Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COM
GBP 25 - UK, ROW
USD 45 - America
INVESTOR EUR 35 - EMEA
S ERVICES
JOURNAL
FULLY AUTOMATIC?
THE PROGRESSION OF AUTOMATED CORPORATE ACTIONS
PLUS
INDIA - CAPITAL MARKETS CUSTODY FOCUS - ITALY
CARIBBEAN- OFFSHORING ANALYSE THIS - HEDGE FUNDS
EUROPE - OUTSOURCING PANEL DISCUSSION - DATA
EMS - EMPOWERING THE BUYSIDE OFF THE RECORD - SETTLEMENT
of art for future generations or building client relationships that stand the test of time. A full spectrum of global capabilities,
We take our relationship with you very seriously, to help you achieve your business including discretionary, principal
and directed lending, as well as
goals, enhance efficiency and mitigate risk. auctions and exclusives
When you’re passionate about your business, the right relationship is essential. Financial strength
JPMorgan clients benefit from the expertise of our entire global franchise. Through Disciplined risk management
this holistic approach, we harness innovative technologies and firmwide resources Innovation in product development
to offer clients more choices, greater customization and unmatched flexibility.
Access to resources and expertise of
a leading financial services franchise
Innovation with superior results.
The products and services featured above are offered by JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., a subsidiary of JPMorgan Chase & Co. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.,
is registered by the FSA for investment business in the United Kingdom. JPMorgan is a marketing name for Worldwide Securities Services businesses of
JPMorgan Chase & Co. and its subsidiaries worldwide. ©2008 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved.
HEADS UP
INVESTOR
S ERVICES
JOURNAL
VOL 5 No. 29 - 2008 A whole new world
Although it is cliché to say these are dollars, to say nothing of major loss of
interesting times in securities services, face in front of clients and competitors.
there has rarely been a time where this On top of this, the area of corporate
monochrome statement as been more actions processing in the back-office is
apt. The industry is set to change antiquated, manual and inefficient. ISJ
beyond recognition in 2008. Tim takes a look at how automation is
Howell, HSBC's global head of changing the corporate actions
securities services, hse recently stated landscape (p16).
that the bank is attracting hedge fund In our panel discussion, we discuss the
business because of the concern that evolving nature of data management
prime brokers are struggling due to the (p24), and in our extensive Analyse This
credit crunch. The hedge funds, with up section, we ask industry experts about
to USD100 billion in assets, are eyeing the changes in the hedge fund industry,
up HSBC's foreign exchange and both in the front and the back of the
treasury products on top of traditional office (p50). Also, our man on the street
fund administration and custody Brian Bollen, gets the dirt regarding
services. A power shift is taking place, European clearing and settlement (p38),
with a few almighty struggles set to take and we examine how and if European
shape over the next few years. appetite for securities lending is
One major shift in the back office changing (p60). Also, for the first time
taking place at present is in corporate we take a look at the complicated arena
actions. Though it is a little- of EMS systems (p65).
acknowledged fact, and most don't like The obvious theme for this issue is
to talk about it, many of the bigger change. The credit crunch, while
firms have sizable contingency fund focusing on CEOs and other front office
squirreled away specifically for when figures, will profoundly affect how the
they miss a corporate action, according back office will be run. ISJ hopes to
to a data reference manager at the major focus on some of the more seismic
software firm Interactive. This is changes during the next few quarters.
because missing an action can
potentially cost an outfit millions of Giles Turner
I Technology 60
16
24 Panel Discussion
The evolving nature of data
management
I Funds
30 Putting the I in BRIC
Focusing on India
I Custody
33 The next stage
Custody in APAC
14 CEO profile
Ali Pichvai, CEO of Quad
I Regulars
Financial 68 People moves
Custody-Depositary / Trustee
Fund Administration
Corporate Trust
CACEIS benefits from an S&P AA- rating
www.caceis.com
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
The pen is mightier than the sword...If you are affected by, or have
an opinion on, any aspect of investor services please write to giles@
Prize winner 2ipartners.com and enter into the running to win an exclusive Cross pen.
The future of SOR judging the power and efficiency of
SOR technology will develop, and
technology financial institutions will focus more on
Since its founding year in 1846,
the quality of the SOR solutions they
Cross, the leading luxury writing
W
hilst MiFID provides a range of use. For now, performance is the key
opportunities for innovation that instrument manufacturer, has had
driver as it allows brokers to set a reputation for innovation,
affects both the buy- and sell- themselves apart by securing liquidity craftsmanship and design. Today,
side it is multi-lateral trading facilities and best prices as quickly as possible. the Cross collection is comprised of
(MTFs) that are driving innovation. Eventually, the marketplace and well designed and always
Offering an automated means for technology changes resulting from appropriate lifestyle accessories for
brokers to match orders with suitable MiFID may well precipitate a shift in where you work – whether that’s at
trading venues, smart order routing the relationship between buy- and sell- the office, at home, on a plane, or
(SOR) is key to achieving MiFID in your car. These include personal
side. Market evolution may result in
leather accessories, timepieces,
compliance and providing competitive technology moving up the chain, with cufflinks and reading glasses.
advantage. In fact, for most, SOR has the buy-side investing in its own SOR The winner of the letter of the
become synonymous with best systems. This does not mean that the month will receive an Apogee
execution. role of broker will become obsolete. Ballpoint Pen from Cross in a
The evolution of SOR technology will While the buy-side is becoming more Black Star Lacquer finish, hand
be determined by the idiosyncrasies of eager for market visibility, there is still polished to perfection and
the new trading venues and the way the accented by polished chrome
a considerable wealth of trading
plated appointments, worth
financial institutions interact with them. experience and expertise that only GBP60. For further information see
Each trading venue demands a different brokers can offer – and that few www.cross.com
set of SOR logic in order to optimise sell-side institutions would care to
trading opportunities on that venue. forego. However, brokers will need to
This way, SOR will evolve from simply invest heavily in SOR technology in the
Next for FX
splitting orders to become a much more near future and develop the most
T
he FX industry is eagerly awaiting
sophisticated algorithmic mechanism advanced algorithms in order to outstrip the forthcoming final report by the
resolving the best trading opportunities the competition and satisfy customer Committee of Payment and
across multi-dimensional dark and demand. Settlement Systems (CPSS) of the Bank
published liquidity pools – intelligent
for International Settlements (BIS)
liquidity access. Ian Salmon, head of European following its survey of over 100 banks in
As the market fragments, metrics for strategic marketing at Fidessa 2006. This is a major “check-point” as
the central banks pursue their stated
Change is the challenge regulations, at whatever stage of the
economic cycle; I believe ‘change’ is the
policy of pressing financial institutions
to eliminate settlement risk in FX, the
for the Transfer Agent challenge. To meet these challenges, we world’s largest financial market. This
need to have ‘change’ at the forefront of comes at a time of increasing growth in
O
ne of the key themes at the recent our minds. TA’s which can offer genuine this market with broadening
International Transfer Agency choice, scalability, flexibility and the participation, more platform based
Summit (ITAS) in Luxembourg, ability to work with whatever stage of trading and higher volumes in emerging
was the globalisation of transfer agency customer transformation an organisation markets.
and the race to dominate the Asian has reached. The provisional findings released by
market. Fund management companies In a shrinking world, it is only a the CPSS in July 2007, found that 55%
are clearly becoming more interested in matter of time before TA’s offer a of surveyed FX obligations are settled by
Transfer Agents (TA’s) who can help with seamless global service. Until then, the CLS, the only global settlement system
managing market volatility at home, key thing is to distinguish the TA best for eliminating settlement risk. This
whilst enabling wealth creation in able to handle consumer’s needs, figure is growing year on year. Fund
emerging markets. whilst managing change, wherever they related FX accounts for a significant
Looking at technology and how it can are in the world – in other words, change proportion of the outstanding 45%.
guarantee robust, real-time support, for is the challenge. Settlement loss is the potential loss of
complex fund structures and a the total value of the trade due to failure
consistent cross border service, with David White, executive director, by the counter-part to deliver, and this
support for unique national rules and Mutual Fund Technologies risk applies to funds. CLS has seen a
;aZm^WaZhdaji^dch!iV^adgZYidndjgcZZYh#GZaVi^dch]^ebVcV\ZbZci!
Wj^aidcYZZeZgjcYZghiVcY^c\#HZgk^XZZmXZaaZcXZ"i]VindjXVciV`Z
[dg\gVciZY#8aZVghigZVb#G^\]i]ZgZ!l]ZgZndjcZZYjh#
HZiiaZbZciVcY8jhidYn"<adWVaHZXjg^i^Zh;^cVcX^c\">ckZhibZci;jcYHZgk^XZh \ZibdgZ
?!D?)NVESTOR3ERVICESINDD
LETTERS / NEWS
significant number of funds become CLS risk and operational profile for is testament to the growing awareness
participants recently, evidence that the fund managers. amongst funds of the need and ability to
funds community is undergoing a shift in Settlement failure can be caused by a eliminate settlement risk. At the last
sentiment towards FX risk. Why is this? number of things, including counterparty quarter date, CLS settled 199,140 fund
As the global economy evolves, collapse, incorrect settlement related instructions with a gross value of
investment managers are turning to the instructions, and human error. Collapse USD521 billion.
international marketplace for higher of counterparty is a rare event, although Furthermore, by demonstrating to
returns and are also viewing currency as the failure of Barings Bank in 1995 is clients, auditors and risk managers a
a non-correlated asset class with evidence of that catastrophic risk. More sharply reduced exposure to settlement
significant opportunities for improved common, particularly around high risk and the virtual elimination of
alpha. Others are uncomfortable with the volume points such as the IMM quarterly failures, investment managers decrease
exposure to currency risk in their settlement dates, are operational errors the funds’ liability to claims and other
portfolios and use forward contracts to and failures. settlement charges.
hedge that risk. As FX becomes more CLS settles the matched payment The consultative CPSS report noted
prolific amongst portfolios, investment instructions related to foreign exchange that despite banks pushing over half of
managers are taking the initiative to offer deals in pairs in real time, eliminating all FX volumes through CLS, further
best practice in both risk management the time zone differences that cause progress was needed for institutions to
and cost control. But how do investment payment delays and give rise to properly control their settlement
managers eliminate the risk of loss in FX? settlement risk. With growing volumes exposure. Current market conditions
Many investment managers historically and values being traded on behalf of accentuate the need to control
traded with only one counterparty, their funds by many investment managers, operational risk and adhere to best
custodian. This avoided settlement this operational control and oversight of practice, and therefore the market will
risk because only the custodian is the settlement part of FX deals has been certainly see financial institutions,
involved in debiting and crediting the the missing link in the life cycle of including asset management houses,
sold and bought currencies. For trading and settling. continue to take the necessary steps
competitive reasons, and often to comply The number of investment funds now towards eliminating FX settlement risk.
with contractual obligations more fund registered as CLS third party participants
Jonathan Butterfield, Executive Vice
managers are now trading with a range of (gaining access to CLS through their
President, Marketing & Communication,
broker banks. This has changed the custodian banks) has reached 2038 and
CLS Bank International.
Cross-Border
TOP RATED 2007
Leading Clients
TOP RATED 2007
Domestic Markets
TOP RATED 2006-2007
and Alistair Darling, UK outlined by the industry in its Securitization Forum and the
chancellor, include the formation latest letter. Securities Industry and
of a UK-US regulatory body, which Financial Markets Association
will offer “individually tailored” MARKET INFRASTRUCTURE asked for acceptance of AAA
international supervision for Oslo - Goldman Sachs has started rated securities in an April 2
leading banks and financial direct trading in equities on Oslo letter to the Federal Reserve
institutions with who are involved Børs and the regulated market Board and the Federal Reserve
in significant cross boarder place Oslo Axess from Monday 31 Bank of New York.
activity. March.
Including Goldman Sachs, Oslo TECHNOLOGY
New York - The Operations Børs has 61 members, of which London - A recent panel debate
Management Group (OMG) has 37 are remote members trading on electronic trading in Europe
submitted to Timothy Geithner, from offices outside Norway. The has highlighted the importance
president of the Federal Reserve number of members on Oslo of technology to leveraging
Bank of New York, its latest set of Børs are doubled over the last liquidity, the role of electronic
goals for strengthening seven years. On Oslo Axess there trading and the impact of dark
operational efficiency across is 46 members, including pools during a series of panel
privately negotiated credit and Goldman Sachs. Goldman Sachs discussions.
equity derivatives products is the third new member on Oslo
Consistent with ISDA’s primary Børs and Oslo Axess in 2008. London - NYFIX, a provider of
purpose, to encourage the innovative solutions that optimize
prudent and efficient SECURITIES LENDING trading efficiency, has announced
development of the privately New York - Wall Street is lobbying the acquisition of UKbased
negotiated derivatives business the Federal Reserve to take bonds FIXCITY, a specialist in web-based
via the continued standardization backed by student loans as electronic trading and liquidity
of documentation, promotion of collateral in its new lending discovery solutions.
sound risk management practices facility to stem a slump in
and education of the market demand for the debt that’s NEWS DAILY AT
place, ISDA endorses the driving lenders to stop writing WWW.ISJNEWS.COM
commitments and expectations loans. The American
www.securities.bnpparibas.com
NEWS ANALYSIS
Another
custody businesses like Nordea that
“simply cannot weather the pressures”,
adds Silitschanu.
one bites
Stemming from the acquisition, JP
Morgan is to make available local
depository services to locally based
the dust
Nordic mutual funds. It will open new
branches in Norway, Denmark and
Finland and additionally is set to grow its
presence in Sweden.Conrad Kozak, global
JPMorgan Chase head of JPMorgan’s Securities Company,
acquires Nordea says: “This acquisition emphasizes
JPMorgan’s commitment to the Nordics.
t’s certainly been a busy month for realized that it is simply not comfortable as ”This latest move makes JP Morgan the
to have a minimum of 20% of the equity other mortgage lenders, preferring to postal mail. Ah well, could have happened
in their home and will have to pay a fee, grow its business “organically”. to anybody.
calculated from what the borrowers “We have a building society model Meanwhile, Britain’s debtors and
original rate was and the size of the where we use retail deposits and the homeowners shifted uneasily on news that
mortgage. HSBC has estimated 75% of bank’s own capital. After growing retail there was a 2.5% fall in house prices in
the new customers will pay less than deposits in the last three years as people March, the largest since the early 90s.
GBP1,000. have looked to save cash with large Gordon Brown’s statement that the price
In the current doleful lending climate institutions like us, we are in a good fall is “containable” is unlikely to comfort
the bank can afford to do this as it does position.”Thorpe goes on to warn that the many, especially in the light of the IMF’s
not borrow its money to finance deal will not be ideal for everybody. “We recent warning that the British economy
mortgages from money markets, as many don’t want this to come across as the is heading for a substantial downturn and
of its rivals do. And the banking giant has golden goose of mortgages.” that house prices in the country could
admitted that rather than a planned Nevertheless, a deluge of new business decline by up to 10% in 2008.
course of action, the move is purely in is expected. The bank has said that it has Recently Caroline Flint, the minister of
reaction to the market. moved staff from other areas to help with state for housing and planning, shrilly
Speaking on the circumstances that the new business. denied a BBC presenter’s accusation that
allowed the bank to make the offer, Overall this could turn out to be a very Labour’s claim that the boom and bust
HSBC’s James Thorpe said: “It’s a number shrewd piece of business for HSBC, and a years were no more, has been
of factors, primarily we had a very little self-congratulation is probably going embarrassingly shown to be false, as the
conservative policy towards lending on over HQ. The bank needed some good storm clouds gather on the economic
which admittedly hasn’t made us made us news following on from the embarrassing horizon. Though some, like HSBC, find
the most competitive in the past.” He debacle last week when it lost a disc themselves in a position to take advantage
also cited the fact that HSBC does not sell containing the names and insurance data of current climes, most will have to
mortgages through brokers and on 370,000 customers. How did this whether the storm, crunch, crisis or bust,
intermediaries and has not bought any happen? They sent it by unregistered whatever you may call it.. I
SEB is the leading provider of custody and clearing Our commitments are efficiency, reliability and
services in the Nordic/Baltic region. Business is built providing the highest service quality.
on long standing partnerships with our clients.
it is decentralised. We are going to see a changing the market, making it more happening with technology today.
lot of innovation in this field. This is why complex and global. We are living in an Formerly algorithms allowed you to take
we developed what we call the advanced evolutionary and complex system. What decisions purely on certain mathematical
execution platform. That’s the vision we is changing rapidly is that liquidity is rules, now the rules are a framework with
had at the beginning, but it takes time to changing in nature becoming which you look at different events in the
implement it. We have been working on it decentralised and most asset classes are market and you take decisions all the
for a while, but we are now gaining becoming electronic. Therefore you can time. It’s not just one set of rules, or one
momentum, it seems that the vision is do everything electronically out of a pool set of decisions. Now, liquidity searching
shared with our market participants. of liquidity that is scattered across a few means that you build a certain number of
places. The buy side who is the final algorithms that predict how the liquidity
What experiences from your time at NET2S investor now has a cross asset type of is on the market. The models we are
have you brought to Quod Financial? investment strategy, but the systems are applying allow you to predict where the
not yet multi asset or cross asset, liquidity is and where it is moving. But
The first thing is obvious. At NET2S
therefore there is an appetite for systems it’s a predictive model and so you have to
we saw multiple cases of how technology
that can look for liquidly and do it in a make decisions, which are contingent on
can be implemented in the trading arena
multi asset fashion. It’s not just different what you see on the market at the same
and this knowledge was the foundation of
trading areas it’s different assets. This is time. Quod brings to the market an
Quod Financial. Secondly, in building any
the highest level of complexity to have advanced execution platform, which is
company you learn a lot of lessons about
cross asset trading because you have to the latest in this kind of technology and
management, whether it’s how to take a
know the liquidity profile of each asset allows you to take dynamic decisions all
company public or how to survive a
class or instrument of asset class, you the time because the machine reacts to
recession. One of the hardest lessons is
have to know how they are tied together, every piece of market data. This wasn’t
how to manage people; how to attract the
it can only be done with machines not on true even three-four years ago.
best talent, how to keep them motivated,
a human basis it’s just too complex.
how to help them grow, but also how to What are your goals for the future?
get rid of non-performing people. I did an MiFID rules seem to have dramatically
MBA and it never prepared me for I have promised myself that my next
changed European Capital Markets, what is company will be a non-commercial
management. That is a skill that doesn’t
come from knowledge of a market place;
your view on these changes? What have venture. I don’t like the word charity, but
it’s something that you have to learn they affected already and what will they it should be a company which helps other
through doing and taking risks. At change in the future? people to achieve their own goals. There
NET2S we went up to a thousand A lot of brokerage houses and buy-side are different phases in life, in the first
members of staff, managing a one houses see MiFID as a cost, but beyond phase you want to achieve and you want
thousand strong company is very the cost MiFID was the catalyst for to prove that you are able to achieve
different from managing twenty, fifty or a changes which are very positive to the something. Once you have done it a
hundred people. At NET2S we were in 8 market. They have encouraged the few times you realise you are playing the
countries, the cultural differences development of a pan-European capital same game more or less, even if it gets
between how people lead the same markets space rather than a fragmented tougher and tougher. After a while you
company in different geographies are national base. MiFID has made Europe have to find something else to
fascinating. You learn everyday, you also more transparent, much more than the challenge yourself. Doing a company for
make mistakes but you also appreciate the US. I believe in transparency in general, non-commercial purposes, in a
differences in different cultures. because it allows for as much information more altruistic manner, is the next
as possible to be shared in an equal challenge for me. I
The increasing complexity of trading manner between market investors and
technology is often blamed for the participants. This in turn ensures that
fragmentation of liquidity in the market, Ali Pichvai is CEO and founder of
there is more competition in the market
what is your view on this? Is fragmentation Quod Financial, which is a provider of
place, which is good for the market place.
a bad thing? A lot of things that were happening in the advanced execution technology for the
US didn’t happen in Europe because global capital markets. Prior to
Technology empowers, but it also founding Quod Financial, Pichvai
MiFID was the impetus for change.
changes the landscape via positive started NET2S Group in Paris in
feedback on the environment. Quod recently produced a white paper on 1996, a capital markets technology
Technology is evolving and enabling a consultancy. He has a Masters in
the need for a fresh approach to algorithms,
lot of things that a lot of traders and Engineering (Physique et Chimie
investors wanted to do, but it also creates
how are Quod’s liquid seeking algorithms
different from previous algorithms? Lyons, France) and Masters in Business
a new reality for new practices and Administration (Bocconi, Italy).
models to emerge. This therefore is There is an evolutionary process
Fully Automatic
As firms acknowledge that they must automate their corporate
actions, Joe Corcos takes a contrasting look at the progress that is
being made in Europe and the US
ike trips to the dentist, corporate actions can be GoldenSource, says: “The US obviously benefits from
The last eight years has seen a steady rise in the volume of corporate actions. In the 2008 the volume is set to be more than
five times the amount recorded in 2000. This is a trend that is not likely to abate, as firms in the US increase cross border
activity and developing markets in Asia and the Middle East look to attract foreign investment. Last year developing markets
rivalled the UK and Ireland in the growth of corporate actions messaging, closely followe by the Asia Pacific region.
strategies to diversify into international securities." still a long way to go. One of the examples could be the
Of course the most pressing issue to be addressed is ISO 15022 method, the Swift. There is much more
that of standardisation. As the volume of corporate acceptability in Europe for using Swift than in the
actions and the blizzard of electronic messaging that states.
they require steadily increases, companies in both the "Standardization of the messages and the market
US, throughout Europe, and elsewhere, must be on the practice would definitely help a lot. In the case of US
same page, data wise. you have the US domestic market and you have the
"I think a standard is desirable, I also think its international market. In the US domestic market
practical impossibility", says Raeves. everything is as per DTCC."
"There isn't a single governing body, and that could The fact that Swift is a European-based organisation
be a regulator or exchange, that could be effective," he also partly explains why it has stronger influence in
adds. Europe. However, the Americans have acknowledged
the fact that despite the size of
their domestic market, they too
Overall - though the automation of corporate actions has come on must adopt ISO, an act that will
by leaps bounds in the last five years - many companies still rely hopefully boost the already
rising appeal of foreign
on the manual methods that have been serving them for decades markets in the US. Swift is now
working with the DTCC to
"So the standardization can only happen on a lower that end.
technical level, where you say ok there isn't any true David Hands, director of product management at
fiscal or legal harmonization of real world stuff, what DTCC says: “We're working extremely closely with
we can do is at least make sure that when we start Swift. I would imagine in the future ISO will get a lot
sending these things around as electronic messages more play than it does today.
that we do that in a language or format that is at least “Traditionally where ISO has not gained much
understood by all of our machines in the same way." foothold is in the US, because people will always base
Currently the ISO 15022 messaging standard, their corporate actions off DTTC files, and I don't
developed in 1995, is the only messaging standard think that inhibits any cross border trading, but acts as
used widely. Swift (Society for Worldwide Interbank a alternative to Swift standards in the US so with our
Communication) has been busy pushing the standard new files going out in ISO we're working very closely
in Europe and more belatedly in the US. with Swift to modify the 15022 standard to
Ashok Panda the product director of corporate incorporate those data elements we need included in
actions at TATA says: "In Europe to some extent the standard.
[standardization] has been achieved. Though there is “When you step back and look at the changes that
Global Corporate With DTCC’s Global Corporate Actions Validation Service you get:
Actions
UÊÊÓ{Ê
ÕÀÊ}L>Ê>ÕViiÌÊV>«ÌÕÀi]ÊÛ>`>ÌÊ>`ÊÃÕ««ÀÌ
OTC Derivatives
services
Mutual Funds
UÊL>Ê
À«À>ÌiÊVÌÃÊ`>ÊiÝ«iÀÌÃiÊ>`ÊÜi`}iÊv
Managed Accounts
V> >ÀiÌ «À>VÌViÃÊ
Alternative
ÛiÃÌiÌà U ,i>Ìi >VViÃÃ Ì >ÃÌ Ó }L> ÃiVÕÀÌià £ÈäÊ
countries
ÃÕÀ>ViÊ
UÊÊÌÀ>`>ÞÊ«ÕLV>ÌÊviÃÊÌ>Ài`ÊÌÊÞÕÀÊÃiVÕÀÌiÃÊvÊÌiÀiÃÌ
U -iÀÛVi iÛià `ivi` LÞ ÕÀ VÕÃÌiÀÃÊ
UÊÊÊ«>ÀÌiÀÊVÌÌi`ÊÌÊLiÃÌÊ«À>VÌViÃÊ>`Ê`ÀÛ}Ê`ÕÃÌÀÞ
standards
UÊÊÊ«Ài`VÌ>LiÊVÃÌÊÃÌÀÕVÌÕÀi
www.dtcc.com
CORPORATE ACTIONS
are required, you're reengineering your internal old systems in place, one of the major blocks to
systems to accommodate this stuff. I think that 15022 automation, incorporating old legacy systems, is not so
has done a good job setting the scene.” much of a factor.
Linda Bookheim, a corporate actions expert at Swift, Mansur says: "Markets like China are definitely
acknowledges: "In general in the US market, how it starting to automate, and they're starting from
does corporate actions is very domestic based. scratch, looking at the mistakes that other markets
"Our role in the US market is about providing have made and saying, 'ok, we need to automate this
guidance and cross border communication. So with process from the beginning, using newer technology,
DTCC adopting the ISO standards it will make it not old legacy tech, that can be easily updated and
much easier for the US community, as they start to adapted to changes in the market'".
increase their cross border investments, to use Swift to He adds that other developing markets, like Dubai,
communicate to the counter parties that are indeed not Taiwan and South Africa have also realized that if they
on the continent." desire foreign investment, they must move their
systems from the old-
fashioned paper-based
Somebody once said that in life the only certain things are death and model to one that is
automated.
taxes. Most financial institutions can add corporate actions to that list The technical hurdles
that must be vaulted by
Bookheim's colleague, fellow Swift corporate actions a company are one of the major disadvantages for an
expert Max Mansur, admits that there are certain outfit that is considering automation. Overall it is a
"data element translation issues" in the US, but that costly, sometimes lengthy process, with any number of
these are being rationalised with the ISO standard and pitfalls.
being incorporated. Recognizing what is realistically achievable is key to
Meanwhile, in Europe there is what Mansur calls a avoiding an overly lengthy and painful process. Raeves
"tremendous amount of harmonization", with the says: “I think people have over-reached themselves
overall goal of the continent being able to act as a sometimes. They haven't simply said we want to make
single, harmonized market. sure that for all of the corporate action notifications
Of 15022 Hands says: “Its quite dynamic and almost that we receive, we have a single validated gold copy,
over-flexible people are saying these days. There's a which is a realistic ambition.
movement to refine specific data content within the “What they've done is said, what we want to do is
message because it leaves less room for interpretation, receive all the data and apply it to all the position
and if you do that people use the standard more entitlements and make sure that we are doing all of the
appropriately, and as people do that adoption will voluntary processing. That makes it a project which is
continue to grow.” a multi-year project which means that measuring the
However, some are less enthusiastic about the benefits is difficult. You also have corporate risks,
supposed popularity of the ISO standard. Steve Miller, including losing your executive sponsors and
senior product manager at SmartStream Technologies corporate management teams. That has been the
says: "Lack of standards has been the main barrier to experience of a few of the earlier adopters.”
automation in general, and take up of ISO15022 hasn't According to Harries, integration of older systems
been as wide as is needed to fully take advantage of the presents a major challenge. In fact he estimates that up
standard. to 60 per cent of the cost of automating corporate
"Swift is doing more and more work in this area but actions is on the integration side of things.
we have seen reluctance, historically, for US He comments: "One of the things we've seen is not
institutions to buy into the work Swift has done." about standards, it's a little closer to home. It's the
Miller went on to admit that though eventually a internal systems where the actual data resides..
standard may emerge, it will "not be in the foreseeable "Some of the bigger obstacles aren't necessarily
future", and referenced the fact that the financial about market practice, standards and adoption of Swift
services industry is "littered with failed initiatives". messages, they're closer to home in terms of building
And yet companies in the US and Europe are the integration, that is a key element in the success of
forging ahead with automation, though they are by no a project.”
means the only ones. Asia and the rest of the world are Harries goes on to warn that any company
catching up fast. According to Swift by far the fastest considering automation should be sure to select a
growth in corporate actions automation is occurring in vendor strong on integration, otherwise "you're
Asia Pacific and developing markets. left with a significant part of the puzzle that has not
Furthermore, since these markets often do not have been solved."
John Byrne, the CEO of Information Mosaic, agrees: Bookheim says: “The cost of implementing a system
“Early on a lot of people have had a bad experience is an impediment, it requires building your own or the
with automation. When you go into down stream purchase of third party software, and in all cases it
processing of automation the systems require a lot of requires a really strong business case.
integration. To automate corporate actions correctly “It's hard to quantify a business case that is based on
you have to be able to reconcile and see all of the potential risk rather than something that's going to
positions that a firm has, correctly.” benefit you and make money.”
Overall, though the automation of corporate actions However, the reality of these possible catastrophes is
has come on by leaps bounds in the last five years, it is considered imminent enough by many institutions and
by no means universal, and many companies still rely many have established a sizable contingency fund just
on the manual methods that have been serving them sitting waiting to be deployed, claims Sey.
He comments: “If
you speak to a
Automating corporate actions helps cut down not only the likelihood number of the
investment banks in
of financial disaster, but also saves on time and resources the industry if you
ask them if they have
for decades. contingency funds for corporate actions they may kind
Nat Sey, the reference data business manager for of shift uneasily, because no one wants to admit to it,
Interactive, calls corporate actions “the last bastion of or indeed the size of these sorts of contingency funds.
manual processing”. But its pretty much accepted wisdom that they do
Many custodians have succeeded in automating exist because in a manual corporate action world
their corporate actions process, as have sub-custodians making a mistake is pretty inescapable at a certain
and data vendors, however the issuers have been point, that's the sad fact.
slower off the mark, generally continuing to pass on “There are pretty severe penalties in place for
notices to the rest of the market in a text form. This missing corporate actions and I don't just mean
makes things ever-more complicated for those further necessarily monetary penalties, there's reputational
down the chain. risk involved here as well in terms of missing a
Panda says: "In the last five or six years the corporate action.”
automating of corporate actions has evolved quite a The undeniable fact remains that by making a large
lot. But as far as the adoption of that by the different portion of corporate actions automatic, the risk of
financial institutions is concerned I'm not very sure being hit is lessened. Some actions of course cannot be
about that because whilst they keep talking about it, automated, but automating the ones that can, it frees-
there is not very much progress in that respect. up more people to look at the ones that can't.
"It almost looks as if they know that it has got to be Sey continues: “The goal of automation is not to
done but they haven't yet taken a decision. They're just receive 100% automation, which is not achievable, you
sitting on the wall and trying to take that jump." need to have a pair of eyes looking at certain processes.
Part of any reluctance to adopt automation of But what automation does for you is to allow you to
corporate actions is to do with the very nature of them. shift the focus of the manual processing towards the
One of the most obvious reasons to automate one's more esoteric events, which are naturally the events
corporate actions is to try and reduce the possibility of which carry more risk”.
missing one and being hit by a financial body-blow as It is simply a matter of encompassing all the data
a result. However, for an outfit that has not suffered flows hitting one's business, whether they are in
such an event, or perhaps whose memory of such a manual or electronic forms.
calamity has faded, there seem few pressing reasons to Somebody once said that in life the only certain
initiate the costly and possibly fraught move to things are death and taxes. Most financial institutions
automation. can add corporate actions to that list, and that being
“On the business side, too often corporate actions the case, automating them helps cut down not only the
have been viewed as a huge challenge offering less likelihood of financial disaster, but also saves on time
strategic benefits than processing new instruments, or and resources.
as being forced on firms due to the need for regulatory Currently the US and Europe are leading the way in
compliance. As a result they are put on the backburner automation, and both sides of the Atlantic are making
in favour of other projects. It has been a reactive approximately even progress, with Europe slightly
process in that it's not until something goes wrong, edging the US. Overall the progress of automation can
causing a significant operational loss or customers be likened to the gruelling winter breeding trek of the
service issue that corporate action's automation is Emperor Penguin - slow, painstaking, and somewhat
given priority.” inefficient, but determinedly inexorable. I
22 INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL
Take
Control with Transaction Lifecycle Management®
www.smartstream-stp.com
PANEL DEBATE
Evolution
Our panel of experts ISJ
debate the evolving
nature of Data
PANEL DEBATE
Management... Data Management
Robert Cumberbatch is the European business lines director, Pricing
and Reference Data, Interactive Data (Europe). Cumberbatch joined
Interactive Data in June 1998 as production director to run the
company's IT operations. Cumberbatch was responsible for the
mission critical IT infrastructure with a 24 x 7 data centre, a 24 x 6
technical support group, network support and project planning. From
January 2003 Robert led an international real-time integration of
ComStock's infrastructure into that of Interactive Data.
Is improving data quality across a firm a incomplete or untimely data – or from the adopting the concept that data needs to be
technology issue or is it more about the gains that can be enjoyed by enriching treated as an asset. Once a piece of data
cultural practices of the firm – should clean, existing datasets. Firms must decide enters the firm, it needs to be scrubbed,
concise data be treated as a higher priority whether their information assets tagged, and tracked as it moves through
throughout the lifecycle of a firm? adequately meet their organisation’s the platforms and downstream systems.
information needs and take the The ability to measure data quality
Cumberbatch: Often, improving data appropriate steps to ensure that they do. through a formal data metrics program,
quality across an organisation is a The aim of this approach would be to which is a constant 24 hour process, is
technological, cultural, organisational and move away from, or to avoid, inefficiency vitally important to the equation. A data
procedural issue. Each of these areas can or to seek further benefits. governance structure is also critical.
have very different drivers and needs, and Rules must be applied to manage conflict
occasionally these drivers are in conflict Orphanou: Data management is both a resolution properly, exercise control over
with each other. For example, the search technology and cultural issue. As data who can change the data and under what
for speed can drive IT architectures to be volumes continue to grow exponentially circumstances, and ensure that the
more distributed, spreading processing due to rising transaction volumes and systems communicate smoothly.
capabilities closer to where they are regulation, it is crucial that firms adopt an The strongest operators in this market
needed most, whilst the principles of a enterprise wide approach to data will look at culture and technology as
‘golden copy’ can drive the push for management and that this is given high being equally important. Though
centralised data repositories. priority at every level within an technology is needed to power the
The need to improve data quality can organisation. solution, at the end of the day, people are
stem from the inefficiencies caused when driving the technology and choosing to
decisions are based upon inaccurate, Kelsey: Organizations are increasingly make the investment based on importance.
Nordea Bank AB (publ)
Making it possible
PANEL DEBATE
Is improving data quality across a firm a incomplete or untimely data – or from the adopting the concept that data needs to be
technology issue or is it more about the gains that can be enjoyed by enriching treated as an asset. Once a piece of data
cultural practices of the firm – should clean, existing datasets. Firms must decide enters the firm, it needs to be scrubbed,
concise data be treated as a higher priority whether their information assets tagged, and tracked as it moves through
throughout the lifecycle of a firm? adequately meet their organisation’s the platforms and downstream systems.
information needs and take the The ability to measure data quality
Cumberbatch: Often, improving data appropriate steps to ensure that they do. through a formal data metrics program,
quality across an organisation is a The aim of this approach would be to which is a constant 24 hour process, is
technological, cultural, organisational and move away from, or to avoid, inefficiency vitally important to the equation. A data
procedural issue. Each of these areas can or to seek further benefits. governance structure is also critical.
have very different drivers and needs, and Rules must be applied to manage conflict
occasionally these drivers are in conflict Orphanou: Data management is both a resolution properly, exercise control over
with each other. For example, the search technology and cultural issue. As data who can change the data and under what
for speed can drive IT architectures to be volumes continue to grow exponentially circumstances, and ensure that the
more distributed, spreading processing due to rising transaction volumes and systems communicate smoothly.
capabilities closer to where they are regulation, it is crucial that firms adopt an The strongest operators in this market
needed most, whilst the principles of a enterprise wide approach to data will look at culture and technology as
‘golden copy’ can drive the push for management and that this is given high being equally important. Though
centralised data repositories. priority at every level within an technology is needed to power the
The need to improve data quality can organisation. solution, at the end of the day, people are
stem from the inefficiencies caused when driving the technology and choosing to
decisions are based upon inaccurate, Kelsey: Organizations are increasingly make the investment based on importance.
Nordea Bank AB (publ)
Making it possible
PANEL DEBATE
An airplane cannot fly itself; it must have keep up with data streams coming in from comply. On the other hand, there are
a competent pilot at the helm, who not exchanges and OTC markets this decade. principles within many regulations that
only understands and can operate the At my current firm 29West, we saw this do overlap. For example, many directives,
technology but also evaluates the real requirement back in 2002 and responded such as the Capital Requirements
world external and practical issues. The by designing messaging systems for Directive (aka Basel II), MiFID and
difference here is that the pilot transporting data messages at speeds as others under the Financial Services
understands the importance of data low as 15 microseconds (0.000015 Action Plan, share common goals in
quality, and using technology properly. seconds) over modern networks and principle. These common goals, which
Though some financial institutions have operating systems. I see many systems at focus on minimising the causes and effects
not always understood this, I think the banks, exchanges and hedge funds today of negative consequences, can include
recent climate has caused cultures to struggling with the tradeoff between strengthening approaches to managing
change and drive their technology toward speed and accuracy. At 29West, we risk, protecting investor interests, and
data quality. provide messaging systems that provide cementing confidence in financial
“guaranteed” messaging at microsecond markets.
Raeves: It depends where you are on the speeds. This is extremely useful for Other aspects of regulation have an
chicken and egg question...It is both a ensuring that a compliance system enabling approach aimed at stimulating
technology and cultural issue. The root actually receives all the trades executed competition and growth; for example
causes of having bad data are a mix of by a high-speed algorithmic trading UCITS III’s product passport, MiFID’s
poor behaviours, institutionalised neglect, system. Or that ALL orders routed to an organisational passport and the removal
and siloed business functions. For all the electronic exchange are both recorded of the concentration rule. Compliance is
pious noises about the central role of data, AND delivered in time to get decent clearly enough, but firms can choose to
financial institutions do not define execution. take further action to grow their business
themselves as data processors - they are in I have seen many examples of data whilst reducing costs. The
the business of making money. If that problems caused by the underlying implementation of new directives and the
means creating another data silo to start application messaging systems simply removal of previous legislation can enable
trading a new product, so be it. losing data or getting so far behind in firms to seek and obtain opportunities to
On the flipside of that argument, the processing the data that it’s not useful to work differently. For example, UCITS
adoption of a shared data software the business. However, the culture of III’s product passport can provide firms
platform can and does trigger a lot of firms that are winning says, “OK, we have with the opportunity to promote products
existential questions about data big technology challenges, but data in new EU countries, whilst MiFID’s
ownership, standards, and governance. So quality is critical to our firm’s integrity passport permits a firm to set up business
no - technology is never the driver, but it and market standing, so let’s do whatever in a new EU country.
can be a catalyst for forward looking firms it takes to solve these problems.” In reality, taking the time to step back
- it is only when you start the process of Ultimately, the firms that understand that and look at the overall picture is the best
automation that you are forced to make a data quality determines the quality of all approach, as it can help to avoid
complete inventory of requirements - and their business decisions will endure and duplication of compliance measures. In
those requirements are more often than prosper. reality, this takes time and discipline.
not in the domain of behaviours, company So yes! Clean, concise data should be Often firms are forced to look at each
culture, and governance treated as a higher priority throughout directive in turn, assess its individual
the lifecycle of a firm. impact and take the appropriate measures
Meinel: Improving firm-wide data quality to maintain compliance.
today is ultimately about cultural How can firms organise their data to not only
practices. However, several thorny meet current regulatory requirements (Basel Kelsey: Risk management is a pronounced
technology issues can impede data quality II, MiFID etc) but also future requirements? theme among our clients right now. It is
even in a firm that really understands the Or will they always be rushing from one understandably tempting (and sometimes
criticality of firm-wide data quality. One regulatory data project to the next? necessary) for firms to drop everything to
newer thorny issue most firms face in chase after one regulatory 'have to' after
today’s environment is dealing with Cumberbatch: Firms are often torn another. But firms are so concerned right
timely delivery of data when trade times between doing just enough to comply now with exposures and managing what
are being measured in milliseconds. Even with individual regulations, and adopting is in their portfolios, that we find they are
firms like UBS, my former firm, that industry best practices, to establishing doing a great deal of self policing. As a
invested and focused on global data sets thought leadership positions. On one best practice, the most sophisticated firms
for most of their businesses throughout hand, certain regulations can encourage a are looking ahead of the curve to areas
the 1990’s, faced the reality that many of minimum best practice approach, i.e. where regulation has lagged but are
these systems were not fast enough to doing the very minimum is sufficient to obvious suspects for future scrutiny.
In order to get ahead of the curve, firms regulatory data project to another. If their data as a means of competitive
must organise data from multiple sources your business has not had this focus in the advantage, the outsourced model may not
so as to understand exactly what is in past, start a business unit whose success is be ideal. Data is an enterprise asset and
their portfolios. They must also ensure critically dependent on the kind of data, protecting this is critical, also questions
that there is clear data governance in messaging, and reporting infrastructure may arise over the audit ability of
place, and rules of engagement as to how that makes it easy to respond to outsourced data management. As a result,
their downstream systems communicate. regulatory demands. Start a cross some organisations will always prefer to
product risk trading unit or provide prime handle data internally.
Orphanou: There is no doubt that the brokerage for a hedge fund and your firm
introduction of new regulations such as will be facing many of these types of data Kelsey: Outsourcing and offshoring are
Basel II, the Markets in Financial issues. The business manager of one of central elements to any organization's go
Instruments Directive (MiFID) and the these units that is succeeding in the to market strategy. Going forward, we
Single Economic Payments Area (SEPA) market will be more demanding than any will see a fundamental shift toward
has put the issue of data management in regulator. outsourcing and the range of services
the spotlight. By investing in EDM and offered by firms, including the purchasing
ensuring it is given high priority What is the cost/benefit return associated and provision of data management
throughout the organisation, financial with outsourcing and or offshoring (security, sources. As the markets continue to
institutions can ensure their data regulatory, legal etc) and has that altered in evolve, we are likely to see a mesh of
management is in good shape and has the recent years? providers emerge, which provide a hub of
flexibility to meet any future regulatory data services to the market.
obligations. Cumberbatch: The benefits of offshoring or Offshoring has certainly helped to
outsourcing can be reducing costs, streamline parts of the data management
Raeves: At the lowest common increasing a firm’s resource capacity and process that are more routine, and there is
denominator level, many of the recent and taking advantage of centres of excellence a compelling cost savings element.
announced regulatory requirements share and competence that are not deemed to be However, firms often underestimate what
four essential characteristics: of strategic benefit to an organisation. it takes, and how quickly subject matter
Quantity: firms need to capture, store These are very important considerations expertise can be developed. Institutions
and distribute more data than ever before for a firm, as unsuccessful offshoring or must recognise that there is no conveyor
(more sources, more internal customers, outsourcing initiatives can prove costly to belt for market knowledge, no substitute
more reporting channels) reverse and put a firm at a competitive for people who have deep knowledge of,
Granularity: higher levels of detail and disadvantage. for example US Fixed income, or
more integrated and connected data sets These benefits have very different value Canadian equities. As firms continue to
Quality: firms must be able to show propositions to firms. For some time, learn from their experience in offshoring,
where the data came from, how a golden reducing costs seems to have been the they will invest more heavily in
copy was created, and the complete audit most attractive reason for offshoring or automation, either directly or via an
trail for composites and individual outsourcing, but this has also proved to be outsourced firm, and put systems in place
sources the largest source of dissatisfaction. As to make up for knowledge gaps. This has
Timeliness: firms must be able to send demand for these ‘cheap’ and capable to be part of any cost/benefit equation.
data in near time - batch processing is out, resources increased and began to
event-driven is in approach supply, then so did their cost. Raeves: Outsourcing and off-shoring does
If they want to create an EDM However, increasing capacity or using not necessarily translate into
program that allows current and future centres of competence to augment straightforward savings - the business
compliance - these four fundamental existing resources introduces different benefit is more about focusing your
qualities need to be included in the design benefits. Here, the focus is on expertise, business on what it does best. Some firms
of the solution. Scalability and future which an organisation doesn’t need to are making the call that managing data is
proofing translates into four golden rules: own or simply does not have. Clearly this not a core competency, others feel that
store more data, understand the structure is less ‘cost’ sensitive to where many much of their market differentiation is in
of it, make sure you can trust the sourcing outsourcing and offshoring organisations their unique understanding of highly
and derivation of the data, and get it in will be heading. complex financial products, closeness to
and out of your infrastructure quickly. their customers, and detailed
Orphanou: Managed Data Services are a understanding of their counterparty risk.
Meinel: My experience in this area is firms viable option for the smaller firms. Hedge There is no right or wrong answer here -
that focus on firm-wide risk management funds in particular tend to outsource data it is tightly linked to how firms define
are usually a bit ahead of the regulators management to their administrators. themselves and what differentiates them
and do not need to rush from one However, for those firms looking to use from their competitors.
comes in, it needs to be treated as an asset achieving this, not least inflexible legacy
Meinel: Although costs are going up in and tracked. Where it goes, how it is infrastructure and the wide range of data
many traditional offshoring locations, the stored, and who can change it is a vital terms from data providers. Flexibility and
benefits are still there for traditional data component to achieving automation. integration is key and financial
cleansing work, generating reports and institutions should look to make more use
for engineering messaging and data Cumberbatch: Automation is a better way of SOA. EDMs should do more than
infrastructures. 29West has several to manage both pricing and reference simply collate, cleanse and store data. By
clients that are connecting middle and data, as the manual collection, re-keying encompassing workflow orchestration
back office groups in India or Asia or US and processing of data will inevitably lead and automating its distribution to
non-financial centers to front office to errors. While automation can reduce downstream applications financial
groups in NY, London or Tokyo using our errors caused by manually moving or institutions can significantly reduce costs
enterprise messaging solutions. Since the entering data between different systems, and improve risk management.
abilities of firms to include offshore it also speeds up the process of making
groups in the culture of the onshore firm this data available to the applications that Raeves: Automation levels in the financial
has improved it is feasible to move even need it when and where required. services industry obey a strict one-way
more responsibility to these “offshore or When errors occur, they must first be logic: virtually all data and most processes
nearshore” groups. identified, then diagnosed and then are suitable for automation, and there is
successfully resolved. When manual no case for manual processing other than
Is automation the key to better organisation processes are used to share important inertia, underfunding, or short-termism.
of firms’ reference data management, data between different applications then Technology is ideally suited for high-
enabling them to better manage risk and cut any errors are very complicated to volume, repetitive processes - and the
costs? And what are the obstacles to getting identify, to diagnose and to resolve. The very business model of the mainstream
a clear view of clients’ data? time taken to resolve these issues can banking and investment industry is
disrupt time-critical workflow processes predicated on scale and cost-effective
Kelsey: Most data and technology experts and thus lead to considerable expense. growth. Finance and IT are a very good
agree that virtually anything in the data The old school means of handling data match.
realm can be automated - it's a function of in individual silos, which focused solely on The challenges of client data are a little
priority, time and investment. But there is the requirements of each business different from product data: products are
a danger in assuming that there is a silver function, often resulted in a number of exchanged between trading parties, but
bullet. Automation needs to deal not only disparate systems. Many firms now focus the (necessary) illusion of unique
with the data itself, but the software and on open access and sharing a ‘golden customer relationships means institutions
platforms that house the data, as well as copy’ across the organisation. Information are loath to consider their
the applications that fuel the business. technologies can achieve this, but other customer databases as a commodity, in the
There is clearly automation in and considerations, such as information same way they would with a security
between each of these layers, which gets security, need to be considered as well. master file. This means there are no
challenged at many points along the way. Information needs to be shared when it is standards for uniquely identifying
At the data level, organizations often required, by authenticated consumers customers, there is no de facto data
want to take the best of class data from who are authorised to see it and with oligopoly in the same way it exists for
several sources. This creates mapping appropriate accountability. product data, and there is no perceived
and normalizing challenges - if you look business driver to make customer data
at even a few standard data fields across Orphanou: Inaccurate data creates a huge more interchangeable.
organizations, more often than not they operational risk and reworking failed or
don't match. It also creates timing broken investments costs the industry Meinel: Automation is key to managing
challenges, making it critical to millions of dollars annually. In particular, reference data. However, I have seen
understand when and how each source reference data underpins every banking several firms technology groups over-
updates their data. product and achieving Straight-Through engineer their automated solutions for
At the software or platform level, firms Processing (STP) represents a significant reference data. New types of reference
will seek to build a competitive advantage opportunity to reduce transaction costs. data are being generated every day. I
by differentiating. This often introduces It is important that an organisation’s favor automated solutions that focus on
proprietary middleware, which means systems all use the same high quality providing key subject matter experts with
more automation challenges. Finally, reference data and that this reaches the highly automated toolsets as opposed to
legacy applications and databases often appropriate business functions efficiently. systems that try to completely automate
exist to do very specific things, and are This will reduce reconciliation issues, and out human expertise and judgment. By
structured accordingly. Again, it's back to improve risk management and choosing and designing a clear
recognizing that once a piece of data compliance. There are many obstacles to standardized publish/subscribe
mechanism into their reference data transparency and can get a more complete want to know risk of issuer but who owns
architecture, firms can leverage the understanding of the financial them, so counterparty information
expertise of a domain expert across instruments streaming through their becomes a key consideration.
product silos. For example, it’s typically applications and databases, and as a result Another form of risk often overlooked
much better long term for an equity manage risk more effectively. in this type of discussion, which can
system that needs forex information to benefit from data management and
leverage the actual reference data used by Orphanou: The sub-prime crisis has investment, is trade settlement risk;
their forex group than by reinventing it highlighted the importance of ensuring specifically, reducing trade failure rates.
or doing it themselves.= financial institutions have access to the This is a form of risk that, in many ways,
In my experience, one of the main right data to evaluate risk. While its organizations have a greater degree of
obstacles to maintaining a clear view of impact is yet unknown, the crisis may control over than the market risk of the
clients’ data is that firms affect the reference data requirements current credit crunch. By that I mean, the
frequently approach client data systems as associated with assets. Financial better the data management capability,
if client data is “static”. That is they put institutions may look to store more and the frameworks that power them, the
much more effort into designing ways to information on customers and more lower the risk of trade failure.
access the data than they do into ways to closely evaluate the risk of investing in
publish changes to client data. The certain products. Financial institutions Raeves: Yes, the credit crunch centred
reality is that client data is much more require a significant history of consistent, around some very complex financial
dynamic than people realize and can be accurate and granular data. EDM products, but reacquainted the industry
handled with the same sorts of data solutions that centrally collect, manage that - however ingenious the financial
management architectures used for and retain critical operational data will engineering - you need to be able to
dynamic data such as orders, trades, and help practitioners to analyse and make answer the basic questions: what is the
payments. better decisions about their credit risk product, how much is it worth, how do
exposure. Such a system also makes it you price this asset, who is my
Has last summer’s credit crunch forced possible to audit data from the point of counterparty on this contract?
firms to take data more seriously to help origin to consumption. It illustrated the gap between the
manage risk? small specialist group of quants and
Kelsey: Absolutely. The turbulence in the engineers who understand the products,
Cumberbatch: Recent events, from the credit markets over the last year has made and the risk, control, and finance
volatility of the global financial markets it imperative that investors measure infrastructure of the wider institution. It
to the sub-prime crisis, have put a exposure and monitor risk very closely. is clear now that CROs and CFOs will
spotlight on risk management and the For most financial firms, this is very high actively corral the sharp end of the firm,
essential reference data supporting this on the agenda right now. and what they need to do is get the right
process. Only by optimising reference The credit crunch not only changed the data - so that the numbers and
data management, and thus having an in- complexion of the portfolio mix, but the calculations that are used for the
depth knowledge of the millions of degree of scrutiny the underlying trading and investment activity, are
instruments flowing through its systems, instruments receive. Though cash the same ones used for risk and exposure
can a firm take a holistic approach to issuance has dried up considerably, management.
effectively managing risk. Critical to this, portfolio managers still need to achieve A shared, centralized and standardized
is the ability to take a 360° view of each returns for their investors, and still need data architecture is what is needed for an
financial instrument . to achieve diversification. They are effective risk architecture - it is the only
Effectively managing and reviewing increasingly turning to the way to catch risk as it flows through the
reference data can help investors derivatives markets as an alternative, and system - whether it is market, credit,
understand the underlying dynamics of a are taking a more global approach in operational or legal risk.
security and help them determine their search of investments. Because each
risk exposure. For example, even though transaction is bespoke, the volumes in the Meinel: Yes. The complexity of the fixed
a security may have an AAA rating, that derivatives markets are eclipsing those of income securitization products clearly got
rating may be supported by internal or the underlying cash instruments. And a lot of attention the last several
external credit enhancement. To they are far more complex to value. months. These particular products are
understand the risk profile of that While lack of transparency in pricing notorious in their sensitivity to data
security, it can be crucial to know complex instruments might have been errors in reference data. I expect firms
whether that credit enhancement will tolerated in a bull market, this is no that continue to trade and deal with these
hold up under stress. With consistent, longer the case; it is simply becoming too products to invest seriously in improving
timely and accurate reference data, much risk for the return for investors to data accuracy and timely deliver of data to
institutions can gain additional bear. Additionally, investors don't only their risk managers. I
Building BRIC
As one of the BRIC markets (Brazil, Russia, India, China),
India challenges China’s development hegemony
in the Asian region. Jamie Darlow looks at why it is such an
investment hotspot and the development of its capital market
ast month, the Ford Motor to a recent report from Celent. average saving rate is 35%, higher than
says it is expected that by 2010 there will Limited, Punjab National Bank, and a series of recommendations for a phased
be anything between 50 and 60 AMCs in General Insurance Corporation of India. liberalisation of controls on capital
India. “The more the AMCs, the more the The transaction is expected to close in the outflows over a three year period. A full
need for need for depositaries, clearing first quarter of 2007. description of the recommendations can be
houses and custodial services,” he Investment in and out of India is huge seen in our boxout, but Daswani from
explains. and the staggering growth in savings and Standard Chartered outlines the
“There is good potential for all such GDP in India has left the regulatory implications here: “Our view is that clearly
businesses in India. Presently, this area is behind in some instances. The rupee is still authorities are relaxing controls over
serviced by the large international banks, subject of controls implemented by the capital flows we are going to see only
and some domestic ones,” continues Securities and Exchange Board of India gradual move towards capital accounts
Sinha. “Down the line, this particular (SEBI) - foreign investors must register convertibility. Near term fiscal overruns on
sector is definitely going to grow because with the regulator. Today there is partial wage revisions for government staff, high
there is a high demand for these services capital account convertibility, where an spending on social sector and so on, along
and as of now the demand exceeds supply. individual can invest up to USD200,000, with turmoil in international financial
Apart from domestic players, it is part of a phased roadmap for convertibility markets might slow down the pace of
expected that international players will of capital accounts driven by the Tarapore liberalisation. Similarly opening up of
come in to fill the gap.” Committee. “Captial account convertibility banking system to foreign ownership will
The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) for us is a 'process' and not an 'event',” a be gradual, and rightly so.”
Group also showed interest in India in spokesperson for the exchange explained. International organisations such as the
early 2008, buying a 5% equity position in While there are conditions to full European settlement service, Euroclear,
the Mumbai-based National Stock convertibility for capital accounts, are anticipating any liberalisation will
Exchange of India Limited (NSE), the including tight control of both inflation lead to an increase in their reach in what
maximum investment permitted by a and fiscal deficit as a percentage of GDP, must be the world's worst kept secret,
foreign investor in a stock exchange under which has to be within a certain range, the Indian economic expansion. This year
the securities laws of India. The stake is country is expected to see full account Euroclear sign a memorandum of
costing the exchange USD115 million in convertibility within a few years. “The understanding (MoU) with the Central
cash from a consortium of selling government of India is taking steps to Depository Services (India) Limited
shareholders, including ICICI Bank make Indian currency convertible on (CDSL) to foster greater cooperation.
Limited, Industrial Finance Corporation of capital account.” Philip Reichardt, head of International
India Limited, IL&FS Trust Company The Tarapore Committee has also made Collaboration at Euroclear, explains the
motivation behind the pow-wow: “We counterparties worldwide. offered by market pundits whenever the
formalised our relationships with an Investment into India is becoming market rises it is attributed to foreign
MoU so that we can exchange easier and more mainstream. March saw investors' money, no wonder we see
information freely. From our side, we will Standard & Poor's launched an index headlines like "Flls Fuel Rally" (Foreign
give them insight into European designed to provide investors with Institutional Investors), in the business
domestic and cross-border transaction tradable exposure to the Indian equity press. This is not unusual with India alone
processing practices as they are keen to markets, listing ten of the largest and most as most developed economies of today
bring themselves in line with liquid Indian companies which trade on might have seen a similar trend in the
international standards.” developed market exchanges. past.”
Reichardt explains the opportunities: Mutual funds are also beginning to But there is a dark cloud on the horizon
for India, given the recent downturn in the
“With the accelerating trends of reforms Indian stock US economy that still accounts for around
a fifth of the world's GDP, according to the
market will witness more and more of institutionalisation IMFs 2007 figures. This depends on the
and the increasing size of money under control” extent to which India has 'decoupled' from
the US, according to Daswani. “The idea
“A lot of the opportunities for us depend develop in India, says Reichardt. “We've of a complete decoupling, in which a US
on how foreign banks are allowed to seen interest developing for these funds on slowdown had no impact on India, is
interact with local banks. In most the international front, with investors clearly implausible given the
instances, the local market is keen to get wanting to add these to their foreign interdependent, linked-up nature of the
involved with Euroclear as we are seen as investment holdings. The Indian equity world's modern globalised economy. For
a proxy for foreign investors. In the markets are still very retail based, but it's proponents of decoupling, the world
Indian market, we work with a large growing and expanding,” he explains. economy is now less dependent on the
network of foreign banks and domestic “Expect to see growth continuing as the United States than before because of
Indian financial organisations. With a few government is keen to nurture the development in China and India, increased
exceptions, the domestic Indian banks are development of more professional advice intra-Asian trade and a more vigorous
not as well known internationally for Indian private clients - and Indian European economy. There can never be a
because they haven't had the business private clients know they need more decoupling from the US economy but the
opportunity.” professional advice because they can't keep magnitude of the impact will not be what
Arun Tiwari, head of the Mumbai office pace with all of the changes, like every it was in the past.”
at Swift, comments: “Economic other market. India has been a safe bet up RBC's Sinha agrees the US subprime
liberalisation in India has come a long way till now, but professional investors must crisis will affect India: “there is no country
and it is on an irreversible path supported know how to manage money in down as in the world that can say a US recession
by all governments that have been in well as upward markets.” will not affect their country. But India will
power since the early nineties. With this in Institutional investors have had an not be affected that much. The total
the background, it will be only natural increasingly important role over the past exports to the US from India represent
that we'll see increased partnerships & 15 years, with foreign institutional around 19% of Indian exports. Ongoing
cooperation between Indian and western
markets.”
Euroclear has existing MoUs with the “The idea of a complete decoupling, in which a US
other depositories in India, the National
Securities Depository (NSDL), the
slowdown had no impact on India, is clearly implausible
depository for the equity market, and the given the interdependent, linked-up nature of the world's
Clearing Corporation of India, a central
securities depository that specifically modern globalised economy”
handles the settlement of government investors and Indian mutual funds now demand in domestic consumption means
securities. Meanwhile, the NSDL has not responsible for assets under their that any decline from exports will be filled
been idle, signing an MoU with Taiwan management representing around 18% of by the domestic market.”
Depository & Clearing Corporation the entire market capitalisation. Stan Chart's view is slightly more
(TDCC) in February. “With the accelerating trends of sobering. “Asia will not be an oasis of
Back in India now, and Swift opened its reforms Indian stock market will witness prosperity in case of a global slowdown,
first office in India in Mumbai late more and more of institutionalisation and and the stock market could be hit hard.
November last year. The organisation said the increasing size of money under the India is doing terrific but no one can be
it is strengthening its presence as a direct control, this set of investors will play a granted immunity in a global
result of sustained growth and major role in Indian equity markets,” slowdown. India may feel collateral
development of the financial services explains Daswani of Standard Chartered. damage in the equity markets,” says
sector in India, and in particular the “The importance of institutional investors Daswani. However, India is certainly
proliferation of international relationships particularly foreign investors is very much better placed to withstand a US
between Indian financial institutions and evident as one of the routine reasons slowdown than a decade ago. I
“Pension fund reform and mutual fund reform and the growth Guardians. The Future Fund was created in 2006 by the
in the number of products, combining with a relatively wealthy Australian government to accumulate sufficient financial assets
local community makes for market potential in Korea,” he to offset the government's unfunded superannuation liability,
continues. “The community is increasingly looking for cross which is expected to grow to over AUD140 billion by 2020.
currency exposure on those investments - many are not happy Superannuation is expected to have a similar, albeit smaller,
having their pension plan entirely linked to the Korean market. impact on Australia's antipodean neighbour. Guardians of New
There has been a thirst for more structured products therefore, Zealand Superannuation's selection of Northern Trust as its
away from the traditions of the cash account. That's driving a lot custodian for the New Zealand Superannuation Fund's (NZSF)
of growth - the demand to get into equities and international NZD11.5 billion (USD8 billion) assets. Northern Trust took
equities, where traditionally they had been money market custodial responsibility for the fund's assets on 1 July 2007.
orientated.” Japan also still holds growth potential, according to Chong
Inbound foreign investment has been possible for more than a Jin Leow. “All markets in Asia represent ongoing opportunities
decade in Korea, albeit with the usual requirements such as for growth,” he says. “In Japan, the worlds second largest
registration with the securities commission. Elliot says Korea economy, we are witnessing the emergence of some of the
has been a pretty structured market but
that we are now seeing liberalisation with
new regulation coming through - currency
liberalisation for example, including
Increasingly, investors are relying more on independent,
account convertibility. bespoke research and less on the traditional bundled
Liberalisation of markets seems to be
something common among developing
research widely distributed by global investment banks
APAC markets. Taiwan, Malaysia, Thailand
and Indonesia, and of course India, are all taking steps to open largest pension funds in the world entering global investment
up markets and promote foreign investment. Privatisation is markets, leading to incredible opportunities for cross-border
expanding the value of capital markets in all APAC countries, custody and securities lending. In some instances these pension
making them attractive to foreign investors from Europe and funds are managing in excess of USD1 trillion in assets each,
the US. Taiwan and Korea have both recently introduced private and growing monthly.”
pension schemes. Developed markets means developed and diverse investments
The other driving factor is of course the growth in the and therefore advanced services are required and it is the
number of those wanting to invest. The middle classes are developed markets that tax the resources of custodians the most.
growing in number across Asia causing domestic custody to Where markets are nascent and expanding rapidly, funds are
increase. India is slated to become a USD1 trillion market in usually investing through equities. This is meat and drink to the
assets under management for wealth management providers by custodian banks, who already have all the technology and
2012. This is thanks to the dramatic growth in middle class experience required to service those clients without much
individuals who are expected to save money and will represent additional investment. There are still huge profits to be made in
42 million households by 2012, according to a recent report the developed markets but this comes with the need to innovate.
from Celent. Funds in Australia, for example, can demand daily valuations,
Indian custody is covered in more detail in our special report, high volume fund switching solutions and capabilities, daily
which reveals the country is fast approaching developed market compliance and performance monitoring, and unitised
status, at least in terms of custody services and the size of the accounting.
market. Those markets considered 'developed' in the APAC Asia is seen by most custodians as purely a growth area, yet
region - Japan, Australia and New Zealand - still have potential there may be some tough times ahead for the funds they service.
for growth, however. “In Australia we find an extremely mature There is much speculation about whether the Asian economies
pension market, but one of the most vibrant hedge fund, private will be badly hit by the US downturn, as they were in 1997.
equity, and offshore fund markets in the world representing Chong Jin Leow says that in 2006 and early 2007 there was
significant high value avenues for growth and expansion for talk of Asia 'decoupling' from the US and Europe and becoming
global custodians with the ability to support these investment a region immune to the economic forces of the US and Europe.
models,” explains Chong Jin Leow. “I believe that the current market conditions serve to
Superannuation in Australia pushed pension fund assets past highlight the recognition that if anything, Asia has emerged as
the AUD1 trillion mark in 2007 and the market is expected to a participant in the global economy and as such feels the impact
grow to AUD1.8 trillion by 2011 and AUD3 trillion AUD by of any economic turmoil exhibited in the world. So, yes, our
2016, according to the Australian Finance Group, Global Funds expectation is that funds will be under pressure in the short
Management Index. The impact superannuation has had on the term as investors attempt to understand the true extent of the
market should not be underestimated - Northern Trust entered credit crisis in the US, however we also expect Asia to
the Aussie market in 2007 with a staggering AUD51 billion recover very quickly given the strong economies that have
(USD42 billion) mandate from the Future Fund Board of emerged since the 1997 crisis in the region,” he concludes. I
exchanges have been behaving like will reshape the European landscape, key questions raised by the CSDs on
English Premier League clubs like bringing structural change and greater governance, feasibility, end-user costs,
Chelsea or Manchester United, pursuing efficiencies.” among others, it could be a jump into the
their own interests to the exclusion of Those mild-mannered people at unknown that Europe's CSDs could find
the good of the game.” It is also plain as Euroclear are far too polite to speak out themselves signing up to.”
a pikestaff that the combination of aggressively and start rocking EU boats, Impartial market observers will surely
political interference and the naked self- even if it means reaching the desired utter a quiet three cheers for the
interest of many if not all of Europe's settlement solution more efficiently and Euroclear way, if only because it is
becoming tangible, and, so far, seems to
work, and is already better than the
"If you are a local player, you are competing planned official alternative. “When we
launch our Single Platform, for instance,
head-to-head with institutions that have a global client it will be multi-market and
base; and that is very difficult " multicurrency. It will process domestic
and cross-border securities transactions
as well as custody, collateral
central bankers threatens to scupper the more quickly, but maybe someone else management and securities lending
private sector's dogged attempts to can do it for them. “Euroclear is neutral transactions on the same platform,
deliver a single, efficient set of plumbing on whether Target2-Securities should covering about 50% of the European
for Europe's financial services industry. go ahead, but we need more information securities markets, while Target2-
Just as Euroclear appeared to be in order to make an informed decision on Securities will only perform the
making demonstrable progress with its behalf of all our clients,” comments Paul settlement function in euro only,” says
efforts to harmonise the five markets in Symons, Director and head of Public Euroclear's Symons.
which it now has a direct presence (the Affairs at Euroclear. In the meantime, the Nordic markets
UK, Ireland, Belgium, France and the “We are looking for ways to cut tariffs to which he makes reference have
Netherlands) and where its long awaited and costs, and believe that we are undergone something of a
single settlement engine has been up witnessing the benefits of competition in transformation in recent years, the most
and running since January 2007, the action as the Commission's Code of recent landmark event being the
European Central Bank's politically Conduct on clearing and settlement, and completion of the takeover of OMX by
driven determination to explore a new platforms emerge at different points Nasdaq, which also owns, to some
mechanism dubbed Target2-Securities of the business. The best providers will extent or other, the CSDs in Iceland,
came out of the blue and hangs over the in the end attract the most business, and Estonia, Latvia and Lithuainia, notes Ulf
market like a dark rain cloud. It will be this will drive consolidation between Noren, SEB's head of sub-custody client
interesting - possibly even riveting - to providers or force a rethink of their relations for the Nordic and Baltic
pick over in detail the results of the strategies. The ECB is looking to create markets, as well as Germany, Ukraine
consultation exercise on the ECB's a monopoly, and we have to ask the and Russia. Norway remains a refusenik,
telephone book-style document on question honestly: which is the best ploughing an increasingly lonely
Target2-Securities, published last solution? The reality is that there is a looking furrow, but anyone who knows
December. The market expects the ECB variety of answers. In the meantime, Norway and its inhabitants will
to decide by the summer of 2008 Euroclear has moved on, and the Nordic recognise the behaviour pattern. There
whether to press ahead with it, or CSDs are following a similar plan in is no way the country will fall in line
whether to kick it into the long grass terms of CSD consolidation and market- with its neighbours just because
where it can quietly disappear and practice harmonisation. There IS light at everyone expects them to, and even if it
vanish from the collective memory. I the end of the tunnel. We conceived our is the most advisable thing to do. In the
personally sense a strong preference for model in 2002 and the target meantime, Ulf Noren points out, ChiX
the long grass scenario, especially from implementation dates seemed very far has now started trading in Sweden and
those who have dedicated money, time away, but suddenly they are arriving can be expected to take 10-20% of
and effort to get us where we are today. thick and fast, and we are delivering on liquidity from the market, and maybe
In the meantime, as Tony Freeman, our promises, which is important for us even more from Finland, where it was
Executive Director of Industry to do. It has been a major challenge, scheduled to begin trading on April 4.
Relations and Market Growth EMEA at involving investment of over 500m. “We are going to see a lot of trading
Omgeo in London, puts it: We are in a Some time after Target2-Securities was fragmentation as the various exchanges
holding pattern in Europe. Planes are first mooted in July 2006, our user- and platforms compete with one
stacking up in the skies over Heathrow populated Board instructed us to carry another,” he predicts.
Airport, waiting to land on a new on and deliver our new business model There is no doubt that 2008 will be a
runway: Target2 Securities. If it is built, as soon as we could deliver. Once critical year, says Paul Bodart, general
and there is a lot of political weight completed, our programme will provide manager of the Brussels branch of BNY
being thrown behind it since the shocks 300 million per year in savings. Unless Mellon. “The push given by the
sent through the markets last summer, it the ECB provides convincing answers to authorities is starting to help, and the
Code of Conduct will be important in average of just under 100bn a month in clearing and settlement saga, and
driving things forward,” he adds. The 2007, but revenue increases did not Euroclear is one of those bright spots.
complexities and difficulties that lie grow by anything like the same “Plumbing takes time to install, but we
ahead, however, are illustrated by the proportion, highlighting the need to are near to having a single process in
sentence that follows: “We have seen 25 keep up the drive to reduce inefficiencies Euroclear. My guys just don't see the
requests from different parts of the still further. point of Target2 Securities, but it seems
overall infrastructure to connect to one Hardly were these words out of as if Clearstream and/or the German
another and so far only one has Thomas Zeeb's mouth than news broke authorities have been nibbling at the
materialised: the first and only practical that Settlement: The Next Generation, ECB's ear. If you've been working on the
CCP interoperability solution under the might be showing at cinemas near you Euroclear project for all these years, it's
code of conduct is the agreement sooner than you thought. Seven leading a bit harsh if a public sector-driven
between LCH Clearnet and Xclear CSDs - Clearstream Banking AG, intervention kicks in just after you finish
(LSE) for peer-to-peer clearing Frankfurt (Germany), Hellenic a decade's work.”
services.” One down, 24 to go. Adds Exchanges S.A. (Greece), IBERCLEAR The key problem, according to some
Michael March, director of corporate (Spain), Oesterreichische Kontrollbank of those close to the coal face, is the
communications at LCH Clearnet: AG (Austria), SIS SegaInterSettle AG vested interests of many of Europe's
“Although the Access and (Switzerland), VP Securities Services central bankers, who are seen to be
Interoperability provisions Code of (Denmark) and VPS (Norway) - signed dragging their feet, in the way that we
Conduct was signed with some fanfare an agreement in early April to establish might expect of turkeys being asked to
in mid-2007, outside London there Link Up Markets, a joint venture to vote for an early Christmas. In short,
remains scant evidence that access is improve efficiency and reduce costs of they want to hang on to their own job
being opened.” post-trade processing of cross-border and the very nice lifestyle that goes with
Elsewhere, Clearstream, whose securities transactions in Europe. that job. Anyone who has been in a taxi
parties at the big set-piece gatherings
are renowned for being much much
livelier than Euroclear's, reaffirms its
belief that the ideological battle between
"One of the problems is that we have spent the best part
two different views of the future has of 20 years getting the central banks out of the
been over for some time and that new
considerations face the market. “The settlement system - now they're coming back"
debate about whose model is best -
Euroclear's, our own or Target2 The Link Up Markets initiative is a driven by a former currency trader will
Securities - has become less relevant result of the changing market recognise the syndrome.
now in today's world of interoperability environment and aims to promote “One of the problems is that we have
set up by regulatory initiatives such as simplified cross-border business as spent the best part of 20 years getting
the Code of Conduct,” says Thomas requested by the Lisbon Agenda, the central banks out of the settlement
Zeeb, executive board member proclaimed the official announcement. system, now they're coming back,” says
responsible for Clearstream's client The seven CSDs believe that improved one market participant. “Another is that
relations. “Also since the events of last interoperability between CSDs with a the determination of ECB president
August the focus has switched to finding single point of access for customers Jean-Claude Trichet to be lender of first
liquidity, to keep the markets results in significant cost reductions. resort when the credit crunch began last
functioning efficiently. We already have “For many years, summer has neutered the commercial
an extremely efficient system both customers have been requesting a banks. The ECB's readiness to wade in
domestically within Clearstream solution for easy access to other and take rubbishy bonds and CDOs as
Banking Frankfurt as well as markets,” said Jeffrey Tessler, Chairman collateral in return for real cash means
internationally, either through the of Clearstream Banking AG, speaking that the banks are literally indebted to
subcustody network, or via using the for the joint venture. The CSDs him and his institution for billions and
bridge with Euroclear and into domestic participating in the initiative have billions. They won't say anything to
markets. We are also seeing dramatic developed a unique solution geared at upset the applecart. They will zip their
increases in competition from our reducing the complexity and the costs of lips and get on with it, even if there is a
traditional competitors as well as new cross-border transactions. We establish bad smell coming from the project and
market entrants; the market has already an environment that creates the the way it is run.”
benefited from this fierce competition potential to reduce current cross-border Please tell us, dear readers, he must be
between Clearstream and Euroclear and settlement costs by up to 80%” Link Up mistaken, surely. A quasi-Governmental
there are more new players looking to Markets is scheduled to be launched in institution putting its own interests
carve out a slice of the action for the first half of 2009. ahead of those of the markets it is
themselves.” As evidence of the pressure While we wait for the dust to settle, supposed to help and those of the people
on both price and service, he adds that our anonymous mole argues that there it is supposed to serve? Whoever heard
Clearsteam grew its assets by an are bright spots in the European of such a thing? I
OUTSOURCING
Hedge funds and funds of funds, part of the governance of that money. We to have someone on the ground who
venture capital, property funds, complex do the performance, regulatory, IFRS know the local regulations, the local
derivatives; all need specialist custody and accounting reporting for them and legal regime, the people, the language
and administration. And although the have provided such services as well as the etc. Services providers that have a global
behemoth players will be doing sufficient insurance piece to retirement company footprint are ideally placed to take on
business volumes to warrant significant AG2R,” she says. this function and accompany clients on
infrastructure investment in supporting Schoen echoes the trend for this sort of their journey up the value chain.”
such investments, niche and smaller client. “ We see a lot of pensions funds The demand then, is for services
players almost certainly will not have and sovereign wealth managers who have providers that are able to offer a modular
that critical mass.. looked to diversify their investments but type offering on a single platform.
This is where the market shows the need help in the back office. This is And some might say that the initial
most potential, according to Mark prevalent throughout the Nordic region landgrab type deals were a failure for the
Schoen, head of product management and especially in Sweden,” he says. services providers in that they ended up
EMEA at Northern Trust. “In this Add to the mix the increasing cost of running several different platforms at
environment you have the perfect compliance, regulatory requirements to great cost and inconvenience to
landscape to buy in components of have risk properly assessed, the ability to themselves.
outsourcing. There are lots of challenges independently value derivatives, as well As if to prove the point there have
with alternatives such as liquidity, as do a good job of servicing the asset in been a number of headline deals that
pricing, cash management, and the fist place and it is easy to see why have been reversed; In 2005 JP Morgan
performance calculation. Systems that smaller and medium sized players such as had abandoned its five-year struggle to
are alternatives literate cost a lot to buy corporates and pensions funds are now at implement an outsourcing deal with
in and then implement. Although you can least considering an outsourced Schroders and ended up paying back
get by on excel up a point there will be a arrangement. some GBP20m (e30m) Were those deals
tipping point where a dedicated system is Philip Courtines comments: “In a failure due to the lack of focus and
required.”
By way of illustration Schoen points
out that a long only system has maybe 10
Take the role of the transfer agent. It has gone
to 20 critical data elements compared to from being a bundled service to now being potentially
between 20 and 50 for a derivatives based
investment. a distribution support type service for
And Philip Courtines adds: “Doing it
all in house when it comes to private
asset managers that have a product they would
equity, structured products, funds of like to sell in unfamiliar territory
hedge funds, or real estate funds is not
really viable. Plus you can't use systems Germany for example, the regulation has definition in them? Could experiences
like SWIFT so if a third party has the changed so that institutional clients now like these now be put to best advantage
know-how and the resource to manage it require independent reporting. This is on the continent?
thus adding value for the asset manager very important when you consider that Connor thinks so: “Players in
then it would be foolish to not consider reports have traditionally been done by continental Europe will now have a
outsourcing.” the asset managers themselves. The pace better service to choose from. Services
She comments that it is this need for of regulation is pushing the industry to providers are in the midst of maturing
innovation with newer asset classes and have more independence.” their initial offerings and can now
investment structures that will, thus Indeed third party providers, if they offering out a tried and tested package
drive change.“One of our important are to capture some of this business need that is more suitable for mid market
client groups is corporate entities who to be able to provide a service that is not players who don't necessarily want to let
manage significant monies but simply just about making cost savings for the go of everything, “ he says.
want to focus on their core business and client but that actively support the Being able to mix and match the client
partner with a provider who has the product range and adds value and can offering but operating on a single
critical mass required to administer it protect the asset manager's revenue platform in a standardised fashion is
effectively.” stream. clearly essential in the current climate.
She gives the example of EDF and Take the role of the transfer agent. It Cook comments: “The days of huge lift
Areva, both of whom have been awarded has gone from being a bundled service to outs are gone and so now it's down to
public money to deal with nuclear power now being potentially a distribution being able to offer the client x and y, not
stations and waste and have then support type service for asset managers the whole alphabet. We've found this to
outsourced to a third party asset managers that have a product they would like to be a more successful business model as it
plus are using BNP Paribas Securities sell in unfamiliar territory. is more scaleable and allows us to have
Services as an full outsourcing partner. Philip Courtines comments: “If you are clients running on the same platform
“In addition to core custody and asset trying to market a domestic product in rather than trying to run many different
servicing, we do all the reporting and are other countries then it makes clear sense ones,“ he says. I
Regulating paradise
Joe Corcos takes a look at the motivation behind
the regulation efforts from the main Caribbean
domiciles and what the future holds for the region
These days it seems like every piece of change and adapt to varying demands of This may be due to enhanced risk
rock in the middle of an ocean is trying to their clients. And the last few years has management and compliance controls in
transform itself into an international seen many of them carefully and industry since the introduction of the
funds centre, with varying degrees of painstakingly add well-crafted new statutory requirements for systems,
success. Malta has set itself up as a regulations for their funds industry. procedures and training.
specialist in fund of funds and even Most of these regulations are less to do “There is a strong compliance culture
Gibraltar is attempting to get in on the with the actual monitoring of funds in in the Cayman Islands. The Cayman
action. Meanwhile, Jersey and Guernsey place, and more to do with who gets in Islands specifically have worked
are forever attempting to expand their and who doesn't. Monitoring is often diligently to develop a very robust anti-
funds markets, despite a perceived limited done elsewhere. money laundering regime that is
capacity. Darren Stainrod, the head of fund comparable with most Western
So where does this leave the services for UBS in the Caymans, says of jurisdictions.”
Caribbean? For a long time this region the location: "The Caymans continues to As well as recently revising its Mutual
was regarded as a hotbed of tax evasion be the domicile of choice for new hedge Funds Law and Money Laundering
and money laundering, the place to go fund launches. Regulations, The Caymans has just
when you wanted something set up "Other jurisdictions like Bermuda and signed a memorandum of understanding
quickly and with little scrutiny. Discrete, the BVI are starting to replicate with the UK's FSA to exchange
fast, and oh yes, boasting fantastic Cayman's successful legislation. As other information and aid each other in
beaches, the Caribbean was the go-to domiciles attempt to carve into this investigations.
option for all and sundry. market, they are faced with changing the And additional to its anti-money
However, this perception faded some mind-set of the regulators and those that laundering efforts, the Cayman Islands
time ago and since we have seen a work in the industry." Monetary Authority (CIMA) has been
transformation of sorts, with locations After first being developed as an continuing to attempt to perfect its
like Bermuda, the Caymans and BVI offshore banking centre in the 1970s, the policies to keep the domicile attractive.
instituting more regulations and Caymans has since diversified into an “CIMA has recently clarified its
presenting themselves as specialist, variety of areas and today is known as the position on foreign domiciled funds
boutique domiciles, with their past as a major hedge fund domicile in the administered in Cayman. Cayman
home for shady deals no more relevant Caribbean. domiciled funds are required to register
than the Caribbean's history as a haven In this regard it had a jump on with CIMA but until recently it was
for the likes of Blackbeard and Henry Bermuda by not requiring those unclear if foreign domiciled funds
Morgan. domiciling their funds in the jurisdiction administered in Cayman needed to
The Cayman Islands is the big gun of to also base their administration and register. CIMA has now clarified that
these domiciles. Setting up a fund in the other functions there. registration for these funds is not
Caymans, which is then perhaps Like the other Caribbean domiciles, the required”, says Stainrod.
administered in Dublin, has become a Cayman Islands has been focussing By clarifying the rules on this, CIMA
model that has been made to run as harder on regulation, and telling anybody has allowed funds from different
smoothly as a Swiss clock. The legal, who will listen about its efforts. jurisdictions to use administrators
regulatory and financial aspects all In December last year, the Caribbean established in the Caymans.
operate in tune with each other, and any Financial Action Taskforce stated: Stainrod adds: “In addition, CIMA has
snags have long since been ironed out. “Caymans suspicious activity reports recently introduced e-filing for their
But an overriding strength of have decreased by an annual average of registered funds.
Caribbean jurisdictions is their ability to seven per cent over the last three years. “This will allow the domicile's growth
&KLFDJR
'Ħğĕ "ĕĞĚğĚĤĥģĒĥĚĠğ
'HQYHU
%BJMZ
XFFLMZ
NPOUIMZ GVOE
0LQQHDSROLV
WBMVBUJPOT 5ģĒğĤėĖģ "ĘĖğĔĪ é
1HZ<RUN
/"7 DBMDVMBUJPOT; 1- 4ęĒģĖęĠĝĕĖģ 4ĖģħĚĔĖĤ
.BOBHFNFOU
QFSGPSNBODF
1SFQBSBUJPO BOE NBJOUFOBODF PG
6DQ)UDQFLVFR mOBODJBM BOE QBSUOFS SFQPSUJOH TIBSFIPMEFS SFHJTUFS
6NLOOPDQ1-
*ODPNF BMMPDBUJPO BOE 4VCTDSJQUJPOT3FEFNQUJPOT5SBOTGFS
SFBMMPDBUJPO UP QBSUOFST BOE QSPDFTTJOH
:LQGVRU&7 TIBSFIPMEFST
$POmSNBUJPO PG TIBSFIPMEFS
"VEJUPS TVQQPSU USBOTBDUJPO EFUBJMT
'Ħğĕ .ĒğĒĘĖģ $PNQMJBODF XJUI 64" 1BUSJPU "DU
,QWHUQDWLRQDO
4ĖģħĚĔĖĤ é -ĖĘĒĝ ,OPX :PVS $MJFOU BOE "OUJ.POFZ
-BVEFSJOH SVMFT
$PVWHUGDP
4ĦġġĠģĥ
&XUDFDR
'VOE 4USVDUVSJOH
'XEOLQ 4FUVQ PG PĊTIPSF GVOE WFIJDMFT
.XDOD/XPSXU
*ODPSQPSBUJPO TFSWJDFT
-JDFOTF BOE SFHVMBUPSZ BQQSPWBM
/RQGRQ
NBOBHFNFOU
0RQWUpDO %PDVNFOU ESBGUJOH GPS PĊTIPSF
WFIJDMFT
6\GQH\
&TUBCMJTIJOH CSPLFS BOE CBOL
7RN\R SFMBUJPOTIJQT
7RURQWR 33# &UND 3ERVICES HAS A COMPREHENSIVE SUITE OF PRODUCTS AND SERVICES FOR THE ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT
INDUSTRY INCLUDING ON AND OFFSHORE HEDGE FUNDS FUNDS OF FUNDS SEPARATE MANAGED ACCOUNTS PRIVATE
EQUITY FUNDS COMBINED MASTER FEEDER FUNDS PRIVATE WEALTH GROUPS AND FAMILY OFFICES /UR SOLUTIONS
CAN BE SCALED TO MEET YOUR EXISTING BUSINESS NEEDS YOUR GROWTH STRATEGY YOUR GLOBAL REACH AND THE
COMPLEXITY OF YOUR INVESTMENT STRATEGIES )N OTHER WORDS n WHATEVER YOUR SIZE YOUR STRATEGY OR YOUR
NEEDS n WE HAVE A PROVEN SOLUTION THAT IS DESIGNED TO MAXIMIZE YOUR EFFICIENCY AND PRODUCE
MEANINGFUL COST SAVINGS
to be scalable in the future, as well as the Ministry of Finance and the Bermuda front”.
providing a solid platform for CIMA to Monetary Authority (BMA) to “What I think you do need to see is
use to provide statistical analysis on a collaborate on writing financial good cooperation between regulators,
timely basis”. legislation. On this occasion, as is because the funds industry, more than
Currently the Caymans retains its place traditional in Bermuda, they also asked many others, is quite fragmented.
as unacknowledged leader among the for the input of the financial industry in “You'll often find that you have a piece
Caribbean domiciles. It has more capacity reviewing the Act and recommending of the action here but the investment
than most and can offer a host of services. pertinent changes or additions to it prior manager will be somewhere else and the
And like other jurisdictions, the Caymans to presentation before the House of custodian may be somewhere else and if
is not resting on its regulatory laurels. Assembly. something goes wrong I think that is
"We do see new regulations being Cox said that the IFA represents "a when regulators do need to cooperate and
introduced in the future to meet certain seismic shift and advance in the you need adequate powers in your own
industry needs such as unit trusts for investment fund industry in Bermuda". legislation to enable you to obtain
Japanese investors, Segregated Portfolio However she went on to assure that whatever information it is that you need
Companies for segregating liability and Bermuda is determined only to regulate that might help to investigate something
the supporting of Shari'ah compliant where needed and that the policymakers in that went wrong or clear up some kind of
products", says Stainrod. the jurisdiction are aware how damaging mess.”
Regulation almost always helps grease over-regulation can be. Of course the need not to over-regulate
the wheels of the actual processes that go Nevertheless, most agree that the is also key, and Dargie is quick to point
into domiciling a fund in a given inclination over the past few years in the out that "The framework here aims to be
jurisdiction. And in doing so, regulation Caribbean has been towards, rather than sensible and proportionate, not to over-
enhances reputation - a major factor when away from, new regulation. supervise when it's not called for."
it comes to choosing a domicile. "Generally speaking there is a trend Despite its small size, Bermuda is also
“If you look at why people choose fund towards enhanced regulation, keeping up trying to present itself as a serious option
domiciles its reputational risk. Caymans with international standards, call it what for fund administrators.
may be in all probability the most you will, here in Bermuda certainly", says Paula Cox said recently: "Other places
expensive domicile of the Caribbean Graeme Dargie, the BMA's director of have funds administered from elsewhere,
locations to base a fund but probably 60 to banking, trust and investments. but a greater share of hedge fund
70% still go there every time. If it's a one He adds: "We are keen to make sure managers are now choosing to set up in
billion dollar fund $20,000 rather than that the regulations here keep pace with Bermuda".
$15,000 doesn't really matter”, says Chris whatever the international standards may Whether there is actually a trend of
Adams, the global product head for be at the time, and of course they're more fund managers and administrators
alternative funds at BNP Paribas. always changing." basing themselves in Bermuda is
Bermuda's finance minister, Paula Cox, Currently Bermuda is striving to debatable, as Dublin and Luxembourg,
agrees with Adams. At the recent present itself as a specialist location for with their far superior resources and
Bermuda International Business funds, free of any association with money infrastructure, look like they will
Association (BIBA) event in London, she laundering, tax evasion, and so forth. continue to dominate this area of the
said unequivocally, "Reputation is It is little wonder this jurisdiction market.
everything". wishes to keep a clean reputation. Indeed, it is the perception that these
Bermuda, the Caymans' smaller Financial services are the number one relatively diminutive jurisdictions in the
counterpart, introduced its Investment industry on the territory, subordinating Caribbean are lacking in infrastructure
Funds Act (IFA) in 2006 in an effort to tourism. Bermuda has one of the highest that is a major stumbling block to
clarify and streamline its regulatory per capita GDP figures in the world, attracting administrators and managers.
regime. mostly driven by the financial services Adams says: "You do what you have to
The IFA did not significantly alter industry. Currently there is well over do in the Cayman Islands or BVI or
Bermuda's regulatory regime, though USD 200 billion in funds in Bermuda. Bermuda, but firstly they're heavily
what it did do was create a new Dargie says: "Since coming to Bermuda resource constrained. I know they're all
classification of authorised fund and I've been quite impressed with efforts to investing in their infrastructure but let's
present a fresh licensing regime for fund keep the bad business out. be clear, they're small islands sitting in a
administrators. The new licensing regime "There are big efforts to make sure that deep blue sea, so there's a physical limit to
simply ensures that administrators are the business we get, the promoters behind what they can actually do.
running the correct operating systems. it and the senior officers are fit and "You see it to a lesser extent in the
Additionally, the IFA grants the proper. At that stage a lot of business Channel Islands, but you still see it, there
Bermuda Monetary Authority (BMA) doesn't make the grade or doesn't come are physical limitations to what they can
more power to carry out investigations here in the first instance because it knows do. I'm aware that there are
and restricts how confidential it wouldn't get through the vetting administrators there but they've
information is used. stage." obviously made a decision based on their
Cheryl Packwood, BIBA's CEO, says of However, he admits that there is “a bit business model that they want to be in the
the act: "It is the policy in Bermuda for of work to do on the money laundering location. Our business model and that of
The Bahamas has nurtured and provided professional and efficient financial services since the 1930s.
Today, through an array of leading financial institutions, we offer full banking, trust and
asset management services, investment funds including SMART©Funds, private trust companies,
foundations and other financial planning products and services.
most of our peer organisations is that we in terms of arbitrage between them, our Ireland with its 12% tax rate this might
don't." view would probably be that they've all happen."
However while jurisdictions in the struck an appropriate balance between However, Ridley went on to admit that
Caribbean may never become having the right KYC and AML controls this possibility is "remote".
administration and management centres, in place because otherwise we wouldn't Another possibility, he writes, is
one well-known and seemingly ever- touch it, and relying on the good name massive growth and success for SIFCs,
present advantage they do have is speed and reputation of the directors of the stemming from more globalisation of
to market. funds and then relying on jurisdictions financial markets and regulatory
For example, it is possible to set up a like Dublin or Luxembourg who actually competition between countries. In this
scenario any negative connotations the
term "offshore" has would be completely
These factors, combined with a willingness to work negated.
with international regulators and of course A more realistic future for SIFCs
according to Ridley, is that some
continuing investment in infrastructure, are crucial jurisdictions will see success, while
to a domiciles survival others will dry up. He also predicts
continued efforts from major powers to
marginalize any attractions such
fund in Bermuda in a mere week, do the work." locations can offer.
according Susan Stirling, the marketing Yet despite the attractive new However, one thing is certain, prudent
director of BIBA. regulations that the Caribbean domiciles regulation is a decisive factor in the
Dargie claims: "One advantage is are instituting, their future is by no survival story of any SIFC, and will
there's a relatively well-established path means assured. continue to be in the future.
to setting up business here. As Paula Cox said at the end of her What is needed, Ridley writes, is "a
"There are a lot of checks and balances address in London, Bermuda cannot good risk based regulatory and
that need to be gone through but by and afford to become complacent, and neither supervisory approach, a flexible and
large the professional firms here are well can any of its counterparts in this sunny adaptive approach to legislation and
geared up to doing this. There is a steady region. regulation to provide the structures,
flow of new business and we try and make The popularity of the area depends products and supervision expected by the
it as easy as possible for new businesses largely on a set number of qualities that it market".
to set up provided they meet the has, foremost among them quick and easy These factors, combined with a
standards, and that applies to new set up of funds and low taxation, that are willingness to work with international
investment businesses, and investment lacking in other regions. Should there be regulators and of course continuing
funds." a major shift in governmental policy and investment in infrastructure, are crucial
Setting up a fund in the BVI is also a several other factors, then jurisdictions to a domiciles survival.
relatively rapid process. According to the like the Caymans, the BVI and Bermuda There are plenty of examples of those
BVI Financial Services Commission it could be in trouble, with their impressive who have tried and failed to become a
takes a mere 48 hours for an application new regulations simply smoke in the successful funds centre. The one that
for recognition and approximately two
weeks to finalize the registration of a
fund. One thing is certain, prudent regulation is a decisive
After many years playing catch-up, the
BVI is now number two only to the
factor in the survival story of any SIFC
Cayman Islands in the assets it has in
funds, having surpassed Bermuda some wind. immediately springs to mind of course is
years ago. In his recent paper, dubbed The Future Vanuatu, which has fallen off the map of
But to some, one Caribbean domicile is of Offshore Financial Centres, CIMA's international funds centres.
very much like any other. Adams says: "If chairman, Timothy Ridley, addressed this Overall, it is this flexibility and
you look across the Caribbean locations I possibility, highlighting one potential adaptability that Ridley writes of that
don't see any material differences. cause as "the major economic powers most Caribbean domiciles do have going
"In the last three months we've set up implementing domestic policies and in their favour. The ability to pass new
Cayman, BVI and Bermudan funds and if programmes that eliminate the need to regulation and new policies as the
you were to ask me I wouldn't be able to use small international financial services landscape of the financial services
tell you why the promoters had gone for centres (SIFCs). This would entail the industry changes is the key to their
those locations. My only belief would be introduction of well-balanced regulatory continuing survival and relevance on the
because their existing fund range was and supervisory regimes and the world scene. But passing the right
there so it's for historical reasons. introduction of tax rates and other costs regulations while resisting any
"Cayman obviously has the lion's share to levels that made it impossible for preponderance to over-regulate is
because they got into the market first, but SIFCs to compete. If this were left to walking a very high tightrope. I
base in
bermuda
a proactive jurisdiction with a premier reputation • low cost set-up and administration • speed and precision
ʥˇˆ˃˔ ʪˑ˗˕ˇʏ ʔʒ ʸˋ˅˖ˑ˔ˋ˃ ʵ˖˔ˇˇ˖ʏ ʪ˃ˏˋˎ˖ˑː ʪʯʓʔ ʤˇ˔ˏ˗ˆ˃ ˖ˇˎʎʖʖʓʎʔʛʔʎʒʘʕʔ ˈ˃˚ʎʖʖʓʎʔʛʔʎʓʙʛʙ ˙˙˙ʎʤʫʤʣʎˑ˔ˉ
ANALYSE THIS - HEDGE FUNDS / PRIME BROKERAGE
Is it becoming more
difficult to launch hedge Where next for the Hedge
funds? Fund industry
CHARLIE WOOLNOUGH, SENIOR BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT MANAGER CHRIS ADAMS, GLOBAL PRODUCT HEAD FOR ALTERNATIVE
AT FORTIS FUNDSERVICES INVESTMENT FUNDS AT BNP PARIBAS SECURITIES SERVICES
espite the fact that the hedge fund industry now hether it is hedge funds or private equity, the rise
t will be a long time, if ever, before hedge funds are he hedge fund industry can no longer ignore the
ecent articles in the media including both the number of trends have significantly altered the hedge
For more information on Custom House, the only hedge fund administrator awarded
a Moodys Management Quality Rating, please review our website
(www.customhousegroup.com)
or contact Dermot Butler (dermot.butler@customhousegroup.com)
or David Blair (david.blair@customhousegroup.com).
Custom House Administration & Corporate Services Limited is authorised by the Irish Financial Regulator under Section 10 of the Investment Intermediaries Act 1995,
which authorisation does not extend to the Chicago or Singapore representative offices.
t h h i hi t d1 1 06/03/2007 20 05 00
ANALYSE THIS - HEDGE FUNDS
edge funds seeking to operate in today's he appetite for institutional investors for hedge
Is Curacao still an
attractive jurisdiction for
offshore hedge funds? and What are the key features
how does Curacao for the successful
differentiate itself from its administration of fund of
competition? hedge funds?
MAI LIEM, MANAGING DIRECTOR & LEGAL CONSUL, SS&C DONARD MCCLEAN, HEAD OF FUND SERVICES, IRELAND
TECHNOLOGIES UBS GLOBAL ASSET MANAGEMENT
uracao has been the base of the earliest funds such as uccessful hedge fund administration is about getting
alternatives given the complexity and lack add a layer of security for pension fund good schemes there are in the market.”
of transparency that surrounds the area. It trustees in that pension fund Despite the poor performance of
is mostly the larger pension funds that can administrators will have to register with Ireland's managed pension funds at
afford to dip a toe into this area without the Pensions Board and trustees will face present, most in the market still have an
overly affecting the diversity of their a mandatory requirement to undergo element of long-term optimism. As
portfolios,” says Daly. regular training. Moriaty points out, the 86.6 billion of
Much of this reluctance is down to a There is also a government green paper assets in the market is almost double the
lack of knowledge among pension fund on the Irish pension funds market that has 44.8 billion of five years ago. There is
trustees, says Daly. While it is often hard been made available for public also the feeling that the current
for trustees to find time to embark on consultation and comment. At this stage it turbulence in the equity markets is as
rigorous education programmes, there are is still quite vague and is more an much a result of investors' panicked
a number of initiatives, courses and examination of all the aspects of pensions reactions rather than any fundamental
conferences aimed at improving this provision rather than a specific flaws in the market.
situation. framework, says Moriaty. In particular it There is also the fear of a recession in
One such initiative was unveiled at the asks how the industry can improve the US but, says Daly, until it becomes
recent IAPF conference - the first set of coverage and adequacy and questions clear to what extent this recession may be
investment guidelines for members. whether there should be an introduction and until the current market turbulence
Moriaty likens the guidelines to the of mandatory incentive schemes for works itself out, there is a risk in too many
Myners' Report which was introduced in savers. trustees instructing their managers to
the UK back in 2004. In all there are seven But what would Moriaty like to see come make any dramatic cuts in their Irish
guidelines for defined contribution out of the consultation process? “I would equity assets.
trustees and an equal number for defined like to see more simplification in the market “It is hard to say that there have been
benefit trustees. “They are basic common so that more consumers can understand it, any lessons learned in all of this, because
sense guidelines but they form the basis of particularly in relation to tax relief and tax of the unique nature of the events that
a good framework for trustees who are credits or how the government's have led to the market's decline” says Daly.
wondering about how they should address contributions to pension funds are “Until everything is washed through, it
investment matters,” says Moriaty. expressed on the average pay-slip.” will be difficult to tell if there will be any
Furthermore, says Moriaty, the guidelines Daly says that she would like to see a long-term effect from this.
have been endorsed by Brendan Kennedy, more reasonable approach to the way that “Personally I don't think things will
chief executive of the Pensions Board, contribution schemes are operated and fundamentally change in the global
giving the guidelines the necessary stamp also opposes the idea of a mandatory equities market and investment managers
of regulatory approval. scheme. “Otherwise pensions become like will want to be careful of moving away
In terms of regulation there is a Social a tax and it will reduce schemes to the from their core investment philosophy as a
Welfare and Pension Bill that is due to be lowest common denominator meaning reaction to the current market conditions.
passed into law later this year which will that we will lose the benefit of the many If they have convictions I would I
SECURITIES LENDING
“Securities lending in Europe has had a its own style and philosophy toward the legislation required to keep up with
few changes since last August, when the way cash collateral is managed. Simply securities legislation. Belgium, for
subprime crisis started in the US,” says put, some lenders may undertake loans at example, issued a world decree in March
Guy d'Albrand, global head of liquidity relatively low fees in order to generate 2007 clarifying that securities lending
management at Societe Generale cash collateral which is then invested in would not be deemed a capital event or a
Securities Services (SGSS). “I believe we lower-quality investments to make a disposal. This has paved for way for
also started seeing a confidence shake-up return. And there are other lenders who Belgian mutual fund owners to lend their
in European institutions, although typically try to maximize the value of the securities without sparking capital gains
certainly not to the extent as experienced
in US banks and custodians.
“There was a shortage of term cash in
The credit crunch and liquidity crisis caused by the
the markets, resulting in an increasing US subprime crisis, the meltdown of giant Bear Stearns,
spread between three-month EURIBOR
fixing and the three-month EONIA and the rumors surrounding the potential
swap,” he continues. “What we starting
seeing then were those institutions that
problems of other investment banks have not
were long on securities, especially fixed dampened market opportunities in Europe
income, realizing they could make more
by lending out these securities, taking loan itself, take the cash collateral, and taxes on their portfolios. Similar decrees
cash on collateral, and reinvesting that invest it very conservatively,” adds are waiting passage by other
cash at much higher rates than before.” Wilson. governments as well, including Spain.
Now, with the steepening of the yield The US credit crunch, adds There is much focus on the BRICs-
curve, fixed income lending activity has Waddington, has been somewhat of a Brazil, Russia, India, and China-due to
increased, and markets have entered a double-edged sword for European the amount of inward investment in those
new era, where there is a spread between securities lending and borrowing. On the countries, and the rise in capitalization is
lending against cash and lending against one hand, many borrowers are focusing a catalyst prompting opportunities in
other securities. Since August, there has on balance sheet constraints and moving securities lending and borrowing. Most
been a growth in fixed income lending away from cash collateral, which has banks have some sort of strategic policy
activity in Europe, with demand for very caused significant growth in business for and involvement for those countries.
high-quality AAA-rated government noncash lenders such as ourselves,” says There is always concern, however, about
bond securities particularly high. Waddington. “On the other hand, Russia, about its politics and policies.
Consequently, demand has outstripped however, the traditional cash collateral There are certain challenges to
supply, lenders are saying. lenders are making huge returns on their expanding the securities lending market
Also, Wilson adds, what the crunch in reinvestments, so both cash and noncash in Europe. For example, d'Albrand says
the US has driven is a greater bias toward lenders are benefiting from the current common accounting practices between
noncash collateral. “The typical model in environment at the same time.” nations are needed, as well as some
the US is that a greater proportion of “I don't expect markets will come back regulatory easing in certain countries.
loans are made against cash collateral,” to their former balance very quickly or In addition to exploring new markets,
he explains. “Given that the dominant very soon,” says d'Albrand, when asked industry participants are also looking at
players in the marketplace are US about an end to the credit crunch. new product development as a way to
participants, there have always a greater “However, it may be that we are in a new generate new and incremental revenue.
proportion of loans against cash balance now. What we see now are JPM's Wilson says it best: “If you're
collateral than against noncash collateral. counterparts much more careful about standing still in terms of what you're
Clearly, if you take cash collateral, you collateral they receive, and in general, doing, you're probably going backwards.”
must ensure that cash is invested in a there seems to be much more risk The product development agenda is
range of money market instruments to consciousness in the markets than before. crucial to the securities lending and
generate a return sufficient enough to The securities lending community is borrowing function, especially as it
pay the rebate back to the borrower and becoming more mature and risk covers new market expansion, where
maintain a spread for the benefit of the conscious.” early entrants in those markets receive
lender.” Despite a the publicity surrounding the the benefits of high fees. Also, effective
One of the trends European lenders are hot markets in Latin America, security product development “looks beyond the
seeing as a consequence of the credit lending participants believe there are traditional securities lending transaction,
difficulties in the US is a reassessment of markets yet to tap in Europe. There are at swaps, equity forwards, and so forth, at
the way cash collateral has been many countries and lenders within those innovative ways to gain early entrance
managed. As a result there is now a far markets that don't engage in securities into some of these new and emerging
greater proportion of loans made against lending because a developed securities markets, even when there isn't necessarily
noncash collateral than against cash lending environment does not yet exist a conventional securities lending and
collateral. “When you look at the and the only form of lending is synthetic. borrowing facility available,” adds
different lenders in the market, each has Of course, in some markets, there is tax Wilson.
Perhaps the “silver lining” in the credit allowing each client to determine how collateral and the correlation between
cloud, globally speaking, is that the credit cash collateral is managed. So that client loan and collateral types are just as
crunch has forced all industry can choose the desired credit risk, important as a credit rating.”
participants to review their securities liquidity risk, and interest rate risk, and Where does the industry go from here?
lending programs. customize a program around its unique Industry participants believe the trend for
“It's a resurgence of a word that's been requirements. Contrast that to a large the remainder of the year will be a focus
in the industry a long time-transparency,” commingled fund, where the same level of on risk management. Waddington
says Wilson. “I define transparency as customization is not possible. believes “Europe is going to have a very
buoyant year. Despite everything that has
happened over the last few months and
With the steepening of the yield curve, fixed income the constraints of much closer risk
lending activity has increased, and markets have entered management, there is still considerable
activity in the markets and demand to
a new era, where there is a spread between lending borrow is still increasing.”
against cash and lending against other securities At the same time, there will be a
wariness in the markets, a wariness in
general surrounding how an investment
enabling clients or beneficial owners to No conversation about a securities house as big as Bear Stearns could tumble
truly customize every component of their lending and borrowing program would and a wariness about the rumors
programs, to fully understand all their be complete without the topic of surrounding other giants like Lehman
risks, and to explore their upside transparency and risk management. The and UBS.
potential and their downside potential, as collapse of Bear Stearns and the scare In the meantime, the securities
well as providing them with concise, mongering about other investment banks lending and borrowing community focuses
detailed, real time, online information
that enables them to review and assess
what's going on. Despite a the publicity surrounding the hot markets in
“Ultimately, what lenders are looking
for is transparency in terms of where
Latin America, security lending participants believe
their risk lies, what risk is being taken to there are markets yet to tap in Europe
generate the desired returns, and where
their exposures are. My own perspective serve to underscore the industry's belief on securing adequate returns on the risk
is that where those lenders are using in risk management as a core factor in any involved. On the borrower side,
providers who have historically been very program. “The days are long gone when it's apparent borrowers are not
transparent, the impact on them has been lenders would just say I'll take any AAA- willing to take spreads as small as did in
less substantial.” rated G-10 government debt at 105% previous years.
For example, when managing cash margin and that's the end of it,” says And, as always, there will be a focus on
collateral, some lenders follow a policy of Waddington. “These days, liquidity of the new ways to generate revenue. I
T
here are two types of dark pools in the current market: Independent
crossing platforms that tend to focus on facilitating block trading;
and single broker/dealer-owned crossing platforms, which are GRAPHS
typically tightly integrated with the broker/dealer’s electronic and The graphs below represent some actual activity at the end of
algorithmic trading group. February in 2007 and 2008. the graph to the left shows the
Independent dark pool operators, such as Liquidnet, POSIT, Pipeline, considerable increase in revenue from securities lending and
reinvestment activity, scaled by the lendable assets, in basis
and NYFIX continue to build liquidity in their respective platforms. Looking
points. American equities have more than doubled in return to
to break into this lucrative electronic block trading market, leading
lendable, demonstrating the increasing demand for high-
broker/dealers financed and launched BIDS, a consortium-led platform quality equities borrowing by funds during the subprime crisis.
designed to function as an industry utility with an aggressive pricing Fewer owners were prepared to lend out their equities over the
schedule; it may lead to pricing compression in the block trading market summer while fund were increasingly keen to borrow them.
if BIDS is successful. In addition to making numerous investments in
leading regional exchanges, ECNs, and other ATSs (see figure below), most
large broker/dealers have also launched their own dark pools in the form
of internal crossing platforms. From the broker’s perspective, internal
crossing provides cost savings in terms of eliminating exchange
transaction fees. From the client’s perspective, internal crossing can
provide rapid, anonymous executions with minimum market impact. While
most broker/dealers are still very secretive about the actual trade volume
that occur within these individual platforms, crossing rates appear to be
anywhere between 4% to 11%, with some of the largest platforms
averaging anywhere between 40 million to 100 million in trade volume on
a daily basis. Taken individually, broker/dealer-owned platforms do not
have enough trade volume to seriously threaten some of the leading
exchanges and ATSs. In order to boost their overall fill rate, some of the
broker/dealer-owned dark pools have started to link up with other broker-
owned and/or independent dark pools.
Credit Suisse has been fairly active in this regard, linking up its
CrossFinder with Instinet CBX, Fidelity
CrossStream, Lehman LCX, Liquidnet (as a SLP)
and many more. When taken together, dark pools
can definitely have a significant impact on
certain orders, especially those orders driven by
dark liquidity-seeking algorithms. Firms that
heavily rely on dark liquidity-seeking algorithms
have reported that more than 40% of shares in
certain orders were filled in dark pools before
hitting the public market for a clean-up. As a
result, dark pools of liquidity are becoming the
execution destination of choice for an increasing
number of sell-side and buy-side traders. The
figure on p66 illustrates some of the options a
fictional buy-side trader potentially faces, given
a specific order to work in the U.S. equities
market. Given a large block order, the trader
might first attempt to seek instant fill in the
block trading market. Any residual order could
be routed to a broker who would then put it
through his or her own internal crossing engine.
Any remaining shares can be routed via a smart
order routing engine to other dark pools before
finally hitting the public market. I
Places
than in the UK. This is partly because
American Stock exchanges, AMEX 29,
NYSE and NASDAQ, have far bigger
market caps in terms of listed equities than
stock exchanges in the UK. These
conditions are very conducive to using
EMS' because speed and volume is a high
priority. Also, in practical terms a lot of the
Catherine Kemp looks at technology originates from the US, a lot of
the prominent vendors are US companies.
the portfolio For managers using EMS' in the UK and
the rest of Europe one of the main issues is
management systems compliance with MiFID regulations
regarding best execution. Portfolio
market - who has managers are using this technology to
show that best practice has been achieved.
invested in EMS The EMS gives the portfolio manager the
information they need to tell the dealer
systems and why? which stock to invest in and to ensure that
his dealing team gets him the best value for
istorically portfolio management systems target different parts of the
alternative investments at Carne Group Other critics have pointed to the fact that there is much more concentration of the
describes what he calls a certain degree of whilst the use of algorithms is a growing assets in the top tier. It will be interesting
“unhealthy cannibalism” in the market: “If trend for the larger houses, they are not to see what effect this influx of independent
you look at the history of these EMSs, necessarily cost effective for mid-market to providers of direct market access will have
before they were introduced the average lower end houses. To successfully use on such a concentrated market.
order size on the New York stock algorithms you have to constantly update Another interesting trend, which has
exchanges was 800 to 700 shares, now it is and remodel the algorithms, otherwise been highlighted by commentators, is that
400 to 500 shares. Since the markets have other traders will pick up the footprint of whilst jobs are being cut in the city and
gone electronic - traders are using crossing your trades and will trade against you. The banks tighten their belts during the current
networks, electronic trading systems, cost of employing a team to maintain an financial crisis, there may well be a cut in
matching networks to trade across several algorithmic system and of implementing an IT budgets and slow down in the rate of
markets on one electronic crossing and this EMS is high, and unless you are trading in management houses' implementation of
has created fragmented or dark pools of high volumes and are making large returns, EMS'. However, analysts have pointed out
liquidity. Essentially the technology has it may not be worth it financially. But that in fact the opposite is happening.
fragmented the liquidity.” And yet it is this ultimately as the market evolves and Denise Valentine a senior analyst at Aite
very fragmentation, which causes traders continues to fragment, fund managers are Group describes: “They are letting go of
to use the technology. going to continue to need more advanced the people before the technology. It's very
Chadda also considers them to be technology to provide data. The clear for everyone in the trading
completely counterproductive in certain algorithmic and direct market access environment that you need to be electronic.
market conditions. “In highly volatile qualities of the EMS makes it the best tool Maybe you can do without an OMS in
markets like we've seen in the last few currently for that. edition to an EMS, but you can't have
months, you'll find that these models just An increasing number of new markets neither.”
don't work, they are based on historical are also starting to use EMS'. Countries There is a degree of cannibalism in the
data, and in the last two to three years I such as Hong Kong, Singapore, and Japan, market. As vendors introduce increasingly
believe the market has fundamentally that are not emerging markets, but have complex trading technology it affects the
changed. It's a new market. People are now not previously seen the kind of vendor liquidity of the market, which in turn
investing in commodities, such as gold, oil presence that is in the UK and US before, creates a need for more technology. But
and grain, as well as shares and bonds and are starting to buy into EMS'. Emerging ultimately technology has fundamentally
so on. There is no historical data for this markets like Thailand and Korea are also changed trading culture by making it
new market because it's only two or three starting to use this technology. In Asia the electronic and currently buy-side traders
years old. So how on earth you can really markets are much more concentrated, are benefiting from the many trading
allow an algorithm to trade on historical unlike the UK and US, where there are solutions that are available on the market,
data effectively in a new market.” thousands of money managers. In Asia and are adapting them to their needs.. I
I
MN is proud to announce our Third Canadian Beneficial Owners' Summit on Securities Lending & Global
Custody. We have held this event in Toronto every other year since 2004 and it has attracted increasing
numbers of leading Canadian Beneficial Owners.
Our independence & experience in organizing events in Canada and throughout the world ensures an
unparalleled educational and networking experience for Canadian Beneficial Owners. This distinguished
event is being held conveniently for all at the Pantages in Toronto.
Delegates will benefit from cutting-edge content delivered by a broad range of leading industry experts who
will provide unique insights on best practices to maximize revenues, minimize program risk and conduct
appropriate due diligence in light of profound industry changes in the past two years.
International: Olivier Storme CACEIS is an Investor Services company with six offices across Europe. Owned in
equal parts by Crédit Agricole and Natixis, CACEIS provides Custody, Fund
T: +352 4767 2847 Administration and Corporate Trust services to demanding Corporate and
E: olivier.storme@caceis.com Institutional clients. We have considerable expertise in Cross-Border Fund
Distribution Support as well as Alternative Investment and Private Equity servic-
ing.
France: Patrick Lemuet Our staff have the language skills and industry knowledge to develop business
T: +33 (0)1 57 78 03 34 relationships into strong partnerships and our powerful IT systems are constantly
E: patrick.lemuet@caceis.com updated to ensure high levels of process automation.
CACEIS is responsible for over EUR1.75 trillion held under custody, and over
W: www.caceis.com EUR850 billion under administration.
DnB NOR is the largest and leading provider of Custody, Clearing and
T: +47 22 94 92 95
Remote Member Service in Norway. In addition, DnB NOR provides a wide
F: +47 22 48 28 46
range of value added services to both Foreign and Domestic clients.
Contact: Bente I. Hoem
Through an Alliance solution with banks in Sweden, Finland and Denmark,
E: bente.hoem@dnbnor.no
DnB NOR can offer seamless regional products, which can be customized to
W: www.dnbnor.com our client's needs.
W: www.handelsbanken.com The cornerstone of Handelsbanken’s philosophy is to put the client and the
/nordic_custody_services client’s needs in focus. Nordic Custody Services are locally present in all the
T: +46 8 701 2988 Nordic markets and offer a wide product spectre to a diverse client base.
F: +46 8 701 2990 Each client is allocated an account manager in each market, fully
C: Johan Wennerberg responsible for the day-to-day activities, as well as a regional relationship
E:custodyservices@handelsbanken.se manager. Handelsbanken provides specialised and tailor-made custody services
A: Blasieholmstorg 12, including complete corporate action services, securities borrowing and lending
SE - 106 70, for all Nordic countries, as well as settlement and clearing services to clients
Stockholm, Sweden that are remote members of the Nordic stock exchanges.
Business Development –
Investment Fund & Global
KBL, leading service provider in the Luxembourg fund industry, offers one-stop shop Custody Services
facilities to international fund promoters. 43, boulevard Royal
Product structuring (of SICAV, FCP, SIF, SICAR, SEPCAV, …), global custody L-2955 Luxembourg
services as well as an efficient fund administration and transfer agency infrastructure Stéphane Ries e-mail :
are some of our fields of expertise that will bring added value to the management of stephane.ries@kbl-bank.com
your assets. Sandra Cortese e-mail :
For all kinds of Undertakings for Collective Investment going from plain vanilla sandra.cortese@kbl-bank.com
cash, money-market, equity and bond funds to sophisticated alternative, venture Stéphane Pesch e-mail :
capital/private equity, pension pooling and funds of hedge funds, KBL offers expert stephane.pesch@kbl-bank.com
legal, fiscal and technical advice as well as access to the global markets. Tel. : (352)4797 3512
Fax : (352)4797 73910
www.kbl.lu
Nordea is the leading financial services group in the Nordic and Baltic Sea region
and operates through three business areas: Nordic Banking, Banking & Capital
Market Products and Savings & Life Products.
Nordea is the leading custody services provider in the region. Nordea provides high T: +47 2248 6238
quality, tailor-made custody services for local and foreign investors dealing with Contact: Anne-Lise Kristiansen
Nordic, Baltic or global securities. Head of Sub-custody and
- The leading financial services group in the Nordic and Baltis Sea region Clearing
- A world-leading Internet banking and e-commerce operation E: anne-lise.kristiansen@nordea.com
- The largest customer base of any financial services group in the region
- A leading asset manager in the Nordic financial market
- The most comprehensive distribution network in the region
aSantander is Spain’s leading financial institution and the largest bank in the euro
zone by market capitalization. Our commitment and contribution to the securities
industry is well established after more than a century of providing services in this field. T: Europe: (34) 91 2893932 / 28
T: USA: (1212) 350 39 02
W: santanderglobal.com
Santander’s cutting edge technology enables it to offer a comprehensive array of inno- E: globalsecurities@
vative services in a broad range of markets. Santander currently has full local capabili- gruposantander.com
ties in Iberian and Latin American markets along with a franchised presence in many
others. Santander`s experience and product range ensures that every aspect of the
securities business is fully contemplated.
Sébastien Danloy Société Générale Securities Services offers institutional investors, asset man-
Global Head of Sales,Investor agers and financial intermediaries a comprehensive range of financial securities
Services services: custody, clearing & trustee services, fund administration, asset servic-
Société Générale Securities
ing and transfer agency. SGSS currently ranks 3rd European custodian and 9th
Services
T: +33 (0)1 41 42 98 65 worldwide custodian (Source: Globalcustody.net) with EUR 2,580* billion in
E: sebastien.danloy@socgen.com assets held and valuates 4,354* funds representing assets of EUR 405* billion
W: www.sg-securities-services.com (as of June 2007).
Standard Chartered leading the way in Asia, Africa and the Middle East.
Standard Chartered has a history of over 150 years in banking and is in many of the
world's fastest-growing markets with an extensive global network of over 1,200
C: Neil Daswani, branches (including subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures) in over 50 countries
Global Head, Securities Services in the Asia Pacific Region, South Asia, the Middle East, Africa, the United Kingdom
T: +65 6517 0022 and the Americas.
E: Neil.Daswani@sg.standard-
chartered.com As one of Asia's leading custodians, Standard Chartered has an impressive track
record across the 16 Asian markets in which it provides securities services. It serves
W: www.standardchartered.com
global, regional and local custodians and broker-dealers, as well as local and regional
fund managers. The Bank plays a key role in promoting the development of these
markets and keeping the international investor community informed of industry
developments across the region.
Unicredit Markets & Investment Banking (MIB) serves as UniCredit Group's global
product and competence center for global financial markets and investment banking
services, including Custody throughout Central and Eastern Europe, including Austria.
T: +43 50505-58510
Brand diversitiy under which the group operates (Bank Austria Creditanstalt, HVB,
F: +43 50505-58579 Bank BPH, Bank Pekao, Zagrebacka Banka and International Moscow Bank), has its
C: Andreas Petzl , Head of Sales roots in local market presence and knowledge, contributing into a single unified
and Relationship Management product across the region. In 2006 the group was recognised by no less than 3
E: Andreas.petzl@ba-ca.com independent surveys as being the best region custodian
W: www.hvb-custody.com/ The group's ability to deliver service excellence across 13 markets is the cornerstone
of our success. From participation in local market associations to our inter group
training sessions, to a client consultative approach, the group continues to work
towards making a single impression - excellence.
SmartCo is a leading provider of data management solutions for the financial industry.
SmartCo’s software, Smart Financial Data Hub, covers all the data area, including SmartCo
financial instruments, market data, third parties, funds, transactions, and provides 37 rue de Liège
full connectivity, a powerful and user friendly front-end, traceability, quality control, 75008 Paris
data enrichment and customisable workflow. France
Our solutions are based on SmartPlanet, an innovative technology focused on data
management, and able to meet evolving business requirements. T: + 33 1 58 22 29 60
SmartCo offers to its customers the ability to respond in the fastest way to regulatory E: info@smartco.fr
and business changes. W: www.smartco.fr
For further information: www.smartco.fr or info@smartco.fr
Fund Administration
Apex Fund Services Ltd is a global hedge fund administration solution for hedge C: Peter Hughes
funds and private equity clients located in 9 separate jurisdictions across the globe. Group Managing Director
The company uses the software solution, PFS PAXUS, which is a fully integrated T: +1 441-292-2739
hedge fund accounting system combined with web-based reporting to allow clients F:+1 441-292-1884
and investors to access their information 24/7 securely online. We will tailor all
E: info@apex.bm
solutions to meet your needs and our continuing focus on the quality of service and
the relationship with each and individual client ensures that we retain our ethos of A: 31 Reid Street,
providing a personalized service rather than a generic solution. Hamilton,HM11
Highly qualified and experienced staff, mirrored with top tier technology and Bermuda
competitive fee structures make Apex Fund Services Ltd the clear choice for your
fund administration needs. WWW.APEX.BM
CACEIS is an Investor Services company with six offices across Europe. Owned in International: Olivier Storme
equal parts by Crédit Agricole and Natixis, CACEIS provides Custody, Fund T: +352 4767 2847
Administration and Corporate Trust services to demanding Corporate and E: olivier.storme@caceis.com
Institutional clients. We have considerable expertise in Cross-Border Fund
Distribution Support as well as Alternative Investment and Private Equity servic-
ing. France: Patrick Lemuet
Our staff have the language skills and industry knowledge to develop business T: +33 (0)1 57 78 03 34
relationships into strong partnerships and our powerful IT systems are constantly
updated to ensure high levels of process automation. E: patrick.lemuet@caceis.com
CACEIS is responsible for over EUR1.75 trillion held under custody, and over W: www.caceis.com
EUR850 billion under administration.
www.imfcfundservices.com
Established in 2002, IMFC Fund Services B.V. is a boutique hedge fund
t +31.20.644.4558 administrator and a trustee with its offices in Amsterdam and Sydney. IMFC
f +31.20.644.2735 offers third parties administration and related services to all type of onshore and
Mrs. Consuelo Nardon offshore funds combining high quality, independency, technology, timely
e: consuelo.nardon@imfc.nl calculation with flexibility, experience, custom-made solutions and competitive
Rivierstaete Building, rates. Our services include: fund set-up and corporate services, NAV calculation
Amsteldijk 166, 1079 LH and other accounting services, R&T agent and other investors and compliance
Amsterdam, Netherlands services. For more information visit our website: www.imfcfundservices.com
C: Fred W. Jacobs, III PFPC is a premier provider of processing, technology and business solutions to the
A: PFPC, 301 Bellevue Pkwy global investment industry. Our core offering includes accounting, administration,
Wilmington, DE 19809 USA investor services, middle-office services and regulatory administration services. Whether
T: 302-791-2000 your products are U.S. or non-U.S. domiciled funds, trust vehicles, limited partnerships
F: 302-791-1570 or commingled investment products, PFPC’s multi-jurisdictional, multi-fund capability
E: Information@pfpc.com allows us to process your complex fund structures - from hedge funds, fund of funds
C: Fergus McKeon and private equity funds to master/feeder and multi-managed funds.
A: PFPC Riverside Two
Sir John Rogerson’s Quay PFPC offers personalized alternative investment solutions tailored to your unique
Dublin 2, Ireland needs. With more than 30 years in the fund servicing industry, our seasoned and
T: +353-1-790-3500 responsive professionals bring you the know-how, focus and dedication to deliver the
E: Information@pfpc.com services you need, when and where you need them, any way you want them.
C: Stuart Mauger
T: +44 (0) 1481 744479 Our clients have access to a broad range of value added services and tailored solu-
F: +44 (0) 1481 744529 tions including global custody and fund administration services for funds domiciled
E: stuart.mauger@rbc.com in the Caribbean and Channel Islands.
A: PO Box 48 Canada Court
St Peter Port Guernsey GY1 3BQ Our services include Trustee, banking and credit facilities, treasury and foreign
C: Deanna Bidwell (Cayman) exchange, trade execution, financial accounting, corporate services, derivative sup-
T: +1 345 949 9107 port services and online access, leveraging a custody network that covers 80 plus
F: +1 345 946 1288 markets worldwide. Our service combines leading edge technology with professional
E: deanna.bidwell@rbc.com expertise and a truly integrated service delivering creative, customised solutions.
W: www.rbcprivatebanking.com
Sébastien Danloy Société Générale Securities Services offers institutional investors, asset man-
Global Head of Sales,Investor agers and financial intermediaries a comprehensive range of financial securities
Services services: custody, clearing & trustee services, fund administration, asset servic-
Société Générale Securities
ing and transfer agency. SGSS currently ranks 3rd European custodian and 9th
Services
T: +33 (0)1 41 42 98 65 worldwide custodian (Source: Globalcustody.net) with EUR 2,580* billion in
E: sebastien.danloy@socgen.com assets held and valuates 4,354* funds representing assets of EUR 405* billion
W: www.sg-securities-services.com (as of June 2007).
Hedge Fund Services, based in the Cayman Islands, Ireland and Canada holds a
leading position in the area of hedge fund administration, offering a complete range
of services including accounting, NAV computation, share holder services, banking W: www.ubs.com/fundservices
and credit facilities. With the dedication and experience of a professional team of C: Mr Gerhard Fusenig
200 and our state-of-the-art web reporting, accounting and shareholder systems, we T: +41 44 235 4992
are well positioned to provide clients with a first class service. E: gerhard.fusenig@ubs.com
With specialist expertise in both single manager and fund of hedge fund adminis-
tration, we provide facilities for both onshore and offshore funds. A: UBS Global Asset
Capabilities also extend to services for investment funds through our teams in Management, Fund Services,
Luxembourg, Switzerland and the UK. Stauffacherstrasse 41, PO Box,
Cayman Islands: Darren Stainrod, tel. +1-345-914 1076 CH-8098, Zurich, Switzerland
Ireland: Don McClean, tel. +353-1-436 3636
Canada: Pearse Griffith, tel. +1-416-971 4702
DIFC
The DIFC is the world's newest international financial centre. It aims to develop the Dubai International
same stature as New York, London and Hong Kong. It primarily serves the vast Financial Centre
region between Western Europe and East Asia. Level 14, The Gate
P.O. Box 74777, Dubai, UAE
Since it opened in September 2004, the DIFC has attracted high calibre firms from
E: info@difc.ae
around the globe as well as its region. Firms operating in the DIFC are eligible for
benefits such as a zero tax rate on profits, 100 per cent foreign ownership, no T: +971 4 362 2450
restrictions on foreign exchange or repatriation of capital, operational support and M: +971 50 4958902
business continuity facilities. F: +971 4 362 2333
W: www.difc.ae
Prime Brokerage
Newedge Global Prime Brokerage Group is a global, multi-disciplinary, solution-
providing team dedicated to delivering superior services to alternative investment Philippe Teilhard de Chardin
industry participants including hedge funds, commodity trading advisors (CTAs), fund T: + 44 20 7676 85 36
of hedge funds, family offices, and institutional investors (insurance philippe.teilhard@
companies, banks and pension funds). newedgegroup.com
The Newedge prime brokerage team offers a global range of brokerage services Vincent Tournant
covering a wide range of asset classes including equities, bonds, currencies, T: +44 (0)20 7676 8171
commodities, and their related listed and OTC derivative products. We also offer an vincent.tournant@
innovative portfolio-based cross-margining solution, a dedicated account management newedgegroup.com
desk, hedge fund start up services, quantitative information on the hedge fund Duncan Crawford
industry, capital introductions services, and recently prime brokerage services to T: +44 (0)20 7676 85 04
Sharia compliant hedge funds. duncan.crawford@
Newedge is a major new force in finance, resulting from the merger of the two broker-
newedgegroup.com
age firms - Calyon Financial and Fimat - on January 2nd, 2008. Newedge is wholly W: www.newedgegroup.com
owned by Calyon and Société Générale, with both companies having 50% ownership.
Securities Lending .
Data Explorers Limited, a specialist and independent company, offers impartial
W: www.dataexplorers.com
T: +44 (20) 7392 4000 quantitative measurement of securities lending performance services to the global
F: +44 (20) 7392 4004 securities financing industry. We help our clients monitor and understand the
A: 155 Commercial Street, relative performance of their lending activity and risk, and turn raw lending, borrow-
London E1 6BJ United Kingdom ing and collateral data into useful, actionable information. We also provide proxies
London: Julian Pittam for short selling information.
T: +44 (20) 7392 5018 Working with the industry we ensure information flows are appropriate and peer
E: jp@dataexplorers.com groups relevant. We are not involved in transactions.
Boston: Tim Smith All of our services: Performance Explorer, Transaction Explorer, Risk Explorer,
T: + 1 (617) 973 5099 Index Explorer and Report Explorer are web based and available to clients
E: tim.smith@dataexplorers.com
over the internet.
T: +1 212 901 2224 EquiLend Holdings LLC was formed by a group of leading financial institutions to
C: Michelle Lindenberger develop a global platform for the automation of securities finance transactions.
E: Michelle.lindenberger@equi- The EquiLend platform is designed to increase efficiency by standardizing, cen-
lend.com/info@equilend.com tralizing and automating front and back office processes, while delivering global
access to liquidity, reduced risk and scalability. The EquiLend platform is
A: 17 State Street, 9th Floor
designed to process equity and fixed income securities finance transactions on a
New York NY 10004
global basis.
T: +44 20 7743 9510 Investors include: Barclays Global Investors; Bear, Stearns & Co. Inc.; Credit
A: 54 Lombard Street Suisse; The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.; J.P. Morgan Chase & Co.; Lehman
London EC3V 9EX Brothers; Merrill Lynch; Morgan Stanley; Northern Trust Corporation; State Street
W: www.equilend.com Corporation; and UBS.
Eurex is one of the largest derivatives exchanges and the leading clearing house in
Europe. Wherever you are located, we provide you with access to the benchmark
W: www.eurexseclend.com futures and options market for European derivatives. Eurex also offers short term fund-
T: +41 58 854 2066 ing products, such as Eurex Repo. Eurex Repo is among the forerunners in providing
F: +41 58 854 2455 integrated trading and clearing for repo transactions. Eurex’s latest innovative market-
E: info@eurexseclend.com place is called Eurex SecLend.
Eurex SecLend. Europe’s leading investment banks participate as borrowers in the
Eurex Zurich Ltd., Selnaustrasse Eurex SecLend marketplace, acting as principal brokers, dealers and intermediaries.
30, 8021 Zurich, Switzerland They all benefit from Eurex’s leading state-of-the-art trading and processing services.
For Eurex, service and technology innovation is not just a buzzword. New trends are
being transformed into inventions through the adoption of advanced trading practices.
Find out more on www.eurexseclend.com.
T: +41 (0)44 218 14 14 FINACE® is the only fully integrated solution today which supports the future busi-
F: +41 (0)44 218 14 18 ness model within the area of Securities Finance and Collateral Management. The
architecture of FINACE® is based on a stable, leading edge technology platform,
E: info@finace.ch
which was developed with performance and robustness as the focus of design. With
A: COMIT AG, Buckhauserstrasse
flexibility at its core, customer-driven extensions and modifications can be quickly
11, CH-8048 Zurich, Switzerland and easily applied to the standard component set.
W: www.finacesolution.com
Pirum provides a full suite of automated reconciliation and straight through process-
ing (STP) services supporting Operations within the global securities finance T: +44 20 7220 0961
industry. The company's on-line SBLREX service encompasses daily contract F: +44 20 7220 0977
compare, monthly billing comparison, mark-to-market & exposure processing, C: Rupert Perry
pending trade comparison, income claims processing and custody reconciliation.
E: rupert.perry@pirum.com
Subscribers to Pirum’s services significantly increase their operational efficiency
A: Pirum Systems Limited
and reduce their risk by using Pirum’s solutions, as staff are able to focus on fixing
the exceptions instead of using their time to check and process routine business. 37-39 Lime Street
These automated processes are more scalable and risk controlled too, allowing London, EC3M 7AY
significantly higher volumes to be managed without corresponding increases in W: www.pirum.com
operations headcount.
Santander is the only Spanish financial institution with a team exclusively dedicated
to securities finance & with the purchase of Abbey in 2004 has expanded its
capacity on a Global basis with trading teams in London (UK) & Connecticut (USA). W: www.gruposantander.com
T: (3491) 289 39 42/54
Santander's leading local capabilities in Spain, Portugal, UK, USA & Latin America,
E: securitieslending@
along with its solid balance sheet & combined with the state-of-the-art technology,
provides its clients with the broadest range of solutions in securities lending & gruposantander.com
financing, including availability across all assets classes, as well as access to
uncommon emerging markets.
Email: securities.finance@sun-
gard.com
Around the world, USD9 trillion in securities financing is managed on SunGard’s
proven solutions for international and U.S. domestic securities lending and repo for Contact: Switch board: +44 (0)
over 250 clients. Through our Loanet, Global One, Martini and Astec Analytics prod- 208 081 2000 Marketing: +44
ucts and services, we provide comprehensive business solutions and information with (0)208 081 2853
worldwide reach for equities or fixed income securities financing. These solutions –
all in an integrated, exception-based processing architecture – includes order rout- Visit: www.sungard.com/loanet
ing, pre-trade analytics, trading, position management, operations, accounting, set- www.sungard.com/globalone
tlement and reconciliation. www.sungard.com/martini
www.astecgroup.com
Technology .
Advent Software EMEA, established in 1998, provides trusted solutions for the front
through to back office operations, based on a true real-time fund/portfolio
accounting platform, to the investment management community throughout Europe, T: +44 (0)20 7631 9240
Middle East and Africa. Advent has an established network of offices across the F: +44 (0)20 7631 9256
region serving a growing client base of asset managers, hedge fund managers, prime E: emea@advent.com
brokers, fund administrators, wealth managers, private banks and family offices who A: One Bedford Avenue,
continue to improve their businesses using Advent’s suite of integrated investment London WC1B 3AU, UK
management solutions. Advent Software EMEA is part of Advent Software Inc. W: www.advent.com
(Nasdaq: ADVS), a global organisation that has been providing solutions to the
world's leading financial professionals since 1983. Firms in more than 50 countries
using Advent technology manage investments totaling more than US $8 trillion.
Aquin are the market leader in investment compliance software with MIG21® pow-
ered by Aquin LawCards® for global compliance including UCITS III and SEC 1940. Annette Lindinger
The company has built its reputation on solid compliance and IT experience in long press@aquin.com
term relationships with its clients. T: +49 69 21 93 66 600
Aquin services a blue-chip client base of the world’s leading investment F: +49 69 21 93 66 650
Mainzer Landstr. 199
management companies, hedge funds, fund administrators and custodians. These 60326
include Citi, State Street, BNP Paribas, Credit Suisse, CACEIS Investor Services, Frankfurt am Main
Allianz Global Investors, Pioneer Investments and Commerzbank. The company has Germany
its headquarters in Frankfurt, Germany with subsidiaries in Boston, London, Paris, W: www.aquin.com
Dublin, Luxembourg and Zurich.
Broadridge Financial Solutions, formerly ADP Brokerage Services Group, with nearly
$2.0 billion in revenues and more than 40 years of experience, is a leading global
Broadridge Financial Solutions provider of technology-based outsourcing solutions to the financial services industry. Our
The ISIS Building integrated systems and services include international securities processing, investor
193 Marsh Wall communication and outsourcing solutions. We offer advanced, integrated systems and
services that are dependable, scalable and cost-efficient. Our systems help reduce the
London E14 9SG UK need for clients to make significant capital investments in operations infrastructure,
T: +44 (0) 20 7551 3000 thereby allowing them to increase their focus on core business activities.
E: info@broadridge.com Proxy Edge – comprehensive solution for institutional global proxy voting management.
W: www.broadridge.com Gloss – leading international STP system which automates the trade processing lifecycle from
trade capture through confirmation, clearing agency reporting and settlement.
Tarot - a UK retail and private client stockbroking, custody and fund management solution.
Securities Data Management – outsourced data services for securities operations.
DST International is the world’s premier vendor of technology solutions to the global
T: UK +44 (0)20 8390 5000
investment management community with over 700 clients in 55 countries, and
Boston +1 617 482 8800
1500 employees in 19 of the world’s leading financial centres. Our wide range of
Hong Kong +85 225 812 880
asset management solutions meet the needs of fund managers, dealers, settlement
F: +44 (0)20 8390 7000
staff, custodians and record keepers operating as international asset managers; from
E: info@dstintl.com
front office simulation, opinion management and modelling functions, through data
A: DST House, St Mark’s Hill,
management, dealing and settlement to custody and corporate actions. The suite of
Surbiton, Surrey, KT6 4QD
products can be used either as stand-alone applications or brought together in flexi-
W: www.dstinternational.com
ble combinations according to specific needs.
Elemes NM is your partner in global agent bank custodian network management pro-
Fingertip Developments Ltd viding a global view of your relationship network in a powerful and easy to use pack-
Curtain Court age. It includes diary, invoice verification, document management, multi-entity
7 Curtain Road views, reporting, account information incorporating fee and rate structures, contacts,
London EC2A 3LT notes and supports eFee – electronic fee invoicing technology.
UK
T: +44 (0)20 7100 9280 Unrivalled extensibility allows you to develop your own functionality with your in-
enquiries@fingertip- house development team.
developments.com
Flexibility does not stop with the software, our commercial terms offer adaptable
pricing to suit present and future requirements for all sizes of organisation.
For more than a decade, administrators, managers, and advisors have relied
on KOGER for dependable software tools backed by extensive industry T: 001-201-291-7747
experience and expertise. Now, for those who want to reduce costs and F: 001-201-291-7808
streamline business processes, Koger offers Fully Integrated Fund C: Mr Ras Sipko
Administrator, a vertically integrated suite serving the back-office E: ras@kogerusa.com
software needs of the fund industry. KOGER USA
Fully Integrated Fund Administrator consists of three core programs: 12 Route 17 North
~ NTAS, the New Transfer-agency System Suite 111
~ E*TAS, Electronic Transfer Agency System Paramus
~ GRID, Global Reach Interface Daemon New Jersey, NJ 07652, USA
Other programs, such as PTAS, KIT, and KORS available separately, complement W: www.kogerusa.com
the core competency of Fully Integrated Fund Administrator.
Over 100 Capital Markets firms worldwide rely on Singularity to achieve step-change improve-
ments in efficiency and cost-effectiveness. Across front, middle and back office operations,
T: +44 (0)20 7826 4470 Singularity's clients are improving performance by automating process and leveraging their
F: +44 (0)20 7826 4480 human capital most effectively. Our process automation solutions combine deep knowledge
C: Nick Stevens and long-standing capital markets experience with award-winning technology. Clients include
E: sales@singularity.co.uk JPMorgan, Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi UFJ, Raymond James, Prudential, Invesco, BNPParibas,
A: Singularity Morgan Stanley, American Express and M&G.
4th Floor, 101 Moorgate -By cutting latency in securities processing, our clients are recognising new
London EC2M 6SL UK efficiencies, reducing costs and increasing throughput
Further Contacts: -By streamlining their customer on-boarding processes, our clients are gaining faster
US T: +1 212 946 2685 access to fees, increasing customer satisfaction, gaining greater cross-sell opportunities.
-By automating their KYC & other compliance processes, our clients & reducing risk.
Singapore T: +65 9616 7732 -By improving collaboration in their client reporting cycle, our clients are providing more
timely and insightful investment performance information.
With annual revenue of USD5 billion, SunGard is a global leader in software and
processing solutions for financial services, higher education and the public sector.
Visit SunGard at SunGard also helps information-dependent enterprises of all types to ensure the con-
www.sungard.com tinuity of their business. SunGard serves more than 25,000 customers in more than
50 countries, including the world’s 50 largest financial services companies.
FORESIGHT
Greg Froese is Head of Investor
Relations at Lionhart, a global,
multistrategy arbitrage fund with
USD 800m undermanagement, with
offices in London, New York,
Singapore and Toronto.
Analysts are suggesting alternative managers are learning
from traditional managers, with the adoption of strategies
such as 130/30. Can alternative managers learn from
traditional managers?
:PV6T
© UBS 2008. All rights reserved.