You are on page 1of 10

Event Perception in Agent Mediated Computer Suported

Cooperative Work
Yiming Ye and Stephen Boies
IBM T.J. Watson Research Center
P.O. Box 704, Yorktown Heights, NY 10598, USA

ABSTRACT

  



!"$#%#'&( )*&(

+,

-/.0%#%#" )1
1$2"1+&*345&(,, #%(&(
671$8
#
(29+:,
-;&$
<=++>
 (&(@?BA= C,D&$,)C.0
,
 >&(&$* 
E2F5GH- 1IB< '&(<J9KJ0L +
&(<;< )M>,)4'&#9*)&(*&$?B,)( C>D&$
&>4D&N#%#
-$
-B(&(41/GH- 9IB< '&$<=JOK
J0P 8
QH*&$R(2S 0,D,
7 <9.0 T&5U 
.QR
-B 
+ ?=C,
,D7&$=4-,D&$T&$,
,V&$*
,)2W+X /,D,
@?Y=;&N#,,)Z&+
 <
.9 4>
[&(C*- 8\,  *&$+C<9,)2W+] ^*&$RH.O


1 
+C )O(2_<O9 
-?_=1, 94`
,)+ *&N#Q48
 #5:%2W71+
 <?

1.
a9
.0INTRODUCTION
#<.0<
/D&$
*&N#9(29 <)&)U C+E&$R1)&(62W<+E&$ 

+,D&$ /=<
48\ *&N#%*M- &( (&(D&N#:?

  



!"$#%#'&( )*&(
+,

-b,
+>B )+=$2> /
.c )U 
1&(,, #%(&()?9d[, #1.0%#%#^ )H+e&$
<M+:O $#</
J0+,
7K ,
,)<]Jf ,)*&(B=RhgJ9KJ0ji> )(&(
(21
/,

/2W+k+,)&( /B+,(B4:, <
8
<
4#,
+ =&(<j<
4l+&$R
-, B&(<j )(&$
(2

1  


- 1 5 2W+&$
,)8\ - .9&?
a9
>&$52F
O+: <9,D&N#%< 7J9KJ0PN&$*

$.m,), #7.0Rn%opNq\?7K  
*+ <
42W>/

D&$)&(>&$: 
>&$1
C*&(++&(<=

*&(+>, #'&(r@<  
< 
4


1+ <
C*2W9
C8
D&$D&$1&( >&(5
*&$+:C+: 
>&$H< %s@8
 1, #'&(r9&( *


+ <
M*2W1/
)&(D&$
&(= 
B&(M< %s@ B+Mj
B*&$+:, #'&$r&(<
< 
<h&( *:+ <:42W1
)&(D&$
&(> 
H&$9< %st 1+H&(<B, #'&$?
a9
*&$R]$2E B,D,
l=b+,D*&$ ;.fu48
,D7TJOK
J0v< 

<b 
4


+ <
?=I=&$ 
+,
w +:[,
,)_+> #*&(0 *&( 1+

D&$/H?wxH(.00+Q$2[
+m,
,)H+C #
O 8
*&(b]&.9&)&(,   ,)*&(j8
-$
(&(4

%#%#j)&(C
>C
 #
/


M +/?/a[7,
,)&$
<
*&$- ,)*&(@9 , 8
*&(:&$,
, #%(&(
C+>
5&#%#(.l5 )>&.9&(1$2">&(48
7$2H
?=a97,
,)7$26&/ ,)*&$B+> #
 2\&(B/*&( #%u&$
<j+& *&Nu&+:+j 4`

&N#%#(.0
-j=&(=/ T&$ 4'&(<y.0j=
 )>4z)<==
5
U@?1{D5*`D&$+, #[|^

K
&$++:n~}NoNq07&/2\&$+C%#(25N&N#%8\+B(#%#'&$ )*&$ ], < 8

9.O */,
$<
9*&( 5&.9&(
)++> (&$!^&(<
<
 +: )&(-N&$,D&$ %#%e 
-$
-z)4`  %#%'j&(<
4*M(2^(&N#%8\+1++> (&$1
5

H.0#<@?
a9H
>$2K&(++1H&N.f&$
?_=&.9&(
$2_$.QR@,)&(^9
+:1 #%S
5N&$B+C8
+> (&$0&9&$\C(2).9& ?[xH(.0 &9< w4zD$2
&N#%#">&(1B
9UD5
H&$,
,
 &$*D&$ #?
a99)Q(&$E9D&$wQ.9&$Q++>
 (&(B D&$
<.0<

,)4'&N#%#=.9B
e&$52\&(5&(,)&(1&(<7:&$+ H$2_<D&$*&
1 )H*&$
+C<@
*/&(w<
<D&$*& D&$9 -?_a99<
(&(wD&$_+&( C
_+&C
[#%RH9D&$7)&(w 
>
&(7&$
 &(<(&(<bT&N#%#H

++C )
$2fN&$+/?:aO
 <(&(>)&(1(&$*=11 8
*&$<M 9QQ$.9.0R&$
<< 9
0D&HH-
&$
<=+&$/+ 1B+:$+ >$2Q
1
?
a9 )01N&N#[2W5J9K
J0 2\&$>7&$D&N# E&$
$2Q&>-$B@<
f+:,)*&( 1 9 <@^&$
<B #
4zD[
*&(C [H
[?w_ [,),
.0%#%#
)H+0+,)*&( 9J9K
Jf79,)&(>+:,
8

-C.0#<!
.9
99<
+CD&$
1$2t9*&$< D&N#"d0Jh&$_
,
+&$+,

-O_, #'&(<7 &O#'&(-9$#%#
$2_<
1.f7+> )<
<<=+,

-?9a95 4#%#%-  S 8

<C<
_.0%#%#
)0(&(+C##>+> )<
<<>.0 :

$E)
*&$ #B
-T&$
</(&(
-M:> 
+ ?
a99 2F+&(=,(<
<B 
1,)&$C<
5.0 
&$B(> 
+ 1.0%#%#Q )>+,)*&( 5=J9KJ0L&$, 8
, #%(&$?
A_0
0 )4#%*20D&$9&(+
1&(- f&$5(2[-(&$0&#1
&>JOK
J0X +&(<T&5*&B&$+:
 0$2^2W
9(&(47
J9KJ0X.0%#%#^ )5 <+C #%8&$- 5&(,)Q$2^-, .9&(?
A *#%#%- &(- 1N&$=
<*&$R:,
 (&(<, >
)D&N#%2>(21
/
?G+> #'&(- T&$,
,V&$*b;JOK
J0N&$
(&(,

<
 )&(+C=$2:&(&(+.0Rj&(<]j48\)&(,)
2W+&(<h4D&$*&(?a9
B&(+&$y

- 7 
J9KJ0&$- w.0%#%#D<*&(+&$(&#%#<
_*& ,D[$2)2F48
D&N#t[<

-1(&(+l.0R)?"{)
+ 
w 4#%#%-
$2Q&+> #'&(- >J9K
J0 +.0%#%#_ ):&$ #CR,B
1,%8

(/(S5
H$
B
1
/(_($*/
 O ([0)
j BD$D10B0%%: B= $* (
(( H '$ZO
0 NN%H H0

(


MB
*N%^5 9)
B

$F9(/( E$ WkQB  *$)
DO
)>9(W9(7$ $ f
%@ 1%%>$
/
$0
>0 ;5'$5C
/(
( (N\Q$*$ 56

)
 M(

ENE$ %M0(9*$>0 )*(50
9$ 
)W))_H$DNQ*$)99
1;$
V$*

 *$y

\W=$ B *(=f

(C
*9$H
E \$=~NN\B9NNH)$ 

:$>(u$ 1($B

*(=
C

1(=VN5(

9
(j( _ 7)DD$
($  )D
5((/)>)4B 71
9'5 \$
9
5 10

(
 (4:M> D$b$f()(
\0H$
V$*wSHw
(9S
0(4 
9$

_$
: '(j9
0 k1
/H >0

 /9

 [$_
1 YH)*> e$ 4'(B0B

=(j44u(

=)4y WE$u
C
1$fN$/:O
5 10

 c($;)
(
=7$ =90 D$

C
(_0

/
  ;$
=$H>*$>B

$;$H($*
 >($DM
B
(

ENH/(1
( 7($h(
)
h=C59( O: *(H$

5
H$)eC*


4;$H$
=

(%_H4

%


1
)% *$9 1( QOH$ 5
/
'$:f

7$ C(9

>:$
4%Q ()


%
(h ;9

74
7
'$j 
(B
4
HOD$9


2.

ARCHITECTURE OF AGENT BUDDY

agent

agent

agent

agent

w W)[()B@)>*WW*(F
H90 @S0D 
H$ 1H >0

:/:
*$)1 kD$

D$ /
)(C9
0 :  >D$ (0

()
) 
(  7$H70


!Q9 0
(0CN$)5
> 1w *(

0_)
 C
9(
Q$ 0$^
9
@w9

 0CBE$79
fvN$(;4* CWCC
D1$Q>0B 
!>S

$91
C0 
(=$ 19>5 \(CB
E1)
 W5
* 
M

9Wm1
H$
/

OWY$H

channel to other agents

Negotiation
Module
Knowledge Base (Calender etc.)
Plan
generation

Event Perception
User Interface Module

channels to user

wWD[$=@B@)>*WW4(
59Q @SQ) 
>N) WCDW> 'N;)Q

7$
b
B$ 9
4h$
4%hB
'$j4
 MB
/
9
/_ [
bB
=$DN 


OW$
1
Hf =C
 50 
 f$
M
w _991
$0
1f$5B
1
*N
9H (0
>$^
>$ 0
5
H$
M
1@
9O
(05*
>$
)$ : 94

Q$^9


4W
>$Q
_$

4'()*(M(9 %
W C
:CD_/9
M['$h5
*(b:  
*(>$= '(5W9>1 /C  
B
C


H= (0
F1(0
9(H= 

; Bw C[


B
0(; >$
$ 1$Q
1
1
4% B>5'(B

99H'$7
901)W>
((

$
B
'$; '
>0=$ 5$Q
9
95B
$@97C
1*(H)\0 ) 
$ @(B

75F$%(0
@05
):)4'[W($
9$"
9 /
0 (4H [0

N$)41 _0)w
0
_O [09:)*( wW((9$^_ 
/_=50%%[ 
5 fF($
5/
*N%^MW(%(f


995 \(0B
eN%(90> %\
4^

9
C

CN$CW %@ 
>*
$H1 ) (!@
1
/((* )
1*$
(NQ
 \(D$
$0
0$@
9$0 

991

14D$
*1f%%_DC=1*9

)$

/)eC(%
B '( 1
'$9
/:
1
11(

W*()\0 %@ 
$H
/@
[ 

)_f$\C(@'(7$:

$ 09
5VN^O>*$
W'(;$
$
O 
'$(:$7$ 
9 >0%%9((

W*$$fM
0
$
N$B4*=5DN%Q
0B (

 
$B(

XHBb
%
$7$:
B($
CFk/j)(6>*$
@
 ])(u u D$
 =  )) O W$>  Zh( 
 W(]
 
b
B*$ !#
"$
j 
:%
& '  wD$ D%()
 )( ) W[((
w
 B($(  B_ H)(B(7(
((  ]( *F
>>
: 'j
W*$
%( 
$+ D$4 D$ _
- ,+ . F
D %/ CN$>(( 
($> 1 04
 / [
11 320 )- "$
=4  2

CD$5 )1) _( 1N$='(B$
$
E$(
 6W1
7 ,+ 1($=
*$(( 

+ W*$
w( 820 )) 9:1)(  9 
%
19
5 [
5 ;D(< 
= "$
7
5
00 :



T/
> 20 ( :? ,@
($
<   B$ A e$ 9 *(9 :$ 9% _
1

$
b
'$;:B
,+ 8 D$ h$

W
4
'$B

 C W( :($
)/<   ; )((
1 = D$  
 WE$;C : )
@
4
95

5 ;D$<
 C7 (N _ 
%
E DD5 ;D$C

'
HF 2f$ E% =G 1

N 1G /(
$C O1
> 1
 
'$8 W: k<   >  =1 
 8(T$
%
/
MN W> " )(<
MN$/:
*$
 W+ OH  HE 1( ) I91$ 9 /
*$1
( 1 + >()(8 ,+

>$ > 
*$1 7 ) 5  (
C
(
$ J *(K
L5/
 
B D$M7 > D;
1

 *(>
D$B > 1% Q : )
 
=(G )(  
G 
% 2=
' !: 2f [ W

 J 9( f% )9


5
4@+ ,+9
 J 9$ 9 

F
1H 1
1( W
M5N 1 
N$N$7/
M H( >20 (Z$
 :*$:<
H  $H $
EN *N
4

 B% f($ 
C ,[/($
% Q1 >2Q O
($ >$ - D$_$1  \(0H   ' C _$ *'$
20  >
P_ ( 4'$B
2f hB($
)<
2+
 1 
1Q R -
2SF     

0/  
>
+ )V$R O2+D$) *$m 9

/
 
1 <2+

/

/7 *N 

 
<
%
29
 7\ Ow+ 20 
7 :H T4 
2+
_ Q_w +(e$
<
2+7
0w* 
1 &2+
> :1C )1 _*(1<   
 L
2+
1
C
7
D$: Q$
G 2+
1

S

[= N% 7 )N$
= [[
S 04 "$[ L 
I5
20 ^$;$ O1
>
  
'  0 5 

9Q ,+
>$> 20:($: ,+QD1(B

[< )*$ 9((0 D$0


1( _C
0>
N$7 20 7$ O [ 9
U W0
7)CB
$S [
C 5
f$ - 95 [% D

U 20 ^4: 2+
0
9*$
0% !$ w((8 )
$> = 7( ;$  N   > )(C

 

7 $H MN$8 )1(!) D)0  Vt H$ 


T$  [
' 20 + ):  0
A WC '$  '9$
[($
Q$_$
  L 
0

 0 @

@ 2+
B
>$7 ) ' Q
 7

= ,+

N$=1 )((( > 



1  
' h 
 H O
[ Q+ )($
50O
D  B
0
4
*$ ;$
< )
=B   ' b  > 20 h
 5!) 9H( 0>
S  %   X M 0 
C   ' 3WO
1@ D )H% SH
M>YQZ3[ 1
= :*$>$T$ 
@
*$B(
b  V@ =< )
 B (l(  >(

*(9*$
W\F0>+P_ ^][
 Z   Q$B(  Y:Z3[ 1>D$ 1 _ 
W *(D$`
_5
* % a Z $  (  [ $
D$bb W(_ Z3[
:
 29
 ' )/($
4 29$  ( 6'(
D$ )
9$ O &2@  M)
1 )4 )> 1 %(

15
YQZ3[ WO:*$( \(4 %*$1 > %

 H% _BD$* *(
Q ($ 
B


'( 7$
 D$
% @D$* YQZ3[  
% D9*$

$7(
'$B

 C T$ C %
$
c+W(cd"v 
 5
eH
*$/ :=$
$ M
B
2f YQZ3[ wC
 jN$< W
>( H

*$
B ;D(  2+D$9 1D$*N$

$
<
%2_ '$wH
U  9 @)(*O[  ($(
 
218 ,+:*$5> 1  


C f5  N 'T4 Z
 hgf NQZGi \E 9H - j0

1 
j Z
f NQZ
D$7
!^9@
,+UF%
 205_0<  9 ;D$<  0C

>*$
 - W
= D $
H1 +P_ ) ][ 

Z 
+ \0 5
>$ 9 )(9 1
9 )B D$*(4
: k4 l1(= m n@] Z ' ,@
 7 ) (< ) 05E$ 

p*p ( 29(@ 


/ 7K
,+BE$ p
To ,+ 1  ]_(
n Y 20 ,:c=]U/]b(
A
kq r   Hl
s/t ;
E
[v uQl1 nl tw
s WD
%/ D)> fHw / ,[$/ 95 w
s WD
%x W 

s 95 4'( Z (

w p'p
,=y7])P=uQl',+ (

 ]_$
n Y l
z 9 Z P=uQl N *$ 29$! 
/ <
l
s/{ 9H 4'$ Z $
w

s 95 4'(  ,:c=])] w


q r   p 
s/{ 9H 4'$ / ,:cd])] w
s f5 w@| 
w D $ s/{ fH w
s/{ WV)
% W 

s c0  @
P_  95O uQl']w
 /fH% 29 / }O ( l
P_ | 
(uQlV% l
s/{ cf  w
s P_ / ,07
f+9-yCuQl n'%l ZGN z ,+I7uQl1'l
,+ Z P^uQl n
'mn'E] Z l
s/{ Pw / ,f: w
s/{ WD
%/ D)C/ f5'4/ ,[( 9H w
5: B<)*$ 7D$/
8)W$
7%9 V@
 :$  '$Bc+W1c="v :6IH8208')7
c+W1c="P=%
" 7,[

F ,[


~F).LO=:O% vH=O -OxQx7)3.Qx%3)x


A v%  O Q < := ? L6.Q
O  v L$RO3 O 8: 3 L>.Q O
 v Q 51  <)x > / eQ
) LO= Hxe+85E(HHF^ 31H
 C dv 7OUR(LOH
3O8F(O 3 ) 6 A 3AO
O  v H+< QO +H$ COR
L &O%O:OE O x O Q: ? e.Q
= @? e5.-Q8CO )3HGO 7O X =
3 L6.-:O @vHO3.-Q
 (1
OHLE=O -)7\O ( <O7LHL

A8-O<' 7O1CxOH %Lv@XO'EbO


x%)CLx=OdHLGQO+eHOO+Ox eH
xO LGO(<R1<O(8 (3L>@v
)= h.3L L8.-QHLCHd

%(3<(++(1H@H D7FEG"BHJI)HLK&UvCOA 
(R

3.3
Single Device Event Perception
$(B(X(
XO^$(3' 8>Ov'
3. EVENT PERCEPTION
3.1
Previous Work
v(%((43: +3 X%G+(=Q' +O
H1'^+1+H 7==1<1HF'=v%)1COO
(v
'C1(3G1
:'%'*L'<(
(3' O>v%(O (+d(G18' 
/>%+H
v<(OH1HECOQH1=(< E 7v(1(3<v
( + v%(G%(:O> %-'<O'E' = 81
3(v3 +vO'F1'<%%(%
(3%^ (1R184
'O((1A%(v1(
%'= )1(C%3' %'L+( 1G(7Ov'
:%' 
+%  ^1>+'8
^(%Cv%()X%
'O8(($v%7%(1C(8%/>%d1<%(
'
C1H 4 

1H18@\%H
+ (%(3
^
H( d(=L'1(+(8C
 ('%'61H<
('OHK $  R G('5(O>(GOv'

+((63'1' 
Q>'11(GO31
O 
XK
X1'OA831'EO1H1b(OAO(v+' 
+ GE3(L1'
X7+(71(O%)' Q(
H %G@L'Q' QOH(R
(v< +1 (%'
v%O 15G1(81A1'
H
%:11:X
'1 (8O'$ G (8%R
O'Ev< )(
-  %8(E

RC%^'%(31<H<OU H
v=H %'$15R
@<(O< 8
>(
%'< C%dE X%5   )+ >((3F 1'

H7%^OH1v)' %^O7E(:O@(% <


H<8%7H vH B+(G%?5(%((B

( (G51(BH 3O(RG%(R
 (R<1
( %^( %6< <H 5<((%v1H
v%+(H
O%8H17( OE<(((7
H
%F1((3+1\%(1 % Cv%5 %5O
+)1 + X%3v% :%)C<
vG(7< (L
/ (%'1?%(1H$$<%C(A%O'1
(7(8%\%(31 v%EC(OH7%-(C()(
H1H % <( 38 X%(
6 H1(
 C 
E% E1'1+1'1CQ'<v%A1
(AE(L(C
H%

%(>(<
(E8Ov81HF7') 7v
(A%8O:1'17  <1(8
^1H=G@(%
 F b1(5%> ' H$' M/G+1813%
(E H FHG'QCF(88%<HF(1A
( e (+<<1'8%3' %&1:%(=%1
H'8%oH<(1H$+(' <GOOHH$
+1H1:1H4C< (8%GOL'<<'<(1:+1C(1O'
+<(7
: +<'+(7%(+%)(7A'
-% vd>'71HC\((6<(% C(
O
N%
>(7H^e-(Q+(F'1(+3(7 O %3'
(E<'< =&1+<'1:d 3QH?%<'1 =&<
(B1GHH%(=COGP
"H$(1
G&8+ 4C(7'   <OH%((<(Ev%73'1
#
(3 O %B'F(B(8>1(513HBv%
'6((G(
N%(E7) (G%7(EH4 EX
+1H(71+:
:1(+17H3+< (7
-
- ==-(1^'
AL+73%( =%<
+
-^Q+%=RO=)O%(@(+CU()O1R
+1C  G7v%7=Cv'E< < H%
(<+((<3(E<OLA18'<1(be:1A1H
<OLA18'<1(^1A5C< (=:O
-
(=C17HHQ< (7=-OCR)@(7' +O
F(77OL'81<H<(1H4C1H> GO (>1
8<

((7L (E< 7+171\78H6


 X%(6(C
(d
 RH1HFv=H6H3'1H1'<E
%'7L) O <  R(C (7O/=b<'7H
'1H1'o88= B3#%<'1 %7=(
=<v3v%(4OL'F(81(
QQ(=
=8OH3v%C18E(G1CO(81(G6
v% 
)1(%'3 5v1<(<'1<)%)'%(
(1(3 LH1H
.-%CQ(+@<+Q()+1()+1.)O+
'<1(2
Q=H-8:1'-O=+%7+(+=%@
(='1H@H ((?%=(@( A%17(='=+O
(F(7E(%(1?>'1HL^1(8<1'C% 3
H313H   B' 8OH1'K

3
 /)< <H %3(

3.2
Event Perception in Agent Buddy
)H UOH(<<Q' =(1(7U(
 (@1=H1+v%
H %<v'5 >8 b%+(d 5(
^(3 (< 
=b1HF'
G(81<H 
 FL'
6H$OO51 +<(1 >OH
H G1( K(51HG<5+ +% 1
H<(1vX* H1'
Q=H:13H%'5O=
=H 7OH(67'1AO1<=(CC%d%
vQ=( v%E8 '1<H 7OQ6OC(3  
H(1H3
 %3(++ +('%b%AO
%$(% 513/<(v%
+1
U(K3
13(
(v% 1@((G%3
(>83%3'

+O-%R(=H1v% ^@(-'7('%(=E
(7v%OC%^(v% Q)('<C1 %'
(1O'<=
3(7 '1<H 71C
(: (

v !#"%$'&)(*(
(+#,-"%$.&7<% (8(> G18(
+<4(% /$(+1H0$21>354%6=/^
(1v 7 ! 8(
(
(97;: 
 RH U' -E'1(R+@(C1^%7%v' -O
H1'4-d%v +(U((Qv%=
<"%$.&>@?A ! "%$.&B4
(*(
(
4. , "%$'&.C

4.
EIGENSPACE EVENT PERCEPTION
G<1'OA(<'1v%H<( >AOL'
(<
%E /1H<' +O(AQ' ;=(1(^$(3=
O3<'1(Q QOO=:E(=1HO'%<(Q(1(
(71'O
/3
(1'6& d%(F(+% (=L
(E<%(1A1HR
-H1v%8<H1 (Q(b%+(1
v+'<O'1 \%v 
"%S==D
&Q%8v% X% =/ 
C1A4F(7(<(14H<v%d%(v%%
((&1+
(+%h1+(:%(8<1'8%
4( L<() Xh<v( UO(=(1((E
-'%X
/
+:<('' =8OQ< (3((
(Q% 1'R
<"%$'&-%)
HQ<=(% ^B1(8 
<(v/< (&%h ^%<vQ'1(8(1
S^=
%:v< 31H3% 1'J
+'
'B%:' E<(
O'>+8%
(3O/=3(7(1vd<v( 7(
 G%-(7('>A<(4%(3< (

4.1

Event Modeling

TUVWU5XZYB[/Y
\Y
]5^._
`;aGYcb*U#[[Y
b
^de.f
gBh)ikjgBl


pk[_.U9Y/\vzY
a;Y
Xp#_FpRo9prp#VY
^.Y*r%zp#^%zU]Us)|
nz] ^.Y
r.V_2U#s2
`

`=a;z^.wJo9prp#VY*^.Y
r._
`=

`

x
=
T
w5Z_
`sAUrp{#z\Y
]J

A
A
A
p#]nXn`)aGYbp#]JUZ^p
z]p \vY*b
^.Uvr


~
*

~
.^.w9p^

{#z\Y
_^.wnY0b
U5Y
bBzY
]5^._Us;^.wnY0b*Uvr.r.Y
_.o9U]ZX5z]n{r.YpXMz]n{v_
xD9UvrDpk[[

^.wnY o9U_._%zM[Yp]ZXn`2a;Y
bp#]{Y
^
p b
U5Y
bBzY
]5^
V
p^.r%zm

e.f*gBh)ikjgBl
`
*`O
. `
` B.B `

`
Bx

YBmnY
VWoM[qpr._tsuUvrYpbBw

Y*\vY
]5^
x=yGp#bwYBmnY
Vo5[qp#r/b
U#[[Y*b
^._0r.Ykp#X5z]Z{_RsAr.UvVXnY
\vzb
Y
_a;z^.w5z]
p^%zVY z]5^.Y
r.\p
[| }M~%;xTwnY
_.Yr.YpXMz]n{v_-p#r.YXMz_.b
r.Y*^%z
Y
Xz]5^.U
dle.g
.kGr.YpXMz]n{v_p^^%zVYz]Z_.^p]5^}M`
+.%.vB
+.%.v

`

`
.B.vB

`;x9UvrWXZY
\vzb*Y.}B`;aGYcXnY
]nUv^.Y
le.g
.5
Rr.YpXMz]n{v_sAUvr^.wnYv^.wB 

z^._W5^.wJ.} d

de.f
gBh2ijgBlktYmnY
Vo5[qp#rcsur.UvV^.wnY^.wBJ dY
\Y
]5^p#_
A
A


.nBxY
^ |
.n
.nB~

*~
.n..9Ypb*U#[nV]

\Y
b
^.Ur)Us5^.wr.YpXMz]n{v_GU#s+pk[[^.wnY=XZY*\vzb
Y
_)sAUr)^.wnY;^.wYBmnY
Vo5[qp#r
A
sur.UvV^.wZY
A^.wJY
\vY*]5^
xY
^
|
;r.Y
onr.Y
_.Y
]5^W^.wZY
b
U[ZV]\vY
b*^.Uvr
A
UZ^p
z]ZY*X5_%zVo5[b
U]Zbkp#^.Y
]Op#^%z]n{^.wnY
|
.nsAUrp
[[;^.wnY


A
A

r.Ykp#X5z]Z{_
`)|

.}vB~*

~
.}vB`
BB~
*

~
BkB`

`

A
A
.d le.g
.k B`
`
.d le.g
.k .8BxRY
r.Yv`2|
2{#z\vY*_0^.wnY

r.Ykp#X5z]Z{_sAUr^.wZY^.wYmnY
Vo5[qp#rU#sG^.wZYA^.wY
\Y
]5^
xT=wMz_Rz_^.wnY
r.Ykp#X5z]Z{_cUsDpk[[/^.wZY

XnY
\vzb
Y
_

^.wnYRVWU5XZYB[8^.rp
z]Mz]n{

oZwOp#_.Yvx2T=wnY[Y
]n{v^.wU#s\Y
b
^.UrR|

.d

a;z^.wJr.Y
_.o9Y
b*^^.Up#]JYBmnY
VWoM[qpr0z]
A
Oz_=

le.g
.k cBx+TwnY
]^.wZYG_p#Vo5[z]Z{Wr.Yp#X5z]Z{_)Vtp#^.r%zmWsuUvr2pk[[

^.wnYRY*\vY
]5^._=p]ZX

^.wnYBzr=p_._.U5bBzqp#^.Y
XYBmnY
Vo5[qp#r._=bp]
9YRb
r.Ykp#^.Y
X
5

^.wnYR_.Y*^;U#spk[[Wp#]nX
U#s;|

xB| %~
*`| %B. `

B. uBx@T=wnYX5zVY
]n_%zUv]@UsV
`0
*`0|
*
`|
p#^.r%zm

z_

.dde.f
gBh)ikjgBlb
U#[nV]n_

r.Ua=_
xT=wnYdde.f
gBh)ikjgBl

p#]nX..dle.g
.k.

b
U#[nV]n_

U#s/{z\vYr.YpXMz]n{v_0suUvr

RUaa;Y=^.rp#]n_%sAUvr.VPz]5^.UWpRV

p#^.r%zmWb
Uv]5
A
`2

`
^pkz]n_^.wZYb*U5YB
bBzY
]5^\vY*b
^.Uvr._Us/pk[[2z^._YBmnY
Vo5[qp#r._
W.
A
B. BxT=wnYpk\Y
rp#{Y b
U5Y

bBzY
]5^\Y
b
^.Ur0sAUvr^.wnY
_.Y
YBm5

UsYpbBwb
U#[nV]{z\vY
_

T=wnY

le.g
.5

.d

T=wZY/p
\vY*rp#{vY/b
U5YB

z]Z_.^p]5^sAUvr

4.2
Event Perception
T=wZYGo9Y
r.b
Y
on^%zUv]WU#sY
\Y
]5^._z]5\vU[\vY
_GV
p
JXMzY
rsAr.UvV^.wnUv_.YUsRz^._
r.Yp_.Uv]n_0_.nbBw

^.r%zmU#s/^.wnY

B;dd

p]Uvr.^.wnUv{Uv]Opk[DV

z_p

U#s\p#r%zqp

^%zU]Z_pk[U]Z{^.wZYoZr%z]nbBzoOpk[

p]ZX^.wOp#^

b
UVo9U]ZY
]5^X5zr.Y
b
^%zUv]n_
`

^.wZYBzrzVo9Ur.^p#]nb
Yvx

x8Y
^

bkp#]9YpoZonr.U
m5zV
d

e.f
gBh2ijgBl

p#^.Y
XLp#b
b*Uvr.X5z]Z{^.U^.wZY[qpr.{vY
_.^W .d

_%z]n{v5[qp#r\p
[ZY
_

0+

T=wZYY*\vY
]5^/)a;z^.w ^.wnY_.V
9Y
_.^=V

  



pk[[Y
_.^/XMz_.^p]Zb*Y

p^.bBwUs^.wnY0UZ_.Y*r.\vY
XY
\Y
]5^
x

0z_Rb
U]Z_%zXnY
r.Y
X^.wZY

4.3
Eigen
Pyramid
Ybkp#]0zV
p{#z]n{0^.wOp#^z]^.wnY;z]5^.Y
r%b
Uv]n]ZY*b
^.Y
X oOY
r.\p#_%z\vY/a;Uvr%[X`
A
+j~
j

j

a=wnY
r.Y

`
*`O9p_

a=w5zbBw

^.wZY=onr%z]Zbzo9p
[b
UVo9Uv]nY
]5^;X5zr.Y
b
^%zU]Z_



Z_.Y*Xz]Ymno9p]ZX5z]Z{Yp#bwb
U[ZV]U#s=

A^.wY
\Y
]5^c|

;b
Uv]nbp^.Y
]9p^%z]Z{r.YpXMz]n{v_sAr.UvV

9Y
^%aGY
Y
]
b
U5YBtbBzY
]5^;\Y
b
^.Uvr
`^.wZY=]nUvr.V
p
[z
Y
X X5z_.^p#]nb
Y
p]ZX

VU5XnYB[8b
U5YB
bzY
]5^._
z_;n_.Y
X
^.U0oOY
r.b
YBz\Y^.wZY=Uvn_.Y
r.\Y
X Y
\Y
]5^
x

RY*r.Y

p#^.r%zm^.wOp#^2Y
]Zb*U5XZY
_

r.Yp#X5z]Z{_0sAr.UV^.wnY0^.wYBmnY*VoM[qprU#sF^.wZY

.n;XnY
]nUv^.Y^.wnYM^.wr.Ykp#X5z]Z{_cUsDpk[[/^.wZY

z]^.Y*r.V_=U#s2onr%z]ZbBzoOpk[Gb
UVo9Uv]nY
]5^/XMzr.Y
b*^%zUv]n_
x

T=wnY

 

`
.B.vB

~
*

~
B`9^.wOp#^/p#o5

onr.Ukm5zVtp#^.Y^.wnYRY
\Y
]5^;^.U9Y/o9Y
r.b
YBz\Y
Xp_=p[z]nYp#r=b
UV05z]9p^%zUv]

U#s+YBz{vY*] Y
\Y
]5^;Op#_%z_
x;/o9Uv]
^.wnYRr.Y
b*U#\Y
r.
U#s8^.wnYRr.Yp
[_%z^.Op#^%zU]

XMzqp{vU]9p
[RVtp#^.r%zmaFz^.w_%z]5

^.wnY
rp#]n^.wnYX5zVY
]n_%zUv]n_Us^.wZY_.oOp#b
Yz]^.Y*r.V_

bBzY
]5^._^.U9Y

r.Ykp#X5z]Z{_p#^G^%zVYRz]Z_.^p]5^/}M`

a;Yr.Y
b*U#\Y
r/p0\vY*b
^.Uvr/U#s2b
U5YBtbBzY
]5^._
`

`2

+
`8_.Uvr.^.Y
Xz]XZY
b*r.Yp#_%z]n{Uvr%
M %B.

XnY
rp
[Uv]n{^.wnYX5zqp#{vU]9p
[Ax T=wnY\vzr.^.Opk[=Us=^.wZY*_.Y\pk[nY
_z_^.wOp#^

^.wnYb
U5Y

dle.g
.k

onr.U
BY*b
^%z]Z{^.w5z_;\vY
b*^.Uvr2Uv]

{M[qpr0\p
[ZY
_t

^.w5z_rp#]nvz]Z{ z_\vY
r.UsA^.Y
]r.YB[qp#^.Y*X^.U

 

{#z\Y
_r.YpXMz]n{v_Us=p
[[2^.wZYXZY*\vzb
Y
_p#^Dpk[[2^.wnY0^%zVWYz]n_.^p#]5^
x

onr%z]Zbzo9p
[Rb*UvV0

e.f
gBh2ijgBl Gz]^.wnY^.rpkz]5

z_Fp.dd0e.f
gh)ijgl.dd0e.f*gBh)ikjgBlV

_.UvVY

^.wnYRb
U5YBtbBzY
]5^._

pk[[G^.wnY0^%zVYz]Z_.^p]5^
`a;YUvn^pkz]^.wnY0b*U#[nV]\vY*b
^.Uvr

pk

z]n{_.Y
^
xT=wZY
_.Y-p#r.Y9Y
_.^X5zr.Y
b
^%zU]Z_^.w9p^bp#]JbB[Ykp#r%[X5z_.^%z]5
{Mz_.wJ^.wnY^.rpkz]5z]n{X9p^pMx

 

.B.vB
XnY
\vzb
Y
_Wp#^^%zVYz]Z_.^p]5^9x

z_

p
_.wOp#r.Y

_%z{v]Op#^.nr.Y
_
xT=wnYn_.YU#sWYBz{vY
]_.oOp#b
Yp#o5

.
.B~
*

~
...z_^.wnY r.YpXMz]n{v_
sAr.UvV

XnY
\vzb
Y
_/aFz^.w5z]^%zVYo9Y
r%zU5XJ|}5~%;x2YX5z_.b
r.Y
^.Y
|
'

.B.vB

5 %.B

_p#VY_%z*Yp#_r.Y
onr.Y
_.Y
]5^%z]n{^.wZY

oOUv]nY
]5^XMzr.Y*b
^%zUv]n_c

 

5Zono9Uv_.Y
^.wnY

~*

YBmnY
Vo5[qp#r._9Y
bpZ_.YUs\p#r%zUvn_

U#s2^.wnYr.YpXMz]n{v_p
[Uv]n{conr%z]nbBzo9p
[;b*UvVo9U]ZY*]5^RX5zr.Y
b
^%zUv]n_
x

z]5^.U

wZY*r.YB

Bx

p#^.bwMz]n{r.YpXMz]n{v_sAr.UvVpk[[

UvrG_%z{v]Op#^.nr.Y
_RUs2p{#z\vY*] Y
\Y
]5^)z_=bp#on^.nr.Y
X 5

XZY
b*UvVo9U_.Y
XJZ_%z]n{_%z]Z{M[qprc\p
[ZYXZY
b*UvV0

~#*

onr.U5p#bw0sAUrY
\Y
]5^o9Y
r.b*Y
oZ^%zU]p#_._.nVY
_2^.w9p^^.wMz_b
UVVU]9p
[z^%zY
_

_.Y
^
xJ/_.9p
[[

oOUv_%z^%zUv].5R|k2| vkp#_

c

p#_]nU#z_.Y Y*^.bvxxWRUa;Y
\Y
r
`8^.wZY
V

b
UVVUv]Opk[z^%zY*_Uvr

.dle.g
.k82dd0e.f
gh)ijglvx

p^.r%zmJbp#]9Y

OY
b
UvVWY
_

yGp#bwb
U[ZVW];U#sGp#^.r%zm
b
Ur.r.Y
_.o9Uv]nXn_0^.U^.wZYWp
\vY
rp{vYb
U

YB
bzY
]5^0\Y
b
^.Ur

~ Us=Y
\Y
]5^.x
z_0^.wnYVU5XnYB[

U#s2Y*\vY
]5^._=[Yp#r.]nY
XsAr.UvV^.wnY^.rpkz]5z]Z{onwnrp#_.YWp#]nXaFz[[2OYZ_.Y
X

z]Y
\Y
]5^=o9Y
r.b
Y
on^%zUv]x

b*U#[nV]@U#sWr.YBsuY
r._ ^.Up{#z\Y
]^.rp
z]Mz]n{_.Y
^
`R^.wnYYB[Y
VY
]5^._
sAUvr^.wMz_

p#^.r%zm

^.wnYY
\vY
]5^._
x29Ur=^.wZY_pVYY
\vY*]5^
`9r.YpXMz]n{v_Rz]r.Ypk[p#onoM[zbp^%zUv]

kRYB[Y
VY
]5^._

p]YBmnY*VoM[qpr
xT=w5n_
`;YpbBw

Us^.wnY b
U[ZVW]r.YBsAY
r._^.U^.wnY r.YpXMz]n{v_

bzY
]5^=V

%
9
+%B.

^.wnY0XnY
\vzb
Y
_Rz]pr.Yp
[_%z^.Op#^%zU]Jp#{pkz]n_.^R[Yp#r.]nY
XVU5XZY[_U#sFpk[[

^.wnYr.Yp#X5z]Z{_csAr.UVp
[[^.wnY XnY
\vzb
Y
_-p#^

p
[[/^.wZYX5z_.b
r.Y
^.Y^%zVY

%B.

Y
Vo5[qp#rG\vY
b
^.Ur._)bkp#]9Y=bp
[b
5[qp#^.Y
X59

p
[[^.wnYRYBmnY*VoM[qpr._=U#s2p
[[^.wnYRY
\Y
]5^._
x2T=wMz_;z_;^.wnY^.Uv^p
[]5ZV9Y
r
Us=^.rpkz]5z]n{_.Y
^Us=XOp#^pMx

p^.r%zm ^.wOp#^2r.Y
onr.Y
_.Y
]5^._=^.wnYRp
\Y
r%

p#{Y;b
U5YBtbBzY
]5^sAUvrYpbBwY
\Y
]5^
x9Ur2p#]5Y
\Y
]5^).`V

pr.Y=_.bpk[qpr\p
[ZY
_=^.wOp#^2bp#]
9Y/bpk[b*M[qp^.Y
X5^p#vz]n{


A
^.wnYXnUv^onr.U5XZnb
^U#s|
/p]ZX j `
|
u j xT=wMz_z_
j

A
^.wnY
oZr.U5b*Y
_._0Us/oZr.U*BY
b
^%z]n{^.wZYr.Ykp#X5z]Z{\vY
b*^.Uvr
|
GUv]5^.U^.wnY

_.nn_.o9pb
Y_.oOp#]n]ZY
X5 ^.wnY0Op#_%z_\Y
b
^.Uvr._
`

`+#xG%^=bp#]

w5n{vYp#VWUvn]5^;U#s+XZY
\vzb*Y
_=aFz[[89YRz]5\U#[\Y
Xx=y2\vY*]5^._)[zvYa=wOp#^=p
o9Y
r._.U]z_)XnU#z]n{bp]9Y=o9Y
r.b
Yz\vY
X50b
U]Z_%zXnY
r%z]n{
a;z^.wMz]p]U#

Uv]5[XZY*\vzb
Y
_

b*Yvx2RUa;Y
\Y
r
`vY*\vY
]5^._[zvY/awnY
^.wnY
r2o9Y
Uvo5[Ya;z^.wMz]

pcn5z[XMz]n{pr.YwOpk\vz]n{pcVWY
Y
^%z]n{ _.wnUv5[X9Yb
U]Z_%zXnY
r.Y
XJa;z^.w
pk[[/^.wnY

XZY
\vzb*Y
_

aFz^.w5z]J^.wZY

nMz[X5z]9{nxJ%]{Y
]ZY*rpk[A`;^.wnY 5z{v{Y
r

^.wnY_.bpk[YU#s^.wnYY
\vY*]5^._ ^.U9YoOY
r.b
YBz\Y
X`/^.wnYVUr.YXZY*\vzb
Y
_
]nY
Y
X

^.U9YRb*Uv]n_%zXZY
r.Y*XxGwnY
] ^.wnY=]5ZV9Y
r;Us8XZY
\vzb*Y
_=YBmnb
Y
Y
Xn_

 !"#%$"#&(' )+*,"#-$./102)#$% 34)5.36&.7189'' :&;


8&;<34((=#$ &>& ? =#"&1? @#=:. &14'9 ?AB $B:):)+C

00:45
123 45
67890

D 1E
D 36E
FHGJI6KML.NPO+Q2RTSUSV#W%XZY[>XZ\J];^]_`X a4b-bc\edfb^hgji1Y[;k \Jlbm1bc^nXog6bYpbgjq
XZ\J];^nrtsT[uvja4b wHYW%XxS bm1bSM\Z^;gjV6Xyl>[>Xz[p];kAbhl;\ZY{bTp(XZSi _TY{];k|X a4b
Y{[;}!Yb[>l;\Z^:d;Wy]_ [;SZS~X a4bl>bm(\JpbcW%rBsuhvja4bAbc\edfb^ gji;Y[;k \Jlp];^4q
W%XZYTV6p(XJbTl-Xz] g6bYZ_];Yk|bm1b^jX+g6bYpb{g~XZ\J];^}~a4b^a#Vdfb[;kA];V#^nX]_
l>bm(\JpbWB[;Y{b\U^4m1];Sm;bl>r

FHGJI6KML.N~Q`b(Xz[;\US bTl,d;Y[Tg6a#\Jp[;S4\ZSZSV:W%XY{[>XZ\J];^]_ Xa4b b\ d>b^gji;Y{[;q


k \Jl-pT];^4W%XZYTV6p(XZ\J].^ gjY](pbWTW%r
t&;): &@6J&;?|71> @4%@: &;8y":t":h>=:?36&(
):7; %$B $">=:/;1*j89B@:&;@4&1$  #85$.%/;0hcc'' )1@>0>.? )
 /;2$@6.:C-f=:@:@4&;$-%z%J $ ":`>=:? 34 &.y):7; $
"6.-(.534"4(#)>' )3>0"#.36&.71tT /1$@6.%t(@#@:&>(T"jC
>=:@#@4&1$2 JJ $-"#&1c' >=:? 34h&( )#%7; $&t34&1f
$ ):)jCB=#$.%/;0 $-&6$h)> 7; )#2=:fJ&1?c'' 05":$
JJ%):7; $h >&)fn>/;&1=#@:$$=:T"5"4(h((T"!/1&;=:@
c.34 "4(#D )>' )t3>0-"#A.36&.71 /;$@4( ? ":&>)+Cf=:@:@4&;$
~z#-(E;*>8y":,2~z>h;C
J-J%4
>*4":89 (()f 7; ): ": )#7; %$B >&D %z%JH2
/1&;=:@#$CxB"#%8x $1*489,(.)> 7; )# ":B6$y z%J (E
):7; %$` >&/1&;=:@#$89 "((T"!/1&;=:@"6.$~zB5
?A?36$C5":89h)> $ 3#=:t":$ )#%7; $h >&t":
6$!/;&;=:@:$t&;3:c :)jCy">=:$* 892"67;2)f 7; ):)):7; $
 >&P/;&1=#@:$* 89 "!(."!/;&1=#@5"6.$h "# z%J
&19~zH?A?36$C4&;9c."h/;&1=#@j*:89B=:"#,c > #/

6) .h(#)): ":T  @: #T @6c',)>  &1#$C,&.8 *j89 &('' 
":%&>TT >7;&1H89 " %$@4&B":y@# :T @6c'M)>  &1#$
J&1M(." f :/ T:? @>'U.Cy"#' #/1" &.n"#9%&>TT >7;%T
&;  $ THcT (1 C; #":&>T >$ ((@#=:$
": )fj%#%$ -"#  f :/)4(f*48B89''M(<; &>TT >$
&.A((T"!T:%? @f'U(.$-"# #@:=:&":$&;:)' 71T' &.A"#
@>0>.?  )+C
H":94$$./;1*>"#y' :/;" J&;((T"c > :/`71&1 D T:%?
@>'U.E $ JJ CB=: #/":@:&>$$ (34&(7;;*~":0. )> 7; ):)
 >&2/1&;=:@#$C2."2/;&1=#@/;:.%$%THcT (;
&>TT >$C9y">=:$*>":&1c':' :/;" J&;M":y$&1#) ' 71T'j&.j >
@:=#989''~34,D H( c;*>8y"f "  $9? =#"' $$y"6.
JJ45 %z%J+tcE#>C o H( (;M
z *:"#-89B(<; "> $y#85)6. ($x :@:=#*n.:)@4((
":t(34&(7;t)6.2.3:$.% &;@:&>$$&tJ=:"#%h):=#%t"#
.?A&;=:>M&.6"#9)6.>CB": 89 $;*;8H"67;9((T":)A9$./;"4(
):T $ &1(.-34 ?.):;C o THcT (; $y? =#"
' $$M"6. z%J .:) HJ=:"#%MT /;A&>TT %>HT:( &;
 $ ? c.> #/(' $$*y"#%t89.<1`"> $ T(T (;
> =:?34%$h($ ":`64'B%&>TT >$&(B":h f :/2T:? @>'U.C
 %THcT c;  $ 3> /`%#&1=#/1"$=:T""6..:&;":
&;=::)&(T /; %&>TT > :. &1 $,? (.> :/.J=>'J*M":89
=:h": @:&>$$,& T:.%": :8%&>TT >$Cy"#$
:8%&>TT >$ 89''34 .<1($B": B46c'%&>TT >$ &("#
T:?A@f'U( &.y":  f :/t71>$C J% T:. :/":66c'
&>TT >$9&(~c''j":yT:? @>'U.$&.oc''j":971>$*:"#xc71./1
&.":64'&>T >$&(c''"# T:?A@f'U($ 8x "$@4%B&
`/( 7;271> .(<;2($ "#? &>):T'&.y": &1$@4&1#)> #/
71>C
B=: :/h":71>B@6@: &;t@:"6.$;*ocJ%": (.)> #/1$BJ&;?
c'' ):7; %$.71c'U(3f' >* 8h4$-T:.&>T >$89 "
$@4% &"#-@# :T @6c' )>  &;:$h&(,"#4$'U01&.,"#
@>0>.?  )`J&1? ))#=: :/`":B f :/@#"6.$1C9y"#%`(<;,"#$
&>TT >$.$h": #@:=#&2"#$&1#)!'U0;&( ":T /;
@>0>.?  )!.:)2T:.% &;%$@4&;:)f :/2&>T >$Cty"> $ @#&(
$$M $9&1> >=#%)h=:>'j"#y&1@' %7;T'j&(~"#yT /1@>0>.? )-"4($
34%&1#$ ):)jCy"#$=>'  #/B64'4%&>TT >$(H":T /;
@>0>.?  )t$ /;6.=:$ T:.%)h J&;?"# 8):7;  (()f :/;$
":&;=:/;"t":T /;@>0>.? )jC y'U.$*M89A&;? @6."> $66c'
&>TT >971&;89 ""#&1$&(~"#yc > :/ ? &>):T' $9&.o''j"#
71>$ (#)-$T' ,"# T' &1$$B&1#A.$y": 7;%>@6T 71)+C
;  ?=>'UEXPERIMENTS
. &1T:@4% ? >$t"67;234@4J&1? )&$"#
Tj% 7;:$$&( ":T /;:$@6.7;%>`@6@: &;.@:@#&."+C
y"# %>7; &;:? > $.$$=:? )-& 34 .-&.% 8x "-$ (;
(1.$ $"#&(8y 2 /;=:>Chy":@4$&12#*c*(#)$"6.
": &.1C9y"#%0`=:$ .3>' $ *4B*n.:)$@4 71T' 0;C,y"#
 $y ?  :/ (3f' B ":B? ):)f'  &.~":B&(B8y":B":0 c.
"6c71  )f $=:$$ &;"#1C9y"#% .A7;%>$B& 34 @6T 71)
 2&;=: T:@4% ? D >$ D (E #*9*.89&;<; :/2(":T  ):$<>$
$@4% 7;T' 04 E t.:)!.-)f $%=#D$ $ &1+*,T ":. &;(
B*j8y">' hB $ 89&1<; #/( .3>' B EB(#) . "67; D# /
? % #/-."#,?  :/.3>' ;*48y">'  H  $y89&;<; :/-.yB E
.:) (B)> $=:$$ &;j*MT ":D ,.y.3>'  &1,.y.3>'  B*#8y">' 
x $y89&1<; #/.y.3>'  B ;E9(#)B.,"47; :/-?  :/(
":B? % #/ (3f' 1*48y"f'  H $,.B D E(#)y.B)> $=:$$ &; 
TD  ":,.y.3>'  &1y.3>'  B*:8">'   $y89&;<; :/.y(3f' 
;E $y989.:&1)<; y#./-,. "4 7;C  :/B? % #/(9":B? % #/ .3>' ;*48y">' 
5.

(0,100)

(100,100)

(0,0)

;

(0,100)

(100,0)

c U t


( h

.
,

y1
9c

(1 c;

c t
( 

 ! #" $%$%&(')*+


)),.-/0'1 '2'13!
!4'5+467" &.83):9
)&3)7!)" &;,.)%<>=?&.4" )
-!
'1 '' 6%)" - A@ )4:9B'1.
&($7" !%&.-C&('
&.8D!',.!&3)'13
$%! :@ 0" - A@ E8F" GHC!& I$ J K
,3)?+" '1(" & @ " $%&L'M" - !M" (8N<BO132" - :@ 8(" GH!& 4$ PJ ,3
PJ , J '8 (Q
'5+&>'M+
7&3) ,3'M" $7I" - :@ )0" )
%,.&('M" & @
'13'7' J &(,3!2:9(" R3 J )+137) MS MT 
$ PJ ,3)U1 $7
"@
8(" ) !M" ' Q
'5+&;'130'5+0" - :@ C)<V1347'13!" )U+#" @ 1('M" & @
83$7" '1 ' @ " $7C)'1.4+" @ 1(')&3)8H<LO13" - :@ 8(" GH!& 
$ PJ ,3) @ &3! 'C8 (Q '1.
-C!
!
)),3-8L'
'139 J K
J A+" & @3W " 9
X!)%&Y" )+%!67" & @
'1F" )A+O&E' (J 7*
8(" GH!& 
$ PJ ,3
" ) @ &3! '8HZ7" 9H13[" )\" &($% J $7C8]" &
8(" ) ,3))M" 7&H*
$ PJ ,3
:9
" )?!C',.!&38HZN" 9^13_" )
'
-'M" & @
''1.
&('!' FJ 7*
$ J ,.2A9
" ) @ &3! '8H<^`V8F" $7" 83U'1.&($7" !7&3-&('" &('
@ !M" 83)<a
1 @ !M" 84" )b(,F" 3X8L+" '1
+#" @ 1('M" & @ 83 K
$7" 7<c1.+#" @ 1(')&3)8 (Q
+c#" @ 1('M" & @ 8.$7" _" )'13?),3-d:9
+#" @ 1(')
,3)8 (Q J J '1./X!)7&3)+" '1(" &e'134&($7" !7&3-&('<
1.+#" @ 1('
,3)8 (Q
 !)7&E+f" '14+" @ 1('g
&388(" )' & 
S ''1.283$7" U" ) @ " $7& (QXW

gh#R3

(100,100)

(0,0)

6

(0,100)

(100,0)

(100,100)

(

j7SAki

83$7" I+" '1



lM&D'1.4'! " &(" & @ 3! ))*9%! ( 1D$7&('*m+  J J  '
#R3C- K
 JU !)<onX7!4 ( 1>#R3- JU !*+  J J  'I+#" @ 1('M" & @ 8 ' t '-
'M" -2" &.)' &('<a . 1I'M" -2" &.)' &('?1 )c; c;+c#" @ 1('! 8 K
" & @ ) 7!!C)X7&38F" & @ ' @ !M" 8.)" &;'13&($7" !%&.-C&('<p130q !)'
@ 48(" GH!& 
 J -/&('A9'130R3- JU !$% '7! SArs t " )U'1." - :
Q +#" @ 1('2! 8(" & @ ) '?'13`C )'* j &.8H*
! 8F" & @ )</lM'O" )?9u J J A+8 (
'1I'M" -2" &.)' &('<21. J & @ '1L:9c'1.
v !8H*  '1H* '1H*xw:'1H* &38:
 J ,.-&>$7 '7!" ) y5Pc;-Pc;F <Da ( 1 7!!C)X7&38.)4'
J J Q
! 8F" & @ )?" &L7&32'! " &(" & @ R3- JU !)<O13! !2'%' P
'! " &(" & @h  J ,.-&L$7 '7!)<^1. Q 9u7!-z'132'! " &(" & @ - '!M" RH<
I97!-{'1.I'! " &F" & @ 8 ' *+ @ " $7I'13 6 ) 7)M" 'M" 7&3)9%!
J ?| )  f ; *3 (F J } ) (f ; *3 (F J U~ ) 1f 1 *
 .(
&38!%,.&384' .( J  )  f <1.X7)M" 'M" %&I:9 X!)7& '('1
Q '1.
'M" -" &3)' &('A9H'1.^7'1/#R3- JU !)A9H'1$%&('\" ) @ " $7& (
6 )X7)M" 'M" %&I:9H'13 .( J ?'13X!)7&U" ) # J 7)+" '1!)X '['
J X%)M" 'M" 7&    <
'13'1L$7&('2 J ,3) ! &.837-$ !M" .(
nX%!#R - J 7*" &;7,3!')'* ;
 * f 1 * w> w * >rs t s * r s t s  *
; * >  !'13$ !M" & C)09%!'1.tC )'#R3-/ JU !:9B'1.

+1.C! k @ " $7)4'13)&3)M" 'M" $7" ' Q :9B'1.4+#" @ 1('M" & @
!)X '?'2" ')?8(" )' & ''132X!)%&N<

q !)'OC$7&('<

?C!?" )O'13U}

(0,0)

(100,0)

 (
HJ6M.+Pj4h4(Z{;4 j:; Z # >ZJ;J%ztn4` .
 4 4(Z{;4 j4Z;T: JB(;c;:j4 TjJ
-4> 99x;j5;> (>%;  f 1 ;> 1 y 
6T(ZZ1 >yj4 cnzyy 4B;:jJ> 9Z,>  > j4
h;{ y(1t;jh  4(ZZ1c   

 (4y #B;n
n4`JZ4>ZJ;; 4 Hy1jJ  j4 JZ4>ZJ; ;A 4
T hn4JZ4>ZJ;,; 4 1jJ
 1jJ

)2X%)M" 'M" 7&I97!XC!)7&3) ''13 $%&(') W

AM#P
AP
CAP

P
A
P
A
P
A

AMA
 AMAX 
AMA
 AMAX 
AMA

 A P
 A P
AMP

A#A

ACA
 AMAX 
ACA
 AMAX 

AMAN 
AMCA

 ACA
AMCA
AMAN 

A#P

 A P
 A P


.(J 

|O9u'!'! " &(" & @ *X'13#" @ &4$ PJ ,3)


!)1.A+&" &4n\" @ ,3!2w(<nX!7'13]q @ ,3!7*^+
&)4'1 ''13qX!)'/#" @ &;$ J ,.C)
!
"@
%- !8'2'13?!C)':9x#" @ &$ PJ ,3)<c|?-%& @ '13-*3'13Oq !)'
#" @ &I$ PJ ,3)
!2'132-%)'O-/ &(" & @ 9, J #" @ &I$ J ,.)<

:3LD2:_33M 7L:m# 7 33#3

140000
eigen value

120000

1
Tester Event Difference

Value

100000
80000
60000
40000
20000
0
0

10

15 20 25
Eigen Index

30

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2

35
0
0

cuXALN4 (%7 X

10
15
20
Eigen Index

25

%

F
AO3.CM 74:x3?(3XC:x3M .# Pm7/X73(.C
32%(.CM 7HL2A:E2 :3?X 7EF 
M %.2P:3.DP /7UP c3_ (7]:M 7HU.U2 7
C7(M 3.L37( .4 I:mA:3.M 30 (%4:M %N

eigen value

0.9

Tester Event Difference

0.16

1
2
3
5
7

0.14
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0

0.8

10
15
20
Eigen Index

25

MX

0.7
0.001

0.6

2-7
5-7

0.5

0.0005

0.4
0

10

15 20 25
Eigen Index

30

35

cuXALNI#x3A7/(uu7

Difference

Cumulative Captured Information

\ %.3:x.AM ?AXAA.32 Fu74AM 7H F

-0.0005
\ %.E3:2%.U:3UM (:M %eCF 27B?A
C7(%\\ %.7%N3AO3^.%4P C0( :3^X5
3?CA.43?(3# A%(7H 3?73P 3I3.M 3
34P ( .;3XA7LM%.C%. 3AAU7^(
U7%7cA.:A4.3M %p:B# 7Ce 3.#3CpL
P:I :F A.C2X5L.UB:3I7C(2A.
:IU.F %7EXAp( :3IXCMCp3VCA.
C7(47^(^(^:3;(4V4AA;P I37M EXA( :3
MC4.c:3 x.%((3# X% 7
33# :37;7U# %e 3.3EP/FL(  XP:3 :
M  (%4:M %e AA.3;(L.%3M .# PBF CM 73
A(#:C V# %L7 .C2O372 3.#3CA( 7% :
(LV4AAp V37M CIXA30 I3M .# PBF CM 73
P:3.U27AAX7M %:x Fu74AM 7H\ 73%MX[3A[
3 \3F A.C:x.CA.4%((3# ?%3F3( F
A.DFULP:L.%M 4XA?3F A.C0 MCV3U
A.4%(^(.[ ^4 XA03F A.CXMc3
C2A.L7C(2(. UFxFx(A.L47CL:247EA:M
A77F :4 .AV3XAC:U3L# 7XA
C7( 3M 7oA.3(A#; p3X%AM 7I%M N;\ %.
%MAA 74I3P 7 Cz:.EF 3VAF A.C0A
3U2A.L%(?(3# U(xFx:3LFM3AOUUO

-0.001
0

10
15
20
Eigen Index

25

MA

[XADN42I#pA C(
BX\
4 2
\ (
^(
U(
 L
(  
X
x
!
"#
$
%
( 
&P ;'
F \ )
('
%
*2+
\ , (
-[(.
(
IC2
(+
I
X
\/
!
"0
#21%3546387635963 "
:;2_2
\= <c(A
(U\E  > E 
\ 73I3A4:373M UFAM 7( 3;U:
%( 3H[3374 4F A.C[ MC3C
:33(3# U:%(47^ (A03AN/V4AAV
 :4F A.CXCMCp3I4A.%(4A. :
U.I4P C :I( :3UX5I3C2A.L7C(
7%(((%:3UFL[P:UP .%M  :x7(x \%[# %
4.UB:XA .( 3X?
>A7CX( 2M XAM 7XA.%
:E.D# 7 3.#XC7I( 7%
F  3:DXA
L7324X# %%(2XA2A# 7 V#AH\3737
3M .# P( M %. :A:LAA.3E]%A:2 7M 7D: (

%
R /D.QI#RPBQPsEGF5A#HuF5EK:@P,PN ODZQ.%R"qGHh'
".#"#z$g#;#%"ts%D'w#PI #x## t 'x# R

@A#BC2D'EGF5A#HIJIKA#LM5N O%P+Q,A#HIGF5N PBP,N6R

Tester Event Difference

Z +R%B.D#t%R *D'AZMFtmD'H N{JR|sPBO%PBw'Gy$QJL PP,H6R


EP,H IGF5OM5P2C2DZBLsgMzDZHw#LDZwxP2C?Mz R RPQKHF5Q'DM
Ps%A#BE-KEEs6 #'u/uu+R u R A#Bw' {UC?Mt%}A#BGM5N
}dF5NPh}PO${A#HIA#BEGF5LC PQAxChChPHNDZEGF5A#HIR

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

0.1
0.01

%
R v?RBAAxIR"qGHEPMMF5wxPHQP2uF5EKA#LEJBP,s BPIP,HE.DZEGF5A#H"R
J= #"z5tx  'x% n t '# R
n 
{ A#HH PMRmJJ, #m.R*K EKPIGF5It%v-qD'O6t
y$qG+t #x R
qR%PBw#LIA#H"R# .=h$. =Z*J2J; .'= ;#
Jx"#?m=##$=5/"=.R#*KEKPIGF5It
JHF5#PBIGF5Er$AZ@{/DZCOBGF5N wxP#t"Jht 'x# R
+R%?R+D'B#P#R"P,BQPsEL%DMIEB.DZEP,wZF5PI/@A#B/sL Bs%AxIGF5#P
#F5IGF5A#H"RP,QKHF5QDM Ps%AxBEJPQ.K HF5Q'DM AxEP # t"| q
qGHEPBHDZEGF5AxH%DMt 'x n R

0.001
0.0001

10 15 20
Eigen Index

25

SUTVWXZY [6\^]`_YaYbaTcVdX'YbWeagfh_Yc ia,YbaYXj k+Yl%Ycma


n Tb2WbYop

6.
qrHgEKF5CONCLUSION
IJsDZs%P,Bt"uPJNPIQBGF5O%P,ND'HgvJwxPHE/y$PNFzDZEPN {/| {}~IIG

yR"JPAxBw#PDZHN$v?RDZHI#R P'D'QEGF5#PhBPDZIA#HF5Hw$DZHN
sMzD'H HF5Hw%RqrH *'..#=#/+5%`52+=#"#
#';+#J, #=8".txs%D'w#PI n x n # t
|PDZEEGM5P#t"}$vt 'x# R
5 R%JA'u/D'BEK6RqGHEPBsBPEGF5HwD?N HDZCF5Q2DZHN$L HQPBE.DF5H
uA#BGM5N"/F5w#KM5P#PM*#F5IGF5AxH6RJ= #"=5".'t
 x n t ## R
5# KEEs6 #'u/uu+R F5O CR QAxC2CMR"qGOCN AxCsDZBIPBRPQ.K HF5Q'DM
BPs%AxBER
5' KEEs6 #'u/uu+R M5A#ELIR Q,A#C2'K AxChP#R H IG@r'uPM5QAxChP''I.DZChPEGFzChP#R

EP,C-EKP?v-w#PHE+LNN |IEPCgRvJwxPHE+LN N$F5ID:{/|{}


IIEP,CEK%D'E:QDZHQ,BP'DZEPD IPHIP$AZ@+wxBA#Ls uA#BDZHNDZEhEKP
I.D'ChPEGF5ChP xPPsEK Ps BGF5xD'QDZHN C2DF5HE.DF5H)EKPIPQLBGF5EGA'@
PDZQ.KhL IP,BRUy$LM5EGFzDZwxPHE/H P,w#A#EGFzD'EGF5A#H$sBAQPIIF5ILIPN?F5H2EK P/IIG
EP,CEA$BP,N LQPh@B.DZQ,EGF5A#HIgD'ChA#Hw$w#BAxL sChP,C?O%P,BI?NL BGF5HwEKP
wxPA#wxB.DZsKF5QDMMzdNF5IEBGF5OL EPNEP'D'CuAxB%R?-y$F5I+L IPNF5H EKP
IIEP,CEA+PHQANPJQAxChC?LHF5Q'DZEGF5AxH$ChPII.DZwxPIRA-PxDM5LDZEP+EKP
sPBG@A#BC^DZHQP A'@+NF"PBPHE$v-w#PHE2y$PNFzDZEP,N{|{}IIEPChIt
uPN P.%HPJEKP/vJw#P,HEUy$PNFzDZEP,Ng{/|{}#PBIGF5AxHgAZ@L BGF5Hw?P,IE
D'H N$ILw#wxPIEJEAL IP+EKF5IJEPIE/EAhQ,A#ChsDZBP+NF"PBPHE+IIEP,ChIR

5' JR%DZLBPMR"qGHEP,BG@rDZQPD'w#PHEI*ChP,E.DZsK AxBIJuF5EK$QKDZB.D'QEPBR


qGH"%+J*/ h#%;#/"z"z.J.5#%t#sDZwxPI
#x n t"vJNNF5IAxHr}PIGM5P PDZNF5H wty$vt # R

}PJsAZF5HEAxL E*EK%D'EPxPHEUsPBQPsEGF5A#HgF5ID`xPB+F5Chs%A#BE.D'HE/E.DZI
F5H$v-w#PHEy$PNFzD'EPN {|{})R}P+s BAxs%A#IPD`CPEK AN$EKDZE/LIPI
D'HPF5w#PHIs%D'QPgEAs%PBG@A#BCEKPgP,#PHEhsPBQPsEGF5A#HE.DZI%RA#B
EKP2Q'DZIPu/K PBP2EKP2HL CO%PBhA'@/NP#F5QPIhF5IKL wxP#tuPs BAxs%A#IP
Dhu/DAZ@QA#HIEBL Q,EGF5H w DZH$PF5wxPHsB.D'C?F5N u/KF5QKQ'D'H O%PL IPN
EA+NF5IQBGF5C?F5HDZEPNF"PBPHE/PxPHEIR*} P/QAxH NL Q,EPs%PBGF5CPHEI/EA
EP,IEAxL B/ChP,EK AN"R

5 n v?RygF5QKA#EEP#R/%`.;m=#h#,#=#Ry$PEKLPH
{A R%mEN6tAxH NA#H"t n R

7.. REFERENCES
R/D'NM5PBR/##""."/J"##.=,#"Gm=#
+,. m=#%h.'#x"=RUKEKPIGF5It
JPsDZBECPHEJA'@*{A#ChsLEGF5H w|QF5P,H QPxt"JHF5#PBIGF5Er$AZ@
A#BAxHEA tA#BAxHEA t"{/D'H%D'N%Dt '#x R


R DQ,I#R%v-QEGF5#Ps%PBQP,s EGF5AxH$IR%sDZIIGF5#Ps%PBQPsEGF5A#H"R"qGH
" =;?**##;%# z#ts%D'w#PI xx t
PMMzDF5BP#t #x R

5Z R%yDZHH"t"v?RPsIA#H"t"DZHN$%R|F5I#F5HN"R/KP
QA#Cs LE.DZEGF5AxH%DMs%P,BQPsEGF5A#HAZ@*IQPHP+NH%D'C?F5QIR
#/"%gm=#$#"+'m",#"#=#t
n  #'%# t"PO BLDZB 'x# R
5' %R%y$Q'JB.D'EK6R#'""'=#2#"hz#.h#R
UBP,HEGF5QPr+DMMt*H w'M5PuAAN {UMF"It Pu P,BIP#t #' R

5' yR%ygF5HI#R/"%?Z'=Jgz"#RJPF5HPC2D'H H"t"AxH NA#H"t


'x# R
5' %
R%y$LMM5PB+D'H N$yRF5IQ.KPMR"y$AN P.MMF5H wgF5HEPB.D'QEGF5Hw$DZwxPHEI
F5H$N HDZCF5QhPH#F5BA#HChPHEIRmqGHU;'.#z#/+5%
U5x"5:* ;%.##';+#J, #
"=5"t'sDZwxPI t"vJCIEPBN%D'Cgt%/KP
PEKPBGMzD'H N"t #' R
5' ?R r?R D'w#PMR%BA#CF5C2D'w#PIPLPH Q,PI+EA'u/DZBNI
QA#HQPsELDM*NPIQBGF5sEGF5A#H"R*h'+#"m=##/"%==t
n  x' t ## R
%R%R *DM5ChPBDZHN$v?RF5PM5NIR{A#Cs LEPB/IL ss%AxBEPN
QAA#sPB.DZEGF5xPhuA#B%RU*#/"%.tyD 'xZ R

.*'%/ x"
)5
 g
  
 
!#"$ $
%. &'("%) % *
+%*!,- %,./*! 0213
0

5798 :2;2;-<=?>$@BAC8DFEHG;#I->JEK; 72>ML!E?=8>MLNMOP8>QD ; 7; >M:2;R8>


46
SUT NE?=?VWX@!; >MEYZ A E; [A]\^IO S WRYV_!_ `'!   %?&a!bQc)d e
)f f
f

#F) g?U&%%"%? hP *)1%!'#M)h+0ij 13


 m)
0
J kl1z

 '#P
m T [.nQ72=:2LNoC;-: = p; AX=?>qOlrPYM;2:-8>J<
s <=tEt=t8>%! u/) "  0 v]
$  %'$*  %% v
!
w 
0 0* g) f ff
eFi? x# '!
* 1 %lh# R*# 
%R* "  *.Q1C*!,')"0!1zZ'x
y 8 T 72>MLN&D 87REG;/zMG;2872Z/8DYM8): =LN {#;2GL|)=8 T 7.B }$~5) d c%& a
) f b}
a'Fx+%!,2%)
)
0 +x`"21%*
"PYM: 7-= pE?A2rl5jNL>A2rX#8)LN3A]L>M<
>M<!; 72A EL>M<)=?> @Z  / 
, R*1"%) 0%%*!,-z)  %) f bb
d!
"m x#*)'!,- *) !'#)
0 +?J*#. M&, %*)
1*!,'Q 1
$t*# 2) *
6*
# * 0" % *x 4
5j78):2;-;2<=?> @A#8D

YM;2:-8>M<]I->ME; 7->JL!Et=t8>ML NOP8>)D ; 79;Q>J:-;]8> SUT NEt=VWX@!; >ME


YZA&E; [.A    %Re )d c #e # w ' * *  
"Qff}

}F% w 0h#%* %*%x#  %


!.)*
Q1Q  %
U .*#. 1
, *!*.  *!,  %% %I->+W7&n =n rPRL>A&8>rWN?N; >;2<A
=?A2=8>rM{X79L=?>6L>M<UO8 8-p; 7L!E?=?| ;/OP8[#p T EKL!E?=8>    %
e}- c!a) b) f b
bFh+0hC'-131#OP8[#p T EL!E?=8>MLN S ;-:2GL>=?A2[FAlD&87#W:)E?=8>
YM; N;-:)E?=8>%'j
   %%Ju&
!X*#]uX*
$ 2$,2
0,&#
v
! %^'U*)j !
!"0 "

 1z)
0 "UQ ff e
F?% 
%P T >J<!L[/; >MELN3A#8D S L!E?7-=OP8[#p T EKL!E?=8>A
!*
U31 '
$*
0% 4
,#v$")ff#
fF *!*)1  
? !

!
0 4
!-1313 
!h)
!% ~
0&*# '
 .) , , ##
zJG;]>M8XN;2<)@$; s > @=?>M;2; 7-=> @
oX; |)=; %Q  -~5#Q dQc) d#) f fd
eRh!C+
%X*) %M 
!#, &0*

,#)%
X*# 1 " hP&,-
$,Q 1*  *x  4 Xx&%'Z,2hP ,20
!,'Q1
x# *#  X*x! *)
+g- !%#hv$ 
e.Rh!C# h` g]%)
0"
?!
!*#I->ME; N?N3=@!; >MEYJ:Q79;-; >
YML| ; 7 A-=> @RI-[/L)@!;R= ]; 7; >M:2; v+! * 
!m) ff f

You might also like