دور الصحافة الاستقصائية في مكافحة الفساد

1

:

#"!
2009

"# !

/ !+.!) !-
+
)(
%% !%&% .

9

%! +8+8
6%7 13
1 #:
; (
@+> 98
C +7 @< 8<
8
? (>
("#=<8
? !-"

! >( +7 / .! ICJ H3"! E F@ G
@ N

E + GM+
(?%
? 9

! K/L 9C
+Q/(
TP@ S>%
-?R ? % !+.!) !-?
L
@ E)8!
(!1
# 8<= G( KM%

<
!(
1J7R%><
!

)
(@
E
# 8=
C E
+Q/

KJ +8+8
1 1(
+Y >
E #:
GM+ (
! T3 %
.
!

) .? ?[ 3 !%&% ?"] ?
! :
)"# ;
T

")% " +7 % K/L
!

<7R b 3
%
.?(
c ?
; 9e)

KJ
!
+ >)< 9
1) !+!@h +L <
3 %

!

.

Y TP @+
"# !
i
!+.!) !-!R /
b C
E / + +
/<L
< !
8"

" + G)
]L 3 !%&% 8? ? . E!"

! 1J N3
!+L J6 +L

# S G
+L n +</+
ER
@] o G/+; ?
< +L !+=
E N

L b

(
@+: E % % b1C
+L
<!<
+
))/! . 2001" I
.
h K!. N

!+L
)8
%
+
?+ o%% K%!6
))%e +M G . +Q/!
!
: -CJ
))/ Kh @)< 8&
@h
"# !
i !
!+.!) K@ !-+t

! 1 J6 "

>!
+L +t)
!-
R
>!

u)8 = G-)@
(8
.!
!
))/!
" 8
@! o N +".! 3
!
n+
"#
"
!).G-
@% )

? /"%
! ]!
?
"
+
:> +R
hL +L R?
E ?%) #6 S@+L( %<R
@ ?%%
% +yC 17 " .2004 GJ6i
+L R n;!
+. KQ!
+ % E G!+L
&!
%C
"?i
R GM! ! S)/ .
) <")
%&%
P
"] ! @! o!
T+R .!
% o+ "}?+
) S
!) (
T<
(<1 +
/R i
+M ;] 8
%
% E ]@ % 3 ) +-(

S
.@ G(
@!

".@uP

? " /"% +
Y o+
t !-?R"
@) T.

. K
% @J
C%!= b ;
(%8!
L %/ (
E
y
)# .) G- @
e u
: "

#LG/
@
C+#
1
+ /! :L @%
# E
+ . @
.
L K K)! < +L+L R
7 8 G n !.
)/
+ <
+L R n +</;!

+ 97
% !
% % G@ b.L
CJ6i ?]L !) " .
3

8R ]L <
J6i @ T&%
? " /"%! !<
E

)(
8
. +8? +7R
&i
E=+ +7.
;
8
.<

>!
o?%@
(!1 E!
CJ6i !
o.>

!R +8 &+ >% )
KP

!QJ
!R
. !)
>
@ ++ GR!
)! < +L +8 J7 +!@h J6
! b!.!? )/

+
8)6 )<%+8@
()/ " . L
" )8 +7?)
? J6i !+#
: @
F@ 6+ S
% ! K/ . !) +
C @! #: C+! +
% "
>!
.
Q)%%C K6?
) b nL
%/
! ! b!.!? %C KP"<%(> G K J6i )
; .K7
"
)
! /%
8

1
>

!
J6i !% #:
? !
9 . %
?9
6 K8#
1 + )(

+ %8 :? . n H3! E
%>+? C @%/ <

+ (
@%/
!
J6

& E! b"

>!
+ S
).+Q.S
-#@ G
-.()*+, :
% )%-

" S+8 :
. 8 :

%
1
1 1
%1 S)
1 1
%. 8 :
1 %

1!
/

: 6 <8 b!.
1 (!

L ;(
? +?

1

%6
1R
;3
C

u !y8y8
#C

%6
JM : 8 + ]?!

%
1 %(
; K @ ) ; E 1 %
1
) G Je
? L
.
R 6
1 1
% %
<@ :.
1
E1 R)
C %
.
!( GP

J :
!
/
" G( 3 E8?
G + ( G
1 G
:!"!% @ ]
/
G
8 G N ye K7 +/"8 + S>%
i ) S"+
!
!
( E
E G(?R +/"8 G
; 9! ) M 37 )
S
(L !)e "+

%8>+ +( Y (.G
%
:
e<8 S 9<1 %
R E8
? 9!

% 9
H !
9%
/
] E8%7
(

/ E8+e
1 :H3 %1 <
1 S% :@ S?

?
1 :
% ]>+
E%/@ 1
(?R K6R uR
#6J.
%
1 1
) :Ky ?8

G ?
8
G %
1 +# :?
!

!) % !

1 ./ "
:9/
)%8 KQ
8
?
}? GP @] S S

%Q" G(?R % !& bS o S
%+(Y] %
? % E H%>+7
J7 K
. %
1
%

K<1
/% @! G+M%% G

1 :8t
%
% %1 E 8
E
8@ S%1 8t

=+ %

.
)
!%& :b ! ) <. 8

6
6
R< ++</.
E1 R

%

: 6 ! ) +#
3 7
6
L

]
:
L
"?i
b<8 ) + S
L " E n
:
!. K").
.H

:S K
E1 >+
)8 N)
8.+ L
6
G
1
.S@%
S@% S 6 ?
6
1

1

) : ! .+
)
1 +L
7
?%=
:
?
)C
@<

" ! b"+

! + +
?%=
:
1?
C
<+1

?%=
C E)8
@<
)

)%C G
)

< % G() 8
?% )
@
S>% H+ " 9/
) %. %/

!

1 %
1 KQ <

%( + 1
>%?

1 .8
L
1
1.

1 :
P
<% 8.
"

:)

:)
. C
@ S Ki @ < .H
1

y)
)y? :
J E !"] @
1 .E)8! E
S
@ 9 +R

9
"/

? : E/C)
? 91
#Y 1 E)8! L

S)Y
(6
1 37 S! G% E
"/ u8P!
S!C%
<
)1 1+C +
?% S u8P
:K1
N ? S
1 .
!() 3C + :1 E1 +R

. 7

() K
7
! 1 ?h!
@%
E1
1 I#C +/"8
1 H%C
% .+/"8
(

9 S @ F+
y!C S "J :)
K@
1
L
C
C
+6
1
.
(
M %
:%<.8

& ! ) S%

() K
; 6
1

o 7 #
:E1R8R :S%1

% " H+ +R
6
1 S%1 E)8 : % <
(8
(+P K#

T K8. % %/ K?!
+# %.
% E:

"M
9
b&% :
1 > < ? :++
%1

(-#C
<
1 % Ki
+R
: K# %

" /

?
L.
=<( GC C.

@ : G
:+e G> K)"< %1 S 3 C
@
1
1
.
%

+7R @ Gt
# !
9<1
< K!. H3! ?
8 b<@ % +tR
1)( +tR
+8 +8
. %8 R
P E
! Ji
+Y

1 @ +/"8
)( N S b<@ E
(
+t%?
% K
P
)
?"!
. K/L b @

F (
< )
y
/L C >! b
R
(
+R
1J!

(; E >! b+=R !%&% .

<
M
%/
P ). +<: !%(L (y)
G 8. +.
( : 0()*+

+(Y

b @% %(#
E!b!.
@
.(
E+i + y+ @ )8

P1 E!6
7 b!.
>%? ?+
"# ?N3 .
* +(Y

Investigative Journalism!+ E
3 % Muck Rekers: !)<%
"# 1= F3 E G
%!. #
1 3 J!C & !( #6
"#
6
7
.19012
*! h %# !<%
!)<%
"# +C E( GE #
? +L
# #;
/!<) E F
t! +! 8&
7<1
+<: + +C !)<
"# % (!
.1906
*?" +3 %
8 !1 9e Gt
8 N)
.
1911
+ +7<@ Gt
C 1912 %(!. <
() 8+8@ N3
+Q/ u %eP !

! E
#7 3 % .
(@
#6
* %8 E KP# 8

CJ6i E 9!@ E! b!. E+e E3
)% .
* ?+L

E
% ! J7 /+R +
"<
)8 +
<R +L8 8 )(
:
G!
E3 S 9C
E K"<
)8
n: 1 N3 )
3 . G-) +M K/L 1968
T<6)
) !- )6 " KFund Of Investigative % S%!@ Journalism!
"h +R T.? 13 ) K%!@ E+Q
+L 60 @ e
J7 +# <!<
+ 1971+<!< EC
1973 9#L>
L? S R
K@ L1
)!
1&
! E <+)
L

1
"
"
. . %/
*
E o]@ 1976@
!) !+
" "IRE
Investigative Reporters & Editors(@ #6
!. ET+
%!. E N!+
( @ b.L

@)!(
.+ +% n7%! y
7 bP ?+L
<7
!
%&%
?
> E+<: K 8
: +7R .
*

(? b 9/; 1976
E#6 K! F+
!. + >+
Newsday+>i Robert Green +(L @ e
+. GE
E
M+ Bollesdon >+ Arizona Republic3
%

?
L !+.!) E !- ,Sy?
C &E <)1 98

@ S) 3 N+8 91% %# !)<%
"# +:>K
@ yy8
#L G/!"% + !+L
"#.
* ?
!t KM%

#6 2001 +
M
#6 +L "!7
)( G E!

P1
"# 3 3) G1
.+:
* @":

. E b" K/L uL
"# E
! b!.@ G+

L b"@ E @(

KJi
+7R C
6 13 ?!% y uY%@ E
<
+/i? +MR
@) u!
%8 <
?
+Q/ K E!+
% (
@(

" K/L E G%6%
6J7 E ! . 1
*
E?
L
: !
"h %/!
"h 6
:
!
<
+/i? y:@ E!
%8 @)
(#
!
(
>+@
?
/% (
)
# 1 ?
# EJ=i . GM)
. 3
SC

J7 ")% "
E
% ! /+R
@+.#
P +7R" /+@ "9>+ 8 +e@ 1 b&%?
P
% tJt E3
.?i 8@ G

) G.RE
]@ +Q
E#
/+ 91%3 S 9
@J7 S 9
1
! +:# )%
8
@ >%

C +L)@ 9>+
L %C R&
E #
%
! +@ E b%
/+R y
KJi E K1+L
!:P@ H
. E
7
ti E e
<7i )y )
L 3
@<
! S
E! E#%e& ?
.
!R E
@%8
)
=
L #6
! KQ H3)
=
L @ @:
1 = %% +L
<+ !

!C @"<
+#
E
F #/
P1!
"h E #J!C G
./
H3%8 E +th@ G K
+
+L? G@ E
J7
8
!
& E
% ! +L? /+R u6!
@ "++

C 9#L "
GY%
+8 o!+ y" # E "K
? #

?(
"+. % )( E.+6 E@

"h E !8 < F1
E
6+C!%&% 1] 6 +<:
S#: 1?
1J
<
#L

"# y

+C / E"%
E%/
"! % !" %
<( E G!
(! 7 G

8
!<
%1? C F=J +C!
%8" " T&%"K
? #
%(#

? 3) F")
b%@"o+ "9
F+!) #-
6 ! &
"# %;+ T<6% !
"h J
S S%6<

" S +e@ E GR&
EQ K! %
3 < S
@ E / E#6 F S(" F!8
+ G"1 o

E
% #6 ?%. @
!" y "++
<7R !
%8 J
F
t% !+! C%#

?% +C!
%8 !
"(8@ S
K
% E!
%8 "
+ :K!L@ #:<
!"
%
!
8& E#Y% %/)

( !1! #Y%"
+<: R
!
<
QC!
! % +M F
t%!)%L !
</ 6
:

+
Ci!
%8 J >)< .
*
? 9

K<1% (

>%%)/@ E K!
%8!8@
E!+ 3 %!8 !+# b G K1 G!
"h %!) E (
b% E +</!

. E# !
"h #R! E

+ K!8 F+#>%@ K +;
/ u:+<:
8
!+ @! G()/ @

F
t%
% #6 +@ b!> K!L!%.b1
)
!
"h #+</ E
% ! /+R
+P
! E @ E
F F@ E K!8
8 !+
!+
+++<7
?% !
Ci)
!
</ <
!i
QC ]? !-% E!
%8 +<8 !++
%? +8 E
!
C!
%8 /! E%6% (
!%1 >%? +C
Ji !
L K
? ?% +L? ]L)@ 1 E!
%8 !+P
K
%) . # E
e<
F %8@ E!+
E!
% 1 E
@ .8 E#6 ++ 1 9<6% !)
"
E %1

b!> E u /+R+</ +e

( >% E
"1 + ! K
K E 8%
#+</
KQ
"+;%" +7h 9t

6
7
!"1

@+ 98% #
K!L! @
/ E Ji< 9R

:> /+R+.?%/ E K!8@ /+R%C F

u
%" o!@ E "]
E H3!+y

E>@(
P@ 9>+@y GC u+</ E
%
!
%&% E /+R

?
.
( :
F+!+ !! y!+8 ! G(%&%y G(1?

<+ + ) =
%

G(@ E+
8 .1
G"1 T<6

+Q
"1R +1 C <"? 96+
K<1%(!. E/+R8 EK!L 8%
(@
%&% 9@
EC %90
!R !
"
! b!.@
+ G@
(</
E G" 3 !)%- @
@ +<8 E@ +
FG
!"
!

(@ E

9<Q!+= (F)! n<@+@ E
%P n%?
E !-?R!+= @+! )!t +% <1
!
"h !+= "C GP@ E!%(#
8 (
%/
!)
!- !? +L
!!%

8 !
@"
G

9<Q@ E
P!+= J7
=J !%=) G(+8

!
%8 %C 3 + 8L <
N! S?] I %/
J7 ?

: !
L !
@ I#

" @ [
?+
!3
( K +!%=)
:L "
%>% "
.
(.
8 G( K
56* 1 23( 0()*+, "
: N
*
?+> S@+L ) ! ( +8 1 o
: +(; +L8
?% ?
Q
) +L? C 2004
!] !
1 # ?
:; 270 %
!" #
?%% 6 ) # 1 3 +R E
8 3
!
G H3
!

&i E?
eL Ji +8. N3 !
8
*
!
P 1950 R
# +C 8 +
1948
@ ;)(

"C < ) . ( u% ?+L ! .8
F
t%+L 6
: G
?y@
(. .!+ ]

!
"7 9@ S@+> N@ S8+ . 1 @ N
<< P<
1 %t . 31952 %%
* N3 F
t% ?
(@+L%;)
9% P 1972@9M+
?(
!
E
o++R
L ?%"/
.1974
@ N F
t% ? #6
(@+L)%% @
! y 1971 -7-12
+C )
? J F
t%"% +
+R .
% E
@ K
; +e@
.
+
8 +R !
8 b;) )(

%1 E@(
@ N<J .4;( +!+ %
1 3
e

+. ,Bbwood Ward Cari Bernstein J
. Washington Post
()*+, 18(9
" 9)
C
J
!
()

?%?
1 7

T
8 % %? E
< %= 86 E8 :; uy
! /
!
&
& +
!"<

K 3 S& 9C
+R
?

o
1997 ) %#6 S
%
u: G
8!
@ F+ u1%<
H+M F+ +(Y
% K6!(! E GM+
% K<1 = % +7 K N
+1 %t E
+% 1917
9
EC S) /@ +

)%3 +Q/% ! 981!
&
>+G

& o +)
)(

(?R +Q @ 8 @ E +8

! b!.!%(L (
.
! # /!" : K+ !+L
R) Q
uL/"
+. G!
! #: ;< /!
%8 ) ?9?+
( @
7
3 !
.
P (

@ S K
% Q
< ++/? +

/ !1+ " K.@
.

)"< !

(
+<:
("#? #+
10
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
+ %) %. u

<?R ! !1 .
u!J. !<
% !#:
<
?

+. !+
!+!@h . #
:;R G()!P!%&%!
8 .

T;+!(
?
>+ )
#C .
;< /!
%8 ) ?. ( 9?+
; ;<; : 0()*+
?% )
K< E !
Q R T +<7 %/ 3 F
.
@?
6 26 3 E ?06*D 6;B
R
8
18 , 15:48 2009
=+; + + >%#R
8 %1 ;
/ <8!: +
y ; 9:>% +.; 26 )<
: !) ;!

P.
1 %! 8
"8 =+; +% >%#
)%6 +8(
!%=) %1
%8 >% ;+. %#) 9<<"@ <+M < +
%?
@3e (
N C!y )
CJ ;!

P+L E S
1@+# K/L ;
/ =+!: ;<8
y

P %1% C E.+R
&
8
"8 ! uL/
6%# ! 9) +<:?(
;+.
)<
: )% "
%)
E?(
?
@ >%
"?
e .n

!+# @+.; 26 9# 3 )% !y
(81 8
>3

)< ? G@ S
P

/" %@ !C )
8 C "!
!%;(
)@ G >y H3
.;R

6%

(?%:
.
P
? ) 9 >%# @ 8<+

-
<?R "
!R
C+ )u
!
"
? E
3) b 2004% +8 1/+R
>( >!

" @) G-
>( +7 K<1 %8 +
(

1 8 %1 % + +
L8 )
+6

8 .2006
<
P1 8 45
" >%#+M G e !6
8) 8<@ C

+ + -
y
<?R "
110+M G .5!6
8
;.@ H* * ; 55B( *)( :

11
%> S #!"

C
! +> S#L+=
: )8 N

"> S#@
(8= @] #: ) C] K/+
S ! S +
! +8 / K3 <
L + +: G< b.3 < S
%>%
L+M S>+7 +7R

+ !
%> SQ o@++
1993
;
H!. 6J
!
%> S #!" % 1+7
@ H+L?
C + @

1
<7
@ E !8 #y F
t+ H3%81
:
o@(
i?
o #Y%
"7 o
!J !()
o b+e
o ! S8 :L!()

o) %%8+R <")
1 +R +; /
!
L !
>+ G@
( 1JJ7
(
L ! F

)"< ! b!. K/@: K!L
o
) +-"

!"h
+e@ o
?%
# IB 0()*+; :
+ )
!(! ) (
) !-
#L(+8&+ e

%@ +> S
"# :7
.1
+ !8>%
; 8? ! #:! 8
+
e %1?
!<
% !
+@<) J!C =) +1i %?
1 +C%6% E
!
%8.
J!C.2 @ b!.! %!? +P +C

%7
+8(
JQ!
!(?%/
#CC.
C .3

: E6 n7
(?%/ u
(!
&
"# 3
H%L !8
1 %?
((>%
/C +M T+!+L +Q
CR.
N .4@<

%/ !P%? !? % @!)b

%/ ! N
.
.5

? o]@ E @
8!. @ b #@%

8 !+L
)

+8 <)>R3 .+R
.6+[

(#6%R

P1 TP G
"# !.b!.
.7+1 %1? @ b.L!)
" @!) b
/C "% .Ji
12
.8 E K!8

)1 !
"h

#6 : !

P1 8

"#
"h C ! b!.!?

: E: u6 G

"#.
%> :@ .9
%&% "CR %) y

"#
:;R

%
"#%M+# !%>( 3
% 3 N/#! b!."< ?
[
S@
.
/ 8+.S@

1
b.L@ .10
E

!:
< K

P1 uL
"#.
( : 0()*+,

) ?!% >+ )(
<+@ (
6 750 J I.8 9 M3.8 I NO 8
Y # -;Q U* Q5 PQ3R8 Q
);
F
< o+M 9(<+ - + ) - /<8 J b)(
@
?J= Hy. J 8
.<)
? &! +L

: !
/
"#
? .
> !y !%=) H
E+L % /@ G+ <+

/<L
8?+L @
. H
b+L !]<8 <)
K/L
%L %R +7R
? EC y ! K
8

@% +M
! +L ! K
8@K7
!"h

)(

!%= +-? P E J+Q/
)(
! .!"h >%
+M +L K

1 <

!

!

- >!
(8
%?
8+L @) G-3
!/K:
) -/ ?
/+ !6
8 < R&
C!<
? ! E F+
8 !t
I#? +!S
% +M S &! !
+L
!K
8
8
13
! 7+ @)+L
%
(81% E+/i? . /R G
C
6
!R
b 6 E !@h
/!%=)K/ .

E % S !
E +# Hy(>R
; G8 S)/

(. %? EC !
H @<
h S
!
% H ?+ +#C S R . 9J E>( !K
=<+/ 8 !8
8 N !"@ u+8@ b!
H
< 8!)% )(
!%+ +;i 83/108 G1+
%. @ G8!
H<.8
%7 @ @+! K? S
- +C +-) +(- .

+(/ % %@+/ @ 8 I#+MR
%
C JR >
%>( >%
?%
e

# M!
;%L K/ .
R ?
86<
!
?
> E %
?%
M !t
H
+ 20 8+7

1 % @!(
b1)
% & 9@ 98<P
<"%
e / .@"
?%
e @ 9; 8 o!L3< =!
8

7
(+L @]
!Q!+ u] K <)
? @K+
%
u]
(< E+ !"!7 +8
@JM <" b# <).y
!

?%
M !t K + "!7 8 @) 9@ +-)
+!

@] +@J#
@+1
("J !
H< 8!+/
!
! !8?(
<8
6 +M @+ +Q Jt + R
< NJ!" K!8 N
J7 PET %!): 8 !+/
Polycarbonate ?%/ (

P
C C
.
3 !% K ?1 E S
(<8@ G@ S
@"!N3
(
C T

(?% / G +P7)

!8J
6 +M.
<+ C
6
< S8!
?} H
H+L !+/
!)
+L
(CJ6
&i
E
8R !+L 8#@+
!
H+</
8] %< H3
6%7 K7! +#.
3@ S"#? 91% E C!

.
?%
M .
( H
%+ G1 EC
.@ K." G1 !
(!
+M J

.
3 % b1!+ (3
&
E
1+!
"h
!
+M!
P@ <" 7+
CJ % @%
!"h
(

M
1"
!< ! .
<+1 K
14
!"h

# J E!%=) G(6(+
@< F
?%.
!
! K + !"h <
"
!
(y)@
+7R )(
R (.C% @ 8+ 7 .
% @! K
"h
8 N
C 3 %+
=
>i %!8 E
S( b G%R .
!K
8
"< +L 8 @< b!
%? H
H
J C F
%?
1 97 >% @
7 b+L (
%
F ). o
e;R
8) K
1!
H)
! ?
<1+1
?%
3 @ S 9 ).3 %:
8 E1& ; K<1
) .
!h ?)
?+. ! ] (
"!% ,?
(?y:>"
?
G 8 +<7)
!%
!/L ) +.
1 @ y
@) ;
37] E!%+L G
?%#
( G3 @ S8 +1 e
) ?!% ( +
^@...\ RO )8 I@)* (

9
@
t ++ +:3 ?+7h +L

)
i %C >+G

"# !
Ei K7y(>R 1 + E %/ <+ F

!%=) !
+(Y E C K6 +R !

8
"
&!
+!"h ).S
!h % N E E)(
]<
"h
F@
E #
P
y(>R

1+ E & E()@
+C
"#
/; S
/%6H
) +- E!)
6
(eL E
# +y G>!
! 1%+
%1 % "
??(.G
%?% E!
& E " o
1+i % @ S%!)

P+;
<@ E
)
i @+ (
( "< K?+

"# % uL/= K:> S% E)
- i 1
J7 P1 66422 9e
1999?
E 9P#: 2001P1 63269 E
+7h +L? 1 @ ++
1+i

20023 6
@ E

#

P1
"# !
Ei E(
!
T..%/
15

( 9C E( J7
2002
&i
P1 63960 E1895 E
S#) P1 N3 T< 2001>!

E

P! J7 3

8 P1 65855 % E P1 180 b1%
+ !
T%/
@ E
% 365 K!8") %C E P130 E"

+

! K! E uY%%

6 !

?% >
" !+
E
K

" + E
<+@ 1 91%%6 uL/
% #:
+?J
"# @ +Q + E F!

8
! E@S
!" %+ G
S 8L
T
8.
N@ K<
?

C !+% E3 TP@ ++
F
!(!
:

P
#
: K/L@ E
+;
E )
39545
( F
J7 P1
%) 2002 #
:
1%
/CR !)% (
E
%? % T #
:
/C &< n E
1+!y?
8
/C
!)
1 !y !
: !
+L i!
+3 @+
(
&

!C &
E
FC !
K!L+. G !8@+ E
(
+6 <
% @ FC +<8 &

(1%C FC!

#
:: "
!
%/ 8

8.

!
#
: i 6+ E
++
E KQ!@ P1 21199
)
K!8 ?
) S ) E?%?
1 @ :91
K!8R E!+ ><
#Y% =
++

8 b
Jy
L + K!8@
/ % b E
) 8+ #Y%+M
N!
#
: K/L@ E%
!"> J7><
#Y% +7>
E
..
(@
P
56)^ ^U;3

!? 8 ++ %6 ?+ !
Ei K7y(>R
%/
( @+@ E !

8 J S K8;( +

P
@ N P!+8 P
!. +</ !(
1
#Y% 29
( G

!. )( G o! E@
( /!(!% 3081
@
+C
( @+ y:?
8 <

=
% 35 9e >)S
J7 "
>

!R b T+ >.FC S
J7 (+ % >!+ "

P1(+ +!.E
" E! T "
#%@ E (
"!7<
(

8b"
8
!%
1 C )%
+ 63

!1 = u J(J T
6 +M
E
% ! % 22 ! /+R >)
(@</@ Sy:?
8
E P%&% +L@ E
" E &!
+!"%@ % 3M
%! E6=).
16
E
!? ++ +. GJ E% <)%
@ +%@ +<+
%)@ E J E% J!8 @"(%C K J!8 >
!R
1R +1 E &!
?

?
!P +M

 u
!R GM
@)3#
+6 < % 190
y
S)> u E!< !
8
b y +L ) 3#
!R @"!(
E! %!.
@ !
1 9)!P!(!
!(19
&!)( G o
(. )3# !o.
<L ER &

+"
C F )
i @b!> G
!(! ! !/]< !"% i ]@ G(<1
8!
8<
E H3+..G
@ N 8 E)!

P
(<& E
;+ (>
( F
1
C E
1+i %/ u/
Ey(>R
1++7R
& 98 )%@
1+ %- (
"
8+L
P)3#
J E
(
"# <1
8!%)
<= "#
?%
% 1 K6 y(>R "
1+) + E 3#
(> 32 E

. E K!8
:
(. i
1
!R ( E
8
E

: 3
; +!

N3 >(
+7 @"(
( G
] ?"< !

8 % b1 N@ Ky(>R !
()/ @)
(!( y.

!C E!

8 S+C ?
6 @%/ )

L E!" %
!%= %/ :L
8 >) E>(y %6%
1+ E
C ! .KP
: 8O

7 3 < ?% 8!% b1+/? !(! ! <
1J8
: b%
* !-) b1%
#L. !
8
/http://www.transparency.org
* "h b1%

.
http://www.globalinvestigativejournalism.org
* + b1% y

.
/http://www.tcij.org
* [
?+ G/ +8
Gc b!
http://www.pogar.org/arabic/governance/finances.asp
17
!
1 3> %-) +8 "

G.8 - 1
+ - 1
< " < %

1J7 @
N3 !
M 37 - 2
n+ 3 E +L?
) % %)> 8
> / # ++

http://www.alsahfe.com/index.php?id=2%7C1581&task=show
. 258 1982 >+L %
#
/ - 3
. 40 2009 %/ " ! ; h oC u? # +<: ++@
- 4
. 2009 3 18 % !<
7R +8 %6
- 5
. ( b.< t ) %) 9@ &
! +)
8"@ 1+8 %y# ;
; E + o!7 +QR G# 3 + - 6
.
%8! !
8 /<L E +8
#L! -) b1% - 7
Posted by Dr. Sassine EL Nabbout - 8
Oct 2008 9
http://kadmous.org/wp/?p=1916
?+/R= % +> b1% - 9
http://www.egyptiangreens.com/docs/general/index.php?eh=newhit&subjectid=3655&subcategoryid=2
60&categoryid=36
18

دور الصحافة الاستقصائية في مكافحة الفساد

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

دور الصحافة الاستقصائية في مكافحة الفساد

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

1

   

   ]L 3 !%&% 8?  ? . E!"

! 1 J6 "

! b!.!?  )/ 

(L !)e "+

 ) :Ky ?8

"  ! b"+ 

  ( : 0()*+

* %8 E KP#  8

" +. % )( E. +6 E@

b% E +</!

! + @!  G()/ @

 56* 1 23(  0()*+, " 

< ++/? +

+ % ) % . u

; ;<; :  0()*+

? ) 9 >%# @ 8<+ 

;.@ H* *  ; 55B( *)( :

%> S #!" 

L+M S>+7 +7R

 o ! S8 :L!()

.8 E K!8

 ( : 0()*+,

!"h  

 ^@...\ RO  )8 I@)*  (

t  ++ +:3 ?+7h +L 

  S#) P1 N3 T< 2001>!

! K! E uY%%

<L ER &

1 3> %-)  +8 "

You might also like

]L 3 !%&% 8? ? . E!"

! 1 J6 "

! b!.!? )/

(L !)e "+

) :Ky ?8

" ! b"+

( : 0()*+

* %8 E KP# 8

"+. % )( E.+6 E@

b% E +</!

!+ @! G()/ @

56* 1 23( 0()*+, "

< ++/? +

+ %) %. u

; ;<; : 0()*+

? ) 9 >%# @ 8<+

;.@ H ; 55B( *)( :

%> S #!"

L+M S>+7 +7R

o ! S8 :L!()

.8 E K!8

( : 0()*+,

!"h

^@...\ RO )8 I@)* (

t ++ +:3 ?+7h +L

S#) P1 N3 T< 2001>!

! K! E uY%%

<L ER &

1 3> %-) +8 "