Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NLRC
G.R. No. 181146, January 26, 2011
FACTS
Teodora C. Axalan is a regular faculty member holding the position of Associate
Professor II in the University of the Immaculate Conception in Davao. She was
dismissed due to 2 instances wherein she was allegedly absent without leave, attending
seminars in Quezon City and Baguio City, respectively.
On the first instance, Axalan claimed that she held online classes. She was
convinced that she cannot be considered absent and opted not to write the letter of
apology requested of her by the University President to avoid any administrative charge.
On the second instance, Axalan claimed that she asked permission from the VP for
Academics who denied giving the same.
After conducting hearings and receiving evidence, the ad hoc grievance
committee found Axalan to have incurred AWOL on both instances and recommended
that Axalan be suspended without pay for six months on each AWOL charge. The
university president approved the committees recommendation and wrote Axalan a
letter informing her of her absences and of her total penalty of one-year suspension
without pay for both AWOL charges effective immediately.
ISSUE
Whether or not there was constructive dismissal.
HELD
NO, there was no constructive dismissal, Axalan having been validly validly
suspended for cause and in accord with procedural due process.
Constructive dismissal occurs when there is cessation of work because
continued employment is rendered impossible, unreasonable, or unlikely as when there
is a demotion in rank or diminution in pay or when a clear discrimination, insensibility, or
disdain by an employer becomes unbearable to the employee leaving the latter with no
other option but to quit.
In this case however, there was no cessation of employment relations between
the parties. It is unrefuted that Axalan promptly resumed teaching at the university right
after the expiration of the suspension period. In other words, Axalan never quit.
Hence, Axalan cannot claim that she was left with no choice but to quit, a crucial