Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 of 8
libcom.org
blog
news
http://libcom.org/library/zanj-slaves-rebellion-ad-869-883
library
history
gallery
organise
forums
Home
Featured
Posted By
Mike Harman
Jul 4 2007 18:40
Tags
Middle East, Iraq,
Melancholic
Troglodytes, 1-1000AD,
class struggle, slavery,
uprisings, Islam
Share
Related
Ancient utopia and
peasant revolts in
China- Ngo Van Xuyet
A proletarian critique of
the Nation of IslamMelancholic
Troglodytes
Class struggle and this
thing called the Middle
East- Melancholic
Trogladytes
Why the reversion to
Islamic archaism?- Lafif
Lakhdar
Revolutionary Reading
Guide
Attached files
Info
The libcom library contains nearly 20,000
articles. If it's your first time on the site, or
you're looking for something specific, it can be
difficult to know where to start. Luckily, there's a
range of ways you can filter the library content
to suit your needs, from casual browsing to
researching a particular topic. Click here for the
guide.
If you have an ebook reader or a Kindle, check
out our guide to using ebook readers with
19/9/2015 12:55 PM
2 of 8
http://libcom.org/library/zanj-slaves-rebellion-ad-869-883
libcom.org.
If you'd like to upload content to the library
which is in line with the aims of the site or will
otherwise be of interest to libcom users, please
check out our guides to submitting library/history
articles and tagging articles. If you're not sure if
something is appropriate for the library, please
ask in the feedback and content forum. If you
don't have permissions to post content yet, just
request it here.
"Hence a wise general makes a point of foraging on the enemy. One cartload
of the enemy's provisions is equivalent to twenty of one's own..."
- Sun Tzu, The Art of War
MILITARY ASPECT
No sooner had they taken up arms (well pots and pans to be more precise)
against their exploiters that they became adept at night-raids on enemy
territory, liberating weapons, horses, food and fellow slaves, burning the rest
to cinders to delay retaliation. During their 15 year uprising (869-883 A.D.) the
Zanj acquired what was for its time state of the art technology: siege-laying
catapults; flame-throwers; rapid chariots; multi-headed arrows. They trained
expert engineers who blocked the enemy's advance by constructing
impenetrable fortresses, cocooned inside layers of water canals or conversely
built rapid bridges and communication lines for uninvited courtesy calls to the
citadels of the gods.
Perhaps taking a leaf out of Spartacus's defeat they did not handicap
themselves by ignoring the seas. They possessed war ships and freighters. In
one battle alone they overcame the Khalifeh's navy to capture 24 ships, which
had been chained together by their captains to enhance their defensive
capabilities! Rafi' in what seems to us an exaggeration puts the Zanj naval
force at 1900 ships!
"We are not fit to lead an army on the march unless we are familiar with the
face of the country - its mountains and forests, its pitfalls and precipices, its
marshes and swamps."
- Sun Tzu, The Art of War
ISLAMIC EMPIRE AND RACE
The Abbasi Empire (750-1258 AD) understood the concept of a progressive
civilization as one constantly increasing its surplus profit. The Tigris-Euphrates
delta, which had become abandoned marshland as a result of peasant
migration and repeated flooding, could be reclaimed through intensive labour.
Wealthy proprietors "had received extensive grants of tidal land on the
condition that they would make it arable" (Davis, Slavery And Human Progress,
p5).
To this end Zanjis, or black slaves of East African origin, were imported. The
term Zanj appears on the one hand associated to a certain geographical area
and on the other it became a "free-floating" classificatory label used for
stereotyping the zanj-as-enslaveable barbarians. This construct then facilitates
the ideological justification for slavery (P. F. de Moraes Farias, Slave & Slavery
in Muslim Africa, ed. J. R. Willis, vol. I, p 27).
The preponderance of foreign slaves in the Islamic Empire was due to an
ironic quirk in the evolution of Islam. The orientalist, Bernard Lewis, is
reasonably lucid on this. He starts by noting, "Quran expresses no racist or
colour prejudice" (B. Lewis, Race and Slavery in the Middle East, p 21). In fact
it had no conception of race in terms of colour, having already decided on the
believer/non-believer criterion for social exclusion. That is not to say early
Muslims were colour blind (see for example, Quran, Chapter XLIX, Verse 13).
Quran's lack of prejudice merely reflected the attitude of pre-Islamic Arabs
who possessed a tribal/ethnic rather than a racial consciousness. Although, it
is worth remembering that, as a reaction against Persian expansionism the
latter were derogatory referred to as "the red people".
19/9/2015 12:55 PM
3 of 8
http://libcom.org/library/zanj-slaves-rebellion-ad-869-883
There was a gigantic hypocrisy at the heart of the Islamic attitude to slavery
from the outset. For whereas the prophet himself both possessed slaves and
permitted slavery as an institution to flourish, the humanitarian tendencies
within Islam prohibited actual enslavement (except during war or as tribute).
Thus a dialectical loop was established whereby economic productivity
required an increase in the importation of slaves leading to the further
commodification of humans and a corollary racist ideology to justify
subjugation, which in turn fuelled crusades in search of more slaves.
Islamic Humanism preceded its Renaissance counterpart by centuries, finding
its negation in the institutions of slavery. It was to the Zanjis credit that they
managed to temporarily supercede this dichotomy. Later on, this humanism
having failed to connect to a generalized system of commodity production
degenerated into humanitarianism. Paul Mattick (Anti-Bolshevik Communism, p
158) makes a valid generalization for the European arena where humanism did
reach impressive levels of achievement and where its fall from grace was even
more spectacular than its 'oriental' counterpart: "With the bourgeoisie securely
established, humanism degenerated into humanitarianism for the alleviation of
the social misery that accompanied the capital formation process". The reign
of the Islamic bourgeoisie has been more halting and uneven, less secure.
Some of the battles won by the 'western' bourgeoisie against European
feudalism are still to be completed by its 'eastern' counterpart. Consequently,
one would expect a more lingering humanist tradition amongst the Islamic
intelligentsia. This is precisely why (bourgeois) sufism remains a powerful
current within 'Islamic' societies.
Compared to the Roman Empire whose slaves were mostly local, the greater
distances involved in the transport of slaves, led to a more sophisticated slave
trade in Islam. Lewis reminds us that through conquest, commerce, concubage
and pilgrimage to Mecca, Islam created the first truly universal civilization.
Here the term 'civilization' is not employed in a moralistic sense but refers to a
system, which creates more surplus value than previous ones. Moreover, we
would qualify the universalistic claims of Islam by pointing out that its
foundation, the umma (Islamic community) is an 'imagined community' where
class and gender inequalities are systematically covered up. It is significant
that this imagined community needed external enemies for its survival and
employed divide-and-rule tactics as brazenly as its 'western' equivalent.
However, despite the policy of dividing the laborers by nationality, pursued by
successive khalifehs, international solidarity between the slaves reached new
heights.
"What the ancients called a clever fighter is one who not only wins, but excels
in winning with ease."
- Sun Tzu, The Art of War
THE REBELLION
Although African slaves working the marshlands and salt mines of
Mesopotamia, especially those around Basra, sparked the rebellion, they were
soon joined by other slaves, serfs, peasants, artisans, tribal Arabs,
manumissioned slaves and the usual rent-a-mob-rabble that are forever lurking
around the dark and dubious alleyways of history, waiting for an opportunity to
do mischief.
One such malcontent was a Persian by the name of Ali Razi (aka Zangi-yar,
literally translated, mate of the Zanjis) who became the leader of the rebellion.
He promised his followers heaven on earth and punished slave-owners
severely in public trials. His knowledge of the occult and expertise with the
astrolabe confirmed his supernatural status. This is not as strange as it
sounds. Spartacus was credited with similar powers: "According to the
credulous Greek historian, Plutarch, serpents curled around [Spartacus] whilst
he slept, and his prophetess wife foretold his greatness even when he was still
a slave" (F. A. Ridley, Spartacus, p 37). Razi appropriated the wealthy and
persuaded their slaves through reasoned arguments to join his ranks. In his
speeches he repeatedly asks the slaves to execute him unhesitatingly if he
should betray their trust. Razi's pledge seems far more genuine than similar
oaths in other secret societies, for instance the Caraboneri.
The fact that the success of the rebellion depended on the leadership of Razi
19/9/2015 12:55 PM
4 of 8
http://libcom.org/library/zanj-slaves-rebellion-ad-869-883
19/9/2015 12:55 PM
5 of 8
http://libcom.org/library/zanj-slaves-rebellion-ad-869-883
Ibn Qutayba thought blacks were "ugly and misshapen, because they live in a
hot country. The heat overcooks them in the womb and curls their hair". Even
the genius of Ibn Khaldun was tainted by prejudice against blacks: "Therefore,
the Negro nations are, as a rule, submissive to slavery because [Negroes]
have little [that is essentially] human and have attributes that are quite similar
to those of dumb animals..."
"Do not repeat the tactics which have gained you one victory, but let your
methods be regulated by the infinite variety of circumstances".
- Sun Tzu, The Art of War
Against such a tirade of bigoted intolerance some black writers began to
deliver counter-jabs. Perhaps one of the first expressions of "Black is beautiful"
came in the shape of a treatise written by the satirist Jahiz of Basra (ca.
776-869), entitled The Boast of Blacks Against Whites, where he purports to
defend the Zanj against their detractors. But these intellectual efforts remained
woefully limited in scope. For example, the satirist and court jester, Abu
Dulama (d. ca. 776), a black Arab poet, was pressurized into self-derogatory
comic routines for the amusement of his Abbasi masters. Lewis (Race and
Color in Islam, p 17) even suggests that Jahiz, being a humorist, was not
"wholly serious" in his defence of Africans despite being probably of African
descent himself. He was certainly more Arab than the Arabs on one occasion
when he attacks the Zanj with venom: "We know that the Zanj were the least
intelligent and the least discerning of mankind, and the least capable of
understanding the consequences of actions..." As ever misconceptions were
best fought during the struggles of the slaves themselves.
TACTICS AND STRATEGY
Ansaf-pour has estimated that the Zanj fought the forces of the empire on 156
separate occasions during their 15-year campaign. Most of the battles waged
in the first six years were won through a mixture of bravery and surprise
guerrilla tactics.
In their seventh engagement, for instance, they out-smarted the Khalifeh's
generals by attacking two villages simultaneously. They acted ruthlessly when
required (executing thousands for siding with the khalifeh) and magnanimously
when it made sense (releasing captured soldiers as part of their propaganda
war against the Empire).
"Be subtle! Be subtle! And use your spies for every kind of business".
- Sun Tzu, The Art of War
Even a movement as non-compromising as the Zanj could not avoid occasional
contact with class enemies. Merchants who sold them provisions when stocks
were low, soldiers who defected to their side only to prove treacherous and
most damaging of all pseudo-rebels who turned coat at the earliest
opportunity.
The prime example of this is Ya'ghub, a Persian who as a (muslim) nationalist
fought the invading (muslim) Arab army, 'liberating' vast junks of Iran. However,
the egalitarian principles of the Zanj proved anathema to him and when the
crunch came he sided with the Khalifeh against the slaves, delivering a body
blow from which the Zanj never recovered. The historical lessons of the Paris
Commune (that the bosses are always prepared to suspend faction fights and
unite against the proletariat) came as no surprise to the Middle Eastern
proletariat. Ya'ghub 'the cunt' taught us that particular lesson long ago!
All this forced the Zanj to develop their intelligence-gathering network far and
wide. Local and converted spies were employed to discover the enemy plans.
Ali Razi would order the snatching of slaves from muslim dominated areas who
were then questioned about their masters' intentions, and released unharmed
having in most cases become converted rebels. And with these messengers
the Zanj preached their egalitarian doctrine to all those who would listen.
The different strands in their movement complemented each other to produce
an all-pervasive assault against private property. The Africans and the tribal
Arabs contributed to the communist trend by attempting to build
non-hierarchical communes similar to the tribes they remembered from before
19/9/2015 12:55 PM
6 of 8
http://libcom.org/library/zanj-slaves-rebellion-ad-869-883
slavery and the Persians under the influence of Mazdaki ideology emphasized
the possession of all things in common.
The Zanj rebellion is one of the few slave revolts where women took an active
part in the struggle. It is worth noting that women and children were
particularly in demand in Islamic lands and hence predominated in the slave
trade.
"Humble words and increased preparations are signs that the enemy is about
to advance. Violent language and driving forward as if to attack are signs that
he will retreat."
- Sun Tzu, The Art of War
THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK!
The Islamic Empire which was born a 'feudal' entity, had after three centuries
of growth acquired millions of slaves working in mines, factories, marshlands,
agriculture and household duties. This had created a parallel, though
subordinate, mode of slave production alongside 'feudalism'. A sign that there
was a surplus of slaves can be seen in their use as court entertainers.
Eunuchs, virgins and even transvestites were employed for the pleasure of the
Muslim elite. In slave markets, known as spectacles, the price of slaves could
suddenly fall after a military victory. Anticipating 20th century consumerism,
one smart trader decided to give away a free extra slave for every 40 Turkish
slaves bought, in order to boost flagging sales!
The first slave traders' manual (vade mecum), which appeared in the 10th
century, concentrated on the physiological and physiognomic features of the
slaves and could be viewed as a forerunner of the science of phrenology. Later
studies analyzed ethnological aspects also. Ibn Buttan who wrote a complete
study of the subject suggested an elaborate technical division of labour for
slaves.
All this knowledge regarding its victim came in handy when the ruling class
finally got its act together and began to wear down the Zanj militarily while
sowing the seeds of distrust amongst them. Cities controlled by the Zanj
began to fall to the superior forces of the khalifeh. Mokhtarieh, their capital and
flagship, was besieged for two year. Finally, in a surprise and daring counterattack, Razi and some of his closest associates fought their way out of the
Muslim's stranglehold to fight one last battle. But the game was up and they
knew it. When the end came, Razi's severed head was paraded throughout the
region to convince the remaining free slaves that resistance was futile. Yet,
thousands refused to believe and fought on in small enclaves in the hope of a
miracle that never materialized.
CONCLUSIONS
"Hence the saying: If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not
fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know the enemy but not yourself, for
every victory gained you will suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor
yourself, you will succumb in every battle."
- Sun Tzu, The Art of War
A bourgeois reactionary once explained the failure of the slaves' revolts in the
Roman Empire thusly: " ... the uprisings were unsuccessful because even in
the most revolutionary crisis of history the slaves were always the tools of the
ruling classes" (Lenin quoted in W Z Rubinsohn, Spartacus' Uprising and Soviet
Historical Writing). Thankfully no one bothered to tell Lenin about the Zanj
revolt. Ironically Stalin who had based his thesis of the division of human
history into 5 successive periods on Lenin, came to exactly the opposite
conclusion: "...the great slave-uprisings of the declining Roman Republic
annihilated the slave-owner class and the slave-owner society" (J. V. Stalin, vol
13, p 239, Speech to the First All Soviet Congress of Kolcholz-peasants). Had
Stalin passed the same judgment on the Zanj rebellion he would still be wrong
but at least on safer ground! As it is both he and Lenin set back any serious
analysis of class struggle in the ancient world through their ill-informed and
reactionary rhetoric. Middle Eastern scholars are to this day grappling with the
adverse repercussions of their rants.
19/9/2015 12:55 PM
7 of 8
http://libcom.org/library/zanj-slaves-rebellion-ad-869-883
What we can say with a reasonable amount of certainty is that there were
certain inherent weaknesses in the Zanj movement which went unnoticed while
they were winning battles and attracting new members, but as soon as they
stalled on the military front, the flaws crystallized as insoluble obstacles.
Following Hannibal's famous victory at Cannae, Marharbal, his cavalry
commander urged him to march on Rome. When Hannibal refused Marharbal
retorted: "The gods have taught you how to win victories, Hannibal, but not
how to use them". The same criticism can be levelled at the Zanj. Having
fought the forces of Islam to a standstill, they failed to take advantage. They
lacked a master plan. Gradually with the new wealth accumulating in their
coffers they began to imitate their old masters. A rigid hierarchical structure
and an elitist attitude towards the rank and file created disillusionment. Some
of the top generals in the Zanj army became indistinguishable from the hated
landlords. Ali Razi who clearly understood the alienation all this created,
seemed powerless to do anything about it.
The same problem resurfaced again in 17th century maroon communities of
the Caribbean. "The long survival of Palmores, for example, meant that the
monarchy of King Ganga Zumba assumed truly dynastic form.... Perhaps the
most bizarre development in this respect was the appearance of Indian
leaders of resistance in Brazil... who, under the impact of Portuguese
Catholicism, styled themselves popes" (K R Bradley, Slavery and Rebellion in
the Roman World, p 10-11).
The heterogeneity of the slaves, which was previously a source of strength,
now became a source of friction. Household slaves and eunuchs began arguing
whilst Razi and his generals fell out over tactics. Some would argue that even
in defeat the Zanj were victorious, in the sense that they (and similar other
contemporaneous revolts) forced the Islamic ruling class to dispense with
slavery as an auxiliary mode of production to 'feudalism'. The slaves' workload
was lessened and they were gradually transformed into peasants and serfs,
some being 'freed' into wage-slavery. Accordingly the Zanj inaugurated a social
revolution but not the social revolution. But perhaps their greatest mistake as
with many proletarians before and after them was to ignore the wisdom of the
ancient axiom:
"In war, then, let your great object be victory, not lengthy campaigns".
- Sun Tzu, The Art of War
Address for correspondence: Melancholic Troglodytes, c/o 56a Infoshop, 56
Crampton Street, Walworth, London SE17 3AE, United Kingdom.
Email: meltrogs1 (at) hotmail.com
Comments
noha_kamal
Feb 12 2014 21:05
Here is an arabic account Zanj slave Rebellion by dr Faysal al Samer #enjoy
blog
news
library
history
19/9/2015 12:55 PM
8 of 8
http://libcom.org/library/zanj-slaves-rebellion-ad-869-883
libcom.org
about | donate | help out | submitting content | other languages | a-z | contact us | site notes
19/9/2015 12:55 PM