Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contex
t
Summ
ary
Example
Antisematism in Britain
February 1945
Analysis
Blunt and addresses the topic
During WW2 Hitler and
friends had just murdered 6
million Jews
There are about 400,000 known Opens with facts about Jews in
Jews in Britain
Britain
o Convey the idea that Jews
Mostly employed in the food,
are inferior as they have a
clothing and furniture trade
somewhat different culture
A few of the big monopolies
Thesis: There is no real Jewish
arepartly Jewish-owned
problem
The Jews seemto have failed
Lists antisematic remarks told
to keep up with the modern
to Orwell by your average Joe
tendency towards big
during WW2
amalgamations
o Have different opinions from
different people: a desire to
If you dislike somebody, you
avoid Jews, Jews getting
dislike him, and there is an end
extra goods as merchants
of it
under rationing, Jews getting
extra goods as customers,
The antisemanite thinks of
Jews as pushy and selfish,
himself as a reasonable being
Jews as cowardly and greedy
People always saythey started
or as lazy and intellectual.
out with no anti-Jewish prejudice
First point: dislike of a specific
but were driven into their
person who is Jewish is
present position by mere
commonly confused with
observation of the facts
dislike towards the whole
One of the marks of
Jewish race
antisematism is an ability to
War has encouraged the
believe stories that could not
growth of antisematism
possibly be true [such as
o
Anti-Semitism had been
blaming a bombing that killed
driven underground by the
over a hundred people on Jews]
war and that the authorities
People will go to remarkable
and media went out of their
lengths to demonstrate that they
way to avoid offending Jews
are not antisemitic
in order to establish their
credentials as not being
We never asked these people to
antisemites
come to this country. If they
People are unwilling to admit
chose to come here, let them
they are antisemantic
take the consequences
It's the Jewish peoples faults
that people hate them
The feeling that antisematism is
something sinful and disgraceful, People suffer from
something that a civilised person
antisematism and it is
does not suffer from, is
something that even humane
unfavourable to a scientific
and enlightened people are not
approach[people] are
immune to (referring to
frightenedof discovering not
antisematism as a disease)
only that antisematism is
Britain isnt really antisematic
Purpos
e
but it totally is
All the great writers were
antisematic suggesting its just
the inteligencias view point
Egoistic motives
Orwell presents himself as
very intelligent
Audien
ce
Background facts which are
already known to any wellinformed person
Other
Political motive
Talks about a political thing
The common man, but a very
specific common man or a really
broad definition
A well-informed person knows
the facts about it but not the
nature of it
Those in intellectual circles
have a large Jewish influence
Random members of the public
dislike Jews for the heck of it
Famous intellectuals could be
labelled as antisematic
Jewish people dont know the
scale of antisematism
Its difficult to pinpoint exactly who
this essay was for, but I think it
was for everyone
Talks a bit about the way the
essays
Language
Notes on Nationalism
Main
ideas
dislike Jews
Shows the uneducated are
much more willing to outwardly
display their dislike towards
Jews than the educated
Pro-German=pro-death wish
and it doesnt really make
sense that a Jewish person
would be pro-the-governmentthat-has-just-killed-6-millionJews
They admire Hitler from the
bottom of their hearts makes
literally no sense but because
Germany and Britain were
enemies in ww2 they jump to
that conclusion
Orwell contradicts himself
earlier in the essay saying
facts and statistics is useless
Hitler is the extremeOrwell
may be suggesting to people
that if they do not revaluate
their anti-Jewish prejudice,
they will become like Hitler
Euphemism used for antiJewish because antisematic is
just too strong a word
Everyone was antisematic.
Especially the important
people and other people just
go along with it
Antisematism camouflages
itself
o Antisematism exists very
strongly in British society but
the majority refuse to admit
it.
o People disguise it under
different words to avoid the
problem
o People will just go along with
what they've been told and
not question it
Your opinion on the Jewish
population is affected by your
educational background
Signific There are about 400,000 known
ant
Jews in Britain, and scores of
quotes thousands of Jewish refugees
who have entered the country
from 1934 onwards. The Jewish
population is almost entirely
concentrated in half a dozen big
towns and is mostly employed in
the food, clothing and furniture
trades. A few of the big
monopolies, such as the ICI, one
or two leading newspapers and
at least one big chain of
department stores are Jewishowned or partly Jewish-owned,
but it would be very far from the
truth to say that British business
life is dominated by Jews. The
Jews seem, on the contrary, to
have failed to keep up with the
modern tendency towards big
amalgamations and to have
remained fixed in those trades
which are necessarily carried out
on a small scale and by oldfashioned methods.
Jews are to be found in exactly
those trades which are bound to
incur unpopularity with the
civilian public in war-time.
And
We need asked these people to
come to this country. If they
choose to come here, let them
take the consequences
A Jewish boy at a public school
almost invariably had a bad
time. He could, of course, live
down his Jewishness if he was
exceptionally charming or
athletic, but it was an initial
disability comparable to a
stammer or a birthmark. Wealthy
Jews tended to disguise
themselves under aristocratic
English or Scottish names, and
to the average person it seemed
Structu
re/styl
e of
writing
Writers
choice
s
Euphemisms/rhetoric devices
Chosen race
Disliking Jews
Anti-Jewish
Disease
o this feeling that
antisemitism is something
sinful and disgraceful,
something that a civilized
person does not suffer
from, is unfavourable to a
scientific approach, and
indeed many people will
admit that they are
frightened of probing too
deeply into the subject
o it seems to me a safe
assumption that the
disease loosely called
nationalism is now almost
universal. Antisemitism is
only one manifestation of
nationalism, and not
everyone will have the
disease in that particular
form
o But that antisemitism will
be definitively cured,
without curing the larger
disease of nationalism, I do
Conclu
sions
not believe.
[antisemitism is caused by]
economic causes, and a legacy
from the Middle Ages
antisemitism is part of the
larger problem of nationalism,
which has not yet been seriously
examined, and that the Jew is
evidently a scapegoat, though
for what he is a scapegoat we do
not yet know
There is more antisemitism in
England than we care to admit,
and the war has accentuated it,
but it is not certain that it is on
the increaseIt does not at
present lead to open
persecution, but it has the effect
of making people callous to the
sufferings of Jews in other
countriesIt is at bottom quite
irrational and will not yield to
argument.The persecutions in
Germany have caused much
concealment of antisemitic
feeling and thus obscured the
whole pictureThe subject
needs serious investigation
[antisemitism is hard to study
because] ones own interests or
emotions are involvedWhat
vitiates nearly all that is written
about antisemitism is the
assumption in the writers mind
that he himself is immune to it
the disease loosely called
nationalism is now almost
universal. Antisemitism is only
one manifestation of
nationalism, and not everyone
will have the disease in that
particular form.
A Jew, for example, would not
be antisemitic: but then many
Zionist Jews seem to me to be
merely antisemites turned
upside-down, just as many
Indians and Negroes display the
normal colour prejudices in an
inverted form. The point is that
something, some psychological