Professional Documents
Culture Documents
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
Background
This toolkit has been produced to help library professionals to plan and
implement arts-led consultation.
The suggestions and ideas contained in this toolkit are the result of a Laser
Foundation funded consultation project undertaken by Bolton Libraries
between July and December 2005. Bolton Libraries used arts-based
consultation techniques to consult with the local community about a project to
demolish an existing library and to replace it with a new library building. The
library in question was in a disadvantaged area of Bolton with a large Asian
population. Bolton Libraries were aware that the community might be
alienated by traditional consultation methods such as questionnaires and
focus groups. As an alternative Bolton Libraries wished to test new and
innovative ways of consulting with culturally diverse communities.
Although the model used by Bolton Libraries was devised to consult about a
new library, the techniques described in this toolkit could be adapted to
consult about any aspects of the library and its services.
If you would like to find out more about the background and the results of
Bolton Libraries consultation project the final report can be found at
www.bolton.gov.uk/libraries.
This Toolkit was written by Helen Thomas from Book Communications. The
ideas contained within this Toolkit have been informed by a variety of sources
and we would especially like to thank Angus McCabe, University of
Birmingham and Katrice Horsley, Katalyst Tales for the inspiration provided by
their 'Evaluation Cookbook' - produced as part of the National Evaluation of
the Children's Fund www.ne-cf.org
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
Contents
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
Contents
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
At the outset of the consultancy it is vital to set a clear and concise range of
objectives.
e.g. ‘The aim of the consultancy is to find out what products and services
local residents want from the new library and its role in the community’.
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
1. Consultancy Structure
The first stage of the planning process is to agree the overall structure of
the consultancy, to do this you will need to look at the following:
• Budget
• The number of sessions you want / are able to run
• Do you want to work with specific groups or have sessions that are
open to everyone, or a combination of both
• Are the sessions going to be one-offs or will you be working with the
same groups of people over a number of sessions
All of the above structures are of value. The structure you choose will be
influenced by budget and capacity. If your resources are limited try and do
a few things well rather than spreading the consultancy too thinly.
2. Budget
Create a realistic budget. This will also help to structure the project. You
might find the following budget headings helpful (all of these headings may
not be applicable to your project):
• Artists fees (consult your Regional Arts Board or, if you have one, your
authority’s Arts team about the minimum and maximum daily rates for
artists - usually it is between £200 and £250 + expenses)
• Project manager fees (for larger scale projects you may want to recruit
an external project manager - allow around £300 per day + expenses)
• Planning meetings (allow time to meet and plan before the project gets
started but also, especially for larger projects, you need to allow time to
meet during and at the end of the project)
• Materials (this will vary from session to session and art-form to art-form
but in the budget allow for £40 per session and then adjust once you
have final plans)
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
• Dissemination (how will you disseminate the findings and how much
will it cost– e.g. printed report, conference, exhibition)
3. Timeline
Create a timeline for the consultancy. Ensure that you have allowed
enough time for things such as Criminal Record Bureau checks (if
required), and recruiting participants. Check the dates of key events that
might effect the timeline e.g. Ramadan, major sporting fixtures etc.
4. Identify participants
Be wary of only consulting with those groups and individuals that are easy
to access. The balance and mix of the participants is a vital component.
5. Recruiting artists
If you are involving artists in your project you need to look for individuals
who fulfil the majority of the following criteria:
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
• Have worked with a range of different age groups and groups from a
range of different socio-economic and cultural backgrounds
• Have worked on projects that involved community consultation
6. Ongoing Management
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
If your project is using artists for delivering the consultancy they may need
training about libraries and library services. One tried and tested way of
doing this is to bring together the whole team working on the project
(artists, library staff, and partners) and provide them with a range of craft
and art materials. Ask them to create something that represents libraries
to them. Ask everyone to feedback on what they have created and why.
This is an innovative way of sharing views and perceptions about libraries.
It also gives library staff the opportunity to talk about what is currently
happening in the library service and perhaps start to dispel some myths.
Also if the artists lack experience in arts led consultation you may want to
consider a more experienced artist providing a day’s training around
community consultation.
If library staff are delivering the project you could consider bringing in an
experienced artist to run a day’s training. This should be a hands-on
session with the artist taking the trainees through a range of activities that
they could use in consultation sessions.
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
If you are delivering an ‘open’ session think about how you are going to
attract participants. Produce flyers and posters that can be distributed
through the library, other leisure providers, schools, community groups etc.
Keep the wording, presentation and tone of the publicity material in the
spirit of the project – creative, artistic, fun and interactive. Issue press
releases and if budgets permit place advertisements in appropriate local
media. Ensure that library staff are on board and encourage them to talk
to library users about what you are doing.
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
This section of the Toolkit presents a range of ideas for arts-led consultancy
sessions. It is divided into four sections:
a) Section one – ideas for ongoing activity that can be run in the library
on a rolling basis and needs little staff input
The majority of the ideas given in the first three sessions are ones which can
be delivered without artists’ input. If your consultancy project involves artists
your sessions could be more ambitious and use a wider range of more
challenging materials and art-forms. Often the process of an artist working
with participants using an interesting and surprising art form is enough in itself
to generate a creative and far-reaching conversation about the subject of the
consultation.
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
a) Section One
Ideas for ongoing activity that can take place in the library and needs little
staff input
Method;
Suitable for;
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
2. Spinning a web
Method;
Suitable for;
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
3. Branching out
Method;
Suitable for;
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
b) Section Two
Method:
• Roll out the paper and secure it to the floor. Draw a path on it
• Write home at one end of the paper and library at the other
• Ask participants to write or draw on their cut out feet something
that would encourage them to make the journey from home to
the library
• Ask participants to visually enhance their feet by decorating
them with either craft materials or dried foods
• Ask participants to place their foot onto the path
• Collate responses
Suitable for:
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
2. On Target
Method;
Suitable for;
All age groups. This activity works particularly well with young
children.
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
3. Library craft
Method;
Suitable for;
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
• Silk painting
• Rangoli (Rangoli is a traditional Hindu art – colourful designs are
made on the floor near the entrance to a house to welcome
guests during Diwali. It can be easily adapted to a range of
settings. Use chalk to draw a pattern on a hard surface – the
pattern can be anything you choose – leaves, symbols, random
shapes etc. Take a range of foods (lentils, sliced fruit and
vegetables, pulses etc.) and use these to fill in the pattern
• Collages
• Clay modelling
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
c) Section Three
Ideas for sessions working with specific groups over a specified time period
1. A thousand words
Method;
Suitable for;
All age groups. Especially useful for sessions with non-users of the
library.
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
Method;
Suitable for;
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
3. Cover version
Method;
Suitable for;
This activity works particularly well with teenagers and young adults
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
d) Section Four
Method;
Suitable for;
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
Ideally this activity should be run in conjunction with ‘Planning Aid’ to find
out details of your regional contact go to www.planningaid.rtpi.org.uk
• A map of the area you want to cover, which you can obtain from
your Local Planning Authority. It will probably be supplied on a
scale of 1:1250, this needs to be scaled down to 1:200 or 1:300
• Four polystyrene sheets (these can be obtained from a builder’s
merchant)
• Ready mixed water based paints
• Paper and card
• Building templates available from Planning Aid
• Cocktail sticks
Method;
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
Suitable for;
All age groups. Primary school children respond well to making the
model.
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
Stage Five :
Evaluation & Capturing Information
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
At the outset of the project you need to be clear about what information you
want to capture. Artists and facilitators need to record information during their
sessions or immediately afterwards otherwise thoughts and ideas will get lost.
In addition to recording essential information such as how many people
attended consultation sessions, gender, age and ethnicity you might want to
consider the following;
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
The ‘Art’ of Community ConsultationToolkit
Bolton Libraries 2006