Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://www.tesol.org/read-and-publish/journals/other-serial-publications/compleatlinks/compleat-links-volume-4-issue-2-(june-2007)/connecting-the-course-book
Brian Tomlinson argues that teachers can overcome the shortcomings of course
books by humanizing, localizing, and personalizing the texts and tasks for the
students. See Alice S. Lees Portal article, "Making ESL Textbooks More Relevant
to EFL Students," Essential Teacher, June 2007.
Developing an English language course book requires a massive investment
these days, which is often only justified by selling the book throughout the world.
Such global course books aim to cater to the needs and wants of all learners at a
specified level, but frequently they end up catering to the needs and wants of
nobody.
Replace the text or add material with the same topic or theme.
Replace the activities or add others that stimulate the learners to think and
feel.
Get learners to do something with a text rather than just study it (e.g.,
have the whole class act out a story or, for example, an agricultural
process) as you read the text aloud.
Get learners to articulate their intake responses to a text (i.e., what they
personally think and feel about it) before getting them to analyse the text
or focus on a teaching point illustrated by it (e.g., ask, "Do you like the old
lady? Why?").
Help learners make discoveries for themselves about how the target
language is used (Bolitho et al. 2003; Tomlinson 1994).
Make sure that for each unit the learners do a development activity in
which they use the unit to express themselves in order to achieve an
intended outcome.
4. In groups, the learners predicted the next scene and mimed it to another
group, who tried to provide the narrative for it.
5. Each learner then had two minutes to read the text from the course book.
Then we had an animated group competition in which groups tried to win
points by reporting differences between what happened in their skits and
what happened in the course book.
6. Finally, for homework, each learner wrote a letter as Mrs. King complaining
about the differences between the film (i.e., the student acting of Scene 1)
and her real-life story.
The learners were exposed to language in meaningful use, experienced a lot of
recycling of language without being aware of it, had many learning opportunities,
and, above all, were involved as human beings rather than just as language
learners.
Possibly the most effective thing you can do is to spend the first five or ten
minutes of each lesson exposing learners to language in meaningful use by
reading a poem, telling a story, recounting an anecdote, telling a joke, setting
riddles, reading a clipping from a newspaper, or acting a scene from a play. Do
not ask any questions or set any tasks, but just leave students in reflective
silence for a few minutes before turning to the textbook. Leave copies of the
days text on your table for learners to take away with them at the end of the
lesson if they want to, and encourage learners to keep a file of the texts they like
and to reread them every so often.
Localising the Course Book
A global course book can make sure that it locates its units in as many different
locations around the world as possible, but unfortunately it cannot do what some
local course books do and start each unit in settings familiar to the learners. On
Target (1995) and Search 10 (Fenner and Nordal-Peedesen 1999), for example,
focus on such global issues as tourist pollution, drugs, water supply, peace and
war, and money versus morals, but they do so by focusing on the learners own
country first. On Target starts one unit with a Namibian song about water before
moving on to a Kenyan story about the coming of the rains, and Search 10 starts
a unit by focusing on World War II in Norway before going on to look at current
conflicts around the world.
Although global course books cannot do this, you can do it for your learners. You
can think of ways in which a readiness activity can stimulate locally focused
mental activity that could make relevant a text set in a distant country.
For example, I once had to use a text about how the Inuit build igloos with a
group of Nigerian students. I started the lesson by asking them about where they
lived and how they built their houses. Soon they were telling me about how they
used locally available materials to make huts and how they could quite easily
rebuild them when they began to deteriorate. I then told them they were going to
read a passage about people building houses in an area where there were no
trees, only ice and snow. I asked them to predict how these people built their
homes and then told them to read the passage and to think as they were reading
about the similarities between their culture and that of the Inuit.
Other ways to localise the course book include the following:
Build up and then use a library of locally appropriate texts that match the
topics or themes of those in the course book.
Get the learners to find and read locally relevant texts equivalent to those
in the course book.
Read aloud the text with its location omitted, and get the learners to see it
taking place in settings that they are familiar with.
For more ideas, see "Localising the Global: Matching Materials to the Context of
Learning" (Tomlinson 2006).
Personalising the Course Book
Unless learners are personally engaged in the learning process, they cannot
achieve effective and durable learning cannot. Only individual learners can really
personalise the course book by relating it to what is already in their minds.
However, you can help the learner achieve this by doing any or all of the
following:
Start and end each lesson in the learners mind (e.g., "You are going to
read a passage about water shortages. See pictures in your mind of what
can happen when there is a water shortage.").
Let the learners each decide which of a number of course books they want
to work with.
Let the learners each find a text that they want to work with that is
connected to the topic or teaching points of the unit.
Let each learner decide which activities in the course book to focus on.