MANAGEMENT (E-HRM) IN MANAGING ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE AND COMPETITIVE RIVALRY IN NIGERIAN BANKING SECTORS
BY SALAU, Odunayo Paul (odunayo.salau@covenantuniversity.edu.ng) Department Of Business Management, Covenant University, Ogun State FALOLA, Hezekiah Olubusayo (Hezekiah.falola@covenantuniversity.edu.ng) Department Of Business Management, Covenant University, Ogun State KALEJAIYE, Peter Oluwadare (petkal2000@yahoo.com) Olabisi Onabanjo University, Ago-I woye, Ogun State
ABSTRACT The activities and practices of managing human resources has been transformed in the recent years due to the dynamic change from labour intensive to capital intensive. The applications of the changes helps in shaping organization towards the attainment of corporate objectives. The objective of this study is to determine how transformational E-HRM contributes to better service delivery by the organization. Descriptive survey design method was used to collect data for the study, a total of 280 copies of questionnaire were distributed to the management and staff of some selected banks in Ogun State, South-West, Nigeria out of which 210 representing 75% were valid for the research. The data collected was analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS). The results show that strong relationship exists between E- HRM and management of organizational change and competitive rivalry. The summary of the findings indicates that there is strong correlation between the tested dependent variable and independent construct. However, it was recommended that HR professionals and organizations can focus on more meaningful e-HRM tasks and should always be empowered to provide more value to their organizations. Also, organizations and managers should offer a flexible model of HRM that meets the changing needs of an increasingly diverse and global workforce. KEYWORDS: E-Recruitment, Human Resource Management, Career Management, Skill Management, Technology, Completive Rivalry
1.0 Introduction The practice and philosophy of human resource management has changed over the years due to rapid change in technology. The act of getting things done through human resource in the banking industries has also changed dramatically in recent years. The activities and programmes of HR has become a fundamental aspect through information technology (Tremblay, Patry and Lanoie, 2008; Ulrich, 1996). Due to increased development of information technology, electronic management has become a cornerstone in the management and development of HR activities. Basically, the significant function of electronic management in human resource cannot be over emphasized when it comes to promoting organizational effectiveness (Adenekan, 2009). Therefore, it is argued that for any establishment of organization to survive in this competitive age, it becomes imperative to adopt the use of e-HRM in order to improve efficiency and achieve a more strategic level (CIPD, 2005). Numerous scholars like Ruel, Bondarouk and Looise, (2004) and Marler (2009) have examined a collection of wide-ranging goals for understanding e-HRM, including cost & savings reduction, improved service & 2 satisfaction of customers requirement in the banking industries (Strohmeier, 2007 and Rousseau, et al., 2008). The need to use the electronic human resource management has helped in promoting efficient staffing processes, reward and incentives, training and development, performance management, health and safety, employee relations, retention and policies on work-life balance (Enshur, Nielson and Grant-Vallone, 2002) and may be used to manage employee information across the entire employment cycle (Thite and Kavanagh, 2009). By definition, E-HRM has been defined as a way of putting into practice HR programmes, policies, philosophies and practices through a deliberate and coordinated web-technology-based control (Ruel, Bondarouk and Looise, 2004). Strohmeier, 2009 sees E-HRM as a systematic way of adopting information technology in performing of HR activities. Grant-Vallone, 2002) posited that eHRM as the application of information technology in managing employee information throughout the employment cycle. Sanayei & Mirzaei (2008) viewed E-HRM as a way of putting into practice the use of internet technology in the implementing human resources policies, programmes and plans. (Oiry, 2009) sees eHRM as the use of information technology in the practice of human resources activities and programmes. (Ruel, 2009) added that E-HRM is a dynamic process of creating value through the use and application of electronic management in the practice of human resource management. (Ramayah, 2011) argued that E-HRM is the use of electronic mechanism in creating values that help in the attainment of corporate objectives. By implications, electronic- Human Resource Management costs lower and improves efficiency by creating mountain of paperwork and streamlining work flow, Automating redundant HRM tasks, Empowering employees to embrace a self- service HRM delivery system, Keeping the banks workflow fully informed about all important human resource compliance issues and corporate events, Speeding up the response time of HRM systems, Ensuring that more informed decisions are made and Improving time management. The focus of this study is to examine the role of electronic-human resource management (e-HRM) and organizational performance in the banking sectors. To achieve the objective of the research work, this study addressed the following research questions. i. In what ways has operational E-HRM been impactful in facilitating efficient HRM process? ii. To what extent has the application of E-HRM influences organizational performance iii. What significant effect does relational E-HRM have on employee commitment? iv. How has transformational E-HRM contributed to better service delivery by the organization? v. What useful policy recommendations will this study offer?
1.1 Statement of Hypotheses Ho1: There is no significant relationship between operational E-HRM and efficient HRM process. Ho2: E-HRM does not have any significant effect on organizational performance. Ho3: Relational E-HRM does not have any significant effect on employee commitment. Ho4: Transformational E-HRM does not contribute to better service delivery by the organization. 3 In equation form, these construct/hypotheses were expressed in the following variable: Y = F(X)
Where; Y is a dependent variable X is an independent variable F is interpreted as functional Where; OP = organizational performance E-hrm= E-human resource management. Y = OP X = E-hrm Hence substituting into y and x respectively OP = F(E-hrm) X = Electronic Human resources Management (E-HRM) X1 = Operational E-HRM X2 = Relational E-HRM X3 = Transformational E-HRM Y = Organizational Performance Y1 = Efficient HRM process Y2 = Employee Commitment Y3 = Better Service Delivery by Organization
2.1 Theoretical Foundations The following theories were examined for the suitability of this study: 2.1.1 I nstitutional Theory This theory was proposed by DiMaggio & Powell, 1983. he offered a constructive and institutional argument that explains the relationship between the environment and the adoption of e-HRM practice. The theory acclaimed that for any organizations to survive and exist, it becomes imperative to respond and adjust to the changing trend in the market and integrate the core values of the organization with the accomplishment of the actual performance. Changes in the organization culture and policies are often influenced by internal and external forces (Broderick and Boudreau (1992). Therefore, electronic human resource management (E-HRM) is now seen as one of the agents of the change. Since the World has turned to a global village, organization that tends to resist the changes and trending pattern in information technology (IT) are likely to experience a significant pressure like e-recruiting or e-learning, even when the traditional recruiting practices may fully satisfy the needs of the organization.
2.1.2 Resourced Based Theory The resourced based theory was propounded by Barney, (1999). This theory serves as one of the bedrocks for explaining electronic HRM. This theory laid emphasis in explaining the relationship between the adoption e- HRM and the effect it has on organizations. Theory emphasizes on how an organization can overcome competitive rivalry and attain high level of performance. The theory added that for organizations to survive, there is need for them to integrate and harmonize the Resourcing strategies in the organization (Gardner, Lepak, and Bartol (2003). These Resourcing strategies are the people, technology, finance and information. The people, 4 therefore, become human resource by virtues of the functions they perform in the organizations. The human resource supplies the physical labour, skills which are needed to plan, implement and exploit other resourcing means to these ends (Barney and Wright, 1998). Therefore, E-HRM and its applications like e-payment, e-info, e-recruitment, e-learning etc., can equally be explained as contributing activities that equips the organization with human resources who create, design and develop productive economic institutions. By so doing, the theory continued to explain how Human resource can become business friendly (Haines and Lafleur, 2008) and translate the consequences of e-HRM to achieving a desired results and outcomes in the banking sectors. 3.0 Materials and Methods A descriptive survey design method was used in carrying out this study using utilizing the stratified and simple random sampling techniques. A total of 280 copies of questionnaire were distributed to the management and staff of some selected banks in Ogun State, South-West, Nigeria. Data were collected through self-administered questionnaires. This study comprises five sections in the questionnaire (A, B, C, D, E). Section A comprised of Personal data of respondents, section B involved the information regarding the Operational Electronic Human Resource Management, section C showed the factors responsible for the Relational Electronic Human Resource Management, section D indicated its effects on organizational performance and lastly section E comprised of the level of E-HRM practices. The data collected was analyzed using statistical package for social science (SPSS). 4.0 Data Analysis Findings and Discussion The data obtained from this study were presented using tables with specifications made on the amount of questionnaire distributed. Out of 280 questionnaire distributed, only 210 questionnaires were duly filled and returned. The results were obtained based on the opinions of the respondents. Socio Demographic Characteristic of the Respondents Variables Frequency Percentage Cumulative Percentage SEX Male Female Total 114 96 210 54.3 45.7 100.0 54.3 100.0 AGE GROUP 21-30 31-40 41-50 51-above Total
170 30 6 4 210
81.0 14.3 2.9 1.9 100.0
81.0 95.3 98.2 100.0 MARITAL STATUS Single Married Total
142 68 210
67.6 32.4 100.0
67.6 100.0 EDUCATIONAL QUALIFICATION OND/diploma B.sc/HND M.sc/M.BA Others Total
02 142 40 26 210
1.0 67.6 19.0 12.4 100.0
1.0 68.6 87.6 100.0 Source: Data collected from survey research (2014) 5 The above table shows that the total number of male respondents is 114 representing 54.3% of the total sample and total numbers of female respondents are 96 also representing 45.7% of the total sample. This implies that the male respondents constitute the larger part of total respondents. The table above shows that 170 (81%) of the respondents are between the ages of 21 and 30 while 30 (14.3%) are between 31 and 40. In addition, 6 (2.9%) are between 41 and 50 while 4 (1.9%) are 51 and above. It can be seen clearly from the table that as the age bracket increases, the frequency decreases. This implies that the age group 21-30 was most represented in the sample. From the table on marital status, it can be seen that the total number of 142 (67.6%) are single while 68 (32.4%) are married. Based on the Age, the table shows that total number of 2 (1%) has an educational qualification of NCE/OND while a total of 142 (67.6%) has an educational qualification of HND/B.Sc. In addition, it was observed that a total of 40 (19%) were M.Sc/MBA while a total of 26 (12.4%) has other educational qualifications. 4.1 TESTING OF HYPOTHESES 4.1.1 H01: E-HRM does not have any significant effect on organizational performance.
MODEL SUMMARY Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate 1 .626(a) .392 .368 .70136
a) Predictors: (Constant), The use of HR technology is cost effective, Using HR applications enhances service delivery of the organization, The use of HR applications, portals and web based technologies has made the HR department flexible, Using HR application saves time and energy. Interpretation of Result: The model summary table shows how much of the variance in the dependent variable (The use of HR technology gives value to the organization) is explained by the model. In this case the R square is .392 if expressed by a percentage will be 39.2%. This means that our model explains 39.2% of the variance the use of HR technology gives value to the organization.
ANOVA (b) Mode l
Sum of Squares Df Mean Square F Sig. 1 Regression 31.723 4 7.931 16.122 .000 (a) Residual 49.191 .492 Total 80.914
6 a) Predictors: (Constant), The use of HR technology is cost effective, Using HR applications enhances service delivery of the organization, The use of HR applications, portals and web based technologies has made the HR department flexible, Using HR application saves time and energy b) Dependent Variable: The use of HR technology gives value to the organization The ANOVA table shows the assessment of the statistical significance (sig=0.000), in which the P-value is equal to .000, and less than or equal to 0.05, therefore we reject the null hypothesis. So we can conclude that at least one of the predicators is useful for predicting the use of HR technology gives value to the organization therefore the model is useful. Coefficients (a)
Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig. B Std. Error Beta B Std. Error (Constant) 1.075 .410 2.622 .010 Using HR applications enhances service delivery of the organization -.040 .108 -.041 -.372 .711 Using HR application saves time and energy .369 .113 .373 3.267 .001 The use of HR applications, portals and web based technologies has made the HR department flexible .262 .109 .252 2.401 .018 The use of HR technology is cost effective .166 .094 .161 1.765 .081 a) Dependent Variable: The use of HR technology gives value to the organization The co-efficient table shows which variables that were included in the model contributed to the prediction of the dependent variable. The study is interested in comparing the improvement of each independent variable; therefore the Beta values used for the comparison in this table, the largest beta co-efficient is .373 which is for using HR application saves time and energy. This means using HR application saves time and energy, makes the strongest unique contribution to explaining the dependent variable the use of HR technology gives value to the organization when the variance explained by all other variables in the model is controlled. The table seeks to explain which of the variables is making a statistically significant unique contribution to the model looking at the sig column in the table; it reveals that using HR application saves time and energy made a unique and statistical significant contribution to the prediction of the use of HR technology gives value to the organization hence, we reject the null hypothesis. The implication of this result is that the practice of E-HRM in the selected banking industries has significant effect on organizational performance, but looking at the co-efficient table, using HR application saves time and energy has significant effect on organizational performance. 7 4.1.2 HYPOTHESIS 2 H0: Relational E-HRM does not have any significant effect on employee commitment. H1: Relational E-HRM has significant effect on employee commitment.
MODEL SUMMARY Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate 1 .570(a) .325 .305 .92834
a) Predictors: (Constant), Employees are trained on using HR related applications, Recruitment and selection process is carried out online, HR technology is easy to use Interpretation of Result: The model summary table shows how much of the variance in the dependent variable (Using HR application increases employees commitment) is explained by the model. In this case the R square is .325 if expressed by a percentage will be 32.5%. This means that our model explains 32.5% of the variance Using HR application increases employees commitment and this in turn, gives competitive advantage.
ANOVA
Sum of Squares Df Mean Square F Sig. 1 Regressio n 41.948 3 13.983 16.225 .000 (a) Residual 87.043 .862 Total 128.990
a) Predictors: (Constant), Employees are trained on using HR related applications, Recruitment and selection process is carried out online, HR technology is easy to use b) Dependent Variable: Using HR applications increases employees commitment The ANOVA table shows the assessment of the statistical significance (sig=0.000), in which the P-value is equal to .000, and less than or equal to 0.05, therefore we reject the null hypothesis. So we can conclude that at least one of the predicators is useful for predicting Using HR application increases employees commitment and competitive advantage.
8 Coefficients (a)
Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig. B Std. Error Beta B Std. Error (Constant) .934 .458 2.037 .044 HR technology is easy to use .032 .141 .026 .228 .820 Recruitment and selection process is carried out online -.017 .104 -.018 -.168 .867 Employees are trained on using HR related applications .665 .120 .563 5.561 .000 a) Dependent Variable: Using HR applications increases employees commitment. The co-efficient table shows which variables that were included in the model contributed to the prediction of the dependent variable. The study is interested in comparing the improvement of each independent variable; therefore the Beta values used for the comparison in this table, the largest beta co-efficient is .563 which is for employees are trained on using HR related applications. This means employees in the banking sector are trained on using HR related applications, makes the strongest unique contribution to explaining the dependent variable Using HR applications increases employees commitment when the variance explained by all other variables in the model is controlled. The table seeks to explain which of the variables is making a statistically significant unique contribution to the model looking at the sig column in the table; it reveals that Employees are trained on using HR related applications made a unique and statistical significant contribution to the prediction of Using HR applications increases employees commitment hence, we reject the null hypothesis. The implication of this result is that relational e-hrm has significant effect on employees commitment, but looking at the co-efficient table, employees are trained on using HR related applications has significant effect on employees commitment.
4.1.3 HYPOTHESIS 3 H0: Transformational E-HRM does not contribute to better service delivery by the organization. H1: Transformational E-HRM contributes to better service delivery by the organization.
MODEL SUMMARY R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate .220(a) .048 .039 .91017 a) Predictors: (Constant), Employees are informed of new development within the organization through web. 9 The model summary table shows how much of the variance in the dependent variable (New methods and strategic changes are introduced to the employees online) is explained by the model. In this case the R square is .048 if expressed by a percentage will be 04.8%. This means that our model explains 04.8% of the variance new methods and strategic changes are introduced to the employees online. ANOVA
Sum of Squares Df Mean Square F Sig. 1 Regression 4.331 3 4.331 5.227
.024 (a) Residual 85.327 .828 Total 89.657 a) Predictors: (Constant), Employees are informed of new development within the organization through web. b) Dependent Variable: New methods and strategic changes are introduced to the employees online. Interpretation of Result: The ANOVA table shows the assessment of the statistical significance (sig=0.024), in which the P-value is equal to .024, and less than or equal to 0.05, therefore we reject the null hypothesis. So we can conclude that at least one of the predicators is useful for predicting new methods and strategic changes are introduced to the employees online therefore the model is useful.
Coefficients (a) Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients T Sig. B Std. Error Beta B Std. Error (Constant) 3.861 .123 31.282 .000 Employees are informed of new development within the organization through web .041 .018 .220 2.286 .024 a) Dependent Variable: New methods and strategic changes are introduced to the employees online The co-efficient table shows which variables that were included in the model contributed to the prediction of the dependent variable. Therefore the Beta value used for the comparison in this table, the largest beta co-efficient is .220 which is for employees are informed of new development within the organization through web. This means employees are informed of new development within the organization through web, makes the strongest unique contribution to explaining the dependent variable new methods and strategic changes are introduced to the employees online when the variance explained by all other variables in the model is controlled. The table seeks to explain the variable which is statistically significant in contribution to the model looking at the sig column in the table; it reveals that employees are informed of new development within the organization through web made a unique and statistical significant contribution to the prediction of new methods and strategic changes are introduced to the employees online. The implication of this result is that transformational e-hrm 10 contributes to better service delivery by the organization, but looking at the co-efficient table, employees are informed of new development within the organization through web contributes to better service delivery by the organization.
4.1.4 HYPOTHESIS 4 Level of E-Hrm Practices MODEL SUMMARY R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate .696(a) .484 .469 .68954
a) Predictors: (Constant), Employee skills are enhanced through web-based HR applications (E-Skill Management), Salary review is carried out online (E-Salary Review), Employee training is supported by web- based HR applications (E-Training) The model summary table shows how much of the variance in the dependent variable (Employee appraisal is done through web-based HR applications (E-Appraisal)) is explained by the model. In this case the R square is .484 if expressed by a percentage will be 48.4%. This means that our model explains 48.4% of the variance new methods and strategic changes are introduced to the employees online. ANOVA (b) Sum of Squares Df Mean Square F Sig. Regression 45.025 3 15.008 31.565 .000 (a) Residual 48.023 .475 Total 93.048 a) Predictors: (Constant), Employee skills are enhanced through web-based HR applications (E-Skill Management), Salary review is carried out online (E-Salary Review), Employee training is supported by web- based HR applications (E-Training). b) Dependent Variable: Employee appraisal is done through web-based HR applications (E-Appraisal). The ANOVA table shows the assessment of the statistical significance (sig=0.000), in which the P-value is equal to .000, and less than or equal to 0.05, therefore we reject the null hypothesis. So we can conclude that at least one of the predicators is useful for predicting Employee appraisal is done through web-based HR applications (E-Appraisal) therefore the model is useful.
11 Coefficients (a)
Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig. B Std. Error Beta B Std. Error (Constant) .591 .403 1.468 .145 Salary review is carried out online(E-Salary Review) -.007 .055 -.010 -.134 .893 Employee training is supported by web-based HR applications (E-Training) .642 .103 .547 6.201 .000 Employee skills are enhanced through web-based HR applications (E-Skill Management) .219 .090 .217 2.427 .017 a) Dependent Variable: Employee appraisal is done through web-based HR applications (E-Appraisal).
The co-efficient table shows which variables that were included in the model contributed to the prediction of the dependent variable. The study is interested in comparing the improvement of each independent variable; therefore the Beta values used for the comparison in this table, the largest beta co-efficient is .547 which is for employee training is supported by web-based HR applications (E-Training). This means employee training is supported by web-based HR applications (E-Training), makes the strongest unique contribution to explaining the dependent variable Employee appraisal is done through web-based HR applications (E-Appraisal) when the variance explained by all other variables in the model is controlled. it reveals that Employees are trained on using HR related applications made a unique and statistical significant contribution to the prediction of Employee appraisal is done through web-based HR applications (E-Appraisal) hence, we reject the null hypothesis.
5.0 Conclusion It was found that operational e-hrm, comprises both efficiency and effectiveness in e-HRM. A few studies address the efficiency of e-HRM. First, there are hints from case studies that support the assertion of increased productivity due to e-HRM. The finding of this generally indicate a reduction of HR staff, faster-processes, cost reduction, and a release from administrative burdens resulting from automation in the banking industries. On the other hand, the findings indicated that savings within the HR department are often seen in the banking sectors as an effect way of simply shifting responsibilities from HR to line managers and employees. Accordingly, considerable cost savings are reported for e-recruiting and e-selection, due to reduced employee turnover, reduced staffing costs, and increased hiring efficiency in the selected banks. Transformational e-hrm concerns the overall changes of the HRM function that centrally aim at the role the HRM plays in company performance and strategy support. This is supported by the finding that HR professionals and organizations can focus on more meaningful e-HRM tasks and are empowered to provide more value to their organizations. Also, 12 organizations and managers should offer a flexible model of HRM that meets the changing needs of an increasingly diverse and global workforce.
References Adenekan, A. (2009): "Internet Recruitment: A Field Study of Applicant Experiences with on-line Recruiting." Human Resource Management 41(2): 175-192.
Barney, P. and Wright, C (1998). The Use of Human Resource Information Systems: A Survey, Personnel Review, 30, 6, 677693. Barney, J. (1999). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99120. Broderick, R. and Boudreau, J. (1992). Human Resource Management, Information Technology and the Competitive Edge. The Executive, spring 6, 2, 7-17. Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (2005). People Management and technology: Progress and Potential. London: CIPD. Enshur E., Nielson T. and Grant-Vallone E. (2002). Effects of the internet and technology on HR processes. Organizational Dynamics, 31 (3), 224-244. Gardner, S.; Lepak, D. and Bartol, K. (2003). Virtual HR, The Impact Of Information Technology on the Human Resource Professional, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 63(2), 159179. Haines, V.Y.Lafleur, G. (2008). Information Technology Usage and Human Resource Roles and Effectiveness. Human Resource Management, 47(3). 525-540.
Marler, J. H., & Dulebohn, J. (2005). A model of employee self service technology acceptance. Research in Personnel and Human Resources Management, Vol. 24. (pp. 139182): Elsevier Tld.
Marler, J. H., Liang, X., & Dulebohn, J. H. (2006). The effect of technology training on technology acceptance. Journal of Management, 32, 721742. Marler, J. H. (2009). Making human resources strategic by going to the Net: Reality or myth. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 20(3), 515526.
Oiry, E. (2009). Electronic human resource management: Organizational responses to role conflicts created by e-learning. International Journal of Training & Development , 111-123.
Ramayah, M. Y. (2011). Explaining the Intention to Use Electronic HRM among HR Professionals: Results from a Pilot Study. Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences , 489-497. Rousseau, D.M., Manning, J.&Denyer, D., Evidence in Management and Organization Science, in The Academy of Management Annals, J.P. Walsh and A.P. Brief, Editors. 2008, Taylor & Francis Inc.: Philadelphia. p. 475-515.
Ruel, H.; Bondarouk, T. and Van Der Velde, M. (2007). The Contribution of E-HRM to HRM Effectiveness, Employee Relations, 29, 3, 280 291.
Ruel, T. B. (2009). Electronic Human Resource Management: Challenges in the digital era. The International Journal of Human Resource Management , 505514.
Ruta, C. (2005). The Application Of Change Management Theory To HR Portal Implementation In Subsidiaries Of Multinational Corporations, Human Resource Management, 44(1), 3553.
Sanayei, C & Mirzaei, S (2008). Research in E- HRM: Review and Implications, Human Resource Management Review, 17, 19 37. 13
Strohmeier, S. (2009). Concepts of e-HRM consequences: A catergorisation, review and suggestion. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 20(3), 528543.
Strohmeier, S., & Kabst, R. (2009). Organizational adoption of e-HRM in Europe: An empirical explanation of major adoption factors. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 24(6), 482.
Thite M. and Kavanagh M. (2009). Evolution of human resource management and human resource information systems: the role of information technology. In: M. Kavanagh and M. Thite, Human Resource Information Systems: Basics, Applications and Future Directions. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Tremblay M., Patry M. And Lanoie P. (2008). Human resource outsourcing in Canadian organizations: An empirical analysis of the role of organizational characteristics, transaction costs and risks. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 19
Ulrich, D., & Brockbank, W. (2005). HR: The value proposition. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Wernerfelt B. (1984). A resource-based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal, 5, 171-180.
SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION, ANGEL G. ROA and MELINDA MACARAIG, vs. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (Second Division), LABOR ARBITER EDUARDO J. CARPIO, ILAW AT BUKLOD NG MANGGAGAWA (IBM), ET AL