Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/clineyeviscare
Clinical review
Abstract
Alport syndrome, a hereditary nephritis accompanied by high-tone sensorineural deafness and distinctive ocular signs was
first noted in the literature during the early 1900s. This disease is caused by a genetic defect in Type IV collagen which makes
up basement membranes in many body systems. The patient will usually have bilateral anterior lenticonus causing varied
refractive errors. You may also note yellow-white to silver flecks within the macular and midperipheral regions of the retina.
The treatment of the visual problems is an important but secondary concern due to the seriousness of the systemic disease.
Dual sensory loss, however, creates an urgent need for appropriate vision care. Due to the high risk for developmental delay
and decreased social integration, early intervention should be considered in the treatment plan. Coping strategies for the
patient (and the family) need to be addressed because of the chronicity of this syndrome. The primary care optometrist will be
challenged by the individual with Alport syndrome since a balance between oculo-visual, developmental/psycho-educational
and systemic care is required. A multi-disciplinary approach by the healthcare management team will enhance the quality of
life and positive outcomes for these patients. 0 2000 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Hereditary nephritis; Lenticonus; Alport syndrome; Deafness; Cataracts; Flecked retinopathy; Developmental delay; Early
intervention programs
1. Introduction
Alport syndrome, a hereditary nephritis accompanied by high tone sensorineural deafness and distinctive ocular signs [1-3] was first reported in the
early 1900s. Guthrie described several cases of familial idiopathic hematuria and suggested maternal genetic transmittance 141. Alport linked the hematuria
with the auditory defects and noted that the severity
of the disease corresponded to gender [5]. The ocular
signs were initially discussed by Sohar in 1954 with
50% of the cases studied demonstrating spherophakia
[6]. Flecked retinopathy involving the macular and
midperipheral areas may be seen upon fundus examination as well. This syndrome should be included in
the differential diagnosis of any flecked retinopathy
[1,7- 151.
Alport syndrome (AS) is caused by a genetic defect
within one of the alpha chains of the Type IV collagen molecule. Type IV collagen is a major constituent
of basement membranes throughout the body. The
anomalous basement membranes of the ocular, auditory and renal systems cause the characteristic triad
of abnormalities in these patients (i.e. hereditary
nephritis, sensorineural deafness and ocular signs)
[1,16-211. Previous authors have attempted to classify
the characteristics used to diagnose Alport syndrome
and its numerous variants. However, legitimate objections to the current diagnostic parameters exist
[1,3,22-241.
0953-4431/00/$ - see front matter 0 2000 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 9 5 3 - 4 4 3 1( 0 0 ) 0 0 0 4 2 - 4
140
P.A. McCavthy, D.M. Main0 /Clinical Eye and Vuion Cave 12 (2000)139-150
2. Etiology
P A . McCavthy, D.M. Main0 /Clinical Eye and Vuion Cave 12 (2000) 139-150
membranes was not initially known. Alport 151 suggested the toxins from Streptococcus were responsible
for this renal disease. Later questions about possible
biochemical abnormalities and problems with tissue
perfusion were considered [31]. The collagenous
structure of the basement membranes became the key
to unraveling some of the uncertainty with this syndrome.
2.2. Type Wcollagen
141
Table 1
Localization of Type IV collagen alpha chains [16,17,19]
Alpha 1 and 2
Renal glomerular basement
membrane (GBM)
Skin
Nerve
Muscle
Vascular
Alpha 3 and 4
Renal GBM
Muscle
Vascular
Ocular
Alpha 5
Renal GBM
Skin
Ocularb
Alpha 6
Gastrointestinal
Pulmonary
Mesangial matrix
Vascular BM"
Tubular BM
Bowman's capsule
Epidermal BM
Endoneurium
Perineurium
Extrasynaptic muscle fibers
Blood vessels, specifically arterial
Distal tubule BM
Bowman's capsule
Synaptic muscle fiber BM
Aorta (low levels only with
alpha 1 & 2)
Lens capsule BM (low levels with
alpha 1 & 2)
Epidermal BM
Cornea epithelial BM
Descemet's membrane
Vascular BM of choroid
Eesophagus
Lung
P.A. McCavthy, D.M. Main0 /Clinical Eye and Vuion Cave 12 (2000)139-150
142
patients have an X-linked dominant inheritance pattern [3,21].This particular type of transmission causes
severe disease in the male patient and a varied presentation of the syndrome in females [2]. The broad
range of phenotypes for women is caused by random
inactivation of one X chromosome causing two populations of cells within organ systems (lyonization)
12,351.
3.2. Autosomal inheritance
Approximately 15% of all cases of AS are due to
autosomal inheritance [3,19,21]. Autosomal recessive
(AR) inheritance has been cited as a rare occurrence
with the lesion involving the long arm of chromosome
2. This would involve the genes of the alpha 3 and 4
chains of Type IV collagen [36]. Autosomal dominant
(AD) transmission of this syndrome is questionable
[22]. (This will be discussed later in the paper.) Atkin
et al. also has questions about AD inheritance in AS
due to a reduction in individuals advancing to severe
renal disease. Reduced penetrance with AD inheritance should result in an increased amount of end
stage renal disease (ESRD) in some AS patients as
they age. Autosomal dominance should be considered
if male-to-male inheritance is discovered within a
pedigree 111.
4. Diagnosis of Alport syndrome and variants
Juvenile
Adult
Inheritance
End stage
renal disease
Auditory deficit
Ocular anomalies
XD, AD
< 31 years old
XD
> 31 years old
100%
Present
Absent
50%
Table 3
Types of Alport syndrome and variants [1Ia
Characteristics
Inheritance
Adult vs. juvenile
Auditory deficit
Ocular anomalies
Subtypes
AS variant
Types
I
I1
I11
IV
VI
XD,AD
J
XD
J
XD
A
XD
A
AD
A/J
AD
J
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
-
+*
+
+
+
"XD, X - linked dominant; AD, autosomal dominant; J, juvenile; A, adult; +, present; -, absent; +*, Epstein syndrome.
143
Table 4
Clinical Course of X-linked AS [22Ia
Males
5 years old
10 years old
15 years old
20 years old
25 years old
Microscopic hematuria
High-tone sensorineural deafness
Hypertension
Renal function deterioration
Chronic renal failure
Cam'evfemales
20 years old
25 years old
MA
LTR
Microscopic hematuria
Renal function deterioration (3% of carriers)
Hypertension (1/3 of carriers)
Chronic renal failure (5510% of carriers)
ultrastructural changes within the GBM. This indicates the severity of the kidney dysfunction [2,30].
To definitively diagnose renal disease, electron microscopy of a kidney biopsy should be performed for
all suspected male and female patients followed by
immunofluorescent evaluation of the tissue [29].
Monoclonal antibody studies of the defective collagen
chains are able to positively identify 75580% of the
affected males and will provide a mosaic pattern in
carrier females 1301. A specific monoclonal antibody,
H51, to the NC1 region of the alpha 5 chain has been
developed. The strong positive feature of this particular antibody is the capability to use it on skin tissue
biopsies, especially if renal biopsies are unattainable
[16]. Future diagnostic assessment techniques will
probably make extensive use of molecular genetics
1301.
5.2. Auditory system
The auditory presentation of bilateral, symmetrical
hearing loss with AS is quite significant [2,7]. Most of
the AS individuals have hearing loss by age 10
[9,14,20,35,39].Auditory manifestations appear to parallel the severity of renal involvement and may be
coincident with the ocular signs [1,5,20]. Females with
AS are less severely affected and the deficit is usually
non-progressive [2,9]. Carrier identification is enhanced via audiology studies since the defect is not
normally manifest in carrier females [39].
The actual defect of the auditory system has been
narrowed down over the years. Anatomically, the middle ear is intact and unaffected 111. The brainstem
also has not shown any significant lesions and cranial
nerve VIII has been ruled out as an etiology [1,12]. A
vestibular component has been identified with this
defect. The patient may present with tinnitis and
vertigo before the detection of the auditory lesion
[1,21. The cochlea is also affected with a loss of
neurons within the organ [7].
The auditory lesion is detected using audiometry.
144
P.A. McCavthy, D.M. Main0 /Clinical Eye and Vuion Cave 12 (2000)139-150
Recently, audioscans 6.e. sweep frequency audiometry using a pulse tone from 250 Hz to 8 kHz at a
30-s/octave rate) have been conducted on these
patients. Detections of very small deficiencies in middle frequency areas have been noted even in carrier
females. Audioscans along with confirmatory linkage
studies may help identify these carriers 1351.
Table 5
Ocular findings in Alport syndrome
Cornea [1,7,12,39,40,43]
Posterior polymorphous dystrophya
Arcus
Anterior layer thickening
Lattice dystrophy
Recurrent epithelial corneal erosions
White limbal girdle of Vogt
Band keratopathy
Posterior polymorphous opacities
Pigment dispersion syndrome
Crystalline lens [7,9-11,23,29,33,421
Anterior lenticonusa
Posterior lenticonus
Lens coloboma
Cataracts
Anterior pole subcapsular
Anterior axial cortical
Internal lenticonus
Posterior axial
Posterior cortical
Posterior subcapsular (secondary to steroids)
Subcapsular vacuolization
Blue dot opacities
Pundus [1,7-15,44]
Flecked retinopathya
Macular
Midperipheral
Combination
decreased to absent
Foveal reflex
Epiretinal membrane
Optic disc drusen
Retinal telangiectasia
~
5.3.1. Cornea
Two prominent corneal findings frequently encountered in AS individuals are posterior polymorphous
dystrophy (PPMD) and arcus. PPMD is due to the
thickening of Descemets layer with subsequent endothelial cell changes [39]. This basement membrane
appears immature with several layers of Descemets
identified in association with the defective endothelial
cells [ 131. Obviously, compromised endothelial cells
can lead to corneal edema. Iridocorneal adhesions
and transparent membranes due to PPMD cause an
increase risk for glaucoma in these patients [41].
Arcus, although a non-specific finding, has an increased incidence associated with AS 1111. Usually,
the arcus will appear bilaterally with interpalpebral
sparing and tends to be coincident with foam cells
noted on renal biopsy [7,11].
It should be noted that certain corneal abnormalities may be observed in all renal failure patients
regardless of etiology 1451. These findings include
white limbal girdle of Vogt and band keratopathy.
Care must be taken to insure a complete differential
diagnosis of the etiology of the patients renal disease.
5.3.2. Crystalline lens
5.3.2.1. Lenticonus. Bilateral anterior lenticonus has
been noted in Alport syndrome since 1966. Lenti-
capsular thinning allows bulging of the anterior cortex. Besides the anatomical problems with the capsule, manipulation of the lens due to accommodation
and normal growth causes additional stress on an
already weakened structure. This weakness can cause
the capsule to rupture with consecutive formation of
an anterior pole subcapsular cataract [1,11,26,30,42].
Anterior lenticonus is an important indicator of
poor systemic prognosis due to renal disease [7,13,39].
It has been reported that no isolated cases of ocular
changes without renal dysfunction had been noted
1241. At this point, the conscientious optometrist will
consult with a nephrologist since visual changes may
be identified before an actual AS diagnosis is determined [13,15].
5.3.2.2. Spherophakia. Spherophakia is a sudden developmental arrest of the lens with aplastic zonules
and is due to the lack of normal zonules in these
patients. Other authors, however, have suggested that
spherophakia is another name for marked lenticonus
[6,111.
5.3.2.3. Cataracts. Although cataracts are not a specific finding for AS, certain lens opacities are significant for these patients. First, anterior subcapsular
formations can occur secondarily to lens capsule rupture. Second, posterior subcapsular cataracts may appear due to steroid use with post-renal transplant
145
Table 6
Differential diagnosis of inherited flecked retinopathies [1,46,47]"
Alport syndrome
Fundus
flavimaculatus
Stargardt syndrome
XD, AD, AR
Bilateral
macular to
Flecks
midperiphery, yellow
to white with ( - )
foveal reflex, pigment
changes, all retinal
levels
normal
EOG
AR
Bilateral, symmetric
fish-tail
Flecks
yellow-white,
posterior pole at RPE
level
AR
Bilateral, symmetric
fish-tail,
Flecks
beaten bronze,
central or peripheral
fundus
ERG
normal
EOG
ERG
mild
abnormal
normal to
FA
normal to
hyperfluorescent
hyper 2nd to
FA
atrophy
No significant VA
loss
Complications
red/green defects,
central scotomas,
retinal neovasc.,
cystoid mac. edema
No significant VA
loss
normal to
EOG
abnormal
normal to
ERG
abnormal
Retinitis punctata
albescens
Fundus
albipunctatus
white or
Flecks
yellow, scattered
Flecks
discrete
spots, no atrophy
transmission
FA
defects, occ. bull's
eye pattern
Complications
red/green defects,
central scotomas
normal with
EOG
time
ERG
reduced
photopic, normal
scotopic
questionable
FA
pattern
~
severely
ERG
abnormal
~
Complications
contracted fields
worse with time
VA worse than
20/200
aAbbveuiations:XD, X-linked dominant; EOG, electrooculogram; AD, autosomal dominant; FA, fluorescein angiography; AR, autosomal
recessive; ERG, electroretinogram; VA, visual acuity.
P.A. McCavthy, D.M. Main0 /Clinical Eye and Vuion Cave 12 (2000)139-150
146
Table 7
Differential diagnosis of drug-induced flecked retinopathies [1,48]"
Aport syndrome
Tamoxifen retinopathy
Talc retinopathy
Canthaxanthin retinopathy
macula or
Flecks
midperipheral, yellow to
white with ( - ) foveal reflex,
pigment changes, all
retinal levels
PPMD, arcus
Cornea
Flecks
tiny, white,
refractile at retinal pigment
epithelial level
small, crystal,
Flecks
within vessels
Flecks
gold-dust spots in
inner retina layers
circumventing macula
EOG
ERG
Cornea
opacities
~
white, superficial
EOG
ERG
normal
normal
Complications
mac. edema
No significant VA loss
cystoid
VA
mild to moderate
defect
~
normal
small b wave
disc
Complications
neovasc., ischemia, retinal
detachment, vitreal heme
VA
normal
~
"Abbreviations: PPMD, posterior polymorphous corneal dystrophy; EOG, electrooculogram; ERG, electroretinogram; VA, visual acuity.
Decreased vision and hearing are also high-risk factors for developmental disabilities [50]. Optometrists
need to consider additional multidisciplinary evaluation if the patient presents with signs of developmental delays 6.e. problems with general development,
motor skills, and knowledge). A careful investigation
of socialization skills in young patients should be
considered since bimodal sensory loss in AS patients
can further complicate the socialization process [27].
Children with chronic diseases suffer great psychological stress due to the disease and treatment process.
Adequate coping mechanisms are necessary to master
these added demands with strategies matching the
severity of the illness and age of onset 1281. Unfortunately, emotional regression including apathy can also
occur in young patients with chronic illnesses [51].
Families may be angry and anxious about the situation and blame the medical community for having to
deal with all the different aspects of the disease. They
may become overprotective of the ill individual as a
coping mechanism. This can prevent appropriate development of the patient both academically and socially. The stress of a chronically ill family member
147
148
P.A. McCavthy, D.M. Main0 /Clinical Eye and Vuion Cave 12 (2000)139-150
An optometrist should recommend a developmental evaluation for the patient when decreased vision
and/or hearing is suspect as an etiology for developmental delay. Formal social assessments, such as the
Meadow-Kendall Social-Emotional Assessment Inventory for Deaf and Hearing Impaired Students
should also be administered. This particular inventory
has preschool- and school-aged items to determine
social and emotional adjustment for a child with hearing loss 1271. Placement in an intervention program is
recommended if developmental or social deficiencies
are present. Federal mandates require care for children beginning at 3 years of age when high-risk factors are present. These educational and rehabilitative
programs can assist in the development of intellectual, social and language skills needed in school.
Good communication between optometrists and the
EIP staff can facilitate the incorporation of visual,
perceptual and developmental therapy into daily activities [26,50].
The health management team should work within a
holistic approach to enhance the patients quality of
life. Treatment regimens must be considered for their
effect on the patients life along with their ability to
control symptoms or disease progression. The patients
perception of the disease process can affect his selfesteem and the emotional adjustment to AS [25].
Additional factors affecting the patients coping abili-
149
150
P.A. McCavthy, D.M. Main0 /Clinical Eye and Vuion Cave 12 (2000)139-150
risk assessment of Alport syndrome [letter]. Lancet 1995;
346:1237.
Lonsdale RN, Robers PF, Vaughan R, Thiru S. Familial
oesophgeal leiomyomatosis and nephropathy. Hisopathology
1992;20:127-133.
Garcia-Torres R, Orozco L. Aport-leiomyomatosis syndrome: an update. Am J Kidney Dis 1993;22(5):641-648.
Thompson SM, Deady JP, Willshaw HE, White RHR. Ocular
signs in Alports syndrome. Eye 1987;1:146-153.
Burke JP, Clearkin LG, Talbot JF. Recurrent corneal epithelial erosions in Aports syndrome. Acta Ophthalmol (Copenh)
1991;69:555-557.
Yeo SMW, Ruben ST, Willshaw HE. Beharioural disturbance
as a manifestation of ocular disease in children [letter]. Br J
Ophthalmol 1995;79:502.
Brownell RD, Wolter JR. Anterior lenticonus in familial
hemorrhagic nephritis. Arch Ophthalmol 1964;71:481-483.
Davies PD. Pigment dispersion in a case of Aports syndrome. Br J Ophthalmol 1970;54:557-561.
Kondra L, Cangemi FE, Pitta CG. Aports syndrome and
retinal telangiectasia. Ann Ophthalmol 1983;15(6):550-551.
Mansour AM. Ocular manifestations of various systemic disorders. Curr Opin Ophthalmol 1994;5(VI):105-109.
Cavender JC, Ai E, Lee ST. Hereditary macular dystrophies.
In: Tasman W, Jaeger EA, editors. Duanes clinical ophthalmology, vol. 3, rev. ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven Publishers, 1995:l-33.
Carr RE, Heckenlively JR. Hereditary pigmentary degenerations of the retina. In: Tasman W, Jaeger EA, editors. Duanes
clinical ophthalmology, vol. 3, rev. ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven Publishers, 1995:l-28.