Professional Documents
Culture Documents
80 on the Design
and Analysis of Power System Grounding
J. Ma, Senior Member, IEEE, F . P . Dawalibi,Senior Member, IEEE, and R. D. Southey, Member, IEEE
Safe Engineering Services & technologies ltd.
1544 Viel, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, H3M 1G4
Index Terms
grounding, safety, touch voltage, step
voltage, foot resistance, ground potential rise, decrement
factor, derating factor.
I. INTRODUCTION
IEEE Standard 80, ZEEE Guide f o r Safety in AC
Substation Grounding, was developed to provide guidance
and information pertinent to safe grounding practices in
AC substation design. Three editions of IEEE Standard
80 (1961, 1976, and 1986) had been published before
the 2000 edition. The newly revised IEEE Standard 802000 [13 has been approved for some time and has been
used by engineers and professionals in grounding design
and analysis. There are changes in Standard 80-2000
with respect to Standard 80-1986 t2], which affect
grounding design and analysis. The objective of this
paper is to discuss the major changes in the 2000
version with respect to the 1986 version that most affect
grounding design and analysis. Pertinent examples are
presented.
11. THE TOUCH AND STEP VOLTAGE CRITERIA
0.1 16
0.1 16
=(1000+1.5Cs .p,)-
J;T
Rf
(3)
Rf
0-7803-7459-UOU$17,00
0 2002 IEEE
=z
P
- 974 -
=(%).
c =-
1
m
K"
1+2c
0.96[
n=1(1+(2nhs/b)2)
112
(7)
112
R2 = ( ( r +b)2 +(2nhs)2)
(8)
K=,-O. 1
kl-z--Standard 80-2000
-----
0 0
0.1
Standard 80-1986
0.2
0.3
- 975 -
I
I
Soil Twe 1
Thickness
Soil Twe 2
Soil
Resistivity
100 R-m
300 R-m
300 R-m
100 Q-m
Thickness
I
I
0.305
0.915
I
1
99.7
100.1
I
I
299.0
299.5
1.524
100.6,
298.4
15
4.573
1 1 1.3
271.6
248.7
20
6.098
121.0
30
9.146
143.1
50
15.24
150
200
Soil
Resistivity
181.7
I
I
202.6
144.2
21.34
208.8
227.2
110.7
33.54
241.5
106.4
39.63
25 1.8
104.2
45.73
259.6
103.1
60.96
272.7
101.7
120.3
TABLE III
GROUND RESISTANCESCOMPUTED WITH
TWO-LAYER SOILS, COMPARED WITH
THOSE COMPUTED WITH AVERAGE UNIFORM SOIL
I
I
Grid
Dimension
5m ~ 5 m
200m
200m
Soil
Type 1
9.22 R
0.58R
Soil
Type2
19.4R
0.33 R
I
I
Uniform
(200n-m)
15.0R
0.48 R
Ti:
T2:
OHGW: 7iYlOAW
Feeders:
OHGW: 3/8HS
NeUtraI:
'
336 kcmil!
ACSR
1
8.23 m
I f -
6l
T2 Phase
a,
t
T1 Phase
2
Feeder
TlOHGW
16
8
0
8
Distance from the Faulted Substation (km)
- 977 -
*, , d l
No Isolating Section
looo~
E
i/'
+ .
With Isolating
Sections 1 and 2
500
With All Four
9
e
s
,
100
200
300
IX. CONCLUSIONS
The major changes in the 2000 version of IEEE
Guide for Safety in AC Substation Grounding (Standard
80-2000) with respect to the 1986 version (Standard 801986), which affect the grounding design and analysis,
have been discussed. Comparisons are made for the
- 978 -
XII. BIOGRAPHIES
Dr. Jinxi Ma (M91, SMOO) was born m Shandong, P. R. China in
December 1956. He received the B.Sc. degree from Shandong
Universitv. P. R. China. and the M.Sc. demee from Beiiine.
_ _ University
of Aeronautics and Astronautics, both in electrical engineering, in
1982 and 1984, respectively. He received the Ph.D. degree in
electrical and computer engineering from the University of Manitoba,
Winnipeg, Canada in 1991.
I .
XI. REFERENCES
IEEE Guide for Safety in AC Substation Grounding, IEEE
Standard 80-2000 (Revision of IEEE Standard 80-1986).
IEEE Guide for Safety in AC Substation Grounding, IEEE
Standard 80-1986, (Revision of IEEE Standard 80-1976).
B. Thapar, V. Gerez, and P. Emmanuel, Ground resistance of
the foot in substation yards, IEEE Trans. Power Delivery, vol.
8, no. I, pp. 1-6, Jan. 1993.
- 979 -