Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Table of Contents
STEVIA: A new player in artificial sweetener game ......................................... 1 Stevia Sweet eners: S afet y, ADI and Met abolism ................................................. 2 Stevias popul arit y spans the globe ...................................................... 3 Regulations on stevia ............................................................................ 4 Safety of stevia . .4 Stevia for use as sweetener in the European Union ................................ 5 Stevia Market. ........................ .5 Sweeten er Market .......6 Mark et of Stevia in India ................... ...7 Large un tapped market ................ ..7 Herbal sweeteners could eat into the mark et .... ..8 Current Pl ayers in the mark et ...... ..9 "Natural" Stevia Muscles into Sweeten er Market ....... .9 New Player on the Fi eld Taking Ai m at Quality, Costs.. 10 Formulation for a Stevia Pure Play . .1 1 Summary . .11 Appendix ..12
The steviol glycosides are used to sweeten a number of foods in Asia and South America. Table 1. Food Use Levels Reported to the Committee
Food type Reported maximum use level (mg/kg)
Food Type
Sauce Pickles
Delicacies 200 Sweet Corn 160 Bread 300 Biscuits Food consultancy Zenith International reports that stevia products saw a 27% increase in worldwide volume sales in 2010 over 2009, taking its overall market value to US$285 million. From mid-2009 to mid-2010, new product launches using stevia extracts increased by 200%, with products launched in 35 countries 237 new products in the first half of 2010 alone, according to market research firm Mintels Global New Product Database (GNPD). Mintel values the natural sweetener product market at US $763 million in 2010, with the stevia market alone at $670 million. A leading stevia manufacturer has projected that stevia will penetrate 20% to 25% of the US$60 billion global sugar/ sweetener market. Regulatory approval in the European Union (granted in November 2011) has set the stage for stevia use to explode on the other side of the Atlantic in 2012 and beyond. Asia Pacific, where the ingredient has been used as a sweetener in some regions for decades, has the largest market share for stevia at 35.7%, followed by North America (30%) and South America (24.3%).
Regulations on stevia
The stevia leaf, which contains several glycosides, is used as a sweetening agent in various parts of the world. It is recognized for its ability to reduce the caloric content of popular food and beverages. The safety of steviol glycosides for human consumption has been tested through peer-reviewed research, including metabolic and pharmacokinetic studies. Stevia is approved as a sweetener for food and beverages in many countries. Governing bodies around the world have concluded that stevia is safe for use as a general purpose sweetener. Specifically, in 2008 and 2009, the Food and Agriculture Organization/World Health Organizations Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA), a global panel of food ingredient safety experts, and the United States Food and Drug Administration stated the use of pure steviol glycosides (95%) is safe for human consumption as a non-medical ingredient up to 4 mg/kg of body weight/day. In 2011, the European Commission authorized the use of pure steviol glycosides (95%) in foods and beverages across the European Union.
Agence Franaise de Scurit Sanitaire des Aliments (AFSSA, or French Agency for Food Safety) Codex Alimentarius Commission (CAC) European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA) Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) Health Canada U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
Safety of stevia
Stevia has been consumed for centuries by the indigenous people of Paraguay. It was also approved decades ago (1970) and commercially available as an alternative sweetener in foods and beverages. Reportedly, stevia extract represents more than 40% of the high-intensity sweetener market in Japan. Stevia extract contains several steviol glycosides and other molecules from stevia leaves; until recently the technology for the separation & characterization of such molecules were not adequate enough to determine the safety and stability of stevia leaf extract that regulatory authorities needed for approval as a food ingredient. However, with the advancement in the process and characterization technologies over time, more high purity stevia extracts were produced and thoroughly studied for generating safety and application data. On evaluation of these data, the global regulatory bodies have come to trust and accept stevia as a safe food ingredient.
The International Stevia Council, the authoritative voice for the stevia industry, applauds the final approval of the European Commissions Regulation to authorize the use of steviol glycosides as a non-caloric sweetener in the European market. Maria Teresa Scardigli, the Councils Executive Director, said: The final hurdle in the regulatory process for steviol glycosides the scrutiny of the regulation by the European Parliament and the Council of Ministers has been cleared. The regulation has been formally adopted on 11 November and will enter into force twenty days after publication in the EU Official Journal, which occurred on 12 November. As a result, consumers across Europe will be able to enjoy products sweetened by steviol glycosides as early as 2 December 2011. Carl Horn, President of the International Stevia Council, said: This is a major step forward for consumer choice in Europe. Steviol glycosides are derived from a natural source, the stevia plant, and are zero-calorie. These two characteristics are key attributes for consumers searching for better for me products in their efforts to lead healthier life styles and manage weight. In the coming weeks and months, consumers will begin to see new products sweetened with stevia appearing on the shelves in European supermarkets. This will include a wide range of goods, including yoghurts, cereals, beverages, soft drinks, confectionary, chocolate and table top sweeteners. Hundreds of new products are being launched each year made with stevia extracts across a wide range of countries and products from table top sweeteners to beverages. Stevia extracts have become particularly common in Asia, South America and the United States.
Stevia Market
A perfect storm driving market demand Driven by a near perfect storm of demand, the market for all natural, zero-calorie stevia sweeteners is exploding. A leading stevia manufacturer has predicted a global stevia products industry valued at $10 billion as soon as 2015. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates stevia intake could eventually replace 20-30% of all dietary sweeteners. The total global sweetener market was estimated at $58.3 billion in 2010. Market drivers include: Soaring rates of obesity, diabetes and heart disease. Increases in the rates of these diseases are linked to high consumption of sugar and/or high-calorie sweeteners, and are soaring worldwide.
Sweetener Market
Strong trend toward natural sweeteners The global sweetener market, dominated by sugar, had an estimated value of $58.3 billion in 2010. Stevia is one of the fastest-growing newcomers in the $6 billion (est.) sugar substitute market. This includes artificial chemical sweeteners as well as naturally derived non-caloric sweeteners. The global sweetener market is growing at 2% to 3% a year. There are two main segments, sometimes called natural artificial, but also called nutritive and non-nutritive. Nutritive sweeteners include sugar and high fructose corn syrup (HFCS); non-nutritive sweeteners include zero-calorie High Intensity Sweeteners, e.g. artificial sweeteners such as aspartame and sucralose, and naturally derived sweeteners such as stevia. Sugar/HFCS comprise 80% of sweetener market and are growing in-line with population expansion. Non-nutritive sweeteners are projected to grow at 5% a year between (20082015). Artificial sweeteners have been dominant but the trend is toward natural sweeteners, according to a Raymond James publication, Agribusiness. In an August 2011 report, market research firm Packaged Facts said artifical sweeteners Sweet N Low (saccharin), Equal and Nutrasweet (aspartame) all saw sales drop in 2010, while natural sugar substitutes saw sales increase. Stevia sweetener Truvias sales jumped 73.7% between 2009 and 2010.
Sales of Splenda sucralose, the leading player in the US retail/tabletop sugar substitute market, dipped 5.6% from 2009 to 201; Splenda fell from a 61% share of the retail sugar substitute market in 2007 to 45.5% in 2010, while Truvia and Stevia in the Raw accounted for 13.8% of the market in 2010. Equal went from 12.4% of the market in 2007 to 6.5% in 2010, and Sweet N Low fell from 13.2% in 2007 to 11% in 2010.
artificial sweeteners. This reduces the potential market size. Nevertheless, even if we consider the additions in the past 10 years (16.15mn, the target market is huge, given that currently only 2.96mn people consume any artificial sweetener. Consumers of artificial sweeteners are growing at a CAGR of 20% during FY07-FY10f. Assuming that a diabetic consumes four pellets per day (each pellet is equivalent to a teaspoon of sugar; in all our calculations, only the pellet form of consumption is considered), the size of the artificial sweetener market is pegged at INR1.25bn or 0.2% of total sugar consumption in the country. Product concentration and raw material cost increases are concerns ZYWL derives 76% of its sales from two brands: Sugar Free and Nutralite. High product concentration and the growth opportunity in both categories are likely to draw competition. In case of Sugar Free, which contributes 40% of sales, the new range of herbal sweeteners using the stevia plant could pose a big threat to artificial sweeteners based on aspartame and sucralose. If approved, they could capture 50% of the market. Another risk is the price of key raw materials such as aspartame. Unlike other FMCG products, the company does not undertake frequent price changes in Sugar Free as it looks to grow the market. This is likely to put pressure on margins.
Lifewater products. Formulations for Coca-Cola's flagship drinks Sprite and Nestea have been modified to include enough stevia to reduce the sugar level by up to 30%. The market share of stevia products among alternative sweeteners is small but growing at a fast pace. The market might shift to stevia at faster rates if supply and quality issues could be resolved. Today nearly all stevia is grown and refined in China and South America. The plant will not grow from seeds and must be painstakingly propagated in greenhouses and transplanted into fields. Harvesting is also challenging. So far production is limited and the cost of stevia extract remains higher than equivalent sugar or corn syrup. UKbased PureCircle is among the largest stevia producers with grower relationships in the stevia shrub's native home of Paraguay and the U.S. PureCircle's Paraguay sources reached commercial production levels in early 2011, and a new grower relationshipp with S&W Seed (SANW) is expected to yield its first stevia crop from a California test field in yet this year.
marketing and brand development expertise. Robert Brooke, the company's chief executive officer, is confident the group can become a successful vertically integrated participant in the stevia market.
Summary
All the companies with stevia products are likely to be beneficiaries from consumer acceptance of stevia as a sweeterner alternative. For the larger players such as Carghill, ADM and Tate & Lyle and Integrion, stevia products may allow them to retain a share of the sweetener market as beverage forumlators such as Coca Cola and Pepsi introduce new non-calorie products. As ADM's income statement demonstrates, sweeteners are highly profitable. However, investments in any of these large conglomerates are impacted by their other businesses such as seeds or food products. To get a pure play on stevia, investors could consider Stevia First, which is bringing proprietary agriculture know-how to stevia cultivation and new technologies to stevia glycocide. As a developmental stage company, Stevia First has no operating history. It may also need to raise additional capital. It can be seen Stevia First is entering the market at the right time, when no player has yet to dominate the market. Thus a long position in STFA entails risk but could be timely.
APPENDIX
The Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA)
Many countries rely on the safety assessments of the Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA), a committee sponsored by both the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) and the World Health Organization (WHO) of the United Nations (UN). Comprised of internationally-prominent toxicologists, biologists and experts in risk assessment, JECFA has been investigating the safety of food additives since 19562. JECFA evaluated safety data of stevia extracts and proposed the specification of the extract containing at least 95% steviol glycosides content and approved an Acceptable Daily Intake of 4 mg (steviol basis) per kilogram body weight. JECFA follows an established set of guidelines for the evaluation of food additives, all JECFA evaluation reports are published in monograph form and are available to the public. Most regulatory bodies of different countries use JECFA determinations of safety in considering approval of food additives (2010 Monograph).