Department of Pharmacy Practice I SSN (online) 2347-2154 Available online: www.ijipsr.com April Issue 1034
ASSESSMENT OF OTC DRUG LABELS FOR PATIENT INFORMATION IN COMMUNITY PHARMACIES IN THIRUVANANTHAPURAM CITY 1 Levin Thomas*, 2 Jayakrishnan S.S, 3 Sheron Joseph, 4 Neethu Varghese, 5 Dileep C, 6 Arun Rasheed
1,3,4,5,6 Al Shifa College of Pharmacy, Poonthavanam P.O, Kizhattur, Perinthalmanna, Malappuram, Kerala, I NDI A 2 College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Govt. Medical College, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, I NDI A
Corresponding Author: Levin Thomas Department of Pharmacy Practice Al Shifa College of Pharmacy, Kerala, I NDI A Email: levinpharma@gmail.com Contact Number: +919526850953 International Journal of Innovative Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research www.ijipsr.com Abstract Over the counter drugs, usually referred as OTC, is defined as a Medication which is safe and effective for use by the general public without seeking treatment by a healthcare professional.
In most countries of the world, there exists a category of OTC drugs. OTC drugs have no legal recognition in India, hence all the drugs not included in the list of prescription-only drugs are considered to be OTC drugs. A cross sectional study was carried on a total of 1290 OTC drugs selected from 10 community pharmacies located within the vicinity of Thiruvananthapuram Medical College to evaluate whether OTC drug primary labels have adequate information for patients to make proper self medication choices. The study period was 3 months. The primary labels of these OTC drugs were then carefully assessed based on the Drug Facts label guidelines provided by the US FDA for OTC drug labeling. The study revealed that the required information provided on OTC drug labels in India is usually quite insufficient for the patient for ensuring safe, effective, and rational use of OTC drugs. There is a clear need for a specific OTC category of drugs in India, with clear-cut laid down guidelines for their complete labeling to ensure that the patient gets sufficient drug information, so as to make a responsible decision for self-medication. The regulatory authority should immensely implement proper labelling standards for the OTC drugs in India for ensuring their safe, effective and rational use.
Key words: OTC, FDA, CDSCO, DCGI RESEARCH ARTI CLE Levin Thomas et.al / I J I PSR / 2 (5), 2014, 1034-1041 Department of Pharmacy Practice I SSN (online) 2347-2154 Available online: www.ijipsr.com April Issue 1035
INTRODUCTION Over the counter drugs, usually referred as OTC (an acronym) is defined as a Medication which is safe and effective for use by the general public without seeking treatment by a healthcare professional. [1] These medications do not require a prescription. In countries like U.S, they are usually stocked in the counter cabinets in the pharmacies, general stores and even in gas stations. [2] India currently ranks 11th in the global OTC market. In India the drug manufacture, import and sales are governed by the Drugs and Cosmetics Act (DCA) 1940, the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules (DCR) 1945 and is implemented by the Central Drug Standard Control Organization (CDSCO) which is headed by Drug Control General of India (DCGI) who in turn functions under Directorate General of Health Services. Prescription-only drugs are those drugs that are listed in Schedules H and X of the Drug and Cosmetics Rules. Drugs listed in Schedule G (mostly antihistamines) do not need a prescription for purchase but the DCA emphasizes a mandatory warning label Caution: It is dangerous to take this prescription except under medical supervision. The drugs listed in the Schedule K which are usually treated as House Hold products can be sold by a non-pharmacist in remote villages whose population is less than 1000 subjects to other conditions. The drugs are categorized into schedules as per the rules published in the official gazette vide notification No. F. 28-10/45-(H)1 dated 21/12/1945. The phrase OTC has no legal recognition in India. The drugs that are not included in the Prescription only list are considered as OTC. Hence all the OTCs do not require a prescription for purchase. [3], [4], [5]. The OTC committee of the Organization of Pharmaceutical Procedures of India (OPPI) is currently working towards the promotion of responsible self medication in order to promote the OTC market. It is also aiming on promoting the importance of responsible self medication through awareness programs and community education. The committee not only promotes OTC use but also emphases on safety [6]. OTC drugs are an important component in health care, allowing the freedom to the patient to self-medicate for treating minor, common health problems, at lower costs and without having to spend time and costs of visiting a doctor. Although OTC drugs are supposed to be relatively safe, readily available and consumed by the patients without a physicians consent, it is very important that the patient have access to sufficient information to make an informed choice for the proper use of these drugs. Hence the label of OTC drugs plays an important role in conveying valuable information to the patient [7]. In USA, the FDA has laid down clear cut guidelines for the labelling of OTC drugs sold in the RESEARCH ARTI CLE Levin Thomas et.al / I J I PSR / 2 (5), 2014, 1034-1041 Department of Pharmacy Practice I SSN (online) 2347-2154 Available online: www.ijipsr.com April Issue 1036
country. US FDA Drug Facts standard labelling format for the OTC drugs includes various components such as active ingredients along with their strength, therapeutic category, indication of the drug, side effects of the drug, warnings, contraindications, precautions, directions, inactive ingredients and storage [8]. But there are no such labelling guidelines for the OTC drugs sold in India. A study was therefore undertaken to evaluate whether the primary labels of OTC drugs have adequate information as per the US FDA labelling guidelines, for the patients to make proper self medication choices and ensure rational use of OTC drugs.
METHODOLOGY: A cross sectional study on assessment of patient information of OTC drug labels was conducted on a total of 1290 OTC drugs, covering all the categories of dosage forms. The OTC drugs were selected from 10 community pharmacies located within the vicinity of Thiruvananthapuram Medical College. The study period was 3 months. The primary labels of these OTC drugs were then carefully assessed based on the Drug Facts label guidelines provided by the US FDA for OTC drug labelling.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
The results of the various labelling components that were assessed for the OTC drugs in the community pharmacy, as per the US FDA guidelines were: 1. Active ingredient(s) along with its strength:
Fig. 1: Active ingredient(s) along with its strength The presence of the active ingredient in the label is of prime importance as it informs the patient about the correct drug and the quantity to be taken. 88.75% of the OTC drug labels mentioned the active ingredient(s) along with their strength, whereas 11.25% did not mention the active ingredients in them. RESEARCH ARTI CLE Levin Thomas et.al / I J I PSR / 2 (5), 2014, 1034-1041 Department of Pharmacy Practice I SSN (online) 2347-2154 Available online: www.ijipsr.com April Issue 1037
2. Therapeutic Category:
Fig. 2: Therapeutic Category Only 40% of the OTC drug labels mentioned about the therapeutic category of the drug, whereas 60% did not mention the therapeutic category of the drug. 3. Use/Indication of the drug:
Fig. 3: Use/Indication of the drug Only 52% of the OTC drug labels mentioned about the Use/Indication of the drug, whereas 48% did not mention the therapeutic category of the drug. The presence of therapeutic category of the drug and indication/use in the OTC drug label ensures that the patient is consuming the right drug for his medical condition. 4. Side effects of the drug:
Fig. 4: Side effects of the drug RESEARCH ARTI CLE Levin Thomas et.al / I J I PSR / 2 (5), 2014, 1034-1041 Department of Pharmacy Practice I SSN (online) 2347-2154 Available online: www.ijipsr.com April Issue 1038
The presence of side effect information in the OTC drug label helps to inform the patient about the expected adverse events associated with the drugs and the necessary precautions they can take to avoid and or minimize them. Only 5% of the OTC drug labels mentioned about the side effects of the drug, whereas as much as 95% did not mention the side effects of the drug. 5. Warnings related to drug interactions, Contraindications, over dosages & precautions:
Fig. 5: General Warnings about the drug An OTC drug labels should have warnings regarding the most common drug interactions, contraindications of the drug, problems associated with the over dosage and the general precautions to be taken while taking the product. Only 26.25% of the OTC drug labels mentioned about warnings of the drug, whereas as much as 73.75% did not mention the therapeutic category of the drug. 6. Warnings related to pregnancy & breast-feeding:
Fig. 6: Warnings related to pregnancy & breast-feeding Some of the OTC drugs may have teratogenicity or may be even harmful to infants who are breast feeding. This necessitates the importance of OTC drug labels to compulsorily have warnings related to pregnancy and breast feeding. 98.75% of the OTC drug labels did not mention about warnings related to pregnancy and breast-feeding of the drug
RESEARCH ARTI CLE Levin Thomas et.al / I J I PSR / 2 (5), 2014, 1034-1041 Department of Pharmacy Practice I SSN (online) 2347-2154 Available online: www.ijipsr.com April Issue 1039
7. Keep out of reach of children:
Fig. 7: Instructions to keep out of reach of children Childrens have a tendency to gulp on various products kept in their homes. This condition warrants the need to inform the adults to keep the drugs protected in a place that is away from the reach of the children. Only 37.5% of the OTC drug labels mentioned about warnings to keep out of reach of children. 8. Directions including how much to be taken, dosage interval, maximum dose allowed per day and the dose for children.
Fig. 8: Direction for proper intake of the drug Only 55% of the OTC drug labels mentioned about proper directions to take the drug, whereas as much as 45% did not contain the direction to take the drug properly. The lack of proper directions in the OTC drug labels can result in intake of either sub therapeutic amount of the drug or toxic doses that can be life threatening. 9. Inactive ingredients in the product:
Fig. 9: Inactive ingredients in the product Present in the label Absent in the label Present in the label Absent in the label Present in the label Absent in the label RESEARCH ARTI CLE Levin Thomas et.al / I J I PSR / 2 (5), 2014, 1034-1041 Department of Pharmacy Practice I SSN (online) 2347-2154 Available online: www.ijipsr.com April Issue 1040
Only 6% of the OTC drug labels mentioned about the products inactive ingredient. Many inactive ingredients in the drug such as lactose may cause severe allergic reactions to the patient. 10. Storage conditions:
Fig. 10: Storage conditions 87.5% of the OTC drug labels mentioned about the drugs storage conditions, whereas as much as 12.5% did not mention the storage conditions of the drug. This can result in improper storage of the drug leading to deterioration in the product quality. CONCLUSION The study revealed that the required information provided on OTC drug labels in India is usually quite insufficient for the patient for ensuring safe, effective, and rational use of OTC drugs. There is a clear need for a specific OTC category of drugs in India, with clear-cut laid down guidelines for their complete labeling to ensure that the patient gets sufficient drug information, so as to make a responsible decision for self-medication. The regulatory authority should immensely implement proper labeling standards for the OTC drugs in India for ensuring their safe, effective and rational use. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors are thankful to all the pharmacists of the community pharmacies for rendering the necessary requirements in this work. REFERENCES: 1. US Food and Drug Administration. Drug Application for Over the Counter Drugs [Online]. 2012 [Updated 2012 September 9]. Available from: htpp://Fda.gov/drugs. Present in the label Absent in the label RESEARCH ARTI CLE Levin Thomas et.al / I J I PSR / 2 (5), 2014, 1034-1041 Department of Pharmacy Practice I SSN (online) 2347-2154 Available online: www.ijipsr.com April Issue 1041
2. Paruchuri A, Pavithran V, Pavani M, Selvamuthukumaran S, Mohanta GP. Drug Regulatory Status Assignment Criteria: A contrast among 2 countries. Int J Pharm Sci Res. 2013; 4(1):181-183. 3. Sarda Rohit, Ladkat Nilesh B, Khodade Ravikiran B, Chaudhari Pallavi M, Kasture Pramod V. The Indian Pharmaceutical Industry: Evolution of Regulatory System and Present Scenario. International Research Journal of Pharmacy. 2012; 3(6). 4. Central Drugs Standard control Organization. New Drugs Division [Online].2012.Available from: cdsco.nic.in. 5. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. Drugs and Cosmetic Rules [Online].2012. [Cited 2006 March 16]. Available from: Drugs Control.Org/Schedule-H. 6. Subai C Basak. Drug Access and OTC Drugs. Pharma Biz. 2012; 7(1):3-4. 7. Joshi M.P, Vaidya R.X, DeSousa E, Mangaonkar Sneha. Assessment of Over-the- Counter Drugs Labels in India for Patient Information. Pharma Times. 2012; 44(6):20-21. 8. US FDA. OTC Drug Fact Label. [Online]. 2009. Available from: http://www.fda.gov/Drugs/ResourcesForYou/Consumers/ucm143551.html.