You are on page 1of 24

16

Sizing & Selection

Linear Actuator Sizing,


Unbalanced Trim
Introduction
An important part of selecting the correct control valve
is the proper sizing of its actuator. In throttling services,
three questions must be answered:
1. Will the actuator handle the throttling differential
pressure?
2. Will the actuator provide sufficient thrust to overcome
application pressures to open or close the valve,
and generate enough seat loading for tight shutoff?

Table 16-I: Guardian Metal Bellows


Effective Area
Model
Number

Body Size
(inches)

1-LP

1-HP

2-LP
2-HP

2 , 3 4 , 1

Bellows
Effective
psi Rating Bellows Area
160

.886

310

.886

1 2 , 2

160

1.916

310

1.916

2 , 4 , 1
1 2 , 2

3. Will the spring fail the valve in the proper direction?

3-LP

160

2.835

With on/off services, only questions 2 and 3 must be


answered.

3-HP

310

2.835

4-LP

160

3.343

The equations in this section use the following variables:


AL = Lower cylinder area, in2
AU = Upper cylinder area, in2
AS = Area of the seat, in2 (see Table 16-IV or
equation 16.1)
AStem* = Plug stem cross-sectional area, in2 (see
Table 16-IV or equation 16.3)
AR = Area of the seat retainer bore, in2 (see
equation 16.2)
P1 = Pressure on upstream side of the valve,
psig
P2 = Pressure on downstream side of the valve,
psig
PS = Air supply pressure, psig
SE = Spring force with the spring extended to full
stroke, lbs (see Table 16-VI)
SR = Spring force with the spring fully retracted,
lbs (see Table 16-VI)
SFC30 = Spring force at 30 percent of stroke in failclosed actuators, lbs (see Table 16-VI or
equation 16.4)
SFO30 = Spring force at 30 percent of stroke in failopen actuators, lbs (see Table 16-VI or
equation 16.5)
FP = Packing friction, lbs (see Table 16-V)
RSL = Required seat load to achieve desired
shutoff, lbs (see equation 16.6)

4-HP

310

3.343

Rev. 4/94

* Use effective bellows area for Guardian valves, see Table 16-I.
For Guardian II valves, see page 16-15.

When an actuators stroke length exceeds the longest


stroke length shown for that size actuator on Table 16VI, the actuator will not have a spring. For actuators
without a spring, SE= SR= 0.
The areas of the seat, AS, and the seat retainer bore, AR,
are calculated using the following equations. Note that
the area of the seat retainer bore is not used when sizing
actuators for valves with standard trim or when sizing
actuators for Class 150 through 600 MegaStream valves.
AS =
AR =

dS2

(16.1)

4
(dS+0.125)2
4

(16.2)

Where:
dS = The seat orifice diameter, inches (Trim Number)
The plug stem cross-sectional area, Astem, is calculated
using the following equation:
Astem =

dstem2
4

(16.3)
16-1

Where:
dstem =The plug stem diameter, inches (see Table 16IV)
The spring forces at 30 percent of stroke in fail-closed
and fail-open actuators, SFC30 and SFO30, are calculated
using the following formulas:
SFC30 = SE + RS (0.30) S

(16.4)

SFO30 = SR - RS (0.30) S

(16.5)

Where:
RS = Spring rate, lb/in (from Table 16-VI)
S = Stroke length, inches
The required seat load, RSL, is calculated using the
following equation:
RSL = dCLS

(16.6)

Where:
LS = Seat load per circumferential inch to
achieve
desired shutoff, lbs/in (from Table 8-II)
dC = The diameter of the seating contact surface,
in (from the following table)
Trim Type

dC=

Standard
MegaStream
Tiger-Tooth

Trim Number

CavControl
ChannelStream

Trim Number +
0.125 inch

Step 1: Determine Actuators Maximum


Allowable Throttling Pressure Drop
(Not required for on/off service)
Refer to Table 16-IV to find the standard actuator for the
given body size.
Determine the maximum allowable throttling pressure
drop (Pa) that the selected actuator can handle by
using equations (16.7) and (16.8):
Air-to-open, flow-over: or air-to-close, flow-over:
ACJO
Pa =
AS

(16.7)

Air-to-close, flow-under; or air-to-open, flow-under:


ACJC
Pa =
AS
16-2

(16.8)

Where:
Pa = Maximum allowable throttling pressure drop,
psi
AC = Area of cylinder actuator, square inches (see
Table 16-III; for air-to-open flow, use the
lower cylinder area; for air-to-close flow, use
upper cylinder area)
AS = Area of the seat, square inches
JO = Air supply adjustment factor for flow-over (see
Table 16-II)
JC = Air supply adjustment factor for flow-under
(see Table 16-II)

Table 16-II:
Air Supply Stiffness Factors
Supply Pressure

JC

JO

30
45
60
80
100
150

14.1
28.2
37.6
56.4
75.2
118.0

14.1
20.7
28.2
35.8
42.4
61.2

Compare the maximum allowable throttling pressure


drop to the actual pressure drop. If the actual throttling
drop is less than Pa, the selected actuator is sufficient.
However, if the actual throttling drop is greater than
Pa, the next larger actuator size should be chosen and
the above calculation should be repeated.
The maximum allowable throttling pressure drop may
also be selected by referring to the appendix at the end
of this section. To use these tables, follow the procedure below:
A) Select the correct table based on the trim size
used on the valve.
B) Find the correct air supply pressure in the left
column.
C) Looking to the right, find the allowable throttling
drop (Pa) for the various actuator sizes and air
actions (air-to-open or air-to-close).

Table 16-III: Actuator Data


Cylinder
Size

Cylinder
Bore Dia.(in.)

Upper Cylinder
Area (sq. in.)

Lower Cylinder
Area (sq. in.)

Stem Dia.
(in.)

Stem Area
(sq. in.)

Max. Vol. Over


Piston (cu.in.)

25

5.50

23.76

22.97

1.00

0.79

100

50+

7.75

47.17

46.39

1.00

0.79

331

50

7.75

47.17

45.67

1.38

1.50

331

100+

11.00

95.03

93.26

1.50

1.77

1031

100

11.00

95.03

91.06

2.25

3.98

1031

200

15.50

188.7

184.7

2.25

3.98

2087

300

19.50

298.6

292.7

2.75

5.94

3733

400*

15.50

371.5

365.5

2.75

5.94

3033

500

25.25

500.7

494.8

2.75

5.94

5519

600*

19.50

590.2

583.1

3.00

7.07

5661

* Tandem, double piston configuration

+ Used as oversized actuators in place of the next smaller actuator

Table 16-IV: Standard Unbalanced Valve/Actuator Data


Valve Size
(inches)

Rating
Class

Full Area
Trim Size

Seat Area
(sq. in.)

Stem
Dia.

Stem Area
(sq. in.)

Std. Act.
Size*

Stroke
(inches)

150-600

.50

.196

.562

.248

25

.75

/4

150-2500

.72

.405

.562

.248

25

.75

1
1
1

150-600
900-1500
2500

.81
.81
.72

.518
.518
.405

.562
.562
.562

.248
.248
.248

25
25
25

.75
.75
.75

11/2
11/2
11/2

150-600
900-1500
2500

1.25
1.25
1.00

1.23
1.23
.785

.875
.875
.875

.601
.601
.601

25
50
50

1.00
1.00
.75

2
2
2

150-600
900-1500
2500

1.62
1.62
1.25

2.07
2.07
1.23

.875
.875
.875

.601
.601
.601

25
50
50

1.50
1.50
1.00

3
3
3

150-600
900-1500
2500

2.62
2.62
2.00

5.41
5.41
3.14

1.125
1.5
1.125

.99
1.77
.99

50
100
100

2.00
2.00
1.50

4
4
4

150-600
900-1500
2500

3.50
3.50
2.62

9.62
9.62
5.41

1.125
1.5
1.5

.99
1.77
1.77

50
100
100

2.50
2.50
2.00

6
6
6

150
300-1500
2500

5.00
5.00
4.00

19.63
19.63
12.57

1.125
2.0
2.0

.99
3.14
3.14

50
100
100

3.00
3.00
3.00

8
8
8
8

150
300-600
900-1500
2500

6.25
6.25
6.25
5.00

30.68
30.68
30.68
19.63

1.5
2.0
2.5
2.5

1.77
3.14
4.91
4.91

100
100
100
100

4.00
4.00
4.00
3.00

10
10
10
10

150
300-600
900-1500
2500

8.75
8.75
8.00
6.25

60.13
60.13
50.27
30.68

2.0
2.5
3.0
3.0

3.14
4.91
7.07
7.07

100
100
100
100

4.00
4.00
4.00
4.00

12
12
12

150
300-600
900-2500

9.50
9.50
8.00

70.88
70.88
50.27

2.0
3.0
3.0

3.14
7.07
7.07

100
100
100

4.00
4.00
4.00

14
14

150
300-600

11.00
11.00

95.03
95.03

3.0
3.0

7.07
7.07

100
100

4.00
4.00

/2

* Minimum standard actuator size. Oversized actuators may be required for large pressure drops.

16-3

TABLE 16-V: Typical Stem Packing Friction Forces


Note: All numbers in pounds-force
Plug Stem
Diameter*
(inches)

Teflon
Single V

Teflon
Twin V

Glass and
Carbon-filled
Teflon

0.56
0.88
1.13
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00

44
49
54
64
82
105
133

49
54
50
60
75
90
105

45
63
78
103
141
184
232

Standard Twin
Grafoil
Grafoil
356
560
712
954
1272
1590
1908

642
842
1001
1239
1557
1875
2193

Braided
PTFE

Braided
AFPI

SafeGuard
SureGuard
Single V

SafeGuard
SureGuard
Twin V

44
49
54
64
82
105
133

271
344
399
486
600
714
829

52
70
85
111
149
192
239

68
89
106
135
177
225
279

TABLE 16-VI: Cylinder Actuator Spring Data


Air-to-open (Air-to-retract)
Cylinder

25

50

100

thru

600

16-4

Stroke
(inches)

Spring
Design

Rate
(lb/in)

STD
STD
STD

180
180
180

281
236
146

322
290
227

416
416
416

4
1
1 12
1 12
2
2 12
3
1 12
2
2 12
3

DUAL
DUAL
DUAL
STD
STD
STD
STD
DUAL
DUAL
DUAL
DUAL

447
447
447
164
164
164
164
447
447
447
447

629
629
405
369
287
205
123
1194
970
747
523

728
762
606
443
385
328
271
1395
1238
1082
925

964
1075
1075
615
615
615
615
1864
1864
1864
1864

2
2 12
3
4
2
2 12
3
4
2
212
3
4

STD
STD
STD
STD
HEAVY
HEAVY
HEAVY
HEAVY
DUAL
DUAL
DUAL
DUAL

300
300
300
300
535
535
535
535
885
885
885
885

1125
975
825
525
2098
1831
1563
1028
3471
3029
2586
1701

1305
1200
1095
885
2419
2232
2045
1670
4002
3693
3383
2763

1725
1725
1725
1725
3168
3168
3168
3168
5241
5241
5241
5241

4
1
1 12

SE: Spring
Extended
(lbs)

SFC30
(lbs)

SR: Spring
Retracted
(lbs)

Air-to-close (Air-to-extend)
SR: Spring
Retracted
(lbs)

SFO30
(lbs)

SE: Spring
Extended
(lbs)

450
450
450

410
396
369

315
270
180

656
656
656
656

582
558
533
508

410
328
246
164

1725
1725
1725
1725

1545
1500
1455
1365

1125
975
825
525

Step 2: Determine Actuator Size For


Actuation Thrust
Calculate the actuator cylinder areas required by using
the applicable group of equations in the following tables.
Compare the calculated areas to the corresponding
areas for the actuator size selected in Step 1. Actuator
areas are listed in Table 16-III. If the calculated areas
are less than or equal to the corresponding areas for the
selected actuator, the actuator size is adequate. If the
calculated areas are larger, an actuator with cylinder
areas larger than the calculated areas must be selected.
When determining the required actuator size, various
service conditions should be considered. For each
sizing equation, the conditions to be considered for that
equation are listed with the equation. Each equation
should be evaluated for each listed condition that will
actually occur. The condition numbers refer to the
following list.

Service Conditions to be considered:


1. P1 and P2 for flow conditions. If more than one flow
condition will occur, each should be evaluated.

2. P1 and P2 at shutoff. If more than one set of


pressures will occur during shutoff, each set of
pressures should be evaluated. The possibility of
P2 dropping to atmospheric pressure (0 psig) should
be considered. Pressures used to bench test the
valve should also be considered.
3. P1 and P2 equal to the maximum value of P1. This
condition may occur if the pipeline is pressurized
and the pipe downstream from the valve is blocked.
For this condition, set RSL= 0 in the sizing equations.
4. P1 and P2 equal to 0. This condition will occur if the
pipeline is depressurized. This condition will also
occur during bench testing of the valve. For this
condition, set RSL= 0 in the sizing equations.
NOTES:
1. On valves larger than 24-inch, the weight of the plug
may need to be accounted for; contact factory.
2. A negative number calculated for AL or AU indicates
that the smallest available actuator will work for the
condition being evaluated.
3. For valves with a trim number smaller than the plug
stem diameter, AS-AStem will be a negative number.
In this case, the negative sign must be retained
during the sizing calculations.

Table 16-VII: Actuator Sizing - Standard Globe valves with Unbalanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve from full open to
30 percent open

Equation

AU >

1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed from 30 percent
open and provide tight shutoff

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

AU >

P1Astem - SFC30 + FP
PS
P2 AS - P1(AS - Astem) - SE + FP + RSL
PS

1 ( with RSL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat and stroke valve
from closed to 30 percent open

AL >

P1 (AS - Astem) - P2AS + SFC30 + FP


PS

1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve from 30 percent open
to full open
1, 3, 4

Flow-over

stroke valve from full open to 30


percent open

- P1Astem + SR + FP
AL > z
PS
AU >

1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed from 30 percent
open and provide tight shutoff

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

AU >

1 ( with RSL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat

AL >
2, 3, 4
stroke valve from closed to 30
percent open
1, 3, 4

AL >

P1 Astem + SF030 + FP
PS

(16.9)

(16.10)

(16.11)

(16.12)

(16.13)

P2 AS - P1 (AS - Astem) + SR + FP + RSL


(16.14)
PS
P1(AS - Astem) - P2 AS - SR + FP
PS
P1(AS - Astem) - P2 AS - SF030 + FP
PS

(16.15)

(16.16)

16-5

Table 16-VIII: Actuator Sizing - Standard Globe Valves with Unbalanced Trim

(and Class 150 to 600 MegaStream)


Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve closed and provide
tight shutoff

Equation

AU >

P1AS - P2(AS - Astem) - SE + FP + RSL


PS

1 ( with R SL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat and stroke valve
from closed to 30 percent open

Flow-under

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

AL >

PS

1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve full open

AL >
1, 3, 4

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

P2 (AS - Astem) - P1AS+ SFC30 + FP

stroke valve closed and provide


tight shutoff
1 ( with R SL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4

AU >

- P2Astem + SR + FP

(16.17)

(16.18)

(16.19)

PS
P1AS - P2(AS - Astem) + SR + FP + RSL
PS

(16.20)

Table 16-IX: Actuator Sizing - ChannelStream and CavControl Valves with Unbalanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve closed and provide
tight shutoff

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)
Flow-over

Equation

AU >

PS

1 ( with R SL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat and stroke valve full
open

AL >

1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve closed and provide
tight shutoff

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

P2AR - P1(AR - Astem) - SE + FP + RSL

1 ( with R SL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat and stroke valve full
open
1, 2, 3, 4

AU >

AL >

P1 (AR - Astem) - P2AR+ SR + FP


PS
P2AR - P1(AR - Astem) + SR + FP + RSL
PS
P1 (AR - Astem) - P2AR- SE + FP
PS

(16.21)

(16.22)

(16.23)

(16.24)

Table 16-X: Actuator Sizing - Tiger-Tooth and High Pressure MegaStream Valves with Unbalanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .
Service Condition

Equation

stroke valve closed

AU >
1, 3, 4
provide tight shutoff

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

AU >
2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat

AL >

Flow-under

2, 3, 4
stroke valve full open

AL >
1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

1, 3, 4
provide tight shutoff
2, 3, 4

16-6

AU >

AU >

P1AR - P2 (AR - Astem) - SE + FP


PS
P1AS - P2(AS - Astem) - SE + FP + RSL
PS
P2 (AS - Astem) - P1AS + SE + FP
PS
P2 (AR - Astem) - P1AR + SR + FP
PS
P1AR - P2 (AR - Astem) + SR + FP
PS

(16.25)

(16.26)

(16.27)

(16.28)

(16.29)

P1AS - P2 (AS - Astem) + SR + FP + RSL


(16.30)
PS

Step 3: Determine Spring Size


If it will be necessary for the valve to stroke open or
closed upon loss of air supply pressure, the fail-safe
spring must be sized. The required spring force is
calculated by using the applicable equations in the
following tables. Each sizing equation should be evaluated for the listed conditions that will actually occur. The
condition numbers refer to the service conditions listed
in step 2.
After the required spring force is calculated, it must be
compared to the standard spring force for the actuator
selected in steps 1 and 2. This spring force is listed in
Table 16-VI. If the required spring force is less than the
standard spring force of the selected actuator, a stan-

dard spring will be sufficient. If the required spring


force is greater than that of a standard spring force,
compare the required spring with the dual (or heavyduty) spring force for the same size actuator (see Table
16-VI). If the dual spring force is larger than the required
spring force, the dual spring should be used. If the dual
spring force is not large enough, a volume tank or larger
actuator will be required. Section 19 contains volume
tank sizing information.
If the spring or actuator size selected to provide sufficient spring force is different from that used during step
2, the calculations of step 2 must be verified using the
new spring or actuator information.

Table 16-XI: Spring Sizing - Standard Globe valves with Unbalanced Trim
(and Class 150 to 600 MegaStream)
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Spring to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve from full open to
30 percent open

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

Equation

SFC30 > P1Astem + FP

(16.31)

SE > P2 AS - P1 (AS - Astem) + FP + RSL

(16.32)

SR > P1 (AS - Astem) - P2 AS + FP

(16.33)

SFO30 > P1(AS - Astem) - P2 AS + FP

(16.34)

SE > - P1Astem + FP

(16.35)

SFC30 > P2Astem + FP

(16.36)

SE > P1AS - P2 (AS - Astem) + FP + RSL

(16.37)

SFO30 > P2(AS - Astem) - P1AS + FP

(16.38)

SE > - P2Astem + FP

(16.39)

1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed from 30 percent
open and provide tight shutoff
1 ( with RSL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat

Flow-over

2, 3, 4

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

stroke valve from closed to 30


percent open
1, 3, 4
stroke valve from 30 percent open
to full open
1, 3, 4
stroke valve from full open to 30
percent open

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed and provide
tight shutoff
1 ( with RSL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4

Flow-under

lift plug off seat and stroke valve


from closed to 30 percent open

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve full open
1, 3, 4

16-7

Table 16-XII: Spring Sizing - ChannelStream and CavControl with Unbalanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action
Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

Spring to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve closed and provide
tight shutoff

Equation

SE > P2 AR - P1 (AR - Astem) + FP + RSL

(16.40)

SR > P1 (AR - Astem) - P2 AR + FP

(16.41)

SE > P1(AR - Astem) - P2 AR + FP

(16.42)

1 ( with RSL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat

Flow-over
Fail-open
(air-to-close)

2, 3, 4
stroke valve full open
1, 3, 4

Table 16-XIII: Spring Sizing - Tiger-Tooth and High Pressure MegaStream Valves
with Unbalanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Spring to . . .
Service Condition

Equation

stroke valve closed

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

SE > P1AR - P2 (AR - Astem) + FP

(16.43)

SE > P1AS - P2 (AS - Astem) + FP + RSL

(16.44)

SR > P2 (AS - Astem) - P1AS + FP

(16.45)

SE > P2(AR - Astem) - P1AR + FP

(16.46)

1, 3, 4
provide tight shutoff
2, 3, 4

Flow-under

lift plug off seat

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

2, 3, 4
stroke valve full open
1, 3, 4

16-8

Linear Actuator Sizing,


Pressure-balanced Trim
Introduction
As noted in the procedure for unbalanced trim, in throttling services three questions must be answered:
1. Will the actuator handle the throttling differential
pressure?
2. Will the actuator provide sufficient thrust to overcome application pressures to open or close the
valve, and generate enough seat loading for tight
shutoff with the given air supply pressure?
3. Will the spring fail the valve in the proper direction?

ASl = Sleeve area, in2 (see Table 16-XIV or 16XV)


When an actuators stroke length exceeds the longest
stroke length shown for that size actuator in Table 16-VI,
the actuator will not have a spring. For actuators without
a spring, SE= SR= 0.
The areas of the seat, AS, and the seat retainer bore, AR,
are calculated using the following equations. Note that
the area of the seat retainer bore is not used when sizing
actuators for valves with standard trim or when sizing
actuators for Class 150 through 600 MegaStream valves.

With on/off services, only questions 2 and 3 must be


answered.

AS

The equations in this section use the following variables:


AL = Lower cylinder area, in2
AU = Upper cylinder area, in2
AS = Area of the seat, in2 (see Table 16-XIV or
equation 16.47)
Astem = Plug stem cross-sectional area, in2 (see
Table 16-XIV or equation 16.49)
AR = Area of the seat retainer bore, in2 (see
equation 16.48)
obO = Off-balance area tending to open the valve,
in2; obO = ASl - AS (see Table 16-XIV)
obC = Off-balance area tending to close the valve,
in2; obC= ASl - Astem - AS (see Table 16-XIV)
P1 = Pressure on upstream side of the valve, psig
P2 = Pressure on downstream side of the valve,
psig
PS = Air supply pressure, psig
SE = Spring force with the spring extended to full
stroke, lbs (see Table 16-VI)
SR = Spring force with the spring fully retracted,
lbs (see Table 16-VI)
SFC30 = Spring force at 30% of stroke in fail-closed
actuators, lbs (see equation 16.50)
SFO30 = Spring force at 30% of stroke in fail-open
actuators, lbs (see equation 16.51)
FP = Packing friction, lbs (see Table 16-V)
FS = Pressure balance seal friction, lbs (see Table
16-XVI)
RSL = Required seat load to achieve desired
shutoff, lbs (see equation 16.52)

AR =

dS2
4
(dS + 0.125)2
4

(16.47)
(16.48)

Where:
dS = The seat orifice diameter, in (Trim Number)
dS = T N + 0.125 for ChannelStream and CavControl
The plug stem cross-sectional area, Astem, is calculated
using the following equation:
Astem =

dstem2
4

(16.49)

Where:
dstem = The plug stem diameter, in (see Table 16XIV)
The spring forces at 30 percent of stroke in fail-closed
and fail-open actuators, SFC30 and SFO30, are calculated
using the following equations:
SFC30 = SE + RS(0.30) S

(16.50)

SFO30 = SR - RS(0.30) S

(16.51)

Where:
RS =Spring rate, lb/in (see Table 16-VI)
S =Stroke length, inches
The required seat load, RSL, is calculated using the
following equation:
RSL = dCLS

(16.52)

Where:
LS =Seat load per circumferential inch to achieve
16-9

TABLE 16-XIV: Standard Pressure-balanced Valve/Actuator Data (inches)


Valve Rating Full Area Seat
Stem
Stem
Sleeve
Size
Class
Trim
Area
Dia.
Area
Area
(inches)
Size
(sq. in.) (sq. in.) (sq. in.) (sq. in.)

Off-balance Area sq.in.


Flow Under Flow Over
To Close
To Open

Standard Stroke
Actuator (inches)
Size

2
2
2

600
1500
2500

1.62
1.62
1.25

2.07
2.07
1.23

.562
.562
.562

.248
.248
.248

2.58
2.41
1.55

.26
.09
.07

.51
.34
.32

25
25
25

3
3
3

600
1500
2500

2.62
2.62
2.0

5.41
5.41
3.14

.875
.875
.875

.601
.601
.601

6.77
6.49
3.86

.76
.48
.12

1.36
1.08
.72

50
100
100

1.5
2
1.5

4
4
4

600
1500
2500

3.5
3.5
2.62

9.62
9.62
5.41

.875
1.125
1.125

.601
.994
.994

11.41
11.41
6.77

1.19
.80
.37

1.79
1.79
1.36

50
100
100

2
2
2

6
6
6
6

150
600
1500
2500

5.0
5.0
5.0
4.0

19.63
19.63
19.63
12.57

1.125
1.5
1.5
1.5

.994
1.77
1.77
1.77

22.69
23.76
22.69
15.03

2.06
2.36
1.29
.69

3.06
4.13
3.06
2.46

50
100
100
100

2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5

8
8
8

600
1500
2500

6.25
6.25
5.0

30.68
30.68
19.63

1.5
2.0
2.0

1.77
3.14
3.14

35.78
35.78
23.76

3.33
1.96
.99

5.10
5.10
4.13

100
100
100

3
4
4

10
10
10

600
1500
2500

8.0
8.0
6.25

50.27
50.27
30.68

2.0
2.5
2.5

3.14
4.91
4.91

58.36
58.36
37.12

4.95
3.18
1.53

8.09
8.09
6.44

100
100
100

3
4
4

12
12
12

600
1500
2500

9.5
9.5
8.0

70.88
70.88
50.27

2.5
2.5
2.5

4.91
4.91
4.91

78.54
78.54
56.75

2.75
2.75
1.57

7.66
7.66
6.48

100
100
100

4
4
4

14
14
14

150
600
1500

11.0
11.0
11.0

95.03
95.03
95.03

2.5
3.0
3.0

4.91
7.07
7.07

108.43
108.43
103.87

8.49
6.33
1.77

13.40
13.40
8.84

100
100
100

4
4
4

16
16

600
1500

12.75
12.75

127.68
127.68

3.0
3.0

7.07
7.07

140.50
137.89

5.75
3.14

12.82
10.21

100
100

4
4

Trim Type

dC=

Standard
MegaStream
Tiger-Tooth

Trim Number

CavControl
ChannelStream

Trim Number +
0.125 inch

desired shutoff, lbs/in (see Table 8-II)


dC =The diameter of the seating contact surface, in
(see the following table)

Step 1: Determine Actuators Maximum


Allowable Throttling Pressure Drop
Refer to Table 16-XIV to find the standard actuator for
the given body size.
Determine the maximum allowable throttling pressure
drop (Pa) that the selected actuator can handle by
using equations (16.53) and (16.54):

1
1
1

Air-to-open, flow-over or air-to-close, flow-over:


Pa =

ACJO
obO

(16.53)

Air-to-open, flow-under or air-to-close, flow-under:


Pa =

ACJC
obC

(16.54)

Where:
Pa = Maximum allowable throttling pressure drop,
psi
AC = Area of cylinder actuator, square inches
(see Table 16-III; for air-to-open flow use
lower cylinder area; for air-to-close flow use
upper cylinder area))
obC = Off-balance area tending to close the valve,
in2; obC= ASl - Astem - AS (see Table 16-XIV)
obO = Off-balance area (sq.in.) tending to open the
valve obo= ASl - AS (see Table 16-XIV)
JO = Air supply adjustment factor for flow-over

16-10

(see Table 16-II)

equation are listed with the equation. Each equation


should be evaluated for each listed condition that will
actually occur. The condition numbers refer to the
following list.

JC = Air supply adjustment factor for flow-under


(see Table 16-II)

Service Conditions to be considered:

Compare the maximum allowable throttling pressure


drop to the actual pressure drop. If the Pactual is less
than Pa, the selected actuator is sufficient. However,
if the Pactual is greater than Pa, the next larger actuator
size should be chosen and the above calculation should
be repeated.

1. P1 and P2 for flow conditions. If more than one flow


condition will occur, each should be evaluated.
2. P1 and P2 at shutoff. If more than one set of
pressures will occur during shutoff, each set of
pressures should be evaluated. The possibility of
P2 dropping to atmospheric pressure (0 psig) should
be considered.

Step 2: Determine Actuator Size For


Actuation Thrust

3. P1 and P2 equal to the maximum value of P1. This


condition may occur if the pipeline is pressurized
and the pipe downstream from the valve is blocked.

Calculate the actuator cylinder areas required by using


the applicable equations in the following tables. Compare the calculated areas to the corresponding areas
for the actuator size selected for the throttling drop.
These areas are listed in Table 16-III. If the calculated
areas are less than or equal to the corresponding areas
for the selected actuator, the actuator size is adequate.
If the calculated areas are larger, an actuator with lower
and upper cylinder areas larger than the calculated
areas must be selected.

4. P1 and P2 equal to 0. This condition will occur if the


pipeline is depressurized. This condition will also
occur during bench testing of the valve.

NOTES:
1. On valves larger than 24-inch, the weight of the plug
may need to be accounted for; contact factory.

When determining the required actuator size, various


service conditions should be considered. For each
sizing equation, the conditions to be considered for that

2. A negative number calculated for AL or AU indicates


that the smallest available actuator will work for the
condition being evaluated.

Table 16-XV: Pressure-balanced Sleeve Area


ChannelStream
and CavControl
ASI = AR = AS

Valves other than ChannelStream and


CavControl not listed in Table 16-XIV
Pressure Class

ASI

150 - 600

(1.10) AS + Astem

900 - 1500

(1.05) AS + Astem

2500

(1.03) AS + Astem

Table 16-XVI: Seal Friction Forces


Type of Seal

Seal Friction, FS, (lbs)

Teflon

FS = 58(TN) + 12

O-Ring and Spring


Energized Elastomer

FS = 14(TN) + 0.029(P1 - P2)

Muskegon Piston Rings

FS = 0.00613(TN)(P1 - P2)

NiResist Piston Rings

FS = 0.0613(TN)(P1 - P2)HS

Where:
TN = Trim Number
HS = Seal height
= 0.13
= 0.19
= 0.25
= 0.38

for
for
for
for

TN = 1.00 to
TN = 2.62 to
TN = 5.50 to
TN = 11.00 to

TN = 2.25
TN = 5.00
TN = 9.50
TN = 22.00
16-11

Table 16-XVII: Actuator Sizing - Standard Globe Valves with Pressure-balanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve from full open to
30 percent open

Equation

AU >

P1Astem - S FC30 + FP + FS
PS

1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed from 30 percent
open and provide tight shutoff

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

1 (with RSL = 0), 2, 3, 4


lift plug off seat and stroke valve
from closed to 30 percent open
1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve from 30 percent open
to full open
1, 3, 4

Flow-over

stroke valve from full open to 30


percent open
1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed from 30 percent
open and provide tight shutoff

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

1 (with RSL = 0), 2, 3, 4


lift plug off seat and open valve
from closed to 30 percent open
1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve from 30 percent open
to full open
1, 3, 4

AU >

AL >
AL >

AU >

AU >

AL >
AL >

(16.55)

P1(obO) - P2(obC) - SE + FP + F S + R SL
(16.56)
PS
P2(obC) - P 1(obO) + SFC30 + FP + FS
PS
- P1Astem + SR + FP + F S
PS
P1 Astem + SFO30 + FP + FS
PS

(16.57)

(16.58)

(16.59)

P1(obO) - P 2(obC) + SR + FP + FS + RSL


(16.60)
PS
P2(obC) - P1(obO) - SFO30 + FP + FS
PS
- P1Astem - SE + FP + F S
PS

(16.61)

(16.62)

Table 16-XVIII: Actuator Sizing - Standard Globe Valves (and Class 150 to 600
MegaStream)
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve from full open to
30 percent open

Equation

AU >

P2Astem - S FC30 + FP + FS
PS

1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed from 30 percent
open and provide tight shutoff

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

1 (with RSL = 0), 2, 3, 4


lift plug off seat and stroke valve
from closed to 30 percent open
1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve from 30 percent open
to full open
1, 3, 4

Flow-under

stroke valve from full open to 30


percent open
1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed from 30 percent
open and provide tight shutoff

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

1 (with RSL = 0), 2, 3, 4


lift plug off seat and open valve
from closed to 30 percent open
1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve from 30 percent open
to full open
1, 3, 4

16-12

AU >

AL >

AL >

AU >

AU >

AL >
AL >

(16.63)

P2(obO) - P1(obC) - SE + FP + F S + R SL
(16.64)
PS
P1(obC) - P 2(obO) + SFC30 + FP + FS
PS
- P2Astem + SR + FP + F S
PS
P2Astem + SFO30 + FP + FS
PS

(16.65)

(16.66)

(16.67)

P2(obO) - P 1(obC) + SR + FP + FS + RSL


(16.68)
PS
P1(obC) - P2(obO) - SFO30 + FP + FS
PS
- P2Astem - SE + FP + F S
PS

(16.69)

(16.70)

Table 16-XIX: Actuator Sizing - ChannelStream and CavControl Valves


with Pressure-balanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .
Service Condition

Equation

stroke valve closed and provide


tight shutoff

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

AU >

lift plug off seat and stroke valve full


open

stroke valve closed and provide


tight shutoff

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

PS

1 (with RSL = 0), 2, 3, 4

1, 2, 3, 4

Flow-over

P2Astem - S E + FP + FS + RSL

AU >

1 (with RSL = 0), 2, 3, 4


lift plug off seat and stroke valve full
open
1, 2, 3, 4

AL >

AL >

- P2Astem + SR + FP + F S
PS
P2Astem + SR + FP + FS + RSL
PS
- P2Astem - SE + FP + FS
PS

(16.71)

(16.72)

(16.73)

(16.74)

Table 16-XX: Actuator Sizing - Tiger-Tooth and High Pressure MegaStream Valves
with Pressure-balanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .
Service Condition

Equation

stroke valve closed

AU >
1, 3, 4
provide tight shutoff

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

AU >
2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat
2, 3, 4

AL >

stroke valve full open

AL >
1, 3, 4

Flow-under

stroke valve closed

AU >
1, 3, 4
provide tight shutoff

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

2, 3, 4

AU >

lift plug off seat


2, 3, 4

AL >

stroke valve full open


1, 3, 4

AL >

P2(ASl - AR) - P1(ASl - AR - Astem) - SE + FP + FS


PS

(16.75)

P2(ASl - AS) - P1(ASl - AS - Astem) - SE + FP + FS + RSL


(16.76)
PS
P1(ASl - AS - Astem) - P2(ASl - AS) + SE + FP + FS
PS
P1(ASl - AR - Astem) - P2(ASl - AR) + SR + FP + FS
PS
P2(ASl - AR) - P1(ASl - AR - Astem) + SR + FP + FS
PS

(16.77)

(16.78)

(16.79)

P2(ASl - AS) - P1(ASl - AS - Astem) + SR + FP + FS + RSL


(16.80)
PS
P1(ASl - AS - Astem) - P2(ASl - AS) - SR + FP + FS
PS
P1(ASl - AR - Astem) - P2(ASl - AR) - SE + FP + FS
PS

(16.81)

(16.82)

16-13

Step 3: Determine Spring Size


If the valve is required to stroke open or closed upon
loss of air supply pressure, the actuator fail-safe spring
must be sized. The required spring force is calculated
by using the applicable equations in the following tables.
For each sizing equation, the conditions to be considered for that equation are listed. Each equation should
be evaluated for the listed conditions that will actually
occur. The condition numbers refer to the service
conditions listed in Step 2.
After the required spring force is calculated, it must be
compared to the standard spring force for the actuator
selected in steps 1 and 2. This spring force is listed in
Table 16-VI. If the required spring force is less than the

standard spring force for the selected actuator, a standard spring will be sufficient. If the required spring force
is greater than that of a standard spring, compare the
required spring force with the dual (or heavy-duty)
spring force for the same size actuator (see Table 16VI). If the dual spring force is larger than the required
spring force, the dual spring should be used. If the dual
spring force is not large enough, a volume tank or larger
actuator will
be required. Section 19 contains
volume tank sizing information.
If the spring or actuator size selected to provide sufficient spring force is different from that used during step
2, the calculations of step 2 must be verified using the
new spring or actuator information.

Table 16-XXI: Spring Sizing - Standard Globe valves with Pressure-balanced Trim
(and Class 150 to 600 MegaStream)
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Spring to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve from full open to
30 percent open

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed from 30 percent
open and provide tight shutoff
1 ( with RSL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4

Flow-under

lift plug off seat and stroke valve


from closed to 30 percent open

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

1, 2, 3, 4
stroke valve from 30 percent open
to full open
1, 3, 4
stroke valve from full open to 30
percent open

Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

1, 3, 4
stroke valve closed and provide
tight shutoff
1 ( with RSL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4

Flow-over

lift plug off seat and stroke valve


from closed to 30 percent open

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

1, 2, 3, 4

Equation

SFC30 > P2Astem + FP+ FS

(16.83)

SE > P2(obO) - P1(obC) + F P + FS + R SL

(16.84)

SFO30 > P1(obC) - P2(obO) + FP + FS

(16.85)

SE > - P2Astem + FP + F S

(16.86)

SFC30 > P1Astem + FP + F S

(16.87)

SE > P1(obO) - P2(obC) + F P + FS + R SL

(16.88)

SFO30 > P2(obC) - P1(obO) + FP + FS

(16.89)

SE > - P1Astem + FP + F S

(16.90)

stroke valve full open


1, 2, 3, 4

Table 16-XXII: Spring Sizing - ChannelStream and CavControl with Pressure-balanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action
Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

Flow-over

16-14

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

Spring to . . .
Service Condition
stroke valve closed and provide
tight shutoff

Equation

SE > P2 Astem + FP + FS+ RSL

(16.91)

SE > - P2 Astem + FP + FS

(16.92)

1 ( with RSL = 0 ), 2, 3, 4
lift plug off seat and stroke valve full
open
1, 2, 3, 4

Table 16-XXIII: Spring Sizing - Tiger-Tooth and High Pressure MegaStream Valves
with Pressure-balanced Trim
Valve
Orientation

Fail
Action

Actuator to . . .

Equation

Service Condition
stroke valve closed

SE > P2(ASl - AR) - P1(ASl - AR - Astem) + FP + FS


Fail-closed
(air-to-open)

(16.93)

1, 3, 4
provide tight shutoff

SE > P2(ASl - AS) - P1(ASl - AS - Astem) + FP + FS + RSL

(16.94)

2, 3, 4

Flow-under

lift plug off seat

Fail-open
(air-to-close)

SR > P1(ASl - AS - Astem) - P2(ASl - AS) + FP + FS

(16.95)

SE > P1(ASl - AR - Astem) - P2(ASl - AR) + FP + FS

(16.96)

2, 3, 4
stroke valve full open
1, 3, 4

Linear Actuator Sizing,


Guardian II Metal Bellows Seal
Introduction
The following data must be used when sizing actuators
for Guardian II metal bellows valves. This information
along with the previous equations listed in Sizing and
Selection section 16 will be combined for accurate
sizing. See Table XXIV for the initial sizing information
needed. While sizing, the actuator pressure limits in
Table XXV must not be exceeded. For valve and
actuator combinations not listed, the actuator pressure
limit is 150 psig.

Table 16-XXIV: Guardian II Bellows Valve


Actuator Sizing Information
Max. Effective Relaxed Bellows
Valve
ANSI
Stroke
Bellows Position Spring
Size Pressure
Length
Area (in. from Rate
(inches) Class
(inches) (sq. in.)
seat)
(lb/in)
1

2, 34, 1 150, 300


112, 2 150, 300
3
150, 300
4, 6
150
4, 6
300
8
150
8
300

0.5
1.0
1.5
2.5
2.5
3.0
3.0

0.75
1.35
1.35
2.38
2.18
4.53
4.75

0
0
0.25
0
0
0
0

36
26
26
15
42
20
112

To determine actuator spring forces, the stroke length


of a valve must be known. Many Guardian II stroke

lengths are given in Table XXVI. For the trims not listed
in Table

Table 16-XXV
Guardian II Actuator Pressure Limits
Valve
Size
(inches)

ANSI
Pressure
Class

Actuator
Size
(sq. in.)

Max. Actuator
Pressure
(psig)

6
6
8
8
8
8

300
300
150
150
300
300

200
300
200
300
200
300

100
60
100
60
100
60

XXVI, the stroke length is determined by comparing the


maximum stroke length listed in Table XXIV to the
stroke length of a standard Mark One valve that is the
same size and has the same trim. The actual stroke
length of the valve with a Guardian II bellows seal will be
the shorter of these two stroke lengths.
Fluid pressure inside the valve acts on the effective
bellows area. This area is listed in Table XXIV and
should be substituted for the actuator stem area in the
actuator sizing equations.
The relaxed position of the bellows is the distance from
the seat where the bellows is not in tension or
16-15

compression. The metal bellows acts as a spring that


is compressed or stretched as the plug is moved from
the relaxed position. To account for the spring force of
the bellows, it is necessary to add a term to the sizing
equations of Section 16 of the Sizing & Selection
manual. The term is added to the numerator on the right
side of the equations for actuator area and is added to
the right side of equations for spring force. This additional
term is designated SB. For equations used to determine
the actuator or spring size required to close the valve,
SB is calculated by using Equation 1.
SB = RB(PR-PA)

Table 16-XXVI:
Cv Data (=% Trim, Flow Over)
Valve Size
(inches)
1

(Equation 1)

For equations used to determine the actuator or spring


size required to open the valve, SB is calculated by
using Equation 2.

112

SB = RB(PA-PR)

(Equation 2)

Where:
SB = Spring force of the metal bellows, lbs.
PA = Actual position of the plug, in. (If the
equation
from Sizing & Selection section
16 determines the force required to
move the plug
through
a
range of stroke values, use the
position that gives the largest value for SB).

3
4

PR = Relaxed position of the plug, in.


(See Table XXIV).

RB = Spring rate of the metal bellows, lb/in.


(See Table XXIV).

Trim
Number

Stroke
(inches)

Full
Cv

.50
.31
.72
.50
.31
.81
.50
.31
1.25
1.00
.81
1.62
1.25
1.00
.81
2.62
1.62
3.50
2.25
5.00
3.50
6.25
5.00

.50
.50
.50
.50
.50
.50
.50
.50
1.00
.75
.75
1.00
1.00
.75
.75
1.50
1.50
2.50
2.00
2.50
2.50
3.00
3.00

4.2
2.3
7.5
5.4
2.6
11.0
5.7
2.6
30
22
18
44
33
23
19
107
49
206
113
405
236
698
474

Table 16-XXVII: Examples of Modifications to Actuator Sizing Equations


Equation
16.9

16.10

16.11

16.12

Modified Equation
AU >

AU >

AL >

AL >

P1Abellows - SFC30 + FP + SB

SB Equation

SB Evaluation Position (PA)

30 percent open
(0.3 X Stroke Length)

On seat
(0.0 inches)

30 percent open
(0.3 X Stroke Length)

Full open
(Stroke Length)

PS
P2 AS - P1(AS - Abellows) - SE + FP + RSL + SB
PS
P1 (AS - Abellows) - P2AS + SFC30 + FP +SB
PS
- P1Abellows + SR + FP + SB
PS

16.31

SFC30 > P1Abellows + FP +SB

30 percent open
(0.3 X Stroke Length)

16.32

SE > P2 AS - P1 (AS - Abellows) + FP + RSL + SB

On seat
(0.0 inches)

16-16

Rotary Actuator Sizing,


Valdisk and Valdisk 150
Introduction
To select an actuator for a Valdisk or Valdisk 150 high
performance butterfly valve, five sequential steps are
necessary:
1. Determine the shaft orientation and actuator stiffness requirements.
2. Calculate the seating and breakout torque.
3. Calculate the dynamic torque.
4. Select an actuator capable of providing sufficient
torque to overcome the seating/breakout torque
and dynamic torque based on available air supply.
5. If a fail-open or fail-close action is required, select
an actuator capable of providing sufficient torque to
overcome the seating/breakout torque and dynamic torque based on available spring torque.

Step 1: Determine the Shaft Orientation


Because the disc in a Valdisk or Valdisk 150 is double
offset, when the shaft is oriented upstream the dynamic
torque created by the process fluid will force the disc
into the seat. A disc with the shaft oriented downstream
will move toward the open position when near the seat.
As a general rule, a valve that is required to fail-close on
loss of instrument air supply usually has the shaft
upstream. A valve which is required to fail open has the
shaft downstream.

The above rule applies to all applications where the


flowing fluid is a gas. On liquid applications with the
shaft upstream, the actuator must be adequately stiff to
prevent the disc from closing too rapidly, thus eliminating any potential pressure surge condition which would
result in water hammer. To determine if the actuator
has sufficient stiffness, calculate the following:
P (max)
Actuator Stiffness (required) =
(16.97)
Sup. Press.
Compare the required actuator stiffness with the maximum actuator stiffness values found in Table 16-XXVIII
(according to valve size). Shaft upstream on a failclosed liquid service can be used, provided the required
stiffness does not exceed the actuator stiffness (max)
for the actuator size selected. Note that in all cases the
standard actuator size for a given valve size is indicated
first in the chart. A larger actuator size may be required
to ensure adequate stiffness. If the required stiffness
exceeds all those indicated for the actuator sizes available for a given valve size, shaft downstream orientation is required.

Step 2: Find the Seating and Breakout


Torque
Using table 16-XXX and the following equations, calculate the seating and breakout torque.

Table 16-XXVIII: Actuator Stiffness (max.) for Shaft Upstream, Liquid Applications
Valve Size
(inches)
2
3
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
24

Actuator Size
Standard
25
3.1
3.1
1.7
0.81

Standard
50

8.8
4.3
2.4
1.3

Standard
100

6.9
6.0
3.4
2.4
1.4
0.98
0.84
0.53
0.39

Standard
200

15.9
13.8
7.8
5.5
3.2
2.2
1.9
1.2
0.87

Toggle-link
100

13.2
7.5
5.3
3.1
2.16
1.85
1.17
.86

Toggle-link
200

30.4
17.2
12.1
7.0
4.8
4.2
2.6
1.9
16-17

Table 16-XXIX: Dynamic Torque Factors vs. Disc Position


Valve
Size
(in.)

Dynamic Torque Factor vs. Disc Position (Degrees Open)


10o

20o

30o

A
0

B
0

A
0

B
0

A
0

4
6

0
0

0
0

0
0

0
1

0
1

40o
B

50o

A
0

B
0

A
0

0
1

0
1

60o
B

70o

A
0

0
3

0
2

1
4

1
4

2
9

A
0

80o
B

90o
B

1
6

4
17

0
0

6
23

-4
-19

4
19

12

19

-8

28

-23

23

10
12

0
1

1
2

1
2

2
7

2
5

6
13

5
10

9
20

7
16

17
38

8
18

28
61

4
8

46
101

-18
-40

65
144

-55
-121

55
121

14
16

1
2

3
4

3
4

10
12

6
8

18
23

15
19

28
36

22
27

54
67

25
32

85
106

12
15

142
177

-56
-69

201
250

-168
-211

168
211

18

10

10

29

19

54

44

83

64

156

73

247

34

411

-161

582

-489

489

20
24

5
7

10
14

10
14

31
42

21
28

58
78

47
64

89
121

68
92

168
227

78
106

264
358

6
50

440
596

-173
-234

623
845

-524
-710

524
710

30

24

49

49

146

97

268

219

414

316

779

365

1230

170

2046

-804

2899

-2436

2436

A = Shaft Downstream
B = Shaft Upstream

NOTE: When degrees of opening are not known, use highest value of Cd for valve size.

Shaft downstream: (Torque required to close valve)


Tst = - TP - TS - PMAX(CBT + COT) - TH

(16.98)

Shaft downstream: (Torque required to open valve)


Tbo = TP + TS + PMAX(CBT - COT) + TH

(16.99)

70 to 80 degrees open, which could result in some


controllability problems. To avoid this, change the shaft
orientation to shaft upstream or limit the disc rotation to
70 degrees.
For gas applications use Table 16-XXX and the following equations to find the required dynamic torque:

Shaft upstream: (Torque required to close valve)


Tst = - TP - TS - PMAX(CBT - COT) - TH

(16.100)

Shaft upstream: (Torque required to open valve)


Tbo = TP + TS + PMAX(CBT + COT) + TH
Where: Tst
Tbo
TP
TS
PMAX
CBT
COT
TH

(16.101)

= Seating torque
= Breakout required
= Packing torque
= Seat torque
= Maximum pressure drop at shutoff
= Bearing torque factor
= Off-balance torque factor
= Handwheel torque. TH = O without
handwheel (See Table 16 - XXXII)

NOTE: Negative values calculated for Tc, Tbo, Tst,


indicate the disc will tend to resist closing. Positive
values indicate the disc will tend to resist opening.

Step 3: Calculate the Dynamic Torque


Since the net torque output of rotary actuators varies as
disc position changes, it may be necessary to find the
dynamic torque on the shaft at various degrees of
opening. This is generally required only when a relatively high actual pressure drop is expected through
part or all of the disc rotation. With the shaft oriented
downstream a torque reversal occurs at approximately
16-18

To close the disc:


TD = - TP - Peff(CBT)

(16.102)

To open the disc:


TD = TP + Peff(CBT)

(16.103)

For liquid applications use Tables 16-XXIX, 16-XXX


and the following equations to find the required dynamic
torque:
To close the disc
TD = -TP - Peff(CBT - Cd)

(16.104)

To open the disc


TD = TP + Peff(CBT - Cd)

(16.105)

Where:
TD = Dynamic torque: (-)values indicate the
disc will resist closing. (+) values indicate
the disc will resist opening.
Cd = Dynamic torque factor from Table 16XXIX for appropriate shaft orientation and
degrees of opening. Use highest Cd value
if degrees of opening are unknown.
Peff = P(actual) at the flowing condition at the
operating degrees of opening limited to
P (choked)
TP = Packing torque factor, from Table 16-XXX

Table 16-XXX: Static Breakout Torque = Sizing


Valve
Size
(inches)

ANSI
Pressure
Class

2
3
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
24
30

150,300,600

150,300*
150*

TP = Packing Torque
(in-lb)
(1)
50
50
57
64
79
79
104
104
122
122
141
141
182

(1) TFE or filled TFE V-ring packing


(2) Grafoil packing
(3) Twin Grafoil Packing
(4) Asbestos free packing

(3)

(4)

(5)

TS = Seat
Torque
(in-lb)

280 477
280 477
333 533
385 590
490 702
490 702
648 870
648 870
753 983
753 983
858 1095
858 1095
1068 1319

350
350
399
448
543
543
691
691
789
789
886
886
1081

63
63
71
81
104
104
151
151
190
190
234
234
342

74
154
270
596
980
1612
2102
4338
5853
6639
9378
11829
19521

(2)

CBT = Bearing
Torque Factor
(6)

(7)

COT = Off
Balance
Torque Factor

0.09
0.20
0.48
1.27
2.73
4.46
8.60
11.98
16.61
21.99
35.50
44.78
110.83

0.13
0.30
0.72
1.90
4.10
6.69
12.90
17.97
24.92
32.99
53.25
67.17
166.25

0.20
0.40
0.71
1.66
2.58
4.25
5.55
25.65
34.62
39.27
55.42
65.40
38.49

(5) Braided PTFE packing


(6) Filament wound glass/TFE bearing
(7) 316 stainless steel/solid film lubricant coated bearing and stellite bearings
* For higher pressure class data, consult factory

Table 16-XXXI: Valve/Actuator Compatibility - Valdisk/Valdisk 150


Actuator
Size
(sq.in.)

Spring
Size

STD. 25

STD.

STD. 25

H.D.

STD. 50

STD.

Valves Size (inches)


2

STD. 50

H.D.

STD. 100

STD.

STD. 100

H.D.

STD. 200

STD.

STD. 200

H.D.

8 10 12 14 16 18 20 24 30

NOTE: For Valdisk valve compatibility with Toggle-link actuators, contact factory.

Table 16-XXXII:
Declutchable Handwheel Torque (TH)
Actuator Size
(sq.in.)

Handwheel Torque
(in-lbs)

25

150

50

250

100 - 200

375

16-19

CBT = Bearing torque factor, from Table 16-XXX


P(choked) is shown as:
P(choked) = FL2 (P1 - FfPV)
(16.106)

Step 5: Select Actuator Based on


Available Spring Torque

Where:
FL = Valves recovery coefficient
P1 = Upstream pressure, psia
Ff = Liquid critical pressure ratio
PV = Vapor pressure of the liquid, psia

If the spring must move the disc to a desired failure


position upon air supply loss, select an actuator from
table 16-XXXIII according to the following criteria.
(Available actuator sizes are indicated in Table 16XXXI.)

Step 4: Determine Actuator Size Based


on
Air Supply
Select an actuator from Table 16-XXXIII with sufficient
net torque to overcome the calculated seating/breakout
and dynamic torque through the full stroke rotation of
the valve based on the available air supply.
After the actuator size has been selected, all gas and
liquid applications with shaft downstream should be
checked for sufficient actuator stiffness. Using the
following equation, calculate corrected air supply:
SC = 0.867Sa - 12.3
Where:

(16.107)

SC = Corrected supply pressure


Sa = Actual supply pressure

Using SC, consult Table 16-XXXIII and confirm that the


actuator size selected has sufficient torque to overcome
the dynamic torque values (calculated from step 3).
Choose a larger actuator size if the torque available
throughout the full stroke rotation is less than the
dynamic torque calculated.

16-20

Finally, check the valve/actuator interface compatibility


in Table 16-XXXI for the actuator chosen.

For fail-closed valves, which do not require tight shutoff


on air failure, the spring must provide sufficient torque
to overcome the calculated dynamic torque through the
full stroke rotation of the valve. For valves requiring tight
shutoff, the spring must also provide sufficient torque at
the 0 degree (closed) position to overcome the required
seating torque.
For fail-open valves, the spring must deliver sufficient
torque at the 90 degrees (closed) position to overcome
the calculated breakout torque. It must also have
sufficient torque to overcome the dynamic torque
throughout the full stroke rotation of the valve.
Should the required torque be greater than the available
springs can provide, a volume tank can be used to
ensure failure on loss of air supply.
For liquid applications with the shaft oriented upstream,
the selected actuator should have adequate stiffness. It
should also provide sufficient torque to overcome the
seating/breakout torque and dynamic torque through
the fall stroke rotation of the valve with the available air
supply and available spring torque, if a failure mode is
required.

Table 16-XXXIII: Net Torque Output of Standard Actuators at Various Supply Pressures (inNOTE: For air-to-open/fail-closed actuators the 0 degreelb)
position shown corresponds to the disc or ball being seated.
For air-to-close/fail-open actuators the 90 degree position shown corresponds to the disc or ball being seated.
Degrees from Fail Position on Air Supply Loss

Actuaor
Size

Supply
Pressure

STD 25 with
STD Spring

150
140
120
100
80
60
40
Spring Torque

STD 25 with
HD Spring

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

3013
2755
2397
1986
1574
1163
751
54

3399
3165
2695
2228
1759
1290
821
86

3700
3444
2928
2412
1896
1381
864
125

3907
3631
3080
2530
1979
1428
876
169

4000
3714
3145
2573
2002
1430
858
213

3970
3685
3110
2535
1961
1386
811
254

3811
3531
2972
2414
1856
1298
738
284

3514
3253
2731
2211
1688
1167
645
299

3084
2854
2390
1928
1463
1001
537
293

2532
2339
1962
1577
1191
806
420
262

150
140
120
100
80
60
Spring Torque

2647
2441
2030
1618
1206
795
440

2973
2738
2270
1802
1333
865
542

3223
2964
2450
1934
1418
902
647

3386
3110
2558
2009
1457
907
749

3448
3162
2590
2020
1448
877
839

3403
3115
2542
1967
1392
818
908

3246
2966
2409
1850
1292
733
945

2976
2716
2195
1673
1151
630
937

2600
2368
1905
1441
978
515
878

2124
1931
1552
1167
781
396
758

STD 50 with
STD Spring

150
140
120
100
80
60
40
Spring Torque

10701
9970
8516
7059
5602
4147
2690
222

11981
11157
9513
7873
6227
4586
2942
343

13015
12114
10318
8515
6716
4913
3111
489

13751
12798
10874
8953
7033
5114
3192
651

14134
13136
11141
9153
7156
5166
3171
816

14089
13083
11075
9073
7062
5058
3049
966

13575
12596
10649
8693
6736
4784
2829
1081

12568
11653
9826
7999
6174
4347
2519
1134

11043
10232
8615
6995
5372
3755
2134
1107

9035
8365
7053
5712
4373
3034
1693
983

STD 50 with
HD Spring

150
140
120
100
80
60
Spring Torque

9774
9044
7591
6133
4678
3223
1148

10898
10074
8430
6790
5148
3505
1428

11781
10880
9083
7281
5481
3681
1726

12380
11425
9502
7585
5660
3741
2026

12651
11652
9657
7668
5671
3680
2304

12533
11527
9519
7516
5508
3501
2529

12000
11021
9073
7117
5163
3209
2662

11036
10122
8300
6473
4646
2821
2667

9648
8837
7216
5597
3974
2356
2511

7850
7183
5865
4527
3186
1846
2167

STD 100 with


STD Spring

150
140
120
100
80
60
40
Spring Torque

26194
24385
20805
17226
13640
10055
6469
704

29415
27397
23329
19271
15200
11139
7077
1049

32022
29784
25330
20859
16399
11929
7472
1461

33847
31459
26685
21914
17153
12391
7624
1913

34730
32253
27303
22368
17413
12472
7526
2370

34559
32069
27104
22119
17133
12159
7181
2783

33234
30831
25983
21134
16296
11447
6605
3088

30711
28446
23921
19394
14878
10350
5829
3225

26943
26936
20932
16920
12915
8901
4893
3135

22035
20378
17119
13808
10485
7167
3851
2775

STD 100 with


HD Spring

150
140
120
100
80
60
Spring Torque

24678
22881
19304
15713
12130
8545
2217

27231
25195
21127
17070
12999
8939
3256

29008
26771
22317
17847
13385
8921
4485

29925
27539
22784
18012
13248
8483
5831

29917
27459
22507
17567
12612
7673
7185

28969
26475
21490
16518
11538
6558
8405

27058
24632
19782
14946
10101
5257
9299

24266
22001
17472
12956
8432
3910
9691

20699
18691
14680
10674
6662
2662
9407

16483
14832
11563
8245
4927
1611
8316

STD 200 with


STD Spring

80
70
60
50
40
30
Spring Torque

27695
24156
20595
17051
13501
9951
704

31132
27119
23091
19072
15043
11022
1049

33903
29480
25069
20643
16227
11808
1461

35838
31134
26406
21696
16969
12253
1913

36820
31916
27014
22126
17223
12328
2370

36663
31730
26813
21876
16952
12015
2783

35280
30501
25699
20897
16109
11307
3088

32620
28139
24656
19173
14703
10219
3225

28633
25670
20697
16724
12760
8785
3135

23416
20206
16926
13646
10357
7071
2775

STD 200 with


HD Spring

80
70
60
50
40
30
Spring Torque

26192
22636
19094
15538
11991
8441
2217

28930
24918
20889
16872
12842
8821
3256

30894
26467
22056
17629
13212
8792
4485

31940
27214
22505
17779
13064
8345
5831

32005
27122
22217
17326
12421
7530
7185

31052
26136
21198
16275
11346
6414
8405

29104
24302
19499
14709
9914
5116
9299

26177
21693
17208
12735
8257
3778
9691

22393
18420
14445
10478
6507
2536
9407

17887
14650
11370
8083
4799
1514
8316

(continued)

16-21

Table 16-XXXIII: (continued)


Net Torque Output of Toggle-link Actuators at Various Supply Press. (in-lb)
NOTE: For air-to-open/fail-closed actuators the 0 degree position shown corresponds to the disc or ball being seated.
For air-to-close/fail-open actuators the 90 degree position shown corresponds to the disc or ball being seated.
Actuaor
Size

Degrees from Fail Position on Air Supply Loss

Supply
Pressure

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

150
140
120
100
80
70
60

55253
51566
44200
36835
29465
25783
22100

50511
47141
40407
33674
26937
23570
20203

48414
45183
38730
32276
25818
22591
19364

47688
44506
38149
31792
25431
22252
19074

47565
44390
38050
31709
25365
22195
19024

47596
44417
38072
31728
25380
22208
19035

47231
44077
37781
31486
25185
22038
18889

46243
43155
36991
30827
24659
21577
18494

44044
41094
35224
29357
23482
20548
17611

40216
37629
32255
26891
21504
18821
16126

STD 100 with


STD 20" Spring

150
140
120
100
80
70
60
Spring Torque

46475
42763
35341
27996
20640
16973
13303
8764

41517
38174
31457
24741
18023
14671
11309
8854

39053
35847
29418
22967
16531
13318
10103
9234

37762
34581
28256
21923
15583
12409
9244
9802

37004
33832
27519
21185
14860
11702
8536
10469

36347
33173
26856
20532
14190
11029
7866
11161

35492
32336
26033
19745
13447
10295
7149
11775

34086
30996
24847
18676
12513
9427
6348
12185

31885
28927
23070
17192
11320
8381
5447
12209

28585
25968
20597
15219
9842
7156
4469
11625

STD 100 with


HD 28" Spring

150
140
120
100
80
70
60
Spring Torque

42482
38800
31452
24099
16745
13077
9405
12677

37897
34552
27836
21123
14404
11049
7687
12491

35540
32330
25881
19447
13009
9794
6576
12773

34250
31070
24741
18393
12063
8889
5722
13330

33432
30261
23946
17627
11299
8139
4976
14038

32745
29572
23233
16909
10577
7414
4249
14783

31840
28686
22399
16095
9798
6652
3506
15436

30466
27398
21227
15068
8900
5815
2735
15804

28395
25457
19580
13712
7836
4900
1962
15699

25370
22747
17376
11997
6620
3930
1242
14847

STD 200 with


No Spring

120
100
80
70
60
50
40

90138
75117
60092
52580
45067
37558
30046

82403
68671
54935
48067
41199
34335
27467

78982
65820
52655
46072
39489
32910
26327

77799
64834
51865
45381
38897
32416
25932

77597
64666
51731
45263
38796
32332
25864

77646
64705
51761
45291
38819
32352
25880

77052
64210
51365
44944
38521
32104
25682

75440
62867
50291
44004
37716
31433
25144

71847
59870
47891
41906
35915
29934
23944

65573
54840
43857
38384
32887
27419
21928

STD 200 with


STD 20" Spring

120
100
80
70
60
50
40
Spring Torque

81372
66376
51346
43764
36215
28722
21221
8764

73545
59778
45950
39076
32250
25402
18554
8854

69667
56415
43301
36736
30176
23601
17039
9234

67776
54835
41931
35455
29000
22546
16083
9802

66960
54063
41139
34705
28245
21806
15359
10469

66341
53409
40508
34045
27602
21140
14689
11161

65317
52467
39606
33203
26775
20364
13944
11775

63265
50725
38139
31846
25573
19282
12999
12185

59683
47718
35730
29737
23761
17770
11784
12209

53947
43167
32194
26720
21229
15758
10272
11625

STD 200 with


HD 28" Spring

120
100
80
70
60
50
40
Spring Torque

77455
62436
47376
39792
32321
24823
17326
12677

69905
56083
42304
35474
28628
21783
14934
12491

66066
52894
39777
33196
26640
20081
13517
12773

64242
51326
38398
31945
25488
19016
12555
13330

63370
50491
37592
31133
24692
18249
11798
14038

62710
49816
36886
30444
23979
17532
11077
14783

61663
48813
35982
29554
23141
16714
10294
15436

59644
47105
34519
28247
21953
15675
9380
15804

56196
44228
32240
26266
20271
14290
8299
15699

50755
39946
28972
23481
18007
12525
7043
14847

STD 200 with


HD 34" Spring

120
100
80
70
60
50
40
Spring Torque

74734
59697
44588
37026
29543
22050
14567
15446

67370
53551
39793
32944
26095
19252
12404
15021

63658
50490
37353
30791
24212
17655
11099
15198

61889
48931
36033
29558
23099
16641
10175
15718

60983
46106
35208
28770
22310
15866
9416
16422

60326
47431
34501
28059
21609
15148
8698
17180

59298
46441
33610
27182
20769
14353
7929
17808

57364
44783
32197
25926
19632
13353
7065
18127

53986
42018
30030
24055
18059
12078
6087
17921

48740
37928
26953
21462
15977
10505
5019
16866

STD 100 with


No Spring

16-22

80

90

Rotary Actuator Sizing,


ShearStream
Where:
Tbo = Seating/breakout torque (in-lb) is the torque
required to close and open the valve.

Introduction
To select an actuator for a ShearStream high performance ball valve, three steps are necessary:
1. Determine seating/breakout torques. (Also determine the dynamic torque in liquid applications.)

TP = Packing torque (in-lb) is the torque required to


overcome the friction of the packing on the
shaft. Packing torque varies with packing
material. (See Table 16-XXXVI)

2. Select an actuator capable of providing sufficient


torque to overcome the seating/breakout torque
and dynamic torque based on available air supply.

TS = Seat torque (in-lb) is the torque required to


overcome the friction of the seat on the ball.
(See Table 16-XXXVI)

3. If a failure action is required, select an actuator


capable of providing sufficient torque to overcome
the seating/breakout torque and dynamic torque
based on available spring torque.

Step 1: Determine Seating/Breakout


Torques.
Normally, ShearStream valves are installed with the
shaft downstream. However, in an erosive service the
valve should be installed with the shaft upstream. With
the shaft upstream, erosive action will occur in the
retainer and not the ball surface or the valve body. To
determine the seating/breakout torque, use equation
(16.108) or (16.109), according to the application.
For shaft downstream, seating/breakout torque is
shown as:
Tbo = TP + TS + Pmax (CB + Cs) + TH

(16.108)

For shaft upstream, seating/breakout torque is shown


as:

Pmax = Pressure drop (lb/in2) across the valve when


valve is in the closed position.
TD = Dynamic torque (in-lb) is the torque required
to overcome the torque on the closure member caused by the fluid-dynamic forces on the
ball.
Peff = Actual pressure drop (lb/in2) across the valve
at the flowing condition which occurs when
the valve is in an open position. Peff is less
than or equal to P(choked).
Pchoked = FL2(P1 - FfPV)
(16.111)
Where: FL = Valve recovery coefficient
(See Table 16-XXXIV)
P1 = Upstream pressure, psia
Ff = Liquid critical pressure ratio
Pv = Vapor pressure of liquid, psia
CB = Bearing torque factor (in3). As the pressure
across the valve increases, the force on the
bearings increases proportionally.
CB(P) = bearing torque (in-lb).
(See Table 16-XXXVI)

Tbo = TP + TS + Pmax (CB) + A + TH

(16.109)

NOTE: A = (TS - P(CS). If A is less than zero, enter zero


for A.
In liquid service applications, the dynamic torque must
also be determined. Actuator sizing is based on the
seating/breakout torque and dynamic torque. To determine dynamic torque, use the following equation:
TD = TP + Peff(CD + CB)

(16.110)

CS = Seat torque factor (in3). As the pressure


across the valve increases, the force at which
the seat pushes into the ball increases (shaft
downstream) or decreases (shaft upstream).
(See Table 16-XXXVI)
CD = Dynamic torque factor. (See Table 16XXXVI)
TH = Handwheel torque. TH = 0 without handwheel
(See Table 16-XXXII)
16-23

Table 16-XXXIV:
Approximate FL
Percent of
Rated CV

Table 16 - XXXV:
Valve/Actuator Compatibility - ShearStream

Approximate
FL

10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100

Actuator
Size
(in2)

.90
.85
.82
.78
.73
.68
.65
.63
.62
.60

Spring
Size

Valve/Actuator
Compatibility
Valve Size (inches)
1

STD. 25

STD.

STD. 25
STD. 50

H.D.
STD.

STD. 50
STD. 100

H.D.
STD.

STD. 100
STD. 200

H.D.
STD.

STD. 200

H.D.

1.5

10

12

Table 16-XXXVI: ShearStream Static Torques - Sizing


Valve
Size

TP=Packing Torque
(in-lb)

TS=Seat
Torque

CB=Bearing
Torque Factor

(in.)

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(in-lb)

(6)

(7)

1
11/2
2
3
4
6
8
10
12

43
50
50
57
57
71
71
104
104

228
280
280
333
333
438
438
648
648

421
477
477
533
533
646
646
870
870

301
350
350
399
399
496
496
691
691

57
63
63
71
71
92
92
151
151

20
40
60
150
360
540
670
1100
1300

0.06
0.06
0.06
0.19
0.38
0.97
1.58
4.38
5.61

0.09
0.09
0.09
0.28
0.58
1.45
2.37
6.57
8.41

(1) TFE or filled TFE V-ring packing


(2) Grafoil
(3) Twin Grafoil
(4) Asbestos-free packing (AFP)

16-24

(5) Braided PTFE


(6) TFE lined bearings
(7) Metal bearings

CS=Seat
CD = Dynamic
Torque Factor Torque Factor
60O
0.1
0.1
0.15
0.42
0.82
1.64
2.62
4.55
6.05

90O

0.25
0.6
0.5
1.0
1.0
2.1
4.5
8.0
10.0
17.0
19.5
30.5
52.0
75.5
108.0 165.5
191.0 218.5

You might also like