You are on page 1of 8

THE JOURNAL OF ALTERNATIVE AND COMPLEMENTARY MEDICINE

Volume 15, Number 12, 2009, pp. 1285–1291


ª Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
DOI: 10.1089=acm.2007.7118-O

Localization of Acupuncture Points BL25


and BL26 Using Computed Tomography

Dietrich H.W. Groenemeyer, M.D., Ph.D.,1,2 Lei Zhang, M.D.,1


Sven Schirp, M.A.,1,2 and Jürgen Baier, M.D., Ph.D.1

Abstract

Objectives: The aim of this study was to provide a metric description of acupuncture points BL25 and BL26, to
investigate their relation to individual anatomical landmarks and structures, and to identify anatomical struc-
tures that are involved in needle manipulation during de qi.
Design: Fifty-eight (58) white patients with low-back pain received 107 needlings that were documented using
computed tomography (CT).
Outcome measures: For each patient, the body–mass index (BMI) and the interscapular distance were measured.
Using the CT scan, the following parameters were assessed: thickness of the soft tissue layer, distance of the
puncture site and the needle tip to the vertebral line, distance of the needle tip to the body surface and the
intermuscular space, and the needle depth in muscle tissue.
Results: The mean distance from the puncture site to the vertebral line was 3.5  0.5 cm for BL25 and 3.4  0.4 cm
for BL26. The distance of the needle tip to the vertebral line was similar (3.4  0.5 cm for BL25 and 3.2  0.4 cm for
BL26). The mean distance of the needle tip to the body surface was 4.1  0.9 cm at BL25 and 3.9  0.8 cm at BL26.
The majority of the needle tips were located in the intermuscular region between the erector spinae and the
transversospinal muscles. There was a significant correlation between the interscapular distance and the
thickness of the soft tissue layer with the BMI at both acupuncture points. Nearly all parameters correlated with
the BMI. At BL26, correlations between the distance of needle to the vertebral line and the BMI were not
statistically significant but the scatter plots indicate a positive dependency.
Conclusions: The results of this study show an association between de qi and needle location within the inter-
muscular septa. BL25 and BL26 are located as clusters in and around the intermuscular region of the erector
spinae and the transversospinal muscles, with a distance to the vertebral line of 3.49  0.58 cm and
3.32  0.53 cm, respectively. Using proportional methods is relevant for the success of acupuncture therapy.

Introduction efforts have been made to examine the anatomy and physi-
ology of acupuncture points in order to understand the
therapeutic mechanism of acupuncture4–9; however, the
A cupuncture points are known as specific locations of
the body that are needled during acupuncture treatment.
Acupuncture points are located along ‘‘meridians’’ that run
mechanism by which acupuncture works remains contro-
versial. The majority of these studies have been of an experi-
longitudinally along the surface of the body and have been mental nature or in vitro cadaver studies.
defined for several thousand years.1 Despite rapid advances in medical imaging techniques,
Traditionally, acupuncture points are localized using cun as modern imaging has rarely been used to investigate acu-
proportional measurement. In addition, acupuncture guide- puncture points in vivo.10,11
lines refer to anatomical landmarks to help localize the exact Among others, Dachangshu, or Bladder 25 (BL25) and Gua-
position of needle insertion. The individual interscapular nyuangshu, or Bladder 26 (BL26) are acupuncture points that
distance, for example, measures 6 cun. After needle inser- are of relevance for the treatment of low-back pain. They are
tion, the needles are manipulated by the therapist in order to located along the medial segment of the Urinary Bladder me-
achieve a sensation known as de qi that is often elicited to ridian and belong to the acupuncture points associated with
enhance the effect of acupuncture treatment.2,3 Considerable the posterior cutaneous branches of the lumbar spinal nerves.12

1
Groenemeyer Institute of Microtherapy, Bochum, Germany.
2
Department of Radiology and Microtherapy, University of Witten Herdecke, Witten, Germany.

1285
1286 GROENEMEYER ET AL.

The anatomical structures involved and the exact loca- pist (L.Z., 18 years of acupuncture experience). Acupuncture
tion of the needle tip during de qi have not yet been de- was performed using 0.350-mm needles (Seirin Kasei & Co.
scribed. We hypothesize that de qi sensation and acupuncture Deutschland GmbH, Dreieich, Germany) and 0.3575-mm
point location can be related to distinct anatomical structures needles (Suzhou Medical Appliance Factory, Suzhou, China).
using computed tomography (CT) imaging. During the procedure, patients were positioned prone in a CT
The objectives of this study were device (Tomoscan M=EG, Philips Medical Systems, Eintho-

ven, Netherlands). Needles were inserted vertically and the
to provide a metric description of acupuncture points
needle was manually manipulated until both patient and
BL25 and BL26,

therapist confirmed de qi. De qi was confirmed when the pa-
to investigate their relation to individual anatomical
tient reported a feeling of heaviness, paresthesias or tingling, a
landmarks and structures, and

sensation of cold or heat in the needling area, or an aching
to identify anatomical structures that are involved in the
sensation in the area surrounding the needle. On the therapist
manipulation of the needle during de qi.
side, a ‘‘tug’’ on the needle or ascending needle rigidity was
considered a positive de qi. The therapist’s de qi sensation was
Materials and Methods relevant for the de qi confirmation (i.e., if the patient did not
This study was performed at the Groenemeyer Institute of have any sensation but the therapist did, de qi was considered
Microtherapy in Bochum, Germany. The study protocol was positive. No metric was employed for the de qi assessment).
approved by the University of Witten=Herdecke Ethics The patient was then asked not to move and a CT scan
Committee in Witten, Germany. was performed (Fig. 1). At first, a lateral 250-mm routine
topogram was made followed by three 3-mm axial slices
Subjects (one center slice focused on needle entry point, one cranial,
one caudal slice) for image reconstruction. Only axial images
A total of 58 white patients (26 male, 32 female) with low- were used for the analysis.
back pain were enrolled in this study after informed consent After a radiologist had confirmed the position of the
was obtained from each patient. Subjects were patients who needle tip on the CT image, the needle was removed, the
received treatment for low-back pain at our clinic and patient’s interscapular distance was measured in an upright
volunteered for the study from March 2002 to January 2003. position, and the patient was released.
The back pain duration ranged from 6 weeks to several Using the CT scan, the following parameters were as-
years. Only patients without a history of severe internal sessed:
organ disease or psychiatric disorders and with radicular
and=or nonradicular low-back pain were included in this  Thickness of the soft tissue layer (distance between body
study. Exclusion criteria were spinal deformation (e.g., se- surface and muscle tissue measured from the needle
vere scoliosis), spinal tumors, systemic diseases, current use entry point)
of antibiotics, immunosuppressants or anticoagulants, and  Distance of the puncture site to the vertebral line
obviously deviating stature.  Distance of the needle tip to the vertebral line
The mean age of patients treated at BL25 was 62  14 years  Distance of the needle tip to the body surface
(range 35–86 years). The mean age of patients treated at BL26  Needle depth in muscle tissue
was 65  11 years (range 31–82 years).  Distance of the needle tip to the intermuscular space.
Further patient data are summarized in Table 1. Demo- The distance between the acupuncture point and the ver-
graphic data were similar across groups. tebral line was described as ‘‘theoretical distance’’ (i.e., 1.5 cun
based on an interscapular distance of 6 cun), and as ‘‘actual
Protocol distance’’ (i.e., from the puncture site to the vertebral line).
Routine CT examinations that were scheduled as part of
the patient’s back pain therapy were used to perform acu-
Statistical analysis
puncture for this study.
The position of BL25 and BL26 was determined tradition- The statistical analysis was done using SPSS Version 11.0
ally by 2 experienced acupuncture therapists. All needling (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). Continuous variables are shown as
procedures were performed by a single, experienced thera- means  standard deviation and range. Normal distribution

Table 1. Patient Parameters

Acupuncture point

BL25 (n ¼ 28) BL26 (n ¼ 36)

Parameter Mean  SD, range

BMI 26.5  3.5, 18.9–33.3 26.4  3.9, 18.0–37.7


Interscapular distance (cm) 14.1  1.2, 11.0–16.5 13.6  1.5, 11.0–16.5
Soft tissue layera (cm) 2.0  1.0, 0.5–4.8 2.3  1.4, 0.6–7.9
a
Distance between body surface and muscle tissue measured from the needle entry point.
n ¼ number of patients; SD, standard deviation; BMI, body–mass index.
TOMOGRAPHIC LOCALIZATION OF ACUPUNCTURE POINTS 1287

FIG. 1. Localization of the acupuncture needle in the computed tomography image (left: BL25, right: BL 26).

was tested using the Shapiro-Wilk test. Normal distribution dlings at BL26 in 36 patients. De qi was confirmed in 43 (88%)
was concluded from a p value  0.1. To test correlations be- of the needlings performed at BL25 and in 47 (81%) of the
tween variables, the Spearman and the Pearson (for normal needlings at BL26. In the remaining 6 (12%) needlings at
distribution) correlation coefficient were used. Median and BL25 and 11 (19%) needlings at BL26, de qi could not be
mean values of dependent samples were compared using the confirmed by the therapist or the treated patient.
Wilcoxon signed rank test and the paired Student’s t-test (for
normal distribution), respectively. Needle localization
The following correlations were evaluated:
Descriptive data on needle localization for BL25 and BL26
 Interscapular distance and thickness of the soft tissue are summarized in Table 2.
layer with body–mass index (BMI) For both acupuncture points, the difference between the-
 Distance of the puncture site to the vertebral line, dis- oretical and actual distance of the acupuncture point to the
tance of the needle tip to the vertebral line, distance of vertebral line was not statistically significant ( p ¼ 0.527 for
the needle tip to the body surface with BMI BL25, p ¼ 0.105 for BL26). In general, the mean distances
 Distance of the puncture site to the vertebral line, distance from the puncture site to the vertebral line and the needle tip
of the needle tip to the vertebral line, distance of the to the vertebral line were similar, indicating vertical needle
needle tip to the body surface with interscapular distance. placement in most cases.
Conversion of the metric data into the proportional ‘‘cun’’
system resulted in the data shown in Table 3.
Results
Overall, there was no statistically significant difference
Overall, 107 acupuncture needlings were performed: 49 between the positive and negative de qi groups ( p > 1.0) for
(46%) needlings at BL25 in 28 patients and 58 (54%) nee- any of the parameters shown above.

Table 2. Metric Description of Acupuncture Point Location

Acupuncture point (mean  SD)

BL25 (N ¼ 49) BL26 (N ¼ 58)

Positive Negative Positive Negative


Parameter (cm) de qi (n ¼ 43) de qi (n ¼ 6) de qi (n ¼ 47) de qi (n ¼ 11)

Theoretical distance of the acupuncture 3.5  0.3 3.5  0.2 3.4  0.4 3.6  0.4
point to the vertebral line
Actual distance of the puncture site 3.5  0.5 3.2  1.1 3.3  0.4 3.6  0.8
to the vertebral line
Theoretical versus actual distance 0.04  0.39 0.44  0.89 0.09  38 0.08  0.95
of the acupuncture point to the
vertebral line
Distance of the needle tip to the 3.4  0.5 3.2  1.3 3.2  0.4 3.6  0.9
vertebral line
Distance of the needle tip to the 4.1  0.9 3.6  1.1 3.9  0.8 4.5  1.4
body surface
Needle depth in muscle tissue 2.2  0.6 1.7  0.7 1.9  0.6 1.1  1.1

n, number of needlings; SD, standard deviation.


1288 GROENEMEYER ET AL.

Table 3. Proportional Description of Acupuncture Point Location

Acupuncture point (mean  SD)

BL25 (N ¼ 49) BL26 (N ¼ 58)

Positive Negative Positive Negative


Parameter (cun) de qi (n ¼ 43) de qi (n ¼ 6) de qi (n ¼ 47) de qi (n ¼ 11)

Distance of the puncture site 1.52  0.2 1.34  0.4 1.47  0.2 1.55  0.4
to the vertebral line
Distance of the needle tip 1.47  0.2 1.35  0.5 1.44  0.2 1.57  0.5
to the vertebral line
Distance of the needle tip 1.78  0.4 1.54  0.4 1.77  0.4 1.91  0.5
to the body surface

n, number of needlings; SD, standard deviation.

Location of the needle tip In patients where de qi was not confirmed (n ¼ 6 for BL25,
n ¼ 11 for BL26), none of the needle tips were located in the
In the group of needlings with confirmed de qi, the CT
intermuscular region. They were found in the erector spinae
evaluation showed that the majority of needle tips were
muscle, the transversospinal muscle, the soft tissue layer, or
located in a cluster in the intermuscular region between
in the proximity of the facet joints.
the erector spinae and the transversospinal muscles (72%
The evaluation of the distance of the needle tip to the
for BL25 and 60% for BL26). Of these, 58% (BL25) and
intermuscular region resulted in a clear difference between
50% (BL26) were located in the superficial third of the in-
the group that confirmed de qi and the group that did not
termuscular region, 26% (BL25) and 32% (BL26) were lo-
confirm de qi sensation. The needle tip tended to significantly
cated in the median third, and 16% (BL25) and 18% (BL26)
be closer ( p < 0.005) to the intermuscular region when de qi
were found in the profound third of the intermuscular
was confirmed (Fig. 2).
region.
Sixteen percent (16%) (BL25) and 17% (BL26) of the needle
Correlation between measured parameters
tips were located in the erector spinae muscle, and 12%
and the BMI in needlings with confirmed de qi
(BL25) and 17% (BL26) of the needle tips were located in the
transversospinal muscle. Of these, 61% (BL25) and 62% Pearson’s correlation between the interscapular distance,
(BL26) were found in the median third of the muscle, 33% the thickness of the soft tissue layer and the BMI was r ¼ 0.59
(BL25) and 28% (BL26) were located in the profound third, (BL25), 0.44 (BL26) ( p < 0.05), and r ¼ 0.63 (BL25), 0.58 (BL25)
and 5% (BL25) and 9% (BL26) were located in the superficial ( p < 0.05), respectively. This result shows a linear correlation
third of the muscle. At each acupuncture point, 1 needle (2%) between both the interscapular distance as well as the
had perforated the muscle. thickness of the soft tissue layer and the BMI.
In addition, 6% of the needle tips at BL26 were located in Consequently, the correlation of needle locations with the
the proximity of the facet joints. BMI were evaluated and the results are shown in Figures 3–5.

FIG. 2. Distance of the needle tip to the intermuscular region.


TOMOGRAPHIC LOCALIZATION OF ACUPUNCTURE POINTS 1289

FIG. 3. Correlation between the distance of the puncture site to the vertebral line and the body–mass index.

The scatter plots show trends of positive dependency be- The results of this study confirm classic and current de-
tween all parameters and the BMI. At acupuncture point scriptions of the localization of acupuncture points.13–15 To
BL26, correlations between the distance of the puncture site date, several studies have been performed to investigate the
to the vertebral line and the BMI, and between the distance anatomical structures involved in de qi to find an explanation
of the needle tip to the vertebral line and the BMI were for the mechanisms and the physiology responsible for this
not statistically significant, although the scatter plots (Figs. 3 sensation.6,16–18 These studies were mostly experimental in
and 4) indicate a positive dependency. nature, including animal studies and studies in human ca-
davers. Although many of them have contributed to the
understanding of de qi, many studies lack standards in the
Discussion
localization of acupuncture points or needle manipulation.
To localize and evaluate acupuncture points BL25 and The results of our study support the hypothesis suggested by
BL26, 107 needlings were performed in 58 patients and Langevin et al. that the network of acupuncture points
documented using CT. Using this imaging modality, the and meridians is a signal transduction network formed by
needle position could be accurately described. The majority interstitial connective tissue.7 In their study, mapping of
of needle tips were located in a cluster in the intermuscular acupuncture points on the human arm showed an 80% cor-
region between the erector spinae and the transversospinal respondence between the sites of acupuncture points and the
muscles. location of intermuscular or intramuscular connective tissue

FIG. 4. Correlation between the distance of the needle tip to the vertebral line and the body–mass index.
1290 GROENEMEYER ET AL.

FIG. 5. Correlation between the distance of the needle tip to the body surface and the body–mass index.

planes in postmortem tissue sections. The intermuscular et al. evaluated acupuncture point Yao Tu to define needling
septa, related to the de qi response in our investigation, are depth and a safety depth.22 The evaluation included one
sites of fascial and connective tissue planes. This association needling; thus, no statistical analysis was done. Yao Tu is an
between de qi and needle location within the intermuscular empirical acupuncture point that is not listed on China’s
septa suggests that acupuncture needle manipulation pro- official standard (GB=T12346-1990).
duces cellular changes that disperse along connective tissue A limitation of this study is the lack of a control group and
planes. the fact that the treatment effect of acupuncture was not in-
The important role of the nervous system in the effect of vestigated. This study did not evaluate the efficacy of acu-
acupuncture has also been well described.12,19 The CT eval- puncture treatment for low-back pain but rather aimed at a
uation in our study showed that during de qi, the majority of description of the location of acupuncture points relevant for
the needle tips were located in a cluster in the intermuscular this treatment. Since an association between needle position
region between the erector spinae and the transversospinal and relevant anatomical structures could be shown, it would
muscles (72% for BL25 and 60% for BL26) and in the median be important to investigate whether the results can be asso-
third of these two muscles. The relevant nerves that can be ciated with any treatment effect. No conclusive data on
found in the intermuscular region are the ramus cutaneus the treatment effect could have been obtained from patients
dorsalis medialis L 4 (BL25) and the ramus cutaneus dorsalis enrolled in this study, because the large majority received
medialis L 5 (BL26). It is likely that this nerve is provoked acupuncture in addition to other back pain therapies such
during needle manipulation in this region and it is important as injections or ablative interventions. CT was shown to be
to note that this nerve is a target of multiple types of invasive suitable for this investigation but does have limitations in the
and ablative procedures for the treatment of back pain. detailed evaluation of tissue. Magnetic resonance imaging
Several studies in considerably larger populations have (MRI) should be used to obtain more detailed images of an-
shown that acupuncture can effectively reduce pain in pa- atomical structures surrounding the acupuncture needle, al-
tients with back pain.20,21 If acupuncture stimulates relevant though nonmagnetic needles are required for MRI evaluation.
nervous structures, its value in the treatment of back pain Moncayo et al. have been able to demonstrate the relation of
may at least partially be explained. acupuncture points to musculoskeletal structures in vivo us-
The interscapular distance is a central landmark for the ing three-dimensional rendering of MRI data and have sug-
localization of acupuncture points on the back. This study gested a close relation of acupuncture points of the Yang and
showed a significant correlation between the interscapular Yin motility vessels as well as of the Dai mai to tendinomus-
distance and the thickness of the soft tissue layer with the cular structures.23 Similar studies should be performed com-
BMI at both acupuncture points, supporting the use of pro- paring groups with positive and negative treatment effects to
portional measurements for the localization of BL25 and further investigate the role of anatomical structures involved
BL26. Overall, the needle locations in this study correlated in acupuncture.
with the BMI, indicating that metric measures alone are in-
sufficient to locate acupuncture points. The results suggest
Conclusions
that proportional methods should be used to effectively
target acupuncture needles and that specific anatomical The results of this study show an association between de qi
structures must be provoked in order to achieve de qi. and needle location within the intermuscular septa. Acu-
The authors are aware of only one report on the use of CT puncture points BL25 and BL26 are located as clusters in or
for the evaluation of acupuncture points. In 2006, Huang close to the intermuscular region of the erector spinae and
TOMOGRAPHIC LOCALIZATION OF ACUPUNCTURE POINTS 1291

the transversospinal muscles, with a distance to the vertebral 13. Yan Z. Anatomical Atlas of Acupuncture Points. London:
line of 3.49  0.58 cm and 3.32  0.53 cm, respectively. The Donica Publishing Ltd., 2003.
needle position correlates with individual anatomical land- 14. Qui P. The New Chinese acupuncture and Moxibustion
marks, suggesting that the use of proportional methods is (Chi). Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Publish-
relevant for the success of acupuncture therapy. ing House, 1992.
15. Ji-zhou. Great Compendium of Acupuncture and Moxibus-
Disclosure Statement tion. Beijing: Government of China, 1601.
16. Lin JG. Studies of needling depth in acupuncture treatment.
No competing financial conflicts exist. Chin Med J 1997;110:154–156.
17. Langevin HM, Churchill DL, Cipolla MJ. Mechanical
References signaling through connective tissue: A mechanism for
the therapeutic effect of acupuncture. Faseb J 2001;15:2275–
1. Bossy J. Morphological data concerning the acupuncture
2282.
points and channel network. Acupuncture Electrother Res
18. Lin JG. Evaluation of the depth of de-qi for various acu-
1984;9:79–106.
puncture loci on human thorax and correlation between de-qi
2. MacPherson H, Asghar A. Acupuncture needle sensations
and electric resistance [in Chinese]. Chin J Mod Dev Trad
associated with De qi: A classification based on experts’
Med 1991;11:628–630.
ratings. J Altern Complement Med 2006;12:633–637.
19. Cai W. Acupuncture and the nervous system. Am J Chin
3. Leung AY, Park J, Schulteis G, et al. The electrophysiology of
Med 1992;20(3–4):331–337.
de qi sensations. J Altern Complement Med 2006;12:743–750.
20. Haake M, Muller HH, Schade-Brittinger C, et al. German
4. Ahn AC, Colbert AP, Anderson BJ, et al. Electrical properties
acupuncture trials (GERAC) for chronic low back pain:
of acupuncture points and meridians: A systematic review.
Randomized, multicenter, blinded, parallel-group trial with
Bioelectromagnetics 2008;29:245–256.
3 groups. Arch Intern Med 2007;167:1892–1898.
5. Heine H. Anatomical structure of acupoints. J Trad Chin
21. Manheimer E, White A, Berman B, et al. Meta-analysis:
Med 1988;8:207–212.
Acupuncture for low back pain. Ann Intern Med 2005;142:
6. Langevin HM, Churchill DL, Wu J, et al. Evidence of con-
651–663.
nective tissue involvement in acupuncture. Faseb J 2002;
22. Huang SR, Lin QX, Tang J, Chen JC. Study on the needling
16:872–874.
depth of point Yaotu with CT scanning [in Chinese]. Chin
7. Langevin HM, Yandow JA. Relationship of acupuncture
Acupuncture Moxibustion 2006;26:635–638.
points and meridians to connective tissue planes. Anat Rec
23. Moncayo R, Rudisch A, Kremser C, Moncayo H. 3D-MRI
2002;269:257–265.
rendering of the anatomical structures related to acupunc-
8. Shang C. Electrophysiology of growth control and acu-
ture points of the Dai mai, Yin qiao mai and Yang qiao mai
puncture. Life Sci 2001;68:1333–1342.
meridians within the context of the WOMED concept of
9. Zhang D, Ding G, Shen X, et al. Role of mast cells in acu-
lateral tension: Implications for musculoskeletal disease.
puncture effect: A pilot study. Explore 2008;4:170–177.
BMC Musculoskel Disord 2007;8:33.
10. Moncayo R, Rudisch A, Diemling M, Kremser C. In-vivo
visualisation of the anatomical structures related to the
acupuncture points Dai mai and Shen mai by MRI: A single- Address correspondence to:
case pilot study. BMC Med Imaging 2007;7:4. Dietrich H.W. Groenemeyer, M.D., Ph.D.
11. Fang JL, Krings T, Weidemann J, et al. Functional MRI in Grönemeyer Institute of Microtherapy
healthy subjects during acupuncture: Different effects of Universitätsstrabe 142
needle rotation in real and false acupoints. Neuroradiology D 44799 Bochum
2004;46:359–362.
Germany
12. Dung HC. Acupuncture points of the lumbar plexus. Am
J Chin Med 1985;13(1–4):133–143. E-mail: krueger@groenemeyer.com

You might also like