Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org
DEALING WITH
POTENTIAL
NATURAL HAZARDS
n
Our proposition
Our trackrecord
PROJECTZONE
15
Countries
El Salvador
Guatemala
Honduras
Partners united
in the Central
American Alliance
for Resilience
114
16
Communities
Projects
2,7
Million Euros
in 2013
100.000
beneficiaries
Pool of Trainers
ASPRODE/
CORDAID
CORDAID
WHERE WE WORK
99
2,000
43
network partners
CONTACT
Jeannette Hamersma
Programme Officer DRR/DR
Central America
Jeannette.hamersma@cordaid.nl
years experience
35
countries
Join us at
www.cordaid.org
540
staff worldwide
projects
459
field partners
36
funding partners
35
strategic partners
21
knowledge partners
20
alliances
CONTENT
OUR PROPOSITION
PREPARING HIGH RISK COMMUNITIES TO DEAL WITH
POTENTIAL NATURAL HAZARDS
Towards a resilient Central America
POOL OF TRAINERS
Building Resilient Communities
OUR TRACKRECORD
BUILDING RESILIENCE IN THE COMMUNITIES OF RO PAZ
Water management, reforestation and food security
13
15
19
MOUNTAIN MICROORGANISMS
Ecosystem Management: a pilot project
21
23
LAS VUELTAS
Strengthening Local Capacities for Water Resources Management
25
27
29
33
35
LA ASOMADA
Building Community Resilience
37
39
IMPACT STUDY
REGIONAL IMPACT STUDY OF THE CMDRR
Program in Central America
43
PARTNERORGANIZATIONS
Partnerorganizations are united in the Central American Alliance for
Resilience. This Alliance has one programme with a focus on water and soil
and community resilience. All the projects are united under one contract
with ASPRODE, the Central American community managed DRR/DR
office with headquarters in San Salvador. In Guatemala, Caritas Zacapa is
working on a project for capacity building and community management.
Caritas Zacapa is part of a large consortium consisting also of Care,
Red Cross Climate Centre and Wetlands International. In the same country,
the organization Colectivo Madre Selva works closely with Ceicom
(of El Salvador) in a project that seeks to stop the operation of the Cerro
Blanco mine located near the border with El Salvador.
With Asoseprodi and other partner organizations in Guatemala Cordaid
supports an emergency programme after the earthquake of November 2012.
RESULTS
n The communities have strong and representative
community organizations (Community
Development Associations, Committees of Risk
Reduction, Emergency Committees, among others),
composed of representatives of different age groups
and geographical areas, in addition to groups
or organizations specific to women, youth and
children.
n The communities conduct their own risk
analysis, define their risk mitigation plans and
contingency plans, and present them to public
and private institutions succeeding support for
their infrastructural projects such as roads, water
systems and sanitation, among others.
n Women play an active role in the community
and participate in decision-making processes.
Youth and adults are now working together
in community work, promoted by the use of
community video mostly by young people as a tool
for disaster risk reduction.
n Because of our intervention in communities
the paternalistic culture has been reduced and
in an emergency, people implement their own
contingency plans and take community action
without waiting for external entities involved in
the internal dynamics of the community.
THE FUTURE
Cordaid supports in the region together with NIMD a project that promotes
democratic dialogue between civil society and politics on safe environment.
The focus region is the three country area of Trifinio.
CONTACT
Jeannette Hamersma
Programme Officer CMDRR
Central America
Jeannette.hamersma@cordaid.nl
POOL OF TRAINERS
BUILDING RESILIENT
COMMUNITIES
The Pool of Trainers proposes a shift in attitude amongst people from organizations
and decision makers: a transformation from organizations that take control of DRR
actions in communities towards communities that take DRR and emergency actions
into their own hands
WHAT IS THE POOL OF TRAINERS?
We are a team of men and women who facilitate the Community Managed Disaster
Risk Reduction methodology. The focus of this methodology is the empowerment of
community members to take actions for themselves and create their own development.
It is a marvelous method that we didnt know about before. We are now trained to face
natural hazards and disasters, states Jorge Pineda, resident of the community Santa
Rita Cimarrn, Chalatenango, El Salvador.
We currently work in Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador, countries that are
vulnerable to various environmental and social-environmental hazards.
Within the field of risk management, there are many initiatives and methodologies that
are based on traditional risk management models in which organizations take control
of risk reduction actions in the communities. This limits communities development,
inhibits the strengthening of local capacities, and creates dependency. For the Pool
of Trainers, the role of external organizations is to accompany processes whereas
community members have active control over their processes and put concrete actions
into place that reduce risks in their surroundings and contribute to transformations.
We believe in peoples capacities. We believe that a world is possible where people in
communities use their power to change their reality and their future, states Maggie
Von Vogt, member of the Pool of Trainers.
Learn by doing!
For us, the best way to learn is by doing. We use participatory, non-traditional methods
that motivate people to use their knowledge and experiences and share it with others.
We believe that learning by doing is valuable and liberating, and for this reason we
choose to work this way and encourage people who participate in our courses to learn
by doing, as well. We promote exploring and learning together with communities,
PROJECTZONE
LESSONS LEARNED
VIDEO AS A TOOL
I asked myself where a video production group fits into all
of this, because when someone says video, you think of a
music video or a movie, but later on I realized that it was a
necessary and important element, because it means going along
documenting what happens in relation to the different dangers
that exist in the communitys surroundings, comments Carlos
Merlos, member of the youth video production team from the
community Sunapa, Chalatenango, El Salvador.
In the Pool of Trainers we believe that participatory video
is a valuable tool for disaster risk reduction. We facilitate
participatory video courses in which we show how this tool
empowers people, creates changes in attitude and perception,
and helps to tell stories about the realities in communities.
With these stories captured on video, it is also possible to go to
decision makers and make important changes.
duration
ADDRESS
3 years
start date
January 2011
investment
336,000 euros
CONTACT
Arnulfo Ayala Rodrguez
General Manager
arnulfo.ayala@asprode.org
10
OUR TRACKRECORD
IN DEALING WITH POTENTIAL
NATURAL HAZARDS
11
12
BUILDING RESILIENCE
IN THE COMMUNITIES
OF RO PAZ
WATER MANAGEMENT,
REFORESTATION AND FOOD
SECURITY
Every winter 16 communities are threatened with river flooding, causing loss of human
life and damages to belongings and livelihoods.
A PROJECT FOR COMMUNITY RESILIENCE
COMMUNITY HISTORY
During winter, the communities near Rio Paz are threatened by flooding,
causing disasters that have destroyed families livelihoods and forced them
to abandon agriculture.
Lands are used to plant sugar cane, which causes agrochemical pollution
and affects peoples health. People that work in the fields are especially
impacted, causing chronic diseases such as kidney failure.
13
PROJECTZONE
A joint agenda
There is a shared space between communities and
the municipality to build a joint working agenda for
local development.
Both the community and municipality are working
to reforest the banks of Rio Paz, developing
educational processes on environmental issues,
propose putting up barriers along the river, and make
up the Area Water Working Group, whose objective
is to achieve adequate management of the Rio Paz
watershed.
These actions described before are aimed at
developing a Sustainable Management Plan for the
lowlands of the Rio Paz area in the short, medium,
and long term. This is Plan is a model that can be
replicated on a national level.
Technical information
Water salinity studies were performed to determine
salt levels in well water, with results determining
that drinking water contains high salt levels, unfit
for drinking. A GPS system has been used to track the
flow of the river so as to later implement mitigation
and prevention measures.
PROGRESS
n Communities have made action plans based on their needs and have
identified hazards as floods and loss of terrains in the estuary of
El Tamarindo.
n The technical investigations and studies as the diagnostic report on
the mangrove forest and salinity studies of the area have important
information for decision making and the creation of more effective
disaster risk reduction work.
n It is important to continue with advocacy actions. The communities and
municipality have a joint agenda to work on DRR, resilience, and climate
change adaptation.
duration
ADDRESS
3 years
start date
January 2012
investment in the
first 2 years
100,000 euros
CONTACT
COMMUNITY ORGANIZATION
The three El Tamarindo, El Chino and El Guayabo are
organized in:
n Community Development Associations (ADESCOS
by its Spanish acronym)
n Community Civil Protection Committees
n Inter-communal Development Association
(ADICOS by its Spanish acronym), those working
with the Mayor and with NGOs on issues that
affect communities.
Angel Ibarra
Executive director
ibarrangel@gmail.com
14
RISK REDUCTION
BY RECOVERING FOOD
SOVEREIGNTY
MICRO-REGION OF
SOUTHERN AHUACHAPN
DRR initiatives
The Salvadorian Ecological Unit (UNES by its Spanish acronym) is implementing the
project Reduction of vulnerability to agro-climatic risks, through advocacy,
awareness raising, and implementation of agroecological alternatives in
12 communities (240 families-1,200 people) since January 2013.
UNES is a non governmental organization that fights for the protection and
conservation of the environment in El Salvador.
The objective of the project is to work towards food sovereignty and to reduce
non-sustainable agricultural practices. This will be achieved by community capacity
building and the implementation of adecuate agroecological practices.
15
DEMONSTRATION PLOTS
PROJECTZONE
duration
ADDRESS
3 years
start date
January 2013
investment in the
first year
122, 300 euros
CONTACT
Angel Ibarra
Executive director
ibarrangel@gmail.com
16
TOWARDS INTEGRATED
WATER AND
RISK MANAGEMENT
Cordaid, together with the Basque organization Euskal Fondoa, are supporting
this initiative which will directly benefit 7,000 people
The project Integrated water and risk management in the canton La Hachadura began
in December 2013 and will run for two years.
The objective of this project is that communities improve their capacity for an
integrated management of their risks and disaster response.
The beneficiary communities are: Hachadura town center, Paz and Progreso 1 and 2, and
the community El Guayabo, which all form part of the canton La Hachadura, located in
the municipality of San Francisco Menndez, Ahuachapn, El Salvador.
These communities are vulnerable due to their location on the lower bank of the Rio
Paz, a river that overflows every rainy season, causing serious damages, such as the
destruction of homes and loss of belongings, crops, and even life.
In addition, some families do not have access to clean water, as it is an area with an
increasing population and the existing water system is insufficient and does not supply
all residences.
WORKING TOGETHER
One aspect of this project is the way in which it will be implemented, which unites the
efforts of various actors.
It reflects an interesting cooperation model between the Dutch agency Cordaid, the Basque
organization Euskal Fondoa, the Municipality of San Francisco Menndez, the organization
UNES (Unidad Ecolgica Salvadorea), community organizations (Water Boards and Community
Development Associations), as well as the work of the communities themselves.
This type of intervention that involves different entities gives important value to the project
and impacts the expected outcomes of the project.
UNES, a local partner of Cordaid, is the organization that will implement components
3 and 4 of the project and has extensive experience working in the area. UNES has
supported community organization, risk management, land planning, and climate change
adaptation processes, amongst others. Components 1 and 2 will be the responsibility of the
Municipality of San Francisco Menndez and the involved communities.
17
PROJECT COMPONENTS
The project intervention is integral,
as it is composed of four closely related
components:
1. Improvement and expansion of the
potable water system in the four
communities.
2. Construction of mitigation works along
the banks of the Rio Paz.
3. Disaster preparedness and capacity
building on Community Managed
Disaster Risk Reduction.
4. Capacity building in communities on
the issues of food sovereignty and food
security.
ACTIVITIES
Some of the concrete actions within the
project are:
n Construction of a new water system for
475 families who do not have access to
this resource at home.
n Construction of a stone masonry
retention wall (Gabions retention wall)
on the banks of the Rio Paz, to help
avoid the flooding that often occurs
every rainy season in the town center of
the canton La Hachadura.
n Awareness-raising sessions on disaster
risk reduction.
n Installation of agro-ecological
demonstration plots using
permaculture techniques.
n Elaboration of community plans and
action strategies on disaster risks.
n Reconstruction and training for
four civil protection community
commissions on the prevention and
mitigation of disasters.
n Elaboration of four community civil
protection plans on disaster prevention
and mitigation.
n Training in the use of tools for disaster
prevention and response.
n Elaboration of maps and school
protection plans by students and
teachers from four local schools, using
the Community Managed Disaster Risk
Reduction approach
PROJECTZONE
A REPLICABLE MODEL
It is expected that this project will serve as an example that can be replicated in other
communities in the region.
It is important to emphasize that in order to achieve tangible outcomes and important
changes in the communities, active participation and join work is necessary between
different actors (local government, communities, NGOs and international cooperation
agencies).
duration
ADDRESS
2 years
start date
December 2013
cordaids
contribution
591,749 euros
CONTACT
ngel Ibarra
President
ibarrangel@gmail.com
18
STRENGTHENING CAPACITIES
FOR RISK REDUCTION
CONSTRUCTION OF
COMPOST LATRINES
Six communities in San Julin, Sonsonate, are working with the Community Managed
Disaster Risk Reduction methodology.
STRENGTHENING TECHNICAL, ORGANIZATIONAL AND
ADVOCACY CAPACITIES FOR RISK MANAGEMENT
The United Community Association for Water and Agriculture (ACUA by its Spanish
acronym) is a non governmental organization that works in processes related to water,
food sovereignty and sustainable agriculture.
ACUA is implementing the project Strengthening technical, organizational and
advocacy capacities for risk management with the objective of improving the quality
of life of 180 families (900 people) that face social, alimentary, and environmental
problems.
To achieve this objective and reduce the impacts of climate change, these communities
are working with the Community Managed Disaster Risk Reduction (CMDRR)
methodology.
The participating communities, Paniagua, El Milagro, Santa Luca, El Bebedero Arriba,
Parcelacin San Jos and El Cofre, were directly affected by the tropical depression 12E,
a climate phenomenon that provoked emergencies and severe damages all around El
Salvador. Floods and landslides were the most common consequences provoked by the
storm.
This experience motivated community leaders to seek help with the municipal
governments and ask ACUA for support on the issue of risk prevention.
The community of El Milagro is composed of 60 families that relocated to the zone after
their houses were damaged during the 2001 earthquakes. The community is located on
the La Pepesquera riverbed, which overflows and floods the community each winter. El
Milagro has shown high interest in the CMDRR process and excelled its organization.
19
A LEARNING PROCESS
The communities involved in the project
have completed their risks analyses, which
include hazard, vulnerability, and capacity
assessments.
They have also elaborated their community
planning. They created development plans
where they detail and prioritize their needs
based on the gaps identified in the risk
analyses.
Next, they planned community development
actions and contingency plans in which they
analyzed possible scenarios to identify what to
do in case of an emergency.
As part of strengthening community
capacities, 20 young people from 6
communities have been trained in the use
of video as a tool to reduce risks. This group
produces videos about different risks in the
community.
Organization
PROJECTZONE
ACHIEVEMENTS
In the community of El Milagro, a sanitation
project is underway that consists of constructing 45
composting latrines.
This is one of the needs prioritized in the
development plan, which responds to the hazard
of inappropriate waste disposal.
In five other communities orchards and fruit gardens
have been planted, plants barriers have been planted
avoid erosion of the soil, and cleaning campaigns
held, and drainage placed to avoid floods.
As part of the contingency plan, some people in
the community have joined the Civil Protection
Commission of the municipality, keeping them
alert and prepared in case of emergencies.
duration
ADDRESS
3 years
start date
January 2012
investment in 2 years
139,987 euros
CONTACT
acua@acua.org.sv
n Joint work: The six communities are organized, but they plan to create a joint work plan and
involve other organizations and local authorities, as well.
This could lay the foundation for creating a multi-sectored advocacy space for implementing
Community Managed Disaster Risk Reduction actions at a municipal level.
n Finishing the construction of 15 latrines.
n Continue with actions for environmental awareness, cleaning campaigns, planting natural
barriers, grow family orchards and make workshops about agriculture.
n Seeking food security measures for the involved families.
20
MOUNTAIN
MICROORGANISMS
ECOSYSTEM MANAGEMENT:
A PILOT PROJECT
Contributing to the preservation and restoration of ecosystems in the municipality of
Santa Isabel Ishuatn
MOUNTAIN MICROORGANISMS
The United Community Association for Water and Agriculture (ACUA) is a non
governmental organization that works in processes related to water, food sovereignty
and sustainable agriculture.
ACUA is implementing the pilot project Mountain Microorganisms with the objective
of promoting the use of them to contribute to the preservation and restoration of
ecosystems.
In this project, there are 60 families (300 people) from the Chiquilequita, La Ceiba and
Los Daz communities, from the Santa Isabel Ishuatn municipality, in the department
of Sonsonate, which is located 72 kilometers from San Salvador.
Changes
During many decades, the families that participated in the project have grown basic
grains, principally corn, bean, sorghum, and occasionally squash.
Their communities are now severely deforested, mainly because of destructive
agricultural practices that have damaged their soils.
Before the start of the project, the communities did not have knowledge about
sustainable agriculture, nor ecological practices which reduce their dependence on
agro-chemical products.
Now, the families of the involved communities have learned to reproduce the MM
and use them in agriculture, make organic fertilizers, prepare repellents for pests, and
21
PROJECTZONE
duration
ADDRESS
3 years
start date
January 2012
investment in
2 years
194,907 euros
CONTACT
acua@acua.org.sv
22
The Water Forum works against projects that threaten the sustainability of water,
such as metallic mining, large-scale dam constructions and others that decrease the
disposition and renovation of water and that put the quality of life of the Salvadoran
population in danger.
FIGHTING FOR WATER AS A RIGHT
The Water Forum works towards achieving the right, equity and sustainability of
water in El Salvador. It is a broad platform of the Salvadoran social movement that
brings together more than 100 nongovernmental organizations, churches, community
associations, funding agencies and municipalities.
Law proposals
Between 2006 and 2008, the Water Forum presented three law proposals to the
Legislative Assembly (Congress) that aimed to respond to the lack of water legislation:
n General Waters law proposal (2006)
n Drinking water and sanitation law proposal (2007)
n Constitutional Reform to recognize the human right to water (2008)
The Congress didnt review the proposals. The Water Forum updated the General Waters
law proposal and went back to Congress in 2011 to present it again.
Since there was still no answer, the Water Forum joined forces with El Salvadors
Human Rights Office and agreed to take the issue to the international level, presenting
a first report to the Inter American Court of Human Rights in October of 2011.
23
ADVOCACY ACTIONS
PROJECTZONE
A new fight!
Since 2012, a new struggle seeking sustainable water
management has been undertaken by the Water
Forum: Trans-border Waters.
El Salvador depends on its neighboring countries of
Guatemala and Honduras for its water. The basin of
the Lempa River is the main source of potable water
for the whole country, and it originates in Guatemala,
with many rivers from Honduras which flow into the
Ro Lempa.
A mega mining project Cerro Blanco located in
Asuncion Mita, Guatemala, is the greatest threat
for Salvadorans; along with the existence of other
exploration projects located along the Honduran
border.
IMPORTANT ACHIEVEMENTS
In April 2012, a positive result was achieved, when
Congress, with 81 votes in favor, approved the
constitutional reform to recognize the human right
to water.
Article 69, Section IV of the Constitution titled Public
Health, Food, Water and Social Assistance was
modified to state: All people have right to adequate
food. The water is an essential resource for life, and
therefore it is the States duty to preserve and take
advantage of water and to assure its access to all the
population.
After six years of fighting for a legal framework in
the country that regulates and assures sustainable
water management, finally on January 2013, the
Environment and Climate Change Commission of the
National Assembly started the revision of the General
Water law proposal presented by the Water Forum in
2011.
The Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources
presented its own proposal to the Congress, which is
also under review. The General Water Law contains
more than 100 articles. The objective of this law is:
To regulate the sustainable and integral water
management, no matter its location or physical
state, as an essential element for sustainability in
El Salvador.
duration
ADDRESS
3 years
start date
January 2012
investment in
2 years
214,228 euros
CONTACT
Xenia Marroqun
xenia.marroquin@asprode.org
24
LAS VUELTAS
STRENGTHENING LOCAL
CAPACITIES FOR WATER
RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
25
LESSONS LEARNED
1. It is necesary to raise awareness on the CMDRR
approach with organizations in the area in order to
strengthen the co-operation between them.
2. It is important to strengthen participatory facilitation
techniques to increase community participation and
inspire involvement in every stage of the project.
3. It is important to promote an integral vision of Water
Resources Management within the communities. Up
until now, the actions have generally been reactive.
4. Communities advocacy processes towards local
governments should be strengthened.
ACHIEVEMENTS
PROJECTZONE
Working together
There is an agreement with the municipality of Las
Vueltas to strengthen community organizations that
manage water systems.
There is also a tree planting campaign underway in
the areas where water springs collect water.
ACTIVITIES PROJECTION
n Experiment with mountain microorganisms for
treatment of greywater and water from tributaries.
The treated water will be used for fish farming and
irrigation.
n Implement sustainable agricultural practices such
as soil conservation projects, crop diversification,
elaboration of organic agricultural products, and
the collection and reproduction of mountain
microorganisms.
n Strengthen the group of youth video producers
in the municipalities of Las Vueltas and Nueva
Concepcin by improving their technical and
methodological abilities, facilitation skills, and
production of participatory community videos that
make an impact in the municipality.
CLEANING CAMPAIGNS
duration
3 years
start date
January 2012
investment in
2 years
154,234 euros
ADDRESS
Colonia Reubicacin 2,
Calle Principal, San Bartolo,
Chalatenango, El Salvador.
www.caritaselsalvador.org.sv
CONTACT
Eberto Domnguez
General Coordinator
negroeberto@gmail.com
Lorena Alvarenga
Monitory and Planing
lorena_ar7@hotmail.com
26
MOBILIZING COMMUNITIES
TO PROTECT VITAL
WATER SOURCES AGAINST
CONTAMINATION
Communities in El Salvador and Guatemala are struggling to stop the Cerro Blanco
mining project, which will cause pollution of important rivers in the region
THE FIGHT TO DEFEND LIFE IN CERRO BLANCO
On September 29th, 2007, the government of the Republic of Guatemala granted authorization
to the company Entre Mares de Guatemala S.A., (subsidiary of the Canadian company Goldcorp
Incorporation), for the extraction of metallic minerals through the mining project Cerro Blanco.
This project represents a high risk of environmental disaster on the border between Guatemala
and El Salvador. The contamination of the goldmine will go directly into the Osta River causing
pollution of riverbeds and riverbanks down river.
The mine will also affect the Gija lake, which flows into the Lempa River, the most important river
in El Salvador. Pollution by filtration of superficial waters will also generate mid-and long-term
impacts. The EIS (Environmental Impact Study) presented by Entre Mares/Goldcorp contains no
plan for the mitigation of these risks, especially once mining company has finished its activities.
27
THE GENERAL
OBJECTIVE IN 2013 IS:
To strengthen community and
social organizations capacities
for analysis, organization,
coordination, and elaboration of
proposals, implementing advocacy
and legal and diplomatic action
plans against the Cerro Blanco
mining project and in defense of
the cross-border water resources.
This objective will be achieved
by working on the following
guidelines:
Intensification of community and
partner organizations social and
political mobilization actions
Strengthening local capacities
to take actions to stop the Cerro
Blanco mining project.
Continue water monitoring,
a health baseline and the biomonitoring of micro-invertebrates
in order to show the social and
environmental impacts of the
Cerro Blanco mining project.
PROJECTZONE
ACHIEVEMENTS
1. Community awareness raising and organization
around the Cerro Blanco mine, Gija Lake and
Metapn municipality. Communities play an active
role in advocacy-based actions aimed at stopping
the Cerro Blanco Project.
2. Sharing experiences between community leaders
and improved coordination between the partner
organizations of Guatemala and El Salvador.
3. Communities have improved their abilities in
identifying aquatic invertebrates that indicate
water quality. Water quality has been monitored
from specific locations related to the Cerro Blanco
Project.
4. The Cerro Blanco project is considered a bi-national
issue, with the Salvadoran government placing it
on their agenda and increasing negotiations with
the Guatemalan government.
This has provoked reactions by congresses,
chancellors, Plan Trifinio, the Salvadoran Human
Rights Defense Attorney, The Central American
Parliament, governmental ministries and the
media.
5. There are two investigations conducted by national
and foreign experts that support scientific
arguments to pose technical questioning of the
Cerro Blanco mining project.
6. The Human Rights Defense Attorney has
elaborated a Special Report on the Cerro
Blanco Mine, questioning its authorization
and pressuring the Salvadoran government to
immediately declare in defense of the human
rights threatened by this project.
7. The issue of the Cerro Blanco mine has been
inclused in the 2013 agenda of the Interamerican
Human Rights Commission and will take more
force in during the year.
duration
ADDRESS
3 years
start date
January 2012
investment in 2 years
236,000 euros
CONTACT
Edgardo Mira
miedgar.mira@gmail.com
David Pereira
pereiradavid15@yahoo.es
28
STRENGTHENING THE
RESILIENCE OF COMMUNITIES
IN ZACAPA AND CHIQUIMULA,
GUATEMALA
Integrating DRR, Climate Change and Ecosystem management & restoration.
METHODOLOGY
Cordaids intervention
Out of the five organizations that form PfR, three have field work: Red Cross, Care and Cordaid.
The local partner of Cordaid in Guatemala is Critas Zacapa, which is working on the
Strengthening of Resilience in communities of Zacapa and Chiquimula project.
Critas, Dicesis de Zacapa is an organization of the Catholic Church of Guatemala that works
towards community development, equality and social justice in the departments of Zacapa and
Chiquimula.
The project is executed in eleven communities: two from the Camotn municipality and one from
Concepcin Las Minas (Department of Chiquimula), and eight communities from the Cabaas
municipality (Department of Zacapa). In total, there are 1,313 families that are being benefited.
(6,600 people)
29
RESULTS
PROJECTZONE
Communities resilience
1. The eleven communities within the project
have risk assessments and risk maps, as well as
development and contingency plans.
2. Drinking water projects have been implemented in
all the communities. Additionally, 4 thousand trees
have been planted as part of reforestation projects
in the watersheds that feed the communities.
3. There is a strong community organization. All the
communities have risk reduction committees, youth
video producers groups, women groups, environment
and agriculture brigades, among others.
4. New micro projects have been identified, to be
executed in the second semester. Projects such as
wood saving stoves, manure latrines and ecological
filters.
duration
ADDRESS
4 years
start date
January 2011
project Investment
CARITAS DIOCESIS DE
ZACAPA.
12 calle A, final zona 1. Barrio
La Laguna, Zacapa. Guatemala.
www.caritasguatemala.org
CONTACT
Christian Domnguez
Director
caritaszacapagt@gmail.com
30
IMPROVING RESILIENCE
THROUGH ALTERNATIVE
LIVELIHOOD
Eight communities from the Cabaas municipality, in the department of Zacapa,
Guatemala, are executing a project with the support of Critas Dicesis de Zacapa and
Cordaid.
The municipality of Cabaas is situated in the socalled Dry corridor that includes the
eastern and south-eastern areas of Guatemala. The average temperature on this area is
32C and can reach extreme temperatures of 43C.
The scarce rains of this area further deepen the difficulties of access to water and the
food security of the communities settling in the region.
Since december 2013, Critas Dicesis de Zacapa executes the Project: Improving
resilience through alternative livelihood, in Cabaas, Zacapa, Guatemala. This
project will last one year and will benefit 3,204 people (604 families).
The participant communities are: Cerco de Piedra, El Arenal, Los Encuentros, El Sols,
Sunzapote, Plan de la Cruz, Santo Toms and Lomas de San Juan. The objective of the
project is to strengthen the community resilience and to reduce the impact of the
drought in the community livelihoods.
31
PROJECTZONE
IMPLEMENTING ORGANIZATION
Critas Dicesis de Zacapa is the social arm of the
Catholic Church and has focused its efforts on
the support for the impoverished communities.
Critas is the local partner of Cordaid in Partners
for Resilience (PfR), where they work along with
the following organizations: Dutch Red Cross, CARE
Netherlands, the Climate Center of the Red Cross and
Red Crescent, Cordaid and Wetlands International.
In the context of this alliance, Critas executes a
Disaster Risk Reduction Project on the communities
of Zacapa and Chiquimula since 2011, including the
eight communities of Cabaas.
duration
ADDRESS
1 year
start date
December 2013
Investment
248,000 euros
CONTACT
Christian Domnguez
Executive Director
caritaszacapagt@gmail.com
32
PROTECTION OF WATER
AND TERRITORY
Community in action
The twelve villages have worked on their disaster risk reduction plans, development
plans, and participatory risk analyses.
Caritas has facilitated the process for the organization of 6 Local Emergency
Committees and 12 waterboards, which are trained to respond to threats to the reserve
such as mining and chemical use in agricultural production.
These committees are also working to reduce risks related to natural hazards that could
affect the forests, water, and the habitants of the region.
Mitigation activities
The buffer zone of the reserve is an area that allows for agricultural production. This
leads to deforestation as well as environmental contamination due to the heavy use of
chemicals that seep into the small water sources that supply water to the seventeen
villages of the La Labor municipality.
Despite the prohibition of human settlements in the nuclear protected zone of the
reserve, several families live here already for many years. Because of the lack of latrines
and waste management and chemical use in agricultural production, these families
33
PROJECTZONE
SOME ACHIEVEMENTS
n Fifteen young people in 6 communities of
Gisayote have been trained in the use of
community video as a tool to reduce risks.
n Members of the six communities have received
training in treatment of solid wastes and other
themes related to the care and defense of water
and the reserve.
n Caritas has assisted the 12 villages and 12 municipal
water boards. Thirteen local water boards are in the
process of obtaining legal status. Another major
result has been the formation of an organization
that includes the municipal water boards of five of
the municipalities that form part of the reserve.
n There is a consciousness raising campaign directed
to the local population, working with the local
media as well as local schools.
DEFENDING GISAYOTE!
LOCAL LEADERS
duration
3 years
start date
January 2012
investment in
the first
2 years
180, 307 euros
ADDRESS
Jos Romero
Director
jr.ramos1960@gmail.com
CONTACT
Pastoral Social
Critas de Honduras
34
THE GISAYOTE
BIOLOGICAL RESERVE:
A HERITAGE OF HUMANITY
35
PROJECTZONE
ORGANIZATIONAL
DEVELOPMENT
As part of the activities of the project,
training was included for technical
staff of Hermandad de Honduras on
the Community Managed Disaster Risk
Reduction (CMDRR) methodology and the
use of participatory video as a tool for risk
reduction.
This 10-day training was facilitated by
the Pool of Trainers (ASPRODE) and is
expected to strengthen the foundation
of facilitators work, as the CMDRR
methodology seeks to deeply analyze field
workers practices in their work with
communities.
This methodology is a unique
characteristic of Cordaid partners work
and the foundation of their philosophy on
working with communities.
duration
ADDRESS
1 year
start date
January 2014
Investment in
one year
128,000 euros
WORKING TOGETHER
Work in the municipality of La Labor will be
coordinated with Caritas Santa Rosa de Copan,
another organization that also works in the area and
is funded by Cordaid. This coordination will serve as
a means of sharing experiences, planning actions
together, and for policy implementation for advocacy
work with the local government and governmental
institutions.
Monthly meetings will be held between staff of the
two institutions to evaluate and plan activities.
Asociacin Hermandad de
Honduras, HDH-OPD,
Barrio La Herradura,
San Marcos, Ocotepeque,
Honduras.
ahdh@hermandadhonduras.com
www.hermandadhonduras.org
CONTACT
Jos Antonio Valle
Executive Director
jvalle@hermandadhonduras.org
36
LA ASOMADA
BUILDING COMMUNITY RESILIENCE
Communities working together for the defense of water resources, sanitation of the
Caje and Suptal River watersheds, and improved livelihoods
TOWARDS COMMUNITY RESILIENCE
La Asomada Community is located 17 kilometers north of the city of Gracias,
department of Lempira, Honduras, and is located near the crucial protected
area of the Puca Wildlife Sanctuary.
La Asomada is made up of approximately 1,096 families who produce corn,
beans, vegetables, and coffee and sugar cane on a small scale.
Currently, their production activities and their water sources are under
threat by resource privatization, deforestation, chemical use, and more.
ACHIEVEMENTS
n Active participation by community organizations in
every phases of the process.
n The communities understand and implement concepts
about disaster risk reduction, climate change and
livelihoods.
n All communities involved in the process have made
hazard maps. The principal hazards are drought,
agrochemical pollution, and deforestation, among
others.
PARTICIPATION
PROJECTZONE
INVOLVED ACTORS
IN THE PROCESS
Community Level: Members of
9 farmers associations, 4 water boards,
4 community boards, 4 womens groups,
4 ecclesiastical base communities, and
4 youth groups.
Municipality Level: The Municipalitys
Emergency Committee (CODEM in its
Spanish acronym) the local government
of Gracias, Lempira participate in
meetings with community members
where they work on water issues.
Regional Level: Allied organizations
for the defense of water, such as as the
Regional Board for Risk Management
Advocacy, The Puca Foundation, and
Jicatuyo Foundation.
duration
3 years
start date
November 2012
investment in the
first year
70,000 euros
Value
MORE
INFORMATION
Red Comal Alternative
Trade Network
www.redcomal.org.hn
ADDRESS
Km. 5, road to La Esperanza,
Siguatepeque, Honduras.
info@redcomal.org.hn
CONTACT
Jos Ismael Garca
Facilitator
joisma89@yahoo.com
Jess Misael Crcamo
Executive Director
jcarcamo@redcoml.org.hn
38
RIO BLANCO
MICRO WATERSHED:
SUSTAINABLE WATER
RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
The Rio Blanco Micro Watershed is an area of great importance because seven water
systems depend on it. These systems have been affected by landslides, flash floods,
soil erosion, and silt accumulations.
COMMUNITY MANAGED DISASTER RISK REDUCTION
IN THE RIO BLANCO MICRO WATERSHED
PILARH is a private, non-profit development institution with experience in
administering subsistence, land buying and microcredit projects. They have more
than 15 years of experience in the organization and strengthening of microbusinesses
and agricultural producers. PILARHs work area is centered in Western Honduras,
specifically the departments of Copn, Ocotepeque, and Lempira. PILARHs work is
centered on promoting the organization and strengthening of community groups in
order to create a basis for future business development.
THE PROJECT
Since January 2014, PILARH is administering the project
Community Management for Risk Reduction in the Rio Blanco
Micro Watershed. This project is supported by Cordaid and will
directly benefit 2,599 people. There are also an estimated 3,000
indirect beneficiaries located in the watershed area.
The project intervention area is located in the town of Las Flores
Lempira, specifically in the village of Mariposa, hamlet El Progreso
(of the same village), the village of Monte de la Virgen, and the
hamlets of El Plann and Corralitos, all located in the Rio Blanco
Micro Watershed (31.73 km2) within the Buffer and Influence Zone
of the Celaque Mountain National Park.
As a part of the project activities, it is contemplated that
communities start the Community Management for Disaster
39
PROJECTZONE
duration
ADVOCACY
ADDRESS
1 years
start date
January 2014
investment in
one year
104,700 euros
ORGANIZATIONAL DEVELOPMENT
As part of the project activities, a training for PILARH
technical staff on the Community Managed Disaster
Risk Reduction (CMDRR) methodology and the use of
participatory video as a tool to reduce risk has been
included.
This training has marked the starting point for
facilitators work with the beneficiary communities.
The CMDRR training is key for follow-up on project
activities and the communities progress.
CONTACT
aspilarh@pilarh.com
40
IMPACT STUDY
41
42
This article summarizes the most important findings of the impact study performed
on the Community Managed Disaster Risk Reduction CMDRR- Program in Central
America developed by Cordaid.
CORDAIDS RESPONSE
The programs work has various characteristics: capacities building; collective
construction of knowledge; political advocacy by communities and partner
organization, administration, and complementary fundraising.
In this context, Asprode cooperates with organizations and networks with political
influence and capacities at national and international level, focusing on actions related
to sustainable water management, climate change and organic agriculture.
This has resulted in law proposals, actions to defend water, and pressure towards local
authorities to assign resources and determine budgets to improve drinking water
maintenance and access systems for communities.
43
IMPACT STUDY
The principal objective of the Impact Study was to determine in what
measure Cordaids CMDRR Program in the last 4-5 years in Central America,
has contributed in building resilient communities. The objective was to
determine if CMDRR is a pertinent, effective and sustainable approach for
enhancing the resilience of communities in zones affected by recurrent
natural hazards such as floods, hurricanes, droughts and others.
Partner Organizations
At geographical level, Cordaids CMDRR program in Central America is
conducted in:
a) El Salvador with 4 Partner Organizations: ASPRODE, that coordinates the
program, the United Community Association for Water and Agriculture
(ACUA by its Spanish acronym), Critas Chalatenango and the Salvadorian
Ecological Unit (UNES by its Spanish acronym).
b) In Honduras: Critas Santa Rosa de Copn, and the diocese of the same
name.
c) In Guatemala: Critas Zacapa, in its first phase, as nowadays it forms
part of the Partners for Resilience program, executed by 5 Dutch
organizations.
Additionally, the synergy of the projects and partners of Cordaids Conflict
Transformation Program (CTP) with the CMDRR projects (from 2011) around
extractive practices (mining) in the border between Guatemala and El
Salvador and other zones of Guatemala that do not form part of the impact
study, but should be taken into consideration.1
1. Partner organizations in CTP program are: Pastoral de la Tierra de San Marcos, Collectivo
Madreselva (in Guatemala) and CEICOM (in El Salvador)
CHARACTERISTICS OF THE
COMMUNITIES
a. They are rural, poor communities that have been
affected by disasters (hurricanes, droughts, floods,
landslides) and find themselves in vulnerable
situations. Their livelihoods are based on the
harvest of basic grains. Most of them lack land of
their own, which is why they rent plots on which
they grow crops, often far away from their homes.
b. Lack of public transportation, roads in very bad
conditions (sometimes practically inexistent) and
in other cases, they are connected by suspension
bridges. Communities risk of getting cut off by a
natural phenomenon is high.
c. The communities are located in highly vulnerable
areas, some of them in high risk zones due to
their geographical location: between creeks
and riverbeds (for example, Cerco de Piedra in
Guatemala, El Corozal in El Salvador).
d. Political polarization affects the relationship
with local authorities, and lessens possibilities of
participation due to the involvement of political
parties and clientelism in municipalities. The 2009
coup dtat that occurred in Honduras has affected
situations in the communities and is increasingly
complex.
44
CONCLUSIONS
There has been a change in the general
situation of the communities, not
only at a physical level but also in the
communitys dynamics, in collaboration
networks and the solidarity between their
members and in joining efforts around a
work plan elaborated by the community.
Partner organizations now have trained
personnel (facilitators) in the CMDRR
methodology. The training experiences
have allowed clearing up and unifying
the conceptual frame for CMDRR,
which has set the base for a shared
(common) language between the partner
organizations and facilitators with
different experiences and backgrounds.
The CMDRR methodology has allowed
exploration and implementation of
different participatory techniques,
which has created spaces for sharing and
discussions about the difficulties and
realities on community and institutional
levels.
The application of the CMDRR
methodology has contributed to the
development of facilitators skills
and experiences. Within the partner
organizations there is openness and
RECOMENDATIONS
The recommendations are principally related to the
communities, such as coordination and relationships
with the municipality with the goal of activating
communication, strengthening local actions and
advocacy plans, and increasing inter-institutional
coordination within the communities.
Other recommendations are directed to the partner
organizations and are related to the need of having
educational plans for facilitators, and institutional
development plans, which implies reviewing criteria,
strategies, politics and mechanisms in order to
articulate and coordinate the different programs that
the partner organizations implement in the same
communities where the CMDRR Program is active.
There are recommendations to seek information
regarding water systems in communities and their
relation with Climate Change (identification of the
hydric recharge areas for a zone, the pollution points,
etc.). The importance of studies that transcend the
communities and focus on riverbeds in several
municipalities has to be considered.
45
46
47
CARE.
ACT.
SHARE.
LIKE CORDAID.
Contact
P.O. Box 16440
2500 BK The Hague
The Netherlands
+31(0)70-31 36 300
cordaid@cordaid.nl
www.cordaid.org