SUNNI SCHOLARS TOOK HADITH FROM SHIMR

BIN ZUL JOSHAN (L.A) IN THEIR HADITH

BOOKS
Amed Ibn e Hanbal and Ibn Dawood narrated from Shimr ibn Dhi al-jawshan (indirectly as i
will explain) and his father Dhu al-jawshan is sahabi

The hadith dont mention Shimr but the scholars of ahlsunnah admit that the medium between
Abu ishaq (one of the narrators of the hadiths ) and Dhu al-jawshan is the son of dhu al-
jawshan : Shimr Lanatollah alih

Here is the 3 hadiths from Musnad Ahmed : Musnad Al-kufyeen :

   ‫  أ‬،  ‫      أ  إق اا‬،   ‫ !م‬

‫ ر‬#‫ أه‬% ‫ * أن ('غ‬+,‫ و‬, .‫ ا‬,/ 0‫ ا‬12‫ أ‬: ‫ل‬5، 67‫ ذي ا‬

2)    : :5 ، %  +;‫< وا‬06  ‫  أ  ;'  أ‬.‫ا‬0 
+,‫ و‬, .‫ ا‬,/ 0‫  ا‬67‫    أ     ذي ا‬... .

3) '6  ‫ أ‬67‫ا‬ ‫ل  =ن  أ  اق  ذي‬5 ‫د‬0  % 
 0?‫ا‬
As for Abu Dawood he narrated in his sunan :

67‫  أ  إق  ذي ا‬،  ‫'  أ‬0‫ أ‬،      ‫د‬% 
+,‫ و‬, .‫ ا‬,/ 0‫ ا‬12‫ أ‬: ‫ل‬5 ‫ب‬
ِ 0ّ?‫ ا‬% #‫ر‬
but the interesting thing is what bukhari said :

‫ وآن‬،  0?‫' ا‬6  ‫ أ‬67‫د  =ن  أ  إق  ذي ا‬0  % ‫ل‬5
67‫ ا  ذي ا‬% * :‫ أرا إ‬:‫  اق و‬D ‫ا  رًا‬
Narrated Muhammed Ibn Abbad Narrated Sufyan from Abu Ishaq from Dhi al-jawshan the
father of shimr al-dhababi and his son( he means shimr was a neighbour of abu ishaq
and i believe he narrated from the son of dhi al-jawshan( meaning shimr )

Sufian also said that Abu ishaq didnt narrate directly from Dhu al-jawshan but from his
son Shimr and i dont think such information was not known by ahmed ibn hanbal and
abu dawood

So congratulation to Ahmed and Abu Dawood for narrating from this ugly creature