Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FOR PREVENTING
HOT-DIP GALVANIZING
BY BERNARDO DURAN, III AND THOMAS LANGILL, PHD
BACKGROUND
specific
areas
galvanizing
to
prior
prevent
to
zinc
hot-dip
from
well
at
masking
steel
prior
to
AGA members.
galvanizing.
INTRODUCTION
(AGA)
to
study
was
conducted
determine
when
Attempting
the
given
to
performance
shorter
restore
of
cure
the
the
times.
original
galvanizing.
TEST PROCEDURE
than 4.
the
study
materials.
Figure 3).
galvanizing
process,
meaning
were
in
diameter
and
Duct Tape
Kapton Tape
on flat plate)
DAP
Household
Adhesive
Sealant
Stop Galv
cleaning
galvanizing
Galva Stop
prior to galvanizing.
Macropoxy 846
3M High Temperature
steps
of
the
metal-bristled
brush.
Aluminum Tape
The
masking
material
came
down
to
masking material.
PHASE 1 TESTING
For flat plate, greater than 90% of the
threaded
holes,
almost
the
entire
including:
DAP
Household
Adhesive
Sealant
entire
Macropoxy 846
threaded
area
must
remain
TEST 1 RESULTS
On the flat plate, nine products failed to
prevent galvanizing on a minimum of
galvanizing
on
Galva Stop
bolt
threads.
Stop Galv
Stop Galv
DAP
Galva Stop
Macropoxy 846
Household
The
Adhesive
Sealant
The
bolts
masked
with
Valmont
manufactures
in Appendix 1.
PHASE 2 TESTING
curing
instructions
to
AND CLEANING
how
the
products
that
The
included:
Stop Galv
Galva Stop
DAP
be considered successful.
Household
Adhesive
criteria
for
determining
the
Sealant
For the flat plate specimens, each
Although Valmont Masking Compound
be
used
in
accordance
with
the
TEST 2 RESULTS
FLAT PLATE
Stop
Galv
and
Galva
Stop
were
hours.
Some ashy material from Stop Galv and
For both the flat plate specimens and the
brush.
masking materials.
not
materials
underneath.
recommended.
and
The
attacked
grinder
the
steel
specimens only.
BOLT THREADS
Three different cure times were tested
for each masking material on bolt
threads, including 30 minutes, 1 hour,
and 2 hours. For the 30 minute cure time
Galva Stop and NAPA RTV Red were
the only products that successfully
prevented galvanizing.
Figure 4: Simple Green and Nylon Brush
successfully
prevented
threads.
CONCLUSION
materials
work
best
at
preventing
solution.
Stop Galv
residue.
Some
baked
on
masking
Galva Stop
Sealant
presented in Appendix 2.
these
materials.
Necessary
these
masking
materials
had
Appendix 1.
Detailed Performance Data of Masking Materials
11
$170.00 / gal.
Valmont
Masking
Compound
ZYP Boron
Nitride Hardcoat
$120.00 / gal.
Maskote Zinc
Stop - Off
$45.00 / qt.
$89.78 /
gal. of Part A & B
Macropoxy 846
Stop Galv
GE 100%
Silicone Caulk
$0.35 / oz
$48.00 / liter
Galva Stop
$0.49 / oz
DAP 100%
Silicone
Adhesive
$1.33 / oz
$0.37 / oz
$1.41 / oz
$1.29 / oz
$0.94 / oz
$1.42 / oz
$1.42 / oz
Price
Product
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
N/A
N/A
1 min.
5 mins.,
48 secs.
4 mins.,
26 secs.
2 mins.,
32 secs.
1 min.
1 min.
N/A
1 min.,
32 secs.
2 mins., 37
secs.
N/A
1 min.
2 mins.,
38 secs.
2 mins.,
21 secs.
1 min.,
22 secs.
N/A
N/A
Standardized
Application Removal
Success
Price
Time
Time
FLAT PLATE
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Success
3 mins.,
24 secs.
10 mins.,
30 secs.
N/A
N/A
5 mins.,
13 secs.
32 mins.,
26 secs.
1 min.,
15 secs.
N/A
6 mins.,
30 secs.
Application
Time
7 mins.,
52 secs.
5 mins.,
28 secs.
N/A
N/A
3 mins.
8 mins.,
40 secs.
5 mins.,
18 secs.
N/A
12 mins., 5
secs.
Removal
Time
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Success
N/A
N/A
5 mins.
9 mins.,
45 secs.
5 mins.,
12 secs.
37 mins.,
10 secs.
10 mins.,
30 secs.
3 mins.
9 mins.,
30 secs.
Application
Time
BOLT THREADS
N/A
N/A
10 mins.,
20 secs.
4 mins.,
18 secs.
3 mins.,
5 secs.
1 min.,
11 secs.
7 mins.,
30 secs.
6 mins.,
50 secs.
4 mins.,
22 secs.
Removal
Time
12
Poured onto the surface and
spread with a foam paint brush.
32 mins., 14 secs.
(31/32 mins.
spent on prep
time for epoxy)
2 mins., 37 secs.
1 min., 32 secs.
4 mins., 26 secs.
2 mins., 32 secs.
1 hr., 33 mins.
3 mins., 48 secs.
4 mins., 16 secs.
Macropoxy 846
Maskote Zinc
Stop - Off
Stop Galv
Valmont Masking
Compound
Yes
Yes
Yes
30 mins.
Kapton Tape
Yes
1 mins., 22 secs.
GE 100%
Silicone Caulk
2 mins., 21 secs.
Galva Stop
Yes
25 mins.
Duct Tape
3 mins., 42 secs.
Dow Corning
Compound #111
3 mins., 20 secs.
DAP Household
Adhesive Sealant
Almost
Masking
Success
Application Notes
17 mins., 26 secs.
Application
Time
3M High
Temperature
Aluminum Tape
Product
Notes
N/A
2 mins., 32 secs.
N/A - product
failed completely.
1 min.
5 mins., 48 secs.
1 min.
1 min.
1 min.. 37 secs.
18 mins., 39 secs.
1 min.
2 mins., 38 secs.
10 mins., 52 secs.
40 secs.
2 mins., 11 secs.
9 mins., 24 secs.
Removal Time
N/A
N/A
Removal Notes
13
3 mins.
5 mins.
2 mins.,
30 secs.
1 min.,
15 secs.
Dow Corning
Compound #111
Duct Tape
Galva Stop
GE 100%
Silicone Caulk
5 mins.,
13 secs.
1 min.
4 mins.
10 mins.,
30 secs.
N/A
3 mins.,
24 secs.
4 mins.,
16 secs.
Macropoxy 846
Maskote Zinc
Stop - Off
Stop Galv
Valmont Masking
Compound
Yes
N/A
Yes
Yes
Yes
N/A
32 mins.,
26 secs.
8 mins.
Kapton Tape
Yes
Yes
6 mins.,
30 secs.
Masking
Success
DAP 100%
Silicone Adhesive
Application Notes
9 mins.,
41 secs.
Application
Time
3M HIgh
Temperature
Aluminum Tape
Product
5 mins.,
40 secs.
N/A
7 mins.,
52 secs.
N/A
5 mins.,
28 secs.
11 mins.,
30 secs.
1 of the 6 holes galvanized
N/A
5 mins.,
51 secs.
8 mins.,
40 secs.
Used flat-head screwdriver to scrape out tape, then used a metalbristled brush to get the rest. Some unmasked areas around holes
did not galvanize, which could fail inspection after galvanizing.
5 mins.,
18 secs.
8 mins.,
26 secs.
6 mins.,
17 secs.
Removal Notes
12 mins.,
5 secs.
6 mins.,
17 secs.
Removal
Time
3 mins.,
50 secs.
Notes
14
Yes
N/A
8 mins.
5 mins., 30
secs.
3 mins.
10 mins., 30
secs.
6 mins., 30
secs.
Duct Tape
Galva Stop
GE 100%
Silicone Caulk
Kapton Tape
N/A
4 mins., 5 secs.
5 mins., 14
secs.
9 mins., 10
secs.
Valmont Masking
Compound
Yes
5 mins.
Stop Galv
Yes
9 mins., 45
secs.
Yes
Maskote Zinc
Stop - Off
5 mins., 12
secs.
Macropoxy 846
Yes
37 mins., 10
secs.
Yes
Yes
Dow Corning
Compound #111
9 mins., 30
secs.
Masking
Success
DAP Household
Adhesive Sealant
Application Notes
11 mins., 16
secs.
Application
Time
3M High
Temperature
Aluminum Tape
Product
N/A
N/A
4 mins., 57 secs.
N/A
N/A
10 mins., 20 secs.
4 mins., 18 secs.
3 mins., 5 secs.
1 min., 11 secs.
N/A
N/A
N/A
7 mins., 30 secs.
Threads
were completely bare.
Removal Notes
6 mins., 50 secs.
5 mins., 44 secs.
2 mins., 40 secs.
4 mins., 22 secs.
7 mins., 55 secs.
Removal Time
Notes
15
Price
$3.98 / 2.8 oz. tube
$48.00 / liter
$4.97 / 10.1 oz. tube
$120.00 / gal.
$14.19 / 11 oz. tube
$45.00 / qt.
Product
Galva Stop
Stop Galv
Yes
Yes
1 Hour Cure
Time Success
Yes
Yes
2 Hour Cure
Time Success
FLAT PLATE
Yes
Yes
30 Min. Cure
Time Success
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
1 Hour Cure
Time Success
BOLT THREADS
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
2 Hour Cure
Time Success
16
Price
$3.98 / 2.8 oz. tube
$48.00 / l.
$4.97 / 10.1 oz. tube
$120.00 / gal.
$14.19 / 11 oz. tube
$45.00 / qt.
Product
Galva Stop
Stop Galv
$1.41 / oz
$1.29 / oz
$0.94 / oz
$0.49 / oz
$1.42 / oz
$1.42 / oz
Standardized
Price
Yes
Yes
1 Hour Cure
Time Success
Yes
Yes
2 Hour Cure
Time Success
FLAT PLATE
Yes
Yes
30 Min. Cure
Time Success
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
1 Hour Cure
Time Success
BOLT THREADS
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
2 Hour Cure
Time Success
17
Maskote
Zinc Stop - Off
GE 100%
Silicone Caulk
Stop Galv
Yes
Galva Stop
Yes
DAP Household
Adhesive
Sealant
Success
Product
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Success
Notes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Success
Notes
Applied w/ a foam brush. One bolt out of the 5 had a little zinc
on it. The material was very gummy and took longer to remove.
Notes
Appendix 2.
Pictures of Masking Materials During Phase 1 Testing
Duct Tape
Galva Stop
Kapton Tape
Macropoxy 846
Stop Galv
Additional Pictures