Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rodrigues
The Evidence-Based Practice Movement A major contribution to the call for a more rational
approach to clinical decision-making was the growth
Most clinical practice, is based on limited evidence, in clinical, administrative, outcomes research, and
mostly textbook information, obsolete concepts, investigation into the determinants of healthcare costs.
nonvalidated case studies, partial or unendorsed These developments have made it mandatory for
reviews and abstracts, and anecdotical or individually healthcare professionals and managers to be aware,
accumulated clinical experience. Proven therapies appraise, and systematically make use of published
backed by ample evidence are underutilized due to data (4).
lack of knowledge or grasp of available evidence and,
frequently, clinicians do not believe that benefits EBP can be seen as a process of turning
observed in clinical trials can be translated into clinical problems into questions and
clinical practice (1). systematically locating, appraising, and
using contemporaneous research and
Evidence-based practice (EBP), which gained impetus critical reviews, i.e., the best evidence
in the early 90’s, replaces the traditional paradigm of possible and the most appropriate
“medicine by authority”, by a more critical and information available as the basis for
scientific approach (2,3). decisions.
EBP values, enhances, and builds on clinical Information and knowledge management constitutes
expertise, facts about disease mechanisms, and human the core activity of the healthcare professional. To put
pathophysiology. Failure to use evidence has been the problem of information, as an essential support
show to result in a considerable lag period before component to appropriate decision making, in proper
therapies of proven effectiveness are implemented or perspective, consider the costly mistakes that stem
ineffective therapies are withdrawn from practice. from incomplete information – of the roughly one
Ultimately, EBP represents the formalization of the trillion dollars spent in healthcare in the United States
care processes that the best clinicians have practiced in 1998, an estimated 25% relates to the delivery of
for generations (3). unnecessary or avoidable care, the performance of
redundant tests, and excessive administrative costs.
The introduction of evidence-based clinical practice
has had a positive impact on medicine and pharmacy – Information Systems and Information Technology
drug therapy being perhaps one of the most significant (IS&T) contributions to EBP is accomplished in six
areas influenced by EBP. Evidence-based practice areas of application (Figure 1):
concepts have been adopted in physician’s training
programs that place emphasis in problem-solving and • Reference Databases
information search skills (6,7,8). • Contextual Data
• Clinical Data Repositories
• Administrative Data Repositories
Information Systems Support to • Decision Support Software
Evidence-Based Practice • Internet-Based Interactive Health
Information
The role of information systems is to capture,
transform, and maintain three levels of facts: raw data,
processed data, and knowledge (9). Data in context, as Reference Databases: Literature, Clinical Trials
processed data, is traditionally referred as and Reviews, Current Research, and Guidelines
“information”. Information conveys intelligence about
a particular topic and can be considered the equivalent Most of the literature on EBP emphasizes the
of “evidence”. Knowledge is information in context. It utilization of published evidence, usually restricted to
represents an intellectual construct of a higher order, papers, reports, and research recorded in formal
where evidence from various fields and sources are technical or scientific sources (7,10,11,12,13,14,15).
linked, validated, and correlated to established Basic research and clinical observational data and
scientific truths and thus becoming a generally evidence are represented in the biomedical literature
accepted body of wisdom. (books and periodicals), in the formal publications of
scientifically conducted clinical trials and reviews,
and in the formal records of current research
Because EBP is an information- and initiatives. Jointly, they represent a body of
knowledge-intensive process, focusing information and knowledge – Biomedical Knowledge
attention on evidence-based practice from – that can be employed in the generation of clinical
an informational perspective and the guidelines, protocols of care, and in the support of
implementation of an information evidence-based decisions.
infrastructure (“infostructure”) in the
clinical and administrative practice Reference databases containing formal scientific and
environment constitute the core of the technical literature are helpful in a research
contribution of informatics to EBP. environment but are of limited service in the day-to-
day practice of the non-academic environment. What
most clinicians require are fast, up-to-date, concise,
and structured responses to their queries that address,
in a systematic manner, the diagnosis, findings,
therapy, and prognosis of health conditions.
3
CLINICAL
BASIC
OBSERVATIONAL
RESEARCH
DATA
BIOMEDICAL
LITERATURE
CLINICAL
TRIALS &
REVIEWS
CURRENT
CLINICAL RESEARCH
DATABASES
UNENDORSED
SOURCES OF
HEALTH
INFORMATION
INDIVIDUAL
MEDICAL
RECORD BIOMEDICAL KNOWLEDGE
(EMR) GUIDELINES
DATABASE WEB-BASED
INTERACTIVE
HEALTH
INFORMATION
DECISION
SUPPORT
SOFTWARE
ADMINISTRATIVE
DATABASES CONTEXTUAL
INFORMATION
(ENVIRONMENT,
ANTHROPOLOGY,
EPIDEMIOLOGY,
SOCIO-ECONOMIC)
PATIENT
ENCOUNTERS EVIDENCE-BASED DECISIONS
Information systems dealing with contextual data and From a population perspective, collections of
information always played an important role in structured records can be maintained in clinical and
making such type of evidence available to administrative data repositories and selectively
practitioners. With the more recent developments in extracted to assist in the construction of clinical
telecommunications they gained renewed interest and guidelines and evidence-based clinical and
increased role. The emergence of Internet-based administrative decisions processes. “Intelligent
contextual information will be examined in detail agents” is a recent development in software
latter.
5
technology that allow selective extraction of data from generated in the U.S. when several chain pharmacies
large data repositories. disclosed patient-specific data to third parties (21).
The privacy issue regarding access privileges and data • Is it to be considered a medical device passive of
control is particularly serious – the transformation of regulation?
data residing in paper in different sites into integrated
digital data, easily retrieved through a variety of • To what extent does the application software
access points, and the recovery of data about allows clinicians to examine the underlying logic
individually identified persons, creates the possibility and to independently evaluate how the software
of misuse. Although, many of the possible uses of arrived at particular conclusions?
detailed patient data, such as population-based studies
of the efficacy of alternate care interventions, can be • What is the role of such products in critical
done without individual source identification, a clinical decisions?
variety of possible uses require patient identification.
• How the consequences of eventual errors are to be
On the other hand, the demands of many care-related dealt with?
tasks such as reimbursement, composite individual
record, auditing for fraud and abuse, “push” It has been pointed out that there is a vast array of
techniques in healthcare delivery, and support to problems that have not yet been addressed. The issues
direct patient care require the ability to access patient- are important in light of the fact that the health
specific data outside the care setting. From a technical information technology industry is investing millions
perspective alone, to merge patient data from diverse of dollars in developing such applications.
sources requires the identification and transport of Developments on a number of policy, legislation, and
patient-specific data with all the attendant privacy regulation issues are badly needed in this area (22).
issues that such process involve.
“Push” techniques, whereby health managers, using Internet-based Interactive Health Information
patient-specific information identify candidates for
potential interventions and reach out health programs, Advances in telecommunications, computer
even though considered, in most circumstances, applications, and user interfaces are changing the
justifiable from the preventative public health and nature of interactions between health professionals
health promotion standpoint, can trigger strong and the population and the Internet (World Wide
opposition. In this regard, consider the controversy
6
Web), a low cost, ubiquitous, and flexible technology, The main health-related concern of the widespread use
is the fastest growing medium in history. of interactive Web-based technologies is the
enormous volume of unendorsed, nonvalidated,
The growing area of Interactive Health misleading, and potentially harmful health
Communication (IHC) is defined as (23): “ the information available on the Internet (24). Clearly,
interaction of an individual, consumer, patient, there is enormous interest of the general population in
caregiver, or professional, with or through and retrieving health information – according to one
electronic device or communication technology to study, of the approximate 50 million Internet adult
access or transmit health information or to receive users in the U.S., over 17 million searched the Internet
guidance and support on a health-related issue.” The for health information for the year ending July 1998,
impact of these technologies are found in the relay of and this number is estimated to double in the next two
data and information, in enabling informed decision years (25).
making, in the promotion of healthy behaviors, in the
facilitation of peer information exchange, self-care,
and in the management of the demand for health IS&T and Knowledge Management
services. Challenges
IHC applications are changing the nature of health How to approach the utilization of clinical and
communications and health practice, they are management health information is still a complex,
accelerating the empowerment of providers and chaotic, and controversial subject. It is not surprising
patients, and making easier for consolidated entities to that many expectations regarding the contribution of
operate within increasingly large and complex health information systems to clinical practice have
organizations. “Old” media, including radio, not been fulfilled.
television and print have effectively contributed to
knowledge dissemination and health promotion – the
new opportunities offered by Internet-based IHC have The history of failures to deliver products
the following characteristics (23): that are acceptable to practitioners, the
difficulties of automating clinical
• Increased access to health information and support decision-making processes, the industry
on demand in any site via a plain telephone line or failure to appreciate the peculiar
any variety of wireless communication options. economics and culture of healthcare
delivery systems, the nagging lack of
• Increased opportunity for interactions among policies, and the improperly understood
users using electronic messaging. and incompletely addressed information
systems technological issues, consist the
• Enhanced ability for widespread dissemination core problems of most experiences with
and for keeping contents and functions current. health information systems development
and implementation.
• Improved opportunity to tailor information to the
specific needs of individuals or user groups. Patient medical records and encounter data as source
of evidence data requires the redesign of clinical
• Multimedia resources, combining text, audio and records, methods to capture and organize data,
visuals. computerization of records, methods for data search,
and data interpretation. Many investigators have
• Increased opportunity for users to remain attempted to extract meaningful data out of textual
anonymous, thus facilitating access to sensitive material recorded in clinical encounters, but the
information and frank discussions about health handling of medical record text is fraught with serious
status, behavioral risks, and fears and difficulties because of the idiosyncrasies of medical
uncertainties. records. An example is HEALNet, a project directed
at information extraction from medical text in support
of EBP using statistical concept representation and the
7
construction of a core information retrieval engine Besides the need for economic and organizational
(26). discipline, true healthcare reform will require a health
information revolution. A key symptom of the
Although information technology has the potential to absence of rationalization in the sector is the virtual
dramatically sharpen the focus of the healthcare lack of systematic and uniform operations-
systems on patients’ needs and preferences, this will measurement techniques and tools and quality and
only be reached by a concerted effort by professionals, control data, which were not required under the public
governments and the industry to address the above cost-plus or private fee-for-service models of care.
problems (27,28).
Health reform “industrialization” processes involve
The great majority of innovative developments in statistical process control, operations research and
informatics products for the health sector and their reengineering techniques, line-employee (direct care
implementation will arise from the motive for profit. provider) performance measurement, benchmarking,
While the private sector is promoting the rapid and outcomes measurement. New techniques include
development of new health information technologies, program budgeting and marginal analysis studies, an
the public sector has been mostly passive and may economic evaluation combining practice data for the
even create roadblocks, intentionally or otherwise, to before period and literature data to model the after
the spread of technology. In special, privacy concerns, period [33]. These initiatives require vast quantities of
software regulatory policies, and ethical and legal healthcare data and a wealth of data processing and
issues regarding telehealth may be the source of analytical intelligence. The ultimate goal of healthcare
conflicts in the near future [21]. industrialization is to provide every clinical situation,
no matter how unique, with automated digital support
The dissemination of guidelines present special that will generate quantitative predictors, optimized
problems. Segmentation of the target audience is decision-making, and maximized results, be they
necessary for effective dissemination of guidelines, a lower costs, improved quality, or a combination of
study in the Netherlands conducted among family both.
physicians to evaluate the adoption of evidence-based
practice guidelines indicated that for some The computerized applications to support such
practitioners it is desirable to make evidence quickly objectives must follow a hierarchy in which systems
available through publications, for other spreading the tasks range in complexity from reference retrieval and
guidelines through local networks was found the processing of transactions to more complex
effective, while for another group a more active, decision-support systems. The functions required by
personal approach was found to be necessary [29]. EBP in management and clinical service delivery
involves both ends of the spectrum. They include
It has been suggested that the most important static and dynamic modeling routines, driven by rules,
transformation needed today in the teaching of normative knowledge databases, and vast stores of
medicine is to foster the information management clinical and administrative data. Their outputs consist
aptitude of future professionals. Training has been of quantitative comparisons of outcomes associated
considered a major component in the implementation with alternative managerial and medical decisions.
of EBP. Evidence-based medicine is an increasingly
important concept in medical school curricula and Those factors are major challenges for medical
continuing medical education [7]. informatics and argue for significant public
investments in technology development through
Getting evidence into practice requires resources and collaborative research efforts among the industry,
organization [30,31,32] and to use evidence-based academic centers, research centers, the health
decision-making requires organizations that have establishment, and the government.
systems for finding and appraising evidence and
professionals who are skilled in searching, evaluating,
storing, and using information and knowledge.
8
4. Berkvits, M. From practice to research: the case 16. Becker, L. The Cochrane Collaboration. Valuable
for criticism in an age of evidence. Soc Sci Med 47 resource for family physicians. Can Fam
(10):1539-1545 (1998). Physician 43:403-404, 412-414 (1997).
5. Rosenberg, W. and Donald, A. Evidence-based 17. Silagy, C. and Lancaster, T. The Cochrane
medicine: an approach to clinical problem-solving. Collaboration in Primary Care: and international
BMJ 310 (6987):1122-1126 (1995). resource for evidence-based practice of family
medicine. Fam Med 27 (5):302-305 (1995).
6. Kenney, A.F.; Hill, J.E. and Mcrary, C.L.
Introducing evidence-based medicine into a 18. Michaud, G.C.; McGowan, J.L.; van der Jagt,
community family medicine residency. J Miss State R.H.; Dugan, A.K. and Tugwell, P. The
Med Assoc 39 (12):441-443 (1998). introduction of evidence-based medicine as a
component of daily practice. Bull Med Libr Assoc
7. Michaud, G.C.; McGowan, J.L.; van derJagt, 84 (4):478-81(1996).
R.H.; Dugan, A.K. and Tugwell, P. The
introduction of evidence-based medicine as a 19. Langton, K.B.; Horsman, J.; Hayward, R.S. and
component of daily practice. Bull Med Libr Assoc Ross, S.A. A Clinical Informatics Network
84 (4):478-81(1996). (CLINT) to support the practice of evidence-based
health care. Proc AMIA Annu Fall Symp pg 428-
8. Shin, J.H; Haynes, R.B. and Johntson, M.E. 432 (1996).
Effect of problem-based, self directed
undergraduate education on life-long learning. 20. Nicoll, L.H. Don’t forget GratefulMed when
CMAJ 148 (6):969-976 (1993). conducting literature searches. ANNNA J 19
(6):521 (1992).
9. Zvarova, J. On the medical informatics structure.
Int J Med Inf 44 (1):75-81 (1997). 21. The Washington Post. Prescription Sales, Privacy
Fears: CVS, Giant, Share Customer Records with
10. McKibbon, K.A. Evidence-based practice. Bull Drug Marketing Firm. February 15, page A1
Med Libr Assoc 86 (3):396-401(1998). (1998).
11. Odunsi, K.O.; Cooke, I.E. and Olive, D.L. 22. Moran, D.W. Health information policy: on
Evidence-based medicine: how do we find the preparing for the next war. Health Affairs 17 (6):9-
evidence?. J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 5 22 (1998).
(3):313-318 (1998).
23. Robinson, T.N.; Patrick, K.; Eng, T.; Gustafson,
12. Lindberg, D.A. and Humphreys, B.L. Medical D. and the Science Panel on Interactive
informatics. JAMA 277 (23):1870-1872 (1997). Communication and Health An evidence-based
approach to interactive health communication: a
9