Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Brian Biegel
w i t h
Peter Thomas Fornatale
Crown Publishers
new york
ISBN 978-0-307-45268-9
Printed in the United States of America
Design by Level C
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
First Edition
www.CrownPublishing.com
Miracle Ball
visit one of these online retailers:
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Borders
IndieBound
Powell’s Books
Random House
www.CrownPublishing.com
To my mother, Sandy
www.CrownPublishing.com
four Esther 41
www.CrownPublishing.com
Acknowledgments 229
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
The sun hung over the first-base side of the Polo Grounds, reflecting off the apart-
ment buildings that lined Harlem River Drive and onto the open end of the sta-
dium behind the left-field stands. The clock in center field read 3:58.
The details of the play itself are familiar to most baseball fans. Branca had
Thomson down in the count 0-1, the result of a called strike right down the middle.
It was the bottom of the ninth. Two men on base. The Giants trailed the Dodg-
ers by two runs in the last game of a three-game playoff series. The winner would
advance to the World Series against the New York Yankees. Out of the windup,
Branca threw a fastball, high and tight. But this time Thomson, the lanky
outfielder turned third baseman, was ready. He pulled the pitch to left field—a
sinking line drive.
The fans in the lower portion of section 35 followed the flight of the ball. A photo
captured the moment perfectly. There was an overweight, middle-aged man in a
white T-shirt and a black jacket in the first row. Next to him was a buzz-cut teen-
ager with thick-rimmed eyeglasses. A row above them stood a man with a handlebar
mustache and a fedora. In the fourth row, a bushy-haired man stood with his arms
stretched above his head and his mouth wide open.
The crowd’s loyalties were evenly divided: The Dodgers fans prayed that the
ball would somehow find its way into left fielder Andy Paf ko’s mitt; the Giants
fans prayed that it wouldn’t. The teams’ rivalry—the oldest in professional
www.CrownPublishing.com
sports—dated back all the way to the nineteenth century, but it had never seen a
moment like this.
The prayers of the home team’s fans were answered: Thomson had hit a home
run; the Giants won the pennant. Thomson’s blast became known as the Shot
Heard ’Round the World.
As for the baseball itself, that’s been a mystery ever since. Just after the ball
cleared the wall, it bounced out of a fan’s glove and ricocheted seven feet to the
left—straight into the hands of a person who would ensure that its fate would not be
discovered for more than fifty years.
www.CrownPublishing.com
lars at auction), but all of their claims have been disproved. The
president of one prestigious auction house has estimated the odds
of locating the ball at an astronomical 1 in 200 million. Similarly,
every baseball historian I spoke with told me that there was no way
to learn what really happened to it.
Fortunately for me, they were wrong.
This is the story of my two-year quest to solve the mystery that
was supposed to be unsolvable. Several years ago, my father realized
that he might have the famous missing baseball, and what began
as a way to help my dad became, frankly, an obsessive hunt. It’s a
journey that brought me from an auction house on Long Island to
the National Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, New York, to
Bobby Thomson’s ranch-style home in New Jersey, to a forensics
lab in Northern Long Island, to a dusty oil field in Texas, and ulti-
mately to a spot on a quiet graveled road in New Mexico that was
just about the last place I ever expected to be.
What kept me going was not simply the desire to unravel this
legendary sports mystery. Like life itself, my search became all about
the journey. Along the way, I met an incredible cast of characters: a
celebrated sportswriter who has made a career out of writing about
the Thomson ball; a crazed Dodgers fan who slept inside the Polo
Grounds the night before the game; a retired NYPD detective who
found an important clue hidden (in plain sight) in an old photo; a
baseball fanatic whose uncanny memory provided a crucial piece
of the puzzle; two men from New Jersey who shared a seemingly
astounding tale that turned out to fit precisely with the other evi-
dence; and many others.
It had been more than half a century since Thomson’s home
run clinched the 1951 National League pennant, but everywhere I
turned, it seemed as if there was another person telling a passionate
story about the home run, or another eminent author or director who
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
Brooklyn Boy
For Jack Biegel and his fellow Brooklyn Dodgers fans, the 1951 season had been
joyous and painful at the same time. Joyous because the team spent so much of the
year in first place. Painful because they coughed up a 13 1⁄2-game lead and had to play
a best-of-three series against the hated Giants to determine who would represent the
National League in the World Series against the Yankees.
On the day of the deciding game, eighteen-year-old Jack needed to be in Manhat-
tan for a job interview. There was a position open as a shipping clerk at a company
in the Garment District. Much as he wanted to go to the Polo Grounds to see the
Dodgers and Giants in person, he couldn’t take the risk; the game didn’t start until
1:20, and afterward he’d have to cover well over a hundred blocks to get down to his
interview by five o’clock. But that didn’t mean he had to miss watching the game.
Every bar worth its salt had a television, the amazing new invention that meant
you didn’t need to be at the ballpark to see every pitch. So he left for Manhattan
about five hours before his interview was slated to begin.
Getting off the subway at Twenty-third Street and Seventh Avenue, fifteen
blocks south of where he needed to be, Jack ducked into an Irish pub on Twenty-fifth
Street just in time to see Jackie Robinson single home Pee Wee Reese for the first
run of the game. He stayed there for several innings, then began weaving his way
through the streets of Manhattan, checking the score through various pub windows,
growing excited as the Dodgers inched closer to the pennant.
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
The Duke was a good tipper, but he impressed my dad even more
with his kindness. Duke affectionately called him Kiddo and on
subsequent deliveries found out that Jack wanted to be a ballplayer
and encouraged him to follow his dream. Jack’s desire to play pro-
fessional ball grew by the day. Especially on the days when Uncle
Heshie gave him the yellow receipt with the two special words
marked on it.
But Dad’s dream hit a roadblock when his father lost his job at
the Washington Fruit Market down near Canal Street in Manhat-
tan. He ended up dropping out of high school halfway through his
senior year to work for Heshie full-time. The money he made there
in tips really helped at home, and he figured he still might be able
to get a tryout with a minor league team at some point. The system
www.CrownPublishing.com
was different then. There were several hundred minor league af-
fi liates across the country, extending all the way down from AAA
to class D ball. And none of them cared if you had a high school
diploma.
Every week my dad would pick up a copy of the Sporting News,
the bible of baseball, at the newsstand near the IRT subway sta-
tion on Eastern Parkway and Utica Avenue. He was a stats freak.
He’d also check out the classified ads, hoping there would be a job
in the Brooklyn Dodgers organization—doing anything. One day
he read in the classifieds that the Hopkinsville Hoppers in rural
Kentucky were holding open tryouts. He knew the opportunity to
play at the professional level—even just in class D ball in the Kitty
League—had to pay more than the $80 a month he was making at
Heshie’s. Plus, this was a chance to live out a dream. He packed the
black metal spikes he wore at Tilden along with his two baseball
www.CrownPublishing.com
gloves and bought a one-way ticket for a bus he thought would take
him to baseball heaven.
www.CrownPublishing.com
Dad pitches the opening-day game for the U.S. Army Special Forces
team in Germany, 1954. From the author’s collection
six years later, when they moved to Los Angeles. Jack was a real
working-class man with the pride and determination that defi ned
Brooklyn in the postwar era. When his beloved Dodgers left in
1957, he was as angry and resentful as anyone. These were his Dodg-
ers, and they were leaving home, never to return. To this day, he
doesn’t like to talk much about it.
Still, Dad never lost his love of baseball. Even as he worked as
a beverage deliveryman, carrying thirty-five-pound cases of soda,
beer, and seltzer up three or four fl ights of stairs, he kept play-
ing ball in pickup games on the fields at Brooklyn’s Prospect Park
Parade Grounds, the same baseball diamonds where many local
legends have played before and since: Sandy Koufax, Joe Torre, Willie
Randolph, and Manny Ramirez among them. Getting drafted
into the U.S. Army and being sent to Germany during the Korean
War didn’t stop him from playing either. He joined the Special
Forces team, where one of his teammates was a tall right-handed
hurler named Johnny Kucks, who would go on to pitch for the
Yankees—and shut out the Dodgers in game 7 of the 1956 World
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
www.CrownPublishing.com
Miracle Ball
visit one of these online retailers:
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Borders
IndieBound
Powell’s Books
Random House
www.CrownPublishing.com