Professional Documents
Culture Documents
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Sage Publications, Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Latin American
Perspectives.
http://www.jstor.org
Conjugating
Eric Selbin
a
If 50 years on it is a challenge toget clear picture of theplace of theprocess known
as theCuban Revolution, no event in that timehas had more lasting impact on somany
people in somany places. The Cuban Revolution mattered,matters, and will continue to
matter. It enabled and enobledpeople around theworld to stand up and struggle or renew
as a powerful testament to both social
struggles already under way, it continues to stand
around
theworld, and itwill provide a
in
countries
commitment
justice work and
actors
not
to
in popular collective effortsas
to
and
do
what
do?for future
model?for
well as effortsto improvehealth care and education. The legacy of theCuban Revolution,
itspremise and itspromise, is deep and wide.
Keywords:
or poststruc
the title, this is not some sort of clever postmodern
Despite
on
be
either
would
the
Cuban
Revolution;
tural(ist) piece
beyond my ken. It
an
to
what
the
subtitle
the Cuban
address
effort
is, rather,
suggests: why
it
matters
it will
50 years ago, why
mattered
Revolution
today, and why
matter
future. The claims herein will break little new
for the foreseeable
too much
of why the Cuban Revolution
ground, but they merit rehearsal;
the vagaries of revolutionary
matters has been lost to the ravages of memory,
the reality of the actually existing revolutionary process, and
ideals meeting
relentless partisans on all sides. Fifty years on, it is a challenge to get any sort
of clear view of the revolutionary process that occurred and is still unfolding
to invoke an almost certainly apocryphal
in Cuba.
(if delightful)
Perhaps,
to tell what
the Cuban
story, after 50 years it is still simply (far) too early
Selbin
University.
is Professor
His
work
Kathryn Hochstetler,
held at the University
and Chair
of Political
focuses
primarily
and the participants
of Texas
LATIN AMERICAN
PERSPECTIVES,
DOI: 10.1177/0094582X08328965
? 2009 Latin American Perspectives
February
Science
on matters
and University
He
revolutionary.
in the Cuban
in the Transition
21-22,
Scholar
thanks
at Southwestern
Helen
Revolution
Cordes,
Conference
2008.
21
22
LATINAMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
Both its inspiration and the fear it and the attendant radical
are still, in
(in Uruguay,
processes
profound ways, being unpacked
and Europe), dealt with directly (in Nepal,
Southern Africa, North America,
and the Philippines),
and planned
for (and dreaded
Colombia,
India, Mexico,
in
is
many places?the
legacy
by) by many governments
powerful and perva
an
no
than
event frozen in time
is
In
this
rather
because
sive.
small part
simply
has proven to be exactly what
and place (and space), the Cuban Revolution
in the twenty-first
most of us who
revolutions
related
(and
processes)
study
a process of
a
is:
revolution
would
suggest
century
deep change that has pro
a
to emulate.
for
others
duced a compelling
story, powerful example
This is a big and broad premise, and space is limited. The more modest goal
in several senses?historically,
here is to situate the Cuban Revolution
politi
even
to argue that it is,
psychologically?and
cally, socially, culturally, perhaps
in some nonintuitive
and perhaps even surprising ways, as relevant today and
as
ithas ever been. In the interest of space, letme stipulate three
for tomorrow
to understand modern
matters up front: (1) It is not possible
Latin America
Cuban
Revolution.
it spawned
and
tomatter.
Two other matters merit mention here. There seems little question
that the
successes and failures of the Cuban Revolution?and
there are plenty of both?
are
of how one views Cuba and especially
the revolu
(hotly) contested. Much
it
that
defined
50
has
for
the
years depends on
past
essentially
tionary process
where one starts from and how one is situated. It can be as simple as where one
continue
about what
sider lightly and inevitably with fear and trepidation; it is also associated
for
access
resources
to
to
for
with
and
food, land, peace, justice,
many
struggles
a home, health care, and education.
For
revolution
sug
many,
opportunity,
gests "better must come."2 It is among that category of terms that is instantly
a
inmost places most of the time as
formost people
recognizable
applying to
a
dramatic upheaval
their
group of united people
involving
overthrowing
government
and,
if successful, making
profound
and
significant
changes
to
23
Cuban
Revolution.
the long-dominant
theorists of revolution
"third-generation"
Academically,
a
to
"fourth" (Goldstone,
2001) may be giving way
(Skocpol, 1979; Goodwin,
and Selbin, n.d.). Guided
2001; Foran, 2005, Selbin, n.d.; and Foran, Goldstone,
to deepen
the human and cultural aspects of our think
by these, the need is
with
about
revolution,
(1978) focus on mobilization
recentering Tilly's
ing
as
has
described
their
and
what
(2003: 24)
Paige
"metaphysical
people
Thus, revolution is understood
(Selbin, 2007: 131) as the
assumptions."
conscious effortby a broad based, popularly mobilized
or
informal,
to
profoundly
transform
the
social,
political,
economic
institu
damental
transformation.
are the cases we are most likely to deem "great" or "social" revolutions;
lesser instances are often labeled as other, related forms of collective action.
academic and the popular?there
is
In the context of both conceptions?the
a clear narrative of revolution for some 220 years now (but easily pushed back
farther [see Selbin, 2007; n.d.]). This social revolutionary
story of
considerably
as the
revolution (Selbin, 2007; n.d.) begins with the 1789 French Revolution
as
it
it
is
and
its
is
is
is
failure
lost
(brutal)
epic,
sweeping,
grand,
archetype?it
its way
radical elements. This saga wends
to the mists of time as its more
These
never
its
realized
1917, which
century to Russia
as
as
came
seen
to
visions
and
France
and
almost
be
best/better hopes
quickly
as the
the ignoble end [or even 1939],
(who,
failure/betrayal
by
grand/great
to claim Russia?). And afterWorld War II there were glimpses of what
wanted
across
the nineteenth
might be possible:
1954, Vietnam and
is Cuba,
leads?it
current and seems
1950-1954, Bolivia
in the 1950s.3 But none
and
introduction of the modern
France's
concept of revolution
Despite
to
it
that
revolution
is
Cuba
the
modern
Russia's
brought
global
preeminence,
as never before that anyone
to
that suggested
willing
community, Cuba
the sacrifices, and take the risks could make rev
engage in the struggle, make
olution. Indeed, people do not fight, risk their lives and those of their families,
on the line
are about com
or put their
lightly; revolutions
hopes and dreams
a
a
In
itmay
and
vision
of
better
world.
this,while
mitment, passion, desire(s),
be ragged around the edges, it is Cuba that remains our reference point today
in its process and promise the guidepost
for tomorrow.
will
the
Revolution
matter? There is an array
Cuban
So why did, does, and
of answers to this, but what follows is guided by several factors thatmight be
as the sociohistorical
summarized
context, symbolic politics, and collective
and
we
memory/ies. With these inmind,
matter.
will
and
matters,
tered,
mat
LATINAMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
24
WHY
ITMATTERED:
REVOLUTION
for
II, there was a moment when possibilities
or under that of
under the yoke of colonialism
whether
subject people,
seemed boundless.
imperialism,
or
inMexico,
he
the Argentine
Guevara,
himself
Cuban
fresh
lutionaries
from around
theworld.
Even more?far
more?were
heartened
in
world.
25
on health, education,
the lives of
food, and housing,
improving
won
made
the
had
Cubans
the right
As
Castro's
millions.6
clear,
early speeches
it.
the
real
and
to change theirworld; thatwould be
revolution,
they could make
a
was
rev
it
The revolution also mattered because
postcolonial /postimperial
as a dramatic social
olution in the South. With the arguable exception ofMexico
a coherent social revolution, revolutions were written for the
not
but
cataclysm
Cuba
introduced in a profound sense the idea
North, where change happened.
of a revolution authored in the South thatwas written not just for theNorth but
for the living. The (clarion) call was not to emulate the European
(or
experiences
even the Chinese) but to fight your own fight in your own way using the lessons
a
learned as they applied; Che's foco (however flawed in retrospect) became
already in the field adapted and adopted the strategies
byword. Revolutionaries
that seemed relevant while others were driven to reconsider how to proceed
focused
as they
sought
demanded
and when
and where
Revolution
The Cuban
called
for armed
necessary.
strug
perhaps unfortunately, romanticized?revolutionary
at a critical juncture.
of the dispossessed
theworld's movement
(1969: 123) suggested, Cuba was
popularized?and,
gle and energized
As Guevara
this
"bad
and
of national
example"
international
that Cuba
is
in a word,
guilty,
the way
because
of
dignity.
Cuba
The
has
Cuban
dignity.
. . . Each
time
that
an
. . . the
the way
of
way
struggle
a
is
bad
bad,
very
example
example
shown
. . .
..
revo
"walked
the walk,"
than just an example, Cuba
sending not only
more
in
most
to
sub-Saharan
of
others,
Africa, but,
notably
lutionary guidance
lasting import, sending doctors, nurses, teachers, engineers, and construction
are the face of the Cuban Revolution
to most of the
These people
workers.
More
world.
WHY
as the modern
exem
itself with surprising quickness
established
Having
to
maintain
has
both
that
Revolution
the
Cuban
of
revolution,
managed
plar
as
even
and
of
revolution"
has
waxed
status
"the
iconic
(Colburn, 1994)
vogue
of itself as a society committed
waned
and to expand the popular perception
and basic needs to all its citizens and to
to providing health care, education,
seems an anachronism,
If in some ways
the revolution
others elsewhere.
framed as some sort of recalcitrant last gasp of the cold war in the grip of unre
or Stalinists
there were
(setting aside that when
pentant Marxist-Leninists
found themselves at times dis
those who laid claim to such terms the Cubans
as "banana
these outdated
missed
socialists"7),
concepts tell us little about
to make
itself relevant in the world. Cuba matters
has managed
reasons.
today for at least three
Cuba provides a living and still vibrant example of people who rose up in the
the revolutionary
face of oppression at a time of global hostility and demanded
how
Cuba
right to change
thematerial
and
ideological
conditions
of their everyday
lives.
LATINAMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
26
task?which
would
may have failed to live up to this gargantuan
momentous
efforts?
with
of
other
such
in
the
protagonists
league
place them
the very real successes on the ground and the
should not deny or denigrate
extent towhich, as a result, they offer theworld an alternative model. As noted
lives.
above, Cuban professionals work around theworld to improve people's
It also stands as a powerful and salutary reminder that evil can be opposed
in the face of daunting odds. The story of the Cuban Revolution
and defeated
and defeating a bru
revolution challenging
is one of a broad-based,
popular
States and powerful
dictator backed by both the United
tal and unsavory
crime syndicates who treated the country as littlemore than a play
organized
hardly ended with themilitary victory of the revolu
ground. And opposition
tionaries. A significant part of the Cuban
revolutionary
legacy is the ability, in
as international
and
foes large and small as well
the face of implacable
That Cuba
around the
resisters, and revolutionaries
cautionary as it is salutary. Radicals,
in the saga of Cuba and plentiful advice;
find inspiration and guidance
world
as
others to avoid mistakes
he made
Castro has not been shy about warning
as suggesting
that they adopt policies that have been successful. Perhaps
revolution
the message
the Cuban
his clearest and most consistent message,
seem
not
to
in
is
that
if
the needs
would
all, ways
many,
ary process
embody,
well
of the people must be met, that dignity and respect matter, and that change is
on one's own terms. Even for those who
possible and, indeed, necessary, but
for today's world, the strategies, boldness, verve, and
find the tactics outdated
can and must
?lan resonate and seem to cry out for emulation?we
struggle to
make
a better world
WHY
today.
made
of the past are no predictor of the future?claims
are
so
1949 in China,
and
after 1789 in France, 1917 in Russia,
on?they
that provide us with the language and
the events and processes
nonetheless
and imagine them. Just as surely as France shaped
the concepts to understand
our understanding(s)
of Russia and Russia of China, so too has Cuba
shaped
If the revolutions
how we
will
remain
important.
the modern
In part, this is because Cuba has become
story of revolution,
one inwhich the narrative is one of renewal, of redemption, of hope, of possi
once dreamed,
bility/ies. Even if (far) less has been realized than many people
a
a revolution and made
the case that Cubans made
it is nonetheless
making
to others. If it is easy to dismiss this as romanticizing
revolution seem possible
remain proud of what they
revolution, it ignores the extent towhich Cubans
27
are
did, who
going and the real proof of the self
they
they are, and where
"realer" by the
of peoples, a hoary concept but a real one made
determination
that
has
around
the
world.
Cuban
spread
revolutionary experience
that
It is, frankly, increasingly hard to imagine a scenario in today's world
to
Yet as people
continue
to seek ways
Revolution.
looks like the Cuban
us
is
to
that
will
who
world?and
their
among
suggest
prepared
they
change
will,
inevitably, turn to the tool kits they carry in their heads
not??they
(Swidler, 1986: 273), and there they will find Cuba: Cuba as a place where a
was able to draw
small band of brave revolutionaries
together the forces of
a terrible dictator and stand up to his allies; Cuba as a
to
down
society
bring
a better world
for themselves and their
sought to build
place where people
a
small country that set out tomake a large impact on the
children; Cuba as
social goals for its own population with others
world and share its ambitious
to the
elsewhere; Cuba as a society that had at least as its goal a commitment
worth
beings.
OF SORTS
we be carrying
Fifty years on, should
astute admonition
that "the
of Marx's
the Cuban
like a nightmare on the brains of the
tradition of all dead generations weighs
At a time when some scholars of revolution are seeking to
living" (1978: 595)?
revolutionaries
and radicals
broaden notions of revolution and the world's
and resisters and activists of various stripes are all too happy to dispense with
is the Cuban Revolution
the dead weight and forge new visions and methods,
reasons
not
the
limned
above.
still relevant? Yes, and
only for
cer
in which we find ourselves
The world
is, in some sense, postmodern;
Should
have
for thousands
of years, continue
Revolution
eyes of
by the
world,
into the contemporary world.
as a child, it seemed a
Revolution
LATINAMERICAN PERSPECTIVES
28
was
revolutionary
possible. As I grew older, I lost my innocence about Cuba's
process but never my fascination with it. I have grave problems with the ease
and people's
needs determined
with which
civil liberties were discarded
by
At the same time, I have unabashed
admiration
for the
the government.
the old order was torn down and the new
audacity and creativity with which
built and rebuilt; as I write this, Ra?l Castro has initiated the latest adjust
in Cuba
and the
ments
in this ongoing process. The decisions
being made
not?are
and will be part
being watched
paths opened up and followed?or
and part of the discussion
of the legacy of the Cuban Revolution
among revo
and politi
and policy makers
academics,
lutionaries, counterrevolutionaries,
cians as we wend our way farther into this century. Itmatters.
NOTES
1.While
is maddeningly
noteworthy
China U.S.
the import
years, itwas
2. The
or "factual"
sort of "authoritative"
any
riposte
of State Henry
Secretary
and impact of the French
too soon
succinct
"Better Must
elusive,
Kissinger
Revolution
of 1789, Zhao
the
especially
in a 1971 visit to
Enlai
Zhao
about
responded
was
is the Jamaican
adopted
by Michael
His
singer Delroy Wilson's.
social
democratic
Manley's
anthemic
and
nature
the revolutionary
of Manley's
National
party. On
People's
to Guatemala
of applying
"revolution"
the appropriateness
remains
contested
scholars.
and Jamaica 1972-1980
1970-1973,
among
tionary
(2005:
and
to tell.
summation
Come"
source
for the exchange
the putative
story is that when
Prime Minister
asked Chinese
arguably
Jamaica,
169);
1971
single
revolu
see Foran
1944-1954,
Chile
inMexico
3. This is not to ignore the myriad
discernible
from 1910
(tantalizing)
possibilities
to 1920 and, perhaps,
again from 1934 to 1940.
an
in The
4. Mrs.
ambassador,
John E. Peurifoy, wife of the U.S.
apt bit of doggerel
published
in the "People"
section of Time Magazine,
State that was
Columbia
reprinted
July 26, 1954?just
verse can be found
one year to the
in Cuba. Mrs.
first failed uprising
day after Castro's
Peurifoy's
website:
in Andrew
National
(1996: 210) or on-line at Arlington
Cemetery's
http://www.arling
toncemetery.net/jepeurifoy.htm.
5. Castro's
inapt description
in Sunshine
(1988: 168).
the early successes
of the new
and there is some grudging
that those gains, particularly
government,
recognition
revolutionary
in areas such as health and education,
have been
largely maintained.
on their commitment
meant
to cast aspersions
7. A phrase
and drive.
presumably
of the most
6. Even many
in Grenada
of the process
observers
of Cuba
churlish
is cited
concede
REFERENCES
Charles
Ameringer,
1974 The Democratic
Gables:
Andrew,
1996
University
Christopher
For The President's
to Bush. New
Washington
Forrest
Colburn,
1994 The Vogue
Foran, John
2005 Taking
University
Eyes Only:
York: Harper
of Revolution
Power:
On
Secret
of Third
Princeton:
World
in the Caribbean,
and
Intelligence
Perennial.
in Poor Countries.
the Origins
Struggle
the American
Princeton
Revolutions.
University
Cambridge:
Press.
Foran,
Pine
Forge
1945-1959.
Press.
In press.
Presidency
Coral
from
Press.
Cambridge
Jack
"Revolutions:
Political
Science
toward
Hodges,
1986
Marx,
of revolutionary
theory." Annual
Review
of
4: 139-187.
Goodwin,
Jeff
2001 No Other Way
Ernesto
Guevara,
1969 Guerrilla
a fourth
generation
29
Out.
Warfare.
Cambridge
Cambridge:
Trans
J. P. Morray.
New
Press.
University
York: Vintage
Books.
Donald
Intellectual
Foundations
of theNicaraguan
Revolution.
Austin:
University
of Texas
Press.
Tucker
(ed.), The
Karl
1978
"The
Marx-Engels
Brumaire
Eighteenth
Reader, 2d ed. New
Jeffrey
Paige,
2003 "Finding
revolution,"
Selbin, Eric
pp.
of Louis Bonaparte,"
York: W. W. Norton.
594-617
pp.
in Robert
in the revolution:
and the future of
social science concepts
the revolutionary
19-29 in John Foran
London:
Zed.
(ed.), The Future of Revolutions.
in the
in John Foran, David
and
2007 "Stories
of revolution
Lane,
pp. 130-147
periphery,"
in the Making
World:
Social
Zivkovic
Identities,
(eds.), Revolution
of the Modern
Andreja
and Modernity.
London:
Globalization,
Routledge.
In press.
The Power of Story. London:
Zed.
n.d. Revolution, Rebellion, Resistance:
Theda
Skocpol,
1979 States and Social Revolution.
Sunshine,
Cambridge:
Cambridge
University
Press.
Catherine
Survival,
in action:
Tilly, Charles
1978 From Mobilization
Struggle,
symbols
and
toRevolution.
and Sovereignty.
strategies."
Reading:
Boston:
American
South
Sociological
End
Press.
Review
Addison-Wesley.
51: 273-286.