Response to ASD Comments ASD Comments (LetterRef: ASD63/6104/SSP318/C50/500(104) ) 1st AIP 3rd Submission Central Plants and Rooms

s and Underground Submission Sub. Date: Doc. Ref.: Ref 1 a i)

and External Works (Part B Open Space) 12-Jan-2009 DSF/BS/143

ASD Comment Major comments on design brief and reports:Clause 1.0 - Introduction The scope of this submission package and the space/areas, which are classified as Open Space presumably to be managed by LCSD, to be rd covered under the submission are still missing from the report (3 reminder)

JRP Response

Appendix

Have been revised in this report. The details demarcation of the Open Space areas can refer to Appendix - D for details.

ii)

The facilities shared use amongst the different user groups of CGC/LegCo, CGC/Open Space, CGC/LegCo/Open Space and LegCo/Open Space should be under separate package of communal facilities. This submission shall only be focused on Open Space and shared facilities in relation to Open Space

Have been revised in this report.

Clause 2.1.2 Design Criteria for MV space Only those rooms/areas solely designed for Open Space should be Have beed revised in this report. mentioned in the design criteria table. Design criteria for irrigation water pump room, water pump room, filtration plant room, etc., which are served use should be submitted under Common Facilities package Clauses 2.2.3 & 2.2.4 - Plumbing and drainage installations Plumbing and drainage installations shall be submitted under separate Noted. packages Clause 2.2 Air and water distribution velocity The proposed design criteria for air distribution velocity shall be Noted. subject to the recommendation of acoustic report. Clause 3.1.1 AC system Tee off reserve from the central chiller plant should be allowed for Open Space.

Chilled water and hot water tee-off will be provided inside Central chiller plant room.

Response to ASD Comments ASD Comments (LetterRef: ASD63/6104/SSP318/C50/500(104) ) 1st AIP 3rd Submission Central Plants and Rooms and Underground Submission Sub. Date: Doc. Ref.: Ref f
and External Works (Part B Open Space) 12-Jan-2009 DSF/BS/143

ASD Comment JRP Response Clause 3.1.2.4 Park toilet CCMS with time scheduling supplemented with local control for Confirmed to provide. circulating fans installed in toilets shall be provided.

Appendix -

Clause 3.1.3 - CCMS Description of CCMS proposed shall be specific for Open Space. Have been revised in this report. Irrelevant information shall be removed from the report Clause 3.2 FS installation Areas/rooms of Open Space proposed with shared use of fire hydrant/ hose reel system, sprinkler, street hydrant, manual fire alarm, AFA, shall be summarized in the report for ease of reference Clause 3.2.5 AFA The fire alarm and evacuation matrix table has not included Open Space Please note the comment made on the same table under CGCO, CGCL and LegCo submissions Fire alarm signal to be repeated to fire repeater station in Park Management office shall be stated in the report Please indicate whether the actuation of building alarm will trigger the alarming in facilities of Open Space or vice versa Clause 3.5 Electrical installation In view of optimization of transformer loading capacity, please review It will be revised in schematic drawing and loading estimation if the electric loading of common facilities/ open space can be in report combined into one single transformer and paired up with the transformer group of central chiller plant for resilience design

i i) ii)

iii)

iv)

j i)

Response to ASD Comments ASD Comments (LetterRef: ASD63/6104/SSP318/C50/500(104) ) 1st AIP 3rd Submission Central Plants and Rooms and Underground Submission Sub. Date: Doc. Ref.: Ref ii)
and External Works (Part B Open Space) 12-Jan-2009 DSF/BS/143

ASD Comment JRP Response Separate power supply cubicle to be housed by a separate switch room It will be revised in schematic drawing and plant room layuot. shall be allowed for Open Space to ease future differentiation of maintenance responsibility as per the ER Section BS2.1 clause 2.1.2.

Appendix

It will be revised in schematic drawing. Clause 3.5.1 Electrical power system The proposed electrical schematic distribution is not acceptable. The power distribution and utility metering shall be categorized into Open Space, Common shared facilities of Open Space and other communal facilities of non-open space. Please note the markup comment on the schematic drawings Clause 3.5.9 Essential power supply Common services to be back up by emergency generator (including NFSI and FSI) shall be categorized into CGC/LegCo, CGC/Open Space, CGC/LegCo/Open Space and LegCo/Open Space Noted and all of them are proposed to property management.

It will be revised in drawing layout. Clause 3.5.9.7 Exhaust flue pipe routing for emergency generator The proposed exhaust flue run is considered too long and technically undesirable in term of reliability. Please review the discharge location Clause 3.5.9.8 Fuel storage and fuel supply system Please clarify the provision of fuel tank room for Open Space.

n i) ii)

It will be incorporated in report.

Fuel pipe trench shall be flushed with the finished floor level of the It will be incorporated in report. generator room in view of the congested room and the safety concern Clause 3.5.11- PQM and BEM system The description of system shall be specific for Open Space, in particular energy apportioning for Open Space It will be incorporated in report.

Response to ASD Comments ASD Comments (LetterRef: ASD63/6104/SSP318/C50/500(104) ) 1st AIP 3rd Submission Central Plants and Rooms and Underground Submission Sub. Date: Doc. Ref.: Ref p
and External Works (Part B Open Space) 12-Jan-2009 DSF/BS/143

ASD Comment Clause 3.5.13 Active harmonic filtering equipment Harmonic filter shall be sized according to the harmonic characteristics of the associated non-linear equipment load so as to meet the requirement as laid down in the Electrical Energy Code instead of 15% of the rating of the connected load as stated in the report. Design calculation shall be submitted Clause 3.5.15 Lightning protection system Lightning protection system proposed shall be subject to your submission of risk assessment as per the BS EN 62305 which has superseded BS6651 as effective on 31 Aug 2008 Clause 3.5.16 Public address system Design criteria of sound level shall be given in the report. Clause 3.5.17 - Induction loop system. Please state the area of Open Space is to be provided with induction loop system. (2nd reminder) Clause 3.5.18 Water leakage detection system Please explicitly state where the leakage detection system is to be provided for Open Space. The proposed areas fall outside the scope of Open Space. Please review

JRP Response It will be provided in DDA.

Appendix

It will be incorporated in report.

It will be incorporated in report.

It will be incorporated in report.

It will be incorporated in report. Clause 3.5.19 Intercommunication system Please confirm whether intercom has been allowed for plant rooms of Open Space and EMSD office which is located under the Green Carpet Appendix D Demarcation plan The demarcation plan has been updated. The B/F driver's Please update the demarcation plan based on the latest agreement with room is under the management of CGCO. the users. Also, please check and confirm if the B/F drivers room is under management of Open Space

Appendix-D

Response to ASD Comments ASD Comments (LetterRef: ASD63/6104/SSP318/C50/500(104) ) 1st AIP 3rd Submission Central Plants and Rooms and Underground Submission Sub. Date: Doc. Ref.: Ref w i)
and External Works (Part B Open Space) 12-Jan-2009 DSF/BS/143

ASD Comment Appendix E Load estimate Please elaborate the breakdown of load estimate of (150kVA normal + 37kVA essential) allowed for building landscape lighting Please elaborate the breakdown of load estimate of 60kVA allowed for ACMV installation Please elaborate the breakdown of load estimate of 132kVA allowed nd for irrigation water pump (2 reminder) Please elaborate the breakdown of load estimate of 158kVA allowed for water feature (2nd reminder) Firemans lift has been included into the load schedule of FSI generator. Please clarify if such is allowed for Open Space. If not, please delete it from the schedule

JRP Response Noted and It will be subject to LDP design.

Appendix

ii)

It will be shown in load estimation.

iii)

It will be shown in load estimation.

iv)

It will be shown in load estimation.

v)

It will be incorporated in common area report.

Have been included in this report. Appendix F Schedule of Maintenance Work The maintenance schedule is incomplete. FS, CCMS, generator, etc., have been missing from the schedule Appendix I Major Equipment Maintenance Route Will be provided in DDA submission for the details of The proposed access route for major equipment maintenance in maintenance route. basement has not been shown on the submitted drawings. Also, the minimum clearance of access dimension required to be maintained all along the route is to be given. Please elaborate the design provision to cater for seismic situation and Have been included in this report. natural disasters as per the requirement stated in the ER. Section 1.0 in design report.

Response to ASD Comments ASD Comments (LetterRef: ASD63/6104/SSP318/C50/500(104) ) 1st AIP 3rd Submission Central Plants and Rooms and Underground Submission Sub. Date: Doc. Ref.: Ref aa
and External Works (Part B Open Space) 12-Jan-2009 DSF/BS/143

ASD Comment JRP Response Maintenance requirements and strategy shall be proposed to address It will be provided in report. the shared use of installations amongst different groups of users, such as CGC/LegCo, CGC/LCSD, CGC/LegCo/LCSD or LegCo/LCSD. nd (2 reminder) Please also refer to comments given on the same submission on Common Facilities for those areas relevant to the Open Space Have been included in this report.

Appendix

ab

ac

Some of the replies to previous ArchSDs comments on 1st AIP 2nd Noted submission is unsatisfactory. Please note the markup comment on the returned report and amend accordingly. Please refer to other comments marked up on the returned design Noted report Major comments on drawings:Power distribution shall be divided into Open Space; Shared facilities There are two kind of power distribution. One is Open Space, of Open Space; and Shared facilities of non-open space another is Common area.

ad 2 a

Power distribution feeders from the main cubicle switchboard and It will be shown in DDA drawings. emergency generator cubicle designed for Open Space and Shared facilities of Open Space shall be dedicated in order to demarcate maintenance responsibility

Local maintenance bypass switch shall be provided for those ATS of There is no ATS in kind of non ACB or non MCCB. non-ACB or non-MCCB types.

Response to ASD Comments ASD Comments (LetterRef: ASD63/6104/SSP318/C50/500(104) ) 1st AIP 3rd Submission Central Plants and Rooms and Underground Submission Sub. Date: Doc. Ref.: Ref d
and External Works (Part B Open Space) 12-Jan-2009 DSF/BS/143

ASD Comment JRP Response Main switch shall be allowed for the respective main supplies of It will be revised in schematic drawings. essential and normal power circuits of Open Space and Common Facilities in order to differentiate the ownership of the power supply system. Separate switchroom should be allowed for open space and common It will be revised in drawing layout. facilities for ease of future maintenance work under different ownership PA Schematic The headend equipment of PA system should installed Noted and will be incorporated in drawing layout. in Park Management office instead of G/F security control room Cubicle switchboard layout plan shall be submitted It will be incorporated in drawings.

Appendix

g h

IT infrastructure schematic diagram. Please indicate the provision for It will be incorporated in drawings. Open Space The following areas/rooms which have been shown on Airside It shall be SWHP plant room. Schematic diagram should not be classified as open space: HV generator room Fuel tank room for HV generator room