Professional Documents
Culture Documents
in Pathology
use of pesticides
grown dramatically
fertilizers
in agriculture
and nitrogen
MD
ingredients
(paraquat),
of humans to agrichemicals
(insecticides,
chemical
hemoglobinemia
have been
reproductive
cancers.
efforts
sures wherever
possible.
pesticides,
particularly
abnormalities
and adverse
to control
Research
classes.
or eliminate
also is needed
24:571-576.
Copyright
inwit
psticicle
ar~tl
tisc
fidd
CIOJS
boo1\
on
this
5Lthjcc.t
do not
Therefore.
HUMAN
LVithout
~mducc
also have
with pesticides
are needed
damage
to be restricted
enhanced
Immunologic
ptxditc1s.
of. fresh
dt-OJ In 30;
(0 50%.
, However, rhe Iwnefits
of
1xsticiclc
ti.46 iilitsl tw (xmsiclet-etl
in light of itic.reaGtig
cx)ticetm
rega-cling
etr~irotitiietilal
degratl;itiot~,
bx~tkc3~
safety, and public hcatth. In this article I h;tvc attempted
IO stittttii3t~i~e the c~ut~rrtit level of ktiowlcclge
t~egartlitig
lhe tiL~tirati health
cftrcts
of +yic~hetiiical
LISC, with
tiiLich
of the infi)t-tiiatioti
taken fixm cxirt-etit rc\ ieu3 mtl
;I
and results
lung
of~tSt-ic,tilttit-;tl
1m)cluctiott
w011ld
fumigants).
to various
and developmental
been reported.
appear
to exposure
;igticLtltLri~al
toxicologic
is common
ammonia),
(nitrate in groundwater).
linked
hematopoietic
fungicides,
burns (anhydrous
tiuttiber
has
approximately
EXPOSURE
TO AGRICHEMICALS
char-
In thr
on human
f~irtnet-s,
ders Cornpan!
lion
Iltiitrd
three
l~rttl
Stales
ttiillioti
fmiily
ap1m~xitiiatel)
hired
fatm
rttetnl~el-s
;Lgt-ichettiicats.
Itt
ttiatiLL~L~tLti~iti~
mtl
haw
ndditioti,
worker-s.
potenti;it
Jx33otis
f.ortnLtl;Ltioti
of
two
tiiillioti
arid
six
tnit-
contact
with
etiiJ>loved
agrichcttiicals,
itt
the
;Ls
well
x5 other
Icvel,
vvcii
tiighrr
woi-ket-s,
\VOI~ld
sotti<
with
Iicton
fal~tll
lah
pationat
espo5tit~~s.
sure for the gettci-;Ll
iti xicl
AI
of
wJx)r-trd
atttt
toxicit\.
iti
where;is
ttiigratit
f~oi~ti~ulatot-s.
and
1;Lrtii
thirtl-
)ltlb. +-
Jx~piilatioti
Jx3ticidca
are
wotkm
IVotio~c~LtJ~atio~i~~t
geticral
s\mtptcwis
Jxmxmtages
pesticide
txJx~sLtix3
~Lttiotig
rhe
~11~0L1tid the
rrsults
liotw
ftx)tn
, sit1c.e
the
LISC of.
qm~xittiatel\
!HM
of
(hlili)rtiia
1xhcicks
____--__
571
HUMAN PATHOLOGY
Contrary to widespread public belief, pesticide residues in fresh and processed foods are typically absent
or well below the legal tolerance levels. However, in
rural areas contamination
of drinking water by pesticides
and nitrates from fertilizers is a concern, since water is
a major part of the diet and significant exposures ma)
occur over a lifetime.H However. few scientific studies
of the health effects of such exposures have been done
and little is known.
ACUTE HEALTH
EFFECTS
OF AGRICHEMICALS
CHRONIC HEALTH
AGRICHEMICALS
Neurologic
EFFECTS
OF
Effects
OF AGRICHEMICAL
Effects
TABLE 3.
573
HUMAN PATHOLOGV
TABLE 4.
With Specific
study.
Recent case-control
studies in Kansas and
Nebraska have demonstrated
a significantly
increased
risk of non-Hodgkins
lymphoma (risk ratios, 1.3 to 2.2)
among farmers using the phenox)zcetic
acid herbicide
,4-D, with the risks increasing
threefold to sevenfold
among those reporting
use fin 21 or more clays per
year. The use of organophosphate
insecticides
by Nebraska farmers also resulted in a significant P.q-fold increased risk for non-Hodgkins
lymphoma. independent
of the effects of 2,4-D, with the risk being over threefold
for those using these insecticides
21 or II~OIT clays pe1
year. Recently, a case-control
study of canine nonHodgkins lymphoma revealed a positive association (risk
ratio, 1.3) with the dog owners use of 2,&D, with the
risk rising to a twofold excess with four or more year])
lawn applications. Although mutagenesis
tests and animal experiments
provide only weak support for the role
1 l-D has been shown to have
of ,A-D as a carcinogen,
_,
multiple epigenetic properties,
acting both as an inhihitor of intercellular
comIlillnication
and a stimulator of
peroxisonie
prolifel-ation.~
Leukemia and brain cancer in children have been
associated with parental employment
in agriculture
and
lymexposure to pesticides,. c as has non-Hodgkins
phoma in recent, yet unpublished,
studies. Brain cancel
in children and stomach cancer in adults also have
been linked to N-nitroso compounds,
which could result
from drinking groundwater
contaminated
by nitrate.x
Increased rates of non-Hodgkins
lymphoma also have
been found in communities
and counties where nitrate
contamination
of groundwater
is a problem. .4lthough
nitrate per se does not appear to present a cancer risk,
it acts as a precursor to nitrite which forms via bacterial
reduction in saliva. Nitrite then reacts tvith other nitrosatable dietary substrates in an acid-catalyzed
reaction
in the stomach to produce N-nitroso compounds,
which
are potent carcinogens
in experimental
animals. It is
intriguing
that several of the cancers associated with
farming (non-Hodgkins
lymphoma. multiple myeloma.
brain cancer, and stomach carcinoma)
are reportedly
increasing in several countries around the world.~*
Immunologic
Effects
Effects
OF AGRICHEMICAL
Developmental Effects
The extent to which pesticides contribute
to the
incidence
of developmentally
related problems in humans is unknown,
although approximately
50% of the
active pesticide ingredients
that have been tested are
teratogenic
in animals. 55 The final outcome of a developmental
disturbance
can be death, malformations,
growth retardation,
functional disorders, or any of these
manifestations
in combination.
However,
functional
deficit studies are currently
not required for the registration of a pesticide.
Most studies of humans exposed to pesticides have
failed to find an increase in fetal malformations.56.57
However, a study of Vietnam veterans revealed an increase of spina bifida, facial clefts, coloboma of the eye,
and neoplasms
in the first year of life in offspring.58
Studies by the Vietnamese also revealed increases in anencephaly, orofacial defects and clefts, and molar pregnancy in persons exposed to pesticides during the war,
although these latter studies are difficult to evaluate.5
Epidemiologic
studies also have linked a variety of congenital malformations
to the rural setting and pesticide
use, including
limb reduction
defects, musculoskeletal
defects, facial clefts, and cardiac and urogenital
defects.60-62 Perinatal
pesticide exposure
in humans has
been reported to cause chronic neurotoxicity,
including
cerebral palsy. Recently, an increase in abortions,
infant prematurity,
and congenital malformations
was detected in female floriculture
workers exposed to pesticides.j3 These findings suggest that extensive evaluation
and quantitation
of human exposure levels and the developmental
consequences
of such exposures
are
needed. Future epidemiologic
studies should concentrate on pregnant
women at high risk for exposure to
pesticides,
particularly
those involved in agricultural
work.
CONCLUSION
Experimental
and epidemiologic
investigations
indicate that pesticides can cause a variety of adverse acute
and chronic health effects in humans and that these
effects are not restricted to only a few chemical classes,
Therefore,
enhanced
efforts are needed to control and
eliminate human pesticide exposures whenever possible.
Additional
research is needed in all of the above-mentioned areas to better characterize
and quantitate
the
adverse health effects of agrichemicals
in humans. In
particular,
future studies should concentrate
on those
individuals at high risk for specific pesticide exposures,
such as farm workers and commercial
applicators.
REFERENCES
1. Baker SR, Wilkinson CF (eds): The Effects of Pesticides on
Human Health. Advances in Modern Environmental
Toxicology, vol
18.. Princeton,
Nl, Princeton
Scientific, 1990
2. Zilberman D, Shmitz A, Casterline G, et al: The economics of
pesticide use and regulation.
Science 253:518-522,
1991
3. Spigiel RW, Gourley DR, Holcslaw TL, et al: Organophosphate
pesticide exposure in farmers and commercial applicators. Clin Toxicol
Consult 3:45-50, 1981
575
HUMAN PATHOLOGY
3.
Hoover RN. Blair A: Pesticides and cancer. in Devita \!. Hclman S. Rosenberg S (A): (Lmc-er- Prevention.
Philadelphia.
PA, I.ippincott. 1901, pp 1-l 1
JO. Garrett NE. Stack HF. Waters MD: E\aluatilm of the genetic
activity profiles of 65 pesticides. Mutat Rea lt%:StJl-325.
I986
31. Eriksson M. Ha~l~ll 1.. Hans-Olov
A: Eq~osure to diosins
as a risk factor for soft tissue sarcoma: A Ilpllation-hased
cast control
study. .J Natl (Lmcer Inrt X2:-%-490.
19W
39. Saracci R. Kogevitus M, Bel-taui PA, et al: (:;mcer mortalit)
in workers exposed to vhlorophenoxy
hel-bicidea and chlorcyhenols.
Lmcet 338:1027-1032,
1991
53. Donna A, Crosignxti
1. Robutti F, ct al: Triwine herbicides
and ovarian epithelial neoplasms.
Stand .J L$:ork Environ Health 15:
47-53, 1989
34. Hoar SK. Blair A. Holmrs FF, et A: Agl-icultwal
herbicide
USCand risk of 1ymphonra and soft-tissue urcoma. JAMA 256: I 1-I I1147. 1986
35. Zahm SH, LV&enhurgcr
DD, Babbitt PA. ct al: A case-control
suldv of non-Hodgkins
Ivmphoma and the hel-bicide 2,-l-clichlorophenosyacetic
acid (2.4-l)) in eastern Nebr-ask;,. E:pidemioloq
I :31%
356, 1090
3ti. Hayes HM, Taro~w RE.. (:antor W. et al: C:asc-control stud!
of canine malignant I~mphoma: Iositi\e ;,sso~ iation with dog owners
use of L,~-dichloroplle~~os~~~~eti~ acid herbicides. J NatI Cancrr Inst
xs:16-1?1
_..
_I , I!)01
37. Lowrngart KA, Pctvr\ Jhl, (Lioni (:, et aI: (:hildho~~d leukemia and pal-ents ocxwpational
rmd home rspc~suws. 1 Nat1 C;IIICCI~
Inst 79::19-36. 1987
3X. Shu SO, (;a0 \T, Brintoll IA, et A: A l~ol~~~l;lti(~ri-l,asrtl~;~s~
c.olltr~cll study of childhood leukemia in Shanghai. (:arltcl-ti:ti:(5-611,
108X
39. Uuckle\ JD, Robivm 1.1.. Svotinshv
R. ct al: 0~ cup;+tional
expraures of parentsand children with acute nc~~~lyrnpl~~~c-~ti~
Iwkemia:
A t-eport from the Childl-ens (Lmcer Study (;~~oup. (:;mwr Kvs 49:
40:~0--1tK~7. 1989
40. Gold E, Gordis I,. Tonucia
j, ct xl: RiA factor\ for br.ain
tumors in children. Am J Epidemiol 109:300-3 10, I !l7!)
1 I. Wilkins JR, Sinks T: Iarent;tl occupation and intracr;miA
nroplaama 01 chiltlhcx~d: RvsuIts of a rawumtrol
intet-view studs. Am
,J Epidemiol 132:275-299,
1090
-IL. lr-eston-MarGn
5, 111 MC:, Benton B. ct al: N-llitt.oo
con,pounds nnd childhood
brain tumor\: .-\ case-control
study. <hwr
Krs
19:5940-5245.
1982
43. Irrussmann
R, I~-ic~ke~~
AR: Endogwour
nitrownine
Ii),.m;ltion and nitrate burden in rcl.ltion to gastric canwr cpidrmiolog,
in Rwd 11, Hill 513 (eda): (;astrit (Lrcinogrnesis.
Amstertlan~. The
N~~thrrlancls, Excerpta Medic a. 1Wi, pp 1-l7-1 62
-1-I. Deve~a SS, Sil\um,m
DT, ~oung Jl,, et al: (:a~I~cl~ irrcidrncc
and mortAt\
tl-end, among whitt.5 in the Inited Statr\. I !)47- 1984.
j Nat1 (:ancrr lnst 79:701-770, 1987
-15. Dais Dl.. Heel D, Fox J, CI al: Internation;tl
rreilds in c attc~~~
ulc)rt;llit~ in Fr.mcr, West (Germany, Italy. .Japan, England and Wales.
.md the LSA. l.;mcet :~Y6:474--IX I, 1!I00
Iti. Blot LL:J. Dr\csa SS. lillvller KW, et al: Rising illcidenw (11
xIenot ;winoma of the esophqus
and gastric c xdia. ,JrlM.A 265: 1287.
1289, I 90 I
576
1!lOI