Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Your Global Supplier of Automation and Information Management Systems for the Power Automation Market
Operator maxSTATIONs
maxSTORIAN
Engineers maxSTATION
Printers
maxNET
RPM
D P U MAXLINKS
D P U
D P U A A D I O I
D P U D B O E M
A A D D T T R I O I O C C T D
B A A D D T T R E I O I O C C T M D
Serial Links
References
China
North China Power Group, Sha Ling Zi North China Power Group, San He LiuLiHe Cement Cogen, Beijing
LiuLiHe Cement, Hebei Province Electricity Company, Xiaguan Shanxi Power Bureau, ShenTou
YiBin Power Co., YiBin GuiZhou PB, ZhunYi GuiZhou PB, JinSha GuiZhou PB, QianBei
MeiShan Iron&Steel, JiangSu YiZheng Chemical,Jiangsu Fortum Eng. Ltd, Jiangsu JiangSu PB, XuTang JiangSu PB,Peng Cheng JiangSu PB, HuaiYin
Yunan Power Bureau, QuQing YuNan Power Bureau, Yang Zhong Hai YuNan Power Bureau, Xuan Wei
Shanghai Electric Power Bureau, Wa Gao Qiao Shanghai PB, MinHang Anhui PB, Tongling AnHui PB, HuaBei AnHui PB, TianJiaAn JiangXi Power Bureau, Feng Cheng
6/11/02
maxDNA
Leading DCS Technology
with
22 Industrial Projects
Plant TianJiaAn upgrade 1 x 300MW (Boiler, Turbine, EMCS) YiBin 410 t/h CFB new (Boiler, Turbine, EMCS) XuanWei Phase VI new (Boiler, Turbine, EMCS, DEH, ETS, Simulation) XunJiangSi new 440 t/h CFB (Boiler, Turbine, EMCS, DEH) XiaoLongTan retrofit (Boiler, Turbine, EMCS, DEH) KunMing retrofit (Boiler, Turbine, EMCS, DEH) TianJiaAn retrofit (Boiler, Turbine, EMCS, DEH) QianBei Units 1 & 2 WaiGaoQiao Phase 1 Simulation 4 x 300MW ZunYi Unit 2 YangZhou Unit 4 ChaoYang ChongQing No. 3 HuaiBei TianJiaAn includes DEH XuTang YangZhou Unit 5 HuaiYin Unit 2 ChongQing Unit 2 YangZhou Unit 6 MinHang ChongQing Unit 1
Size (MW) 1 x 100 2 x 300 1 x 125 1 x 100 1 x 100 1 x125 2 x 300 1 x 125 1 x 200 1 x 200 1 x 200 1 x 200 1 x 125 2 x 300 1 x 200 1 x 200 1 x 200 1 x 200 1 x 125 1 x 200
Year 2003 2003 2003 2003 2003 2003 2002 2002 2002 2001 2001 2001 2001 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 2000 1999 1999 1999
Information Technology
SIS Application Optimizes the Relationship between Heat Rate vs NOx production
Boiler OP
Low NOx Optimizer
SO2 formation in fluegas NOX formation during combustion process Heavy metals (Hg and arsenic)
All require a different means to control. In addition there are greenhouse gases such as CO2
Natural gas has lowest NOx formation - all is fuel NOx Oil Coal
- Thermal NOx - Fuel NOx - Thermal NOx - Fuel NOx
20-40% 60-80% 10-20% 80-90%
- Increases exponentially with temperature. - Proportional to the square root of oxygen content. - Increases rapidly with oxygen rich atmosphere. - Decreases with delayed mixing.
Composition of Air...
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Nitrogen Oxygen Argon 0.93 0.03 CO2 21 78
Western PA Bituminous Coal Heating Value 13,000 BTU per pound Percent by weight
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
n rb on ur e n lfu n ge dr og e oi st Su ge xy As h r
75
2.5
2.3
1.5
6.7
Ca
tro Ni
Hy
Temperature is key (>1800 starts NOx formation) Time (longer the burn the less NOx) Turbulence (mixing of fuel and air is critical)
Most NOx above 1800F Minimize NOx by keeping average flame temperature
low
Must set classifier for smallest particle size Fuel/air mixing rate regulates the burn rate and thus
the resulting average combustion temperature
Turbulence...
Necessary for mixing fuel Excessive turbulence promotes rapid burnout and
high average combustion temperature
Low peak flame temperature Flame is yellow Gradual burn Temperature on the other side of furnace will
increase
100% is 1.00 ratio of moles of fuel to oxygen Excess air is additional over this amount <100% at the burner area results in lower
temperature
Low NOx Burners extend flame pattern and lengthen burn-out time
Windbox Sec Air Pri Air Burn-out Zone Sec Air Burn-out Zone
Sec Air
Boiler Air Leakage Dirty Boiler O2 Sensor Problems CEM System Problems
- O2 Levels - Secondary Air Damper Positions - Burner Tilts - Overfire Air Damper Positions
Reduce NOx 20% to 35% Reductions Improve Heat Rate 50 to 100 Btu/kWh Reduce LOI to Sell Fly Ash Reduce Potential for Severe Slagging Eliminate Opacity Excursions
Enhances the performance of Low-NOx Firing Systems
Optimization Objectives
Objectives are specific to the unit and situation Lowest Possible NOx Control NOx to Target Minimize Heat Rate (Increase efficiency) Constraints can be applied LOI CO Opacity Steam Temperatures Gas Temperatures
Software based Calibrates final control elements Learns process and improves upon model as it learns Can be closed loop or operate in supervisory mode
Combustion Optimization
Solves for the Optimization Objective Applies Constraints Adjusts Boiler Control Settings
- Furnace O2 Level - Burner Tilt Angle - SOFA Tilt Angle - Windbox Pressure - Mill Loading Pattern (biases) - CCOFA Damper Positions - Boiler Cleanliness
Parametric Relationships
NOx, lb/MBtu
0.560-0.580 0.540-0.560 0.520-0.540 0.500-0.520 0.480-0.500 0.460-0.480 0.440-0.460
NOx
0.460
0.66
0.440
15 12 9 0 0.69 6 3
0.63
Burner Tilt
-9 0.75
0.72
-3
-6
0.57
0.54
Boiler OP is a Neural Network based Combustion Boiler OP calculates optimal settings for the Boiler OP presents on-line information to the operator Boiler OP evaluates current operating conditions and
predicts the impact on performance. and can adjust the boiler control settings in closed loop mode. controllable parameters. Optimizer.
Boiler OP Background
Developed by Lehigh University Energy Research Center Over 10 years of experience in the application of
sizes, geometries, and fuels and Potomac Electric Power Company
Over 20 Boiler Optimization projects on boilers of different Over 40 Professional Staff, Faculty, and Grad Students Extensive work with EPRI on Heat Rate Calculations and
Performance Measurements
Boiler OP Structure
Expert Expert System System
Performance Advice
DCS
Combustion Controls Data Acquisition Information Management
Conduct Parametric Tests Build Database Correlate Data Using Neural Networks Determine Optimal Solutions Convert Results into Control Curves Configure the Operator Displays Install Software & Validate Model Train Operators
Neural Networks use a database to build a model. - Without good data, the model is not correct. Neural Networks can not distinguish between good data
and bad data.
All operating constraints must be considered. - The goal is a physical optimum, not just mathematical
Parametric Testing
Boiler Controls
An Expert System
Plant Engineer
Plant Data
establishes test criteria & guides the test engineer through the test sequence
and advice is presented to the test engineer based on 15 years of combustion optimization experience
Boiler OP
Parametric Relationships
Relationships developed through parametric testing Boiler OP uses Neural Networks to correlate key
parameters to boiler control settings are complex!
- NOx = f(O2, Tilt, ) - Heat Rate = f(O2, Tilt, ) - LOI = f(O2, Tilt, ) - Opacity = f(O2, Tilt, )
Optimization Algorithm
Heat Rate
10,150 10,100
BT = -8 deg.
0.17 0.16 0.15 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3.0 3.2 3.4
AVERAGE ECONOMIZER O2
BT = -8 deg.
Control Curves are generated for key parameters Setpoints are determined by the optimization objectives & constraints Control Curves are configured into the combustion control system
Morgantown
SOFA Damper Position (%)
50
SOFA #20
30
20
10
SOFA #19
275 325 375 425 475 525 575 625
0 225
Load (MW)
20
15
Open
10
-0.10
-0.08
-0.06
-0.04
-0.02
0 0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
-5
-10
Close
-15
Performance Advice
DCS
Combustion Controls Data Acquisition Information Management
April 20
May 20
Jan 25
Feb 24
Operator Display
Presents Optimal and Actual Boiler Settings Penalty Box shows impact of control deviations on
- NOx - Heat Rate - LOI
Displays Neural Network Model Limits Displays Status of each Key Parameter Allows Operator to set Update Interval
Operator Display
T-fired Twin Furnace Example
Penalty Box
Operator Display
Wall Fired Example
What IfAnalysis
An optional engineering & training tool Allows manual entry of Actual data Shows impact of deviations from optimal settings on
- NOx - Heat Rate - LOI - CO
What if the Optimization Objectives, Constraints, or Operating Conditions Change? Example: Objective is now to minimize LOI at Target NOx
New Optimal Solutions can be calculated with the New Control Curves can be configured in the
Combustion Control System same Neural Network Model developed from the parametric tests
FIELD RESULTS
Boiler Types
4 Corner-Fired Boiler with Conventional Burners 4 & 8 Corner-Fired Boilers with Low-NOx Firing Systems Wall-Fired Boiler with Dual Register Burners and OFA Wall-Fired Boiler with Flue Gas Recirculation Systems Arch-Fired Boiler with Conventional Burners
Fuel Types
Eastern Bituminous Coal Western Sub-bituminous & PRB Coals Coal Blends (Eastern & Western Coals) Lignites Anthracite Oil Gas & Gas Co-firing Landfill Gas & Coal Co-firing
FIELD RESULTS
T-FIRED UNITS
Boiler Characteristics Fuel Type EC EC EC EC EC EC,WC EC,WC Unit Load (MW) 4X108 1X150 585 92 315 2X250 510 240 Baseline NOx (lb/ MBtu) 0.60 0.75 0.45 0.30 0.36 0.22 0.22 NOx Reduction (%) 25 40 22 23 31 8 38
Four-Corner Boiler with Conventional Burners. Eight-Corner Boiler with LNCFS-III LowNOx Burners. Four-Corner Boiler with LNCFS-III LowNOx Burners. Twin-Furnace Boiler with LNCFS Low-NOx Burners. Eight-Corner Boiler with LNCFS-III LowNOx Burners. Eight-Corner Boiler with Low-NOx Burners and Overfire Air (OFA). Eight-Corner Boiler with Separate SHT and RHT Furnaces. Low-NOx Burners and Overfire Air (OFA).
FIELD RESULTS
WALL FIRED UNITS
Boiler Characteristics Fuel Type EC EC, WC, G WC EC, WC, O EC EC, WC EC Unit Load (MW) 650 280 600 150 2X300 750 630 Baseline NOx (lb/ MBtu) 0.75 1.13 0.24 0.68 1.11 0.67 0.47 NOx Reduction (%) 20 31 34 29 15-35 33 27
Opposed Wall-Fired Boiler with Dual Register Low-NOx Burners and OFA. Front Wall-Fired, Twin-Furnace Boiler with Conventional Burners. Opposed Wall-Fired with Dual Register Burners. Front Wall-Fired Boiler with Conventional Burners. Front Wall-Fired with Conventional Burners and Flue Gas Recirculation. Opposed Wall-Fired with Low-NOx Cell Burners. Opposed Wall-Fired Boiler with DRB-XCL low-NOx Firing System with OFA
Four 108 MW & one 150 MW Units Tangentially-Fired Pulverized Coal Conventional Burners Original Firing System Eastern Bituminous Coal Four Burner Elevations All Four Mills Needed to Optimization Objective Meet NOx Regulations
Without Converting to Low NOx Burners Achieve Full Load