.


 


   
 

    

 !"# $%#&

 /
0 1
2
 34 56 *+"

'
()
*+"
,- . 
4%
 789 :;< :
= >6

?@A
B)C >- . D9 E# #

  
2008  
1429

978-9953-87-398-5


All rights reserved. It may be reproduced

with permission of the Academy of Change
The authors have asserted their right under the
Copyright, Design and Patents Act 1988,
to be identified as the Authors of this work.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data.
A Catalogue record for this title is available from
the British Library.

   

(AOC) $3 45'6 17 890
 

   
 
info@taghier.org :(#);  (961-1) 785107 - 785108 - 786233 :
www.taghier.org % ! 1102-2050 "#$ !  13-5574 :.
asp@asp.com.lb :(#)* + ! (961-1) 786230 :&'
http://www.asp.com.lb :,--* )% /0 12

..
 
  




  
   
   
  


7 ............................................................................ 

11............................................................................ 

21............................................................ ! !" #

23........................................................

 


24................................................ 
 
 
29............................................................ 


31........................................... ! &$ %$$" #

33................................
    
 :

35..............................     
 : 
37...................... ! "  
# $

 :

39....................................................... ! %'( #

41........................................................... %& 
 '
42.......................................................... %& 



47.................................................. ! )  #

49.........................  
#&   " (

52......................... ) %*+ " (


5
55............................ - ""
" " (

56..................... . )  / "')" " (

57.................... 0) 1
#& 2 " (

59........................................................ 3  


61..........................................................  *&" 

64....................................................................... 
65...............................................................  4 
66................................................  5    %
67...........................................................   *6/
69................................................... %3  74

71...........................................! &$+ , -

77............................................................................ &

81......................................................................... 

6
 

     


   
  !"# $% & '(  )*+
,- .#/ 0
4#/ 5 67  8 2 9:- ;<  12 % &3 

!-
D/ D+ E(:- .4#=! #> ? &?@ A1 B#
F GH 6
7 0 I +  J * 'IK LMNO #PQ
RS- ;<
   G 
 T
 U
F< 0

S !> 0 V W 7A  !!&- X  4
- Y4 +
.$Z  [ &?@
8\] ^1-
O3  
  _7 ><   %3 `a-
#Y(
 bc4c- G '1
 b :- d=
 ># ? &?@
 8(& 
 e%<
  f 1I b#=? $,-#%
'1i 5 Y% 
 #
 ? &?@ d
, 0 gh
.;  ? &?@
#< 6<+ X #4S ) (Y j#O

"
     "

 YY- 
&
%  "l] 0 A m
" d > `a4
+#,
S-  
o p $
 q#% > n:N d#
X 7p g
- 4 r
 7<
Y+ + n:N d#  ? &?@
9] L FZ - ? > X G? " 4#s?  8#(O 'Y=-
.m
 'I 4 r
 7< Bt%  Y( ;7 &u +
7

  
   8

#6 sZ  967 &Fa+ 8#O tZ v3 ;#Sw4 x : y#? :?3
F / ? > gH 9M
z 0 ! 4#  9A1 mc?
967 &F< 4 2 l] 0 9&(?< ;#6 sZ ${ ;< v3 % 
i<  Y%@ 1 9s: t&- X I4/  :1 B <
.!= #6 sZ

S- > 9V :1- 
S4 ;< 04#6 sZ 

Lf) 8
SZ  :1 Bt% + #6 sZ 7 |3  V7<
 i i
m
 
& '+ :A O S  i i
M 
.(~ ...
>#/ Z  Y!=  &% E+  A 1f q# H€
n
‚  I4/ :1  t% 0 %
7 7ƒ+ n:N
( )
  _7 >< „ % . 1 04#6 s
 4 / f ;
!
B 1Z ; &?@ 4#1! f q#: .+# !Y
 %
 73
H6 b 
 +< X :Z 4 d
, …#1% +
F4  U?< 8
Z 7
 n:N … S=? !I d
%p
  4r
I%

7 A G#=! '1 ;< 'r&
.!% :Z '( 'M+
0 '+ ˆ‡&rf m
  :i 0 †r4  d Y H6 ;3
l# y& v3  1Z '- : 5r †3 ? Y3
.8€ d <  ,-

(1) Sarin (2001), BodyHammer, Tactics and Self Defense for the Modern
Protester, v1.1, http://www.devo.com/sarin/bodyhammer.html, accessed
March 6, 2007.
 9  

5 % 87 ;Y4 ;< 0 ‰< :1 ŠH6 0 ‹4/

d= : (& 87 Z ŠH6 GV  _7 >af m


A   Y d= B 1- ;af …% 
  Y/
;<  Yr
 0Y_ > 
6 F  Y B 1- ;< 0 P
;
A#4 04H D+#tZ ‡ %< q F@ 87 Z ŠH6 0 (&-
€ e
f +#tZ  Y/  >#/ < .G
w/ #=
#Œ< < 4
  ; Y € LAŽ4 ;< 0 N
b wf  :- + >  ; Y
.LA q
<


 
  
 


10
 ‡îè¸
...
  
    "

 
 " 
  



11
12
   
  


   
  

,
  ! "#$ %
&'( )*

+ , -.


/01 2 

3 4#+ ,/01 2 5678+
<3 ?3 ->
9:; 63 <+:= >63 ,6 
: 6

9G3+ 5.#= @!8 6A3B ?63 56!C+ ,D)E6F

 <CH
  IJ
+ ,2= ?3 &0)H C 6
 5  6
.520


 !
 90!
 L

"#$ M 

 <CH
 ?63+
N7>
 @CO ? 5PQ RB ?3 53 S+68+ ,56T %U6

XCY .0 3 
  !

Z 
[ \W# V+ .I#6
+
+ 0 3 < 
+ <;
 _   
 ]-!
 ^3=
%
/01 2 
,XH
 W# 6 IJ 6
6
.+
S0! RcB V  . #!
+ !
 6
b a6H
`+ ,06$
.3+!F %+d :! Z ? "#$
>U3+ e. G* 3 >O e
&A( 6Cf 6.+
H_Y ? e 0_03 V Trassuk )g h ,iA( :0620

&A( S _ jB "E
C:F+ k
 PZ6
 &= +6[+
? <30_
 <.0
h ,C[ P_+ ?3 0 3 Zl 6m=
13

  
   14

0# ) ,\2 Cf V &A( 3n _ 
  nF SmY

( )
. 1 

 SmY V D>3

.
   
2500 
   :1 

.
   
1700     :2 

(1) Richard A. Gabriel, Karen S. MetzFrom Sumer to Rome: The

Military Capabilities of Ancient Armies Publisher: Greenwood
Press Publication Date: 1991
15 

.
   
900 
   :3 

.
   
400     :4 


  
   16

.
   
200    :5 

.
   
100     :6 

V .  S+Y &A( &0C &= 4!7F ?3 eAo. p+
 3=

Rq= V 9:020F P>
 P>!
 V r3 0# 6) 3n 6_
.MY ?3  3
17 

"   
  !  :7 

.#
$ %  & '

<ZW>
+ p+
 ^n _ jB k
+ C:F PZ
 "E

+
< [ 0U+ XA+s
 U
) '!
 0U6
 V 60

( )
. 1 _
+ C0mb+ ,A0
+ ,C30


(1) Complete Encyclopaedia of Arms and Weapons.


  
   18

 

p+
 ^n _ jB 
 <) t 0
36+
+x= ,?3Y %0 v 
 Uw
 -;E
 jB 
Z 6uo.
L
g &= gBzN$ += OE
 %0 -3 pE
 y63 -;E6w

:jB / 
+ ,pU
 9:B {O ?  . -3  k

?3 lC2+ ,/01 ?63 l6A "#6$ 6Cf :

( )
V ?3Y %0  }~ &+: 
0[ S ?63 , 1 <6G(
.">
 V iA( 5! 5 _€ Rc= ?C# F v(
M
 R2 
 jB ?C# F R0$ ^ &6v :

^+ 5‚U= <>c  r.H _ C[ <!
&= h ,-!

X [ F 5#0ƒ+ ,
 -!
  :6
 V 5#06
( )

5T0! V P>
 9+c &= ) , 2 
 ) ' XW

<… %†3 4. ,4P„
 "
 _= V 506+ ^6 6
.^ _Z+ 
 "‡ %= 9: 3
5PQ RB  5#GB+ ?C# F X8 6ƒB :


,e ^0!
3 %+2 ^ -!
 6
Q p6B+ ,56
 63+!3+
50G pˆB  &+U3+ XH
 M01 &+‰ &+6# F.
.Š
+ 530U1
jB 
 : !3 ?3 
 ) R7EA !A :
 
S ?3 ,1 5! +E
5#8+ ,9:>6F U63

.
 


 



 
   (1)
(2) Gene Sharp, The Politics of non-violent action. Boston: Porter
sargent, 1973. Three volumes.
19 

p+
 !
^n _ „3 ,„C[ 5!
IC‹ V 56_f
.CH

Œ #C <#F V p+
 ^n 6_ &B :l63
5#)
3) ?C# F ^0 IUC &= ?3 Zl >6. ,X 6
&0
0 5uo. ,<#F H.3 <0 -6.: 6 5#:062+
,IOn
 V X [ 0_Y jB )
 W# ?3 l">) lR62
S _ ?3 Zl  \c= 
 :!.B )+ ,@C. V 
 6)+
?C# F -3‰ Ž8 D L
g+ .: F 
 
  :

-3 0 @ G. 5T 
+ .5U *6 56!
p+6
( )
. 1 5U1+ 0$
^n _ ?3 /T l2 0C &= R7E6
 6+ :
S= V 3n _ 0>; C &=+ ,‘
 ? p.
 0#+ ,p+

V 
  .  l:  ,OE
  ) 630;#
S2 jB 
+ ,"#$ ’G V ^
 <+:= I
46

) .e “[ I” XW
 - • –A ?3 5#>  OE6

C  03Y \W# „3  IC
 6—= jB \>6 AZ I6”
IC
™>

 ,9 F F
 <6_˜F ?63 DU6Un 3
.
 ?3 p0
 W# „3  
 <)

 
 !" #$% &'
  #* +, -/ 0
12 34 5 (1)
"C< D
E!
 
*" 6
7 -/ #8
 9 : ;< =>? @#>* 5A><
.FEG
 HE:I
7J
20
 Ê늇Ûa@Êaìãc@Þìy

 




21
22


 


  
      
  
( )
! " #$$ % $  &'   ()*  + 1 
 / 0$ 1
23 4   .,- ( )*

  &' 5#6 78 , )9 : ;<$= 
: # 
.!?#4$' ;@6 :
  
 ●
. A- B' C DE :  
 ●
F G HI JKLM ;
= N 1$ O # F M PQ
:  ●
1
S$?
TU 9# V8 F G !?#4$  R*
 +;W1 "$G I J,'0= H*G M +N 0$C ;  
\- '1   ] +( ? (6X ;?'Y ( Z[
^?0$* +_ 18C ,` I a' b$ 2?8 +_KLM _^?8 $/ C
; I < ;? GQI ( ? (6X ;?'Y ( Z[
de# 0M c ; 0S' M <$C U 9# F G 
.1# , #f
- N R ! 4 "#g ! c _18C

(1) Complete Encyclopaedia of Arms and Weapons.

23

  
   24

] ;S'- ;?LZ &' h$ ij :  !"# ●

  / b$ +U 9# !01 ( )' <$$
!* ; 8 k
+lP &' , #I
 A$=
 
' " #=
; m D?'1$ n   
 ;?Z )= 5E1 <$
FQ
T(` k4 e 
 !$= F M Po  +pM
.J #= &' pM J 
* _0X8 qr- ;?4<9 
;M3 ; B M Po :$% &'( )
* +, !"# ●
F@ ;?Y bX3 JKqr  FQ
TU 9# N6Y ;I')
"FM"  ; #r 7')= F M Po  +;L # sM FG*
(;?'1$ ;? ) bX3 JKLM  FQ
T
 A$= ; 03
.;L # FG*
25    


 
 
 FG F ' ;?*E !?#4$ ;1Z k'w 
 
* 0#?I +?' N43 ?#4*   2?8 +_ S)
sM #G +( 1') ( Ii D $ X' i
 ; m ;1=
+;I=  I ; 
 ;e $C
GW +;'G*
.;'G$ ?'1$ !#4 ; 
] ;?   b xI # y$#
:5#6 78 , )9 <$
:

1

GW 2?8 _?#4*  - +_ ? sM- G9 
{$ +yq E` 6 _ s $= ; 01 "?I" , )z <$
DE  |  +b 90
75 HI J   E )
.;?I- F'L
   ;Z9 <$*
;'G$ ;' J
 !?#4$ ;  ~o ;
e[ I c *^?}

.
)L &' 4 ' ; m 
  c

  
   26


  
 
 
 :8

!
 "# 
    ... 
   
 
.$%  &
'( )
*+ ,' -

: 

2
kG?6G   +;? I G JG= G &' FG
+;LI J$ *  ;0?1$ $0 FG* +&) F1

~o 5$G
 +;0?1$= ;01' H$G
I ;
= I € I  1*
b _‚ 9 FG lEI +
$= HL X'
)L 
; 0„ F@ ;… ^?0$ .
)L  ƒ8 5$G
 F [
.
)L 4
:

3
+2's=  (^?} |  +;? J ) G EY†
H  &'- ; 03 
 } NZ LR ; $0 F Kz
. ~o ;
e[ I
27    

:

4
;S
G ( <$* +F  : D?'1$  
Z {$ +G9 n)  +6L
 KsG  "q9
;M3 ;‡' ?R N Xˆ d0 2?„ +b 100
70 HI 
0M +J #= ~o ;R 3 F X' JKLM ; 0„ ^?0$ .H1
N 4o +( 9 ;I $G ;r k)* S) ;8  ; F
.U 9# I ;
 $= K 0 ~o  
C +€‡ Yo  '1 "4 +bX3 KLM 
I?
 
 S$C  !R$ (C 8  J #=  JKLM ;„ d0
. L=

  
   28


  
/ 
 
 :9

+ 01 2 3
4   
/

5 
 " 
/ 3
67 "/
.1' 01 "/
29    




-8 
 
/ /% ## 
 :10

'%  
   -9 (
.
 
  "/ 

  
   30

&' h$
 I6

+ €E <$

G0$'
xI 1=  ~o # ‰)$# + <$ + ‚ O [ ;??M
: I O [  ;<$=

  
 

 
   


:~o xI 1= b1#*

"')$* C + ‚ O Š J8 _ ‹ $/ ] k :

.b E "')$* ] ;? #s |GI +E
 _0

* 0#?I . ‚ O Š
? ~o ‹ $/ ] k :


(  gC 5'$Π  lS$ ;3 8 E xI 1

* C HE xI 1 FQ
TE ;M3 { $= := "„
€ L$C " (C 3 !?‘  .1
5'Ž    ;M3 :
|L  ’#[
 ;) !eI ;iL1 ;1 ; m Je ~o
;1)#= €E &' F^M$? O G$8C qi F 2?8 +(@ 1
. S$C :
 de  0M  !'e
 o45 ;^I xI 1= BLs*
 +_8 _P <$* ] xI 1= ; 8  “I  (10) G9
+ ” R &' @$ G9I F $Ls?
HiL1 <$ ; 8 
k$M HI ;
= •
G ˆ +b 50
30 0 #?I ;
= FG*
. 0$? DE –<9
 Ê늇Ûa@âa‡ƒn
a@pbî
b
c@Þìy

 

  

31
32
  
      :


 
    
( )
"#$ %&  ' ()*+ ",$ - ./ ( 1  !
((11 789) / 01 2 3+ "#$,  45
(
!
# </ (*>
;8 1 <-   < ;8=

. ?
@&! ?  ABC  D /

Handle Positions

Arm Strap
Positions

Arm on
Center Line

.
 
   :11


.
 
  
     ! (1)
33

  
   34


 
 

  



./01
2& 3 45 67 )  !" #$%&
'(  )*
+
 ,-

.->
. -?
@! 8A BC D/ <-5 = )89
 :;!
.EF
1
C G!H
C 
 . -?
IJ K5 )L+ /
3N . -?
@! EAO
.P4 Q
 5O
8AR
. S 


.&S )+
 @!
 L+! .T%U
.&V

.P4 Q
" XJ Y
Q/R
Z @! -T W*
+ 

 _A 3C .]S E` a\ .[5\]$^
 \5 EAO

/  3 4 ) O4 1

[ [b
EF1
T` :1

.

 L  / ./ c$5d E` :DH
Q
"
35       


   
 
 :

a\ f_AD
L+ / .!T$^
Q-!T$
E!gC e%U [4b
 ! #
+j
& 
i$9
@! -$T$9 .ha^
3C _g )R5C
.G!H
 L 
C 

. C )
 
f " \ L+
kjl .m
f2^

L+
kj\ 
i$9/ .ha^
3C 6S .*
+
 :DH
n
p qD
 3 q5 K!S 3N ).&V
fno [4  .5 " 3 4
[5j
 S

r%^
Q
0 L+
@!V .5-V
_ $ ).

.:Kq!s 3 q5

 
L+
t5 uS c L+
i$ 'v5 $
a
)#
+j
w 
 L+
5 P$ x
  )c-
.K%O
r%a
.5y 8ha
i$5 L+
kj\ (C :]T$ 
{ #
+j
'( e5y [ )3Fz
 E!
r%F .&7
..-]$a .5U/
G!H
C 
 f+a^
 fno .&V
kj\ 3C 
E7 +
C #-
 .5
|  
34z/ cFC x )8
..V

[   cqF L+

S ` .UOF
[ _v& 
\ . V
}!  c  .%a / Q+H
RC )G!H
[ 

G!H
[ *UOa
n f " cF| 
i$9
 c-~ L+
eD
.:DH
p qZ @! 8AR!

  
   36

 
S $/ L+
i$ .q" 3 4$ L
. S  C
QR h )  !" #
+j
 #$%&
'(  
 #"

.+ & BC €S Ea  Q/R

Z [4b 67 #
+j

:DH
 a  ;l
D/ 
[4-
‚_%& L+
3&
0
q4$5 = )
 
 2q
ƒ )#$%&
'( fn5| e5y [
p qZ „$O [ KTa )Ka&C  :DH
p qZ */N/
.[5\]$^

37       

     

 
 :


S

L+
-P )… 4O/ i$ L+
rT/
Q4$4$ T/ - †T$F p 9 )‡ih
[ . -ˆ
.! 3-R .-K^
‰a
rT/ @! &ŠF a\ aa4  )K
i$9

.L+
kj\ v 
i$9

)K!d  .%T$ 3 4 )3|

.!( L+
kj\ 3 4  % g .1
)K R BC ET  [ . -?
&‹$ 3C / 
j
3 n%$5 # U$^
[ n _  e5y [ } 0 3 45
xC E` )rT%
-T5 rT%
<5$ )Œa$ / [&

c!T ET$ / Th

0N )K$"y Ž  cqF #&+O^
SC -
%" [ . -?
@Š x uS c!o  [ E!U/ .+^

.[5n C n GT
)-KT"  [ [5n C n ! n;w K$! L+
q .2
)x  ab „q!$ .]$ 3 4 3C . -?
@! E`
j 
[ U" jsC [= S
 c!o  )c  ET$
Œ5 [ <-!$
..S


E` ‘/9 &’0 -& #$%&

'v/ ‘L
 jsC  .3
67 #&+O^
D"C f
 [ &‹$ 3C . -?
@!
C 9C [- )k+Z [ Π/ -KT c55 '( U$5
Ž  #+ O>
c55 }5J [ I+O^
2;T5 3C L

.c9C+

j )“;a! .99
ZaT
SC . -?
#/ Eyi$
T5 .4
uS ):\q$
@! ”+" ). -?
#/ c$! [ &‹$
E`

  
   38

@! )L+
d  #&+O^
#/ Q&V
ea [4b
Q-!& 
i$9
Xs [ :\q$
@! Œ+$ 3C . -?

+ E!" @! Q&V

jqa ).aT Q
+h C .U/
ea 3 )•
...2q"

  X #b v )S


 :K C .&V

C s‹$
C $
@! Ka/ - . -?

.L+
[ L a

j\ .!q
 Ê늇Ûa@pýîØ“m@Þìy




 

39
40



Ka & -T fnT$ Q4O Xs [ L+
i$
&jF fnT$ K L+!! )– .ya^
.-K^
E7 .Zs .5U/
:Xv^
%9 @! Ka
L! ‰Oa
 n & ci$5 6S :
 

.c-  fno eya .5d cqF [ ˜
j

KqF [ Q -?

 6S :  

5 D$
Qx™ . D
Q
T^
‰ J 3‹& )”2KC C

jl .i$^
Q4O$
SC /^
4O T5 )L+ /
.†A

Ž
$sx .--D Q4O i$ 6S : 
v .c qZ  I/+ „$O €
S :DH
 GTR
‰F
.m^
8H
 6!v^
Q4O

41

  
   42

  
%9 @! Q4O$
[ L
FC .(( “O/ a\ q$4a9
:DV
x Xv^

.6!v^
4O .1
.m^
8H
4O .2
./^
4O .3
 

1
e5 n
C #/ [5_%& {q a 4O$

j\ E

!šU$5
3N (12 4h) f+ D
 <R$5 -& )4O$! 3 4^
-T

[ [4= :;S &C 3- [5n C n [ 3 4$5 6!v^

žC+
6%O$! s

-Ka & i$5 3C [4b )L+

#!S n

G5 X
GD
! Y
p qD
 .c%SD/
6!v^
LC [ ! & 3 4$5  fn ..!m .5
2/ :K+n
e5q
*RC "/ Ÿb )L+! #!S 8 n
C 7
4 [
.4O$
89  .g+q
[&




:12

     

   

 
 

 
! 
"
.#
$% &

43     

f_D" Q
Us  8/
$^
4O

j– 4O$

j\ IP$5
 ):DH
GZ  [4= I/+ &C €
Sz 
 .TU$
@! 4O$

j\ 2&5 .cU/
$ 4O$
3
  [ &‹$

!s . €
Sz K! 8AR5 :DH
p qZ  fS
 .UF
.K
)c n

}9   @! 4O$

j\ Q
2= -$T
).^
n
C SC @! r%
*  .yO
Q
" „ S
0  v-
-$T5 ).yO
B5C [ c%P 3C c! Y
p qD
@! 3N
.e5q
n
C #/ E5+$
 :\q$
 @! } 0

  
   44

   

2
)jqa$
 K9C cFC x 6!v^
4O$/ c%h 4O$

j\

 !" G!H
 n & G )m 8s  3\]$^
G5 6S
)+n X
GD
- )cC Bj
nq
[ .!m .5
2/

j\ :/ (p qZ 7
4) .q!H

p qD
 n

 5 -a/
..
 ! :\nC X-T$9
 
GD

8AR 8H
. 3C 4O$

j\  .99
f2^
3
GZ a  fsŠ^
-a/ )c . €
Sz .yO
GZ @!
3&
0 .Zs )Ž$i^
GD
f^ ¡?
[ s¢
.yO

-& .[5\]$^
X S pq$ x
[ .yO
ab 5 y m^
8H

:K qZ  @ q
Œn .yO
f‹q  }$4$

j\ :\5
*
j5  3C%5 x 67 :Ka&C  :Km/ C :\_s‹
.[5\]$^

 

3
.UF X S LC .T/+C [ 3 4$5 
4O$

j\
UA5 )L+
LŸ .F 4^
p qD
-J 67 ).52&
i$5 ./-! .!s

.S^
L+
!S _g [ n


[ c/ 3 T
5 )[5\]$^
n .!" . S  fn 4O$

j\
@! ž !1/ c$! 52 ).yO
[ f_%& Q
" C :KqFC
:K5 x )K
K$9
.yO
n
 [4b Y
.S^
!$ †+

K$a5 " )
 !" . T C .-$ LC
0 /^
3 45 3C
_v&
.fm
n 4h  4O$

45     


i$5 3C L+
Q4£O¤ .! 3-R ŽU
RC [
p qD
@!   v- )LU$^
+¤ £" .!(-$ +n -T
e5
 -T
Q -ˆ @! ETD5 )4& ‰Oa
.5d E
 .

¥
0 -&C c @! .5-V
kj–   3C .
p qD

..i$^
L+
tF;$
3C - . -ˆ & @!T W‰Oa
34  -;$
a
L+
.!S -T
. -ˆ js‹ 6S )q!9 n>
KT"  ji$
).
p qD
 ¦4 .s qa^
.yU^
L+
C .-1

..q!s [&C f_AD

.5nq
L+
!S js‹5
46
 Ê늇Ûa@Éîä—m@Ö‹ @Þìy

 

 

47
48
 :#$99C #$5U/ L+
@! X DV
[4b
.U%
n
^

i$9/ ):KqFC *UOa
B5‹/ L+
aD ●
.-$;-! f $^

(1)
. #DDi$ [ L+
*
h ●
!o KTaD [4b Y
L+
L
FC rT/ [ €P$a9
.:KqFC *UOa
B5‹/

      


1
aD s n
^ 
 K9
+D .4$9%
.-
"
/" T
#+n C L+n  "
" 5 J [4b 6S )L+
Ka
( )
X-T$9
[4b -& ) y "
" U e5y [ 2 #F+
.5$ L+& "
" *Ug
:
  


L" U/ "
" [ .F
L+
aD


  
            !  "! (1)
. *+, -/0/
 -/++$0 & ' . #$%
123 4 565 78 2

9: ;<= >?@A  + B0 " C D (2)
.2E , #$2F G C
49

  
   50

r/ „%v ƒ ) y "

" U ƒ )+Oa^/ xC
.L+!
Π/ U$ qS U" :$5 L+
-T$^ .5¨
_ $ 
[ c!S [4-$5 @4 [s9 #4/ L+! !T
.V
[
.;aq9C .FU/  f+  k%$Fx
E` )c s [ ]a

[ i$^
.R%" .5-V L+
: r%^
#/ .5y
\ -& c
i$9
[4- *UA
. S © C )L+ / I4$Sx

)r%-& l-T$9
 .4$9%
k5 [ c!d )5$ L+&
[ ./>
.K1
3 4 67 s

[ c #R% E& C
.ª+H
 
*Ug

 
        :13


         
.!    
51      

"   #$
%
&'  () :14

+$ '  ,+%$ -   "
"

/ $
0
 1   2
 3 ()
,# ) 
" +4 5)  $   6 7 8  )
 ("
. )  0 6   96 0

  
   52

    
2
Q
+
 QaSO
Q;T .!s

Q
+yz
v 
. K/ L+
kj\ 2-$ )L+
aD$ 
 
+D
34  KiqF :$5 6S )k%$Fx
_v x ¦C a
 aD$

i$ 3C [4b )[

Q
 
|
2q$9
"C ¦C -& ‰Oa

K5y eO .;{ Q

" ¦‹& -
Q
" K] 67 
_%T$! 3\]$^
K-5 Y
QqV
[ .!qS Xs GaT/
.:Km
+™ [ B+RV

:Q
+yz
kj\ [ 3 F Ia\
QaSO
Q;  i$ Y
:

 ●
.f_%4

)f_AD
Q
+
Q;  i$ Y
:
 
 ●
E
^
} j& ).S%
:!T$ i$ Y
Q
T
K!v
.«qa Y
.m^
Ž+
2

:
  

‰Oa% )cTaD  . / L+

[ L a

j\ |$b
«qF [4b f\]^
*/ [ ."n 30 %" 59 n
„%v eZx 85O/ K$UA ƒ ).55 «aw Q
+yz
kj\
85O

i$9x 3
+s Ia\ )K
i$9
 l r/^

:eZ

53      


  




 $  5  ;   :15


.<=  9> 

& @UA 67 eZ

85O
[ f_%& Q-& 
i$9
●
Rq5 . V
kj\ © )(­
q
) Q
+y¬ .5m

.S^

85O
[ .-& . )r/^
-T ®!g %S 
i$9

..5 $! r/^

Π( X S eZ

K$%v )+yz
K .UA$ Bm
n 4$9/ “ 
i$9
●
( )
C r% „%v [4b ) 1 eZx 85h e5y [ +yz

.i$-! c
^
4$9%
“ !
 #R%

 
  
 
  
  !"# $%& (1)
.'*+, !- .
+/ 

  
   54

 /? + /$   /&'  @8 :16


5  +$ /? 7 8  A0 B C
6 %0  $ E -  () @D , 4 0
@$0  7 8 ? +  & +0 
.
6 
F$%  
55      

 
    

3
)k%$F .$x _g ¦C -& )aD$
. K/ } j& |$ 
E` [4  )k%$Fx
„q!5 x E1
 X%S .TR/ .F & -P
C -D5 [ ‘ .& .5  3n ‘ 3 4
3C [ 5jP$

v 
i$9x "  RC 3
jl )5 y „" Q

l
Q/
X-T$9x
3 45 6S .q!H
p qD
 3 45 L+
kj\
Q
" K! Y
.qqH
.yU^
Qj^
Z \ l v

.EAO
.P4
:
  

:L+
kj\ v aD Q
+$s
.(( Ia\
¯  & “   +
$s
:$
5 3C KU/C Q
+H
XC ●
@!C c
.UA$ p& :;V

j\‘ :9100 × :9 100
Xs [ k ƒ %S 5  3 4
E( :$5 ƒ ):1

C eZx 85O/ fT

: 3N „" .° 3&
0 )#%v

.3 4
e52  [ !5 3C [4b *
A/
KRT/  .F 4
“

[
n eD!5 3C ¯v
+H
 ●
.p
y
@! eZx 85O/ C *
A/  rT%

 fm
n - )kC .
| T/ ŽaZ *
+
\ 6 v
+H
●
Π/ .P$q
kj\ 3 4 )Ka žC
5-$ s
.K1

.Sa
[ X%V
rT/ 5   .q!H
ŽaD
.S [
#%F1
[ #!%S )89
X S cU/ ŽaD! .q!H

ª+s [5
ª
sN/ <Da5 x )#R%-& -K
i$9x

  
   56

3 4 6S )sC .5U/ -K$5d „ 

0 x ŽaD

../Z¬ . ŽaD
ª+s p
y

:DH
3C x WL+
.aZ  .%5g .5y ¦ & 
„"$s

0 uS )8ha
: p
K$9
 ./ TZ ` B$T^


 8ha
IJ  )s

 t%P
¦N ŽaD
DT

3C yO
DT [4b
j\  cFC k%$Fx
E` .K$! q
3N } 0  )L+
i$ ED$ ŽaD
EF  e ±
.$T^
k%$F
 2& „$O  ² P!
(C L+

jl

  ""    


4
i$5 6S )aD$
.9 ).\a$^
.qH/ L a

j\ |$b
f2K
e5naZ  -T$5 Bj & )GqH
r/
" q
"
_%& “ c i$5 .K!F *a(C QD
[ K$5" .m/K4

X
yC  cTU :$5 ("
@! :9 5 }³) r/
 q
[
3 4
[ E9a “ } 0  .z/ i$5 -& ).%9a
.GqH
}$9%
C
:
  

85O/ KD :$5 W.%9a^
X
y
 " q
" U T/
 “ !

j\ 3 45 67 4$9%
C ¯ 4
“ !
 eZx
„%v$ L+
}³ 4/ #%( - ƒ ):DH
.K
  z

[ L F BC C .2S
C X%V

i$9
Rq5 )r/^

‰F .5 $ Œ v
X S .-
n n
 
i$9
 ).%9a^
8m
O

.L+
 GTR

57      

Plexiglass    !    


5

$ -& )K!4O KTU . K/ }$9%
“
C 2-$
X4h‹/ L+
kj\ 4O [4b ). a$ X4h‹/ Ž
9

( )
 fn^
kj\ Π [ ) 1 .-1
C .5nq
L+ & .q!$´
3C [4b ¦C -& )
5$ +n  v K!T ETD5 6S )K$F
:9 1.5 “ !
}³ 3 45 3C E`
jl ). K/ 4a eO$
v&C C #S eD!/ K$5  B+R
[- x )"
@!
.&S *UOF :25 )"*
g ."a/" C " ! / 9" & *
A/
 (C l fn^
kj\ [ . aD^
.-1
L+
3C Ga

 GaT
cS9 [ !i$
 yO
n 34
[ Gqµ = )[5\]$^
< ca E;J ¦C 6S )[5\]$^

Bj & )caT/ ‡ih

SC  X Z
k-T c%Rg fS
.v Q$l
e!U5
:
  

+Oa .U9
/ 4h BC  }$9%
“
C U [4b
X-T$9/ )m/K4
+Oa^
X-T$9
Rq5 )m/K& C )5
.r/^
„%v$ ./ !U^
[&
E( :$5 Œv

0 ¶s/ )[&
rT/ .5  f+  k%$Fx
E`
.5 $
kj\ 3 4 3C [4b )
_%& 4$9%
“ !
3&

     
! # $ "     " 
   

(1)

 % &' *+  ,
-.  /+!- 0123 456 78 /
.% 5
 !

  
   58

).!U$^
EF
1
X y @!   EOH
[ Q
+y 
i$9/
( )
. 1 r/^
Π( X S
EOH/ ‡s *
g 
i$9/ ŒOs
kj\ „%v [4b
KRT%/ }$9%
“
C Z [4b -& )
Z _C
.KRT%/ .!D$ “

*/z 99 C .%Os 3%R/
<U9 Q
0 .4$9%
“

kj\ 3C  R5C k%$Fx
E`
.5-V r/^
a .FU/ 
i$9
 .S Ia\ 3C )ž"
.}$9% / I4$Sx
[ B5

2001   

  :17

     
.  !"#   $%   & '(

. :; ; 5
 8 <
 = 7$ >2?@ .73 A; 5
 (1)
59      

#$ % 

6
“ C EOH
[ “  5 3C L+
X4hC 8/C [
*
+
jma [4b -& )K]
.%S s
n  ^
3 4
[

j\ Q
2= [ ):1
[ .
.K1
-J sC .%S
 +]F
„q  )X-T$9x
 )[5 4$
. K9 L+

[ KUA5 Y
.S^
AZ c/  [ .ci$9 Bj
¶iO

.:;! f_%& .5d vb x ·$ / ):1

60
 òíbàzÜÛ@ô‹‚c@ÞbØ’cë@†aìß

 


  

61
62
fn .5C 
i$9
e5y [ c- - 3C 8ha! [4b
*UOa
SC "  Xv-&‘ 
i$9x
 aD$
.!K9 \`
3C ca4b -& )Q
\]^
S  L+& c$
+n .!; 
i$9/
#&+O^
rT/  (Š 3C ‹5 Y
c
+% c
+Th K! E$45
& s
n T%U
+4a$9x
.%y´ e5y [ )GaT
4T 
 (Š " C )f^
k+(™ GaT
Q9+=  .5O/ tqF
ca4b -& ).^
4T  T/ $a5 ¥ Bj
ªq$^
+ K-1

.¥T! c$R" .
 +K²
n
^
[ 5T
Ia\ ).5
L+
 .z/
x Xv^
%9 @! Ka &jF ).5-P! K
i$9
[4b u
*h

:DV

.f0 H
●
.."

. j%
●
..5
.5-V
Q
nC ●
.f
^
.Ug
●
.Q
+]a
 |A
.Ta"C ●

63

  
   64

&'
8hF 
 B+ ."
 f0 s *
+/ žC
.5d 3
)\]$^
Q5 C C [ žC
.5d 3C 0 )f\] © I+O5
@! ŒR
T/ X
rT/  fnO^
Q-!T$
[ :g /
kj\ \;$ 
_v& "

†+C @! -
Q
" 3C x )žC

© Eg
! ."
 f0 s *
+
[ ,g  } j )Q-!T$

.@;$S
‰OF C © .&+O^

 
        18

.  

:Q
+s f 8ha
C
Xqy
ŒT C / Qo [ f0 s *
h :
  
.Q/R
(C ‡D$x Km
+
%" m
 Ž+ / \ OS
65     

C .5nT
Q
+
/ Qo [ f0 s *
h :
  
.\¨
+
 .5+a

(1)
. .54T
Qq!i^
/ Qo [ f0 s *
h :   

( '
n
 [ !o .TaD . j/ 8ha
B5 3C } j& [4b
(C [ :1
.5" )¸aq9z
C  q
C }$9%
v )."

[ Q%y *
+
e5y [ R5C } 0 :$5 3C [4b .Q/R

[4b -& )XUa/ [ v&C "y%

" "Q
 !%
" v t/^

.5d   \ )v .S%! i$ u

f;a
Q
$9 *
+

.5-V .5
K]
EmS 
i$9
C )K]
 +D!
.K]

 ! " # $ %&'   # 19


.()  *      )

.
  
   (1)

  
   66

)
 % *!
f& Q5+%  i$ Y & .5
Q
n
  -&
Q
n
D& )K
i$9
[4b .5-P! sC
n
 & l
 

@! 5
C +
.5-V t%! 3C [4b u
 )+
.5d
.*
9 S

!  %    +  20


., -'  '/- */  012


Ž+ C .;aq9 QFU/¹ v sC n

 
i$9
[4b -&
67 t/^
C :1
@! eD! )Gv& 4O/ p q! m

.•
....K]
 )[U%
 )+D
 )G$4
@-J
C ¶-" @! KD [4- fv4/ f $ n
^
kj\ „F&
0

( )
. 1 f
^
. j%
kj\ Ž  t/ *
+
ƒ Km
+
 ).!s
n ".!F"

.     ! "  #$%& #'*     (1)
67     

& +,
)."
 Qxj/ *
+x .V
[ .Ug
kj\ X-T$9
,A5
.&S +%$x
 jsŠ5 6S ).&V
 &C .5S  5 =
).Ds
 )f $^
.4$9%
n
^

i$9/ aD )Zq^

.-& @! aD$

-$T5 ).4$9%
!i$
"QF-y/" v
*Ug & 3C .99
f4q
 .-T
 f+K^
 )f $^
n
^

)+D
.UA v )#!Dq #/  :1
[ &P$
*2 @UA5
.•
...L 4
 G$4
#/  L
+j
@!C C )G$4
C

3  0(!    -'   4 3   # 21

.!   5
  $* -&  ,  ''6 4 -

  
   68

:
  

n
^
*
2
 p
y
X
yC Q9^
jsC :$5 .5
%
 .1
.K$5d

C ).%9a^
X
y
Q
0 .4$9%
n
^
+$s
:$5 .2
5J :$5 )E9a +Oa 
i$9/ Π!U^
X U
 KD/
Π!U^
.S^
E7 4$9%
“ ! E9a^
†T

“ +$s
E` L
+j
[ @!
*21
.UA$   v- )K$UA
)L 4
 G$4
#/  .UA$ E9a X y B0 4$9/
[ .a4= .S &C X S cq [4b 67 E9a † B0
.L
+j

a <%D5 67 .%9a f+

S .+/ 3 © }$9%
[i5 .3
.3/j
  4O$!  /"
c!4O$ 3 Q
|q" .U9
/ [s
}$9%
 T$
:$5 .4
.E9a^
4O

8m
h 5-$ 4O^
}$9%
 .%9a Π( - :$5 .5
UA^

*21
  v 8/_ )KRT/  *
2
8/
( )
. 1 K]! UA^
*21
 [U%
 +D!
(C ‡D$x  q
C ¸aq9z/ ."

.q!g
kj\ #U% :$5 .6
.QD

 54 267 8'9 :;< =9 "01 2 , 34-" +,-
 (1)
.,6,>? @@* AB>? C4; D E&F GH=? A  I&JH
69     

*
$ -. /(!
)3 T
 º Y
Q5-4
[ ."

Q
+]a
*
+
3
\jsC E

+ 
[ )L ! ^
|A
[ ."

.Ta"

)|A
[ Ž
 La" *
h [4b  v .Ta"
. S q )+%$x

T/ .O-"
[ Q%y C )»y La" 
i$9
[4b } 0 +jT
0N
kj\ +(™ Gq @! 5 = )3 -!
_D C H
 K-g
.5-V .S%
Q
+]F -T$$ Q
+]a
. S  .Q
|A

.[5\]$^
e5q$ i$ 3C [4b .5-& n
 .5C [ 3 T

.6)   % %2 7    8 9  22



  
   70


!  0 1!
@! :K ):K$UOFC [ 3 9‹5 x Ga
ŒS *UOF 3
.
/z
X4h
[ 6P%
:KT5 x ):K
\C ³ [ #5
n
C  .5-V
kj\ +4C
 3 uS ):KqFC .5-V
[ – 
$ .F
V
f25A
S i$ Y
.F
V
.4!-^

Q4$4$ .9
+n 3 ..9$q^
QF
V
*
$
 .^^
¦TU"
+4‹/ Ga
*UOF X   6T% 3C [4b .
QF
V

$
 tqa
[ L! fqP!
}$4$& )l DSx .
/
nz .5-V
L+ v

i$9x
 )FSC G" $
 *8%/
.K a [  R Km
j5  
.5+R
QF
V

$
[ [5$T^
a Q4$4$/ } 0 .! fn5| [4b
„52 / f* !-^
QF % / pj
 )q
 4
E 9C 
i$9/
.
 v *U
C
Ki$ Y
QF
V
 T$
.q& *UOa
ž+5 -&
f
n
kj\ q 67 ). %
Œ4 & EAO
.P4 Q
"
#Uha
Q
nC @% fn
+z
 :!T % .[5\]$^
Ln+  K$!
.†+
c [ *
$x
 ’ :K$A/ eJ @! f+n" f5
 Ê늇Ûa@âa‡ƒn
ü@òîàÜÇ@Áiaìš

 

 


  

71
72
}$4$/ .!T$^
Q9
+! D$i^

j\ OF [ pl
3
)^
3Fz
.5% +K² \ p H
[ .5" ! L+

[ 5/ @5 x )c!%$ .aD/ 

@! D5 Bj

} 0 @$9
3 )cn
+ eJ )c5C+ [ _%T$
 )c Z L³
‰F S vb Bj
1
.5-V .%9a^
m9
L
/
fn
+ 2\ )T
f " Q49z ) DH
KK$5 Y
GTR

.Q D

:. $
‰a! k%$Fx
E
j 

 
[ T
5J .&T \ L
D
 4
.&T^
3
}-$
 )Ž V/ .% U^
.{C &‹ )P$^
f4
kj\ v e!s  L
/z
.F4N/ 3bz
 )Ka L /
n
$
@! .FFz
./;$
[ fnq$9x
 \5 U Q
n

.f+ -T^

   
Ga
.q!q/ }-$
²  x <!Dx f
n
kj\
)+ K-1
C ):DH
C B+RV
K]^/ + K]
@! ‡V

73

  
   74

( )
.!S^
 )L
D
.T%U/ <PD

f+  ) 1 ¥T
C
..^
 _\-1
‰
¼
 )– b Y

_g  „i$9

0 )L
Z † s Q
nC [ f
nC B‹&
.–PZ f 3 4 ¦N K~ C ¦
C %" C ¦4
 
#% U^
 c]F )c$q! ):DH
.9
+n E` -&
c
nC ):KT- K! Œ+$5 Y
E 9
 ):K" 7
)cT%
$5 Bj
TD $
:!
9 c4
$4 c;
$
9

c!K cqa nz fnR Q4$4 Q;
$9

i$9

:J Y
\ \S .5+RV
#F

3‹/ ca" )-K$!
.L
D

 
5P$ ).DPq$ .9
+n 3 F
.9
+n [ } j& /x
SC ½D C T
½D!  \ )–  Y
.5U
 c$\
 :$5 .9
+
kj\ @! *a/ )•
...L
D
  DH

( )
. 2 #F

kj\  T$! .;
$9


      ! "# $ % &'*+ (1)
- . /+ 01$  2 3,4 5 6 !2 !7 58 *,#
096
 : 2
;! 
$< 5 6 0= >? @ A7!  *
.0B
P M NO – L24 ) 84 3$ D$ 09EE7 09 F 2$ GHI JK* (2)
T+ 8 .09;$< 0E2 ! 019S. 0E2 ! 09R!< 0E2 (Q;
.&9W 09XB+< "V2 9= 54N"
75       

 
B+R
[- )\ i$ K! Œ+$5 3C E` f
nC B‹&
 L 
 )Q
n

i$9
Žy RC @! *UOa
E5+
K
i$9
.5y f
n
kj\  „!D Y
.qa
ž+
^

.#DDi$^
B5C @! KU/

 
.T%y  e
$5 w E5+$
T/ f
n
kj\ 5 U E`
 .5-V
:$ G& C ).5+ .5-V
f4q )c$( -$?

.5+RV
f4q
†T5 [q/ l4hC @$a G& )caT/ -$ˆ
.s¢ -$ˆ [ G!$µ :K C K ‰Oa!
 
. /  :\+4C   Ga
*UOF ‹;!5  fn

-4 3C %" )[4-^

+ Y
\ \S ./;$  )./;$

:[5C [ &‹$
:K! :”
nC .! @!
K
i$9
 )#PPD
34^
 32
 f
n

i$9

.¸m$F RC e Bj

:!
4O /

.^
f+" \ -$\x/ f51
 .² P!^
QS;a
[
} 0 3 ).qa
K$UOFC .UA$ z
\|K jPh @!
-$\x
 )GaT
«  L "
 tqa
8%  \ 5
 +
S
:K!5 cFC -& )lRa "s
+^
 .5+RV
”+ D/
.-! BD$! f5 E 9C .q!$´ "

76
 ò¸b©a



77
78
#F

& IK$F
@! .--D .g f " -$?
c
5 a
 T%U
:KS @! *R
 n

.…K^ .FFz
p


E 9

i$9/ L
 eV
& c 3N W:Km
+™ *
/
.”
*
$
[ .5$T^
Q

Ln Y
.as
.5+RV

Q5P$
4 ./;$9x
 L
/z
@! +n" BO%
T

@! f+n" 65V
DT
 XDx
m9 „/ " )K!/5 Y

.99
n
^
T

j\ K ` Y
.5+R
Q !T^
_ 
)c!/5 Bj
BP$! .%9a^
./;$9x
@! + vT
 )f4q
L
/z
Q
|A
+(™ [ ªT
 .5"
.q& [ 8ha
6P%5 3C q45
@! T"  ; ).yO
Q
" Ki$ Y
L ! .!^

( )
. 1 -
Q
" 0C [ ªT
 .5"
[ €P$5 „F$Fx

f [ l  +P$ a KSC ¾T QT-$?

3
WK! – $ KaT/ f
n‹/ KqF 2!
 x \ )P$^
 p H

C $9x
9C K f5 Q
+s m
/ [ -m
n 6P% /
.-$;-! ^
GaT

2K***; 3***6 *** 3***Y 7 Z***[K
***;X (1)

http://urgencemanif.meagerman.net

79
80


● Gene Sharp, The Politics of non-violent action. Boston:
Porter sargent, 1973. Three volumes.
● Leonid Tarassuk and Claude Blair, The complete
encyclopedia of arms & weapons, Simon and Schuster,
1982
● Richard A. Gabriel, Karen S. MetzFrom Sumer to Rome:
The Military Capabilities of Ancient Armies, Greenwood
Press Publication 1991
● Sarin (2001), BodyHammer, Tactics and Self Defense for
the Modern Protester, v1.1, http://www.devo.com/sarin/
bodyhammer.html, accessed March 6,2007
● http://www.florilegium.org/files/COMBAT/W-T-
Shields/W-T-Shields-art.html
● http://urgencemanif.meagerman.net

81
82
 
  

 


   ...
 

   

    

   

 

(1)  

(2)  

83
84