Silent Cry of the Poor A Flood of Greed in the Section 8 & Public Housing Program By Ruby Bozeman-Davis & Viola Davis copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 2 Silent Cry of the Poor Featuring: Sisterhood of Survivors (SOS) Residents of Section 8 and Public Housing Repertoire Community Resource Center with Joyce McKibben (Founder/CEO) Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter with Ruby Bozeman-Davis and Viola Davis (Founders/Community Missionaries) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 3 Silent Cry of the Poor Sisterhood of Survivors Mission: Educate, Empower, Mentor, and Train women to come together to be self-sufficient and home owners in the future. Eliminate the fear, intimidation, threats, coercion, and suffering experienced by residents who challenge wrongdoing by people who work for programs directed to help the poor. Elevate women to be self-sufficient to the point of no longer needing assistance from governmental systems. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 4 Silent Cry of the Poor Sisterhood of Survivors Residents of Lithonia Housing Authority copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 5 Silent Cry of the Poor Repertoire Community Resource Center with Joyce McKibben (Founder/CEO) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 6 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter www.unhappytaxpayerandvoter.com www.campaignwindow.com/talkissues copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 7 Silent Cry of the Poor copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 8 Silent Cry of the Poor Did You Know? A child was admitted to the emergency room to have roaches removed from the childs ear. A woman filed a police report to stop Housing Authority staff from entering her apartment unannounced while she is in the bathtub. A woman was threatened for advocating for the poor and shining a light on problems with the Section 8 and Public Housing program. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 9 Silent Cry of the Poor Section 8 & Public Housing Residents Vs DeKalb County Housing Authority and Lithonia Housing Authority copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 10 Silent Cry of the Poor Section 8 Housing Act: The Section 8 Housing Act provide for the Section 8 Rental Assistance Program was enacted as part of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, which served as an amendment to the U.S. Housing Act of 1937. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 11 Silent Cry of the Poor DeKalb County Housing Authority and the Lithonia Housing Authority have failed to achieve the major goals of the program as stated in the manual such as: Encourage participating families to exercise their rights under freedom of choice housing. Reduce areas of high minority concentration with very low- income families. Encourage affordable housing providers to rent decent, safe, and sanitary housing to low-income families including housing opportunities for elderly and disabled/handicapped persons. Create, maintain and encourage programs that assist families and help them become economically self-sufficient. Provide timely monthly rental assistance payments as incentives to private property providers to rent to participating families in the DCHA rental assistance program. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 12 Silent Cry of the Poor Housing Quality Standards (HQS) under the Section 8 program is designed to ensure that the owner provides decent, safe, sanitary and affordable units. Basically, HQS is established standards to ensure the unit is in good condition and it does not endanger the health and safety of the family. (Page-32) Owner/Landlord Informational Manual copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 13 Silent Cry of the Poor Exposed wires at Lithonia Housing Authority Violation of the Housing Quality Standards (HQS) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 14 Silent Cry of the Poor Exposed wires at the Lithonia Housing Authority Violation of the Housing Quality Standards (HQS) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 15 Silent Cry of the Poor Why should Taxpayers and Voters care? DeKalb County Housing Authority operation budget is 56 million per year. Money used to finance Housing Authorities is your tax dollars. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 16 Silent Cry of the Poor HQS have been established to ensure minimum acceptable levels for units such as toilets must be a private flush toilet fastened to the floor, adequate ventilation either from an operable window or an exhaust fan, heating system capable of heating the unit to a comfortable temperature in each room, unit should not have any unvented room heaters that burn gas, oil, or kerosene, no roaches or rodents infestations, smoke detectors must work, exterior doors must be reasonably weather tight and have a permanent type of weather-stripping and threshold that seals, etc. Owner/Landlord Informational Manual (Pages 34- 39) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 17 Silent Cry of the Poor Violations of Housing Quality Standards at the Lithonia Housing Authority. Lithonia Housing Authority inspections were performed by inspectors working for the DeKalb County Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 18 Silent Cry of the Poor Under the Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity, owners are prohibited from discriminating in housing because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, and handicap. It is illegal for anyone to threaten, coerce, intimidate or interfere with anyone exercising a fair housing right or assisting others who exercise that right and advertise or make any statement that indicates a limitation or preference based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status or handicap. (Page-57) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 19 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter filed complaints with the following: Senator Saxby Chambliss Senator Johnny Isakson DeKalb Housing Authority Lithonia Housing Authority HUD FHEO DeKalb County Board of Commissioners CEO Vernon Jones HUD Inspector General copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 20 Silent Cry of the Poor Senator Johnny Isakson was the first to answer our cry with a written request to the US Department of Housing and Urban Development to investigate the threats, intimidation, etc. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 21 Silent Cry of the Poor We thank Senator Johnny Isakson for his concern and untiring pursuit to serve the constituency of Georgia, particularly DeKalb County. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 22 Silent Cry of the Poor View Documents at Exhibit F Section A pages 1-2 To view documents Proceed to Table of Content copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 23 Silent Cry of the Poor Senator Saxby Chambliss also sent letters to the US Department of Housing and Urban Development. We thank Senator Chambliss for his concern and untiring pursuit to serve the constituency of Georgia, particularly DeKalb County. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 24 Silent Cry of the Poor Lynetrice Preston Tenant admitted her child into the emergency for a spider bite that was infected that require the child to receive IV antibiotic and a stay in the hospital. Ms. Preston has complained repeated about infestation of roaches and spiders and the need for professional exterminators. She has also complained about mold and other problems. Please see personal letters and documentation within Ms. Prestons file. (Exhibit I Section A 1-26) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 25 Silent Cry of the Poor copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 26 Silent Cry of the Poor Lynetrice Preston Tenant received a letter from the Rushing Firm, LTD for termination of lease dated June 18, 2004 for violation of lease agreement section (F) maintenance and services, subsection (2). One of the violations involves the heating equipment. Ms. Preston asked Atlanta Gas Light to inspect her heating unit. The heating unit has not operated correctly for over a year. Atlanta Gas Light documented that the heating unit must not be turned on until the conditions indicated have been corrected such as improper vent and appliance in bad order that need to be serviced or replaced by a qualified agency/person. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 27 Silent Cry of the Poor Lynetrice Prestons bathroom was Nailed Shut for over three days. She and her four children had no other place to go to the bathroom. She was later threatened with eviction for exposing the deplorable living conditions at the Lithonia Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 28 Silent Cry of the Poor DeKalb County Commissioner Lee May, Assistant Loretta Davis, and Community Missionary Viola Davis went to 7170 Center Street (Ms.Prestons apartment), Apt. 14 to witness the bathroom Nailed Shut. Commissioner Lee May copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 29 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter filled out the request form to schedule an appointment with the Executive Director Martha Calloway at the Lithonia Housing Authority on 8/16/06. We requested verbally to view the annual audit report. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 30 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter stated the fact that we witnessed the bathroom nailed shut and requested to discuss the reason Ms. Preston was in tears from being told she would be evicted by the Housing Authority. Patta Wolford stamped and signed the form. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 31 Silent Cry of the Poor Lithonia Housing Authority response? Called the police on members of the Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter the same day. Called the Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Alliance Poverty Pimps. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 32 Silent Cry of the Poor Deplorable Living Conditions at the Lithonia Housing Authority Violation of Housing Quality Standards. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 33 Silent Cry of the Poor On 10/24/06, Ms. Lynetrice Preston received a Danger Slip from the Atlanta Gas Light and had her gas turned off due to improper vent and appliance in bad order. The repairs required a qualified agency/person. (Exhibit C Section E page 7) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 34 Silent Cry of the Poor Ms. Preston Childrens Playground copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 35 Silent Cry of the Poor Ms. Prestons Backyard View copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 36 Silent Cry of the Poor Owner has a responsibility to maintain the property in good condition and complete repairs within the required timeframe upon request by DCHA or the tenant (within 24 hours for life threatening HQS failures) (page-21) Owner/Landlord Informational Manual copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 37 Silent Cry of the Poor Residents called for the removal of a dead cat without anyone answering their cry. Residents repeatedly complained about dangerous mold out of control. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 38 Silent Cry of the Poor James Judy Tenant was evicted due to her daughters failure to complete community service. James Judy is classified as a disabled person by law and has a person who is to handle her legal affairs. When she went to court for the eviction, Lithonia Housing Authority had Ms. James Judy sign the legal document for eviction instead of dealing with the person assigned to handle her legal affairs. The fact that Ms. James Judy was disabled with a mental condition was not stated in the court despite the Lithonia Housing Authority having full knowledge of such facts. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 39 Silent Cry of the Poor Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity has additional protection for people with a disability such as physical or mental disability that substantially limits one or more major life activities, have a record of such disability or are regarded as having such a disability. (Page-57) Owner/Landlord Informational Manual copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 40 Silent Cry of the Poor James Judy Tenant felt intimidated by Mrs. Martha Callaway because of the verbal abuse, inhumane treatment, constant interference into Ms. Judy family affairs, and unreasonable charges such as $600.00 for a water bill when it is stated on the lease that the owner will provide water. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 41 Silent Cry of the Poor Lease Agreement states the landlord shall provide water and sewer for dwelling unit without any additional charge to the tenant. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 42 Silent Cry of the Poor Natasha D. Anthony Tenant felt intimidation due to the maintenance staff constantly entering her apartment without 24-hour notice and without acknowledging who they were before entering the room. She has made police reports and complaints. Maintenance staff has entered her apartment on several occasions without prior notice and at times she was in the bathtub. Picture of a Model copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 43 Silent Cry of the Poor Natasha D. Anthony Lithonia Housing Authority staff has entered her apartment with other people who do not work for the housing authority. Ms. Anthony has filed police reports for stolen property. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 44 Silent Cry of the Poor Llechandra Riggins Tenant complained of staff entering her apartment without a 24-hour notice. She felt an inability to enjoy her apartment without fear of someone coming in unannounced. Picture of a Model copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 45 Silent Cry of the Poor Lease Agreement states Landlord covenants and promises that the tenant, upon regular and full completion the requirements of this lease shall peaceably and quietly use, occupy, possess and enjoy the premises for the full term of the lease without, hindrance, eviction, molestation, or interruption whatsoever, except as provided expressly by the lease. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 46 Silent Cry of the Poor Shirvica I. Griffie Tenant felt intimidated due to violation of her right to privacy. She would often complain about the severe infestation of roaches and spiders to the Lithonia Housing Authority. She also complained about the mold. When Ms. Griffie moved into the Lithonia Housing Authority, she was told she could leave after one year. However, she was threaten with the lose of her Section 8 voucher if she left the housing authority like many other women living in the residence of the Lithonia Housing Authority. She was forced to live in deplorable living conditions with her children. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 47 Silent Cry of the Poor Infestation of roaches Roaches allegedly fell on the Inspectors head at the Lithonia Housing Authority Violation of the Housing Quality Standards copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 48 Silent Cry of the Poor Infestation of roaches is a violation of HQS. Note the roach in the cotton candy. This apartment is at the Lithonia Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 49 Silent Cry of the Poor Infestation of roaches Roaches were noted to be embedded in the bricks outside the apartments at the Lithonia Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 50 Silent Cry of the Poor Shannika L. Grant Tenant called the health inspector at the DeKalb Health Department due to the lack of response from the Lithonia Housing Authority to her complaint of mold. Mrs. Martha Calloway calls Ms. Grant with an attitude several times to say Ms. Grant should not have called the health department. Ms. Grant has 4 children to include a set of twins with asthma. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 51 Silent Cry of the Poor Shannika Grant was allegedly threaten with eviction and lose of her Section 8 Voucher/Public Housing for calling community activists and the health department. Staff of Lithonia Housing Authority called her job several times causing her stress and fear. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 52 Silent Cry of the Poor Lithonia Housing Authority Executive Director Martha Calloway refused to move or relocate Ms. Grant to a new safe sanitary apartment despite repeated documented request from Ms. Grant twins physician. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 53 Silent Cry of the Poor Cassandra Austin Tenant called the health department about mold due to the lack of response of the Lithonia Housing Authority. Ms. Austin received a call from a person after office hours asking her why she called the health department. The person threatened Ms. Austin by saying she would lose her apartment and her Section 8 voucher if she reports to the health department again. Ms. Austin felt threaten and stated she has a right to call the health department. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 54 Silent Cry of the Poor Dangerous Mold Out of Control at the Lithonia Housing Authority copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 55 Silent Cry of the Poor Dangerous Mold at the Lithonia Housing Authority. Would you pay to live here? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 56 Silent Cry of the Poor Dangerous Mold at the Lithonia Housing Authority. What would you pay to live here? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 57 Silent Cry of the Poor Dangerous Mold at the Lithonia Housing Authority. Would you rent this apartment? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 58 Silent Cry of the Poor Dangerous Mold copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 59 Silent Cry of the Poor Dangerous Mold at the Lithonia Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 60 Silent Cry of the Poor More Dangerous Mold at the Lithonia Housing Authority copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 61 Silent Cry of the Poor Would you pay to rent any apartments at the Lithonia Housing Authority? If you answer is no, we want to inform you that it is your tax dollars that finance the misery of the residents at Lithonia Housing Authority. How much money? Lithonia Housing Authority refuses to answer the question and refuses to allow the Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Alliance to view the HUD mandated annual audit report. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 62 Silent Cry of the Poor Ericka Hutchins Tenant complained of the poor heating system in the apartment. She also complained of the deplorable living conditions. She reported her daughter received first and second degree burns from the heating system that require treatment at the DeKalb Medical Center at Hillandale Emergency Department. (Exhibit C Section D page 6) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 63 Silent Cry of the Poor December 2006, Ericka Hutchins received a Danger Slip from Atlanta Gas Light that stated the appliance was in bad order. Lithonia Housing Authority sent Ms. Hutchins an eviction notice for having her gas utility turned off. Court case was amended after evidence was presented in court that the gas was on. It was alleged that Lithonia Housing Authority retaliated against Ms. Hutchins for bringing attention to the deplorable living conditions. Exhibit C Section C page 5 copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 64 Silent Cry of the Poor Ericka Hutchins appeared before DeKalb Board of Commissioners and was a strong voice against the Lithonia Housing Authority. Civil Action filed by the Lithonia Housing Authority v. Erica Hutchins in December 2006. Initial pleading changed after allegation was not verified. Ms. Hutchins was evicted from her apartment. Ms. Hutchins alleged this was an example of retaliation. (Exhibit B Section L pages 26- 28) Lithonia Housing Authority Office copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 65 Silent Cry of the Poor Exposed gas lines at the Lithonia Housing Authority. Violation of the Housing Quality Standards. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 66 Silent Cry of the Poor Deplorable Living Condition with roach infestation at the Lithonia Housing Authority. Violation of the Housing Quality Standard (HQS). copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 67 Silent Cry of the Poor Deplorable Living Conditions Residents were instructed to clean dangerous mold away with bleach at the Lithonia Housing Authority. Would you pay the live here? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 68 Silent Cry of the Poor Teneeco Howard Tenant felt intimidated and deceived by management. She has a very extensive file from writing complaints to the Lithonia Housing Authority about the deplorable living conditions. Mrs. Martha Calloway was very angry with her for documenting the problems. Ms. Howard wrote letters to Ms. Betty Davis complaining of the living conditions and lack of repairs to her apartments. The Lithonia Housing Authority would use the inspection process to threaten Ms. Howard with termination several times. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 69 Silent Cry of the Poor The Lithonia Housing Authority would use the inspection process to threaten Ms. Howard with termination several times. The letter from the Lithonia Housing Authority dated September 27, 2006 stated Ms. Howard had seven days to vacate the premises despite there being no court order. They made reference to a letter dated September 11, 2006 that Ms. Howard never received. The manner in which the Lithonia Housing Authority has utilized the eviction process is in clear violation of HUD policy and procedure as well as state law. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 70 Silent Cry of the Poor Failed inspections and Re-inspection are the responsibility of the owner to schedule with the inspector. If the unit fails the inspection, the owner must schedule a re-inspection with the inspector after the necessary repairs have been completed. After the residents brought attention to the deplorable living condition, DeKalb and Lithonia Housing Authority changed this policy. The failed inspections were unfairly used to evict residents especially if they were viewed as troublemakers. (Page-33) Owner/Landlord Informational Manual copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 71 Silent Cry of the Poor 1. The manner in which the Lithonia Housing Authority has utilized the eviction process is in clear violation of HUD policy and procedure as well as state law. Ms. Howard was required to pay $517.00 for a security deposit while other tenants were given an amount of no more than $200.00. Exhibit I Section H (pages 65-83) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 72 Silent Cry of the Poor Section 8 Policy: Owners are prohibited from charging Section 8 families more for a security deposit than their unassisted families. Owners are prohibited from charging a security deposit that is in excess of private market practice. The owner may collect appropriate security deposit amounts as directed by State and Local law. (Page 10 and 21) Owner/Landlord Informational Manual copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 73 Silent Cry of the Poor Safi M. Yusuf Tenant felt intimidated because she repeatedly requested to relocate to an area in Clarkston to be near other people from her country for added support with her family. Lithonia Housing Authority made it clear to her that she would lose her assistance if she moved to another location. She was forced to live in a one-bedroom apartment with three children. The heating unit in her apartment was dangerous and she had problems with flooding when it rained. Ms. Yusuf appeared at the DeKalb County Board of Commissioners meeting to voice her problems to the public and now worry about retaliation. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 74 Silent Cry of the Poor Mrs. Yusuf and her family escaped death on December 18, 2006 when the carbon monoxide exceeded safe levels. Atlanta Gas Light turned off her gas when the temperature was below freezing. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 75 Silent Cry of the Poor Atlanta Gas Light gave Ms. Yusuf a Danger Slip to explain the reason the gas must be turned off. The carbon monoxide at the space heater registered 11ppm. Normal level is zero per opinion of the local fire department. Exhibit C Section A and B copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 76 Silent Cry of the Poor The media (WSB) was called to force Lithonia Housing Authority to replace the defective heating units. Ms. Yusuf was allegedly threatened by Lithonia Housing Authority staff for calling WSB (Channel 2) and Joyce McKibben. Ms. Yusuf stated, I cried all night and I want to move closer to my people in Clarkston, Georgia. Exhibit C Section A and Section B copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 77 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter letter to HUD Secretary Alphonso Jackson concerning the Life Threatening Situation at the Lithonia Housing Authority. (Exhibit C Section F & G) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 78 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter email a memo to Sherry Ware concerning the Life-Threatening Situation and were instructed by Sherry Ware to wait for correspondence in the mail. (Exhibit C Section H and Section I) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 79 Silent Cry of the Poor Heating unit: Before and After being exposed on WSBTV Safi Yusufs apartment at the Lithonia Housing Authority copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 80 Silent Cry of the Poor Lithonia Housing Authority forced the resident to signed with the Authorities gas provider. If the residents refused to use their provider, they were allegedly threatened with eviction. Due to the higher cost, some residents were allegedly evicted for having their gas turned off for lack of payment. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 81 Silent Cry of the Poor Joyce McKibben with the Repertoire Community Resource Center met with Cynthia Johnson and Legal Aid in an attempt to get the resident access to the regulated provider. Cynthia Johnson was with the Georgia Public Service Commission. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 82 Silent Cry of the Poor After several meeting, Cynthia Johnson and Joyce McKibben were successful at bypassing the agreement between Lithonia Housing Authority and the gas provider to offer gas service to low income residents from the regulated provider at a cheaper price. Research is yet complete to assess if the Housing Authority received monetary compensation for the agreement. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 83 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter were informed of a HUD regulation that mandates Housing Authorities evict residents if any of the utilities are off. As Community Missionaries, we are working hard to repeal this regulation/rule. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 84 Silent Cry of the Poor The inspector will make sure the number of bedrooms is correct and that the rent is appropriate for the unit size. The inspector notes any safety hazards along with defects or deterioration such as peeling paint. The inspector is looking for the unit to meet the basic level of health and safety for all units leased under the Housing Choice Voucher. (Page-32) Owner/Landlord Informational Manual copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 85 Silent Cry of the Poor Ethel Gibson Mrs. Ethel Gibson was a tenant who made every effort to assist her next-door neighbors that are an elderly couple living in deplorable conditions. Lithonia Housing Authority would spray for infestation in Ms. Gibsons apartment and refuse to spray the elderly couples apartment next door. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 86 Silent Cry of the Poor Ethel Gibson Ms. Ethel Gibson would use her own money to buy roach spray to help with the infestation of her elderly neighbors. Ms. Gibson also made verbal complaint about the two apartments above her being empty and going approximately a year without being properly cleaned. She felt this made the roach and spider infestation worst. What would you pay to live in this apartment at the Lithonia Housing Authority? What would you pay to live here? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 87 Silent Cry of the Poor Lease Agreement states if a tenant leaves the apartment unoccupied for a period of 30 days, the unit will be considered vacated. Landlord and the Public Housing Authority (PHA) must be advised and approval given beyond the above period of time. Lease Agreement extermination services and repainting shall be provided by the landlord as conditions may require. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 88 Silent Cry of the Poor We decided to ask the Inspector General to research the two apartments above Ethel Gibson at 2582 Kelly Street #1 to see if the Lithonia Housing Authority continued to collect federal funds while the apartments were empty. We requested an investigation to verify if the actions stated above is a constant practice of the Lithonia Housing Authority with the knowledge of a few at the DeKalb County Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 89 Silent Cry of the Poor Pictures were taken of several empty apartments to compare with documented payments from HUD. Potential for fraud increases with project based programs. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 90 Silent Cry of the Poor Lithonia Housing Authoritys vacate apartments Did they continue to collect payments while the apartments were vacate? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 91 Silent Cry of the Poor copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 92 Silent Cry of the Poor Vacate Apartments at the Lithonia Housing Authority copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 93 Silent Cry of the Poor Lithonia Housing Authoritys vacate apartments Did they continue to collect payment while the apartments were vacate? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 94 Silent Cry of the Poor The Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Alliance in partnership with the Repertoire Community Resource Center have endured verbal threats, negative characterizations, intimidation, retaliation, and interference to help residents within the Section 8 and Public Housing program receive decent, safe, and sanitary housing. We have had to endure verbal insults while we attempt to advocate for the poor and elderly residents concerning the deplorable living conditions at the Lithonia Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 95 Silent Cry of the Poor CEO Vernon Jones and the DeKalb County Board of Commissioners appoint people to the DeKalb County Housing Authority Board. DeKalb County Housing Authority does Lithonia Housing Authority inspections. They also provide funding for the Section 8 & Public Housing programs. CEO Vernon Jones copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 96 Silent Cry of the Poor Joyce McKibben and the Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter encouraged the residents of the Lithonia Housing Authority to speak at the public comment to inform the people of the deplorable living conditions. DeKalb Board of Commissioners stated they did not have any jurisdiction over the Lithonia Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 97 Silent Cry of the Poor After researching the money, the Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Alliance sent the DeKalb Board of Commissioners a memo titled, Selective Jurisdiction: $78,750 for a for profit business or nonprofit organization. The document questioned the BOC contract to Jason Lary Presents in Lithonia, Georgia; yet, DeKalb refused to get involve with the deplorable living conditions at the Lithonia Housing Authority. (Exhibit D Section A pages 1-7) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 98 Silent Cry of the Poor After the document was given to the Board of Commissioners, CEO Vernon Jones allegedly sent the memo to Jason Lary. The Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter was unable to get an explanation from the Board of Commissioners as to how CEO Vernon Jones obtained the document. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 99 Silent Cry of the Poor Jason Lary contacted Joyce McKibben by telephone and was screaming and cursing. Joyce McKibben stated in her letter that it is literally with fear and trembling that she write the letter. Joyce McKibben contacted the Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Founder Viola Davis to find out why Jason Lary cursed her out. Unfortunately, Ms. McKibben had no knowledge of the memorandum. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 100 Silent Cry of the Poor Joyce McKibben wrote a letter to document the threats made by Jason Lary. (Exhibit D Section A-D) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 101 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Alliance wrote a memorandum to CEO Vernon Jones and the DeKalb County Board of Commissioner asking why CEO Vernon Jones sent our document to a private individual. Did CEO Vernon Jones instruct Mr. Lary to intimidate both Joyce McKibben and Viola Davis? Exhibit D Section C & F copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 102 Silent Cry of the Poor Joyce McKibben endured the following threats of violence: Martha Calloway threaten Joyce McKibben and stated she would have her thrown in jail if she came on Lithonia Housing Authority Property. Physical contact witnessed by residents between Joyce McKibben and Martha Calloway. Attempt to get media to write bad stories on Joyce McKibben concerning her nonprofit. (Exhibit D) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 103 Silent Cry of the Poor Viola Davis with Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter endured the following threats: Verbal threats given to Joyce McKibben and residents of the Lithonia Housing Authority to pass on the Viola Davis. Negative Characterization of the Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter by Jason Lary during a Lithonia City Council meeting. Local Media contacted by Martha Calloway to discuss the Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter. (Exhibit D ) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 104 Silent Cry of the Poor From left to right: Ethel Gibson, Lynetrice Preston, and Natasha Anthony have filed a complaint against Martha Calloway and the Lithonia Housing Authority due to constant episodes of intimidation, harassment, and retaliation with the FHEO. They submitted documentation to receive their Section 8 Vouchers to relocate. (Exhibit B Section A-K pages 1-25) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 105 Silent Cry of the Poor The three Sisterhood of Survivor Founders received a 14 day termination letter from the Lithonia Housing Authority despite the Housing Assistance Payment (HAP) paying the rent on the same day of 1/9/07 for Barnes-Gibson, Preston, and Anthony. Again, they submitted documentation to receive their Section 8 Vouchers to relocate. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 106 Silent Cry of the Poor The three women gave Martha Calloway a request for a conference on the 14 day notice of termination and Section 8 Vouchers. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 107 Silent Cry of the Poor When Natasha Anthony requested Martha Calloway stamp her paper, Martha Calloway refused. Ms. Anthony stated, Mrs. Calloway had a nasty tone. (Copy of Letter and tape of incident provided on Request) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 108 Silent Cry of the Poor Joyce McKibben with the Repertoire Community Resource Center worked diligently for over four years to bring attention to the deplorable living condition in an attempt to resolve problems with the Lithonia Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 109 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter request funding to the Lithonia Housing Authority be cut completely and the residents living in the deplorable living conditions receive their Section 8 Vouchers to relocate to safer living conditions and/or relocation to other public housing units. We request a full investigation of the DeKalb and Lithonia Housing Authorities inspection process and the negligent inspections that cause the residents suffering. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 110 Silent Cry of the Poor The Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Alliance request a forensic audit of the Lithonia Housing Authority operation budget, federal funds for the Section 8 and Public Housing Program to verify alleged mismanagement, fraud, etc. HUD needs to revoke and/or terminate Lithonia Housing Authority right to participate in the Section 8 and Public Housing program due to a long history and practice of non-compliance with state and federal rules, regulations, and laws. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 111 Silent Cry of the Poor Reason for a forensic audit is to answer the following questions: How much money was allocated for repairs and new appliances for the units at the Lithonia Housing Authority? Did Lithonia Housing Authority continue to collect payments on the vacate apartments? What happened to the large number of residents unfairly and illegally evicted due to utilities being turned off, lack of repairs, failure to comply with Housing Authorities process, etc? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 112 Silent Cry of the Poor Under the False Claim Act, Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Alliance and the Repertoire Community Resource Center request the DeKalb and Lithonia Housing Authority be held accountable to the fullest extent of the law. Inspectors who falsified reports need to be fired from the Housing Authorities. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 113 Silent Cry of the Poor Federal Time for Fraud and False Claims copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 114 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter request drastic action for the following reasons: Martha Calloway lied to HUD when she received no request for the annual audit of the Lithonia Housing Authority. We requested the annual audit twice verbally despite having the police called on us. We have included the request in writing on at least two documents hand delivered to the Lithonia Housing Authority. Please see Exhibit A Section A, B, and C; Exhibit H Section C pages 5-7. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 115 Silent Cry of the Poor HUD Regional Director Bob Young used statements from Martha Calloway that were false to explain to the Senators about the incident at the Lithonia Housing Authority. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 116 Silent Cry of the Poor Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter Alliance gave DeKalb and Lithonia an Open Records Request to view the Annual Audit mandated by HUD and other documents/information. They hand delivered the request to the office of the Lithonia Housing Authority. In Mr. Bob Youngs letter, he suggested the Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter submit an open records request. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 117 Silent Cry of the Poor Documents from City Clerk of Lithonia, Georgia and Resident Representative, Charlotte Sledge. (Exhibit G Section A and other documents on request) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 118 Silent Cry of the Poor Whos lying? Martha Calloway or Residents of Lithonia Housing Authority Mrs. Calloway stated one of the Board members is a resident; however, Agnes Sanders left the Board since 2/23/06 according to Lithonia City Clerk and newly appointed member Charlotte Sledge signed a document dated 1/9/2007 that stated she was never informed nor attended a Resident Advisory Board or Board of Commissioners meeting. (See Exhibit G) copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 119 Silent Cry of the Poor U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development mandates a resident must be on the Housing Authorities Board. Martha Calloway has refused to answer our open records request on their budget, units, etc. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 120 Silent Cry of the Poor Section 8 vouchers used within Lithonia Housing Authority were unfairly maintained through threats, coercion, and intimidation in order to pay the mortgage and salaries. We have requested information on the Section 8 program for over one year, yet HUD and DeKalb County Housing Authority are unable to provide a written agreement between Lithonia and DeKalb County Housing Authorities. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 121 Silent Cry of the Poor Housing Authority of DeKalb County gave the residents of the Lithonia Housing Authority until December 15, 2004 to move if they did not want there tenant based voucher to change to a project based voucher. Unfortunately, the document was dated December 23, 2004. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 122 Silent Cry of the Poor The residents of the Lithonia Housing Authority endured verbal threats, intimidation, coercion, and deplorable living condition to hold on to their Section 8 Voucher. New residents were told their vouchers were portable until they lived in the apartments for one year then their vouchers were changed to project based forcing them to stay in the deplorable condition. DeKalb and Lithonia Housing Authorities engaged in the deception together to the detriment of the residents and their families. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 123 Silent Cry of the Poor Mrs. Martha Calloway refused to give residents their Section 8 Voucher to relocate to safe, sanitary, decent and affordable housing of their choice. She changed their tenant based vouchers to project based vouchers without a legal or clearly defined rule and/or regulation from HUD. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 124 Silent Cry of the Poor Housing Quality Standards have been circumvent through the use of an inspection system and inspectors that passed housing that clearly should have failed. Every tax dollar used to finance these units needs to be repaid back to the taxpayers and voters due to negligence and abuse of power. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 125 Silent Cry of the Poor Mrs. Martha Calloway, CEO of the Lithonia Housing Authority, lack leadership allegedly for the following reasons: No viable resident on the Board of Commissioners No functional Resident Advisory Board No Annual Audit report A Board of Commissioners that was missing half of its members No constant scheduled public meetings copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 126 Silent Cry of the Poor Mrs. Betty Davis, CEO of DeKalb County Housing Authority, has leadership allegedly for the following reason: Successfully returned the authority to a high performance agency by having an annual audit Complete Board of Commissioners with scheduled public meetings. Resident on the Board of Commissioners Functional Resident Advisory Board with a Members Handbook. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 127 Silent Cry of the Poor Mrs. Martha Calloway continues to be CEO of the Lithonia Housing Authority. Mrs. Betty Davis was fired from the DeKalb County Housing Authority. What is wrong with this picture? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 128 Silent Cry of the Poor DeKalb County Housing Authority has a budget of the following: Approximately 56 million tax dollars per year Public Housing units 525 Waiting List 1,655 Section 8 - 5,766 Information may be view on their website at www.dekalbhousing.org copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 129 Silent Cry of the Poor Lithonia Housing Authority has refused to answer any question about their budget, board, units, inspections, etc. How did the Lithonia Housing Authority manage to terrorize the residents and hold them hostage to these deplorable living conditions? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 130 Silent Cry of the Poor Lithonia Housing Authority units need to be condemn. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 131 Silent Cry of the Poor Should our tax dollars be used to finance these atrocities? Should our tax dollars continue to finance this misery? Would you rent any of these apartments from the Lithonia Housing Authority? How did the apartments at the Lithonia Housing Authority pass inspections? copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 132 Silent Cry of the Poor We pray that you will help us by taking the following actions: Make a donation to the Repertoire Community Resource Center and the Unhappy Taxpayer & Voter to keep us fighting for the Least of Thee. Call your elected officials and demand they change/repeal the regulation and/or rule that mandates the Housing Authorities to evict families if their utilities are off. Call your elected officials and demand they keep the Section 8 Vouchers tenant based to prevent an increase in fraud and abuse of power. Repertoire Community Resource Center with Joyce McKibben. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 133 Silent Cry of the Poor Contact Information: Joyce McKibben has information on the history of the deplorable living condition the residents have endured at 770-896-4581 Attorney Melvin Johnson at 404-297-2671 if you have questions on the abuse the residents have endured as well as evictions. Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter at 770-267-0034 or via email at voterwhocares@aol.com. Website: www.unhappytaxpayerandvoter.com. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 134 Silent Cry of the Poor HUD Secretary Alphonso Jackson at 220-708- 0685, fax 202-708-4087 or via email secretary_jackson@hud.gov Office of Inspector General at 1-800-347-3735 or via email at hotline@hudoig.gov Senator Johnny Isakson at 770-661-0999 and fax 770-661-0768. Address at One Overton Park, 3625 Cumberland Blvd, Suite 970, Atlanta, Georgia 30339. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 135 Silent Cry of the Poor HUD Office of Inspector General Hotline, GFI, 451 7 th Street, SW, Washington, DC 20410, toll free at 1-800-347-3735 Senator Saxby Chambliss, 100 Galleria Parkway, Suite 1340, Atlanta, Georgia 30339, Main: 770-763-9090 and Fax: 770- 226-8633. copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 136 Silent Cry of the Poor United States Representative Hank Johnson, 5700 Hillandale Drive, Lithonia, Georgia 30058, Phone: 770-987-2291 and Fax: 770-987-8721 Atlanta Regional Office of FHEO, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Five Point Plaza, 40 Marietta Street, 16 th Floor, Atlanta, Georgia, 30303-2806 Phone: 1-800-440-8091 and 404-331-5140 copyright by Ruby Bozeman- Davis & Viola Davis 137 Silent Cry of the Poor Housing Authority of DeKalb County, 750 Commerce Drive, Suite 201, Decatur, Georgia 30030. Phone: 404-270-2600 at website http://www.dekalbhousing.org Lithonia City Housing Authority, 6878 Max Cleland Boulevard, Lithonia, Georgia 30058, Phone: 770-482-6563 Table of Content View copies of documents
Title VII Disparate Impact Liability Makes Almost Everything Presumptively Illegal … It Gives the Federal Bureaucracy Extraordinary Discretionary Power. But What Does It Do to the Rule of Law? And Who Benefits?