Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://homeoint.org/books3/kentmm/ars.htm
4/6/2015
The complaints of the head must conform to the generals that apply
to the head, and the complaints of the body must be associated
with the generals that apply to the body. It is a difficult thing to say
which one of these two circumstances is most general, and it is
sometimes difficult to say which one is the general of the patient
himself, because he confuses you by saying:
"I am worse in the cold," but when his headache is on he says:
"I am better in the cold, I want to be in the cold."
It is really only the head, and you have to single these out and study
them by the parts affected. When things are so striking you must
examine into it to see what it is that brings about modality.
You will see a similar state running through Phosphorus; the
complaints of the stomach and head are better from cold, i. e., he
wants cold applications upon the head with head sufferings, and
wants cold things in the stomach with stomach complaints, but in
all the complaints of the body be is ameliorated from heat.
If he steps out into the cool air, he will commence to cough, if he
have a chest trouble. So we see that the modalities that belong to
the part affected must always be taken into account. For instance,
you have a patient suffering from neuralgia or rheumatic affections
and these same pains, extend, to the head, then he wants the head
wrapped up because they are ameliorated from heat.
But when it comes to cases of congestive conditions of the head,
he then is better with his head very cold. Now, as I have said, there
is an alternation of these states in Arsenicum.
I will illustrate by mentioning a case.
Once a patient had been dragging along with periodical sick
headaches. The sick headaches were better from cold water, cold
applications to the head, could hardly get them cold enough, and
the colder the better. These headaches came every two weeks, and
so long as they were present he desired cold to the head.
Then these periodical headaches would be better, for long periods;
but when they were away he was suffering from rheumatism of the
joints, which was also periodical, and also more or less tenacious,
and when this rheumatism of the joints and extremities, with more
or less swelling and oedema, was present he could not get warm
enough; he was at the fire and wrapped up; he was relieved by heat,
and wanted warm air and a warm room.
This would last for a period and then subside, and back would come
his sick headaches and last for a while. That is what I meant by the
alternation of states. Arsenicum cured that man, and he never had
any of them afterwards.
The alternation of states sometimes means that there are two
diseases in the body, and sometimes the remedy covers the whole
feature in alternation of states.
I remember another case, which will illustrate this peculiar nature of
alternation of complaints, which is shared by other remedies
besides Arsenic.
A patient suffered from a pressure in the top of the head, such as I
recently described to you under Alumen.
She would suffer for weeks from that pressure on the top of the
head, and the only relief she could get was from hard pressure; she
tired herself out with hard pressure and would contrive all kinds of
weights to put upon the head.
That would go away in the night and she would wake up the next
morning with constant urging to urinate. The irritable bladder
alternated with pain on top of the head.
Alumen cured. In many of these anti-psoric remedies we have an
alternation of states.
This illustrates the necessity for getting the symptoms of all the
states that present themselves for cure, otherwise you will many
times prescribe in a chronic case of psoric character and
temporarily relieve it, when back comes another aspect of it.
You have only hastened the disease a little faster than it would go if
let alone. But that is not homoeopathic prescribing. Be sure, when a
remedy presents one state, that it is a clearly indicated in the other
state, otherwise that remedy is not the similimum.
You must hunt until you find the remedy that has both states, or
you will be disappointed. We sometimes do not discover this
alternation of states until we have brought it back two or three times
by incorrect prescribing.
Some people are so reticent and so difficult to get symptoms from
that we do not always get these symptoms.
But you examine your record and you find where - you have made a
foolish prescription, that you drove a new condition away and back
came the first trouble, and you kept on with this see-saw business.
Now remember in doing this your patient is not improving, and that
you must re-study the whole case, taking the alternating states into,
account. In Arsenic, the head symptoms alternate with physical
symptoms.
You will find running through certain remedies, as a part of their
nature, that mental symptoms alternate with physical symptoms;
when the physical symptoms are present, then mental symptoms
are not trates the necessity for getting the symptoms of all the
states that is determined it is a good point, but sometimes you do
not find a remedy, because many of our remedies are not well
recorded; they have not yet been observed in their alternations and
marked as such.
We find in Podophyllum the peculiar feature that the headaches
alternate with diarrhea; he is subject to sick headaches and to
diarrhea, and one or other will be present.
In Arnica the mental symptoms alternate with uterine symptoms.
The uterine symptoms, when ob served, look like Arnica, but these
go away in the night and mental symptoms come on, the mind
being heavy, gloomy and cloudy.
When you have remedies that have these manifestations it requires
a greater depth of vision to see the alternation of states, because
these things are not always brought out in the proving, for the
reason that one prover had one group of symptoms, and another.
grows better towards the end of the heat as the sweat breaks out, it
is ameliorated by the sweat.
In chronic headaches, congestive
complaints, a tendency to shrivel is
prematurely old, wrinkled appearance
mucous membrane of the lips and
becomes wrinkled.
Eyes: The eye symptoms of this remedy are very prominent. In old
cases of suppressed malaria, in broken down constitutions, in
pallid, sickly people who are subject to general catarrhal conditions,
and such catarrhal conditions as localize more especially in the
nose and eyes, the eye symptoms will be troublesome.
or
the
the
the
Now let some of these discharges slack up and you have a chronic
state apparently from retained secretions, but it is a form of blood
poisoning. So it is with suppressed ear discharges, suppressed
throat discharges, suppressed leucorrhea and ulcerations.
Arsenicum is one of the medicines that will conform to the anaemic
state that follows each suppression. At the present day it is
fashionable to use the cautery, to make local applications to stop
leucorrhoea and other discharges and to heal up ulcers.
Now, when these external troubles go there is an anaemic state
established in the economy, the patient becomes waxy and pallid,
sickly looking, and these catarrhal discharges come on as a means
of relief because of the suppression of some other condition.
For instance, since the suppression of a leucorrhoea the woman
has had thick, bloody or watery discharge from the nose. It is
frequently suitable to the constitution when an ulcer has been dried
up by salves, or an old car discharge has been stopped by the
outward application of powders. The doctor thinks he has done a
clever thing in stopping such discharges, but he has
only
succeeded in damming up the secretions which are really a relief to
the patient.
Such medicines as Sulphur, Calcarea and Arsenicum are suitable
for the catarrhal discharges that come from these suppressions, in
broken down constitutions.
Arsenic is also like unto the condition that has been brought about
from the absorption of animal poisons. It goes to the very root of
the evil, as it is similar to the symptoms brought on from a
dissecting wound. Arsenic and Lachesis are medicines that will go
to the cause at once and antidote the poison, establishing harmony
and turning things into order.
The nose symptoms, then, of Arsenic are very troublesome and
furnish and extensive part of the symptom image of an Arsenicum
patient. They always take cold easily, are always sensitive to cold
and the catarrh is always roused up on the slightest provocation.
When an Arsenicum patient is at his best he has discharge more or
less of a thick character, but when he takes a little cold it becomes
thin; the thick discharge that is necessary to his comfort slacks up,
and then he gets headache and on comes thirst, restlessness,
anxiety and distress.
This goes on to a catarrhal fever of two or three days duration, and
then the thick discharge starts up again and he feels better; all his
pains and aches disappear. It has been of great service in
epithelioma of nose and lips.
Inflammation of the throat and tonsils with burning, increased by
cold and better by warm drinks. There is redness and a shriveled
condition of the mucous membrane.
When there is blood poisoning going on, as in diphtheria, and
exudate appears upon the mucous membrane and it becomes gray
and shriveled, ashy colored, and this sometimes covers the whole
Many of his complaints are increased with the sweat; for instance,
thirst is increased, the drinking is copious and does not relieve, it
seems he cannot get enough and patients will say:
"I can drink the well dry," or
"Give me a bucket of water."
Such things are indicative of the state of thirst. During the fever he
wants little and often; during the chill he wants hot drinks.
Arsenicum is a very useful medicine in the eruptions of the genitals
with burning.
In little ulcers that burn, even when they are syphilitic; herpetic
vesicles that appear upon the foreskin and upon the labia; chancre
or cancroids with burning, smarting and stinging, but especially in
those that are weak, that offer no willingness to heal, but that do the
very opposite, that spread, those that we call phagedenic, those
that eat from their outer margins, become larger and larger.
Genitals: In the male and female sexual organs there are many
symptoms of importance. In the male organs a dropsical condition,
dropsy of the penis, oedematous appearance, so that the penis is
enormously swollen and looks like a water bag; the scrotum,
especially the skin of the scrotum, greatly swollen and humid round
about, the parts.
In the female the labia are enormously swollen with burning,
stinging pains, hard and swollen. Erysipelatous inflammation of
these organs, ulcerations, of a syphilitic character; these when
such symptoms burning, smarting and stinging are present.
In the female, violent, burning pains in the genitals with or without
swelling, burning that extends up into the vagina, with great
dryness and itching of the vagina.
The leucorrhoeal discharge excoriates the parts, causing itching
and burning with great suffering. Whitish, watery, thin discharges
that excoriate; so copious sometimes that it will run down the
thighs.
The Arsenicum menstrual flow is very often excoriating in
character. Copious leucorrhoeal flow intermixed with menstrual
flow, very profuse and very acrid.
Larynx and chest: Arsenic has loss of voice, laryngitis, with dry
teasing cough; a cough that does not seem to do any good; hacking
constantly, dry, hacking cough.
Study its relation to asthma and difficult breathing, dyspnoea.
Arsenic has cured some long standing cases of asthma of a
nervous character; asthma that comes on after midnight, in patients
who suffer from the cold, those who are very pallid, dry wheezing
cough, must sit up in bed and hold the chest, anxious restlessness
with prostration.
The heart symptoms are troublesome to manage when they get to
be like Arsenic; the symptoms correspond to a state of great
weakness, great palpitation, palpitation from the least exertion or
excitement, great anxiety, anguish, weakness; he cannot walk, he
cannot go upstairs, he can hardly move without increasing the
palpitation; every excitement brings on palpitation.
"Severe paroxysms of palpitation or attacks of syncope during
endocarditis."
Arsenicum corresponds to most serious complaints of the heart,
corresponds to many of the incurable complaints of the heart; i. e.,
when you see Arsenic corresponding in all of the symptoms with
these marked cardiac affections, dropsy of the pericardium, etc.,
you have a class of cases that are very serious,