Professional Documents
Culture Documents
QXD
50
1/11/07
CHAPTER 2
1:24 PM
Page 50
pothesis. By contrast, Taylor appeared content to simply state, There are many bonds
of union which show that Africa and South
America were once joined. Further, whereas Taylor viewed continental drift as a
somewhat speculative idea, Wegener was
certain that the continents had drifted. According to H. W. Menard in his book, The
Ocean of Truth, Taylor was uncomfortable
having his ideas coupled with Wegeners
hypothesis. Menard quotes Taylor as writing, Wegener was a young professor of
meteorology. Some of his ideas are very different from mine and he went much further
in his speculation.
Another controversy concerning priority came with the development of the
seafloor spreading hypothesis. In 1960,
Harry Hess of Princeton University wrote a
paper that outlined his ideas on seafloor
spreading. Rather than rushing it to publication, Hess mailed copies of the manuscript to numerous colleagues, a common
practice among researchers. In the meantime, and apparently independently, Robert
Dietz of Scripps Institution of Oceanography published a similar paper in the
respected journal Nature (1961), titled
Continents and Ocean Basin Evolution by
Spreading of the Sea Floor. When Dietz
became aware of Hesss earlier, although
unpublished paper, he acknowledged priority for the idea of seafloor spreading to
Hess. It is interesting to note that the basic
ideas in Hesss paper actually appeared in
a textbook authored by Arthur Holmes in
1944. Therefore, priority for seafloor spreading may rightfully belong to Holmes. Nevertheless, Dietz and Hess both presented
new ideas that were influential to the development of the theory of plate tectonics.
Thus, historians associate the names Hess
and Dietz with the discovery of seafloor
spreading with occasional mention of contributions by Holmes.
Perhaps the most controversial issue of
scientific priority came in 1963 when Fred
Vine and D. H. Matthews published their
paper that linked the seafloor spreading
hypothesis with the newly discovered
data on magnetic reversals. However, nine
months earlier a similar paper by Canadian geophysicist, L. W. Morley was not accepted for publication. One reviewer of
Morleys paper commented, Such speculation makes interesting talk at cocktail
parties, but is not the sort of thing that
ought to be published under serious, scientific aegis. Morleys paper was eventually
published in 1964, but priority had already
been established, and the idea became
known as the Vine-Matthews hypothesis.
In 1971, N. D. Watkins wrote of Morleys
paper, The manuscript certainly had substantial historical interest, ranking as probably the most significant paper in the earth
sciences to ever be denied publication.
With the development of the theory of
plate tectonics came many other races for
priority by researchers from various competing institutions. Some of the new ideas
that unfolded from this body of work will
be presented in this and later chapters. Because priority for scientific ideas is complicated by the frequency of independent and
nearly simultaneous discoveries, it became
prudent for investigators to publish their
ideas as quickly as possible.
By 1968 the concepts of continental drift and seafloor spreading were united into a much more encompassing theory
known as plate tectonics 1tekton = to build2. Plate tectonics
can be defined as the composite of a great variety of ideas that
explain the observed motion of Earths outer shell through
M02_TARB6927_09_SE_C02.QXD
1/11/07
1:24 PM
Page 51
FIGURE 2.18 An alternate hypothesis to continental drift was an expanding Earth. According to this model Earth was once only half its
current diameter and covered by a layer of continents. As Earth expanded
the continents split into their current configurations, while new seafloor
filled in the spaces as they drifted apart.
FIGURE 2.19
asthenosphere 1asthenos = weak, sphere = a ball2. The temperature/pressure regime in the upper asthenosphere is
such that the rocks there are very near their melting temperatures. This results in a very weak zone that permits the lithosphere to be effectively detached from the layers below.
Thus, the weak rock within the upper asthenosphere allows
Earths rigid outer shell to move.
The lithosphere is broken into numerous segments,
called lithospheric or tectonic plates, that are in motion
with respect to one another and are continually changing in
shape and size. As shown in Figure 2.20, seven major lithospheric plates are recognized. They are the North American,
South American, Pacific, African, Eurasian, Australian-Indian,
and Antarctic plates. The largest is the Pacific plate, which
encompasses a significant portion of the Pacific Ocean
basin. Notice from Figure 2.20 that most of the large plates
include an entire continent plus a large area of ocean floor
(for example, the South American plate). This is a major departure from Wegeners continental drift hypothesis, which
proposed that the continents moved through the ocean
floor, not with it. Note also that none of the plates are defined entirely by the margins of a continent.
Intermediate-sized plates include the Caribbean, Nazca,
Philippine, Arabian, Cocos, Scotia, and Juan de Fuca plates. In
addition, there are over a dozen smaller plates that have
been identified but are not shown in Figure 2.20.
One of the main tenets of the plate tectonic theory is that
plates move as coherent units relative to all other plates. As
plates move, the distance between two locations on the
same plateNew York and Denver, for exampleremains
relatively constant, whereas the distance between sites on
different plates, such as New York and London, gradually
changes. (Recently it has been shown that plates can suffer
some internal deformation, particularly oceanic lithosphere.)
Eurasian
plate
North
American
plate
Eurasian
plate
Arabian
plate
African
plate
Caribbean
plate
Cocos
plate
Philippine
plate
Pacific
plate
South
American
plate
Nazca
plate
Scota plate
Antarctic plate
51
Australian-Indian
plate
Antarctic
plate
M02_TARB6927_09_SE_C02.QXD
54
1/11/07
CHAPTER 2
1:24 PM
Page 54
Plate Boundaries
Tectonic plates move as coherent units relative to all other
plates. Although the interiors of plates may experience
some deformation, all major interactions among individual
plates (and therefore most deformation) occur along their
boundaries. In fact, plate boundaries were first established by
plotting the locations of earthquakes. Moreover, plates are
bounded by three distinct types of boundaries, which are
differentiated by the type of movement they exhibit. These
boundaries are depicted at the bottom of Figure 2.20 and are
briefly described here:
1. Divergent boundaries (constructive margins)where
two plates move apart, resulting in upwelling of material from the mantle to create new seafloor (Figure
2.20A).
2. Convergent boundaries (destructive margins)where
two plates move together, resulting in oceanic lithosphere descending beneath an overriding plate, eventually to be reabsorbed into the mantle, or possibly in
the collision of two continental blocks to create a
mountain system (Figure 2.20B).
3. Transform fault boundaries (conservative margins)
where two plates grind past each other without the
production or destruction of lithosphere (Figure
2.20C).
Each plate is bounded by a combination of these three
types of plate margins. For example, the Juan de Fuca plate
has a divergent zone on the west, a convergent boundary on
the east, and numerous transform faults, which offset segments of the oceanic ridge (Figure 2.20). Although the total
surface area of Earth does not change, individual plates may
diminish or grow in area depending on any imbalance between the growth rate at divergent boundaries and the rate
at which lithosphere is destroyed at convergent boundaries.
The Antarctic and African plates are almost entirely bounded by divergent boundaries and hence are growing larger
by adding new lithosphere to their margins. By contrast, the
Pacific plate is being consumed into the mantle along its
northern and western flanks faster than it is being replaced,
and therefore is diminishing in size.
It is also important to note that plate boundaries are not
fixed but move about. For example, the westward drift of
the South American plate is causing it to override the Nazca
Divergent Boundaries
Plate Tectonics
Divergent Boundaries
Most divergent 1di = apart, vergere = to move2 boundaries are located along the crests of oceanic ridges and can
be thought of as constructive plate margins since this is where
new oceanic lithosphere is generated (Figure 2.21). Divergent boundaries are also called spreading centers, because
seafloor spreading occurs at these boundaries. Here, as the
plates move away from the ridge axis, the fractures that
form are filled with molten rock that wells up from the hot
mantle below. Gradually, this magma cools to produce new
slivers of seafloor. In a continuous manner, adjacent plates
spread apart and new oceanic lithosphere forms between
them. As we shall see later, divergent boundaries are
not confined to the ocean floor but can also form on the
continents.
M02_TARB6927_09_SE_C02.QXD
1/11/07
1:24 PM
Page 55
Convergent Boundaries
55
Continental Rifting
Divergent plate boundaries can also
develop within a continent, in which
case the landmass may split into two or
more smaller segments, as Alfred Wegener had proposed for the breakup of
Lithosphere
Pangaea. The splitting of a continent is
Magma
chamber
thought to begin with the formation of
an elongated depression called a conAsthenosphere
tinental rift. A modern example of a
continental rift is the East African Rift.
Whether this rift will develop into a
North
full-fledged spreading center and evenEurope
America
e
g
tually split the continent of Africa is a
d
Ri
matter of much speculation.
Nevertheless, the East African Rift
represents the initial stage in the breakup of a continent (see Figure 13.20,
Africa
page 366). Here tensional forces have
stretched and thinned the continental
Lith
osp
crust. As a result, molten rock ascends
here
Asth
Upwelling
eno
from the asthensophere and initiates
sph
ere
volcanic activity at the surface (Figure
2.22A). Large volcanic mountains such
as
Kilimanjaro and Mount Kenya exFIGURE 2.21 Most divergent plate boundaries are situated along the crests of oceanic ridges.
emplify the extensive volcanic activity
that accompanies continental rifting.
Research suggests that if tensional forces
5 centimeters (2 inches) per year. This is roughly the same
are maintained, the rift valley will lengthen and deepen,
rate at which human fingernails grow. Comparatively slow
eventually extending out to the margin of the plate, splitting
spreading rates of 2 centimeters per year are found along
it in two (Figure 2.22C). At this point, the rift becomes a narthe Mid-Atlantic Ridge, whereas spreading rates exceeding
row sea with an outlet to the ocean, similar to the Red Sea.
15 centimeters (6 inches) have been measured along secThe Red Sea formed when the Arabian Peninsula rifted from
tions of the East Pacific Rise. Although these rates of lithoAfrica, an event that began about 20 million years ago. Conspheric production are slow on a human time scale, they
sequently, the Red Sea provides oceanographers with a view
are nevertheless rapid enough to have generated all of
of how the Atlantic Ocean may have looked in its infancy.
Earths ocean basins within the last 200 million years. In
fact, none of the ocean floor that has been dated exceeds 180
million years in age.
Convergent Boundaries
The primary reason for the elevated position of the
oceanic ridge is that newly created oceanic crust is hot, and
Plate Tectonics
occupies more volume, which makes it less dense than
Convergent Boundaries
cooler rocks. As new lithosphere is formed along the oceanic ridge, it is slowly yet continually displaced away from
Although new lithosphere is constantly being produced at
the zone of upwelling along the ridge axis. Thus, it begins
the oceanic ridges, our planet is not growing largerits
to cool and contract, thereby increasing in density. This
total surface area remains constant. To balance the addition
thermal contraction accounts for the greater ocean depths
of newly created lithosphere, older, denser portions of
that exist away from the ridge crest. It takes about 80 miloceanic lithosphere descend into the mantle along converlion years before the cooling and contracting cease comgent 1con = together, vergere = to move2 boundaries. Bepletely. By this time, rock that was once part of the elevated
cause lithosphere is destroyed at convergent boundaries,
oceanic ridge system is located in the deep-ocean basin,
they are also called destructive plate margins (Figure 2.23A).
where it may be buried by substantial accumulations of
Convergent plate margins occur where two plates move
sediment. In addition, cooling causes the mantle rocks
toward each other and the leading edge of one is bent downbelow the oceanic crust to strengthen, thereby adding to the
ward, allowing it to slide beneath the other. The surface explates thickness. Stated another way, the thickness of
pression produced by the descending plate is a deep-ocean
oceanic lithosphere is age-dependent. The older (cooler) it
trench, such as the PeruChile trench (see Figure 13.9, page
is, the greater its thickness.
357). Trenches formed in this manner may be thousands of
Mi
dAt
lan
tic
Rift
valleys
M02_TARB6927_09_SE_C02.QXD
56
1/11/07
CHAPTER 2
1:24 PM
Page 56
Upwarping
Continental crust
A.
Continental rift
B.
Linear sea
C.
Mid-ocean ridge
Rift valley
Continental
crust
Oceanic crust
OceanicContinental
Convergence
D.
FIGURE 2.22 Continental rifting and the formation of a new ocean basin. A. Continental rifting
is thought to occur where tensional forces stretch and thin the crust. As a result, molten rock
ascends from the asthenosphere and initiates volcanic activity at the surface. B. As the crust is
pulled apart, large slabs of rock sink, generating a rift valley. C. Further spreading generates a
narrow sea. D. Eventually, an expansive ocean basin and ridge system are created.
M02_TARB6927_09_SE_C02.QXD
1/11/07
1:24 PM
Page 57
Convergent Boundaries
Continental
volcanic arc
Trench
Oceanic crust
Continental crust
Subduct
ing
oce
a
100 km
nic
l
it h
Continental
lithosphere
os
ph
e
re
Asthenosphere
Melting
200 km
A.
Volcanic island arc
Trench
Oceanic crust
Continental crust
Oceanic lithosphere
Melting
100 km
Asthenosphere
S
n
cti
du
ub
here
osp
lith
c
ni
ea
oc
200 km
B.
Collision mountains
Continental
lithosphere
Suture
Continental
lithosphere
57
OceanicOceanic Convergence
Subductin
g oc
ean
ic
lith
o
M02_TARB6927_09_SE_C02.QXD
58
1/11/07
CHAPTER 2
1:24 PM
Page 58
kilometers wide. This newly formed land consisting of an arcshaped chain of small volcanic islands is called a volcanic island arc, or simply an island arc (Figure 2.23B).
The Aleutian, Mariana, and Tonga islands are examples
of volcanic island arcs. Island arcs such as these are generally located 100 to 300 kilometers (60 to 200 miles) from a
deep-ocean trench. Located adjacent to the island arcs just
mentioned are the Aleutian trench, the Mariana trench, and
the Tonga trench (see Figure 1.17).
Most volcanic island arcs are located in the western Pacific. Only two volcanic island arcs are located in the Atlanticthe Lesser Antilles arc adjacent to the Caribbean Sea
and the Sandwich Islands in the South Atlantic. The Lesser
Antilles are a product of the subduction of the Atlantic beneath the Caribbean plate. Located within this arc is the island of Martinique, where Mount Pele erupted in 1902,
destroying the town of St. Pierre and killing an estimated
28,000 people; and the island of Montserrat, where volcanic
activity has occurred very recently.*
Relatively young island arcs are fairly simple structures
that are underlain by deformed oceanic crust that is generally
less than 20 kilometers (12 miles) thick. Examples include the
arcs of Tonga, the Aleutians, and the Lesser Antilles. By contrast, older island arcs are more complex and are underlain by
crust that ranges in thickness from 20 to 35 kilometers. Examples include the Japanese and Indonesian arcs, which are
built upon material generated by earlier episodes of subduction or sometimes on a small piece of continental crust.
ContinentalContinental Convergence
As you saw earlier, when an oceanic plate is subducted beneath continental lithosphere, an Andean-type volcanic arc
develops along the margin of the continent. However, if the
subducting plate also contains continental lithosphere, continued subduction eventually brings the two continental
blocks together (Figure 2.23C). Whereas oceanic lithosphere
is relatively dense and sinks into the asthenosphere, continental lithosphere is buoyant, which prevents it from being
subducted to any great depth. The result is a collision between the two continental fragments (Figure 2.23C).
Such a collision occurred when the subcontinent of India
rammed into Asia, producing the Himalayasthe most
spectacular mountain range on Earth (Figure 2.24). During
this collision, the continental crust buckled, fractured, and
was generally shortened and thickened. In addition to the
Himalayas, several other major mountain systems, including the Alps, Appalachians, and Urals, formed during continental collisions.
Prior to a continental collision, the landmasses involved
were separated by an ocean basin (Figure 2.24A). As the continental blocks converge, the intervening seafloor is subducted beneath one of the plates. Subduction initiates partial
melting in the overlying mantle, which in turn results in the
growth of a volcanic arc. Depending on the location of the
subduction zone, the volcanic arc could develop on either of
*More on these volcanic events is found in Chapter 5.
the converging landmasses, or if the subduction zone developed several hundred kilometers seaward from the coast, a
volcanic island arc would form. Eventually, as the intervening seafloor is consumed, these continental masses collide
(Figure 2.24B). This folds and deforms the accumulation of
sediments and sedimentary rocks along the continental margin as if they had been placed in a gigantic vise. The result is
the formation of a new mountain range composed of deformed and metamorphosed sedimentary rocks, fragments
of the volcanic arc, and often slivers of oceanic crust.
M02_TARB6927_09_SE_C02.QXD
1/11/07
1:24 PM
Page 59
59
India
Continental
shelf
deposits
Tibet
Developing
accretionary
wedge
Ocean basin
Continental
crust
Subducting oceanic
A.
litho
sph
ere
Melting
Asthenosphere
B.
Himalayas
India
today
Ganges
Plain
10 million
years ago
India
Tibetan
Plateau
38 million
years ago
Suture
55 million
years ago
71 million
years ago
Asthenosphere
C.
FIGURE 2.24 The ongoing collision of India and Asia, starting about 45 million years ago,
produced the majestic Himalayas. A. Converging plates generated a subduction zone, while partial
melting triggered by the subducting oceanic slab produced a continental volcanic arc. Sediments
scraped from the subducting plate were added to the accretionary wedge. B. Position of India in
relation to Eurasia at various times. (Modified after Peter Molnar) C. Eventually the two landmasses
collided, deforming and elevating the sediments that had been deposited along the continental
margins. In addition, slices of the Indian crust were thrust up onto the Indian plate.
crests are the inactive zones, where the fractures are preserved
as linear topographic scars. The trend of these fracture zones
roughly parallels the direction of plate motion at the time of
their formation. Thus, these structures can be used to map the
direction of plate motion in the geologic past.
In another role, transform faults provide the means by
which the oceanic crust created at ridge crests can be transported to a site of destruction: the deep-ocean trenches.
Figure 2.26 illustrates this situation. Notice that the Juan de
Fuca plate moves in a southeasterly direction, eventually
being subducted under the west coast of the United States.
The southern end of this plate is bounded by the Mendocino
M02_TARB6927_09_SE_C02.QXD
60
1/11/07
CHAPTER 2
1:24 PM
Page 60
Inactive
zone
Transform fault
(active)
Inactive
zone
*Radiometric dates of the ocean crust itself are unreliable because of the alteration of
basalt by seawater.