Symbiosis Law School, NOIDA Symbiosis International University, Pune
In March, 2014
Under the guidance of Dr. Ankur Jain
Course in Charge
Human Resources And Total Quality Management C E R T I F I C A T E
The project entitled Organizational and individual stress Submitted to the Symbiosis Law School, NOIDA for Human Resources And Total Quality Management as part of internal assessment is based on my original work carried out under the guidance of Dr. Ankur Jain from December 23 rd , 2013 to March 27 th , 2014. The research work has not been submitted elsewhere for award of any degree.
The material borrowed from other sources and incorporated in the thesis has been duly acknowledged.
I understand that I myself could be held responsible and accountable for plagiarism, if any, detected later on.
Signature of the candidate: Manu : Sahil :
Date: 27-03-14
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I wish to dedicate my sincere thanks and acknowledgements to Dr. C.J. Rawandale for his support and motivation.
I wish to acknowledge Dr. Ankur Jain for providing me with the opportunity to enhance my knowledge by submitting this report and all the support.
Index
Table of Contents
Objective ............................................................................................. 1 Research Methodology .......................................................................... 1 Literature Review ................................................................................. 1 Introduction: ....................................................................................... 4 The Organization ............................................................................... 5 Workplace Factors Causing Stress .......................................................... 7 Interactions Between Work And Home Stress ........................................... 9 Individual Stress Management ............................................................. 10 Causes of Stress ................................................................................. 12 1. Causes of Organizational Stress ..................................................... 12 2. Causes of Individual Stress ........................................................... 15 Questionnaire .................................................................................... 17 Analysis ............................................................................................ 19 1. Age Group of candidates .............................................................. 19 2. Candidates clarity of expectations from him at work ....................... 19 3. Candidates clarity of Goals and objectives of department ................ 20 4. Strained Relationships at work ..................................................... 20 5. Too many deadlines at work for the candidates .............................. 21 6. Overwork of Candidates ............................................................... 21 7. Helping Colleagues and co-workers ............................................... 22 8. Control on own Job ..................................................................... 22 9. Participation in decision making .................................................... 23 10. Medical Problems due to stress .................................................. 23 Results .............................................................................................. 24 Discussion ......................................................................................... 25
1 | P a g e
Objective
To ascertain the existence of Individual stress in an organization To ascertain the extent of Individual stress in an organization To ascertain the existence of Organizational stress in an organization To ascertain the extent of Organizational stress in an organization
Research Methodology
This research thesis will be carried about by way of an empirical research involving the distribution of a questionnaire to the sample which consists of candidates working in several types of organizations. This research thesis is conducted with the help of Likert Scale as a tool/technique used for research.
Literature Review
1. B.V. Christiana (2009) Impact of Stress Management on Human Competencies Asia Pacific Journal of Management
This paper examines the stress in the workplace. It identifies the Human Resource staff as often being in the front line in dealing with cases of work-related stress and its becoming crucial for managers to identify sources and formulate strategies to reduce it. 2 | P a g e
2. J. Rupa, V. Durai (2012) A Study on Stress Among School Teachers with Special Reference to Madurai District
This research analyzes the conceptual and theoretical overview of psychological stress in the workplace specifically for teachers, focusing particularly on organizational sources and consequences of stress. This overview draws primarily on literature from social psychology, organizational and industrial psychology, and organizational studies.
3. M. Mansor, Dr. Tayib (2010) An Empirical Examination of Organizational Culture, Job Stress and Job Satisfaction International Journal of Business and Social Science
This papers assessment on job stress reveals that the employees are uncertain on the evaluation for a raise or promotion. It is also found that there are significant correlations among organizational culture, employee job stress and job satisfaction at RMC-WPKL. The results of this study signify that action should be taken to change the departments culture orientation, reduce employees stress and improve satisfaction.
4. L. Guillen, K. Korotov (2009) Organizational Culture, Leadership, Change, and Stress INSEAD Working Paper
This research work examines how do organizations become and remain great places to work. Changing mindsets is never easy and the need for adaptation usually induces a high degree of stress, both at individual and organizational levels. Learning how to manage organizational change 3 | P a g e
processes effectively may serve as a platform keep individual and organizational stress at acceptable levels.
5. Kahn, Robert L.; Byosiere, Philippe (1992) Stress in organizations
This paper talks about Organizational stress. It is defined as a rapidly expanding field, characterized by disagreements about terminology and definitions but underlying agreement on the variables of interest and their causal relationships / these relationships constitute a hypothetical sequence that begins with organizational antecedents to stress and then identifies the stressors they generate, the perception and appraisal of those stressors by individuals, the short-term responses evoked, and the effects of long-term exposure / at each step in this causal chain, the moderating effects of individual differences and interpersonal relationships are acknowledged
4 | P a g e
Introduction:
Stress is a general term applied to various mental and physiological pressures experienced by people feel in their lives. Stress has been defined in different ways over the years. Originally, it was conceived of as pressure from the environment, then as strain within the person. The generally accepted definition today is one of interaction between the situation and the individual. It is the psychological and physical state that results when the resources of the individual are not sufficient to cope with the demands and pressures of the situation. Thus, stress is more likely in some situations than others and in some individuals than others. Stress can be positive or negative. Stress can be positive when the situation offers an opportunity for a person to gain something. It acts as a motivator for peak performance. Stress can be negative when a person faces social, physical, organizational and emotional problems
The degree of stress experienced depends on the functioning of two protective physiological mechanisms:
Alarm reaction. When confronted with a threat to our safety, our first response is physiological arousal: our muscles tense and breathing and heart rate become more rapid. This serves us well when the threat is the proverbial bull in the field rushing towards us. We either fight or flee. Present day threats tend to be more psychologicalfor example, unjustified verbal attack by a superior at work. It is usually not socially acceptable to act by fight or flight, and an alternative means of expressing the resultant emotional and physical energy is required. This falls in the arena of assertive 5 | P a g e
communication. Adaptation. The second adaptive mechanism allows us to cease responding when we learn that stimuli in the environment are no longer a threat to our safety. For example, when we first spend time in a house near a railway line, our response to trains hurtling past is to be startled, as described above. Over time, our response dwindles. If this process did not function, we would eventually collapse from physical wear and tear, and mental exhaustion. 1
Stress is experienced when either of these mechanisms are not functioning properly or when we find it difficult to switch appropriately from one to another. It is the perception, or appraisal, of the situation that is key to whether or not it causes stress. This is the basis of the transactional model of stress, whereby the ability of a person to prevent or reduce stress is determined by that person's appraisal of (a) the threat within a situation (primary appraisal), and (b) the appraisal of his/her coping skills to deal with that threat (secondary appraisal). These appraisals have been shaped by past experiences of confronting stress and, in turn, influence future behavior and appraisals. Thus, the process of appraisal, behavior, and stress is continuous, and managing stress can result from changing the way the situation is appraised (cognitive techniques) or responded to (behavioral or cognitive techniques). 2
The Organization The Organization which we approached for the empirical study was Race Honda, a leading dealership in two wheeler automobiles. It is an authorized Honda two-wheeler dealer namely - Race Honda, 80-A, Radheypuri
1 http://oem.bmj.com/content/59/1/67.long#sec-7 2 http://oem.bmj.com/content/59/1/67.long 6 | P a g e
Extension, Jagatpuri Road, Delhi - 110051. They devote themselves to helping and serving our customers to the best of our ability.
Workers at Race Honda believe the two-wheelers they offer for sale are of the highest quality. They pledge to deliver you relevant, correct, and abundant content. They strive to deliver 100% customer satisfaction from the moment one first contacts the dealership. Their goal is to provide one with all the information one needs to make an informed decision, whether purchasing a new vehicle from them or exchanging your old vehicle with a new Honda two-wheeler or getting your vehicle serviced at Race Honda. They are confident that once you know the facts, you will choose to buy and service your next vehicle from Race Honda.
7 | P a g e
Workplace Factors Causing Stress
The workplace is an important source of both demands and pressures causing stress, and structural and social resources to counteract stress. The workplace factors that have been found to be associated with stress and health risks can be categorized as those to do with the content of work and those to do with the social and organizational context of work (fig 1). Those that are intrinsic to the job include long hours, work overload, time pressure, difficult or complex tasks, lack of breaks, lack of variety, and poor physical work conditions (for example, space, temperature, light). Unclear work or conflicting roles and boundaries can cause stress, as can having responsibility for people. The possibilities for job development are important buffers against current stress, with under promotion, lack of training, and job insecurity being stressful. There are two other sources of stress, or buffers against stress: relationships at work, and the organizational culture. Managers who are critical, demanding, unsupportive or bullying create stress, whereas a positive social dimension of work and good team working reduces it. 3
An organizational culture of unpaid overtime or presenters causes stress. On the other hand, a culture of involving people in decisions, keeping them informed about what is happening in the organization, and providing good amenities and recreation facilities reduce stress. Organizational change, especially when consultation has been inadequate, is a huge source of stress. Such changes include mergers, relocation, restructuring or
3 http://www.who.int/occupational_health/publications/en/oehstress.pdf 8 | P a g e
downsizing, individual contracts, and redundancies within the organization. 4
o Long hours worked, work overload and pressure o The effects of these on personal lives o Lack of control over work and lack of participation in decision making o Poor social support o Unclear management and work role and poor management style
4 https://www.boundless.com/management/organizational-behavior/stress-in- organizations/ 9 | P a g e
Interactions Between Work And Home Stress
Increasingly, the demands on the individual in the workplace reach out into the homes and social lives of employees. Long, uncertain or unsocial hours, working away from home, taking work home, high levels of responsibility, job insecurity, and job relocation all may adversely affect family responsibilities and leisure activities. This is likely to undermine a good and relaxing quality of life outside work, which is an important buffer against the stress caused by work. In addition, domestic pressures such as childcare responsibilities, financial worries, bereavement, and housing problems may affect a person's robustness at work. Thus, a vicious cycle is set up in which the stress caused in either area of one's life, work or home, spills over and makes coping with the other more difficult.
Women are especially likely to experience these sources of stress, 7 since they still carry more of the burden of childcare and domestic responsibilities than men. In addition, women are concentrated in lower paid, lower status jobs, may often work shifts in order to accommodate domestic responsibilities, and may suffer discrimination and harassment. 5
5 http://www.healthline.com/health/stress-causes 10 | P a g e
Individual Stress Management
Most interventions to reduce the risk to health associated with stress in the workplace involve both individual and organizational approaches. Individual approaches include training and one-to-one psychology servicesclinical, occupational, health or counseling. They should aim to change individual skills and resources and help the individual change their situation. 6
Stress affects different people in different ways. The experience of work stress can cause unusual and dysfunctional behavior at work and contribute to poor physical and mental health. In extreme cases, long-term stress or traumatic events at work may lead to psychological problems and be conductive to psychiatric disorders resulting in absence from work and preventing the worker from being able to work again. 7
There are a number of ways by which the risk of work stress can be reduced. These include: Primary prevention - reducing stress through ergonomics, work and environmental design, organizational and management development, Secondary prevention - reducing stress through worker education and training, and Tertiary prevention - reducing the impact of stress by developing more sensitive and responsive management systems and enhanced occupational health provision. The organization itself is a generator of different types of risk. Tertiary
6 http://www.andersonpeakperformance.co.uk/personalstresstips.htm 7 http://www.who.int/occupational_health/publications/pwh3rev.pdf 11 | P a g e
prevention in organizations places an emphasis on the provision of responsive and efficient occupational health services. Contemporary work stress management should, therefore, encompass tertiary prevention. A good employer designs and manages work in a way that avoids common risk factors for stress and prevents as much as possible foreseeable problems.
12 | P a g e
Causes of Stress
Factors that cause stress are called "Stressors." The following are the sources or causes of an organizational and non-organizational stress.
1. Causes of Organizational Stress
The main sources or causes of an organizational stress are:-
Career Concern : If an employee feels that he is very much behind in corporate ladder, then he may experience stress and if he feels that there are no opportunities for self-growth he may experience stress. Hence unfulfilled career expectations are a major source of stress.
Role Ambiguity: It occurs when the person does not known what he is supposed to do on the job. His tasks and responsibilities are not clear. The employee is not sure what he is expected to do. This creates confusion in the minds of the worker and results in stress.
Rotating Shifts: Stress may occur to those individuals who work in different shifts. Employees may be expected to work in day shift for some days and then in the night shift. This may create problems in adjusting to the shift timings, and it can affect not only personal life but also family life of the employee. 8
Role Conflict: It takes place when different people have different expectations from a person performing a particular role. It can also occur if
8 http://oem.bmj.com/content/59/1/67.long 13 | P a g e
the job is not as per the expectation or when a job demands a certain type of behavior that is against the person's moral values.
Occupational Demands: Some jobs are more stressful than others. Jobs that involve risk and danger are more stressful. Research findings indicate that jobs that are more stressful usually requires constant monitoring of equipments and devices, unpleasant physical conditions, making decisions, etc. 9
Lack of Participation in Decision Making: Many experienced employees feel that management should consult them on matters affecting their jobs. In reality, the superiors hardly consult the concerned employees before taking a decision. This develops a feeling of being neglected, which may lead to stress.
Work Overload: Excessive workload leads to stress as it puts a person under tremendous pressure. Work overload may take two different forms: - 1. Qualitative work overload implies performing a job that is complicated or beyond the employee's capacity. 2. Quantitative work overload arises when number of activities to be performed in the prescribed time is many.
Work Under load: In this case, very little work or too simple work is expected on the part of the employee. Doing less work or jobs of routine and simple nature would lead to monotony and boredom, which can lead to stress.
9 http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/145855.php 14 | P a g e
Working Conditions: Employees may be subject to poor working conditions. It would include poor lighting and ventilations, unhygienic sanitation facilities, excessive noise and dust, presence of toxic gases and fumes, inadequate safety measures, etc. All these unpleasant conditions create physiological and psychological imbalance in humans thereby causing stress.
Lack of Group Cohesiveness: Every group is characterized by its cohesiveness although they differ widely in degree of cohesiveness. Individuals experience stress when there is no unity among the members of work group. There is mistrust, jealously, frequent quarrels, etc., in groups and this lead to stress to employees.
Interpersonal and Intergroup Conflict: Interpersonal and intergroup conflict takes place due to differences in perceptions, attitudes, values and beliefs between two or more individuals and groups. Such conflicts can be a source of stress to group members.
Organizational Changes: When changes occur, people have to adapt to those changes and this may cause stress. Stress is higher when changes are major or unusual like transfer or adaption of new technology.
Lack of Social Support: When individuals believe that they have the friendship and support of others at work, their ability to cope with the effects of stress increases. If this kind of social support is not available then an employee experiences more stress. 10
10 http://www.webmd.com/balance/guide/causes-of-stress 15 | P a g e
2. Causes of Individual Stress
Certain factors outside the scope of an organization also cause stress. These main sources or causes of non-organizational stress are: -
Civic Amenities: Poor civic amenities in the area in which one lives can be a cause of stress. Inadequate or lack of civic facilities like improper water supply, excessive noise or air pollution, lack of proper transport facility can be quite stressful.
Life Changes : Life changes can bring stress to a person. Life changes can be slow or sudden. Slow life changes include getting older and sudden life changes include death or accident of a loved one. Sudden life changes are highly stressful and very difficult to cope.
Frustration: Frustration is another cause of stress. Frustration arises when goal directed behavior is blocked. Management should attempt to remove barriers and help the employees to reach their goals.
Caste and Religion Conflicts: Employees living in areas, which are subject to caste and religious conflicts, do suffer from stress. In case of religion, the minorities and lower-caste people (seen especially in India) are subject to more stress.
Technological Changes: When there are any changes in technological field, employees are under the constant stress of fear of losing jobs, or need to adjust to new technologies. This can be a source of stress.
16 | P a g e
Career Changes: When a person suddenly switches over a new job, he is under stress to shoulder new responsibilities properly. Under promotion, over promotion, demotion and transfers can also cause stress.
17 | P a g e
Questionnaire Organizational and individual stress NB: Your responses to this questionnaire will remain anonymous and only group data will be presented. It will not be used as an evaluation of your work or capabilities.
1. I am clear what is expected of me at work Never ( ) Seldom ( ) Sometimes ( ) Often ( ) Always ( ) 2. Demands of different groups at work are hard to perform simultaneously Never ( ) Seldom ( ) Sometimes ( ) Often ( ) Always ( ) 3. I am clear about the goals and objectives for my department Never ( ) Seldom ( ) Sometimes ( ) Often ( ) Always ( ) 4. Relationships at work are strained Never ( ) Seldom ( ) Sometimes ( ) Often ( ) Always ( ) 5. I feel that there are too many deadlines in my work that are difficult to meet i. Yes ( ) ii. No ( ) 18 | P a g e
Individual stress: 6. You have to leave some tasks Yes ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) because you have too much to do? 7. If your work gets difficult your Yes ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) colleagues will help you? 8. Do you feel you have control Never ( ) Sometimes ( ) Often ( ) on your job? 9. You are able to plan your own work Never ( ) Sometimes ( ) Often ( ) 10. You participate in decision making Never ( ) Sometimes ( ) Often ( ) for your own job 11. You have some control over the Never ( ) Sometimes ( ) Often ( ) pace/ content of your work 12. Do you ever suffer from any of the following? o Anxiety Never ( ) Often ( ) o Chest pain/palpitations Never ( ) Often ( ) o Indigestion or nausea Never ( ) Often ( ) o Sleeplessness Never ( ) Often ( ) o Irritability Never ( ) Often ( ) o Backache Never ( ) Often ( ) o Stomach disorders Never ( ) Often ( ) o Inability to concentrate Never ( ) Often ( ) 13. I make sure that I take time for myself, away from my other commitments, on a regular basis. Always ( ) Usually ( ) Sometimes ( ) Rarely ( ) Never ( ) 19 | P a g e
Analysis
1. Age Group of candidates
2. Candidates clarity of expectations from him at work
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 20 - 30 30 - 35 35 - 40 40 Above Age Group 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 Never Seldom Sometimes Often Always 20 | P a g e
3. Candidates clarity of Goals and objectives of department
4. Strained Relationships at work
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 Never Seldom Sometimes Often Always 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Never Seldom Sometimes Often Always 21 | P a g e
5. Too many deadlines at work for the candidates
6. Overwork of Candidates
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Never Seldom Sometimes Often Always 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 Yes No Sometimes 22 | P a g e
7. Helping Colleagues and co-workers
8. Control on own Job
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 Yes No Sometimes 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 Yes No Sometimes 23 | P a g e
9. Participation in decision making
10. Medical Problems due to stress
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 Yes No Sometimes 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 24 | P a g e
Results
a) This research study was conducted on majorly the employees under the age group of 20 35 years of age (Table 1) as it was done in an automobile showroom. b) As you can see form Table 2, a large chunk of employees are well aware of the quality and quantity of work expected from them in the organization and from Table 3, that most of the employees are also aware of the objectives and goals of their departments in the organization. c) Table 4 suggests that their do exist some strained relationships among personnel at work place but the quantum of that is not so alarmingly high. d) Table 5 and Table 6 show us that in the concerned organization, there exists a problem of overworking and over burdening the employees with deadlines. e) Table 7 reflects that on-the-job conditions are good for workers as the workforce is helping and cooperative. f) Table 8 entails the lack of self-control on own jobs of the workers as well as Table 9 shows that the employees in the organization are not even considered and involved much into the decision making processes. g) And finally, Table 10 reflects that workforce of the organizations, majorly, suffers with Non concentration, Irritability and Back ache.
25 | P a g e
Discussion
a) This research thesis has candidates who are young and hardworking and under the age group of 20 35 majorly because this was conducted in an automobile showroom where it is required that the major part of the workforce be clerical in nature and shall be full of energy as there is a lot of analog work to be done. b) The information about the work to be done s made well aware to the workforce and the objectives in the organization of the concerned department are also clear, quantitative and well commuted to every worker. c) The organization is lacking focus upon maintaining good relationships among employees as there exist some strained relations and the organization may suffer for that. d) The showroom managers are also overburdening the employees and imposing strict deadlines upon them as a result of which the employee satisfaction has been affected, which in turn can lead to decrease in the overall efficiency of the working of the affected workers. This problem can be solved by recruiting the required number of employees as there could be a problem of under-staffing in the organization. e) The workforce, though coping with the issue of strained relations, still is cooperative and helping towards each other as their moral values should have been positively upright. f) The organization lacks the involvement of employees in the decision making procedures and giving the workers some liberty as to the ways of doing their routine jobs. This can lead to the barricading creative and novel ideas from reaching the management from the ground level workers. 26 | P a g e
g) Individual and organizational stress exists in the concerned organizations and can be seen by the existence of multiple medical problems among workers arising out of this stress.