Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kinetic
analysis of diethylbenzene-benzene
faujasite Y
L.M.
Chemical
Engineering
Tiako
Ngandjui,
Institute,
Louaain
D. Louhibi,
University,
1 voie Minckelers,
transalkylation
F.C. Thyrion
B-1348
over
Louvain-la-neutie,
Belgique
Received 13 May 1996; received in revised form 14 June 1996; accepted 2 September 1996
Abstract
The thermodynamics
and kinetics of the diethylbenzene-benzene
transalkylation
have been studied in liquid phase over faujasite
Y in a batch reactor. The reactionswere conducted at severaltemperaturesbetween423 and 513 K. The main product of the
reaction was ethylbenzene. When the molar ratio of benzene over diethylbenzene was greater than five, a selectivity in
ethylbenzene
greater
The initial
rates showed
reaction
followed
a first order
Faujasite Y; Temperature
1. Introduction
2. Experimental
fax: +32
10
134
L.M.
Tiako
Ngandjui
et al. /Chemical
Engineering
rates determination
3. Thermodynamic
equilibrium
3.1. Mathematical
expression
considerations
and Processing
36 (1997)
AC?::= -R.ln(i$,
133-141
exp( -g))
(1)
+ RT In(x$Y)
(2)
Ji
1)
RT
(6)
L.M. Tiako Ngarzajui et al. /Chemical Engineering and Processing 36 (1997) 133-141
135
BZ
EBZ
IPBZ
BBZ
DEBZ
TEBZ
lTBZ
Aromatics
Fig. 1. Influence of temperature on thermodynamic equilibrium concentrations
$ 2 EBZ
WI
with BZ, benzene; EBZ, ethylbenzene and DEBZ, diethylbenzene. They are respectively 14.85, 14.69 and
14.28 dm3 mol-
at 450, 500 and 505 K.
Although thermodynamic
calculations on such complex system are based on many assumptions, they give
a good idea of the influence of two main parameters,
the temperature and the ratio of reactants. Now, the
fact that only diethylbenzene and small amounts of
triethylbenzene are really observed indicates that the
system is not yet at equilibrium
but it is a property of
shape-selective catalysts to promote deviation from
equilibrium.
4. Kinetic results
The effect of temperature on the equilibrium compositions is presented in Fig. 1. These results are given for
a starting stoichiometric mixture of benzene and diethylbenzene at a pressure of 6 MPa. It can be seen from this
figure that the temperature has nearly no effect on the
equilibrium yields. At any temperature, the predominant
product is ethylbenzene but the amounts of other alkylbenzenes and polyalkylbenzenes other than diethylbenzene are not negligible at a stoichiometric
ratio of
reactants. When the ratio benzeneldiethylbenzene
is
increased to five, the relative amounts of by-products
becomes negligible as it can be seen in Fig. 2. So if the
goal is to produce high yields of ethylbenzene without
significant amounts of by-products, a molar ratio close
to five should be chosen on thermodynamical
grounds:
that implies an important recycling of benzene.
80
To prevent extragranular diffusion limitation, experiments were conducted with the smallest particle diameter (d, < 89 urn) at two stirring speeds, 600 and 1000
rpm, all the other conditions being identical. The initial
rates of transalkylation
of diethylbenzene
obtained
from these two experiments did not show any change.
In addition, a simple comparison of the amounts of
reactants transported to the grains by diffusion with the
initial rates of reaction for one grain revealed a higher
value for the first quantity.
In addition, experiments realized with several catalyst
particle diameters extending from 40 to 1000 urn
showed that, the catalyst particle diameter did not
affect the rate of the transalkylation
reaction as far as
the particle diameter is lower than 90 urn. For this
reason, the results reported in this work will refer to a
catalyst particle diameter smaller than 90 pm and a
stirring speed of 1000 rpm.
Experiments realized in order to check the catalyst
stability showed that the activity could be considered
constant during the time of reaction.
4.2. Evolution of products and reactants againkt time
iZ
EiZ
lPSZ
BbZ
DiBZ
TiBZ
Aromatics
Fig. 2. Influence of molar ratio of benzene over diethylbenzene on
thermodynamic equilibrium yields at 500 K
136
L.M.
1.2
Tiako
Ngandjui
T=433K
et al. /Chemical
eBeniBle
0.8
2
5 0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
Time (s)
Fig. 3. Evolution of reactants and products during transalkylation.
P = 6 MPa, A& = 3.38 g, heptane weight: 124 g
traethylbenzene is absent and the amount of triethylbenzene is very small. The presence of triethylbenzene
can be justified by the intervention of the dismutation
reaction. So, two reactions have to be considered in
order to propose a model for the conversion of diethylbenzene in the presence of benzene (Scheme 1).
4.3. Kinetic analysis of the forward and reverse
transalkylation reactions
4.3.1. Kinetic study of the forward reaction
Engineering
and Processing
of
the dismutation
of
Q,-;
OGe
*
2$-,,,
(RU
- Dismutation
CH,-CH,
FH2-CH,
$2~CH,
Scheme 1.
$H,-CH,
133-141
5. Discussion
DEB2
CC
BZ
DEBZCDEBZ
DEB2
+
bEBZGBZ)2
-E
(8)
(I+
36 (1997)
bBzGz
+ bmrsz%mz
+ bzGw42
(9)
The same reasoning hold for the reverse reaction
when starting with ethylbenzene
rOzj-9 In = Et
(10)
L.M.
Tiako
Ngandjui
et al. /Chemical
Table 1
Summary of experimental results of the forward transalkylation
Engineering
TROI
TR02
TR03
TR04
TR05
TR06
TR07
TROS
137
133-141
Volume (1)
Gz(mW)
GEBz(molll)
0.538
0.430
0.390
0.365
0.445
0.630
0.430
0.370
2.409
0.647
0.544
1.491
1.580
1.303
2.495
2.510
0.601
3.185
0.945
0.599
2.165
2.510
0.405
1.505
36 (1997)
reaction
Experiments no.
and Processing
0.173
0.155
0.242
0.174
0.330
0.475
0.149
0.150
b,,zG,z
-ix I+ bBzGz
+ ~EBZCEBZ
+ &mzCmBz (11)
bEBzC,Bz
(14
T=483K
C DEBZ
bD,Bz
C DEBZ
+
b,EBz&Bz
(13)
and under the same assumptions
as above it becomes
bDEBZ CDEBZ
rl =k;
= ,,s =
$BzC:z%Bz
+
bBzC:z
b,EBzCkmzCiz
(15)
bDEBzC&Bz
2 = k(bBZ + bDEBZ)
(16)
8
i%
5
0.12T=523K
e
k
wn
om
0.0
Initial
0.2
concentration
0.4
0.6
0.6
1.0
1.2
of diethylbenzene (molll)
138
L.&f,
Tiako
NgancZjui
et al. /Chemical
Engineering
and Processing
36 (1997)
133-141
Table 2
Summary of the kinetic parameters of the forward transalkylation reaction at various temperatures
T(K)
423
453
483
513
0.0035
0.0156
0.06
0.192
0.08
0.15
0.4
0.7
0.9
0.94
0.96
0.96
These results allowed us to calculate an activation energy amounting to 81 kJ mol- I (Fig. 6) and a difference between the adsorption heats
(2 DEsz-?.Bz) equal to -46 kJ mol-.
benzene dismutation
and the exchange of an ethyl
group between ethylbenzene and benzene molecules. As
the second reaction will not modify the respective concentrations of the two molecules, only the first reaction
will be considered. The following rate expression for the
initial rate of disappearance of ethylbenzene can be
written:
(17)
which can be rearranged as:
(18)
A graph of C&,/r& versus C,,jC,,,
at 483 K is
given in Fig. 7: this allows us to calculate a value of 2
for b,,,/bBZ and a value of 0.0062 1 s - gcat - i for R at
483 K. This value of is very similar to that determined
from the linear
relationship
between r,, and
C&,(0.0065 1 s- gcat- I).
6. Modelling
Using the kinetic results obtained above, it is now
possible to propose a kinetic model in order to predict
the evolution of products and reactants during diethyibenzene transalkylation
in the presence of benzene.
. .
In the conditions where C,,,, is low, the term b,,.
in the rate expression can be neglected. The
BZ CTEBZ
following equations can be written for a batch reactor:
1.9e-3
2.0e3
Z.le-3
UT
2.2e-3
2.3e3
2.4e3
[K-l]
L.M.
Tiako
Ngandjui
et al. /Chemical
Engineering
and Processing
36 (1997)
139
133-141
Table 3
Comparison of activation energies for transaskylation of aromatics over zeolite catalysts
Authors
Reaction
Nature
Catalyst
Activation energy(kJmol-)
Y(Si/Al= 13.8)
HYD-3(Si/Al=
12.8)
WY-3(Si/Al=
12)
Various zeolites
Y
6% Ni-Y
HZSM-5
Pentasil (Si/Al = 36)
Pentasil (Si/Al = 110)
81
107
85.8
83
87 * 10
93+13
100-121
53i5
56kl
Phase
This work
Corma et al. [ZO]
Transalkylation
Transalkylation
of DEBZ-BZ
of aromatics
Liquid
Gaseous
Toluene transalkylation
Toluene transalkylation
Gaseous
Gaseous
Toluene disproportionation
Disproportionation
of toluene
Gaseous
Gaseous
From these data it can be observed that the activation energy calculated in this work falls in the range of the ones reported in several publications
for toluene or aromatics transalkylation in the gaseous phase.
d%,z
-=
dt
7. Conclusions
&z&z
+M,
+ bmzkz
+ bDEBz&Bz
bEBz&Bz
I?
bBzCBz + bmzhz
+ bXBz%Bz
(
bDEBZ%EBZ
+
bmzcmz
bEBz%Bz
(21)
bDEBZ C2
DEBZ
&mz
-=
dt
bBzCBz + bEBz%z
+ bmz&Bz
(22)
1
CL
co Em
Diethylbenzene has been converted, with high selectivity, in liquid phase, over faujasite Y. The thermodynamic study shows that the transalkylation
is an
opposing reaction. The temperature has little effect on
the position of the equilibrium. The operating condition
that allows a high yield of ethylbenzene is a high molar
ratio of benzene over diethylbenzene. The kinetic study
under initial conditions shows that the transalkylation
reaction follows a first order mechanism. A transalkylation model considering all the aromatics present in the
liquid phase predicts the product distribution
and fits
the experimental data rather well, although some simplifying approximations
are made to describe this system of opposing reactions.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank Professor D. Decroocq
and M.P. Galtier for fruitful discussions. They are also
grateful to the Institut francais du Petrole for financial
support.
3000
6dOO
9000
12OCO
Time (s)
140
L.M.
Tiako
Nganafjui
et al. /Chemical
Engineering
and Processing
36 (1997)
133-141
xi
vi
ni
Superscripts
*
adsorbed species
initial conditions
forward reaction
inverse reaction
d
in
Fig. 9. Comparison of the experimental evolution of reaction products with the model
Appendix A. Nomenclature
bi
G
-4
r
r
T
P
BZ
EBZ
IPBZ
BBZ
DEBZ
TEBZ
TTBZ
ki
MC
t
nG
G
GP
AGZ
AG;
NI
;:
L
fP
Yi
References
K.A. Becker, H.G. Karge and W.-D. Streubel, Benzene alkylation with ethylene and propylene over H-mordenite as catalyst,
J. Catal., 28 (1973) 403-413.
VI Y, Morita, H. Matsumoto, T. Kiruma, F. Kato and M.
Takayasu, Adsorptive and catalytic properties of LaY zeolite in
the alkylation of benzene, Bull. Jpn. Pet. Inst., 15 (1) (1973)
37-44.
234.
[ill K.J. Chao and L.J. Leu, Conversion of toluene and trimetylbenzene over NaHY zeolites, Zeolites,
(1989) 193-196.
in
(1959)
26-29.
Analysis:
172- 192.
L.M. Tiako Ngandjui et al. /Chemical Engineering and Processing 36 (1997) 133-141
A. Streitweiser and L. Rief, Mechanism of transalkylation of
ethylbenzene with gallium bromide-hydrogen bromide, J. Am.
Chem. SOL, 86 (1964) 1988-1993.
[I81 D.H. Olson and W.O. Haag, Structure-selectivity relationship in
xylene isomerization and selective toluene disproportionation,
Am. Chem. Sot. Symp. Ser., 248 (1984) 275-307.
P91 L. Tiako Ngandjui and F.C. Thyrion, Kinetic study of the
oligometialion
of isobutene over H-mordenite, Chem. Eng.
Proc., 31 (1992) 1-6.
m A. Corma, F. Llopis and J.B. Monton, Influence of the structural parameters of Y Zeolite on the transalkylation of alkylaromatics, J. Catal., 140 (1993) 384-394.
P71
141