HOME PAGE

TODAY'S PAPER

VIDEO

MOST POPULAR

TIMES TOPICS

Travel with the NYT

dvc1337...

Help

Search All NYTimes.com

WORLD

U.S.

N.Y. / REGION

BUSINESS

TECHNOLOGY

SCIENCE

HEALTH

SPORTS

OPINION

ARTS

STYLE

TRAVEL

JOBS

REAL ESTATE

AUTOS

OP-ED CONTRIBUTOR

Raise Wages, Not Walls

By MICHAEL S. DUKAKIS and DANIEL J. B. MITCHELL Published: July 25, 2006

Log in to see what your friends are sharing on nytimes.com. Privacy Policy | Whats This?
RECOMMEND TWITTER LINKEDIN E-MAIL PRINT REPRINTS

Log In With Facebook

THERE are two approaches to illegal immigration currently being debated in Congress. One, supported by the House, emphasizes border control and law enforcement, including a wall along the Mexican border and increased border patrols. The other, which is supported by the Bush administration and has been passed by the Senate, relies on employers to police the workplace. Both proposals have serious flaws.

Whats Popular Now

Judge Says U.S. Must Help States Enforce Voter ID Laws How to Punish Putin

Related Blogs Mises Economics Blog

July 26, 13:34 PM AM

"Every time I read a new proposal from a politician for what the government should do to handle immigration, I think we've hit bottom. But then I'm afraid we haven't. ..."
California Insider
July 26, 9:02 AM

SHARE As opponents of the House plan have rightly pointed out, walls rarely work; illegal immigrants will get around them one way or another. Unless we erect something akin to the Berlin Wall, which would cost billions to build and police, a barrier on the border would be monitored by largely symbolic patrols and easily evaded.

"This is another way of saying that raising the minimum wage hurts lowskilled workers by denying them the opportunity to grab hold of the first rung of the economic ladder. ..."
Marginal Revolution
July 26, 6:14 AM

"The minimum wage creates unemployment among the low-skilled. As a result, the minimum wage tends to create disproportionate unemployment among teenagers and young African Americans. ..."
ParaPundit
July 26, 0:21 AM

The Senate approach is more realistic but it, too, has problems. It creates a temporary worker program but requires employers first to attempt to recruit American workers to fill job openings. It allows for more border fencing, but makes no effort to disguise the basic futility of the enterprise. Instead, it calls on employers to enforce immigration laws in the workplace, a plan that can only succeed through the creation and distribution of a costly national identification card. A national ID card raises serious questions about civil liberties, but they are not the sole concern. The cost estimates for producing and distributing a counterfeitproof card for the roughly 150 million people currently in the labor force and the millions more who will seek work in the near future extend into the billions of dollars. Employers would have to verify the identity of every American worker, otherwise the program would be as unreliable as the one in place now. Anyone erroneously denied a card in this bureaucratic labyrinth would be unemployable. There is a simpler alternative. If we are really serious about turning back the tide of illegal immigration, we should start

MOST EMAILED

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

17

articles viewed recently

dvc1337 All Recommendations

1. Report Issued on War Crimes in Syria

2.

RETIRING

As Living Standards Fall for Seniors, Some See Signs of Silver Revolution 3.
N.F.L. ROUNDUP

Receiver Sanders Joins the Broncos FreeAgency Haul 4. Ukraine Premier Makes Plea at the U.N. 5. Backstrom to Receive Medal 6. China Snubs U.N.s North Korea Report 7.

"The economic downside for the economy as a whole would be fairly small. ..."
No More Apples
July 25, 18:42 PM AM

"Now here's the thing that they didn't quite say. By raising the minimum wage the onus is put on employers

STATE OF THE ART

Discovering Two Screens Arent Better Than One

instead of taxpayers. ..."

Michael Williams -- Master of None
July 25, 16:42 PM AM

"But illegal immigrants work illegally and aren't paid the minimum wage -- only legal workers are. ..."
JustOneMinute
July 25, 15:05 PM AM

by raising the minimum wage from $5.15 per hour to something closer to $8. The Massachusetts legislature recently voted to raise the state minimum to $8 and California may soon set its minimum even higher. Once the minimum wage has been significantly increased, we can begin vigorously enforcing the wage law and other basic labor standards. Millions of illegal immigrants work for minimum and even sub-minimum wages in workplaces that dont come close to meeting health and safety standards. It is nonsense to say, as President Bush did recently, that these jobs are filled by illegal immigrants because Americans wont do them. Before we had mass illegal immigration in this country, hotel beds were made, office floors were cleaned, restaurant dishes were washed and crops were picked by Americans. Americans will work at jobs that are risky, dirty or unpleasant so long as they provide decent wages and working conditions, especially if employers also provide health insurance. Plenty of Americans now work in such jobs, from mining coal to picking up garbage. The difference is they are paid a decent wage and provided

8.

THE NEW OLD AGE

Mammography's Limits, Seldom Understood

9. For-Profit Schools Face New Default Rules 10.

MUSEUMS SPECIAL SECTION

Wooing a New Generation of Museum Patrons

Go to Your Recommendations
Whats This? | Dont Show

"One can't say this idea lacks imagination. ..."

Hit & Run
July 25, 5:12 AM

"I'm guessing any conservative economist who predicted employment contraction of that magnitude following a $3 hike in the minimum wage would get roundly blasted as an alarmist wingnut and shill for business. ..."
Neuticles aren!t funny
July 24, 21:50 PM AM

The battle over the MedFly

ALSO IN VIDEO

"Won't the effect actually be to incentivize additional 'off the books' employees at subminimum wages? ..."

Fashion month fast-forward What's In It: Cookie Dough Oreos

benefits for their labor. However, Americans wont work for peanuts, and these days the national minimum wage is less than peanuts. For full-time work, it doesnt even come close to the poverty line for an individual, let alone provide a family with a living wage. It hasnt been raised since 1997 and isnt enforced even at its currently ridiculous level. Yet enforcing the minimum wage doesnt require walling off a porous border or trying to distinguish yesterdays illegal immigrant from tomorrows guest worker. All it takes is a willingness by the federal government to inspect workplaces to determine which employers obey the law. Curiously, most members of Congress who take a hard line on immigration also strongly oppose increasing the minimum wage, claiming it will hurt businesses and reduce jobs. For some reason, they dont seem eager to acknowledge that many of the jobs they claim to hold dear are held by the same illegal immigrants they are trying to deport. But if we want to reduce illegal immigration, it makes sense to reduce the abundance of extremely low-paying jobs that fuels it. If we raise the minimum wage, its possible some low-end jobs may be lost; but more Americans would also be willing to work in such jobs, thereby denying them to people who arent supposed to be here in the first place. And tough enforcement of wage rules would curtail the growth of an underground economy in which both illegal immigration and employer abuses thrive. Raising the minimum wage and increasing enforcement would prove far more effective and less costly than either proposal currently under consideration in Congress. If Congress would only remove its blinders about the minimum wage, it may see a plan to deal effectively with illegal immigration, too.
Michael S. Dukakis, the governor of Massachusetts from 1975 to 1979 and from 1983 to 1991, is a professor of political science at Northeastern University. Daniel J. B. Mitchell is a professor of management and public policy at the University of California at Los Angeles.

Ads by Google

what's this?

3.75% APY CD Rates

Open A High Yield CD & Get 3.75% APY For 12/Months. FDIC Insured!

dotellall.com

A version of this op-ed appeared in print on July 25, 2006, on page A19 of the New York edition with the headline: Raise Wages, Not Walls.

E-MAIL PRINT REPRINTS

Get Free E-mail Alerts on These Topics

Immigration and Refugees Wages and Salaries Labor Dukakis, Michael S

Ads by Google what's this?

Lumosity Brain Games

Challenge memory and attention with scientific brain games.

www.lumosity.com

Home

World

U.S.

N.Y. / Region

Business Privacy

Technology

Science

Health

Sports

Opinion

Arts

Style

Travel RSS

Jobs

Real Estate

Autos

Site Map Advertise

2011 The New York Times Company

Your Ad Choices

Terms of Service

Terms of Sale

Corrections

Help

Contact Us

Work for Us