Professional Documents
Culture Documents
and a potentially higher interest rates. A cut in CRR would lead to a fall in interest rate. A cut
in interest rates would make savings in banks unattractive. Thus, depositors may move to the
stock market at a time when the revival of the bourses is crucial for regenerating Indian
industry. Thus a reduction in CRR would boost the securities prices and players are also
expecting the Government to align the savings rate to the same structural levels.
(CRR), statutory liquidity ratio (SLR), prime lending rates (PLR),
Repo Rate etc, to control the money supply of the country. This paper aim to discuss about
the impact of reverse repo rate and cash reverse ratio in the share price of banking companies
listed in National Stock Exchange. The analysis of the study showed that the security prices
reacted to the announcements of reverse repo rate and cash reserve ratio. We considered the
following determinants Oil prices, Gold price, Cash Reserve Ratio, Food Price Inflation, Call
Money Rate, Dollar Price, F D I, Foreign Portfolio Investment and Foreign Exchange
Reserve (Forex). We have taken into consideration the Multicollinearity problem among
different macroeconomic variables and attempted to eliminate it.
Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) is the amount of funds that all Scheduled Commercial Banks
(SCB) excluding Regional Rural Banks (RRB) are required to maintain without any floor or
ceiling rate with RBI with reference to their total net Demand and Time Liabilities (DTL) to
ensure the liquidity and solvency of Banks.
In terms of Section 42(1) of the RBI Act 1934, Scheduled Commercial Banks are required to
maintain with RBI an average cash balance, the amount of which shall not be less than 3%
and higher rate not exceeding 20% of the total of the Net Demand and Time Liabilities
(NDTL) in India.
Demand Liabilities are liabilities which are payable on demand and Time Liabilities are those
which are payable otherwise than on demand.
The components for computation of DTL include Demand Liabilities, Time Liabilities and
Other Demand & Time Liabilities (ODTL) as under:-
Demand Liabilities:Current Deposits, Savings bank deposits, Margins held against letters of credit/guarantees,
Balances in overdue fixed deposits, Outstanding DDs, Unclaimed deposits, Credit balances in
the Cash Credit account and deposits held as security for advances which are payable on
demand & Money at Call and Short Notice from outside the Banking System (Liability to
others).
Time Liabilities:Fixed deposits, cash certificates, cumulative and recurring deposits, time liabilities portion of
savings bank deposits, staff security deposits, margin held against letters of credit, if not
payable on demand, & deposits held as securities for advances which are not payable on
demand and Gold deposits.
Other Demand and Time Liabilities (ODTL):ODTL include interest accrued on deposits, bills payable, unpaid dividends, suspense account
balances representing amounts due to other banks or public, net credit balances in branch
adjustment account, any amounts due to the banking system which are not in the nature of
deposits or borrowing.
4
Example:If a person deposits Rs 1,000 in his account, the bank can use it to lend others, but it has to
deposit a percentage of that amount with the RBI. Hence, CRR is 4%, the lender will deposit
Rs.40 with the RBI and has Rs.960 left at its disposal.
If a person deposits Rs 1,000 in his account, the bank can use it to lend others, but it has to
deposit a percentage of that amount with the RBI. Hence, if CRR is 5%, the lender will
deposit Rs.50 with the RBI and has Rs.950 left at its disposal.
Lower CRR means bank can give more money as loan = lower interest rates = cheap
loan = more people take loan to start business or building house or buying car = boost
in economy. However, can also lead to inflation, if people have more cash in their
hands than the items available for purchase in the market.
Higher CRR = bank can give less money as loan = Higher interest rate = it becomes
expensive to start a new factory, buy a new house / car/bike. This can curb inflation
but may also lead to slowdown in economy, because people wait for the interest rates
to go down, before taking loans.
With every cut in 25 basis points in CRR it would infuse the liquidity of Rs.16000
crore
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on Tuesday cut the repo rate as well as the cash reserve
ratio (CRR) by 25 basis points, or 0.25 percent. Heres a quick explanation of what that
means. It will be obvious to some readers, but many people havent studied economics and
are unfamiliar with the terms.
The repo rate, which now stands at 7.75 percent, is the rate at which the central bank lends
money to Indian banks. As the repo rate goes down, it gets cheaper for banks to borrow
money. That makes it easier for people to borrow money at cheaper rates too. As more people
borrow money, which ought to be the result of action like this, theyll spend more money.
Thats good for the Indian economy.
The CRR, meanwhile, is the amount of funds banks must keep with the RBI. The CRR is at 4
percent, which means for every 100 rupees, the bank keeps 4 rupees with the RBI in cash.
The ratio indicates the policy stance of the bank and is used as a tool to manage liquidity, or
the amount of money in the system. By changing this ratio, the central bank can control the
amount of liquidity. Tuesdays cut would release 180 billion rupees (or about $3.35 billion)
into the system, meaning banks would have more money to lend to borrowers.
Cutting the repo rate doesnt always cut lending rates, of course. Banks might worry that
lower lending rates could hurt their profits. However, IDBI Bank cut its base rate after the
RBI announcement, and the head of Indias top lender, State Bank of India, said banks likely
will cut lending rates.
Why does the RBI need to do things like this? The central bank must keep inflation in check
while stimulating growth. This is important to India, whose growth rate in recent years has
slowed. That has led to questions about the countrys prosperity, the future of its swelling
ranks of middle-class citizens, and the possibility that years of economic success for the
country and millions of its inhabitants might not last.
Avoiding higher inflation also is important. Data released earlier this month suggests that
inflation is at a three-year low, which makes it easier for the RBI to cut rates. Still, there is a
fear it could rise again, especially after a rise in diesel prices. Other concerns include fiscal
deficit and current account deficit. Thats the reason that the RBI hinted further rate cuts
would be conditional on the governments moves to control fiscal deficit. Hence, the RBI
remains cautious about rate cuts going ahead. The Sensex fell more than 100 points on
Tuesday because of this.
The next development to watch out for is the release of the annual budget on Feb. 28. As
Andy Mukherjee notes at Reuters Breaking views:
Finance minister P. Chidambaram has promised fiscal consolidation and other reforms. If he
avoids the temptation to indulge instead in vote-buying populist measures that increase the
governments spending commitments, there may be hope not just of another rate cut, but of a
recovery too.
7
Features
The cash reserve ratio measures the liquidity of a banking institution, and represents the
amount of cash on hand as a percentage of total transactions. The U.S. Federal Reserve sets
minimum cash reserve ratios for all banks in the U.S., and includes cash on hand as well as
cash deposited at Federal Reserve bank locations. These ratios apply to transaction accounts
only, and do not include CDs and other private loan instruments. As of April 2011, the
Federal Reserve requires 0 cash reserves for deposits up to $10.7 million. Banks with
transactions ranging from $10.7 to $58.8 million must maintain 3 percent cash reserves, while
10 percent is required for deposits over $58.8 million.
Considerations
While the availability of cash reserves provides numerous benefits to society and the
economy, it also poses a serious drawback in the form of lost interest. Banks do not earn
interest on cash reserves, which results in reduced earnings for the bank and for its customers.
In a 1992 release, the Federal Reserve estimated this loss to exceed $700 million per year in
pre-tax earnings, which represents a loss of roughly 2 percent.
10
11
Demand Liabilities
'Demand Liabilities' include all liabilities which are payable on demand and they include
current deposits, demand liabilities portion of savings bank deposits, margins held against
letters of credit/guarantees, balances in overdue fixed deposits, cash certificates and
cumulative/recurring deposits, outstanding Telegraphic Transfers (TTs), Mail Transfer (MTs),
Demand Drafts (DDs), unclaimed deposits, credit balances in the Cash Credit account and
deposits held as security for advances which are payable on demand. Money at Call and Short
Notice from outside the Banking System should be shown against liability to others.
Time Liabilities
Time Liabilities are those which are payable otherwise than on demand and they include
fixed deposits, cash certificates, cumulative and recurring deposits, time liabilities portion of
savings bank deposits, staff security deposits, margin held against letters of credit if not
payable on demand, deposits held as securities for advances which are not payable on
demand, India Millennium Deposits and Gold Deposits.Borrowings from banks abroad
Loans/borrowings from abroad by banks in India will be considered as 'liabilities to others'
and will be subject to reserve requirements.
against
the
inter-bank assets.
Likewise
sums
placed
by banks
issuing
12
13
Exempted Categories
Scheduled Commercial Banks are exempted from maintaining average CRR on the following
liabilities :
i) Liabilities to the banking system in India as computed under Clause (d) of the Explanation
to Section 42(1) of the RBI Act, 1934.
ii) Credit balances in ACU (US$) Accounts.
iii) Transactions in Collateralized Borrowing and Lending Obligation (CBLO) with Clearing
Corporation of India Ltd. (CCIL).
iv) Demand and Time Liabilities in respect of their Offshore Banking Units
(OBUs).Although Scheduled Commercial Banks are exempted from maintaining average
CRR on the above liabilities, they are required to maintain 3 per cent statutory reserve
thereon. Scheduled Commercial Banks are not required to include inter-bank term deposits /
term borrowing liabilities of original maturities of 15 days and above and upto one year in
'Liabilities to the Banking System' (item I of Form 'A'). Similarly banks should exclude their
inter-bank assets of term deposits and term lending of original maturity of 15 days and above
and up to one year in 'Assets with the Banking System' (item III of form A) for the purpose of
maintenance of CRR. This concession is not available for maintenance of SLR.
for that defaulted fortnight only after working out cost of shortfall at the rate of 25 per cent
per annum and subtracting the amount so worked out from interest payable amount.
Penalties
Shortfall, if any, observed in the maintenance of the CRR is reckoned against the eligible
cash balances required to be maintained on the NDTL. The total amount of interest payable
so arrived at is being reduced by an amount calculated at the rate of 25 per cent per annum on
the amount of shortfall. In a situation where shortfall exceeds the level at which no interest
becomes payable on eligible balances held by a bank on net basis i.e. (after interest deduction
on the amount of CRR shortfall) the penal interest under sub-section (3) of Section 42 of the
RBI Act, 1934 is made
Applicable The Scheduled Commercial Banks are required to furnish the particulars, such as
date, amount, percentage, reason for default in maintenance of requisite CRR and also action
taken to avoid recurrence of such default.
Fortnightly return in Form A
Under section 42 (2) of RBI Act, 1934, all Scheduled Commercial Banks are required to
submit to RBI a provisional return in Form 'A' within 7 days from the expiry of the relevant
fortnight. It is used for preparing press communiqu. The final Form 'A' is required to be sent
to RBI within 20 days from expiry of the relevant fortnight. Based on the recommendation of
the Working Group on Money Supply: Analytics and Methodology of Compilation, all
Scheduled Commercial Banks in India are required to submit from the fortnight beginning
October 9, 1998, Memorandum to form 'A' giving details about paid-up capital, reserves, time
deposits comprising of short term and long term, certificates of deposits, NDTL, total CRR
requirement etc., Annexure A to form A return showing all foreign currency liabilities and
assets and Annexure B to form A return giving details about investment in approved
securities, investment in non-approved securities, memo items such as subscription to
shares /debentures / bonds in primary market and subscriptions through private placement.
For reporting in Form 'A' return, banks should convert their overseas foreign currency assets
and
bank credit in India in foreign currency in four major currencies viz., US dollar, GBP,
Japanese Yen and Euro at the FEDAI noon mean rate on reporting Friday. The explanations to
item No's. I, II and III of the return in form 'A' are given below:
Item I - Liabilities to the Banking System in India .
16
17
Repo Rate:
The repo or repurchase rate is the interest charged by the RBI to banks when they approach it
for short term loans.
The repo rate is linked to the interest rate borrowers pay when they take loans from banks
because the latter always charges interest which is higher than the existing repo rate. Hence,
lower repo rates could induce lenders into lowering the interest rates they charge from
individual borrowers too, thereby making credit more affordable.
CRR determines bank interest rates: If a man had deposited Rs.1,000 in his account when the
CRR was 5%, the bank will have at its disposal Rs.950 after it deposits Rs.50 as CRR. The
bank in turn lends the Rs.950 to a borrower who will eventually repay the bank.
The bank will once again lend this amount (Rs.950) to another borrower after depositing 5%
of the amount (Rs.47.5) to the RBI. In this manner, the money will keep exchanging hands, or
it continues to be created and available for subsequent borrowers. This means that Rs.1,000 is
18
helping generate a far higher amount in the economy in an indirect manner. Therefore, even if
the CRR were to be increased by only 1%, the money generated in the economy would
reduce drastically.
19
The year 2009 saw investor wealth double and in many cases even triple. This was the most
powerful and phenomenal turnaround that any bear market has ever witnessed in the history
of the stock markets. And the best part is that this is not the end of the road for this rally. All
technical and fundamental indicators point towards a more robust growth in the economy and
a more sustained rally in the stock markets in the year 2010.
But a price has to be paid for this vibrant economic growth. Strong growth leads to stronger
demand, which automatically translates into higher prices. And these high prices ultimately
culminate into higher inflation. Inflation appears to be one of the many dark clouds in this
otherwise spotless clear blue sky of stock markets.
20
As loan rates go up, consumers tend to borrow less and eventually spend less. Thus the
demand for goods and services goes down. All inflated prices start coming down due to the
decrease in demand. And as prices start moving downwards, inflation starts coming down.
But as is the case with every antibiotic, CRR also comes with its own share of side effects.
Let us understand the effect that CRR has on various sectors in the industry.
Banking
Increased interest rates lead to lower credit growth and further bring about the overall
profitability. Thus, banking stocks might face selling pressure.
21
Real estate
CRR hike will reduce liquidity in the markets. Consumers will be less inclined to borrow
home loans at higher interest rates resulting in a fall in demand. Also construction companies
will have to borrow at higher rates thus increasing their overheads.
Auto
The same applies to autos. The demand for automobiles will decrease due to increased
lending rates and the cost to company will rise sharply due to increased borrowing rates.
Hence, auto stocks can also see a downturn. Overall almost all sectors will be affected in
some way or the other with a generalized slowdown in industrial growth. Since liquidity is
strapped to an extent, consumer demand is low owing to increased interest rates. Companies
have to borrow at higher interest rates adding to their cost. Hence, the stock markets on the
whole can witness some selling pressure.
Debt markets
CRR hike can also increase paucity of funds in the debt market. But one of the negatives of
this move is that the yields of bonds increases as bond prices decrease since banks sell bonds
to create liquidity. As the prices of bonds decrease, the returns on debt mutual funds will also
plummet.
Effect On Companies
The cost of funds will go up for small and medium-sized companies that have no access to
foreign funds.
22
23
Cash reserve ratio (CRR) like the name suggests is the ratio of cash that bank needs to keep
reserved with the central bank. CRR can also be defined as the proportion of deposits that
banks need keep with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in cash fortnightly. Presently the CRR
is 6% that is, for every Rs100 deposited in the bank; bank will need to deposit Rs6 with RBI.
Or in other words, banks cant lend or use this Rs6 for any purpose. This does not mean that
the remaining Rs94 can be used by the banks for lending as other than CRR they have to
meet other predetermined proportion of the deposits as directed by RBI. Also banks dont
earn any interest on the funds deposited (as CRR) with RBI.
The main purpose of CRR is to protect the risk of the banks depositors to an extent and to
ensure that a bank maintains some funds in liquid form.
The other purpose it serves is, it helps to adjust liquidity in the system, the supply of money
circulating in the economy. When there is excess money supply in the market, RBI will
increase the CRR to drain out the excess. Inversely if the economy is falling short of liquidity,
then RBI will decrease the CRR to release more funds in the market. This is thus one of the
instruments that the central bank uses to control inflation.
When the CRR is increased, the amount of funds that a bank can lend decreases. Banks then
try to encourage more deposits by increasing the interest rates. Rising interest rate usually
discourage loan seekers as a higher interest rate means that the cost of money has increased.
CRR is only one of the factors that influence interest rates. Change in CRR has a major effect
on the bank though it may not have a major effect on investors unless other factors also
influence interest rates
24
25
permitted I think by the kind of inflation trajectory that we expect going forward," he
reiterates.
Chinoy is looking at about 5.6% growth for this year which implicitly assumes some pick up
in the second half. However, there are concerns around inflation trajectory to be significantly
higher because of electricity price increase, diesel price hike and the fact that global
commodity prices will be higher than we initially thought. According to him, inflation is
likely to go above 8-8.5% over the next few months.
Meanwhile, Anant Narayan, Standard Chartered Bank also believes that RBI will sort of take
on the mantle of trying to address the growth perspective as well and hopefully the macro
economic situation globally.
"I think the guidance given by the RBI which looks at growth is focusing on the right part. To
me growth has a direct bearing on inflation in terms of improving supply. It has a direct
bearing on fiscal deficit, because the only way India generally controls fiscal deficit is by
increasing revenues which requires growth and it has a direct bearing on FX itself, because
balance of payments requires that India positive growth story tor remain, so that money
comes in into the system," Narayan emphasises.
Bond market
Looking at a bond yield range of 8.05-8.25%, Anant Narayan of Standard Chartered Bank is
optimistic that rerating of overall risk in India is still some distance away. Stressing that a
mere Rs 17,000 crore is not going to fix the liquidity crunch which stands at Rs 40,000 crore.
"Specific to government bonds, every time we have liquidity infusion through CRR cuts, in
the minds of the market players it takes away the need for further OMOs to that extent.
26
about
coinage;
(ii)
Decisions
to
paper
to
create
credit.
CRR is a major tool used by the RBI to control money supply in the economy. Cash reserve
Ratio (CRR) is the amount of funds that the banks have to keep with RBI. If RBI decides to
increase the percent of this, the available amount with the banks comes down. RBI is using
this method (increase of CRR rate), to drain out the excessive money from the banks.CRR
impact interest rates, when RBI increases CRR it means banks have to keep additional funds
with the RBI, if banks keep more with RBI they can offer less at high rate of interest to
customers. Hence RBI increases CRR when they want to take away the excess money from
markets and vise-versa. Liquidity in an economy also gets impacted with a change in CRR,
when RBI reduces CRR from time to time they plan to inject money into the system.
Along with CRR RBI also uses repo rate, reverse repo, bank rate as instruments of monetary
policy.CRR also impacts individual as it impacts the stock market, borrower.
Hence CRR is a major qualitative monetary tool with which the RBI plays upon to control the
situation in the economy.
27
28
To Illustrate:
If a depositor deposits Rs.1000/- in bank, it increases the deposit by Rs.1000/- and if the CRR
is currently 9%, banks will have to hold Rs.90/- and will be able to use only Rs.910/- for its
lending and borrowing activities. If suppose the CRR rate was reduced to 7%, then banks will
have to keep Rs.70/- as Cash reserve (CRR) with RBI and hence will be having Rs.930/- for
its banking business activities. Hence @7% the liquidity in the economy will be higher than
at 9% as the availability of money is Rs.930/- against Rs.910/- respectively.
RBI controls liquidity, growth, inflation and other economic parameters of India through the
application of appropriate CRR rate. It will be most appropriate to note that the money from
public raised as deposits etc., are the funds which are kept with RBI as CRR. The Banks will
have to pay interest on such deposits but will not be able to earn any money on such funds
which are kept idle with RBI as CRR.
Reserve Bank of India does not pay any interest on the money; they receive as CRR from the
Commercial/Scheduled Banks. Considering prudent Management Principles, to keep scarce
resource of production namely Capital as reserves without any economic activity is not
considered good. However, the larger principles of economy of balancing and directing the
course of economic activity take priority over the prudent Management policies in the case of
Cash Reserve Ratio.
From the individual banks perspective, it is mandatory requirement for the bank to abide by
and keep their licenses going. Hence, they will have to maintain the Reserve.
policy for monitoring the economy of the country. Hence CRR cannot be done away with.
He totally differs with the views of Mr. Pratip Chowdhry.
30
CONCLUSION:
CRR is definitely an essential tool for controlling the various parameters of the economy.
However at what cost the essential tool is to be maintained? CRR is an artificial tool to create
demand or supply of most essential factor of production that is CAPITAL. While hoarding
up of commodities to create artificial scarcity and jacking up prices is prohibited by law for a
trader etc., it is being followed as principle for economic parameters control by Central Bank
as part of monetary policy in the guise of CRR. Considering the contrary stands of RBI and
Finance Ministry on the requirement of paying interest on CRR deposits, it would be worth
watching the future course of direction of the issue contemplated in this article. The reserve
requirement (or cash reserve ratio) is a central bank regulation employed by most, but not all,
of the world's central banks, that sets the minimum fraction of customer deposits and notes
that each commercial bank must hold as reserves (rather than lend out). These required
reserves are normally in the form of cash stored physically in a bank vault (vault cash) or
deposits made with a central bank. The required reserve ratio is sometimes used as a tool in
monetary policy, influencing the country's borrowing and interest rates by changing the
amount of funds available for banks to make loans with. Western central banks rarely alter the
reserve requirements because it would cause immediate liquidity problems for banks with
low excess reserves; they generally prefer to use open market operations (buying and selling
government-issued bonds) to implement their monetary policy. The People's Bank of China
uses changes in reserve requirements as an inflation-fighting tool, and raised the reserve
requirement ten times in 2007 and eleven times since the beginning of 2010.
31
WIBLIOGRAPHY
www.google.com
www.wikipidia.com
www.scribe.com
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40