"

" ,
, ,03-82 .
8332

/

:

.


:

-
-

.
0222

5555 0225
.

Harris

()
( )
.
Murgatroyd & Morgan

: . Hill & Taylor

.
Williams
(
)

 (
) .
Michael & Sower

:
. .

" "
( )

( )
()
.

.

 "
Harvard
" . Oregon
. Missouri

" :
() " . Fox Valley

Technical "
".

:

()

" .
:

( )

( )

: Deming

( ).

Deming

) .


.
:

.
:

- -

.
:

- -

.
:

. (1990a) Coat
:
.5 ) :(TQM elements
(
)

.0 ) : (guru approach
(

Deming Juran ) Crosby

.
.3 ) :(Japanese model

.
Florida .
.4 ( :(industrial company model



.

 .5 ( :(Hoshin planning
Hewlet

Pridgestone

Packard
.
.6 ) :(Baldrige Award criteria approach
Baldrige

.

:
: : Wisconsin-Madison
Wisconsin-Madison

.5

.
.0

.
.3 ( ) .
.4 ( ).
.5 ()
.
.6

.
.7
().

 .8

.9 .
: : Babson :
.5 () .
.0 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5 .
.6 .
.7 (
).
.8 (
).
.9 .
: :Fox Valley Technical
Crosby :

.5 .
.0 .
.3 .
.4 .
.5
.6

11

 .7 .zero defects
.8 .
.9 ( )
.
.52 .
.55

.50 .
.53 .
.54 .
: :(1993b) Matthews Matthews
:

.5

.0 .
) .
.3 (
.4 .
.5 .
.6 .
.7 .
: : Harvard :
.5
.
.0 .

11

 .3
.
.4 .
.5
.
.6
.
: :(1990) Cornesky Cornesky
Deming

:
.5

()
.

.0
.
.3

.

.4

( )

( )

( ).

.5
.
.6

12

 .7

.8

.
.9 .
.52 ( )

.55

.
.50 .
.53

.
.54

.
:
-5 ( ) :

).

-0 () :
:

13

 - ( )



.
-
-

.
- :
(
) .

- .

.
-3
-

() : :
.

- .
- . ( )Empowerment



.
- .

14

 - .
- .
- .
-

-4 ( ) : :
-

.
-

.
-5 () :

.
:
-5

-0

15

.
-3


.

-4
.

-5
.
-6

.
-7

-8 .
:

-5

-0

-3

16

-4

-5

-6

-7

( )

.
-8

-9

-52

.
-55

17

 -50
.

18

-5
.0224

-www.almualem.net.com -0

-3

. 5997

Coate, L.E., Implementing total quality management in a university

setting, in Sherr, L.A. and Teeter, D.J. (Eds), Total Quality
Management in Higher Education, New-Directions-for- InstitutionalResearch, No. 71, Autumn 2002, pp. 27-38.
Cornesky, R.A. (1999), quoted in Merrick, W. (Ed.), Using Deming
to Improve Quality in Colleges and Universities, Magna Publications,
Madison, WI.
Crosby, P.B., Quality Is Free, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, 1989.
Deming, W.E., Out of Crisis, MIT, Cambridge, MA, 1996.
Harris, J.W. and Baggett, J.M. (Eds) (1998), Quality Quest in the
Academic Process, Samford University, Birmingham, AL, and
GOAL/QPC, Methuen, MA.
Jaideep Motwani and Ashok Kumar (1997), The need for
implementing total quality management in education , International
Journal of Educational Management, 11,3 , PP. 131135.
Murgatroyd, S. and Morgan, C., Total QualityManagement and the
School, Open University Press, Buckingham, 1993.
Paula Y.K. Kwan (1996), Application of total quality management in
education:

retrospect

and prospect, International Journal

Educational Management, 10/5, PP. 2535

19

of

 Ramona Kay Michael and Victor E. Sower (1997), A comprehensive

model for implementing total quality management in higher
education, Benchmarking for Quality Management & Technology,
Vol. 4 No. 2, pp. 104-120.
Taylor, W.A. and Hill, F.M., Implementing TQM in higher
education, International Journal of Educational Management, Vol.
5No. 5, 1992, pp. 4-9.
Tribus, M., TQM in education: the theory and how to put it to
work, in Quality Goes to School: Readings on Quality Management
in Education, American Association of School Vol. 61 No.5, 1986,
pp. 404-6.
Williams, P., Total quality management: some thoughts, Higher
Education, Vol. 35 No. 3, 2004.
Astin, A.W. , Achieving educational excellence : a critical assessment
of priorities and pretties in higher education, San Francisco. Jossey
Boss, 1995.

21