[RESURRECCION 2. BORRA, FLORENTINO A. TUASON, JR, VELMA Fico an GOED € BEGUN mh pay Oe Cretan eben) geeoes he "fr bey az Chama of fectoes (EDMELEC™ ey bevy) tad Nasu mfr ety ad Fovenine Tze (Case fer tei) as COMELEC CommasoeerPettner abo Sevny ar Diecr W of he CONELECS Ea Depertmest Dor be the gy ofthe appointment of Vel Caco (Cac or sing Dacor hae £0 Febery 3 Bh hes Ogee ‘ato Semis ened he spitnesto pence Dacor S788 8 S"Sengonry cen Ou febeay SON commas fetso $host woul sp he stent of pttone te same postin Fempenn amet fox Febany 2 08. fe otic sed acted the Or Inne 1 DL Presest Armye esewed theod radtorthersme eon ofseve en expiagar Fbrnty 2 200 They Me he epcay a6 CDMELEC Olinos, feninye aed > Ghaigeefthe ED inthe waergumentofpettinee. (Grea, 7 ded pi 0 201, semadig bead of gveramest oervi 38, OL tag COMELEC Gempbietiwi the ow Department agra Bxgye,slgig tat Aervesergument voted Seton 21 [bof the Omuibar Ect Code. petinne the tet pettnn questing the appointment 2d the Gromerbuet of te COMELE. respective Pettoeer chine tat ‘coustat the independence ofthe COMELEC, a wellaz Deprineat Snabncosh pettane! cheng he der lepity of the debunements made by CONELEC Fannce Sener sad Tena bynyofeabiessedotier emoluments lathe merstine, on September 6, 201, Peridet Mapa! a0 Ghmnzed tren sed Wasorse Conmaronerseperiney rtm taeeen yea expig Febeaty2 2H They aoe hiro ot 4 Wiehe of so et pte tie a he jadcalreve ncontteton leze: 2 Whether or aot the assumpton of oes by Bengyo, Bore Srsed. by the Pesest anoest wa tempest) Sppeitmest poked by Stor 1 (2, Bele De of te ‘serempto of oce by Beniye, Born aad Team 302 Leg whether or tot the seneval of herod ‘he aw Deparment eps aad wAawt astray, bing legalFre sve: Propriety fod Review Jesper ait tt te tn ik te I he et of den se i Tevtving the erasavtmay af hed Sarnappomtments sued bythe Priest te Bene, Bott sad ‘Tgron tebe aH he font equeee sie peat Thee te”) te ceanace of su aetsl ad appopente contoveny: (22 perotal snd [nice eltvect ofthe pry ming the coartatnal Eve, the ‘rece of the flea view E pleaded 2 the ees portuny and (i the contastoeal nee tthe emote fhe cae ny of tad intemappoimnents atthe exert, Aespondents ist thot the sal tve in thie se the ey of pettnacre semigenett fom the ED tthe Le Deparment Garegesthy th ay of thead enipye sesergned petinne fom the ED, whee she wae Stig Dimcoy te the lw Defrinest whet she war peed on det "Benpow'seutorty os Ouirmon of the Commision on ection, and {the Commision» Chef Execatve Offer = Biden, sexpondens he bufalGhimne ofthe COMELES Erni pettnes only Director ef he Eber wassgnmente withowt kal base Z nt the bil COMELEG hammer, an otecented bythe fone: inigunest# tpl ad ste be tee cm [Bu Chat, petouer ars peosaload materstabe the eatin Aecpondente hip on pettoues bebted act of gest Nowever te notte at of flag of he pt ‘he constteineal tev wae med atthe eecteppetety. The eit span ates cousin! wie ae hie tne nthe patos cont be covered 3 the aL 20 at cnpye ov ad Teneo when she fled ber pits bere the Goo Sehek the eatert oppor fr pleading the courtatbea Erte Si susieen norcrossMovover. the kgaly of pettus sassganent binges ‘conrnetanaty of fengayos 24 arin appantnest ad erg ‘te: Uniar the conrtatbnaay of Benge so ina poutnest Sel seumtinn of ofce © tobed, the kpalty of peinnes deimined Csi, the ls motoot te ae # the very conte ‘one ed by pein any event the iste ied by pettoner & of monourt ingortance tothe ple Te ely ated byte COMELEC the conde f the Woy 18 2000, sy be pet date # te conrttetonaleree ied by pet (Intcoked ehcp wh the Gots deny te determine whether othe Second lest: The Ntureof an Ad nein Appoint a tempoarysppntneat tat spoked b Sarton 1) ile DC of spencyahilieony ihe erp rmotte pce In ane capecty” (Empince pp) fawn ar evoked bythe Peston st her pasate aad con eves be Geppeved or simply brpaced by the. Commeroe ot petinent For the satan pettiner chine tat ated Inenmappeitimeet ie temporty fm chnacter aad congue ebay te ot eens of Soe 1 (BS Ho IRAE Stone 00 posting ore cess ofthe Gators Gimmasbe and the Conmisbe on had especie. Pete! Inert the bot sentence of ec 1 (2 of ile BCC t wean hat Confined by the Commer ment for on tes doer be The mine beindpetinners theory & tat o et conte bythe Comes teimiated any tne fry cre nthe word of peter 2 Suan Wein petitioner argumest wittont mer, ‘ale ert mane sada ao beget behav by the erent nce the sppones ta alii into off The ct at eb 2 Confimaton by te Gommeson ot Sppaintneatsdoct ot she [Penmappeieineetpemavest chase yr diapered by the Conmarion ox Appts oY tat the setrengaph ofSecton 16, iil it {ppeintmest shal befeive onl untldeappea! by the Commesoe Cope” ematical ny ato (f) Sectnn 10, rele Vil ofthe onrteton whch pvier tat the ‘The Comtteton inpoces no condition onthe effec of 240d Sect of he Conmiion on Appointments the Ganebbanted ot Indl chasen may thu ua and perform hi funcin without se Sf time. Ms tke to such ofee is complete. athe mngege of the fettoeer aigece thot shod intrimappomtent e uedoutedly fempoary in claacler The aigmest © et ae bed was aarvered By ctpeience deat ‘pate vespondert Ube bere steed seven ‘a intr appotnent chek penser neler wndewtade 2 ppistner tempor ele The er defined by Boch ones ‘tere mate tht i done bythe Present of the Pmentaran it the ‘meantime whie the Bard of Regent which original vested bytheUniversity Carter with he power of oppintmen i unable to act ), of the Omer Se, 251i Acts. The flowing stab gut of WHERE, te orequoted proven ae applicable tthe saad aed baelertonr on ay 16 200tes prtins sad romero reassign fr pesone| when nee it the effective performence of te mandted functions during the rhibited pera, povided thatthe caager th sergeant eld [Peronnel hin the thi geied bo electon dy cal eed ive otke Ped bain” Empiase apple) No. 330, eqaiing due note and ering nore ay tac o argument canbe made thie tiny (ip posts cheton ay, rer on 0 COMELEC eld poronnlaad sot 15 ied tke pesmael ete etnes Unie the tvted fice specitea verted wt he per wo tesa esr COMELEC ‘he COMELEC on honceanot gs ae ‘eosigenert eligi wcalton ves eskse Rectan Wo 200 fiom the CDMELECor borcto sete impement ach tae orcad by bo t0 Ban jomacty, Bengay. Te CDMELECen bone: COMELEC ing Caco Offer in Charge ofthe ED = gal ene Fp ere: Legato Dibursement to Rerpondents WHEREFORE the pein dened Reh of merit Core agpiet HONORABLE SIMPLO ¢ GRO, SOTO P. DENEAISP, SATS. SAGUADERA. MANUEL ~BTRAVINA and. MANUEL a ‘ASUIMPANG,pettiner, {EVIL SERVICE COMMISSION, TEOMIO ARANDELA, CRO GELVEZON, ‘TEOBULFO DATO-ON, ana MESON GEDUSPAN,rerpondente Sie P.Demeiifor patosfox Muzonsforprivete respondents ames Vileruave for Ci Service Commision verano vas accepted bythe the Stig sor bir, peitserDeretip commended “st scpeadent Teste Rnvdeh fom Sexier Lea! Ofer (Celeron, on the ther tad ar pometed fm nsf Se lege Offces,tespadestsTeodole Unt znd Wes Geer ete Febrary 2 1808, ps scwcd govenerof loin One north Bie be ifmed erpadent ithe bgafice othe Princ trey Ofc stort i maha te, eG ae ‘appointed by Governor Gro 7 the Pvc ‘elather lad srmaged the repacement of the other ag feet {Scunpeg and pettines Hansel Tove tok the pce sf esposdent (March 15,1908, petiner Govern vas appeased by (March 9,190 the erste Bae i tetpondet!serminton ig! sed ondrng tat they be immed them The ar sppened by petaoner Grit tthe Ch See ina contenbe het tat the portion of» Cay legs Ofer heh prima contetat” The Cur hel it [cing be be anton ve se, 7 Phi 29) th pinay conbdenta “denotes nat on confacace shespttede ofthe pois ft the det ofthe ffce bet pinay ese ntinacy wh insures edo of ater oteate (imple 5a 165, 19SCRA SE, vaste — Cnphyee ellag, peasy covfdental perkins fora mags confece them ender bathe ease a ny, when the rzpoaert Cy yor of Dae mined see oh ite cae of lg wr Mutac, C2590, November 3, 1960, 2 SERA 17 he wee ee appeited or ehted ent andThe forgoing mere cbonter iat the Cou seating tre Iestce JBL aye, seted i the ase Glipert. Cndere, C2872 Hatch 3,965, 1 SCIA fim office tre oa a bag az conilence thet gst lates the Ofce of Pesdent the Gare ‘urdering ml yrtin to be pray confdeatalbel = opie bce bythe stee ofthe functor ofs poi iy pel etter, thew postions ae oth rina Horcatre sed tetetve Cente not sppiabe We apie with the pettnneis and aazver the question eater ppoponnded inthe afrathe. Xe gel offs appnated by 3 ayer te we vrai bff th iy hae or Ae conte story spine bythe pi Se. 19, Cnctin of pston of Provincial Atarmey and Gey Lagalofeer — To erst the prove» Prova atrey aed ny eal oft may be std rere the feacions Aero perotmed by the vocal sed cay fae scr ne hap ove ed (aloticer for chileaer of he povine aud cy sal be tasted w the pevacal storey 3nd cy pl ce respecte Emphareeppeg |vitae of Repeic Act Ho SHES, bat he province adety eglofeer sere athe gander sn eon fot Ie chi caer ofthe posuce sed the cy tnt fey work fo Thee sence be peceely cteorced by Bu to be arted ofthe fests, paver sad dat of cy gots 2 {crcer"to be eadered bythe ofcer cou mensch tated seneae Sins teed tacos an corp ge. eg Pinay confetal portion endrupon er of condone "te Cort Streewher hzsentar mer timnted He teim meh evpoed rabiy fe deep a vr of sethet ‘Stopletprerattntentertirttretecetsee frome polcemas seniag inthe Hater Patol a vebton t the ‘ihn te Otee ofthe Present wee notconredsa bythe Cut The eo seed extend the poferbeal ebtbectipto the eg Fostiaroccepied by thce suborder aye tema fom tat ofthe Shr very th set ft eon hn &252 ratomiy comptes office bea, ag he eck oH pet ieckeappere ate ot ody cae deca ee secuntyofteawe principe these members ofthe chilzene “Thar with spec wth gplasetante or ceontintes of the poviec otncy timely, Cie Geberon, Teo Dron ted leon Gods sechats! qeaiatonr The porkna ae hgalytechacal in chacter ‘he tens of en esl Offer ad lage Ofer I nena petra oe ‘hese bythe Cod Serce Commaron Cnsegesthy the feller et he ‘aid tems, being permanent employees, copy secuity of tame 25 Segedhy svete they hve seeped ‘hei termatbn sch 2 apphing fr canner, ot ensign ofce ed seg the opal for Hah 35,02 acheoedgg thee at fpomtnaetteominted/ecpied™ le camstapee with peice ti veg The reepondents {hove mentnned net Cena the eves weve actin dpe pon the fly of he Gedary e hvety SFFRMED Seperate Opinions‘orey 22 Heth) ‘lhatslinclsacer lng eaderthe otepey of peomnnent employes Wish scatyofterve ander the cdsenae tem dere have, wes troetiment te nal of he pl sévee tad poctmenttowheh Heowes Me byaty aed ete te eed Goveray nasfer @ subject t© the provi of the chil service bw res and Iegubvoas other word be my tt be vermvedorsespended exept ‘Srenue povided by hw. Move recta, be may beromoved fom fee fr competence hone, ‘Covina ef concece him nhl by ve sere, ope thts cee portion be deveinged er she Povey the spo syste, whetebyeverine 2 new Governor E ‘chee becan appoint oun mony ttm the series fhe one Tepidicr of be competence and psormance oo etree nthe ved ofeach gene ae ett iy aggaste the problem which tz fr to bog paged (Seni eat. oe 6 Lngal Ofc nd as iaetaie sa eda lege Ofer to Sens Lgel OME ad eat Pvc ‘Atone ander the tes of tree Governor, bere Gv. Gif was mone terminate pate meposdert Snphye ofthe cha sents sist be mioved or sepended exept se povided bb Abe of put i the trmintnsador rps ‘perofcowdeace whch east uly sutraaated aur be tbe. ted by e Goveens fr He aleged eof tet od tial ate whch alegedlytrggered the be of concn ot the prt ofthe Goverat nthe priate fespondent war not seca frratevependent The reson get bythe Goveroy i semisig Pate respondents zener doer ton appentarebeaatated bt ove aemptigtrhced te appl the ane storementoned hag ie the cr of El ‘St cactertaned cs on speciy deak wh the yostins of) eel hie tae at Codnta nud Seon oes cy gotta ‘the PUB chet Lgceunel te sae ceed tt by sy mene pred ‘he appleathe ofthe al precedente to gh eet or ce jer appmpinte case wher sah nsw E ogre) med 35 thede conden rates ebtng the el pect povacl degee of wart Hence beth portions being pinay confident the teimaton fom ofic af the kgplaerettorsatondiate ores mest Tewse lbw ara onreqcace of the ber fcosfence upon tem Lat scated or sebonontes of the Povacel Storey a= he a clancter ng nde th cotegry of permarent employee \rah sear of tenn andes he chlsenee trem, Tderent ewes fiom the marty pion nar testnest ofthe prtisn of Previa fnteter i rabect the prover of the cid zene bo, eke 30d nether words he may sot be removed or erpendedeicept for chee poviled by bow. Hove specfeny he may emeved fom ice fr mampeteace, dehonet other mecondect bet ast thefa bin whe by very ate fut popes nts aves poston be deveped the Pvt etreey ‘2 minince the “season? wherely eentine + sem Gveran nz own man by sevnieting te cence ofthe one epider of be competence snd perormanceo= sleged “bar oonfdence having the aged (peenmentsence slips the demoaleton of thse offees se Soporte wal peer sole eu eit generac (a) Sear lps! Ofer fre 6) legal Ofer ad hr sdmietnie {aed + Lngal Offer Sens Lngal Offer a fa) to horney vedr te time of thee B) Geer fice To eacremosiueh ermine priate repent Ande, whe Gtihe chi snie sho be mimoved or suepended ene br cee ove by toed bythe Governor fr he alleged er of test 20d tial ate whch alegedlytrggered the be of concn ot Seip ofthe Gover he pate veydcet ws ot pct friatevependent The reson get bythe Govetor im Somisting Pate respondents zener doer ton appentarebeaatated bt ay be trmistd 3¢ 20 tine by the Province Governor por bar of Confer, stoi! be the bet thing 0 bother exe i stamping to provinclatorey2ppeited by te provincgoverns being akin tat 6 ev eateries pri cone 32 consequence of the bz of confidence upon him bythe povncal ing tthe ez of ge i specteay dea with te porto fc eal ‘eer sad PB chit gl coun verpetvey, and ht the ports ot ialsaumet orsunate rye te Hgheclaalinclnacter aadhie tae at Codntanud Senos cy gotta et ecu he tt oy me ce Zppeston of te sl precedents o ga set or ce jer appmpinte case wher sah nsw E ogre) med 35 not conta the Grestonaate bares tt bgeal te psa tat tet pec feet ade coufueatal mutter sebtig tthe ge tpect of ove race Frondeforpetinee (0 2 September 1804, pettoner wate confer ert the FS Depa Commarose’ detilag the nonezeace ofs FB baer ariged fo tego 5 Pettoners report recommended the Bujetstepacement ths conpetest sd sble Buyer t hadi the coor bowpi to he stein 'Os it Octber 1506, pettorer tubnated” suothet the Prerdent We tine conceraag Col Jackson Plc [t) al epee Docc ‘orwevhing dye coveing te ped Reverb 00 3B Zp Sipbyon he poyere seh nisin smpoyoestshond go poboged lave of stsace wtow pry wien! teg conecd Kita tom we sonke.‘The appction was spied bye immediate rpereo shot egece ud resteton See Cl fepenoAmeina (fet, sd the penonel of Col Domace ogee at) toed nthe Rag Somcectihe FH (25 October 1906, when petitive wae sendy in Mai stedig 2 legpi Cy from he FI Cental Off Geez Cay by vespoadent Jere FIISCommerbeer Bog Gen Miguel Vibes Pet) ering teBe reminded tat a 20 gent of FI inert i tortie of FB of 34y segebny commited by npnye/otcak tnt Regine en racy tothe Of of the Pesan hilacehng whch ‘iveralyefectad the Brea’ image ond posed the We view thenot you are raguied to submit your ‘olnaion in wring within fe (9) arin dy rom ‘ecu hero wy wo deipnay ste shonl be he Se fomed fetes ht your apleston ors haat Hue beer snetbe| love des Gcatar 21856 Imamach ae your sens in tat agin 51 fe) seeded you ar dinces t rport for work thereat sein 0) wring dy fom he det of th pobaged/aasetorzed sheaee Fettinner however, ld sheady Mth county 9825 Octer 196,204 see te comp nth the eigenen of the send feat eave (AHO. The peloged atecnce, az welliz he fhe 1 ei tad been apace by he nmedae cit ecu Sete, ptioerexed olde tse thatthe acon why sy pn he Oe of he ene = ese ‘mport to the than Deputy Commissioner Mandece {SOL65: parler by Ay Gornge, #5 ond Decor {a Ajo No nverogavon war underaten inet of ny capo le the meanwhile. the FAIBRS shee the matter shoul be brought ta th etonon ofthe Deputy Becutve Secretary of Malostong 20 ‘hot taken for te goad of heArarat thet the same wes done in god fh ond atfrony fen mative” Moleson of fies nit and eguoton wee te gounde foryourteminen fr lar of cofaree, ene en fe» tins wih payer nena {commeros' whit the Commasor dest. Repradest Commer eb sist the grat of pettbnet® applaton fr wacton ve ign rehire Vitor (SC tar, 8-251 ated 5 My BED 3nd Ihess of 4 offees or employes mest be contingent Fetinaes alenges Ns dima ae ting sity. Te propre of dct wth th Ofc ofthe Prestert, Bu the care poviled by nce "or ofconnce fe be scot fae tht thse bling pen conden (nken the ester he Py Since Gonmicen, oe doch’ that pectin tbe pomatiy onfientat or when the postin ghes thechaacter ofthe deter ‘actone aed so pny confident in ste portantbe were aptethydechred a “gh coer event nas tof inners Mo 7h dre Spent 1 by fumes Prsiden/Prine Minter creating the Bureae of ‘a vow he 8, the tency tfanne tow teed enacted siete A peter Be Shy pn Siesta oe moe ‘rl "to ey opors can razs Mamagemert ed Aude hale the FUIB seat ‘ep decciptos of tat poston one stk byte sea sed ny or by aleening actual opertons: mie MM eaysertorponacton, propecia the eat Gtlerd snd ee oleened) senhoercoues of Uffcaney or lock of economy, wederaer requied ist dnt oferntur oroncaton lune, deceres 2d pressure of ‘the wrganzaton foamy he Wovrandimpove effcineystdis and vcomments Imeeatr time Indra rf) aod prevertan of ‘Sonvol dees sew te compinion anh vod y atinpotore souiter fr toe of Emplce Sopa Gia'Sere det (RA. 230, He tenonveet the poste wich fal determiner whether + postion Fry cotdetl poty atemaig NG of coer ad must be, of eke woul thes be Tipetiee, by eect fot he otectnn facet ‘our Sopa" Weak imporaet a aote tat the concept Conrestve of pliany content” postions har bet mony gin "bythe Cour Thar inDe lor Sortr by the ourtaton Thee portnes vo the Helos dagiee ofeanfeace orb crcl bowedost rar torn ne, my tbe ppeetments coming under the category be female appointment imps confidence, bat much ordinary corfsecerpeces nthe erent of pasion tha primary confaonel The bier phase esate ot ony conisece nthe aptuae of the Sppenee or he cuts of eof bt pinay care a Sia oe pa os nye oa ‘penne Pessues fr the sey of suck offal Brae Gyvieosirte Dene Cy May bas tered to derguite 42 "pmriy confident” eg. renter af te Getome Poice Force or Rt Patt Spee atau the Governor of he Cenol Baa hogs of he ‘esopapier = the Ofee of the ee evieat ht the date of pttoner etd to he sted ud aa (ondunton wn the emrnenton co seabed ovnve the meget faak aad fagle stun of the porkon accep by petioner dencored bythe et tnt he iby stacked t uae to move tsa PiSooa0s nosth st the tne le went os ve eter 3800) There thes appe nothing to seggest ht petiners porte ar “MGA ot coe “prinmay conta! in wtee. The Sct tat pttioeer my, inte doc et sete chamceice he pote se pony secordingh, we bei iment aed Audit Seabee F peer wih, 32 sendy noted, was the thet W petioaer Ta wae aot gpl mera upon er of onience” on the prof the Fis Commaroner nr tev noeticer Iepleuce povided bye rhe denen ltom tbe sents? Erpyee of the Chilsence cop coe yb a5 guint of tot pacdeal sed sate doe jm fo petinner her be vty no denny at ‘octets guest hin for having submited 2 repre dec the Ofte of te Pret Mabeaaag. whieh aévenehy acta the \iheh Memorsedam wa tot rece by pttioer However et biconfer (Sed concep imped tat ofers may ot be ramos ot fe mere ‘ilo hace vcd wit the power of remvel or ihact our Morava the cure act atta or fc he Siminsteton ofthe offen, sed. mart be rested te someting ofa ntetonta nye dey affecting the pitond tro th pute Inthe acatcase we hive soe ens that petitoner ar chged wth er sad vegubtons consetig mote sect. of ‘ete ht pene was pot preciinte fete te apps er net lave war snot) appaved byte Fills evtnlOffe in Guezon Cy Vie met however leno 2couat ‘he cicameuace at he appictton for eave wthont pay bad beet pplatn fr leave wthont jay wat vely demanded by impetnas Fussy seteed any pede by weacon of he sowsasbiy of thocll te cals ogemest islet bambi Etpated oy many le fom the spyeating power the FH feat of demtzl frm the sents vat tedeh nek the cae of Depety Encatie Seca, Offs of te President Conceiing the thes RegbvalDiectarof Fl Reps fettinnes are ¥ coveted by the rele nny DeVore” Beapmin otigCvpnton (PHC) He sent» kg Peden ih Aye segert compkte rsamp PHIKC Bonn! tp (Comma) stow witagly teed nectige eames) ‘Aon sot gab ir quotas dueling sends derpae pple of bag sang (emma) shoul wt die tag themeler enesency pstnar omen) shor Cs tons on oe of secenty at (Compa) aad abou vepectehl sereGayssereer teow ‘The ramovlot Bord Secretary Gy tom the pinay heh hen en rene (2 There oof cous fr amoval The znaing of the turn of lonsoy 121859 to Parco Coat 2 corserperig scampi ramp ofhe Bad of stat the Deco were gnbbugaz qrots ducing Nand cerptesppcant of bagsmedng was onset of ‘Shea, The tga wor a prvieged communication premmebly mase good foth and erp of bang of neeny 121959 to the Priest ofthe Piipiaer Uasaeactofteacheryor deat the Brad Fert Ae pita ont the sending ofthe teagan the Prien ofthe Piippiee war acto ce duty The fepam war's pivieged commentston presamathy seat goed ft ot being ved by (premment comport vas derbed bythe Present "Ere Order Wo 389prmaiy confer! ‘tur with the abou intr thr te poston be led Ip on appaae of ureustones honesty ad neg ee thf arte Sy peng ‘Mecondect wasn conconance wih the honey ond near ques forthe portion Seruming tht Gay owed byahy tthe Band tat laylty wes in th ares of 00d gvernmar se etn the pucoal mrs ofthe Decors w te een of Wa the case at tar we note tat patter seat hs confetal ad ppesarably sak) veprt to 34 ofee having veal adminette Fipereon sed contol ve the PB the fe of te Present; ttecomphined of That repertvarspidegedcommansaton adhe itor therefenpyethe beneitof the pecempton sheeted god ‘ah Te spenders hve wot Tepe int petioes acted wth wolce infect Wie do not belive hat pttone's act conteved Gives by whch peitane euitned he yey te te FilBes on Ineeatondad ahinatey tthe Government of the Repbic oftheiments lnchvoges sepcentng the appptote pean fr ptones WHEREONE te Peto fs rsa ey GRANTED DUE COURSE ‘Niger's te fetoeoed flan lr 6B 503ed 88-77 of prc frit pondent E10 Carver av hechy ANKULLED sed SET ‘Shoe. Febtscrpntens ie beeby OHOENED to veneer AR, pee {067 ated September 2 083 of the GlSeniteCommarioe 3) (on Augest 1906, pttonr wae pit Cy Storey by th hes ‘he iajorotQeeon Cy under the Fredo mnConrthation of 1908 (iy 24,1992 the wetted myer mel Matha Je Mayor Mathay ered + kts‘ dated Jay 26 1892 pettiner, wed (11983, repent Vee yor Chin L Pane af Quezon City {ied compbint wth the CSC apt petbuer and» certain nce L dinette deipnay atin gut A Wesco © owever Sey Mr owl at be lied to ce holing the poston of the lege Offer (CR) Sore ofQveron Cy ' vas dei byte CSE Ginmeron herby reoher to deny the motes ‘or smcomerton of iy terete Mir Secodiaghy, CSAesalaton No, 93-4057 ded September 21, 3882 The Commas tereby orders the Carier of the eesen iy gavernment ie sop oyment of ses to ‘Sty tse oternae te mer sal be peony eae, the peti cy geoff ntcantentn band (SC ae no sutory to enoveat terminate the sence of ppeetmest wns as Pract 337 1337 imped epee she Confiertal sna of the portion when @expaded the datas of Cy Pi enabe the pvc 3nd cry freinents te ial theneches afte ful ine ond rotd sanicecat lg offee the portions of provi aera ed iy gfe may ected rere, the fuetnae ‘hithere.perbened by the frovacil aed cay fae in song 4 ge ove aed faloteer for chieaer of he pies aad ey sal be tasted w the povacal storey 3nd cl eer mepctieh.Emplaseuppled) ‘See 16. tpponiment, Quite, Compeartin wets nd Bete [t) The ey lel fies sal be ppd the cy mayor sabpet te cizerveeb (2 ts pee stall bea pote cy lester 6) The ey eg otcer sta cee rach coment owances 36 may be determined by (4 The ey eet otcer stall be the chia ladverat ‘ec sndallffer thereof sndsececheba (a Represent he cay in al cis cer Siesta he cy ay offer het Sheetitesocny £2 my: (When segsied, daft erdace(el Ghee opine i witng when weqtered by the mer or the (6) teertinte ot case be inverigated ayy offer fr neglect, (orate sud poset nthe c Ineertvben diced bythe myer + of i Pata B37 sono ti fey peter Wha doce, tt mes spect the tines a7 Prine Big 337 uae mic We bel st the portion of (Gay lags Offer ts fe conser nthe porns of pve atrney Sppointed bythe pvacalgevetvor both eng porns coi the Dy vite of Hepa to. S1, beth he prove torney and cy gale sere athe lel adv ed placer forthe etl cues of the pve sed fe ey hat they wor for Therzener sve precoey (ategorced by bu tobe tested zener ‘Seder by the ofeer woul meat rach tested ‘edey hie Ce oe ppoinent che Age 86stomatal expied wher tow Quer City Mayor Matay war ected Soticesedzuteeqeenthsctmed be postin ys apple powes o = 1) Te Commarea tatne depen {Gres vobing he import of pemy oteepearoe ‘Srmore ha they dys or fae nseamoueteceeding tecommendstn a2 the peasy to be impored ‘trey wade the Rdmineintne Cote te est enne fre cine tat he aot covered by Rep At, 7160, thence ows at Te acl Govemmert Cade of 881 whch expe {ater tnt the fem of the mpl ofc sta be covterminows wth he fee appointing ethoray. *Meaiuee tat the coteemioes pov pp et eateappintnen fe ltr touts ay leg Ofer contents i tajrtatay ely intended t peti th ener of pettus Cy Lees he cates ne ane by renga ial Ge eniered pet “anc Cy eens on dnw he ier aac tht Mayor thay sence cequest poof that he does sot tad pettioner continue the id WHEREFORE, he ron petition heey DISSED fo Falciano, Bin, Rageldo, Devise Je, Sle, Mel, Quiszon, Pane,le rito v Gul Sania Commizion (94 SCR SS, | zated in my pvc atoray nb sey ey tomes. Roar ckar thet # steed be the be Words, goveios and najorcovl gob te prvacalatorey 24d RY {orncy went ennie nes cee aficey, cabpet we toma ony fr ‘Guess proved by baud the chiene ler Ini eefetute, eves, ht the laa Government Gade of 1891 (ep. el. 7150 ie Se 81 mae the ports of gpl offen coserinoes winihatofthesppointngsetire. Th, amy opines, cera 31 ‘hedemenleatoe wih the male steer gvetomentempiyes sce appeutmest tthe poston of Rep ofcer aa tow be based of ot pevicalatrne sede sory Into v. Ci! Seice Commision 198 SCRA S50, | xated my thecayatieme| net pom content eter te pvc governor or mae Ciygovenmeat or wheh hese caveser storey fone govern sed mayan could ge bet the pvc otorney3ed cy Terain tes cect offer sabectt renwal oa Sivke The spol system’ enw ges fee eget ast te pon Fpviaca lore andy tere