Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of Sustainability
by Michael Chusid, RA, FCSI, Steven H. Miller, CSI, and Julie Rapoport, PhD, PE, LEED AP
Photo Steven H. Miller
4/7/09 9:57:35 AM
ASTM C 216
Concrete Brick
ASTM C 1634
Embodied Energy
0.891.31 MJ
(8501250 Btus)
CO2 Footprint
Recycled Material
06%
Not typical
3599%
Shrinkage/Expansion
Expands 0.08%
Shrinkage 0.065%
Shrinkage 0.065%
Dimensional Consistency
warpage
230
25
114
Brick made from fly ash utilizes a high proportion of recycled content and
has very low embodied energy and carbon dioxide emission associated
with production, offering a green material choice. Colored brick is achieved
by pigmenting with colorfast mineral oxides.
Photo courtesy Calstar Cement
Alternative fuels
A few plants employ methane gas
captured from landfi lls as part of their
firing fuel. Methane is frequently
referred to as natural gas, and its
capture for beneficial use is a valuable
contribution. Presently, only a
handful of plants utilize captured gas
fuel. These plants still consume large
quantities of energy, emitting CO2 in
the process.
Petroleum coke, an inexpensive byproduct of oil refining, is also used as
a firing fuel in a few instances.
Although this product also reduces
energy resource depletion, it still
consumes energy and emits about as
much carbon dioxide as the highest
carbon-content coal.
Recycled materials
Several conventional clay brick
manufacturers claim to employ a
percentage of recycled materials. In
some cases, however, this recycled
material is actually reclaimed virgin
clay excavated from the top layers of
other mining operations, as opposed
to material previously used by
industry or consumers and then
recycled for a second use. Both
reclaimed and recycled content
address material consumption issues.
Use of recycled material can help a
project earn credit under the U.S.
Y Built-In
Pre-Formed
CORNER
BOOTS,
STAINLESS
STEEL
CORNERS &
END DAMS
are available,
for perfect
corners
every time.
NO-CLOG
ZBuilt-In
DRAINAGE MATTE TERMINATION
BARS
lets water pass,
with pre-drilled
unobstructed,
holes, allow quick,
to Weep Tabs.
one-man
installation.
Built-In
^NO-CLOG
WEEP
Built-In
\Clearly
]STAINLESS
Specified [ Built-In
TABS
EDGE DAM
deliver
moisture
to the
outside
of the
building.
STEEL
DRIP EDGE
releases
moisture
away from
building.
LAP JOINTS
enforce
complete
secure
coverage.
directs
moisture
out of
building.
4/6/09 10:22:53 AM
Using recycled material in brick can help a project earn credit under the USGBCs
LEED program. Unfortunately, these materials have little, if any, impact on the
more fundamental concerns of energy consumption and CO2 emission.
ASPECTS OF SUSTAINABILITY
Sustainability is an umbrella concept that has come to encompass
efforts to address a multitude of environmental sins. Sustainability
issues surrounding brick manufacture (and construction processes
in general) include:
raw materials consumption;
recycled content;
embodied energy; and
greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
Raw materials consumption deserves attention to preserve limited
natural resources for future generations. Use of recycled material
helps reduce raw materials consumption, and the associated
environmental impact of extraction processes (e.g. mining and
quarrying). It also relieves the burden on landfills and other disposal
sites. These are important challenges to mitigating human impact on
the natural ecosystem.
The concept of embodied energy has been used to quantify the
energy consumed during extraction, processing, and manufacture of
a building product. Lowering consumption of finite energy resources
such as fossil fuels not only mitigates resource depletion, but also
lightens the environmental burden of resource extraction.
Furthermore, embodied energy relates to greenhouse gases, as
fossil fuel energy consumption is associated with significant carbon
dioxide emissions. It is not an absolute relationship, however,
because the quantity of CO2 emitted varies by fuel type. For example,
the coal used to fire many conventional clay brick kilns emits
approximately twice the CO2 per Btu as natural gas.
Although use of captured fuels (e.g. methane gas from landfills) or
by-product fuels (e.g. petroleum coke) helps slow depletion of fossil
fuel reserves, it does not lessen CO2 emissionsarguably the most
urgent of the sustainability challenges.
CO2 emissions also result from other construction-related activities
besides energy consumption. Portland cement production has a
very large carbon footprint, emitting almost a ton of CO2 per ton of
product. Surprisingly, the energy required for this process accounts
for less than half the CO2 emitted.
When limestone (i.e. calcium carbonate [CaCO3]) is fired in cement
kilns, a chemical transformation takes placefor every molecule of
calcium oxide (CaO) produced, a molecule of CO2 is released. This
means every ton of portland cement production releases about
500 kg (1100 lb) of CO2 from the chemical reaction alone, independent
of energy consumption. Energy consumed for cement kiln-firing
emits the remaining CO2 of the ton-for-ton calculation. Therefore,
more energy-efficient kilning processes can never address even half
of the CO2 problem associated with portland cement. This limitation
presents a strong incentive to identify other cementitious materials
for brick production.
cs
Flush Window
Unlimited Color Selection
Custom Made
Conserves Energy
Easy Passage
Custom Sizes
Easy to Install
Quick Shipping
www.eliasoncorp.com
may 2009 | the construction specifier 35
Eliason_H2.indd 1
4/6/09 3:19:52 PM
FLY ASH
When coal is burned, approximately five to 10 percent of it is turned
into ash. Fly ash is a lighter ash product that would fly away if not
captured in the smokestack (which it is, for all U.S. coal-fired power
plants). The heavier ash that does not rise is called bottom ash.
Fly ash is defined in ASTM C 618, Standard Specification for Coal
Fly Ash and Raw or Calcined Natural Pozzolan for Use in Concrete,
as the finely divided residue that results from the combustion of
ground or powdered coal and that is transported by flue gases.
It is a powdery substance composed of glassy-smooth particles.
In 2007, about 72 million tons of fly ash were produced in the
United States. Less than 45 percent of it was used in beneficial
applications. During the past decade, approximately half of utilized fly
ash was mixed into concrete; other uses range from soil stabilization
to fillers for paint and plastics.* The remainder is sent to landfills or
kept in retention ponds.
Two classes of fly ash are defined by chemical composition. Class
F generally contains less than 10 percent calcium oxide (lime), and
is used as a pozzolanic additive to replace a percentage of portland
cement in concrete. Class C can contain 20 percent lime or more,
and has both cementitious and pozzolanic properties.
Fly ash is known to contain trace amounts of mercury and other
heavy metals. In the ash produced by the vast majority of American
power plants, these quantities fall far below the thresholds used
by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to define a
hazardous material. It has been used in concrete for decades,
and has been historically included in conventional fired clay brick
in portions ranging from six to 35 percent. The trace heavy metals
present in fly ash are effectively bound and immobilized when
incorporated in a construction material such as concrete or brick.
Environmental groups have endorsed the use of fly ash in construction
materials such as concrete and asphalt.**
cs
www.safti.com
888.653.3333
7/31/08 11:09:59 AM
Samples of fired clay brick (left) and concrete brick (right). Both are associated with high levels of carbon dioxide emission.
Photo Steven H. Miller. Photo courtesy Calstar Cement.
Brick masonry has been a part of the built environment for at least seven
millennia, making it one of the oldest construction technologies still
in common use. Its longevity stems from performance properties, the
availability of clay, and the simplicity of brick production.
Photo BigStockPhoto.com
4/1/09 2:51:45 PM
Field testing demonstrates fly ash brick is easy to build with. The photo on the right shows the material has good mortar adhesion.
Photos courtesy Calstar Cement
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Authors
Michael Chusid, RA, FCSI, is president of Chusid
Associates, a consulting firm specializing in technical and
marketing services for advanced construction products and
materials. A member of the Los Angeles Chapter of the
U.S. Green Building Council (USGBC), Steven H. Miller, CSI,
is an award-winning freelance journalist and photographer
specializing in issues of the construction industry. He is
also a consultant to Chusid Associates. Chusid and Miller
can be contacted via www.chusid.com. Julie Rapoport,
PhD, PE, LEED AP, is director of product development
at Calstar. She received her PhD in civil engineering
specializing in cementitious materials from Northwestern
University. Rapoport is a licensed professional engineer in
California and a LEED-Accredited Professional. She has
investigated cementitious materials in both research and
industry for more than a decade. Rapoport is a member of
American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) and American
Concrete Institute (ACI), and sits on the latters Technical
Committee on Sustainability. She can be reached at
jrapoport@calstarcement.com.
Abstract
Brick production has three major issues determining its environmental
impactmaterial usage, energy consumption, and associated
CO2 emissions. Recent advances address these concerns with the
development of fly ash brick, a composite of non-clay materials. This
article explores the technology, delving into possible applications.
Masterformat No.
04 20 00Unit Masonry
32 14 16Brick Unit Paving
Uniformat No.
B2010Exterior Wall Exterior Skin
B2010Exterior Wall Construction
G2010Roadway Unit Pavers
G2030Pedestrian Unit Pavers
Key Words
Divisions 04, 32
Carbon footprint
Concrete brick
Fired brick
Fly ash brick
Sustainability
The word ceramic is said to derive from the IndoEuropean word ker, which means heat. High heat is
a fundamental element of ceramic manufacture.
3
See the EPA press release, EPA Proposes First
National Reporting on Greenhouse Gas Emissions,
March 10, 2009.
4
The EPA estimates 124 million Btus per year are
consumed by the average single-family home.
5
Points can be earned under LEEDs Materials and
Resources (MR) Credit 4, Recycled Content. It is
expected a revision of the program, LEED 2009, will
be released shortly. Under the current draft of the
revision, this credit remains unmodified. However,
it is still subject to change, and should be checked
against the final published version when available.
USGBC states all new project registrations will be
required to use LEED 2009 as of August this year.
6
Projects employing regional materials can earn
points under LEEDs MR Credit 5, Regional
Materials. These credits are the same in the current
draft of LEED 2009, but still subject to revision.
See note 5.
Reliability
Over 60 years of manufacturing
custom aluminum ladders for
the building and design community.
O'Keeffe's
Reputation
Most frequently specified ladder manufacturer.
Security
Certified to meet OSHA/ANSI 3124 standards.
Convenience
Custom options and fast lead times (7 days from receipt of order).
Quality
Lightweight, non-spark, maintenance-free, high-strength 6063-T aluminum
construction with 1-1/4 deeply serrated square rungs for maximum grip and foot
traction.
Variety
Three basic types of aluminum ladders: fixed access ladders, ship ladders, and cage
ladders.
Safety
1600 lbs. capacity.
888.653.3333
www.okeeffes.com
12/4/08 3:17:27 PM