Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Graduated Student
Kuo Hui Shun
August 2007
1980
Abstract
Since the initial stages of 1980s, the global world faced the huge shift. Many
security scholars try to challenge and review the mainstream security studies that
derived from a combination of Anglo-American, statist, militarized, masculinized,
methodologically positivist, and philosophically realist thinking. The Welsh School
of Critical Security Studies is one of the most important approach. The Welsh School
thinks about security as developing in the light of the Frankfurt School, and brings the
tradition of critical, epistemology position, and emancipation to the security
studies. The Welsh School separate the core of critical security studies(CSS) into
three concepts: security, emancipation, and community, therefore, this study try to
explain and review these concepts.
Firstly, CSS tried to deepen the concepts of security, deconstruct statism and
bring the referent to individual, and then broaden the agenda of security to discuss
the traditional and non-traditional issues in the globalization world. Secondly, CSS
emphasize the relationship of theory and practice, and expect to achieve their goalemancipatory politics. Via the construction of emancipatory community, people
could released from contingent and structural oppressions, and create a free and equal
environment.
Despite the states still the major referent in international institution and security
environment, and the main concept of The Welsh School still not practice in
contemporary politics, but the first task of CSS is to bring a revision of the world, and
then create a comprehensive and humanity security thinking.
II
Adn
2007.8
III
1
1
5
..14
..15
..16
..17
..18
..23
..29
..35
..36
..41
..47
..55
..56
..64
..73
..77
IV
..........78
..89
..94
..97
..97
101
105
(Security Studies)
(Booth,
1991: 314)
2001 911
2003
SARS
Buzan
(Smith, 2005: 32)
Buzan
Buzan Ken Booth
(Booth, 1997: 106)2
3 (comprehensive
(mainstream)(traditional)(orthodox)
3
Robert Keohane Joseph Nye (complex
interdependence)
2003203
security) 4
19985-8
199932
19987
Barry Buzan
5
20 90
Ken Booth
individual
Kenneth Boulding
(Booth, 1991: 315)
(Booth, 2005:10-12)
Robert W. Cox
(problem- solving theory)(critical theory)
Cox
(critical)
9
(Booth, 1991,
317)
(post-positivism)(post-naturalism)(Booth, 2005:
10-11)
(Frankfurt School)
Richard Wyn
Jones(1999) Security, Strategy, and Critical Theory
Ken Booth (Booth, 2005: 261)
Max Horkheimer
Horkheimer (immanent
critique)
200654-56
200138
Antonio Gramsci
200455 1
(critical)
(Booth, 2005:
259-260)
Buzan 1983
(Buzan, 1983:
30-34)
Immanuel Kant
Hedley Bull
(Booth, 1991: 319)
(deepening)
10
Booth (emancipation)
(Booth, 1991: 319)
10
(liberty)
10
Emancipation is the freeing of people (as individuals and groups) from those
physical and human constraints which stop them carrying out what they would freely choose to do.
War and the threat of war in one of those constraints, together with poverty, poor education, political
oppression and so on. Security and emancipation are two sides of the same coin. Emancipation, not
power or order, produces true security. Emancipation, theoretically, is security.
11
Booth
(Booth, 1991: 321-322)
Booth
Johan Eriksson
Eriksson
Eriksson
12
Michael William
Eriksson
(realistic)(Smith, 2005:
44) Andreas Behnke Eriksson
Ayoob
Ayoob
Ayoob
(Ayoob, 1997: 125-128)
Mohammed Ayoob Booth
Ayoob
(Smith, 2005: 45)
13
1994
(Booth, 1997: 108)
1997 Keith Krause Michael C. Williams Critical Security
Studies: Concepts and Cases
2005 Ken Booth Critical
Security Studies and World Politics
1998
199819-33 2001
200135-64
14
2004
Ken Booth
Richard Wyn Jones
15
16
(metatheoretical
assumptions) 1
(what it is not)
Ken
Booth Richard Wyn Jones
(Wyn
Jones, 1999: ix)
Ken Booth Richard Wyn Jones
(critical theory)
17
1923
(the Institute of Social Research) Carl Grnberg
(interdisciplinary
materialism)(Wyn Jones, 1999: 10-13)
(fascism)
Max Horkheimer 1934
1937 Horkheimer
(Traditional and Critical Theory)
Horkheimer Adorno
Horkheimer
(self-consciousness)
18
Horkheimer
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 14-16)
Horkheimer Adorno
Hebert Marcuse
20
Horkheimer Immanuel
Kant Kant
20058-9
200138
Horkheimer
19
200140-41
Horkheimer
Horkheimer
Horkheimer
Horkheimer
(Horkheimer,
1972: 188)
20
18-20) Horkheimer
(pre-Cartesian)
Horkheimer
(potentiality)(Horkheimer, 1972: 245)
Horkheimer
Thomas Kuhn (paradigm shifts)
20065455
21
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 21)Horkheimer
(Horkheimer,
1972: 200)
200656
Horkheimer Horkheimer
(individual human beings)
Horkheimer
22
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 23)
Horkheimer
Robert W. Cox
1981 Social Forces, States and World Order: Beyond International
Relations Theory. 1983 Gramsci, Hegemony and International
Relations: An Essay in Method.
Cox (Wyn
23
Cox
(Hegelian Marxism) Antonio
Gramsci Andrew
LinklaterMark Neufeld Mark Hoffmam
20057-9
Horkheimer Robert Cox
Cox
80
24
Horkheimer Cox
20059-11
Ken Booth
(the idea of the real)2
Heikki Patomaki Colin Wight
(realism)
25
(Booth, 2005: 10)
(objectivity)
(critical distance)
Horkheimer (immanent critique)
Horkheimer
3(statism)
26
(Wyn
Jones, 1999: 94-100)
4
(epistemological self-consciousness)
1980
Stephen M. Walt
Horkheimer
((Wyn Jones, 1999: 100-101)
Booth
Martin Shaw
27
(formation)(recognition)(expression)(disintegration)
(created)(negotiated)(ascribed)(denied)
Horkheimer
Horkheimer
Booth
Horkheimer (Wyn Jones, 1999:
115)
http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/: 2007/5
/2
28
Ken Booth Richard Wyn Jones
Antonio Gramsci 6
Keith Krause
(Krause, 1998: 298)
1994 1997
Keith Krause Michael C. Williams
Critical Security Studies: Concepts and Cases
29
200455 2
Steve Smith
Keith Krause Michael Williams
(broadening)(deepening)
1997 Krause Williams Cox
Krause Williams
Critical Security
Studies: Concepts and Cases
(Krause and
Williams, 1997: viii)
30
Booth
8
Keith Krause
Michael Williams
Krause
8
(worldwide)
(universal culture norm)(Booth, 1997: 110)
31
(Krause, 1998: 299) Critical Security Studies: Concepts and
Cases Booth
R. B. J. Walkersubaltern Mohammed Ayoob
Simon Dalby Beverly Crawford Ronnie
D. Lipschutz Karin M. Fierke (Krause and
Williams, 1997: xvi-xix) Krause Williams
Ken Booth
Booth
(cosmopolitan)
(epistemologically self-conscious)(Booth, 1997:
109)Booth
32
(universal solidarities)
Richard A. Wilson
(securitization studies)
33
Booth
(common
humanity) Krause Booth
34
20
35
Edward Luttwak
(Booth,
1991:317-319)
Ken Booth
(Booth, 1991: 314)
36
(the absence of
threats)
(being safe)(feeling safe)
3
4 Robert Cox
(security is essentially a
derivative concept) (Booth, 2005:
13)
(Booth,
2005: 21)
4
W. B. Gallie
(Smith, 2005:
29)
37
(Booth, 2005: 21)
(survival)
38
(Booth,
2005: 14)
39
(securitizing)(politicizing) (Booth, 2005:
14)
Booth
(Copenhagen School)
Buzan
(Booth, 2005: 14-15)
40
(security studies)
(strategic studies)(national security studies) 20
90
Richard Wyn Jones
(oversimplification)
Max Horkheimer
Richard Wyn Jones Horkheimer
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 94)
41
(statism)
(Wyn
Jones, 1999: 95)
/
(inside/outside dichotomy)
42
Richard Ned
Lebow
Christian Reus-Smit
Reus-Smit
19
10
43
11
Hobbes
J. Ann Tickner
11
44
(Tickner, 1995: 180-181)
Buzan
45
Horkheimer
Booth Immanuel Kant
Hedley Bull
12
Barry Buzan
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 113)
13
1983 People, State and Fear Buzan (state-centrism)
1991 Security: A New Framework for Analysis
Buzan (a narrow selfclosing definitional move)(Wyn Jones, 1999: 113)
46
14
(Krause and Williams, 1997: 45-46)
2004: 57
14
47
International SecuritySean M.
Lynn-Jones Steven E. Miller
16
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 105)
17
15
48
(Booth, 1997: 335-336)
(Booth,
2005: 15)
18
18
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 108-112)
49
(Southern Africa
Development Community)
(South Africa)(Botswana)
911 20042005
2006: 4
50
(military forces)
51
(Cheeseman, 2005:
64)
(new wars)(uncivil
wars)(wars of the third kind)
52
(Cheeseman, 2005: 74-75)
2001
911
911
911
Graeme Cheeseman
Clausewitz
(Cheeseman, 2005: 64)
53
Booth
Booth
54
Ken
Booth Peter Vale
20 90
(apartheid)
(Booth and
Vale, 1997: 329-330)
(emancipation)1
Booth 1991 Security and Emancipation
Booth
55
(false necessity)23
(emancipation)
80 90
2
56
20
1960 1970
subaltern
Booth
(Booth, 2005: 181)
Booth
(Booth, 1997: 113)
57
CSS (emancipation-oriented)
CSS
(Wyn
Jones, 2005: 215)
Marx Horkheimer
Horkheimer
Horkheimer
Horkheimer
1947 Theodor Adorno Dialectic of Enlightenment
Horkheimer Adorno
58
Adorno Horkheimer
Adorno Horkheimer
(repetition) (predictability)
(calculability)(Wyn Jones, 2005: 220-223)
Jrgen Habermas
5
Habermas
Habermas
Horkheimer
59
Booth
(Booth, 2005: 181)
6
Booth
(a philosophical anchorage)
(a strategic
process)
60
(Westernization)
911
(Al-Qaida)
61
Saudi
Arabia911
(Holocaust) 19 20
(Booth, 2005: 264)
(Wyn
Jones, 1999: 120-121)7
/ Michel Foucault
62
(Wyn
Jones, 2005: 217)
8
Wver
Wver
8
63
64
(Booth, 1997:
109)
360
21 (political
community)(Booth, 1997: 109)
(community)
(sociality)
Booth
Vale
65
(Linklater, 2005:
116-117)
Andrew Linklater
66
(Linklater, 2005:113-114)
Immanuel Kant
(billiard-ball
model)
9
Kant
(Linklater, 2005: 119)
Kant
Kant
9
67
(Linklater,
2005: 119)
(publicity)(dialogue)(consent)
(Linklater, 2005: 120)
Kant
19
10
10
Booth
68
(Linklater, 2005: 120)
(social arrangement)
Jrgen Habermas
Ken Booth
Peter Vale
1991 Ken Booth
1945 44
69
(security communities)
Booth
(Booth and
Vale, 1997: 338-339)
Booth (emancipatory community)(Booth,
2005: 109)
11
11
70
Booth Vale
12
Deutsch
Deutsch
12
Booth Vale
71
(Booth and Vale, 1997: 339)
(Pretoria)(Moscow)
ANC
(Non-Proliferation Treaty,
NPT) Nelson Mandela
72
(Southern African
Development Coordination Conference SADCC)
(Preferential Trade Agreement of East and Southern Africa PTA)
73
Booth
74
(revision)
75
76
Walter Lippmann
(Ayoob, 1997: 124)
1
Lippmann
Arnold Wolfers
(external)(outward)
(Ayoob,
1997: 124)
20 80
77
Ken
Booth
78
(broadening)
(Ayoob, 1997:
121)
Patrick Morgan
79
3
Morgan
Walt
(Walt, 1991: 212)
Walt
(statecraft)
Walt
Security has long been about the survival and physical safety of the actors and
their people; by extension it concerns the deliberate use of force by states (and some other actors) for
various purposes. Broadening security studies to cover other harmseconomic, environmental and
so forthis unfortunate for it lumps together deliberate, organized physical harm (or threats thereof )
with other threats and pains.
80
Mohammed Ayoob
Stephen Walt
(intellectual coherence) Ken Booth
Eric Herring Walt
Walt
Pristina
Belfasat
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 106)
81
Booth Herring
(irrelevance)
(ignorance)
Theodor W. Adorno
(all reification is a forgetting)
(broadened)(restricted) Krause
Williams
(Krause and Williams, 1996: 249)4
82
(hyphenating security)
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 106)
6
Daniel Deudney
83
Mathew
(Darfur)
1956
2003 (Darfur)
(Janjaweed)
2005
84
2007 6
2007
R. B. J. Walker
7
Walker
In the end it has never been possible to pin security down to concrete practices
or institutions with any great precision, no matter how insistent the voices of military and defence
establishment might be. The whole point of concepts of security that are tied to the claims of state
sovereignty is that they must expand to encompass everything within the state, at least in its everpotential state of emergency.
85
(citizenship)
(Wyn
Jones, 1999: 112)
86
R. B. J. Walker
(cooperative or common or world security)
(universal)(particular) Walker
Walker
Walker
(Wyn Jones, 1999: 113)
87
(Bosnia)
(Rwanda)
1990 NATO
88
(Smith, 2005:
57)
(political
implications)(Eriksson, 1999:
311-312)
89
Ken Booth
(Booth, 1997: 106)
8
(Eriksson, 1999: 318319)
Johan Eriksson
Eriksson
90
(Eriksson, 1999: 320-321)
Mohammed Ayoob subaltern
subaltern
(Ayoob, 1997: 121-124 ) Ayoob
(ethnocentrism)
(Linklater, 2005: 122-123)
(Williams, 1999:
342)
91
Michael C. Williams
10
George F. Kennan
11
(Linklater, 2005: 121-122)
10
92
subaltern
(Linklater, 2005:
123)
93
subaltern
Mohammed Ayoob (1997) Defining Security: A Subaltern Realist
Perspective
Booth
(Ayoob, 1997: 126)
Ayoob Booth
Booth
Ayoob
1975-1990 (Damascus)
Assad (Beirut)
94
Ayoob
(Ayoob,
1997: 127)
Ayoob
(ethnicity)
1947
(Ayoob, 1997:
127-128)
95
(Linklater, 2005: 121)
Booth
(Ayoob, 1997: 128)
subaltern
96
(false necessities)
(Booth, 1997: 106)
97
Max Horkheimer
Horkheimer
(Booth, 2005: 262-264)
Kant
Antonio Gramsci(Booth, 2005: 261)
98
(regressive theories)3
(denaturalize)
(historicize)
(Booth, 2005: 7)
99
(Booth, 2005:
269)
Ken Booth
100
Simon Dalby
(discipline)
(military-industrial-academic complex)
Booth
5 Antonio Gramsci
4
(Booth,
1997: 115)
101
Gramsci
(traditional intellectuals)(organic
intellectuals)
Edward Said
2003
George W.
Bush Tony Blair
(Booth,
2005: 274)
102
Kenneth Boulding
(Booth, 1991: 315)
103
104
1998 4 5-14
2006 2005
http://theory.people.com.cn/BIG5/40764/63787/63791/4388461.html#
2007/5/8
2005
7 71-77
2003
2006 7 54-56
1998 37 8
19-33
2001
2 1 35-65
2003 4
3 1-14
2005
7 7-14
http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007/5/2
2007
http://news.yam.com/afp/life/200706/20070617394773.html
2007/07/02
1999
38 2 21-36
2004
6 55-61
105
2001
1 38-43
2005
http://www.africa-taiwan.org/fast_tw/perspectives/detail.php?o_id=8
2007/07/02
Alker, Hayward. 2005. Emancipation in the Critical Security Studies Project, in
Ken Booth, ed., Critical Security Studies and World Politics. 189-213.
Ayoob , Mohammed. 1997. Defining Security: A Subaltern Realist Perspective, in
Keith Krause and Michael C. Williams, eds., Critical Security Studies: Concepts and
Cases.121-146.
Behnke, Andreas. 2000. The Massage of the Messenger? Reflection on the Role of
Security Experts and the Securitization of Political Issues, Cooperation and Conflict.
Vol. 35, No. 1, 89-105.
Booth, Ken. 1991. Security and Emancipation, Review of International Studies. Vol.
17, No.2, 313-326.
Booth, Ken. 1997. Security and Self: Reflections of a Fallen Realist, in Keith
Krause and Michael C. Williams, eds., Critical Security Studies: Concepts and Cases.
83-119.
Booth, Ken. 2005. Critical Explorations, in Ken Booth, ed., Critical Security
Studies and World Politics.1-18.
Booth, Ken. 2005. Introduction to Part 1, in Ken Booth, ed., Critical Security
Studies and World Politics.21-25.
Booth, Ken. 2005. Part 2: Community, in Ken Booth, ed., Critical Security Studies
and World Politics. 109-112.
Booth, Ken. 2005. Part 3: Emancipation, in Ken Booth, ed., Critical Security
Studies and World Politics. 181-187.
Booth, Ken. 2005. Beyond Critical Security Studies, in Ken Booth, ed., Critical
Security Studies and World Politics. 259-278.
106
Booth, Ken. et al eds. 2005. Critical Security Studies and World Politics. Boulder:
Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Booth, Ken. and Peter Vale. 1997. Critical Security Studies and Regional Insecurity:
The Case of Southern Africa, in Krause and Williams, eds. Critical Security Studies:
Concepts and Cases. 329-358.
Booth, Ken. and Steve Smith, eds., 1995. International Relations Theory Today.
Cambridge: Polity.
Bottomore, Tom. 1984. The Frankfurt School.
Buzan, Barry. 1983. People, states, and fear: The National Security Problem in
International Relations. New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
Buzan, Barry. 1991. People, states, and fear: An Agenda for International Security
Studies in the Post-Cold War Era. 2nd ed. Boulder: Lynne Rienner.
Buzan, Barry. Ole Wver and Jaap de Wilde. 1998. Security: A New Framework for
Analysis. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Cheeseman, Graeme. 2005. Military Force(s) and In/security, in Ken Booth, ed.,
Critical Security Studies and World Politics. 63-87.
Cox, Robert. 1981. Social Forces, States and World Order: Beyond International
Relations Theory, Millennium: Journal of International studies. Vol. 10, No. 2, 126155.
Cox, Robert. 1983. Gramsci, Hegemony and International Relations, Millennium:
Journal of International studies. Vol. 12, No. 2, 162-175.
Cox, Robert. 2002.
Keohane, Robert 187-231
Croft, Stuart. and Terry Terriff, eds. 2000. Critical Reflection on Security and Change.
London: Frank Cass.
Deudney, Daniel. 2000. The Case against Linking Environment Degradation and
Nation Security, Millennium: Journal of International Studies. Vol. 19, No. 3. 461476.
107
Krause, Keith. 1998. Critical Theory and Security Studies: The Research Programme
of Critical Security Studies, Cooperation and Conflict. Vol. 33, No.3, 298-333.
Krause, Keith. and Michael C. Williams. 1996. Broadening the Agenda of Security
Studies: Politics and Methods, Mershon International Studies Review. Vol. 40, No. 2,
229-254.
Krause, Keith. and Michael C. Williams. 1997. From Strategy to Security:
Foundations of Critical Security Studies, in Krause and Williams, eds. Critical
Security Studies: Concepts and Cases. 33-59.
Krause, Keith. and Michael C. Williams, eds. 1997. Critical Security Studies:
Concepts and Cases. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Linklater, Andrew. 2005. Political Community and Human Security, in Ken Booth,
ed., Critical Security Studies and World Politics. 113-131.
Morgan, Patrick. 2000. Liberalist and Realist Security Studies at 2000: Two Decades
of Progress? in Stuart Croft and Terry Terriff, eds., Critical Reflection on Security
and Change. 39-71.
Patomaki, Heikki. and Colin Wigh. 2000. After Postpositivism? The Promises of
Critical Realism, International Studies Quarterly. Vol. 44, No.2, 213-237.
Reus-Smit, Christian. 1992. Realist and Resistance Utopias: Community, Security
and Political Action in the New Europe, Millennium: Journal of International
Studies. Vol. 24. No.1. 53-85.
Smith, Steve. 1996. Positivism and Beyond, in Steve Smith, eds., International
Theory: Positivism and Beyond. 11-44.
108
Smith, Steve. 2005. The Contested Concept of Security, in Ken Booth, ed., Critical
Security Studies and World Politics. 27-62.
Smith, Steve. Ken Booth, and Marysia Zalewski. 1996. International Theory:
Positivism and Beyond. UK: Cambridge University Press.
Terriff, Terry. Stuart Croft, Lucy James and Patrick M. Morgan. 1999. Security
Studies Today. Cambridge: Polity.
Tickner, J. Ann. 1995. Re-visioning Security, in Ken Booth and Steve Smith, eds.,
International Relations Theory Today. 175-197.
Walt, Stephen. 1991. The Renaissance of Security Studies, International Studies
Quarterly. Vol. 35, 211-239.
Walker, R. B. J. 1990. Security, Sovereignty, and the Challenge of World Politics,
Alternatives. Vol.15, No.1, 3-27.
Walker, R. B. J. 1997. The Subject of Security, in Keith Krause and Michael C.
Williams, eds., Critical Security Studies: Concepts and Cases. 61-81.
Williams, Michael. 1999. The Practices of Security: Critical Contribution,
Cooperation and Conflict. Vol. 34, 341-344.
Wyn Jones, Richard. 1999. Security, strategy, and critical theory. Boulder: Lynne
Rienner Publishers.
Wyn Jones, Richard. 2005. On Emancipation: Necessity, Capacity, and Concrete
Utopias, in Ken Booth, ed., Critical Security Studies and World Politics. 215-235.
109