Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1) Why was the Swatch so successful? In what way was this watch different from
others in the industry?
Before Swatch started, Nicolas Hayek said Why cant we design a striking low
cost, high quality watch and build it in Switzerland just by reading this statement
we can come to the conclusion that this was a new innovative idea, so what
separates swatch from the rest of the other watch producers? * High quality
* Build in Switzerland
* Very low cost
Why was swatch so successful? Hayek had led the way for the success of the
swatch by committing SMH to a business strategy that in many ways defied
industry wisdom about how global watch companies should be run, this strategy
was based on: * Strict commitment to vertical integration
* Decentralized marketing
* Portfolio management
Swatch watches were a not the typical Swiss watch however they managed to
maintain a high Swiss Quality image. They were the pioneers of a new-industry.
The swatch team decided that the Swatch would have a unique message, one
unlike that of any other watch brand in the market.
2) Do you agree with the original product strategy? The channel strategy? The
promotional strategy? What about the pricing strategy?
1. The product strategy: I do agree, if swatch did not exist, Swiss manufacturers
would have lost huge market share in the sale of watches because of the high
prices. Swatch with its innovative thinking not only created a new face for Swiss
watches but also kept the majority market share of watches in the nation of
Switzerland.
2. The channel strategy: Swatch promoted and sold there watches in supermarkets, food stores and small boutiques situating it in those places you dont
attract the normal person that has already come to the decision of buying a watch
you attract the person that just encounters it in their daily life and will buy it
although they never actually thought of buying a watch.
What do you think has been the contribution of the marketing function, the product design
function and the operations function to the success of Swatch?
The success of Swatch took place despite the other branded goods equal
desperation for growth and the value-conscious consumers resistance to price increases in
an era of low inflation (Noella, 2002), and are opting for high-quality private label goods
instead of brands (Devincentis and Kotcher, 1995). Thus, Swatchs innovative evolution had
essentially had broaden their consumer base.
For Swatch, the recuperation and improvement from their diminished market share
due to their high-priced watches and the availability of low-priced brands, can be attributed to
these three factors. First, the development of their product from the use of classy materials to
plastic cased watches and the subsequent cost reduction that they garnered allowed for lower
prices. Thus, enabling them to compete with other brands.
The production process having designed to be more efficient than its competitors
allowed for the manufacture of cheaper products. The development of the operation however
was due mainly to the change in the product design; both increasing the economies of scale
of Swatch making it able to increase its target market and thus, boosting its market share. As
illustrated by Carter, Melnyk and Handfield (1995) product design is one of the primary locus
of competitiveness in today's dynamic marketplace.
What Swatch did was introduced a new trend coupled by an inherent company philosophy that
welcomes change, and positions the firm to adopt, with flexibility and ease, differing goals and strategies
as conditions warrant. And, finally, Swatch had configure itself in order to swiftly develop and launch new
products, speedily manufacture these products, and deliver them to a more sophisticated, demanding,
and competitive marketplace through the use of cross-functional and concurrent engineering structures
and processes (Carter, Melnyk and Handfield, 1995). This strategy by Swatrch can be linked to the
fundamental idea behind cross-functional teams is to include marketing, engineering, manufacturing,
finance/accounting, R&D, purchasing, quality assurance, designers, suppliers, and even customer
representatives in the early, formulative stages of the design process. This approach helped to minimize
the cost of design changes and maximize results for Swatch. According to Thomas and Sadat-Hossieny
(1995), approximately 70% of Swatchs product's ultimate cost is determined during concept
formulation, when engineering designs are in their early stages and product objectives are being
determined by marketing.
Cleverly planned, the Swatch watch took on a different role, it had transformed itself to
a piece of accessory. The packaging accorded to the new look by Swatch had offset its former
image and included the younger crowd. Thus, the marketing strategy in line with its new
design had attain a marketability extended to ignore social stratification.
No matter how impressive a product may be, it must be marketed correctly to succeed. Hayek
realized that the Swatch required the public to think about watches differently. Until the 1970s
watches were considered purely functional items that one wore to tell time. There was no
fun involved with buying or wearing a watch. Harnessed correctly, this could be used to
create an advantage over the Japanese brands. Hayek, along with his newly hired advertising
agency, decided to position the Swatch as a fashion accessory. To appeal to the consumers
emotional side Hayek hired designers from all areas, not just accessories, to create an easily
recognizable image. Swatches would not be black and white like their predecessors; they
would be alive with vibrant colors and crazy designs to match moods and senses of style. The
underlying Technical Innovation and New Product Development: Swatch strategy was to
motivate customers to buy multiple Swatches.
Unlike other brands, the company marketed the trendy synthetic watches to young
consumers with the idea that as they grew older they would upgrade their watches to higherend SMH brands like Omega, Blancpain, or Longines. Customers often bought Swatches in
bulk, coordinating different watch styles with their wardrobes, something that Rolex and Casio
have not done.
Furthermore, Swatch launches every three months a new set of designs would be
rolled out; each would be composed of the five basic Swatch lines: formal, active sports,
casual leisure, fashion, and art. The revolving change in the lineup enticed people to buy
Swatches more frequently than absolutely necessary, just as changing fashions frequently
created a wardrobe half-full of unstylish clothes.
What do you think the Swatch operation would look like in terms of inputs, the transformation process
and outputs? Sketch out a diagram that models the marketing, product design and operations functions.
In the 1960's, the name of the game was to produce low-cost products by employing
methods of mass production. Companies built facilities as large as could be properly
managed to take advantage of economies of scale. In the late 1970's and early 1980's,
Japanese and European producers introduced lower cost goods, and U.S. producers
responded by emphasizing increased production efficiency and waste reduction philosophies.
Manufacturing strategies of lean production, inventory reduction, and just-in-time were copied
from the successful Japanese manufacturers, who established themselves as world-class,
low-cost (cheaper) producers (Jurkus and Willins, 2001). In essence, there were three basic
ways in which companies can compete: development, production, and distribution (Carter,
Melnyk and Handfield, 1995). This is where Swatch built its competitive advantage. Following
the model, we can see that Swatch had first evaluated the market, created an innovative
product design and devised a production operation that will minimize cost without diminishing
the quality of the product. Coupled with an effective marketing plan, Swatch became one of
the best selling watches of all time.
Situation Analysis
1.1
Introduction
Swatch
well known on the uniqueness and the varieties of their designs, as well as becoming a
brand which follows current trends and styles. Since the brand was introduced in
1983, by placing itself under the parent company Swatch Group, Swatch has been one
of the largest and well known watch manufacturers in the world. Swatch is known for
their simple and stylish designs, which attract a lot of consumer especially young
people who are passionate and concern about their appearance and style.
Swatch products are classified in different groups, which are Swatch
Originals, Swatch Irony, Swatch Skin, Swatch Beat, and Swatch Bijoux. All these
groups are the main ranges of the Swatch products, each of the group have their subfamilies which include different designs and different choice of colors.
The
Swatch Originals are the first and the main design of Swatch. The
watches are made with plastic materials and it comes with a lot of different colors,
sizes, and designs. The Swatch Originals are the most familiar group of Swatch and it
represents the main image of the brand. The Swatch Irony is the watches that are
metal cased, the watches designs are professional and can be used in formal
occasions. The Swatch Skin is the thinner version of the Swatch Originals, the Skin
family currently holding a world record of thinnest watch which measured at 3.9
millimeters. The Swatch Beat is a decimal time concepts, the watch has digital display
and the time is set to international time zone. The Swatch Bijoux however is not a
watch product line, it is the jewelry products made by Swatch and their partner,
Swarovski.
In this Situation Analysis, the focus will be on the Swatch Originals product
line. This is relevant as the Swatch Originals gives direct brand image of Swatch and
it is the most familiar Swatch product line among the audience.
Swatch is already an established brand in the market. They have been in the
industries for over 20 years and have been known from all around the world. However
in Malaysia, people may have different and negative perspective toward the brand.
Swatch is known for their simplicity and stylishness, and their watches are
known for using plastic element as the main material. For that, people tend to believe
that the price of Swatch watches are unreasonable and expensive, most people would
compare the high price of Swatch with those cheap watches in night market that look
almost the same, regardless of the high quality of Swatch watches. The other problem
is that Swatch is less known for the quality of their products, this is because they
emphasize mainly on the design of their watches. So, people would question about the
price of their product.
Bring the brand closer to the people by organizing exhibitions and contests
To balance the product image between the design and quality wise
Packaging
Pricing
Unit
Packaging
Pricing
Unit
: Bicoloured Collection
: RM165
: 1 watch, Swatch Club Registration form, warranty card, manual
Packaging
Pricing
Unit
Product
Colors
brown
: Bicoloured Collection
: pink n grey, green n violet, orange n petrol, cobalt n pink, yellow n
Product
Colors
2.5 Distribution
Swatch products are distributed directly in Malaysia. Although the products
are not manufactured locally, but the products are distributed directly through the
parent company called The Swatch Group. There are currently 10 official Swatch
outlets in Malaysia, with 5 of them alone located in Selangor, and each in Pulau
Pinang, Melaka, Sabah, Johor, and Perak. The Swatch Group Subsidiaries Office is
located in Wisma Goldhill, Kuala Lumpur.
The products are mostly available at the official outlets. However, Swatch still
uses certain retailers and wholesalers to distribute their product, but the number of
retailers and wholesalers are restricted and only up to some extent due to the
requirement of specialized services for the products. This has classified the products
to be distributed in a selective distribution.
2.6 Product Life Cycle
among consumers as their watches are 80% more cost effective and use less assembly
parts for their productions. Since then Swatch has become famous especially for the
young people, this is mainly because Swatch's main idea is to create a brand that
emphasizes on style, simplicity and trendy.
Swatch is famous for their trendy and up-to-date designs, the manufacturer
always keeps up with the latest fashion style and tries to be as creative as possible to
stand out from their competitors. Swatch can be classified as a trend setter rather than
just an ordinary watch manufacturer.
Attractive designs
Lightweight materials
Water resistant
The pins that connect the watch to the strap get loose easily
Users will not have to worry about time inconsistency of their watch
The watch can be seen in the dark easily because of the glow in the dark material
Users will not have to worry about the watch being exposed to water
Users will not have to worry about the watch getting dirty
Disadvantages
Users will have to be careful not to have the watch scratching with other things
Users will have to avoid dirt getting through the exposed battery
Users have to be careful not to lose the connecting pins between the watch and the
strap
Users may eventually stop wearing the watch because they are not comfortable with
the rubber strap
media is the easiest and the more effective way to get to the customer nowadays.
Swatch often organized and promotes their activities on facebook and twitter, for
example the Daddy's Favourite Colour Campaign, the audience are asked to simply
upload their pictures into facebook and Swatch will choose the best as the winner, the
prize were given by post to the winner. This is how well and efficient Swatch's
strategy is in using social media.
Swatch also has its own youtube channel for the viewers, they often upload the
review of their activities as well as promotional video on the channel. Locally, Swatch
has been reliant so much on the use of social media.
Age
Gender
Education
Occupation
Income Range
: All races
Geographic Location :
: 10 - 50 years old
: Male and Female
School to higher education
RM500 - RM20 000
Urban and Sub-urban
4.1.2 Psychographics
Perception
Learning
Motivation & Needs
appearance
Attitude & Personality : Consumers who have good taste in design and have
interest
toward fashion and trends.
Lifestyle
4.2.1 Primary
Managing Director
Directing and guiding the employees in order for the company to run smoothly.
Employees
4.2.2 Secondary
Bank
Helps distribute the products to the necessary locations in exchange for the wages.
Media
Helps advertise the brand and products and create awareness among the consumers.
The problem faced with the industry is the lack in technical experts, and tied
to availability of funds. These factors have deterred the small and medium size local
players from engaging in design and development activities in the industry. Unlike the
major fashion centers such as Hong Kong, Shanghai and Singapore, Malaysia has
limited number of design houses and designers.
5.1.3 Development of the Industry
Clothing & Apparel are basic consumption items for the consumers, in both
developed and developing countries. The industry, especially clothing, is laborintensive and requires relatively modest capital to start up and operate. Therefore,
developing economies such as China, India, Malaysia, Cambodia, and others, that
have pool of low wage rates labors, appeal to the companies seeking off-shore
production with cost advantage than the developed countries.
The growth of Malaysia's clothing & apparel industry accelerated in the early
1970s, when the country was on the course of export-oriented industrialization.
Malaysian exports of clothing & apparel have increased significantly over the years
driven by a few factors increased market access after the phasing out of the export
quota system.
Although the industry is presently increasing but it still considered young
compared to high fashion countries like Paris and United Kingdom. This is because of
the culture and thinking way of Malaysian, clothing & apparel are linked to luxury,
which is unnecessary. Therefore, warehouse sakes and annual mega sales helps to
solve this problem.
In order to survive in this fierce competition, the watches brand keep coming
out with latest innovative improvement in term of design and the functionality. Strong
Unit Selling Proposition is important for the company to stand out against other
competitors.
5.2.2 Changes in Marketplace
Positive
More market competition resulted in companies to produce better products for the
consumers.
Negative
Too much competition will leave behind some companies, thus may lead to
unbalanced competition in the market.
More competition could lead in profit loss and market share reduction if failed to
meet the par
Timex
Timex is an established and well known watch manufacturer in the market.
Timex is the current day successor of the Waterbury Clock Company, founded in
1854. The initial purpose of Timex was to produce watches that simply work,
especially when they produced watches for the military during the world war. As time
passes, Timex has been one of the largest and most famous watch manufacturer in the
world, their watches emphasize on design as well as quality. Timex now produces
wide range of watches, which has set them to become a trend, especially among the
young adults.
7.1
7.3
Strengths
7.2
Opportunities
Weaknesses
7.4
Threats
Age
Gender
Education
Occupation
: Students
Allowance Range
: All races
Geographic Location :
: 18 - 24 years old
: Male and Female
School and higher education
RM 500 - RM1500
Urban and Sub-urban
Psychographics
Perception
Learning
Motivation & Needs
Lifestyle
Age
Gender
Education
Occupation
: Working professionals
Income Range
: All races
Geographic Location :
: 25 - 30 years old
: Male and Female
School and higher education
RM1500 - RM4000
Urban
Psychographics
Perception
Learning
Lifestyle
observation, most people who visited are just people who were window shopping and
never intended to buy anything, the price of the products might as well be the reason
they refuse to buy Swatch products.
Photos show type of people who visited the store, there were parents with their kids
and young couples. At times, the shop would be filled with a lot of visitors.
This shows participants at the given age group are not willing to spend too much for
their watch, due to them being student and do not have their own salary.
Question 7 - Which of the following factors do you consider the most when
purchasing your
watch?
This question was made to determine the factor people consider the most when
choosing their watch. Result shows that most of them prefer the design of the watch,
followed by quality, price, brand, trend, and other. This shows that young people are
more aware and care about the look of the products they choose.
Question 8 - Have you heard of the brand Swatch?
This question was made to determine the brand awareness among the participants. As
it shows, 985 of the participants have heard of the brand and only 2% of participants
never heard of Swatch. This shows how Swatch has been an established brand in the
market.
Question 9 - If yes, where did you heard of the brand from?
This question was made to determine where did people heard of the brand. Most
people are being informed through friends & families, followed by newspapers &
magazines, internet, tv & radio, and others.
Question 10 - Have you ever own Swatch product?
This question was made to determine whether the participants ever own Swatch
product. The result shows almost equal of percentage, with 46% have owned Swatch
product, and 54% never owned Swatch product. This shows that most people are
already familiar with Swatch brand.
Question 11 - Have you ever been to any Swatch stores in Malaysia?
This question was made to determine how many participants have been to local
Swatch store. The result shows 88% of participants have visited Swatch store before
and only 12% otherwise.
Question 11 - What do you think of the price of Swatch watches?
This question was made to determine people perception toward the price of Swatch
watches. As is turned out, 48% think that the price is expensive, followed by 36%
who think it is reasonable, and 16% have no idea about the pricing. This is in fact due
to the different amount of income received by each person.
Question 12 - Have you ever come across any activities or campaigns organized by
Swatch?
This question was made to determine whether people are familiar or have encountered
any activities organized by Swatch. The result shows that only 10% of participants
had came across activities by Swatch while the rest are not.
Question 13 - What are you expecting from Swatch in the future?
This question was made to determine people's expectation from Swatch in the near
future. Most people wanted a lower price range for the products, followed by variety
of product designs, quality of products, more local stores, and more contests and
campaigns.