You are on page 1of 60

Reinforced concrete at high temperature

Materials' behavior and structural


implications

Outline

Concrete microstructure

Thermal properties of steel and concrete as a function of the


temperature

Thermal analysis of reinforced-concrete and prestressed-concrete


sections

Mechanical properties of concrete and steel as a function of the


temperature

(Simplified calculation methods)

(Evaluation of the bearing capacity)

Concise overview on structural effects

Concluding remarks

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Concrete microstructure

fresh concrete

water/cement

0.65

0.45

0.25

hardened
concrete
pore

calcium hydroxide
Ca(OH)2

unhydrated cement
grain

hydrated cement
grain

(from Atcin e Neville, 1993)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

ettringite
(sulfoalluminated calcium)

Concrete microstructure

Transition zone in concrete


Componenti del clinker
Tricalcium silicate (alite, C3S)
Bicalcium silicate (belite, C2S)
Tricalcium alluminate (C3A)
Tetracalcium ferroalluminate (C3AF)

3CaO-SiO2
2CaO-SiO2
3CaO-Al2O3
4CaO-Al2O3-Fe2O3

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

30-70%
10-50%
7-15%
6-20%

(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)

Fresh concrete without silica fume


Mature concrete without silica fume
Fresh concrete with silica fume
Mature concrete with silica fume

(pc) Portland cement grain


(sf)
Silica fume particle
(CH) Calcium hydroxide = Ca(OH)2
(CSH) Calcium silica hydrate gel
(ett) Ettringite (calcium sulphoaluminate)
(agg) Aggregate particle

Concrete microstructure

Up to 20% of the cement paste volume is occupied by pores:

nanopores (pores in the gel) contain adsorbed water, i.e. water that
is chemically bound (d 50 nmm)

micropores contain free water (d 500 nm)

Above 100C, the free water tends to become vapour, thus


producing vapour pressure in the micropores

Above 150-200C, the adsorbed water tends to dissociate, thus


enhancing pore pressure

Above 450C, the portlandite Ca(OH)2 dissociates into calcium oxide


CaO and water H2O

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Above 700C, calcium carbonate CaCO3 dissociates into calcium


oxide CaO and carbon dioxide CO2, thus starting concrete
breakdown (calcination)

Above 500C, the cement paste is almost completely dehydrated;


aggregates (particularly siliceous aggregates) have their
crystallization water expelled, and start breaking down

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Concrete thermometer

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Thermal properties - Concrete

Good insulation properties, incombustible and stable (T 400-450C)


but sensitive to:

high temperature (T 500C)


stress state (preloading)
thermal gradients (T/t ; T/x)
spalling (explosive/gradual/local/extended)
strength increase by using optimized mixes

Mix-design optimization:
aggregate (siliceous < mixed < calcareous < light < basalt)
binder (cement, microsilica, fly ash)
water content and water/binder ratio (w/c ; w/b)
added materials (calcareous powders)
fibers (metallic, polymeric, inorganic, hybrid)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Comparison between concrete and other


building materials

R/C and P/C structural members behave well at high


temperature, because of concrete very good insulation properties:

at 20C/800C
thermal conductivity

concrete
steel
timber

1.0-2.0/0.5-0.85 W/mK
54/27 W/mK
0.12/0.18 W/mK

specific heat c

concrete
steel
timber

900/1250 J/kgK
425-650 J/kgK
1500/750 J/kgK

thermal diffusivity D

concrete
0.3-0.8/0.3-0.4 mm2/s
steel
17.0/5.5 mm2/s
timber
0.05-0.25/0.15-0.30 mm2/s

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Example of concrete highly-variable thermal


properties - (SCC)

10

NSC, HPC, HSC fc20 = 50, 80, 90 MPa


Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Example of concrete highly-variable thermal


properties LWC/HPLWC

11

NSC, LWC, HPLWC fc20 = 30, 40, 60 MPa


Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Example of concrete highly-variable thermal


properties Shotcrete

12

fc20 = 15*, 50**, 45** MPa (*,** with/without alkali)


Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Thermal properties given in EC2

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

13

Thermal analysis of R/C and P/C sections

14

Inside a concrete member, heat transfer is by pure conduction,


controlled by Fouriers equation

The reinforcement (ordinary or pre-/post-tensioned) is IGNORED,


because (a) of the low steel ratio, and (b) of steel very high diffusivity
(a reinforcing bar very quickly reaches thermal equilibrium with the
surrounding concrete) Ts,i = Tc (xi,yi,zi)
Boundary conditions are generally based on heat convection and
radiation, should a temperature-time curve be assumed, but they can
also be expressed in terms of heat flux

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Role of reinforcing steel

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

15

Temperature profiles for slabs (thickness


h = 200 mm), fire duration 30-240 minutes

16

x is the distance from


the exposed surface

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Temperature profiles (C) for a column


h x b = 300 x 300

17

R30

R60

R90

R120

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Position of the 500C isotherm in a square


column

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

18

Temperature profiles (C) in a beam


provided with a top slab

hxb=150x80- R30
Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

19

hxb=300x160- R30

Position of the 500C isotherm in a beam


provided with a top slab

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

20

Temperature profiles (C) in a circular column,


diameter = 300 mm

21

R30

R60

R90

R120

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Position of the 500C isotherm in a circular


column

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

22

Temperature profiles in concrete beams


provided with a top slab (standard fire)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

23

Structural role of the thermal properties

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

24

Mechanical properties of concrete at high


temperature (400-600C)

25

The following data are typical of ordinary concrete, whose specimens


were heated without pre-load (unstressed specimens):
Compressive strength:

fc600/fc20 = 70-30%

Tensile strength:

fct600/fct20 = 20%

Modulus of elasticity:

Ec600/Ec20 = 15%

Poissons coefficient:

c400/c20 = 200%

Fracture energy:

Gf400/Gf20 = 125-133%

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Typical test modalities

26

The heating rate (dT/dt) is usually very low (0.5-2.0C/min).


Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Mechanical decay

27

fc20 = 40 MPa (Takeuchi et al.)


Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Role of the stress state


in uniaxial compression

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

28

Comparison between hot and residual


behaviour (SCC)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

29

Mechanical decay and thermal properties

30

0.60
105

fc = 45 MPa, Basaltico, di miscela


108

0.50
increasing
heat sensitivity

116

0.40

95

94

/ fc

20

120

600

fc
0.30

0.20

106

110

109

fc = 65-70 MPa
Basaltico, Portland

91

fc = 45 MPa
Siliceo, Portland

97
92

93

Siliceous-blended

Siliceous-blast

Siliceous-portland

Calcareous-blended

Calcareous-blast

Calcareous-portland

Basalt-blended

Basalt-blast

96
98

fc = 65-70 MPa
Calcareo, Portland

increasing insulation efficacy

Basalt-portland
0.10
0.00

0.20

0.40

0.60

Dc [mm2/s] (mean values 200-600C)

Mean diffusivity (200-600C)


Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

0.80

1.00

Residual fracture energy

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

31

Mechanical decay (from EC2)


Compressive strength

Concrete temp. ()

Siliceous aggregates

kc ( )

Calcareous aggregates

kc ( )

32

20

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

100
0

1100

1200

1.00

1.00

0.95

0.85

0.75

0.60

0.45

0.30

0.15

0.08

0.04

0.01

0.00

1.00

1.00

0.97

0.91

0.85

0.74

0.60

0.43

0.27

0.15

0.06

0.02

0.00

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Typical design values for the compressive


strength

For normal weight concrete:


kc,T 1.0

T 350C

kc,T 910 T / 560 T 350C


Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

33

For lightweight concrete:


kc,T 1.0

T 500C

kc,T 1000 T / 500 T 500C

Mechanical decay (from EC2)


Tensile strength

34

fck,t ( ) kc,t ( ) fck,t

kc,t 1.0
for 20 100
kc,t 1.0 1.0 100 / 500 for 100 600

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Typical design values for the modulus of


elasticity

kE,T 1.0

35

T 150C

kE,T 700 T / 550 T 150C

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Stress-strain relationships for concrete at


elevated temperatures

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

36

Example of stress-strain curves


Alkali-free shotcrete (fc = 45-50 Mpa)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

37

Creep in concrete one day after loading at


10% of the initial strength

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

38

Mechanical properties of reinforcing steel


Hot-rolled steel
Elastic-plastic-hardening behaviour up to 350C
Elastic-hardening behaviour beyond 400C
(Almost) Elastic-plastic behaviour beyond 600C
Below 400-500C the ultimate strength is ft20 fy20

At 600C the ultimate strength is ft20

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

39

Mechanical properties of reinforcing steel


Cold-worked steel
Elastic-hardening-softening behaviour up to 200C
(Almost) Elastic-plastic behaviour beyond 200C
At 500C the ultimate strength ft500 is 1/3 ft20
At 600C the ultimate strength ft600 is 1/6 ft20

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

40

Steel High-temperature behavior

Carbon steel (R/C)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

41

High-strength steel (P/C)

High-temperature behavior
Stainless steel vs. carbon steel

42

Fire duration / Temperature (Standard Fire)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Residual behavior
Stainless steel
Tempcore/Termex and high-strength steel

43

1.2

fy /fy

20

0.8

0.6

12 Inox Cold-Drawn fy = 666 MPa


24 Inox Hot-Rolled fy = 494 MPa
24 Tempcore fy = 496 MPa
12 Tempcore fy = 519 MPa
0.5'' Strand fy = 1730 MPa

0.4

0.2

High-Bond Bars

0
0

100

200

300

400

500

Temperature (C)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

600

700

800

900

44

Coefficient ks() to be applied to the characteristic strength (fyk)


of tension and compression reinforcement (Class N)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

45

Coefficient kp() to be applied to the characteristic


strength (fpk) of prestressing steel

Steel temp. ()
Cold worked Class A
Cold worked Class B

kp ( )
kp ( )

Quenched & tempered

kp ( )

20

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

100
0

1100

1200

1.00

1.00

0.87

0.70

0.50

0.30

0.14

0.06

0.04

0.02

0.00

0.00

0.00

1.00

0.99

0.87

0.72

0.46

0.22

0.10

0.08

0.05

0.03

0.00

0.00

0.00

1.00

0.98

0.92

0.86

0.69

0.26

0.21

0.15

0.09

0.04

0.00

0.00

0.00

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

46

Mathematical model for the stress-strain relationship of


reinforcing and prestressing steel at elevated temperature

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

General overview on structural effects

47

In R/C and P/C structures :

(1) restrained thermal elongation


(2) materials mechanical decay
(3) geometry reductions (spalling)

In steel structures :

(1) steel mechanical decay


(2) increasing deformability and buckling
phenomena (because of decreasing
elastic modulus with the temperature)

In timber structures :

(1) geometry reductions because of timber


charring (charring rate 0.5-0.9
mm/min; temperature-damaged sublayer 35-40 mm)

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Main structural effects in concrete members

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

48

Some structural effects in tunnels

49

Tunnel sotto la Manica (1996)

Frejus (2005)

San Gottardo (2001)

concio prefabbricato

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

The St. Gotthard Tunnel

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

50

Stress state in tunnel linings

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

51

Buckling

52

Pentagon Building, 11.9.2001

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Local effects on geometry

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

53

Spalling

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

54

The role of concrete permeability


(Khoury, 2000)

Normal-strength concrete
(NSC)
Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

High-performance/high-strength
concrete (HPC/HSC)

Moisture content and spalling sensitivity


(Khoury, 2000)

3%

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

56

Role of polipropylene fibers

57

with fibres
(0.15-0.50%)

without fibres

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Role of polypropylene fibers


An explanation on why they reduce spalling

Concrete spalling with load- and


heat-induced stresses, and pore
pressure
Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

58

Effect of pp fibers according


to Jansson and Bostrm
(2008)

Concluding Comments - Concrete

59

Concrete is a rather heat-tolerant material ( 500C), with very good


insulation properties, to the advantage of bar protection

Cracking and buckling are favored at high temperature, because of the loss
affecting (less) the tensile strength and (more) the elastic modulus

Because of its low thermal conductivity and high stiffness, concrete is rather
sensitive to thermal self-stresses, that may contribute to cover spalling

Because of concrete composite nature, spalling is favored by both moisture


vaporization (with pressure peaks in the pores) and kinematic incompatibility
between the coarse aggregates and the cementitious mortar

Polypropylene fibers markedly reduce concrete spalling, even for rather low
fibers contents

Basalt aggregates give concrete superior resistance to high temperature and


lower thermal conductivity

Light-weight aggregates improve concrete properties at HT, because they


reduce the hollow-aggregate/mortar kinematic incompatribility

Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

Concluding comments R/C structures

60

Concrete structures are rather stable at high temperature (thanks to


their intrinsic stiffness), but they are sensitive to axial restraints, that
may improve the behavior of heated members (because of extra
compression), while worsening the behavior of the contiguous
members (because of extra shear and bending)
Generally, a properly-designed reinforcement against seismic actions
is also effective in fire, and vice-versa
Evaluating the maximum temperature reached by a fire-affected R/C
structure is badly needed (and not easily done!), should the structure
survive the fire, as often occurs in R/C constructions, contrary to what
occurs in either timber or steel constructions
The static redundancy of R/C structures improves structural
robustness (thanks to load redistribution in fire) but allows the static
effect of fire to propagate up to the members further from the
compartment in fire ( thermal elongation of the heated members)
Fire Safety of Materials and Structures Concrete

You might also like