You are on page 1of 66

2014

ASEAN CORPORATE GOVERNANCE SCORECARD ROUND 2014


SELF-ASSESSMENT

Table of Contents
PART A: RIGHTS OF SHAREHOLDERS .............................................................................................................................................................................. 1
A.1 Basic Shareholders Rights ................................................................................................................................................................................ 1
A.2 Right to participate in decisions concerning fundamental corporate changes. .............................................................................................. 1
A.3 Right to participate effectively in and vote in general shareholder meetings and should be informed of the rules, including voting
procedures, that govern general shareholder meetings. ............................................................................................................................................. 2
A.4 Markets for corporate control should be allowed to function in an efficient and transparent manner......................................................... 8
A.5 The exercise of ownership rights by all shareholders, including institutional investors, should be facilitated. ............................................. 8
PART B: EQUITABLE TREATMENT OF SHAREHOLDERS ................................................................................................................................................... 9
B.1 Shares and Voting Rights .................................................................................................................................................................................. 9
B.2 Notice of AGM ................................................................................................................................................................................................ 10
B.3 Insider trading and abusive self-dealing should be prohibited. ..................................................................................................................... 12
B.4 Related party transactions by directors and key executives.......................................................................................................................... 13
B.5 Protecting minority shareholders from abusive actions ................................................................................................................................ 14
PART C: ROLE OF STAKEHOLDERS ................................................................................................................................................................................ 15
C.1 The rights of stakeholders that are established by law or by mutual agreement are to be respected. ........................................................ 15
C.2 Where stakeholder interests are protected by law, stakeholders should have the opportunity to obtain effective redress for violation of
their rights. .................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 19
C.3 Performance-enhancing mechanisms for employee participation should be permitted to develop............................................................ 20
C.4 Stakeholders including individual employee and their representative bodies should be able to freely communicate their concerns about
illegal or unethical practices to the board and their rights should not be compromised for doing this. ................................................................... 21
PART D: DISCLOSURE AND TRANSPARENCY ................................................................................................................................................................. 22
D.1 Transparent ownership structure .................................................................................................................................................................. 22
D.2 Quality of Annual Report ............................................................................................................................................................................... 23
D.3. Disclosure of related party transactions (RPT) ............................................................................................................................................. 27
D.4 Directors and commissioners dealings in shares of the company ................................................................................................................. 27
ii

Annual Corporate Governance Report | Philex Mining Corporation

D.5 External auditor and Auditor Report ............................................................................................................................................................. 28


D.6 Medium of communications .......................................................................................................................................................................... 28
D.7 Timely filing/release of annual/financial reports ........................................................................................................................................... 29
D.8 Company website........................................................................................................................................................................................... 30
D.9 Investor relations ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 31
PART E: RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE BOARD ................................................................................................................................................................... 32
E.1 Board Duties and Responsibilities .................................................................................................................................................................. 32
E.2 Board structure............................................................................................................................................................................................... 34
E.3 Board Processes.............................................................................................................................................................................................. 40
E.4 People on the Board ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 47
E.5 Board Performance......................................................................................................................................................................................... 50
LEVEL 2 : BONUS ........................................................................................................................................................................................................... 52
PART A: RIGHTS OF SHAREHOLDERS ............................................................................................................................................................................ 52
A.1 Right to participate effectively in and vote in general shareholders meeting and should be informed of the rules, including voting
procedures, that govern general shareholders meeting. ........................................................................................................................................... 52
PART B: EQUITABLE TREATMENT OF SHAREHOLDERS ................................................................................................................................................. 53
B.1 Notice of AGM ................................................................................................................................................................................................ 53
PART C: ROLE OF STAKEHOLDERS ................................................................................................................................................................................ 53
C.1 The rights of stakeholders that are established by law or by mutual agreement are to be respected. ........................................................ 53
PART D: DISCLOSURE AND TRANSPARENCY ................................................................................................................................................................. 54
D.1 Quality of Annual Report ............................................................................................................................................................................... 54
PART E: RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE BOARD ................................................................................................................................................................... 54
E..1. Board Competencies and Diversity .............................................................................................................................................................. 54
E.2 Nominating Committee .................................................................................................................................................................................. 55
E.3 Board Appointments and Re-Election ............................................................................................................................................................ 55
E.4 Board Structure & Composition ..................................................................................................................................................................... 56
iii

Annual Corporate Governance Report | Philex Mining Corporation

E.5 Board Performance......................................................................................................................................................................................... 56


LEVEL 2 : PENALTY ........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 56
PART A: RIGHTS OF SHAREHOLDERS ............................................................................................................................................................................ 56
A.1 Basic shareholder rights ................................................................................................................................................................................. 56
A.2 Shareholders, including institutional shareholders, should be allowed to consult with each other on issues concerning their basic
shareholder rights as defined in the Principles, subject to exceptions to prevent abuse.rights as defined in the Principles, subject to exceptions
to prevent abuse. ........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 57
A.3 Right to participate effectively in and vote in general shareholders meeting and should be informed of the rules, including voting
procedures, that govern general shareholders meeting. ........................................................................................................................................... 57
A.4 Capital structures and arrangements that enable certain shareholders to obtain a degree of control disproportionate to their equity
ownership should be disclosed. .................................................................................................................................................................................. 58
A.5 Capital structures and arrangements that enable certain shareholders to obtain a degree of control disproportionate to their equity
ownership should be disclosed. .................................................................................................................................................................................. 58
B. Equitable treatment of shareholders ....................................................................................................................................................................... 59
B.1 Insider trading and abusive self-dealing should be prohibited. ..................................................................................................................... 59
B.2 Protecting minority shareholders from abusive action ................................................................................................................................. 59
C. Role of stakeholders ................................................................................................................................................................................................. 59
C.1 The rights of stakeholders that are established by law or through mutual agreements are to be respected. ............................................. 59
C.2 Where stakeholders participate in the corporate governance process, they should have access to relevant, sufficient and reliable
information on a timely and regular basis. ................................................................................................................................................................. 60
D. Disclosure and transparency .................................................................................................................................................................................... 60
D.1 Sanctions from regulator on financial reports ............................................................................................................................................... 60
E. Responsibilities of the Board .................................................................................................................................................................................... 61
E.1 Compliance with listing rules, regulations and applicable laws ..................................................................................................................... 61
E.2 Board Appraisal .............................................................................................................................................................................................. 62
E.3 External Audit ................................................................................................................................................................................................. 62
E.4 Board structure and composition................................................................................................................................................................... 62
iv

Annual Corporate Governance Report | Philex Mining Corporation

PART A: RIGHTS OF SHAREHOLDERS


A.1 Basic Shareholders Rights
Item
No.

A.1.1

Question

Does the company pay (interim


and final/annual) dividends in
an equitable and timely
manner; that is, all
shareholders are treated
equally and paid within 30 days
after being (i) declared for
interim dividends and (ii)
approved by shareholders at
general meetings for final
dividends?

Response

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

Page 42 of Management Report in DIS 20/ Notice of


AGM
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014%20D Companys dividend policy is to
efinitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf
distribute at least 25% of core net
income as dividends, and to pay
Glossy AR page 87
dividends within 30 days after
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/file/Philex declaration. (Last cash dividends was
%20Annual%20Report%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduc declared on February 26, 2014 and
ed.pdf
paid March 26, 2014 - 29 days after
declaration with February being a
Dividend Policy disclosure
short month.)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Dividend%
20Pay-out%20Policy(1).pdf

A.2 Right to participate in decisions concerning fundamental corporate changes.


Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Do shareholders have the


right to participate in:
A.2.1

Amendments to the
company's constitution?

Yes

A.2.2

The authorisation of
additional shares?

Yes

By Laws
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Amended
%20By-Laws(1).pdf

A.2.3

The transfer of all or


substantially all assets, which
in effect results in the sale of
the company?

Yes

CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PMC%20
Revised%20CG%20Manual(1).pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Shareholders have the right to


participate in as follows: (i)
Amendment of Articles of
Incorporation; (ii)
Increase of capital stock; (iii)
Sale or disposition, including the
constitution of a mortgage or a
pledge, of all or substantially all of
the Companys assets.

A.3 Right to participate effectively in and vote in general shareholder meetings and should be informed of the rules, including voting procedures,
that govern general shareholder meetings.
Item
No.

Question

A.3.1

Do shareholders have the


opportunity, evidenced by an
agenda item, to approve
remuneration (fees, allowances,
benefit-in-kind and other
emoluments) or any increases in
remuneration for the non-executive
directors/commissioners?

Response

Yes

Source/Link
CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userf
iles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20Manua
l(1).pdf
By Laws
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userf
iles/Amended%20By-Laws(1).pdf

CG Manual (page 18)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userf
iles/Corporate%20Governance%20Man
ual.pdf

A.3.2

Does the company provide noncontrolling shareholders a right to


nominate candidates for board of
directors/commissioners?

Website
Yes

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/corp
orate-governance/keypartners/shareholders
By-Laws
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userf
iles/Amended%20By-Laws(1).pdf

ACGR page 86

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

Shareholders have the right to participate in


the following: (i)
Waiver of pre-emptive rights for specific
transactions; (ii) Mergers and consolidations
(Sec. 77. Code); (iii) Amendment of By-Laws.

Company respects rights of the minority


shareholders and develops policies toward
ensuring that the Board will, in all cases,
consider the corporate interests as a whole.
Key guidelines include (i) emphasis on the
fiduciary responsibilities of the Board and the
officers to the Company and its shareholders,
and the duties of care and prudence; (ii)
emphasis on the avoidance of conflict of
interest and on prompt disclosure of
potential conflict; (iii) prompt, full, and fair
disclosure of material information; (iv)
adoption of policies on related party
transactions; and (v) other policies toward
avoidance of actions that will favor the
controlling or major shareholder/s at the
expense of the minority shareholder.
Right to nominate is corollary to the right to
vote, which is expressly provided in
Companys CG Manual and By Laws.

Item
No.

A.3.3

A.3.4

A.3.5

Question

Does the company allow


shareholders to elect
directors/commissioners
individually?

Does the company disclose


the voting and vote
tabulation procedures used,
declaring both before the
meeting proceeds?

Do the minutes of the most


recent AGM record that
there was an opportunity
allowing for shareholders to
ask questions or raise issues?

Response

Source/Link

DIS -20/ Notice of AGM page 23/ page 27 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014%20D
efinitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf
Yes

Minutes of AGM (page 2)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf
DIS -20/ Notice of AGM page 23/ page 27 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014%20D
efinitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

Yes

Minutes of AGM (page 2)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf
DIS -20/ Notice of AGM page 2/ page 6 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014%20D
efinitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

Yes

Minutes of AGM (page 8-9)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

Election/Voting Procedures are


discussed both in the Notice of AGM
and Minutes of AGM.

Proxies are tabulated and results


announced for each item on the
Agenda.

Recent AGM provided for an open


forum/Q&A for shareholders to ask
questions and/or raise issues.

Item
No.

A.3.6

Question

Do the minutes of the most


recent AGM record questions
and answers?

A.3.7

Does the disclosure of the


outcome of the most recent
AGM include resolution(s)?

A.3.8

Does the company disclose


the voting results including
approving, dissenting, and
abstaining votes for each
agenda item for the most
recent AGM?

Response

Source/Link
Minutes of AGM (pages 8-9)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf

Yes
ACGR (pages 81-82)

Comments

Questions and /or issues or concerns


raised during the AGM open forum are
part of the AGM minutes.

Minutes of AGM (pages 9-11)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf
Yes

Yes

ACGR (pages 82)

Minutes of AGM
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Minutes of AGM include all the


resolutions taken up during the AGM.

Voting results are disclosed and


included in the Minutes of AGM.

Item
No.

A.3.9

Question

Does the company disclose


the list of board members
who attended the most
recent AGM?

Did the chairman of the


board of
A.3.10 directors/commissioners
attend the most recent
AGM?

Response

Yes

Yes

Did the chairman of the Audit


A.3.12 Committee attend the most
recent AGM?

Yes

Minutes of AGM (page1)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf

Yes

Did the CEO/Managing


A.3.11 Director/President attend
the most recent AGM?

Did the company organise


A.3.13 their most recent AGM in an
easy to reach location?

Source/Link

Minutes of AGM (page1)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf

DIS -20/ Notice of AGM page 2/ page 6 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014%20D
efinitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf
Yes

Minutes of AGM (page 1)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

Attendance of the Board of Directors is


disclosed in the Minutes of AGM.

Attendance of Board of Directors in the


AGM
Directors Present:
Manuel V. Pangilinan - Chairman
Eulalio B. Austin, Jr. - President and
CEO
Robert C. Nicholson
Oscar J. Hilado
- Independent Director;
- Chairman, Audit and Risk
Committee
Eliza Bettina R. Antonino
Wilfredo A. Paras - Independent
Director
Bienvenido E. Laguesma
Barbara Ann C. Migallos -Corporate
Secretary

The AGM of Company was held at


Crowne Plaza Galeria Manila, Ortigas
Avenue corner ADB Avenue, Ortigas
Center, Quezon City, Metro Manila.

Item
No.

A.3.14

Question

Does the company allow for


voting in absentia?

Did the company vote by poll


(as opposed to by show of
A.3.15
hands) for all resolutions at
the most recent AGM?

Does the company disclose


that it has appointed an
independent party
A.3.16
(scrutineers/inspectors) to
count and/or validate the
votes at the AGM?

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Yes

DIS -20/ Notice of AGM page 2/ page 6 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014%20D
efinitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

Shareholders were given pertinent


proxy forms a month before the AGM
to allow them to votes for each item in
the agenda.

Minutes of AGM (page 2)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf
Yes
ACGR page 83

Yes

Minutes of AGM (page 2)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
NAL.pdf
ACGR page 83

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Voting is conducted by poll for


shareholders attending in person, and
tabulation of proxies for shareholders
represented by proxies.

Company disclosed the appointment of


independent party (e.g., Sycip Gorres
Velayo & Company or SGV & Co.) and
the independent election inspectors
(Messrs. Jose Pepito Zabat and Marc
Bonnie Wong) in the AGM to count
and/or validate votes.

Item
No.

Question

Does the company make


publicly available by the next
working day the result of the
A.3.17
votes taken during the most
recent AGM for all
resolutions?

Do companies provide at
A.3.18 least 21 days notice for all
resolutions?

Does the company provide


the rationale and explanation
for each agenda item which
A.3.19 require shareholders
approval in the notice of
AGM/circulars and/or the
accompanying statement?

Response

Yes

Yes

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

Co. Website:
Voting result are disclosed to the
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%202014
Philippine Stock Exchange and posted
%20Annual%20Stockholders%20Meeting.pdf
on the Companys website immediately
after the meeting.
Minutes of AGM
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%20Voting tabulation prepared by the
%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)%20FI
Companys transfer agent (Stock
NAL.pdf
Transfer Service, Inc.) is attached to the
Minutes of AGM as annex. All voting
ACGR page, 82
results for each agenda are reflected in
the tabulation.
Co. Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PMC%20Di
As early as February 27, 2014, the
sclosure%20-%202014%20AGM%20schedule.pdf
Company announced the details of
annual shareholders meeting on June
ACGR page, 80
25, 2014. These are posted on the PSE
website and the Company website.

DIS -20-(Notice of AGM) Details of Agenda


page 3-4 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014%20D
efinitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

The rationale and explanation for each


agenda is attached to the Notice of
AGM

A.4 Markets for corporate control should be allowed to function in an efficient and transparent manner.
Item
No.

A.4.1

Question

In cases of mergers,
acquisitions and/or takeovers
requiring shareholders
approval, does the board of
directors/ commissioners of
the offeree company appoint
an independent party to
evaluate the fairness of the
transaction price?

Response

Source/Link

Comments
As matter of practice, the Board either designates a committee of
directors or a senior officer to choose an independent consultant
and to formulate the objectives and parameters of the study and
the desired end product or deliverable, and evaluate fairness of
terms and conditions.

Yes

ACGR, page 88
In cases of mergers and acquisitions, the CEO and the CFO,
together with external financial and technical consultants, prepare
a detailed recommendation for consideration by the Board. An
independent party is named for a specific transaction. In most
transactions considered, an independent adviser is retained.

A.5 The exercise of ownership rights by all shareholders, including institutional investors, should be facilitated.
Item
No.

A.5.1

Question

Is the share ownership by


institutional investors, other
than controlling shareholders,
greater than 5%?

Response

Source/Link
Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/investorrelations/shareholder-matters/shareholdingstructure

Yes

Annual Report (Glossy) page 86/ page 88 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/file/P
hilex%20Annual%20Report%202013/PMC%20AR
%20Reduced.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

There are no controlling shareholders. SSS


and PCD Nominee are institutional
investors with share ownership greater
than 5%.

PART B: EQUITABLE TREATMENT OF SHAREHOLDERS


B.1 Shares and Voting Rights
Item
No.

B.1.1

B.1.2

Question

Do the company's ordinary or


common shares have one vote
for one share?

Where the company has more


than one class of shares, does
the company publicise the
voting rights attached to each
class of shares (e.g. through
the company website /
reports/ the stock exchange/
the regulator's website)?

Response

Yes

Source/Link

Corporation Code, CG Manual, ACGR


CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PMC
%20Revised%20CG%20Manual(1).pdf
By Laws
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Amen
ded%20By-Laws(1).pdf

Yes

Corporation Code, CG Manual


CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PMC
%20Revised%20CG%20Manual(1).pdf
By Laws
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Amen
ded%20By-Laws(1).pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

One share is entitled to one vote.


Cumulative voting, which enhances the
ability of minority shareholders in voting
for the election of directors, is allowed.

The Company has only one class of shares.


Each share has one vote.

B.2 Notice of AGM


Item
No.

B.2.1

Question

Does each resolution in the


most recent AGM deal with
only one item, i.e., there is no
bundling of several items into
the same resolution?

B.2.2

Are the company's notice of


the most recent AGM/circulars
fully translated into English
and published on the same
date as the local-language
version?

B.2.3

Are the profiles of


directors/commissioners ( at
least age, academic
qualification, date of first
appointment, experience, and
directorships in other listed
companies) in seeking
election/re-election included?

10

Response

Source/Link

Comments

DIS -20-(Annex to Notice of AGM of Philex Mining


Corporation - Details of Agenda) page 3-4 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014
%20Definitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

In the Notice of AGM, a detailed agenda


for each item is presented for resolution in
the AGM. There is no bundling of several
items into the same resolution.

Minutes of AGM (pages 9-11)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/PX%2
0%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%2025%202014)
%20FINAL.pdf

Minutes of the AGM discloses resolution


for each item in the agenda, and there is
likewise no bundling of several items into
the same resolution.

Yes

DIS-20/Notice of AGM
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014
%20Definitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

All notices/circulars are written and


published in English language.

Yes

DIS-20/ Notice of AGM Pages 7-9 / pages 11-13 of


link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014
%20Definitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

Directors profile, professional background


and other material information are
provided in the Companys DIS, GIS,
Annual Report, etc.

Yes

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

B.2.4

B.2.5

Question

Are the auditors seeking


appointment/re-appointment
clearly identified?

Has an explanation of the


dividend policy been
provided?

Response

Source/Link

Comments

DIS-20/ Notice of AGM Page 18/ page 22 of link


Yes

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014
%20Definitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

External auditors seeking reappointment


are clearly identified.

DIS-20/ Notice of AGM Page 42/ page 77 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014
%20Definitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf
Yes

Policy of Company is to declare cash


dividend of up to 25% of the Companys
core net income should the circumstances
allow for its declaration. Further, the
SEC 17-A Annual Report page 20 / page 22 of link) timing of payment will be within the 30http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/SEC_1 day period prescribed under corporate
7-A_2013_PMC.pdf
governance best practices.

B.2.6

Is the amount payable for final


dividends disclosed?

Yes

Dividends payable are disclosed. Dividends


DIS-20/ Notice of AGM Page 7/ page 211 of link
payable amounted to P483.4 million in
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014 2014 compared to P460.7 million in 2013.
%20Definitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf The Company declared cash dividends
amounting to P0.05 per share in February
SEC 17 A Annual Report - page 32 and 34 of link) 2014, representing regular dividends from
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/SEC_1 the Companys core income for the full
7-A_2013_PMC.pdf
year 2013. There were no dividends
declared in 2013.

B.2.7

Were the proxy documents


made easily available?

Yes

DIS-20/ Notice of AGM Page 24/ page 28 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/2014
%20Definitive%20Information%20Statement.pdf

11

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Proxy documents are attached to the


notice / DIS and are easily available to
shareholders.

B.3 Insider trading and abusive self-dealing should be prohibited.


Item
No.

B.3.1

B.3.2

Question

Does the company have


policies and/or rules
prohibiting
directors/commissioners and
employees to benefit from
knowledge which is not
generally available to the
market?

Are the directors /


commissioners required to
report their dealings in
company shares within 3
business days?

12

Response

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

Amended Policy on Dealings in Company Shares


of Stock
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Amen This is covered by the Code of Business
ded%20Policy%20on%20Dealings%20in%20Comp Conduct and Ethics and Policy on Dealings
any%20Shares%20-%20June%2025,%202014.pdf in Company Shares of Stock.
Code of Business Conduct and Ethics page 4
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/code
%20of%20business%20conduct%20and%20ethics.
pdf

Yes

This is covered by the Revised Policy on


Dealings in Company Shares of Stock.
Amended Policy on Dealings in Company Shares
Under the policy, all concerned directors,
of Stock
officers and/or employees to report to
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Amen Compliance Officer all respective dealings
ded%20Policy%20on%20Dealings%20in%20Comp in company shares within two (2) business
any%20Shares%20-%20June%2025,%202014.pdf days, and for the Company to disclose the
same within three (3) business days from
date of transaction.

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

B.4 Related party transactions by directors and key executives.


Item
No.

B.4.1

Question

Does the company have a


policy requiring directors
/commissioners to disclose
their interest in transactions
and any other conflicts of
interest?

B.4.2

Does the company have a


policy requiring a committee
of independent directors/
commissioners to review
material/significant RPTs to
determine whether they are in
the best interests of the
company and shareholders?

B.4.3

Does the company have a


policy requiring board
members
(directors/commissioners) to
abstain from participating in
the board discussion on a
particular agenda when they
are conflicted?

13

Response

Source/Link

Related Party Transaction Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Related
%20Party%20Transaction%20Policy.pdf
Yes
Conflict of Interest Policy
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Conflict
%20of%20interest%20Policy.pdf

Comments

This is covered by the Conflict of


Interest Policy and Code of Business
Conduct and Ethics.

Related Party Transaction Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Related
%20Party%20Transaction%20Policy.pdf
--

Yes

This is covered by Related Party


Transaction Policy. Review is conducted
by the Corporate Governance
Committee of the Board of Directors to
Charter of Corporate Governance Committee
ensure that all significant related party
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Corpora transactions are in the best interest of
te%20Governance%20Committee%20Charter.pdf
the Company and shareholders.

Conflict of Interest Policy page 9


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Conflict
%20of%20interest%20Policy.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

This is covered by the Conflict of


Interest Policy and the Code of Business
Conduct and Ethics.

Item
No.

B.4.4

Question
Does the company have
policies on loans to directors
and commissioners either
forbidding this practice or
ensuring that they are being
conducted at arm's length
basis and at market rates.

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Yes

Conflict of Interest Policy (page 8)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Conflict
%20of%20interest%20Policy.pdf

This is covered by the Conflict of


Interest Policy and the Code of Business
Conduct and Ethics.

B.5 Protecting minority shareholders from abusive actions


Item
No.

B.5.1

B.5.2

Question

Were there any RPTs that can


be classified as financial
assistance to entities other
than wholly-owned subsidiary
companies?

Does the company disclose


that RPTs are conducted in
such a way to ensure that they
are fair and at arms' length?

14

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Related Party Transaction Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Related%
20Party%20Transaction%20Policy.pdf
Yes
Charter of Corporate Governance Committee
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Corporate
%20Governance%20Committee%20Charter.pdf

Yes

Related Party Transaction Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/Related%
20Party%20Transaction%20Policy.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

This is provided in the Related Party


Transaction Policy to the effect that as
matter of policy, the Company shall at
all times abide by the standard that the
RPT is fair and at arms length.

PART C: ROLE OF STAKEHOLDERS


C.1 The rights of stakeholders that are established by law or by mutual agreement are to be respected.
Item
No.

Question

C.1.1

Stipulates the existence and


scope of the company's efforts
to address customers'
welfare?

C.1.2

Explains supplier/contractor
selection practice?

C.1.3

Describes the company's


efforts to ensure that its value
chain is environmentally
friendly or is consistent with
promoting sustainable
development?

C.1.4

Elaborates the company's


efforts to interact with the
communities in which they
operate?

15

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Yes

In line with Code of Business Conduct and Ethics,


SEC 17A/ Annual Report (page 6)
Company upholds fair and transparent dealings with
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
customers. Relationship with customers is governed
files/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
by long-term contracts.

Yes

Vendor Relations Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
This is covered by the Vendor Relations Policy.
files/Supplier%20Contractor%20Relatio
ns%20Policy.pdf

Yes

Glossy Annual Report


(Pages 66 -73 / Pages 68-75 of link)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/file/Philex%20Annual%20Report%
202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduced.pdf

Glossy Annual Report (pages 76-81/


page 76-83 of link)
Yes

Companys efforts are geared toward becoming a


socially and environmentally responsible company.
Related activities are discussed in the Companys
Annual Report.

Community programs are geared toward developing


livelihood and providing for their social, cultural,
educational, health, safety, and environmental
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
needs. Programs are discussed in the Companys
files/file/Philex%20Annual%20Report%
Annual Report.
202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduced.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Code of Business Conduct and Ethics


page 3
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/code%20of%20business%20condu
ct%20and%20ethics.pdf

C.1.5

Describe the company's anticorruption programmes and


procedures?

Conflict of Interest Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/Conflict%20of%20interest%20Poli
cy.pdf
Yes

Policy on Gifts, Entertainment and


Sponsored Travels
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/Policy%20on%20Gifts%20Entertai
nment%20and%20Sponsored%20Trave
ls(1).pdf

Policy of Company is to avoid the direct or indirect


commission of bribery and corruption of
representatives of government or regulators to
facilitate any transaction or gain any perceived or
actual favor or advantage, excluding permissible
additional payments for routine governmental
actions allowed by applicable laws and regulations.
Related policies are as follows: Code of Business
Conduct and Ethics, Conflict of Interest Policy, Policy
on Gifts, Entertainment and Sponsored Travels, and
Vendor Relations Policy.

Vendor Relations Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/Supplier%20Contractor%20Relatio
ns%20Policy.pdf

C.1.6

Describes how creditors' rights


are safeguarded?

16

Yes

As matter of policy, the Company upholds the rights


of its creditors by publicly disclosing all material
information, such as earning results and risk
SEC 17 A page 60;
exposures, related to but not limited to loan
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user covenants. Corporate disclosures, controls and
files/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
procedures include periodic reports to major lenders,
such as the latest certified financial statements,
among others.

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Does the company disclose the


activities that it has
undertaken to implement the
above mentioned policies?

C.1.7

C.1.8

C.1.9

C.1.10

Customer health and safety

Supplier/Contractor selection
and criteria

Environmentally-friendly value
chain

Interaction with the


communities

17

Yes

SEC 17A(page 4)
As part of commitment to welfare of customers, the
Page 6 of link
Company representatives and Company customers
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
meet annually to review and discuss for
files/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
improvements the operations and related activities
of preceding year..
ACGR page 62

Yes

Vendor Relations Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user Please see policy for details of selection and criteria.
files/Supplier%20Contractor%20Relatio
ns%20Policy.pdf

Yes

Glossy Annual Report


(Pages 66 -73 / Pages 68-75 of link)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/file/Philex%20Annual%20Report%
202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduced.pdf

Yes

Glossy Annual Report (pages 76-81/


page 76-83 of link)
Please see Annual Report for community
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
development activities.
files/file/Philex%20Annual%20Report%
202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduced.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Please see Annual Report for discussion of activities


undertaken by the Company to promote
environmental awareness and to show commitment
for environmental protection.

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Code of Business Conduct and Ethics


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/code%20of%20business%20condu
ct%20and%20ethics.pdf

C.1.11

Anti-corruption programmes
and procedures

Yes

Conflict of Interest Policy


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/Conflict%20of%20interest%20Poli
cy.pdf
Specific policies of the Company have anti-corruption
programmes and procedures which aims to uphold
Policy on Gifts, Entertainment and
the highest professional standards of business
Sponsored Travels
practices, core values and ethics in its business
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user dealings .
files/Policy%20on%20Gifts%20Entertai
nment%20and%20Sponsored%20Trave
ls(1).pdf
Vendor Relations Policy
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
files/Supplier%20Contractor%20Relatio
ns%20Policy.pdf

C.1.12 Creditors Rights

18

Yes

Glossy Annual Report (pages 46/ page


The Company provides periodic reports to major
48 of link)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user creditors, such as certified financial statements
files/file/Philex%20Annual%20Report% among others.
202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduced.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph
Does the company have a
separate corporate
C.1.13 responsibility (CR)
report/section or sustainability
report/section?

Yes

Comments

Sustainability in the Website:


Environmental Stewardship
Community Empowerment : H.E.L.P Program
-Health; Education; Livelihood; Public Infrastructure

Glossy Annual Report (pages 66-74)


Caring for the Environment
Nurturing Communities
Separate Section in the Glossy Annual Report for:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/user
Caring for the Environment
files/file/Philex%20Annual%20Report%
Nurturing Communities
202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduced.pdf

C.2 Where stakeholder interests are protected by law, stakeholders should have the opportunity to obtain effective redress for violation of their
rights.
Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments
Corporate Affairs: Atty. Michael T. Toledo, SVP for
Corporate Affairs

C.2.1

Does the company provide contact


details via the company's website or
Annual Report which stakeholders
(e.g. customers, suppliers, general
public etc.) can use to voice their
concerns and/or complaints for
possible violation of their rights?

Investor Relations: Mr. Rolando S. Bondoy,


Division Manager - Investor Relations

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ta
Trade Creditors & Suppliers Inquiries: Ms.
lk-to-us/corporate-address
Paraluman M. Navarro, Division ManagerCorporate Finance

Telephone No.: (632) 631-1381 to 88 / Email:


philex@philexmining.com.ph

19

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

C.3 Performance-enhancing mechanisms for employee participation should be permitted to develop.


Item
No.

C.3.1

Question

Response

Does the company explicitly disclose


the health, safety, and welfare
policy for its employees?

Yes

C.3.2

Does the company publish relevant


information relating to health,
safety and welfare of its employees?

C.3.3

Does the company have training and


development programmes for its
employees?

C.3.4

Does the company publish relevant


information on training and
development programmes for its
employees?

C.3.5

Does the company have a


reward/compensation policy that
accounts for the performance of the
company beyond short-term
financial measures?

20

Yes

Yes

Source/Link

Glossy Annual Report (pages 62)


Page 64-67of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/u
serfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Re
port%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduc
ed.pdf
Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/c
orporate-governance/keypartners/employees

Comments

The Company follows safety and health


management programs for its employees, host
communities, etc. This is in keeping with policy of
Company to respect the dignity and rights of its
employees, including the rights guaranteed by
existing labor laws, to promote safety,
nondiscrimination, environmental awareness, and
commitment in the workplace, and to support
programs that champion the engagement and
development of employees.

ACGR (pages 67-69)


Yes

Yes

ACGR pages 69-70

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Company adopted reward policy in the form of


Stock Option Plan that accounts for the
performance of Company beyond short-term
financial measures.

C.4 Stakeholders including individual employee and their representative bodies should be able to freely communicate their concerns about illegal or
unethical practices to the board and their rights should not be compromised for doing this.
Item
No.

C.4.1

C.4.2

Question

Does the company have procedures


for complaints by employees
concerning illegal (including
corruption) and unethical
behaviour?

Does the company have a policy or


procedures to protect an
employee/person who reveals
illegal/unethical behavior from
retaliation?

21

Response

Yes

Source/Link
Whistle Blowing (WB) Policy
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/u
serfiles/WHISTLE%20BLOWING%20
POLICY.pdf

Comments

Please refer to Policy.

ACGR pages 69-70

Yes

Whistle Blowing (WB) Policy and/or


procedures to protect from
retaliation
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/u
serfiles/WHISTLE%20BLOWING%20
POLICY.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Policy and procedure to protect employee from


retaliation is provided in the Whistle Blowing
Policy.
Please refer to pages 19-26 of WB Policy
- Discussion of Procedure for Complaints on
Retaliation.

PART D: DISCLOSURE AND TRANSPARENCY


D.1 Transparent ownership structure
Item
No.

D.1.1

D.1.2

Question

Response

Does the information on


shareholdings reveal the identity of
beneficial owners, holding 5%
shareholding or more?

Yes

Does the company disclose the direct


and indirect (deemed) shareholdings
of major and/or substantial
shareholders?

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

Glossy Annual Report (page 86)


Page88 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20 Please follow link for details.
Report%202013/PMC%20AR%20Re
The Company discloses the shareholdings of
duced.pdf
major and/or substantial shareholders on a
quarterly basis.
Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/i
nvestor-relations/shareholdermatters/shareholding-structure
ACGR page 74-75

D.1.3

Does the company disclose the direct


and indirect (deemed) shareholdings
of directors (commissioners)?

Yes

D.1.4

Does the company disclose the direct


and indirect (deemed) shareholdings
of senior management?

Yes

22

SEC 17-A Annual Report page 48 of


report/page 50 of link
The Company discloses direct and direct
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ shareholdings of directors (commissioners) and
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf senior management on a quarterly basis.

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

D.1.5

Question

Does the company disclose details of


the parent/holding company,
subsidiaries, associates, joint ventures
and special purpose enterprises/
vehicles (SPEs)/ (SPVs)?

Response

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

SEC 17-A Annual Report pages3-4


of report/pages 5-6 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ The Company discloses details of the
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf parent/holding company, subsidiaries,
associates, etc. as part of Corporate Profile in
Website
the Annual Report and website.
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
about-us/corporate-profile

D.2 Quality of Annual Report


Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Does the company's annual report


disclose the following items:

D.2.1

Key risks

23

Yes

Company disclosed in Annual Report the following


key business risks:
a.) Exploration and Development of Mineral
SEC 17-A Annual Report pages14- Deposits
17 of report/pages 16-19 of link
b.)Mineral Agreements, Permits and Licenses, and
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ Operating and/or Royalty agreement
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf c.) Operational Risk for Mining Operations
d.) Price Risks
e.) Environmental and Natural Events Risks

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

D.2.2

D.2.3

D.2.4

D.2.5

Question

Response

Source/Link

Does the company's annual report


disclose the following items:
Corporate objectives

Yes

page 11 of Glossy AR/ page 13 of


the link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ Corporate objectives are disclosed in the Annual
userfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20 Report and company website.
Report%202013/PMC%20AR%20Re
duced.pdf

Financial performance indicators

Yes

Company disclosed as part of financial and nonfinancial indicators the following:

Non- Financial performance


indicators

Dividend Policy

Yes

Yes

SEC 17-A Annual Report pages3537 of report/pages 37-39 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

Details of whistle-blowing policy

Yes
Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/WHISTLE%20BLOWING%2
0POLICY.pdf

24

a.) Safety Performance; b.) Earnings Per Share


(EPS); c.) Tonnes Milled and Metal Produced; d.)
Total Production Cost Per Tonne and Operating
Cost Per Tonne of Ore Milled, and Per Ounce Gold
and Per Pound Copper Produced e.) Exploration
Activities

Glossy AR page 87/ page 89 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
Dividend policy is disclosed in the annual report.
userfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20
Report%202013/PMC%20AR%20Re
duced.pdf
SEC 17-A Annual Report pages6061 of report/pages 62-63 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

D.2.6

Comments

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Details of Whistle-Blowing Policy are provided in


website and discussed in the annual report.

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

SEC 17-A Annual Report pages4143 of report/pages 43-45of link

D.2.7

Biographical details (at least age,


qualifications, date of first
appointment, relevant experience,
and any other directorships of
listed companies) of
directors/commissioners

Yes

Details and information (at least age,


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ qualifications, date of first appointment, and
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf relevant experiences) of directors/commissioners
are provided in the Annual Report.
Glossy Annual Report page 32-35
of report/page 34-37 of link)
Directorship in other Listed Companies are also
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ seen on page 42 of the glossy annual report and
userfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20 pages 53-55 of the SEC-17A
Report%202013/PMC%20AR%20Re
duced.pdf

SEC 17-A Annual Report pages5758 of report/pages 59-60 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
D.2.8

D.2.9

Training and/or continuing


education programme attended by
each director/commissioner

Number of board of
directors/commissioners meetings
held during the year

25

Yes

Yes

Directors trainings and seminars attended are


Glossy Annual Report page 44 of
disclosed in the annual report.
report/page 46 of link)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20
Report%202013/PMC%20AR%20Re
duced.pdf
SEC 17-A Annual Report pages 56
of report/pages 58 of link
Meetings and attendance are disclosed in the SEC
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
17 A annual report and Glossy Annual report.
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Attendance details of each


D.2.10 director/commissioner in respect
of meetings held

Details of remuneration of each


D.2.11 member of the board of
directors/commissioners

Does the Annual Report contain a


statement confirming the
company's full compliance with the
D.2.12 code of corporate governance and
where there is non-compliance,
identify and explain reasons for
each such issue?

26

Response

Yes

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

Glossy Annual Report page 43 of


report/page 45 of link)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20
Report%202013/PMC%20AR%20Re
duced.pdf

SEC 17-A Annual Report page 46Director receives per diem is P8,000 per board
47of report/pages 48-49 of link
meeting or committee participation attended.
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

SEC 17-A Annual Report page 64 of


report/ page 66 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Yes

Glossy Annual Report page 49 of


report /page 51 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
userfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20
Report%202013/PMC%20AR%20Re
duced.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Companys Annual Report contains statement of


conformance to corporate governance standards
and best practices.

D.3. Disclosure of related party transactions (RPT)


Item
No.

Question

Response

D.3.1

Does the company disclose its


policy covering the review and
approval of material/significant
RPTs?

Yes

D.3.2

Does the company disclose the


name of the related party and
relationship for each
material/significant RPT?

Yes

Does the company disclose the


nature and value for each
material/significant RPT?

Yes

D.3.3

Source/Link

Comments

Related Party Transaction (RPT)


Policy
Company has policy to review material and/or
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ significant related party transactions (RPT) in the
userfiles/Related%20Party%20Tran form of Related Party Transaction Policy.
saction%20Policy.pdf

SEC 17-A Annual Report pages 3739/ pages 39-41 of link


Details of RPT are disclosed in the audited
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ financial statements (AFS) of the Company.
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

D.4 Directors and commissioners dealings in shares of the company


Item
No.

D.4.1

Question

Does the company disclose


trading in the company's shares by
insiders?

27

Response

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

SEC 17 e company disclose trading


in the company's shares
Trading of Company shares by insiders are
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ disclosed in the annual report.
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

D.5 External auditor and Auditor Report


Item
No.

Question

Response

D.5.1

Are audit fees disclosed?

Yes

D.5.2

Are the non-audit fees disclosed?

Yes

D.5.3

Do the non-audit fees exceed the


audit fees?

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

Audit and non-audit fees of external auditors are


page 40 of report/page 42 of link
disclosed in the annual report. Non-audit fees
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/ exceeded the audit fee for the year on account of
userfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf required assistance in due diligence of Company
projects.

D.6 Medium of communications


Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
corporate-governance/companydisclosures/sec-filings

Please see link for the required disclosures, and


for the schedule of release of quarterly financial
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/i results.
nvestor-relations/calendar-ofevents/release-of-financial-results

D.6.1

Quarterly reporting

Yes

D.6.2

Company website

Yes

http://www.philexmining.com.ph

Yes

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/i Please visit our website at philexmining.com.ph.


nvestor-relations/companypresentations

D.6.3

Analyst's briefing

28

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.
D.6.4

Question
Media briefings /press
conferences

Response

Source/Link

Yes

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/
newsroom/press-release

Comments

D.7 Timely filing/release of annual/financial reports


Item
No.

Question

Response

D.7.1

Is the audited annual financial


report / statement released within
120 days from the financial year
end?

Yes

D.7.2

Is the annual report released


within 120 days from the financial
year end?

Yes

D.7.3

Is the true and fairness/fair


representation of the annual
financial statement/reports
affirmed by the board of
directors/commissioners and/or
the relevant officers of the
company?

29

Source/Link

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/in
vestor-relations/calendar-ofevents/release-of-financial-results

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/u
serfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

SEC 17A Annual Report page 67-68


of report/page 69-70of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/u
serfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Yes

Comments

Please refer to the Statement of Management


Responsibility (SMR) related to the fairness of the
Glossy Annual Report page 100 of
annual financial statements/reports of the
report/page 102 of link)
Company and signed by relevant officers of the
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/u
Company.
serfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Re
port%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduc
ed.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

D.8 Company website


Item
No.

D.8.1

Question

Business operations

Response

Yes

Source/Link
Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/investorrelations/performance-update/productionupdates
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/corporategovernance/company-disclosures/sec-filings

D.8.2

D.8.3

Financial statements/reports
(current and prior years)

Materials provided in briefings to


analysts and media

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/investorrelations/corporate-disclosures/financialreports
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/corporategovernance/company-disclosures/sec-filings

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/xoP
hilex_Analyst%20Briefing%201H2014%20Perfo
rmance[1].pdf
Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/investorrelations/shareholder-matters/shareholdingstructure

D.8.4

Shareholding structure

30

Yes

Glossy Annual Report page 86 of report/page


88 of link)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfiles/file
/Philex%20Annual%20Report%202013/PMC%2
0AR%20Reduced.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Website
D.8.5

D.8.6

D.8.7

Group corporate structure

Downloadable annual report

Notice of AGM and/or EGM

D.8.8

Minutes of AGM and/or EGM

D.8.9

Company's constitution
(company's by-laws,
memorandum and articles of
association)

Yes

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/aboutus/corporate-structure

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/investorrelations/annual-reports

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/corporategovernance/company-disclosures/notice-ofstockholders-meetings

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/corporategovernance/company-disclosures/minutes-ofstockholders-meetings

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/corporategovernance/documents-and-policies/by-lawsand-articles-of-incorporation

D.9 Investor relations


Item
No.

D.9.1

Question
Does the company disclose the
contact details (e.g. telephone,
fax, and email) of the officer /
office responsible for investor
relations?
31

Response

Source/Link

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/inv
estor-relations/contact-us/investorrelations

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

PART E: RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE BOARD


E.1 Board Duties and Responsibilities
Item
No.

E.1.1

E.1.2

Question

Does the company disclose its


corporate governance policy / board
charter?

Are the types of decisions requiring


board of directors/ commissioner
approval disclosed?

32

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Yes

Corporate Governance Manual


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/documents-andPlease refer to copies of the Company By Laws,
policies/manual-and-reports
CG Manual and CG Policies posted at Company
website.
Corporate Governance Policies
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/documents-andpolicies/policies

Yes

Corporate Governance Manual pages


5-8
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co Types of decisions and the extent of powers and
rporate-governance/documents-and- responsibilities of the Board are provided under
policies/manual-and-reports
the Companys Corporate Governance Manual
and under the Corporation Code of the
SEC 17-A 2013 Page 53
Philippines.
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

SEC 17-A Annual Report: (Page 5253)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
E.1.3

Are the roles and responsibilities of


the board of directors/
commissioners clearly stated?

Yes

Corporate Governance Manual:


Sections 2.1.3 to 2.1.5( Page 5-8)

Comments

Role and responsibilities of each Director are


clearly stated in the By Laws, Annual Report,
Corporate Governance Manual and the
Corporation Code of the Philippines.

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

E.1.4

Does the company have a vision and


mission statement?

33

Company vision is to a highly respected, worldclass natural resource company committed to


deliver excellent value to its investors,
employees, and other stakeholders.

Yes

Company Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/our-values-andCompany mission is to be a responsible mining
principles/vision-and-mission
corporation that discovers and processes
minerals and energy resources for the use of
society.

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Company Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/our-values-andprinciples/vision-and-mission

E.1.5

Has the board review the vision and


mission/strategy in the last financial
year?

Yes

CG Manual -page 6 / page 9 of link


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us Company vision and mission are reviewed by
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M Company on annual basis.
anual(1).pdf
Glossy AR page 44
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

E.1.6

Does the board of directors


monitor/oversee the
implementation of the corporate
strategy?

Yes

CG Manual
page 6 / page 9 of link
The Board oversees implementation of
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us corporate strategies as provided under the
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M Companys CG Manual.
anual(1).pdf

E.2 Board structure


Item
No.

E.2.1

Question

Are the details of the code of ethics


or conduct disclosed?

34

Response

Source/Link

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/code%20of%20business%20c
onduct%20and%20ethics.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

Item
No.

Question

E.2.2

Does the company disclose that all


directors/commissioners, senior
management and employees are
required to comply with the code?

E.2.3

Does the company disclose how it


implements and monitors
compliance with the code of ethics
or conduct?

E.2.4

E.2.5

Do independent
directors/commissioners make up at
least 50% of the board of
directors/commissioners?

Are the independent


directors/commissioners
independent of management and
major/ substantial shareholders?

35

Response

Source/Link

Yes

Code of Business Conduct and Ethics


page 7
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/code%20of%20business%20c
onduct%20and%20ethics.pdf

Yes

Code of Business Conduct and Ethics


(Page 7-9) :
Please refer to section on policy
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
implementation and monitoring.
erfiles/code%20of%20business%20c
onduct%20and%20ethics.pdf

No

Yes

Comments

Company has two (2) independent directors in


compliance with the Securities Regulation Code
SEC 17-A 2013: (Page 52-53)
which requires "at least two (2) independent
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us directors or such independent directors shall
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
constitute at least (20%) of the members of such
board, whichever is the lesser".
An independent director means a person who is
independent of management and who, apart
from his fees and shareholdings, is free from
CG Manual Annex 1
any business or other relationship with the
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
Company which could, or could reasonably be
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
perceived to, materially interfere with his
anual(1).pdf
exercise of independent judgment in carrying
out his responsibilities as a director of the
Company.

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

E.2.6

Does the company have a term limit


of nine years or less for its
independent
directors/commissioners?

E.2.7

Has the company set a limit of five


board seats that an individual
independent/non-executive
director/commissioner may hold
simultaneously?

E.2.8

Does the company have any


independent
directors/commissioners who serve
on a total of more than five boards
of publicly-listed companies?

E.2.9

Does the company have any


executive directors who serve on
more than two boards of listed
companies outside of the group?

36

Response

Yes

--

Source/Link

Under the SEC rules, an independent directors


may serve as such only for a total of five (5)
ACGR 2012
years. In case of reelection, the director must
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us comply with two (2) year cooling off period.
erfiles/Philex%20Mining's%20SEC%2 Under the Companys ACGR Year 2012, in case
0Annual%20Corporate%20Governan of re-election, term shall be limited to four (4)
ce%20Report%202012.pdf
years. To date, no independent director has
served for more than five consecutive years.

CG Manual
page 9 / page 12 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf
Directorship in Other Listed
Companies:

No
SEC 17-A Annual Report pages 53-55
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

No

Comments

Glossy Annual Report page 42


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Response

Does the company have a


E.2.10
Nominating Committee (NC)?

Yes

Does the Nominating Committee


comprise of a majority of
E.2.11
independent
directors/commissioners?

No

Source/Link

CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
Nomination Committee Members:
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
Manuel V. Pangilinan (Chairman)
anual(1).pdf
Juan B. Santos
Marilyn A. Victorio-Aquino
Website
Robert C. Nicholson
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
Wilfredo A. Paras (Independent)
rporate-governance/governancestructure/the-board-and-committees

No

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/governancestructure/the-board-and-committees

Does the company disclose the


terms of reference/ governance
E.2.13
structure/charter of the Nominating
Committee?

Yes

Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Charter%20of%20the%20No
minations%20Committee(1).pdf

Did the Nominating Committee


meet at least twice during the year?

Yes

Is the chairman of the Nominating


E.2.12 Committee an independent
director/commissioner?

E.2.14

Is the attendance of members at


E.2.15 Nominating Committee meetings
disclosed?

37

Yes

Comments

SEC17-A Annual Report (Page 57)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Glossy Annual Report page 44
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.
E.2.16

Question

Does the company have a


Remuneration Committee?

Response

Yes

Does the Remuneration Committee


E.2.17 comprise of a majority of
independent directors?

No

Is the chairman of the


E.2.18 Remuneration Committee an
independent directors?

No

Does the company disclose the


terms of reference/ governance
E.2.19
structure/ charter of the
Remuneration Committee?

E.2.20

Did the Remuneration Committee


meet at least twice during the year?

Yes

Source/Link
CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

Committee Members:
Juan B. Santos (Chairman)
Website:
Oscar J. Hilado (Independent)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
Robert C. Nicholson
rporate-governance/governanceEdward A. Tortorici
structure/the-board-and-committees
Wilfredo A. Paras (Independent)
SEC 17-A 2013 (Page 55)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Charter%20of%20the%20Com
pensation%20Committee(1).pdf

No

2012 ACGR
Is the attendance of members at
E.2.21 Remuneration Committee meetings
disclosed?

38

Yes

Comments

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Philex%20Mining's%20SEC%2
0Annual%20Corporate%20Governan
ce%20Report%202012.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

E.2.22

Question

Does the company have an Audit


Committee?

Response

Source/Link

Yes

CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

Does the Audit Committee comprise


entirely of non-executive
E.2.23 directors/commissioners with a
majority of independent
directors/commissioners?

No

Is the chairman of the Audit


E.2.24 Committee an independent
director/commissioner?

Yes

Does the company disclose the


terms of reference/governance
E.2.25
structure/charter of the Audit
Committee?

Yes

Does the Annual Report disclose the


E.2.26 profile or qualifications of the Audit
Committee members?

Yes

Does at least one of the


independent
directors/commissioners of the
E.2.27
committee have accounting
expertise (accounting qualification
or experience)?

Yes

39

Comments

The Committee Members are:

SEC 17-A 2013 Page 55:


Oscar J. Hilado (Chairman -Independent)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us Marilyn A. Victorio-Aquino
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Robert C. Nicholson
Eliza Bettina R. Antonino
Wilfredo A. Paras (Independent)
Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/governancestructure/the-board-and-committees
Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Revised%20Audit%20Committ
ee%20Charter.pdf

SEC 17-A 2013 - Page41 to 43)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
ACGR pages 43-44

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Did the Audit Committee meet at


E.2.28
least four times during the year?

Is the attendance of members at


E.2.29 Audit Committee meetings
disclosed?

Does the Audit Committee have


primary responsibility for
E.2.30 recommendation on the
appointment, and removal of the
external auditor?

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Yes

SEC17-A Annual Report (Page 56-57)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

Yes

Glossy Annual Report page 43


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

Yes

Audit Committee Charter page 2


Section 3
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Revised%20Audit%20Committ
ee%20Charter.pdf

Audit Committee is responsible for the


appointment, setting of compensation,
retention, removal and oversight of the work of
the External Auditor, in a manner consistent
with applicable laws, regulations and valid
corporate practice.

Response

Source/Link

Comments

E.3 Board Processes


Item
No.

E.3.1

Question

Are the board of directors meeting


scheduled before the start of
financial year?

40

Yes

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co Schedule is set at the beginning of the calendar
rporate-governance/governanceyear.
structure/attendance--appraisal

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

SEC 17-A Annual Report pages 56


pages 58 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
E.3.2

E.3.3

E.3.4

Does the board of


directors/commissioners meet at
least six times during the year?

Has each of the


directors/commissioners attended
at least 75% of all the board
meetings held during the year?

Does the company require a


minimum quorum of at least 2/3 for
board decisions?

41

Yes

Sixteen (16) meetings were held. Attendance


Glossy Annual Report page 43 of/
details are disclosed in the SEC 17 A annual
page 45 of link)
report and Glossy Annual report.
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf
SEC 17-A Annual Report pages 56 of
report/pages 58 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

No

No

Glossy Annual Report page 43 of


report/page 45 of link)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

ACGR page 32

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

In Philippine setting, there is no law or rule that


requires two thirds vote for Board decisions.
Effort is exerted for the Board to reach a
consensus before a vote is taken. When a
consensus is not reached, the vote may be
deferred to allow more time for discussions.

Item
No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

E.3.5

Did the non-executive


directors/commissioners of the
company meet separately at least
once during the year without any
executives present?

Yes

ACGR (Page 32):

A separate meeting of non-executive directors


without the presence of the CEO or any of the
executive officers is held at least once a year.

E.3.6

Are board papers for board of


directors/commissioners meetings
provided to the board at least five
business days in advance of the
board meeting?

Yes

ACGR (Page 33):

The policy is that board papers are provided to


directors at least five (5) days in advance.

E.3.7

E.3.8

Does the company secretary play a


significant role in supporting the
board in discharging its
responsibilities?

Is the company secretary trained in


legal, accountancy or company
secretarial practices?

42

Yes

Glossy Annual Report pages 48-49


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf
CG Manual pages 13-14
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Corporate%20Governance%2
0Manual.pdf

Yes

Glossy Annual Report pages 48-49


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

E.3.9

Question

Does the company disclose the


criteria used in selecting new
directors/commissioners?

Response

Source/Link

Yes

CG Manual Annex B:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

DIS 20 Notice of AGM pages 10-11/


page 14-15 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/2014%20Definitive%20Inform
ation%20Statement.pdf

Does the company disclose the


E.3.10 process followed in appointing new
directors/commissioners?

Yes

Are all the directors/commissioners


E.3.11 subject to re-election at least once
every three years?

Yes

43

Comments

.
Charter of the Nominations
Committee:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Charter%20of%20the%20No
minations%20Committee(1).pdf

By Laws Article 2 (Page 4) :


The Board of Directors shall be elected annually
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
at the regular meeting of the stockholders.
erfiles/Amended%20By-Laws(1).pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Response

Does the company disclose its


remuneration (fees, allowances,
benefit-in-kind and other
emoluments) policy/practices (i.e.
E.3.12
the use of short term and long term
incentives and performance
measures) for its executive directors
and CEO?

Yes

Is there disclosure of the fee


E.3.13 structure for non-executive
directors/commissioners?

Yes

Do the shareholders or the Board of


Directors approve the remuneration
E.3.14
of the executive directors and/or
the senior executives?

44

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

SEC 17-A Annual Report (Page


46/Page 63) :
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/governancestructure/remuneration-policy

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/governancestructure/remuneration-policy

As matter of policy, the remuneration of


directors and other officers must be competitive
and at a level that will attract and retain talent
and motivate them to continue their efforts in
contributing to the long-term success of the
SEC 17-A 2013 (Page 63) :
Company. The compensation is in accordance
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us with the Corporation Code and the Company
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
By-Laws or as approved by the shareholders.

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Do independent non-executive
directors/commissioners receive
E.3.15
options, performance shares or
bonuses?

Response

Yes

Source/Link

Directors are entitled to bonus equivalent to


Website
fees equivalent to 1.5 percent of income before
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
tax of Company, as provided in the Companys
rporate-governance/governanceBy-Laws. In year 2013, no bonus was given to
structure/remuneration-policy
the directors.

SEC 17-A 2013 (Page 59):


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
E.3.16

Does the company have a separate


internal audit function?

Is the head of internal audit


E.3.17 identified or, if outsourced, is the
name of the external firm disclosed?

45

Yes

Yes

Comments

Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/keypartners/internal-audit/

Internal audit group is a separate and


independent unit within the Company directly
reporting to the Audit Committee.

Head of internal audit is Ms. Geraldine B. AteoSEC 17-A 2013 (Page 59):
an who is appointed by the Management, in
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us accordance with the Company2013_PMC.pdf"
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
he external firm disclosed? t Committee. by the
Board and is set at P8,000 ($200). to

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Does the appointment and removal


E.3.18 of the internal auditor require the
approval of the Audit Committee?

Does the company disclose the


internal control procedures/risk
E.3.19
management systems it has in
place?

Does the Annual Report disclose


that the board of
directors/commissioners has
conducted a review of the
E.3.20
company's material controls
(including operational, financial and
compliance controls) and risk
management systems?

46

Response

Source/Link

Yes

Audit Committee Charter Section


3.2.1 (Page 4):
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Revised%20Audit%20Committ
ee%20Charter.pdf

Comments

Risk Management Policy, SEC 17-A


(Page 62):
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Yes
Company Website:
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/riskmanagement
SEC 17A Annual Report page 67-68
page 69-70 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Yes

This is part of the Companys Statement of


Glossy Annual Report page 100 /page Management Responsibility (SMR) of the
102 of link)
Company.
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Does the company disclose how key


E.3.21
risks are managed?

Does the Annual Report contain a


statement from the board of
directors/commissioners or Audit
E.3.22
Committee commenting on the
adequacy of the company's internal
controls/risk management systems?

Response

Source/Link

Yes

Major Business Risks, SEC 17-A 2013


(Page 14-17):
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

Yes

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/2%20Corporate%20Governan
ce%20Confirmation%20Statement%2
0%2002%2024%202014.pdf

Comments

E.4 People on the Board


Item
No.

E.4.1

Question

Do different persons assume the


roles of chairman and CEO?

47

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Glossy AR page 41 Composition of


the Board of Directors
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf
Yes

The Chairman & the CEO are held separately by


DIS 20/ Notice of AGM (Directors and unrelated individuals
Executive Officers)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/2014%20Definitive%20Inform
ation%20Statement.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

E.4.2

Question

Is the chairman an independent


director/commissioner?

Response

No

Source/Link

Glossy AR page 41 Composition of


the Board of Directors
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce Board Chairman is Manuel V Pangilinan who is a
d.pdf
Non-Executive Director
SEC 17-A 2013
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

E.4.3

Has the chairman been the


company CEO in the last three
years?

Yes

CG Manual Section 2.3, Page 10


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

E.4.4

Are the role and responsibilities


of the chairman disclosed?

Yes

Glossy AR page 43 - Chairmans Role


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf
Website
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co
rporate-governance/governancestructure/key-mandates/

48

Comments

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

E.4.5

Question

Does at least one non-executive


director/commissioner have prior
working experience in the major
sector that the company is
operating in?

Response

Yes

Source/Link

Atty. M. V. Aquino, a non-executive director, has


SEC 17-A 2013 (Page 53)
extensive experience in mining and natural
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
resources.
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

Glossy AR page 43 and 47


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

E.4.6

Does the company disclose a


board of
directors/commissioners
diversity policy?

Yes

DIS 20/Notice of AGM (Management


Report - Page 56 / Page 91 of link
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/2014%20Definitive%20Inform
ation%20Statement.pdf
SEC 17-A 2013 (Page 53)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

49

Comments

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

E.5 Board Performance


Item
No.

Question

E.5.1

Does the company have


orientation programmes for new
directors/commissioners?

Response

Source/Link

Yes

ACGR, page19

E.5.2

Does the company have a policy


that encourages
directors/commissioners to
attend on-going or continuous
professional education
programmes?

Yes

Glossy AR page 47
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

E.5.3

Does the company disclose how


the board of directors/
commissioners plans for the
succession of the CEO/Managing
Director/President and key
management?

Yes

E.5.4

Does the board of


directors/commissioners conduct
an annual performance
assessment of the CEO/Managing
Director/President?

Yes

E.5.5

Is an annual performance
assessment conducted of the
board of directors/
commissioners?

Yes

50

Comments
Directors orientation is held for new directors.
Orientation program includes mine site visit as
necessary.

ACGR page 10

Glossy AR page 44
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
On a yearly basis, the Board conducts an
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
assessment to evaluate their performance and
d.pdf
overall compliance with laws, regulations and
best practices.
CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

E.5.6

E.5.7

Question

Does the company disclose the


process followed in conducting
the board assessment?

Does the company disclose the


criteria used in the board
assessment?

Response

Source/Link

Yes

ACGFR, page 90

Yes

CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

Comments

E.5.8

Is an annual performance
assessment conducted of
individual
director/commissioner?

Yes

Glossy AR page 44
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
On a yearly basis, the Board conducts an
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
assessment to evaluate their performance and
d.pdf
overall compliance with laws, regulations and
best practices.
CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

E.5.9

Does the company disclose the


process followed in conducting
the director/commissioner
assessment?

Yes

ACGFR, page 90

Does the company disclose the


criteria used in the
E.5.10
director/commissioner
assessment?

Yes

CG Manual
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

51

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item
No.

Question

Is an annual performance
assessment conducted of the
E.5.11 board of
directors/commissioners
committees?

Response

Source/Link

Yes

CG Manual Section 2.2.3 (b)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PMC%20Revised%20CG%20M
anual(1).pdf

Comments

LEVEL 2 : BONUS
PART A: RIGHTS OF SHAREHOLDERS
A.1 Right to participate effectively in and vote in general shareholders meeting and should be informed of the rules, including voting procedures,
that govern general shareholders meeting.
Item No.

Question

Does the company allow the


use of secure electronic voting
A.1.1(B)
in absentia at the general
meetings of shareholders?

52

Response

Source/Link

No

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments
Printed proxy forms are distributed to
stockholders and are sent back to the Company
thru postal mail (free mailing cost), courier,
electronic mail (scanned copy), and /or fax
machines.

PART B: EQUITABLE TREATMENT OF SHAREHOLDERS


B.1 Notice of AGM
Item No.

Question

Does the company release its


notice of AGM (with detailed
agendas and explanatory
B.1.1(B) circulars), as announced to the
Exchange, at least 28 days
before the date of the
meeting?

Response

Source/Link

Yes

Minutes of AGM (page 2)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/PX%20%20Minutes%20AGM%20(June%202
5%202014)%20FINAL.pdf

Comments

Website

PART C: ROLE OF STAKEHOLDERS


C.1 The rights of stakeholders that are established by law or by mutual agreement are to be respected.
Item No.

Question

Does the company practice


C.1.1(B) integrated report on its annual
reports?

53

Response

Source/Link

Comments

Yes

Annual Report
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf

The Companys Annual Report includes


individual and detailed reports on its
sustainability and corporate governance
initiatives, financial performance, CSR programs
and other Corporate campaigns (e.g. Employee
Development Programs, Environmental
Management, Community Engagement)

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

PART D: DISCLOSURE AND TRANSPARENCY


D.1 Quality of Annual Report
Item No.

Question

Are the audited annual


financial report /statement
D.1.1 (B)
released within 60 days from
the financial year end?

Does the company disclose


D.1.2(B) details of remuneration of the
CEO?

Response

Yes

Yes

Source/Link

Comments

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/inv
estor-relations/calendar-ofAudited consolidated financial statement of the
events/release-of-financial-results
Company is released within 60 days from the
financial year end.
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/Press%20Release%20of%20Au
dited%20Financial%20Results.pdf
Annual Report (page 46)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us Remuneration of the CEO, together with other
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
key officers, are disclosed in the annual report.

PART E: RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE BOARD


E..1. Board Competencies and Diversity
Item No.

Question

Does the company have at


E.1.1(B) least one female independent
director/commissioner?

54

Response

Source/Link

No

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments
The two independent directors are male but
there are three (3) female directors in the
board.

E.2 Nominating Committee


Item No.

Question

Response

Source/Link

Comments

DIS 20/ Notice of AGM page 10/ page Process and Criteria for Selection of Nominees
14 of link
for Directors

Does the Nominating


Committee undertake the
process of identifying the
E.2.2(B)
quality of directors aligned
with the company's strategic
directions?

Yes

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us The Committee assessed the candidates


erfiles/2014%20Definitive%20Inform background, educational qualifications, work
ation%20Statement.pdf
experience, expertise and stature as would
enable them to effectively participate in the
Glossy AR page 41
deliberations of the Board. The Nominations
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us Committee screened the nominees to
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep determine whether they have all of the
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce qualifications and none of the disqualifications
d.pdf
for election

E.3 Board Appointments and Re-Election


Item No.

Question

Does the company use


professional search firms or
other external sources of
candidates (such as director
E.3.1(B) databases set up by director or
shareholder bodies) when
searching for candidates to the
board of directors/
commissioners?

55

Response

Source/Link

Yes

Glossy AR page 43
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/file/Philex%20Annual%20Rep
ort%202013/PMC%20AR%20Reduce
d.pdf
SEC 17-A 2013 (Page 52)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

E.4 Board Structure & Composition


Item No.

Question

Do independent non-executive
directors/commissioners make
E.4.1(B)
up more than 50% of the board
of directors/commissioners?

Response

Source/Link

Comments
Company is compliant with Philippine law that
requires minimum of at least 2 independent
directors in the Board.

No

E.5 Board Performance


Item No.

Question

Response

E.5.1(B)

Does the company have a


separate level Risk Committee?

No

Source/Link

Comments

Board of Directors Risk Committee is part of the


Audit and Risk Committee.

LEVEL 2 : PENALTY
PART A: RIGHTS OF SHAREHOLDERS

A.1 Basic shareholder rights


Item No.

Question

Did the company fail or neglect


to offer equal treatment for
A.1.1(P)
share repurchases to all
shareholders?

56

Response

Source/Link

No

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments
The Company does not have any share
repurchase program .

A.2 Shareholders, including institutional shareholders, should be allowed to consult with each other on issues concerning their basic shareholder
rights as defined in the Principles, subject to exceptions to prevent abuse rights as defined in the Principles, subject to exceptions to prevent abuse.
Item No.

Question

Is there evidence of barriers


that prevent shareholders from
A.2.1(P)
communicating or consulting
with other shareholders?

Response

Source/Link

Comments
There are no barriers and the Company ensures
that there is an open and effective
communication with all shareholders.

No

A.3 Right to participate effectively in and vote in general shareholders meeting and should be informed of the rules, including voting procedures,
that govern general shareholders meeting.
Item No.

Question

Did the company include any


additional and unannounced
A.3.1(P)
agenda item into the notice of
AGM/EGM?

57

Response

Source/Link
Notice of AGM
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/2014%20Definitive%20Inform
ation%20Statement.pdf

No
Minutes of AGM
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
erfiles/xxMinutes%20of%202014%20
AGM.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

No additional or unannounced agenda during


the 2014 AGM.

A.4 Capital structures and arrangements that enable certain shareholders to obtain a degree of control disproportionate to their equity ownership
should be disclosed.
Item No.

Question

Did the Company fail to


A.4.1(P) disclose the existence of
Shareholders?

Did the Company fail to


A.4.2(P) disclose the existence of Voting
Cap?

Did the Company fail to


A.4.3(P) disclose the existence of
Multiple Voting Rights?

Response

Source/Link

The company has always been diligent in


disclosing to the stakeholders material
information, including capital structures and
arrangements via the Securities and Exchange
Commission, the Philippine Stock Exchange and
the Companys website

No

No

No

Comments

Notice of AGM
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us No voting cap. Please see Notice of AGM
erfiles/2014%20Definitive%20Inform
ation%20Statement.pdf

Notice of AGM
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
No multiple voting rights. Rule is one share one
erfiles/2014%20Definitive%20Inform
vote. Please see Notice of AGM
ation%20Statement.pdf

A.5 Capital structures and arrangements that enable certain shareholders to obtain a degree of control disproportionate to their equity ownership
should be disclosed.
Item No.

Question

Is a pyramid ownership
A.5.1(P) structure and/ or cross holding
structure apparent?

58

Response

Source/Link

No

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments

B. Equitable treatment of shareholders


B.1 Insider trading and abusive self-dealing should be prohibited.
Item No.

Question

Has there been any conviction


of insider trading involving
B.1.1(P) directors/commissioners,
management and employees in
the past three years?

Response

Source/Link

Comments
The Company has enough policies and
procedures to address insider trading and other
related mal-practices among its directors,
officers and staff.

No

B.2 Protecting minority shareholders from abusive action


Item No.

Question

Has there been any cases of


non-compliance with the laws,
rules and regulations pertaining
B.2.1(P)
to significant or material related
party transactions in the past
three years?

Response

Source/Link

Comments
The company has always been diligent in
disclosing to the stakeholders material
information, including capital structures and
arrangements via the Securities and Exchange
Commission, the Philippine Stock Exchange and
the Companys website

No

C. Role of stakeholders
C.1 The rights of stakeholders that are established by law or through mutual agreements are to be respected.
Item No.

Question

Have there been any violations


of any laws pertaining to
labour/employment/
C.1.1(P)
consumer/insolvency/
commercial/competition or
environmental issues?
59

Response

No

Source/Link

Comments

Our commitment to faithful compliance with all


the laws and regulations are embodied in our
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/co key policy statements on:
rporate-governance/our-values-and- Environmental Policy; Human-Rights Policy;
principles/key-policy-statements
Ethics Policy; Intellectual Property-Rights Policy;
and Site Safety Policy

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

C.2 Where stakeholders participate in the corporate governance process, they should have access to relevant, sufficient and reliable information on
a timely and regular basis.
Item No.

Question

Response

Has the company faced any


sanctions by regulators for
failure to make
C.2.1(P)
announcements within the
requisite time period for
material events?

Source/Link

Comments
The company has always been diligent in
disclosing all material information, via the
Securities and Exchange Commission, the
Philippine Stock Exchange and the Companys
website.

No

D. Disclosure and transparency


D.1 Sanctions from regulator on financial reports
Item No.

D.1.1(P)

D.1.2(P)

Question
Did the company receive a
"qualified opinion" in its
external audit report?

Did the company receive an


"adverse opinion" in its
external audit report?

60

Response

Source/Link

Comments

No

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
The Company receives Unqualified Opinion.
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

No

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
The Company receives Unqualified Opinion.
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Item No.

Question

D.1.3(P)

Did the company receive a


"disclaimer opinion" in its
external audit report?

D.1.4(P)

Has the company in the past


year revised its financial
statements for reasons other
than changes in accounting
policies?

Response

No

Source/Link

Comments

http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
The Company receives Unqualified Opinion.
erfiles/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf

No

E. Responsibilities of the Board


E.1 Compliance with listing rules, regulations and applicable laws
Item No.

E.1.1(P)

E.1.2(P)

Question
Is there any evidence that the
company has not complied
with any listing rules and
regulations over the past year
apart from disclosure rules?
Have there been any instances
where non-executive
directors/commissioner have
resigned and raised any issues
of governance-related
concerns?

61

Response

Source/Link

The Company has been in compliant with all the


listing rules and regulations over the past year.

No

No

Comments

Notice of AGM (page 11)


No director has resigned or declined to stand for
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/us
re-election to the Board of Directors due to
erfiles/2014%20Definitive%20Inform
disagreement on any matter.
ation%20Statement.pdf

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

E.2 Board Appraisal


Item No.

E.2.1(P)

E.2.2(P)

Question
Does the Company have any
independent
directors/commissioners who
have served for more than nine
years or two terms (whichever
is higher) in the same capacity?
Did the company fail to identify
who are the independent
director(s) / commissioner(s)?

Response

Source/Link

Comments

No

Glossy AR (pages 34-35)


http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfil To date, no independent director has served
es/file/Philex%20Annual%20Report%202 for more than five consecutive years.
013/PMC%20AR%20Reduced.pdf

No

Glossy AR (page41)
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfil
List of Board of Directors and their position.
es/file/Philex%20Annual%20Report%202
013/PMC%20AR%20Reduced.pdf

E.3 External Audit


Item No.

E.3.1(P)

Question
Is any of the directors or senior
management a former
employee or partner of the
current external auditor (in the
past 2 years)?

Response

No

Source/Link

Comments

SEC 17 A Annual Report - page 43-45


The profile of the companys senior
http://www.philexmining.com.ph/userfil management can be read on the Companys
es/SEC_17-A_2013_PMC.pdf
Annual report.

E.4 Board structure and composition


Item No.

E.4.1(P)

Question

Is any of the directors a former


CEO of the company in the past
2 years?

62

Response

Source/Link

Yes

ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard | Philex Mining Corporation

Comments
On April 3, 2013, consistent with the
provision of the CG Manual that the roles
of Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
(CEO) shall, as practicable, be separate,
Mr. Manuel V. Pangilinan relinquished the
position of CEO, the Board elected the Mr.
Eulalio B. Austin, Jr., to the CEO position.

You might also like