~ 9  j84g :eoE ,7 u:E , $: 1-*} 
q d% ' g}:> j% ~ 6
% \ n(- 3 L: 1 ,W A * L:
K ' j8 VB$, % ~ *8E6 j8D ' re%  ,r,
,4 59, %
=\ M 3 , 7,D

r,4 -. '* E -7;% 6   =  L$L  p,4 [1
a6Zg ,p,D '* a6Z% j% _ {[ =M6. 8I  ?8$E
7E `,4 ,  , L$ '*   L$L$ / k '*
=7E * ,  ,r
,4 
=6 5,+  YE8, /+e3 i* E  'E 1  
 5,+ r}> 'D =~   % ~  6 `$> k [1 
[Ug> j% V:
,n I r(8 i* :L > V, =:L reg

6
3 ,G4 k- A d!> 3 $ N  > j%   I 7,7(
7( i* p4- ^ , ):> 9$$ D1 8( '
/ ,3 C(8 C!
5 T6 z}  ,:L
=: 6*8B

  :L j8D> , F i* .  `


a 8D M 9 ' vg> 9U% :4 9U% 0M y-
M (  T8B ' vg> 9U% ,-F *+ 9
: ?6 =$1F p-. M v[ 6, 9U% , X
joE =0M 9UF b[1 5 , A :L )DZ ,  
9

7,: O
 ,$ -M,
pI, :L 4- joE {s '* C +*
=r>s 18(
'8     81 )D. e% % :1   L$L 
, 4- 9$  Q / 6,> , L$, C>  hw 8B
Q [1 jODR j6 z:1 =K, _0U%  'y {s ), j% i*
=-. /87L i*  4- p,D [1  =-. N6  ,_0UF
d[ k 'D =jeQ T6 -. -DE 89>  :1 U% '
j-B  
 %  :6 0<Q 4- 6 81 p,D  rE `,4
:6 . i* D8D :D D, V7,e K E =* 
LP D j8D> j% 81 P6 L  j4 ,  C,+$
-D> 'D
=,e,>-
% D84 ue4 q8 ,G < 7,e

,:6 n,  
 q8}e A T% ,e,>] hP89
:6 -.
9 u 8> '  - 5 =: 6 'y 'D

; 4 Y d% ,I} -. ' 5 % 


9 },
 8I
-! 3 {s j4  .  < r,B- r>6B, ,U 
 6.  -DL 6t 1 =-U ; d% i* S
=:6 -DL '* 'D%  ,
3 NZ eO$* L$U i* p-X
j%  : O4 1 -. '* j8E6 G d: , -DL
U6, ' C8D. 5: j% 6
3 ,* % \ I} -.
3 9 8D. =7,$1% 8D. ' T6 '* -: ?
,7E
~ * 7I$U% e 7_6<% C8D. wE% V, E ,LD>
-}, 0
= 6B I} -. 7E j8D> j% X: C3  U6,$ q-Q

10

1  :Nge j% :
'R ,B_6 <L,  N8U6 _ 'D
 - -L j N8Be K :e s ?jeQ \ V , -. 
,-U `e( ' ?zs % 8 : [1 i* r> R % ,zs % [1 L j%
rE ?, /> - 5 y  j8D j% je dF 'D 3 re% @6 '
-F [1 j% )$, ~ E8$E j8D> jF (
u
b81 i*
=q} h4
X: s ?-L -. 6 1 OE =5:, -% 81 B$9 -. d%
- {s  O
,6$  ?61F 5 ,- /69I> K a6R j%
?N+ [1  ?, ' A e6;- %6 z:1 1 ?d '-U
6B % 81 ,- $ |% h-> z:1 =7Le -.
%6:
% r> U [L:> i* -L [1  6_ ,rE%  -L$ , C 
6
3 C  j%  :eM 9B: A vge h-, 6
=7:
,U3
;% 5 C   p w, eD '* {1e ,6m j8D> j%
6B> ' 6
3 ' re% )$ #.
)7Le ?::
OE ,e hDE ,'-U
=rLe 6B
-L -.
5,,
5+$ n 8 e i* -L -
~ B*  , s ,: K
_0 ):> ,B [1
j% 8I,e j% 0
,B /: [1 =  8e ' /e 8( j : K
, 8F
)B K
 jeQ     F B 1 , -. K
e28
 -. '* , A -9we j% jF ' M4  a6R =T-UF
j% 'D T6 d% A ?j  81  'D =7: )1% T-U% )_ 
- $ &/ -  " z:1 1 ?T-UF )B 
B -. '* ,  e
-: ?
N8F ' N dg
6% rD7,: j% ~ 6
% 28 3 I}
j8D re% 'e d[  % {s '* g}: j% 'D d[  '*
11

=-. # j% r$U 28 3 /- z:1 =)e ?U6, {s _*


=r:  r vg: ,N! [1 i* ~ 2, ~
8(  9
,-1 7,
i* ,-. 6  N8 P6 $ F b[1
vg> ='-DL T8_% N8B* u6_ C , DP} 4}
$
X: d[ &/-." k9:
 N! i* 
( / 6_ re%   %
,-EQ V, X
), reg
r
8( h<t  6_ =- $ j8D j%
=7_9e 18_ -. /87L  $Z i* M4 CB,e z:1 ue4
=r:  {s i* vg: 
,L: `1[ % L: /87L i* 1-18(   DE% /8B>
`1[ =6. _0UF -DL  F   ~  `$ d[
p8< % ,  -DE : ,k0UF  `1[ ~  % 81 L:
L  % 
8- E =`_8  % i* BE ,bg9U L
 81 :1 
8IB = % L: c,e ' hg,> 
d[ L 81 `PI L j% {s V: =L
j-g, '[ 5^
[1 A }  ~  =, P6 5^ K
'  % L: )  
ry O4 ,D 0D L: `1[ -: =&L: %6" re% i* 
% i* % ,, % [$ i* P_ -e  A ,b /M:

Le  % i* [$ A - :  ,WF [$ K


j28 d[ 9B
d[ ,/M:
( '* b6 '* L: -DE  a  6_ =$B* %
=-DL : ' b68 &- pF" j4
,M4 C06> r$* U% L: `1[ < *%  'D
E- _0UF 6B, 6*8B K
 r:
YE8, ' ~ *8e a6t R V,
12

L )1L 8_ -L L: 6B> K j% (% ' ,: T6
8}  :D _9 )B j%   % {[4 = I}
_F i* 4;3 ND;% ' D; CeD h}D, j% :6
8_ 7$ j% ,dI,_3 `e  'D W j _0UF 7e( 
i* )P_ 8,L 5, (% ' /6B, 8. 9, %- -- ,
=-.
b* '* ,rLe  '* 6. %  6B b[1 6

rO*% r,I; '* ,b DE% u$D; rE C-% ,  r,L$U
=*  8I

*
*
*
 # ,1806 /*  j6:   C 8, j8( 6t
 /7  r ~ U ! ~ E8$E  #( b6 j4 =u 1 r,(2
N0U j8( r:
 i* g> T8_% r j4 =#L: )$* I,_3 )$*
K 1805 /*  =b< r,8L  r> 7E u$D}> , C8:
,/8*% 
b-XI> ue4 , ,u 1 ' c > ~ * 32 r: j4
G i* Ke+$ VL}, -6> ue4 $ F T]D :
3 ue4
c  6
 =#(  rD$ X< u
A j(  B,e =
$P y% ' q, 3
(  C-; =j8( '
3 6t :

j4 d[ ,#( K


~ }E ~ ; 59B:> 8 N C[U% O4 ,I
-; 6BE 6  i* =r,(2 K
 ,- A  ]I A -B,L
{[ , 8}  -g> ,r>6 I} r
% E-
r,8L  j8(
13

 ,S  0 N0U ' 3 ,~ _0 1-4s i* vg 3 b6+e


'6 l  j8( g}e 1 =r>  '* r,4 d[ p,D
uU% u,4 #( 68 E ' C8: 6
=8L( 6*>  j}
,(2 c2 ,KI;  b[1" :{[4 u 1 7  ,MM j8(
'* k 6
,6 hB uZ ,O7w
'* '6
j}
8 : i* j8( / % $P CB6< T6 uL< 6_ H1I=&p-X
=H2I&( 
7: 
r;% , %- #( c > 6B" :|,
d[  ? #( 7: c > hDE , %- u 1 ue4 s
6
'-U NL% 8 7: `+: ,: 66Z Ie% ' 81 ,r$(
,r> `>4 j8  81 ,Bain Kt
h< 6_ ?j8( 3
7lQ B- wE% j% 6B, pF j4 =& 8; 0
" reg
#( pF

H3I
= 76 5t : &)7$Ps " E- N0U ' 1 b3F r

,c6]4 ( 9 ,   :   =2004 =j ,d6


4 1
5 =
Capaldi, N. 2004. John Stuart Mill: A Biography. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.

,#48
{
=   !" =1975 =-
,t 2 2
153 = ,z 88e

Mazlish, Bruce.1975. James and John Stuart Mill. New York: Basic
Books.

=1966  z 88e  r 6*% =1882 =   :K


3
=334
A. Bain, John Stuart Mill (1882; reprint, New York: Augustus M.
Kelley, 1966)

14

,H1I/M:
( ?8$L
 #( VB, 1808 /* 
,b-* ' K,  j4 K ,e9-
 L: `1[ p <% ;
A ~ M4 #( r
-g> 6_ = XI r*>% ' ~ 6 {s 6
n<%
i* /M:
f Y9> ue4 , C3B ' ~ 4 ~ 6* `,4 re% ( 
rBL C-, E I - )$, 8D. _ ' 5y8
'* r
,4 `e( A ,1-7;% `,D ' ~ 6* {[4 h% =j8+
,H3I1821 )* +,-. /+ p,4 ,H2I1818 #$% &'(
=H4I1829 01 23 45  6 p,4
2+e )*% joE ,p+* M C2+eQ b[1 4 )
~ P_ /M:
A #( %
,U XI j8( j r 0
6BE =r:
 81 #
, 6( D
b6 )$> i* ?S% &=:$D
~ -6( L$U" j8D
I 6_ j8D j% 'D  k8L 89 V7,:  )$> i* I
q  6 ' {s ?-e ' e =r:  ; d% r$*
=r>E : e d[ ,(7   87} r
,4  r,   '* <L,

b6 r %6
 =ee8 X$  ~   VB$, j8( [U% MM ' 
z->g  =b-DE   j8(   -F $
% \ j4 _; $> $
r> '* > $
% ]> 7:D ~ e $8 -BE  r,
- '* a6 , 
:L {$>  r,Le
=18321748 /M:
( 1
The History of British India 2
Elements of Political Economy 3
Analysis of the Phenomena of the Human Mind 4
15

~ ( j
' }: V7,:
 r$*  j4 b6 : 0
rLe %6
/ ,$ j% r: 5_8, ' joE ,u_ d% *y /6* %6 N0U
j | _ 6_ =ee8 X$ )$ ,
C%6

V, -4s% 3 =b[$> )$> 6:*

 b-4s% q /6_% j =d-* ' MM  u:4 K j4 [1
 * j4 ,C-L r$* Y$%
~ ; d6 9*% K 81 8I
, $+eQ X$
7e 5 * ee8 CO$4 i* ,}> P_ '*
)$>% W =`$_ -7l '* 7LF 1 :9 C_9
i* 7,D j4
qO F -UF 
-*Q C4-. 
0U === ~ ; 6*8B '
:^ A S u$B,e ) ,C-L -B 6
7,  , ,NEF
,p8 CD q-_  C[U% :e%  8 e i* -4s% j% 59, %
' Anabasis $. p,4 j4 =ee8
b%-_% p,4 N% j4 d[
X$ ' q d% )$>% W =ee8
b%-_% p,4  81 j8E8:2 hg>
~ 6* %-_% j% *
V, :>0

j4 u_8 {s _ 'D =:M uX$

8 #>1 p,4 C%-_ % -4s% )7:


' ,e8 -M: p,4 '
'4:7  - )$> '#94' j8E8:2 ,4 ,r$D
&'
p,4  Cq( O4 L 0L 
 i* u$ ,;42 <=
,j 8 ' ~ q ( ,>?> : @A  ,-0 #:(8
~ $_
&'( 6648 ' ~ q ( {[4 C%-_
% 'l% ,-_  ' 0

 C%-_
{[4 =r]  :% K
 '* ,'B9  C4

C m u N% b-* ' 


   j4 K d% 1813 /*
C  
~ - 4>DE ' ,87 `> ` ,j80EF
j% %  ,H'I V, H (4: ) #'
) '4-G ) F
#
~   , ' j4 reF ,7E[ wEF ' j4 UF    b[1
16

5_8, ,:9 j4 ,r   5^  ,d6 'D =77E% j% | :

~ 6
%    'D W q;% 
,    _% N[
% j% BE # ,:
j4 d[ 6, 3 T6 i* )DR j% f B$ 'D =G /8_% j%
N8B> , BB. ' ,$> (% ' `Ie `,  , r6
i* 7Le E-X  ee8    wZ $* D
C - :e
'D W /F {$>  re% ,* i* ,7$* `,D j4 , 7Le 9
j% d 6B
'D W , $+eQ A ee8 ' #8B 8( z:1
X$
ee8 CO$D  9> , 8(8 #8B ' 6L, %
u:4
6_ '4% W F :>0
|,
 ,K. {s  :>0 )$ ,
C%6

b[1 )  :1: ?-*% '4% W $4 4 V: '* r! A -9y%


 ~ ]< N(- _% ' 81 ,| uI: j4 re% 3 ,$<8, B
 ,  r
,4 ' C6$ 6* B b[1 l  h! j4 ,W
=H1IC8: {$> N0U r,D j% r$* j4  4 #$% &'( d%
)$ > ,ee8 `,D C7% %-_ j% 6
 ,* eM $
K
/_ , 8, ' ~ 6* {[4 `,4 =yL, p  6:\ ]
`,D
%6
 ,Y9:   6
[U% ) =/8$  Cq-B 

d-DE * N% j rLe '* N8B = 6 Y9: )$> , :>0
j8 $D NO*F *8 ' s8Ug  '* 7$Be% , 618} 5^ 1
9 1e i* uES% ,~ 6$ 33  *8+ b[1 5B> = C 8,
t
j8( --Z ?S ' ,N8
j+4 6e% c6$>
e  8,e 8> (
  p,4 5B =1991 A 1963 ' : 28 1e k-X,  6_ =j8

JKL p,4 ,* 'M q   87E '4 p,4 % =NF 6$+  (7
9 = ,NF q  ' s8Ug 61} [1 =S q   M3>$
17

9X 6I i* -M*  6 E + n> 81 qL4 d% rE YB


j% r:
 i* 64% 6_ ,L: f
Y
'! j4 b6 j%  =7E
=Y9:     &L:" z:1
/M:
j% ,:,e :eoE ,53 q4[
5,, re% {s 6
K> re% 
~ 9
BE # +,e%  #(
~ I; Oe ,L: `1[ N9
% ' 0
i* j-_ 5
1 6B B % b9*% r$> j j8( N_ 6_ =Y
~ -B*
,1
ue4 {s 
B  7E , I} L$D, 'D =re-_%
j ,b6 7 O j4 , 66} -9E =r,8L ' /-t  reF
% L
r6  d% C  %  , {s  
-X,  ue4
`$ W" : j8( '* q_6<F 6% N_ B3 $-  =8L
p,4 ' 79; -BE H1I&=6 d% ?- W r>  ,6 d% 5 ~ 6
%
:  %-Be ,r_ % K
7$* -tM* 'D ,(7  
, _0UF 8 d% ,:1 :@ d[ -F OE 'D
 16(% , 8F -M4% ' j N8B ' | 6
3 ,*
1-% \ j4
b8 e -} 'D W ,`.
b8 e j-} 8e8D W % q:
% j% D$7
`. p  Cg}e
1 ===8 q?6 -*}
-U ; d%

' ,-4[ ' V  3 M4 }:, b[1  j =?8 8w 


H2I
&=_0UF d8 e uL_% % 
  :z
j8( {[4 =202201 = ,rLe 5(- ,t2 1
=6866 = , 
M. St. John Packe, Life of John Stuart Mill (London: Stecker &
Warburg, 1954), pp. 6668.

612 = ,NF 6$+ =$D NO*F : C 8, j8( 2


18

' '  j4 K ->  j% p-X, ' # {[


W -DE 
% \ ue4 ,I 3 . p,43 ' . b-*
 $L 2F 'D =1836 /*  b6 E 6
3 ~ P 7: c-
[U% 6BE =1827 /* 5
V, ,-7;% 6 |8 C-,  .  8<
+7
-} ' reg
-; ,  ,e3
DE% b-> p,43 A 
C[L e j8D- 7y , C_3 j% 8 V, -  
H1I
C[
 $ b[1  7O,

X j% 8 V: ,b 6<  BM


-; K b6:* Q %6

:5}B:>
=L> W 7:D ,7Le qB$> ' 5}B:, OX j% u::l
6 

'D , . CIX: F 6 81 /8: ,$$ {$> ue

b[1 ,$wL ,4 q-B


Le '* hLU% j% u
~ M* =T6( j

8B 7: 6, % O~ P u:4


, r,*  8 i* 618}
'D , 8}
1%-_% % % , 8; j j 1%-_% :D =8.
 ,$  j% ~ :,B u <%
;1- 
 d% j

=H2IrLe qB$> '  Ts ,r>s (% ' 2,0


ue4 p,43 C3 'D ,2F ' rLe  },e 7: 
A  ~ I; l re% )  =r> B
N0U -U K ' b>

139 = ,Y
 5(- 1
139 = ,Y
 5(- 2
19

]$ f '* ~ 4s ~ 8_ ~ E6 n<% re% 3 ,jF )  6
=D 0D
,KD- K  '-DL ' B$ )w> ue4 
  g}e
,Ricardo  D 6L )7: ,/M:
`e( A b6 q_6<% ' 8e4 '[
', % j8( ,* 5 , j-B P%   I,_3 qO$* 2-
%
,Grote C-( c 8( ,j8eB  y8 -:  ' ,Austin

->  N6+$ M `e8 ' =6B je8  KI, 4 '
 , '" j% #( 6( 6BE =: C6B, % j g}e re% 
K
5 5e< 5:< 't 81 6. [1 A 
~ $ ~ * jg
jOQ
j% ],* r:D ,` E [1 # =& _% K
 q 4 i*  6B
j4 d[ ,r:
  8} [1 - =&k0U 6* )*%" 81 '6
r4D, $_" 'D ,r
  *O,(3 8  r: , j% 'D '
=.Q %  8(8
?*3 K
rM%  , j% ' r,: &:

%6 8$_ '[ p} ' ^  D; 231822 q,; 
i* Y$9 j%  -_ =&  k0UF  )7 ]e" re% i* L:
Utilitarian &Le" n$9I U 1 ,&L: ^" )  
,6:\ j!; `,D  b6 r:* 1823 /*  = $+eQ X$ A
35 |8 rE B
 ,e9] 8D $ 
>  -P j4 d[
=r>E V, 1819 /* [: b6 rE * d[ rLe `,D  ,~ *
7  j4  :
 ,~ 66;   7% %- '  c > 6_
u 1 uE8> c  ' C8: 7 6
 =r,U% r% )  M ,u 1
j4 K '4 C: 6< ' : _ d% ,1858 /*  g+E
20

5
59Be" : N_ E 6
 =e-E  j8:E% :6  j( 
' 6  rP9* r$* i* g,  wL 7 `e 6_ =&v
`$X> r,(2   d% j% A  ;% O8E- 8e4 '[ 'D =Y
l j8:E%  ~ ,
 T; 6_ =*8y8 A -B,L L r$*
,q*Q
-} ~ D7:  j4 K ,1873 /*  = -, 
b  
 8> V.
`<% 7(Q `, ' /8 6
 =j8:E% A `1s
]_ `e+
j8:E%  'E =: 67 b-* j4 ,1873 8 % 7
=r,(2

t > ,L$, 5y8  C3B `,D ' ~ 4 ~ 6*  `,4
-7
=rBB , 6 V7,:
* d[ - j28, b-DE   rB* T6
1843 N$L OP r,4 ' = I,_3 Y9:  C7  r
JKL 1861  Q"  1848 )* +,-. /+
rB h<t  6_ =1874 <'# R .2 S?I 1863 M3>$
N8 je r,4 NB )1%" reg
_0UF /8$ Y9: N8 j8:
H1I
&=*O,(3 /8$ 7:

Lewis S. Feuer, John Stuart Mill as a Sociologist: The Unwritten


Ethology, in John Stuart Mill, On Socialism (1879; reprint, Buff
alo, N.Y.: Prometheus, 1987), p. 10.

21

22

H1I

TU VE W#= : 29 +

E  C  ,1859 /*  ,-. '*  p,4 6< 8E


=e9-
 d 8,DL   ?8g '* 7E c-U , rP i* 8_
=2: 0
NF -. ?8$E b ,*
  p,D 'D
( 6
`,4 
% i* -. /87L  $Z p,D -*  u:,
 1

='4 <=  C: :1989  Riley je8( p,4 81 NF =AF
t e 
-. p,4 '* 2,     `,4 6_ =z 88e j6: ,c6$>
 E j8:
,Acumen $$ ' 5 , j-B L$L I p,D 
j8( --Z ' ,2005 1= Z 42 TQ @BX :>* > J
t
# IL NB ,R =e9-
,/}}> ,6  '84%
e  ,6e;
=c  Gray d-( j8( --Z ' M =158127 = ,p,D '
e  ,1991 L '4 C: R .2 j8:
Smith 
t
<= F
+ j8:
{[4 d-( j8( hg> ' 5
- =z 88e j6: ,c6$>
t
=z 88e j6: ,c6$>
e  1996 eM 9 ,L '4 C:
]$ * :$ ~ 6! j4 1983 AF 9  d-( h_8 j% A }
 ,1996 eM 9  rL_8 
r:D =|]$   6:*
i* ,6$B, CB,e3 /% 6I> 3 -. '* E6$  + j% T-
9>- -. p,4    kLU q  Y*F p F j% ,*
)1% , ,\D;% 5^  ]$ 5  ] 7E z}> , CO

-: i* /8B d /6B,  , N8 /87L 1 k [1  O


-. p,4 N8 C  6 j% A ;% j% % =xi = =
 F  4-
`,D ' -U ~ 6* 5(- P_  uy 6_ =Z 3  6:* 787L
=7 u(
,

23

N:>g  =: K
q-_ ~ },e r,4 5 % 81 p,D [1 N  3
E6 , p,D N8IE  7y-* ,  DE% p [1 
'* r87L 6g>   1 8 , +. b DE% '* r6B d[
=-.
p,D$ ~ I$> 1],e j% 'D NF IL  -BE z:1
 Y> -89> 5 8> 81 Oe -. '*  r8B  4 j% ,r$D

:-BL b[1  q(


reg
+ ,X$ 
%6 C 81 NB [1 ' ?6\
 b-E% 5 5,+ G , ,  LD B$9  8I
)DR j% `
$L 8B /6, 
q8 ,-9 b-4Q i* d89:> , 8F
ry-L d[ _0UF b-4Q N0U ' % e8e_ C
8B* D; i*
,H$  N\  E < M # '] :|, 81 %6 [1 =/ d%-
0E ^9 O2' 0K 3> '4_9  
 `#' E ,=a E '+4
,9
<"' 0K # h#% gK 'b M ,Z"cL +4
E < def
,i_L Z"cL +4
E < +4
0E _ N ^9 2 j ^ E <
d% n< j =<'4`l m= i F- +   M ,^U #k
 U6,$ ~ E4 ~  ], 3 ,_0U% % ~  ~ .< j4 q8 ,-E
r
/B /6* %  -g
/B$ -L b-4 Y r( i* 'D 3 =r48$
% ,_ ds ' 6 % r$+ {s jF % ,{s L j% r.< ' jF
p F b[1 =~ P< ~ -% % O~ D ~ -% '-U d%  ], {s jF
-F _:e j% % ,r>E> i* , e :e r N8Be jF  ~
 % ],>
i* r1-4Q # ,r  8,e % ,r9
:,_3 i* r$ e % ,r
24

b-4Q d% {s ]e V, =h 8 e i* ?> s r,Bw %  -%


r n(- ~ 48$ r:* b7:e j% 8e d[ z8$ j8D j% 6
3 pB %
; d% z8$ ' 68 q  =-U ; q[  `, j%
='-U d[ q  81 5,+ /% ~3! reg}
j8D d[
=/, N0B, 3
5,, j% rB ' joE b6 81 rI d[ q  %
=H1Ir$B* b6( OE rLe 6 jeQ
}_: 81 ,p,D ' rE61 
NF IL  n,,L =1
?6G ,-L i* 7,  5,+ 59, , 8B ' 'D 6_ _%
=-. ' -L r$* IR j% 'D 6_ _% jOy
)1 8I* h$,  :$ `P6  -,    [Ug
 -. j N8B =9$ -. K
 '* ,-. (% '
/D. jF , jX9 ' K8D  O. $  ue4 
[U% '  - 5 'D =: C- 5B 9$
j8,, ue4
=)7,- YBZ (% ' 8D. 8_ i* 6 5y8 j8 :
8D. j8D> j% % z  A : <8> V, DEF C 89>
 j8D 89, [1 j% : ' M4 ],* 6_ =`}$ $M
i* `} 9$ j% ,)7Le% 8B j% 8$B ' : jF ,jX9
[1 E-  'D =n I GIe  8F 5y8
$L4 rLe
8 )@6%  9$ j8D, '[ : j N8B },
8(8  { 8 F  =. 9 ' 5554 ,-. p,4 1
=64g,$ r,y Oe ,<F : 
25

6 > 3 :   j N8B ) =9$ E )7$* 5B ' )1  

d% ,jX9 ' 8: [1 j% 64! =K8D  $%   84 i*


jX9 ND;% ' -U D; d% '* b-9U  B 3 ,$F jX
ND;% ' MD
%8 % V, j8D `X  re% T- re 
=
 X$X, i*  6B r6 ~ },e 5 % Y*% reF ,T-UF jX9
z:1 j% A  <8, {s 6
=5,+  )0> : 
i* 8M j% 0 5 ,'7 d%- ' 8: [1 ' _8$ (
=K\
# -% $F g, 8B % n I 6.
-E r0U ' 5,+ 59, d[ N+ j%  d% '
; 5y soE ='-U ' #L:  jOy  81 -L i* bs8Le
Y 5,+$ #$E ,rLe i* 3 ~ -9U D} 3 r$ 5y8  rLe
i* r% 5,+ -L j% LD 3 reg
[1 r%  L =U6, 
6 -E 4 jF ,g9U % p8< d%- [1 j% T- re% -+ r:8
~ B, ~ :P4
,N0B, 3 [1 ' NLF :M,  'D =r>s 6
0
re 
,)7Leg
: i* j 6B 3 '[ ;F {[4 :M,
A L9 I K 'D = '  89,  :(F {[4 :M,
8 3 ,` : 89, A K #:( -E% I K ,w: $-
= _ jeQ i* r_ -E  Y 5,+$
pB 5w j% ` ,'-U q[  ; `> soE
'* ~3! j8D j% ` } j%  T- =rEF +,e ,j8eB
{s T% s r*B> '* % ,-U ; 8 e S  S TsF
X: jeQ - j%  T- {[4 =-U ; i* TsF 8_ A
26

 r,- ,U6 k9: d% z Q *8  r,- i* ,}> j%


 r,- ,b DE%
 rLe '* ,  r,- , 8} -DL
)7w
A /Owe3  -EF - ,r$} r>81 r_s ,U
=C*^  ~ w

jF ,-9L
5,+ r:* ]  #D* 1 b DE% j%  -}
,L d%-  YE8, /+e3 'E i* 4 6 A /8B 5,+
rLe 5,+ 7E -L , C3+ j% 81 5_8  a6R d[ 'D
= -, 
5 8,> -L i*
[1   O.
L> X$
`,D  j% 81 :1 r0e 
 -EF k8B '* a6 , 81 =-. '* E6$ I p,D
ds!> 3 )\E% C}> ue4  )  j}  8$L j%
jF ,L: b DE% 81  6:* -: b[1 6I N. 9
='-U
r,L: )> i*  6B ; D j8D jg
d: `1[ [1
{[ =$ )7  '-U i* ~ $ -!> 3 ue4  r> 
-. jeQ q9* i* C-B6  6_ ' -
 -}
i* -9 'D 1g>  ' :9E -M4% % -} reF , :
i* ,6 jX 1 -B6 j% T- re 
=MD
5 % 5,+
)@% j8y-L 5,+  K$*L K  qw*F  8 e
=j8e_ A $F -_ N8 , 5,+ n< 8I

i* ,} re% ,* i* ,p,D q (% )1% IL [1 D}


7$* /8B> , P- # F {[4 -4[ ,+ $  F D\
MD
k8L> X$ 8_ 9$
5,, re% i* 5,+ A -: 87E =+.
27

={[4 N. j8D> j% E- 87E |,


 =rLe i* -L r
5,, 
r$M d[ 8eB `e 2+,> *O,(3 z8$  e  2]t  
5,+
`_ jg
B 3 =*O,(3 [: % *3 81 ,5,+

i* -7 d[ ,_0UF 


8, N0U ' S   8I
}

={s A  % 64 r,$ % } [e M ,E D;


B: -DL - }_: A M IL   B,: =2
,~  < $F d% j8D j% 'w  z:1 # re% 6B, re =N6
D} 3 r>s 6
$F d% jF g9U i* : j8D j% 'D '
d% d%  < j% {s =@6 Y$9 KB A  3 B9: 9$
IL [1   :9 =~  O7$4 % 6 % Y9: i* /8B> j% `
=$F _ ' Z 3 , q9UF i*  , ' M4 $M%
- j8D j% ` &BB" : r  j% i*  
` re N8B =6( 6B* A  , reoE 3 ,  [U% Be
g
8$B j% ,BB. j8D$, )% j], '[ ,K  i* V,
~ M p =?-F 5^ A CIeQ
b],* d[ ,-B  0
=8_ O 6P d%- hU reF ,r6*o
_ ~ -S 5,+
~ M p -U ?-9 i*
84  - 8]3  0
5y -6B> q %  ,rLe u_8  ~ E8$E j4 d[ ,8$ %
' r:* ?-t *  ) 8B
1679y e-  8]3   
=r,I;  n>
q  5_ i* /2. ry* q  p F  : 
r,+ =q  CD  q-( ' Tsg,,  j N8B 87E =y 
28

 reF ,~  < j8D j% 'D 8B d%- j% 1 {s  AF


 5  ~ -% -B jF  r #$E /8I je 6(8 3 re%
d%-
, BM ],> 3 =)16:* ' /Dg
: vg j% j N8R
~   6:*
C q E u  ~ MDE ,d%- {s  < i* 0
r,+ - j% 6
 =  <  % {s 6
K> ) K: C
p [1 ' M ,CB,e ' 16y M j% 'D   -: ,AF
g9U i* : j8D K V, re :NB K E =7 B: ' ~ 6*
' ~ B j8D d[ jeQ ,)1y YE ?,
j8 $ )oE
r$* ~  < b-  ~ BE ?, W 81 j ~ e( j8D r%  <
 jg
{s i*  - ,6 L q  6I
n 3% |,

j% 1 r%  < ' ~ B j8D j% } 7E 'D , 68


jeQE =re09
C r% w_: A   > - z:1 j8D>
=N6 ] N0U ' 3 ), 3 {s 'D ,rP9U% n I> i* _
=6B:$ y-* 84 ' 3 vg> 3 /DF _ j
{,> j%  `( C8D. i* j :N8B -U d% z:1 )
6- ' joE N. 9
 =5,+ n< U 7E : C6B,

 - =L 1% ' 3 j8D ' $ C6B, b[1 ' :
j% ,r,I* i* ~  N  3 d%- [1 T- ' j r8B
[1 i*
= 8. N0U ' 'D 8 e wE% i* vg b6( d%- 0<
j% r$* `$X r% 0I
'! ' j% 81 ,~ B* ~ -% :1  0
=r$* )y* 5B j% ,'-U :
-F [1 --B, V
t >  Oe   >  q9UF %8 % j  N8B
nI ) 
uD
=n -B  K$M ,:L$ % O4 ,{[ p =/
29

N8B K , -DE  <F |]$ `e IL [1  T-e


'* {1e ,6 d% CD Q V, 9$ {$, 3 q^  j
# 0E m= n 3a H$ :  :?-.
N8B =$_F d% CD 
' < n 3a H$ o
, pE4 qr 0E ^ #  @$Q9
N < # det K% ' j det K G 8 n 2 s-E
81  5 % j% 59, % 4%=H1Iu#2"9 v7 : G wG 8
CD  j% '> O
= :r8B
$ b[1 6
~ :y f B `
-DE b[1 'D =6. [1 A  -F
# x2
# ;
=b-e 7( S  16
 =` { ,U
,-L -. i* 8B 6>   [Ug M IL  =3
-. /87L ~ 47,e 6 > j% j -L i* 7y-E r%  'D ,
'D , C3.  3 /, -L N0B, 
'! re =)$ r7(8

3 re N8B ,-9U  '-U :  % 5w j% } [\ 7E


d[ -9 j% T- =q 4 - j8D> j% X: NEF j% 6% *6
N0B,  b 5,+ r
), d[ /3 /6* 81 -L -. 67,
6
)_ -% 1 -L PB$, j% ], 3 5,+ j% V:
,-L
r$ j% T- 5,+ jF ,r,1E  r> 23 % T- 3 ,s
 6B * % z:1 j% T-  'D =5+$  j8D> jg
$L4
 =7: L, 3 
-+, L> i*  6B , ,U3 i* jeQ
reF ,)7:
OE /+e3 i* -9L W  j% 81  d%  {s 2 
 8(8  { 8 F  =. 9 ' 65 ,-. p,4 1
=64g,$ r,y Oe ,<F :
30

=6$B, 'E 1 7(, e , 68  7 joE {[4 N. ue4 8
,< rE r> ; D j8D j% r%  )7 ' joE {[
_9 6I 1 8B 5E6E =6
I} )B,> 3 8% 1
=bS bU ,}: X,   5E6 d[ 8_8 ,I} 
5,+  PB$, <F -DL % i*  4- {[4
8$ BB. '* 8M  j% j8$B, j-DL 59, s =eQ
> j% YPB $ j4  {s 38 ,: K
7M
 7E},4 i*
=h},D
59,> 3 -B j% {[4 n I ' 'D , e -B j% n <
$$ -L$ j,23 -L -.E =-. ' 8(  3 -
#L:,
jeQ )$ >   F 1 : K
CE0,U3  j =*O,(3
K
5  :D  6B T-e :$ 8:, joE {[4 =rLy `e8(
:
/ ,3 )7$* -Le K 'D =KL$, e% K

Q CO
j8L$, :E =~ w
)7w
' )$ , K
 )7:
N8R [1 joE K
=?0,U ' )7:
 ?}D,  )\ , j% ` 59

,-. ' `e  : {, W 8 V, re%  T-
5+}> ,  5 )7$> )7E}De ' ~ ; j8$, )oE
q  N6>  ~ - 5,+ j4 s =B [1 ' d[ z8$
-M4% 8D j8D, +,: joE $F q d6Z 66 DEF
' 8: [1 =*8
j8,, ' 89, K:8 ' hg,> qL4
=)\8 ) ; rE :$ , ,~3 6 % ~ , }: 89,
8 e 8B h8 r(8> * A d! -*} 5_ j%  6B,
4 ' 5L,: ?8 r$D
5,+ j% T- re ) =q:
u 8%
31

K
 5,+ K
N8R ?8 {s jF ,jeQ  d-L `e i*
=rE  3 ~ 64 j8D 5_ -%  8B
/,e3 /6* -L j% i* '1] j% IL [1   NR
j% 6B, 81 =*O T8, i* -L T8, i* j,_ j, 
$* N0U ' Y, /,e3 [1 j% ,/,e3 wL r9
5,+
 ? 6, =5,+ i* 1O -9 N0U ' -B6
87E =*O,(3 8eB T8, A jeQ  d-L `e u4 '
_* -,> 6L $ C 
/6B, i* -L  6_ j% T-
-L 6 K {s ,d-L 89, } w: K
 r:
NR
r(  K U  / ,3
r9 d[ / Xw 7(8  rLe
9 K
/ ,3E =5 N9> , Ke8B$  - 8B
9  . 5 ,$ 66(  ?},4 ' 5,+ /-R 6
Q
~ y `$9,  d%  *O,(3 /6B,E = :
K
)$, 
=
w, .  K
- [UF ' ~ D:
 N8 / rP6 i* _6 qLy  {s 6
 [Ug =4
5,+ 9$ 6 5
- IL  _: , b-4Q 6
A ( z:1 j%  T- =IL$ ry d[ j8: 81 ,-L i*
-L - $ rE j8D d[ N+ 8I
ny  8(
81 =-. b[1  U6, j% 5,+$ rE YR d[ N+ ,:\
k8B k-U /6
/ $
reoE 5,+ ; U6 K re% i* YE8
5E: O. 
B ,'-U q[ /6* ,*O   ,'-U
=5,+ {s ' 7$* IR ,
32

8_  j% 'D 3 T-U% k-9


'-U js! '[ :
 5+} =pB 
M
rD 5,+ d% j8D Oe ,j8eB

5,+ i* j N8B =ds! -L B,e  ,


87 /8B j%
NO, ' '-U -[Z K -E N8 r  /6,   ~ (
/6, 
 7E n , P0B C- ' 1 b[1 =-9 8_
=B % b-4Q
j% 'D ' j N8B  joE ,rLe 3 -L ds! 3 O: 'D
joE 7:  'D ,r.< *-> , PwL V:, D : r I:
5:, soE =C -_ ' rI  s  -. 4 ; D
) , i* r:6 j% 5,+ 59, 0E r.< *- '* }
 1  C*9e3 b[1 =~  ~ *9e r:* [Ug j% )Do
j%
re% 5,+ b-  5t, 3 d[ } [1 ds! j% 7:  'D
rLe i* -L r$+, d[ 9 pB
V  [1 =r.<
joE ,: ' 9 pB A EyQ
 =rL: rE% 8I

87E |,
 ,rL: ds! 81 TsF E r$* 5B d[ 68 }
=r6 i* r
B B$, 9
j% 'D , q  N:, +. 
 /6B IL [1 
'-U C-  U6, b ~ L_8 [, j% 6
 =r,-e >
'* M r>-DE  p-9y3 `P8} 2 NR rL_8 ny8
-  5,+ /% ~ P ( K! :  87E =-L -.
: 5^ NE% j% 64! ' j4 j Nq, K =) ' :
87E {[ ={s i* ' ! reoE T-Ug
%  8I
5,+ i* -!,
33

-9 j% 81 {[ bL> =: 6 'y U6, eD T-


-9 ~ M4 k8L -L - i* rLe -L
5,+ /_  M,
  C06,
N8B wL  j% V:
=-L NE%  M,
(% ' -EF i* r>  5,+ -L jg
N8B i* -EF NE%
=e0B r$M _0UF 5,+  qy 
~ *8y8 N:, reF p,D  <U % IL [1 `,D
,&TsF %6" r$* Y$9 ,- $  /87L N8 C  6  -7,;
i* ; d% _ 28 3 :|, 8 : i* rI$> 'D d[
\:>gE -DL b[1 F ~ -e ='-U TsF `> K 3 rE%
=IL, ' q

=q, 3  `, - ,B M L TsF K


 
 Y $ j% 6
3 pB *6, d[ V:
L TsF
3 =k8B 7E )\ nI 1 ,)7:
;F 7 nI

%6 jg
-B 6  i* r:D ,q, 3  `, /87L   5 8,
V, re% T-  j% 1 T-U% 9Be =-. 6B, ] 81 TsF

LD Oe ,TsF L


t,: j% d  ' #$E TsF %6 YB ,
={; Ts% 8_8
r
j7, 3 ~ -9U D} j%
6B: /% ~ 8,L N+ z IL [1   j% 0e {[4
=M4 C :  ~ 6L j8D 6B: ' 8:  =NE *O,(3
`   jF =6B: ' 5
e B* q-( d% i* ~ 8_ 5w r:D
'* ,$ O~ P ~ 8,L j8D j% ` N+ j% 81 ,NB [1  rB9:
=):,$ 5w j% ` NEF j% K  ,q 
34

'* r>-DE ny8>   [Ug p,D ' UF )B  =5


r++ bq -* j% 6E =CB9, $MF N0U ' -.
=Y9, A # IL  j N8 , ,B
 N8IL  7}_e

- $ %6 '* ~ *E :1 N reg
f B -4[ 87E |,

d[ %6 4 ~  j0D}> z8$$ K,* K>6*_ z:1 jg
 ,X$
:|, 8 : i*   8 ,H1Ip,D [1 r$* /8B
/% ~38 # -L j% 1 AF :   j>6*B j>1
=b -U ; d% nI 3 ue4  rE% '* 5,+
'* 7E ] j% 8B  8I
5,+ 59, , 68 Cq-(Q
; Q nI: )6B> 1 -L {s z8$ ' rP,  % r1-4
  Cq-(Q b[1 j% j- 8e4 s ,r '-U -+1 % ,:_Q
NEF '* r48$  N8 -L j% 1 eM =rLe -L nI
 5w j% 7
'D , ,'-U nI
 y ],> ,
/23 6% j% T- 5,+ j4 s e8eB % *O,(3 C
8B$
=H2Ir,O.
- k8 /87L
%6 =$MF -*   %6 )
4   U6> *O,( 'E 1  +, j% )7L  j = +,
~ 8_ 5w r:D =K 6 A 5,+ * uZ j8D> j% X: ,-E
9$
8D. 5,,> j% T- 3 87E =N+ [1  8D. 9$ i*
. 9 ' 193 ,-. p,4 1
=. 9 ' 194193 ,-. p,4 2
35

8D. q9* j% T- reF ,7:8 _ -[Z  Y.


Oe ,5:
8_ 8D. q9* : Oe  89U i* d89:> 8 5
5:  Y.
5E j%  T- ~0M /8 N LE =-EF  i* 6. k8L>
' # 'D , %  j8D> j% 'D   q }
-L> j% B reoE |,
 = 8e z:1 j% L> j% 8D. Y
'[ ' q-
F O. : C, s ?-F i* 8D.
8  K> CBI$ 5y _ ' ,re} % ) j8
={s i* q:
:, -_ s3 d} /% N+ E -9
d% N9
 ` re $PB -DL _: ,8B A  B,: )
{s Y9: ,?-F 6% T6 ~38B 6B [1 8 3 6:* 6B*
 ], =-. U   6:*  : j% ` d[ ,c  8B* i*
=5,+  8B$ $L C6B, '* 2+,> By -DL b[1 j%
_0UF C ,3 ' 66( $$ }: NM  i* c E
e7, 3 joE |,
 ,7$1 'D 3 'D ,7:* 8(- 'D ,
=N8B   ' ~ *8e 6 B [1 ' , 8B

d-L z8$  ~ e( z:1 j%  T- K *  8I

j% ` 8D. U6, joE ,-U


% D}
6 U6> *6,
~ 1! ;F 6% j4 soE =^  8I
~ 6m j8D
* qF 0
ny8 ' ={[
r O X: re% 64! 'E 8D. ' wE% 
j% 5,+$ :
d  ' j% 6B, re% {s  Y i* 81
'D =-D, <%  D1 ):> i* ~ _ qLD
~ ,, j8D
j ={s YBZ `I ' joE 6 , C9$
8D. 5,,> K
36

B,:> K$ e% A 7; Z j% 81 8D. r$L> q %8 %


YBZ % * C2+e A d! ' $ z8$ [1 jF ,)1 6_%
=: % 6 ?61%

37

38

, C 8, j8 $D NO*F  i* ^  C6,*


6e% c6$> :  5 j,
8,e 8> ( 9 e ,
Ce ,j8
 j8( --Z ' ,~ 6$ 33  5B> , ,N8
j+4
'M q   '4 p,4 5B =1991 A 1963 ' L N0U
=310 A 213  LI ' ,*
# = ,U L> '*  * 81 ^ NO*% ' * 4 j
 4 = O$ g> - 1 C-: ,^$ 6 7: z:1
^E =~ +7: # ?61 81 %  iM ^ '* r8_% j% 59, %
7(8
A N8<8 L4 % =-E 7( M 1 P7:  8< 
f B -} 3% 1 iM )( 7( =)(  7 i* 6, 
j =)( re% )$ j4 j V, ,)( e re% ~ ^ ~ Ie %-B K
=-U q Q ,q )$
- f B 9*% j%  ^-> 6:*   u
6_

= - j$
87L X$
r04 r Be% j% b DE%  X$
~ 
j ,V: L> ' V: Be A p-_% 81 ~ B- Y;% j% u
=
-  , B- '* 6,
% 3 V, L, A ~ e% -9y% u:4

39

p-X 3% (% ' I  -. {, '* 6,


% u:4
~ e%
7,y C * CO$4 hy% j% ' 6
3 j4 =f B b8, :
 r i* B
8 : '   q, T-> O4 K,E8B K

t W {s 4  :D =$<F r,X


,,*9,  6_ i* $e% 6_ 6%
A r$<8 j%  6- d[ V: '*  6:* ' 3 YE8, 
=f B

 C0 81 uy
6BE 6PL$ ~ 

'-DL A C ;Q
q p,DE =~ e% DEF ,qO F CO$D
f B T- 3 V, 7$* q8w qB ' 6
3 j4 ,`,4 C-e
i* 81 8 b6:* '  ?y% 6_ =-U K. K
~ - rLe
K 8_ K
hy% u:4
 ' \ -t j4 K ,r$4g
p,D
=d6:* ' 7E 8\ B
% =h! $4
p,D AF 
- ^ 1 b[1 u =U% 0
=  1922 /*  t e ,* ;
r r^-> j% Y 6BE =-.
D; i* Cq( z:1 % :1 -BE q:M, 
,7$* 03 | ', W
=ueeQ i* {s 4 ,C3B  618;
TU VE W #=
2012{6{4 8 y=

40

, , Q - ,


?-  81 # NB [1 8y8
  )  g~ 9U r$* Y$ 9 d[ `1[ ,. q8 >
 d% :*O,(3 % e6 -. 81 r*8y8 j 
=H1IL$L
=-L i* *S D}
5,+ 7 O j% 'D , 9$ 6
C $9I
u}_8e O$_ ,  
i* -9>
  e wB b[1
|,
 ,. :,_   N6 5y8 q  'D> 7:D ,*
r4 6 ~ *8y8 ~ -_ nI> j% \ n(- ,~ B* ~ g> 7$* 
u w_ % 5_8 =B,$  F N! re% i* :
[: \8 8Be  ' V:
: j 
,k0Q i* 66(
CL j 7 u$< , 89, $-  'D ; 8I /6_%
,66( ?-l l  :% -7> u <% ,d #: '  ,
=_ ds ' -M4% 8 e i* 8y8 -18( N:,> L$,  `$9,>

B   Q - 8y8 p,D [1  N:, ' re N8B j%  6IB 1
/% 
jeQ 1 6B qwB 8y8
: 6:* ?-  % ,,.
= 787L
-. N:, Oe ,
41

q (%  , CO 2-
% 81 9$ -. K
 j
je8  8>  ~ <8IU ,C0+ /6_% \8 {$,e ,  ,
K
6 j4 6B 8I   : [1 'D =$+e  
j4 =8D. K
 K:8 ' CB9 
K
% K:8

::M,  s =K  /D. jX '  O. -.
8IB
6
3 )% 81 /D. A -: ue4 ,je8  -B6 C8D.
$_ % -E )4 ' j8Lg, /D. j4 =j8DR 't ~ 8IU 8e8D j%
 X k- '* %  8
 )7,9$ j6, 8e4 ,4 LP %
W ,K8D  y ' 6, 'D> W _F i* % ,'-U wU
 - )@6 'D> W O
 )7,:1 d6Z i* j- : 'D
B  O j 8$ $ [, C,3 ue4 O7 @6Z
% i* {[4 7 -: j4 'D ,  ],> )8_ ue4 =:7$
8R j% 'D 0 ue4 F ; 89 ' * (  $>
b86, j% )\ 'D , 7Le ( 6
,)78_ q:
% 6y r6, 
)7B>  : ' j8Lw, VB$, V, =K(  q6*F 6y
4 A q8+$ ' 6
3 j4 ,8D ' R 3 d[ 6 S
8D {$ j%  'D =8D  r,7 B ' T8_%
d% jg; reg; ,59B -E% i* q8B, 3 i* ~ 2* rLe 81 j8D
)1 [ t [Ug j% K:8 i* ~ 23 j4 ,8D X< ' 6
i* j8<-R '[ /8B ?61 j4 ,{[ =r b B: 6y O~ P
)4 $ n j% X: , 9$ i* 8_ 5y 81 )7:  $I
6_ =-. $D
b6I_  81 6B [1 ,*O i* 7, O

?* i* N8I. N0U ' ,AF =K,B-9


{s YBZ 8
42

j4 ,  k8B. % C-. )  7$* Y$9 ,: CeI

B
rE js ! |,
 `(8
~30U H6 )4. _ ' 747,e
D}
-Ug, 1 ,eM % =/ jI % -, % ,6 
9$$ 7 NEF 
j% 
, 8, 
8y 5y 7E ,/*
M j% 7E L -U % 8e ' 1 % *O BE8 / $,> 4.
,4. 9$ C- 9 y 
 F j6$ )  =*O nI
W N. 'D =8B ' NF : A 8w A ,-U
% D}

4  -.   NF ?6\ n<% ,M : 5 {[4 'D>


% )4. 9$ i*  8, 6 8B {$> i* N8I. 81 jD
 =_ ' 7w
i* 8$I 6_ 8e4 s D
7$* N8I.
j% ,-U 6
e, 3 N0U ' 6 * B
Ke_ : l
r
g
3 8 e i* 5(e jOy 8( S i* 6 6 )D. 8w
={s q  q d% YB ,  8R W ,r9$> reX ' )7B
j- 3 8 <% K
: i* V>% eeQ j!} /6B> 5 'D
Cs $B, 9$ )7D j8D j% B> 9   j% rE
nI j% 81 MF . j% )\ 6
 =: 5L:  5 d8,> 3 nI
K$M % )7$_ ' K: KLl8 - 6  j6, j8!
16  b[1 N0U ' re% )\ 6 j4 =)181 i* )\ * 'D ,)\
~ 6
% 76,  q ' 8D. C9$ j% ~  8:w j% )7 8
j4
:$ j8D jg
B ,66 `$9 [1 =)7.I
 8 e i*
87 #P- ?6\ 81 - i* n<% ,,_! L j8,: /D
6 A =B [1 ' p  rE j4 jD d%  ,-B6 p .
43

9$ 66Z A -> ue4 , B


 87 m `$9 [1  4
,U
vg> 4. 9$  MM. 87 -,  5 =/D.
66Z 8y8 j% j6B, : 
%6
,   8I
K8D 
8 : i* -DL b[1 ue4 =6. k8L> % ,R [U% C[
9$
/D. 6y r6,e -% 81 8D. 9$ i* 8_ 5y j :|,
j b6-e  =: nI 5  -D,  8I
)7.I ,> '[
)  )7, $I j8D> j% ,`} )7Le% )1 /D. j8D j% 81
  6y 7R ' A (
u FE =  F  $I 1
/D. j4  =7Le i* X ' ?8U ' z:1 # =7Le
7 8
j8D ,7$_ ' 87
)\ * jDQ
 F /% K!
 =76,  r (%
7L:
 j% 7:D , 9$ i* )7:g> j%
4-  8 e i* 'D ,F 9$ 3 /D. 9$ j8D> ' . b[1
, 8} ' r$ % ,DL, ' 8 : [1 =/6, 0 ` : D}

 i* d[ ,
F ]$ ' UF   % K
~ ,: j4
'[ {% =e9-
c U  F ]  '7 81 N   6
q:M, 
L> j% 8D F 28  i* 8_ % 8(8
j-B
H
i* )1 '* j2, ,6(8> j% \ X: 3 re% j- , C8D.
]  K  '-DL K
)$ ' 4 6_ i* T-E )7$ 8 e
'7 81 j8D j% 'D ' j4 {[ r; h_8 z:1 =  F
=- Cs rP8}e i* u+; , ?- X,> W 8 e6$
 j
;F  ,L$L   C-:  +: 'D
j8D> j% 'D , hw 6I, '8 '* h}D ,{[4
44

j8(,R 3 : j $PB -DL j =}L L


p+ q  uL,U
rE ue4 u_  @6
-DE 6> 6_ )7Le% i* )9$ 6B> A
b ,*
r:* j-B % ,BE : r
)$R ; -B6 8D.
 
-,> W -DL b[1 j% O4 =6   ~ 8(8 j4
G Cq( , CE- e3 _ ' ,_! CE- e L
p-9y0
,H1IK<X ' $$_ E E ' ~ q8 1-M4% j4 , ,e-L  8M
Oe ,: K
C !$ )P6  L
N % i* g}:> W ,
5 'D =-B, 3 B9 z8$ 6,  6y (L +Le3 L

r( ' 4 O_ ,Z -B6  87 u <% '  -
5, 'y qw*F T8_% ' 6 % i* 7Le uy-E , F
CB,e3  ,$ yU 8 ,: 8D. u <% ;)F
: [U% =7Le i* 7$ j% * P_ -DE F n(- ,
: 9$ "  &v[ )D." _ ' , C  j% j j84 6
9$ j8 O '[ &:" j =N. BB '* ]>
H 3 &)7Le% i*
)D." ;9$ E )7$* 5B '[ : )7Le% )1 OP 8
Oe rLe ' -L i* 5B d[ )D. # r:* a6 ,e d[ &v[
: ' :> :   j ) =5 ' -L i* 5B d[ )D.
% $F d% ;~ }e )1-M4% % : ' 6* ]4%   $
O
|,
 ;$F )1 ,*
K8B )7Le% j8$ '[ ;F

z:1 j8D, re% : [1 ;)78_ :


' 

5_  : `-


)7B, 7 )7,( 6B
{s ' : B> , C,0 (
=Y r(  i* 9$ 8I, '[ d% 1
45

8D. 9$ 6B> joE ,{[ =9$ /6,   T-U% q  % '
9$ p <% j8D K 7,% ' ; 6BL> 7$ 3 -EF i*
=*O  T8_F ?-9 /% d% ,*O /% ,:  8I
K!
r
4 > d[ rLe 6B
'-DL q4[ 7Le 4 > q; -: b[1
],> '[  F 5,+  7 C*O C- 7Le
W {[ =yL % BB. )7.I 5 Be - i* -B6
n<%   C-:  ;7Le uM>  
8< -: b[1 r(8>
i* X: ,  ' ~ q ( *  8I
&$F jX" > j
=7: R j% 5,+
 j4 ,T-UF jX9 ND;% jg; reg; ,$F jX j
NE% N0U '  re% ,*
AF ( 6
: 8Le  ?8
G -: d jeQ N   ,  8I 1 b[1 , C9$
81 j8D j% 'D rLe 5,+ j% 84 % q0B 'D =8y8 A
-EF i* *^  8I
reX O 5,+ j% V:
9
i* ,B 3 jX9 ' 8: [1 j% {[4 84 % rE '8(8
-E i* _ 5,+ j =  9$ N0U ' ),> , NO*F
-F ' ~36
U -% 6<% s =~0E {[
/8B 81 ,b-%
' D; dg
r X: 3 P  -% % 6<% s % ,  I
' ~ * -M4% *O,( eX O {[
reoE ,7E U6, j% ND;F
3 jX9 [1 j% )  = 79y3 8e% ' M4 ' 66
' $B 3 z 3 re 3 ,E-9, C
8B* D; i*   -L

~ M4 k8L 8 e i* . `e8( 5^ A X$X, re%  ,p-\ [E:
46

jX ' _8 joE |,


=7Le - 6, , jX9
d%- jX ' _8 A {[4 8*6> (. j% s :LD> 3 8D.
b DE% N8R
j% A 5,+  ' _8 ,'7 8} 6P
C
8B  P 8
,7y-L j% ,z8$$ 6*8_ A < r> 
q8}e j 'D%  N8R
V, ;7:* j8B}: '[ {% i* ,e8eB
j% A : 5^ -9w ,r_- 5 ):, 3 d-E `e( d% D}> %
j% *O d%- rE 59, d[ T6$ 6 z:1 =r61 i* 
r:* E6 6. [1  j ,-L N0B,    8 e i* U6,
{s  reg; ,eeQ j!}$ `9 5y8   r:* V: 3 -%
= 6, 3 ' _8 jg;
5y8 j8D j% _3 [\ n(- 3 re% ' )- i* 'D
6. 5y8 N8  N! joE ,*  8I
_ : K ?0U
t e h4 d%
-9 d-L N0B, 3 K
)$ YE8, a6
5^ ' r$*  A (
N   d[ 8y8 81 *O,(3
; dF :

-6( .   4 j =~ -B> `e8
' 6
3 reoE ,{[ ='-U : NE% i* 8B 5y i* 6,
/B  ,j8eB N0U ' NF /B  ,48$ 6*8B 
-E
5y8 j8D> 3 , q;F ' M4  / d%- N0U ' M
N! 81 [1 ?6*8B r$* j8D> j% X: s =j8eB NX,;3 P0
,@6 Cq:M, 3 ' $_ ?0
'D =eeQ j!}  #P-
=7$  -4[ /6B> d% 67}> W , $ F ' 6 81 N! [1 joE
: ' ,K, > K>E % N0U 7Le 
(Q
N! [1 R W
47

O4 =7Le B-9
r$* 
(% 6_ 7Le :  L N0U '6$
j%
:
N81s 6I j8D K 6$
% K *  vg , p8 j%
$D} d% j- 3 ,j4 6$
% * d%  ,: joE {s 5 =-U
O~ P BL,  j% j6B, 8e4 : jg4 6 -F j ={s 
6> )7,    6*8BE =6*8B r$* j8D> j% X:  i*
N8B* i* |8, d[ )18 [1 =7Le '* E6  [
 y )\
],> 3 , ,$ d-  g, i* $MF 6% 81 : )
-, 
j89$ : 'D ,H1IM N8B O4 je e  BE
z8D; % q8}e j 8$.   g> j =AF 9 K
 7:

[1 ,~ w
)7w
i* : 7y-L , z8$ 6*8_ 8I

' u *  8I


 j N8B> , BB. L
~ > nI g,
;% /% ; _ ' q8 ,g}
p % q6
 `$9,> , 8F
j% 8: j% : ,* 6_ =rLe /% } _ ' % ,'-U
,p F $ ' wE% B [1 ' , 5y8 8I
)1-*}
6_ =~ : ~ 48$ ]> p % )@6 j8D j% d   ' 
 %6 =L 0E ) )7:* NB j% j8R e% {s  )7+;
8E, j% :$ X: , LD N8 )1q j8B:, :  d[
: / $  j% X: reg
r$B*  je 4 rR d[ 8} 81 G
=8$L j% ,r$M j-} '[ '-U ,81 `R  8$L jg
K^%
81 )D.  b  j% rLe K
 r:
? ' z:1 # N. 9

 N8 ~ : ~ % 6!> p % z:1 j8D> 3 K 'D =7R , 8F
=je e  1  j N8B d[ d $+eQ M A :1  } 1
t , 
=1390 /*  AF -$ M [1 /6
48

; wL> re% i* d%- {s ,* 'D reoE ,: L j% X:
'* 6 > 3 % K> ,d%- {[ p % u9*% s =6 jeQ
5  d%- joE ,'-U ;% T6  wL> i* 6,> 84
~ wL> re84 ' ~36
: ' *8 T6 wL> - {s
_ ' 0
81 7$wL , 8F joE d je :
'D =6 ;
` nI> Oe ,~  ~38B ~  BE ],> 3 {s  r4 } '
k[ 8% k0UF N8 b DE% ) 8I
r6 8(8 68
r>6B*  R  8I

8,D j8D> , f q:M, 
,_$
q8y i* 4  8I
f b[1 L reoE . b[1  V, ,:6
% q:M
-6 8F N8 : q joE |,
=I} r>0wL>
8I
) i* -!> , L$, p F 5+
-g,> /8$
-!> , p F 6* -M4  $> p F b[1 ,'-U z8$
% ,)7$B* j8D> 6_ p F b[1 =-U 8y8 d% N8 ) i*
 -*} % ,*O,(3 )1-*} % ,E- )6B, % )1q81%
)7E ) % , B,3  -9X X 6. M ,*O,(3
-U =*  * >[ )7, $I d% ,)7Le% 8I

joE ,:7 B rE 6(8> 6$


d%  =~ *8; 1-M4% 81 p F b[1
1-*} 7.I ' ,B9 {$> ' 5:> 6$ C_0U% ' ~ 4 O~ _
,K
  6 K] Q K
8(8 k0UF =B9 k8L,

q0: K
 ,)1*  z8$ K
 ,c8e   F p <% K

1 Oe 8 : [1 i* 68,> , -*} q  joE |,
 ,K0L
OE 6P )_0*  :7 B9 -EF _0UF -*}$ 
+, 
K % ,'7 7_8 : B 6BL> K ,-U `e( ' =)7:

49

 7$* -7> 6P _0UF -*} joE ,1-D 7,:1 nI>


-! -U 4 %6 z:1 =:\ ' 6I Yy 8L: C0* `X
b[1 ue4 q8 ,d%- % j8eB 7y-L , z8$ 6*8_ i*
7R , 8 8w
:  81 ,$ % 
 6*8B
8w [1 =)7,\ 71-D> % 7Z , % j88e6 ) 71-D %
-*} 87l  ` reF ,~ _Le # r:D , F  ' e%
-  j8_-R : u$( , -*} _ ' ,~  _I uB
`e( A ,5,+$ @6  nI joE N. 9
=_e 
r(8>  4 I 1 I \ ,e6  C-! ' MD
~
 % 84 N0U ' # 6 [1 u 7:D =_0UF -*}
' 66 q}e N0U ' Oe zs % _0UF j8eB [\ S
j% O4 =zs % _0UF j8eB [1 A d!> , 8L:  -*}
nI
\ jg; 3 -*} 1 , 8L:  ' T-U% -*} z:1
, 7Le 8B
C_0U% q}e N0U ' 7Le '* u
-*% ,5,+
=B
 -*} G 5,,>
d8B )B T6 % ,5,+ T6 8L:  -*} joE |,

7,y , 6*8B $ : '  6 d[ P- -F 1 ,r:
;F =d%- % j8eB C
8B* $P uZ : G / ,$ C,+
  88B W 8} -DL  )7, i* K6B, 8e4 '[
CE0 6B '* -: ?
,%6  ' 5y8 [1 ^7

N,  K8X} 8e4 =5y8 {s <L> 5 G 869< ,


)\! ' ~36
,71-D % 7R j% 5,+ i* X: , 8F '*
d ~ e8e_ j8D> j% X: 5,+  8L:  -*} ue4 s O*
50

8e4 : Be 8I


 -*} X> 8 6B =-EF i*
'* ~ *E * w_ A <8, 8R W ,G j8:! 3 )7Le% )1
$ 6 7E ue4 , 68 . =*  8I
_e  5 -.
 *8 _ ' 8_  8I
7$* E8 %6 i* u:
wB
,M4 ~ 8% :$> . b[1 =:6 jOQ w_ 1 -EF ' $$_
$
_ ' ~  -:$ ,E3  :9> % A {s  ` 
8
d[ _0UF b-D
8}E =_0UF #. r$* Y$9e  g9
-*}$ ~ 8y C3. -M4% ' 6 81 $ `I, r
-}
, :D e ' -Z ' N% 8e4 '[ ;F =_0UF
K *  8I
8e8D W  :D 7Le i* Y$9> ue4
'D =H1I7Le :D  ' -M4% :6 d%-  ?0,U3
O

L i* /, :


E % YBZ j% j , : 6 uL U K

L,3
\  L,D> j% A LP % :4 4 C-9y ,T-UF
W '[ 6;: A C$_F C-9y ,j V, 7,,4 ,  F

)7$* j4 =?0,U3


O A )71[ k:,* i* )7$ 89,
=X L 8 I j%  )\ % 3 re% 84 % )F {s 8$L j%
)> ,1 T-U%  %  # ,4- b[1   reoE |,

 ,f ' * # % i* 5,+ 6y -EF k8B
?*3
i* 9$    ~ B r reg
5,+ T8* 6y ~ :$* ?8_8 )>
- ' r6 O
)\ W '6 '[ ,/ p,D =r$* K( 
3 ~ B 1 ,*
w - i* jF `$%  j 8e4 ,:
= :4 PF ue,>] A :1  ;Q 1
51

8I
'-U /% N! jeQ j% ~  -De% ,r* ,e 'D
d #: T6 n, /6e joE {s 5 =:6 r>6B,
~ E G ),@ , 8F 8I

j% (  A ~   -% 81 0


d%  $ : ' -4[ 8( \ j8D D 3 :6 -.
j   r$BM
:6 a43 /6* 7E VB% , C3.  3 ,jD
=:6 CE0 L
r, k0_ A >- 3 re% ,* i* ,n,
], ,~ m> 0 -M4%  V, ,K:6, ;F ) j1s% 
B, j% 'D ' =R CLZ % j ~38B n, `(
?0 B 3 'D ,:D   P  CE0U 8(  ;
3 je d% 5 -U ; n, j% 'D ' ;6B P 
; n, j% 'D ' ;H1I'68 ' % ~ D84 j4 s
' $_ 6* z:1 'D =H2IO Ce6 >% ' -E d% 5 
' )7:D ,~0$_ {s ' 6
% A p1[$ 6, 3 )@6 '[ :
-*} j8D> K =-U .  
'! 3 ; d% 5 8m,
7I W 7,* p8(8
18* joE ,66; _< N >  $F
=4 '1
e j% )  ,d $+eQ   ,$ < ?-$ ~ -e
e j% 3 ,
 % j6$
)  N. r$* 1  B% e9-
 d%-
' r
j7, 3 q, 
-}e 6$ [1  =8_ _% d $+eQ j8eB
=a8M 6B
j8:! 3 '[ K  d% 1
i* :6 r>6B* /8B> ; d% 5 n,$ 6,  i* # re% V:
2
=N : 8 i* /8B> 3 6 +.
52

) ,[L:, , 9$ _ ' C<8I  S U6,


 6B
,-L N0B, 3 )$ / d% ' ~ 
e # {s  ` j%
A -:e :$ , ,:e-7l K
B* N >  ,  ' 5
e 81
`}  =`}  $I w1:  $I M % i* 8D.
% ,rLe `} 8_ 1 8D. 8_ j% -}> j% 6
)$,> W 9]
-. nI> j% 'D 'E {s j8$L K =`} d% 81 @% j%
7$*   j 7,y-* M 8D. ' 7$*   y-* -L
1 8} ' r
j7, 3 6_ z:1 j V, 'D =/ d%- '
`e8  -EF i* -9$ j8eB _ ' m % 6y 87$
DL> Ve% j a6R , [1 =  j8eB$ yU 'D> W ,
 N+ 'y 5B 3 % 5B 8y8 j4 s  N8 -
6> %
d[ ,8D. U6,$ 1: 8} joE |,
 ;j8eB 9$
  j8D O
,r$* 81 d[ 8 : i* ~  ~ 6L ^  8I
],
, g 8I
K,  % i* O~ P_ j8D j% 'D  6B
r$m
*  8I
/6, N8B %6 6(8 3 re% 5_8 =\8  6
-B =` :  % ~  : 8D. U6, 8:
6% j4 s  66 ,

=I} )0wL, ~ BE <U C3  {s :
,r0< 'D S % r$* N8I. 'D 5Le d% j- K ,:
K  ,8I  q-( [,> j% 8D. U6,> jg
j8$B )oE
*O,(3  ' 8e d% NO, j8$wL '-U : 
j%
A eeQ . C3 ' -U ~3 8Lw j% ' ~36
~ -B>
`e( A ~  j8$ : j% 3 =j8eB 9$ y C3+
% 5 )1-*} / r(8, [\ ~ BE w_ % ' -U `e( % K
53

d[ 6 T6


)1 8; 6B ~ BE % ,8D. 9$ 6y
)7:l T6 ~ BE % ,  8y8 g  < )7.I j8D
'D ;j8$wL d[ 8 : i* 8y8 d8> j% 'D 8D. jg

-
6> '*  d% d%  % i* )7L_8 j -B  ~ e :
=8D. 9$ yU j8D> jF  : ],> , 8F  N8
?-F 6% joE ,f % 6*8B$ pX [1 `
re% | 6
8D. U6, joE |,
 ,-U ?-9 6B
~ 9 j8D j% 'D
= :  e rE VB$ , rLe 6B
` :  ~ 6g> VB$
reg
+ ,X$ 
%6 C 81 NB [1 ' ?6\
 b-E% 5 5,+ G , ,  LD B$9  8I
)DR j% `
$L 8B /6, 
q8 ,-9 b-4Q i* d89:> , 8F
ry-L d[ _0UF b-4Q N0U ' % e8e_ C
8B* D; i*
YR 7$(% ' , 68 X :|, 81 %6 [1 =/ d%-
/8B d[ L -
7E 8$U6, j% ,*^ % -E  8I
,:$
d[ 68 ?6\ =C[  1 ,5,+ -E% ' ; d% r

5,+ -E% ' -E d% 8 e Y r(8


8B   r$(% ' 'D
j ='-U i*  8_ j 8$. 1 ,r, 6y , ,
~ E4 ~  ], 3 ,_0U% % ~  ~ .< j4 q8 ,-E d% n<
%  -g
/B$ -L b-4 Y r( i* 'D 3 =r48$  U6,$
6 % r$+ {s jF % ,{s L j% r.< ' jF r
/B /6*
=~ P< ~ -% % O~ D ~ -% '-U d%  ], {s jF % ,_ ds '
j% % ,r>E> i* , e :e r N8Be jF  ~
 % ],> p F b[1
54

# ,r  8,e % ,r9


:,_3 i* r$ e % ,r -F _:e
{s ]e V, =h 8 e i* ?> s r,Bw %  -% i* r1-4Q
r:* b7:e j% 8e d[ z8$ j8D j% 6
3 pB % b-4Q d%
z8$ ' 68 q  =-U ; q[  `, j% r n(- ~ 48$
d[ q  81 5,+ /% ~3! reg}
j8D d[ ; d%
5,, j% rB ' joE b6 81 rI d[ q  % ='-U
=r$B* b6( OE rLe 6 jeQ =/, N0B, 3

%6  8IB j N8_% j% A 8*6> ( % z:1 j% 'l% 3


a6 ,e 3 ' e =6;- ' A j8$I K  :
i* Y9: j% 81
, e8eB ' 8X$ W '[ B p} % ,NLF '* :1
A (
j8$ '[ ;F =6;- ' % i* j8eB 16R
{[4 )7Le% )1 )\E% ' )7, ' 6
3 )\ '-U *

N:,> 3% ` : ' ,rLe `$ =(  TsF ' )7,
 8I
)7Le% : 7E j8D , C,+ ' L$, C3.
 > , AF C
8I =8$ $- A 6
8$I W *
U d% 8( rE : ' j8D ~ 6 ]D ' $> PB$, 89,
i* 59, reoE K , -
~ $ )4. j8D K ;7$* `$X,$
N8<8 'D 3  YBZ A ?6  % /6,   8 e
5 ,$ * )D. ND;% 6% 81 jX9 =T-U% 
7
 /6, j% , 8F KZ 81 rE61 j8D j% 9S ,-
]
~ E > ,
5y d% i* Y9:> 3 %64 -. =' , YBZ i* 0
' ' , i*  _ eeQ rE nI> d[ '  _ yF '
55

3 )7%  3 '  [1 vg j% A =ED, -. B: N0U
,j ; M ; % N8X -
% 6% M } :w *9
)F 5^  'D =H1Ir$M ; i* 8M
Kl8m 8e4 j [1
' _ 6
6% [: : n<% ,NB [1  
\:,e '[
K =:_Q % :,_3 N0U ' C[ KZ 8 e ; 3 i*
YB , 4 ~38B b-4Q 8 3 ,$- b[1 A : I
i* Y9: [1 ='-U 0 (% ' 3 ~ ]
 j8D 3 ,)7.<
C
8B N0U ' b-4Q i* Y9: re% O$M S d6 b-4Q
=jI 
B y-L
,+ 7$* IZ j% 'D   % '* i% :e% ny% j% %
~ B, ~ ; 1 ,*
-+ Y. -DE '
L: ],*% :e =L: '* 0
j% 6
3 'D =_0UF P 5^ r$* /8B> d[ UF %6 1
b ,*
je P6 nI i* P_ ,7e 5 g
L: j8D>
wUo
g
3 reg
Be :$ nI b[1 j% % ' =~ 6B> ~ :P4
-L NEg
Y$, OE BE (  -9 A -L$ PB$, 9
'-U y L
; d% /_ s ='-U : nI i* -!> ,
' % ,j8eB Y- '* q8 ,r,_ 1(8 -1l + z:1 joE
=e8eB C
8B Y9> j8g ' j8D 3 K / E- N0U
, '-U  $I ),> , 
Q NEF ' M4 z:1 {[4
 6 q9* M ,G j>Q i* Y r( '* -L ( 'D
/23 -U E d% % ,r: '* E6  N rI:
/B % ,D 
=N8X -
% % j ; M O~ D j8D  i* 8M d% 1
56

{s  r %  sBe M ,r,O


-L 5,, d[ 5,+ nI
8% b[1 = $ ' r 8_ 3 hy je  % 5,+
N  5,+ /% 7:* ~3! jeQ j8D j% Y r( '* 28
' =G /B r( ' j% @6 ny8 ' j8D K G r_ /6*
,rE% N0U ' BE # '-U Ts%   ; `, j% 'D
j8D K. ,$4  ,K E '* r*:, N0U ' {[4 Oe
3 eM  $ :
re% n < =TsF '* Y r(8
)7% ~3!
  6-e K AF . ' MD
]4% [. ' 6_ U8> ' 6

'-U /% ~3! } +e j% 1 6*B =} i* b-4Q


'* r*:, `
)7% ~3! r$+e j% % ,)\ Ts% ' r O*
,-L$ (  C_0  4  =q:M, 3 81  ,TsF ?B
5,+ /% ,)7.I -g,> '[ ;F /% ~ e8e_ ~3! j8D
8_ p % jF ' M4  z:1 =)\ ~  r,LI
-F /  s
p F b[1 g}:> j% 6
3 'D ,! b[1 -L Z /6* i* :$Z
n(- d[ 8: ' g j8D> j% oE :g$ < CO '
r
)DZ 8  wE% 8 e i* reg} z K 7E ?, j% ~3^ r
 )D ,   j8D> j%  ;rE )D , j% 'D D; dg
5,+
K = 8$ $ 5,+ V , 8F k8L>  `_8* -L
joE ,! -E ,  B [1 ' , p F jg; ' j8D
nI R  )D. B9: A U6 j% X: rLe -L y
rLe i* )DR j% -L i* ,( U O
5,,> 3 , '-U
r$ , C3. E uZ 5B> 3  84[ . jF _ D}

=5,+  '-U -EF )D /% ~3!


57

7,LI
,5,+ nI 7E j8D> L ' B9: z:1 'D
\ ue4 j [1 ,BE S  _0* \ ,-L nI '* $B,
~ <% _0*
 q  {s 4 i* $,} B9: {[
:*% =0
BE 'D '-U i* -! % ,rLe i* 3 -! 3 d[ -L  '
N8_% K =rE 6U 3 *8 8 e i* )7,4 } )1y N0U '
=r48$  8L S  '* a6Z% :eoE rLe i* 3 -! 3
'-U i* -! O
rLe i* -!  4 jF {s ; ' 6
3
'* a6Zg  ,r(8 [1 ' z8$ i* *3 'D =r0U '
 1 eeQ - $  : B9: 1 b[1 js =6
OE {s
,*8$ U6 N+ 1 AF :CB a0 ' hg,> %
, 8} -DL - ,7e 5 g
w -
7E `9e b[1
% -e ue4 q8 ,5y8 5^ N8 h_8 d%-$ B$9 -.
- q  '* , - ,: % _0U% % $* % ,$*
i* ,h$, %6 uZ 5B re% -. ' UF 8: 6 O
=1e
,'-U ;F i* -! d[ -L z8$ i* ,} re% ,*
 $ 81 ,-DL - '* r$IE 'D 3 $ : ' 'D
=7Le p F A 4  8I
6:, ,-DL - % ~ -B> r,%
D}> ,: ?61% YB ,  - k[ - 1 eM
4 ), j% 9S ,6-e O
/B - ,:,I; ` : 8 e i* .
)\ ` 3 r
/8Be  j%  ,5,+  :e8U ' _* j {s
% ?- e3 % Y.
), :48$ j% j8: 8e4 j V, TsF
z:1 ,-. C3 ' KF K+ i* q:
re% 1 MM =g9
8e8D j%  -EF - 1 ,7Le 6. 'y 5B> ,T-U% -
58

,'-U Ts% i* ,} 3 ?61 d% YB , Z3  )7,- ,~ 


6;- ' 8X$
:1 )7:* a6 ,e '[ : j% O~ P E3 5
=6$ y-* 8e8D j% j b-4 j j8E, )%
~ , j8D 3 P  8I
C-. b[1 rE /
Z 3 5, d%
5, d% ], 3 =rE 8(8 8D. D; '* -: ?
,~ -
=8_ j Y$9 8 e i* 8(8 C-. {$> rE 'D> W s ~  ~ -
:.< q   - 1 ) 3 [1 Y ,> , 68 -.
_* % )7.< ' '-U j- N e 3 e%  ,< :,B-9

re6
 r, I )$ . 81 je 4 =7$* N8I $ )187(
i* .
-E D O ' 6L,> j% $ 'D =r  r$B*
i* -E 4 b-4 ' 6L,> j% 'D  -M4% ,rL: by- d[ 8 :
=B$  : 6> , B-9
.
re% i*  K*%  6 O
 ,66( k9: 5  %6 [1
 8I
, r: -M4% %6 6(8 3 5_8  'D ,@6
BB -
  _% 5,+ N[ =PB C O d%-$ /  5 S
r1L > i* : b-4Q rP b DEF ~ BE r  r 
N8 r1L > i* : b-4Q r M } 2,3 N8
{s  L 0L 7BE 6B C,+ u:l =*O,(3 2,3
Y- '* r:> Y r( '* 'D  z8$ ' q ( 4 j%
d6 we3 i* ,}> 6 0 jg
K$$, , 9$
ue4 O
DL,  B-9 b[1 =K:8 5^ _ ' /, B
O~ P y- ,q8_% q6*% G R , XI C 87  8B
59

re% 
,$U6 C
-9y3 % :(F CO+\ uZ 8_8 -9
joE )!} : z-> U ' I_ E V, z:1 ue4 8
(  A 87 ' 8 e i* ,~ , ~ -% j8D j% 87
'D {s
E: P6  i* N8I. V, ,e3 )1 6B
j8D 3 re%
U6, ' j8eB 5: Og; ' 6. W  j0* z:1 =- $
C,+ ' D )+. ::$ < . <L>  4  8I

9$ - 9$ K


IL 81 )1F  'D , 
5y reg; ' j4 IE 81 ,6 :D K
IL d% ,8e6
i* j-9 '[ : '* j8L$, '-U e% d6%  -L y
C4-m ?0
d% _0UF 5B C4-m 'D =8e6 j!}
C13 6P d%- '* ,
3 6y uB ,  5B
M *O,(3 8F
Y$, OE `e [1 i* ~ M4 4-> W 6P
p F 6% =C[ A -:  } z8$ i* 1 4->
D}>  )1> , 8 T8_% 81 d[ ,'6 j% 81 {s q 
N( E 89
 jF )  ~ 8Dm j4 ,_0UF 8}
~ 8Dm % ,eQ z8$ `e8( 5^ i* -9$ * ,'6
-F   4 [1 # 'D =:6 /DF
6}, / ,3 -

6;% Ky  8L_ '[ ,6.   K $I 


jF
`e( A '8(8 8e8D j%   W B
 Ce6$ y 
]4% =- :\  7B i* 164g>  :6 hP89 :D
3k * OP p,4 h! ,ue84 u(% 81 {s i* NM
jX q  A ?6@ d[ ,Systme de Politique Positive
  DEF  be67; q d% k8L 8 e i* -L i* 5,+
60

ue84 j4 j q6B L 0L K


~ $I> ;F -M4F M
=e8eB 8Xw # _0UF 8Xw N0U ' {s L
 5 8 W  z:1 ,'-DL  < q  q:M, 

,-L 8 e i* -L i* 5,+ C0< 5 8> A {[4 6 ,


CX, 5^ jF ,5, N0U ' V, d%- 8_ N0U ' {s
joE ,-L 8_ ?y 5,+ 8_  > 7$* `$X W  ),> ,

,PB$>  8I
qL,U3 7$* `$X ,  ' # d 6 , [1
L * nI> j% 7$* `$X ,  ' oE #D i*
-E A ,K:8 % ~ D 8e4 q8 ,/ 8:
  ~ *8e =-M4gE -M4%
 [1 =z8$$ ~  ~ 1 ,*
'-U i* < )\8 )7P
9  -*} %8 % wE% ' 6* _ ' ~  8_ 6e VB$,
q d% L
-9 uZ bB
 ~  `I re% (  A ,
|,
 ,6 ,> Oe VU> 3 C,+ 8_ 'D =8B p T8
r(  ?8_8$ _0UF *:B ' d8_ ( _ ),> W  reoE
j% 5_8,e j% `+E -EF -  ]  U6, '* >: q8
=W$ . ?- A -:
b6 > b8e 67}e
wB  S 8X ' ~36
,N6 [\ ` : ' j8D
-L 81 ,7: 6 -E N:> i* 6  :Le% Be j% ,
. q  r
?> d[ :1 r>-4s d[ / %6 r$* /_ d[
K
 r:
ILe j%  , d[ ,-DL - 81 -L [1 = 6 A
~ q ( D}> C-. b[1 =
,D /0D - 81 r
>- -U -E
 ?> , j6$ 5   k0UF ' r
j7, 3
61

, $ L$L # F 'D ,-. C ! :6 n,

: A rLe 6B


 y j8D> 3 O
C-. b[1 7$* /8B>
d%- _ ' M4 _ ' V, ~  87L j8D> 3 O
% *  8I

,)$ r(8 i* )7L> K ,# F b[1 =)7: r_8,e  )- i*


  6 joE |,
 ,:*8y8 ' T-UF /_F i* {[4 Y9:>
B
A U6 wE% T %  i* j8D 8y8 ' q  [\ $}
OE 66( z:1 'D W s f B | -LX j% 8( % {[ =8y8
j-B N0U ~ M4 _8e -F T-U% - }_:  U% K ,r8_g
=y 0M

62

E I - '* E6 A ( z:1 6> W re% 8(-e
59,e =6, % 6 L 8D. 6y O. P  T6 1 ,*
-DL   7(, e j% 'D + 6(8> 3 re% j Le j%
YL,> 3 d[L:> % > 27( dF ne j% 28 3 re% 1 ,,
8:! j% ` , q  )7$*  j% : nI 5 ~  r.I
[1 j ) =7*O
)\ n
 , DEF f )\ -B j% % G
_ '  (e  8I
-t E j% ~ M4 r Y -. w_ ' `e
<U % rP9* A ( z:1 6> W re% (  A KB
 p,D
V, N   E I N8 d $+eQ j8eB j% )  =p,D [1 
PO0 _ 8> % /%  j4 O$M ,d,  j8e_ reg4 /8
q:M, 
, B: 6y r$L> ' -4[ -9U 6(8 3 re% 3 ,:
A wB q  28 -, ' ?8
5E6

 K ,,_! 5$\ 


i* `$X j% n(-  ' *  8I
=H1I)$  '* ?- e3
E I yB j8e_ 8D. C-_% V, CO$D b[1 
,4 ' -E% 64% W 1
= 5 =0D _: h_8 q9* ~ :B r: 6IB j4 Oeg4 ,1858 /
63

 % `} /% ~  ! ue4 q~ 8 ,d 8,  6$


 8D.
1 ,6   3 ,q  '* , i* -9 NZ j% ,{s
A :E6 W  C}_: -  r h ! d[ U6, [1 joE {s
jg
,*:_ hy%

j% _ reg; ' 'D W ,:  6 $4 V, X>


,6$ [1 ' uL,U  B: i* > C
8B /3 67*
=`e( ' [1 =-,> W PwB B0 C$* jF =5$\ C3 q:M, 

-F B0 C$* _ -. V:


'D> W oE -U `e( '
i* /D. B,e % C ! B,e N8 'D> W 7E 7(8 )7,E = 
,_ *S 81 ,k0U ~ E: %~ 6 ]t ,*  e N8 ue4 Oe ,)E>
joE , I ' 6_ dg
5,,> IL [1  6B +. ue4 s =X9
 -. C(  _g
: 5,, j% X: reg
B> _0UF *:B
'* b6
 ' rE :% '* -: ?
,r,}_: %6 d% '* j0*Q
,_ %6 j4 j e j% :<I,U ' # :1 O@ 3 |,
=k0UF
=Be a0 -9
/B [1  L,4g =L
k0U ~ E: %6 X9
)$*  8$   wB 6% O~ P j4 8y8 [1 j% 1 AF
k8E rLe 5E /- i* U '8 B K re% 1 eM =k0UF
joE j8eB -9 % 8eB pB $P c U rLe 5y |,
 j8eB
-( # ,)7D% N(- wE% _ ' 7$4g
)% _t ' ,], r$,_
q~ 8 ,B [1 ' , NEF  j% 1 MM =T]4 $wE Oe
=$1F p-. _ ' Oe N,3 _ ' u ,U /%   < ue4
-R d[ } _ ` : ' j8D O
< C3. 

 ?8}D E 5_ s BE nI [1 'D ,L [1 pD>  i* '-U
,B E K
_F i* $,m $< 8( C 'D% s ,- , pB*%
,/8+7$ uy-> , 7Le 8D. joE . b[1  V, =- ,
Bo
 8 e i* 8 68 1 ,:(F C8D. T6 #
'* E6 p
' ,rLe 18( 6y 7(8 CO+\ b[1 i* 
8B
h! =#L:
64

sLe `} T6 / q, 3 '* ~ > 84[ q-(Q j8D j%
=b]<
-DL> 3 % `} 5 ~  +: 8D. j% js L:
: j% T-> , k-9  3 ,; d% -7_ 89 -E  ~ 6
%
,B [1 ' d[ -7B    `} Y -De% ::D =G j8$B
6
-7B$  9$ =8D. N0U ' % S  8I
q8
 1 ,{s  Y.
5,,> 3 C8D. wE% j =*S  s
r-4 _F i* Y. [1 =C8D. %8 % ' ~3 '% u [1
6y r,  ),> K r-4 re% O$M / d%-$ ~ BE r,  ),> K
r 6 ( q:M, 
6 d% i* ~ ^ : j4 8 =/ d%-
[1 CD   ~ B T8_% 8e8D ' ~ ^ : joE ,)@%- h d%
{s j4 j )D   Y ' 68 } [\ j8D  }
A  -F
# x2
# ; CD  j% '> O
=b 6B

D$ d%- j4 s =` { ,U -DE b[1 'D =6. [1
' 8 d[  j% 
,7I 3 \ _ 3 I;
k-E z:1 j8D reoE ,U - re84 6 ' G 5,, j-
4 6* i* % BE ;% w
i*  8_ K
 6 A
`$ re% 81 d%- '* , CD   C[
 :* 'D =)7:
N(% ' ,K^% : ' Oe 6 -E ' BE # -. b[1
'[ ' {[4 7$ ,|.  ' 7$ re% O$M B,
=d%-  j8:! '[ ;F ' -M4% 7$ ,d%- j8y 
d%- N6,  <-E j8$  : joE ~  < 84[ d%- j4 soE
65

-g
L,e3 ' j8- R )oE ~ U d%- j4 s =n < -U
g9
8_ -M4% 9e ny% z  i* N8I. 81 ,{s '* % B 3
=g9 5 p8I /69< +,e ,BB. '*
4 j% s ,$B,  8I
K,. K>1  -: A (
' e

j% ' ~ 6
% KB j8De ' =\ 
B
+. '  Y; \ O7: 
bE ' '64g, :4 8 ,U d% 81 r9 Ve d[ d%-
=H1Ir9e j% g9 ' E
=~  < j8D O
r9 C9$ V> d[ d%- :n.E
=K8I 8 )7:D ,r, < j-D: r j6- '[ N. 9

:$ g  u )\8 ,  8 E- j8D$, 3 )7E


q9* j8wE- K =)D.  ' -U ; 4 ,  ,K^%
j% j8yL )oE 6 E d% re% ' B i* )F K d% O <-E
B: #9 r
/8Be E 4 j =H2IY$9 KB rLe 81 )7:B
84 1w 3 ,r,eQ 6( + 1 ,I 1% ' :e% L
=P;
 M Y} A 8  =NF Y} -
, -BL   %6 1
=95  LI
j% {s V: joE  w_ k6< ' K:B, )84 j% j8yL )% d% 2
k6< ' 64g, jF =jL$, j-% j[1 ,64g,
_< s 6
wB
j4 O~ 6BE =64g,
_< wB j%  
: 3 'w 3  w_
N8 6> #} j% j8D 4- 1 F j% ' ~  &'64g," :
= F
66

$PB BB. joE , T6 )$  )D.  q8 '


d[ 8B M $ : ' 8_ \ u K8I  : j
'D ,/8I  re% ~ 6( )$ ; 4 =-: : ' \ 7:e
6y C, % s d  ' j% T-> , 1 : ' $_
jg
j-B , q9UF jg
N8B % ,I A )7Le% )1 )1 B,E
/> KB i* )% j8: K d% i* ,}> O
GD> 3 $
B )@6
i* ,* '[ j-U % ,B$9 9$ p <% z8$ =r:
B$9 BM b[G   j-} ,6m   8I
)\ : 8wU
j8,, '[ : % =~ -B> 5y8 5^ N8 < )7P 
,)7P i* Cy* ~ e% j8 |,
 z8$ ' wE% 5y8

,g9  j8B K n I,$ -, '* ~  '6


8 '[
5 j% j6 , q   BE \ 6 3 BM
j-} {s 5 )oE
)1 '[ ;F 7$B , q  % ,)7$M G j8:! )\8 't
 } B u$_ O$4 =)\ )1-% j8$   )7: i*%
I* i* :w r,B bO,* 2 ,} rD 0
W
I, d[ W ' q  {s ,-E D :
,W : =~ 8*
) 5 e B
=*O,(3 r,B r1[ r,LP r
 d% :r
t j% 'D ' joE :
ds - , )D  ], reg
 ~ I; hIe
,: d[ 6$ r8;  $ r :
W j4 s 5 8 6I
*O 9$ b[\ 78 , BM j =rE  d[  % r
`1[ hP89 j6$ 8I j% z 6 K ~ 6
% `1[> 3
/, B:
,j '!> 
,'!>   ue4 T-UF p F
Y i* re84 !  r* i* B$ 81 =~  < 81 b- 
67

w  E6I j% rB$B 3 =d%-  r L '-U W8* 6y


j% ,r$* 6, d[ W 81 6, W8 d% 6Z , 1
>% ' r$ j% 'D ' j4 j6:  ~ ,:,>-
r$ , p F
s 6
 y BB z:1 joE {s 5 =KD
 8;8Le84 % s8

j% 1 ,7$  + ' 6_ dg


r:, d[ 8y8 M
6B, j4 * 4 jF ,I* g
5,,> 3 ,-EF jg; g; , 8I
Oe ,09
BE # B0 8I u,% , q  ' M4  I

VZ , q  ' ~ M4 j% rLe 6B


j64g, ' e =7L {[4
q  ' ~ M4 j% O$M ,$B 8I  7wE ), / N8B
j
=y8E- j 1 / N8B
VZ   ue4 ,
: OE $, +. b[1 i* M j% 'D * z:1
/-Z
{s i* q:
 I
5,,> %  C9$ L> K
C9$ {$> r
/8B> -U q d% '* h$, 3 [1 joE ,g9 8;
u9*% )D. D$  =< 7,!  7D i* q:

8 e i* 76,  'D ' j% O


'D =76, V, je
~ -% j8: K ?~ 6
% 76,  /6* : ' `$9e 7E ,U
Oe ,j88I )% j8*  )% : 3 [1 joE P ' re% j8:
81  Y 81 O
)*:_ i* q:
?, )7$* -L `(8 jF
?> dg
~ 6
% /8Be 3 :e% 8 =K8I  8e4 j V, ,

5^ 7: :eoE ,U j8D> j% 'D q  b[1 j :P `(8

8e% 5^ i* Y9: d[ *3 =:>( 5^ '* i,e :e!;
i* 5B =r:
z8$ d% i* O~ $ ~ y* j8D j% 'D 3 z8$
` q  k6<% A <8,
B `( -EF 8D. Y>*
68

,KB $- j8X$ K 'D =:


7 8$<8, j% ,)7,*9, 
w r$ O
~  , 6 3 )7P `(8
?, '* )7*:, joE
i* -9U % k6I
j- f
O {[4 ,~ :( 6 Oe
% 6_ j 1 },e 1 % e6 .  q8 eQ nI
q~  j679w 8e4 $1 C_%  '-U : j% -+ ,
y
C8D. 'D =rLe g9 -De 3 V, [ :$E =_< % j j-
5B> , 8F ' % 6% -D: 3 T-U% 8%  q~ 9U% uD>  )F
 N8U6 $  `P -E M ,9$ I,U 'y
3% ,`P % -E 28 3 re% {s : 7E =*  p-
?, j% ` ?C2 L, 3 '* -: ?
p- d%  U6e
KB r  q 6(8 3 =) 6_ wE% `
C8D. :
` 
,: 28 = . -F E4 eOy z:1 'D ,Y$9
, :48$  e6;- 8 e i* _< eq j% Le j% ,:$*
'* 5,+
Q ' SF 5:e K ryLe  4 81 [1
=MU 6 E 1],e , q  e Y-
' MD
]4% ~ 8% Le ' e =3 :81 {s i* 8( 'D
W reF k< d% 81 ~ : ~ % j% Le j% K
)* k-E z:1 ={s
81 r_6< j% Le j% K
 ,b6:L, uy-t *  : 4  6
Y :9 d[  F d   =rwE-
O /6  %
 , -.
5,,e j% 81 L -F d%- k6< E
7(8
jeQ 59, T-U% S z:1 u ,rw r,w_:
=Y i* re8D B9: eOw {$, j%
69

d z8$ A -e % ,r


: 6B,   > A -e
?r$* 81  %8 % '-F '[1 ' ~ % T-e 3 s =  $
% [U !d )7L$ :D 8B A {s  ` 8 3 64g,

,7$* )D. i* _ ; 4 


B :[
 y u w_
{s & 6_" j% O4 ={s i* j 6B 3 -U ~ I; j8> > z:1
Y
 ( 4 ' )$ 1%  jF ;BE e  6_ 1 }
M4 8% i* 8BE 8$E ,U % j )$e q
j8:! 8e4
N^Q r( i* T-e s js =8B 1], j% j 6F 'D 3
s ?: K
0B z8$ B9: q  ' MD -MD },e
~ E {s j4
ue4 s 3 ,{[4 j8D j% 6
3 -% 81 M4 -M4 81 0
A 8 {s joE 8 r; 5y  O~ P u2  eeQ j!}
,  b[1 =7  I> 'D d #: q9U% j $PB BB.
q8 ,jeQ  /3
-6( q 4 6I 1 d B 
N0U ' rP9U% n I> i* _ 81 =~ _0U% % ~ -DL ~ :P4 j4
K ,Be z:1 j8D j% 6
3 s :16 ]
# =] }_:
 ,  6,
`1[>  C O q  =] L> L4 :
B i* -% d% O\ j8D ' N6 YPB. 'D ,N6 YPB. 7$m
d-> j% i*  B YPB. ' -4[ 6* z:1 # =r$* -
> W 
B 8B j%  ,|,
=1: K> CB$> j ,7L:
7,D
'D ' j% 1 ,6 <U i* 6,> d )D $ ,
j8D> K 3 7$* O,*3 'D 3 reoE ,U j8D> K 7  I>
BM rD Y , ;  [Ug: =O~ P : , n I, 
~ E
VB
% reF :, 8F
r_ N0U ' ?{[4 n<% hDE 0
70

CIeQ i* ,* reF =r48$  rP r(8 B,e3 i* ~ ,L: r$B*


81  5^ ' 'D 6 ]4% A 5L,: V, ,b6y NB j% 'D  D
9X 6I '-U ~ e% rL: - j% ,{s  n <
c7,e  je dF 68  j% -} reF =rE 81 $ OE
_ ' reg}
NB j% 'D  O, 3  1 K 8y8 , E-
D 7E 'D ,  5^    ,q  h$, j8$R ;%
)D je z:1 # =8y8 [1    N8B 8e% ' 8e
~ <% 9, 
d B j% O4 , b[1 ' 3 r,D p,4 0
T6 j8D> K =T-U%  % N0U ' O~ D nI ~ 4- #
q
r,e B N0U '  r% / n I>  ,
 * jeQ
  {}  `, '* j8D>  6
%  b[1 joE ,'-U
K, O,*0 )$  F 16  
,K d% i* q:
?,
 y  8I
,b6y NB j% 'D q 4 jeQ ?- K =7$*
reg
)$* i* 81 d%- re8L ' 6y rL_8 [, j% 6
 ,_F i*
n j% 6
 ,7:* 6R j% ' ~36
C
8I Cy*3  -e
 Y. r joE ,b d% ' 8y8 i* bB 'D q8y 4 N8U6

' : ' *8 % ; d% )D ' U


rD j% T- j%
=r
/_  M
88B W '[
' hg,> , 9$, *8+ ' `$9e j% -EQ ' #
) 
?- > , ,VB. -EF ' M4 qOD. ' $_ 6*
)1 '[ ;F d%  )D% b6  5w j% ,&/ 87"
~   re6  ,< )7Dg
8BM j% )\ YR ' wE%
V, ,D8D :D 1 ,~ m> #P:D _% =BM b[1 8,D
71

' K N8 A ]I


uI:> -B> ,;F 6% H1I`89> 6:*
j89, 3 ,6  i* ,qF V, =`89, 6y +$ :D
N8 r8B  4 E- 6
3 )E 6
)-D, i* N8I.
j% : ~ 8 'D W 8 ,'>8e q E V, =r++ j2 
7, I
, BM
8} 59,> '  joE ,7, <  {D}e
q  DE 68 eOw =H2Ij r
-}e d[ 8 : i*
A 8,L 8*6 1 -], ' 6_ ]4g
5,,> , :6 8(8
[1 B W s = % A 6:,> 3 % i* :1]   5^% W
{s 5 ::D =KB '* '6
e :eoE ,}E t_ s % ,d6 ,
G -B , PB . l  r
/B 'D  wEg
:_ 6_ j8De
 <-E BB. 9 j% 'D q d% :$% j8De 3 ,d B
z:1 ue4 s re% 8(-e j% 59,e ,O~ P_ d6 , -,  s =: N8<8
i* ~ _ d B j8D K H3I7$* -M: :eoE wE% BB
E p-_% A :$<8> :e% i* O,*3 : 28 {s q:%  ,7B$ >
% &38" L< qLy r
6IB
D8D :D  09< 81 `89, 1
=*L}$ r$1!> -
F ' r$ NO*g
/_ reF u ; i*  6B
],> '>8e q E ue4 p,D [1  rE `,4 d[   re% 3 2
j% : YR re  N8B K |,
 =$ :
KB C(  _%
O7 ,-e % -DE % -% 6(8 3 re% {s V: joE '>8e q E  {D}e
C_ L ' =YB , {D}, jD i* 8$> ,KB >- uX$
% ::l
q E j%  :  r,-e N0U ' 6
OE u% ',}: j% 6B
',}: C3 joE |,
 ,-B> ],> % ,K 6 A   < '>8e
='>8e C3 ' k% 1 
s+$ / j8eB 
=',}: q E A '>8e q E ' :$B,e K I  w
81 [1 3
72

d[ 6B 81 [1 =e*  7 N8<8 'D BB. ' :D
68  1 b[1 ,r$* IR j% /8I  jeQ 'D
=7$* N8I $
,-. C}_:  C3+ 0
: B j% `-X '
3 |,
 ,'D 6 _% A 7E i* rE j8y d[ u_8 
6( j8D> ' oE E-9, .  6( p F 'D> W  re% j-
~ <%  F
)7Le%  j8yL 3 )% j 8I, )% `-X =0
5^ jg}
- }_: q-( `(8 ' jg
j-B
K I
%6 j% j- )7:D ,7E ~ 48D} 5y8 j8D> j% 'D , 5y8
64! F 7E {D}, ` 3 E-9, . d% : -DE % ~ :
s !7: '64g, )7Le% )1 )F 64! % {[
j8: ~ 
-D: ; d% rE 6(8 d[ u_8  64! % i* w_ % e],*
:eoE DeQ
r ne j% j {s r n s -DL b[1 KB
)D $ K$1! wB ],e : j8BL, '[ ' e :e% Le
=-U ?-9 A 5,e 3 w_ :e% ,KB

-} r:D jOQ A -B,L reg


h<8 d[ |.  
`
# ,KB i* )g
: -} {D}, * e ' `*-

Y joE |,
 =6
j8$L  j8$ 3 )F Oe )7P  <
d%- {s k6< i* /8B 3 r$* : /8+1 ' O.  d% d%
:|, )*  )*  ' z:1 =5,+$ :
r,% i* /8B  6B

,9  $ 7:* q:X, 3 'D 3 


,~  6L C6B, 

%  7( ' j% O$M 6e  ~ ( C8D $ j% (  A


73

 8I
5B> %  ,  ' 8:  =5,+$ T-U% nI
(  $ 3 ~ ; z:1 joE ,8D. C! 'y ~  S
Cq-(Q [,> j% ,7 $ 
,C8D $ n j% 'D I
+ z:1 =$ / d%- {s  16! ,< 7P ~ BE
 )1DL> ' -M4% : ' M4 G -DL 
,7e  ~ M4 T-U%
b[1 ?y j6- '[ )1 BE SF j% 1 ,B
 +.
5:e j% , SF i* 8B 5we j% ~ 6
% :$* :( 3 ,9 DEF
= SF 3 b6- 3 ~ -%
' # ,B: i* 8B -]> NZ DL,  B-9 b[1
B-9 b[G % g> 1 =7Le N0U ' Oe f BB N0U
'D =d%- 8%  /8I )D.
 1 g
)*  A (. `:+,,
' I E Be 81 b8$E  4 j% j- 3 {[
j8L,D '[
M 81 ,d% g r>s 6
81 K d% 5L e j =T-U% A 9Be
-Be K =rLe d%- jg; reg; B:$ (
 B:$ 8,L ?0U
[1 joE ,6 E d% 81  ~ % j% -Be O$M ~  ,-9U d%  ~ % j%
5,, 6 L d%- 'D W  ,q  K
)DR 8I O~ D  `$9,
ne j%  :$* :( 3 :N8B> 6_ =rLe '* E6$ , <-L

re N8B j% r 28 3 'D ,r: 3 % ,5Ee r% j N8B j% Y6e $


s =rLe ' q ( d%- k6< jF ,N8B  -% [1 'D =k< d%
7E , w_ k6I
6B,e j% rE p8- ' j4 j )$e j% e %
6B , z:1 # ?_< w_ 84 g ,  : 8
j8D
Oe SF d% # [1 ,L
~ Ee j8D j% 'D BB. h
74

5Ee %6 re r NB %6 Deo


` je )7, K =: wE% d%
3 6 L f j% i* Q ' r: 'D 7E ,~ 6 E b- r:D
8B q  `e( i* j8LB '[ {% ?Ee j8D> j% \ 'D
)1-> 3 uegE =T8*6 b[1 N0X,   ~ 6
% 8BL ' /8 '

=BB. 8y8 '* r$IE 'D ' jg4 5L: 8y8 j8:,
d[ %6 j% j- )7$ d[ 68 ` joE ,#D i*
' =BB. 81 %6 [1 j% 81 Oe r:* V: 3 -% r, i* j8$
+. b[1 /6,  'D ' j4 s 5L:$ N* Be z:1 j8D
i* 76,  eD j B: e( 6% i* X F Cs
 -*}
% Ke8B
-Z K $ : ' =-U `e

1 6< 5, ' rLe 6B


oE ,K d% k6< i* *3

% ,B$9 r>  ' hL, 81 r


n>  _% =rLe DeQ
=rw E -t `e[
L 8} ' hL,
O,
3 :wE 8, d[ q8 '*  y  8< 9*% V,

wB
B:
g :eoE ,8B
d%- [1 E-e :eF K d%-
> 3 /6* ' 'D 6_ ]4g
-;% , wB ~ *8 ,Ug  , 8$
' ,d%- - 6y 'D  T8_% +. 7E ],
> w_ 1 ,18 e
jOQ N8 6> 7:* a6Z% , q  =5L: p
' k6I p

_0UF f ' dg


jOQ % ,C8 6
.
jOQ r 8(8

9 [1 joE  F [1 i* 4- U6e K =*  8I


8B
1 b[1 1 :N8B re% 64! ' jF ,N*  )I *  
5y8> jF 7$1! 8 e i* KB (  $> 3 % j],> , f
75

O4 , q  6% 81 r 8(8


jOQ 1 ?j8eB  uZ
je re% :yE s 3 KB
18 e -} j% q- 59, 3 j88B>
Kl 8e8D j%  j8- 3 '[ : ' ~ M4 j% 5_8 ?/8I
8} j% K
%
j% f B | n =)7Le% K
 )7:
[1 j88B
,
r:*%  81 # {s 'D O7 K %6  < N8 KB

<= 9 g  u 7 | 8 > {[


6I_% Oe =I E
?-9 i* NB j% 'D  O, 3
)\ O j ,<'4`l
r:% :eoE e< v*:_ -M4% '* ~ *E -t  )*  [1 j% 8 =_:

,K d% L
jeQ KB $
O7 =rLe 6B
6}
rwE %
b B,E d%- {s E ' V, r:B $
O7 ,{[4 M b 

 )D. [1 rE6 K ,~  1-D:, % C> 1 T8B, A
 I L reoE ,rLe '* 5E6 d%-$ O, 3 <-E )-Z A
6% ': 3 =r % b6$
1g
~ 6 ! rD j4 j V, ,rLe
K ~ -9U _% *0   _% j8D O
I E j%
, q  joE #D i* 
,T8B, '* ~ 6
% ~ }E d%- j8D
b[1 =~  ~ 4,E 7E E3 [1 j8D , q  1 B [1 '
) K (  q9UF 5E% g}
utD>  , 8F w
1
b[1 K
' 6+e :e 
=B0 N(F  `*- N81[ C %
t ,  , ,V:> 3 ,  , C $ 8F
j8eB 6 7E u6
~ +e j8eB YB  ,f e% N(- wE% i* qwB$
t ,  u;* f 
'D ,N(-
Y$, OE r h !
OE C
'[ ;F 6y  z8$ '* E6$ _ L 3 6

= 87 ' N8B 1L> 8LU % /+L uK 8LU


76

reg
~ -D> ~ -  4[>  u$E O7 6. 2 ' {e
e8eB C9$
V: 3 8 e i* /69< ,-B V*6 ( z:1 j4
6_ =qO
q 6$
 *  -B 6 =r:2  / d%-
i* b 8I> b* -B 8E-* ' wE% 't C8$ r:* :,$<
i*F M )*  j4 re% )$e ' e =j  {s  * ' U
re%
j80EF ) /\Q 6I 81 ,b6
' $wL $ 5
,H1I"i mastri di color che sanno" 89 % 6:* K<- L: `1[
[1 =T-UF L$L -E 5^ _0UF L$L <%  '[$
d[ ,b6
8;* '[ D '-DL 5^ )$
r -_
% d[ )$
k8L re2 D d[ ,: L% ' -M4% 6
~ ,< -7;   N  
,EBM )$
 87} r,:6 u$( , T-UF qO F 5^ j2
YL = 8+L YL 7,
C8
b6$
1% r$* )D j8eB re%
r$* V* d[ } j 
,6 G ?> , \ -De% reF

,e r6,  d[ , 81 [1 =&j8$ '[ 6 " 1: 9  * 1
,5
- 6}: , _X \Q 68D ' NF q   ,89 % h<8
' ^->  =151130 C
F ,L 0L$ r, '* a6 , j4 
:6 $4 u$wE ::D ,&s, %" 81 , j4 \Q 68D$ jOM*
L$E % K
#$ j8$ '[ s, % u% ~0$_ :* uE K"
L_ '[$ j80E% -B u% :1 :5 b6+ r -: )7$4
^-> :d+% ,e )  \Q 68D ='-U ' r p-_%
=117  L< ,1959 ?   ,jOM* '
77

r ,H1Ij80EF F
#  m -e r dg
'! 'D W reg
r
K
}L 5} re% ]t ,* r> rP N0U ' reF 8+L

k6I
r>6( D  j% 6B,e :$ :6% K
P36 4 =p}
d[ jeQ i* /- d% i* 7D M C8
uD ,~ e[
=K. {s V, 8;* '[  K
' -6B> wE% Y , j4 r$
7E u$y , C3. ) -4st joE -B e 6

,6  q:M, 


,-M ' T-M A B,: '4 j8D 6
6B 6B ' p-B
+ > i* 5_ d[ a6. 1
67; '[ -4s  z-> d[ (- =: POeO h% |8 _
~ P1 ~ -% r>O$4 8  r>
eO j% (  A _0UF r,* ' 0
~ + r,$( j  ' ~ e-_ *
r$* )Dt  (- [1 ,4 8$* s 0
) =:%  D  /% -B 9 -,  1 j80EF F
#  m 1
,66( \ U
 ,6 G ?> , \
? 3 reg
-B
r48$ '* rLe '* E6$ -B ' m 1 =:%  p} E
j% r$* YL, ' jF ,-B '* ~  > ~ Ie ],> 3 7:D ,D  /%
b[1 = , : 
U% r:D ,b6:* ' : 5y j80E%
=P- 
F 8I: ' s 6
],> ,L$L 7,_ '* 6* ,  
`+e 42 8,46 7^->  ,1935 /*  - N% 
- A u^-> 6_
E6 j-L% 1 D?
E  j8:
C m 
% 'y 8m
*% 6_ =q9UF ' 6* i* ,}> ^ 'D =j6E j89-_%
-B 4m j8:
1973 /*  Ce -_ C * 8,46 7,^->
1e , ,j6E  m q:M, 
8m 1e , C   i* u$,;
=1973 /*  $B,  8I
-_
78

rE t q( d[ (- !? 6 reg


? g
 ,C8
 B-9

-% 81 ,I$  reg4 b8$* ,r$* j4  Be re% 8:l )1U
, -*} =K. {s  r )7,$ `
/8 )7$* Y9: re% ],e
,n -B   $ 8I
j  G #Z
i* )7D  )* )$
j88B :  ,O7: eM ~ <8IU
' 6  i* 8e8D W {% =C8
O7$* 8D '[ {%
,#D i* 
=: ) r$* j8D  %8 g
8 )1 , SF
-*} ' )7Ie '* 6  6_ r$ )7Ie j8$R 8e4 )oE
,)78_ K
 )1*  6P ue4 , :8 _0UF :6
e* rE O
, 8I ' * 4  j8R '[ ' e% )% d%
K,, K8$  : K
) 8} D -L 5+
,.
],> ue4 CO$4 5 K r
 Y; d[ ,:7D #P =/3

r*>   ~ I$ j4 O
,H1Ir8_ DE% 5^ A :
-LD  
T8B, /3 1% ' K : jg; {s  reg; ,b2 ;
j )7 h '[ ,b[1 :%  )7_0U% )7: `
re2  j8} ~ 8@ 8e4 )% 8 =:7D #P z8$ ' ~ 2 ;
'[ j86$B, j8  =E  8 e i* ~  ~ 8E> 8eD
6
3 PF q67} 8^ '[ j% i* )D $ d8_ 
j j-}
N8_%" = = =8 r
(gE :6664 :26 V, +e  q(  A :1  ;Q 1
~ > )  6B K '* ~ ( jeQ '
 j-> ?8 j [: )De ~ w% )D
:
( 3 !? 6( 6_" : r
 :7D #P Y}E &!qO ` i*

8B* Y , :8
(% &?)D% OE =rL6 ), 6_ ),e% 1 =87; A 6

&!C8
79

8: 3% )G 6 K6$B, K  ' ~ S d% )7: ~ S 8e4 )%


=#8
#6B j4 )18^ '[ {% ' ~ 6 j%
e],* s ,~ ^ $MF b[1 T8_% 81 ,-U ~3M hy% 8*
s =rE 5B d[ } $wE D
B b6 g9 Y* j%
~ <% 9$ 5_8  ; dF j4
' r$ p % r j8D> j% 0
j8D } [1 joE ,O~ $* )1-M4% re2 1% wE% re% rLe
,bg
, W$ Y$9 )4. j4 =8$ % 84  8]Q
,` E [1 # =1 8< VBe%  6 i* r> $ E 6_
r>g}e A -:
r: r_8,e 3 -% 81 ,`$_ k g
5,, j4 r:D
`e+
Y$,> ~ ^ ue4 6BE r `:
> , $$B q9UF % =_-
B* 7+,e% , _0UF C
,D wE% 1 ,r>
,4 j% O4 ,K$ 
~ <% uL$,U j [1 -4[ q  h$, 3 ,)6B W
-M4% '* 0
' -M4% ~   ], d[ ,(- [1 =n G -7,; , ),
679y ,b6
8D d[ ' -1  K  /D. )
C2+eQ 5^ _ i* rw ~ _8 ,R 8$ % j4 = 
r,$( I}
 ,- n,L, B
5,, j4  ,$ B

j% T- j%  YLU% {s 5 =_0UF r>    NM 6
r>( N0U ' ,r ~ S # W  $I  j8D '  
V-   j4 6P 5,+ j% )$ j4 =Y V7,:
77E ,
re% ,T% re% 'l % ,T% re% 3 ,5,+ 7$* j4 , . )  =\
81  %8 % nI j% j N8Z , : r8Z ~ D O, ~ , j4
5,, O
,$ )4 4 =: G '! , \ / L
,r$*
80

n 3% r( ' j% 'l 6BE ,W b `(8


Y* # ' r

hDE r9
 u2 s re% )$ 'D W ,V,; YP- k-L, jg
5,+$
'6 j4 =~  r>,; W 6> T-U%
 D}> 'D ' j8D
j%  re% r 6
|,
 ,PB
- {DL> A 
?6@ 66
j%  =r,
 
B r( j% % 66 '6 {s Y:, j% r(
,\ 6I ' re% % n < re% r 6 'D W   6B /e
B ~ -% r :
'D W `$ I r '* `-X  , [1 j% 
3 re% 6( -% i* /8B re N8B j4 /: [1 j%  ,Y6I,
5_8, j% b 6B
'D W reoE ,N8F ' N dg
r
Y6I, 59,
~  j8D j% 'D /: [1 j%
re% 7:  nw>  81 ,66+,$ 0
5^ [U% 6
,66+, NU    '6 +e d% r
/_
,8 )1-M4% /D. L 0L k % joE r$4 {s (% ' =C ,*3
7( ' =  79y
n ,`(8
r  ' `

O re =bg
 ,   g YPB. -M4% ' BB. b[1 ],> d-e
j% 'D d[ D ?0,U3 T6  -DLe j% #L:   - 
[1 uB:,* e-  8]Q j% 8 W    r$* j8D>
)D l  r_:,* ' ~36
8$ % 84  )D l  '6
j% ` re N8_% BB $ 8$ F ?IeQ p
' 'D =K9:9_
w ), _   7y-* 'D + % jg
?e
8$ % 84  , ue4 +. b[1 ,b[1 :%   $
`$X 
.Q jg
'!   z:1 # =  },e pB
q
8$ % 84  '  -M4% 5,+ L> A d! j% r$*
81

d% ' 6_% re% 'e j% 'D d[ } re% 5 ,  N8 rLe
; dF N8_% :e =BB. b[1 z  i* re2 1% ' -U ;
{Le  '> 'D> W  re ,q  : ' i* pB Y9> i* YE8
D
~ M4 r: )$*% % ,r: U 8$ % 84  ' )D% {e%
 ~ 6(t r: -M4% u:4 % ,D. {$> ' >- i*% {$B* j% % ,{e2
-M> K Y $ {*>  r: O~ I> -M4% u:4 % ,BB. '* 
{ '  {e% rE T-> d[ E3 '* 5:, j% {
6 reoE ,r$*
{$> r ue4 8$ % r
' d[ E3 81 ,K8I '
=~  L ! P,:
'* E6 j89, 3 )% :6 -. q6*% 
z 6
+ % A q8+$
'6$ w1: q  6B> ?6G pB /6, 
=8$ % 84  h_8 -]> rLe u_8  g; ' j8D '
b[G ~ e% j8$B )oE p-7,$ )7% N 3 re% j6 K
  d679w j% 81 ,j8e8( 8,46 N8_ j88B +,:
BB. - j% X: :m 79y3 j% 81 )\8_ j8D =Y i* 8e4
\ N8 3 e8eB C
8B j% ,* i* ,+:
12, O~ P 1 ,G
 Cs jF 
 ue4 j ,?9   BB. /% 8_ 3
/6* A *6 +. ' D} [1 = w q9UF /% Ee
=Y_6,  ,
VR jF LD 6 A `- :6 n,
j4 j BB. 79y i* c- 3 re N8B> , -: j
3 -: b[1 ,7P[ i* 6B ' 79y3 jF {s ]  z:1
59,e 3 ::D ;66 YPB. N8_ 6I_ '* d> g
7 'D
82

eeQ )\ '6> '[ ;F 1B$ , $ /-4 i* 7,:

' : rE- 'D W ~ -% W$


 ; h}D K !YPB. b[G
-% 8I
~ 9 j4 re% W$ uM K ,8B
W [1 # _
, C6 )1% ' ], {s joE ,r>-U % be j!;  ~  )7
5 N. 1 O4 ,C3. 
 ;:$ 76B j% jeQ 'D
' j8e8( 8,46 joE ,H1I:6 0<Q qO*2 PF K 
: 7 : 'D 61 '% 1 6 b[1 j% j8: r,$4; i* )1
j% ,7} 81  5E: b[1 p <% q ( j8D j% % =
b[1 `
reoE ,K-+ ,* ' )g4 8$  j% 81 )G8 j8D
7$* 8D j%  :
6 I /6: i*  ~ -% # -:
[\ ~ BE = 8 N8B 9 5y8 81 Oe ,)7$*  j8D>
r,_ i* : /% hB j% X: 66( BB A *6 joE %6
:6 , #$+  66( j8e_ -E B j4 d[ M 
#$+ YE8 W s Y:} bI j8D j% ,6B je8  #-48
: j% ny8 ' j =r_ i* ,r
 % O 6
, 8L i*
t
~ 4 ~ e2 j8B 3 K: 
$  B-9 b[1 '* j8E6 '[
i* `$F  ,B> 8y8 A -: [1 j% :l `$% =j
'D - Cs 
8- ue4 O
66 YPB. j% j8: '[ {%
=j 7: LD :6

=,e,>] q8}e A T% d[ ,


-X 
 %  1
83

79y3 i* O~ P ,:> BB. j PB %6 j ,N % i*


j% A -U 8$> ~ 6 : 1 -D , +7 
sD f ' 81

=C] p +, 5^ r


[D> %6 {s 5 r:D ,@6
BB nI>

=79y3 L
5B$ uy-> , YPB. i* $Mg
q  ,

=j-_ 6 7,$_-* ),> j% 'D ' joE ,6


F A 5B> W 8 V,
0<Q 4- u6e :BE :6 q  '* $M% )D9*% 8*

u6*% =5B 7Ie j4 'D ,-8 _ _F i* - '* :6
t %  =11551100 Arnold of Brescia ] 68e % C9$
k-
{[4 =k2 i* 13071250 Fra Dolcino 8:}, -E

-> =14981452 Savonarola 3 e8E N ue4


5_ =H2Ij8 e6L 5t _  =79y3 ,B$ AlbigeoisH1Ij8+F
j4 ,-8 67* 6
V, =H4IK 8\  j4 {[4 =H3I&j8t,, "
NI,  )> 6BE =7E O
- 4  79y3 `Ie +:
 8]Q ' ,H5I2 6e0L 9 e  ' ,:,>]

D$ j% 8 {[4 e9-


' <g,
> j% 'D ' j4 =:

-D u_  u> 


  D$ j% 8 % ,N8% E u;* d 
_e  7E j4 , C3.  3 O~ P n+: 79y3 =7D '

+% 6B 8I  7  j4 , ,e-E  % :6  ue4 E 1
Albiga


~ e% j8E- '[
h$D j8( >% '
=14151370 ,81 j8( >%
6:81 D+$
 e-E ' q (% i* ,}>   ue4 
 %  B9:
Vaudois e-L X$  )7

84

2
3
4
5

; z:1 # =)179y j ~ $* N8Z 8_ I* j8$D}

 8]Q    Ym 'D ' j4 re%  {} j% 59, _*

,9B, ue4 79y3 C$* jF C  C,e 7:D =e-

8*6 ' $8 CE 7:


IL> I_ CE 3 /6> 3 ue4
j% \  % 3 , L /1F ' re =6% 7, Y$B 3 ,

,:> 7$ ,g9 7 -B,L :4 8_ s 6


{$, BB. j% 'e
8 e  O.
jeQ -} `X  =_-  k2U e e  i*

C
8B$ ` : Y9, j% O4 =BB. 8 e r,  ' -M4% g9
d% },e h_  ~ (e   j8D ,*O,(3 V, ,e8eB
,~  < q  6% j8D K :  1 BB $ BB.   =O7:

 8I
z:1 j8D 'D ,M4 C- % 6 - b 8e gL9 j% 'D

u_ vg j% A ,rE},4 * i* ' _ j-B T6 i* e% *
' r+: ` : '2  87 A d%- 8* j8D> j% rE ?I,
d6I, i* ~ _ r$ /6B, ' ~ E4 ~ 6_ YBR j% A ,79y3
=b 8e qL A - , C3  5

'[ i* C8
)D e j 6e W :e N8B ' z:1 j8D
j8$,B 8e4 '[ e6(% : i* e 3 :e ;66( q
j8>g
n < =66 q  p <% 7E 'E 6 ~  :e :e 
;qeF
6.   e-*} j 
;_e  i* C8
)D e 6e W :e%
I 8 e i* ~ MU q  -M4% 6y  _ C
8B* Y9,
Be 3 :$
+:
:e% *6e :Le% 4 e 3 e8* 'D =/, NI, 3 6 A
i* C
8B* -L j8eB N   =8eB 79y3 7; ' V,
85

V, C
8B b[1 -E j 
=7:* , i* _F i* % ,q 
 > j% ~ 6
% N8B  '  8 e i* ~ e ~ -% # b[1 :% 
B  LI D  C$( T6 q:% =8_ D
 ~ 8
. q H2Ije i* )Dt  1857 H1I/*  Cornwall N8 e 84
C
8 T6 i* `,4 Lg
L$> reF ~ -7; 21 6 '+

5,, (- [1 j NB =  '6$  CO$D 

 ,-7; ' _g


{s 6
 =r> `e8( 5^  P; r
8}> 3 z8$

K, :  KI; N8_ D  uwE ,Old Bailey 


6%
' X
e1Q 6% -> ,KL$  1  4 }$ H3IK,L$,
=: 6B, O@6 # re% k6I
:$*% OF K  6% ' B
I,_3  rB ' ,:(% 81 ,H4I ; /-t  rLe `$
3 re PB 8eB %6 i* I,_3 E )_% =8I$ 6% '
d% )@ 3 ro
'! 'D W s D    )6B,
}$ n
[1 ' '[ ;F ,* N %6 [1 = 8}: 
 r
re% O4 ;)4   ' '6, j8eB '* K( U )g4 B
= p,4 6< ' BE K,: _ d%
28 31  ,Bodmin Assizes K8
Dm  )D. j4 ,|8
8> 81
8L* r:* 6< |, / ' ] NF j8e4  =1857 88
h! =D$
 ?3->   ,1857 #9% p 17  z881 p8D( c 8(
h! =1857 88 28
#9% p 4  , 8   ;   Dm ,'}0(  j 
h! =1857
86

1
2
3
4

8_8 j r$* q6,*3 % } [1 _ 'D re% ~ :y L


r j4 % ~  b6 } [1 j4 s pB $P uZ
; d% j% {[4 : r:D ,` E [1 # =r,$4; i* ;%
j4 s pB $P uZ 8_8 j r$* q6,*3 % r,_ 'D -U
'4 E i* /8B [1 =r: /6B 6 i* 6, - C
=\ _ 3 r: joE 8}: 
'! } 'D W s re% bL
, ,
~  ~01( j8D j% 6
3 q;F b[G '! d[ } j
)1 8I 5^  K:!  ' 4 E j% ~  > u
M ' jF
G '! j% 'D 3 wB b[1 =? 1 :
)\ 87} ;%
V42g
j8,, '[ ;F 6* '* -DE Ve% r6 ; d%
_F i* -7,; '[ ,)2+e )7$PwE wL
,W  
~ wE =K:!  ' )g
)7: K
-B$ :

b[1 joE ,{s '* 0


'6 $ 5^ j% :yE soE =7L:
7  % 8B>   ,e 6*B
'6 $ 5^ 7}
B> 6*B b[1 joE ,K
sD ' 8e8D j% 6
3
j8D$, '[ {% 3 :M,> 3 ,p[D$ 6, 3 )@6 '[
' ~36
@-4 6B )7PO,e
j8E K d  7(8 i* %-
i* B9: _:,
rLe '6 d[ j8eB j =p[4 -g
n,
3 N8L d  bB
 'D 3 ,'$  rE6G Y$, OE 8 : [1
`- 8e re ) =79y3 CL$ ' B
 1-D$  ; b ,*

re9$ uZ N8U6$ } 1!> ,  jF ,79y3 ' ~ 


j8eB [1 j =rB , 3 re%  y  8I
uM> ,  1
 1 O$M K:!$  j8D> D> 7$* /8B , -:
, 
~
s4 -U /8
'! 3 d[ } j4 s reF ='-ED$
87

5:, j [1 p[D ' '! 5: d[ ` j% {s V: joE
~ E
Ky-  j8eB [1 y8 qe ' = : ' rE8U BE 81 0
6, 81 Oe   PwE r$* 8_% d[ /87L j% Le jg
r
=)7Le% )1 )1 DE% )6B, '
u % '  O
 ,79y3 CL$ B
' 64g,
b[1
-D, 8IB i* NM 1  6B
,79y3  - i* 0*
 ~  B , j6 )7$ d[ , $+eQ N8B*  X$
q8
j8, rE 8 W d[ u_8  q %6  I
jOQ
~ E j6- )7$ d[ D
'D =$ : ' %6 Y9> 0
ND;% 9> -, 
~ eOy :9> 3 / B  joE h 
[1  =~ -B> 6 ( 6 u , 8eB 79y3 ' %8 %
q A - C3 
f\ K>- n9 p-9w u_8
5E: NU A - C3 
r
-9y 6B
6B 
j8D '6$ q reg
. u_8  : r
V1,  =66(
i* rLe 6B
`I,$ q ,B Bw N8B  ,O~ P
`; -*}  `I, ' P  T8_% z:1 j8D>  =_F
3 ,6$ [1 1% ' V9 8 CB9 T6 O~ P 8(8  1 ,
W '[ {% 8B
679w jF ) M, 3 4 87 A -F c,R
~ 1% )1 ,* '* ~ 6
% 8L_8,
j N8R d[ q j =H1I79y0 0
q (% %8 % '* ~ :$* 7E , )> , B-9 ' ~ M4 ~ -[e [Uge j% 'D 1
6F ; h8 ' 8_ *-( i* ,; d[ ,e9] I}
/*  8:\ } 8:( r
/_ d[ -,  :
,/ q*3 M
= i* ' j8(6 j8I, 1B% , ee- `9 j8D> O
=1857
88

q {[
:*% ,-F [1 81 -DL -. ~ eD e9-
j8D> j%
, C6B,
-_Q j8wE- '[ {% 8I
: -*}
3 e8eB C
8B$ P-  j4 $8 E N0U =7 -
Cs 1 *O,(3 <8 'D =*O,(3 <8  > i* 6 
~ 6,  _% e9-
 : j% (  A d8_ 1-% j = -F
j6$  : 6,  ' 5,+ 1-R , q  '* ,$
=8eB pB $P uZ 8_8 i* d89:> q '* ,$ T-UF
)1%6 j% 8:$*% +eQ p . q 'D ;7 CL,3
-6(  ]:
1 6B p,D 7E 6
, 6 j% 81 K$ 8:\ )D 
8D. hPl8 j% ~ :y :  ,8D. N8F i* BE I , ,
_ 6_ ={[
j-1, '[ % KBB. K $ 3 V9> j% 28 3
12  r,B9: 1% ' 6} /% 1B% $4  ,(   28 ~ * ~ :% j
5 e9] 8D. n> j" :  N_ ,1857 ]E8e M '>
reg; ' j4 ,'6 )  7$* j8B$9 , CE- ,K$ 8:\ '
j === $  8: j N ,9] ) 3 8< $_-*
j8 )7*6e 3% ` 'D ,:6 C- $ ) '4- 81 n,
, -. :> ,77E% O4 $D b[1 =B n, $4 /6, 
 =rLe  F i* j6, '[ K  K
 - d% ,5+$
 d% 6 $
'!> ,   hP89 5^ 5 n, :>
j N8B> , BB. A -: uL% j% % =&n r
/8B d[ $
'y ,6$ [1 8D  ~ * ~ I: X} jF ~01% ], d[ jeQ
)1 n 18g
j8:! 3 '[ j% i* : d[ %6
'! ,]  2
h$, i* N6 d[ 67} [1 T-e K =n, Vt c U ~ ^
A VL,U :6 79y3 j% '  -, j% 59, d[ ' ,d-DL
h! ?(  A
89

'* j8:X, )7$ ~ 6 q-M ' j8X$ '[ :$ :



 *O,(3 8Xw -% joE ,'-U ;F 5 9 C_0
N8U jF ;j8eB 8_ M  81 Oe : 7: -L: , q  u4
'[ j =r>8_ `4 K
 } K
NR j% ' %8 % # '+
% 8 d% A j8(,R 3 '[ ,)7,} LD j8g U6
j8,,
, 87 ' % ,C ! C*8+ ' % ,9$ 1% ' 5:<
)G '  j% 3 '$  )7P '* n, ' re8}  )@6 #
8e8D jF (
8 )1 ,q8
)7:* 86 , j% ~ q8 :
A (
8 : q3!1 ={s NO, )1 6B
j8D V, ~39
%
~ . u_8  5_t 8e 3 :e% ) 'D =)G BL} A 8*6 4
 Le :4 O4 :>6B, '* h$, C6B,
j8:! '[ i* ~ 4
=)\ :,$ N0U ' {s '* B 3 ~ :Leg
5_8e :e% 3 
u9 -B L$L 'D ,/6*Q rIe j4 -B j% n <
=7$D
-DL B k8E 1 8e Ce -DL qO  #}4
:D 'D ,8  j8B $ 8e4 PF K  j% n <
6B C>: k8E 8> ,,: 7 -+}4 C-12  
- j =\0l ' 7$* B$> O
18e Y> ,G Z , Lw
;q % <g, 3 ,; d% ,_ A d! 3 *O,(3 `I,
=8B
1e m '* :,3 % )7P qLUQ : M, r:D
6B* 4  hw % 8B \: 3 -X s} q  joE ,: :

 -,> Oe ,~ 6


% 6
CE 1 8e ,: 18,> 1 3 ;( %
)$ 1% '-DL ; Bw -P6  q9 N,;3
q8 q8y d% :> j% j , DEF b[1 p <% )1 '[ , 6
90

A d! [1 =:$  j!} i* ~ *U % ~ BB ~ q8y j4


q  5^ B reF ,: 
-e 7( ' ~  N8B 5y
wX $ A q8+$ j ,-F -1l  G  j 6P
Y$9 - -E j ,'+ A r  % ; d% )-X> _ '
q6
K
I $F d%-
j8$B 3 '[ _ ' B /6,  i*
5^ qB
 ,-DL W*  /0 i* L $  : 9U b[1 =-DL
'D =, 7y ' ~  `-_ 8 e i* 9 `
-P q;F
D
 w, 81 -DL P67, ' 8: [1 
B 5E6 d[ 'M
~ 4 O~ _ j% rE T-e d[ 5y8 =d B$ _0UF *+}
K
 r:
L,R j% r, $I ' j% ], ~ M
 ~ }e '-DL -M4% '
 8R j% ,)*:_ 7$* u_ , # F $<F f
rLe
` :, H1I)7+P,e ' 'D 6_ ]4% 8LD j%  )R>
~ _ j8D ' 5y8 [1 ,uI
18wE j% )\ Y , C6B
,?8 ?-> 3 R CI}
j8,, ;% c,e i*
W :2   8e4 '[ ' B9: : ' KB :, '-DL
e%  )1 )7(,e i* ~ _ j8D j% 5_8,e '[ ;F =-DL
=. B9: B
?- OE +,: 6B K
_0 81 :1 8IB 1
j,6B B9: _ D :
/87L j% 3 `-X ) 3 [1 ) 
=jE je 4 :81 Y9: `,4 5^  b6+e {s i* NM -7;% =+,e
  I 6B joE O~ $ B j8D K =jE -B js =je -B
7LD , P,: j N8B j%  6IB =  < +,e A O~ D d!,
/6* e7 ' 8e 81 )7$_ ' y8E- C6B 5 ` :,, j-DL
 81 ,B9: Y :, A j-B,L )oE |,
 ,-DL : ' k6I
=-9 % w
6
b-4s i* vg
91

,>-  DEF j8$R *O `4 A /Owe3 j2+, 3


5y8 5 j8y-, K , 87 qy Q j8 '[ %
j86, 3 )7 -> , +. j86, )oE 
j6- '[ % = DE% ' j8$R O
:,_3 i* )7,$ , +.
)O,1 )1 DE% $B> N0U ' {s j8$L )oE . [1 p:,(
,f A k-9, j 7E a6 , 'D , 8F i* 1_
vg> j% 'D , XI $ P i* B )% V:

,5 % T8_% ue4  N8B* j% 8 7Le qB$> ' S  8I

_ L ={s a6R K 3 L


YPB nI> j% ~ 6
% 'D 3 ,
j-+@ {[
)oE 8 : [1 i* j8E, K )% 1 -F 
{[
:*% ,: N8B* 5 8> 8B> reg; ' d[ 68 -F
=5y8 5E % i*%  qd- d-DL 
*O i* K(  `e( ' ),D, L , [1 ],> u:4 s
),D, [1 P,e ' j% NF /B  T-> j% {$E , -F
#
3 , DEF ;(  q  $; * }_: % z:1 j8D> 3%
j ,qL,U3 1I j8D ' } B: [1 ' +: 59,>
>: TsF 8e% %8 % 'D = },e3 K
 7:
NR j% 'D ' j4
,*O ?- 7$B P,e A d!> 3 ,  8e% 5^ - '*
,K(   N8B* `Ie ' Oe K(  N8B* `Ie ' j8D '
)7$B* pI ,~ 8Im ~ 6B r$D
B )1 89> j8D '[
6
OE K, O
G 8$B j% 'D q  j% ' ?8 `1

b  `R j% 59, d[ ' =*O i* ( U q %


W
92

 CI}
6*8 DEF ds ' M4 N8B* jB> K
- DEF ' $$ % > i* j- 3 ;g
d% ,LPU
~ L : r: j% 'D -% A )G d!> j% }U ,$B, 9}:
ds ' : 
L b[1 -E% K
' T-e 6_ ?k0UF % '6$
/6, 81 r>  d[ ,I Y_6 )7L ,Y w
!ED, ' 6_ V % YB , -, 
9
C06,
/8B r$B*
~  -D,  8 {$7, ,r>D  59, 3 d[ r$B* reO K

j% j O
 ,*O q K
 r$B* by * K
YE8,$ r:
~ -DL j8D j% je dF 'D 3 =b  +: ' ~ 6
% 'D,
P,e % 8 e r$B* > 81 -DL4 NF r( j% z % s 3 O~ *
w , 6 6
rL: -DL d[ } =7 b8B j% 'D
L>  -M4% ,rP9U% N0U ' V, ,BB. /6B>  )1 K :
=DL,
)7LeF j8  3 )% -+ 8$R {F   I q 
j% '* {1e AF ( 6
D}> F #   -DL - j
23 oE ,{s ' #D i* 
=/ '-DL 16 D}>
i*% A N8<8 ' K : KD   {s ' -M4% V,
O
 ,  z:1 j4 =r N8<8 )1 6B
j8D B* T8,
8 ' /* 8(  /* -E% j-DL ,B,  {[4 j8D
[1 ' d[ 8  ,~ 6
% j8D ' ,_ z:1 'D W 'D =$B
7E p_ , C3.  =-DL : ' }e `; ,B
 ` joE ,-DL : ' K9}e )84 8 e j6$ 6% jD
rB$> )> 6_ *O '* c  d-: DL, ' ?8 j% 81 {s
28 3 re% b8 E u< )7E z:1 j8D K T-U% e ' =~ ,_!
93

, $ F )*g
 B: k0 ), K d% ,f

B }: ' | T8, 8$
8(-e ' :eoE , N
X}>
D 5y8 =4 6 A  ,  , CE 
( d[
' 7, 1
 ), K , O. N;Q LD> (  A 7
V, re% V, ,b [( '*  , 3 ~ 64  : B* joE ,N6
-4 ' 8e A ~ E j8E6 ~  d q4[ ds ' ;F
 
 % 5y  b[1 5E6  ' NM :6 j4 =-DL C:PD
NM z:1 =:6 0<Q 4- pB*%  S Cq( , L
,~ * EB -M4% E i*  F ] i* ~ 8IB j4 re% ) ,-U
NM =* 'M j-B$ M hI: 167; , :, 4- 
eF d-DL O,U3  b-e ,rB
 ' V, ~ 6% _% j4 ,
CL b[1 =Fichte rt, tE Goethe r>8+
C-g> , L N0U
j4 'D ,7E C 89> ue , DEF 8I
~ :
~ E0,U h$,
9$ e j4 E4 CL b[1 N0U re% 81 ,z} q 7:

r$m R j% j )6_ B* 6,  ' $, )> ,E 4  =~ 8D
t % d[ 5E6 =66( 6, 

 % ( a0M CL b[1 N0U 9*
C ! i* % d B i* %- 'Z 4 =j r$* 1 
=CL {$> ' 6 A b-e 8y8
b  L,Be j% 'D 
% 6 5E6 ' a0M C3. b[1 5^ j% -}e ' e E [:
5E6e K 3 66( 6
5_8,e j% : 8
# ,? :, 3 {; i*
=66( ' -DL :,- '*

94

q  j N8B: =H1I+. ' M Y} A j B,:e e8*


% Le e8* |,
 ,g9U i* ,}> 3 *O 7$B> ,
n(- , LD _   F [1 i* -:e e8* ,  <
 \ O
,7, < j% A -:
,G <% 6:* G  Z j% q  b[\
r
-} O* -: ?
 =:$*  8I
 -
_ :> 3 ,7$*
?*0 b6,  /6* T6  d%-
~ 8_ ~ eO '! d[ }
-DL
5:,B j% r
6 re% 3 ,r%  g9U i* j8D j% 'D ' jg

W  ,d%- [1 joE ,r%  < T6 '* -: ?


re% 1 ,,
re% i* 
 ,?8U j  -D, >  8I
}_:$ 5w
= 6B* re% i* # , 6B*
j4 d[ 6B
# /8 )16* j% . '. e% z:1
N> j } B j%  g
3 reg
j-}   r$*
i* r )$* 3 } [1 j4 8 V, ,  < % j8: -DE
E6 59, 3 j4 ,-DL {$> 7$* u_ , # F
k0Q
~ ^ ~ *E 7:*
: q3!1 9,  s = 9 Cy*3 -M4% 6y 0
j% 8: j% 9 ' joE ,)$ U % i* )6B* # 6> -

rE j8D 
,rE 5Le 3 j8D N, 5y8 7y8
O
E - j%  , r; ' j8$ )oE :\ )\ j8D> K = 
j% {s 5 'D ' =~ eg, O~ D ~ wE *O r
B> d[ d%-
' jF ;7 i* N6 8 e i* *,  8I
d%- [1 E -
Y} }_:
1%6
6_ j4 , +. ' M Y}  B: j  %6 1
=66  LI  NF
95

,B: %6 K =>  8I


B: p
6 'D ' j8D j% :
)D i* P_ 1 ,*
# 6PB 
M
],
> , DEF joE
=B9: B: -1 ' -7 
% 87l _ 5(> jg
:_ B
d%- j% :yE 8 d% ,~ e( eDQ b[1 :y 8 'D
T8\ ' 8:4 r:8, r:D ,} B* U  n I
b[1 u$E ,+ $ 5w 3 + % A 6:,> 3 -DL4 ,  ,
u b[1 =BB. R j% _ }$ 7E X: ,  1
T8 u 8 : [1 i* } 7$R , BB. =BB. E-
=$<% BB '* ]> CO$D
E6I
{,> ,T-U% E-U
X:  T6 )D. B j% _F i* ue,>] -D: 3
T6(%  dgE ,{s YBZ e % soE = 123 8: i* O6*
A ~  r , 8F i* rD r$B* } /6, j% '
-% z:1 j4 s ?7<8I
q r j8D> j% d  ' j% ( 
[1 j% 64! ' joE ,)7L :>  T-UF 8F ' b k8L )7
K =rLe 81 b 7$* /8B> , # F } )7L j% 81 q
F ' 8y8 [1 j4 ,K 8y8 N8 -g
: '!
reoE ,  < r:* )1 DE% j8D> j% d  ' j% (  A jD

Cy*3 6y _F i* r:* E6 i* ' _ 8e8D j% )G 6


:N8B ' z:1 j8D O
'D =H1IP}
,jeQ   ~  7 8% b[1 =  % :6 C6B, {s NM 1
X: ,  < j8D> j% VU8, j% 6
3 \8 ~ DE% R K reoE {[
=_F i* P} Cy*3 6y 7:* E6 i* ~ _ j8D j% r$*
96

W )84 - j =)1 7$* /8B> , # F 8$, )7*"


=qX4 - )% : 3 q  b[1 N8 2:,
_ 8
,C-: L -+
{s j8$L 3  6:\ j8$, '[ ;F
N8Be j% h ' j8D  =1-4[> K1] )7E N0U ' Oe
 I; _ 8 W )F  6:\ YPB. # g
K$1( j8$ )
&=7w NR 1-D:
M 5y8  ?4 )$, ' 8: [1 ,rE {; 3 -% [1
NB j% 'D k0Q i* q d% z:1 # re% ,* i* ,Cy-
YPB. G ),> , 16   81 [1 =y- C-: 6y
=6 h<  hB> +. 5^ j% s , ' 7$* /8B  y-
D :
'D =Cy*3 i*  3 ,Cy* z:1 u
t e 3% i* BB. 6,> ,d%- ?0,U B 8y8
K
j 
O~ P z:1 9 /8$  V, =p F ' K,
w, K,*8
j N8B> C-: 
;7Le YPB $ T-U% CL> 8(8 eD
reg
k3 L> C-: 
 ;#} # 4- 1 F
6 /B j% ` ;K+4F `
#H1Ij8,(8$L N8L '
/B j% A =  I 1 j8D> j% 'D 3 T-UF -: j% i*
:7E 6_ j8De 3 :eoE ,r$* :1] L4 ?-e j% A ,{s i* 6
U6 d[  1 % Y
  6B , j4 =\ 8( 3  j8,(8$L 1
C 6_ =k3 6:* `\ D; i* c- k3 C$* 5^ 
1743 r28E3 e-L W 'D =* 'M j-B P%  -: b[1
=k3   F : 81 K+4F j% u% 1794
97

N8 ,e K 'D =L
7$Be , -: 7(8
Be , # F
  '6 k0UF M ,B 3 O
~ 6B> -M4F 5y8 A
'* E6 +. 
% 0 joE ,. j!; *O,(3 C_0
A  , -1 6:L> A -> C3m ' hg,> N6+$ M d%
,j; ) `9 =d%- {s '* h$, -U d% wL>
j4 re%  -4s ,6B 8I q9U K
eM >-  vg d[
r,w_ G 6 d[ D 7,(3
rIU + w_ 6 O~ P
j; r$L j4  =r,wB r,   ' -M4% V, 7 6 W j ,81
d% 6 ; d% _ ' b6$B> X: )4   +:$ $ 84
wB ' 81 re( 3 )$ 3 d[ j =BB. A I V, 8y8
d% 6B
j8D 3 O
 ,8_ r
 % j8D> O
=7:* MD )$ 3
p F 6 j% M
b 6B
'D W s 'D =7w6 j% ;
0E ,p F {$> 1  V, )$ 3 ,
B ?-9 7 6:, ,
h_8 joE |,
 =-U i* d% wL>  r$* 6:,  r6 6(8
j8D j% oE ,{[
B W s ,)D. Y$> 81 r :
B9:
N8B d% ,: ) L  L re% % 9$ g> uZ ~ -P
+ A 5, j% LD 3 =8B
r p[+: re% -} d[ h_8

' j8y-  7 vg )7,B-9


-
> , ,r$ ' /8I
t +. q9* A  1 b[1 u =16:L, +
7B y 
i* ~ _ j8D j% ` =r$B* 5 BB 
5y8  7y %
j8[ ,k6I
7:* j8E6 ,~0E G j8:! ;% ' 7*O
\D;% -M4%  +. b[1 i* 5$9 W s =7$  )187( _%
-: 7( i* K, , , 8B
-} 3 ,~ *:_ 8B
98

,7$* ,:> \ T6I,> 77(8> j% 81 b-e 7( d%   I


b[\ d6I, reg; ' d[ BB. ' q  {s ~ 6
% {$, ' reoE
Y9: KLBM
j8L<8 ' P
j8> > =7,2 
8I
_09
E6 i* ' B {% i* V, Y9: ,5y8 {s )7$*
j8D> j% 
B  'D 'D ,  < )7,+,e j8D> O
=)7P '*
~0B* )7Le% 8w W ) ={s #D* j- )% )   < 
N8_F 8 6 W ,)7:* L$, B-9
j-DL '[ {% jD 
V: dg
,j], 3 )oE |,
 ;/8I q3!1 \8B j% 'D ,
3 ) =)7Le% )1 r:* j8E6 d[ %6
K* ,$  '
j8$ 3 =T-UF q (F B
]> L> , q (F d% j8$
K
d-1 d-:  :  'D ' j% K> , C ,*3
p8( K8_ K K
,U3 q  Y9: K> , % ,KL_8
`$B d[ BB. ' q  {s j8$7 ) =-U i* 6% wL>
?- 3 ;rD 6I j% ~  :, B$ X: h4 -B j 
j d,
)187( )71,e  4 '[ {% 3 ~ B q  [1
 O7: D 6! p F - j% 8 ,wB e( i* Z
5y8$ BB )7E dF d  we3 [1 =q8yF T8_% l
/8IU d% z:1 'D W s re% r>  ' $ ,eeQ _0UF
, +. T8_g
)1 e )18( ,e j% 6
0E 7 BB dF
=G vg j% /* 6 -7F 'D
,C ,*3 b[1 8_ ' '87,$ r: ~  ,-. B: 6* 'D
j% *  8I
 q:
F d  ' # :  N8B j% 'D
99

_ ' \ ~ 6:L> % )7P '* ~ *E NB j% 'D  4 87L 8$
d jeQ j8D jF ( z:1 u ='6 N(  L 0L
=1 % 4s )IU T6 C9X % q9UF 5^ -> i* ~ _
), re% 
,7$* - i* _  ; O~ P z:1 j8D j% LD
:
wEF ' =K$,  : $w> reg; ' q d% E
 y8 # F 8  6_ 8e8D j% 6
,9 N8B p <F
) =_ i* 9$ 8:g j% ,18$> , YPB $ @6
'D 
8< % . 20 18 3 E-
j8,, 3 )% j84 6
5^ j $PB -DL ' jF
-} j% )Do
 , 
{% _ ' 7$* 
(Q 'D % u 6_ C% , C
8I
=7 b[1 i* ~ IIU 8
6> '[
'D  -M4% \ )*2g  ,8y8 A -: b[G ~36( -_g
)7E 6B
87 V7,:
j8$B '[ {% 7.I )*  j%
D 6B [1 )  =H1IG :,_3 `I j% X: d[ BB.
D; dg
-g,> 3 -. B: A *6 +. joE ,r
-_Q )> d[
j8D j% $ X: reg
-B UF %6 [1 V, reF =ND;F '
;Cy*3 5^ i* y- B-9
- )> reg
B B* jOy \
~ 6B )7L reoE : BB
B ' j N8B j%  6IB ,T-U%  
1
)%  =)7L ' K 6B [1 87
j8$B e% z:1 =7: ~ :
8_ BB. b[1 nI j8*  )oE ,87 V7,:
K 6B [1 j8$B
' 6_ _g
~36( B  joE {s 5 =\ , j8D> 3 O
4
=)7,+ nI +. b[1 p <% r*6 8B
100

,-U `e( ' ?8(8  A -7> W s 7$* - 'D h4 'D
<-E z:1 'D> W s ~ y- - 6% j4 j ?-e j% : 'D h4
0 `(8 ' 'D W s ?~ y- # re% CQ Ky$
qO$* L 0L i* ` _F iE ,Cy*3 b[1 i* 87
-M4%  G )$* i* 8e8D j% C
8I  )7$* K, '[ '6
-
C
8I C-4s s 3 a6R j% [\ 'D 3 ;8_ 1 8<
6(8 =7E 7y 'D ,  : q8yF wE% uZ uy
$D} b[1 5 ,  < 7,B- D8D :D T6
' 7P B$,
)\ n ' K
~ > ~0IE IL> 7E =(- 
V9> 3 =BM i* G 8$B j% )\ 6
3 '[ K
 ,G :,_3 N0U
'D ' % ,'6 N( 'D ,r$B,  N8  O7: *8 %
,)7+}> ), V, 
,)\ n ,> B 5y8 j8D j% )7:
|,
 ;7$* -   {s ,/8I + i* 03
88B
j89, 0E j8 : % =_e  `,4 q-B
)\ n reoE
[1 z 6 =r$* N8I. `I js 81 ,U js j {[
/B
6 r:D ,/8I + i* K$9 8e8D j% K$ 6L  j% /:
~ 
i* B [1 ' , E- De K
 BB. b[1 K
5+$ 0
r
n  k8L $B EBM ' ~ 6_ : 9 |,
 ,W B

N0U ' =$B -. ' 6 


)\ n 3 j4 j ,K :$
r $,> d[ B k8L, i* N8I.  /: n+: $ 8 b[1
~ B* _ 5:I> W - j6
EBM j% n < =ry-%
3 ,~ ] ~ 4 0
~ , #  8 [1 'D =: wB ~ 4s * 5:I> j% 1 6B
j%
i* ,j8:! ue,>] jF ,,e,>] 7E 8> , j6$ 
101

! rL:
R j% 6
3 ; 4 j% ,-: : ' _F
joE ,{s A EyQ
=K$$ 7$Z 'D 3 ,K '  
1%-B , `,D qB
 W$ |. 5y8 l  ~ $*  , '
8$ ?- j% e % s =K 6  K*% '* ~ 6
j8 6

,4  - z:1 j8D> j% 6
0E ,r,E- )7$* X:  4 eeQ
=8_ j q 4 e
*O 7$B> , q  j8D> K re%  ' 6_
 j% - 81 -. B: p i* `> TsF j4 s ,  <
~ S # r:D ~ $B* ~ S [1 6 O
-E ,q  b[1 p g
K$1( :
_0UF 8B i* 1-%  ' q  _ i* -! 3 [1 =~ _0U%
# j8: :  B: p j% 1 BB. 'D =}$
j8: M4 j%  Oe ,K d% 7$* /8B , # F BE
% % , DEF M,> d%- '* ]>
, CO$D 8> 3 =b: {[4
7:* ]> CO$D {$> ue4 , DEF ' ~ X< ~ q ( 3 M,> 3
:%  3 , -DL d8_ /87L :6 j8D j% ' ~36
 =<F 
V: ' q ( d% B
s =`$_ -7l '* : 7LR $$_ C * 3
=8( r 8 0E  -18 % , L B i* 6  ' reoE
j% 'D 3 IE 81 ,  >  O~ * ~0IE D}> BB. b[1
=:$E O7 g, 6 ' rB rE8e
C6B, _0UF f 5^ 
-  BB. b[1 nw,>
,G ( '[$ :
8. V:
$ ~ ^ 7E =~ -B> :6
:7$ 67 6B, % %6 j4 O$4 ='S )7*>F :

102

8B
8}  j-, r
 <% joE ,T-UF C6B, i* k8L,
-M4% O
 ,6  G j-} 8e4 , 8B ' rLe 6B
b:
h_8, % ,*O d% 81 nI 8 j%  7:  ={s ' V,
A ,: 3 r:D s8Le ' r$* s8 ,  O
L,R . b[1  ,r6B>
5( , y K,+,: K>1 ' +,e d% nI> K ={s ' 6
%
6_ %6 j8D {[
 = 6,
N6 d% L, %6 N8 N6
CE0,U % hP89 ' 684 % *O ' N8B d%-4 reD ,
'* b8  ~ <;% )7  j r*>% j8D ,G ? q 
~ M4 j8,@ 3 ,: p % N0U ' )G )7*:,_3 # )7E0 %
,-U `1[ k:,* )71[ '* 0e3
; d% /8B j% -DL

E6$  ,O~ P KB, 8e4 6  =a6Z  ~ e C3. b[1 jF
j 8(-> )7:D ;)7e( A W O, 3 % W 6y )7Le% '*
+ $ {s )1 6B
j4 j j8, 3 )7$ $  A
z:1 j4 j 7:* '6>-  j8B$B 3 ,)6B w1:
 [Ug %6  > ' $- b[1  =7$  +
j6>-
6PB 5^ ' K$ '* 5e  ~  =. r>8_ j6BL

j1s%  BB.
. *8 qB
  j8e , 
8I j8
6:
,)G8$_  # N8B -1l  3 G j8,@ 3 BB 1 ,K:!
D,} 3 =)748$ i* BB -9 `,D> )6( $,> j% j
=18( '* 5E6> N >  6B j8D> K 
8I b[1 M ' 6%
)$ r$(% ' >B O
#R K$>B hy% V, )$ $- {$> 
6B* % 8( ' $- {$>  =T-UF f '* rE0,U T6
  F 7P 8B '[ : ' 4 6* z:1 j8D j% 'D
103

33 5^ ' f b[1 8  8e2 '[ ,-DL ND;% 5^ 
r+,: j%
L d[ /, g,
)I;  8% '[ ,\
6B nI> K 'D =~  6B b[1 u
> , N8B  jOQ
8 3 K d% ,
  8I
# $  8I
: 7$B , 
wB 8I
8. b8_   A Y
  j4 O4 ~ *8E6 B
6B, 4 j: 6 ,  z:1 j8D ,r$* jOQ 7-9 ,
,$U >  8I
r
N8B % ,r:* ]> , C$D} q:M, 

( % ' r


)$  -g4 r>6B* [Ug K rLe q- -R Oeg4
N0U ' 1 ,U % ,r$B*  ~ BB ~ -% 6B b[1  ( A b8*6>
.
$< 7E 6(8> D> 3 $- A I> j% A ;I} 
-+,
D> % /8 -M4 ' $
,C3 z:1 j ) =}$ e6(8
-+ , _ M ,B c U g4 6B > ,$F D}>
b[1 =r,4 > jeQ U rE j8D j% 'D -U -% d% ' B Z
t > B
sL:
 66( -DE dF O /6* N0U ' 8_ -7
dg
`$B % B 6L> 3 B d% s 6
7:D ,B U A
=K E O7B, <-
j8D> j% q8 q
j% 'D #L:   Y*% a6Q s 6
$1! f
% N  BB ~ 6
% nI> j% j ,, C6B,4 B  >
 {s a6R j% rE 'D d[ T6 i* ~3M 6+e =)7L % -*}
[1   
:*% =  f
j8:! 7E {, , LD
/DF d% ,  81 re% hP89 #P:D 5^ b],>  /B
 6B ],> b[1 =66 67 7$* ,} , 18: 
104

3 {s 5 =T Ie ) j88B '[ 5^ _ ' Ke8B4 8B
% } r48$  6;   h% 4 K
' ~   6+e
~0E r48$ r
#B d[  j =7  ;Q
z8$ [1 ' ,
' ,r6 joE |,
=r,:4 qw*% % r,B % r: 1% C* 81
t % % 6B, , _0UF  /DF ' *8 ,`e(
r u9*

`e( ' r6 ,G rLe )D  6*8B4 /8I )D 6I


_ '
5  6 A YL,> , ,8 C O /DF ' *8 -U
,T-U% /D% 5 M4 j%  h$, , /DF b[1 

8> 7$  1 ,/DF b[1 


5 S  8I
,>
r$+> 9 re =e6 . CO,1 nI   6B K

*8+$ BB. bq3 9 , b[1 ' AF *8+$


;K8$ K4 q-BL )1 K4  j% K  5^ '! =eM
t )   $ j% 7 F ' j%
 :X U6 j% _ H1I

H3I
H2I
`R j% ; ~ 6
% 8L$R 3% ; 8e6 0 8:6 3% ;qO C8D$
;H5I{[4 bq r z$E r
8 [Ug j%  % ' j% ;H4IrL: r r-_

:1 } 81 =66 67  Cq( , PwL A C ; q9*o
 %6
-
 `B   U6 j% 7 F re===" :24 19 V, +e  q(  A
=& C8D$ :X U6 j% '
=&8e6> 0 8:6> 3" :17 V, +e A :1  ;Q
&==~ 6
% 8L$Z 3 ===" :345 V, +e
&==={L:4 {-_ `Z j%===" :3112 #_- +e
~
=&w% zq r z->E ,{
8 [Ug {,4m  % '" :405 V, +e
105

1
2
3
4
5

C8D$  % s )e% ;H1IrL:


),@ 6X joE 6X -g
8,@ 3%
' 8 ) =H2I_6< 89 j8D$  8 j% )7$* X:E
~ E G j8:! ) =q;F b[G j8:! ) j88B K KBE:
i* 0
8m 8% % O~ P j8 , 8F
: r
'! d[ 8 :
. jOQ 81 jOQ j4 s 'D =Be 5y8 1 ~ 6
% 18 W
,* d[ 6. i* ,B f b[G )O joE 
YB , d[
' j*8e \ ,~0IL> $^ [U!> K ,f j =-M4% 3 r
 i*
6:* 76B> % ,/8I i* 7E[_  :E- C6, 3
s 'D =8m 8% % : 6B, , 8 p g4 jDQ
3 , 8F ' r  3 ~ 6* `$9,>  /DF jg
)-4s
81 r$* IZ  4 joE ,G   DL, - V, )\
i* -9
' wE% )% j8*6 '[ K1-D ;F E  5y8, {e%
\ j9$ 3 ,K K:! i* f$ -9 3 ='-U :
'D ,f b[1 C8< / A   j8:!  =)\8B* i*
B -9w 8 e i* ,7e A CO$D ' 6, o
j-} 3
Y$, K =6*8B YE O~ ,: '! z8$  ( A G,  A
`1[ T6 d% A r N8B zs % [1 A -: '! joE z8$
-F
=n *  
j4 PF K  h_8 j% ' KB i* j8De j% 59,e
u 8>  j r$* 81 d[ 8 : i* j4 re% 8 ={s '* ~  ~ L$,
=&rLe -g
),@ 6X joE ,6X -g
8, 3" :346 V, +e 1
&===_6< 89*% j8D$  8
" :3312 _8 +e 2
106

 8] e A K1-D K] '  8X LP ' _  


q3!1 `R h4 -e" :)7:* j88B )16*% j4 6:* =e-
 je d% '* 6I re% 'e 3 N8_ 81 &~ w
)7w
j8 
T8_% 8 e i* )6B* V:
j8R ~ :B 8e4 )oE . u_8
` 81 [1  =K. {s [: -U u_ d%  8$E  MD

3 ,7_9e 5 8>  -4[ /6B> d% j YBZ 3   j%  #P-


=) s K
 F i* 7   8IB ~ e-_ 18 - 6
V, N >
rE N 1 3 /> 6+
j-: '[ '6
KD, ;F 5 V,
,*  8I
: L  -M4% _< :
G j8:! )7P 8 e
t ' vg )\8B*  ~ e }: :6 : [1 joE
% #48e % 'L4
:4 #$ n N8_% j =)I; A ~  ~ -_ j8D je '
CO$4 A CIeQ -+
a6R  2+, -% d% ,:> 3 ,)\8B* 
 ` L> M4 ~
 % z:1 j% {; 3 =Y$B `> 3 *e $^
8 e i* 7,8 ' MD
L,Z : LP9 ~  ],> , f j%
 ` ,E- hP89 5^ K
4} f r
L,Z  k8L
t K$ j%
' 'D , f ' AF L V: qB
  j 6
LP9
~ <U j8D d[ %6 j% 81 {s q  p F 6% j% 64!
f ' -M4% r:* E6 K, reg}
N,$ y-* -M4% j8D 7:

j6  6* z:1 j8D 3 K =KE8}D /8I 6y T-UF


=)8L( q j8: K$, K$ joE r: 3 `
# ,6$B, f 5^ i* *  8I
rLe q Y9:
8g
, , f i* {[4 Oe ,7: :6 _0UF BE
107

C0
$ p CX$ 5^ =. j8; > E- EI.
7$ C0 1 ,1 e h4 7, d% ,. N8 
8% % i* 8$B ,7$* j8BL, 5 7 1 -D ,5
K 3 BB. 1: : ) )$ 3 C0 7:D ,@6

=)7 :
_ BB ! ]U   1 ] 7$
,_8,  % U % I '  ~ I; j% `X  a6R
j4 ,r> $ 7E- j4 , P} )D. % NMF 6% -4[,E
L O4 rLe  -_  1: z 6 j4 re% 8 I ' b[B:> j% 'D
M4 YPB z:7E :B: p  {[ p % 64g,
z:1 =j
3 ~ BB ~  B 7R j% V:
/, 1: z  'D 3
b[\ :
V, 'D =~ E8g ~ -% I} 
-+, 7$ j% 6

81 V: N8 N6 O i* ,* } [1 j% 8 ,YPB.


i* I  j4 reoE ,~0E re87L e% _ ' ~ $  ~
 _ :
Y*% ~ -% rLe  z r7E
 j4 ,V: [\ MD
Y*% )7E
-%  DL, '* )7L_8>  M, , :
T6 >B    =MD

(% 6_ =)7P9U% hIe  ` 81 ,{; 5y8 8 3 K 


=&:B d%-$ Y /8:" reg
h< K  `>4
E-$ d  S ^Q p 1 :q- Nq, O
'D
BB. z 6 eeQ ' q ( d% j4 s re% n I ' 1 ?B.
84 '* -DL h_8,> 1 ?N0y  _ q  VB j% 6
0E
j% w_ F 'D 3% ?*O ' 8B nI> j% -+
 BB
N0l 
G Z u$l s 3 ~  8}  $U 87L j8D>
108

BB. b[1 N > 7E ,: BB


j8^% : ' s ?{}
+,e wE% ?61 V % j% O~ P j8: : j4 ?)7E8(  {$
5+
-_Q  ' 6 ,  8I
 68> 1 89, q4[$
1 ?YB ,  rE61 l  BE q4[ [1 /6 7E ;7 YPB.
?:$ D /O, `
: O {$
-, 
  , /6B> 5 =B [1 ' -g
_% 3 e%
'D ' j8D D ;{D}, %  :$ -,> 8> 3 f 6*
$- A u$< , YPB. % 6
$ 9 . _
81 T-U% 6
w_ N8 d8B N6 q7,e j =g}
?0,U3 /6*
B [1 ' d[ D, =d%- )*6> D> ' d  `e(
=6 L q    /  -9U re% O$M   I q    6L
d  d%- ?0,U    6, 5( [1 j% ) 'D
3 re% 3 ,~  /23 re% , -% re% V:
,6 u_  K:

: BB L> A (. j =6L r_8* 5^ j% {s '* ,:
4[ p, 3   )7 j8* 1 )16y 7:* E6$ % 78I
: z  /% ~ BP* j8D, j8 [1  U j ;BB. b[\ .
~ 6 ]D ' $> 3 j8 [1  U j% n < =H1IBB $ K^%
3 ~ * {s 5 > 7:D ,BB.
/ ?*3 5E: ' ]4% 7$
b[1 ' L, 3 jDQ
7E 8 3 , C3.  =r
j7,
,7:* 6
)6B> j8R )1  $ T % j% % :eoE , 
8 O4 K #Le%   g C
8<  % )6B> V:

=/8IU \ 8 3 ,BB. b[1 j8^% : z 6 6:* 1


109

k:,* i* )7w  r    N[ ; A j8, 8e4 )%


=w h_8
P 8 j8$ y% ,{[
/B$  '*  ' ~36
'D
d[ ,H1I-B |6 7: j =Y
  )@6 ue4 , $,
d[ 8: ' $  j4 ,j80E% C m  P  8I
: T6>
 P$ $ Be '*  * ~  % 7: [1 j4 =r
nIe%
-U ; :_Q BPE  7
K ; 1-6 ,. L$L 
'D W |,
 ,*O T6 5P} d%-$  8F
3 r )$* 3
6m V: d% q9*o
6
)B W n I r7( i* 8y8 )7L
' joE r$7 ~ 4 6 [$, nI K E |,
 ;G d: , f$
i* ) P_ ,-B, )7E i* N8I. A !  i* ry 'D
{$> 7$* /8B> , #  {[4 f V: ny p, 
A V> V9 8 8I C(   - C;B: ue4 =f
r% `9 )7L j% jOy 81 7: 6IB j4 = ~ *8e  ?61
d%- # % 6 r% # % 2  j% r _: d%- 
=`:( A ~ :(  Kw_:, K%- )7E j4 N. 9
 =_:
j% 1 ,7: qL; 3 $* ' > 64g,
ue4 C;B: b[1
9$
5,, 6I ' s8Ug ue4 7$* 6:,> ue4 , C6B
we3  ' 6
% `-_ ' r}> 'D> W =B ' #

=w + )6B> ) +. N0U '  d% 1


110

=H1I"Socratici viri" N8B* D; d[ d8B |6 7:


B$ d8B

i* 81  ~ M4 k8L 6B


~  K+7: A '6 6. B 'D
 8< g
,}> 3 . $, 1: j% O4 ,r
-_ 6, 
' r$* 4 VB$, d[ } =O7$m R 7: i* 8I '
5 8}.
-, q-Q /B j4 j V, ,`,D % K$
1 +,: j8D> ,KE-9 d% O / Q
-} 3 ,rE8(  `,D$
} ?- j% ,'-DL K
V, ,~  p-X, ' j8D re%
'* ~ *E ; d% r8B OE q ( hy% j% O4 ;KE-9 -e 7(
 [1  5P} ' =r8I r6B b 6*% d[ p8 81 r%
Be 2-
  6L d[ Y9: d% ,$ Y9: jg; ' '87,
=
Q YPB. C j , O  q9UF % -:  hw
P +,e j8D j% 64g,
reg; ' B [1 ' d[ $ 6B:
~  b ,*
'D ,Ly
-6( -DE % 
 E- % i* N8I $ 0
+7: ` 6, : VB$, j% A ;V* _ r joE ,) 3 
,/ '-DL ' 4 6* z:1 /8D '$E 66( ' $ 6B: i*
,a
F E- -E 5^  ,-DL ' j6, T8, z:1 j8D 
joE ,-U 8y8 dF :
% =9 /8$ Cy- q:M, 

r9_ d[ 8} 6B


3 &E-" V> j% Y ,> 3 } q
9}e +
/B  r: 
8$9 j8D, ue4 , $B $ 
A j; P    Cq( =&-B p <%" 1: :>3  * 1
:-e =8D>%
See Cicero, Letters to Atticus (Latin and English), trans. E.O.
Winstedt, 3 vol. (London: Heinemann; New York: Macmillan,
1912), Vol. III, P. 230 (xiv. 90).

111

'-U j% % r: >s  


8} [1 59_ q8 ,/8I 5
7   ( z:1 joE  z:1 j8D> 3 K =r$* b8y-E
,h 6B ,E ;*:9<  8I
1 `I ' j8D 
<-L b[1 ' rLe } /-R K ,h ' %8 % 81  

N8B d%  j8*2: e% z:1 j4 s =7Le qB$> ' r Cq( s
Xw % j8eB )7: W s r,*2: 6,  i* % ,*O+$
,)7 5,e D :8B* n,Le j% ,{s i* )1-D}e e8* ,*O,(3
q3!1 38 :$* K, d[ -F
:* /8B ' z:1 jg
-Le j%
i* :
6 d[ -F
% =67( 67+
 ,:Leg
r
/8Be j% :
=7,8 % :>6B, KB  / d% :6 j4 j r
/8Be j% /8
q  8:> j% K -U d8_ ` z:1 /6B>  A EyQ
'D
/6B,> j% A ~  <  ` 81 , L: r j8D> j% 'D
= F '* qO 6
r:* 6
j 1 d-DE T8, A eeQ
*O r$B> d[ d%- j8D j% :BE K,eD  j V, e-e
r$B> d[ d%- j8D j% ;n I 81 -U d% j8D |,
 ,~ 6 E
i* N8I $  % #4 d%- 5 r
w> 'D ,~  < *O
K>1 ' ~ *8; -M4%  z:1 'D =BB.
Y* 8; ny )7E
~36
,O7:
BB. jO,B '[$ K
w, '%6  81 ,K,.
d% A ( z:1 j8D> ,~ 6 E -U ~  < 6% j8D j% '
q ( i* 3 *O d% ,} 3 , ,BB. B
e6 , $_F
joE  y8 -+, YPB. ?0
1 , 8F
Y$, OE =7:
4 j8D>  ~ 6
% % ~ e 7:D   < `X  j8D> P} q 
112

j8D ~ e% ,~ 4 q  [1 j8D ~ e% :BB. ' q (  =BB.
j% X: T-U% YPB '  ,:
,b8} ,rE   q ( r:D ,~ X<

$_F q joE ,-U `e( ' =\ 6. 5w> q  b[1 `I>
, ,1+, % 5B$ uy-> , q  ' ~ w
~ 8* j8D>
5 .I A  V> ,e >-  7B> ue4 , 8B u9
1 7Le ,* 64 r,7(8 A % ,*O d%  8(8 BB.
jF ,~ -D> -M4F . 1 ue4 UF . =$D BB.
,Le3 j4 ,d B 7$*  , 6*B 81 O~ P j4  ,
`X> d%- 8%  V, re% 6+e |,
=q:M, 3 81 YEF  
=-U q ( #; rE > d[ u_8    BB. ' q ( #;
t   reoE ,BB A BB hw re% L d[ ,/6B, V,
R

vg Oe {s '* ,: 'Z d% ,T-U% m $4  P ( BB BE
wE% b ' -M4% ~
8$9 BB. ' 66 -9} j84 ' ~  %
6P d%- j8D K V, =r$m  d[ q  '  C(.
d% d% ,* ` re% (  A ~ P ( j8D reoE , F
~  <
re% i* -U d%- 16, , BB. ' q ( i* ,} 
' rIe  U6 d[ $ g9 6B '* -: ?
,)_ d%
j8y-L '[ jF 66} q, 3
B9: je d% -} ' =BB.
)7Le% )1 j2+, ,)138 7:* 2+,: :4 YPB A b,e3 :$*
6B, B9: } j% 81 a6R d[ =1-e , YPB. 
'*
 # wEF ' joE ,?-9   , P} BB. ue4  re%
j  , j8E6 {[4 P}  BB $ j8D j% r h !
,  : -M4%   )1 ?-9 '  , q3!1 jF ,?-9
113

j8*  d[ D. -9; A KwE- e% uL  )1 ' 6(%
=$D D. 81 re%
: ) =* 'M j-B  8F ue4 h4 -::
p+*Q   8e4 )18> '[ K$,  : 5^ K$,
pF )$  M6. C2+eQ 5P-
 , w. V O

M6. 8I 1% K


CE0,U3  4 6 A 8X
6_ =L$L
b[1 jg
4 2 ,*
j-} 8e4 )% (  A 6B 8I 1%
1 6I
)1 8; 6B ,E =)7.I ue4 CE0,U3
H1I
8  Cw_:> )7:
C-+Le K `-> 5y8 1],e 6<
,?-9  , d%- ' LMD $,D 8  q u9 =
:B4
6  Ey 5 wE% D;  7Le D}> * A b:* C-9y
*O ' 8B q  j% 81 {s  ` 'D W =Ce8D '
81 #D 
;8  q ' BB. '* 7$  6
% * LI

' 6_ i* ,}> ,BB. A 8  q ' p-_% ue4 s ,n I


,; {s 5 =MD
7: _% g9 ' 6_ i* ,7: ]4% BB.
 w
ue4 , BB. ' r
j7, 3 6_ i* 8  %6
C   d%- > i* YPB. b[1 uL ) ;*O d%  8(8
8  67* [: =jE89 q7,e 6
uB
, CL$ j 1 ,r
,9  $  B M ,G d: j4 , DEF joE
1750 /*  =e-E d8 ?8$E ,17781712 8  z( j( 1
r:D r,9
` jeQ j rE N_ ,O 3 $> 8 T_9 j8:
~
,4 e
M=y. #23 r,4 -7;% ' =5,+  w. L
L$ ->
=1762 G 1762
114

t  -F
W ,5:9I 5,+  kL: 8L 8B$ 6L 6B
, 1  \ j8D, '  5 ;KLBM : N8B* '* ~ 6
% p-X>
d% M G : A . u_8  8*6> (. j% ) ,7B ,>
8y8 [1  CO$D jF ,NEF
164g> ), j% , u_
=8_ ? :,  i* uE ;
5y8 j%    E- @6 YPB. ' =-U NM [1
-B, 3 % /:$ p  z:1 j8D j% `$9,    $ )$
i* $B r,w_ ' 6% 5 8 j% A ,0<Q % /6B,$ p 
 )$ j% ,rLe 6B
/6B, /:$ ~
 nI jF LD 8 e
DL,  K,B-9 K>1 ' B- 4 =r- X:  rL X:
5,,> 4 6 A > 7:D ,T-UF B-9 p8* ' 7Le 6,>
~ M [U % =T-UF -DL y  `
D. B

Be 0
-B6 K
:$ .  O~ P 167}e , w, p w,
K
 ,#E:, j, K
 , D$ K
 ,-B, F
-. K
 ,-L * : *O,(3 * : K
 ,hL, [
q  '* , -
, ), W s ={s A  ,we3
7:* E6 \ 8*6 ),> W s ,CP:M b[1 ' ?- D [ 
4 IR jF <-E z:1 j8D> '$E ,8B 18 ' rLe 6B

j  L4 n(-> j% 64! ' j8D  ;rB i* w, - ' ?-
Cs . P  =-U ?-9$ T-UF LD  ?- nI
O,( 8, ' ~ *8e 4 6 A BB. ],> ,V F
5,,> , 1 BE : ' $_ j% (  A n < [1 ,6yF
115

 8I
6,
/B$ )7$1! 8 e i*   ,    N8B

' _; $* N0U ' ), 6, joE |,


 ,6
' 8   <
g g
Y$, OE = C uZ j8$>B, K
 , K

j4 s ,  [U% 5y8 N >  , -4s ,  P '
5+},  ' -U d%- i* $wE% Ky , K%- ' dF
d[ d%- 81 d%- [1 joE ,b8( NO, - # 6g,
d[ 81 d%- [1 = jD *  $_F d% j8D j% ?I>
y-  1E- `e( ,$7
nI . u_8  M
e9-
 6(8 3 j% z 6 e% =7,I ' _% 81  i* N8I. -9
1-4s% Oe =5y8 b[1 ) N8 q  ?0,U 6y `I> j
re N8B> , $} BB. i* 7E N6( 3 6, $M% 1 ,*
:1
?-% 5^ !ED, 68 <-L joE ,d B$ PB . 
t W j8D K V, =q  8:> N0U ' 1 BB.
~ -B> ~ 
T6 j8D j% 'D ' joE ,{s  Y i* j4 6 8y8 i*
Y , h_8 )7: 6% z:1 j4 j r j8L$, '[ :
s 7: ~ q ( BB. ,  ,)@% '* ~ *E re88B K r O, 3
=)7,I
8L,
T6 8B f 
'D" :r8B
 ' z:1 j8D 6_
-M4% 1 ,7% 5y8 i*g
_0* \ , f ~ <8IU ,*O
1   k0UF ],> NM  i* =YPB ?Ie% 84 '
'* h$, ~ _0U% 6
; d% ,8y8 [1 N8 , BB.
&=~  ~ 9 j8D   k0UF
116

# {[ ,~ ^ P )1% $ : ' g b[1 ],>
Y9:  N8Be j% _ 'D = 6*B ,U3 7: wE% 81  z:1
:> s -Be j% 6L ' j8D ,  k0UF i* Y9: 3 %
-;g :eoE ,66 67 k0U% :> ue4 s =  k0UF
'   k0UF ?- ; d% 6B
j4 j p-X, 3

% i* ~ :y %  7:* a6Z re% L j% p,D [1 N0U


8(8 ue4 C_0U% A O~ P +eQ } =k0UF ' 4 %6
{$> n I> 7E ` , P i* r>;   ,B ,~ B
joE {[4 =5E % ` % C_0U% 7$m Z j% % B C_0UF
i* 'D 3 `X  ,~  *  8I
 84[ C; Q {$>
-B,L> ,0
X< ~ -; ~ PR ~ 
 \ jF ,~ E- 1L> n( F
' *8 0,  ~ 6
% 'D ' 'D W =C, _ A
' d% ,)6B 67 ' \OD,  j p,D [1 ' _0UF f
 P6
`e8 ' M4  r:D , 89, ' E4 $- $
/e
joE {[4 = ,  P6
`; A BE ~ 7(8 j4 , ,
L>  d87 7: ' 8: [\ n 6* 81 ,#8
#6B
B C_0U% L ,C-X ' r
 6  b6 r
q( d[ %6
r PIe ue4 ;j- je8 C_0U% 1 ,L$, 'D
, ( 6 A V, ,k0UF {$,
B ~ e 4 6 A K $
j4 j   k0UF r$* Y$ 9  j =k-
B re% 7E 6
n * ' 'D W :6 k0UF > r$* Y$9e j% wEF '
 6,
u g> 6BE =~ M4 -Ug, :2 <% ' 1 
,K 8. %
1% j% )  ,AF  j-B N0U D8D :D _ '
117

N8B % i* PB$>  8I
G j8$B 3 ue,>] 6. 
7$* 18$U% , C06, j% 3 ,7: -F < IL
8L,4 -F `  )% 5_8 =5_8,e j% 'D  MD
_% ue4
7$m 8$% V9 8 8I  7 uLy% , q (F NI, 

uy , LP9 N8 9 ~ BE 1 ,U )> 66( CEy
k0UF b[\ )* ' 6
:6 eeQ j% -D: ' -U e% =CEyQ
M4    , I_e  N8B  ->% 3 ::D ;PF 7$ A
' MD
%8 % 5y  j8D, eeQ j!} j% ,7 `e8 '
k0UF b[1 c U ' -*} ~ DE% z:1 j% 38 |. 7y
k0UF
V  j =
 F I} . D},
u
6 A 7E ;E  84 i* N6> , C0 5^ Z  
=:8 6y c+, 4
V ,~0*E # U ;~ 
 # $ V F 7E61 j
#  p:,( 8 e ,_0UF 8 8 e # q] 8 e
, C-  6* j Y
7L<  _ 6_ = 8 e d8B 
5, ' 7*  =G -g> , C.I i* 6. k8E 6  7:* V7:>
nI {s 6
rLL u d[ ,8 ):I4 61  u$( .
81 : ' ?8 :
F nI K =6*8B >3 ):< -
5_8  5B> k0UF b[1 joE ,$yL  $ ` :  - 5E6
+, 7    L> ,j86_F r
q(  wE% ' MD
Ve%
4 8; K
IL N0U ' ,7  %  ee% eeQ k0UF
j8D  6B
3 , :
' r>8U nI K
 `(8
je
118

~ I; r$* 8 d[ ` '* ~ e *O -E% nI


/O,13
8*6> ,$ *9 i* /8B %6 7  %  k0UF b[1 j =5L:

7,* N0U ' # 'D ;PB 8D. C9$ 5^ * A
b[1 B /6* N0U ' Oe ,'6 r-R -g
-g> K 9}e  8I

' 6B d% OE ,7$*  8M -, '* {1e ,C9$


,R :8 )F wE% k0U%  re% K  =)7$* 8 d[ 
i* T6, r+ 5 V, ` :, 3 ~ * ~ B 6 8 e `(8
) q  [\ -4s V, % -_ z:1 # re% 3 ,-L$  -.
67 # ,j-B j =H1IE   k0UF  `(8

 6 81 `I:  ; d% K*
' j N8B d[ 81 ,66
j4 s =H2I6 Y  Y  ) reoE r: n$<% 81 ' K$
reoE M6. k0UF  *O 8 e / ,3 -DL $_ z  z:1
O$M ~  ,  I ' # ,e  ee8 I ' s8Ug
/-D 7}
_0* r  4 j% < . C_0U%  6+e :e%

Q # # ,6 =DG -L>   k0UF j% 1  -DE 1
=6 8 e r>s ' q- G /8B ,
i*  [e j% 'D ' =j-B  8(8  /0D [1 N. 9
2
W * 5 , j-B hI,:  /0 Q '* p-X ?  jF 61} [1
6 A }>  1 % ,   j% ny8 ' =/8 r$* 1 O4 'D>
 * '
 6 ' r  <  )4. T =K, i* q(
~ ( ,  '" :  N8 N_ :N_ O7:*

I {$>  
I* ' 0
eM - =" K:! jU r8 jU  jU 6BE ,r: % 81 '
81 ' 6 81 0( A8E , ; K$ -% ' | '" :N_ : j%
=)4. b &=r8   jU 6BE r: K$$ n$<%
119

1DL
Q V, I} -D k0UF 8  *+}
 ,:6 q  # ,? eQ q  ' s8Ug 81 Oe ,-
1 rE *9 j8D> _0U% /e l  g}: j% r j4  ,:$>
=~  G ? 68 B
j% De '* ,-U je d% jg; {s  g; ,j84%  6
% :e
De % ,  k0UF ND;% 
' 7,2 'D p8 b[1
3 , `9 ' /> _0U% %6 q}eQ 20 `9 ' ~ M4 j%
=k0UF b[1 K
 7:
YE8, 'D   k0UF 7$* ,}>
f 8 e B [1 ' h_8 s '* {s ' -M4% V, 6
% :e 

~  ue4 n N8_% j% ny8 ' j% T % :e =rLe n )>
r$9,> q d% K
 7:
YE8, 'D ' j% ;j8D> j% \ 6 % O4
'y ry 'D k0UF  2, 81  4 j% ;$} k0UF
_ ' r uy->  k8L 8 e i* 7E0> j N8_F b[1 k9e
=j4 8e d% ' z8$$ * /e d% 7: 89:, j% 8 '[
i* 3 ,}> 3 n N8_% j% -DE 5 ~  YL, b:$_  'D
j% ;{s ' -M4% i* ,}> j% 7: 6IB
 'D W ,BB. ' q (
N8_%  7 k-9, ), W  k0UF    F : ' ~ M4
: b[1 j% ,7 k-9,
e z:1 'D> W %   # !
b[1  % i*   :D r,_% d[ k0UF /e  ~  C[te
 i* Q  ~ E g~ 9U `D>-e :e% 6B,*% {[ =N8_F
 % , 6*B d% ,67$ , 6*B i*   %6  8M$
  7:D : i* 7y-L %6 [1 7$* ,} j% 7<
120

N8 ,> Bw -: b[1 j% {[4 6B,*% =%6 {s  P (  8I

 8I
'87, i* > %  ,$ : ' 4 S A j
1% ' M4 j  d[ _0UF )$, ` 6, _ ' 4
D}> : q3!1 NR =: K
be b  > i* 7:  
ue4 , :6   -  ,d :  % i* N8B
7: VB$,>  ,7$D>   k0UF 5 `:( A ~ :( >
d! j% b}U%  V}U% =7 ' ~ w
79>    

~ e6, j8D I} ' 8e 87l 1 L


r,+,e j% % A {s
~ s
,$  Q re% '>  A 7Le )$> I; d% ,~ eU 0
re% 6B,*% =r
-}> % V F  /87L A N9, 59,> 3 7:D
z:1 j8D> j% ' 6
0E $ _0UF  YBZ 59,e V,
I ' 7:,  'D k0U% % '* h$, T-U% C_0U%
i* ;  k0UF 5 `:( A ~ :( > j% ,E  
  re N8B> , 6*B i* q~ :M,  #   /: j% ,*
B$ I_: . l  q   8:> 8( ' 6
3 BB.
_0UF YPB.
/O,13
%6e K re% d  ' # =d
  7$* ,}> YPB % 1+,e j%   7$* ,}> 3 ,
j8D reoE NQ %  , ' 8: [1 a6R , 5_8  =L

r:+,e j% 8(-e j% 59,e 3 S reoE {s 5 =b-U A r% ' ~ S


i* N8I $ rE ` d[ 'M re% i* r -: ` ,D

BB. ' ~ q ( j% *6 ' z:1 j8D K =r 6 3 d[ 


e j% X: {s i* *3 ' 6
0E ,7$4 BB. D}
b 6
r$ q*3 {s ' )$
  j4 s =r$*
121

 * M ~   , [1 i* e j% ` ,bX ~ l


j% j8   % s ={[ e 6< 5, j% ' 6
3 'D =*6 i*
)7Le% )1 )7$* X: reoE  $ KLI: 8e8D j% LD 8$
B  _0UF ), ) j ='-ED$ KLI: 8e8D j%
Oe ,  '6 8E- W '[ ' BE 8 e% * ' 1
0 r6 ; d% =b8wE    '6 8E-* e% ' {[4
b[1 ' p-7, joE |,
 ;{s ?- pF  > i* ~  d*
=BB. A L: % d! j% 'D 3 BB.
'* , -. 6 _% A 8,L /6, 3 j% *% 3 e%
% :6 LP9  ~ 6 5w j% reg; ' :D q  5^
:,_3
6  N8B p <% -} BB 4 j% 64! ' =L$L
O4  ' MD
7(8
 V, 7$> 164g> ), G /,
3 re% 8 O4 /8 i* % ,W  1 T-U% BB 6(8> 3 re% 8
5^ i* `$X =AF BB. 6B> % 66Z 59,> T-U% BB 6(8>
~ (0* u ~  -. }_: jg
?*% e% ,LP nI> j% q 
, BB. ;~ q8 16 > LP9 ' Y> }_: j% 5_8 ={[
G Y9: ' j% -+ h: V7,:
E -> -e 5y8 j8D> j% X:
i* 5Ee g> r j8D ' q  K
/I, [1 'D =/8I ' ],
q6\ ' ]4% 6B
i , d[ `_- i* Oe ,# ,  ,
K
h:  : 81 # 9,  j =C[ e # .
: b-D K =BB. hI: f\ jO,D 81 Oe ,BB. q (%
3 K 'D ; 8*6> p % z:7E ,KE-9 A CIeQ i*
122

,C Z A N8 ,> `$I,> q9UF joE 6 ?-9 3 j8,


' nI, )w,, F BB 4 ?, '* 7Le BB. h_8,>
' 6e% 81  z:1 # 2, $B   ' =
sD 8F
3 z:1 'D W s : w_  KE- K
B9: )D. i*  6B
j%  =~ P M ?-9 '* 5E6 j4 6 ?- '* 5E6
/% % z:1 # reoE  6: ' )1  6B b[G j8,, '[ :
4 '* ,7: `e( 4 '* j8E6 j8E6 z:1 j4 s 3 BB.
)8< O  i* ' _ 8e4 ,7: q ( d% i* ,} d%
='-U
- ,d%- - A ( z:1 jg
IL [1  u(
6,> , $ $B 9 .   ,d%- '* ,

% I,U
j -4g =9 . ' T-UF 8eF 5^ 7$*
= 84[ -: 7(8  , p %
j% ~  'D ' jO,D r$* -L
 d[ d%- j% 81 NF
je rLe 81 re% L reoE {s -D: ' =n I d%- 81 j8D
=/8I
'D ' joE ,~ 6 E C8D d%- j8D K re% 81 M
j%  ;BB. ' q ( i* ~0,} j8D j% {s a6R  ~ M4
'7 % 6P d%- ,} j%  , r; ' % : '
' reoE 8y8 [1 N8 , BB. i* 8y8 d% 8I

/69< N0U ' 3 BB. ' B, q  87


% z:1 j8D
=*2:, q 
123

~  < # *O r$B> d[ d%- j4 8 V, re% 81 M
W  reoE ,r$* 6> d[ 8y8 N8 7O,
BB. j4 Oe BE
{s j8$L re8$B '[ joE 0UQ 8B V7,:
 :$ -,
#  % b: -4[ )7E d% j ,T8\  , ' 8 e i* BE
5
- ` 81 [1 rLe %6 V: j% O4 =7$* /8B , B9:
I} ' d8. b-% ' ~ -m ,hw % w
~ 67 j8D
Oe  E  # -% ds ,D; )D - nI  =z8$
% 8e j 8$.  F  6B, p-9y3 a6  BE
=I} 
-+, B Y- '* `$B ' _< BB *:_
-: 7( N:>% j% 6 ,d%- - 8y8 ze j% _
j8D j% 9S q  5^ '* , -
O X: re $PB
d[ ' 'D =hI: B: 6 2+, 3% ~36, 7:* ,
6. 2 )> re% ],e 1 ?yL 6. b[1 ) - j% rE L
jF ,r: 6PE 3 -% [1 ?q, 3
)1 u^81 '[ -; s
t > 
-+,
7E j8D - 4  q, 3
8; z:1 j8D re% -7
j-U 6 8B
q  b[1 '* 5E6 )IU 4 j% ,~ 8_ ~ ] /8+\
8_ -*} % -7l% s )7:*%  -7 r d6I, `I ' j%
9e j% 'D ' =6. 2 ; re% i* 8y8 8I

,$ : ' )7 8y8 81 ,6. uM> 8y8 }_: 
* 5 6: reF ,u$_  -M4% r>s 6
r$* 62% ' ::D
=N6  N6,*3
9 ' T8_%  %
[1 j4 8 V, ,K d% '* , B- j% rE {; 3 
5y8 Y
j8D> j% 4 * M j8D> j% 'D ,~  < d%-
124

d% B [1 ' , Cy*3  P- `e 'D = B,e
  j8D re% 81 N6 r
d- d[ p8$ F i* Cy*3
=E6I
BB. r,e '* h}D W  q ?-9 e  , '
u4 % ,~ B9: 6 E +
+ 1 Cy*3 b[1 -9U%
-* % ,$  B-9
wB :* -* % ,+. YPB.
 -, 
a6R [1 4 'D =$  B-9
 d%-
' j], 3 e% _ ' : ' V7,:
E-9,  8I
`X
ds ' K$1(  O
8e4 j qLD ds  ' % K$1
z:1 j8D> j% : ' joE |,
;T-U% M4 `e8(  qLD
6eF ;r8}> qE 8(8
~ _0U% k< / r(8, 8B p %
z8$ ' 8: [1 5: U6, i* _ j8e_ z:1 j8D j% {s '
d% ,N6,  B: ,
* r:e  :
% =N6  
' joE ,{s A  I} e1Q -U X$ `+} eQ
8 6  $ F b[1 D:,   ' ]4% h,
-}e j% 'D
~ <% z:1 ue4
 'D ; : - i* d,
7-Z A 8* 0
d%- 6y 76,  6B> 81 $ : ' rE : `-
j 6P  d%- 6y BE /6,> 3 % 81 a6R  =BE 6P
6 R j% 1 7,+,e j8D> j% n(- ' Oe ,7$* 87 *
=Y. i* r> _I r,  i* 76, d[ }
)*% 81 6  $ F b[1 L
5_8  joE {s 5
d%- 'D *    % ;~ e N  6y / 6,> K 'D 
7$D
`1[>  b[G r:* E6 N0U ' 7$* IR j% K
125

j% 'D B [1 ' q  T8_% =*O ' 8B q  A ~ -B>
S% )g
h d%- p <% )It  j% 1 N ; 7D>-
*O ' 8B  q  
j8$R '[ =)\ k0U% 3
 )16* jF ,B , 7}, ' 8: [\ <U  8I
j8y-
~ $_ j8D 
j%  4 /O,1
)1 -} 3 ,g> )\ # 0
)1 6B
j8D 3 8F  `
'D =jQ N6
8$ 
  jg
8e8D ' )F ,6P d%- 6y 0 [1 /6, 
-4[> 6PE r j8D> ' N % i* /6, 3 [1 j% O4 ,r6, 
 8I
=)7,w_ i* ~ $ 6>- j% T8 -% r j8D ' ,)7 :

* ~ es% VB$> j% *O d%- L q  'D ' j8D ' *
' 6_ _% N0U ' N6,*3
),> ,  [. X$ N0U ' 3
7:* ,
3 )\ 'D 3  b[1 ,20  q Q '* ,
3
' ,$L: q Q j% K  ;)7_8 '  j% j $e% 6_ 8
-> j% L
g; ' 6P d%- 1% `e( ' 6, \B*
A CIeQ j N8Z *O d%- w1: q '* , '* :
BB.  $I   ,~  )7 ' joE |,
=q  b[G b8L, '
 i* ; X$ /6,  ' 8: [1 6B> ), j% ,6
 CO+\ M, (. joE ,'-% K
,e j% :$* j4 s ,NM
='6 6y  CO+\ M> A (. ~ M4 k8L> K:!  6y
=K*8: ' d% 6B> 9$ j8eB jg; ' # re% ny8 ' 'D
=r$Le j% ~ ^ :
6  d% d%- r$* j8D j% X:  )D
d% '6e j% ,6 i*  4 ?-l i* :D%  6:,e j% :
6
8*6  r
8$ % j4 s N6  r_8 '* -: ?
;
126

B> /6* % `I, %  -7 % ,0UQ A ~ B,E -7


d[ h_8 `
Ps- b[1 $,e j% :
6 3 'D =-*}
d%-
'! } b[1 j4 8 V, ,N6  } b[,
'* -: ?
,; 4 i* :Me / e j% X: =:%- _:
 --B> 6:* k6I ,-  q6\
5,, j4 s ,r$R d[ d%-
8 e i* -% d%   3% ,)1 DE%  --B> r8IU r8B
1 b[1 =)7, $I re% 6B , j% 'D q d% ),D 3% )7 q
re% 3 , -, 
h  % )  ;/ B:$ BB. k0UF
k0UF b[1 j8*- '[ K+ ' M4 6(8 re% 'l% j% 6
k6I
j8R '[ ' ]4% 6* V, z:1 6(8 re% ,4 6 A
=k0UF b[1 8, j% 0U

127

128

3
-

~ -% : j8D j% d  '  , p F uy-*

, M `_8 uy-*


,'$  7:* , q  D}> 

_0UF 9 `I> \0U ' je -DL 9 `I>


e8* =*8: 84 ' )- i* 164g> ), % -. b[1 n: W 
: j8D j% / $,> 3 7Le p F b[1 ue4 j h}D,e j
_* j )  1[L: j% V:
,)7P `(8
  ~ -%
)7,! i* j8E, 8e4  , )8U ' _0U% % 
j% 6% *6 3 =N. 9
r: 6
3 -% UF  [1 =<
V, E ,{s ' #D i* 
=q 4 - j8D> j% X: NEF
{$> '* , 7E ), , ?- j8D> K 7,eI 6BL> q 
8: -, A $E 8* 7:* , -  d[ 8: ' q 
j % ,q-BL 58  j8,  [  j PB d%- j =TsF '
K -
N+ r z
 j% X: ,_ ' 8e 1 < D$

8B 5_8> N6 ' j8D 'D ;89 e 'y W A / 6B
6} /% ,E3 i* r$ % r,L; ' r
Y9e s K ; i*
129

y 28 = [  6% 'D /% K+, : ' `y



 ,7*8e j4 O7 '-U q[  ~  j8D> , NEF
h d%- N0U '  ,79y d  ' j8D 7 C3.
-L - j =$  U6, N0U '   u* s %
r:D ='-U
rE% > 3% ` :  6m j8D> j% `
j% ,)7I , 8F  '-U j!;  U6, '* 5:, s
r z> j% X: ,rI , 8F  rD r8 5 rE% )+:>
p F ],> ;< r,! i* rP `(8
$ -.
- j8D> j% X: q  j% K > , 7Le p F 1 {[ *6
G vg , YPB. j% ;~ 8I # jeQ :|, 8 : i* 1
' # d%- /,e j% ;YPB ?Ie% N8F '%  1 jeQ
q  K
e B C(  )>% _% '* ~ e j4 s 3 
8- 8F
j% A , -F
# ,` -% 81 q  8:> j% ;y ,
`e8( 5^ z  i* j r$* 1  MD
 6_ -M4%  nI>
i* Y9:>  6B
)\E%  :  i* f b[1 Y9:> =BB.
j8D> j% 4  d #: j84 q:% 6L ' j%  =)7P
;  L$, p  z:1 j8D> j% M
X: ,L$, q z:1
ue4  - N+
CI} ' L$, 8eF VZ j% X:
.  L$, k-9 _ ,U ), j% X: ,'-U
> 3
=k-9 b[1 
- ` : ' j% ; d% ' K * D}

8F  rLe i* d-L 5


9 64! j% rE p8- ' , I,U

~ 8Dm } z8$ j8D K =AF ( 6


'-U ) 3 ,
0* [1 joE ,'-U C* % 6B> L
Oe r,I; L
#
130

re84 `e( A eeQ $ P- Ce8D 6% p i*


=*O,(3 d-L /6B,$ P- j8D
' vg> 3 %6  {,  jeQ 7EI 
8< )*% j
/6* ' vg> Oe ,8B  A !  N8 : q
j% j-} *  8I
: j4 8 = 84[ X
a43
;9  $   F 7 8F ' 81 -L * :$ -. 89,
_ ' , C $9I
r:e  5^ Y- '* 
vg 3 -% re%
d  q ( r>s 6
81 Oe ,EBM )$,   6  w.
-. 6B> 3%  -9U z:1 j8D '$E ,q;F b[1 5 Y S
7:
6. 8> 8I
$P1 
8< z:1 j8D> ' ,1 6_ Y
), 3 : ) -e  re% 1 $D} =*O,(3 -9 K

d% Y ,> % % ,d-L PB$, z8$$ >s _ g
?*3
7$* )1 ,  '* y-
: ) -} =s 6
/
3 ,r$* 1   b[1 j8$ '[ )1 )F  -% [1
K*%   :  b[1  3 d[ ` 87L j% j89,
)1 '[ K*O,(3 K_0UF K $I$ :
% =5
) joE j r$* 1 O4   '* Ky  )7,9

' q ( d% D}> % i* PB$, A j-: 3 K $I q3!1


~ e% ~ , ~ BP* 1 ,*
,q, 
7 j-: ) 
;iM )-e
81 re% )7Le% j8 $I q3!1 6B,  / N8B r(  hB ~ -,
W ,Wilhelm von Humboldt u81 j8E )7$7$E = U
i* rO*% 6% V:
,'2    N( ' re8D
 r$
87}
131

B f 7,y-E , X % ,jeQ  j $PB -DL


1 ,-
 wX C- ' 8
u  - % 2F
A I, ~ +e b-M4% 8 e _% i* r>D$ -89>
,Y :, /> 4
b87( 7 r(8 j% je 4 i* ` , X j |,
$PB
~ <8IU )7:*% `Ie 7w j% ` , X ,$ % $4 j
* : 1 X b[1 , :
' )8U i* g, j6- '[
-.  ,K; ' 6
3 {s YB , re% , 89, 9$  -L
d-L j8L: g}: '-F '[1 qB, ' re% ,h_8 8:>
 V, )7L W 'D =H1I<F  ~  j, j[$ ,) 8:,
=e% c U : ' $_ 6* 3 r:
%6 M %6 i* ', 8 : ) j% ) ,{s 5
b[1 9 ~ I; j6 K p-X, 3
j-} ,u81 j8E
d% 8y8 [1 A -:e j% :$* j% 3 ,-L * :$  B
j% 'D 3 u81 j8E -e 7( $F -e 7( K
?0,U3
81 z8$  2,3 j% T- ' z:1 # =( 6  ~ E0,U 3 j8D
6$B> T8 k0Q i* q dg
/B /6* )7$* X: : j% 
)7,B- Z j% :
6 3 re% { 64! ' 6 ' =~ w
)7w

)7D i* N6> k0Q i* I


% ) j!;    . 
j% Y. ' j8D ,-U `e( ' =-L )7,I; i* % 
j% : i* ` reg
)*  (  A B$9 _ -L$ 9e
1311 ,   :eF
u8 j8E j  1
=h!
132

j% _ W  k0Q i* ?- q 6(8 3 reg4 ) 8}


T6 j% i* :1] 8 e ~ ; L> W ,D 
-+, jg4 ,r 8>g
re% -D: ' z:1 # =1 ' wE% 1 z8$ %  k-
j% )Do
nI 
p} '  )7 6> : )$> X:
'D =r: L, 3 89, j%  ] ' r
,4 )>  8$
nI r ~ 2, nI ,r>D$   w: $- A jeQ I K
=< r,B-9
] L /6, j% ` : b  64g,

B d[ $+



-+, ' q  {s i* -M j% r$* h_8,

: C* 6B> j =< r,I; rE-l i* ` : Y9,


r  81 ,)7,
- ' )1 8$>  N8 6 
r9> '-U
} 8*6> p % 0 z:1 'D =r Y , |,
 ,re2
G  j% X: , LD N8 P7: -B rP9* /6* A
,6. j By j8D> j% 'D : q3!1 
- j% 81 NF =r>
)1L> j% 81 M =)$ r(8 i* 7B> i* 8$ W O
%
CE =} [1 ` : 3 r:D ~  < j8D O
)7,
-+,
[1 ?-l j8D> O
 ;, I} , ?-$ Y$

j8D> K V, re% 81 M =,  8: ' r>* % }


 j% {s 5 r
6 3 ,r  : s 6
6( C
i*  3 [1 jF ,C* 84  ' ,C b[1 `(8

= je    ],> , CLI ' ~ % rE -X j% % r$>
, 8} )D. z Q _ ' , eeQ CD$ j
/B 6:* 3 7,  ), 3 ,_0UF N8 V, ,B }:
= U dg
/8B 3 , -F 81 reF K -g
/8B d[ =C 

133

 -  % wEF 81    - d% 6L, 3 {[4


T8B jg; {s  g; ,_0UF $B e8_ j =r$* N8I.
' {6 8(8 CD$ j =/6, 3 5 3 ' ,> 3 ,$w
j8D ,r
j88B '-U j% -+  
/8B> K 1  `$>
s =r
j8:! '-U j% -+ q
'! ' jg; {s  {eg;
7( ' _ u K d% N8B z8*6> , p F ue4
[1 V:,> K r$* 1  T8_% nI> ' p F b[1 joE ,z-e
ue4 s ;_ ds ' hy% nI> j% \ n(- ' j 
,d%-
ue% z-*} 5 )+:> 3 K 8 e i* ?,$ z8*6> , p F
z-*}  j%  )1 8 : [1 i* ?, joE ,{,I;
9B: b[1  =8_ 9}e j8D> j% ' ~36
9
 $U {,I;
e6(8 -*} 7E U6,> , C3. :M, % :eoE ,UF
='-U k8B % I}
r , W ' r
 q  % W  6 d[ } j
L> O4 6$B, i*  6B T8 D$ % A c,R 3 r> 9U
r 6
3 s =r>D$ 5^ /6, rL:
r> 9U , d[ =-B
g:, V, )D. B9: N36, 3 ,T- V, 0 /6, j%
, , -B s3 20 8 5 V, }: ,q;F

y / . A c,R reoE b -_ A <8, K ,b -_ A <8,


/20 6B j =  q
r <8> d[ b -_ i* u M  #L:
6B i* S  8I
6, CD$ b[1 ' r6, r$9, d[
j% 'D ' =< b-*} rD. ~ BE r48$ ' 6 , d[
 '* {[
~ 6, ,K 6(   $ 6;  6_ j8D
134

r,_ . b[1  j8D, s 'D = 8F b[1 ' d%


j ,-9
: r
/8B  BE u $E _ \ , 8F j ?jeo4 :
K
' =NEF b[G /8B d[ }  {[4 Oe ,NE% '
 )$ 8 : i*  . 7E / 6,> , jeQ NO*%
' )1% 81  z:1 # re% 64! ' ,NO NOD 8 e 
, [  > ,'4 V:> j% 'D ' j4 re% L: =rLe jeQ
' ,C8$I i,> #P:D 6 }> 
,wB )4Z ,z  p Z

j% G j7, 3  U z:1 j8D,E ,je D; i* C3 _


q: N(- '* ~ y8* V, ,q: N(- '* ~ y8* C3 Be
'[ ,W '  , q (F . u_8  j8:D '[
j =L
r+,:,  r+,:> j% 9 59,> O*  :* j],
/B$ I ,K 9 ~ BE V:>  u eeQ 9
' 7Le -89> 8: A c,Z -+;  
;r u< O
w

=. 'PD D}> , $U6 T8B  ~ BE ,`e8 5^
O j% [  8F ' jg
Be j% n( F i* 'D '
~ e% 4[ ,
3 % $ 4[ >3 jg
Be j% ,)77E :
j% K 6 A Be =$ | V*F >3 ' wE%  '*
6, 3 ' rLe 6B 6(8 3 'D =:
~ <U j8D j% X: :7E
j% % ,:
<U j8D> j% M
X: :E :> jg
?*0
5_8e ~ E :$* ~ -9U 3 # :
<U 5E6 :40, jg
?e
joE {s 5 =~  Ly 5E6 C- b[1 ue4 s 3 ,rE :Le%
d[ q  6B
D jeQ ' ~ q ( D}> 5E6 C-
3 K 3 -9U 8B 5E6 j8D> 3 =
8w C6B, r$D}>
135

?61F ' *8 89,> K d% ,)$ 8 : i* e28, j8D>


,T-UF N8 ?61F j% K  ,8B $- A I, N8
: {$ =$U Ly > ,7 8(8 j8D> j% X: ,
u =Ly )1-POy jF Oe 8_ ) jF # ~ U ~ 48$
9 $IE =hw w 8B 5E6 K
 $< z:1
K ; -*} 5E j N8Be K =H1I-U `e i* 1
:8_ 6 3 [1 joE ,-U ; -*} 5E ' ~ *8:> -M4% T8_%
O
|,
 , 9$ /  ' ]4% ~ 6_ r$U6
{$, re%
' 6  i* ~ _ 64g,
j8D r:D , ' 6  i* ~ _ j8D
N8 ,> j% _9$ 'D =_9$ -U O~  3 8B 5E6 u =
6B
O~ P vg> j% 8B 9}: 9$ 'D 'D , C6,  A
=$ 9 9 ' vg  k8L  '
{% O~ P )1 8} ' 6_ _g
j8,, '[ ;F
] )$, N0U ' 7[ )> -*} )@6 '[ ;F
8B C 6B j =T8_F )1 8 I j% {[4 j89, -DL
r: c- d[ 6I {[4 1 8_  I} 5E6  ,
5,+ /8B =#L: y ' _F 6B $wL$ d8B `. )
N0U ' # ,C 6B b[1 -89> N0U ' r.I R r(8

} =)7:I h4 )$ 3 reF N9


F 7: 5:I ,  E
'* ] j% V:
rLe qB$> '  < rE r> j8D> d[
j% 7$* `$X 8B 5E6 j% 81 K>UF K,$ '  r:   1
=8_ -POy Oe Ly -POy # ,:>
136

,< r,EB L


rE u6> C 89> d[ 8 : i* < r,
j8D> 3 d[ } =I; `< re r:* NB } [1
j% O$M ,I; `< # rLe qB$> '  < rE r>
BE rLe qB$> ' 5E6 'D> W s =I; \ u   
5,, reoE ,8_   -9 uZ ue4 s ,8_ {[4 ue4 Oe
d-L `e 5+}> X: 3 re% '> u:4 s =9}e 8_ I}

5,+ jg
'!> j% 6
0E ,rLe '* h}D i* 5E6 C-$
M4 i* ,} reF wE% N  # re% ,8_ 5P A (
#
' 8, T8, j% ,I} ' MD )\ '[ ' : '
=
8- 8F ' #  _9
Cs T8B {$> ue4 ,5,+ ' -D - 

5,+ 8_ i* 4 C( 6
6B, -L _9 ' | T8,
-9 79y 5,+ 8_ 6B  'D W 
K. {s 
,d-L PB$, `e  -EQ
u> $- z:1 ue4 =7$*
{s  
8I ue4 =7 d8_   *O,(3 T8B ue4
% * i* 8B N8B % /(F ds ' : 
1 K.
,
8I b[1 i* `$X,$ =)7E i* -9 )7: `$9,> 6*8_
,-
F 6y )7*  C8
 M jE, /: j8eB j4
Oe )% T8*6
,r$D
jeQ i* )7,9$ j8y-L 8e4 )% V:

I} b[1 ,r,I; i* -9   r> 5^ i* j-9


$ 6 r j 5,+ 'D =16B,  i* 5,+ -M W ,
-EQ 81 #  9 67, d[ -9 ;d-L `e i*
137

8F CX> =6. j $$_ 84 Oe I} N8 5E6 
)7,>- wL
q8_F h8* rE ue4 d[  [: $P1  8I

6y , -, '   I} )L< wL


% ,)7_8 %
V, ~  )7$* -9 ' 6
3 j4 '[ ,eF Ke8B
 % ='F ' $B
Q )89 uZ j8_8 : 59,
,1e% A *O,(3 CB9 i*% ' ,; 4 joE |. e*
% -L j =`e 
81-  
_ e% uZ re% 8 O4 
3 ,BE )7Le% OE Oe '-U OE BE # ,$P
% ?y ,I; ` : d[  % ?wE % s :)7Le% j8g
<-E i* IR U6
 5E % wE%  j% reg; ' d[ 
` : 81  :)7Le% j8g Oe ? 123 8: ' r:D  :
d8, y  )1 '[ : * r$L d[  ?y8
 r
/8B O* } N! {s ' V, %8 % 81  'D ?dI,_3
)% :*% 3 =r: wE% ?-l i*% 4-
j8,, '[ : 
)\
i* -9 3 s =)\8 ` :  i* re8$wL , 81  j ,
rLe B joE |,
=, 81 O
/B q:M, 
 d% )@6 j8D j%
81 r
j-DL  N% joE ,,$ : r
/8B OE V, =:$ 5yU
) U j8 O 3 ;H1I*O M j8R ) ;6*B YE /,e3
`-X k[ '* j6, )1 ;*O 7$L> , q;F K
' 3
 j8$L *O 'y *O 5 j )g4 {s j8$L )% V:
1
- M  \ 6 _% 6 -: b[1 =*  8I
*O L>
=& *O 5 C8" 
138

' )oE ,-F   =)P- '* )1,


 6B
z8$  s}
)\ u ;% A j88 , < )7,9 )7*> /6* N0U
j8 I ,~  BE nI> eeQ ) 6_ d[> ,8, 
  )\ j8D> 3 , 5, % 8_ C % i* ' _ 
d[ 5y8 81 [1 7E =>  8I
)7I )7: 
e -*} % q %
? 9$ rX,e
t -e  {[4 re
9U )*% joE ,-: b[1 ` =H1I'L4

6B 'y 5B d[  4 i* *9 ,}> = Q 1 je


#  ;b q 3 [1 L> j% 6
3 ; U je # =
0U z:1 # {[ ,~  6 E  9 =9U 87E `(8

}$ :
=r$U6
 9 ,B> j% 6
3 ; dF
i* qwB  r$* c- z:1 # ,. '* -: b[1 R d[
, 68  6B =r>eD % r> 6_ % jeQ CD$  ' D$  %
~ % /6,  s ;   A rLe )$> i*  6B 1 jeQ 7(,R
-M4% 8 e i* y
L  Q b[1 * T8 - dF r>D$ '
t -e 1 b[1 =CD$  j6
j8D j% r wEF ' joE ,qL4
,'L4
j], 3 '[ : ' M4 LL  8I
G '! -e 1
t >% ' )7Le%
_% L,
jOQ ' LL  8I b[1 hg,> ='L4
X: reg
B>    j% )@% ' =   re% j6B,  ~ 6}>

t j8( 1
 h:( A - A -9y ) ,e-E  6 15641509 'L4
=-8 '>  5 h$,U r:D =,e,>] `1[ ! 6% 81 =8
=p-X  K  K>810 )1% ' ],
139

j8D 3 N. 9


;Q [1 ;r8 
5} j% jeQ i*
N0U ' d% ,*9 N0U ' Oe ,)7Le% re8$wL d[ 8 : i*
6  b[1 j8D> j% ' -L 0E |,
 ,9$ )\ 7w> 
=H1I5+$
,B [1 ' -4 8 e i* ,d8_  . u_8  6(8
, eeQ I}  :H > .  Bw -: b[1 : ,
, 9 1 ,u , YEF Yy WF 6 A 6},
),>
 j% k6I
j6B, : ' ~ M4 j% {; 3 =-: b[1 7$wL>
j% )7BU )\  % O4 )1 8 : [1 i* )7 B> )1 ), '[
59 ,B> K +;F j% j8: : ' M4 j4 O$M ~  ;8e8D
7, ' MD
^% nI> Ce8 D; i* )$ B> % e6 I%
i* Y$U jeQ j% 6B,e :$ '6 ' q ( d% j4 s 'D =9
j% '6 [1 5 )+: O
AF ' joE , r>L< ' i*% 'P4 6
,7 ,L> 1-89>   )D$  5^  V9*% V F 'PD [1
j8BBR K b* '* - re% ,8(8 ' 18m \I,  #
 2 4 j8BBR K ,r$* j _ )1 d[ NM 8 e /6B> 4
,ee :LD /87L$ ~ BE =5,, ?, )7L i* ) 6B
z:1 'D =~  7$* qwB ), 3 q 3 : u t: :, joE
B D}> , : 6% ={s '* h$, eQ 2,0 
`e( A ,:8 jeQ T6 C[  D BM 81 eeQ
t `1[ ' LL  8I    F 9B: j% 3 1
 re% 1 'L4
=I}  -L * : 87
n 3 {s 5
140

-89, '* e8 NM z:1 =H1I  jeQ T6 C[ De
i* -9 '*   80EF NM r 6: d[ ,v[
i* j8D j% }$ wEF ' j8D O
=rB /8B 3 r:D C[
'D =H3I#B%  8< i* j8D j% ' ~36
 H2I#48e j8(  8<
/8 :6 j4 8 =H4I $4
 8< i* j8D j% {s ' V, wEF
I;  U 4 i* ,}> r,I; ueD $4
M ;
=#48e j8(
NO  1% ' ~ e% j8 I   ( A  j
`[> N0U ' j8D> 3 )!;  DL, )7,  6
5,,e
DL> Oe% C48$  8,: )7E d-E 81  4 )I;
' s8Ug C  b[1 :0 =h! 1 .2 ::t,
.2 j8:
,:t, j8( C3B ' NF q  ,190  LI
)( =1848 /*  j6:  8}: ,'
4- )*2 ,d6:$,D  ' ( 81 15721514 #48e j8(
 Presbyterianism K} LP # % 6_ =6:$,D   :6 0<Q
t >% ' :6 rP  81 ,6:$,D 
='L4
d-D* 6P_ `9U  =0 _ 404450 |8 #B%
C8 s j4 ,  r>qO,e  `$B, M4 j4 re NB =e8
=4 -D*
~ -D* ~ 6P_ ~ 9U ~   j4 =0 _ 429495 |8 $4

_ 429 A 461' L N0U :% _ A8> =:F 1[  q:%
' r
 <% 
j4 6_ = $4
* ~ e% 7$* Y$9 E 1 ,0
472 /*  = 8(4e% F j8:2  8(>-
)7: ,L 0L
=8$  )  `>D$ C 5
% )6B>  )1 0 _
141

1
2
3
4

'y ,8: ' r:D d-L `e :> N0U ' Oe ,:
1 NEF j% O$M =)7.I '-U k8B 7y-L> , 6.
eeQ .   1 {[DE ,G j88B ' I; '*  8<
,-*} 5E->  DE ~ E q~ [ 9> ,9}e  *8:, -
#: [1  jg
,d #:
-E 4
-> , $I 2 >
2 O$4 =r qO,e3 -6 ' nI 8 e i* B 3 O
wE% d
C2 |,
 ,rL: r,_ C2 ,d-L re( -89>  }
. NO,4 ' )*% ~ 6_ 6+e :1 ='-U _ s j8D j% i* r> 6_
oE -EF  ~3O,4 -M4% . j8D> K =-L [1 8( N8
z:1 j8D j% 6
3 =)7: hg,> , C*O  ~3O,4 -M4% nI>
T6,> j% j 8$ $ d  81  6B
*O $,D i* Xy
8> z:1 'D ,'-U k8B i*  9  T8_F CL
, -89,  j =eQ 89, -e 7( ' V, {s '* E
), Oe '-U p i* r8 ; ' r: N0U ' -L 16BL
=H1I'-U ;F -89> p i* AF ( 6
7$* N8I.
r,4 )>  jF ,E<  U 6(8> 3 rLe -L$ :
V,
q +$ wEF 89, N0U ' r,e28 ), '-U nI r$U6

i* 5y8 d[ 6B wL


~ :D nI -% 81 ,r,9 *O,(3
'-U nI 6 ' :, 6*8B
-L 6 B K =eF `e
K 'D ='-U U A ?6 , C_9 -*} 89 [1 joE
 ~ * ~ D ,: j% reg; ' 8 : [1 i* b 89> ' $B, joE |,
 1
=eQ 89,
142

3 6B, [1 rE  `e( i* -!> 3 , 8F  -L 6 B


_ ds q d% -89> /6* {s jg; ' joE c* e3
b 8; 6
soE =6B B N0U ' 89,> j% 'D , I} 8_ q:M, 

 5,,> V, =7$4g


r, hw 6$ reoE ,~38B 6B j4
jg
; D n j% d  ' ,, <-E g
; 4
' B
  , CL G ),> ,  6 j =L$,  R
r
u  d[ 5 8 T6 i* 0* 1 , N(F -e 7(
%8 % ,: 3 jX9 )D V, =, <-E i* N8I.
-L$
`e Y   4 ;r$l  ~ 8(8 d-L `e j4  b 
r$* Y$ 9 d[ ) 3 '* -: ?
,~ eX r>s 6
], d-L
= -% %    [L: re% *6 j4 s O*
:>  > j% ,-89, 7Le 1 -L * : j u$_
j% 6

L
,: ,: j% 59, d[ 68 -F 81 -L * :
6  z:1 1 =+. /,,U
j /8_g ,6(  8I
' 89, ~ 

re N8B ' wE% eeQ j!} ' 5y d% '* NB j% 'D 
j8D j% 'D s ?r$* j89,  wE% A )7Le%  p-B
?{s j N8R re% T8 $ 9> d% 8I
N8B ' %8 %
'[ {% :_Q E4 j8D> ' C ,*3 b[1 j% rE {; 3  'D
i* 6 )_% j% A {[4 c,% |,
=:_ ( : -M4% )1
, 89,  C:PD$ K 5Le Cs  89,  C:PD b[1 j%
L, 0 j8 3 -. j6- 3 '[ {% A ,ny% j% d%
i* j 6B :  8I
~ U j +
 O
)% ,8*9,  j 7:
143

{$> ' L, 3


'-U ; O - 
B 77E
=-.
O
-. j6- 3 '[ {% j% NF /B  _g js
{% _ ' -.   ' ~ ; 8$, j% )\ 'D ' j8D
j!}  )_ :* 1 <F j% 6% -D: ' =6- '[
8 y8 66( YPB : h},D j% A ( O~ P z:1 =eeQ
=  < B
 YPB. T6 8> 3 K 5y8  '-U
 q6$ ;% A {[4 (. 8*6> Oe ,` E [1 #
ds ' -M4% :, z8$  )1X 6_ 8e8D 66( C 
-D: ' j =   wEF Q wEF k[  ,_
~ E NOD < W j% ' j% r$* K, {s
r$ 5^  0
;L: b[1 Kg> ; 4 6B  # reg
?*% e% =r> 
8 ,.  )G  d!> j% n(- '[ : ' 4 6* z:1 #
~ q ( j8$D} )7E , C O  KZ d% A ,j-U 7>
; F n$ 81 XI q  [1 'D =eeQ 8 ' ~ X<
BE 8 ) =64 4-
eeQ . nI, : q3!1 j6E
t  '[ ;F
)1 ) 
;_ ' 8(8 'D> W  ~ 8% j8$U6

W s =<F
8(8 9 q;F 8( i* j8ER '[ C[

re84 '* d B h_8, 7E ,r$: 66( q z:1 'D
6B q;F j8$L '[ V: j%  ~  [1 j8D 1 ?~  
)*  z:1 ?4 # /eF4 18$L j% ,7$*  `

-% A N8 ,> C O C6B, wE% V, 6 :> jF 6. k8E


144

i* 6+, )7,<% > '[  ' 5


,> z:1 'D W s ;|
C O DEF {$> 7$* /8B> , p F nI> j% j 8$.
-X<% ' 8+:> ' B [1 ' , ,  joE ,6$B> 8% -
/6* A 8*6 ` z:1 j8D ' ,L
 q d% ' 1B$,>  1
j% n < =9e   8]Q 5 a6 O4 C w. 6e
;O~ P {[4 8$ j% ,  ' X< $_% )1 -B p <%
59,> 3 =7E j8: , 
 L ' 6
3 :6 6(8 V, 'D
)D
)1 -B p <% =-. ' 8(  3 -
#L:, -B
 i*  6_ _% |,
 ,'-U : ' -E -M4% )7,
6 $$_ `8B ' d% 'y Ts 8y-, j% j )7Le%
)7,I; D}> e! b-E% LD j%   5,+ 1 6 ,
 R jg
#L:
BM /6* ?8 5E6
8y soE =<
6, 59, 3 d[ )7P ( 4 84 j% ,`8B b[1 ' 6
' -4[ ~ ; `D ' 5,+ joE ,6 j  jg
Xw uZ
)oE ,)18_ 4 8_ CI; ds 8e4 s =)7,-B*
,5P; d* -% A )7+Z  n$L W d[ 5,+ ?61 j8 I
% )7L8*  j8E6: )% i* e<  6+
)7 } j%
C30; ' j8D,} )g4 ,{s A  )7P81% `
j8$B,
=j6 T6 U By :_ M 8:
> 3 F -(e
\ O A (. ,-B % i* 8B b[G % K
d% -D: ' re% ~  z 6 :eoE , O  -DL  -
n,L,

: ) j% {[4 z 6 ,-: : ' h_8 [1 ;


145

ue4 s ` -% -B j% : ' =~ P r


j8D 3 5_8 
V:  ' 'D =8 ) % $^ 6I_ 
,4 ' ~ I; 'D
6(8 3 j4 j ,L -DL  <F 81 ,-B$ BB.
)1  j8: : ) joE ,p+* 8*6> 3  N8B ;
A ~   h  -1 b[1 =7:* q:X, 3 ~  )Do
j%
N8B 59,> 3 d[ -F 1 <F =p-X, 0 8*6> 3 % ( 
j% 7 8
 84 6 j% j89, 3 ) =r>6PL
-}> j% $<F 
'D O
-} j% )Do
j4 8 ?{s 84 6 j% )\ Ve% =)\ L>
r$tE < 6
3 q N% =<% b[1 ue4  )\ <F L> j%
j8D, reoE ~  )7:*% n,E 8*9,  s ;)7:*% n,L> j% 81 )7
-% '  re% )$e K 'D ={[4 <F
8,, j%  <-E )7%
9 q;F 5^ j% ,AF -$ ; r
/_ 3 _ ' )>
j8,, 3 '[ ;F ' `$9e :eoE ,<F O 1 8(8
N >  re% j- )7$ jF LD 5y8, ' 6B
8$ , j% <F

_ O$4 reg
)7Le% 8:t  9  j% ,1 +:, <F /% 8% z:1
=7 )7,( C2 <F A )1 B,E
)74 
B k8L, )-D, :$E V, % :$_ O7 re% 1 - BB. j
j% 81 W q e% h$,  q; / 5
9 joE ,
L % BB.
N0U = :
K
:7 8B 81 8, % d qF nI
q:% Ve% (  A ,V9 8 8I  ,)6B  , 87*
8_ -L T6 ue4 ,|.  A 9_Q 87* ' 89 NB,e3
j4 reoE 4 *O,( 5y8
% * `18
5,, j4 s ; rLe 
146

' j =*O -


 -EF 5w . u_8  =G j7, 3 8_
)DR / d%- j% 1    @6
j8D> j% D> , 8F
8_ ,1O 8_ 1 ) 3 [1 Y ,> , 68 8B =j W
6B
[1 Y9: =1O P- N8 YE ?,> K C8D.
i* Y9: O$M .  *O,(3 _0UF C_0 i* rLe
8 / d%- 1 g
)1 ?-  > '[ : = C0,
8 )1 : q3!1 j8D D-% LE =6$
4  rLe 87 )1
=9 8, B9 ' AF ( 6
j8Lg, $+e  , jD
z:1 =*O d T8, d% ,K 87^ ' O~ P j8Lg, )7:D
3 j 1O j% 81 ,.   66( `e( /6B>  A Ey
qO*2 ' % ,6 % '6 N( % 5,+ N( 4 ' 1q [Ug>
,)7:* DL,
j88B ~  )7$M ~ e% z:1 j =`,D ' % ,KE-
=6P- C L< i* , $  ' ,)7 
86 , % )18
YL, {s ' wE% q d% j N8_% 3 ={s 4 ' D,;% 3 e%
[1 'D =. u_8  eQ B$ e6, . 5 *  8I

=* 8D j8D> j% K* ;% ' hg,> , 8D. 5: 3
,6, : 8D % -B 8D % uB>  j% _ Y W
1 : L< 7P  %   \E% ' r$* 5+}>   q8
T8, k8E qB> 3 u*9,  % uB>  j% _ \ Y W ,B
81 6;> jg
7L: 8B *O u   6B
3 ,d
% 6 ; g>  I:
3 '%  O~ P r$L> ue4 -%
D. 8F 5^ %6> =   6 `18 p <% ' $$_ E
6 i*   {s j8D ;-E% 6 i* %6> j% \ 6
3 
147

b[1 > i* _ re% 81 8, jeQ 6 ?S j =6 -E


uZ   D. 8 ~ $U 
+, 3 i* ,6
d[ N9
F * ' 8: [1 6% 3 e% =K,8,L K:
7P8
W )D i* 8B
q0, 3 i* d8B d-B je YLI
A } j% 81 r
/B r YR  4 j =r:* O~  b-g
/ ,$ r$(
 BE u r*> i* '-U b-4 i* } 8_ j =k-9
(-$ 6L
 {[4 1 Oe ,-U ; 4 89> - 5 +:
K9 8, e% ' hg,> , 1O q nI> K 'D =rLe d8B
b[1  : 3 ,:7 8B nI> j% A 7$  j8D> K %

r (. 8*6>  j% 6 j% N.


[\   I> *
% 
B
BM4
{% T6 d-L `e 2-
' 6  ) 6  81 / b3
< ?- b[1  =-DL ' i*% C8, i* j8LB '[
i* )7+}> ,' , ;F u4  ' ~36
,X: C[

z:1 'D> W T-U% C_%  =1O '* h$, 8 e i* ?,


Oe ,h$, 8 e i* BE # 8E> s 3 ,{[
)7_ ' T6(
,.   /,e3 /6* i* NM 8( - j =wE% 8 e i*
 = 87+$ 6U r>s 6
81 ,$ Ie0 E- - %
~ *8e ?8g '* c- + w
 / d%- jX j%
j8D j% ,jX9 ' - ,   ,rE p8- ' joE ,g9 '
8_ ' 4 6B
)> j2 % jD 4  =?8g '* K( U :
6B j4 ,?8g '* c- ' 4 6_ z:1 j4 ,I}
,} j4  5 *  8I
` :, 5,+  ?8g '* c-
=
F *+} $B 8. -B 6B ' 5,+ {s r$*
148

i* j- '[ 6* j%  [\ ) -9 CO ' j


=~  X< ?8g '* c-
 8 -. ' 'D N _% 9e j% )7 ' j u$_

A N8 ,, 8F b[1 


n$ I> O
'  5 re%  % i* ,,
reF BE 5+}, Y , 3  1 L N0B,  'D =C*
;/ N8B
6(% j8D> C NEF  wE%  A d! O

Y )\ '[ )1 BE 8 u
 B* k8L,
K,, : j% O4
j% A 8*6  z:1 # =< )7,B-9
) $<8  
j4 s =7: X< 6* % K e i* P_ : 5^  j8D>
joE ,] ' d-9L Y9: ' N6, 6_ V, } T6
1 B-9 b[1 jF # ,wEF 1 .  rB- 9  r,B-
;?-4 8 : =C[
81 r,B- F Oe ,s 6
wEF
3 =
'* 7w
 59,e 3 8 e i* r
},> 3 ?- V,
ue4 s 3 [F ' ~ (2 5w % ~ L9 d6>- j% } 59,
, [F h
q 4 8, r6 j4 % r _ i* $IL
IL> ' 7 % r B i*  IL> 7E =7: ,U3 59,
- d6 )7$D}> 4  ~ w
)7w
 r} 1 ?h9
 BE j8L$, : j4 8 ?)76_% B  )7G}> ' -M4%
=6 `_  ~ ^ )1 N e 3 :$ ~ E4 ~  [1 jD )7_s%
)1 89, L$, ?-l A {[4 j8(,R KL$, ;F 'D
 < 5y  '8(8 8e8D j% ~ ^ j89, 3 s ;-
5 'D 3 re% O$M ~  ,_0UF : 8 #Le  )$
6*> j% 'D , q;FE =9 : #Le  8:> j% C>:
149

~ BP* s 1 j8D> O


r,9
qB> 3 rLe -89> i* ~ : ~ I;
],> , . B- j =rLe -89> ' r: -U ; /%
'%  , L  r>D$ 5^  ,K }  <  
b 4-> u,}> , q*F ' -U } :
j8D> O
,\8%
:
K
4 CE0,U z:1 =$U6 r> 4 Y > % Y$>
 T8B
)1-g> ,W )7,$
_ ,)7,, I  ' 
) k-  8:> z:1 'D W  re% (  A ,L$, _0UF
T8, A 8B>- '  '  )7,I i* 8$IR ' )oE
3 js sO$E =)7,9
r$* j 6B d[ |O _0UF B
~ M4 jF \8_ K, , . k- ks 3 *O 6< 5,
~ 1 z:1 j% rE 6+e jD z:1 # ?7$* j : '
~ > 0
i* :( 3 s ::1- -F C ! 
q:M, 
k[ 8:,
' O, % VB 8 % KU6, % h6+, b-D % `R j%  -E d%
'[ {% 6* jF ,  6 % k 8 p% % e-9} % y-
'D  '  (  A ~ 6( 4 8F b[1 ' -% 4 j8R
'D =81-D '[ 6* i* rLe q Y9: ,{s ' )7:
r$L 3  L reg
r 'D d[ %- ]4% ( 6
 (-
~ _0U% ~0E `D>  reg4 6B ,: reoE 5 r$L  L 3 % ,6%
?   6 A OXe3 i*  6B {6 j8D> j% C % s =~ :}
j8D> j% 6
0E ,: / j% j 6-> O4 ?,> j%  M,
' ~ 8*6 j8D> j% % ,7 eD ,Z % pBF p <% '
jF , 6 A OXe3 /6, % j% C6> 6_ =K7 ;%
d% ,? [1  4 6 A OXe3
rL: n d[ }
150

' )*% -F rLe -,


- '-U '* ?0,U3
r O
r: r>D$,  I ~ e8: b ,* -9 - 87E ;L$ B,e3
=H1Ir
_F 7$8Z

 r  % i* ), j4 d[ 6 8e  ?8 B,3 A 8*6  z:1 1


 Q e8eB : ' 1%  reg
; d% i* )D. UF C8:
i* 4 r,4-> ue4 s r>8 6
r,< N 'D ' nI ;re!;
U6, ), s =r,4-> p i* 6 B> , ,B, CBLe 9X, LD 8 e
t s ,< r>  B_6 <L, 5^ 
re% 6
' 8 6 q 6(
Ve% ' Ve% )1 ;% Y9: K
r -: 6:* ?8g '* c U
~  p8$ F [1 =j8: i* 64 D  1 /% 5y8 reoE :
N 8 e i* 7 _8
),> KL$  1 jF ,+: r j8D 
9
YPE 7( r
j8, O
,wB j% K  ,87} T6  k8L %
 ~  , $+eQ K   O~ P :$1[ 8 e i*  . 
 '* 8y8 V7,:
Y9:> CO4  b[1 =KL$  $w>  j6*
j =jeQ - OE K$,  K : K
d%- 8}
,-L i* _ % 5y '* 8e8D  6
% )1 '[ ,KL$  wB
 : 6> , B-9
?,  -E 4 Y / '* 8e8D  6
%
j89, 3 j8L$  wB q3!1 ,'-U 3 OE r8 rD.
[1 ' , -.  `- j% 'D _ jeQ j%  8I, j% V,
' : j4 ,'6 $ k- N8B ' j4 K , /F  =B
{[ =Ke+$ II '4%  )7y {s ' ~36
j8B  1%
T-e ,. u_8  a6R {s T-e j% g(L i*   j8D '
B-9
K4 : q3!1 $ i* )7LeF j8BLI L [1 p <%
j-} rLe u_8  ,'6 `
)179y ' ~36
  ee
=h! j8B ,  i* '6 $ N8I ' uI
y-

151

 8I

8m / d%-  |. b0   CO T6
j =-L i* N6> l8 $ C0* g
n 3 r$ jF <U
 {[4 Oe q4[  BE # N6,*3 81 $ / 8,
/B$ )7E6  8B ' $> C % ks% % :$ #$E ,N8
b[1 )@6 '[ {% j87L 3 )7E |,
 ,d*  -% dg

eU  B [1 ' '[ : 5^ j8w ,C- ksF
BB. b[1 K
:9
soE =)1 B, i* ,* ' ,? h:
,k0UF KZ b
C%6
8_ 4- j PB E3 5 
[1 ' 4- j N8_% ::D =r_8,e j% :$* K,  ny8 ' joE
  5_8  MD a6 6BE :b[1 :%  L
C%6
B
k9e i*  z:1 ;-EQ M> z8$  6 , /,e3
 [1 ' wE% :% 8,L N z:1 #$E ,jQ -*}
5 
C13 b[1 = ' :e8UQ hI. _0UF K , 
 u_ d% ' ~ 6,  -M4% 87  .   
 ),: ; 4  ( m z8$$  6*8B -L ~ -B>
~ 87L %  ~ 84[ j4 q8  [1 =N8B  z8$
r :
M I} j =q d%  8B
- /6* 81 ~ :y
M 66; 6_ -E ,-:$ ,E3 I; 0
} j8D j% 1
' q ( 4 i* :I %- i* -L
j4 d[ d66. q[.
}  j% r$* `$X -:$ uE3 8 e i* 2]  9
=K  /8* '* / b   l8 $  8I
~ L$,
,p8- 81  hIe 6,> , M 5 * N. 1 O4
' ~36
 =-U hI:$ e6, 4m 3 ,: 3 N8B$ |.  joE
152

_0UF  Q -9> j% ,}: B


 C_9 6;> j%
Lw -*} 1  [1 +,e joE ,8B -*} i* 8B

/,e  7y jDQ


joE Ly %  ,Lw C_9
% j =B %  Q `e( ' 8_ % j 6*8B 5 ( U
84 8 e 7+, j [: u <% 5  k9e d% i* 8_ CI;
_9$ #L:, d% j $+e  6(8 D 3 =6$B> CI; -
'  O
}: [1  ?> , _9 'D =NO*F N  3
d[ $B =r
j7, 3 8 e i* 4 % i* 7 -: 'D
O
 
,6L 81 j8D> O
 ,: 81 i* YL : NO*F 6
VB
  ,~ 6 ~ ; O~ P > 7:D , jQ 8 e 81 j8D>
X< ~ ^ ' e :*^ 7$4 j 1 $+e * j =~ X< ~ ;
:>* N0U ' BE * q;g
/B i* j _ :e% 6 ,-Eg4
/, y-
j8:6 j8_0UF j8:  -} ;5
 
r$* 1  i* $+e u <% 'D =8 : [1 i* 8F 5y '*
h$, e ' N( A c, :  ,{s '* h$, e wL
j
=$+e 5(-> j N8 e V,
,eQ /6B, /% )P6 6 81 jD 4  C jX j

81  wE% -% ?67,  $


B 
5y  O~ P j8D re% 
% /6B,  % -.  ,?- `
,V*6> $
_ 1 ,,
O
F ,- $ ~  O~ P K ,  u =H1IK , 
_0 '* j  a6 , ?8  =rLe q$ L$, C> b[1 u 1
=7:

153

 /B> K ;7E j8- 3 e% i* C:Z -E A ?6


L jD {s  ,nI> oE B [1 ' , C3  -.
`w: 3 d[ )P6 6I 'D =K , /8I ~ L$ ,'  '
' 6* z:1 j8D -. N0U ' re% ,* i* ,-. 81 K ,$
'D=-EF ' z:1 6(8  6B
$B, :D K , 4-
K:3 ' d% 5 h , j% 6B, %6$
j% 'D reF ,'- U
j9$ ~ wBe j8D K. ,$4  =K , ` % -. ` j8D
M 81  -M4% j ;: {s ' - , _F i* 'w, ,C
) =C ' , K
k [1 81   >  /O,10
7E C jX jF ,$D$ )$ V:
 > \ # W q (%
B
-DL ' z:1 6(8 3 =r$4g
k N 1 b[1 =/O, $

' e =9$
V},e  q:M, 
O
,C i* PB +.
5,,> - Cs ue4 )F b[1 j% 6
3 =::*% /% +,: T-e
jD
$ 1 F '
' g+E c- W % s ,<F

js 7E ;. j8:E ' M4   7


5,,> 
,D q-B ?->
= F )% T8_% )*% K. {s  ue4 ,{[4 7Le u$(
, 
 F PB$ Cm % *  ?j u <% h4 'D
) j8F q
 j4 K C
X  j88+, PF 1
j4
' j4 'D ,P 6
 )@6 y 8I_  j8:D _
i* =/6B, -. 5 8_ u,_ C j% K
 F  '
'  ' : L /6B,
K `; 5,, j% 'D ' joE 6 
* : z0, '* h_8, K ?`} [1 h_8, V,E =h_8, )
i* ~  j8D> ' oE ,
 % )% i*  X> 5_ 8 =-L
154

67, d[ C jX jF ,k  N. 1 O4 rLe D}


3 r:D ,s} 8F /-R re =8 w
81 # 
 F )F
, ,
M q2F '* :$ 6B =~  X,e ~ ^ :e% 9S ,X, 6,
j% ' j ; D 6
3 re% n < ;e6(% e
@6>- j4
X,> j% 'D q2F 'D ,j-U L  8 e i* r
0 d6>-
reoE X> z:1 j8D K re% *-e B-9 b[G =:  K>- % -
jF ;- % NO '* -DE % ' ~ _09e # ,X, (F j8D
 $  : 5^ N
i* -9 ' - % NO '* 7Le -DL
::D =H1IT-U% 6 .  : 5^ _ ' ~ 6
VB$> ) 7Le
 66( C* -, 
5:Ie ' :E :X,$ j8$
_ {[4 j86B>
' ,$ j8_8> ' e ;wE% q;g
\6,  ), j% A 7Be ,C3
' , '* :>-DE j% ) ,k0UF  V, )$,    
j% i* )71-4 % '-U :_ ' AF ( 6
hg,> _0UF
,r$* e  81 /6B, # =r$* ' e d[ 8 : i* K 8e8D
* : j = ,  6B> % -M4% :eg
,e :eoE ,#D i* 

:Le% :$( :e% 8 `P+ :$E :e% 'e ' =r$* e  1 -L
 81 -U ; '* ; ?0,U j% V:e ::D ,KG}, ~ ^
r,I;  Be ' r6  A O7: 6 d% b,e uL$ q N% 
04 G 5,, ,   5^ eD % ,r$* k8L> ' -U T6 
% 7E =-[e ]* KI  :6 =O7: d% ' wE% q c,eQ
=`e8 
 D. ' MD V, ,`18 ' MD
5,,>
=/,e0 ~ 66 j8D j% reg; ' - % NO DEF 8_ % q9* j% O4 1
155

 u9*% %  KI$ : `9 . A {s  ` 8


6 A ue4 , C ' <U  8I
 *8 -D $-
)7 : j% 3  :,  K
 F -M4% V, 59, 3 e% * ' 
A {[4 8*6  j ) =L , 
5 L 0L qOD. `B
A -X j%  )7e r
5,, d[ 2,3 81 K:I
p+*Q
8:w j% ,5,+  B* 4  )@6 D wE% 'D 6 _%
`<: 8$,R j% D. ' 6_ ]4% i* 8$I '[ {% j%
{s 8BB '[ : j% 64! ' j N8B> 6_ =9$ ?
)7Le% i* -, 
8E )% 6
3 ,eQ /6B, 8L},4
8 <% 6BE ,#D 81 a6 d[ 'D =W  /6B, % i*
~0<% 'Z )7$* %-9 j4 s ,K: ?3 {[4 8$l ,'6(
4 )7+e  2 6BE =`e(F d6% i* {s j8D j% 6
0E
:*% ,}e  D
$+eQ j8:  r$*  O
/B  N
)1 DE% 5^ j8D> 
,KG}, : 4 8$ j% {[

d% q3!1 joE |,


 ;7Le 6*8B  f
8Dm )748$ 
/ d%-$ 6. /: j =+: [1 O )1 ' K:I
$, eF r$* ue4 d[ ): D} ' :  e 81
-E  n+:> j% -L * : 59,> W  ;KI   
7PO,e $: 7B
8 ' )- i* ,
 % joE ,: [1 6y 7Le
=KI '* T-U% e nI> j% 7$* `$X ?8 , $
( d[  ?I [1 ' j V, 
 % L d[ 
# ?~ :4 ~ q ( #  ' ~ : , ~ q ( 
 F )F $P*
reoE 2,3 6(8 K ;K:I ' ~ 2, -M4% K
 F j% -F
156

8:, 81 {s  ` 'D =r ~  # K ,$ +,e j8D


)F CB9 -EFE =K
 F K
EBM I}  `+
,)* 8:> Cs C   8B$9e ;O~ * ~ E0,U 7w
'* h$,
E 4  j4 re% )  ;_ r -% A 7: 4 d! C  1
,T-UF CL$ )1 6< 5, 3 L$, C   -E '[ ' e%
B
b-4 jDQ
j4 re% 8 2, 8F ' j% '> E 4 ue4
Y-9 6 E 4 m j% 3 ,1 7B-   i* T-UF CL
C-9y ,)P +e d% 2-Z ue4  ~ e T-UF CL /6B> /%
CL 7y-> , 9 8F VB$,> j%  ,> j% A '  5 E 4
r$4g
8 
 %  `e8 6, 6B, 89, j% %  =T-UF
b[1 ' _% ( 6
L, 3  j [: C%6
'D =C  6> A
: 5^ :  (  :I NM 8 e 64g,
/6B,>  =6PL
Ke-L j ,UF )7 r
,4  ,H1IL48>  6 N8B =KG},
 V, r$* 8e4  ~ M4 k8L 6B
~ w
)7w
j87} '
( 6
'D $+eQ i* 7Le 0 Y9> 'D =Y
 
A -E  e-E  ~ y_ j4 =18591805 L48>  #D% 1
6
 =D-%  j8+ P  /:   6 r 2 5 6 , C38
=D-F PwB /: N8 O0 O 2 N8 ~
,4 e O8*
'4E 8 D42"'# 87} r
,4 `,4 qwB ' NB,  L48> 'D
b 6< 8E YB =1840  M 6< 1835 /*  NF q  6<
j% 6B,*% =- 13 5t 6_ j4 1850 /* N8$
re% (  A ,~0P1 ~ 1+e
Q '#2 OP$ j8:
UF r>8:  rL% d[ r
,4 A :1 } 
=1856 *4>
157

N8B ,H1Ip,D [1  _ ' G C67},  -BE  =MD


T8_%
 K23 OF eQ 89,$ K23 '-% z:1 j u81 j8E
' e=h_8 8:> -.  ,~ w
)7w
'* j8L$, :
?- j =6$ [1  /8 '* ~ 8 _:, O7: M -F j% 0e
~ 8 nI> ,)I; D}> ,-EF L$, CB9
Z ,
q% *O,(3 CL ue4 Y
  =6 ,  8I
$O, /8 '*
W8* r$* Y$9e j% 'D OE > L$, '7 C*:I 'D
=4 (  A rLe W X}> oE . u_8  % ;L$,
A j8, ,7Le q;F j%-B j ) N8Be e  8I

8 e )7E )\ r(8,> ,7Le '4F A j81[ ,7Le q;F


=164g, 7Le  ,7Le C-. k8B. )@6 ,7Le q;F
CE0,U3
e B q
u 7:D ,h_8  4 k-E z:1 >
CX, 5^ =~ -, N   `[, c6e3 j% O4 =uL,U ,
i* `$X re% i* ,c6e3 [1 i* 5+}> . u_8   
)$,$ 5 8> 4 =i*F
 VeF 5E-> j% CX, b[1 5^
 6B )79 4} C-! uZ : 5w )$, jF ,{s 2 
 C: , j% O4 =-*} YPB $ / j  A N8<8 i*
qB$ T8, i* 5 N0U ' c6e3 ' 2 > C0<8 P 
5 YE6, <8 ,6
'4%  j8:9B '[ : K
}
 +,  23 L
2 , re% O4 =-U jD ' _Q  CX,$
?- C  _ ds ' 5 % k9e i* : N0U ' *:I
=132 )_  LI  1
158

?61F b[1 i*% V, 89 ?61% 5^ n,E N0U ' ,R-
B9    8> 3 L> 3  - j% 
, E: /%
 Y  5^ ' V, T8_% 1 8_ z:1 =CB9 5 Oe 7:

i* / d%-$ , :\ 1 , :


K
/ r
}, a6
' 6*   6(8 j4 =T-U% - j6$
 6$ [1  6
1 ' G KD, ;F u:D , ~ *O,( 2  `<:
  B -DE j = 6,
F )G u8 'D ,-MD d%
N8B* ' -M4gE -M4% L, ,  r j% u
M ' j8D K , 87
,/,e3 /6 *O,( )* d% h_8, |,
 =K$ K 
:1 i* 7Le 1 > $E *O,( 8_ % h_8,> re% V:

q 5 ,> , N8 q  i* 7, 5w> jg


), ,-MD
= 87 N8
Cg, ' * $,4 D} p F b[1 5^ j_ j
j% 59,> h4 T-e j% `I ' j% (  A -L * :$ 
j% 'D ' nI W  6 , 
8I
{s L, =7_8
L,Z
j%  ' j% T- j% ,7,B
-} 87 ' 4[ q  +e
j4 8 V, 
,'F 8 e 'D> W j V, ,CE0,U z:1 j8D>
* : Cq* 64g> e % s =%8 F 8 e % jF 
 6
~ <% -L
 6
% N   dB c6e3 jF ,j 81 u_8 joE 0
[1 6y  (e *E CO+1 % '; 'D 3 =NO,43 '* j8D
5^ nI j% -L d[ `$9 j =-D -  3 /8+\
j% A B z:1 'D> W soE =r$* T[X, O
8: : KG} :
159

5^ i* '2 vg ,~ -B> 6 ),: e A ~ -B> . N8 ,>
'6 '* 6
% i* rE ],
> : [1 '* h$, , C8:,
  K =9$ L E % i* V, 
,k0UF
i*  _  V, *
nI> oE ,8:, 67}> j% j : E
=b 8I>

160

9$ %6> '% ?rLe i* -L  N 6. ,js ,81 
 ,-L$ 7II X: , eeQ . 6B 81  ?5,+
?5,+$ I 6B 81
8F O7: D C-E8> s  r,I VB$, O7: 6 4
' q  {s `,: j% X: -L$ =8I r( i* r ,
j% X: 5,+$ =P- ( 6
-L r
),@ d[ eeQ .
=P  8I
5,+ )@ d[ q  `,:
z:1 j8D> ' re% )  ,6B* i* # g, W 5,+ j% )
3 ,r: *O,(3 C ,3 0,    6B* U3 T6(
b[1 
B  q
5,+ [\ '6 5,+  VB$, ; 4 j%
rE j8} 5, -E j N8B> , -+ BB. j% O4 ,L:
8 e z8$ ' K
~  ,$ -E 4 j8D j% /20 ' 
nI
Q /6* 81 NF :'-% ' z8$ [1 hg, =B
` : <U nI
Q /6* n<F i* % ,~ w
)7w

)1L, N0U ' % n 8e_ e N0U '  k8B 4 7L:I>


161

%6 N0U ' b66Z ), d[ rI:


-L /_ 81 M =:w
  rB>* i* 5B> , C w, NO*F ' hI: N*
5,+ j8D =Bw TsF 6y b-E% '* % 5,+ '* E6
`: j8R '[ {% p i*  b[1 -E  Y i*
-E NE% j8D> O
=r$* 5,+$ 28  4 [1 # =G qE8
$> j% j ,)7.I  : *- A -B,L> % ,'-U s! K
`_e j% N6 ' ], . b[1  =,
M )7_8B k- 7$ ~ 6
dF j8D  =j8eB N0U ' # 'D ,d%- N0U ' h
5,+$ joE '-U nI i* $ -% -L ?> ' q (
j4 s O
 N! % =z8$ [1 k8E I,U3 0<
reoE 84[ z8$  U6,   2 , 3 % 2 , / nI
' $ % %  Q N z:1 # 'D =B:$ ~ 8,L ~ *8y8 nI
q:M, 
-U ; d% nI i* -L z8$ -! 3 K B [1
)1 s 3 '-U i* r48$ -! jF t  z:1 j8D 3 K % ,rLe
;% )1 5y8 [1  ;F 5^ j% ,* i* {s  %

[1 ' , C3. 5^  =)7L ' ,


6B
j8,, j8X

,*O,(3 e8eB K,: ' ,> - z:1 j8D> j% X: B
=`_8 N8_ L
/B$
%6 re% Le j% %6 [\ D )7L q8 _ ' j8D
j8,@ 3  j% *6e j% ,eeF ' 5
: a43 /6
),
, 9 NO*F
)7Le% 8$X} j% X: 3 ~ w
)7w
z8$

j ={s   $I )\ ue4 s 3 '-U 


 j-U G /8B
162

6  87  Be d% A # * 2 A 8*6> (.


' Y$9: 3 d[ jQ j ='-U U  , eeF #
 )7Leg
q:,*3
: :_Q  i* -M j% 59, ee% 5E
-U :e =H1Id2+ % -. V:
{s j4 q8 ,'0 
3 F  7B 3 ;C[
/O,13 PwE jg; ' $B ;
7 ' =7  /6_ i* 'D> W j [1 ,*O,(3 PwL
reoE )$, V, 'D =~  K*8: '[1 2  % , ( 6
)$,
5 ;/ Q N0U ' L O$M :_Q :,_3 N0U ' b-% YBR
C[
q:,*3 PwE -X 68  joE )$, $- q7,e
6* j% jeQ i* jeQ Y ' =:_Q :,_3 N0U ' 1
)7: 68 5+} j% ,K ' X   ~ w
)7w
:
~ w
)7w
8+} j% X: =X z K , j% i* bU%
)1-*} r(8> 2 ,$ )D$    2 i* $ % $4 j
i* ,qB. DEF ' ~36
D. DEF 8F 8 e )7E61%
*^ % -L YR 3 'D =7wL j% ' ~36
jeQ _ ' 5E- 8 e
i* r>  rL:  L 3% r: `$9> 
-U je i*  j%
9 .
~ O,1 : -M4% j% {s ={[ 81 b , d[ 8 :
),> , C3. q:M, 
 ;rLe } {s 81 K }
} {s 
-U ; d% /O,1 joE 8_ I; C_0

' j4 j rL: -B } ze j% K


~ _-E z:1 j N8B j%  6- 1
' % j8eB
 r$* Xwe j% K
 , -g
/B '* 5:, j% r wEF
=-F {[
/B '* 5:, *O,(3 Xw N0U
163

r
5,+ /O,1 j% O4 ;rL:
} /O,1 A B
~0y ],
-4[ 3 /O,1 81 '-U 8 e r48$ q:M, 
-EF 6% b ,*

(- j4 O7E =H1IE- `e( z:1 ) =S  *  8I



b-*} , E-$ ~0 je 4 T6 joE * %- % ~ *
j% 6
3 |,
=-U ; d% T6  % B 3 O
k8L> rE-l
OE rE61% } [1 )D i* `$X,   5,+ U6> j8D
i* # ~ : U6, [1 j8D j% 6
3 ,b j C[
81 rI
LI
: N8 * CyE i* Oe b6 r
<U E-
A \% ' U  CyE3 b[1 j8D> j% 'D =*
U  8I
Y9> j% n(- ' joE   < j8D> K V, ,1-U
d6% i* 6 ; i* ), Y9, j% 3 =-L C3. 
=. ?-l N8 MD j8E- 3 )7E |,
 ,'-U ;%
' q  [1  81 -L * :  ` : N+ joE |,

j% ~ w
)7w
8 e  z8$  d  ' =eeQ j8}
j% : rE 6B 8 e i* jF `$%   6*8B *- j8D>
Y ' joE rLe } OE 'D ;)1 ,e
j8D s 8$
8y- j% '-U 28 'D =-.  O
5,,> j% -L r,PB$>
,rD%  r>6* A - eg, DEF  r$* 89Xw 
r$*
OE UF )D. 81 rLe }  'D ;r>  8B> i* .
Ve% 1 -[ ,  I: 6y 7D>- j% 'D q9U% % =rI

=U6, {s 7$* :e j% 'D , E- `e [1 1


164

, 8F
r  b6B,
'-U O i* `>  ' MD

=r.I % j-
3 rL:
-L q:,*  $ % 6. `e8 j% :*% 3 e%
soE =~
8- 3 ~ :D #  =r '-U -e  -!> j% \ X:
reoE ,bU r,L:  )1> , CLI ' dg
~ E- } j4
. b[1  j8D reF ,  b[1 ' p+* ~  : ~ E61 ],
4  8I
-B,L j4 s =eeQ 9$ |M NOD A ~  ~ -_
=p+*Q #D* j8D, 8 e : -*} joE 6. CLI A
 : % 6, k[ r$* Y$9e j% 'D  6_ ,Y. ' 6_ z:1
] 3 j4 j 6_ 81 , 6 A * M , [1 j% )
~ E61  :  8I
  
r$ re% 3 ,r6 d[ } q[
rE 6(8> ; d% ; B,0 ~ E61 E-9, C3.  , 8L:$
r6 j8D> j% 6
3  : 8B
k[ ' 8: [\ w CLI
3 ,-U ; d% Y  ~ 9 } j8D 3 O
=-*} b[1
;B-9 b[G r$* )D e jF :E6 8 e i* ?, j% 'D ' j%
joE ,7:  `- j% 'D BB 81 8} )D. [1 j% 
j% r, $I ' j8D {[4 =~ B {s ' b [ e j% r, $I '
j8D  =r48$ L
\ rLe -
 `_8* % ' b [ e
 - -M4% 8 e i* :$ / 6B> 6 b[1 j% 8 ~  ~ -% 64g,

j% 8 {[4 ,. u_8  z8$ p  )1L r


n>
,g9U i* r: re% A eg
-U ; -e uL$ j% } 6B

' 6
: YR re ) =pF $_ % ~ E } {s ],e j% j
165

uDe j% j ,K ;  $ :% i* q:


?,e j% 
Ve j% K $
 ' e NM  i* =:,-E  O
'D r,-E
:eF ,~ :$* r :
:,( -,  j 'D r:+,e j% : YR ;r, I
,Y. : =)1 ' -M4% )7$B,e '[ :  < ,U Y
5,,e
' n(-
re% 'e :4 s r: '-U [ e j%  ,:( ' V, O

=re8I ' i* q -% s j8D j% rM6. n(-
% r,$4; i* )1
'E ,6* )6B, :E> uZ L$, CeD z:1 j8D> K
81 8IB j4 s 3 ,r>6* i* '-U 6* wLe j% 'D
6
D j% 'D L$,  b[1 N0U ' =' , i* r>6*
3 r 3 q9U% `
'-U d6% i* ~   _ C
8B* }
`_8* 1 ,*
3 C
8B b[1 6
D 3 r:D ;S  8I
81
B 6IB
~ 6*
r$* 5B> F # ,7Le q9U e 
59, 3 d[ , 3 : e8*- -7 d[ } =r$* pB
rLe w j% 59, 3 d[ ,y8, CeDQ 'y  j%
i* e8. C[$ q  V d[ , s! C[$  OXe3 '*
-: j% 5_8, j% r 6
3 } [1 ,B 8} C[$ p
~ $_ r j8D j% ,e -e : r
# ;8 )1-*} ' 0
2,3 N0U ' )8 Y ,  s 3 5y8 [1 ' D,} j% Y r
i* N8I.  Y. |,
`,4 ,*O,(3 r>_0*  
=rLe G  ,  B-9
-g, 3 Y 81 ,7$wL
6*
' q  {[
Y$, OE :  81 reg}
N(% d[ -F j
nI i* -! 3 } n< d[ I} z8$
166

-, j% X: , 68 CBw joE ,r )_0*  '-U


NEF % =r '-U e '* ~ 6
% 7$IE 'D 3 , 8F 1 \
k8B i* d6, j =~  L$, $ `$9,> oE '-U
> ,
,r :
Y r(  i* )G  U % Ts% d% B % ,'-U
)7: L, 3 % )\0X,  % ,,  )7} % )7$* p[D %
b[7E ,TsF 6y )7:* E6 '* eF :,3 V, % ,Y r( j
7<  9 C3.  ,_0UF B,e0 n$I> 5y8
~ 1%
~  E: 1 BE NEF b[1 u =_0UF q  pB$ 0
1 ,7 d! d[ L: 6, 3 59 {[4 Oe ,k0U
= B,3 T8, A I 6 A 7$* *3 28 8%
81 d[ 6. ,89 q8  TsF ` ,`$B 8_ j
,k6I /6* kL: ,1-4 1-M4% 5,+$  h8 -M4%
,'-U i* -9 ` ,rE  q, 3 ,rE8, ' `wX
j8ee8 r  81 ` D ' q- I ' -M4% 5^  -
,j-U YL K -L
8} ,5} d% TTo
% -M4% 1 r , 8F r>s j% ' 7<  , eeF
{; 6(8 , P 5^ r.I -B r$ , ,16*  4 '
~ 1-D ~  ~ I; 7< '  ,_0U% Ps b[1 :g}

~ B
 1e-4s , q9UF i* Y9: 3 [1 =_0UF : '
,Y_6 V:
_0U%  ~ 8% u b[7E ,rLe A q- -e L4 N8
~ e1-
j8D> O
=6; T6 '* -: ?
hy `e8( D}> 3
/ I} -D A B,E3 % Y. ' q}e 6_ d% i*
167

k-U i* ,}> K 3 _0UF eQ / $,> 3 7:D ;C[


} [1 :, j% ` )7$(% ' '-U ;% 8 e `(8$
t 8F ' # :Le% 8 e C( r$* Y$9e  j =rL:

~ *O,(  $
`(  * j ={[4 '-U 8 e C( A ?- 7,8 s 3
C[ / :> ,EI. ?0U q d% :> K ,rLe 8 e q-
'[1 '* '-U /% ~38 ; d% ], 3 ;C[ -89> %
='-U /%  nI O7:* ` R j% 'D 3 reF ,'-F
i* } b- j% 'D -% 81 , ,*3 j6BE K
, j
eQ K
 ,I} -D % EI. Be N0U ' Y
rLe
- # , [1 ,'-U k8B i* re6* 
B 7B , ,
{s b :48$  e-*}  P1 k-E A d! 87E =L 
,g}
r$* -9 :B ' j% 'e 8%  : q % q8 ,}
,: q % joE =-9 {$>  : Y 3 re% )$e 8%  : q % %
} '* :Leg
Tg:e j% 'D ' ,:P,  '* ]e j% 'D '
:e% [1 V: # 'D ;: d[ q '* : q d[
~ <% re% T-e j% :eg; ' =k9> 3 r> +e jg
j89
 , 0
r>  q8 ' r> 6E% s =L re% % r9U i* pB 4
 `-e j% ' ~36
 :{s ' -M4% r> 6Le jF :E6 ' [1 joE
`:+, h4 r Ke jg
,r,
8B* hL N e :eoE ,r$* pB B
'D : :
=r48$ L
rI> j% `$X ,   %
% `wX # 'D , 8L: O
 ,BL; 5y8 j8D j% } b[\
j% 'D -% %8 % ;5,+$ 6* reg4 r$e ' ;66} q, 3
168

L: 9
U6,e W j [1 ,reg; r4e j% 81 r
/B :LeF ]e
8 ~  ~ L$, h_8 j8D =r$* Y$B % r
/O,13 7l N0U '
% -E  8I
q8 ,r: '-U O. 20 6*8B i* T6> re%
i* Oe r$* . b[1  5B> 3 rEF  `_8 j =*^
j% r$* - j% ,b-E% 5 ~  r,LI
,5,+$ 6
3 ;'-U
j% *- j% 6
3 ,E  i* r pB4 R  8I
WF r
5_8
8 e i* ~ 66; WF j8D
~  } [1 ], . b[1  =?4
% B-9
[L:e j% Oe ,r$* )D e j% BE # |,
:$* ,:D 
# B
 .  re% K  ;:Leg
be 6<% d[ :D T-Ug

' ~ y-* ,: j% 'D  q:M, 


r$* Ts% d% 5_8e j% e  '
=G r ne , -. Cs < :e8; ):>  :6, 

 q  K
, e 6B
j% : ' M4 -D:
O
='-U )@ d[ q  K
 ,b8 ~ 6% )@ 3 d[ }
j8D j% 5,+ -E% 6% z8$ ' q ( dF 'D h4 :q3!1 N8B
;~  N  ; 6(8 3 ?'-U -EF ' a4 /6* 5y8
E dg
/8B j% } i*  , '
9U  8I
rL: s!
r
K9>- ; _F i* Ts% z:1 j8D j% j P %
 ~ L$> a6% soE =)7:* ~ 6
j8B '[ ;F i* ~ 
 % S  8I
7: j8L,: d[ {% ds! {[
reoE ,r>D$,
` j =5,+$   8 $B> A   d! ,S
t  reoE $B % 6 r> 6B TsF
'[ {% 5^ i* ~ S a6

+ Oe ,` E [1 # =) ' 6_ d%  r$* j6,


169

;*  8I
 :
' re8U A C6 )6B> i* _  rLe
-D> -M4 s ;)7_0U% /-4 % )8 i* ~ * nI j% 'D '
j% g; ' j8D ' `D>-> L d% joE B [1 ' d[ z8$
=L>  -M4% $ / 8+ ' $B>
L
'-U ~ S Ts% ` } 'D W s ,~ U%
 : N0U ' Ts ~  {s 5  reoE ,r>_ % r$Ps
j% 'D '[ {% nI ,rLe w
/ $  j% X: ,G /8B ,
=r
j8$ % r48$ A j-: K )7$w % )16L
i*  z8$ `_8* ,B> j% 'D ' j4 8 V,
;F @ j% 5,+$ X: 0E% ,rLe EX % - -L
~ 1% 8 )% ny8 ' '[
~ ^ YL,e ' e ?)g; )74 r 0
5,+ #% |,
;)7Le% ' XI NLF  X: re% i*
j% )7Le% )D i* {[4 j 6B 3 '[ KX O
M
~  $

N8 % : 


Q % -D
% OB j4 s ?)7Le% S )7B
 g; ,} 'Z 4 D}
Y> 
   %
3 sO$E ,j8eB 1-R , 7 % NEF ' M4 jg; {s
: ' 'D 6. A {[4 NEF b[1 uD j8eB V
NO4 ' 8:4 ,/ d%-$ X: 3% ) ?*O,(3 eDQ $
):> i* _F i*  j% ,j8eB  7: 6
3 , 8IB `e8(
i* *O,( C
8B* 
Y9 j% Ps- b[1 6y 8_  -
`e 6B> 81 :1 8y8 # ?7, O
KE- ;F
66( p  i* T- , C3  r(  Y-9 6 % d-L
170

, 8F q:M, 


. b[1  5: q z:1 # =}  $<%
u,% 8% 1 . u_8 V, W 6
[: u:% u
- (
z:1 j8D> j% 6
3 =; d% -L  : % 6L  % 
-+,
% _0UF YPB. T6 ,* 16
'D ] ' 6_ :2 E
8_ j N8 e j% 81 :1 rBe  4 =,
 BB % i* LI.
=)7B ' uD$1% , 7Le 8\  ( 6
(

-! j% 'D rL:


q- r_8 d[ TsF j% ~  ?*% :e
-! O
 ,)7.I )7L> N0U ' r,$P* -E% i* X
 8I

z8$ N0U ' q- 5E6 K =*  8I


5,+ i* _%  8I

% K ; 8 e r(8 ny / , k-U A B [1 ' d[


C[ /
< NEF E ' ~ q ( 8 3 8y8 joE ,-M4%
~
_ nI
s :NM  i* =$D$ 6  V:
_0UF e 0
? +,e % rLe y i* r> 6_ /6 +,e ,} n<%
i* % r,$P* i* kLeQ '* ~ (* % ,re8 6 '* ~ (* ,-[,
 ` 'D ;r$* pB B  c- 3 Y
j6 reoE ,)$,
rE `
# ,r:P 8 e % r,$P* 8 e r(8
r0U  81 r
B*
)\ II j8D> j% X: j4 ,  8 u8  s =b-[>
t , 
, _0UF ! joE ,EI C OM, 3 -M4%  u6
' N i* N8I $ r* ,_ H1IN8t e 

c 8( j% 3 =7Le 1
>  d[ ,N8t e 

c 8( N8 6> e9-


 8}e% 6_ D z:1 1
r$* B B% ) =7$  )P- ' ~ 6* `D>  C8 T6o

=
d $+eQ  `>D #,_ =/6*Q
O7$* )D r,B}* i*
171

M
bI joE r
<U 4S q}eQ r* ,_ 8 r:D ,r,B}* (%
=Y:} 81 j8D
r,$P j . ( ` K a6. M4 81 -U NM
;b8 ( % r>8_ i* 
8, Y , joE , C* i* reQ
C* >
r,$P j . ` re% 8 rLe 6B
{s Y , O
r:D
 ' WF `> C b[1 ue4 s ,s 6
@-4 u
4 =I}
- )D
)7,  r$* j6, '[ % ,)7
'-U nI ~ 8* `(8 /3
,  YL '
/3 {s ' T8_% `(8
{[ ~ *8E6 j8D j% j )1-*}
j8D reoE ,C[ wL> )D
b ]  r48$ j8D j% j %
i* # ,kLUQ {s i* *3 _0UF q, 0 ~ yU
j8D> j% 'D , b6 r$* ,B> , q9UF L
# r
t  K ,M
=kLUQ {[ 6
' r,E 6_
' rLe ; 6B

,: 8 e r$* `> 6m `( q% '* ? e% z8$ N0U
re84 -+ ; d% `_  3% X: =*O,( `e[
~ e[ j8D reoE
q:% -D d[  % d6: _ X: 'D ,-D  
8_8
6m -9U % ,6m z:1 j8D - 4  , I,U
=
k9e ' c- wB joE , 87 i* % -EF 6% i* q8 , 
=j8eB % k0UF k9e  5y8> -.
 > % #$ 4(   6> ~ 6% 7$( D. b[1 8$ c 8(
/*  NF 7y-* j4 ,r> -7;% u <% 6_ =N8t e 

c 8(
=1731
172

r$* Y$9 j% 'D  % a.  -+


Y$, OE 'D
t d[ :w 
k- 3 z8$ N0U ' 5,+ i* -L r_8
r:
; d% i*  5_8 % 87 8 e 6m `( d%
r$Z 5,+ 59, 5y 81 n-  5y8 [1 :rLe q:M, 

i* KX _ ' 6


3 j4 s =jeQ -. )*F  nI
)1 )7.I {s ), j% wE% :eoE ,)7Leg
)$ q:,*3 /6*
86B j% i* ) 6_ _* K
 )7:
N8 e j% ?6G # )7Le%
% j% 59, % 3 ::D =G ~ B r j% *6 3 5E: 5,+$
A ?w b-E% 5E- P  {$, 3 5,+ jg4 wB +

 ~ 48$ )7: 68 `D>- K 3 0B z8$$ d 


_0UF % e8eB k-9
q8 r$* pB B ) ' 0B*
' NF q  $ )7$* B$9 9$ {$, 5,+ j4 ={s `

j% 7E N  7$D


B1- 8L9 E r% ue4 ;)
81 |.   j =)  0B z8$ i* ' _ )7$
 G - , ?- 4  ` 6,  )D , d[ 6
V7,:
j8,,  [1 q:
%  j% 59, 3 re% n < =B
j% O4 ;D.  A e m  8I
-B,L rLe 81 reF , D.
;~ +e 1-M4% 1 O~ P u ,-L C3.  ,b87( wE% +,e
wE% rLe M ~ U
D4 ;:   j% i* ~  _ r:D
~ $_
-+4 j8*-* b-E% ' 4 6* d% 5,+ z-> s =r: 0
0B ,*3 N0U ' )7 , ), j% i* j 6B 3 ,NL%
i* /8$ Y , d[ 81 rLe 5,+ joE ,(F $8 `_8$
Oe )$, C9$ 5+
BE # 5,, d[ 5,+ j =+,:
173

i* 87 ' N8B d%- 9$ O~ P 7  , :\


{[4
d[ ;)7Leg
)D $ 0< : _% )1 '[ {% N8B*
i* 7*B j NR j% 'D 3 , 9 C
8B 6*
5,,
[1 ;)8E- '[ B, q,  )7Le% i* j8$ '[ {%
9$ A c,R reoE {s 4 `e( A re% * 6 j% r 28 3 5,+
1 ,-E I} j!}  *9 -E -F 6<Q
N6 f 5^ A ~ :,  ,7E -B 0< j8D> j% X: j!;
# =`_8 8$ , j% )7$* K, '[ {% d6%  , 
g,$  wE% R q j% b ' -M4% r$* `$X q z:1
V '[ {% K
' =N8$. %8 % A q8+$ ' z8$ i*
d% )7E j4 s ,N6,* % EI
?, i* )71-4 A 5,+
64g,
)oE ,$B, 9}: I} ' rLe 8: ' ;%
jg
~ 6
% $4} b[1 i* ; d% -} ' =: i* j-,
r$* -9
Y. )\ re% O$M re!;  r$* -9
Y. '-U
i* 0* re% i* 87
{s ],  ;)!;  )7P[ ' b8:
/8B  ,*  9$ b[1 r(   j% *+}  
{s i* NM4 =~  5,+ r
b-g  #D
-:$ ,L$ :$*  8I

pB*%  ,H1IM  }> {$ 67*  5_ d[ ?Q e -4s%


i* 8-4 -L% >% A8,  ,e9-
 $1F p-. ' C8: 6
1
= 87^ A 0 88 ,r % 89_ NF  }> {$ 8$U ,9$
 5, C[$ i* 8_ ~ 8_ r*>% 81 -E '6}, ' 8-4 j4
 }> 9,  C3m 6* 6
 1658 /*  8-4 E 6
 =e9-

= =1660 /*  ~ D$ c8> e9-


-* ,  NF  }> '
 M
174

 8I
 =j, 8 K-79, T6 V*F _0UF `I,
j-U @6 ,  6B ' 5,+  A (. N8 NB
6B j% n < :N8_% ,C[$  OXe3  : )748$ N0U '
; ' 6B b[1 ue4 s ~ <8IU ,U -% \ j8D 6_ 
=q8
rLe 81 pI 3% ' eI.
5,, '-U q8 L
*L$ O~ * Ts% ` re% rE L z8$ '* j a6 ,e ::D
'[ 59, h4 )$*% 3 ,'-U TsF ` j% j rLe
 8I
6
3 6B j%  DL, ' )7Le% 8: j% {[
j8:!
 z8$ d6> K 6B jF ,  ' -M4% 5L: YBZ j% *
5^  7E L , :7 % ! `_8 {[4 d6> oE
=N pB VB$> z8$ [1 j% 8 7:* ,:> j% ~ -B> C3.
} z8$  87 U6, w6 +. T8_% 'D
~ E 87 U6, K re% 1 ?
jg
~ 8_ ~3O, z:1 joE 0
B$, 8F LE = jD  U B-9
), U6,
-9 $F d% joE '-U 8 e `(8 d% *O,(3 k0UF

Y$, OE reF ,g9U i* re84 ' -M4% p8< i* j8D j% r n(-
8I
)DR j% 3 87  L 3 B [1 ' , P

d% 'D =K z8$  O


O   r.I i* > 
B$, P 8I
$_F i* j8eB4 -L K $ $%
* ,j8-79, 7y-E , 8B VX% C[$$ ~ m M  }> j4
~ L 12 `+e% CB} ' ~ 6* [  ,C[$
$ 
 0
=*S
175

;p8I A r: g9 A p-_% j8D j% ~  r n(- v[ z8$

N8F '%  : B [1 ' , C3.  / d%- jF
; :
g9U 81  p8< 81  N8 K: e% d%
87 jF ,V: [1 V, r j8D 3 M4 j%  re 
;'-U
{%  % ,
/O,1 Ve% ),@ 3 < r>0wL,
3 ),@ 3
z8$ d% j% j6B, : ' M4 z:1 =)748$ i*  '[
~ 2 L,  b ,*
r: jq, ,)7LeF q  81 Oe re8+

t K N_ re% ~ : KI, 6% '* ?-* 6_ =)1-*}


q 2
)
N0U ' b-*} j   : q3!1 j '-U :6 -*}
81 r%-
} 8; 'D !@-D )6B* % )* i* )1 
t #
;d%- {[
'! reF q, 3
-} -U ; 8; M4
t u r(  r,L 
L,3  }  j% O$M
 M4
M ,r
 reg; 81 ; d% ks j =7$* s8 , 3  $
z ~ M ~ 87^ , j% ; d% i* 7 ' =r,Lm % r%
,je( \ 6(8 , P 5^ OE ,U3  ~ -% -EF
 ] r:6> d[ z8$ Oe% '* :,3 3 )7$* -L 3
8F i* B [1 ' ~ 6 5y ~ 87^ T% : ' 'D =$}
 ]  r
87 X} V, [: ?7$*  ,
 -DL  ~ e reoE } z8$  87 U6, K ?$}
i* 8} % ?,
; d% /_ '* >:  L T8 q d%
 81 84[ )D.  j% 3 = 87 {s '* h$, 8 e
' P
j8> 6% i* VL D 3 Y_ p+ U ry-
% '6 q0 ' re% i* _0UF C-: p <% K_0UF 5^
176

-}e :eF ,p8< i* 8F j% 81 ~ :$* r 6,


j88B  =L$L
z8$ Ke8_ '* :
8$_ :8B*  ,Le j% : j8$9 )1 ={[4 %
t
L j% KD 87 59, sOE='-U : 5 :  $
 N8 I} b-*}  j% CO$, b[1 Y9> T8
i* y-L   7$ j% ,\8 N8B ^ z:1 j4 s ,
?: 5^
: ' BE 6(8 ~ S # :1 r ;% d[  j
/8B  i* $M% r p% j% : f B 5_8, j% 'D ' ;-:
i* 76B> r>0wL> #$,
6$ [1  |.   87 r

_0UF 8} CE- e N8 ~3B `,4% 3 e% =_0U% Ke8_ %


i* y-*  8I
r}_e% j% ' ~ M4 )1% 8y8 81 ,~  8(8
~ E ::D =ny8, 
K
%  ,$MF 
-* A (
0
_ N% 3 :e% ,$* 9U % r r
de% d[ %6 j%
Y- '* K
% j% `I ' # re ) = S r(  (
~  z:1 j% $MF ' M4
81 , T6 N8 5;% T8_% ' 0
I T6 A _0UF  r$* Y$9e j% 'D  6 5 8>
 * % i* ~ 6
% ?0U 3 , C3. _% i* d6, A
q9*  IL [1 ' B
  Le X;g  =I} -. N
={s i* $M%
p F : G -} , q6 -*}  -:: q6
ds f

:6 )1 h$, '[ ;F j% i* )7y* i* 6 > 3


)1 8:,  ~ <8IU ,-P; ' )1 re8 O  j8 O 3 )7:*
177

# re N8_% {s i* ~ * ~3M f B 9*F =)7: )D


)7Le%
' -M4% K$ T6 ~ 8Le `  )1-P; % K  6B* 
-: , NEF ' 4 6* z:1 # =- : ). j8$4g )84
j8$ r
-}  k8L 2 B, ' 6B
j8
 F j8  7
 /-m - : ). 4% j ~3% =8 6  B-9 b[1 b 2 B> '
-m -E ;r*8e 3 66} 8L: (  L 3 [1 'D ;)7:
3 )7:D ,- pS 28 3 reg
K$ 5^ '! ,)7:  {[4
7 ). ' )1 8Le joE {s 
B  =2 B,$ M ],
, +: j% ,* i* ,d -X 8L: M ,LI b[G ), +:
{% T6 V, 2 B,$ M O~ P 6> oE , 8}  ~  -X:> K
z:1 =, E: '* j8D  6
% I} )* ],> '[
 1-e , +: -DE  8(8 8B b[1 i* -:$ uL$ NM
j L: =6:\ T6 ~  8_ 1 , :6  +: -*}
O /6* i* j )% ,K$ ' r$1% -M4% 6$
 e :e%
 66 q
[1 j8D ' =6$ {s 6 'y - : ). 4g

d%-$ _0UF 9$$ *   {s ],e 7E =H1IK$ 0

1-E% 5,, , $B b[1 ={s i* ~ , ~3M d8


- E  ],> 1
t
>% d% : j6 8e4 '[ -L e ' 1 ,    6

p- A 8$< K =K$ ' ~


-1 )10
' -E '[ ,u; 2
t ,6:\
u_ K =-B ). 4% '* 8:, j% 9S 6:\ /D )G _
-L
N8B i* j8$ YE ,K$ )D uZ {s 6
Y: b[1
9$$ * 6  j4  j% d% =- : ). 4% '* 8:, j% 9S
=
j8:, [1 :8 A 8:\ -L N  3 ,)7E $<g,  n<%
178

- : ). 4% j ?{s  ` 81 OE ,{[4 'D> W s ?/


/-m re% k6I
j8:! 81 = 87 [\ :
~ 2 B L
],
79y3 ' ~ *8e 5: [1 ,* 59,e 3 -U `e( ' = ' b-D
`
~ 79y j8D ' r:D ,g}:  ' ~ : j8D O
=:6
=- : ). 4% r*>% i* -L ' 6(8 3 re% ,* i* ,'6
87 j% 81 5: [1 e r$(F 'D d[ 68 N8B `
=)7I , >[ C ,*3 -E } k[
r jg; 3
 * j% j F ) ], =: ~ -_ -U ~3M pg
; Y  -PD ]4% ' n -L4 1 {8D B-  i*
= Q p i* T-U% B- dg
 * 87+$ 28 3
i* BE # '6 N( c2 A 
 % p8:(  : 5^ -:
A -B,L  79 /6* i* 3 {[4 ], Oe ,'6$ h re%
b[1  ue,>] d% j8D hDE =2 B, 2 ;0 ~ M _8
s 'D ?7$* {8D  b-4 m  ,~  _I -*}
3 , 8F  ~ w
7w
-  U6,  Y i*  ue4
b[1 ,  +7:  8I
'D  % d% iE ,'-U nI #
re],  5:  )7, i* : /8$ j% 59, ' % ?C3.
?jeQ  r,B ~  ~ -%

~ y-L # c  :,3 [1 j% )  =- : ). -B ). 4% '*
 ],> k  ; 8_ '  5 `,4 re% 3 ,)7:  )7$*
=h! '64
179

6 L ' ], q d% 5: i* 6,$ + z:1 u


 C O b[1 u4 A *6 +. ' T8_% I} _0UF
Y9: V:,e jF 6,  i* 'De W  ;C-  ' ], '[ K*%
6
0E ,g9U i* )F '-U 79y : 28 re N8Be ,'679w
=:$* Y9e 8 )$ V7,: b],e j% :eg; ' %6 N8_ ' [ e
j%
,r$m   *3 j4 j ,$MF b[1 i* 6%  O

/ d%- jF ,::
g}:> j% 'D 3 h_8 ' B, % ,* i*
j% % ,: /8. 4% '* :,3 -L j% r n(- 3 e9-

,)7(2 /6* % )7(2  ,)* OE : j!;  U6,
8e i* ,} r
g d[ |, NM 'D =)\8 % )6B ~ BE
N8F ' N dg
N8Be j% 59,e 3 8e 81 ,-.  U6, '
,E4 8B
7E j8,, j8-79, j4 - 4  =~  N2 6_ b-9U j
,8-4 )D /% V e9-
 6e0+e 8e  a6 O4
,< rE 8e% 5^ ~ -B>  E 8e% 5^ 5: 8
E\ T-UF C+,  pF _- VB 8 ~ <8IU
N   ={s  r
j7, 3 ~ +e 8BB , {[4 ,$,$
:6 _0UF )71L )D
j], : ' M4 6$ [1 
A AF ( 6
: q3!1 ,: ;e8$ 7E 5, b[1 j%
 *O,(3 5y8  :7 8B ],> , ,V9 8 B9
'[ : IR j% ~ 6
%  , ' #$E |,
 ,D$ b[\ |.
j8D hDE =j]  $% i* : $-  q  b[1 j8$R
N0U ' G )\ 8 rE P  --B> ), K 5,+ B
8;
180

'[ H1I+7: :LD LP9 -EF _0UF :6 -*}


Y
 j 8$9 j% : B
jg; ' j8D '% ?6},
j8,
)7I 3 OE )7E8e% jR '[ qB>F ;F q3!1 ' 
[1 j% % ' ?)\. '-U 84 < )!}
8,@ j%
28 3 re% *6 87^ 4 8D D NB j% X:  w
81
N8B ), K = P(  % j- , g
5,, j% ; dF
 j% ; d% 59, '$E ,T8*6 b[1 r$* /8B> d[ %6

% ,$F  N0U ' %6 {s YE ?, i* B9:  8I

/ ,0 ~ 6, ; 4 j8D j% 6


3 ;6$  :7 8_ d%
8e  PF j8:8, 77E O4   $8e88D -DL

~ <% u $E% s ,6e0+e


7y % ,   )6B
7; : 6B* 0
 ~  5(->   % L , Ce6 j% 3 =8BL
=8BL 7y % 6,>
=Y
 NM ' ~3O, n( % 7*8_  ,T-U% eD z:1
~  z:1 j% ~ ^ )$e ' e
'8D, 8 e 6. W  ~ 8_ 0
C !
p8 I  % ~
8 I {s j4 q8 ,5,+$ -B6
d[ 6$ 1 ,6 , C38  -:e js e8* =-B  
5,+ rE ),> d[ 6$ ,r( )>%
i*  [1 rE YB ,
K ,z:1 $F 8; j NB =-B6 ' 6_ _g
8D.
i* 4   6m 7:
/ ,$> ,e,>-
LP 1 +7: 1
j-B P%  e9-
 |   }> j8( 7 % 6_ , k0UF
=* 'M
181

% 1   
), } -1 ' -7 d% i* : 
8} [1 joE ,r$M YBZ : g  k8L 8 e i* kLeQ 
q (%  re% ,CBL: y  $ : ' n(e j8eB4 
' j% X$ 5L>- U6 `< } 6 Z3 ' M4
{s j8D j% j r$U kLeQ  % i* 8M r$* ~  `I
6 A rE  N8_ re% {; 3 ,NB  [1 =: ' * M
~ 87L # N8B [1 b 8I d[ 5y8 'D ;N. 5_ '* 4
5 jB K -B6 8}$ $,m +,e r:D ,` E ~ :D
-L$ 28 , LD 8I
B: Y 87+$ j PB /87L
},e 8(8
~ yE K>-DL K>1 A :Ly% soE =r$U YL: j% 7E
4 uB
: -M4% -} j% 'D 'E ,4;3 q  5 
d% i* IR j% % X< 'D i* 6  ~ ; } {$, K
%6  ' {[
7; q z:1 =d6  ?0
U
t B K
   8I
~0<% ,:
: i* 7$BM
)M ,KE- .
1w*% {[
:*% ,B9 b[1 d%- <U  8I
Ky-
 K$ -M4% j8$D} '[ K NO j% ?- ' =)7Le%
8(F j8 NO VB$, j% X: re% ~ :B j8:! C*:I ' M4
)7: U  7
j8,, '[ j% ,j6 NO 1B$, , 7Le
k8L U I ,
)\ n j% X: 3 )7: -M4% 6+
j8$ %
t  %  7  ) )1 ' U
S j86, )1 =6
-7 NO    H1I$E S ~ e% nI> 6_ ,k0UF
8B j86, ~ e% _0UF : ' )7$* j8B, )% V:
1
=)16y
182

C6$ -M4% N 5E '  p <% 5: I , ' )7:
,< j!}  Pw_ I,U 87+$ j4 s =~ Le -M4F
d% 87^ j% % ,: q3!1 z8$  g9 'D  '* (* :eoE
M d-L r48$ i* 7Le 9$ q* i* /0 j% 'D r:
-E
=*  8I
: i* / 87 7*6 , 9$

b[1 :%  jF ,~ e( yE3 wB 5w: 'D
eDo
~ -9U z:1 j% O4 ,< . -  -E C47,e L

g; ' q ->


,+: '  \ )*% C47,e a6

-% 4 j8eB
5: j%  BE # 6m  ~ B 87 q9*
g
? , 8F ' 6* d% 5: j% {[4 Oe ,~ U b],
=U -% re% '  ?67,    {s ,-

T6 `; i* j8eB - ,C-D i* jQ 5: ) 

8e d% ~ -B> 6 , C38 `; hIe i*  $+eQ C-,


- jF ,H1Ic0 -F j4  3 8 D C
 > '
-F BB  r: 6IB Oe , j8eB r$* e d[ , 8 5

ue4 j8eB [1 -E  $ 


8I j% )  =\O,  -
N% 81 ,1851 / Maine Law K 3 j8eB
?-  A :1  ;Q 1
3 ,7$D
3 T8, i* 8 D C
 5
-R D-% j8e_
8e8 j-  2  -_% 6_ =:I, % DeD % 9 -
'4%  *
,e ) =- pS '* :,3 5+}> ?6G ,1851
/, -. C-_% 6_ 3 12 ue4 1855 /* N8$
re% V, ,T-U%
=7y % i* 8$
183

38 {s  O
,_ ' r>-_% , C38 ' 6*  rPX  ~ 
t , $<F
VB$,> m {s 5 C%6
re% 3 ,7 
j8eB ?-*
1% ' )7Le% j], '[ ' 6* ' G j7, 3    ~ 6g>
=6$ [1  r M j8e_ -_Q :  },  ?6G ,jQ 
[\ u$D}> , ,7Le i* Y$9> O4 h , % *O b[1
>-D K
 '$ A C2-
K   u,4 ,-X
j8:! '[ X$ P0B $+eQ 6 N( ' 6 h ,
 j% X: =f i* P_ j8D> j% X:   1% q jg

~ <% 8B N  > i* $ - b[1  e,  8$ 


r$* 0
K
NI b[G j8,, '[ 6* $_ T6 j8$ '[ {% '
= r> : ' 6*  T-e O4 ,  .  j-7,} '[
rL % Y* '* p-*% d[ ,h , ) 
a6 , ;% 6_
`I, -]>   b: '* ~ 6
r@8}> 'D %6 dg
?*0
d[ b2,( 'D 3 d[ 5 8 (. A ;% ,79y3
=r,*^ G '!> , f K
 B [1 ' , f K
IL
5B> % | 6> w d%- -DL
B$, P 5^ j :N_
C NEF
B$, P 5^ j ;5, k9e c U
, -6B, 0I 3 5w 3 % | 6> *O,(3 C_0
M E -4s i* Cg W r:D =-L G N8
W 7Le 6 G u8U

-L 9 Cs C NEF 1 ,K,B


 K,L '* h$,
b[\ 64g,
,: 8 D C
 pS j% ) ;*O,(3 #
 +, ,d  }e 81 8 D C
 5
j% 3 =MM L
N8 # r$* *3 M d[ z7,e3 'D =*O,( E 1
184

6$ 'D re%  ;{$7, 5P - N8 Oe ,5 -
N8I.  , '  j% 6,> jg
- pS r$* /-Z j% M

Y.
'84 `% :e :N8B h , >-D 'D =r$_ ' r$*
z8$ L
*O,(3 _8B 7E {7,:> - 4  5, 
=*O,(3 k8B. b[1 h-> A j B,:: =-U '8 *O,(3
j% 64! 'E ,*O,(3 _8B {7,: q d% z:1 j4 s
B -6> 7E =p [1  U6> -9B 8 D C
  
 8I
*O,(3 C
-9y3 LZ Y$ jg
'F   F
! Y$
L,e3 N0U '   B {7,:> 1 =-,
 ,- Y> 1 =r>6e   `P *
-L> d[
' 9UF
d   N0U ' _0UF d-DL -89,
`% j% B '  -% 81 ,5,+  ?y K18> N0U
=I} C_0 4} 6*

~ y-* _ _ ' 67;% W  *O,(3 k8B.  -e b[1


' j :  81 8w  NB  _% j =- [1 ' \ ny%
4 ' ?, j% -U -E 4 i* K, re% Y$9 *O,(3 B
Ve%  YL ' 4 j ;E% * X: d[ 8 : i* ~  ,*
/8B jg
9
:8 *O,(3 B {7,: Oe {s  <L,
81 *L ' ( 6 b[1 $ d[ %6 j =:* h. 5E-
j8eB
z7,e z:1 j8D ' ;-. 6y d-E U6> d% ' MD
-9U%
O
,ue4 O7 - F Y dg
-B 3 re ) ;%6 [1 b ] 3 - $
 $  ;~ 6
% 7:* IEQ j   q k:,* - q:M, 

185

5^ {7,: [1 joE ~  b],*% d% '* ; d% 7E ] ,


: 4 9 %6 [1 =h , |  7: , *O,(3 k8B.
je 4 T6 d6 V, d-DL _0UF NOD  ~ ,D ~ B
= b  `  6 4 _ ' rL-> ), 8 e i* ,-U
, -.    U6, i* T-UF 7 $MF '
 8I
b[L:> )> Oe BE r
667, ), W U6> 81 ,-L Y ' 1
=u /8
 5, 81 ,8 6% [: ~   (e
q  , 8  '* 8 F  6 /8 q- :, j
Ee * {; j 81 ,$ : ' ~ :D {s j4 O$4 ,r_2
3 =87$ :
3 :6 : ' ~ P / $  re% 3 ,X$
K
8 : [1 i* *  8I
G N8B j  b[1 > 'D
[1 joE : 
7, K reF ,NO*F ds ' : CE
)$ ' r
8 ' j8D O
|,
=7*> A '-U -9w
, b[1 j-U *- j%  Y. ; D j8eB 'w j%
[1 'D =K /8  5  k9e i* I,_3 C$* Y$> N0U '
4 5, j%  j-U 7D$, , S  $I i* )P_ -],
, -L C_% } i* Y9:> 3 oE |,
; b[1 ;
8B i* (  g
{[4 Y9:> 1 3 ;G /B } ,
D}  bB$, d[ rE j% n < =rE 8e% i* e8eB
), : ' $_ r
/8B> d[  'D ;'-U :
* /8
' : ' M4 7$* IR , , N0U ' r:* 8,
$B b[1 j8D> j% 9S ,rE ' r$* j8$IR d[  N0U
186

j =r
/B /6*  - 
/B ,U  - : '
)oE ,6F /8 5 * s re% 8: j%  ~  Y i* K$
Y$> ), j4  'D :/% , -(% 
B /%  * j!
6
3 {s 5  d[ XI 6 joE ,NO*F ' V X
` :,> -(F  2 i* I  '-U , (% '  ' r
j8$wL 8e4 s hPl8 {$>  
K $
 )1 ;)7$* 5
' 6 
`$9 z:1 j4 s =-(F i* N8I. N6
-
j8D> jg
* # g> N0U ' j8D j% 'D {s joE ,8,
joE |,
=: ' < CL b[\ 8 F ' -U /8  $9
/8 rE i* 8B '* E6 r$(% ' 'D d[ 68 `
E [1 ;:6 : ' P(  re% A ~ 6P* j8D j% 6
3 6F
' D; dg
7$* *3 'D 3 , 5, E8 '
j% :$* B
=H1Iin corruptissim republic plurim leges =ND;F
qO ' r:> )> 6_ r$M ; d% % 5,+ j% i* +. )Be
~ 47,e rLe u_8  j8D 3  C-. L z7,e dF /B,e0
j8D j% } `( ' j $PB -DL j = :
' :e8UQ
7$* 5B  i* 7L: )B,:> j% \ 59,>" 1: :>0
X$
 * 1
37 0 _ 32 8  8]Q A 
8: $D b[1 =&W '
: 8]Q  C8 r
,4  Tacitus 8,4> 1 %  ,0$
=Tacitus Annals I, lxxiii
Tacitus, The Annals, in The Histories and the Annals (Latin and
English), trans. Clifford Moore and John Jackson, 4 vols. (London:
Heinemann; New York: Putnam's Sons, 1925-37), vol. II, p. 566 (III,
xxviii).

187

:6 79y3 C3 5  F ue4 ~ :6, -U }


=~  C3. b[1 ], oE -DL b[1 u$t_ s ,_ ' u_ ,
9B
-L h_8  -D, C3  N0U ' 56:> , -*} j
, 8B
u ,{s r
;  h, n,E B  ,6F /8
t
1 7$* N6> , :1[ . 'D ,q6B j679w
7$* j4
Z
/6* i* / * % {s =7$* 8e4 , 7Le :1[  F

t
=679w
'  ~ 8 # reF )7: r
n O
/B  '-U
' :L ' {[4 r:D LD NE% BE b-D 3  jg
B,* re
=)16y U6,e W s `e[
-
a43 $_ 8; i* 6 $MF b[1 `e( A
3 , 79y3 X 81 :-U ~3M hy% j% 3 : 3 ,jeQ
% 7E -}> - 4  6$ [1 E < ' 56:> , ,7E 
8
'D =-:$ ,L$ j8 8 LP -1l N8  ~ ; N8B> jg
 9
~ 66( ~  j% 1 ,36 Cs (L BB. N8 MD N8_
3 ny Z +,e re% ny8 ' 81 d[ r$* O~ P_ ~ : ~ 8* 
# ! G 5,, ,   CLI 1 ' V, 6e VB$,
/8B d[  F n<% : ' ?3 C r
'! '6 [1
=P
-7D ?-X$, C 9B h I *  ,r$4g
5, r$*
j% jg; {s  reg; ,'6 [1 j% 81 /B [1  :@ 
' r* B r ! re j% ;b67; r6 ,r: wE% T-U%
8B '6 [1 >% ' '-U ~ <;% j% ;r> `
q6
' 8:* )7Le )> )% ;rLe 8eB  h: N0U ' )7*
188

A 8tE )% (  A j j 9


)%  ;rE g}e d[ 6$
6$ [1 1% ' ~ M4 joE ,q- I   N : qe jD  _Q
% n-  ~ -% {s j4 j p8I ' j8D re% ~ :$* j8
;F q  /,e3 i* 8B
)7 Q $ N  ` :
AF ( 6
M d[ j8 8 6B*  8(8 %6 j ='-U

81 :6 n,$ 


8w
8 : [1 i* )9R d[ q6 [1
t re%
6:\ K$ T6 r
8 -F [1 =C(  6> R
~ <g, q~ 6* M re% 6 'D ,K:I
'[ : r O K 0
z:1 # =: E ' j8  )% j8* 6  $+eQ j86 ,
%6 [1 j% )  =8 8 %6 [1 B*  8I
E- ' : -M4%
~ S ~ 6> ], reoE ,-. %6 l  ~38B j8D j% '* ~  6

5,+ hIe 8B ~ 66}> re84 6 3 re% ,* i* ,%6 {s i*
b3  / , r$* j8D j% ' -U hI: rE -R d[ u_8 
V:e 3% ` {s 5 =%6 {s 6y T-U% ~
 % z:1 j% O4 ;-U
_0 C< q: `e( ' rLe 6B
*8 _0 b[1 j%
' -U D; d%  N. 1 O4 ,\  y '1 ,* 'D v8$
 8(8 bL> 'D ,p-X, 0 ~ M {s 6 O
=c  ND;%
i* c  A -: i* q: -> , ,W$  C DEF
' ~ M4 j%  ` : K [1 =%- r(,Z d[ 68 -F re%
c2 j j8D> j% i* C(2 6* K
' (2 j8D> j% wL> q:
j% % C  b[G ?> j% T-UF j6$ ' `$ 9 3 =k0Q i*
j8:! )%  % i* j6$ {$> Ke8_ ' D ' q ( d% L>
b3
j8 8 d% j8wE- -_% K 'D =e8 8 6B

189

;N6 * rw,B>  ~ M4 k8L 8 e i* '-U _ ' P6


' 6
'4  -B,  ,)7P uwE , )10
84-> K
j% `I 'E ; V:D ~ .< b8$( ' N% 8e4 F j4 %
' )7: 'D jX9 %6 q:M, 
f ' %6 d% i* T-e
j6* dg
88B 3% 9S ,8y- , Ke8B uZ z:1 
'* - 3 '  X  , -.
8  T-UF j6$ 6y
r ~ I; `e8 
' ], `>4 _ UF L  =)7_-
p-. - i* 9}e 8_ $
# /B r
j7, 3 j2
d[ 5,+ [1 6y H1I w. `$( 7E61 $
Oe $I
q 8 A 89U 81 b-  6 5y   ,C(  6> O
3 ::D ,{[4 q 8 A 89U % T % | :
= w $ :

j%  = , i* -U 5, b-4  Y. 5, dF j4 j )$*%


C,+ ' 6* j8$9 3  j8eB ' j8e '[
k0Q i* )\ _0* 3 ;% i* X: re% _% 3 :eoE ,T-UF
5^ ' N8B re% 6 5y q   8$U6, j% 5,+ {[

6< ` 5y8 {s jF S _0 p <% ;F


r
)\ _0* 3 ;% d% ,C8$D ?3 )7:* j6 ;F
,{s  8 s ' N  )Do
=q  )g; ' #
/6B> r(  8LB )7* % ; O b[1 '* ,
3
: 8 V,
7:y ' ], 3 , LI: P 8
)7; -E% K
$ f
ue4 K -
] i* $ 6  w $ ue4 s =K$ CD 
= w.   $ Oe ,`$I   $ u % V:
1
190

,-
] j% ' ?8 *6e j% h 'E ,W i* -9> -
]
-7B> 66( ' . A }:> O
,~ -B> 7$* qwB )> j% 6

16* 6 i* 8 : [1 i* 7, 1 'D ,  w. j = w.


6 W re% (  A ~ 4 ~30 e $ : <F
u <% % 6
3 87B
i* % ,7:* E6 -U ; d% % K: 7$ 1 6B

T8   w. b[1 /% j8D ' ={[


/B m _F
 $ }:> ) ' 6,$ -,> j% A %8 F A  ' NB,e3
 8]Q ' -X q   a6 O4 K9}: -
] d6% i*
=e-

191

192

C LI b[1 i* 1:y-* , f Y9> ), j% ' , '
'D ,k0UF 8D.  L$, -L 5^ ]* B :,  8I

f nI> K 3 -M B-9


{[
/B$ <-E z:1 u
j8D> j% 'D V, {s ,_ ds ' -M4% *  8I
8B
7-g , $$B C0 =7 <L, N8 B:  F
# f ny8> G 6IB Oe $IL, P 8I
:1
 6B
CB9> # :1 r-%  j =1  YBZ $- V, 7*>
6 V: ny8>  6L> j% \ 'D =H1ICB9, ' C:* 81
j% ,p,D [1 r$* /8B d[ %6 4 ~  j0D}> K,* K>6*_
' 7E j8D 3 , C3.  O7:
j28, _  )D. 6*>
=. i* Y9:> , 1 O7: 6*_ d% ny8
/% ~38 # -L j% 1 AF :   j>6*B j>1
=b -U ; d% nI 3 ue4  rE% '* 5,+
= 84[ f Y9> L4 '* $M% q9* d% 1
193

'* 7E ] j% 8B  8I


5,+ 59, , 68 Cq-(Q
,:_Q ; Q nI: )6B> 1 -L {s z8$ ' rP,  % r1-4
nI   Cq-(Q b[1 j% j- 8e4 s ,r '-U -+1 %
],> , NEF '* r48$  N8 -L j% 1 eM =rLe -L
C
8B$  5w j% 7
'D , ,'-U nI
 y
=r,O. /23 6% j% T- 5,+ j4 s e8eB % *O,(3
%  j%  :  1 7-% j% % , AF wB
` 81 BE '-U nI i* 5B j% 'D d[  NO,
] O~ P re% {s '* ,: 3 ,5,+ U6> ] j% 'D d[ 68
 )( q  V ~ I; j% M4 C3  a6R =U6, [1
% ,'-U   % WF *  8I
|,
  
`
 8I
-U ; 7$* N8I. V:, j4 $ i* rL: IR
C ! `
`X  g}: nI  , [1 =8B
;8(8 C ! b[1 ue4  r: A  3 , *O,(3
=C ! % l  7: A  3 , ' T-U% C3 z:1
 8I
 ,E:> ,U  % :
,D :7  n+: ; d%
i* N8I $ B
 %  -U ; d% i* /6B, ; d% *
' 5Pw b67( ' rE:  U ' 5L,: reoE ,04 b6- q
j% $ / nI$ wEF ' j% i* ~ ^ YL,e ::D =r$% U
=B [1 ' , `_8 ' _* j )7E61% YB , : V
Y d% )7$% pU '[ KE:, 5,+
n: 3 ,T-U%  

re% -} 3 ;e ' 8: [1 6y eI.  _0U% % 8e_


194

/6, 
; n+: K 3 E:, h_8  U6,
`9
=8B % e % - , M ,/ nI G -Bt  3 
H1I

[]

5
A8, d[ } =*O,( E 1  +, j N8_% j% %
i* '-U nI i* -! -g
/8B 87 A 5$ ' 8e d%
'y 5B %6  ' r48$ joE |,
;*  8I
5,+
,C8D. `( ' j% '  j4 re%  ` 81 [1 ;5,+ I,U
C$* ):>  F uM> ,7 ],
> ue4 , C3. 5^ 
 6
3 YB , W {s j4 j ,j r
? ' 'D =5:I,
qB
  81 e6,  g
6( 5$ i* N8I $  wE% j% ,8
i* N8I.  ~ -% j} j4  ,~  ~ -% KP K+,:
wB =-.  +, %6
?-  81 [1 =-U jD ' )728
[1  r:* 5E6e d[ -. %6
< wB '* h$, r
<
% , +, i* 8_ -E j =e,  ' 7:* B> 3 7:D ,p,D
;8B ' 64g,
81 Oe , +, -F ), d[ c,eQ i*
7M e , 8B 'D ; 8F ' O~ P 1 [ ),> , 8B
 ' 5,+$ YR d[ z8$ ' q  {s i* 3 -!> 3 :1
~ E ,:> 3 F 3 q 3 U 1 ,r$* ~ 8_ 5w j% %6
 0
 U6 3 -L -. %6 joE |,
=7+,:> j% 7E
L ,
g}:> , P )  U6 81 3 ,r>s 6
-.  +, %6
=ny8,  2 7,Ly% 6_ ,IL [1  /_ ':*  5w W 1
195

d[ 8 6B 81  :_ ' ,%6 {s i* 8B 8I

8$.    -9 '  p <% i* -L


j% X:
-L
j% X: d[ 6B 81  ;X, Y- '* X 8_ j
'7  K$ O. C> % , I C,3 8I

3 -. i* Cy* B [1 ' , $ F 'w,> 3 =-9


ze j% ,T-UF 8 d> N  ,O~ P wEF ' j%  '
28 re% -D:e j% 'D 3 =)7$* -9 ' ~36
)!} :
,-U `e( ' =CX b[\ )7$* -9 ),> j% *  8I

;-.
<U P ~  % ],>  +,  U6,
Y$,> P z:1
,KI A j8EF ,  - ,b0*% 84[ K 3 j8e_ _ '
U6, ?61 j8D C3 I,U
1 , ;/8 5
i* 8B
$ i* N8I.  , % `I ' +e j% 81 ~ ^ 7:
% t,: -  # ,~0U6> 1 ,*
y8E- C0U6, b[1 =:
=d} -  Oe ,5P
[]
1 ,66( g M ,/8 5
81 ,$MF b[1 6%
hPl r$* Y$9e j% 'D   : 8B 9
 N!
?6G -.  *  8I
U6, 'D T6 d% A =H1I
8D $ 7$* ?0U 3 , hPl8 ' j ?a8. % )P- 5:
7E},4 {[4 ,7*8_ _ )P- 6y C,3 [,> j% 1
5,+ *  O
, 8D  7(% % :1  $D
 6IB 1
=)P- BE # , 8F N8I 5: ?6G ,r: q ( %
196

-M4% 8D $ P_8 Ll8 'D =7*8_ 6


g}
pB B
;
B 7,Ll ' -. p i* /6, 3 q Q MD
y-*
dF * L - ' ~ -B> q ( d% j% ,* 'D ' jF
C07, ' 6  re% i* ,{[4 hI: 8 e i* ,r$M 'D je
, C9$ T6 C% s {s 5 =H1I z8$ 8e% 
pD> 3 P36 ` 6, ~ I; ,U '8 T% s V, %
U6, \ 28 Oe ,- 8_ ,e
 $ u oE ,-(
3 - dF / 6,> % > /8 'D> W s =7_ j 8$ $
' 'D =7
 7:I> - Y. ' j8DE ,)P- pD>  ?6G
-
u -F 
8$9 /8 j8D> j% -F BB  'D
j% j :   8B -E 'D 3 ,6L {[4 Oe BE
=T-U%   >
~ wE
 9$ `( ' O~ $ ~ q ( z:1 j N8_% {s '* 0
; d% % 8D N8 T% soE =a8. 6y ,Z jg
B
u_ z:1 'D W ,j8g  reg
?- ( 8* 6- ~ ee -U
j% j q 8 A rE r
zQ 'D 'E ,-9 ' b-[ ,
O
/B ' hg,> -. jF ;r,- i* BB q6,* d% {s  j8D
j8D 3 K ,{s 5 =-7:  8B  `- 3 81 ,q- r
`-
d% 6B
j8D '$E ,7*8_ -9U - Oe 4} 8_8
KB z:1
 d8_ E r6 j4 s  -B j% ,rLe -F `< T8 ,;
T6  'D =7: r}* `D K4D 5e< j% NM  i* 3 1
=KD /6, 
GD>  'D , )P-
197

oE |,
 ;rE N8U6 Y , ~ -% -  r8U  . b[1
' 8B
r: # -9 ' } -[Z BE X: re% T %
~0L } j4 s /0D [1 Y9: 3 =-9 {[ rLe ->
3 8 e i* NX}e3 %  Q   j4 % ,j[1 c,1   %
, P i* Y9:> ,T-U% C ,* z:1 = [
DL, r n,
eF ' :D 8eF d% -Be j% :8 6_ ,/8 5
_ '
-E 'D ' ,NM  i* =rL 3 , 8eF d% %6 h
N8 ~ -[Z R q6 i* YI$ 5y _ ' , q-(
59, 3 s ,-. i* 6 > {s  j8D j% j ,-9 r,
'D = 8U \ @} ,  j% E- /6* 6- j% d}
L< d} 2] j% B [1 ' , C3. 5^  }e K
~ -% * C6, 0  b[1 i* N8I.  [1 joE `
 =jF 5^  ~ L$D -% ,jF 
 ~0 ,
 D>- )P- r(  _- 5y8 1 % j% 59, % , 68
j6- '[ - i* 4 6 > z:1 j8D j% j ,) /6, 

Y
 H1I/M:
bO %  )6B> 1 ,T-U% -F  8 /6, 
K =8B   5+$ ?8g -F [1 =K, Y 6
t
/ $,
j% n I ' , ' joE ,8B 6%  N8U6 d-
~
_ 6B [1 j8D 4 ,j8eB
,: C$D; *- ,/  0
d% q8}e   re% 
,{s A  87} 7; 5_8, M
'D W re% ,~0E /]
 6B j% K  z:1 j8D B,  ?0U
/M:
( 1
198

~ 
6B   ?-  z:1
j% V:
=e8eB : ' 0
' , 8B % ,8 8B /% y CB* qB 81 ?6\
-E 'D =7-
 u< , ?- uE-t * 8   < ],>
76,  'D , 8 5
 {[ $  Cs C,
u_8 +,
5P / $  j% 'D ,NM  i* =-+$ Cg4
B_6 , ,d} j8:* )  ,5 $* rE u d[ Y_6
p8 +> ,7PS ' ?6\ '* N! ,*  4 *8:
' j8D O
-E , L< z:1 j8D> 3 K =d} r9 d[
,rPS 6I
81  BB d}$ K , ; 8( /20
t
-F u6,
 6_  b[1 j%  6L> 6
OE p % q8}e  
N8I. ~ M4 `I '  3 B [1 ' , eF =-(
 :   8I
 /6,  
8< ' ~ M4 6 > 7:D ,) i*
={s ?},4 ), j% j
[]
s Y- '* rLe 6y )P- 5E  5,+$ 'D Y. j
j N8B d[ %6 i*  y8 8B A } B C,
 i* r
U6, 'D 3 r< i* ~  ,B d[  z8$
U6,$ ~  : ~ *8y8 # -D ,NM  i* =pB % 5:

6y h: NE% ' L

 ; '% j% Y s 'D ;,


} {s i* -L
 j%  ' j% 6B,*% ,p g> uZ '-U
 e - ty s re% bL ,rLe 81 r$* ,B ,U 8e_ 6_
81 T-U% L `D>  s re% ,
8B$ ~ yU j8D reoE . b[1
199

`
\ 5w , 
8B 6;  > j% ` . {$> uZ 5_
'-U q[ (  A -D rE -! } :
=eM L
W s :-U ~3M )D ='-U Y
-( 81 -D E rE_ joE
h 'D W s % 87 ' 6* i* IR N84 ; 'D
;r$4 `
~ e8e_ `_  j% r$* C,E3 ' j8DE ,8B 6%
'* 5:, jg4 ,'-U 8 e e8eB r>( q%  ~ BL j4 s 'D
' / ,3 {[
qE8 i* b-D
 j% jX9 ' #$E ,rL% *
[1 Y9: =, T-U%  z:1 'D> W s b-4Q
 N0U
=r: 'D -U ` d% % r$4 81 `*, 6I j4 q8
j8D> j% \ X: 3 , NEF ' MD z:1 ,{s i* 0*
,BE \ K$*L ;F S  8I
ds!> 8D ,~ e8e_  8m
 [1 =)$ z8$ 6*8B L ],> '$  5B> K 7:D
 Y r( z:1 |,
 ,'-U q Q E uZ 5B> NEF {$>
% ' :D , p Cq Q L b[1 'y 5B> =7:
=S  $< BE 1 :*8y8
7,$< j% ~ <8IU ,7$* u_8
:*8y8 81 d[  i* ), L j84 ' *3 'D
 ],> 3 , NEF ' ~ M4 OE 7Le ( 6
d8_ L

={[4 % ; d% T- 3  -D:, s 6


, f 5 Y, p8( A reg}
c, e -U 8y8 z:1
/8 r( i*
L d[ } z8$ '  [U =-4s
,r,_ % r:
5,+ /_ j N8R -. / 'D ,/8 m re%
j :!  =rLe } i* rO,
5B S r:* >: TsF jF
200

X: 7E ,8 : [1 i* ?,  ~ - *L j4 s :  81


/B i* r+}> % r Ie  ~ -% rLe 6B
8e8D j% '-U
w
], 3 : B-9
?,$ -U ; 8* j ?{[

E 81 . % nI: j% {s =rLe } i* ~ _ ~ 48$


i* -!> , NEF jg; {s  reg; re% 6B,e O
|,
 ,*O,(
~ $_ 'D =5,+ _ ' -9$ 
_ *  8I
'-U
' 0
3 . j% ) re% : K reF NF 9e3 n Ie :$ DL,
'y L
5B> % 3 ,-L -. h-> k9e 'y w
5B>
s ={s j
)D =-L -. %6 A *6 p F k9e
?,
,)7Le% 3 3 -% 4  ,:$ ne j% /20 ' j4
i*
8e8D j% 6
0E ,)7,! i* )7 :
wEF re% 6 8 e
j% r$* X:  N8 )7:
OE },  rLe 6B
~ -%
6
3 r$E 8 -% 4 j =C_3 8B$, 89 q  8,
3 8y8 [1 N8 {} 8M 3 =reg}
nI: ~ 8 j8D j%
r_2 6I j8D K ,r, Ie ' I;  8I
n<: 6L, K
t  [1 = OB  *6 =~ S 6 5,+ b],   81
U6

: ' CE 8( r


:*% ,6B, ' ~ 66( ~ :* B: 
B- /8B> '[ ,/ nI$ ~ 6( ],  5 7.I ,>
/% {s  U6,e j% :
6 7E =/ nI [1 B i* )
{[4 ]Ie j% ,e  8( i* ]Ie j% 6
3 NM  i* ?28 3
j%  ~ - j8D j% K }
6 1 'D =H1I OB 8( i*
*O,( BB -B  j =N8B -% 81 OB % e  j%  6IB 3 1
= OB % e  rE -7 3 5, 6(8 j% 'D 3 re% 1
201

5B> , C3. ' 1 . b[1 ? OB$ ~3 : -6 % ~ 8_ j8D
A 8L i* ny8 ' # ,'%6 K
<L 6. i* w

-F
N8B `e( 'E =`e( 4 nI + z:1 =,:> O@%
' n
 k2 ,: :7 q- j7, BB j N8B 'D
={s ?0
~ 8 j8D j% 'D ~ -% /- j% 'D 3 ,7, 
=u
 D}
~ 8m % u
 D}
~ 8 j8D j% X: L [1
3 p [1 ' 5,+ joE ,  < 7:* 5E6e , f ue4 soE
6
% A  j% 59, 3 =-L 3 3 q d% 9  r jg;
j%  ~ - ; 4 j8D j% X: ={s '* -L : m '
{s Be i* =L '* V:M j%  - -U } j% O$M R

D}
-B> jg
y8L  6 % 87 j% ) re NB j% 'D
BE -! d[ z8$ ' ~ *8e j% ,pB % 5B -F ,d89$
Y. )\ joE L
~ S b ,* )> s ,S /% U 81 -L nI i*
/% ~ S j4 s  N8 8,L N! _F i* 6(8 re% E  /,
j% 'D 0E VeF b6  E3 [1 A BE -:
={s 
`1[ DEF g> ,  )7,m  ?,  K9 8e8D
)1 ,* 'D 3 '[ K+} g> ,>[ 7, $I
), ,
81 ,K `e(  S I;  $I )\ '[ d% ,'  , 
5E )\ j% j8E '[ ,U re% 6 6B,> d[ `e
j8D> ' re% 64! ' j NB j% 'D ' =r   ,
I;
`>-> N0U ' ,U dg
 w> z:1 j8D> ' , U % z:1
{s j4 q8 ,< ) U j[, -EF  8 e i* 8F
-. ' 'D 6_ _g
 ,)7Le% )1 ) 
,Y % D '*
202

 $I -F )\8 5+}> j6- '[ ;F C e '


3 OB N8 . Ke8B j N8B 'D |,
=)G < >[
5^ j8D j% X: re% ,ND;F ' D; dg
7:* E6 'D
d%  % ,~ w
)7w
C8
% )8
 OB `  ~ -% :
{s 5 =)@-P2 qw* BE ~ 8,L j8D )4;
)_% VB,$
~ (e j8D ' 5: j% n < =* O_ C8
_o
O 28 3
j% 'D OB C8
joE ; 8_ '  ut9*% O7 re% ,~ 6
%
  i* {s 5 1-D j8D, 7:D ;T-U% Cq* uZ O~ P 6>
d% 7:* )$ 3 
,8X  ' : ( 6
\O*%
j% 5,+$ X: 6_ _% 81 [1 =7 V j4 ' 3 ;
N  8U% ' =+. b[\ G j7, 3 8_ z:1 =rBB , V
{ _ i* ,} d[ _0UF s[} -], LD @% --B>
d[ ,C0EQ
{s ' r 6
3 rLe *L$ n K  E 
_ ,  i* {s -E j 8B '+ % )-X> i* ,}
 V, U6, 28 3 re 
=-B _ j OB u
`<
 4 ~ -B> =$ # % i* 5 q  4} C$
+ 6(8> 3 'D ;?-9, D}
76,  'D > % T}>
;NM  i* H1IK 3 j8e_ nI %6 [1 i* /B> j% 'D
/ 6, j%    $I \ j% ) ,8B 8  E jF
/6, 3 (% ' 1-E% 8( ' 6
3 re% 3 ,-L  8I
7+,:
] [1 ,BB S 81 +, q3!1 5E 'D =C
$ 
=183 )_  LI -e 1
203

j% g; ' CeOy 8_ 1 CeOy `$ 8_ -E 6$


= ] [1 38 * -. i* ~ 6> j8D>
[]
wE% _: ~ : ~ 48$ j% 6 ],> K :T-U% g z:1
'* } :M> j% z8$ - j 7$* X: 7E ,*L nI
Cq-( s 6 i* X: 1 ,NM  i* ?{s 5 r
/B
' ~ < 7$* N8I.  j% % ,'M L>- -D P  
1 O4 ,g b[G Y$, OE ?7E > , '4F 6* 66Z N0U
' MD
/B ' 6
3 ,T-UF $ P 5 :
N.
7$* N8I. nI V, C9}: i*  -E j =C ,
;~  1- '* ( 6  3 h$, 3 q-( 81 _ ds ' `<%
 2 4 j =~ ] -. j4 s 3 ~ ] q-(Q [1 j8D '
i* j 6B 3 '[ {F :
-. ' 8e 64g,
1 L$D,
1   joE r$* j 6B '[ {F :
 ;66 5L>- -
,C[$ 8e ,U j =U ks ; 
B )7$* -L> 
8B*
_0UF e8eB ) ,
qE8 6
)7$U kLe  )7,B-
= )1-6B, z
> j% 6
3  )g; 1 -EF 6 /%
N8 D ,U '6> g4 AF $18$ C ,*3 b[1 6> O

-E j% -4[e j% 6
3 'D =U6 -F $ U 8y84
 re% ,k0Q i* r: -L 3 -% 81   -F `P
D}
`P b[1 ' r
j7, 3 q ( j8D j% 6
3 j6$ )
i* C
8B* -E '* 5:, j% 59,> 3 6 joE |,
 ;S 
204

j N8Z j% \ 'D C


8B* 1 407, 3 8 
/6, 
,-: `( 6 i* 5B |,
=8 b[1 q
: 
/_
q:X, 3 j8D$7, 59, , 5$ 8e%  ,`P -E 6:*
T-> , 5$ A ~   y  8I
} [1 ;)7, $I 7:*
/6, 3 i* 6 > CD
/ 6,> K ~ :B )G > % 6
q 64g,
81 : ds! d[ q j% 3 =X$ 5y8,
A C9}: i*  -E joE |,
=r:* q:X, 3 'D
j% E i* C-Q ' 6_ ]4% YBZ A d!> , ( 6
3 -% 81 Oe ,` E ~38B ~ -% # 6B   c,Z 6
=rw>-e j% ' 6

p8 6, ?5$ b[1 5


 2,3  'D T6 d% A
, '4F 5^ =6B, N0U ' 7BBZ 6IB
 , -F i*
[1 Y9: ,H1I7E  8B 5w j% `$9,> : 7E B,$
jg
B$U 5,+ 6y CL jF p '4% i* <U  8I

8 D C
 5
0< ,B> j% ` : ' |,
=7E g}:>
87} % KE- ;% i* jD {s  7407, 3 _F i*
7 (. 8*6> e% % 5y ;z8$ ' /3
)\
C -D> s IU- `  ;k0Q n,L 6*8 i*  
_-$
reF % p u
`< T6 +* `
'F 8L< D> a8
9, (% ' VB,$ '4F b[1 u <% s % ,7:* ?-9 X
v j% -4t s  ?0U 59, % 3 =\ 6*Q j8eB 6y C2+,$
=196  LI i* 1 )_ 0 5( 1
205

66Z X: re ~0M B:$E =%6  ' 1-]> 'D T-U% 8_ g

j% 81 n ?61 YB , ,8 D C


  C0m 6*
, C : 6* $B> |,
 ,7 N8<8 `I ' +e
Bw$ 5 -
BE # . [1 'D =q- q- 7E -,
7 , p C8
/6,  j8 '[ : 
z:1 jF
7E  > 5,+ '  3 ` : 3 {[4 Oe ,7$* 8M
uZ 7w> ,j8+ % NL% g4 R  8I
$ CB9
68 VR V, )1 6t e :eg4 ,NLF ' g4 ,8B we
j NB d[ %6 81 # [1 'D =B,  -. C2,
)7:
; d% B ' ;- 6$
d%  r ~ :,  )DZ $ CB9
j% 6
3 ,8 : [1 i* CB9 {$> )DZ j% 1 6_ Y -. 6B 
1-E% )DR j% -. i* 7 6> A - 87 5^ [L :,>
=NLF4 3 7D 'D 3 re% 5B 6
uM j% 6
 , -g4
h K j% 6
3 :8_ 81 q:M, 3 A q8+$ - j
'D  %  u[t
B [1 ' , 87 j PB E3
b6 [1 ,Cw_:, ' $,4 1 6$ [1 C ! j =:1 7,  
C8D A ,:> ~ 8_ 5we j% :>   Be :e%  ` 81
-. j% K  ,8
F C8D. {[4 V*6> , jX9
8*6> j% 'D d[ -9 6B   j N8Z :> ! 
~ LBM> 84  BB qL4 Cs 8B +e j% (% ' r (.
=H1I~ _0U%
='-F   %8 % i* I e j% A :
d! [1 1
206

[ - ]
j!}  ,-L - j% A NB [1 ' Y
 q (  CS%
 -EF ' 6* d% T6 $t
B - i* d89:> ,b6 81 rI ,
~ ^ )7I , )7Le% j!; ,N, kL>3 Y- '* ,8: j%
 -F [1  $D} 6(8> 3 =)1 -U ; d% 3
j%  'D ,X> j )7:* a6 ,e '[ : 5^   uB

 V, jF `  d  ' joE ,X,> j% 'D  Q


d% C>   : U6 j% ; d% 7E -g, 3 , C3.
81 C> 3 b[G / ,3 joE j8$L K ,)7:
OE 8B r} 
Y$ Ke8_ n( F i* 6$
4  6(8 {s 5 =*  8I
` -%
C> 
j8 $  3 :E = 6*B b[\ Cq:M, 3 

j8D d[ > 3 j% jF 


 ],
 'D ;X k8B k-
t
 ,NM  i* =/ ,3 [1 ' )7$ e jF ?4 ` 81 )\ ~ s!
/8B d[ > 3 ], ,T-UF  , j6$ )  6$ [1
~0
Y_- ' 684  jg
rL: n % rLe 5
; rE
d[ ` j =/ d%- _ ' % j8eB
-L B 3 ,~ 3
` 81 r>  ' ~ *8 $,  -L 0< 6Be r$(% '
/6*  ` j :E-9, . b[1  8y8 V7,:
b-e ,(
81 ,'-U  0U  , } *89 NEF  U6,
-% rL: b ,  j% i*  81 *89 b ,U j =r,- *-
r, $I YBZ wE% j% O4 ,r$Z r:D _F i* % ,r$_ ' p8-
5 K 'D =r,B- i* b-  ,U
r O  81 ^  8I

d% '* 5:, |,


 ,r,- '* N2:, reoE ~ 6* nI rLe }
207

Cs R reoE |,


=68 L [1 6
r,-. B, /6, 
[1 j8D ' ~ 6*IE j ' =rLe 5
r O ] d[ ?6\
> -. d% $ 
b[1  5y  8 3 ,~ - }
} j8D j% X: re% / $, j% 'D 3 -. %6 j =r.I
' # r,- '* ,
}$ O j !~ - j8D 3%  ~ -
b[1  4 8y8
8_ 2]> , ,p F b[1 j% ny8 ' =-.
5y8 ~ 6_ z:1 j% 6+e {s 5 ;MD
{s ' 5 % Y9> \ ,.
/ $,> C  1 ,. C  L
jD 4  7$*
6B  -e j% :$* X: re% Oe ,:,- '* i,e j% 3 -, 

 5^  6B  L -


`9 d[ %6 'D =7$* zs %
6B
j8D j% / $, %6 [1 ,BE )7Le% K$*L
d% 3 , 8F  )7:
OE K ,$ 8 <% '[ ;F
t j% )1 -U ?-
/6*   V, ;)7 , ' )7Le% 8$ R
,8B* % C>  % 6(8> 3 r$$E B [1 ' *8 t 8(
re 7E NB j% 'D ,N _ % N
_0* \ , {$> q:M, 

t j ' V,


% z:1 j8D> 3% X: B [1 ' d[ *89 .
=/ ,3 '* 5(  k0Q i* -
[ - ]
C 67},  , 2, r,B  ,C68 j8E )$7$E j  64!
% C_0* i* ,}> , C> 3 j $PB b-e 7( ,~ Le G
t j8D> j% ~ 6
% \ X: 3 I; C6U
,6m :2 L 3  $
, < 
), d[ ,c  81 ,C> 3 b[1 )1% j%
208

,c  5 +: ~  KE-9 -*} 'D> W  L,:> rE61% j% 1L


[1 ={s  r, KE-9 ' d% '$ j% 3 r$. c,R 3% X:
r,}_: nI> 3 re% 66} 6B, BPL F ' $ 8y8
-F r (. 8*6>  6B
3 :1 r:>% ' ,-
*  8I

~ (8 j8D j% A ?6@ C68 j $ 84[  =ny8,


BE B j% . b[1  {s r: ,_ 6_ =8  
=+,: {$, r
 %  N8U6 j 7 <8> , +,: '* j0*Q

'D 3 g j% {; j z % jD p F A k-9> re% 8


;  K =7$* ,_ , # F M 9
# % i* 7,8>
i* -U ; 5+}> i* ,z8$ % n 6*8 N0U '  ,
C_8, }: j% : B-9
?,  b -,  i* O,*3
t  j% ,9
g}:> E3 {[
r> 9U ' q ( d% '1
} {s 8 e re( ' _0UF C ,3 ' 66( $$
~ wE =7$1 'D 3 'D ,7E 'D C , 1 ,-U
'* 0
% ,'-U i*  q8}e A '6_, KE- K
_0 C% s ,{s
 N. 1 O4 V, % U 5_8 d%  T-U% ~ E-% uy s
KE-9 i* 5B> ,8(8  A T-U% ?-% 87l A C% c 
6B -,  j% O4 ;T-UF ?-F b[1 8 e C , '6_,
C ,3 b[G qE8 i* )* -% r j8D j% 6
3 bqX % <F
5,, 3 {s 'D =G qE8 L4 i* _F i* % r6* '
O7 6B
qE8
/ Q (  A C ,3 b[1 6, j% T % u
 d  :* 7:D ,r b D ?-9  :
'M j4
\ j8D j% X: 3 re% 8 C68 j8E T- O4 V, =8y8
209

> 3 [1 ' O7Le   KE-9$ e8eB - $ :


-%
,e8eB : ' -4[ -% \ j8D j% X: 3 re% {[4 % '
d% j =KE-9$ _0UF -. i* ~ X
~ g>  
-!> % 3
?- 5^ j.  [Ug jg
_0UF : ' / $ ;
;'-U 7 nI i* -!> j% g; ' 89U s -B j% _
t W s
)$ '* ~ _0U% N! reoE nI b[\ ` : j28 
: C0 b[1 -4s% :e =T-UF ?-F i* r_8 d[
7 8*6> (. jF # ,- $ / %6 ny8>  6*$
#D i* ,d[ ,k09 8y8 d% C[
8y8 [1  ~ ^
q 4 1 NLF nI jg4   r;Be d- ,{s '
=k0Q i* \ _ 3 KX nI
[]
)DZ G ? * f 6(8> 3 re% O
re% _ ' C-4s
X:  `+ Z j% ,`+ Z j% X:  n:  ~  oE ,-.
1 -. -*} j% 7E 6+e , C3. ' 6 z:1 =n: j%
=k0Q i* 7$m   % T %  1 ,M6. 
 %  T8_F
,< re!}
Y$, OE 6-  E  ~ - } j8D j% X:
-U ; '* 
e ?,
6-  E  ~ - j8D j% X: 3 'D
u_8  ,6 =81 re!; 1 -U } j!; j%  [

 $ % 3 ,C[
re!; OE ; 4 - rE /Z d[
='-U i* 7 O r4> 9$ F r,  i* B -9 qB
o

 1 ,$P C_0   ~  r$1 ), D / ,3 [1
210

T-UF C3. 5^ ' )1%   i* S 1g> 7$
c,% ~ -% u )(2 i* c2 9 r; 9$ j =,
[\ /, NI, 0 -F r(,R  4 j% {s =H1I:1 rE 8 A
,j8eB O
',,> j% ,7Le k8B.
C(  5,,> j% 81 
3 8y8 [1 8I
reF =H2I-U ; d% jg; {s  'g;
 j8>g Oe ,-.
 8, A )PB )$ '* j8E6 g+$
(8
6 qE /% BB. B Oe =9$  ' )1 ,*

j =-.
< )1L NO,  q  ,NLF   j8D>
' ~ q ( 8e8D j% )7E L  ; NL% j% ' D q-
8B X A -:
{s ,d2+ V:
# ,-. V:
rLe
 j8eB$ U6> Ve% i* 7(8
 / d%- 7 O ,
8B X
-} / d%- j =rL% i* . B$9 r>-9
 rLe pF -  ~ -B> U6> d% b L  -M4% 8I 
' MD
Ve% 8 e i* -. j 6B   /8* j% :  ,?,
#% =)$, w_ [Ug: ,NM  i* =)$, =9$$ )1-6B>
t > j% 6 i* X: re% ~ -B> r
)$ @6 '
-L> / $
81 ' {s 5 ?~ :8 6 8 je 4 i* ,K T8, V, ,)$,
j z:1 =-. %6 `e8( q ~ 8_ ~ ,U D} 3 8y8 [1 jF 1
b 8 ,-F [\ X$ ~ 9
~ (0* z:1 j% 81 NF = -4[ O4 {[
=, $  
'* 5E6 ; z:1 # re% 81 ,M ` , $    8 2
Oe ,c2F - /87L Y9> q8 N0U ' C(  i* c2F 9$
=-U -% A q8+$

211

je 6(8 ' ?BB. b[1 64! z 6 j% V} 3 d[ }


8eB ?- ` ,% '68 C( 6_% ' j% -D: 64g,

b 6t  O~ $> b9 j% 'PD [1 +: j% 6


pF ,. u_8 
 'D =rLe 8 e '-U 8 e .    8I
b 6
/B$
; 6(8 D 3 ,pF `( {s ,* i* ^ z:1 j% K
/ $  j% X: re PB _3 A uI: jF 6,  i* 6$ [1 
(% '  w> % 67( d% z 3g
~  $
j8D j% ' ~36
 =b[L:,

/ 6B K V, N8_ /6* % r8_   r z


 ,b68 )$, Kg>
H1I
r
?  N   %6 z:1 = ~ ; {s rL$D j% j )$,
 LI: eD z:1 j8D> j% j L p+e j% 81 ,*  8I

6y ,_0U% -( 81 r$B ` 6, )$, b6 /9 )6B>


 qE8  pF YLU% s re% ,5,+ 6y )\  3 '[ q:
F
5B> j% r
qE8 ), j% 'w> j% 6 i* X: reoE / ,3
='D%  pF i* L$D,
joE ,} )$, -L> j% 8D. `( ' jg
Be K
i* X: , 5y8
< C
8I$  5w j% {s jg; '
A j 8y8 N8Z C
8I b[1 =7 6> L4 ,7 6> 6
u_8 *y A d!  ,p F hP89$ p-  -
j% 8 =)$, N8 C*2:  )$,$ I j% X: d[ 67
j% Do
joE ,L D 6 )$, /  -B> @% )Z 8D.
'68$ -F z> j% Do
 =)$, [1 )6B> q:* 7Le i* -E8>
=6 p i* j8D K d% 1
212

,j- , B-9


 j- d[ jD  )$, i* L9 I 
' BL CB9$  6 /8 - 5E  6*  1  Z j%
' 6(8 3 '[ NL 7O,
 6 h I 5E6> j% p09
6 )$> 6y M> , 8B Cy*3 j =)7$> /8 A8,
6 [Ug> j% 81 7E61 Oe ;6 _ ' )$, -E i* Y9:> 3
' z:1 # = h$, -% 81 ,)$, [1 r(8> 7 7B>* i*
: )$> 4 i* ! 6 j8D> j% i* : ~ y* -M4% 81
 -L * : % 8I
r,$_ q 4 =r: 4 q ( d% i* %
 8:, i* {[4 Y9: ,.   q   8:, I}
=0M 8F b[1 7$,Z , 7Le D F ,R d[ ,)$,
V, : 8B $ - 81 6 _ ' /* )$> 8( j
d[ `B 81 )7$D} d[ `B j%  ;~  KG}, 8e8D
A  (e qLD
5,,> ue4  ,8D.  :7 8B -
  8I
d!  81 ,B N8 ~ 6,  }:> oE ,6. [1
 i* -: ?
/0D [1 Y9: =6 N8 6,  A
% >8:74 % D$ ue4 q8 ,K. {s  :7 9$
~0<% 6 /8B> j% ' 6
3 j4 s =`}  % ,-B, %
' 4 6* K
' 6 - j8D j% X: ,)$> d%   5y8

'-U qB
 , E. NM )6B> ?6G T- , ,E:, p +,
K ), [\ q:M,  g}: j% 'D ' =2,3 ' K T8, 
  j% 59, 3 re% (  A h$, '   ~ 8* 5,+ j8D
' = 6  8D. 5$9w> W   : $> C ! g
rLe
jg
8D. B> j% ,' j81% p
' ,. b[1  28 re% 64!
213

5$9w> j% \ 28 re% O$M ~  ;C 6 NO*g


5$9w>
5 } C4 /e rE 6(8 3 6$
  C4  o

 8I
'D =*:I  * NX;g
09y0 ~  : j8D <
)$> )6B, K$1! ;F ' ?4 6* i* 6$ ,; s ,*
i* ' _ )7Le% ;F q3!1 j8D ,8D. ?S uZ
5E jOy A -:
,<U 6  rLe 6B
6( )$> q9*
C6* `e( A ,~   )$,  j8e_ r9 d[ hD,
=)7Leg
hD, 66> i* j 6B 3 '[ ; 6 '
' 3 j8D> ' B [1 ' j8e_ -E A 68  j
$-  KP6, NLF 5^ }> , , Ce ,3 N0U
 h},De V, ,L 4 rE ' , j% 6
3 -* 66Z 'D =-D
' joE q-B 59, 3 L9 j% K> soE =q-B reDo
j4 s
;N8B [* p j4 s 3 ,pF p i*  6 A r  'D
,_ s b66> 59, ,5y8, $
pF )-X> {[4 'D
,:  - Ce ,3 b[1 66 ` =r$
B  Y- '* -F
j% $ : ' +e j% A , 6,
5y8 k9e 5 8> 5
, E- ' Ve% 6 r6 j8D j% ; 4 i* ~   j8D
j% X: ,VeF 6. {s q  OE =G ~ L,m  j% {s k8E
I ' 4 j% 
,5y8 5^ N8 *8 Ce , z:1 j8D>
V, =7; i* N8I.
9 r 28 qLD ' K T8, A
b[1 N0U ' d%- i* )$  g>   K
 6 K
N8 e
 V, ,j ,3  +:$ 20 E- j8D> j% X: ,C>
)PB )$ i* YPB. i* ~   8IB ,Ce ,3 `>- i*%
214

,E-  NL 6 Cs q (F N. 9


 -+ YPB. i*
% '6 N8 6> , Ce ,3 % =76,  CX$ M
i* 6,> j% \ X: 0E N6+$ M T-UF 5y8 %  
j% _ ' YPB.
B$, 8F i* Oe ,q  E % BB
%  F [1 i* ,zs % d%- [1 T-> :4 %  6 % ~ L!
5y  /B  j8D W ,B [1 ' d[ /: l  =zs
u_8  N. r$* 1  N6+$ M YPB. 5^ 8I
%8 %
K_  % :D N( ' )7,LI
 {s -E% g}:  ;.
j8D j% *- 81 BE 6  j8D j% i* ,j )\ 1 O4
z:1 j8D ' =':, K_  % ':, :D N( ' q3!1
7Le 6  ,{s )1
,U s ,'6    ' )7B 
A ?6 , 6 C3m 5^ j =T-U% 5y8 7E j8$, ,
C3m 1 N6+$ M 5y8 8I
)G Z 7:8 5 }>
j% h},D> j% -> j% ~  ` : 8 e i* 6$ 28 'D ;-S
<8, , P,:  jF 20 E- {$, ~ I; jg
67}>
N j8D, =7 O, 3
-6( ,/8$ 8y8 d% 8I
,7
z8 N8 j ,  +: i* ~ _ j4 s wE% L$L `
5 YL, 'D W s V, % ,r YL, d[ ?8$L j4 O@% ,ue4
6 $ ; ' ,
 j% i* N8B * z:1 # ;O7: d%
T % :D =G r8B
67} jg
~  $
j8D 3% 9S ,  K1]

8 =~  *8 j8D> j% ` E- ' $ -L  Ce ,3 j%
:7 ' V, ,'7 ' ; d% , 
C8D $ nt re%
q9* {s jg; ' joE ,1!  re8D
Cq* `
,)$,
215

j%  C68 j8E 5 YL>% e% =6. k8E 9U 9$ C8D.


% $ C 7  T-UF  C7} %  C( 6
 j8 +: j ,3 j86B, '[ 5 n: j% X: :7
d% B [1 ' , C7} {$> p <F j8D 3% i* ; ,U3
j% i* 64 / d%- r9 d[ j28 ?0
)7E: i* 2,
=1! } [1
[]
N8  )1L g j% 6+e b6 )$, N  #
-E j N8Z '68$ _0UF C ,3 z  j N8Z -.
jg}
+. T8_% g}
6(8> , 8F  ,e8eB C ,3
`,  rLe L j ={[4 eM jg}
jF ' M4  AF
. k9e  H1I! NEF -M4% ' 6 81 d
'P4 8(8

j% 'D  n: j% V:


! b[G 09y3 j =
$L9 % L9 5,, W  q:
F 6y -( 81 e % Be j8D>
jg
67 % jD
,D 6$
 = .  -L
_F i*
/-( 81 NLF ' X$ X< 6* ' -M4% p+e joE ,{[4 nI
4 jF ,)7$* ' I , )7$U i* j8} '[ 5^ 6y 9U
KE:, 6* 2 N0U ' 8(F C8, 6@ 66( L
 j6$ ' M4  B9 Ke8B joE |,
 =* i* N8I $
O@6 j% C jE-9 9,  s 3 c  -Z , 
 F  B
9$ c U 6 ' ~ 2 u ,$P* *o
$LD 
=g}
! jeQ  , , NEF d% 1
216

/% P< B [1 ' , Ke8B j84 '* -: ?


 =*
-*} ?- i* AF ( 6
h_8, -% 81 {s 
Ke8B j =- $ ~ _-U D}> 3 F ,>8B 6> 3 % 3 ,$ 
j 8$. (% ' 6 _ ' C0U6> 1 B [1 ' ,
j% B,e3 _0 j% X: ,'-U ds! E 81 q E 8_
{s A ?w> j% d%- p8< ' 'D W j V, 5,+ ' )<8
), , ,-. N8 . DEF joE {s 5 =e8eB 
8B
P  -L - i* BB. C6, /% 87 D
789>
r8 6B> A ?6 m F T6I,> ?8 ,b ~ 6% 3 ,
,j-. ! '  rL%  j% {s 38 7,+,e j8D> K
O
NLF q3!1 ' ~ -_ j8B '[ : ' MD TsF `>
q3!1 ?> LD 8I '  8< g
)7y- 8 e i* LD rE
 r:D> d[ d[ `-X /3 j Be K =H1INLF
'E , :
_ ' -. / A `-X B,E3 5 ,- $
r j8D j% j '-U q[  /23 Y r6 ~ I; 8I,e j% 'D
=; d% q[ j rLe    Y d% k0Q i*

r$ ; d% j% 81  b6IB  'D = 6 A `<   `4-> 1


% ~ -_ } [1 j4 q8 ,KP K-  NLF ' ~ -_ rE-l
~ 2
'  8< g
> r % 7Le B9:  'D %  %  6  0
'  8< g
-g, j% % ) - 5^  NLF q3!1 5 8I
 b8( )D
} [1 i* 5B TsF ' ~ M4 joE ,)\Eg
8I
=NLF q3!1 N
217

[]
N8 $ F ' 4 E p,D ' UF )B V, uB
%
,p,D [1 8y8 A w
,:> 3 , ,8D. U6, 6
e p F j8D> K $ F b[1 g}:> =r
B $< i* 7:D
-EF NE% 6B,
Y$, 3 8y8E =-. %6 N8 6> 3 U6,$
j% 8D $ X: j4 s O* Nge ' :E :)6* N8 6 Oe
)\ -F z> j% ' ~36
)7, $I ,q *  `,> % ,~ ; >
=*89> C*^  % -E LI
r
88B
0 z:1 ,-. i* 6> d% i* 8D. U6> ,} 3 K
=8I  1Me j% {s 5 'D Cy*
i* b[L:> j8D j% n(- ' joE  -% [L:> 6:* re% 81 NF
*   6:* ,*  8I
=8D. 6 i* b[L:> ' wE% -EF 6
' z:1 # ,r>  j88, '[ ;F 8e r>  L4 --B> %
[1 =rE I; nI %  $I )\ '[ ;F ' wE% 81
Y- '*   },e3   ue4 , C0U6, '6 %6
[1 'D =*:I$  C$  8D. |! % j8eB
,LD rE O
rE 8 8>  I,_3 qO$* r:> 8y8
=p,D [1  f
8I r( i* $< r u
,C3. ' M4  =:*8y8
~ >  -M4% M *3
'D , 8
~ : ~0* j[L: 3 O
8,  -EF j% )
b[L:> ), j% ' , ' {s 5  ,8D. 8! rE 1[L: j%
8B,  81 v[ B )7$, $ 84 -EF d% )7$_ '
218

5y8
E8g E- )7P9* ,)7D%   ,9}: )D$ 
` 81 # [1 j% )  ={[ +,e 7 ,$ )\ z> ,
 KL$m 1 /% 6> , CO4   P- ` re% 3 ,68
 ;} -. $  6$ C !  ;   wB
b[1 =*8 C^ _ ' 6> U *:< 5 } 6(8> j%
Y- '* 3 8y8  >-> 3 ,-. uZ c 6:> P u
` : jD 81 [1 # =-89,
Y$,> P 1 Oe ;6
C* e
7L<8
;:8 )$, ' q (g4 P b[1
 p7 
 )$, '  q  ,'8$  ` 6, 64g,

,$P I} ee Bw -P6 ' r$1% c-U ,-. `}$
C4   ,4} nI$ ` F -: i* )168>
* r; % * 5E ' ~ _09e ?, i* )168> d% 4}
, p F # )168> , ?61F
)748$  ; 3
5y 'D 3 ,C9$ C b[1 j =~ w
)7w
'* )\ >
jF `$%  $- 9 ' T-e O4 ,~ e8I rPB
 % - 8, 
 % i* 6:,> 3 , j6$    - $
C-. ' ?4
_ ' E $  9 Cs nI NO*F   j =$ 
)w> CZ _ ' *:I  D 5 }   ,$  j+$
`
_ ds ' -M4% G nI: ,7E N 5y8 j8*89, ~ <;%
-89,  -L * : A ,:> % i* 7,y-*
d[ C  5^
5^  G}, j8D> j% 8D. NO*% i* `$X =L   8:,
-L
- C !   reoE ,-U `e( ' ,'D =j6$
=p +, ] ' r  3 8:> *8:, p  z:1 *89
219

]$ d 4- 8, 6L 8 e i* 7Le  j% 6 59,>


E- e 528> i* 9}e  8I
> j% M4 p  '* :
4 KD 1 6 7 j =
-+, b[1 ' L, 8F N8
B> 3% ' ~36
,r
+,
'-U 5L: j% ' 
- ]U `<
=7$ _t ' ue4 s 3 p  % 8(8

 81 8D. C0U6> 6B> q  T8_F M `


Ll 4 j ={[  j 16  9$ 4-> '* >: D
5 % },e A d!> ~0<% 8D. G 5$9w> , hPl8 A ?w>
q  8Z i* 6 ,  8I
> ,? N i* 1g,
p  i* * % ,8D. i* * A 87 ' }: 89
D 89U k-9 ue4 s =8D. nI j% A ?6@ K
C w  C4 Kg, `>D z8: 66.
,{s A Ey ;8D. ' ~ *-E ~ ^ ue4 s , C
' j r
/8B>  D
,$  #+ 6$ C ! u <% s
Ll8 K,
/8B> 8D. ue4 s ; 4-  Q  -P ,NO*%
j8$9, j8Ll8 q3!1 j4 ,)7> 5E L$, C ! b[1 5^
E I - 5^ joE ,`>-  2 % _-> 4  8D. A
[1  j% g; ' j8D ' , #$+$ -B6 :
 Q  j:
qL4 C2 O$4 =) 3
3 ~ - zs % 6$
wE% i* N8I.  C>  7 C2 O$4 $ 7

6B 2 7E $ B 8B  ' K$1! ;F
 UF L  _ z:1 j4 6_ =r
/8B> j% 'D d[ TsF
220

'* 8D.  e6 6 qw*% 5^ ,U X: reg


B e9-

V4s%  _t ' hPl8 {$> X }> j% (% ' ,E:> j , Y-
MD `t,4 _ 6_ =O~ $> )1-M4% )7$* 8M 'D '[ :
' 4-> ]4% uB , +. K
' =b6y % _3 [1 nI
' LD O
 kE
5,, 3 )P6  - hl8 j% Ky 
j8D, , ,`18 wE% p[,(3 20 F `>- 
6U  % ,'7  
s( -M4% :7  i* 8M i*  _ O~ P
b[1 j% 8 p-X, 3
-}e ' =T-UF  C ! C4
t ,  +.
=$<F 
8I i*  - 4 ,_3 [1 Ie% _ ' u6
 j% {s =Ky  ' -DL b[1 vg> j% 64g,
`- -F re
=B /:$ :
jF /O< -F 5_  81 ~ y* re],
$ 6$   , `18 5^ p[,( ~0E 'D ' j4 re% 8
A 'D +,: b[1 YBZ A - _3 joE ,8D. 6U 
d[ 5,+ * ' q ( 4 j% 8 => 3 /6* ` j% 4 6
j% 8 ,8D. d6%  j4 $; 4 q % ): j, / $,
EBM 5^ joE ,N(- 6_% _ ' O~ P X }> 8D. `<:
qO$  6_ q4s q:M, 
6$ [1   q4[ ~ -B>  8
7 1 j8D,  y -_
  4-  j8D, KM
% d% = 8F 5^ (% ' 5,+ B
7 5$9,> , 68
r(8, (% ' : ' )*F 8 7 g+$ , 7 j8D,
7 5$9, , 7 ;r$* )7$* K,  4  Cq0Q
?61F j8D,  =} /6B, (% ' j8m9 j B ;F
-_ b[1 ?8L<  } B j% 1 89$ 68
221

8D. X> ), ' /: [1 l  =7$U ' qB> 3 /6B,
?8LI c U ' 87 j% {s =X, A   (
j8D> ,
~ 1! } j8D 20 $ ] {$, 3
y % B,e3 0
 )D
% jX9 8* C% 8 V, =-_ * B-
5L>- j% A -U K ' -B6 C !  8 9
j8D '$E ,8D. 0< j6- '[ ' B A /D % )4
81 [1 =-_ nI r:* -> 3 0< d% YBZ 'D '
C ' T-e O4 , -  8]Q r
- d[ `D 5y8
j =7,0 61} ED <-L )\ u : '[ ;F
j%  - j% b 6B
j =-_ 27 /% r $ 3 rLe B
=)  6y % )6
)DR j% 59, 3 r:D , A )7: ;
8I
r,  j89, d[ :w B: Y
j8,, )
 =/8 - {[ )1[L:> /6* -+
B b 6I /8 - 4
9 ' joE  8 -M4% -
 ~ 89> -M4%  w
5,,> , j6$
' 6 r
/8B> q 4 j% 5_8, j% i* ,* d[ , 87 j%
6 ' 8$9 j% j ~ ; )7Le% ' 8$L 3% _F i* % ,)7$(%
], 87 [1 ,r$* L4 V, Oe q L
jsQ BE #
(  A 8F q8> K ;C ' rI  4 '* ! 6
;& 8M" V O
j88B 8D. i* j-, )oE ,G j8$B 3
9$ j6
% * 9$
{s j4 q8 ,-U ; vg 
,-_ A b-% 6I ,9$ -4 A LB ,F ' *S
j8D j% j -_ X,> j% j ~ -B> j4 O4 q 4 8
=7$m R j% -U ; d% 6B

222

[L:> i* ,* `} :


~  h$, 67} :% 2] 'D
,-D 6  : ' 4 )_  e-E  =rL:
rO*%
; yL,e 4  |,
;h<
y > _F i* A8> )7: M4
9U N  B |8, K$1! ;F ' rE g
3 6* z:1
j!}  ]U ' j8e-L r
),  j = 6 A 8B N,_
8$E :e6 NO*F 8e% ' 8e 4  j8D-F rE ] -D
 _ KD-F ' *8 4 j8D,  8D j KD-F u4->

q4[ ' ?4 6B


  NO*F  zs %  [1 [L:> i*
`} ;- `; 4 r$* j8D j% X:  81 [1 =/  /:
6 , jg
~ 6
% n ' ;~ - j8D j% 64! ' -F [1 i* B
BE -9 j89, '[ N(- ' *^ % ( d% _ '
j8D ' =7   4-  Q 6B i* B i* ' _ )F
5w $4} b[1 i* ~ ;  j% 8(-> j% -_
% 6B

N0U ' ; 4 7E ), , 0  'D =re8R 3 q dF


i* [L: j% L
-_ ry > q dF 'D 3 -_
81 8D. D\ d% B [1 ' , 0 8,  j =k0Q
=B )D (F w: j4 'y  $  6B ] ):>
rL: p[, j%  r+e 2 r>s 6
):, [1 jB> 2 O$4
|,
 ,< ry-F )7$ 5,+ CE 5^ ' : 6_%
{s =-_ qw*% {s  O
; 4 8* NO,4 2
K8D  j% O$M )7e )7,:  _t ' j6, /D. jF
,jX9$ k8$ % 81 :I N! j =)7D  _t ' j6,
^  -L 8w j% O4 =K0L 
% jg; {s  reg;
223

*O j% ) ,r,*O :


8 C(  Ve%  81 K*8
=7Pw*F F q9* *O 8B (% ' 8(8 7Le
CqLD C 7 5^ p,  j% :
'* `X 3% X: {[4
~ (* ,d! -% 81 )4. 27 'y 6$  P-
A ,~0( /% 0
j% {s =rLe )4. 27+$ 6B,  6B B }: z01
,eF 5^ jg; {s  reg; ,/e  j8$ ,~  j89
 bqw*%
y-* )7$ [1 ;,
 6*8_ N0U ' 4 6 A  j% r$* K,
-P ~ e% j84 K ,N8D K>-  OXe3  )P6 q-
uZ j8B )oE ,rLe )6B  N8 6 d[ e89 jI
6% N
i* -9U   9 `e( 8 e E6e3 q-
K13 '[1 6y 68 3 j =27  KB qw*F
E. ,-1  Kw_:, j6 e4 j ~ B ~ >  K9>-
T8, 6:* rLe )4. 27  6_ i* L. 59, d[ 68
K:D, e% ' *8 CB,e3 /% ~ 8,L re84 81 ,K 5E
-E8, jF  B- z:1 j8D> j% 6
3 |,
=27 c U rLe 6B

)7P9* ,8D. '* B, 8 e i* ,B [1 ' j8:D, e%


Cs $ j!}  n < )D A <8,$ 20 ] -L
~ E e % s =X F
' 27( P  8I
:6 j8D j% 0
DEg
vg j% 59, 27( ~ <8IU qLD ds ' K!
:e 6 : 3% e % s ,C: , V:, j%  `- $<%
`*8, 3% 27 [\ 6
0E ,B[. u , 1 A -_
= :
)D. 20 C 7 :> D}> , '7 5^ r$U 
224

)+. Cs 8D. `I> ,  ,`e( ' ,:6 js
i* :6 ;r6B> jeQ -. :
E S 1 ,-L
l  ,5,+ 8B *O Y9, ' vg> , 5E: -U `e
5,+ U r(  5B> , YP8 2 (% ' ,)G ? rPO*2
, g 1 ,j28,
Y$,> g :$* -L [1 =r0<
q4[  4- 9$ 5E: ' 'D 6_ ]4% Kg> L4 N8 6>
}e ' 6. k8L ~ 6_ 8D. C8:B$ )$e j% j ,d 4-
  %6> 6 d% 6:* : O4 1 js I,U
g =5,+
Y$, OE 16B*% $ F `<% ' 6 [1 j ?5E: i* :\
, ,<L,
Y$,> 4 6 A 1 g b[1 j =8D. NO*g

# ,*8:, M4 C ,* ::*% `Ie Be j% ' 7E : 6
3
d[  %6 j% 6B,*% :D ={[ B$9 6*_ 5y 9,

 ,::*% /% VB j% ` d[ NM d% ,j%  qB$ r(, e


'D ,
8I i* `$X, A E\ C> 5^ ],e r
d[
5 )+: 8 e i* 9$$
)*% 1 :|, 8 : i* r:* ,
b[1
 C8$$ 'D 4-> _% vg j% i* 2 ,qLD
A d! j% reg; ' NF %6 Y9> j% 3 = 4- ' C8$
, NO*F 5^ j% 81 :6e0+e 8e C3  a6R  r}> +,e
), j% X: S  $I 7E )\ '[ -E 74e j% ' , 3
_ ' )1 ,U ), ,K8D. K! ' 4 6* K
728>
), j% ` eM 6*B Y9> N0U ' ) =$  #+
8D. ' -E _ ' $  j!} ' -E 4 i* d 4- ?SQ
4
/8B 
, 64  SQ 27 j% O4 ;
225

  NO* -L {s ' ,D *8: C] C8$


' ,:(F j6$  r

  q 4 ' ,$  Y: 5^
 Y d 4- ):, [\ j8D j% X: =  )$  f
 ,D E-  j%  U `( r$* ,  4 E-
_ 3 , C  , ' ~ - , j8D K ='-U ,  jD
5E- r_8 N0U ' {s ,$  #+ 6F Bw q  \
j2 N. 9
\ j8D r, Ie joE ,r,0 5 8 k9:
/  i*  8IB j8D, P  !4 $L r,9$ 'D ;4
-% 4  =G 6; 5y8> , Ke8B *o
K$  K8
q3!1 -6B, z j% X: reoE  6*8B  e r - 3
L :
 =)7,B9: 1% /% ! $P uZ ,K!
' 7Le 6*8B 5y X: ,j8eB /% j8! )oE 6*8B
BE 81  4-  Q 9$ * j8D ;, 27 _
)4 $ g+$> j% 7,* /6*   ,9> ue4 s  i* ?SQ
$  Y: A g+$> .  ` % j8eB -E (% '
81 [1 =j8eB  `
8E, W '[ K! ? (% '
j% q-BL '* hL, j8e_ #$+ G 6 % , LD$ / /87L
 q-BL '* hL,$  F  '* K! i* ?
7 O C9$ % j =0 b[1 q e% )  $IL: $m Y:
,C[
. {$>      < ue4 6. [1 q  #$+
BE # B*  8I
-!> , P   Q q8 c0* (% '
6(8> 3 re% ,* i* ;1g
0 i* {[4 Oe ,$  Y: i*
7Le N8Z 7$ 8 e i*  Q q8  _0U% Y \ $m B9:
226

A L> j% A  
d!  ,K(,  '$ * A
5 d _0UF 5y8 d->  `, T-UF $  Y:
C0I
5,, q-BL '* hL, j8e_ #$ j =$ B9
~ M4 76, 3 C0< 1 ,*-E Ke8_ 5y d Q b-4Q
76,   /> Y i* 81 =8y8 [1 N8 d%-  A -:

C0< 7:D ,:8  $I


8_ _0* 7E j8D> , . 
$  j!} i* ?SQ  ' ~  7_9e c U j8D,
$  Y: 5 CO$, C8$$ d 4- 27 'D =E
 j% 8D. 59,> 3 = Q -E 5^  $ _ r j8D,
67 LR 64%  8I
6* d[ }: ' 6. k8L ~ 6_
LZ ' ~36
,8D. /8B> K $D} %6> 'D =-L T6 -89,
m R 1 7}e  oE  7(F -EF C0< }:
/8B, ~ e( ?8_8
)1-g> % 64 j8$ )7$ K ;)7}e
j = D:, 3 ~ e% nI: 0Q
/8B> j% ' ~36
,)7:* )7$

=)7: hg,> '[ -EF _ 1 89 T6 i* 6 _


8 V, 6+, \ 8% )7$ j%   1-E% / B> , 6
)* -% d% YBZ 'D 3 re% 6L -F )18B> j% C % %
5 8, nI  , 6 j% O4 =~ X< : j8D K ~ B
~ $_ )@6 j8D jF eM >-  vg> )7,E  -EF T6 B
' 0
  O Y- '* vg  \ -7 - % EyQ  Q  7
r$(% ' d[  NO4 j% ?9   6+, ,NO*F <L>
u$wE , 8. 8B A B,E3 `
,7L: ' q D
u y
= 0 -M4%  8I
 > j% eD   F ' 7L:> j%
227

228

References

Anderson, Elizabeth (1991) John Stuart Mill and Experiments in


Living, Ethics 102, 426.
Annas, Julia (1977) Mill and the Subjection of Women,
Philosophy 52, 17994.
Bailey, James Wood (1997) Utilitarianism, Institutions, and
Justice (New York: Oxford University Press).
Baum, Bruce (1997) Feminism, Liberalism, and Cultural
Pluralism: J. S. Mill on Mormon Polygamy, Journal of Political
Philosophy 5, 23053.
Baum, Bruce (2000) Rereading Power and Freedom in J. S. Mill
(Toronto: University of Toronto Press).
Baum, Bruce (2003) Millian Radical Democracy: Education for
Freedom and Dilemmas of Liberal Equality, Political Studies 51,
40428.
Bentham, Jeremy (1961) The Collected Works of Jeremy
Bentham, ed. J. H. Burns (196179), J. R. Dinwiddy (197783),
Fred Rosen (198394), Fred Rosen and Philip Schofield (1995
2003), Philip Schofield (2003) (London and Oxford).
Bentham, Jeremy (1970) The Collected Works of Jeremy Bentham:
An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, ed. J.
H. Burns and H. L. A. Hart (London: Athlone Press).
Berger, Fred (1984) Happiness, Justice, and Freedom: The Moral
and Political Philosophy of John Stuart Mill (Berkeley: University
of California Press).
Berlin, Isaiah (1969) Four Essays on Liberty (Oxford: Oxford
University Press).
Bronaugh, Richard (1974) The Utility of Quality: An
Understanding of Mill, Canadian Journal of Philosophy 4, 317
25.
Brown, D. G. (1973) What is Mills Principle of Utility?
Canadian Journal of Philosophy 3, 112.
Brown, D. G. (1974) Mills Act-Utilitarianism, Philosophical
Quarterly 24, 678.
Brown, D. G. (1982) Mills Criterion of Wrong Conduct,
Dialogue 21, 2744.

229

Callicott, J. Baird (1989) In Defense of the Land Ethic: Essays in


Environmental Philosophy (Albany: State University of New York
Press).
Capaldi, Nicholas (2004) John Stuart Mill: A Biography
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Carlisle, Janice (1991) John Stuart Mill and the Writing of
Character (Athens: University of Georgia Press).
Cooper, Wesley E., Kai Nielsen, and Steven C. Patten, eds. (1979)
New Essays on John Stuart Mill and Utilitarianism, Canadian
Journal of Philosophy, Supplementary Vol. 5, 119.
Copp, David (1979) The Iterated-Utilitarianism of J. S. Mill, in
New Essays on John Stuart Mill and Utilitarianism, ed. Wesley E.
Cooper, Kai Nielsen, and Steven C. Patten, Canadian Journal of
Philosophy, Supplementary Vol. 5, 7598.
Crisp, Roger (1997) Mill on Utilitarianism (London: Routledge).
Cupples, Brian (1972) A Defence of the Received Interpretation
of J. S. Mill, Australasian Journal of Philosophy 50, 1317.
Di Stefano, Christine (1991) John Stuart Mill: The Heart of
Liberalism, in Configurations of Masculinity: A Feminist
Perspective on Modern Political Theory, ed. Christine Di Stefano
(Ithaca: Cornell University Press), 14486.
Donner, Wendy (1991) The Liberal Self: John Stuart Mills Moral
and Political Philosophy (Ithaca: Cornell University Press).
Donner, Wendy (1998) Mills Utilitarianism, in The Cambridge
Companion to Mill, ed. John Skorupski (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press), 25592.
Donner, Wendy (1999) A Millian Perspective on the Relations
between Persons and their Bodies, in Persons and their Bodies:
Rights, Responsibilities, Relationships, ed. Mark J. Cherry and
Thomas J. Bole III (Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers), 57
72.
Donner, Wendy (2006) Mills Theory of Value, in The
Blackwell Guide to Mills Utilitarianism, ed. Henry West (Oxford:
Blackwell), 11738.
Donner, Wendy (2007) John Stuart Mill on Education and
Democracy, in John Stuart Mills Political Thought: A
Bicentennial Re-Assessment, ed. Nadia Urbinati and Alex Zakaras
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 25074.

230

Donner, Wendy (2009, in press) Autonomy, Tradition, and the


Enforcement of Morality, in Mills On Liberty: A Critical
Guide, ed. C. L. Ten (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Donner, Wendy, and Richard Fumerton (2000) John Stuart Mill,
in The Blackwell Guide to the Modern Philosophers, ed. Steven M.
Emmanuel (Oxford: Blackwell), 34369.
Duncan, G. (1973) Marx and Mill: Two Views of Social Conflict
and Social Harmony (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Eggleston, Ben, and Dale E. Miller (2007) India House
Utilitarianism: A First Look, Southwest Philosophy Review 23,
no. 1, 3947.
Eisenach, Eldon J. (1998) Mill and the Moral Character of
Liberalism (University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press).
Lewis S. Feuer, John Stuart Mill as a Sociologist: The Unwritten
Ethology, in John Stuart Mill, On Socialism (1879; reprint, Buff
alo, N.Y.: Prometheus, 1987), p. 10.
Fuchs, Alan E. (2006) Mills Theory of Morally Correct Action,
in The Blackwell Guide to Mills Utilitarianism, ed. Henry R. West
(Oxford: Blackwell), 13958.
Garforth, F. W. (1979) John Stuart Mills Theory of Education
(Oxford: Martin Robertson).
Garforth, F. W. (1980) Educative Democracy: John Stuart Mill on
Education in Society (New York: Oxford University Press).
Gaus, Gerald (1980) Mills Theory of Moral Rules, Australasian
Journal of Philosophy 58, 26579.
Gray, John (1996) Mill on Liberty: A Defence, 2nd. ed. (London:
Routledge).
Green, Michele (1989) Sympathy and Self-Interest: The Crisis in
Mills Mental History, Utilitas 1, no. 2, 25977.
Green, Michele (1994) Conflicting Principles or Completing
Counterparts? J. S. Mill on Political Economy and the Equality of
Women, Utilitas 6, no. 2, 26785.
Habibi, Don A. (2007) John Stuart Mill and the Ethic of Human
Growth (Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers).
Harrison, Jonathan (19523) Utilitarianism, Universalisation, and
Our Duty to Be Just, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society n.s.
53, 10534.
Hart, H. L. A. (1963) Law, Liberty, and Morality (Stanford:
Stanford University Press).

231

Heydt, Colin (2006) Rethinking Mills Ethics: Character and


Aesthetic Education (London: Continuum).
Hoag, Robert W. (1986) Happiness and Freedom: Recent Work
on John Stuart Mill, Philosophy and Public Affairs 15, no. 2,
18899.
Hoag, Robert W. (1992) J. S. Mills Language of Pleasures,
Utilitas 4, no. 2, 24778.
Hollander, S. (1985) The Economics of John Stuart Mill, 2 vols.
(Toronto: University of Toronto Press).
Kinzer, Bruce L., Ann P. Robson, and John M. Robson (1992) A
Moralist In and Out of Parliament: John Stuart Mill at
Westminster, 18651868 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press).
Kymlicka, Will (2002) Contemporary Political Philosophy: An
Introduction, 2nd edn. (Oxford: Clarendon Press).
Laine, Michael, ed. (1991) A Cultivated Mind: Essays on J. S. Mill
Presented to John Robson (Toronto: University of Toronto Press).
Locke, John ([1689] 1980) Second Treatise of Government, ed. C.
B. Macpherson (Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, Inc.).
Long, Roderick T. (1992) Mills Higher Pleasures and the Choice
of Character, Utilitas 4, no. 2, 27997.
Lyons, David (1994) Rights, Welfare, and Mills Moral Theory
(Oxford: Clarendon Press).
Lyons, David, ed. (1997) Mills Utilitarianism: Critical Essays
(Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield).
Mazlish, Bruce.1975. James and John Stuart Mill. New York:
Basic Books.
Mill, John Stuart (196391) The Collected Works of John Stuart
Mill, ed. John M. Robson, 33 vols. (Toronto: University of
Toronto Press).
Morales, Maria (1996) Perfect Equality: John Stuart Mill on WellConstituted Communities (Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield).
Morales, Maria, ed. (2005) Mills The Subjection of Women:
Critical Essays (Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield).
Nussbaum, Martha (2004) Mill Between Aristotle and Bentham,
Daedalus 133, no. 2, 6068.
ORourke, Kevin C. (2001) John Stuart Mill and Freedom of
Expression: The Genesis of a Theory (Lanham, MD: Routledge).
Packe, M. St John (1954) The Life of John Stuart Mill (London:
Secker and Warburg).

232

Rees, J. C. (1960) A Re-reading of Mill on Liberty, Political


Studies 8, 11329.
Riley, Jonathan (1988) Liberal Utilitarianism: Social Choice
Theory and J. S. Mills Philosophy (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press).
Riley, Jonathan (1998) Mill on Liberty (London: Routledge).
Riley, Jonathan (2007) Mills Neo-Athenian Model of Liberal
Democracy, in J. S. Mills Political Thought: A Bicentennial
Reassessment, ed. Nadia Urbinati and Alex Zakaris (Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press), 22149.
Rosen, Frederick (2003) Classical Utilitarianism from Hume to
Mill (London and New York: Routledge).
Rossi, Alice (1970) Sentiment and Intellect: The Story of John
Stuart Mill and Harriet Taylor Mill, in Essays on Sex Equality,
ed. Alice Rossi (Chicago: University of Chicago Press), 363.
Ryan, Alan (1988) The Philosophy of John Stuart Mill, 2nd edn.
(New York: Macmillan).
Sarvasy, Wendy (1984) J. S. Mills Theory of Democracy for a
Period of Transition Between Capitalism and Socialism, Polity
16, no. 4, 56787.
Schneewind, J. B., ed. (1968) Mill: A Collection of Critical Essays
(Garden City, NY: Doubleday and Company).
Semmel, Bernard (1984) John Stuart Mill and the Pursuit of Virtue
(New Haven: Yale University Press).
Sen, Amartya, and Bernard Williams, eds. (1982) Utilitarianism
and Beyond (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Skorupski, John (1989) John Stuart Mill (London: Routledge).
Skorupski, John, ed. (1998) The Cambridge Companion to Mill
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Skorupski, John (2005) The Place of Utilitarianism in Mills
Philosophy, in The Blackwell Guide to Mills Utilitarianism, ed.
Henry West (Oxford: Blackwell), 4559.
Skorupski, John (2006) Why Read Mill Today? (London:
Routledge).
Smart, J. J. C., and Bernard Williams, eds. (1982) Utilitarianism:
For and Against (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Sosa, Ernest (1969) Mills Utilitarianism, in Mills
Utilitarianism, ed. James M. Smith and Ernest Sosa (Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth), 15472.

233

Souffrant, Eddy M. (2000) Formal Transgression: John Stuart


Mills Philosophy of International Affairs (Lanham, MD: Rowman
and Littlefield).
Stafford, William (1998) John Stuart Mill (New York: St Martins
Press).
Sumner, L. W. (1979) The Good and the Right, in New Essays
on John Stuart Mill and Utilitarianism, ed. Wesley E. Cooper, Kai
Nielsen, and Steven C. Patten, Canadian Journal of Philosophy,
Supplementary Vol. 5, 99114.
Ten, C. L. (1980) Mill on Liberty (Oxford: Oxford University
Press).
Ten, C. L. (1998) Democracy, Socialism and the Working
Classes, in The Cambridge Companion to Mill, ed. John
Skorupski (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 37295.
Ten, C. L. ed. (2009, in press) Mills On Liberty: A Critical
Guide (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Thompson, Dennis (1976) John Stuart Mill and Representative
Government (Princeton: Princeton University Press).
Urbinati, Nadia (2002) Mill on Democracy: From the Athenian
Polis to Representative Government (Chicago: University of
Chicago Press).
Urbinati, Nadia, and Alex Zakaris, eds. (2007) J. S. Mills Political
Thought: A Bicentennial Reassessment (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press).
Urmson, J. O. (1953) The Interpretation of the Moral Philosophy
of J. S. Mill, Philosophical Quarterly 3, 339.
Varouxakis, Georgios (2002) Mill on Nationality (London:
Routledge).
Vernon, Richard (1998) Beyond the Harm Principle: Mill and
Censorship, in Mill and the Moral Character of Liberalism, ed.
Eldon J. Eisenach (University Park: Pennsylvania State University
Press), 11529.
Vogler, Candace (2001) John Stuart Mills Deliberative
Landscape: An Essay in Moral Psychology (New York: Garland
Publishing).
Weinstock, Daniel (1996) Making Sense of Mill, Dialogue 35,
no. 4, 791804.
West, Henry (1972) Reconstructing Mills Proof of the
Principle of Utility, Mind 81, 2567.

234

West, Henry (1976) Mills Qualitative Hedonism, Philosophy


51, 1015.
West, Henry (1982) Mills Proof of the Principle of Utility,
The Limits of Utilitarianism, ed. Harlan B. Miller and William H.
Williams (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press).
West, Henry (2004) An Introduction to Mills Utilitarian Ethics
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
West, Henry, ed. (2006) The Blackwell Guide to Mills
Utilitarianism (Oxford: Blackwell).
Wilson, Fred (1990) Psychological Analysis and the Philosophy of
John Stuart Mill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press).
Winch, Donald (2004) Thinking Green, Nineteenth-Century
Style: John Stuart Mill and John Ruskin, in Markets in Historical
Contexts: Ideas and Politics in the Modern World, ed. Mark Bevir
and Frank Trentmann (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press),
10528.

235

236


9 ================================================================ )( 6B
23 ================================================================== -. p,4
41 ==================================================================== 6B =1
63 ====================================================== B: -DL - =2
129 ======================================= 9 . :* T6 -L =3
161 ============================================ -L i* 5,+ 9$ 6 =4
193 ================================================================== CB9> =5
229 ======================================================================= 5(-

237

238

You might also like