Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5: 247-254 (1996)
ORIGINAL REPORT
SUMMARY
In an attempt to assess the relative toxicity of amoxycillin and amoxycillin-clavulanic acid, we
compared the adverse drug reactions reports collected using the spontaneous reporting system of a
Regional Drug Surveillance Centre of Spain for both drugs between November 1986 and December
1992. During the 7-year period 1986-92, the 247 reports of amoxycillin-clavulanic acid represent twice
the number of reports of amoxycillin alone, and the number of reports related with sales received
concerning the association were higher than those concerning amoxycillin alone. The adverse effects
classified as severe were quantitatively and qualitatively similar for both drugs and gastrointestinal and
skin are the most common system-organ affected by both drugs. With amoxycillin-clavulanic acid
there is a higher proportion of stomatological reactions reported and a later onset of adverse drug
reactions related with oropharyngeal lesions, and the reaction of the resistance mechanism when
compared with the other organs and systems affected. The duration of the adverse drug reactions to
amoxycillin-clavulanic acid is longer than for amoxycillin alone. In conclusion: (i) the adverse drug
reactions profile of both drugs is different; (ii) the higher reporting rate for amoxycillin-clavulanic acid
may be due to more recent marketing; and (iii) amoxycillin-clavulanic acid produces proportionately
more gastrointestinal and fewer skin adverse reactions than amoxycillin alone.
KEY WORDS - amoxycillin; amoxycillin-clavulanic
drug reactions
INTRODUCTION
248
I. MARTINEZ-MIR ET A L
Amoxycillinclavulanic acid
Amoxycillin
Overall
1986*
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
4
41
37
38
34
32
31
1
20
22
13
9
14
13
103
796
817
824
887
926
1077
Total
217
92
5430
*Only 43 days
(1996)
249
Central/autonomic NS
Organ senses
Psych ia t r ic
Gast ro -in test inal
Liver and biliary
Endocrine/metabolism
Card iovas cu la r
Respiratory
H ae mato logy
Urinary
Rep roduct ive
Body as a whole
Resistance mechanism
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
247-254 (1996)
250
1. MARTINEZ-MIR ET AL.
Abdominal pain
Colitis
Constipation
Diarrhoea
Dys ph ag ia
Dyspepsia
Enan thema
Enteritis
Flatulence
Gastritis
Gastroin te. haemorr
Gingivitis
Haemor roids
Hiccup
Ileus
Nausea
Stomati tis
Tongue disorder
Toot h d isco 1ou ratio n
Vomiting
10
15
20
Amoxycillin-clavulanic acid
Amoxycillin
Fig. 2 - Profiles of the proportion of the total number of reports of amoxycillin-clavulanic acid and amoxycillin
for digestive reactions reported from November 1986 to December 1992 to the Comunidad Valenciana Regional
Drug Surveillance Centre. Note that a single report can contain several clinical manifestations
247-254 (1996)
25 1
Mild 84
77 repor
Severe 2%
2 reports
Moderate 14%
13 reports
Severe 1%
3 reports
oderate 23%
49 reports
Amoxycillin-clavulanic acid
Amoxycillin
Fig. 3 - Summary of the adverse drug reactions reported according to the severity of the adverse effect using the
Spanish National Pharmacovigilance System rules from November 1986 to December 1992
24.87
6.7
14.0
4.27
2.5
1.02
Table 3 - Onset and duration period for the different organs and systems affected
Onset period
(days; mean SD)*
AmoxycillinAmoxycillin
clavulanic acid
Overall
Digestive
Skin
Oropharyngeal
Resistance mechanism
2.89k3.07 (388)
2.70f2.46 (219)
2.68f2.01 (106)
4.47f2.00 (34)f
9.50f9.31 (8)f
Duration
(days; mean fSD)*
AmoxycillinAmoxycillin
clavulanic acid
3.08k2.48 (163)
3.36k2.79 (39)
3.27k2.47 (97)
2.67+ 1.25 (3)
~
4.64f7.08 (359)t
4.43k7.34 (199)
3.88f3.77 (100)
13.20+ 15.22 (30)$
8.50 +_ 2.99 (6)
~
3.1912.00 (133)
3.10f 1.86 (77)
3.27k2.47 (97)
2.67+ 1.25 (3)
_
(1996)
Tooth discolouration
Improves
Known from
anecdotal reports
Known from
anecdotal reports
Known from
anecdotal reports
Unknown
Pharyngi tis
ACA
ACA
63/M
35/F
Tonsillitis
41/F
Otitis media
Palpitation
Dizziness
Haemorrhoids
Unknown
Condition aggravated
Unknown
Urine discolouration
Lacrimation discolouration
Unknown
Dizziness
Sinusitis
ACA
1 I/F
4 1 ~ A
Tooth discolouration
Otitis media
ACA
Tooth discolouration
11/M
7 1 ~ ACA
Improves
Unknown
Upper respiratory
tract infection
Upper respiratory
tract infection
Tonsillitis
ACA
2IM
Improves
Improves
Unknown
Unknown
Salpingitis
Pyelonephritis
ACA
ACA
33/F
62/M
Improves
Unknown
Gastroenteritis
Epistaxis
Gastritis haemorrhagic
Vomiting
Haemorrhage rectum
Haematemesis
Haemolytic anaemia
ACA
3 1 ~
Improves
Unknown
ACA
17/M
Improves
Improves
Improves
Improves
Improves
Improves
information
No alternative
No alternative
No information
No information
No information
No information
No information
No information
No information
No alternative
No alternative
Weak alternative
Strong alternative
No alternative
No alternative
No information
No information
No alternative
No information
NO
No information
No information
No information
No alternative
Positive: ADR
reappeared
No information
No alternative
No information
ACA
69/F
Unknown
Strong alternative
No information
No alternative
Alternative
ethiologic
candidates
Rechallenge
Improves
Unknown
Stomatitis
ACA
33/F
Upper respiratory
tract infection
Upper respiratory
tract infection
Tonsillitis
Tonsillitis
3 1 ~ ACA
Information against
the relationship
Unknown
Urinary retention
Constipation
Exanthema
Photosensitivity reaction
Exanthema
Photosensitivity reaction
Pruritus
Fixed drug eruption
Tonsillitis
3 1 ~ ACA
Diagnosis
Drug
Age/sex
(years)
Table 4 - Details of the patients experiencing adverse events in temporal association with the use of these medicines, but they are not published or
there are only anecdotal reports in the literature
r-.
h
Y
A
k
%
=!
h)
VI
h)
253
5: 247-254 (1996)
254
1. MARTINEZ-MIR ET AL.
REFERENCES
1. Brogden, R. N., Carmine, A., Heel, R. C., Morley,
P. A., Speight, T. M. and Avery, G. S. Amoxycillin/
clavulanic acid: A review of its antibacterial activity,
pharmacokinetic and therapeutic use. Drugs 1981;
22: 337-362.
2. Wiholm, B. E. Postmarketing surveillance of adverse
drug reactions by spontaneous reporting and register
data: The Swedish approach. In: Drug Epidemiology
and Postmarketing Surveillance. Strom, B. L. and
Velo, G. (Eds), Planeum Press, New York, 1992,
pp. 9-20.
3. Speirs, C. J. Prescription-related adverse reaction
profiles and their use in risk-benefit analysis. In:
Iatrogenic Diseases. DArcy, P. F. and Griffin, J. P.
(Eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1986,
pp. 93-101.
4. Rawlins, M. D. Spontaneous reporting of adverse
drug reactions I: The uses. British Journal of Clinical
Pharmacology 1988; 26: 7- 11.
5. Tubert-Bitter, P. and Begaud, B. Comparing safety
of drugs. Post Marketing Surveillance 1993; 7 :
119- 137.
6. Capella, D., Avila, P., Cabeza, L., Moreno, V.,
Vidal, X. and Laporte, J. R. Cuatro afios de
experiencia en farmacovigilancia. Medicina Clinica
(Barcelona) 1988; 91: 93-96.
7. Meyboom, R. H. B. and Royer, R. J. Causality
classification at pharmacovigilance centers in the
European community. Pharmacoepidemiology and
Drug Safety 1992; 1: 87-89.
8. World Health Organization Collaborating Centre
for International Drug Monitoring of Adverse
Reaction Terminology. Uppsala, 1984.
9. Begaud, B., Pere, J.-C. and Miremont, G. Estimation of the denominator in spontaneous reporting.
Post Marketing Surveillance 1993; 7 : 51-70.
247-254 (1996)