Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Issue: Whether or not Laureano had the right to prove the parol agreement existing between the 2? YES in this case, what was involved does not involve the law relating to the introduction of parol evidence for the purpose of changing or modifying the terms of a written instrument and that it doesnt fall within the prohibitive provisions of sec. 285 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The evidence was not offered for the purpose of varying the terms of the conveyance between the 2, but to show a contemporaneous collateral agreement where it is stated that the conveyance could be defeated and terminated. Oral evidence is admissible to show that a conveyance absolute in form was in fact a mortgage. the right to establish by parol evidence the defeasible character of an absolute written conveyance is too well fixed in our jurisprudence to be questioned ( Reeves v. Abercrombie) extraneous evidence is admissible to inform the court of every material fact known to the parties when the deed and memorandum were executed (Russell v. Southard) the true consideraton of a deed may be proved by parol evidence, and that a deed absolute on its face may be shown to have been executed in fact as a security. The right is a substantial one, not to be varied or defeated by any form of expression or character of recitals in the instrument.
Parol evidence is admissible in equity to show that a deed of conveyance was in fact a mortgage. The court looks beyong the instrument and looks at the real transaction, any evidence whether written or oral, tending to show this is admisisble. This does not violate of the rule which precludes such admission for the purspose of changing or contradicting the terms of the agreement. In this case the parol evidence was offerred to reinforce the claim that there was an agreement to reconvey. If the transfer was without consideration, it would lend more color to the contention of Laureano that there was an agreement to reconvey. Held: appealed decision REVERSED. Remanded for further proceedings.