Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Introduction
1.1 Hydrogen fuel cells basic principles
Definition: A fuel cell is an electrochemical device that converts a supplied fuel to electrical energy and heat continuously, so long as reactants are supplied to its electrodes. Neither the electrodes nor the elctrolyte are consumed by the operation of the cell (page 17). Example: Acid electroclyte fuel cell Anode: hydrogen gas ionises, releasing electrons and creating H+ ions. 2H2 4 H+ + 4eCathode: oxygen reacts with the electrons from the electrode and H+ ions from the electrolyte to form water. O2 + 4 H+ + 4e- 2H2O An acid electrolyte allows only H+ ions to pass through. The e- have to pass through an external electric circuit. Certain polymers also allows only positiv ions to pass and can be used as electrolyte, so called proton exchange membranes PEM. Note: For all primary batteries and therefore for fuel cells, are the electrons flowing from the anode to the cathode. Thus the anode is electrical negative and the cathode is electrical positive. Cations: positive ions Anions: negative ions
First the activation energy has to be exceeded for an exothermic reaction taken place. If te probability of a molecule having enough energy is low, the reaction rate is slow. The reaction rate can be accelerated by using a catalyst raising the temoerature increasing the electrode surface area (for fuel cells)
The chemical reactions have to take place at the surface of the electrodes, due to removing or supplying electrons. These reactions of the fuel with the electrolyte at the electrode is called a three phase contact. The reaction rate is propotional to the effective surface area of the electrodes. Requirements for the electrodes: high effective surface area (highly porous material) incoporate with a catalyst endure high temperatures in a corrosive environment
Space vehicles Vehicles and mobile applications, low power CHP Portable electronic systems, low power but long running time For small CHP plants (hundreds of kW), first commercial one For medium to large CHP (up to MW) For all sizes of CHP (from kW to multi MW)
Proton exchange H + membran PEMFC Direct methanol H + DMFC Phosporic acid PAFC Molten carbonate MCFC
H+
20-90
ca. 220
CO3 2-
ca. 650
O 2Solid Oxide 500-1000 SOFC Advantages and disadvantages are discussed later.
Fuel cells can be used successfully in CHP plants or in mobile power systems, like vehicles or electronic equipment.
Note: The mole is a measure of the amount of a substance in respect to its molar mass. H2 molar mass: 2amu 1 mole = 2g H2O molar mass: 18amu 1 mole = 18g One mole of a substance always has the same number of molecules, given by the Avogardro's number N = 6.022 x 1023. The Faraday's constant gives the charge of one mole of electrons. F = N x e = 6.022 x 1023 x 1.602 x 10-19 C = 96485 C Using the basic reaction of the hydrogen/oxygen fuel cell, it can be seen that one mole of H2 and half a mole O2 deliver one mole of H2O. However, note that the Gibbs free energy of formation is not constant. It depends on the temperature and state (liquid or gas). When the values are negative it means that energy is released. Electromotive force EMF = reversible open circuit voltage OCF In a reversible process in the fuel cell, all Gibbs free energy would be converted into electrical energy. The basic reaction provides two electrons to the electric circuit for each molecule of H 2 used. So for one mole of H2, 2N of electrons pass through the circuit. Flowing charge: -2Ne = -2F [C] The electric work done equals the product of charge times voltage E. In a reversible process, the electric work also equals the Gibbs free energy released.
Given is the electromotive force EMF or reversible open circuit voltage of the hydrogen fuel cell. In practice the voltage would be lower, due to the fact that some irreversibilities also apply even when no current is drawn from the cell. In general
to the HHV or LHV. If the information is not given, probably the the LHV is used.
Table 2.2 shows the theoretical efficiency limit of a hydrogen fuel cell in respect of the operating temperature. However in practice there are some differences. Voltage losses are less at higher temperatures, so the fuel cell voltage is higher at high temperatures. Waste heat of higher temperature cells can be used. Fuel cells do not always have a higher efficiency limit than heat engines. The mentioned decline in maximum possible efficiency with temperature for the hydrogen fuel cell is not exactly occur for other cell types.
For 100% efficient hydrogen fuel cell, the enthalpy of formation is converted into electric energy. Considering the fact that not all fuel is used during operation, the fuel utilisation coefficient is introduced. This is equivalent to the ratio of fuel cell current and the current that would be obtained if all the fuel were reacted. The fuel cell efficiency in respect to the HHV is therefore given by
2.5 The effect of pressure and gas concentration 2.5.1 The Nernst equation
As mentioned in 2.1 is the Gibbs free energy change dependant on the temperature and in a more complex relation on the reactant pressure and concentration. In a chemical reaction every reactant and product have their own 'activity'. In case of an ideal gas, the 'activity' is definded as a = P / P0 with P: partial pressure of the gas P0: standard pressure, 0.1MPa The activity of a gas is proportional to its partial pressure. The produced water in a fuel cell can either be a liquid or steam. In case of liquid water, it is a reasonable approximation to assume aH2O=1. The activities of the reactants and products of a chemical reaction jJ + kK mM modify the Gibbs free energy change, given by the equation
0 g f : molar Gibbs free energy change at standard pressure (from gas tables) R = 8.314 j/Kmol molar gas constant T: temperature It can be seen, that when the activities of the reactants increase, g f becomes more negative, so more energy is released. On the other side, if the activity of the product increase, g f becomes less negative, so less energy is released. Substitute this equation in the equation of the EMF gives the Nernst equation.
with
with E0: EMF at standard pressure The Nernst equation gives the EMF dependant on the product and reactant activities. The derived EMF, also called Nernst voltage, is the reversible cell voltage that would exist at a given temperature and pressure. Using the rules of logarithmic functions an the definition of activity, the equation can be simplified.
In nearly all cases will be the pressures partial pressures, that is, the gases will be part of a mixture. It often appears that the pressures at cathode and anode are the same, to simplify the design. Note: In a mixture of gases, the total pressure is the sum of all the partial pressures of the components. From the gas law equation it can be shown, that the volume fraction, molar fraction and pressure fraction of a gas mixture are all equal. Example: CH4 + H2O 3H2 + CO2
The products are three parts of H2 and one part of CO2 by moles and volume. If the reaction takes place at 0.1MPa the partial pressures can be derived PH2 = x 0.1MPa = 0.075MPa PCO2 = x 0.1MPa = 0.025MPa
It can be seen, thet the EMF of the fuel cell is depending on the system pressure P. A hihgher pressure leads to a higher voltage. For high temperature fuel cells, for example SOFC at 1000C, the predictions of the Nernst equation correlate with practise. For lower temperatures, as in a PAFC at 200C, the voltage change is even bigger. This occurs due to increasing pressure also reduces the losses at the electrodes, especially at the cathode. A similar effect occurs from switching from air to oxygen (). The voltage losses at the cathode decline for pure oxygen.
2.6 Summary
reversible OCV or EMF
max efficiency
f x 100% max = g f / h
Nernst equation The pressure and the concentration of the reactants affects the Gibbs free energy, and thus the voltage, given by the Nernst equation.
Note:
even the open circuit voltage is less than the theoretical value there is a rapid initial fall afterwards the voltage falls less rapidly and mor linear there may be a higher current density at which the voltage falls rapidly again
For a higher temperature fuel cell the graph changes. The reversibel 'no loss' voltage is smaller, but the difference between the 'no loss' voltage and the operational voltage is less, due to the initial voltage drop is significant smaller.
Note: the OCV is equal or just a litle less than the theoretical vallue the intial fall in voltage is very small, and the graph more linear there may be a higher current density at which the voltage falls rapidly again The focus of chapter 3 is on the questions: What causes the voltage to fall below the reversible value and how can this situation be improved?
3.2 Terminology
Commonly five terms are used to describe this voltage difference: Overvoltage or overpotential Polarisation Irreversibility Losses Voltage drop Every term is used in the book!
Tafel equation
The constant A is higher for slow chemical reactions. The exchange current density i0 is higher if the reaction is faster. The current density i0 can be considered as the current density at which the overvoltage begins to move from zero. The equation is only true for i0 > i.
In order to get the current instead of the voltage the Tafel equation is cahnged in the ButlerVollmer equation The importance of i0 can be seen in the following graph for values of 0.01, 1.0 and 100mA/cm2.
Measurements of i0 shows a great variation in respect of the e;ectrode material. For hydrogen fuel cells are the values at the oxygen electrode (cathode) lower by a factor of 105. Therefore is the overvoltage at the anode negligible compared to the cathode. For other fuel cells, for example a DMFC, the anode overvoltage is not negligible. In these cases the equation for the total overvoltage combine the voltage drops at both electrodes. I can be expressed as
with
To conclude, the effect of internal current is much less for high temperature cells, because i0 is much higher. For low temperature cells internal current and fuel diffusion is usually not of great importance in terms of operating efficiency, but it has a marked effect on the OCV.
Assumption: Introduction a limiting current density i1 at which the hydrogen consumption rate is equal to the max. supply rate. At i1 the pressure would have reached zero. P1 is the pressure when i is zero. If we assume a linearly fall from P1 to P(i1), tha the pressure at any current density is given by
Substitution in above equation delivers the voltage drop due to mass transport.
The negative sign is due to the fact that it is a voltage drop. The term RT/2F will be different for each reactant and is in general substitute by the constant B. This theoretical approach has many limitations, like: supply of air instead of pure oxygen lower temperature cells mixed fuel production and removal of reaction products build-up nitrogen in air systems An empirical approach is more favourable, because it provides an equation which delivers much better results and will be used in the rest of the chapter. With m is about 3x10-5 V and n is about 8x10-3 cm/mA. The mass transport or concentration losses are important when Hydrogen is supplied by a reformer. The reaction rate on a demand change is too slow. The supply at the air cathode is not well circulated. Build-up nitrogen can block the oxygen supply at high currents. Water is not removed qickly enough in PEMFC.
with
E: reversible OCV in: internal and fuel crossover equivalent current density A: slope of the Tafel line i0: exchange current density m & n: constants in the mass-transfer overvoltage r: area-specific resistance This equation can be simplified, due to in is usually very small and has little impact on operating losses of fuel cells at working currents, so it will be cancelled. The term of the activation overvoltage can be rewritten as
Finally we get a simple equation, that fits excellent results in respect to real fuel cells.
Example:
To summarize the irreversibilities due to their importance in different conditions. Concentration and mass transport losses are important only at higher currents. The should be very small in well designed systems. In low temperature hydrogen fuel cells activation overvoltage and ohmic losses are important Fuel cells using mixed fuel, as methanole, the activation overvoltage at anode and cathode dominates. In higher temperature fuel cells the ohmic losses are the major factor.
Another way of describing the water content is the dew point, the temperature to which the air have to be cooled in oeder to reach saturation. Example: Pw = 12.35kPa dew point T = 50C (see table 4.1) Sometimes it is necessary to humidify the gases going into the cell, so the mass of H2O added has to be calculated. To do so, note that the mass of a species in a mixture is proportional to the product of molecular mass and partial pressure of the species.
P = Pa + Pw
Note that the mass of water is inversely proportional to the total air pressure P, so higher air pressure requires less added water to achieve the same humidity.
due to the assumption, that all water is removed by the cathode air supply, the following equations can be used.
With Pe: electrical Power of the stack Vc: voltage of a single cell O2: supply or use rate of oxygen : air stoichiometry The exit flow rate of the non-oxygen components of air is the same as in the inlet. The non-oxygen components amount to 79% of the air. This will be graeter than the oxygen molar flow rate by the factor 0.79/0.21 = 3.76. Substituting the molar flow rates in the first equation delivers
The water vapour pressue at the outlet only depends on the air stoichiometry and the air pressure at the exit. This eqution gives the worst case conditions, not water vapour in the inlet. If the realtive humidity of the excess air is too dry, it could be changed by lowering temperature increase losses lowering air flow rate and hence reduce cathode performance increasing pressure more enrgy for the compressor None of these options is really attractive. Another option is to extract the water of the excess air and supply it to the reactants at the inlet. This requires additional equipment, extra costs, but is often justified by an increased performance. The water pressure can be derived, taking the humidity of the inlet air into account, is given by with
Note that humidities are lower at greater airflow. At higher temperatures the relative humidity falls sharply. Note that if the relative humidity of the excess air is below 100% the fuel cell has given all its water, but the air is not yet saturated. That means the fuel cell dries out. On the other side a relative humidity greater than 100% is basically impossible, because the air stream would contain condensed water and the electrons would become flooded. At temperatures above 60C, the relative humidity of the exit air is below 100% at all reasonable values of . Above this temperature extra humidification of the reactants is essential in PEMFC operating. This causes the difficulties in choosing the optimum operating temperature; higher temperatur means better performance but also increasing humidification problems. The key is to set the stoichiometry so that the relative humidity of exit air is about 100% and design a balanced water distribution within the cell.
4.5 PEMFC cooling and air supply 4.5.1 Cooling using the cathode air supply
PEM reaches normally efficincies of around 50%, so half of the chemical energy is changed in heat. The heat produced by a PEM, if the product water is evaporated within the cell is
The way the heat is removed depends greatly on the size of the fuel cell, beolow 100W it is possible to cool the cell and evaporate the water by air, without using any fan, only due to a open cell design. The fact that damp air is less dense than dry air aids the circulation process. For more compact types a small fan blows the reactants and cooling air through the cell, though a large proportion of heat is lost through natural convection and radiation. For systems with a power higher than 100W, seperate cooling is needed.
If the reactant air and cooling air are the same, the equation would be the same. This gives an exit air humidity at 50C of 26%, that means that the relative humidity decreases, and so the PEM will quickly dry out. In order to reduce to a desired value of 3 to 6, the air flow rate has to be reduced and a seperate cooling system is required. Seperate cooling is achieved by adding cooling channels in the bipolar plates of adding additional cooling plates in the cell. Air cooling works for cell powers up to 2 kW.
flow field is made of foamed metal, with a sponge-like structure. Then a thin solid metal plate is added between two foamed plates. A corrocsive resistant coating is added. Cooling plates can be made in the same way. One porous metal slice between two solid plates. Advantage: already available material, cutting and moulding the plastic deals only process steps
Another problem is the possible imbalance of this system. The single cells are some way apart. If one cell becomes rather warmer, this would lead to more rapid water evaporation, and so to higher resistance and higher temperatures. The cell got in a vicious circle and would end up dried.
We also saw, that the activation overvoltage is related to the exchange current by a logarithmic functio. So we can say, that if the pressure is increased from P1 to P2, then there is a gain in voltage and power.
with
C: voltage gain constant, depeding on the change of i0 with the pressure, R, T and F. I: current n: number of cells
On the other side we have the power consumption of the compressor and the electric propulsion.
with
T1: entry temperature c: compressor efficiency m: motor and drive efficiency : air flow rate The air flow rate is connected to the electric power, the cell voltage and the air stoichiometry, by Substituting the electric power by nIVc and the air parameters cp and , we get the power losses.
The highlighted part is the voltage loss. We can get now the voltage change for a rise of the pressure by The following plot shows two graphs, a realistic and optimistic one, for the different parameters.
It can be seen, that for the realistic values, the nett voltage will always be less for higher pressures. The made derivation is a quite simple one and a lot of other factors have to be included to get a realistic view of the effect of ibcreased pressures.
SOFC:
operates between 650C and 1000C. Since it is a solid state device, it has many advantages due to its mechanical simplicity and can be used in a wide range of applications. The advantages mentioned above consider mostly the use of the waste heat. PAFC, MCFC and SOFC must always be thought of as a integral part of a complete fuel processing and heat generating system. The common features of all three types are: used fuel needs processing fuel utilisation fuel is a mixture, in which the hydrogen is used. This means that the concentration will decrease, what reduces the local cell voltage. Exit gases carry a large amount of heat, which can be further converted into electricity and
thus leads to higher efficiency. Heat can also be used to preheat fuel and oxidant. Ensure high electrical and thermal efficiency and reduce the exergy losses are the key aspects in designing such a system.
If the partial pressure of hydrogen falls from P1 to P2, the voltage change will always be negative. The RT term means that this drop will be greater for higher temperatures. The same occur for the oxygen utilisation from the air. Figure 7.1 shows the effect of it in four cases. 1. Standard hydrogen fuel cell operating at 1bar with pure hydrogen and oxygen. 2. Using air at the cathode and a mixtue of 4 parts hydrogen and 1 part carbon dioxide at the anode. 3. Nernst exit voltage for 80% fuel utilisation and 50% air utilisation. 4. Nernst exit voltage for 90% fuel utilisation and 50% air utilisation.
Sometimes the voltage drop can be reduced, by using opposite flow direction (counteer-flow), so high oxygen concentration at the point of the cell with low hydrogen concentration. A factor ignored yet, is that in MCFC and SOFC the product steam ends up at the anode, hydrogen is replaced by steam. This will also cause a fall of the OCV. The important conclusion is, that in the case of reformed fuel containing carbon dioxide or when internal reforming is applied, all the hydrogen can nevver be consumed in the fuel cell itself. Some hydrogen must pass right through the cell and can be used later to provide energy to process the fuel or to be burnt to increase the heat energy. To find an optimum, extensive modelling is needed.
On the other side are the losses high at abient temperature and so the practical efficiency would be well below that limit. To reduce the voltage losses we have to raise the temperature, but this reduces the Gibbs free energy. If we assume now a revrsible process operating at high temperature, the waste heat can also be converted into electricity. Using thermodynamic basics and the Carnot limit we get the same maximum efficiency as mentioned above. Figure 7.2 shows the efficiency limit of fuel cell, a heat engine and a combined cycle. Note that the temperature limit of the heat engine is the combustion temperature of the fuel.
A fuel cell operating at around 800-1000C can approach the theoretical maximum efficiency, as
well as heat engines. Figure 7.3 sketches a possible combined cycle system based on an SOFC.
The work done by the two compressors are the major losses in the system. Assuming realistic values such a system can reach efficiencies of around 60%. Working at higher pressures offers the possibilties to reach even higher pressuers.
minimum difference. This so-called pinch temperature defines the target for the optimum process design, since in a real system heat cannot transferred from above or below this temperature. Other considerations taken into account are the materials of the BOP components and their mechanical layout.
The Nernst reversible potential, taken the CO2 transfer into account, is given by
In practice the CO2 produced at the anode is externally recycled to the cathode. The anod exhaust gas is fed to a burner, which converts any unused fuel into water and CO2. The exit flow of the burner is then supplied with fresh air to the cathode inlet. The process also pre-heat the reactant air. Another method of reuse the CO2 is a membrane seperator. The advantage of this method is unused fuel gas can be recycled to the anode or used for other purposes. If an external supply of CO 2 is already existing this can also be used. MCFC doesn't need nobel metal catalysts, due to the high operating temperature. Nickel (anode) and nickel oxide (cathode) is used. Furthermore it is also able to convert CO directly and reform hydrocarbon fuels directly. The high operating temperature of MCFCs provides the opportunity for achieving higher overall system efficiencies and greater flexibility in use of available fuels compared to low temperature cells. Unfortunately, the higher temperatures and the aggresive medium of molten carbonate electrolyte also place severe demands on the corosion stability and life of the cell components.
converted into hydrogen at operating temperature. IR eliminates the costs of an external reformer and thus systems efficiency is improved, but the cell configuration can get more complex. IR is only possible with an additional metal catalyst, due to the low anode surface area. Key requirements for the MCFC reforming catalyst area-specific sustained activity to achieve the desired cell performance and lifetime resistance to poisons in the fuel resistance to alkali/caronate poisoning