Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Energy Storage
Is distributed energy
storage Germanys
missing link?
Geothermal
China turns to
geothermal to
combat carbon.
Data Points
Affordable,
Available
Rooftop Solar
p. 78 p. 68 p. 48
Intelligent
Inverters
How new technologies for PV
are enhancing communications,
control and interaction.
SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 VOLUME 17 ISSUE 5
Wind
The exciting and
lucrative wind
O&M business.
p. 40
1409REW_C1 1 9/11/14 11:15 AM
www.solar-frontier.com
MORE
Photo by Rolf Schultern, photon-pictures.com
For more information, enter 1 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_C2 2 9/11/14 11:15 AM
c
o
n
t
e
n
t
s
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 1
Photo of the
Narragansett
Bay Commission
(NBC) wastewater
treatment facilitys
three wind turbines
in Providence, RI.
Credit: Goldwind.
40
30
30
COVER STORY
Intelligent Inverters
Stealing the Show
Inverters are rapidly
adding value to PV system
architecture by enhancing
communications, control
and grid interaction.
David Appleyard
40
WIND POWER
The Big and Booming
Business of Keeping
Wind Turbines Spinning
Wind farm O&M is growing
by 40 GW per year and is
expected to reach 555 GW by
2023 making it an exciting
and lucrative industry.
Elisa Wood
50
RENEWABLES IN THE
DEVELOPING WORLD
Electrifying Kenya:
How One African
Country Is Approaching
Renewable Energy
Development Confusion
about renewable energy
projects and the governments
ambiguous energy policy is
overshadowing excitement in
Kenya. Sherelle Jacobs
63
BIOENERGY
Food For Watts:
Turning Post-consumer
Food Waste into
Renewable Energy
A new project in Oregon
creates biogas from
consumer food waste and
developers have big plans
for the future. Mike Crummy
68
GEOTHERMAL ENERGY
China Turns to
Geothermal Energy
To Tackle Carbon
Emissions As China
scrambles to reduce its
carbon impact, it has set
gears in motion to develop
its geothermal resources.
Meg Cichon
features
ON THE COVER
Innotech Solar supplied
more than 400 PV
modules to Ulra Winery
on the Turkish Riviera.
Credit: Innotech Solar.
1409REW_1 1 9/11/14 11:11 AM
IF ALL THIS REALLY MATTERS!
Visit us at WindEnergy Hamburg, 23-26 September 2014, Hall B1, Booth-no. 320
www.hove-as.dk
For more information, enter 2 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_2 2 9/11/14 11:12 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 3
departments & columns
On RenewableEnergyWorld.com
RenewableEnergyWorld.com is your daily
dose of news, opinion and technology updates
about the renewable energy industry.
Visit us on the web to:
|e|:|er |o a||end one o| our upcom|n webca:|:.
|earn abou| how |o e| your produc| and
:erv|ce: |n |ron| o| our aud|ence.
|ead a wh||e paper.
5|n up |o rece|ve our award-w|nn|n e-new:|e||er:.
Wa|ch a v|deo.
Commen| on our |op new:.
72
HYDROPOWER
Hydropower Financing Gets a
Boost from the US Department
of Energy The US government has set
its sights on non-powered dams as ripe
for government investment. Vince Font
78
ENERGY STORAGE
Is Distributed Energy Storage
the Energiewendes Missing
Link? In Germany, the first state-
sponsored storage scheme is off to a
sluggish start. Paul Hockenos
5 Editors Letter
|very|h|n |a: an
|nv|ronmen|a| |mpac|
6 Regional News
New: |rom |he C|oba|
|enewab|e |nery |ndu:|ry
25 Te Big Question
Are 5o|ar |oadway: v|ab|e?
48 Data Points
A||ordab|e, Ava||ab|e
|oo||op 5o|ar
58 Te Project
|||: |ar||n Nex| Cenera||on
5o|ar |nery Cen|er
60 Show Preview
|enewab|e |nery
Wor|d Con|erence and
|xpo, Nor|h Amer|ca
83 Training and
Educational Events
84 Calendar
84 Advertisers index
85 Last Word
Cu:|omer |naemen|
|: rey |o Un|oc||n
|he Cr|d: |o|en||a|
features
1409REW_3 3 9/11/14 11:12 AM
For more information, enter 3 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_4 4 9/11/14 11:12 AM
A
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 5
A story we covered this month on RenewableEnergyWorld.com was
about the misrepresentation of the number of bird deaths at Ivanpah.
In our article, Susan Kraemer explained that the Associated Press had
reported that 28,000 birds had been killed by the concentrating solar
power plant, Ivanpah, which went online earlier this year. The 392-
MW facility, which received a $1.6 billion loan guarantee from the U.S.
government and additional financial backing from industry giants like
Google, is a shining example of a clean energy success story. Kraemer,
who was in the process of writing a full-length feature story about how
to keep birds away from CSP projects, knew that number was exag-
gerated. The actual fact is that 321 bird deaths occurred from January
to June 2014 with 133 as a result of solar flux, which happens when a
bird flies through the concentrated sunlight and gets singed.
New energy projects go through a rigorous permitting process
before they are built. Kraemer pointed out in her news story that 188
permitting documents were filed with the California Energy Com-
mission for Ivanpah, and some of those were 300+ pages long. And it
doesnt stop at initial permits oversight organizations continue test-
ing and monitoring after projects are online and generating power.
Unfortunately it is virtually impossible to generate power and not
have an impact. Every single energy project, no, every single human
endeavor that involves building anything has an impact on wildlife.
Skyscrapers, cars, power lines, oil spills, communication towers, heck,
even cats kill birds! While we wish we could avoid injuries and fatali-
ties, and we take every possible precaution available to us to lessen our
impact, the truth of the matter is that we cannot continue making tech-
nological progress without harming some creatures along the way.
At Renewable Energy World, we try to focus on solutions rath-
er than dwell on the morbid and troubling aspects of the problem.
Thats why Kraemers follow-up article was about how CSP developers
and plant operators can keep birds away from their projects through
everything from mobile radar devices and bio-acoustics to trained fal-
cons and hawks. You can read it here.
Since we cant go back to living in caves and cooking over camp-
fires, were going to have to accept that some animals may be harmed
or killed as a result of our human activity. As uneasy as that makes us,
we can be comforted in the knowledge that were doing everything we
can to make those incidents as few
and as far between as possible.
From t he Edi tor
Jennifer Runyon, Chief Editor
CHIEF EDITOR Jennifer Runyon
ASSOCIATE EDITOR Meg Cichon
SENIOR OPERATIONS MANAGER
Stephanie Kolodziej
EDITORIAL OFFICES
REW Magazine
PennWell Corporation
98 Spit Brook Road, LL-1
Nashua, NH 03062-5737
PRODUCTION
ART DIRECTOR Angela Millay
PRODUCTION DIRECTOR Mari Rodriguez
SENIOR ILLUSTRATOR Chris Hipp
AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT
MANAGER Emily Martin
AD SERVICES MANAGER Toni Pendergrass
ADVERTISING
For information on advertising in future issues
of the magazine, please contact:
PETER ANDERSEN +1 603 891 9385
AMY LANZA +1 603 891 9360
PETER JANSEN +49 2841 40 999 60
PATRICK AGYEMAN +44 (0)207 738 8556
SUBSCRIBER CUSTOMER SERVICE
Renewable Energy World is circulated free
to professionals in the renewable energy
industry. To start a free subscription visit
www.rew-subscribe.com. For customer
service contact rew@halldata.com.
Professionals outside the renewable
energy industry may start a paid
subscription. For pricing information visit
rew@halldata.com, call +1 847-763-9540,
or fax +1 847-763-9607.
CORPORATE OFFICERS
CHAIRMAN Frank T. Lauinger
PRESIDENT AND CEO Robert F. Biolchini
CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER Mark Wilmoth
2014 PennWell Corporation. All rights
reserved. No part of this publication may be
reproduced in any form or by any means,
whether electronic, mechanical or otherwise
including photocopying, recording or any
information storage or retrieval system without
the prior written consent of the Publishers.
While every attempt is made to ensure the
accuracy of the information contained in this
magazine, neither the Publishers nor the authors
accept any liability for errors or omissions.
1409REW_5 5 9/11/14 11:12 AM
100
Proposed access road
Proposed chain link fence & gate
Inverter storage container
Battery storage container
Proposed solar array
Transformer vault
R
E
G
I
O
N
A
L
6 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
US State Breaks Ground on a
Perfect Solar + Storage Microgrid
that Can Provide Resilient Power
In August, Green Mountain Power
(GMP) broke ground on a solar plus
energy storage microgrid in Rut-
land, Vermont with one expert
calling it a perfect project. The
2.5-MW Stafford Hill solar project
is being developed in conjunction
with Dynapower and GroSolar and
includes 4 MW of battery storage,
both lithium ion and lead acid, to
integrate the solar generation into
the local grid, and to provide resil-
ient power in case of a grid outage.
The companies said that this project is one of the
first solar-only microgrids in the nation, and the first
to provide full back-up to an emergency shelter on the
distribution network. Solar power and battery stor-
age will provide clean reliable power to a school that
serves as an emergency shelter, helping a communi-
ty cope with loss of power in a future disaster, said
Lewis Milford, president of Clean Energy Group, which
manages the Clean Energy States Alliance.
This project is a national model for the future of
clean energy combining solar with energy storage,
said Dr. Imre Gyuk (pictured in hat at podium), Energy
Storage Program Manager in the DOEs Office of Elec-
tricity Delivery. This project provides resilient power
during emergencies while benefitting the grid at other
times. The technical innovations will reduce cost and
make the project commercially viable. This is the
perfect project! It has social value, technical innova-
tion, and furthers renewable integration for the grid.
GMP said that the project puts Vermont in the
forefront ofthe new movement toward microgrids,
energy storage, and grid modernization.Solar +
storage and microgrid technologiesare poised to
revolutionize resilient power, bringing clean, local-
ly-generated power to communities all over the
world. These systems can keep critical facilities,
such as emergency shelters, firehouses and fueling
stations, operating when the grid goes down.
There is a great need for such resilient power solu-
tions, as shown by recent disasters like Hurricane
Sandy, which affected the entire eastern seaboard
and left millions without electrical service. With this
project, Vermont takes a giant step toward addressing
this need, as well as meeting Vermonts clean energy
and emissions reduction goals.
The $10 million project is expected to be up and
running by December 2014.
Country
No. of
Plants
Capacity
MW
AC
United States 349 6,240.2
China 219 4,709.8
Germany 277 3,454.6
India 184 1,975.1
United Kingdom 233 1,791.9
Spain 171 1,680.0
Italy 85 898.2
France 57 732.2
Canada 56 717.3
Thailand 62 592.6
South Africa 15 503.0
Ukraine 19 490.2
Japan 16 308.0
Romania 17 277.6
Chile 7 269.4
Bulgaria 13 225.4
Czech Republic 26 216.8
Greece 12 117.5
Portugal 11 110.3
United Arab Emirates 3 103.3
The top twenty markets account for 97 percent of the
worlds utility-scale solar. Credit: Wiki-solar.org.
THE INSTALLED CAPACITY OF UTILITY-
SCALE POWER PLANTS IN THE LEADING
COUNTRIES AT THE END OF JUNE WAS:
1409REW_10 10 9/11/14 11:12 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 11
Germanys 200-MW Borkum
West II Offshore Wind Farm
Nears Completion
The first construction phase of the Borkum West II offshore
wind farm, a 200-MW development in the German North
Sea, is now complete.The project is located approximately
40 kilometers north of the island of Bokrum.
This development is the first full-scale commercial proj-
ect to use the AREVA M5000 wind turbine, following its
installation at the Alpha Ventus test site. The last of the 40
wind turbines was successfully installed during June 2014
and the project will now move into the commissioning
phase, which is expected to be completed in 2015.
The project is being developed, constructed and operated
by Trianel Windfraftwerk Borkum GmbH & Co. KG (TWB),
a company owned by 34 municipal utilities from Germany,
Austria, Switzerland and the Netherlands.
SgurrEnergy provided technical advisement for the proj-
ect, which covered construction monitoring on the develop-
ment, including monthly reporting to the project lenders on
construction progress, program and budget reviews, as well
as on-site monitoring of progress through site visits.
[Weve] been involved in this landmark project for
around five years, said Andrew Cole, project manager at
SgurrEnergy, and its fantastic to see it reach this con-
struction milestone and take another successful step
towards completion.
Hanwha Q CELLS
Completes 13.3
MW Solar Power
Plant in Portugal
Hanwha Q CELLS announced that it has
completed its first solar park in Portu-
gal as engineering, procurement and con-
struction provider (EPC). The installation
in the municipality of Montijo (South-East
of Lisbon) features around 51,000 of Q
CELLS modules and was fully connected
to the grid as of May 2014.
The 13.3-MW plant is expected to pro-
vide clean energy to some 5,475 local
households with an average consumption
of 4,000 kWh per year. Hanwha Q CELLS
said that it was able to build the plant in
just five weeks, with an additional time
for connecting it to the grid and complet-
ing all test runs.
Since 2009, Hanwha Q CELLS EPC
team has been working to reduce the con-
struction time for power plants. Over the
five years time, the company said that it
reduced construction time on a 1-MWp
system from 3.9 days to less than a day.
Quick construction as well as the suc-
cessive connection to the grid significantly
reduces costs and ensures earliest possible
yields and thus enable a quick return on
investment (ROI), said Hanwha Q CELLS.
To date, the company has installed more
than 600 MW of solar power plants with
outputs greater than 1 MW since 2007.
The PV system in Portugal proves
Hanwha Q CELLS expertise as full-ser-
vice-provider regarding the development
and EPC of PV power plants, said Frank
Danielzik, Vice President Development/
Sales & EPC at Hanwha Q CELLS.
Credit: SgurrEnergy.
1409REW_11 11 9/11/14 11:12 AM
At the end of the day, if a
product on the shelf is not
bought, it is marked it down
to a lower price for customers.
If its still not bought, a couple of different things happen next:
Any food waste thats
suitable for charitable
donations is collected by
charity partners who come to
the store to get it.
If its not ok for humans,
certain products including
bread go to make animal
feed. Some stores also send
fruit to feed the animals at
safari parks.
The same thing happens to
remaining food waste
collected from Sainsburys
supermarkets around the UK
using Sainsburys delivery
trucks.
If its not suitable for any of
that, it is picked up by the
empty Sainsburys truck that
has just delivered food to the
store.
That waste is picked up
by a Biffa truck and taken
to the Biffa anaerobic
digestion plant at
Cannock.
That gas generates electricity
at the AD plant. A byproduct
of the process is called
digestate, which is a great
fertilizer and used by local
farms.
The food waste is sent to big
silos that act like a human
stomach to break down the
food into bio methane gas.
Electricity for Sainsburys
Cannock store is directly
supplied to the supermarket
via a 1.5km electricity cable
that runs directly from the
AD plant. If we make too
much electricity the rest goes
back into the National Grid.
news R
E
G
I
O
N
A
L
12 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
UK Supermarket To Be Powered
Exclusively by Waste-To-Energy Plant
U.K. retailer Sainsburys
announced that it will power
one of its supermarkets
with 100 percent renewable
electricity produced from
an anaerobic digester,
making it the largest retailer
to be off-grid using an anaero-
bic digester.
Sainsburys feeds the
waste-to-energy plant with
materials from its supermar-
kets located throughout the
U.K. The plant is based in
Cannock in the West Mid-
lands, operated by recycling
company Biffa, and directly
powers the Sainsburys Can-
nock retail store.
All general waste from
stores is recycled or turned
into fuel. Surplus food that
cant be used to feed peo-
ple is processed into animal
feed to support British farm-
ers or used to generate energy
through anaerobic digestion.
When waste enters the
digester, it will be turned into
bio-methane gas, which is then
used to generate electricity.
This power will travel along
a newly constructed 1.5-kilo-
meter transmission cable to
directly supply the store.
Dentons advised Sains-
burys on the energy, con-
struction and property
aspects of the project.
[ cont >]
This infographic shows how a nearby anaerobic digester will power the
Sainsburys supermarket. Credit: Sainsburys.
1409REW_12 12 9/11/14 11:12 AM
Power-One. Raised to the power of two.
Power-One is now officially known as ABB. But this is much more than just a name change. One
of the most innovative inverter manufacturers in the world now has the engineering, infrastructure
and financial clout of a Fortune 500 company. The benefits to our customers and the solar industry
as a whole should be felt for years to come. ABB now has one of the industrys most comprehensive
offerings of solar inverters for residential, commercial and utility-scale pv installations.
For more information please visit: www.abb.com/solarinverters
For more information, enter 5 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_13 13 9/11/14 11:12 AM
news R
E
G
I
O
N
A
L
14 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
This is another in a series
of industry-first energy and
sustainability projects led by
Sainsburys in recent years,
Rajan Phakey, partner in Den-
tons Energy, Infrastructure
and Project Finance practice.
Sainburys also plans to heat
its stores in the winter months
with ground-source heat
pumps. Working with heat-
ing company Geoscart, Sains-
burys will store waste heat
from its refrigeration systems
underground and then pump it
back into the store when nec-
essary. The retailer plans to
use the technology across 100
stores, and expects to cut up
to 30 percent of its heating
consumption.
Were delighted to be help-
ing to reduce energy use and
carbon, said Paul Crewe, head
of sustainability, engineering
& energy at Sainsburys said in
a statement. I hope that with
Geoscarts help well now see
more retailers following suit.
LATIN AMERICA
1409REW_20 20 9/11/14 11:12 AM
For more information, enter 8 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_21 21 9/11/14 11:12 AM
news R
E
G
I
O
N
A
L
22 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
Yingli Solar Continues
Expansion in Latin America
Yingli Green Energy Hold-
ing Company has expanded its
footprint in the Americas by
opening the companys third
Latin American office in Santi-
ago, Chile.
To facilitate the opening of the
new office and Yinglis growth
in the Chileansolar powermar-
ket, Yingli has brought on Rob-
ert Muhn to serve as Managing
Director of Yingli Green Energy
Chile. Under his leadership, the
Santiago office will initially focus
on the burgeoning utility-scale
solar market segment in Chile,
where Muhn will build on the
companys track record of sup-
plying large-scale solar plants in
Latin America. Yingli has already
deployed more than 25 mega-
watts (MW) of solar in Chile.
Chile is a high-poten-
tial solar market and home
to some of the strongest solar
irradiation in the world, par-
ticularly in the Atacama Des-
ert, noted Muhn. While we
see tremendous growth poten-
tial in Chiles utility-scale mar-
ket, we also anticipate that the
countrys relatively high elec-
tricity prices and strong solar
resources will provide a foun-
dation for a thriving and sus-
tainable distributed generation
market in the future.
As demonstrated by the
companys long-standing pres-
ence in the region, the South
and Central American solar
energy markets are a major
strategic priority in Yinglis
long-term global development
plans. In addition to Yinglis
permanent offices in Mexico
City, So Paolo, and Santiago,
the company also maintains
warehouses and invento-
ry in both Mexico and Brazil,
which expedite and streamline
regional module deliveries.
Our continued investments
in Latin America are a reflec-
tion of our confidence in this
key emerging markets long-
term growth potential, said
Jeffrey Barnett, Vice Presi-
dent of International Sales at
Yingli Green Energy Americas.
Thanks to our strong team of
professionals across the region,
we are establishing lasting
partnerships with pioneering
companies to help drive the
expansion of solar PV across
Latin America.
Led by Brazil, Chile, and
Mexico, the Latin American
region is expected to install
over 700 MW of solar capac-
ity in 2014, accordingto GTM
Research. Industry analysts
also predict that solar demand
in the region will exceed one
gigawatt in 2015 and achieve a
50 percent annual growth rate
for the next several years.
Presented by:
www.aseanpowerweek.com
www.powergenasia.com
www.renewableenergyworld-asia.com
www.powergenos|o0nonce.com
Supported by:
For more information, enter 14 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_43 43 9/11/14 11:13 AM
44 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
WI ND POWER
Ofshore Wind
O&M Adds Even
More Complexity
Since the spring of 2012,
DONG Energy has been
gradually taking over the
operation and maintenance of
the 400-MW Anholt Offshore
Wind Farm located between
DjurslandandAnholtisland in
Denmark.
In the frst fve-year warranty
period, DONG Energy will be
responsible for maintenance of
the wind farm in cooperation
with turbine supplier Siemens
Wind Power, but after the
warranty expires, DONG
Energy will assume the full
responsibility for O&M at the site,
creating jobs for approximately
50 turbine technicians. Including
vessel crews, storage
and administrative
functions, a total of
70 people will be
employed as part of the
O&M organization.
O&M for the Anholt
Offshore Wind Farm
is operated on-site
from a pair of new
offces as well as a
storage and workshop
facility, plus changing
rooms for the service
personnel in Grenaa. With
a location right on the quay,
service technicians have direct
access to the service vessels.
Monitoring takes place from
shore the wind turbines
built-in monitoring system is
able to diagnose errors, and if
necessary, shut down the wind
turbine in case of
a critical error.
All information
on site conditions
such as wind
speed, wind
direction and
wave height
including status
and production of
each wind turbine
is collected by a central DCS
(distributed control system),
which is connected to the
internal monitoring system of
each wind turbine.
In the summer scheduled
servicing takes place, with
technicians working intensive
12-hour shifts per day for seven
days straight and then taking a
seven-day break. Inspections
include typical performance
and safety tests, replacement
of flters, lubrication, inspection
of bolts, replacement of brake
pads and oil changes in the
gearboxes and hydraulic
systems. During the winter,
technicians only perform
repairs and start up turbines
that have become faulty.
An offshore engineer from DONG Energy
climbs the transmission piece at the foot of a
464ft (141.6m) turbine. Credit: DONG Energy.
The Anholt Offshore Wind Farms 111 turbines
cover an area of 88km2. Credit: DONG Energy.
1409REW_44 44 9/11/14 11:13 AM
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
13
900
14 15 16 17
Source: BTM Consult - a part of Navigant, March 2014
18 19 20 21 22 23
GW
Off-warranty
In-warranty
Global Onshore O&M Market 2013-2023
(20 years operation scenario)
EDF Renewable Services
858.521.3575 | O&Mbusdev@edf-re.com
www.edf-renewable-services.com
EX EX EX EX EX EX EX EX EX EX EXPE PE PE PE PE PE PE PE PE PE PERT RT RT RT RT RT RT RT RT RT RTIS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS ISEEEEEEEEEEE ||||||||||| CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO COMM MM MM MM MM MM MM MM MM MM MMIT IT IT IT IT IT IT IT IT IT ITME ME ME ME ME ME ME ME ME ME MENT NT NT NT NT NT NT NT NT NT NT ||||||||||| IIIIIIIIIIINN NN NN NN NN NN NN NN NN NN NNOV OV OV OV OV OV OV OV OV OV OVAT AT AT AT AT AT AT AT AT AT ATIO IO IO IO IO IO IO IO IO IO IONNNNNNNNNNN
EDF Renewable Services understands renewable energy facilities represent
a substantial investment. With 25 years of experience and over 8,000 MW
of energy under contract in North America, we are the trusted leader to
optimize plant performance, maximize availability, and minimize downtime.
OPTIMIZE AVAILABILITY | MAXIMIZE PROFITABILITY | ANALYZE PERFORMANCE
25 YEARS OF
O&M EXPERTISE
AND EXPERIENCE
WI ND POWER
same access to data and sup-
plies as the manufacturer,
and they may be small and
undercapitalized, according
to Navigant.
Duke Energy, the U.S. larg-
est electric power holding
company, adopted two of the
options simultaneously. The
company made the decision to
keep its services in-house, but
also go with an independent
service provider. It did this
by acquiring Outland Energy
Services, a Minnesota-based
independent since 2005. It has
since folded Outland into Duke
Energy Renewables.
Growth of the global onshore wind market for O&M, in-warranty and
off-warranty: 2013-2023. Credit: BTM Consult, Navigant.
For more information, enter 15 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_45 45 9/11/14 11:13 AM
46 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
WI ND POWER
of the assets that we do, added Jeff Wehner, vice president of
operations, Duke Energy Renewables.
Fixing from Afar
Duke also works on a range of technologies, while many other
companies specialize in one or two, Wehner said. The servic-
es range from short-term a la carte arrangements to long-term
contracts where Duke controls a facilitys operations.
One of its most interesting services involves a monitor-
ing station located at Dukes headquarters in Charlotte, North
Carolina. The station remotely watches Dukes wind farms
around the United States, as well as those under contract.
On the screen in Charlotte, Duke can spot and troubleshoot prob-
lems on any of the given wind farms. Sometimes they can fx the
problem from the monitoring station, if it involves resetting equip-
ment, for example. Other times they contact onsite technicians, or
Dukes mobile team, to undertake the repairs at the wind farm.
What we really try to focus on is condition-based mainte-
nance. There are all sorts of monitors on these turbines. We
look at things like temperature and vibration and hopefully
fnd issues before they become bigger issues, Wehner said.
Radically Different Approach
Meanwhile, an entirely different route is being taken by the
North American subsidiary of Chinas giant wind company
The company main-
tains Dukes feet of 15
wind farms, which have an
installed capacity of 1,700
MW (and another 400 MW of
capacity under construction),
representing a $2.5 billion
investment. And at the same
time, it also handles O&M
for about 300 MW of outside
wind farms. For example,
Duke recently signed a long-
term deal with Consumers
Energy to service its 105-MW
Cross Winds Energy Project,
under construction in Tusco-
la County, Mich.
We see this market in
operations as a strategic
part of our business model,
said Greg Wolf, president of
Duke Energy Renewables.
We see opportunity.
He added that Dukes frst
priority is to ensure that its
wind operations are operat-
ing at best performance and
at least cost. Because its feet
is so large, it enjoys scale in
the market, and offers its
O&M customers the benefts
of that scale.
Over the past 18 months
weve positioned ourselves
uniquely in the marketplace.
We focus as an asset owner
on the production and safe-
ty of our workers. We can
translate that over to our
customers, who dont neces-
sarily have the same expe-
rience and understanding
Wind service technicians in front of a wind turbine. Credit: Duke Energy.
1409REW_46 46 9/11/14 11:13 AM
PENN STATE
|
ONLI NE
U.Ed.14- 0642/14-WC-1119ajp/smb
Develop your understanding of renewable energy
technologies and their applications in society.
Customize your masters degree with options and
graduate certifcates in:
bioenergy
solar energy
sustainability management and policy
wind energy
Renewable Energy and Sustainability
Systems Graduate Education Portfolio
Apply now: worldcampus.psu.edu/rew
Sust ai nabl e
devel opment
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 47
WI ND POWER
Goldwind. Wind farms that use Goldwinds turbine need far
less O&M than most because the machines operate under a
direct-drive system. That means no gear box, which is the
most maintenance-heavy component, according to David Hal-
ligan, CEO of Goldwind USA.
Its about effciency, getting costs down, lower mainte-
nance, and a lower labor requirement, Halligan said.
A Goldwind turbine achieves a 20 percent savings over its
lifetime on O&M because of the lack of gear box and other eff-
ciencies built into the machine, he said.
Further, because the machines are direct drive, they
are well-suited for distributed generation. They do not
require a grid connection to excite a generator; the turning
of the rotor excites the generator. As a result, Goldwind
turbines can be found serving food processing plants, waste
water treatment facilities and similar large energy users
that are located in windy places and may want to go 100
percent renewable.
Clearly, the O&M indus-
try is a big new big play
whether its the approach of
EDF Renewable Services and
Duke to better service the
machines or the position-
ing of Goldwind USA to pro-
vide machines that can be
serviced less.
After years of develop-
ment, a massive feet of wind
turbines are whirring. Now
its time to make sure they
operate as effectively as pos-
sible for as long as possible.
A new and growing O&M
industry is rising to the occa-
sion to get the job done.
For more information, enter 16 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_47 47 9/11/14 11:13 AM
The plunging costs of solar
systems and the broad availability
of sunlight mean that rooftop systems
are increasingly able to compete with
electricity from the grid around the country.
NOW
NEAR TERM
1-3 years
LATER
4+ years
p
o
i
n
t
s
d
a
t
a
48 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
1409REW_48 48 9/11/14 11:13 AM
CREDIT: Union of Concerned Scientists.
Average rooftop
system cost
INSTALLING ROOFTOP SOLAR PANELS
HAS NEVER BEEN MORE AFFORDABLE
THE NUMBER OF HOUSEHOLDS
WITH ROOFTOP SOLAR IS SKYROCKETING
And
because most
people lease,
installation costs $0
See more about Affordable, Available Rooftop Solar here.
Since 2007, the cost of
installing an average-
sized rooftop solar
system has nearly
halved. In fact, after
accounting for tax
credits, rebates, and
other support, in
leading states a 5-kW
system could cost
homeowners less than
$10,000
In 2006, some 30,000 U.S.
homes had rooftop solar
systems. By 2013, that
number had grown over 1000
percent to almost 400,000
homes. Projections from the
U.S. Energy Information
Administration suggest
were headed to almost
1 million homes by 2020.
$10 K
$0 K
2005 2007 2009 2011 2006 2008 2010 2012 2013
$20 K
2006
30,000 homes
2013
400,000 homes
2020
900,0003.8 million
homes
$30 K
$40 K
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 49
1409REW_49 49 9/11/14 2:32 PM
50 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
RENEWABLE S I N THE DEVELOPI NG WORLD
Electrifying Kenya:
How One African Country
Is Approaching Renewable
Energy Development
Kenya has taken some major steps to boost its renewable energy
production recently, according to reports. However, confusion
about projects and the governments ambiguous
energy policy is overshadowing excitement.
SHERELLE JACOBS, International Correspondent
Kenyas renewable energy ambitions have attracted growing
attention in recent months. There has been a strong uptick in
interest in the countrys wind energy potential in particular.
Last year, Kenyas Ministry of Energy and Petroleum said in an
investment prospectus for 2013-2016 that it plans to boost wind
power generation by 630 MW as part of its target to increase
electricity levels by 5000 MW by 2016. In March, the Kenyan
government also signed a fnancing document for the largest
private investment in Kenya. The Lake Turkana Wind Proj-
ect (LTWP) in northeastern Kenya, spanning 40,000 acres,
will provide the countrys national grid with 300 MW of wind
power capacity, or a ffth of the countrys installed electrici-
ty capacity. Construction is due to begin imminently and the
facility is expected to be online by 2016. Three hundred and
sixty fve wind turbines will generate the energy at the farm.
All is progressing very well now and hopefully the long
awaited fnal notice to proceed on the transmission line will
be in place this week, said Carlo Van Wegeningen, Chairman,
Lake Turkana Wind Power. This is the last CP we are wait-
ing for to allow to proceed and commence construction, he
added. According to Van Wegeningen, the project will have
huge benefts. It will increase the power generation capacity
to the country by 17 percent.
At US $0.09 per kWh LTWP
will be the cheapest new and
clean source of power in the
country after geothermal,
he said. Todays average cost
of power in Kenya stands at
approximately US $0.12 per
1409REW_50 50 9/11/14 11:13 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 51
Kenya cityscape from above.
Credit: Shutterstock.
kWh. LTWP will save the Kenyan economy some $150 million
a year in fuel replacement costs. It will contribute $1 billion in
income tax payments over the life of the project, Van Wegenin-
gen added.
As well as the Lake Turkana farm, a number of other wind
power projects are in the pipeline in Kenya. They include the
Kipeto Wind Project in the Rift Valley Province, which will
have a capacity over 100 MW; a 90-MW Electrawinds project
in Lamu; and the 61-MW
Kinangop wind farm project
in central Kenya under UK-
based wind turbine supplier
Aeolus Power.
Kenyas wind energy poten-
tial is high, say experts. Wind
speeds of as much as eight to
1409REW_51 51 9/11/14 11:13 AM
52 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
RENE WABLE S I N THE DE VELOPI NG WORLD
14 meters per second are being recorded in several areas of the
country, making wind-powered electricity production attractive
on a commercial level as well as an environmental one. The gov-
ernment is keen to boost its intelligence about the best sites for
wind farms and has set up 61 wind masts and data loggers all
over the country over the last three years to this end. It plans to
erect 34 more this year. After gathering suffcient information,
the state plans to offer the best sites for wind power generation
up to investors.
Solar Power On the Grid Not as Strong
In contrast to Kenyas booming wind power sector, Kenyas
solar policy has been beset with confusion. In January, The
Guardian reported that the country planned to source half of
its energy from solar by 2016 through a plan to invest $1.2 bil-
lion jointly with private frms to install nine major solar power
plants across the country. The government has announced
no such plans. On the other
side of the spectrum, in
November last year there
were media reports that
the countrys government
had suspended new licens-
es for solar plants and wind
farms until 2017 and would
focus on cheaper non-renew-
able energy sources instead
in a bid to slash electrici-
ty costs. Insiders deny that
this is the case. There is no
sign that there is any off-
cial moratorium, no high
ranking offcial has said so.
Kenya seems very much still
Acacia tree and green grass of Lewa
Conservancy with Mt. Kenya in
background, North Kenya, Africa.
Credit: Shutterstock.
1409REW_52 52 9/11/14 11:13 AM
ww www. w.po powe werg rgen enfi fina nanc ncia ialf lfor orum um.c .com om
DECEMBER 10-11, 2014
Orange County Convention Center
Orlando, Florida
Leading
Th The e PO POWE WER- R-GE GEN N In Inte tern rnat atio iona nal l Fi Fina nanc ncia ial l Fo Foru rum m is is ddes esig igne ned d to to
pr prov ovid ide e co corp rpor orat ate- e-le leve vel l pr proj ojec ect t de deve velo lope pers rs aand nd ffnnan anci cier erss an an exc xclu lusi sive
ve venu nue e to to llea earn rn, , ne netw twor ork k an and d do do bbus usin ines e s. s. WWe e ar are e co co-l -loc ocat ated ed wwit ithh
PO POWE WER- R-GE GEN N In Inte tern rnat atio iona nal, l, tthe he llar arge gest st ccon onfe fere renc nce an and d ex exhi hibi biti tion on
fo for r th the e po powe wer r ge gene nera rati tion on iind ndus ustr try. y.
Th The e Fi Fina nanc ncia ial l Fo Foru rum m co comb mbin ines es tthe he lea earn rnin ing g an and d ne netw twor orki king ng
ex expe peri rien ence ces s of of aan n in indu dust stry ry-l -lea eadi ding ng ccon onfe fere renc nce e wi with th tthe he opp ppor ortu tunity
to to ddo o bu busi sine ness ss oone ne oon n on one e wi with th tthe he wwor orld lds s ttop op enggin inee eeri ing ng,,
pr proc ocur urem emen ent t an and d co cons nstr truc ucti tion on ffrrms ms aas we well ll aas s hu hund ndre reds ds oof f or orig igin inal a
eq equi uipm pmen ent t ma manu nufa fact ctur urer ers s an and d su supp ppli lier ers. s.
Supported By:
Owned & Produced By: Presented By:
5 EVENTS + 5 DAYS
www.powergenerationweek.com
For more information, enter 17 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_53 53 9/11/14 1:17 PM
54 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
RENE WABLE S I N THE DE VELOPI NG WORLD
in the document and on-grid solar has no mention at all. The
government effectively foresees that solar will contribute zero
percent of power generation on-grid, he adds.
Ondraczek also points out that the governments preference for
wind energy over solar is considerable.
Wind has been around for longer than solar and people are
only just starting to lobby properly for solar projects in Kenya.
The state also sometimes points to some evidence that suggests
wind is more competitive than solar but this is based on outdat-
ed numbers. Technology and costs improvements are constant-
ly being made when it comes to solar and it is catching up with
wind, he added.
Insuffcient subsidies for solar projects have prevented the
industry from really taking off, argues Ondraczek. Despite
the fact that feed-in tariffs have been in place for a few years
nothing signifcant has really happened because of insuffcient
subsidies, Ondraczek said. The tariffs for sale are not suf-
fcient to facilitate any major uptake, he added, pointing out
that this is perhaps unsurprising for a sub-Saharan African
open for business in this
regard, said Janosch Ond-
raczek, a researcher on
solar energy in East Afri-
ca and a project manag-
er for renewable projects at
PricewaterhouseCoopers.
Ondraczek points out that
on grid solar energy produc-
tion does not feature in the
aforementioned investment
prospectus and enthusiasm
for solar on a government
level is weak.
There is much less convic-
tion from the government that
this is what they want to pur-
sue, said Ondraczek. There
is very little mention of solar
Power lines in Africa.
Credit: Shutterstock.
1409REW_54 54 9/11/14 11:13 AM
Covering every aspect of the power generation industry, POWER-GEN International, NUCLEAR POWER International, Renewable Energy
World Conference & Expo North America, POWER-GEN International Financial Forum and the GenForum converge in 2014 to form Power
Generation Week. Beneft from fve days packed with pre-conference workshops, technical tours, over 70 conference sessions, panel
discussions, three exhibition days and multiple networking events. Gain access to nearly every facet of the market all under one roof.
Learn more at www.powergenerationweek.com
>> DECEMBER 7-11, 2014 >> ORANGE COUNTY CONVENTION CENTER, WEST HALLS >>
>> ORLANDO, FL, USA >> WWW.POWERGENERATIONWEEK.COM >>
Owned & Produced by Presented by Supported by
For more information, enter 18 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_55 55 9/11/14 11:13 AM
56 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
RENE WABLE S I N THE DE VELOPI NG WORLD
country; they have limited funds to play around with subsi-
dies, Ondraczek argues.
Of-grid Solar Steadily Rising
Although the government has limited enthusiasm for on-grid
solar projects, it has pursued a policy of ramping up off-grid
solar production in rural areas as part of its 2009 Rural Electri-
fcation Master Plan. So far around 744 public places in isolat-
ed areas, from health centers to schools, have been hooked up to
off-grid solar power through the initiative. Demand for PV panels
is estimated to have risen by around 200 kW peak. Five off-grid
stations have been put in place and as they enjoy solid internal
rate of returns of 20 percent, the operation is being expanded- to
build new plants and also make existing ones bigger.
The biggest challenge in Kenya is access to electricity in rural
areas so that is why the government has been keen to work in
this area, said Njoka.
The government has spent serious money on this and there is
quite some government momentum and conviction, Ondraczek
also said.
Despite the governments exclusive focus on solar in the con-
text of rural areas, according to experts, solar has huge potential
on-grid as well in Kenya.
There is no question that solar has huge potential both on-
grid and off-grid, said Ondraczek. The level of sunshine, grant-
ed, is not as good as northern Africa but it is still a lot better than
in Europe. A big advantage of solar is that it does not take a long
time to build the infrastructure so it can be rapidly deployed. You
are talking a couple of months rather than a couple of years. If
you consider all that then the reluctance to look beyond the off-
grid niche is not justifed.
The potential for solar is high, Njoka said. The only chal-
lenge is most of the land that could be potential sites for plants
and so on is owned by communities rather than the government.
So negotiating with the community can sometimes be tricky. A
lot of investment is also required for solar PV so that makes some
investors a bit reluctant, he adds.
Nonetheless, there are signs that organizations in the private
sector are showing more and more interest in deploying large
solar projects of their own.
There is basically real potential for solar wherever the gov-
ernment is not involved, said Ondraczek
In May, the British frm
Solarcentury successful-
ly fnished installing a 1-MW
PV plant at the Changoi
Tea Farm in Bomet County,
Kenya. It has gone down in
history as East Africas larg-
est solar project to date.
Williamson Teas solar
farm in Changoi is a shining
example of the opportunity
for solar in Africa, and indeed
the emerging markets, to help
meet the increasing energy
demands of growing econ-
omies, according to Solar-
century CEO Frans van den
Heuvel. Sustainable energy
sources are becoming more
critical especially as the cost
of fossil fuel energy continues
to rise globally, he added.
The installation is expect-
ed to slash the energy costs of
the farms owner, Williamson
Tea, by roughly 30 percent.
The frm will be less depen-
dent on energy from the grid
and costly diesel.
There will probably be
many more of such exam-
ples to come and things are
likely to happen a lot quicker
in this arena than any gov-
ernment initiative, Ondrac-
zek said.
Hope is also being pinned
on Kenyas geothermal
industry. Kenya has huge
potential for geothermal
which has not been tapped,
say observers. Once the
1409REW_56 56 9/11/14 11:13 AM
READ the Industrys
Most Trusted Renewable
Energy News and
Information FREE!
Get up to minute
renewable energy
news and information
the way you want it
online, by email or
on your smartphone!
RENE WABLE S I N THE DE VELOPI NG WORLD
the capital, Nairobi. The sites drilling rate is around 40
wells per year. One well has an 18 MW annual capacity. It
is estimated that today the site holds around 280 MW of
geothermal electricity capacity, which site operators aim to
soon double.
The LTWP is also expected to have a positive knock-on effect
on the geothermal industry. The transmission line being con-
structed for LTWP will allow for more geothermal power genera-
tion to access the grid as it will cross the entire Rift Valley, which
is rich in that resource. This will also contribute enormously to
the Countrys rural electrifcation expansion program, said
Van Wegeningen.
According to Ondraczek, the outlook for Kenyas renewable
energy sector is positive, although enthusiasts should expect
reform rather than revolution. There are big developments like
Lake Turkana but overall things are crawling- nonetheless in
the right direction. And we should expect more positive news to
come out of the country over the next few years.
infrastructure is built, the
industry could rival non-
renewable fuel sources like
coal. Out of the renewables,
geothermal is the most reli-
able in the Kenyan context
and it is a quick fx solution,
said Njoka. The country has
estimated geothermal ener-
gy potential to be 10,000
MW, with the cost of devel-
opment of around $4 million
per MW.
Major geothermal projects
underway include one at
Olkaria, Kenyas biggest
geothermal plant, which is
located 80 km northwest of
1409REW_57 57 9/11/14 11:13 AM
t
h
e
58 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
A rst-of-its kind, this solar
+ natural gas plant came
online in 2010 and is still
exceeding expectations today.
It boasts 190,000 mirrors and
covers roughly 500 acres.
Sunshine heats fuid in the
tubes, which then produce
steam to turn a turbine and
generate electricity. When
the sun goes down in the eve-
nings, the natural gas portion
of the plant kicks on.
project Proling Stand-out
Renewable Energy
Projects Worldwide
FPLs Martin Next Generation Solar
Energy Center
1.
2.
1409REW_58 58 9/11/14 11:11 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 59
1: About 191,000 mirrors over
roughly 500 acres make up about
75 megawatts of capacity to help
offset natural gas usage at the
Martin Next Generation Clean
Energy Center.
2: The combination of solar and
natural gas at FPLs Martin Next
Generation Clean Energy Center
means the company can take
advantage of the sun when it is
shining, while ensuring the plant
is producing power 24/7 to meet
customers needs.
3: FPL protected the natural
environment of the area,
preserving a 450-acre freshwater
cypress swamp on the property
that is available for public tours.
4: Heat from the sun reflects
off of the mirrors to heat fluid
in the tubes, which is moved
over to the plant to generate
steam to produce power.
5: FPLs Martin Next Generation
Clean Energy Center has a
capacity of more than 3,500
megawatts of electricity, enough
power for more than 700,000
homes and businesses in south
Florida.
All images credit: FPL.
3. 4.
5.
1409REW_59 59 9/11/14 11:11 AM
60 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
Show Previ ew
A SPECI AL ADVERTI SI NG SECTI ON
What do you get when you bring
40 renewable energy professionals
into one room, give them more
than 200 abstracts submitted by
renewable energy experts from
all over the world and ask them
to come up with 16 cutting-edge
educational sessions? The answer:
one amazing conference program.
This years Renewable Energy
World Conference and Expo
takes place in Orlando, Florida,
December 8-11 at the Orange
County Convention Center. Once
again, the conference is co-located
with Power-Gen International,
Nuclear Power International and
the Power-Gen Financial Forum,
which means that more than
22,000 energy professionals will
be attending the events.
Why go? Well, if not to mingle
with PennWell editors, myself
included, then perhaps the
following will entice you:
MONDAY, DECEMBER 8
MORNING: Enjoy your choice of
4 renewable-energy focused tech
tours all within the city of Orlando.
You could visit a bioenergy plant
that converts waste organic matter
into clean energy; a wind service
training center, where new and
experienced wind technicians
sharpen their skills; a community
solar garden one of the hottest
solar trends happening right now
in the solar industry; or a large
commercial rooftop solar array. Or
you could spend your day at one
of our pre-conference workshops
covering many important
renewable energy topics.
EVENING: Get all dressed up and
attend the Annual Awards Gala.
Who will win the Renewable
Energy Project of the Year? Who
will be named the 2014 Power-
Gen Woman of the Year? Who
has written the Renewable Energy
Paper of the Year? Find out during
December 8-11, 2014
Orange County Convention Center
Orlando, Florida
Click To Visit Event Website
RENEWABLE ENERGY
ISSUES ILLUMINATED
There are only a few conferences you can attend where
you can absorb four days worth of learning across the
entire renewable energy spectrum of technologies,
policies, markets and financing. Renewable Energy
World Conference, North America is one of them.
JENNIFER RUNYON, Chief Editor and Conference Chair
1409REW_60 60 9/11/14 11:14 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 61
our awards banquet, which takes
place at Epcot and includes an
elegant dinner and fireworks.
TUESDAY, DECEMBER 9
MORNING: Wake up and attend
the keynote session with high-level
visionary speakers including David
Walsh, CEO of Mitsubishi Hitachi
Power and Kimberley Greene, CEO
of Southern Company. Then, if you
are so inclined, attend the Keynote
Speaker Luncheon or the Women
In Power Luncheon or dine right on
the trade show floor after visiting
some of the 1,400+ exhibitors.
After lunch, go to your first session,
selecting between the following:
Large-scale Penewables Success
Stories;
Lnabling Mechanisms lor Consumer
Adoplion ol Penewable Lnergy,
Penewable Lnergy Slorage Syslems.
Enabling the Grid of the Future;
Lxploring Novel (Hybrid) Lnergy
Technology Schemes; or
Penewable Lnergy lor All. Policies
and Prospecls lor Penewables in lhe
Developing World.
You can explore the speakers and
exact times of these sessions here.
Once you have taken in that
education, head down to the
tradeshow floor and have drinks
with 22,000 of your closest
friends, grab a bite to eat and get
ready to Howl at the Moon at the
networking party.
WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 10
MORNING & AFTERNOON: Your
morning and afternoon educational
tracks offer a plethora of new
information on the latest renewable
energy trends, such as Powering
the Developing World; Fossil and
Penewable Lnergy Parlnerships,
Transactive Energy; Microgrids; and
Nexl-Cen Ulililies wilh speakers
from leading renewable energy
organizations such as Burns and
McDonnell, Black and Veatch, First
Solar, DOL, LDl Penewable Lnergy,
Duke Energy, HECO, Southern
Calilornia Ldison, DNV CL,
Washington Gas Energy Services,
NPLL, SPV Markel Pesearch,
Schneider Electric, Hannon
Armstrong and many, many more.
Wednesday evening enjoy Happy
Hour once again with 22,000 of
your closest friends.
THURSDAY, DECEMBER 11
MORNING: Start the day with
a networking breakfast where
you can select a table that will
be discussing your most pressing
renewable energy problems
and issues. Get answers to your
questions and provide insight for
others at your table. Then, hop on
over to the mega-session where
the future of the electric power
industry will be debated in light of
the most recent EPA regulations on
greenhouse gasses.
Finally, head back down to the
tradeshow floor and see if you
won a car! In 2013, the winner
was a member of the geothermal
industry. This year it could be you.
If you are serious about your
career in the power generation
industry, then this is a show that
you cannot miss.
Hope to see you in Orlando!
1409REW_61 61 9/11/14 11:14 AM
Be an Active Market Leader.
Create Brand Awareness.
Generate Leads.
Not a subscriber? Join our 200,000 other readers today - its FREE!
Learn How
For more information, enter 19 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_62 62 9/11/14 11:14 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 63
BI OENERGY
Food For Watts: Turning
Post-consumer Food Waste
into Renewable Energy
A new project in
Oregon creates
biogas from consumer
food waste and turns
it into electricity.
MIKE CRUMMY, Contributor
Since its inception nearly a
decade ago, Essential Consult-
ing Oregon, LLC (EC Oregon) has
built up an impressive rsum
when it comes to the planning and implementation of U.S.
biogas projects. In that time period, the company has pro-
vided dozens of feasibility studies, performed GIS mapping
in several states, and provided services for the development
of four full-scale biogas plants.
The most recent of these biogas plants, the $16 mil-
lion JC-Biomethane LLC project, had been in the compa-
nys sights for more than fve years. The new plant in Junc-
tion City, Oregon, which opened in mid-2013 anaerobically
digests organic material to generate methane-rich biogas,
which then fuels a generator for the production of electrici-
ty. This project carried particular importance for its found-
ers, since they happen to live in the area. But beyond the
The $16 million JC-Biomethane, LLC project, which opened in mid-2013 in Junction City, Oregon, produces
550 cubic meters of biogas an hour. Credit: Legacy Building Solutions.
1409REW_63 63 9/11/14 11:14 AM
64 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
BI OENERGY
personal connection to the region, there were other local factors
that made the site an excellent location to demonstrate the poten-
tial for similar facilities across the country.
The community here is very focused on sustainability, land-
fll diversion, renewable energy, said Dean Foor, project engi-
neer for EC Oregon and chief executive offcer of JC-Biometh-
ane. Between federal grants, state tax credits and a $2 million
contribution from the Energy Trust of Oregon, we had a good
groundwork here for developing this type of project.
While still in the development phase, the project did encoun-
ter one early wrinkle that dictated a modifcation to the original
facility plans. The expiration of a tax incentive tied to pre-con-
sumer food waste forced the plant to turn to post-consumer food
waste as its feedstock source. This twist of fate ultimately gave
JC-Biomethane the distinction of being the largest U.S. biogas
plant focused exclusively on post-consumer food waste.
The feld of waste management as a whole seemed reluctant
to embrace the technology of processing food waste into biogas,
said Foor. The technology
needed a push to make it hap-
pen and show its potential.
The biggest adjustment
from the change in feedstock
was to the design of the
receiving building. Instead
of handling clean organics,
JC-Biomethane would need
a separator to remove con-
taminants from the food
waste. The company also
wanted to account for odor
control and greater storage
capacity requirements. In
short, the receiving build-
ing on site would need to be
much larger.
A translucent polyethylene fabric roof allows ample natural light into the building, reducing the need for artificial
lighting on the operations floor. Credit: Legacy Building Solutions.
1409REW_64 64 9/11/14 11:14 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 65
BI OENERGY
At the recommendation of
Evergreen Engineering, JC-
Biomethane turned to Lega-
cy Building Solutions to pro-
vide a tension fabric building
to receive waste for the plant.
In contrast to traditional ten-
sion fabric structures, Legacy
buildings feature a rigid frame
design that uses structural steel
I-beams, which allows the man-
ufacturer to customize to the
exact length, width and height needed.
Essentially we modeled up the dimensions we would need
to accommodate trucks making deliveries and loaders operat-
ing inside of the building, said Foor. We also needed space to
house different equipment arrangements and hold the amount
of inbound material we anticipated. The height needed for truck
tipping was another consideration.
The end result supplied was a 120 x 160 foot structure with a
polyethylene roof that peaks at a height of 47 feet. The building is
outftted with Rytec high-speed fabric doors for truck entry, and
also includes a two-story offce complex within the envelope of
the larger structure.
We have about 3,600 square feet of offce space inside the
building, said Foor. We did some retroftting in that area of the
structure late in the process as well. Our architect worked with
Legacy on a modifcation to
provide an exposure from our
offces to the western view.
The whole engineering phase
with Legacy was excellent.
They were very responsive to
our ideas and turned things
around very quickly. Even the
installation was fast the
whole building was erected in
about seven days.
Odor Control Technology:
A First for North America
Legacys structural steel
frame design allowed JC-
Biomethane to mount equip-
ment from the I-beams as
well. The receiving build-
ing includes a special odor
control system, a feature
that isnt legally required by
To receive inbound food waste,
Legacy Building Solutions
supplied a 120- by 160-foot
tension fabric structure designed
with structural steel I-beams.
Credit: Legacy Building Solutions.
After a bioseparator breaks down organic substrate and removes hard
contaminants, the cleaned substrate is pumped outside the receiving
building into a homogenization tank. Credit: Legacy Building Solutions.
1409REW_65 65 9/11/14 11:14 AM
66 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
BI OENERGY
federal or state regulations, but that Foor and others determined
would be advantageous both for plant workers and neighboring
businesses and residents.
The odor control system is comprised of two large hoods
established over receiving areas where the food waste resides
for extended periods of time. A vacuum over the area pulls in the
atmospheric gases emitting from the waste and moves the con-
taminated air through ducting to an ozone system just outside
the building. A series of 132 UV lamps create ozone, which reacts
with any volatile odors and neutralizes them.
Were basically pooling multiple exchanges of air per hour
through our building and using an ozone reaction to control
odor, said Foor. Its a unique application. This technology is
used at biogas plants in Europe, but we dont know of any other
biogas plant in North America that has used ozone for odor treat-
ment. We think thats a frst.
Other Unintended Benets
Though the fabric building was chosen primarily for its cus-
tomizability and overall effciency for the application at hand,
JC-Biomethane immediate-
ly started noticing additional
environmental and cost bene-
fts from the structure.
The fabric roof allows a lot
of natural light into the build-
ing, which is a big advantage
on the operations foor, since it
reduces our need for artifcial
lighting inside, said Foor. It
provides signifcant sheltering
from rain, wind and cold. Even
though we didnt have it insu-
lated, its still noticeably more
comfortable inside during the
winter. We thought it might be
hot to work in during the sum-
mer, but the structure actual-
ly provides more of a shading
and cooling effect.
The receiving building peaks at a height of 47 feet, providing space for truck tipping inside the structure.
Credit: Legacy Building Solutions.
1409REW_66 66 9/11/14 11:14 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 67
BI OENERGY
Te Anaerobic Digester Process
The operation offcially kicked off when JC-Biomethane began
processing food waste in July 2013. The facility receives most of
its post-consumer food waste from commercial sources in the
Portland metropolitan area and throughout the Willamette Val-
ley. Currently, trucks are bringing in about 1,500 tons of food
waste per month, enough to produce 550 cubic meters of biogas
an hour.
After a bioseparator breaks down organic substrate and
removes hard contaminants, the cleaned substrate is pumped
outside the receiving building into a homogenization tank, where
it remains for several days. The material then is moved into an
oxygen-free, continuously stirred tank reactor (CSTR), where
heated waste anaerobically digests for 30 days. Here is where the
bacteria convert the organic waste into biogas, which rises to the
top of the tank.
The processed digestate material from the CSTR then
gravity overfows to a post-digester tank, which collects the
biogas in its infatable gas holder. Biogas is then piped into
a cleaning tower where bacteria remove gas contaminants.
Remaining solids are converted to a sweet-smelling fber com-
post byproduct, while odorless liquid digestate goes into a
large holding tank to be sold as liquid fertilizer. Meanwhile,
the biogas moves through underground pipes for water remov-
al and fnal cleaning via activated carbon.
At this stage, the biogas is now ready to fuel the plants
16-cylinder, 2,000-horsepower MWM co-generation engine. Com-
bustion of the gas in this combined heat and power unit turns
a generator that converts mechanical energy into electricity.
The engine has a 1.55-MW capacity, and is expected to produce
12,250 megawatt-hours of electricity on an annual basis, enough
to power approximately half the homes in neighboring Junction
City. The generators electricity is sold to Portland General Elec-
tric as part of a 20-year power purchase agreement. JC-Biometh-
ane began selling its electricity in October 2013, three months
after the frst loads of food waste entered its doors.
Doubling in Size and then Going After New Markets
According to Foor, JC-Biomethane already expects to
double its food waste intake within six to nine months to
3,000 tons per month. This quantity would match the exist-
ing facilitys maximum capacity, and, as a result, there is
already some consideration
for expansion.
As far as the prospects for
developing additional bio-
gas plants, Foor acknowledg-
es there are some challenges
to replicating the JC-Biometh-
ane model. In our existing
plant, it is all electrical pro-
duction, he said. We secured
our rates with the electric util-
ity at a time when they were
considerably better than they
are today. The future of biogas
plants is more likely hinged
to us being able to sell ener-
gy into the vehicle fuel market.
We can take our methane-rich
biogas, clean it with carbon
dioxide, and compress it so its
a direct replacement for com-
pressed natural gas. The vehi-
cle fuel market is probably the
most ideal use for this energy
source anyway, so thats where
our attention is focused as we
look at future facilities.
Mike Crummy is a writer with
The Promersberger Company
in Fargo, N.D.
[Editors Note: Would you
like to see one of these
anaerobic digesters up
close? Then come to Renew-
able Energy World Confer-
ence and Expo, North Ameri-
ca in December. On Monday,
December 8th, well visit Har-
vest Powers Energy Garden.
More info at this link.]
1409REW_67 67 9/11/14 11:14 AM
68 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
GEOTHERMAL
China Turns to Geothermal
Energy To Tackle Carbon
Emissions
As China scrambles to reduce its carbon impact, it
has set gears in motion to develop its
geothermal resources.
MEG CICHON, Associate Editor
The UN has amplifed its warning about carbon emissions as
of late, stating that climate change is indeed real, and may very
well be irreversible if countries do not act now. Since its latest
declarations, all eyes are now focused on the worlds biggest
carbon polluters, and China tops the list.
To combat its carbon critics while also supporting its rapid
growth and development, China decided to kill two birds with
one stone and focus its energy on developing renewables
fast. In the frst half of this year alone, China installed more
than 3 GW of solar capacity, ramped up its offshore wind
development, and invested billions in electric vehicle adoption.
But despite this progress, China still has a long way to go, so
in July it announced that it would open the door to a technol-
ogy that has been mostly shut out of the country for more than
a decade: geothermal.
Replacing Baseload with Baseload
Chinas booming population and energy demand call for
cheap, stable electricity, which is why it accounts for
nearly 50 percent of global coal use. As it develops inter-
mittent wind and solar projects in order to reduce its
emissions and control air pollution, it still has a need for
stable, baseload power. China is not alone in this endeavor
many countries, including the U.S. and Germany,
are looking to stabilize their grids and believe
geothermal energy is a viable answer.
Geothermal is in a very
good position when looking at
emission goals because it is a
one-two punch, said vice pres-
ident of business development
at Ormat Bob Sullivan. As we
build renewables into the elec-
trical grid we fnd that because
of intermittency you have to
back them up and have fexible
resources. Geothermal can do
that without a carbon footprint.
When you back solar and wind
up with a green resource you
get bigger bang for your buck
a one-two punch.
1409REW_68 68 9/11/14 11:14 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 69
Geothermal plant.
Credit: Shutterstock.
China has realized both its need for rapid renewable develop-
ment and a reduction in carbon emissions, and announced plans
for a geothermal energy development plan.
Government Support
The Chinese government is culling together plans for compre-
hensive geothermal development in conjunction with its 13th
fve-year plan, which covers the years 2016-2020. As part of
this plan, it hopes to develop 100 MW of geothermal by 2015 in
northern, central and southwest China. It will initially focus on
high-temperature resources, them move to low- and medium-
temperature applications.
According to the National Energy Administration, it will focus
onthe development of deep geothermal district heating proj-
ects, large-scale promotion of shallow geothermal energy devel-
opment, and the utilization of geothermal energy demonstration
construction projects while
exploring suitable areas for
local development.
In order to speed this
growth along, the govern-
ment will establish a national
geothermal energy data and
information system by next
year. This system will be sim-
ilar to National Geothermal
Data System recently devel-
oped by the U.S. Department
of Energy. These resources
aggregate information such
as geological resources, poli-
cy incentives, and permitting
1409REW_69 69 9/11/14 11:14 AM
70 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
GEOTHERMAL
processes into one database to help speed along the development
of geothermal projects.
Not only will this database help build geothermal electrical
generating capacity, but it will also forward the governments
initiative to ramp up geothermal heating and cooling systems.
According to recent legislation, China hopes to offset a major
portion of its coal consumption, which accounts for 66 percent of
its energy use, with geothermal heat pumps (GHP). In fact, geo-
thermal has the potential to completely replace the nations coal-
heating systems. Demonstration projects in Beijing have shown
that GHPs will be a major player in reducing carbon emissions,
according to the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL).
A Range of Opportunity
To date, China has 25 MW of installed geothermal capacity. How-
ever several regions, such as Tibet and Yunnan, have vast poten-
tial. According to geologists, the land along the Himalayas, which
extends into Tibet and nearby Nepal, holds the greatest potential.
The hottest and best known of the geothermal systems are in
Jammu and Kashmir, which form part of the northwest Hima-
layan geothermal province that extends through Nepal and
Tibet, said geologist at the Energy and Geosciences Institute,
University of Utah, Geo Moore during an energy conference in
India. I hope lessons from elsewhere in the world can help har-
ness these resources in the Himalayas.
These areas have previously faced development barriers. Much
of the high-temperature resources are on a collision zone of two
continental plates and volcanic zones, making drilling very diff-
cult. Resources are also located at higher altitudes, which is cost-
ly for equipment transportation.
However, according to a resource assessment report released
by MIT, many of these barriers have been overcome with improve-
ments in technology. And with the recently announced government
support, many in the industry are hopeful for new development.
Strides in the development of enhanced geothermal technologies
(EGS), which exploits resources in dry rock with hydraulic stimula-
tion, may open far more resource potential throughout the country,
according to the report.
Direct-use geothermal has gained much more traction in China.
One of its biggest success stories is the city of Xianyang in Shaanxi
provice, known as Chinas Geothermal Energy City. Xianyang
began developing its hot water resources with temperatures
ranging from 55 to 120C in
the 1990s and now has 30
wells used for heating, hot
water and other recreational
activities. Geothermal has so
far offset nearly 150,000 tons
of CO2 emissions annually,
according to a report released
by the United Nation Universi-
ty in Iceland.
Earlier this year, the Xian-
yang government signed
a memorandum of under-
standing with Iceland-based
geothermal developer Okra
Energy and China-based
petroleum developer Sinopec
Group, to pool resources and
further develop the geother-
mal district heating system.
[The] delegationwas sat-
isfed with the Sino-Icelandic
geothermal cooperation and
spoke highly of the progress,
according to a release from
Sinopec. He also expressed
[willingness] that Iceland
wouldstrengthen cooperation
with Xianyang Cityin respect of
[pollution] treatment, geother-
mal exploration and tourism.
Geothermal is a viable
renewable energy answer
that can both reduce emis-
sions and improve economies
exactly what China needs.
Geothermal has all the attri-
butes of a coal facility. It pro-
vides very reliable baseload
power to count on day in and
day out and provides jobs for
a better economy.
1409REW_70 70 9/11/14 11:14 AM
NEW
HYDROPOWER
PLANTS
FOR CONSTRUCTION
WITH A TOTAL
OF 39.4 GW
ELECTRICITY ELECTRICITY
CONSUMPTION CONSUMPTIO
GROWTH
520 TWh
TO 785.1TWh
AVERAGING 4.7%
INCREASE / YEAR
increase in % of total energy portfolio
RENEWABLES
EXPECTING
BILLION
US
DOLLARS
IN REQUIRED
INVESTMENTS
NEW THERMAL
POWER PLANTS
UNDER CONSTRUCTION
WITH A TOTAL OF 3.8 GW
NUCLEAR
POWER
PLANT
UNDER
CONSTRUCTION
WITH 1.4 GW
HYDRO
POWER
PROJECTS
(>50MW) UNDER
FEASIBILITY STUDIES WITH
AN EXPECTED TOTAL
OF 6.9 GW
KM OF NEW
LINE BY 2022
FROM 51,500 TO
155,500 KM
AVERAGE INCREASE
IN WIND, BIOMASS,
SMALL HYDRO (<50 MW) GROWTH
EXPECTED GROWTH FOR
ELECTRICAL ENERGY
GENERATION
119.5 GW TO 183.1GW
AVERAGING >4.2%
INCREASE / YEAR
MVA JUMP IN
TRANSFORMATION
CAPACITY
FROM 249,600 MVA -
TO352,800 MVA
Source: Epe (Empressa
De Planejamento
Energetico Company)
Pde 2022 10-Year Plan -
Published Dec 2013
INTERNATIONAL SOLUTIONS
FOR BRAZILIAN UTILITIES.
GLOBAL PERSPECTI VE TOTAL GTD COVERAGE TECHNI CAL MEETS COMMERCI AL
came together to
collaborate and
discuss the future of
the Brazilian electric
power industry.
51
A LOOK AT THE POTENTI AL OF THE BRAZI LI AN ELECTRI C POWER MARKET
on-site
generation
will more than
x
2
53.5 TWh TO
115 TWh
BILLION
US
DOLLARS
BILLION US
DOLLARS
TO BE SPENT IN
TRANSMISSION
LINES
GROWTH
TO BE SPENT IN
SUBSTATION GROWTH
to
WIND POWER,
BIOMASS
AND SMALL
HYDRO PLANT
GENERATION
WILL JUMP FROM
Supporting Associations: Offcial Endorsement by: Owned & Produced by:
- Conventional & Renewable Power Generation
- Hydropower Generation
- Transmission & Distribution
NATIONS
weve included a
world-class exhibition
- allowing utilities the
chance to talk directly
with suppliers.
JUST CONFERENCE
PROGRAMS,
I
n
2
0
1
3
,
#POWERBRASIL
S O PAULO, B RA S I L / T RA NS A ME RI CA E X P O CE NT E R
WWW. POWERBRASI LEVENTS. COM
For more information, enter 20 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_71 71 9/11/14 1:28 PM
72 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
HYDROPOWER
Hydropower Financing
Gets a Boost from the US
Department of Energy
Te US government recently identied non-powered
dams as ripe for government investment. Heres a
rundown of what to expect from this exciting new DOE
opportunity that seeks innovation in hydropower.
Closed Sluice Gates of a Reservoir
via Shutterstock.
VINCE FONT, Contributing Editor
At 3.79 million square miles, the United States is the fourth
largest country in the world by total area. Scattered through-
out that vast landscape are some 80,000 non-powered dams
that, if harnessed, could hold as much as 12.1 GW (or 12,100
MW) of renewable energy capacity. The U.S. Department of
Energy recognizes this, and recently announced its intention
to provide billions of dol-
lars in loans to hydroelectric
power technology developers
to convert all that standing
water into power.
In July, the DOE
announced $4B in loan
guarantees for fve key areas
1409REW_72 72 9/11/14 11:14 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 73
of renewable energy tech-
nology. The loans are part
of the Presidents Climate
Action Plan, which aims to
cut carbon pollution and
decrease greenhouse emis-
sions through a variety of
measures, including loan
guarantees that support
clean, innovative technolo-
gies. Among the fve areas
on which the DOE has decid-
ed to aim its considerable
focus is the enhancement
of existing facilities includ-
ing micro-hydro or hydro
updates to existing non-pow-
ered dams.
Peter W. Davidson, Execu-
tive Director of the Loan Pro-
grams Offce (LPO) for the
DOE, views the announce-
ment as nothing less than
a watershed moment for
the U.S. hydropower indus-
try. This is the frst time the
loans program has specifcal-
ly called out hydro and small-
scale hydro as something
were interested in developing
further, Davidson said. If we
can fnd a way to bring power
to some of those 80,000
dams, we could relatively
easily tap into a huge amount
of power.
Davidson, who added that
there are some very non-
invasive ways to power up
dams with minimal envi-
ronmental impact, pointed
to a study that identifed the
potential to harness up to 8 GW of power capacity simply by con-
verting 100 of the countrys top existing non-powered dams to
power-generating dams.
Were very hopeful that developers will work on projects for
these non-powered dams, Davidson said, adding that doing so
would present a great opportunity to accelerate the deployment
of hydropower in the United States.
As part of the PCL Construction design-build team, Black & Veatch
designed a new 30-megawatt powerhouse and other hydropower
components to increase the installed capacity of Puget Sound Energys
Lower Baker development to 109 MW. The project was completed in
2013. Credit: Black & Veatch.
1409REW_73 73 9/11/14 11:14 AM
74 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
HYDROPOWER
Carlos Araoz, Vice President and Director of Hydropower and
Hydraulic Structures for Black & Veatch, pointed to addition-
al areas of hydropower that may also beneft from loan program
dollars. These include requests for loans to upgrade existing dam
power plants with more modern and therefore energy effcient
-- technology. There are some very old power plants out there
that could be replaced, either on a per-unit basis or by a single
unit of a much larger size, Araoz said.
Norman Bishop, Senior Vice President of Hydropower and
Renewable Energy for Knight Piesold, sees the DOE initiative as a
much needed boost for the U.S. hydropower industry. For many
years, other renewables have had the benefts of a wide variety of
incentives, Bishop said. Certainly, the hydro sector of the coun-
trys renewable portfolio needs a jump start. This program is the
frst of potentially many more that will attempt to capture energy
that would otherwise be wasted.
Bishop said DOE efforts to collect feedback from the renew-
able energy industry about the loan program was an encour-
aging and important frst step. Prior to the offcial launch of the
program, a series of meetings were held in six cities throughout
the country. During this 30-day public comment period, renew-
able energy developers were encouraged to voice their concerns
and suggestions.
We had an extremely good response in those public meet-
ings, Davidson said. We received a number of very helpful pub-
lic comments and we incorporated as many as we could into the
fnal solicitation. Full details of the public comments, including
DOE response, are available online.
The application process for the DOEs Renewable Energy and
Effcient Energy Projects Solicitation is being rolled out in two
Bonneville Power
Administration completed
the modernization of BPAs
Celilo converter station at
Dalles, Oregon, which uses
solid-state silicon chips that
should allow the system
to work cooler, safer and
be ecologically improved.
Credit: DOE.
parts, each with a series of
specifed due dates ranging
from October 1 of this year
through December 2 of 2015.
Part I will require applicants
to pay a $50,000 applica-
tion fee and provide a proj-
ect summary that shows they
meet certain requirements
set forth by the DOE for loan
consideration.
There are several key
requirements that must be
met, Davidson explained.
The project has to be locat-
ed within the United States
or its territories, it has to
reduce greenhouse gas emis-
sions, and it has to utilize a
new technology or process to
achieve that.
Approved applicants will
then move on to Part II of the
process. Those companies
requesting $150 million or
less in loans will be required
to pay a $100,000 fee. Those
requesting greater than $150
million will be required to
pay a $350,000 fee. These
1409REW_74 74 9/11/14 11:14 AM
Download the Preliminary Event Guide and register today at:
www.power-gen-middleeast.com
BOOTH AND SPONSORSHIP
ENQUIRIES:
Kelvin Marlow
Rest of the World
T +44 (0) 1992 656 610
F +44 (0) 1992 656 700
E kelvinm@pennwell.com
Bridgett Maddux
Americas
T: +1-918-831-9130
F: +1-918-831-9834
E: bridgettm@pennwell.com
Liu Zizhen
China
China Exhibition World Co.Ltd
T: +86-10-659 200 71 ext 888
T: +86-13-910-435 166
E: zghwfzxh@163.com or
liuzizhen@world-fairs.org
20 14 20 14
12-14 October 2014
Abu Dhabi National Exhibition Centre
Abu Dhabi, UAE
www.power-gen-middleeast.com
WHERE GLOBAL POWER
FORCES CONVERGE
Renowned for its high-quality and world-wide perspectives, this high-calibre event is the
industrys leading platform that features a world-class multi-track conference and diverse
exhibition foor providing the perfect opportunity to:
* NETWORK with 4000 attendees including senior executives and industry leaders
* DEVELOP new business contacts with high-level decision makers and infuencers from
as many as 60+ countries
* SHARE information about critical issues, exciting new developments and benchmark
projects within the region and world-wide spanning across 100+ key industry topics
* HEAR from 150+ internationally renowned chairs & speakers
* MEET with 150+ leading exhibiting companies
* PARTICPATE in insightful technical tours of Ansaldo Thomassen Gulf Repair Facility,
Masdar City
REGIONAL OPPORTUNITIES
STRATEGIC THINKING
TECHNICAL SOLUTIONS
Owned and Produced by: Presented by: Offcial Airline Partner: Host Destination Partner: Supported by: Co-located with:
G
E
T
1
0
%
O
F
F
E
T
I
H
A
D
A
I
R
W
A
Y
S
F
I
R
S
T
C
L
A
S
S
,
B
U
S
I
N
E
S
S
&
E
C
O
N
O
M
Y
R
E
T
U
R
N
F
L
I
G
H
T
S
For more information, enter 21 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_75 75 9/11/14 11:14 AM
76 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
HYDROPOWER
fees which, all told, could cost
individual developers anywhere
between $150,000 and $400,000
have come under criticism by some
who believe it may discourage
smaller developers from applying.
Weve worked very hard to
make those fees as low as possible,
Davidson said, explaining that per
2005 Energy Policy Act specifca-
tions, the DOE is required to charge
monies to cover the administrative
costs associated with the intensive
due diligence necessary when pro-
cessing such high dollar loans.
Araoz believes the fee struc-
tures may deter smaller devel-
opers from participating. If a
developer has a big project and
can get the initial funding put
forward, it may be worth their
while to go that route, Araoz
said. But if the project is small and on the borderline of visi-
bility, maybe not. Araoz added that developers of substantial-
ly larger projects may fnd fees in excess of $400,000 a worth-
while investment.
Youre always going to have some part of the sector that may
not be addressed, or that may fnd the terms and conditions a bit
prohibitive, Bishop said. But this is a frst of its kind program that
I think should be embraced and encouraged by our industry.
In emphasizing the more user friendly nature of the loan pro-
gram, Davidson noted the DOEs ability to stretch repayment terms
as long as 30 years. Repayment terms will be deal-specifc, and will
be commensurate to the offtake agreements developers have with
the entities they will be providing power to something David-
son said would be near impossible to achieve through a commercial
bank, and which he said will play a crucial role in giving projects
the necessary time to become self-sustaining.
One of the reasons this is so important, Davidson said, is
because many of these projects will need a longer period of time
to pay themselves back. The economics arent as strong to be
able to pay off the whole loan in a shorter amount of time.
Looking ahead, Bishop
said, I see this as a pro-
gram to be built on. Im very
hopeful that, when the appli-
cations start to pour in, it
will be fully subscribed for
many years.
We think the technology
is ready to be demonstrated
at commercial scale, David-
son said. Once thats done,
these industries will really be
able to take off and they wont
necessarily need government
funding anymore.
Interested parties are
encouraged to apply now
by visiting the Loan Pro-
grams Offce online applica-
tion portal.
Black & Veatch provided engineering design for the Northern Colorado
Conservancy Districts Carter Lake Hydroelectric Project, which harnesses
kinetic energy from moving water through intake, tunnel and outlet
works with a 2,600 kW hydroelectric facility that generates renewable
energy. Credit: Black & Veatch.
1409REW_76 76 9/11/14 11:14 AM
9-11 JUNE 2015
AMSTERDAM RAI
AMSTERDAM
THE NETHERLANDS
Sophia Perry
T: +44 (0) 1992 656 641
E: sophiap@pennwell.com
Submit an abstract for Renewable Energy World Europe 2015
CALL FOR PAPERS
Owned and Produced by: Presented by: Supported by: Co-located with:
Join us at
Renewable Energy World Europe
the health check for the industry
www.renewableenergyworld-europe.com
POWER SECURE
FOR A SUSTAINABLE ECONOMY
Abstract Submission Deadline: FRIDAY 10 OCTOBER 2014
Renewable Energy World Europe features the industrys most comprehensive multi-track conference, examining critical
aspects of the renewables sector.
The Advisory Board of Renewable Energy World Europe, is now accepting abstracts for the 2015 conference.
Renewable Energy World Europes insightful, practical and thought-provoking multiple track conference sessions cover
strategic and technical topics and are conceived and designed by leading power industry practitioners with the aim
of presenting only new, relevant and valuable content.
If you have such a message, you are invited to submit an abstract and share your knowledge,
experience and ideas with your renewables peers.
A full listing of suggested conference topics and themes are listed under the CONFERENCE tab on
www.renewableenergyworld-europe.com. Abstracts focusing on emerging opportunities in the industry as well as
the integration of renewable energy into the power system are of particular interest.
For further information on the conference, please contact:
For more information, enter 22 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_77 77 9/11/14 11:14 AM
78 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
ENERGY STORAGE
Is Distributed Energy Storage the
Energiewendes Missing Link?
In Germany, the rst state-sponsored
storage scheme is of to a sluggish start.
Safts Synerion Home
Energy Storage System.
Credit: Saft.
PAUL HOCKENOS, Contributing Editor
For years, critics of the Energiewende, Germanys clean-ener-
gy transition, have carped that the countrys power system
cannot be based on intermittent generation sources namely
onshore wind and solar PV without advanced storage tech-
nology to balance supply and demand. In Germany, battery
storage has come a long way fast, and a year ago the German
government started the frst-ever subsidy program to sup-
port storage systems for homes, businesses, and public institu-
tions, like schools. Yet the program has been slow to catch on,
and observers maintain that its long-term impact on the Ener-
giewende as such will be minimal.
A year ago, Germanys beleaguered solar industry rejoiced
when the government-owned development bank and federal
environment ministry announced loans and repayment support
for combined rooftop PV and
battery storage options of up
to 30 kW. The sector thought
it spotted an opportunity
to redeem itself on the Ger-
man and international mar-
kets with a technology that
German PV and energy man-
agement frms had long been
perfecting.
The logic of battery technol-
ogy is pretty simple: By stor-
ing power generated when the
sun is shining and demand is
low, the owners of household
battery systems can use more
of the electricity they gener-
ate when they need it twice
as much, say experts. Larger
storage systems, if connected
to solar plants, could help inte-
grate even more renewables
into the system, dramatically
reducing disparities in supply
and demand the bugbear of
PV and wind power.
Yet, 14 months down the
road, German PV and ener-
gy management companies
have sold only around 10,000
decentralized battery sys-
tems (not all in Germany),
with about 50 percent of the
1409REW_78 78 9/11/14 11:14 AM
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 79
new German owners tak-
ing advantage of the subsi-
dies. The Leipzig-based PV
company Deutsche Energie-
versorgung says that only 15
to 20 percent of its battery
customers use the supports.
Roughly a third of RWE
Home Power Storages clients
have availed themselves of
the subventions.
Critics say the bureaucracy
required to obtain the credit
is cumbersome, and that new
laws in Germany that will tax
self-consumption have put
a damper on sales. The fact
that these small-scale sys-
tems are designed only for
self-consumption (theyre
not connected to smart grids
or the larger power system)
limits their usefulness for proving extra grid fexibility to bal-
ance renewables.
Indeed, the numbers so far are modest, even though both pro-
ducers and suppliers of distributed storage hardware say busi-
ness has been picking up as of late spring.
A study of 13 European (mostly German) frms conducted by
the magazine Sonne Wind & Wrme, found that Bavaria-based
Sonnenbatterie led the feld having sold 2,500 transportable
intelligent lithium storage systems in 2013-14, mostly in Germa-
ny. It was followed by Deutsche Energieversorgung that sold just
100 fewer, and Nedap of the Netherlands with 2,000. Saft Batter-
ies out of Nuremburg moved roughly 1,000 systems, half of those
in Germany and the other half in Austria, Switzerland, Italy, and
Luxembourg. A number of other frms, including E3/DC, Bosch
Power Tec, and Frankensolar sold less than 1,000 models.
About 85 percent of the units sold were the more tradition-
al and substantially cheaper lead-acid batteries; while 15 per-
cent were the newer lithium-ion-based models, which are more
expensive but also tout more capacity. Not only can lithium-ion
batteries store more power while requiring less space, they can
be charged and discharged more frequently than lead-acid bat-
teries. The prices of the systems range from 6,000 to 30,000,
The Sonnenbatterie eco was introduced at Intersolar Europe in 2014.
It uses lithium-iron-phosphate technology and high-quality electronic
components and can be wall-mounted. The basic version has a capacity
of 4.5 kWh. Credit: Sonnenbatterie.
Boschs BPT-S Hybrid lithium ion
batteries have a storage capacity
ranging from 4.4 to 13.2 kWh,
depending on the model. Credit: Bosch.
1409REW_79 79 9/11/14 11:15 AM
80 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
ENERGY S TOR AGE
depending on size, model, producer, and type. Most of the inves-
tors were households, followed by small businesses.
Since the program launched in May, 4,000 battery buyers were
awarded a total of 66 million in low-interest loans and more than
10 million in grants. The state development bank KfW grants a
low-interest loan for the purchase of a combined PV and storage
system or for retroftting an existing solar-installation with stor-
age. And the state may cover up to 30 percent of the loan. Yet in
2013, more than half of the available monies went untouched.
The support programs were slow getting started, says Tom
Rudloph of SMA Systems, one of the early Germany-based pio-
neers in battery storage. But theyve ironed out some of the
wrinkles, so its working better now.
The jury is still out on whether the batteries with or without
the supports are worth it for small PV users.
Germanys main solar advocate, the German Solar Energy
Association (BSW), claims that small battery units wont make
or save homeowners a bundle, but in economic terms alone
are probably a break-even proposition, depending on con-
sumption behavior, type of PV system, location and other factors.
There wouldnt be government incentives if small-scale bat-
tery storage was completely economical at the moment, admits
David Wedepohl of the BSW. But at least half the systems in
Germany sell without any incentive.
The point is to create a market for storage, create economies
of scale, and generate experience with this new technology, says
Wedepol. In the future, if were serious about running our econ-
omies on 90 percent or 100 percent renewable energy, were
going to need it. He notes there are factors besides economic
viability that motivate people to invest in storage, such as energy
independence. Most of the battery companies say independence
is their customers primary motivation.
Yet others adamantly disagree. Wolfram Walter, CEO of the
Freiburg-based ASD Sonnenspeicher, says the purchasers of
the current generation of batteries are simply burning money.
Walter calculates that the per kWh cost of stored power from
rooftop PV is anywhere from twice to fve times the market cost
of electricity. The lead-acid batteries cant store enough power
over their entire life spans to make them worthwhile, says
Walter, whose frm has a lithium-ion product on the market.
Walter argues that the next generation of battery, namely paral-
lel automatic charge and discharge units or pacadus, which ASD
Top view of the Bosch BPT-S 5
Hybrid. Credit: Bosch.
With Pacadu (parallel automatic
charge and discharge unit), ASD
has developed a new electronic
device that can be installed
onto each individual battery cell.
Credit: ASD Sonnenspeicher.
1409REW_80 80 9/11/14 11:15 AM
Sol-ion
system
Energy conversion
& management
PV panels
Connection to
grid & metering
Distribution
To
grid
Li-ion
battery
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 81
ENERGY S TOR AGE
more complicated in Germany. While experts agree that PV solar
is now fully competitive with fossil-fuel and nuclear-generated
power, the equation has changed with new legislation in Germany.
For one, PV subsidies are rapidly being phased out, which
caused newly installed PV in Germany to drop 57 percent from
2012 to 2013 with 2014 looking no rosier so far. Moreover, recent
reforms envision taxing the self-consumption of solar power from
plants larger than 10 kilowatts. Renewables producers who con-
sume their own electricity will have to pay 30 percent of the sur-
charge that fnances renewables subsidies as of August 2014. If
the law stays on track, that share will increase to 35 percent in
2016 and 40 percent in 2017.
But at least now the law is in place, says Henkel of RWE Eff-
zienz. There had been so much uncertainty. This wasnt helpful
for the market, she says.
The German battery makers are also confdent that markets in
Europe and beyond even as far away as China and Australia
will grow, as theyve already showed signs of doing in the last year
and a half. Theres been a strong increase in [demand in] recent
months in other countries, Christoph Lapczyna, spokesman of
Sonnenspeicher will introduce
later this year, is the battery of
the future. The pacadu tech-
nology connects cells in paral-
lel and thus increases battery
performance by preventing the
losses in voltage.
Firms marketing battery
storage today say costs are
coming down rapidly, and that
storage systems will soon be
a better deal. Rudolph of SMA
sees costs decreasing by about
5 percent a year. Just look at
prices over the last year, says
Nina Henkel of RWE Effzienz,
noting their fall. This is a
very dynamic market.
But in terms of PV, every-
thing has suddenly become
A schematic of a typical
home energy storage
system setup. Credit: Saft.
1409REW_81 81 9/11/14 11:15 AM
THE LONGEST LASTING BATTERY
FOR YOUR OFF-GRID HOME.
LEARN MORE AT ROLLSBATTERY.COM
82 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
ENERGY S TOR AGE
Bosch Power Tec, told the Ger-
man press, especially in Italy.
Italy is a very fast growing
market since the fnancial ben-
efts of storage systems are
almost immediate because of
high electricity prices.
A bigger question looming
behind these developments is
just how much the state subsi-
dies and the take-off of decen-
tralized power storage is
facilitating the Energiewende
and assuaging critics. Most
experts say not much.
The problem is that these systems are confned to self-con-
sumption models, says Oliver Opel, a research analyst at Institute
for Sustainable and Environmental Chemistry of the University of
Lneburg. In order to pro-
vide real fexibility theyve got
to be connected to a smart
grid. He admits that house-
hold storage options for elec-
tricity lower demand and help
shift the PV peak at noon,
providing more space for
wind and solar in the system
as a whole. But its too small
to make sense to connect to
the grid.
Opel believes the future is
thermal storage using chem-
icals or stones in connection
with wind power. This [the
current program] is just the
beginning, he says.
The SMA Sunny Boy Smart Energy is a
combination of a modern PV inverter
and a battery with an effective
capacity of 2 kWh. Credit: SMA.
For more information, enter 23 at REW.hotims.com
1409REW_82 82 9/11/14 11:15 AM
MICROGRID EXECUTIVE MBA TRAINING
Co-Generation
Wind
A variely of olhers
NOVEMBER 3 - DECEMBER 12, 2014
Length: 6 weeks
Instructor: ahesh Bhave
Partner: FenewableEnergyvorld.con
This course will cover all of these
technologies, including:
Solar
Ballery Slorage
BioCas
Renewabl e Energy
Trai ni ng Event s
Microgrid Executive MBA Training
RenewableEnergyWorld.com
Online 3 Nov 12 Dec 2014
Wind Turbine Climber & Rescue Trainer
Gravitec Systems
Poulsbo, Washington
22-26 September 2014
Biomass One-Day Course
The European Energy Centre
Edinburgh Napier University,
Scotland and Online
1 October 2014
The Renewable Energy Mini-MBA
Green Power Academy
Cape Town, South Africa
6-10 October 2014
The Renewable Energy Mini-MBA
Green Power Academy
San Francisco, California
20-24 October 2014
Forecasting & Modeling
the Future Energy Mix
Green Power Academy
London
1-5 December 2014
Solar Training Solar Electric
Lab Week (Battery-based)
Solar Energy International
Paonia, Colorado
13-17 October 2014
Developing Geothermal Projects
Green Power Academy
London, 24-26 November 2014
Renewable Energy and Communication
Tower Technician Program
Airstreams Renewables
Tehachapi, CA
20 October 5 December 2014
Temperature Stacking In Thermal
Storage For Biomass Heating Systems
Heatspring Learning Institute &
Biomass Thermal Energy Council
Free lecture - Online
Anytime
Hydropower and the
Environment, South East Asia
International Centre for Hydropower
Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
26-31 October 2014 (Application
deadline in September)
Here we offer a sampling of short renewable energy educational events and certificate programs throughout the world.
If you would like your training event to considered for inclusion in this listing, please email REWNews@Pennwell.com subject line: Education and Training.
1409REW_83 83 9/11/14 11:15 AM
84 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE
Renewabl e Energy Wor l d Cal endar September t hr u November 2014
Adver t i ser s I ndex For more information on the products and services found in this issue click here.
Renewable Energy Roundup
& Sustainable Living Expo
Belton, TX, US
26-28 September 2014
GRCs 38th Annual Meeting &
GEA Geothermal Energy Expo
Portland, OR, US
28 September - 01 October 2014
T: +1 530.758.2360
Conference of European
Biogas Association
Alkmaar region, Netherlands
30 September, 2014
NHA Hydraulic Power
Committee Fall Meeting
Holyoke, MA, US
06-08 October 2014
T: +1 202.682.1700
E: help@hydro.org
INDIASOL 2014
New Delhi, India
08-09 October 2014
POWER-GEN Middle East
Abu Dhabi, U.A.E.
12-14 October 2014
T: +44 (0) 1992 656 632
E: suemc@pennwell.com
Solar Power International 2014
Las Vegas, NV, US
20-23 October 2014
T: +1 703-738-9460
E: info@solarpowerinternational.
com
Sustainability Summit 2014
Freiburg, Germany
13-14 October 2014
T:+49 761 479140
E:info@sustainability-summit.org
Solar Energy UK 2014
Birmingham, UK
14-16 October 2014
T:+44 207 8710122
E:mmanthena@solarmedia.co.uk
All-Energy Australia
Melbourne, Australia
15-16 October 2014
T:+61 2 9422 2973
E:jon.williams@
reedexhibitions.com.au
4th Annual Solar
Arabia Summit
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
19-20 October 2014
T:+971 44 557956
E:register@
solararabiasummit.com
HydroVision Brasil 2014
Sao Paulo, Brasil
21-21 October 2014
T: +1 918-831-9704
E: tchambers@pennwell.com
Greenbuild 2014
New Orleans, LA, US
22-24 October 2014
Taiwan International
Photovoltaic Exhibition 2014
Taipei, Taiwan
22-24 October 2014
T:+886 2 27255200
E:pv@taitra.org.tw
Energy Storage Australia 2014
Sydney, Australia
23-24 October 2014
T:+86 21 68407631
E:katem@cdmc.org.cn
East African Renewable Energy
Forum and Exhibition 2014
Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
31 October - 01 November 2014
T:+255 27 2543047
E:eabcenergyconference@
eabc-online.com
The 6th Offshore Wind Series:
Offshore Wind Procurement
& Construction Summit
Hamburg, Germany
03-05 November 2014
T: +44 (0)20 7375 7224
E: miranda@
windenergyupdate.com
GEO-T Expo 2014
Essen, Germany
11-13 November 2014
T: +49 (0) 201 72 44-742
E: anna.pietler@messe-essen.de
RenewableUK 2014
Manchester, United Kingdom
11-13 November 2014
T: +44 20 7901 3000
E: info@RenewableUK.com
Intersolar India 2014
Mumbai, India
18-20 November 2014
International Tidal
Energy Summit
London, UK
24-26 November 2014
T: +44 (0)20 7375 7224
E: sellis@tidaltoday.com
Asean Power Week43
EDF Renewable Energy45
Hanwha Q Cells GmbH9
Hove AS2
Messe Essen GmbH23
MTU Friedrichshafen GmbH17
Nexans21
Northern States Metal29
Pennsylvania State University47
Power Brasil Events 201471
Power Generation International
Finanacial Forum53
Power-Gen Middle East75
Power Generation Week55
Power One Inc.13
Radco Industries Inc.19
Renewable Energy World Conference
& Expo North America27
Renewable Energy World
Europe 201577
Schneider Electric4
Solar Frontier Americas Inc.CV2
Solar Promotion
International GmbH35
Suntech Power Co. Ltd.24
Surrette Battery Co. Ltd.82
The Adveritsers Index is published as a service. The publisher does not assume any liability for errors or omissions.
Selected multi-day conferences, expos and events for the Renewable Energy Industry
1409REW_C3 3 9/11/14 11:15 AM
Last
the
RENEWABLE ENERGY WORLD MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 2014 85
Lisa Caswell is
responsible for driving
the eMeter business
and working toward
complete integration
into the Siemens
Smart Grid division.
Prior to eMeter Ms.
Caswell served as the
VP of Global Alliance
Sales at Chordiant
Software. She has a
history of working
with firms that
have fundamentally
changed an industry
or business practice
area including: Aravo,
Ariba, CBT Systems,
Visioneer, Apple
Computer, and IBM.
Customer Engagement Is Key to
Unlocking the Grids Potential
Americas electrical grid is one of our
nations most important infrastruc-
tures, and one where improvement is
long overdue. The Energy Information
Association estimates that our vulner-
able grid and its subsequent power
outages cost American businesses as
much at $150 billion every year.
Its no secret that creating a stron-
ger, smarter and more resilient grid is
a challenge, and a majority of the pres-
sure to modernize this critical infra-
structure is left on the utilitys shoul-
ders. Strides have been made in recent
years, for example demand response
programs have helped consumers
manage usage while utilities less-
en stress on the grid. There has also
been movement toward smarter man-
agement of renewables through vir-
tual power plants. However, customer
engagement remains an important key
to unlocking a truly smart grid.
Many utilities struggle to find the
right way to interact and educate con-
sumers on the changes we need to see.
A study by J.D. Power showed that util-
ities lack the ability to meet consum-
er needs when it comes to online and
mobile content and information. Over-
all, utilities need to make a concerted
effort to educate customers and make
the end-users not just a part of the pro-
cess, but advocates for change.
Better customer engagement could
take many different forms, such as
giving customers the ability to track
electricity or water use in near real-
time or view an estimated bill on a
smart phone or computer. It could also
give them the ability to see the cost of
electricity per unit and make changes
to avoid higher energy rates.
This type of customer engagement is
taking place in the City of Fort Collins,
Colorado, which recently offered eMe-
ter technology, called Energy Engage
Mobile, to its customers. The utili-
ty linked 68,000 electric smart meters
and 34,000 water meters to the mobile
app, which communicates usage infor-
mation to customers. The solution has
been the backbone of the citys innova-
tive advanced metering project, allow-
ing customers to see 60-minute inter-
val reads for water use and 15-minute
interval reads for electric usage, a sub-
stantial improvement from the month-
ly bills that City of Fort Collins consum-
ers were used to seeing.
Technologies like these are an
important next step in making the
health or sustainability of the grid a
collaborative initiative. They enable
utilities to manage the influx of data
from smart meter deployments and
help consumers better understand how
they interact with the grid.
Customer engagement isnt the only
path to a smarter grid but its an essen-
tial part of the puzzle that utilities and
technology vendors cant ignore.
1409REW_C4 4 9/11/14 11:15 AM