c

WHITE BOOK
c
c
c
c
STUDY COMMITTEE 22 : OVERHEAD LINES
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
Prepared by :

SC22 Convenors
Bernard Dalle, Secretary
Paul Meyre, Chairman

December, 1998

page 1 of 10
c

WHITE BOOK
c
c



   

c
c
c
INTRODUCTION
P
c
cc
c


c 

ccc

cc

c

c 

cc

c


c

c c

c 
  cc
cc

c

c c

c 
 c c

  c 

c c 
c 

c   
c  c 

c


c

 

c
  

cc
 c
cc


c
c
cc
c


c
 
c
c

cc
c


cc
c 
c

c

c
c
c cc

c

c
c
P
c 

c 

cc
c 
c c c 
c


c c c

! c  

c c " c 
c 
c 
c 

c c  

c 

c 

c c


c
c cc
c
 
cc


c
c
cc#
c
c 
c
cc
c
 

c
 
cc


c
 c 


c c
c
$c
 c c 
c
 c 



cc 
c  %c c 
c
c  %c 
c   c


c 
c c c
c
c
c   
cc
cc
c
1. ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS AND REGULATORY CONTROLS
c

c
c

c
c
c
c
c
c

P
c
 
c cc

c

c 
c

cc 
ccc cc


c c 
c 

c 
c
c

c 
c
 c &'(
c $c

c c
P 


c

cc
c) 
c
cc % cc*+&*c 

cc
c

c  c 
c )
c c 

c c 
c ) 
c 
c 
c  c c


c  c 
c 

c
 c 
c 

c c

c  

c  c

c c

c 
 
c  

c 

c c 




c ,-c P.-c $/c
 c


c 
c

  c 
c c  c 

c
 c

c $c  %c
 c

ccc c
c


cc
c
 cc*+&0c 
c
c


c
c 
c  c c
c c 
c 
c 

c 
c  c    c
 

c c
c c #
c  c 
c
  

c c  
c  c c  c
c 



c c c 
c 

c c 
c 

c
 c


cc

 
 c


c



c 
 
c
c

cc
c



cc
c
 
c c
  c 
c c c 


c  
c 
c c 
c
 c #c

1

c c c 

c c  
c  c 
c 

c c 
c 
c 

cc
$

cc

c

c
c
c



cccc 


c
 c 
c c


c
c c

c

cc

c
c c
c 


c
c %
c c



c 
c c 
c 
c
 
c 


cc
P


c c

c 
c 
c c *++*c c 
c

c 2c  c


c 


c

cc$cc
 
c

c



c 
c2c
Jc


c
c

 

cc   c 


3c

 c c

c
c
c  cc

c

3c
Jc 1
c
cc
 
c

cc  c

c cc 
c

c


c
Jc

-c*++4cc
c
1

cc
c-5,)cP
 c

c  cc
c
 %c  c 
c

c c c  c c
 c c 



c c 
c




c 
c
 c  
c c
 
c 

c 
c
page 2 of 10

P 
c  %c  c 
c #c 
c


c c 


c 



c c



c c
 


c
c 

c c c 
  cc 
c c c
c
 

c c 
c 


c cc

c c  


c 

c c c

c
cc
c 


c
 %c
c
c

-
 c c 

c 

c c 
c
 
c 
c c 


c

c c 
c
6 
c *++0c

c c 


c  c
 
c 
 
c c c c

c  c 
c c 


c

c  c *++&c

c P
c 

c

c c
*++0c c 
c

c 



c  
c  c c  

c c  
c c

c


c c 
 c  


c  c c 

c 
c 

c c  
c c



c c  
c 

c  c 
c

c   

c c 

c  c


c c 
c 

c  c 

c  


c 

c $
c 
c 



c

c 

c 
c   c c 

c   
c  
c 
c  c 
c


c
c
c c
 cc
c cc
c
c
 %
c
c
c

cc
c
c c
  

cc


cc#
c
c


c
 
 
c 
1

c 
c 

c 


c c

c 

c 

c c 
c

 
ccc

c
c cc

c

c cc
cc#c
 cc


c 
c-c
c
cc c


c
1

cc

c


ccc
 
c
cc



c c 

cc  

c

c
c
2. COMPARISON OF HIGH VOLTAGE OVERHEAD LINES AND UNDERGROUND
CABLES
c
c -c

c 

c 
c c 

c 

c 
c 

c 
c c 
c c  cc

c c 
c  7
c 
c  c 
c  c
 
c 
c 



c 8

c


c c
c c
1
c c 
c c 1c

  c
c c c 
c
cc
c
c

c
c c

c

cccc


c
c 
  c
c

c

cc
1


c c

c

c
c
 
c
c 


c

cc
 ccc
c
c
 %
c 

c
c 
c
 
c

cc
c



c
c c  c
c
 %
cc
c
c 5-5,)c 

cc


c



ccc
 c
 c 
c
 cc

c  
c

c c c 9c : %c 5 c 9:5*;!'*c c
%
c
c 

c  
c  c    c



c c
 
c


c c


c

cc
 c 

cP
c9:5c
c 
cc

c


c c <.c 

c 


c c 1


c c 
c #
c 
c





c  c 04c 

c 
c 
c &0'c '''c %c c

c <.c 
c

c  


c  
c c 
c 

c  

c P
c 5


c  c 
c
 
c c < c .
c 

c 

c c 8
 c 

c =c *c >c


c c 
c 9:5c c 
c 

c  c ?c c  


c  
c 

c

 
ccc

c c'@?cc
c 
c
c 
c

c
c
c

page 3 of 10
c

A. PRINCIPLE OF OVERHEAD LINE DESIGND

c
c " c
c*+0'c

c 


c

c

cc 
  c

cc
c
 #
c  

cc

cc 

cc%cc

c

c 


c


c
 cc

c 
c

ccc
c 
c
cc c


c 
c  c 

c 

c c 


 c 

c c  
c 
c
c

c

cc
c 

cP 
c

c
cc
c c
c-)cc*++'cc 
c-)c&0ccc

 cc

c

c
c
c 
cc


c

cc

c 
c
c 

c


ccc
c c

c

c 
c 
c c 

c  c c  
c 
 c
c  c 
c

c

c c 
c 
c 
c c #c 
c 

c c   c 

c

1


c c 

c 
c P 
c  %c
 c  
c c
 c 
c
 

cc 
c

c1
c c c
c
c4'c

c
c
c -c
c1
c
 cc


c c
c


cc
c %c
ccc 
cc

c
   
c c c 

c
 
c   c 
c  c c 
c c 
c



c
cc-)c
 cc
c

c
c
c -c 
c c-5,)(
c
cc 
c
cc%
c 
c
c
c
 c

 c c -);P**c  c 



c

c c 
c 

c c 

c  
c

%
cc
c

 c
1

cc-);P**c
c
c
4. ELECTRICAL ASPECTS OF OVERHEAD LINES
c
  c 
c
  cc 
c

c



cc

c
c


ccc   cc
c


cc
c

c
c

c c

ccP 
c

c
c   c 
c c c
c
c

c c

c 


c
c
c
cc
c
ccP
c
  cc
c


c c  
c c
c 


c 
c 
c   
c c %
c 
c 
c
   c=cc>c
c
c P
c
c ccc   c
cc cc

cc
c cc 
 

c

c
c
c c
c 
 c

cc
 c

ccP
c c
cc   c 

c 
cc
c
c
cc

c
c 
cc
  c 
c   c 
c


c c $c 
c   !! c 
c

c 
1

c 
c 


c c  

c  c 

c c P 
c


c
c


cc

cc
c

cc 
%c
c
cccc


ccP
c

c


c 


 c 
 c c c  c 
%c  c 
c 

c 1
c c 
c
%cc
c
cc c


c

c c

c
c
cc#
c

c
ccc  
cc
 cc
 c 
%c


c=c@c>c
c
c P
c 

c c 
c 
 c 
c  c 
c  c 
c 

c 


c

c 
c



 c  c
c

c 


c
c
c
. OVERALL DESIGN OF OVERHEAD LINES
c

c
c

-c 
cc%
cc#
c

ccc

c
cc*+&Acc %c c

c

c c c
c 
c


c c 
c 
c 
c c 
c 

c  


c
  
#c
c
c
c 
c
c cc

c
c
B c
 
c

c

cc)
 c 
c
cc


2c

Jc

6 
  c


cc

c 


c 

c=c4c>cc
-
c
 
cc 
c 

cc

c 


c

c=cAcc>c
Jc B
c 

c=c0c>c
Jc 
c

cc

c c

c
cc


c=cCc>c
Jc

c
c

page 4 of 10
c

c
c
. INSULATORS
c
" c 
c 
c 
c 

c c c 
c  

c 
c  %c c 
c

  c c

 c


cc 
cc 

c

cPc
c 
c 
c
c
c

c 
c  cc
ccc))P,$ccP
c 
c
cc



c2c
c
Dccc  

c c
c


cc
c1 cc

c
ccc!c,
 cc 
cc
c

c*+C+c
ccc!c- cc

c*+&*c
DcP
 c

c cc
1

c c 

c

c*+&@c
Dc: 
c



c c<.c 

c

c=c&c>c
Dc6 

c


c c
 c


c=c+c>cc
Dc 
c

  c
c  
cc




c=c*'c>c
Dc5
c c
c-
 ccE 
cB  
cc

cB,6c,c=c**c>cc
Dc8

cc

c c,
cc

c-

c=c*c>cc
Dc $

c c 
c ,


c c 
c F


c 
c 
c 8

c c < c
G
 c6
 
c-

c=c*@c>cc
Dc

c6
 
cc

c-

c

cc<."c

c=c*4c>cc
Dc,

cc-c

c"
 cP

cc

c-

cc=c*Ac>cc
Dc

cc6
 
cc

c
c6
c-

c=c*0c>cc
c
6


c
cc
 cc
c:5c
c

cc
c
cc
c

cc
 cc
c
 
c c

c c
c c 
c c 

c


c 

c c 
 c



c : %c 
c 
c 
c 
c c


c 
c
  


c c 
c 
c 

c 
c 
c 
c


c c  c

 cc
cP
c 
c  
cc 

c

c
c
c
c

cc
c


cP
c
cc
c 
cc
 c   


c
cc cc

c
c
c 


c
c

page 5 of 10
c

. FOUNDATIONS
c P
cc 
c
c

c

cc



cc

cc


c
 c
 

cc 
c
c


cc
 c


cc


cc
c
 
c
c
c
c cc 
c
 c


c
 

c 
cc  

cP
c

c 
c
 cc  
c

cc 
  cc 
c
cc
%
c cc
c 

cc
c

c

c
 c
c
c " c  
c 
c 


c c


c 
c 

c c 

c c 
c


ccc
c c

c

cc 
c 
c2c
c
Jc


c

ccc



c c 

cc
c



c

c 
c 
 c c 
c

c 
c 


c c 

c



c  c

c


cc

c

cc
 cc c
c c
c
  
c
Jc 
c


cc


c 
ccc

 cc
Jc 
c ccc

 cc
c   c c  c

 c c
c


c
Jc 

c c  c 

c 
1

c c
1


c  c 

c

cc

cc 
  c
Jc 

c   

c c 
c 

c  c 
c 
c 


c 
c
  
c c 
c
c
Jc 
 
c  cc
c


c
c
c

c cc

cc 
c
 c 

c
c 
c  c c 
 c c  
c 
c 

c c  c

c#c


c
Jc  cc
c
 
cc
 ccc c

Jc

c
c
c
c
c
c

c
c
8. TRANSMISSION LINE STRUCTURES
c

c  

c 
c  

c 
c c    c c 
c 


c c 

c


c
  

c c 

c c 

c

c
  

c Gc


c 
c


c  
cc 
 c
 
cc
ccc

c
 c

c
c "  c 

c c  


c
c 
c 

c 

c
 
c c c
 

c
c-c



c cc  c
c cc 

cc
c


 cc

 
c c 
c 

c 
c c
 
c c c  
c c


c  c


cc
c 


c

ccc
c
c

  
cc
c  
ccc
c

c
c
c
 
c 

c ccccc
c
c
c #$% && 2c"
cc
c
cc
c
c
cc

c
c
ccc
cc
c

c c
cc
c 
  cc
c


c

c
c


c


cc
c

c

c 
c

c
cc

c
 c c 
c  c
 

c  c ;c  c  c
 

c
c
c P
c 


c c c 
 c  c 

c 
c
  

c


c



c c
c 
cc
cc


c 
c c
c
   c


cc


c


cc
c
 
c
c
cccc
c
c
  !! ! c 
c 

c
c   
c cc 
c  


c

c


cPc
 
c

c

cc
c
cc&'(
c*+&&!*++'cc 
c

c cc-)c&0c=ccc

 cc

cP 


c

c>c
c
c

page 6 of 10
c

c $c

c cc

cc
c 




c

cc
c cc
c


 c 
c 

c
#
c c
 c 
c
c  c 
c 


 c
  cc
c 
 c

c

cP
c cc


c

c 
c


c

cc*++*c=c*&c>cP
cc  

c  cc

c2c
c
c Jc 
 c
c

ccc


c
cc
c

cc c.c
c@0?c
c Jc 
 c 
c

c c  c 
c 


c 
c 



c 
c 



c
cc

cc
cc
c


cc 
c
c   cc

c
c
1

c
c Jc 
c c

c c 
c


c c 
c  
c  c 
c

 c 


c c
CA?c


cc-)cc 
c&0c

c

cc  
c
c
$c

cc 
c


c 
 c  c 
c 

c -)c 0Ac  c ;*+C+c

c 

c 
 
c c c  c c

c 
c  c c

c  
 c


c
 c 
c

 c 
 cc 
c 
c  


c

c
c

%cc

c
 cc
c

c


cc
c
c
9. MECHANICAL BEHAVIOR OF CONDUCTORS AND FITTINGS
c
 ! ' #%&' & ' %   % # %
& 
c
c " c 
c 
c   c c 
c
 c  c 

c 

c c 
 c

c  c
 
c



c  
c 
c c 
%
c   c 
c  
c
 
cc
c

c cc 
c
c c 
c

c cc
P 
c  c 
c 

c c 
c @!*A'c <#c 
1
 c 
c  c 

c c c

c   c

ccP
c


c  cc 
c
c
c

c
c
 c
c
cc
1

c c

cc#
c 
c
c 
c


c

cc
 
c  ccc
c %c 
cc*+&&cc*+&+c
c

P
c



c c  
c c 
c 
c 


c c 
 c 

c

  cc
c
cc 
c

cc


c
c  
ccG
 
cc


c c




c  


c  c


c c c c c 

c c
  c 
c

c
 #
cc



cc   c
c
c 
c

c



cc

cc*+&Acc*++Ac=c*+c>c

-c 
c
#
c  c 
c


c 


c 
c 
c 

c 

c c 
c
  c
c 

cc8c
 

cc
c


cc

c  

c
cc
 cc


cc

c

c


c"
cc  
c
c

c


c c 
c c  c   c c 
c 
c c 
c c c 
c
 
c 




c c c 
c 

c P
1

c  c 

 c 
c
  c

!c 
c

c



cc*+C+cc
 
c c

c

c c c
 % 
c 

c   c 
c  c c  
c c 
c


c 
c

c
 #
cc

cc*+&*c

c
~&& ! 
c
c E
c  
c 
c

c c 
c  c c 
c c %
c 
c

c c ) 
c 
c 

c 
c  
c 
c #
c  


c c


cc


c c

!

cc
 
c
c%
!
c
cc
$c

c c 
c  c
 c c

!
c 

c  c 
c   c  c
 c
cc 

c
c
c

page 7 of 10
c

c
 (%#&  
c
c 5c 
1
c 


c  c 
 

c c 
c



c  c 
c


c c  
c 
c c
  

c c $c 
c  c
 c 

c c
c


c
c

cc*++Ac=c'c>cc
c

-
 

c


c 
c 
c

c c

 c 
c c c
 
c c P
c

c c 

Hc 

c c



c  c 


c 


c 

c

 

ccc
 c
 c
c

cc*++c=c*c>cc

c
c

)! )%c

P
c

c c  cc
c c 
c

c 
c
ccc

c c


cc

 c  
c c  cc
c cccc
c
 c

 


cc
c
c 
c



cc8c  

c

c
 

cc
 
c
=cc>c c 


c  c  
c 

c c 

c  


c 
c 
c



c

page 8 of 10
c

10. FUTURE ACTIVITIES

c
)
c c 
c  %
c cc
c c
 c  


cc 
c

c 
 
cc


c

cc


c
 c
cc#
c c 

ccc

c<c
 
cc
 
c
c %
c 
cc
c


cc
c
cc 
c
c
c


c2cc
c
*c P
c



c 
 
c 

c c 
c 



c c 
c
 
c
cc 
cc c
c


cc

c

cc

c


c
c cc
c
 
cc2cc
c
Jc  c 
c 


 c 
c  c
  

c  c c  
c

c
 
c

c

cc
c c3c
c
Jc
 c c 
c

 !
 c 

c c 
c 
c  

c c
  c 


c3c
c
Jc 

c  
c  c  c 
c  c c  

c 
c


cc
c
c $
cc

  c

c
c c

c
c
c
c 
  c
c 
c 

c 

c 
c 
c  

c c 

c c 
 c  c  c 
c


c

c  c
c@'ccA'c

ccc 
c cc

c

c
c 

c
c P


cc
c cc 
c c 
c  

c
 c
c


cc

c
c cc
 
cc
c

c
c 
c 
c 
 

c c 

c 


c  c 

c

c  cccc

c

c

cccc
c
@c P
c c c 

c 
c 
c c 
c

  c  %

c c 
c


c 
c 


c

  c 

c c  c 
c
 c c

  c 

c c 
c c 

c
c c c c 
c
#
c 

c 2c  
c 

c 
c 
 c  
c  c  c
 c 

c 
  c 
 
cc 

c %

c c
c


cc 
c

 
cc
c

c

c  c
c cc
 c
c
-c  
c
c
c
c c

ccc 


c 
c

c
cc

c
cc
c 


cc%

c c


c
cc
c
ccc
c
P


cc 
c

c
cc
cc
c 

c c
c


c
c

c 
c c c 
 
c c 
c

c c 
c 
c

 

cc

c


c c

c
c  cccc


c

c

c
c
11. REFERENCES
=c*c>c

c
=cc>c

P
c 5


c  c 
c  
c c < c .
c 

c 

c c
8
 c 

c 

c c 
c 9:5c 
c 

c c )
 c c
"


c*++0c/Ic*0+cc
c 

c
 cc


c
c
c

cc
cP
 cE  
ccc
c**'c
)
 c/Ic*44c*++cP
c
c
 cc

c  
c
c
*ccccc!c:5*c
c
c

page 9 of 10
c

=c@c>c
c
=c4c>c
c
=cAc>cc
c
=c0c>c
c
=cCc>c

)
 c /I*04c *++0c 6 

 c 

c c   c 
c 
c
cc!c:5c*c
6 
  c


cc

c 


c 

!)
 cIc*@0c!c*++*c
-
c
 
c c 
c 

c c 

c  


c 

c
)
 cIc*@Cc!c*++*c
B
c 

c)
 cIc*0Acc*++0c

c

cc

c c

c
cc


c!c)
 cIc*0*c
!c*++A

c
=c&c>c : 
c



c c<.c 

c

c!c)
 cIc*@'c*++'c
c
=c+c>c 6 

c


c c
 c


c))P,$cIc*@0c*++*c
c
=c*'c>c  
c

  c
c  
cc




c))P,$cIc*4*c
*++c
c
=c**c>c 5
c  c 
c -
 c c E 
c B  
c c 

c B,6c ,c
))P,$cIc*4@c*++c
c
=c*c>c 8

cc

c c,
cc

c-

c))P,$cIc*4@c*++c
c
=c*@c>c $

c c 
c ,


c c 
c F


c 
c 
c 8

c c < c
G
 c6
 
c-

c))P,$c*4Cc*++@c
c
=c*4c>c 

c6
 
cc

c-

c

cc<."c

c))P,$c
Ic*0*c*++Ac
c
=c*Ac>c ,

cc-c

c"
 cP

cc

c-

c))P,$c
Ic*0+c*++0c
c
=c*0c>c 

cc6
 
cc

c
c6
c-

c))P,$cIc
*0+c*++0c
c
=c*Cc>c Bc

c!cP
 cE  

c!c,Jc&*!c*++4c
c
=c*&c>c P
c  c c 


c 

c 
c 

c 

c c )
 cc /Ic *@&c
*++*c
c
=c*+c>c 5
c c . c G



c c 

c 

)
 c /c *0@c
"


c*++Ac
c

c
=c'c>c B
c 


c c 

c 
c 52c 5c 

c
B 
c)
 c/c*0c 
c*++Ac
c

=c*c>c ,


c c F


c c -
 

c 

c )
 c /c *4@c $
c
*++c
c
c=cc>c ,


c c F


2c B
c  c B
c  c 

c c 

c


c)
 cIc*0Ac$ c*++0c

page 10 of 10
c