IN THE MATTER OF an application for protection pursuant to s.7 of the Canadian
Charter of Rights and Freedoms, Part I of the Constitution Act, 1982, being Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (U.K.), 1982, c. 11 by Masoud HAJIVAND (IRAN):
IN THE MATTER OF a request for deferral of removal pursuant to s.48 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, S.C. 2001, c. 27 by Masoud HAJIVAND (IRAN):
STATUTORY DECLARATION OF MASOUD HAJIVAND _________________________________________________________
1. I am the Applicant in the above-listed matters and, as such, I have personal knowledge of the matters discussed below.
2. I was born on August 24, 1976 in Ahwaz in what is now the Islamic Republic of Iran. I am a citizen of Iran and no other country.
3. I am swearing this affidavit as Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) will soon be scheduling my removal to Iran where I am at immediate risk.
4. Since coming to Canada, I have become strongly connected to Christianity a religion in which I have found some true peace and understanding. In December 2013, I formally converted from Islam to Christianity along with my Canadian common-law partner. But my conversion puts me at very serious risk in Iran. Apostasy is a serious crime in Iran which carries the possibility of the death penalty. Christian converts and those who assist them as arrested every day in Iran. Moreover, my conversion has been published on the internet as my family and church colleagues attempt to rally public support to stop my deportation. These on-line campaigns began after I was detained by CBSA but now that I have learned of them, I am every worried how they will affect my safety in Iran. I am certain Iranian authorities would have seen this material and it will remain accessible when I return to Iran. As I am being returned to Iran without a passport, I will be arrested upon arrival and my apostasy will become known.
5. My only request is that Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) and Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) review my case and my new evidence of risk and grant me the protection I so desperately need. I know I have made mistakes in the past with immigration authorities and I accept these. But my failure to appear for removals has been motivated by my fear of returning to Iran. I have been in Canada for seven years. All I want is to remain in this country with my Canadian common-law partner and with my church community. I sincerely hope that, if I am eventually booked for removal, that CBSA will defer by removal until CIC can consider by case and grant me protection.
i. Immigration history:
6. I fled Iran in 2007, arriving in Canada on January 29, 2007. I was forced to flee after I had become involved in land protests in my home region. Our family are of the Sunni Vahabi sect, a persecuted minority in Shia-dominated Iran. In the mid-2000s, the Iranian government seized many of the lands in our community for oil exploration without providing any compensation. In response, peaceful protests were organized in front of the state capital and the governors office in Ahvaz, Khuzestan Province. As with so many protests in Iran, these were brutally repressed by the regime and many people were killed. In one protest in January 2007, my young brother was killed; his body was only released to us by authorities a few weeks later. In another protest around the same time, some of my friends were arrested; I was also stopped but I managed to escape. That night, the Iranian authorities came looking for me at my home. I assumed that my friends had given them by name. I was already in hiding at the time and, fearing losing another son, my father arranged for me to be smuggled out of Iran.
7. Upon arrival, I immediately made a claim for refugee protection in this country. My claim for protection was refused heard by Member Sterlin of the Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB) on February 24, 2009. Regrettably, it was refused on March 16, 2009. I did not seek leave and judicial review of that decision as my lawyer said that there was no purpose to doing so. I was also working as a superintendent of a residential building and so I had very little money at the time but still made too much to qualify for Legal Aid Ontario funding.
8. On January 18, 2011, I submitted my first Pre-Removal Risk Assessment (PRRA) application in Canada. At the time I had started attending the Christian Evangelical Fellowship of Christ Church in Toronto for a little over a year. My experiences in Iran including the death of my brother, being forced to leave my family had caused me significant trauma as had my time navigating the refugee system in Canada. I wanted to reach out to find comfort in a community that would accept me. When I started attending Christian services, I was first drawn to the friendliness of the people and how welcoming they were. Everything about Christianity and Christian people was the opposite of Islam. From the part of the world I am from, Muslim peoples are always at war and are always killing one another. There seemed to be little room for compassion or acceptance in my old faith. But Christianity and Christian people seemed very accepting and Christian countries like Canada were so peaceful.
9. In these very difficult times in Canada, I found a sort of home at church. From more sporadic visits, I started attending church for more frequently and eventually every Sunday. At first I came for the company and the community but I quickly found myself drawn to the message of Christs forgiveness and acceptance and of the promise of being redeemed through believing. I began to let Jesus Christ into my heart and to seriously begin considering to convert to Christianity. I had approached Pastor Petrosian in early 2011 about making this important decision. He informed me about the Bible study and preparatory classes that were required of converts a process that takes several months to complete. I had hoped to get baptised by mid-2011.
10. I mentioned all of these facts in my first PRRA application. Since I had not yet converted, I could only explain to CIC my intentions of being baptised and become a Christian. After submitting my PRRA application, I continued to attend the Christian Evangelical Fellowship of Christ Church. But there were many times that the pastor there was unable to attend our Bible studies and preparatory classes and they had to be cancelled. Sometimes, he had to even cancel the church services. While I liked the congregation, I was increasingly unhappy with the clergy there. By the time mid-2011 came I truly felt like a Christian but I had still not completed my baptism.
11. My PRRA application was refused on June 9, 2011 and I was provided the decision on July 13, 2011. On July 28, 2011, I was served with a Direction to Report for removal to Iran on August 23, 2011. I was terrified to go back to Iran and I was at a loss about what to do. I knew that I was a Christian in my heart but I would be unable to practice my religion in Iran. The Iranian government does not recognize the right of Muslims to convert; apostasy is a capital offence. If I was forced to return, I would not be able to attend church or to even tell people that I was a Christian or I would be putting my life at risk. At the time, I was in a common-law relationship with Salma ARSHADI since April 2008 but we had never thought of putting in a sponsorship. My lawyer had told me that my risk application would likely be accepted and we did not have money to pursue both options. But after I received my Direction to Report, I knew I had no other option. Salma submitted an In-Canada Spousal Sponsorship on my behalf on August 11, 2011 but it was not possible for it to be decided before my removal date.
12. I decided to contact my refugee lawyer, Stephen Morris, to help me challenge my removal. On July 27, 2011 he filed an application for leave and judicial review in respect of my PRRA refusal (IMM-4829-11). And on August 23, 2011, another lawyer that Mr. Morris referred me to brought an emergency motion to stay my removal. But because the motion was brought so late, the Honourable Justice Zinn declined to schedule a hearing to have by motion heard.
13. At this point, I was in a complete panic. I felt like I was being asked to choose between maintaining my connection to Christ (and staying in Canada) and following the immigration law (by appearing for removal). To be honest, it felt like I had no choice. In fear for my life as an apostate, I made the very difficult decision not to report for removal. I know that my conduct was wrong; I am not trying to excuse my actions but I am trying to explain them. How is someone supposed to react when they really feel their life is in danger? As a result of my failure to appear for removal, an immigration warrant for my arrest was issued by CBSA on August 24, 2011.
14. For nearly two years, I was living underground in Canada. It was a very difficult time as I was always under constant fear of being arrested and deported to Iran. But I did not know what other options I had. I continued to live at my reported address with my spouse. But when CBSA came to look for me, my wife told them that I had moved. During this time, I continued to attend my church but many of us in the congregation were not happy with the interruptions in the service schedule due to our pastors absences. I spoke with another friend at church and she told me of another church that she also attended: the Revivaltime Tabernacle Worldwide Ministries Church on Dufferin Street in Toronto. She asked me to attend with her and I did.
15. I first attended at Revivaltime Tabernacle Worldwide Ministries Church in the beginning of 2012. I was immediately drawn in to the community there as they were very warm and inviting. Over the next year, my relationship with Christ grew closer and closer especially as I was facing new problems in my personal life. My relationship with my common-law partner, Salma, was slowly breaking down. We would fight more and more about trivial things; she seemed unhappy and I did not what I could to change things. I felt so alone in the world and I had only my church and my friends to turn to for support. Our In-Canada Spousal Sponsorship was approved-in-principle on September 11, 2012 but throughout that time and after, my relationship with Salma felt like it was unravelling.
16. By the end of 2012, I felt comfortable enough at Revivaltime Tabernacle Worldwide Ministries Church to ask to be baptised into the congregation as a full Christian. I wanted to undergo conversion earlier but the church does not let anyone convert who states an interest; you have to prove your knowledge of and devotion to Christ by being part of the church community for a while. Baptism was a very important step for me since my family in Iran are Sunni Muslims, which is a minority religion there. Islam was important to my family both spiritually and in terms of our identity. I knew that if I converted that I would not be accepted back into my family. I also knew it would cause serious problems with the Iranian authorities. But I felt that I had no choice in the matter I was drawn to Christ and I knew I needed to be baptised to be a genuine Christian.
17. In 2013, I began to take the Bible study and preparatory classes for religious converts. But things began to completely fall apart in my life in May 2013. On May 24, 2013, I was arrested by CBSA under a warrant and placed in immigration detention. The arrest put tremendous stress on what was my already very troubled relationship with Salma. Salma suffered from several medical issues, including anxiety, depression and nervous breakdowns. I was hoping that I could alleviate her suffering but it was not to happen. I had taken upon myself the financial responsibility of running her household as she was unable to work and I looked after her and her son. However, her mental state overtook her feelings for our relationship and our relationship broke down.
18. When I was arrested, Salma refused to assist me. Instead, my friends helped me in that situation and I swore to myself that I would never return to Salma. On May 27, 2013 I was released from detention without any bond three days after my arrest. On June 13, 2013, Salma withdrew her sponsorship, which marked the end of our relationship. On June 21, 2013, my In-Canada Spousal Sponsorship was refused.
19. I knew at this point that I needed to submit my own immigration applications explaining why I needed to remain in Canada. At this point, I had been in Canada for six years and I had converted to Christianity in my heart and was about to convert on paper. I thought that these would be important circumstances to explain to CIC and to ask for relief. After I learned that my sponsorship had been withdrawn, I went to go see Mr. Michael Crane, the lawyer who was referred to me by a friend. I brought him my entire immigration file and spoke to him about my history and my need to remain in Canada. He explained that I needed to submit an application for permanent residence in Canada on humanitarian and compassionate grounds (H&C). He also said that I should submit a second PRRA application since I was now more involved in a new church.
20. I paid a deposit at the first meeting and the balance one week later. Mr. Crane said that he would take care of everything. I have no legal training and my English is not strong. I thought of immigration lawyers as being experts in their field; I trusted Mr. Crane to know what steps to take and what needed to be included in the applications. After now retaining new counsel more than one year later, I have serious concerns with how Mr. Crane represented me in both applications. For the purposes of this affidavit, however, I am focusing on his representation of me in my PRRA. I believe that he acted with professional negligence in how he prepared and submitted my PRRA application.
21. In all of our appointments, Mr. Crane never gave me a list of documents to gather in support of the H&C and the PRRA. Instead, at our meetings I suggested documents that I could bring in and Mr. Crane simply said sure or OK. But these all related to my H&C application. Mr. Crane never asked me to bring in any documentation in support of my PRRA application. The lawyers who had prepared my In-Canada Spousal Sponsorship with Salma (not Mr. Crane) had previously asked me to get a letter from my church confirming my attendance. I obtained this letter in September 2011 and it was in the immigration file that I gave to Mr. Crane. This was the only piece of personal evidence that Mr. Crane included in my PRRA. Mr. Crane never asked for an updated letter from my church, never asked for the contact information of clergy at my church, and never asked me to bring in any other documentation of my Christian activities.
22. Mr. Crane prepared my PRRA affidavit in front me. He only asked me a few questions and then drafted a very short PRRA affidavit. It was only four paragraphs long and one of those paragraphs concerned my Christian activities. In fact, my PRRA affidavit was just a shortened version of my H&C affidavit. Even though I spoke about this to Mr. Crane, my affidavit never included any statements about when I became a Christian in my heart, why Christ is important to me, when I started attending church, whether I still attend church and how often I attend. The affidavit also did not explain how returning to Iran would impact me personally in terms of my ability to practice Christianity and my fears of being arrested for doing so.
23. In a letter responding to these concerns which my present lawyer sent, Mr. Crane states that I refused to give him any details about my Christian activities in Canada, including whether I was attending church. I completely reject this. During this whole time, I was attending church with Pam and had a very close relationship with the clergy there. If Mr. Crane had asked for that information, I would have definitely given it to him. It does not make any sense why I would not provide it. And, in any event, the affidavit Mr. Crane prepared one year later for my stay motion was virtually identical to my PRRA affidavit even though by this time he clearly had all the missing information.
24. On June 19, 2013, Mr. Crane submitted my H&C application. I think that this consisted of just the immigration forms and payment. I think it was then updated a month or so later. On August 19, 2013, Mr. Crane submitted my second PRRA application. I do not know why Mr. Crane waited so long to do so since my affidavit was signed on July 12, 2013 and no other evidence except my first PRRA decision and the US Department of States Interreligious Freedom Report on Iran were included. And Mr. Cranes cover letter amounts to essentially two paragraphs of submissions so preparing the submissions was not the reason for the delay.
25. Mr. Crane never provided me with a copy of my PRRA application before it was submitted, only after. As I said above, I trusted him as a lawyer to whom I had paid a lot of money to know what needed to be included in my PRRA. If Mr. Crane thought what was sent in was sufficient, I did not think I had any basis or knowledge to challenge him.
26. Around the time that I was preparing my H&C and PRRA application, I moved into the home of Poopak Pam Shiraldini, a citizen of Canada. Pam and I had been introduced in June 2012 by our mutual friend Yones Yahyavi. He had invited both of us along with other friends to a party at his home. Pam and I became acquainted and spent most of the time at the party together. We exchanged phone numbers and decided to keep in touch. I had turned to her for support during the breakdown of my marriage. And I could tell we had a connection that went beyond friendship but I tried to suppress these feelings while I was still with Salma.
27. When Pam offered to let me live with her, however, our relationship changed. We began to speak about our true feelings for one another and we entered into a conjugal relationship. As part of our evolving relationship, Pam became more involved in the Church. It started when she starting accompanying me to church so we could spend more time together. But eventually Pam formed her own connection with Christianity. By early Fall 2013, Pam decided to join with me in my decision to formally convert to Christianity and become baptized.
28. For a few months before and after our baptism, Pam and I were attending bible study at our church. Sometimes, we attended for 1.5 hours before church began every Sunday. At other times, we attended classes on Wednesday nights. After a while, the time came to pick a date for our baptism. We decided to become full Christians on a special day New Years Eve. On December 31, 2013, Pam and I were formally baptized as Christians by the Revivaltime Tabernacle Worldwide Ministries in front of the congregation. It was a beautiful ceremony and I knew right away that I had made the right choice in following my conscience.
29. In all my phone calls with Mr. Crane asking for an update on my file, he never asked me for an update on my Christian practices. But I knew that getting baptised was important and I wanted Mr. Crane to see the certificate. I brought a copy of my baptismal certificate to Mr. Crane. He did not ask for any other information. For example, he did not say that I should bring in photographs of the ceremony or swear an affidavit about what the ceremony meant to me as a Christian. Mr. Crane submitted the certificate alone to CIC without any submissions or any other evidence on February 12, 2014.
30. Over the next couple of months, Pam and I continued to live our normal life. We went to work, we took care of Pams Canadian daughter, and we went to church. We were confident that had done what we needed to gain me protection in Canada. But my whole world came crashing down on May 16, 2014. On that day I was called in CBSAs office at 6900 Airport Road to receive my PRRA and H&C decisions. Both were refused. CBSA informed me that I would have to leave Canada in a few weeks. I was eventually scheduled for removal on July 2, 2014. Pam and I were there together and we were devastated when we learned of the results. We are simple people and we just did not understand why the Government of Canada would send me back to Iran knowing I was now a Christian. Pam was particularly upset crying and even yelling at one point because she also knows that fate that awaits me in Iran if I go back. And the idea of being killed or imprisoned is too much for her.
31. Pam emailed Mr. Crane and told him about the refusals and asked for an appointment. When we met with Mr. Crane he never accepted any responsibility for why the applications were refused even though in both applications that Officer said I had not provided enough evidence and details about my Christianity. Mr. Crane just said that we would have to challenge the decisions in Court and that he would bring a motion to stop my removal from Canada. I asked him why the PRRA Officer did not believe I was still attending church. I said that I could bring in a current letter from the church to prove that I still attend and Mr. Crane just said sure again. I brought him that letter, dated June 1, 2014. The letter was very easy and quick to obtain because my church supports me fully. If Mr. Crane had asked for a similar updated letter before I would have definitely obtained it.
32. Even though the PRRA Officer said in my second PRRA decision that I did not provide enough details about how, when and why I became a Christian, Mr. Crane never provided any of these details in my stay motion either. My stay motion was heard by the Honourable Mr. Justice Hughes of the Federal Court on June 26, 2014 and was denied on the same day. The judge found that I lacked clean hands as I had evaded a previous removal. He also found that my application did not raise a serious issue.
33. At this point Pam and I were simply devastated. We were also shocked at Mr. Cranes performance in Court. We could hear the lawyer from the Department of Justice and judge complaining how the PRRA lacked even a basic sufficient affidavit from me explaining whether I went to church, why I converted, what Christianity meant to me and whether I would continue to practice in Iran. At this point, Pam and I knew that Mr. Crane had done a very, very poor job of preparing the PRRA. All along I thought it was the Government of Canada who had acted unfairly but now I realized it was Mr. Crane.
34. The following day, I had a pre-removal interview at CBSAs office at 6900 Airport Road. The Officer I met with asked me whether I would leave Canada as scheduled on July 1, 2014 as scheduled. I told him honestly that my life was in danger in Iran as I am an apostate and I will be killed for my beliefs. Because of my statements, I was arrested and placed on immigration hold as someone who was unlikely to appear for removal.
35. While I was in detention, Pam became frantic. We both were terrified at the prospect of me being removed to Iran. She hired a new lawyer, Panthea Jafari, to try to explain to the Court that Mr. Crane had acted with negligence in my case. On June 30, 2014, Ms. Jafari wrote to the Court asking it to reconsider the denial of my stay motion but, on the same day, the Court refused. Pam felt very powerless in the situation but she and my friends wanted to do something. Pam contacted a group called No Deportations to Iran (NDTI) to help assist her in. They are an NGO in Canada that opposes any forced returns of Iranians to that country in light of the terrible human rights situation there. NDTI began to hold public protests at Mel Lastman Square and in front of the Immigration Holding Centre in Toronto, on June 29 and 30, respectively, to protest against my deportation. I was in detention throughout this period and I was unable to see the demonstrations. But when I heard of them, I was happy to know that people supported me and what I was going through.
36. On July 1, 2014, my removal was scheduled to take place. The CBSA guards came to my cell. I realized that if I stood and walked out of that cell, I would be walking to my death. I do not know how someone is supposed to react in such a situation but I decided my only choice was to stay seated. I did not get up when the Officer asked me to stand to be handcuffed. And when they eventually tried to drag me up, I held on to the bars of my cell. The whole time I was crying and telling them that I would be killed in Iran if they sent me. Eventually, there were six guards in my cell and they realized that I was not going to board the plane voluntarily. In the end, when CBSA informed the airline that I was not cooperating, they cancelled my ticket.
37. I remain in detention today. I was transferred from the Immigration Holding Centre in Toronto, Ontario to the Maplehurst Correctional Complex in Milton, Ontario and now, finally, to the Central East Correction Centre in Lindsay, Ontario, which is 200km from Toronto. I am very isolated where I am and my only contact with the outside world is Pam. Most days I just pray or sit in silence. In July 2014, Pam pulled together what little money our family still has to hire an immigration law firm to help address my very serious immigration problems. This is when we hired Mamann, Sandaluk and Kingwell LLP.
38. Prior to taking over my file, my lawyer, Anthony Navaneelan, reviewed my file and began searching for my case history on the Internet. He was very surprised to see that No Deportations to Iran has created a website in my name: www.savemasoud.com. The website includes details of my case, photographs of the protests that NDTI has organized and urges the public to write to public officials about my situation. Most troublingly, the website repeatedly identifies me as a Christian convert in Canada. My counsel also found a Change.org petition signed by over 200 people published on the Internet that explicitly states that I have converted from Islam to Christianity. These websites were the first hits on Google when my counsel searched Masoud Hajivand.
39. I am extremely worried that my case especially the fact that I am an apostate being published on the internet will put me at risk if I am returned to Iran. I have been in detention for the entire time that NDTI has been advocating for my case and I was not aware of the steps that they were taking on my behalf. As I said above, I am in a jail 200km from Toronto. I spoke to Pam about it and she said that she also did not realize the website said so clearly that I was an apostate. I have asked my lawyers to contact NDTI to remove this information from the websites. But I am worried that the damage has already been done. Even if they do remove it, I fear that it will still be searchable on the Internet or that Iranian authorities will have already seen it.
40. I am being returned to Iran without a passport which means that I will be subject to automatic arrest upon landing at Ayatollah Khomeini International Airport. I will be held for questioning and then taken to a special court to determine what I was doing outside of Iran and why I am returning without a passport. I am certain the interrogations will be abusive as they always are in Iran. All the Iranian authorities will have to do is look on the Internet if they have not done so already to see that I converted from Islam to Christianity while in Canada. This is a capital offence in Iran and, even in less severe cases, is grounds for arrest and prolonged detention.
41. Apostates are thought out a traitors by Iran and are dealt with harshly by the regime. I am very worried about being beaten or tortured in detention. And, if I am convicted of apostasy in Iran, of being subject to cruel and unusual treatment, or death. Everyone in Iran has turned their backs on me; I will have to face the consequences alone. As Pam has also converted, she cannot even come with me to be by my side. At the same time, however, I know I cannot simply abandon Christ when I return to Iran. He is my saviour now and I am committed to following this teachings in Iran. When I return to Iran, I hope to be able to find other Christian converts and continue learning and practicing and spreading with word of Jesus.
42. I am now in a truly desperate situation. Because of the negligence of my former counsel, the compelling evidence that I have converted to Christianity was not presented to CIC. And, on top of that, since my PRRA was decided, my status as an apostate has been disclosed on the Internet and would be knowable to the Iranian authorities. But I am legally barred from filing a new PRRA until October 2014. I only hope and pray that CBSA will allow me to stay in Canada until that time. All I am asking is for the Canadian government to take another look and my case to see the genuine risk that awaits me in Iran. Pam has filed an In-Canada Spousal Sponsorship in my case in July 2014. But I do not know if I will be in Canada long enough for it to be reviewed and granted. I also kindly ask that, if CBSA will not consider my risk issues, that they at least allow me to stay until my sponsorship can be approved-in-principle. I make this affidavit in support of my applications for protection in Canada and for no other or improper purpose.
SWORN BEFORE ME at the City of ) Lindsay, in the Province of Ontario ) this 12 th day of August, 2014 ) ) ) ________________________________ _____________________________________ ) MASOUD HAJIVAND KATHRYN LYNCH ) BARRISTER AND SOLICITOR and ) NOTARY PUBLIC IN AND FOR ) THE PROVINCE OF ONTARIO )
Jill Raitt, Raymond F. Bulman, Frederick J. Parrella - From Trent To Vatican II - Historical and Theological Investigations (2006, Oxford University Press, USA)
Ambrosios Giakalis - Images of The Divine - The Theology of Icons at The Seventh Ecumenical Council - Revised Edition (Studies in The History of Christian Thought) PDF