Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION
1.1
Introduction
The main objective of this plant design project is the production of methane from
palm oil mill effluent (POME). POME is a form of biomass. Biomass can be defined as
organic matter that can be used as a source of energy. One example of a commonly used
biomass is wood. Wood has been conventionally used as a form of fuel till the current
era. This chapter will cover the history and background in the production of methane and
also other topics such as the application and uses of methane, market survey, site
locations and the synthesis route of the product.
1.1.1
History
Mankind has, for most of its existence, relied on renewable energy resources like
wood, windmills, water wheels and animals such as horses. The development of new
energy resources was a major driving force of the technological revolution. As for biogas
or methane, it all started in 1630 when Van Helmont mentioned about a flammable gas
emanating from decaying organic matter. Back then, Van Helmont was one of the early
observers and interpreters of natural phenomena who nowadays would be called as
scientists. In 1667, this gas was described more precisely by a man named Shirley. He
is now generally considered as its. An Italian physicist, Alessandro Volta wrote a letter
on November 14, 1776, about a combustible air was being produced continuously in
lakes and ponds in the vicinity of Como in northern Italy. Volta observed that when he
distributed the bottom sediment of the lake, bubbles of gas would rise to the surface. He
also noticed that more bubbles came up when the sediment contained more plant
material.
In 1806, William Henry showed that Voltas gas was identical with methane gas.
Humphrey Davy in the early 1800s observed that methane was present in farmyard
manure piles. In 1808, Davy conducted the first laboratory experiment to produce
methane by anaerobic fermentation of wastes. In earlier periods, anaerobic fermentation
was carried out mainly as a municipal waste treatment process and resulting energy
recovery was not primary concern. In 1895, biogas from a waste treatment plant in Exter
in England was collected and used to light nearby streets.
1.1.2
Background
Biomass is a readily available renewable energy source that has received
increasing attention due to rising prices of fossil fuels and the urgent need to mitigate
anthropogenic global warming. The conversion of biomass into gaseous and liquid
biofuels by microorganisms can be considered as a way to gain safe and sustainable
energy. While the use of energy crops for bioenergy production leads to increase in food
costs, the utilization of agricultural by-products and residues for the production of
biofuels, especially biogas, can increase economic and ecological benefit of biomass use
and concomitantly prevent the accumulation of harmful bio waste in the environment.
Palm oil production is one of the major industries in Malaysia and this country
ranks one of the largest productions in the world. In Malaysia, the total production of
crude palm oil in 2008 was 17,734,441 tonnes. However, the production of this amount
of crude palm oil results in even larger amounts of POME. In the year 2008 alone, at
least 44 million tonnes of POME was generated in Malaysia. Currently, the ponding
system is the most common treatment method for POME but other processes such as
aerobic and anaerobic digestion, physicochemical treatment and membrane filtration
may also provide the palm oil industries with possible insights into the improvement of
POME treatment. The method chosen to be utilized in this plant design project is
anaerobic digestion.
Methane derived from anaerobic treatment of organic wastes has a great potential
to be an alternative fuel. It is an odorless, colorless and non-poisonous gas. The
conversion of the waste to methane, or also denoted as bio methane, is not only an
alternative cost-effective way of energy production, but it also contributes to very large
overall reductions of greenhouse gas emissions as leakages of methane into the
atmosphere are avoided.
The advantage of this process is the option to use the polysaccharide constituents
of plant material to produce energy, such as electrical power and heat, in relatively easyto-manage and small industrial units. Alternatively, the gas can be compressed after
purification and enrichment and then fed to the gas grid or used as a fuel in combustion
engines or cars. Its greatest advantage is the environmentally friendly aspect of the
technology, which includes the potential for complete recycling of minerals, nutrients
(phosphate) and fiber material (for humification) which come from the fields and return
to the soil, playing a functional role by sustaining the soils vitality for future plantation.
1.1.3
of plant based (lignocellulosic) organic waste materials and also from other types of
organic waste such as cow dung, pig slurry, effluent from slaughter houses and landfill.
Biogas, a clean and renewable form of energy could very well substitute (especially in
the rural sector) for conventional sources of energy (fossil fuels, oil, etc.) which are
causing ecological-environmental problems and at the same time depleting at a faster
rate. Biogas is a mixture of mainly methane (CH 4) and CO2 with very small amounts of
sulphuric components H2S. This process is carried out under anaerobic conditions, where
volatile solids are destroyed and converted to methane and carbon dioxide (Power and
Murphy, 2009).
The typical composition of the biogas is 55 70% CH 4, 30 45% CO2, 0 2%
nitrogen and ~500 ppm H2S. Among its components, methane, or also denoted as
biomethane, is the most important one, particularly for the combustion process in
vehicles engines. Methane is a valuable renewable energy source, but also a harmful
greenhouse gas if emitted into the atmosphere. This is due to the greenhouse gas effect
of methane is about 23 times higher than carbon dioxide. Methane gas that is produced
from manure is around 4800 6700 kcal/m 3. As compare with pure methane gas contain
energy of 8900 kcal/m3.
In addition, methane from biogas has definite advantages because it can be
produced when needed and can easily be stored. It can be distributed through the
existing natural gas infrastructure and used in the same applications like the natural gas.
Apart from utilization for renewable electricity and heat production, methane from
biogas can replace fossil fuels in the transport sector.
1.2
Biomethane
1.2.1
What is Biomethane
Biomethane is a naturally occurring gas which is produced by the so-called
anaerobic digestion of organic matter such as dead animal and plant material, manure,
sewage, organic waste, etc. Chemically, it is identical to natural gas which is stored deep
in the ground and is also produced from dead animal and plant material. However, there
are several important differences between biomethane and fossil fuel derived methane
despite the fact that both are produced from organic matter.
Natural gas is classified as fossil fuel, whereas biomethane is defined as a green
source of energy. Like its name suggests, fossil fuel derived methane is produced from
thousands or millions of years old fossil remains of organic matter that lies buried deep
in the ground. Production of fossil fuel derived methane, however, depends exclusively
on its natural reserves which vary greatly from one country to another and are not
available in limitless amounts. Biomethane, on the other hand, is produced from fresh
organic matter which makes it a renewable source of energy that can be produced
worldwide.
Methane is about 20 times more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide if
released into the atmosphere. Furthermore, its use for power generation produces heat
and emits carbon dioxide and some other gases but despite that biomethanehas a number
of environmental benefits which make it a green source of energy. Organic matter from
which biomethane is produced would release the gas into the atmosphere if simply left
to decompose naturally, while other gases that are produced during the decomposition
process such as nitrous dioxide for instance further contribute to the greenhouse effect.
1.2.2
Application of Biomethame
1.2.2.2 Definitions
1. Biogas - Describe the gas which is made in anaerobic digesters or land fill sites
typically 65% methane and 35% carbon dioxide, with contaminants in the form
of water, hydrogen sulphide and siloxanes.
2. Biomethane - Upgraded from biogas. The upgrade process removes the
contaminants and the majority of the carbon dioxide removed. Biomethane is
typically 97% methane, 2% carbon dioxide and 1% oxygen.
3. Natural gas - Such a gaseous fossil fuel consisting primarily of methane but
including significant quantities of ethane, propane, butane, and pentane.
4. Petroleum gas (LPG) - is used to describe a gas produced when refining
petroleum, typically supplied as a variable mix of propane and butane.
1.2.3
Advantage of Biomethane
There are many advantages of biomethane product which has unlimited potential
when it comes to proficient power utilization and preserve the environment at the same
time. Other advantages of biomethane are:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Figure 1.1: Greenhouse Gas Emissions for a 2002 Generic 1.6 L Passenger Car
Source:
Gas Spec
EEV (Directive
CO
NHMC
CH4
NOx
PM
(g/kWh)
3.00
(g/kWh)
0.40
(g/kWh)
0.65
(g/kWh)
2.00
(g/kWh)
0.020
2005/55/EC)
Cursor 8 Litre 200
G 25
2.53
0.006
0.017
0.38
0.003
kW
GR
2.16
0.004
0.015
0.43
0.003
Local authorities to trade allowances rather than pay up to 150 per tonne of waste
sent to landfill.
Each LA is required to reduce disposal of bio-degradable waste to landfill by
progressively increasing amounts up to 65% by 2020.
1.2.4
manure and organic waste resulting from food processing continue to accumulate.
Similarly, harvested bio-mass stored in silos designed to be large enough to maintain the
necessary supply of energy from biogas throughout the year. Thus, the production of
biogas and biomethane makes an important contribution to a stable and reliable energy
supply. The regularity of supply has the ability to balance the fluctuating electricity
production originating from alternative renewable energy sources such as wind and
photovoltaic. This advantage is increased by the ability to inject the gas directly into the
existing natural gas grid and to use it independently from its production location.
1.2.5
direct substitution of biogas for natural gas or LPG, however, will not work for most
standard commercially available burners. At given fuel gas feed pressures, gas must flow
into combustion in the right stoichiometric ratio with air. Because of its high CO 2
content, if biogas flows through the burner orifice at the pressure intended for feeding
methane or propane, the fuel-to-air ratio is insufficient to ensure flame stability.
A relatively simple option is to provide the combustion equipment with a second
as is biogas burner that operates in parallel with the first. In this case, regardless of the
fuel used, air flow is kept constant. Burner orifices for the respective burners can be set
such that each burner meters the proper amount of gas to meet combustion
stoichiometry. This could require other control measures such as (for simplest control)
complete switchovers from pure biogas fuel to the fossil alternative, and modest (a few
hours worth) backup biogas storage, but is otherwise straightforward.
Some operations that use landfill gas have adapted standard equipment to allow
easy switchover from different fuel sources, whether landfill biogas, natural gas, or oil.
An example of such equipment is the Cleaver-Brooks boiler at the Ajinomoto
Pharmaceutical plant in Raleigh North Carolina, which has operated successfully using
landfill gas for more than 10 years (Augenstein and Pacey, 1992; US EPA, 2001).
Conversion of a boiler system to operate on biogas typically involves the
enlargement of the fuel orifice and a restriction of the air intake. Important
considerations include the capability of the combustor to handle the increased
volumetric throughput of the lower-Btu biogas, flame stability, and the corrosive impact
of raw biogas on the burner equipment.
To prevent corrosion from H2S and water vapor, operating temperatures should
be maintained above the dew point temperature (250 F) to prevent condensation. It may
also be advisable to use propane or natural gas for startup and shut down of the system,
since higher operating temperatures cannot be maintained at these times.
If the biogas has energy content lower than 400 Btu/scf, the combustion system
may be limited by the volumetric throughput of the fuel, which may result in de-rating
of the equipment. In addition, the burner orifice should be enlarged to prevent a higher
pressure drop across the burner orifice due to the decreased heating value and specific
gravity of the biogas results. However, orifice enlargement will degrade the performance
of the burner if it is ever operated on natural gas or propane.
To resolve this problem, the propane or natural gas can be mixed with air to
create an input fuel with an equivalent pressure drop and heat input as the biogas. It is
also possible to achieve fuel flexibility by using a dual burner system, as mentioned
above. This allows optimum performance of the burners since they maintain the pressure
drop for each fuel independently.
1.3
Market Survey
Market survey of methane is about an organized effort to gather information
1.3.1
renewable. The largest non-renewable energy resource found in Malaysia is oil, and
second, is natural gas, primarily liquefied natural gas. The energy demand and supply by
source are also shown in relation to the countrys fuel diversification policy. In order to
reduce the overall dependence on a single source of energy, efforts were undertaken to
encourage the utilization of renewable resources.
The demand for supplemental biomethane is growing significantly as
environmental legislation concerning reduction in greenhouse gas emission. Moreover,
against a backdrop of rising crude oil prices, depletion of resources, political instability
in producing countries and environmental challenges, only renewable energy has the
potential to replace the supply of an energy hungry civilization. In this case, due to
biomethane has the potential to replace natural gas, therefore its demands are based on
natural gas demand.
Natural gas is a vital component of the world's supply of energy. Up to 50 to 75%
of natural gas consists of methane. It is one of the cleanest, safest, and most useful of all
energy sources. World natural gas consumption, around 75 trillion cubic feet (TCF) in
1994, is rising faster than that of any other fossil fuel. Although there are abundant of
gas reserves but they are unevenly distributed. The global market for gas is much
smaller than for oil because gas transport is costly and difficult. Furthermore, the
shortage of natural gas becomes a concern nowadays and the world is searching for
another source which more sustainable and not dependent. One of the best solutions is to
establish methane obtained from POME as a renewable source of energy.
A major setback for biomethane is, either it is bought on liquefied natural gas
price or a new price that the government willing to pay for renewable gas. Only few
countries that involved in biomethane production, such as Sweden, Denmark, German,
Finland and now Ontario and Canada, has their own biomethane price in order to
encourage production of biomethane. Hence there are no specific sources on price that
can be reliable for biomethane. Alternatively, in economics term, natural gas price is
used as reference.
Basically, the demand for methane is determined by population growth,
economic growth and per capita consumption. Demand for natural gas also depends
highly on the time of year, and changes from season to season. In countries with four
seasons, in the past, the cyclical nature of natural gas demand has been relatively
straightforward: demand was highest during the coldest months of winter and lowest
during the warmest months of summer. The primary driver for this primary cycle of
natural gas demand is the need for residential and commercial heating. As expected,
heating requirements are highest during the coldest months and lowest during the
warmest months. This has resulted in demand for natural gas spiking in January and
February, and dipping during the months of July and August (EIA, 2011).
Total demand for energy in Malaysia has increased from 1243.7 PJ in 2000 to
1631.7 PJ in 2005 as shown. The main demand in 2005 was for petroleum products
(derived from crude oil) at 62.7%, followed by electricity (utilizing gas, coal and oil) at
19.0%, natural gas at 15.1% and coal & coke at 3.2%. For the year 2007, the total
demand for energy is forecasted to reach 1655 PJ, with the percentage for petroleum
products to decline to 61.4% whereas for coal and coke to increase to 3.9% in line with
the national fuel diversification policy.
Interestingly, the final energy demand reported in 2007 is 1852 PJ which is an
increase of 9.8% compared to the demand in 2006. Even though there is an upward trend
in the demand which is due to the positive growth projection of the economy, the
government will make sure that its fuel diversification policy is executed so as to reduce
Malaysians overdependence on oil as the energy source. The policy focuses on four
main energy sources; oil, gas, coal and hydro for a reliable and secure supply of energy
to the country.
1.3.3
World Demand
Figure 1.4: Energy Consumption by Fuel 1980 2030 (Quadrillion British Thermal
Unit)
Source: EIA Annual Energy Outlook 2009 with Projections to 2030
Based on Figure 1.4, The Energy Information Administration (EIA), in its
Annual Energy Outlook 2009, estimates that natural gas demand in the United States
could be 24.36 TCF by the year 2030. That is an increase of six percent over 2007
demand levels as compared to an expected total energy consumption increase of 12
percent (from 101.89 quadrillion BTU to 113.56 by 2030).
The EIA predicts an annual demand increase of 0.5 percent over the next 21
years and it is important to note that this steady climb in demand for natural gas could
increase as demand for low carbon fuels such as clean natural gas increase. While
forecasts made by different Federal agencies may differ in their exact expectations for
the increase demand for natural gas, one thing is common across studies: demand for
natural gas will continue to increase steadily for the foreseeable future.
1.3.4
Malaysia Demand
The main oil and gas farm is Petroleum Nasional Berhad (Petronas), a 100%
Bio-methane Price
1.4
Synthesis Route
Fresh POME
Digestate
Waste
Treatment
Anaerobic Digester
1. Hydrolysis and
acidogenesis
2. Acetogenesis
3. Methanogenesis
CH4
Lean amine
recycles
the acid removal unit in order to produced purified methane with 99% purity. In this acid
removal gas unit, there are two major equipments which are gas absorber and stripper.
Gas absorber is where the separation of methane from carbon dioxide and hydrogen
sulfide takes place. In this part, carbon dioxide and hydrogen sulfide are known as acid
gas.
This acid gas is removed from biogas with the help of methyldiethanolamine
(MDEA) as the absorbent. The purified methane then fed into gas compressor before
kept in gas storage. MDEA that used in this plant is recycled back into the gas absorber
via stripper. In the stripper unit, acid gas becomes the distillate product and then flare.
The amount of acid gas that been flared could be measured and calculated to obtain
CER. Meanwhile, as for the lean amine, which happened to be the bottom product is
recycled and reused in gas absorber.
1.4.1
with hydrogen sulfide or any other sulfur containing compounds is known as sour gas.
While processing natural gas, it is vital that sour gases are removed from the stream. The
presence of sour gas in pipelines can cause corrosion. Sulfur is also lethal to humans and
animals. Carbon dioxide on the other hand should be removed from stream as it is not
combustible and also forms weak acids that can cause corrosion when water is present.
Therefore, it is an undesired component.
The most commonly used method is sour gas removal is known as sweetening or
amine gas treating. Amine solutions are brought into contact with the gas stream in an
absorber column and the acid gases are absorbed by the amine solutions. Primarily two
forms of amine solutions are used, monoethanolamine (MEA) and ethanolamine (DEA).
Regeneration of the amine solutions are done by removing the sulfur compounds and the
solutions are then recycled.
1.4.2
gas contributing to global warming. Many sources mentioned that this greenhouse gas is
produced in large quantity worldwide by many important industries, including fossil-fuel
electric power generation, steel production, chemical and petrochemical manufacturing,
and cement production. In the past several decades, continuous and rapid development
of these industries has caused considerable concern in this regard.
The growing evidence that links the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide (CO2) and
global climate change highlights the need to develop cost effective carbon sequestration
schemes. CO2 accounts for over eighty-two percent of all greenhouse gas emissions in
the U.S., even after considering its relative greenhouse warming potential (GWP).
Nearly sixty percent of CO2 is emitted by utility or industrial power systems, which are
based on fossil fuel combustion. Future power generation technologies such as fuel cells
or gasification need to mature and to lower costs to gain widespread application.
Vv
vsequently, it is likely that for the next several decades the bulk of the CO2 will be
emitted from the fossil fuel-based energy infrastructure, both existing and that likely to
be added in the near term. Separation of CO2 from a mixture of gases can be
accomplished through various means: low-temperature distillation, membranes,
adsorption, physical and chemical absorption.
Chemical absorption, for example amine-type absorbents, is well suited for CO 2
recovery from flue gas. The chemical reaction between CO 2 and amines greatly
enhances the driving force for the separation, even at low partial pressures of CO 2. The
costs of this technology are relatively insensitive to the feed CO 2 content. Consequently,
chemical absorption with amines provides the most cost-effective means of directly
obtaining high purity (>99%) CO2 vapor from flue gases in a single step.
Chemical absorption with alkanolamines has been generally used in processes
such as natural gas sweetening and hydrogen production for the rejection of carbon
dioxide. However, in these applications, the CO 2 partial pressure is significantly greater
than
that
in flue
gas
such as
MEA
1.4.3
Methyldiethanolamine (MDEA)
Alkanolamines are widely utilised in the chemical industry. For example, they
agricultural products and surfactants. However, in spite of their importance there are
surprisingly few compilations of thermodynamics data for these compounds in the
literature at temperature and pressure conditions removed from ambient.
Methyldiethanolamine (MDEA) is a psychedelic hallucinogenic drug and
empathogen-entactogen of the phenethylamine family. It is a tertiary amine and act as a
solvent. It has a greater capacity to react with acid bases because it can be used in higher
concentrations. This advantage is enhanced by the fact that it is reacting with all of the
H2S and only part of CO2. MDEA also delivers energy savings by reducing reboiler
duties and lowering overhead condenser duties. It has proved to be highly selective for
absorption of H2S when compared to CO2 resulting in even lower circulation rates and
higher quality acid gases for recycle to sulfur recovery unit. Among MEA, DEA, and
MDEA, MEA has worst reputation for corrosion related problem.
1.5
The reaction:
POME
CH4 + CO2
1000 kg
MT
SM3
0.6 kg
9534 kcal
M3
1 mmBtu
RM 13
252190.217 kcal MMBt
u
*(positive value)
EPI > 0
From the analysis above, a value of RM 1.221 x 108/ year is obtained which is a
positive value. Hence, it can be concluded that this project is feasible.
1.6
Objectives