Professional Documents
Culture Documents
T4 with Channa
T4 with Channa
Personalized attention is our theme, and we
will have an individual discussion for each
paper you write. We will have about 10 mocks
for May 2013 session.
KYP
This is known as Know Your Pre-seen (KYP)
issued by T4 with Channa.
KYP is a repetition of the pre-seen and the
objective is to make reading the pre-seen
user-friendly.
There are few slides included outside the preseen and they have been marked with an e.
Next step..
TCP will issue below documents after the KYP
231 short questions on the pre-seen, this is as a
test, to ensure you have reviewed the pre-seen
well (Our answers will be issued once you
attempted all the questions)
Industry review on Fleet Maintenance
Pre-seen Analysis
Industry Background
Many companies worldwide operate and
manage a fleet of vehicles.
They can be either:
Leased or
Owned
Industry Background
Management of the vehicle fleet in companies
done
Mostly by own in-house fleet management
department
or
Outsourcing
Vehicle investment
Vehicle acquisition and de-fleeting
Vehicle financing
Vehicle maintenance
Driver management
Speed management
Fuel management
Improving the efficiency of the fleet
Providing compliance with respective regulations on vehicle safety and
road-worthiness
Health and safety management
To Note
Although there are number of revenue
segments inside the Fleet Management
industry, currently BVS Private Limiteds
business only focused on Fleet Maintenance
and does not encompass the many other
aspects of fleet management, such as the cost
and selection of vehicle acquisition.
Vehicle Maintenance
All vehicles need to be maintained in order to:
Meet regulations
Maintain operational efficiency
Reduce running costs
Reduce breakdowns and therefore provide greater
degree of operational efficiency
Prospects in Europe
Within Europe alone, the number of commercial
vehicles deployed in company fleets is forecast to grow
to four million vehicles by 2014.
Position Company
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Lex Autolease
LeasePlan
Alphabet
Arval
ALD Automotive
Volkswagen Group
Leasing
Mercedes-Benz
Financial Services
Lombard Vehicle
Management
Arnold Clark Finance
GE Capital
Parent company
BVS
Number of Vehicles - Breakdown
90,000
81,000
80,000
Number of vehicles
69,600
70,000
60,300
60,000
50,000
40,000
54,900
47,500
50,700
55,000
Other
customers
42,600
13,400
18,600
24,800
32,200
JAR
30,000
Total
20,000
34,100
32,100
30,100
28,100
27,000
26,000
Mar-11
Mar-12
Mar-13
Mar-14
Mar-15
10,000
Mar-10
BT Group vs JAR
BT Group plc is a British multinational telecommunications
Services Company headquartered in London, United
Kingdom. It is one of the largest telecommunications
services companies in the world and has operations in over
170 countries. Through its BT Global Services division it is a
major supplier of telecoms services to corporate and
government customers worldwide.
BT is the worlds oldest telecommunications company. BT's
origins date back to the founding of the Electric Telegraph
Company in 1846.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BT_Group
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
BT Fleet vs JAR FM
BT Fleet represents the specialist fleet management arm of the BT Group and manages over 75,000 vehicles. It has
a 500 garage network, of which over 63 are owned by BT Fleet.
Products
Fleet management
Service, maintenance and repair
UK-wide network of BT Fleet owned garages
24/7 emergency assistance for tyre and glass replacement and roadside assistance
Comprehensive management information
Savings on franchised dealer costs
MOT and Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations (LOLER) testing
Single phone number for bookings and repairs
Wide range of vehicle types - cars, commercial vehicles, plant and equipment
Total transparency and an industry-leading service
Vehicle management
Risk management
Vehicle funding
Accident management
Consultancy
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Vehicle hire
BT Fleet vs JAR FM
BT Fleet about them!
We are consistently pushing the boundaries of technology,
environmental awareness and service to make sure our customers run
their fleets in not only a responsible manner, but an effective one,
again delivering cost savings in everything we do.
You can be confident that all of our processes are built with you in
mind, driven by our ISO 14001, environmental management, and ISO
9001, quality management accreditation.
http://www.btfleet.com/AboutUs/AboutUs.aspx
Company Profile
Key event
Before 1994
1994
2005
Restructuring of JAR.
were given profit targets to meet over the next 5 year.
2006
2007
Despite the profit target set, operating losses continued of JAR FM,
this prompted the main Board of JAR appoint a new CEO, Toby
Baum for the JAR FM.
2008
JAR FM has reduced its operating losses to 3.0 million, the lowest
level for many T4
years
.
with Channa
at Wisdom
Key event
2009
June 2009
Early 2010
Key event
2011
2012
2013
Financing of BVS
Finance Sources
Million
Assets
Million
Equity
5.1
1.4
Current Assets
19.7
(16.4)
TOTAL
6.5
Assets
3.3
TOTAL
6.5
3.2
Finance Sources
3.2
3.3
5.1
0%
20%
40%
1.4
60%
80%
BVS uses a more conservative approach to Financing as Net current assets are
financed by more permanent source
financing
based on rough estimates.
T4 withof
Channa
at Wisdom
100%
Year of 1994
Before 1994;
state-owned industry in its home European
country.
1994 onwards;
Privatised as JAR
Established separate fully-owned subsidiary
companies for the various parts of its business
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
JAR
A large telecoms company.
To support the telecoms business, JAR owned
and operated a large fleet of vehicles.
JAR
established
separate
fully-owned
subsidiary companies for the various parts of
its business.
JAR had managed its own in-house fleet, then
it was split into two separate subsidiary
companies.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Fleet maintenance
Fleet procurement
(JAR FM)
Restructuring of JAR FM
JAR FM had been loss-making for many years,
as its facilities were under-utilised and badly
managed.
Therefore JAR FM has been restructured in
2005.
In order to improve company-wide
profitability. JAR FM, were given profit targets
to meet over the next 5-year period from
2005 onwards.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Continuous Losses
Despite the operating profit targets the level
of operating losses continued at the same
level as previously.
Reducing Losses
By 31 March 2008, JAR FM had reduced its
operating losses to 3.0 million, the lowest
level for many years.
June 2009
The Board of JAR was under pressure to
increase group profits and to concentrate on
its core activities,
Valuation of MBO
The agreed valuation was 4.0 million for the
MBO.
This included;
1. 120 specified workshops that would be
transferred and managed by BVS.
2. Liabilities for 860 employees that would
transfer to the new MBO company.
3. Inventory of materials and spare parts.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Establishing BVS
MBO deal was finally reached.
The new MBO company was to be called BVS.
Toby Baum persuaded a private equity
investor, PIE, to take a 60% stake in the
Company.
Shareholdings
The shareholdings are as follows;
Shareholder
Toby Baum
70,000
17.5
Leo Willems
30,000
7.5
Phillip Beck
30,000
7.5
Annika Larsen
30,000
7.5
PIE
(private
provider)
equity 240,000
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
60.0
Borrowings
Toby Baum was able to negotiate and obtain a
bank loan for 1,400,000
Interest rate of 12% per year
Repayable on 31 March 2015
The bank also agreed to an overdraft facility to
help meet the peak demands in working
capital
Interest of 14% per year.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Before the
MBO
Transferred to Remaining
BVS
with JAR
Work shops
260
120
140
Employees
1500
860
640
Overall structure
Overall structure of the book value of finance
provided at 1 April 2010 was as follows:
Management
0.8 million
PIE private equity
1.2 million
Bank loan financing
1.4 million
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
2011
million
2012
million
2013
million
2014
million
2015
million
Revenue
84.0
92.2
102.6
118.1
139.8
Operating Profit
1.2
3.8
5.1
7.2
10.0
No. of Vehicles
50,700
54,900
60,300
69,600
81,000
Year of 2012
Employee numbers had grown slightly to 890
employees, due to additional work carried out
by Head Office staff.
Summery of Financials
Description
Year ended
31st March
2012
Year ended
31st March
2014
Year ended
31st March
2015
Revenue
84.9
93.9
102.6
118.1
139.8
Operating
Profit
0.5
4.4
5.1
7.2
10
0.6%
4.7%
5.0%
6.1%
7.2%
OP Percentage
140.00
118.10
120.00
102.60
100.00
93.90
84.90
80.00
60.00
40.00
20.00
-
0.50
2011
4.40
2012
7.20
5.10
2013
Operating Profit
2014
Revenue
10.00
2015
Operating Profit
OP %
No. of vehicles
Latest Forecast
million
Business Plan
million
% Increase
122.9
102.6
20%
6.6
5.1
29%
5.4%
5%
82,100
60,300
36%
In 2015
As per the business plan, it was planed to
achieve a revenue of 140 million by 31 March
2015, which is a growth of 65% from 2011.
Operational
planning
Monitor
performance
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Vision
Strategic analysis
Business strategy
Monitor
performance
Profitability analysis
Strategy reviews
Operating reviews
Customer responses
Operational
planning
Sales planning
Resource planning
Capacity limits
Planned improvements
Adapt and change
31 sty
March
2011
31 sty
31 sty
31 sty
31 sty
March 2012 March 2013 March 2014 March 2015
JAR
63%
55%
47%
39%
32%
Other
37%
45%
53%
61%
68%
Business Plan
Growth in revenues from 84 million to
almost 140 million by 31 March 2015
Challenging, but achievable
Core business
Vehicle servicing at a Fixed annual price, per
type of vehicle,
price per
vehicle
type of
vehicle
expected
mileage
Core business
Customer requirements
Vehicles are serviced on time
High standard of maintenance work
Core business
Frequency of vehicle servicing depends on,
Mileage and type of vehicle
Vehicle manufacturers recommended service
frequency
Environmental
conditions
in
different
geographical regions
Revenue streams
Fixed price
maintenance
service
Mechanical*
repairs
Replacement
tyres
Additional fleet
management
services**
Mechanical repairs*
BVS charges its customers based on labour
time as well as the cost of bought in parts,
with a small mark-up on parts
New findings
Many company fleet managers wanted to
outsource much of their fleet operational work
BVSs customers were under pressure to control
and reduce their fleet operating costs
Seeking a one-stop outsourcer
- provide key management information on each
vehicles operating efficiency other than servicing
and maintaining
- This information can be gathered using Telematic
technology
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Telematic Technology.
A piece of electronic equipment which is
installed in each vehicle which allows the
vehicles fleet management department, and
its outsourced maintenance supplier (such as
BVS), to gather a range of data on each
vehicles operation.
Telematics
Outsourced suppliers
Outsourced suppliers
Leo Willems
Selecting and appointing a range of
outsourced workshops to undertake BVSs
customers vehicle maintenance in the
geographical areas where BVS did not retain
its own managed workshop
Outsourced suppliers
Why ?
Only 120 workshops were retained by BVS
after the MBO
With BVSs expansion into two neighbouring
countries, it was necessary to appoint reliable
outsourced companies which have the vehicle
capacity and experience to meet BVSs strict
criteria for maintenance and repair work.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Outsourced suppliers
5
outsourced
suppliers
for
vehicle
maintenance
Undertake maintenance work for BVSs
customers vehicles at over 320 locations
Independent chains of garages and workshops
which have spare capacity
Presented to customers as BVSs partners
Outsourced suppliers
BVSs signage and BVSs logo on all paperwork.
BVSs customers would not necessarily be able
to distinguish between any of BVSs own
managed workshops and an outsourced
workshop.
All work undertaken by all of the outsourced
workshops is updated on BVSs FLIS.
Outsourced suppliers
Work allocated to outsourced workshops
depends on,
Geographical location
Customers selection of the workshop
The overall number of vehicles BVS is
responsible for maintaining
Workshop managers
Head Office staff
The senior management team
BVSs customers
FLIS holds;
vehicle,
customer,
each engineer and
managed workshop or outsourced workshop.
2.0 million
Incurred Final cost (net of the agreed payment received from
outsourced suppliers, for installing FLIS at all of the outsourced
workshops)
2.3 million
Accounting for the cost Administrative expenses
IT systems training
During the year ended 31 March 2011, all
employees and outsourced workshop
personnel were trained extensively in the use
of these new IT systems.
Additionally, they all receive regular annual
training in respect of FLIS system updates and
any new features it offers.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
84 Customers
Customer marketing
Over the first 2 years of trading, Phillip Beck was proactive in speaking to company fleet managers to win
new business.
He has been promoting the services that BVS offers
to its customers, its quality of service and
maintenance standards as well as the range of
management information that BVS can provide to
help each fleet manager run his or her fleet as cost
effectively and efficiently as possible.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Customer marketing
Phillip Beck considers that BVS offers a competitive
service, clearly priced with good levels of service and
quality of work.
BVSs geographical expansion to cover 2
neighbouring countries, as well as its home country,
also enabled it to attract fleet managers who were
looking for a single outsourced fleet maintenance
company across these 3 countries.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Customer marketing
Phillip Beck has worked closely with regional
and central government departments in BVSs
home country over the last year in order to try
to win the fleet maintenance work for some of
the governments fleet of vehicles, including
emergency vehicles such as police cars.
Procurement
Procurement of tyres
BVS fitted over 500,000 tyres in the year to
March 2012 for its customers.
BVS considers that the cost, as well as the
quality of these tyres, is very important.
Some customers specify which manufacturers
tyres they require to be fitted, whereas other
customers leave the choice of tyre to BVSs
expertise based on quality and value for
money.
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Procurement of tyres
BVS has a contract with a large European tyre
manufacturer which attracts a good volume
discount.
BVS Employees
BVS Employees
895
890
885
880
875
870
Employees
865
860
855
850
845
1-Jan-10
1-Apr-10
1-Jul-10
1-Oct-10
1-Jan-11
1-Apr-11
1-Jul-11
1-Oct-11
1-Jan-12
BVS Employees
Current Employees
19%
(166
employees)
Workshop based
Head Office
81% (724
employees)
BVS Employees
Toby Baum the BVS Board recognise the
important role all employees contribute
towards the companys success and the need
to deliver high quality of service to customers.
BVS Employees
Account
Manager and
Support team
Customer 1
Customer 2
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Customer 3
BVS Employees
Some of BVSs account managers provide
support to many customers, especially those
customers which have small vehicle fleets.
Established by whom?
Toby Baum established the performance related pay (PRP)
For whom?
for all employees
Since when?
from 1 April 2010
Terms of PRP
If BVS;
meets,
or exceeds,
the business plan annual operating profit, then;
a proportion of the annual profits will be paid to all
employees,
PRP history
BVS
Financial
Overview
81,000
69,600
47,500
50,700
2010
2011
54,900
2012
60,300
2013
2014
2015
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
JAR
NA
32,100
30,100
28,100
27,000
26,000
Other
NA
18,600
24,800
32,200
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
42,600
55,000
COS
GP
OP
NP
2012
2013
2014
2015
84.0
92.2
102.6
118.1
139.8
64.9
71.6
79.7
91.9
109.5
19.1
20.6
22.9
26.2
30.3
1.2
3.8
5.1
7.2
10.0
0.7
2.5
3.4
4.9
6.9
160
139.8
140
118.1
Euro millions
120
100
80
84
64.9
92.2
71.6
102.6
109.5
91.9
79.7
Revenue
COS
60
40
20
GP
19.1
20.6
22.9
2011
2012
2013
26.2
30.3
2014
2015
0
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
26.2
22.9
Euro millions
25
20
19.1
20.6
GP
OP
15
10
5
0
PAT
10
3.8
1.2
0.7
2011
2.5
2012
5.1
3.4
2013
7.2
4.9
2014
6.9
2015
2011
Budget
2011
Actual
%
Change
2012
Budget
2012
Actual
%
Change
Revenue
84.0
84.9
01.07
92.2
93.9
01.84
COS
64.9
66.2
02.00
71.6
72.8
01.68
GP
19.1
18.7 (02.09)
20.6
21.1
02.43
0.2
00.00
Dist. Cost
Ad Cost
0.2
0.2
00.00
0.2
17.7
18.0
01.69
16.6
16.5 (00.60)
OP
1.2
0.5 (58.33)
3.8
4.4
15.79
Fin Cost
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
00.00
PBT
1.0
0.3 (70.00)
3.6
4.2
16.67
Tax
0.3
0.1 (66.67)
1.1
1.3
18.18
PAT
0.7
0.2
T4 with(71.43)
Channa at Wisdom
2.5
2.9
16.00
00.00
92.2 93.9
84 84.9
80
Euro Millions
70
71.6 72.8
64.9 66.2
Revenue-Budget
60
Revenue-Actual
50
COS-Budget
COS-Actual
40
GP-Budget
30
20.6 21.1
19.1 18.7
20
10
0
2011
2012
GP-Actual
4.5
4
3.8
Euro Millions
3.5
2.9
3
2.5
2.5
PAT-Actual
1.2
1
0.5
OP-Actual
PAT-Budget
2
1.5
OP-Budget
0.7
0.5
0.2
0
2011
28100
28100
20800
32200
33200
91.0%
91.5%
516
851
122.9
COS
79.7
98.5
GP
22.9
24.4
OP
5.1
6.6
3.4
4.5
PAT
(Euro-Millions)
80000
Euro Millions
70000
60000
60300
50000
40000
30000
33200
32200
28100
28100
20800
20000
10000
0
0
Plan
Total
Forecast
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
JAR
Other
Government
Percentage increase
Managed Locations
0.50%
Outsourced Contracts
64.92%
1000
Vehicle Hours
851
800
600
Capacity at Managed
Workshops(Plan)
516
8.5
9.0
400
Capacity at Managed
Workshops(Forecast)
Utilised
200
Idle
0
Plan
Forecast
Outsourcing
91.0
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
91.5
140
122.9
25
120
102.6
Euro Millions
Euro Millions
22.9
98.5
100
79.7
80
24.4
60
20
15
10
40
6.6
22.9 24.4
20
0
5.1
4.5
3.4
0
Revenue
Original Plan
COS
GP
GP
OP
PAT
Revised Forecast
2012
Actual
Change
(,millions)
%
Change
Revenue
84.9 100.00
93.9 100.00
9.0
10.60
COS
66.2
77.97
72.8
77.53
6.6
09.97
GP
18.7
22.03
21.1
22.47
2.4
12.83
0.2
00.24
0.2
00.21
0.0
00.00
18.0
21.20
16.5
17.57
(1.5) (02.38)**
OP
0.5
00.59
4.4
04.69
3.9 780.00
Fin Cost
0.2
00.24
0.2
00.21
0.0
PBT
0.3
00.35
4.2
04.48
3.9 1300.00
Tax
0.1
00.12
1.3
01.38
1.2 1200.00
PAT
0.2
00.23
2.9
03.10
2.7 1350.00
Dist. Cost
Ad Cost
T4 with Channa
at Wisdom
**Admin costs reduced from 2011
to 2012
by 1.5 million which is 02.38%.
00.00
2011
0.2
0.1 0.2
0.2 0.2
1.3
2012
2.9
18
16.5
72.8
66.2
COS
Fin Cost
Adm Cost
Tax
Dist Cost
PAT
COS
Fin Cost
Adm Cost
Dist Cost
Tax
PAT
Efficiency Ratios
Days
22.47%
Asset turnover
4.100
04.69%
Inventory turnover
06.3
58.240
03.09%
Receivables turnover
60.1
6.078
ROCE (4.4/(5.1+1.4)
0.6769
Payables turnover
68.7
5.314
Working Capital
Liquidity Ratios
WC cycle
3.3 million
(02.3)
1.201
Quick Ratio((19.7-1.6)/16.4)
1.104
Investor Ratios
0.018
EPS (2.9/0.4)
7.25
57.25
Gearing Ratios
Gearing (D/A) (1.4/22.9)
06.11%
Debt/Equity (1.4/5.1)
27.45%
22
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Equity of BVS
Shareholders
No. of
Shares
%
Holding
0.50
@PAR
4.50
Sh:Prem
70,000
17.5
35,000
315,000
30,000
7.5
15,000
135,000
30,000
7.5
15,000
135,000
30,000
7.5
15,000
135,000
240,000
60.0
120,000
1,080,000
400,000
100.0
PIE
(Private Equity
Provider)
TOTAL
* Par Value of a share
0.50
** Share Premium
4.50
200,000 1,800,000
Investor Ratios
EPS
7.25
57.25
Equity of BVS
Shareholders
%
Holding
17.5
7.5
7.5
7.5
TOTAL
Shareholding
17.5
7.5
60
7.5
60.0
100.0
7.5
Equity of BVS
Equity 2012
Million
0.2
Share Premium
1.8
Retained Earnings
3.1
TOTAL
5.1
0.2
1.8
Equity
Issued Share Capital
Share Premium
3.1
Retained Earnings
Amount
( Million)
Loan
Gearing Ratios
1.4
0.2
( 0.168)
0.032
0.032
Gearing (D/A)
06.11%
Debt/Equity
27.45%
22
Finance costs
Loan interest
0.168
Amount
( Million)
As @ 31/03/2011
3.4
ADD Purchases
0.2
LESS Depreciation
( 0.4)
As @ 31/03/2012
3.2
Amount
( Million)
3.2
Current Assets
19.7
Inventory
Trade Receivables
1.6
17.8
17.8
0.3
Total Assets
22.9
Assets
3.2
NonCurrent
Assets
Current Assets
19.7
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Inventory
Trade
Receivables
Cash and Cash
equivalents
Amount
( Million)
Trade Payables
Tax Payables
0.5
16.4
0.5
14.6
14.6
1.3
Total Liabilities
17.8
1.4
Debt Liabilities
Non Current
Liabilities
Current Liabilities
1.3
1.4
Current Liabilities
JAR(For acquisition)
Current Liabilities
JAR(For acquisition)
Trade Payables
Tax Payables
16.4
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Amount
( Million)
Current Assets
19.7
Current Liabilities
16.4
25
20
19.7
Euro Millions
16.4
15
10
5
0
Current Assets
T4 with Channa at Wisdom
Current Liabilities
Key Personnel
Position
% of
Age
shares
Past Experience
Toby
Baum
Managing
Director
17.5
48
Fleet maintenance
operations Director
Leo
Operations
Willems Director
7.5
55
Phillip
Beck
7.5
40
Sales and
Customer
Support
Director
Position
% of
shares
Age
Past Experience
Annika
Larsen
Finance
Director
7.5
40
Jonas Kral
45
Board Representative
in many businesses
Jan Grein
NEDRepresentat
ive of PIE
(60%)
IT manager -
32
IT manager
Carmen
Kemp
HR
Manager
55
N/A
End of KYP